Trust assessment method, system, and related device
Through the trust level evaluation system and the trust level evaluation certificate, the problem of difficulty in consensus on the trust evaluation model in heterogeneous networks is solved, and interoperability and network security guarantees for cross-domain trust level evaluation are achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/CN2024/091999
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-06-01
- Filing Date
- 2024-05-09
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
AI Technical Summary
The heterogeneity of the network and multi-stakeholder in the future make it difficult to form a consensus on the trust assessment model, and the trust level assessment in cross-operators and cross-domain scenarios cannot achieve interoperability, making it difficult to ensure network security and credibility.
Provide a trust assessment method and system to generate trust assessment certificates through trust assessment between trust level assessors (TLA) and trustees, and use trust level assessment archives (TLA files) and evidence to ensure the assessment results. authenticity and immutability, and provide flexible and interoperable trust level assessments in different network scenarios.
Achieve the unity of trust level evaluation in heterogeneous networks, avoid cross-domain interoperability problems caused by non-standard models, ensure the security and credibility of the network, and ensure the authenticity of the evaluation results through trust level certificates. Sexual and immutable.
Smart Images

Figure CN2024091999_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
A trust evaluation method, system and related equipment
[0001] This application claims priority to the Chinese patent application filed with the State Intellectual Property Office of China on June 1, 2023, with application number 202310645708.1 and application name “A trust assessment method, system and related equipment”, the entire contents of which are incorporated by reference into this application. Technical Field
[0002] The present application relates to the field of computer technology, and in particular to a trust evaluation method, system, and related equipment. Background Art
[0003] In recent years, with the rapid development of technologies such as mobile internet, big data, and artificial intelligence (AI), network infrastructure, including mobile communication networks and the internet, has assumed enormous social and economic value. As the value of networks becomes increasingly prominent, cybersecurity has also assumed immense importance, becoming a crucial component of national security.
[0004] Future networks (such as 6G networks) will be large-scale, heterogeneous networks with numerous business scenarios and diverse stakeholders. It's difficult to apply a unified trust level approach to all scenarios. At the standards level, a unified trust grading model also struggles to align with the interests of different countries, regions, operators, and equipment vendors, making it difficult to reach consensus and promote it across the industry. Therefore, ensuring network security and trustworthiness has become a pressing issue.
[0005] Summary of the Invention
[0006] The present application provides a trust assessment method, system and related equipment, which can be used for trust assessment of network devices in different network scenarios to ensure the security and reliability of the network.
[0007] In a first aspect, the present application provides a trust assessment method for a trust assessment system including a trust level assessor (TLA) and a trustee, wherein the trust level assessor TLA performs a trust assessment on the trustee based on a first trust level assessment TLA file and evidence submitted by the trustee to obtain the trust level of the trustee. The evidence includes one or more statements describing relevant information about the trustee; the first TLA file includes multiple trust levels and an assessment model corresponding to each trust level; the assessment model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results of one or more statements required by the first trust level, wherein the first trust level is any one of the multiple trust levels. The TLA verifies the statements provided by the trustee to obtain a verification result for each statement, and then determines the trust level of the trustee based on the verification result of each statement of the trustee and the verification result required by each trust level.
[0008] Among them, TLA is generally a computing device, such as a server, etc.; the trusted party is generally a network device, such as a switch, router, wireless base station, core network virtualized network function, etc.
[0009] This application provides a TLA profile for trust level assessment, as well as a trust assessment method based on the TLA profile. It can be used for trust assessment of network devices in different network scenarios, such as base stations and gateways in communication networks, switches, routers and other devices in the Internet, data center networks or campus networks. It solves the problem of the inability to unify trust level assessment models in different scenarios in heterogeneous networks, while avoiding the problem of difficulty in cross-domain and cross-scenario interoperability caused by the use of non-standard and customized models. On the premise of achieving a certain industry consensus, it can provide a trust level assessment method with certain flexibility and interoperability to ensure network security and reliability.
[0010] In one possible implementation, the first TLA file includes a statement list, where the statement list includes one or more statement names, where the statement name includes any one or more of the following: a trusted party's identity, software integrity, hardware integrity, protocol status, interface status, security protocol, cryptographic algorithm, or key length. It should be understood that the statement list in the first TLA file includes statement names corresponding to one or more statements in the evidence provided by the trusted party.
[0011] A TLA contains one or more TLA profiles, allowing different TLA profiles to be used for trust evaluation of different trusted parties as needed; for example, different types of trusted parties can use different TLA profiles for trust evaluation. Each TLA profile contains a list of claims that indicate the claims that a trusted party must submit when trust evaluation is performed using that TLA profile.
[0012] In one possible implementation, the declaration list in the above-mentioned first TLA file also includes indication information corresponding to each declaration name, wherein the indication information corresponding to the first declaration name indicates whether the declaration corresponding to the first declaration name is required to be provided by the trusted party when a trust assessment is performed based on the first TLA file, and the first declaration name is one of the declarations in the declaration list in the first TLA file.
[0013] In a possible implementation, the verification result includes compliance, partial compliance, or non-compliance. The verification result can reflect whether the statement submitted by the trusted party complies with the requirements of the TLA and the degree of compliance.
[0014] In a possible implementation, the first TLA profile further includes metadata, where the metadata includes any one or more of a publisher identifier of a publisher of the first TLA profile, a TLA profile number (TLA profile number) of the first TLA profile, a version number of the first TLA profile, or a validity period of the first TLA profile.
[0015] In a possible implementation, the first TLA file further includes any one or more of an applicable country or region, an applicable device type, an extension field, or a publisher signature; wherein the applicable country or region indicates the country or region to which the first TLA file is applicable; the applicable device type indicates the type of device to which the first TLA file is applicable, and the applicable device types include routers, wireless base stations, and core network virtualized network functions; the publisher signature refers to the signature of the publisher of the first TLA file on the first TLA file using a private key; and it can prevent the TLA file from being tampered with.
[0016] In one possible implementation, the trust level of the trusted party is carried in a trust level evaluation certificate generated by the TLA; the trust level evaluation certificate also includes a first TLA profile number corresponding to a first TLA profile, where the first TLA profile number indicates the TLA profile used to perform trust evaluation on the trusted party.
[0017] By using certificates to carry the trust level, the authenticity and immutability of the trust evaluation results are guaranteed. The TLA profile number used for the evaluation is added to the certificate, binding the trust evaluation result to the corresponding TLA profile. This allows users of the trust level evaluation results to query the specific trust evaluation method used and decide whether to establish a connection with the trusted party.
[0018] In a possible implementation, the trust level evaluation certificate further includes any one or more of a version number, a serial number, a signature algorithm identifier, a TLA name, a validity period, a trusted party name, TLA public key information, a TLA identifier, a trusted party identifier, a proof number of the evidence, a Merkle root, or a TLA signature; wherein,
[0019] The above serial number is used to uniquely identify the trust level evaluation certificate of the trusted party;
[0020] The signature algorithm identifier indicates the signature algorithm used by the TLA to sign the trust level evaluation certificate;
[0021] The above validity period indicates the validity period of the trust level evaluation certificate;
[0022] The above-mentioned TLA public key information includes information of the public key corresponding to the TLA private key;
[0023] The above-mentioned evidence certification number is the number returned to the trusted party by the evidence storage center after the trusted party submits the evidence to the evidence storage center. This evidence certification number can ensure the transparency of the evidence and prevent tampering and repudiation;
[0024] The Merkle root is generated by the trusted party based on the statements included in the evidence. It can be used by TLA to confirm the integrity and correctness of the evidence and prevent evidence from being tampered with.
[0025] The above-mentioned TLA signature refers to the signature of the trust level assessment certificate content by the TLA using the private key, which can be used to confirm the integrity and correctness of the evidence and prevent the content of the trust level assessment certificate from being tampered with.
[0026] In one possible implementation, the evidence submitted by the trusted party further includes metadata of the trusted party and / or a signature of the trusted party; the metadata of the trusted party includes any one or more of an identifier of the trusted party, a timestamp, a version number of the evidence, or the Merkle root.
[0027] The timestamp indicates the time when the trustee generated the evidence; the Merkle root is generated by the trustee based on the statements included in the evidence; the trustee's signature refers to the trustee's signature on the statements included in the evidence using its private key; or the trustee's signature refers to the trustee's signature on the statements included in the evidence and the trustee's metadata using its private key. This can be used to confirm the integrity and correctness of the evidence and prevent tampering.
[0028] In one possible implementation, before performing a trust evaluation on the trusted party based on the TLA profile and evidence, the TLA further includes:
[0029] The TLA receives a trust level assessment request, which includes an identifier of a trusted party and instructs a trust assessment to be performed on the trusted party. The TLA then sends an evidence request to the trusted party, which includes a declaration name included in the declaration list in the first TLA file, and is used to instruct the trusted party to submit a declaration corresponding to the declaration name included in the declaration list in the first TLA file. After the TLA receives an evidence response including the above evidence returned by the trusted party, the TLA performs a trust assessment on the trusted party based on the evidence.
[0030] In a possible implementation, the TLA stores one or more TLA files and a TLA file usage policy, wherein the usage policy indicates a default TLA file and a priority of each TLA file, wherein the first TLA file is one of the one or more TLA files.
[0031] In one possible implementation, the trust level assessment request includes one or more TLA profile numbers, which are used to instruct the TLA to select a TLA profile from among the TLA profiles corresponding to the one or more TLA profile numbers to perform a trust assessment on the trusted party. The party submitting the trust level assessment request can specify the TLA profile to be used for the trust assessment of the trusted party, which can increase the party submitting the trust level assessment request's confidence in the TLA's assessment results.
[0032] In a possible implementation, when the trust level evaluation request includes one or more TLA profile numbers, the TLA selects, based on the priority of each TLA profile, a TLA profile with the highest priority from the TLA profiles corresponding to the one or more TLA profile numbers as the first TLA profile.
[0033] In a possible implementation, when the trust level evaluation request does not include a TLA profile number, the TLA selects a default TLA profile as the first TLA profile.
[0034] In a possible implementation, the evidence response submitted by the trusted party to the TLA further includes an evidence certification number, which is a number returned to the trusted party by the evidence storage center after the trusted party submits the evidence to the evidence storage center.
[0035] In one possible implementation, after the TLA obtains the trust level of the trusted party and feeds back the trust level to the party that sent the trust level evaluation request, the TLA may also receive an update request and re-evaluate the trust of the trusted party based on the update request; wherein the update request includes the identifier of the trusted party. The TLA then re-evaluates the trust of the trusted party according to the aforementioned process.
[0036] In a second aspect, the present application provides a trust assessment method for a trust assessment system including a TLA and a trusted party, comprising: the trusted party receiving an evidence request sent by a trust level assessor TLA, the evidence request including a statement name included in a statement list in a first trust level assessment TLA file, the statement name instructing the trusted party to submit a statement corresponding to the statement name, the statement corresponding to the statement name being used to describe relevant information of the trusted party;
[0037] The trusted party encapsulates the statement corresponding to the above statement name into evidence; wherein the evidence includes one or more statements of the trusted party;
[0038] The trustee sends the above-mentioned evidence carrying the declaration to the TLA, so that the TLA performs a trust assessment on the trustee based on the evidence and a first TLA profile to obtain the trust level of the trustee; wherein the above-mentioned first TLA profile includes multiple trust levels and an assessment model corresponding to each trust level, the assessment model corresponding to the first trust level includes the verification results of one or more declarations required by the first trust level, and the first trust level is one of the above-mentioned multiple trust levels.
[0039] In one possible implementation, the evidence further includes metadata of the trusted party and / or a signature of the trusted party; the metadata of the trusted party includes any one or more of an identifier of the trusted party, a timestamp, a version number of the evidence, or a Merkle root;
[0040] Among them, the timestamp indicates the time when the trusted party generated the evidence; the Merkle root is generated by the trusted party based on the statement included in the evidence; the signature of the trusted party refers to the signature of the trusted party on the statement in the evidence and the metadata of the trusted party.
[0041] In one possible implementation, the statement list in the above-mentioned evidence request also includes indication information corresponding to each statement name, wherein the indication information corresponding to the first statement name indicates to the trusted party whether the statement corresponding to the first statement name must be provided.
[0042] In a possible implementation, before the trusted party receives the evidence request sent by the TLA, the process further includes: the trusted party sends the trust level assessment request to the TLA; wherein the trust level assessment request may include one or more TLA file numbers, for instructing the TLA to select a TLA file from the TLA files corresponding to the one or more TLA file numbers to perform a trust assessment on the trusted party; the trust level assessment request may also not include a TLA file number, in which case the TLA uses a default TLA file to perform a trust assessment on the trusted party.
[0043] In a possible implementation, after obtaining the above evidence, the trusted party further submits the evidence to an evidence storage center, and receives an evidence certification number returned by the evidence storage center to the trusted party.
[0044] In a possible implementation, the above evidence is carried in an evidence response sent by the trusted party to the TLA, and the evidence response also includes the above evidence certification number.
[0045] In one possible implementation, after the trusted party receives the trusted level obtained by the TLA through trust evaluation of the trusted party, the trusted party may also send an update request to the TLA, instructing the TLA to re-evaluate the trust of the trusted party. The trusted party may send an update request to the TLA if, for example, the trusted party's trust level evaluation certificate expires, one or more of the trusted party's declarations change, or a security incident occurs.
[0046] In a third aspect, the present application provides a trust evaluation system, including a TLA and a trusted party, wherein:
[0047] The TLA is configured to send an evidence request to a trusted party, the evidence request including a claim name included in the claim list in the first TLA file, and instructing the trusted party to submit a claim corresponding to the claim name included in the claim list in the first TLA file;
[0048] The trusted party is configured to encapsulate the statement corresponding to the statement name into evidence; wherein the evidence includes one or more statements of the trusted party;
[0049] The TLA is further configured to perform a trust evaluation on a trusted party based on a first TLA file and evidence to obtain a trust level of the trusted party; wherein the first TLA file includes multiple trust levels and an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level, and the evaluation model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results of one or more statements required by the first trust level. The first trust level is one of the one or more trust levels.
[0050] The operations performed by the TLA in the above-mentioned trust evaluation system may refer to the operations performed by the TLA in the above-mentioned first aspect or any possible implementation of the first aspect; the operations performed by the trusted party in the above-mentioned trust evaluation system may refer to the operations performed by the trusted party in the above-mentioned second aspect or any possible implementation of the second aspect.
[0051] In a fourth aspect, the present application provides a trust assessment device, which is configured to implement the operations implemented by the TLA in the first aspect or any possible implementation of the first aspect; the trust assessment device includes:
[0052] a communication module, configured to receive evidence submitted by a trusted party, the evidence including one or more statements, the one or more statements being used to describe relevant information of the trusted party;
[0053] A processing module is configured to perform a trust evaluation on a trusted party based on a first trust level evaluation TLA file and evidence to obtain a trust level of the trusted party; wherein the first TLA file includes multiple trust levels and an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level, the evaluation model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results of one or more statements required by the first trust level, and the first trust level is one of the above multiple trust levels.
[0054] In a possible implementation, before the processing module performs a trust evaluation on the trusted party based on the TLA file and the evidence, the processing module further includes:
[0055] The communication module is further configured to receive a trust level assessment request, the trust level assessment request including an identifier of a trusted party, the trust level assessment request instructing a trust assessment to be performed on the trusted party; then send an evidence request to the trusted party, the evidence request including a declaration name included in the declaration list in the above-mentioned first TLA file, for instructing the trusted party to submit a declaration corresponding to the declaration name included in the declaration list in the first TLA file; and after the TLA receives an evidence response including the above-mentioned evidence returned by the trusted party, perform a trust assessment on the trusted party based on the evidence.
[0056] In a possible implementation, the TLA stores one or more TLA files and a usage policy for the TLA files, where the usage policy indicates a default TLA file and a priority of each TLA file.
[0057] In a possible implementation, the trust level evaluation request includes one or more TLA profile numbers, which are used to instruct the TLA to select a TLA profile from TLA profiles corresponding to the one or more TLA profile numbers to perform trust evaluation on the trusted party.
[0058] In a possible implementation, when the trust level assessment request includes one or more TLA profile numbers, the processing module is further configured to select, based on the priority of each TLA profile, a TLA profile with the highest priority from the TLA profiles corresponding to the one or more TLA profile numbers as the first TLA profile.
[0059] In a possible implementation, when the trust level evaluation request does not include a TLA profile number, the processing module is further configured to select a default TLA profile as the first TLA profile.
[0060] In one possible implementation, after the processing module obtains the trust level of the trusted party and feeds back the trust level of the trusted party to the party that sent the trust level assessment request via the communication module, the communication module may also receive an update request, and the processing module is further configured to re-evaluate the trust of the trusted party based on the update request; wherein the update request includes the identifier of the trusted party. The processing module then re-evaluates the trust of the trusted party according to the aforementioned process.
[0061] In a fifth aspect, the present application provides a trust assessment device, which is configured to implement the operations implemented by the trusted party in the second aspect or any possible implementation of the second aspect, including:
[0062] a receiving module configured to receive an evidence request sent by a trust level assessor TLA, the evidence request including a statement name included in a statement list in a first trust level assessment TLA file, the statement name instructing the trusted party to submit a statement corresponding to the statement name, the statement corresponding to the statement name being used to describe relevant information of the trusted party;
[0063] a processing module, configured to encapsulate a statement corresponding to the statement name into evidence; wherein the evidence includes one or more statements of the trusted party;
[0064] a sending module, configured to send the evidence to a TLA, so that the TLA performs a trust assessment on the trustee based on the evidence and a first TLA profile to obtain a trust level of the trustee; wherein the first TLA profile includes multiple trust levels and an assessment model corresponding to each trust level, the assessment model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results of one or more statements required by the first trust level, and the first trust level is one of the multiple trust levels.
[0065] In one possible implementation, the evidence further includes metadata of the trusted party and / or a signature of the trusted party; the metadata of the trusted party includes any one or more of an identifier of the trusted party, a timestamp, a version number of the evidence, or a Merkle root;
[0066] Among them, the timestamp indicates the time when the trusted party generated the evidence; the Merkle root is generated by the trusted party based on the statement included in the evidence; the signature of the trusted party refers to the signature of the trusted party on the statement in the evidence and the metadata of the trusted party.
[0067] In one possible implementation, the statement list in the above-mentioned evidence request also includes indication information corresponding to each statement name, wherein the indication information corresponding to the first statement name indicates to the trusted party whether the statement corresponding to the first statement name must be provided.
[0068] In a possible implementation, before the receiving module receives the evidence request sent by the TLA, the sending module is further configured to send the trust level assessment request to the TLA; wherein the trust level assessment request may include one or more TLA file numbers, for instructing the TLA to select a TLA file from the TLA files corresponding to the one or more TLA file numbers to perform a trust assessment on the trusted party; the trust level assessment request may also not include a TLA file number, in which case the TLA uses a default TLA file to perform a trust assessment on the trusted party.
[0069] In a possible implementation, after the processing module obtains the above evidence, the sending module is further used to submit the evidence to the evidence storage center; the receiving module is further used to receive an evidence certification number that the evidence storage center will return to the trusted party.
[0070] In a possible implementation, the above evidence is carried in an evidence response sent by the trusted party to the TLA, and the evidence response also includes the above evidence certification number.
[0071] In one possible implementation, after the receiving module receives the trust level of the trusted party obtained by the TLA after performing a trust assessment on the trusted party, the sending module is further configured to send an update request to the TLA, instructing the TLA to re-evaluate the trust of the trusted party. The trusted party may send an update request to the TLA if, for example, the trusted party's trust level assessment certificate expires, one or more of the trusted party's claims change, or a security incident occurs with the trusted party.
[0072] In a sixth aspect, the present application provides a computing device comprising a processor and a memory, wherein the memory is used to store instructions, and the processor is used to execute the instructions. When the processor executes the instructions, the method described in the first aspect or any possible implementation of the first aspect is implemented.
[0073] In the seventh aspect, the present application provides a network device comprising a processor and a memory, wherein the memory is used to store instructions, and the processor is used to execute the instructions. When the processor executes the instructions, it implements the method described in the above-mentioned second aspect or any possible implementation method of the second aspect.
[0074] In an eighth aspect, the present application provides a computer-readable storage medium, characterized in that it includes computer program instructions. When the computer program instructions are executed by a computing device, the computing device implements the method described in the above-mentioned first aspect or any possible implementation of the first aspect.
[0075] In the ninth aspect, the present application provides a computer-readable storage medium, characterized in that it includes computer program instructions. When the computer program instructions are executed by a computing device, the computing device implements the method described in the above-mentioned second aspect or any possible implementation of the second aspect.
[0076] In a tenth aspect, the present application provides a computer program product, which, when running on a server, enables the server to execute the method described in the first aspect or any possible implementation of the first aspect.
[0077] In an eleventh aspect, the present application provides a computer program product, which, when running on a network device, enables a server to execute the method described in the second aspect or any possible implementation of the second aspect. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0078] In order to more clearly illustrate the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present application, the following is a brief introduction to the drawings required for use in the description of the embodiments. Obviously, the drawings described below are some embodiments of the present application. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without any creative work.
[0079] FIG1 is a schematic diagram of a trust evaluation system provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0080] FIG2 is a schematic diagram of a trust level assessment file provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0081] FIG3 is a schematic diagram of another trust level assessment file provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0082] FIG4 is a schematic diagram of a trust level evaluation certificate provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0083] FIG5 is an interactive diagram of a trust evaluation method provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0084] FIG6 is a schematic diagram of a trust assessment device provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0085] FIG7 is a schematic diagram of another trust assessment device provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0086] FIG8 is a schematic diagram of a computing device provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0087] FIG9 is a schematic diagram of a network device provided in an embodiment of the present application. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0088] The technical solution in this application will be described below with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0089] In recent years, with the rapid development of technologies such as mobile internet, big data, and AI, network infrastructure, including mobile communication networks and the internet, has assumed immense social and economic value. As the value of networks grows, cybersecurity has also assumed immense importance, becoming a crucial component of national security.
[0090] The fifth-generation mobile communication system (5G) adopts a brand-new service-based architecture (SBA), introducing new technologies such as network function virtualization, network slicing, and edge computing. More services are migrating to the cloud, breaking down traditional network boundaries. The open architecture, the introduction of new technologies, and the convergence of cloud and network have made network security risks more complex. In the upcoming 6G era, cloud and network convergence will be further enhanced, the service-oriented concept will continue to deepen, and the integration of air, land, and sea will be achieved. Due to the evolution of various architectures, traditional plug-in and patch-based security mechanisms are unable to effectively support the security and trustworthiness of the huge amount of services and traffic carried by next-generation networks. Therefore, it is imperative to integrate security and trustworthiness concepts into the network architecture during the design phase to create a natively trusted next-generation network.
[0091] Trust is a complex concept characterized by subjectivity, contextuality, and dynamism. Therefore, accurately assessing the trustworthiness or trust level of an object (device, service, etc.) is a crucial issue for next-generation networks. The primary challenge lies in the distributed, heterogeneous nature of future networks, with numerous stakeholders involved in the ecosystem, making it difficult to reach a consensus on trust assessment models. Furthermore, achieving interoperable trust level assessment across carriers and domains remains a challenge. Therefore, designing a scalable, interoperable, and flexible trust level assessment framework to ensure network security and trustworthiness has become a pressing issue.
[0092] The present application provides a trust evaluation system, as shown in Figure 1, which is a schematic diagram of a trust evaluation system provided by an embodiment of the present application. The trust evaluation system includes a trust level assessor (TLA) and a trustee. The TLA is used to obtain evidence submitted by the trustee from the trustee, and perform a trust evaluation on the trustee based on the evidence to obtain the trust level of the trustee, and then send the trust level of the trustee to the party requesting the trust evaluation of the trustee or the above-mentioned trustee. The above-mentioned evidence includes one or more statements, each statement is used to describe relevant information of the trustee, such as the software integrity, protocol status, cryptographic algorithm, etc. of the trustee.
[0093] The trusted party generates the above evidence and sends it to the TLA, which then evaluates the trusted party's trust level based on the evidence submitted by the trusted party. The TLA is typically a computing device, such as a server, while the trusted party is typically a network device, such as a switch, router, wireless base station, or core network virtualized network function.
[0094] Optionally, the trust assessment system may further include a trustor, configured to establish a connection with a trusted party based on the trusted party's trust level. After obtaining the trusted party's trust level, the TLA may send the trusted party's trust level to the trustor. The trustor may be a network device, a network controller, or a network management system, among others. The network controller may be a software defined network (SDN) controller, a path computation element (PCE), or the like.
[0095] Optionally, the above-mentioned trust assessment system also includes a TLA owner, which is used to issue a trust level assessment profile (TLA profile) and usage policy to the TLA. The TLA profile includes a trust level assessment model for trust assessment. The TLA performs trust assessment on the trustee based on a TLA profile. The usage policy refers to the policy of selecting the TLA profile when the TLA performs trust assessment. The owner of the TLA is the owner of the network where the TLA and the trustee are located. Among them, the TLA owner is generally an enterprise or organization, such as an operator. The TLA owner issues the above-mentioned TLA profile and usage policy to the TLA through a computing device. In the embodiment of the present application, for the convenience of description, the TLA owner is used to represent the computing device used by the TLA owner. The TLA profile and usage policy will be introduced later and will not be described in detail here.
[0096] Optionally, the trust evaluation system further includes a third party, which is used to provide the TLA owner with third-party endorsement, third-party certification, etc. of the trusted party. The third party is usually the manufacturer of the trusted party.
[0097] In an embodiment of the present application, after receiving a trust level assessment request for performing a trust assessment on a trusted party, the TLA obtains evidence submitted by the trusted party, which includes one or more claims, and then performs a trust assessment on the trusted party based on a first TLA profile and the one or more claims submitted by the trusted party to obtain the trust level of the trusted party. The first TLA profile includes multiple trust levels and an assessment model corresponding to each trust level, and the assessment model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results of one or more claims required by the first trust level. The first trust level is one of the multiple trust levels. It should be understood that the TLA stores one or more TLA archives, and the first TLA archive is one of the one or more TLA archives.
[0098] The above-mentioned trust level (TL) is used to describe the degree of trust that a subject (such as the above-mentioned trusting party) has in an object (such as the above-mentioned trusted party). In the embodiment of the present application, the trust level is divided into five levels, namely untrusted, minimally trusted, moderately trusted, highly trusted, and fully trusted. For the convenience of description, the embodiment of the present application uses TL0 to TL4 to correspond to the above-mentioned five trust levels, that is, TL0 corresponds to untrusted, TL1 corresponds to minimally trusted, TL2 corresponds to moderately trusted, TL3 corresponds to highly trusted, and TL4 corresponds to fully trusted. It should be understood that the above-mentioned division of trust levels is only an example and cannot be understood as a specific limitation. The trust level can also include fewer or more levels, and the embodiment of the present application does not make specific limitations.
[0099] In an embodiment of the present application, a TLA profile (including the first TLA profile described above) includes multiple trust levels and an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level. The evaluation model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results for one or more claims required by the first trust level, wherein the first trust level is one of the multiple trust levels described above. That is, the evaluation model corresponding to a trust level includes verification results corresponding to one or more claims. When a claim submitted by a trusted party meets the verification results required by each claim included in a trust level (e.g., TL2), the trust level of the trusted party is TL2. The verification results include affirmed, partially affirmed, or violated.
[0100] As shown in FIG2 , FIG2 is a schematic diagram of a trust level assessment file provided in an embodiment of the present application.
[0101] The TLA profile includes a trust level list and a trust level evaluation model. The trust level list includes the above-mentioned multiple trust levels, indicating the trust levels that may appear in the evaluation results when the TLA adopts the TLA profile for trust evaluation. Figure 2 takes 5 levels TL0 to TL4 as an example. The trust level evaluation model includes an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level. The evaluation model corresponding to a trust level includes the verification results of one or more statements required by the trust level. Among them, the verification results include confirmed, partially confirmed or violated, indicating the possible results of a statement when the TLA verifies a statement. It should be understood that Figure 2 only shows the format of the trust level evaluation model. For a certain TLA profile, the verification result of each statement requirement in the evaluation model corresponding to each trust level is determined.
[0102] For example, if the claims corresponding to the evaluation model in a TLA profile include four items, claim 1 to claim 4, the evaluation model corresponding to TL0 is as follows.
[0103] The TL0 evaluation model described above indicates that when a trustee is evaluated using the TLA profile, if, among the statements provided by the trusted party, the verification result of statement 1 is "compliant", the verification result of statement 2 is "compliant", the verification result of statement 3 is "partially compliant", and the verification result of statement 4 is "non-compliant", then the trust level of the trusted party is determined to be TL0.
[0104] The TLA profile also includes a claim list, which includes one or more claim names indicating claims that the trusted party needs to provide when using the TLA profile to perform a trust assessment on the trusted party. In this embodiment of the present application, the claim name includes any one or more of the trusted party's identity, software integrity, hardware integrity, protocol status, interface status, security protocol, cryptographic algorithm, or key length.
[0105] In a possible implementation, the above-mentioned declaration list also includes indication information corresponding to each declaration name, wherein the indication information corresponding to a declaration name indicates whether the declaration corresponding to the declaration name is mandatory or optional when a trust evaluation is performed through the TLA profile. If the indication information corresponding to a declaration name is "mandatory", it means that when the TLA profile is used to perform a trust evaluation, the trusted party must provide the declaration corresponding to the declaration name; if the indication information corresponding to a declaration name is "optional", it means that when the TLA profile is used to perform a trust evaluation, the trusted party may provide the declaration corresponding to the declaration name or may not provide the declaration corresponding to the declaration name. It should be understood that FIG2 only shows the format of the declaration list. For a certain TLA profile, whether the declaration corresponding to each declaration name is mandatory or optional is determined.
[0106] For example, if a TLA profile declaration list is as follows.
[0107] This means that when trust evaluation is performed using this TLA profile, the trusted party must provide a statement corresponding to claim name 1, a statement corresponding to claim name 2, and a statement corresponding to claim name 4. It may or may not provide a statement corresponding to claim name 3.
[0108] It should be noted that if the declaration list does not include indication information corresponding to the declaration name, it means that the declaration corresponding to each declaration name in the declaration list must be provided.
[0109] As shown in Figure 3, Figure 3 is a schematic diagram of another trust level assessment profile provided in an embodiment of the present application. The TLA profile also includes metadata of the TLA profile. The metadata includes any one or more of a publisher identifier, a TLA profile number, a version number, or a validity period.
[0110] The publisher identifier indicates the publisher of the TLA profile and is used to uniquely identify the publisher of a TLA profile; the TLA profile number is used to uniquely identify a TLA profile; and the validity period indicates the validity period of the TLA profile. It should be understood that the validity period can be a point in time, indicating that the TLA profile can be used for trust assessment before the point in time; the validity period can also be a time period, indicating that the TLA profile can be used for trust assessment during the period indicated by the time period. The metadata of the TLA profile may also include other data, such as a publication address, which indicates the address where the publisher published the TLA profile. The publication address can be a uniform resource locator (URL).
[0111] In a possible implementation, the TLA profile further includes any one or more of applicable country or region, applicable device type, extended field, or publisher signature.
[0112] Among them, the applicable country or region indicates the country or region to which the TLA profile is applicable; the applicable device type indicates the type of device to which the TLA profile is applicable, that is, the trust level of which type of device can be evaluated by the TLA profile; the applicable device types include routers, wireless base stations, core network virtualized network functions, etc.; the publisher signature includes the signature of the publisher of the TLA profile using the private key to sign the TLA profile.
[0113] It should be understood that the above TLA may also include other information, such as a public key certificate, which is used to indicate the public key certificate corresponding to the private key used by the publisher of the TLA profile.
[0114] In an embodiment of the present application, before the TLA performs a trust evaluation on the trusted party, the TLA will send an evidence request to the trusted party, and the evidence request is used to instruct the trusted party to provide evidence for the trust evaluation. The above-mentioned evidence request includes one or more declaration names, and the one or more declaration names are the declaration names included in the declaration list in the TLA profile used by the TLA to perform the trust evaluation on the trusted party. It should be noted that if the declaration list in the TLA profile includes indication information corresponding to each declaration name, the above-mentioned evidence request also includes indication information corresponding to each declaration name. That is, the evidence request includes the declaration list in the first TLA profile used by the TLA to perform the trust evaluation on the trusted party.
[0115] Optionally, the above-mentioned evidence request also includes an identifier (ID) of the trusted party.
[0116] Optionally, the evidence request may further include a TLA profile number of a TLA profile used by the TLD, which is used to indicate the TLA profile used by the TLA to perform trust evaluation on the trusted party.
[0117] Optionally, the evidence request further includes a random number (nonce) generated by the TLA to prevent replay attacks.
[0118] After receiving the above-mentioned evidence request, the trusted party will return an evidence response to the TLA. The evidence response carries evidence, which includes the statements provided by the trusted party based on the proof list included in the evidence request. It should be understood that if each statement name in the statement list in the evidence request corresponds to an indication information, then if the indication information corresponding to a statement name is "optional", the trusted party may provide the statement corresponding to the statement name, or may not provide the statement corresponding to the statement name. In other words, the number of statements submitted by the trusted party may be less than the number of statement names included in the statement list in the evidence request.
[0119] In one possible implementation, the evidence may further include metadata of the trusted party, including any one or more of an identifier of the trusted party, a timestamp, a version number of the evidence, and a Merkle root.
[0120] The timestamp indicates the time when the trusted party generated the evidence, and the merkleroot is generated by the trusted party based on the various statements provided to the TLA. It can be used by the TLA to confirm the integrity and correctness of the evidence and prevent the evidence from being tampered with.
[0121] In a possible implementation, the above evidence may also include a signature, which is the signature of the trusted party on the submitted statement and metadata.
[0122] Optionally, in the case where the evidence request includes the TLA profile number, the evidence response also includes the TLA profile number.
[0123] Optionally, after generating the above evidence, the trusted party can also submit the evidence to a registry, where the registry is a central repository for evidence, such as a blockchain or logging system. The registry will return a proof number to the trusted party, which ensures transparency and prevents tampering and repudiation. If the trusted party submits the evidence to the registry and obtains a proof number, the evidence response will also include the proof number obtained by the trusted party.
[0124] The TLA performs a trust assessment on the recipient based on the received evidence response, obtaining an assessment result (i.e., the recipient's trust level) and generating a Trust Level Assessment (TLA) certificate based on the assessment result. The TLA certificate includes the recipient's trust level and a TLA profile number, which indicates the TLA profile used by the TLA to perform the trust assessment on the recipient.
[0125] In one possible implementation, as shown in FIG4 , which is a schematic diagram of a trust level assessment certificate provided in an embodiment of the present application, any one or more of the version number, serial number, signature algorithm identifier, TLA name, validity period, trusted party name, TLA public key information, TLA identifier, trusted party identifier, evidence proof number, Merkle root, or TLA signature of the TLA certificate may be included.
[0126] The version number indicates the version of the certificate; the serial number is used to uniquely identify the trust level evaluation certificate of the trusted party;
[0127] The signature algorithm identifier indicates the signature algorithm used by the TLA to sign the trust level evaluation certificate; the name of the TLA indicates the name of the issuer of the TLA certificate; the validity period indicates the validity period of the TLA certificate; the name of the trusted party indicates the trust level in the TLA certificate is the trust level of which trusted party; the public key information of the TLA includes the information of the public key corresponding to the private key used by the TLA; the signature of the TLA refers to the signature of the TLA on the content of the TLA certificate.
[0128] It should be noted that the evidence proof number and Merkle root in the TLA certificate are submitted by the trusted party. If the evidence response submitted by the trusted party includes the evidence proof number, the TLA certificate includes the evidence proof number submitted by the trusted party. If the evidence response submitted by the trusted party includes the Merkle root, the TLA certificate includes the Merkle root submitted by the trusted party.
[0129] It should be understood that the TLA certificate may also include more information, such as the subject name of the certificate, that is, the name of the trusted party, and this embodiment of the present application does not impose any specific limitation.
[0130] The fields included in the TLA certificate and the functions of each field are shown in Table 1. The trust level, TLA profile number, evidence number, and Merkle root in the TLA certificate are located in the extensions field of the TLA certificate.
[0131] Table 1
[0132] By using certificates to carry the trust level, the authenticity and immutability of the trust assessment results can be guaranteed. By adding the TLA profile number used for the assessment to the certificate and binding the trust assessment result to the corresponding TLA profile, the user of the trust level assessment result (such as the trustee) can query the specific method used for the trust assessment and then decide whether to establish a connection with the trustee.
[0133] The following describes a method for performing trust evaluation on a trusted party based on the TLA profile and TLA certificate provided by this application, in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. As shown in FIG5 , FIG5 is an interactive diagram of a trust evaluation method provided by an embodiment of this application. The trust evaluation method includes S501 to S507.
[0134] S501. The TLA owner sends a usage policy of the trust level assessment file to the TLA.
[0135] In this embodiment of the present application, the aforementioned usage policy includes a TLA list and priority information. The TLA list includes the TLA profile numbers corresponding to the TLA profiles that the TLA can use for trust assessment; the priority information includes the priority of each TLA profile. The format and related description of the TLA profile can be found in the description of Figures 2 or 3 above and are not further detailed here.
[0136] In one possible implementation, the usage policy further includes a default TLA profile number. The method for selecting a TLA profile for trust evaluation based on the usage policy will be described later and will not be repeated here.
[0137] S502. The TLA receives a trust level assessment request.
[0138] The above-mentioned trust level assessment request (TLA request) includes the identifier (ID) of the trusted party, which is used to instruct the trusted party to conduct a trust assessment on the trusted party. The sender of the trust level assessment request can be the trusted party or the trusting party. For example, the trusted party needs to establish a connection with the trusting party. Before the trusted party sends a request to establish a connection to the trusting party, the trusted party sends a trust level assessment request to the TLA; or, the trusted party requests to establish a connection with the trusting party. After receiving the request, the trusting party initiates a trust assessment on the trusted party to the TLA and sends the above-mentioned trust level assessment request to the TLA.
[0139] In a possible implementation, the trust level evaluation request may further include an available TLA list, where the available TLA list includes one or more TLA profile numbers, for instructing the TLA to select a TLA profile from the available TLA list to perform trust evaluation on the trusted party.
[0140] The TLA profile numbers included in the available TLA list may be part or all of the TLA list; the TLA profile numbers included in the available TLA list may be determined after negotiation between the trusted party and the TLA, or may be determined after negotiation among the trusted party, the TLA, and the trustor, and the embodiments of the present application do not specifically limit this.
[0141] S503. The TLA generates an evidence request according to the trust level assessment request.
[0142] After receiving the trust level assessment request, the TLA determines to use the first TLA profile to conduct a trust assessment on the trusted party and generates an evidence request based on the first TLA profile. After confirming the first TLA profile, the TLA obtains a list of claims in the first TLA profile and includes this list in the evidence request, indicating which claims the trusted party needs to provide to the TLA.
[0143] Optionally, the above-mentioned evidence request also includes an identifier (ID) of the trusted party.
[0144] Optionally, the evidence request may further include a first TLA profile number, that is, a number corresponding to a first TLA profile used by the TLA, which is used to indicate the TLA profile used by the TLA to perform trust evaluation on the trusted party.
[0145] Optionally, the evidence request further includes a random number (nonce) generated by the TLA to prevent replay attacks.
[0146] The following describes a method for TLA to determine the first TLA profile.
[0147] In one possible implementation, if the trust level assessment request does not include the available TLA list, the TLA selects a TLA profile with the highest priority from among the TLA profiles in the TLA list as the first TLA profile for trust assessment on the trusted party. If the usage policy includes a default TLA profile number, the TLA selects the TLA profile corresponding to the default TLA profile number as the first TLA profile for trust assessment on the trusted party.
[0148] In a possible implementation, if the trust level evaluation request includes the available TLA list, the TLA selects a TLA profile with the highest priority from the TLA profiles corresponding to the available TLA list as a first TLA profile for trust evaluation of the trusted party.
[0149] If the TLA does not have a corresponding TLA profile in the TLA list or available TLA list, the TLA sends a profile retrieval request to the TLA owner, including the TLA list or available TLA list. Upon receiving the profile retrieval request, the TLA owner searches for the corresponding TLA profile based on the TLA profile number in the TLA list or available TLA list in the profile retrieval request and then sends the TLA profile to the TLA.
[0150] S504. The TLA sends the evidence request to the trusted party.
[0151] S505. After receiving the evidence request, the trusted party generates an evidence response according to the evidence request.
[0152] After receiving the evidence request, the trusted party parses the evidence request to obtain the declaration list in the evidence request, and generates declarations corresponding to each declaration name based on one or more declaration names in the declaration list. It should be understood that if each declaration name in the declaration list in the evidence request corresponds to instruction information, then if the instruction information corresponding to a declaration name is "optional", the trusted party may provide the declaration corresponding to the declaration name, or may not provide the declaration corresponding to the declaration name. That is, the number of declarations submitted by the trusted party may be less than the number of declaration names included in the declaration list in the evidence request.
[0153] After generating a statement corresponding to each statement name based on the statement list, the trusted party encapsulates the statement into evidence and then generates an evidence response that includes the evidence and sends it to the TLA. The content of the evidence response and the evidence can be found in the description of the above embodiments and will not be repeated here.
[0154] S506. The trusted party sends an evidence response to the TLA.
[0155] S507. The TLA performs a trust evaluation on the trusted party based on the evidence response, obtains an evaluation result, and generates a TLA certificate based on the evaluation result.
[0156] After receiving the evidence response from the trusted party, the TLA obtains the claims in the evidence response and, based on the claims in the evidence response and the trust level assessment model in the first TLA profile, performs a trust assessment on the trusted party to determine the trusted party's trust level. Specifically, the TLA verifies each claim provided by the trusted party and determines the verification result corresponding to each claim, i.e., whether the verification result for each claim is confirmed (affirmed), partially confirmed (partially affirmed), or violated (violated). Based on the verification results corresponding to each claim and the verification results for each claim requirement in the assessment model corresponding to each trust level, the TLA confirms the trusted party's trust level (i.e., the aforementioned assessment result).
[0157] For example, if the claims corresponding to the evaluation model in the first TLA profile include four items, claim 1 to claim 4, the evaluation model corresponding to TL2 is as follows.
[0158] If, in the evidence provided by the trusted party, the TLA determines that the verification result of Statement 1 is "Compliance", the verification result of Statement 2 is "Compliance", the verification result of Statement 3 is "Compliance", and the verification result of Statement 4 is "Partial Compliance", then the trust level of the trusted party is determined to be TL2.
[0159] After obtaining the assessment result, i.e., the trust level of the trusted party, the TLA generates a trust level assessment (TLA) certificate based on the assessment result. The format of the TLA certificate and the meaning of each field can be referred to the above description of the TLA certificate and will not be repeated here.
[0160] After generating the TLA certificate, the TLA sends it to the sender of the trust level evaluation request. For example, if the trust level evaluation list is sent to the TLA by the trustee, the TLA sends the TLA certificate to the trustee so that the trustee can use the TLA certificate to establish a connection with the trustor.
[0161] In one possible implementation, after receiving a trust level assessment request for a trusted party, the TLA may also send a third-party evidence acquisition request to the TLA owner. This third-party evidence acquisition request includes the trusted party's identifier and is used to request the TLA to obtain a third-party endorsement, third-party certification, etc. provided by a third party to the TLA owner. After receiving this third-party evidence acquisition request, the TLA owner sends the third-party endorsement, third-party certification, etc. provided by the third party to the TLA owner to the TLA. The TLA performs a trust assessment on the trusted party based on the evidence response and the third-party endorsement, third-party certification, etc.
[0162] In a possible implementation, after sending the TLA to the trusted party, the TLA may further receive an update request, where the update request includes the trusted party's identifier and is used to request the TLA to re-evaluate the trust of the trusted party.
[0163] Optionally, the update request also includes the original TLA certificate or the certificate serial number of the original TLA certificate.
[0164] Optionally, the update request further includes the available TLA list as described in S502 above, where the available TLA list includes one or more TLA profile numbers, for instructing the TLA to select a TLA profile from the available TLA list to perform trust evaluation on the trusted party.
[0165] Optionally, the update request may further include an update reason field, which indicates the reason for updating the trusted party's TLA certificate. Different values in the update reason field indicate different update reasons. Examples of update reasons include expiration of the original TLA certificate, a change in the trusted party's configuration resulting in a change in the declaration, detection of a security incident by the trusted party (e.g., a distributed denial of service (DDoS) attack), a change in the TLA policy or an update to the TLA profile, or abnormal behavior by the trusted party. Examples of abnormal behavior by the trusted party include a high packet loss rate or detection of a disconnection by the trusted party's neighboring nodes.
[0166] This application provides a TLA profile for trust level assessment, as well as a trust assessment system and assessment method based on the TLA profile. These can be used for trust assessment of network devices in different network scenarios, such as base stations and gateways in communication networks, switches, routers, and other devices in the Internet, data center networks, or campus networks. This solves the problem of the inability to unify trust level assessment models for different scenarios in heterogeneous networks, while avoiding the problem of difficulty in cross-domain and cross-scenario interoperability caused by the use of non-standard and customized models. On the premise of achieving a certain industry consensus, this application can provide a trust level assessment method with certain flexibility and interoperability to ensure network security and reliability. At the same time, this application provides a certificate that carries the trust assessment result, that is, a certificate that carries the trust level, and uses the certificate to ensure the authenticity and non-tamperability of the trust assessment result.
[0167] The trust assessment method provided in this application can also be used to classify the trust of network devices in the network and construct end-to-end paths of different trust levels to meet the network security requirements of different services or different traffic flows. For example, in the above embodiment, the trust levels are divided into five levels. If the data of a service requires the transmission of a network device with a medium trust level (TL2), the data can only be transmitted through network devices with a trust level of TL2 or above.
[0168] It should be noted that the contents included in the TLA profile and the contents included in the TLA certificate described in the above embodiments are all preferred embodiments. Other reasonable contents that can be conceived by those skilled in the art based on the above description also fall within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0169] For the sake of simplicity, the above method embodiments are described as a series of action combinations. However, those skilled in the art should be aware that the present invention is not limited to the order of the actions described. Secondly, those skilled in the art should also be aware that the embodiments described in the specification are preferred embodiments, and the actions involved are not necessarily required by the present invention. Other reasonable step combinations that can be conceived by those skilled in the art based on the above description also fall within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0170] The trust assessment method provided by the present application is described in detail above with reference to the accompanying drawings. The apparatus and related equipment provided by the embodiments of the present application will be described below with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0171] The present application provides a trust level evaluation device, as shown in FIG6 , which is a schematic diagram of a trust evaluation device provided by an embodiment of the present application. The trust evaluation device is used to implement the operations implemented by TLA in the above-mentioned trust evaluation system; the trust evaluation device 600 includes a communication module 610 and a processing module 620.
[0172] The communication module 610 is used to receive evidence submitted by the trusted party, where the evidence includes one or more statements, and the one or more statements are used to describe relevant information of the trusted party; the processing module 620 is used to perform a trust evaluation on the trusted party based on the first trust level evaluation TLA file and the evidence to obtain the trust level of the trusted party; wherein the first TLA file includes multiple trust levels and an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level, wherein the evaluation model corresponding to the first trust level includes the verification results of one or more statements required by the first trust level, and the first trust level is one of the above-mentioned multiple trust levels.
[0173] In one possible implementation, before the processing module 620 performs a trust evaluation on the trusted party based on the TLA file and evidence, the communication module 610 is further used to receive a trust level evaluation request, where the trust level evaluation request includes the identifier of the trusted party, and the trust level evaluation request indicates that a trust evaluation is to be performed on the trusted party; then, an evidence request is sent to the trusted party, where the evidence request includes the declaration name included in the declaration list in the above-mentioned first TLA file, and is used to instruct the trusted party to submit a declaration corresponding to the declaration name included in the declaration list in the first TLA file; after the TLA receives the evidence response returned by the trusted party including the above-mentioned evidence, the trust evaluation is performed on the trusted party based on the evidence.
[0174] In a possible implementation, when the trust level evaluation request includes one or more TLA profile numbers, the processing module 620 is further configured to select, based on the priority of each TLA profile, a TLA profile with the highest priority from the TLA profiles corresponding to the one or more TLA profile numbers as the first TLA profile.
[0175] In a possible implementation, when the trust level evaluation request does not include a TLA profile number, the processing module 620 is further configured to select a default TLA profile as the first TLA profile.
[0176] In one possible implementation, after processing module 620 obtains the trust level of the trusted party and feeds back the trust level of the trusted party to the party that sent the trust level evaluation request via communication module 610, communication module 610 may also receive an update request. Processing module 620 is then further configured to re-evaluate the trust of the trusted party based on the update request, wherein the update request includes the identifier of the trusted party. The processing module then re-evaluates the trust of the trusted party according to the aforementioned process.
[0177] Specifically, the operations implemented by the communication module 610 in the trust evaluation device 600 may refer to the sending and receiving operations of the TLA in the above method embodiment; the operations implemented by the processing module 620 may refer to the trust evaluation operations of the TLA in the above method embodiment, which will not be repeated here.
[0178] The present application also provides another trust level evaluation device, as shown in FIG7 , which is a schematic diagram of another trust evaluation device provided by an embodiment of the present application. The trust evaluation device is used to implement the operations implemented by the trusted party in the above-mentioned trust evaluation system; the trust evaluation device 700 includes a receiving module 710, a processing module 720 and a sending module 730.
[0179] The receiving module 710 is used to receive an evidence request sent by the trust level evaluator TLA, where the evidence request includes a declaration name included in a declaration list in a first trust level evaluation TLA file, where the declaration name instructs the trusted party to submit a declaration corresponding to the declaration name, where the declaration corresponding to the declaration name is used to describe the relevant information of the trusted party; the processing module 720 is used to encapsulate the declaration corresponding to the declaration name into evidence; wherein the evidence includes one or more statements of the trusted party; the sending module 730 is used to send the above evidence to the TLA, so that the TLA performs a trust evaluation on the trusted party based on the evidence and the first TLA file to obtain the trust level of the trusted party; wherein the above first TLA file includes multiple trust levels and an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level, and the evaluation model corresponding to a trust level includes the verification results of one or more statements required by the trust level.
[0180] In a possible implementation, before the receiving module 710 receives the evidence request sent by the TLA, the sending module 730 is further configured to send the trust level assessment request to the TLA; wherein the trust level assessment request may include one or more TLA file numbers, for instructing the TLA to select a TLA file from the TLA files corresponding to the one or more TLA file numbers to perform a trust assessment on the trusted party; the trust level assessment request may also not include a TLA file number, in which case the TLA uses a default TLA file to perform a trust assessment on the trusted party.
[0181] In one possible implementation, after processing module 720 obtains the evidence, sending module 730 is further configured to submit the evidence to an evidence storage center. Receiving module 710 is further configured to receive an evidence certification number, which the evidence storage center will return to the trusted party. In one possible implementation, the evidence is included in an evidence response sent to the TLA, which also includes the evidence certification number.
[0182] In one possible implementation, after the receiving module 710 receives the trust level of the trusted party obtained by the TLA after performing a trust evaluation on the trusted party, the sending module 730 is further configured to send an update request to the TLA, instructing the TLA to re-evaluate the trust of the trusted party. The update request may be sent to the TLA in situations such as when the trusted party's trust level evaluation certificate expires, when one or more of the trusted party's claims change, or when a security incident occurs with the trusted party.
[0183] Specifically, the operations implemented by the receiving module 710 and the sending module 730 in the trust evaluation device 700 can refer to the sending and receiving operations of the trusted party in the above method embodiment; the operations implemented by the processing module 720 can refer to the operations of the trusted party in the above method embodiment, and will not be repeated here.
[0184] The present application also provides a computing device, as shown in FIG8 , which is a schematic diagram of a computing device provided by an embodiment of the present application. The computing device 800 includes one or more processors 810 , a communication interface 820 , and a memory 830 , wherein the one or more processors 810 , the communication interface 820 , and the memory 830 are interconnected via a bus 840 , wherein:
[0185] The processor 810 may be configured to implement operations corresponding to those performed by the TLA in the method embodiment. The method for implementing the trust evaluation of the trusted party by the processor 810 may refer to the introduction in the method embodiment, which will not be described in detail here.
[0186] The communication interface 820 may be a wired interface or a wireless interface, and is used to communicate with other modules or devices, such as receiving a trust level assessment request, receiving an evidence response submitted by a trusted party, and sending a TLA certificate to a trusted party. The wired interface may be an Ethernet interface, a local interconnect network (LIN), etc., and the wireless interface may be a cellular network interface or a wireless local area network interface.
[0187] Memory 830 may be a non-volatile memory, such as read-only memory (ROM), programmable read-only memory (PROM), erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM), electrically erasable programmable read-only memory (EEPROM), or flash memory. Memory 830 may also be a volatile memory, which may be a random access memory (RAM), which is used as an external cache. By way of example and not limitation, many forms of RAM are available, such as static random access memory (SRAM), dynamic random access memory (DRAM), synchronous dynamic random access memory (SDRAM), double data rate synchronous dynamic random access memory (DDR SDRAM), enhanced synchronous dynamic random access memory (ESDRAM), synchronous link dynamic random access memory (SLDRAM), and direct rambus RAM (DR RAM).
[0188] The memory 830 can also be used to store program instructions and data, so that the processor 810 can call the program instructions stored in the memory 830 to execute the operation steps performed by the TLA in the above method embodiment. In addition, the computing device 800 may include more or fewer components than those shown in Figure 8, or have different component configurations.
[0189] Bus 840 may be a Peripheral Component Interconnect (PCI) bus or an Extended Industry Standard Architecture (EISA) bus. Bus 840 may be classified as an address bus, a data bus, a control bus, etc. For ease of illustration, FIG8 shows only one thick line, but this does not mean that there is only one bus or only one type of bus.
[0190] It should be noted that the above-mentioned processor 810 can be a central processing unit (CPU), or it can include a CPU and other accelerator cards. There can be multiple types of accelerator cards. For example, the accelerator card can be a co-processing unit including a graphics processing unit (GPU), a tensor processing unit (TPU), a programmable logic device (PLD), a complex programmable logic device (CPLD), a field programmable gate array (FPGA) or a digital signal processor (DSP) and other chips. The computing device 800 can include one or more accelerator cards of any of the above types, or it can include multiple types of the above accelerator cards, which is not specifically limited in the embodiments of the present application.
[0191] Specifically, the specific implementation of various operations performed by the computing device 800 may refer to the specific operations performed by the TLA in the above method embodiment, which will not be repeated here.
[0192] The present application also provides a network device, as shown in FIG9 , which is a schematic diagram of a network device provided by an embodiment of the present application. The network device 900 includes one or more processors 910 , a communication interface 920 , and a memory 930 , wherein the one or more processors 910 , the communication interface 920 , and the memory 930 are interconnected via a bus 940 , wherein:
[0193] The processor 910 can be used to implement the operations performed by the trusted party in the above method embodiment. The implementation method of the processor 910 can refer to the introduction in the above method embodiment and will not be repeated here.
[0194] The communication interface 920 can be a wired interface or a wireless interface, and is used to communicate with other modules or devices, such as sending evidence requests and TLA certificates from the TLA, and sending the above evidence responses to the TLA. The wired interface can be an Ethernet interface, a local interconnect network (LIN), etc., and the wireless interface can be a cellular network interface or a wireless local area network interface.
[0195] Memory 930 may be a non-volatile memory, such as ROM, PROM, EPROM, EEPROM, or flash memory. Memory 930 may also be a volatile memory, such as RAM, which serves as an external cache. By way of example and not limitation, many forms of RAM are available, such as SRAM, DRAM, SDRAM, DDR SDRAM, ESDRAM, SLDRAM, and DR RAM.
[0196] The memory 930 can also be used to store program instructions and data, so that the processor 910 can call the program instructions stored in the memory 930 to execute the operation steps performed by the trusted party in the above method embodiment. In addition, the network device 900 may include more or fewer components than those shown in Figure 9, or have different component configurations.
[0197] The bus 940 may be a PCI bus or an EISA bus, etc. The bus 940 may be divided into an address bus, a data bus, a control bus, etc. For ease of illustration, FIG9 shows only one thick line, but this does not mean that there is only one bus or one type of bus.
[0198] It should be noted that the above-mentioned processor 910 can be a CPU, or it can include a CPU and other chips. The other chips can be of various types, for example, any one of PLD, CPLD, FPGA or DSP chips. The network device 900 can include one or more chips of any of the above types, or it can include multiple types of the above chips. The embodiments of this application do not make specific limitations.
[0199] Specifically, the specific implementation of various operations performed by the above-mentioned network device 900 can refer to the specific operations performed by TLA in the above-mentioned method embodiment, which will not be repeated here.
[0200] An embodiment of the present application further provides a computer-readable storage medium having instructions stored therein. When the computer-readable storage medium is executed on a processor, the computer-readable storage medium can implement the method steps implemented by the TLA in the above method embodiment. The specific implementation of the processor of the computer-readable storage medium in executing the above method steps can refer to the specific operations of the above method embodiment, which will not be repeated here.
[0201] An embodiment of the present application also provides a computer-readable storage medium, which stores instructions. When the computer-readable storage medium is executed on a processor, it can implement the method steps implemented by the trusted party in the above method embodiment. The specific implementation of the processor of the computer-readable storage medium in executing the above method steps can refer to the specific operations of the above method embodiment, which will not be repeated here.
[0202] In the above embodiments, the description of each embodiment has its own focus. For parts that are not described in detail in a certain embodiment, reference can be made to the relevant descriptions of other embodiments.
[0203] The above embodiments can be implemented in whole or in part through software, hardware, firmware, or any other combination. When implemented using software, the above embodiments can be implemented in whole or in part in the form of a computer program product. The computer program product includes one or more computer instructions. When the computer program instructions are loaded or executed on a computer, the processes or functions described in accordance with the embodiments of the present invention are generated in whole or in part. The computer can be a general-purpose computer, a special-purpose computer, a computer network, or other programmable device. The computer instructions can be stored in a computer-readable storage medium or transmitted from one computer-readable storage medium to another. For example, the computer instructions can be transmitted from one website, computer, server, or data center to another website, computer, server, or data center via wired (e.g., coaxial cable, optical fiber, digital subscriber line) or wireless (e.g., infrared, wireless, microwave, etc.) means. The computer-readable storage medium can be any available medium that can be accessed by a computer or a data storage device such as a server or data center that contains a collection of one or more available media. The available medium can be a magnetic medium (e.g., a floppy disk, hard disk, magnetic tape), an optical medium, or a semiconductor medium. The semiconductor medium can be a solid state drive (SSD).
[0204] The steps in the method of the embodiment of the present application can be adjusted in order, combined or deleted according to actual needs; the modules in the device of the embodiment of the present application can be divided, combined or deleted according to actual needs.
[0205] The above is a detailed introduction to the embodiments of the present application. Specific examples are used herein to illustrate the principles and implementation methods of the present application. The description of the above embodiments is only used to help understand the method and core idea of the present application. At the same time, for those skilled in the art, according to the idea of the present application, there may be changes in the specific implementation methods and application scope. In summary, the content of this specification should not be understood as a limitation on the present application.
Claims
1. A trust evaluation method, characterized in that: include: The trust level assessor TLA performs a trust assessment on the trusted party according to the first trust level assessment TLA file and the evidence submitted by the trusted party to obtain the trust level of the trusted party; the evidence includes one or more statements, and the one or more statements are used to describe the relevant information of the trusted party; The first TLA file includes multiple trust levels and an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level, the evaluation model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results of one or more statements required by the first trust level, and the first trust level is one of the multiple trust levels.
2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The first TLA file includes a statement list, the statement list includes one or more statement names, the statement name includes any one or more of the trusted party's identification, software integrity, hardware integrity, protocol status, interface status, security protocol, cryptographic algorithm, or key length; The statement list in the first TLA file includes statement names corresponding to one or more statements in the evidence.
3. The method according to claim 2, characterized in that The declaration list also includes indication information corresponding to each declaration name, wherein the indication information corresponding to a first declaration name indicates whether the declaration corresponding to the first declaration name must be provided when a trust assessment is performed based on the first TLA profile, and the first declaration name is one of the declaration names in the declaration list.
4. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized in that: The verification result includes compliance, partial compliance or non-compliance.
5. The method according to any one of claims 2 to 4, characterized in that: The first TLA archive further includes metadata, and the metadata includes any one or more of a publisher identifier of a publisher of the first TLA archive, a TLA archive number of the first TLA archive, a version number of the first TLA archive, or a validity period of the first TLA archive.
6. The method according to any one of claims 2 to 5, characterized in that: The first TLA file further includes any one or more of applicable country or region, applicable device type, extended field or publisher signature; Wherein, the applicable country or region indicates the country or region to which the first TLA file is applicable; The applicable device type indicates the type of device to which the first TLA file is applicable, and the applicable device types include routers, wireless base stations, and core network virtualized network functions; The publisher signature refers to a signature of the first TLA file by the publisher of the first TLA file using a private key.
7. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, characterized in that: The trust level of the trusted party is carried in the trust level evaluation certificate generated by the TLA; the trust level evaluation certificate also includes a first TLA file number corresponding to the first TLA file, and the first TLA file number indicates the TLA file used for trust evaluation of the trusted party.
8. The method according to claim 7, characterized in that The trust level evaluation certificate also includes any one or more of a version number, a serial number, a signature algorithm identifier, the name of the TLA, a validity period, the name of the trusted party, the public key information of the TLA, the identifier of the TLA, the identifier of the trusted party, the evidence certification number of the evidence, the Merkle root or the signature of the TLA; wherein, The serial number is used to uniquely identify the trust level evaluation certificate of the trusted party; The signature algorithm identifier indicates a signature algorithm used by the TLA to sign the trust level assessment certificate; The validity period indicates the validity period of the trust level evaluation certificate; The public key information of the TLA includes information of the public key corresponding to the private key of the TLA; The evidence certification number is the number returned to the trusted party by the evidence storage center after the trusted party submits the evidence to the evidence storage center; The Merkle root is generated by the trusted party based on the statement in the evidence; The signature of the TLA refers to a signature of the TLA on the content of the trust level assessment certificate using a private key.
9. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 8, characterized in that: The evidence also includes metadata of the trusted party and / or a signature of the trusted party; The metadata of the trusted party includes any one or more of an identification of the trusted party, a timestamp, a version number of the evidence, or a Merkle root; Wherein, the timestamp indicates the time when the trusted party generated the evidence; The Merkle root is generated by the trusted party based on the statement in the evidence; The signature of the trusted party refers to the signature of the trusted party on the statement in the evidence and the metadata of the trusted party using a private key.
10. The method according to any one of claims 2 to 9, characterized in that: Also includes: The TLA receives a trust level assessment request, the trust level assessment request includes the identity of the trusted party, the trust level assessment request includes the identity of the trusted party, The evaluation request instructs to perform a trust evaluation on the trusted party; The TLA sends an evidence request to the trusted party, the evidence request including a statement name included in the statement list in the first TLA file, for instructing the trusted party to submit a statement corresponding to the statement name included in the statement list in the first TLA file; The TLA receives a proof response sent by the trusted party, where the proof response includes the proof.
11. The method according to claim 10, characterized in that The TLA stores one or more TLA files and a usage policy of the TLA files, wherein the usage policy indicates a default TLA file and a priority of each TLA file; wherein the first TLA file is one of the one or more TLA files.
12. The method according to claim 11, characterized in that The trust level evaluation request includes one or more TLA profile numbers, which are used to instruct the TLA to select a TLA profile from TLA profiles corresponding to the one or more TLA profile numbers to perform trust evaluation on the trusted party.
13. The method according to claim 12, characterized in that Also includes: According to the priority of each TLA file, a TLA file with the highest priority is selected from the TLA files corresponding to the one or more TLA file numbers as the first TLA file.
14. The method according to claim 11, characterized in that Also includes: In case the trust level evaluation request does not include a TLA profile number, the TLA selects a default TLA profile as the first TLA profile.
15. The method according to any one of claims 10 to 14, characterized in that The evidence response also includes an evidence certification number, which is a number returned to the trusted party by the evidence storage center after the trusted party submits the evidence to the evidence storage center.
16. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 14, characterized in that Also includes: The TLA receives an update request and re-evaluates the trust of the trusted party according to the update request; wherein the update request includes an identifier of the trusted party.
17. A trust assessment method, characterized in that: include: The trusted party receives an evidence request sent by the trust level assessor TLA, wherein the evidence request includes a statement name included in a statement list in a first trust level assessment TLA file, wherein the statement name instructs the trusted party to submit a statement corresponding to the statement name, and the statement corresponding to the statement name is used to describe relevant information of the trusted party; The trusted party encapsulates the statement corresponding to the statement name into evidence; wherein the evidence includes one or more statements of the trusted party; The trusted party sends the evidence to the TLA, so that the TLA performs a trust evaluation on the trusted party according to the evidence and the first TLA file to obtain the trust level of the trusted party; The first TLA file includes multiple trust levels and an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level, the evaluation model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results of one or more statements required by the first trust level; the first trust level is one of the multiple trust levels.
18. The method according to claim 17, characterized in that The evidence also includes metadata of the trusted party and / or a signature of the trusted party; The metadata of the trusted party includes any one or more of an identification of the trusted party, a timestamp, a version number of the evidence, or a Merkle root; Wherein, the timestamp indicates the time when the trusted party generated the evidence; The Merkle root is generated by the trusted party based on the statement in the evidence; The signature of the trusted party refers to the signature of the trusted party on the statement in the evidence and the metadata of the trusted party.
19. A trust evaluation system, characterized in that: It includes the trust level assessor TLA and the trusted party, where: The TLA is used to send an evidence request to a trusted party, wherein the evidence request includes a statement name included in the statement list in the first TLA file, and is used to instruct the trusted party to submit a statement corresponding to the statement name included in the statement list in the first TLA file; The trusted party is used to encapsulate the statement corresponding to the statement name into evidence; wherein the evidence includes one or more statements of the trusted party; The TLA is further used to perform a trust evaluation on the trusted party according to the first TLA file and the evidence to obtain a trust level of the trusted party; The first TLA file includes multiple trust levels and an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level, the evaluation model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results of one or more statements required by the first trust level, and the first trust level is one of the above multiple trust levels.
20. A trust assessment device, characterized in that: A communication module, configured to receive evidence submitted by a trusted party, wherein the evidence includes one or more statements, and the one or more statements are used to describe relevant information of the trusted party; A processing module, configured to perform a trust evaluation on the trusted party according to the first trust level evaluation TLA file and the evidence to obtain a trust level of the trusted party; The first TLA file includes multiple trust levels and an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level, the evaluation model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results of one or more statements required by the first trust level, and the first trust level is one of the above multiple trust levels.
21. A trust assessment device, characterized in that: include: A receiving module, configured to receive an evidence request sent by a trust level assessor TLA, wherein the evidence request includes a statement name included in a statement list in a first trust level assessment TLA file, wherein the statement name indicates that a trusted party submits a statement corresponding to the statement name, and the statement corresponding to the statement name is used to describe relevant information of the trusted party; A processing module, configured to encapsulate the statement corresponding to the statement name into evidence; wherein the evidence includes one or more statements of the trusted party; A sending module, configured to send the evidence to the TLA, so that the TLA performs a trust evaluation on the trusted party according to the evidence and the first TLA file to obtain the trust level of the trusted party; The first TLA file includes multiple trust levels and an evaluation model corresponding to each trust level, the evaluation model corresponding to the first trust level includes verification results of one or more statements required by the first trust level, and the first trust level is one of the multiple trust levels.
22. A computing device, characterized in that The method comprises a processor and a memory, wherein the memory is used to store instructions, and the processor is used to execute the instructions. When the processor executes the instructions, the method according to any one of claims 1 to 16 is implemented.
23. A network device, characterized in that: The method comprises a processor and a memory, wherein the memory is used to store instructions, and the processor is used to execute the instructions. When the processor executes the instructions, the method according to any one of claims 17 or 18 is implemented.
24. A computer-readable storage medium, characterized in that: The method comprises computer program instructions. When the computer program instructions are executed by a computing device, the computing device implements the method according to any one of claims 1 to 16.
25. A computer-readable storage medium, characterized in that: The method comprises computer program instructions, and when the computer program instructions are executed by a computing device, the computing device implements the method as claimed in any one of claims 17 or 18.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Trust evaluation method and system and related equipment
CN116887289A
Method and apparatus for an ephemeral trusted device
CN103098068A
Trust level evaluation method and device, electronic equipment and storage medium
CN114465759A
Method and apparatus for secured social networking
US20150046696A1
Single sign-on framework with trust-level mapping to authentication requirements
US6892307B1
