Information processing method, information processing system, and program
The blockchain-based ledger system addresses the challenge of insufficient information in evaluating organizations and products by deriving evaluation values from related entities, ensuring accurate and tamper-proof assessments.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/JP2025/043891
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2025-05-07
- Filing Date
- 2025-12-16
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-12
AI Technical Summary
Existing evaluation methods for organizations and their products lack sufficient information, particularly regarding labor and environmental impact, making it difficult to accurately assess the organizations and products involved in complex supply chains.
An information processing method and system that utilizes a blockchain-based ledger system to derive evaluation values by referencing related organizations and products, even when direct information is insufficient, through smart contracts and NFT tokens.
Enables comprehensive evaluation of organizations and products by leveraging indirect information, ensuring accurate assessment and preventing tampering, while maintaining data integrity.
Smart Images

Figure JP2025043891_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Information Processing Method, Information Processing System, and Program
[0001] The present disclosure relates to an information processing method, an information processing system, and a program.
[0002] Recently, when evaluating organizations such as enterprises, it is required to conduct evaluations that include perspectives such as labor and the environment, in addition to legal, financial, and business aspects of the organizations. Furthermore, when evaluating an organization, it is required to perform the evaluation not only on the organization that is the subject of evaluation, but also on other organizations that provide goods or services to that organization. Non-Patent Document 1 discloses a method for analyzing the impact of corporate activities on the environment. Using this method, it is possible to conduct corporate evaluations from an environmental perspective.
[0003] "Discovering All Environmental Effects: How Life Cycle Assessment with LCA Software Works", [online], iPoint-systems gmbh, [retrieved on April 9, Reiwa 7], Internet <URL: https: / / go.ipoint-systems.com / blog / discovering-all-environmental-effects-how-life-cycle-assessment-with-lca-software-works>
[0004] However, in practice, there may be insufficient information related to the organization that is the subject of evaluation or the provided items (for example, provided goods, provided services) offered by the organization, making it impossible to appropriately evaluate the organization or the provided items.
[0005] Accordingly, the present disclosure provides an information processing method and the like that can perform evaluation of an organization or evaluation of provided items offered by an organization even when inherently necessary information is insufficient.
[0006] An information processing method according to one aspect of the present disclosure is an information processing method executed by one or more computers, wherein when the evaluation value of a k-th organization (where k is an integer of 2 or more) related to the first organization affects the evaluation value of a first organization, and when the evaluation value of a first offering that includes at least one of the goods and services provided by the k-th organization affects the evaluation value of a first offering that includes at least one of the goods and services provided by the k-th organization, the method derives the evaluation value of the first offering using the evaluation value of the k-th organization when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th offering, or when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th organization when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th organization, the method derives the evaluation value of the first offering using the evaluation value of the k-th offering.
[0007] An information processing system according to one aspect of the present disclosure includes: an information acquisition unit that acquires information regarding the evaluation value of the first organization, the evaluation value of the k organization, the evaluation value of the first provided item, and the evaluation value of the k provided item, when the evaluation value of the k organization is affected by the evaluation value of the first organization, and the evaluation value of the k provided item is affected by the evaluation value of the first provided item, which includes at least one of the goods and services provided by the k organization; and an information processing unit that derives the evaluation value of the first provided item using the evaluation value of the k organization when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k provided item, or derives the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the k provided item when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k organization.
[0008] A program according to one aspect of this disclosure is a program that causes one or more computers to execute the above-described information processing method.
[0009] These comprehensive or specific embodiments may be implemented as a system, device, integrated circuit, computer program, or recording medium such as a computer-readable CD-ROM, or as any combination of a system, device, integrated circuit, computer program, and recording medium.
[0010] The information processing methods disclosed herein allow for the evaluation of an organization or the services provided by an organization, even when essential information is lacking.
[0011] Figure 1 is a schematic diagram showing multiple organizations, a database for organizations that records the evaluation value of each organization, NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation value of each organization, and multiple offerings, a database for offerings that records the evaluation value of each offering, and NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation value of each offering. Figure 2 is a schematic diagram showing an example where information regarding the evaluation value of an offering is insufficient. Figure 3 is a schematic diagram showing the overall configuration of the information processing system in the embodiment. Figure 4 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of a ledger server that manages the evaluation values of organizations. Figure 5 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of a ledger server that manages the evaluation values of offerings. Figure 6 is a schematic diagram showing the overall configuration of the information processing system in a modified example 1 of the embodiment. Figure 7 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of a ledger server that manages the evaluation values of organizations and offerings. Figure 8 is a schematic diagram showing the overall configuration of the information processing system in a modified example 2 of the embodiment. Figure 9 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of an organization-responding system that manages the evaluation values of organizations. Figure 10 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of an offering-responding system that manages the evaluation values of offerings. Figure 11 is a diagram showing the correspondence between organizations and offerings. Figure 12 is a schematic diagram showing multiple organizations, a database for organizations that records the evaluation value of each organization, NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation value of each organization, and multiple offerings, a database for offerings that records the evaluation value of each offering, and NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation value of each offering. Figure 13 is a sequence diagram showing an example of processing performed in the information processing system of modified embodiment 2. Figure 14 is a diagram showing an example of displaying the evaluation value of the first offering. Figure 15 is a sequence diagram showing an example of other processing performed in the information processing system of modified embodiment 2. Figure 16 is a diagram showing an example of displaying the evaluation value of the first organization. Figure 17 is an explanatory diagram showing the data structure of a blockchain, which is an example of a distributed ledger. Figure 18 is an explanatory diagram showing the data structure of transaction data. Figure 19 is an explanatory diagram showing transaction data related to the execution of a smart contract. Figure 20 is an explanatory diagram showing processing related to the execution of a smart contract. Figure 21 is an explanatory diagram showing the structure of NFTs and metadata.
[0012] (Summary of this disclosure) In recent years, when evaluating organizations such as companies, in addition to the organization's legal status, financial status, and business status, factors such as whether the way employees are employed complies with labor standards, and the amount of pollutants and CO2 emitted by the organization's activities are also considered. 2 The evaluation must include aspects such as labor and environmental considerations, including whether emissions are within regulatory limits. Furthermore, when evaluating an organization, it is required to evaluate not only the organization being evaluated, but also other organizations that provide goods or services to that organization.
[0013] Furthermore, when evaluating the products provided by an organization, it is important to consider not only the quality of the product, but also whether the working conditions of the employees involved in its production comply with labor standards, and the amount of pollutants and CO2 emitted during production. 2 It is required to evaluate products from various perspectives, including labor and environmental aspects, such as whether emissions are within regulatory limits. Furthermore, when evaluating a product, it is required to evaluate not only the product being evaluated, but also the parts and materials used to produce it.
[0014] To conduct these evaluations, it is necessary to trace and evaluate other organizations that provided goods or services to the organization being evaluated, and to trace and evaluate the parts and materials used to produce the product being evaluated, starting from the product being evaluated.
[0015] Figure 1 is a schematic diagram showing multiple organizations, a database for recording the evaluation values of each organization, NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation values of each organization, and multiple offerings, a database for recording the evaluation values of each offering, and NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation values of each offering. Note that NFT tokens may also be written as NFT.
[0016] Figure 1(a) shows a first organization, a second organization directly related to the first organization, and a third organization indirectly related to the first organization. In this figure, the second organization is a supplier that provides goods and services to the first organization, and the third organization is a supplier that provides goods and services to the second organization.
[0017] Furthermore, an organization is a group formed to achieve a specific purpose. In this embodiment, an organization refers to the company itself or a designated business office, business group, or department within the company.
[0018] Furthermore, Figure 1(a) shows a database for organizations where the evaluation values of the first organization, the second organization, and the third organization are recorded, as well as NFT (Non-Fungible Token) tokens corresponding to each organization's evaluation value. The NFT tokens corresponding to each organization's evaluation value are recorded on the organization's blockchain.
[0019] The evaluation values for each organization include, for example, an evaluation of the organization's employee labor, an evaluation of legal compliance, an evaluation of environmental impact, and CO2. 2 It is derived based on an assessment of at least one of the following: an assessment of emissions, an assessment of the maintenance of goods and services, an assessment of the length of traceability tracking, and an assessment of the risks to changes in economic conditions.
[0020] The organizational database is a database used in common by the first, second, and third organizations. The organizational database may reside either within or outside the blockchain.
[0021] Recording NFT tokens corresponding to each organization's evaluation score on an organization-specific blockchain is intended to manage information while effectively preventing tampering, without using privileged nodes (e.g., centralized servers or client-server model servers).
[0022] Figure 1(b) shows a first offering, a second offering directly related to the first offering, and a third offering indirectly related to the first offering. For example, the first offering is the product, the second offering is the parts used to produce the product, and the third offering is the materials used to produce the parts.
[0023] Furthermore, the offerings are not limited to physical goods such as products, parts, and materials, but may also include services provided by the organization. The offerings only need to include at least one of the goods and services provided by the organization. Goods provided by the organization include, for example, tangible goods such as materials, parts, and products, and intangible goods such as information and energy. Services provided by the organization include, for example, services such as transportation, manufacturing, support, and assistance.
[0024] Furthermore, Figure 1(b) shows a database for offerings in which the evaluation values of the first offering, the second offering, and the third offering are recorded, as well as NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation value of each offering. The NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation value of each offering are recorded on the blockchain for the offering. The relationship between each offering, the evaluation value for each offering, and the NFT token corresponding to each offering is created for each of the multiple first offerings provided by the first organization.
[0025] The evaluation values for each item provided include, for example, an evaluation of employee labor related to the item, an evaluation of legal compliance, an evaluation of environmental impact, and CO2. 2 It is derived based on an assessment of at least one of the following: an assessment of emissions, an assessment of the maintenance of the products provided, an assessment of the length of traceability tracking, and an assessment of the risks to changes in economic conditions.
[0026] The database for the offered items is a database that is used in common by the first, second, and third organizations. The database for the offered items may reside either within or outside the blockchain.
[0027] Recording NFT tokens corresponding to the valuation of each offering on the blockchain for that offering is done to manage information while effectively preventing tampering, without using privileged nodes (e.g., centralized servers or client-server model servers).
[0028] The organizations and products shown in Figures 1(a) and 1(b) have the following relationships: The first organization produces the first product, the second organization produces the second product, and the third organization produces the third product. To explain this in terms of a flow from upstream to downstream, the third organization provides the third product to the second organization, the second organization provides the second product, which it has produced based on the third product, to the first organization, and the first organization provides the first product, which it has produced based on the second product, to someone other than the second and third organizations. This other person could be another company other than the second and third organizations, or it could be a general consumer.
[0029] On the other hand, when tracing organizations and deliverables, we track things from downstream to upstream. To explain it in reverse, from downstream to upstream, the first organization obtains the second deliverable from the second organization in order to produce the first deliverable, the second organization obtains the third deliverable from the third organization in order to produce the second deliverable, and the third organization obtains the resources to produce the third deliverable and produces the third deliverable.
[0030] In the configuration shown in Figure 1, the evaluation value of the second organization directly influences the evaluation value of the first organization, and the evaluation value of the second offering directly influences the evaluation value of the first offering provided by the first organization. Furthermore, the evaluation value of the third organization indirectly influences the evaluation value of the first organization, and the evaluation value of the third offering indirectly influences the evaluation value of the first offering.
[0031] When evaluating the first organization to be evaluated, it is desirable to have all the information regarding the evaluation values of the first, second, and third organizations, as shown in Figure 1. Similarly, when evaluating the first product to be evaluated, it is desirable to have all the information regarding the evaluation values of the first, second, and third products, as shown in Figure 1. However, in reality, there may be insufficient information regarding the organization to be evaluated or the products it provides, making it impossible to properly evaluate the organization or products. For example, if materials from the same lot produced in the same process are separated and different composite materials containing some of these materials are provided to different customers, it may be difficult to derive an evaluation value for each composite material (product) provided to each customer, and the evaluation value of the third product may not be recorded on the blockchain for the products.
[0032] Figure 2 shows an example where there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the provided items.
[0033] Figure 2(a), similar to Figure 1(a), shows the relationships between the first, second, and third organizations. The organization database records the evaluation values of the first, second, and third organizations. The NFT tokens corresponding to each organization's evaluation value are recorded on the organization's blockchain.
[0034] Figure 2(b) shows the relationship between the first, second, and third offerings, similar to Figure 1(b). However, in Figure 2(b), the blockchain for the offerings records NFT tokens corresponding to the valuation of the first offering and the valuation of the second offering, but does not record NFT tokens corresponding to the valuation of the third offering. Therefore, there is a problem in that the valuation of the first offering cannot be properly derived because the valuation of the third offering, which is originally necessary when deriving the valuation of the first offering, is missing.
[0035] Therefore, in the information processing method disclosed herein, when there is insufficient information to evaluate an organization or an offering, the organization or offering is evaluated using other evaluation values recorded on the organization's blockchain and the offering's blockchain.
[0036] For example, in the information processing method disclosed herein, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third offering, as shown in Figure 2, the evaluation value of the first offering is derived using the evaluation value of the third organization recorded on the organization's blockchain. This method allows for the evaluation of the first offering even when the necessary information is lacking.
[0037] Furthermore, although the information processing method disclosed herein differs from the explanation shown in Figure 2, for example, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third organization, the evaluation value of the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the third offering recorded on the blockchain for the offerings. This method allows for the evaluation of the first organization even when the necessary information is lacking.
[0038] Furthermore, while the above describes an example where there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third organization or the third offering, the evaluation values can be similarly derived even if there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the second organization or the second offering. Also, while the above describes the relationship between three organizations, the evaluation values can be similarly derived even if there are two or four or more organizations. Also, while the above describes the relationship between three offerings, the evaluation values can be similarly derived even if there are two or four or more offerings. Also, while the above shows an example where the third organization is indirectly related to the first organization, the evaluation values can be similarly derived even if there are two or four or more offerings. Also, while the above shows an example where the third offering is indirectly related to the first offering, the evaluation values can be similarly derived even if there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the second organization.
[0039] In the following, as a description corresponding to the second organization, the third organization, or the like, the description of the k-th organization (k is an integer of 2 or more) may be used. Also, as a description corresponding to the second provided subject matter, the third provided subject matter, or the like, the description of the k-th provided subject matter may be used.
[0040] Hereinafter, an information processing method and the like according to one embodiment of the present disclosure will be exemplified.
[0041] The information processing method of Example 1 is an information processing method executed by one or more computers, wherein when the evaluation value of a k-th organization (k is an integer of 2 or more) related to a first organization affects the evaluation value of the first organization, and when the evaluation value of a k-th provided subject matter including at least one of a product and a service provided by the k-th organization affects the evaluation value of a first provided subject matter including at least one of a product and a service provided by the first organization, when information related to the evaluation value of the k-th provided subject matter is insufficient, the evaluation value of the first provided subject matter is derived using the evaluation value of the k-th organization, or when information related to the evaluation value of the k-th organization is insufficient, the evaluation value of the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the k-th provided subject matter.
[0042] In this way, by deriving the evaluation value of the first provided subject matter using the evaluation value of the k-th organization when information related to the evaluation value of the k-th provided subject matter is insufficient, the first provided subject matter can be evaluated even when originally required information is insufficient. In addition, by deriving the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the k-th provided subject matter when information related to the evaluation value of the k-th organization is insufficient, the first organization can be evaluated even when originally required information is insufficient.
[0043] The information processing method according to Example 2 is the information processing method described in Example 1, wherein when it is determined that information related to the evaluation value of the k-th provided subject is insufficient due to the non-existence of the evaluation value of the k-th provided subject, the evaluation value of the first provided subject is derived using the evaluation value of the k-th organization instead of the evaluation value of the k-th provided subject, or when it is determined that information related to the evaluation value of the k-th organization is insufficient due to the non-existence of the evaluation value of the k-th organization, the evaluation value of the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the k-th provided subject instead of the evaluation value of the k-th organization.
[0044] In this way, when there is no information related to the evaluation value of the k-th provided subject, the evaluation value of the first provided subject is derived using the evaluation value of the k-th organization in place of the k-th provided subject, so that the first provided subject can be evaluated even when originally required information is insufficient. Further, when there is no information related to the evaluation value of the k-th organization, the evaluation value of the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the k-th provided subject in place of the k-th organization, so that the first organization can be evaluated even when originally required information is insufficient.
[0045] The information processing method according to Example 3 is the information processing method described in Example 1, wherein the evaluation value of the first provided subject may be derived by referring to the relationship between the first organization and the k-th organization, the relationship between the first provided subject and the k-th provided subject, the relationship between the first organization and the first provided subject, and the relationship between the k-th organization and the k-th provided subject, or the evaluation value of the first organization may be derived.
[0046] As described above, the evaluation value of the first provided subject can be appropriately derived by referring to the relationships between the respective organizations and the respective provided subjects. In addition, the evaluation value of the first organization can be appropriately derived by referring to the relationships between the respective organizations and the respective provided subjects as described above.
[0047] The information processing method according to Example 4 is the information processing method described in Example 1, wherein the first organization may be an organization that generates the first provided subject based on the k-th provided subject.
[0048] According to this, it is possible to derive the evaluation value of the first offering generated based on the kth offering, or the evaluation value of the first organization that generates the first offering based on the kth offering.
[0049] The information processing method in Example 5 is the information processing method described in Example 1, wherein if the evaluation value of the organization k is equal to or greater than a predetermined evaluation standard, it may be determined that the evaluation value of the first provided item meets the evaluation standard.
[0050] According to this, the first item to be offered can be properly evaluated.
[0051] The information processing method in Example 6 is the information processing method described in Example 1, wherein if the evaluation value of the provided items k is less than a predetermined evaluation standard, it may be determined that the evaluation value of the first organization does not meet the evaluation standard.
[0052] According to this, the first organization can be properly evaluated.
[0053] The information processing method in Example 7 is the information processing method described in Example 1, wherein when deriving the evaluation value of organization k, the evaluation value of organization k may be adjusted based on the data collected by the automated data collection system used by organization k.
[0054] According to this, the reliability of the evaluation value of the k-th organization can be taken into consideration, and an evaluation value of the provided items or organization can be derived.
[0055] The information processing method in Example 8 is the information processing method described in any of Examples 1 to 7, and the evaluation value may be recorded on the blockchain.
[0056] According to this, it is possible to record evaluation values for provided goods or organizations while effectively preventing tampering with evaluation values, without using privileged nodes (e.g., centralized servers or servers in a client-server model).
[0057] The information processing method in Example 9 is the information processing method described in Example 8, wherein when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k provided item recorded in the blockchain, the evaluation value of the first provided item is derived using the evaluation value of the k organization recorded in the blockchain, and the evaluation value of the first provided item is recorded in the blockchain; or, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k organization recorded in the blockchain, the evaluation value of the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the k provided item recorded in the blockchain, and the evaluation value of the first organization is recorded in the blockchain.
[0058] According to this method, the evaluation value of the offered goods or organizations recorded on the blockchain can be read, and the evaluation value of the offered goods or organizations derived through calculation can be recorded on the blockchain. This makes it possible to record the evaluation value of offered goods or organizations while effectively preventing tampering.
[0059] The information processing method in Example 10 is the information processing method described in Example 8, wherein a proof token may be issued based on the evaluation value recorded on the blockchain, and the proof token may be displayed.
[0060] According to this, a certification token containing an evaluation value of an organization or its offerings can be notified to the user utilizing this information processing method.
[0061] The information processing method of Example 11 is the information processing method described in Example 8, wherein when the evaluation value of the first provided item is derived using the evaluation value of the organization k, information indicating that the evaluation value of the first provided item was derived using an evaluation value other than the evaluation value of the provided item k that should have been used is recorded on the blockchain, or when the evaluation value of the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the provided item k, information indicating that the evaluation value of the first organization was derived using an evaluation value other than the evaluation value of the organization k that should have been used is recorded on the blockchain.
[0062] According to this, it is possible to record the evaluation value of the first provided item or organization while substantially preventing falsification of the record, as it is recorded that the evaluation value of the first provided item or organization was derived using other evaluation values.
[0063] The information processing method in Example 12 is the information processing method described in Example 8, wherein if the evaluation value of the organization k is lower than a predetermined evaluation value, information indicating that the organization k needs to be monitored is recorded on the blockchain, or if the evaluation value of the goods provided by k is lower than a predetermined evaluation value, information indicating that the goods provided by k need to be monitored is recorded on the blockchain.
[0064] According to this, it is possible to record the evaluation value of the provided items or organization while substantially preventing tampering with the record, while also recording the need to monitor the organization or the provided items of the k.
[0065] The information processing method in Example 13 is the information processing method described in any of Examples 1 to 7, wherein the evaluation values are the evaluation of employee labor, legal compliance, environmental impact, and CO2 of the first organization and the k organization, respectively. 2 It may be derived based on an assessment of emissions, as well as an assessment of the maintenance of the first and k offerings, an assessment of the traceability tracking length, and an assessment of the risks to changes in economic conditions.
[0066] According to this, it is possible to appropriately derive an evaluation value for the first provided item or an evaluation value for the first organization.
[0067] The information processing system of Example 14 includes an information acquisition unit that acquires information regarding the evaluation value of the first organization, the evaluation value of the k organization, the evaluation value of the first provided item, and the evaluation value of the k provided item when the evaluation value of the first organization is affected by the evaluation value of the k organization, and the evaluation value of the k provided item is affected by the evaluation value of the first provided item, which includes at least one of the goods and services provided by the k organization; and an information processing unit that derives the evaluation value of the first provided item using the evaluation value of the k organization when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k provided item, or derives the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the k provided item when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k organization.
[0068] In this way, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th item, the evaluation value of the first item can be derived using the evaluation value of the k-th organization, thereby enabling the evaluation of the first item even when the necessary information is lacking. Similarly, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th organization, the evaluation value of the first organization can be derived using the evaluation value of the k-th item, thereby enabling the evaluation of the first organization even when the necessary information is lacking.
[0069] The program in Example 14 is a program that causes one or more computers to execute the information processing method described in any of Examples 1 to 7.
[0070] This program produces the same effect as the information processing method described above.
[0071] The embodiments will be described in detail below with reference to the drawings.
[0072] The embodiments described below are all comprehensive or specific examples. The numerical values, shapes, materials, components, arrangement and connection configurations of components, steps, and the order of steps shown in the following embodiments are examples only and are not intended to limit this disclosure. Furthermore, among the components in the following embodiments, those not described in the independent claim representing the highest-level concept will be described as optional components.
[0073] (Embodiment) [Configuration of the Information Processing System] The information processing system in this embodiment will be described with reference to Figures 3 to 5.
[0074] Figure 3 is a schematic diagram showing the overall configuration of the information processing system 1 in this embodiment. The information processing system 1 is an example of a system that promotes the effective use of resources.
[0075] As shown in Figure 3, the information processing system 1 comprises an organizational ledger system 10 and a ledger system 20 for provided items. The information processing system 1 is connected to a storage device 5 and terminals T1, T2, and T3. The information processing system 1 may further include the storage device 5 and terminals T1, T2, and T3. Each of the above devices is connected to a network N and can communicate via the network N.
[0076] The ledger system 10 is an information processing system (also called the first distributed ledger system) that stores information using a distributed ledger. The distributed ledger of the ledger system 10 stores the generation history of NFTs (Non-Fungible Tokens) that are associated one-to-one with the evaluation value of an organization. The above NFTs are trace NFTs for organizations that trace the evaluation value of an organization on the distributed ledger. The ledger system 10 corresponds to the organization blockchain shown in Figure 1(a) or Figure 2(a).
[0077] The ledger system 10 can execute processing using smart contracts with a distributed ledger. The ledger system 10 generates trace NFTs for organizations using processing by smart contracts.
[0078] The ledger system 10 includes ledger servers 11, 12, and 13 (also referred to as ledger servers 11, etc.) as a group of servers that maintain a distributed ledger. When at least one of the ledger servers 11, etc. receives transaction data, that transaction data is shared by all the ledger servers 11, etc. and stored in the distributed ledger. Note that the number of ledger servers included in the above group of servers is not limited to three, but may be two or more.
[0079] Ledger server 11 is a computer server that holds and manages the distributed ledger. Ledger server 11 holds the distributed ledger and updates it in synchronization with other ledger servers (specifically ledger servers 12 and 13). Ledger server 11 constitutes part of the blockchain for the organization shown in Figure 1(a) or Figure 2(a) and is connected to terminal T1 used by the first organization via network N.
[0080] Ledger servers 12 and 13 are servers similar to ledger server 11, and operate independently of ledger server 11. Ledger server 12 constitutes part of the blockchain for the organization shown in Figure 1(a) or Figure 2(a) and is connected to terminal T2 used by a second organization via network N. Ledger server 13 constitutes part of the blockchain for the organization shown in Figure 1(a) or Figure 2(a) and is connected to terminal T3 used by a third organization via network N.
[0081] The ledger system 20 is an information processing system (also called the second distributed ledger system) that stores information using a distributed ledger, and is a different system from the ledger system 10. The distributed ledger of the ledger system 20 stores the generation history of NFTs that are associated one-to-one with the evaluation values of the offered items. The above NFTs are trace NFTs for offered items that trace the evaluation values of the offered items on the distributed ledger. The ledger system 20 corresponds to the blockchain for offered items shown in Figure 1(b) and Figure 2(b).
[0082] The ledger system 20 can execute processing using smart contracts with a distributed ledger. The ledger system 20 generates trace NFTs for the provided items using processing via smart contracts.
[0083] The ledger system 20 includes ledger servers 21, 22, and 23 (also referred to as ledger servers 21, etc.) as a group of servers that maintain a distributed ledger. When at least one of the ledger servers 21, etc. receives transaction data, that transaction data is shared by all the ledger servers 21, etc. and stored in the distributed ledger. Note that the number of ledger servers included in the above group of servers is not limited to three, but may be two or more.
[0084] Ledger server 21 is a computer server that holds and manages the distributed ledger. Ledger server 21 holds the distributed ledger and updates it in synchronization with other ledger servers (specifically ledger servers 22 and 23). Ledger server 21 constitutes part of the blockchain for the offered items shown in Figure 1(b) or Figure 2(b) and is connected to terminal T1 used by the first organization via network N.
[0085] Ledger servers 22 and 23 are servers similar to ledger server 21, and operate independently of ledger server 21. Ledger server 22 constitutes part of the blockchain for the offered items shown in Figure 1(b) or Figure 2(b), and is connected to terminal T2 used by the second organization via network N. Ledger server 23 constitutes part of the blockchain for the offered items shown in Figure 1(b) or Figure 2(b), and is connected to terminal T3 used by the third organization via network N.
[0086] The storage device 5 is a storage device that stores data. The storage device 5 can be accessed (specifically read from or written to) via the network N from the ledger system 10, the ledger system 20, or terminals T1, T2, and T3. There may be one or more storage devices 5. The storage device 5 can store various types of information. The information stored in the storage device 5 can be used as metadata for NFTs generated by the ledger system 10 or 20.
[0087] Furthermore, if the storage device 5 stores information that can only be accessed by a device with usage rights, the storage device 5 may, upon receiving an access request for such information, determine whether the sender of the access request has usage rights, and only grant access if the sender of the access request has usage rights. The storage device 5 may determine that the sender of the access request has usage rights if, at the time of receiving the access request, the sender of the access request possesses a usage rights NFT.
[0088] Terminal T1 is an information processing device used by a user of the first organization. Terminal T1 comprises a processor (e.g., CPU (Central Processing Unit), hereinafter the same), memory, a user interface (display screen, speaker, or touch panel, hereinafter the same), and a communication interface. It can accept information input using the user interface or communication interface, and can also generate, display, output audio, or transmit / receive information. Terminal T1 may be, for example, a personal computer, a tablet, or a smartphone.
[0089] Terminal T2 is an information processing device used by a user of the second organization. Terminal T2 comprises a processor, memory, a user interface, and a communication interface, and can accept information input using the user interface or the communication interface, and can also generate, display, output audio, or transmit / receive information. Terminal T2 may be, for example, a personal computer, a tablet, or a smartphone.
[0090] Terminal T3 is an information processing device used by a user of a third organization. Terminal T3 comprises a processor, memory, a user interface, and a communication interface, and can accept information input using the user interface or the communication interface, and can also generate, display, output audio, or transmit / receive information. Terminal T3 may be, for example, a personal computer, a tablet, or a smartphone.
[0091] Figure 4 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of the ledger server 11 that manages the organization's evaluation values.
[0092] The ledger server 11 includes an information acquisition unit 101, an information processing unit 103, and a storage unit 104 as functional units. At least a portion of the functional units of the ledger server 11 are realized by the processor (e.g., CPU) of the ledger server 11 executing programs using memory.
[0093] The information acquisition unit 101 has a communication interface that is connected to the network N in a communicative manner. The communication interface of the information acquisition unit 101 may be a communication interface for a wired communication standard (e.g., Ethernet®), a communication interface for a wireless communication standard (e.g., Wi-Fi®), or a communication interface for a mobile communication system (3G, 4G, or 5G, etc.). The information acquisition unit 101 is used when a functional unit of the ledger server 11 communicates with other devices. The information acquisition unit 101 is capable of acquiring information regarding the evaluation values of a first organization, a second organization, and a third organization in the ledger system 10.
[0094] The information processing unit 103 performs processing related to the distributed ledger 104a and transaction data. Specifically, when the information processing unit 103 receives transaction data from the ledger system 20 or terminals T1, T2, T3, etc., it verifies the digital signature contained in the received transaction data and controls the storage unit 104 to store the successfully verified transaction data in the distributed ledger 104a. When storing transaction data in the distributed ledger 104a, the information processing unit 103 can generate a block containing the transaction data to be stored and control the storage unit 103 to store the generated block in the distributed ledger 104a if an agreement is reached with the information processing units 103 of the other ledger servers, namely ledger servers 12 and 13.
[0095] The information processing unit 103 can perform information processing by executing a smart contract using the distributed ledger 104a. If a smart contract is not used, the information processing unit 103 performs information processing according to normal program code. As part of the above information processing, the information processing unit 103 executes the process of generating an organization-specific trace NFT using a smart contract.
[0096] In this embodiment, when there is insufficient information necessary to evaluate the first organization, the information processing unit 103 refers to the relationship between the first organization and the kth organization (where k is an integer of 2 or more), the relationship between the first provided item and the kth provided item, the relationship between the first organization and the first provided item, and the relationship between the kth organization and the kth provided item, and derives an evaluation value for the first organization.
[0097] For example, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third organization, the information processing unit 103 derives the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the third provided item recorded in the ledger system 20. Specifically, when the information processing unit 103 determines that there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third organization because the evaluation value of the third organization does not exist, it derives the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the third provided item instead of the evaluation value of the third organization.
[0098] The information processing unit 103 may determine that the evaluation value of the first organization does not meet the evaluation criteria if the evaluation value of the third provided item is below a predetermined evaluation criterion. Alternatively, the information processing unit 103 may determine that the evaluation value of the first organization meets the evaluation criteria if the evaluation value of the third provided item is equal to or greater than the predetermined evaluation criterion.
[0099] Here, we will explain an example of deriving the evaluation value of the first organization. For example, if the evaluation criterion for the evaluation value of an organization is set to 1 or higher, and three scores (0: NG, 1: OK, 2: Good) are provided as evaluation values for each organization, and three scores (0: NG, 1: OK, 2: Good) are provided as evaluation values for each item provided, then the evaluation value of the first organization is expressed by (Equation 1) shown below.
[0100] Evaluation score of the first organization = Score of the first organization alone × Score of the second organization × Score of the third organization ... (Equation 1)
[0101] For example, if the individual scores of the first organization are 2, the second organization is 1, and the third organization is 1, and all the scores are the same, then the evaluation value of the first organization will be 2 × 1 × 1 = 2, and the information processing unit 103 can derive the evaluation value of the first organization without any problems. Furthermore, the information processing unit 103 can determine that the evaluation value of the first organization meets the evaluation criteria.
[0102] However, if the evaluation value of the third organization is not recorded in the ledger system 10 (blockchain for organizations), the evaluation value of the first organization cannot be simply derived. Therefore, the information processing unit 103 uses the evaluation value of the third provided item recorded in the ledger system 20 (blockchain for provided items) instead of the evaluation value of the third organization. For example, if the score of a particular third provided item among the evaluation values of multiple third provided items provided by the third organization is "0", the information processing unit 103 substitutes "0" for the score of the third organization in (Equation 1). In this case, the evaluation value of the first organization becomes 2 × 1 × 0 = 0, and the information processing unit 103 determines that the evaluation value of the first organization does not meet the evaluation criteria.
[0103] If the information processing unit 103 derives the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the third provided item, it may record in the ledger system 10 (blockchain for organizations) information indicating that it derived the evaluation value of the first organization using an evaluation value other than the evaluation value of the third organization that should have been used. In the example above, the information processing unit 103 may add information indicating that it derived the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the third provided item to the information that the evaluation value of the first organization = 0, and record this in the ledger system 10.
[0104] Furthermore, the information processing unit 103 may record in the ledger system 10 (blockchain for organizations) information indicating that the third organization needs to be monitored if its evaluation value is lower than a predetermined evaluation value. For example, the information processing unit 103 may add information indicating that the third organization needs to be monitored to the information showing the evaluation value of the third organization and record it in the ledger system 10.
[0105] Furthermore, when deriving the evaluation value of the second organization, the information processing unit 103 may adjust the evaluation value of the second organization based on the data collected by the automated data collection system used by the second organization. Similarly, when deriving the evaluation value of the third organization, the information processing unit 103 may adjust the evaluation value of the third organization based on the data collected by the automated data collection system used by the third organization. For example, the automated data collection system is a system that uses AI (Artificial Intelligence) to search the attendance management system and email system within an organization and check for illegal overtime work by employees. The following explanation will use the second organization as an example.
[0106] For example, the information processing unit 103 adjusts the evaluation value of the second organization by the calculation process shown in (Equation 2) below.
[0107] if (the current score does not contradict the results of the collected data) {return current score × 2} else {return current score} ... (Equation 2)
[0108] As shown in (Equation 2), the information processing unit 103 doubles the score of the second organization if the score of the second organization recorded in the ledger system 10 does not contradict the results of the data collected by the automated data collection system used by the second organization. On the other hand, the information processing unit 103 sets the score of the second organization to its current score if the score of the second organization recorded in the ledger system 10 contradicts the results of the data collected by the automated data collection system used by the second organization. Through the above calculation, an evaluation including the reliability of the evaluation value of the second organization can be performed.
[0109] The memory unit 104 is a storage device that stores information. The memory unit 104 stores the distributed ledger 104a. The memory unit 104 is implemented using a non-volatile storage device (SSD (Solid State Drive) or HDD (Hard Disk Drive)), etc.
[0110] The distributed ledger 104a stores data having a structure in which blocks containing one or more transaction data are linked together in a chain. The one or more transaction data stored in the distributed ledger 104a include transaction data containing the contract code of a smart contract, transaction data containing instructions to execute a smart contract, or transaction data containing other information.
[0111] Figure 5 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of the ledger server 21 that manages the evaluation values of the provided items.
[0112] The ledger server 21 comprises an information acquisition unit 201, an information processing unit 203, and a storage unit 204 as functional units. At least a portion of the functional units of the ledger server 21 are realized by the processor (e.g., CPU) of the ledger server 21 executing programs using memory.
[0113] The information acquisition unit 201 is a communication interface that is communicatively connected to the network N. The communication interface of the information acquisition unit 201 may be a communication interface of a wired communication standard (e.g., Ethernet®), a communication interface of a wireless communication standard (e.g., Wi-Fi®), or a communication interface of a mobile communication system (3G, 4G, or 5G, etc.). The information acquisition unit 201 is used when a functional unit of the ledger server 21 communicates with other devices. The information acquisition unit 201 is capable of acquiring information regarding the evaluation values of a first provided item, a second provided item, and a third provided item in the ledger system 20.
[0114] The information processing unit 203 performs processing related to the distributed ledger 204a and transaction data. Specifically, when the information processing unit 203 receives transaction data from the ledger system 10 or terminals T1, T2, T3, etc., it verifies the digital signature contained in the received transaction data and controls the storage unit 204 to store the successfully verified transaction data in the distributed ledger 204a it holds. When storing transaction data in the distributed ledger 204a, the information processing unit 203 can generate a block containing the transaction data to be stored and control the storage unit 203 to store the generated block in the distributed ledger 204a if an agreement is reached with the information processing units 203 of other ledger servers, namely ledger servers 22 and 23, regarding the generated block.
[0115] The information processing unit 203 can perform information processing by executing a smart contract using the distributed ledger 204a. If a smart contract is not used, the information processing unit 203 performs information processing according to normal program code. As part of the above information processing, the information processing unit 203 executes the process of generating a trace NFT for the provided items using a smart contract.
[0116] In this embodiment, when there is insufficient information necessary to evaluate the first provided item, the information processing unit 203 refers to the relationship between the first organization and the kth organization (where k is an integer of 2 or more), the relationship between the first provided item and the kth provided item, the relationship between the first organization and the first provided item, and the relationship between the kth organization and the kth provided item, and derives an evaluation value for the first provided item.
[0117] For example, as shown in Figure 2, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third item, the information processing unit 203 derives the evaluation value of the first item using the evaluation value of the third organization recorded in the ledger system 10. Specifically, when the information processing unit 203 determines that there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third item because the evaluation value of the third item does not exist, it derives the evaluation value of the first item using the evaluation value of the third organization instead of the evaluation value of the third item.
[0118] The information processing unit 203 may determine that the evaluation value of the first provided item meets the evaluation criteria if the evaluation value of the third organization is equal to or greater than the predetermined evaluation criteria. Alternatively, the information processing unit 203 may determine that the evaluation value of the first provided item does not meet the evaluation criteria if the evaluation value of the third organization is less than the predetermined evaluation criteria.
[0119] Here, we will explain an example of how to derive the evaluation value of the first item provided. For example, if the evaluation criterion for the evaluation value of the item provided is set to 1 or higher, and three scores (0: NG, 1: OK, 2: Good) are provided for each organization's evaluation value, and three scores (0: NG, 1: OK, 2: Good) are provided for each item provided, then the evaluation value of the first item provided is expressed by (Equation 3) shown below.
[0120] The evaluation value of the first item = the score of the first item alone × the score of the second item × the score of the third item ... (Equation 3)
[0121] For example, if the individual score of the first item is 2, the score of the second item is 1, and the score of the third item is 1, and all the scores are the same, then the evaluation value of the first item will be 2 × 1 × 1 = 2, and the information processing unit 203 can derive the evaluation value of the first item without any problems. Furthermore, the information processing unit 103 can determine that the evaluation value of the first item satisfies the evaluation criteria.
[0122] However, as shown in Figure 2, if the evaluation value of the third offering is not recorded in the ledger system 20 (blockchain for offerings), the evaluation value of the first offering cannot be simply derived. Therefore, the information processing unit 203 uses the evaluation value of the third organization recorded in the ledger system 10 (blockchain for organizations) instead of the evaluation value of the third offering. For example, if the score of the third organization is "1", the information processing unit 203 substitutes "1" for the score of the third offering in (Equation 3). In this case, the evaluation value of the first offering becomes 2 × 1 × 1 = 2, and the information processing unit 203 determines that the evaluation value of the first offering meets the evaluation criteria. Note that the above example shows the score of the third organization being substituted directly for the score of the third offering, but it is not limited to this. For example, instead of the score of the third offering, a value obtained by multiplying the score of the third organization by a predetermined coefficient may be substituted.
[0123] If the information processing unit 203 derives the evaluation value of the first offered item using the evaluation value of the third organization, it may record in the ledger system 20 (blockchain for offered items) information indicating that it derived the evaluation value of the first offered item using an evaluation value other than the evaluation value of the third offered item that should have been used. In the example above, the information processing unit 203 may add information indicating that it derived the evaluation value of the first offered item using the evaluation value of the third organization to the information that the evaluation value of the first offered item = 2, and record this in the ledger system 20.
[0124] Furthermore, the information processing unit 203 may record in the ledger system 20 (blockchain for offered items) information indicating that the third offered item needs to be monitored if its evaluation value is lower than a predetermined evaluation value. For example, the information processing unit 203 may add information indicating that the third offered item needs to be monitored to the information showing the evaluation value of the third offered item and record it in the ledger system 20.
[0125] The memory unit 204 is a storage device that stores information. The memory unit 204 stores the distributed ledger 204a. The memory unit 204 is implemented by a non-volatile storage device (SSD (Solid State Drive) or HDD (Hard Disk Drive)), etc.
[0126] The distributed ledger 204a stores data having a structure in which blocks containing one or more transaction data are linked together in a chain. The one or more transaction data stored in the distributed ledger 204a include transaction data containing the contract code of a smart contract, transaction data containing instructions to execute a smart contract, or transaction data containing other information.
[0127] In the above, the expression that the device transmits information or data to the ledger system 10 means that the device transmits the information or data to one of the ledger servers 11, etc., provided by the ledger system 10 (for example, ledger server 11). Similarly, the expression that the ledger system 10 transmits information or data to a device means that one of the ledger servers 11, etc., provided by the ledger system 10 (for example, ledger server 11) transmits the information or data. The same applies to the ledger system 20.
[0128] The information processing system 1 of this embodiment includes information acquisition units 101 and 201 that acquire information regarding the evaluation value of the first organization, the evaluation value of the kth organization, the evaluation value of the first provided item, and the evaluation value of the kth provided item when the evaluation value of the kth organization is affected by the evaluation value of the first organization, and when the evaluation value of the kth provided item is affected by the evaluation value of the first provided item, which includes at least one of the goods and services provided by the first organization; and information processing units 103 and 203 that derive the evaluation value of the first provided item using the evaluation value of the kth organization when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the kth provided item, or derive the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the kth provided item when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the kth organization.
[0129] In this way, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th item, the evaluation value of the first item can be derived using the evaluation value of the k-th organization, thereby enabling the evaluation of the first item even when the necessary information is lacking. Similarly, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th organization, the evaluation value of the first organization can be derived using the evaluation value of the k-th item, thereby enabling the evaluation of the first organization even when the necessary information is lacking.
[0130] [Modification 1 of the Embodiment] The information processing system 1 in Modification 1 of the Embodiment will be described with reference to Figures 6 and 7. Modification 1 describes an example in which the ledger system 10 and ledger system 20 of the Embodiment are configured by a common ledger system 10A.
[0131] Figure 6 is a schematic diagram showing the overall configuration of the information processing system 1 in a modified example 1 of the embodiment.
[0132] As shown in Figure 6, the information processing system 1 of Modified Example 1 includes a common ledger system 10A. The information processing system 1 of Modified Example 1 is connected to a storage device 5 and terminals T1, T2, and T3, similar to the embodiment. The information processing system 1 of Modified Example 1 may further include a storage device 5 and terminals T1, T2, and T3. Each of the above devices is connected to a network N and can communicate via the network N.
[0133] The common ledger system 10A is an information processing system that stores information using a distributed ledger and has the functions of both the ledger system 10 and the ledger system 20 shown in the embodiment. The distributed ledger of the common ledger system 10A stores the generation history of NFTs that are associated one-to-one with the evaluation value of an organization, and the generation history of NFTs that are associated one-to-one with the evaluation value of an item provided. The above NFTs are trace NFTs for organizations and trace NFTs for items provided, which trace the evaluation value of an organization and items provided on the distributed ledger. The common ledger system 10A corresponds to the blockchain for organizations and the blockchain for items provided shown in Figure 1 or Figure 2.
[0134] The common ledger system 10A can execute processing using smart contracts with a distributed ledger. The common ledger system 10A generates trace NFTs for organizations and trace NFTs for provided items using processing by smart contracts.
[0135] The common ledger system 10A includes ledger servers 11A, 12A, and 13A (also referred to as ledger server 11A, etc.) as a group of servers that hold a distributed ledger. When at least one of the ledger servers 11A, etc. receives transaction data, that transaction data is shared by all the ledger servers 11A, etc. and stored in the distributed ledger. Note that the number of ledger servers included in the above group of servers is not limited to three, but may be two or more than three.
[0136] Ledger server 11A is a computer server that holds and manages the distributed ledger. Ledger server 11A holds the distributed ledger and updates it in synchronization with other ledger servers (specifically ledger servers 12A and 13A). Ledger server 11A constitutes part of the blockchain for organizations and the blockchain for offerings shown in Figure 1 or Figure 2, and is connected to terminal T1 used by the first organization via network N.
[0137] Ledger servers 12A and 13A are similar to ledger server 11A, and operate independently of ledger server 11A. Ledger server 12A constitutes part of the blockchain for organizations and the blockchain for offered items shown in Figure 1 or Figure 2, and is connected to terminal T2 used by a second organization via network N. Ledger server 13A constitutes part of the blockchain for organizations and the blockchain for offered items shown in Figure 1 or Figure 2, and is connected to terminal T3 used by a third organization via network N.
[0138] Figure 7 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of the ledger server 11A, which manages the evaluation values of the organization and the evaluation values of the items provided.
[0139] The ledger server 11A includes an information acquisition unit 101A, an information processing unit 103A, and a storage unit 104A as functional units. At least a portion of the functional units of the ledger server 11A are realized by the processor (e.g., CPU) of the ledger server 11A executing a program using memory. The storage unit 104A in the modified example 1 has the functions of both the storage unit 104 and the storage unit 204 shown in the embodiment.
[0140] The information acquisition unit 101A in Modified Example 1 has the functions of both the information acquisition unit 101 and the information acquisition unit 201 shown in the embodiment. The information acquisition unit 101A in Modified Example 1 is capable of acquiring information regarding the evaluation values of the first organization, the second organization, and the third organization in the common ledger system 10A, as well as the evaluation values of the first, second, and third provided items.
[0141] The information processing unit 103A in the modified example 1 has the functions of both the information processing unit 103 and the information processing unit 203 shown in the embodiment.
[0142] In Modified Example 1, the information processing unit 103A derives the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the third provided item recorded in the common ledger system 10A when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third organization. Furthermore, in Modified Example 1, the information processing unit 103A derives the evaluation value of the first provided item using the evaluation value of the third organization recorded in the common ledger system 10A when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third provided item. The information processing system 1 in Modified Example 1 can achieve the same effects as the information processing system 1 in the embodiment.
[0143] [Modification 2 of the Embodiment] The information processing system 1 in Modification 2 of the Embodiment will be described with reference to Figures 8 to 11. In Modification 2, an example will be described in which the information processing system 1 further includes an organization response system 30B and a provided item response system 40B. The organization response system 30B has the functions of the information acquisition unit 101 and the information processing unit 103 included in the ledger servers 11, 12, and 13 of the Embodiment, and the provided item response system 40B has the functions of the information acquisition unit 201 and the information processing unit 203 included in the ledger servers 21, 22, and 23 of the Embodiment.
[0144] Figure 8 is a schematic diagram showing the overall configuration of the information processing system 1 in a modified example 2 of the embodiment.
[0145] As shown in Figure 8, the information processing system 1 of Modified Example 2 includes a ledger system 10B, a ledger system 20B, an organization correspondence system 30B, and a provided item correspondence system 40B. The information processing system 1 of Modified Example 2 is connected to a storage device 5 and terminals T1, T2, and T3, similar to the embodiment. The information processing system 1 of Modified Example 2 may further include a storage device 5 and terminals T1, T2, and T3. Each of the above devices is connected to a network N and can communicate via the network N.
[0146] The ledger system 10B and the organization-based system 30B are information processing systems that store information using a distributed ledger. The distributed ledger of the ledger system 10B stores the generation history of NFTs that are associated one-to-one with the evaluation values of organizations. The above NFTs are trace NFTs for organizations that trace the evaluation values of organizations on the distributed ledger. The ledger system 10B and the organization-based system 30B correspond to the organization-based blockchain shown in Figure 1(a) or Figure 2(a).
[0147] The ledger system 10B includes ledger servers 11B, 12B, and 13B (also referred to as ledger server 11B, etc.) as a group of servers that hold distributed ledgers. The configurations of ledger servers 11B, 12B, and 13B are substantially the same as those of ledger servers 11, 12, and 13 in the embodiment. The functions of the information acquisition unit 101 and information processing unit 103 of the ledger server 11, etc. shown in the embodiment are provided in the organization-based system 30B of the modified example 2.
[0148] The ledger system 20B and the provided item handling system 40B are information processing systems that store information using a distributed ledger. The distributed ledger of the ledger system 20B stores the generation history of NFTs that are associated one-to-one with the evaluation value of the provided items. The above NFTs are trace NFTs for provided items that trace the evaluation value of the provided items on the distributed ledger. The ledger system 20B and the provided item handling system 40B correspond to the blockchain for provided items shown in Figure 1(b) and Figure 2(b).
[0149] The ledger system 20B includes ledger servers 21B, 22B, and 23B (also referred to as ledger server 21B, etc.) as a group of servers that hold a distributed ledger. The configurations of ledger servers 21B, 22B, and 23B are substantially the same as those of ledger servers 21, 22, and 23 in the embodiment. The functions of the information acquisition unit 201 and information processing unit 203 of the ledger server 21, etc. shown in the embodiment are provided in the provided item handling system 40B of the modified example 2.
[0150] Figure 9 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of the organizational response system 30B, which manages the evaluation values of the organization.
[0151] The organization-response system 30B includes an information acquisition unit 101, an information processing unit 103, and a user interface (not shown) as functional units. At least a portion of the functional units of the organization-response system 30B are realized by the processor (e.g., CPU) of the organization-response system 30B executing a program using memory. The configuration of the information acquisition unit 101 of the organization-response system 30B is the same as the configuration of the information acquisition unit 101 of the ledger server 11 shown in the embodiment. The configuration of the information processing unit 103 of the organization-response system 30B is the same as the configuration of the information processing unit 103 of the ledger server 11 shown in the embodiment.
[0152] Figure 10 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of the provided item management system 40B, which manages the evaluation values of the provided items.
[0153] The provided item handling system 40B includes an information acquisition unit 201, an information processing unit 203, and a user interface (not shown) as functional units. At least a portion of the functional units of the provided item handling system 40B are realized by the processor (e.g., CPU) of the provided item handling system 40B executing a program using memory. The configuration of the information acquisition unit 201 of the provided item handling system 40B is the same as the configuration of the information acquisition unit 201 of the ledger server 21 shown in the embodiment. The configuration of the information processing unit 203 of the provided item handling system 40B is the same as the configuration of the information processing unit 203 of the ledger server 21 shown in the embodiment.
[0154] Figure 11 shows the correspondence between organizations and the products or services they provide.
[0155] As shown in Figure 11, the first organization produces the first product, the second organization produces the second product, and the third organization produces the third product. The second organization is a supplier that provides goods and services to the first organization, and the third organization is also a supplier that provides goods and services to the first organization. The first organization produces the first product based on the second and third products.
[0156] In Modified Example 2, the information processing unit 103 derives the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the third provided item recorded in the ledger system 20B when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third organization. Furthermore, in Modified Example 2, the information processing unit 203 derives the evaluation value of the first provided item using the evaluation value of the third organization recorded in the ledger system 10B when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third provided item. The information processing system 1 in Modified Example 2 provides the same effects as the information processing system 1 in the embodiment.
[0157] [Information Processing Method (1)] The information processing method (1) and other details related to the embodiment will be explained with reference to Figures 12 to 14. First, before explaining the information processing method (1), the relationships between the multiple organizations and the multiple items provided will be explained.
[0158] Figure 12 is a schematic diagram showing multiple organizations, a database for organizations that records the evaluation value of each organization, NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation value of each organization, and multiple offerings, a database for offerings that records the evaluation value of each offering, and NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation value of each offering.
[0159] Figure 12(a) shows a first organization, a second organization directly related to the first organization, and a third organization directly related to the first organization. In this figure, the second organization is a supplier that provides goods and services to the first organization, and the third organization is also a supplier that provides goods and services to the first organization.
[0160] Furthermore, Figure 12(a) shows a database for organizations in which the evaluation values of the first organization, the second organization, and the third organization are recorded. The NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation value of each organization are recorded in the organization ledger system 10B (the organization's blockchain).
[0161] Figure 12(b) shows a first offering, a second offering directly related to the first offering, and a third offering directly related to the first offering. For example, the first offering is the product, the second offering is the parts used to produce the product, and the third offering is other parts used to produce the product.
[0162] Furthermore, Figure 12(b) shows a database for offerings in which the evaluation values of the first offering, the second offering, and the third offering are recorded. The NFT tokens corresponding to the evaluation value of each offering are recorded in the offering ledger system 20B (the offering blockchain). The relationship between each offering, its evaluation value, and the corresponding NFT token is created for each of the multiple first offerings provided by the first organization. In this example, information regarding the third offering is insufficient, and therefore the evaluation value of the third offering is not recorded in the offering ledger system 20B.
[0163] The organizations and offerings shown in Figures 12(a) and (b) have the following relationships: The first organization produces the first offering, the second organization produces the second offering, and the third organization produces the third offering. The second organization provides the second offering to the first organization, the third organization provides the third offering to the first organization, and the first organization provides the first offering, which it has produced based on the second and third offerings, to other parties different from the second and third organizations.
[0164] On the other hand, when tracing organizations and deliverables, we track things from downstream to upstream. The first organization obtains the second deliverable from the second organization and the third deliverable from the third organization in order to produce the first deliverable.
[0165] In the configuration shown in Figure 12, the evaluation value of the second organization directly influences the evaluation value of the first organization, and the evaluation value of the second provided item directly influences the evaluation value of the first provided item. Furthermore, the evaluation value of the third organization directly influences the evaluation value of the first organization, and the evaluation value of the third provided item directly influences the evaluation value of the first provided item.
[0166] When evaluating the first organization being assessed, it is desirable to have all the information regarding the evaluation values of the first, second, and third organizations. Similarly, when evaluating the first product being evaluated, it is desirable to have all the information regarding the evaluation values of the first, second, and third products being evaluated. However, in reality, there is often insufficient information regarding the organization being evaluated or the products it provides, making it impossible to properly evaluate the organization or products.
[0167] As mentioned above, in Figure 12(b), the ledger system 20B for provided items records the evaluation values of the first and second provided items, but does not record the evaluation value of the third provided item. Therefore, there is a problem in that the evaluation value of the first provided item cannot be properly derived because the evaluation value of the third provided item, which is originally necessary when deriving the evaluation value of the first provided item, is not available.
[0168] Therefore, in information processing method (1), when there is insufficient information necessary to evaluate an organization or a product, the organization or product is evaluated using other evaluation values recorded in the organization blockchain and the product blockchain.
[0169] For example, in information processing method (1), as shown in Figure 12, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third offering, the evaluation value of the first offering is derived using the evaluation value of the third organization recorded on the organization's blockchain. This method allows for the evaluation of the first offering even when the necessary information is lacking.
[0170] Furthermore, in information processing method (1), although it differs from the explanation shown in Figure 12, for example, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third organization, the evaluation value of the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the third provided item recorded in the blockchain for provided items. This method allows for the evaluation of the first organization even when the necessary information is insufficient. The following describes the processing performed in the information processing system 1 of modified example 2.
[0171] Figure 13 is a sequence diagram showing an example of processing performed in the information processing system 1 of the modified embodiment 2.
[0172] This section describes an example of deriving the evaluation value of the first offering using the evaluation value of the third organization when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third offering.
[0173] The information processing system 1 in the modified example 2, as shown in Figure 13, includes an organizational ledger system 10B, a ledger system 20B for provided items, an organizational correspondence system 30B, a provided item correspondence system 40B, and terminals T1, T2, and T3. In Figure 13, terminals T1, T2, and T3 are shown separately as functional units related to the organizational ledger system 10B and the organizational correspondence system 30B, and functional units related to the provided item ledger system 20B and the provided item correspondence system 40B.
[0174] First, the provided items handling system 40B performs initial setup on the ledger system 20B for provided items (step S101). For example, as an initial setup, the provided items handling system 40B registers the first, second, and third provided items that may be subject to evaluation. The ledger system 20B for provided items records the relationships between the first, second, and third provided items.
[0175] Meanwhile, the organization management system 30B performs initial setup on the organization ledger system 10B (step S201). For example, as an initial setup, the organization management system 30B registers the first, second, and third organizations that may be subject to evaluation. The organization ledger system 10B records the relationships between the first, second, and third organizations.
[0176] The organization response system 30B requests each organization to register its own evaluation value (step S210). Specifically, the organization response system 30B outputs instruction signals to each terminal T1, T2, and T3 of each organization, instructing them to register their respective evaluation values.
[0177] Terminal T2 of the second organization sends a registration signal to the ledger system 10B for the organization to register the evaluation value of the second organization, and registers the evaluation value of the second organization (step S211). The ledger server 12B of the ledger system 10B for the organization records the evaluation value of the second organization in the distributed ledger 104a.
[0178] Terminal T3 of the third organization sends a registration signal to the ledger system 10B for the organization to register the evaluation value of the third organization, and registers the evaluation value of the third organization (step S212). The ledger server 13B of the ledger system 10B for the organization records the evaluation value of the third organization in the distributed ledger 104a.
[0179] Terminal T1 of the first organization sends a registration signal to the organization ledger system 10B to register the evaluation value of the first organization, and registers the evaluation value of the first organization (step S213). The ledger server 11B of the organization ledger system 10B records the evaluation value of the first organization in the distributed ledger 104a. The evaluation value of the first organization to be registered in the organization ledger system 10B is an overall evaluation value of the first organization, including the evaluation values of the second and third organizations. In order to derive the overall evaluation value of the first organization, it is necessary to perform a trace starting from the first organization, but this explanation is omitted in this sequence diagram.
[0180] The processes described in steps S201 to S213 above only need to be completed before step S130, shown below, begins. The following explanation will focus on the processes performed in the provided items handling system 40B, the ledger system 20B for provided items, and terminals T1, T2, and T3.
[0181] The provided items handling system 40B requests each organization to register the evaluation value of the provided items (step S110). Specifically, the provided items handling system 40B outputs instruction signals to each terminal T1, T2, and T3 of each organization instructing them to register the evaluation value of the provided items.
[0182] Terminal T2 of the second organization sends a registration signal to the ledger system 20B for the second provided item to register the evaluation value of the second provided item, and registers the evaluation value of the second provided item (step S111). The ledger server 22B of the ledger system 20B for the provided item records the evaluation value of the second provided item in the distributed ledger 204a.
[0183] In this example, the third organization is unable to derive an evaluation value for the third provided item, and therefore cannot output a registration signal from the third organization's terminal T3 to register the evaluation value for the third provided item. Consequently, the ledger server 23B of the ledger system 20B for provided items does not have an evaluation value for the third provided item registered. In this situation, a trace is performed starting from the first provided item, and the first provided item is evaluated.
[0184] First, the terminal T1 of the first organization requests the provided item handling system 40B to perform a trace starting from the first provided item (step S120). Specifically, the terminal T1 of the first organization sends a request signal to the provided item handling system 40B requesting a trace starting from the first provided item.
[0185] The provided item handling system 40B receives the above request signal and starts tracing from the first provided item (step S130). Specifically, the provided item handling system 40B performs the following processing to obtain the evaluation values of the first, second, and third provided items.
[0186] The provided item handling system 40B sends a request signal to the ledger system 20B for provided items, requesting the presentation of an evaluation value for the second provided item (step S131). In response, the ledger system 20B for provided items returns the evaluation value for the second provided item to the provided item handling system 40B (step S132). As a result, the provided item handling system 40B obtains the evaluation value for the second provided item.
[0187] Furthermore, the provided item handling system 40B transmits a request signal to the ledger system 20B for provided items, requesting the presentation of an evaluation value for the third provided item (step S133). However, since the ledger system 20B for provided items does not have an evaluation value for the third provided item, the provided item handling system 40B fails to obtain an evaluation value for the third provided item (step S134).
[0188] Therefore, the provided item handling system 40B determines that there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third provided item and decides to derive the evaluation value of the first provided item by substituting other evaluation values. More specifically, since the provided item handling system 40B does not have an evaluation value for the third provided item, it decides to derive the evaluation value of the first provided item by using the evaluation value of the third organization instead of the evaluation value of the third provided item (step S140).
[0189] The provided item response system 40B transmits a presentation request signal to the organization response system 30B requesting the presentation of evaluation values for the third organization (step S141).
[0190] The organization response system 30B receives the above presentation request signal and instructs the organization ledger system 10B to present the evaluation value of the third organization (step S142). The organization ledger system 10B transmits the evaluation value of the third organization to the organization response system 30B (step S143), and the organization response system 30B receives the evaluation value of the third organization. The organization response system 30B transmits the evaluation value of the third organization to the provided item response system 40B (step S144). As a result, the provided item response system 40B obtains the evaluation value of the third organization.
[0191] The provided item handling system 40B derives an evaluation value for the first provided item based on the individual evaluation value of the first provided item, the evaluation value of the second provided item, and the evaluation value of the third organization (step S150). Then, the provided item handling system 40B registers the evaluation value of the first provided item derived in step S150 in the ledger system 20B for provided items (blockchain for provided items) (step S151).
[0192] If, as described above, there is no evaluation value for the third item, the evaluation value for the first item is derived using the evaluation value of the third organization instead. For example, the evaluation value for the first item is expressed by (Equation 4) shown below.
[0193] The evaluation value of the first item provided = the evaluation value of the first item provided alone × the evaluation value of the second item provided × the evaluation value of the third organization ... (Equation 4)
[0194] The provided item handling system 40B sends a completion notification to the terminal T1 of the first organization indicating that the tracing of the first provided item has been completed (step S160).
[0195] Terminal T1 of the first organization transmits a viewing request signal to the ledger system 20B for provided items, requesting to view the evaluation value of the first provided item (step S161). The ledger system 20B for provided items transmits the evaluation value of the first provided item to terminal T1 of the first organization (step S162). Terminal T1 displays the evaluation value of the first provided item on its display screen (step S163).
[0196] Figure 14 shows an example of how to display the evaluation value of the first item provided.
[0197] Figure 14 shows an example where the "Relationship of the First Offering" shown in Figure 12(b) is displayed on the display screen of terminal T1, and by touching the icon for "Evaluation Value of the First Offering," a "Proof Token" containing the evaluation value of the first offering is displayed. The proof token is issued based on the evaluation value recorded in the ledger system 20B for offerings (blockchain for offerings). This proof token contains a token ID and information regarding the evaluation value of the first offering. This proof token also contains information indicating whether or not the evaluation value of the first offering was derived using an evaluation value different from the evaluation value of the offering.
[0198] Furthermore, the provided item handling system 40B transmits a viewing request signal to the ledger system 20B for provided items, requesting to view the evaluation value of the first provided item (step S164). The ledger system 20B for provided items transmits the evaluation value of the first provided item to the provided item handling system 40B (step S165). The provided item handling system 40B displays the evaluation value of the first provided item on the display screen, which is the user interface (step S166). The display screen shown on the provided item handling system 40B is the same as in Figure 14.
[0199] By following the steps described above, it is possible to evaluate the provided items even when the information necessary to evaluate them is lacking. Furthermore, by using the ledger system described above, information regarding the organization's evaluation values and the evaluation values of the provided items can be accurately retrieved, stored, and viewed.
[0200] [Information Processing Method (2)] Information processing method (2) according to the embodiment will be described with reference to Figures 15 and 16.
[0201] Figure 15 is a sequence diagram showing an example of other processes performed in the information processing system 1 of the modified embodiment 2.
[0202] This section describes an example of deriving the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the third provided item, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third organization.
[0203] As shown in Figure 15, the information processing system 1 of the modified example 2 includes an organizational ledger system 10B, a ledger system 20B for provided items, an organizational correspondence system 30B, a provided item correspondence system 40B, and terminals T1, T2, and T3. In Figure 15, terminals T1, T2, and T3 are shown separately as functional units related to the organizational ledger system 10B and the organizational correspondence system 30B, and functional units related to the provided item ledger system 20B and the provided item correspondence system 40B.
[0204] First, the organization management system 30B performs initial setup on the organization ledger system 10B (step S301). For example, as an initial setup, the organization management system 30B registers the first, second, and third organizations that may be subject to evaluation. The organization ledger system 10B records the relationships between the first, second, and third organizations.
[0205] Meanwhile, the provided items system 40B performs initial setup on the ledger system 20B for provided items (step S401). For example, as an initial setup, the provided items system 40B registers the first, second, and third provided items that may be subject to evaluation. The ledger system 20B for provided items records the relationships between the first, second, and third provided items.
[0206] The provided item handling system 40B requests each organization to register the evaluation value for each provided item (step S410). Specifically, the provided item handling system 40B outputs instruction signals to each terminal T1, T2, and T3 of each organization, instructing them to register the evaluation value for each provided item.
[0207] Terminal T2 of the second organization sends a registration signal to the ledger system 20B for the second provided item to register the evaluation value of the second provided item, and registers the evaluation value of the second provided item (step S411). The ledger server 22B of the ledger system 20B for the provided item records the evaluation value of the second provided item in the distributed ledger 204a.
[0208] Terminal T3 of the third organization sends a registration signal to the ledger system 20B for the third provided item to register the evaluation value of the third provided item, and registers the evaluation value of the third provided item (step S412). The ledger server 23B of the ledger system 20B for the provided item records the evaluation value of the third provided item in the distributed ledger 204a.
[0209] Terminal T1 of the first organization sends a registration signal to the ledger system 20B for provided items to register the evaluation value of the first provided item, and registers the evaluation value of the first provided item (step S413). The ledger server 21B of the ledger system 20B for provided items records the evaluation value of the first provided item in the distributed ledger 204a. The evaluation value of the first provided item to be registered in the ledger system 20B for provided items is an overall evaluation value of the first provided item, including the evaluation values of the second and third provided items. In order to derive the overall evaluation value of the first provided item, it is necessary to perform a trace starting from the first provided item, but this explanation is omitted in this sequence diagram.
[0210] The processes described in steps S401 to S413 above only need to be completed before step S330, shown below, begins. The following explanation will focus on the processes performed in the organization management system 30B, the organization ledger system 10B, and terminals T1, T2, and T3.
[0211] The organization response system 30B requests each organization to register its evaluation value (step S310). Specifically, the organization response system 30B outputs instruction signals to each terminal T1, T2, and T3 of each organization, instructing them to register their evaluation value.
[0212] Terminal T2 of the second organization sends a registration signal to the ledger system 10B for the organization to register the evaluation value of the second organization, and registers the evaluation value of the second organization (step S311). The ledger server 12B of the ledger system 10B for the organization records the evaluation value of the second organization in the distributed ledger 104a.
[0213] In this example, the evaluation value for the third organization cannot be derived in the third organization, and the terminal T3 of the third organization cannot output a registration signal to register the evaluation value for the third organization. Therefore, the evaluation value for the third organization is not registered in the ledger server 13B of the ledger system 10B for organizations. In this situation, a trace is performed starting from the first organization, and the first organization is evaluated.
[0214] First, the terminal T1 of the first organization requests the organization response system 30B to perform a trace starting from the first organization (step S320). Specifically, the terminal T1 of the first organization sends a request signal to the organization response system 30B requesting a trace starting from the first organization.
[0215] The organization response system 30B receives the above request signal and starts tracing from the first organization (step S330). Specifically, the organization response system 30B performs the following processing to obtain evaluation values for the first organization, the second organization, and the third organization.
[0216] The organization response system 30B sends a request signal to the organization ledger system 10B requesting the presentation of an evaluation value for a second organization (step S331). In response, the organization ledger system 10B returns the evaluation value for the second organization to the organization response system 30B. As a result, the organization response system 30B obtains the evaluation value for the second organization (step S332).
[0217] Furthermore, the organization management system 30B sends a request signal to the organization ledger system 10B requesting the presentation of an evaluation value for the third organization (step S333). However, since the organization ledger system 10B does not contain an evaluation value for the third organization, the organization management system 30B fails to obtain an evaluation value for the third organization (step S334).
[0218] Therefore, the organizational response system 30B determines that there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the third organization and decides to derive the evaluation value of the first organization by substituting other evaluation values. More specifically, since there is no evaluation value for the third organization, the organizational response system 30B decides to derive the evaluation value of the first organization by using the evaluation value of the third provided item instead of the evaluation value of the third organization (step S340).
[0219] The organizational response system 30B transmits a presentation request signal to the provided item response system 40B requesting the presentation of an evaluation value for the third provided item (step S341).
[0220] The provided item handling system 40B receives the above presentation request signal and instructs the ledger system 20B for provided items to present the evaluation value of the third provided item (step S342). The ledger system 20B for provided items transmits the evaluation value of the third provided item to the provided item handling system 40B (step S343), and the provided item handling system 40B receives the evaluation value of the third provided item. The provided item handling system 40B transmits the evaluation value of the third provided item to the organization handling system 30B (step S344). As a result, the organization handling system 30B obtains the evaluation value of the third provided item.
[0221] The organization management system 30B derives an evaluation value for the first organization based on the evaluation value of the first organization alone, the evaluation value of the second organization, and the evaluation value of the third provided item (step S350). Then, the organization management system 30B registers the evaluation value of the first organization derived in step S350 in the organization ledger system 10B (organizational blockchain) (step S351).
[0222] If, as described above, there is no evaluation value for the third organization, the evaluation value for the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the third provided item instead of the evaluation value for the third organization. For example, the evaluation value for the first organization is expressed by (Equation 5) shown below.
[0223] Evaluation value of the first organization = Evaluation value of the first organization alone × Evaluation value of the second organization × Evaluation value of the third provided item ... (Equation 5)
[0224] The organization response system 30B sends a completion notification to the terminal T1 of the first organization indicating that the tracing of the first organization has been completed (step S360).
[0225] The terminal T1 of the first organization sends a viewing request signal to the ledger system 10B for the organization, requesting to view the evaluation value of the first organization (step S361). The ledger system 10B for the organization sends the evaluation value of the first organization to the terminal T1 of the first organization (step S362). The terminal T1 displays the evaluation value of the first organization on the display screen (step S363).
[0226] Figure 16 shows an example of how evaluation values for the first organization are displayed.
[0227] Figure 16 shows an example where a "certification token" containing the evaluation value of the first organization is displayed on the display screen of terminal T1. The certification token is issued based on the evaluation value recorded in the organization's ledger system 10B (the organization's blockchain). This certification token contains a token ID and information regarding the evaluation value of the first organization. This certification token also contains information indicating whether or not the evaluation value of the first organization was derived using an evaluation value different from the organization's evaluation value.
[0228] Furthermore, the organization management system 30B transmits a viewing request signal to the organization ledger system 10B requesting to view the evaluation value of the first organization (step S364). The organization ledger system 10B transmits the evaluation value of the first organization to the organization management system 30B (step S365). The organization management system 30B displays the evaluation value of the first organization on a display screen which is the user interface (step S366). The display screen shown on the organization management system 30B is the same as that shown in Figure 16.
[0229] By following the steps described above, it becomes possible to evaluate an organization even when the necessary information for evaluation is lacking. Furthermore, using the ledger system described above, it becomes possible to accurately read, store, and view information regarding the evaluation values of the organization and the services provided.
[0230] (Explanation of the Distributed Ledger System) The ledger system 10 or 20 (also called the distributed ledger system) described above will be explained in detail below.
[0231] A distributed ledger system is a system that stores and maintains information using P2P (peer-to-peer) network technology, in which multiple nodes are connected. A node is an information processing device in which a processor (e.g., a CPU) executes a program using memory to perform predetermined processing.
[0232] In a distributed ledger system, each of the multiple nodes autonomously and distributedly maintains and synchronizes copies of the information. This allows the distributed ledger system to properly store information while effectively preventing tampering, without using privileged nodes (e.g., a centralized server or a server in a client-server model).
[0233] Furthermore, a device attempting to access a distributed ledger only needs to access one of the multiple nodes provided by the distributed ledger system; in other words, it does not need to access a small number of centralized servers or other devices. This avoids the concentration of communication or processing load on a centralized server that can occur in centralized systems. This has the advantage that the resources (CPU or memory, etc.) of the nodes do not need to be of very high specifications, and the communication lines to which the nodes are connected do not need to have a large communication capacity. As a result, a distributed ledger system can be configured using general-purpose nodes or communication lines, which can contribute to a reduction in the required computer resources or communication resources, or a reduction in the costs required for nodes and communication lines.
[0234] Furthermore, distributed ledger systems can store information with high fault tolerance and allow information to be accessed with high fault tolerance. If all of the multiple nodes of a distributed ledger system fail, the distributed ledger system will stop, but since it is rare for all of the multiple nodes to fail, it is rare for the distributed ledger system to stop. This is an advantage over centralized systems, where if the centralized server fails, information cannot be stored or accessed.
[0235] Referring to Figures 17 to 21, we will explain the data structure of distributed ledgers, the execution of smart contracts, and the data structure of NFTs.
[0236] Figure 17 is an explanatory diagram showing the data structure of a blockchain, which is an example of a distributed ledger.
[0237] A blockchain is a chain of interconnected blocks, which are the units of data. Each block contains multiple transaction data and the hash value of the previous block.
[0238] Figure 17 shows blocks B1, B2, and B3 included in the blockchain.
[0239] For example, block B2 contains the hash value of the preceding block B1. The hash value of block B1 is calculated by performing a hash algorithm operation on the contents of block B1.
[0240] Furthermore, block B3 contains a hash value calculated from multiple transaction data contained in block B2 and the hash value of block B1, which is then included as the hash value of block B2.
[0241] Thus, because blockchain has a structure in which blocks containing the contents of the previous block as a hash value are linked together in a chain, it can effectively prevent tampering with recorded transaction data.
[0242] If past transaction data is altered (in other words, tampered with), the hash value of the block containing that transaction data will be different from the value before the alteration. In that case, to make the block containing the altered transaction data appear correct, all blocks from that block onward in the distributed ledger, which is stored by multiple servers, would have to be rebuilt, and this process is practically extremely difficult. Due to this characteristic, tampering with transaction data contained in a blockchain may be virtually impossible.
[0243] When a node stores transaction data on the blockchain, it generates a block containing the transaction data to be stored and attempts to reach an agreement with other nodes by performing a consensus algorithm-based process on the generated block. The node then controls itself to store the block on the blockchain once an agreement is reached. This allows multiple nodes operating autonomously and decentralized to connect legitimate blocks to the blockchain. As a consensus algorithm, PBFT (Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance), PoW (Proof of Work), or PoS (Proof of Stake) may be used. Note that when using Hyperledger Fabric as an example of distributed ledger technology, the consensus algorithm does not need to be executed.
[0244] Figure 18 is an explanatory diagram showing the data structure of transaction data.
[0245] The transaction data shown in Figure 18 includes a transaction body BP1 and a digital signature BP2 (also simply called a signature). The transaction body BP1 is the data itself contained within the transaction data. The digital signature BP2 is generated by encrypting the hash value of the transaction body BP1 with the signing key (in other words, the private key) of the creator of the transaction data.
[0246] A node that receives transaction data can use the digital signature BP2 contained in the transaction data to verify that the transaction body BP1 is legitimate (in other words, that it has not been tampered with). This makes it virtually impossible to tamper with the data contained in the transaction body BP1. Furthermore, by storing the verified transaction data on the blockchain, the legitimacy of the transaction data stored on the blockchain can be maintained.
[0247] As described above, transaction data included in a blockchain is stored in the blockchain by linking the hash values of the transaction data and the hash values of the blocks. This ensures that the transaction data included in the blockchain is stored and maintained virtually without tampering. This is an advantage that distinguishes it from a database or distributed database where data is simply stored as a collection.
[0248] Figure 19 is an explanatory diagram showing transaction data related to the execution of a smart contract. Figure 20 is an explanatory diagram showing the processing related to the execution of a smart contract.
[0249] Referring to Figures 19 and 20, a series of processes related to the execution of a smart contract using a distributed ledger will be explained.
[0250] In step SB1, the node stores transaction data B11, which includes contract code B12 describing the processing of the smart contract, in the distributed ledger B10. For example, the node obtains transaction data B11 by receiving it via communication from an information processing device or by generating the transaction data B11 itself, and stores the obtained transaction data B11 in the distributed ledger B10. Step SB1 is performed before executing the smart contract.
[0251] In step SB2, the node stores transaction data B15, which includes the instruction B16 to execute the smart contract, in the distributed ledger B10. For example, the node receives transaction data B15 from an information processing device via communication and stores the received transaction data B15 in the distributed ledger B10.
[0252] In step SB3, the node reads the contract code B12 from the distributed ledger B10 in response to the fact that the transaction data B15, including the instruction B16, was stored in the distributed ledger B10 in step SB2, and executes processing based on the contract code B12. The result of the above processing may be included in the transaction data and stored in the distributed ledger B10.
[0253] Through the above series of processes, when the distributed ledger system receives transaction data B15 containing the instruction B16 to execute a smart contract, it automatically (in other words, without human intervention) executes the process according to instruction B16, enabling highly efficient (in other words, fast or in a short time) processing. This high-efficiency processing has the effect of reducing power consumption. Furthermore, because it does not involve human intervention, it is possible to prevent human tampering with information, fraudulent activities, or human errors. In addition, since the results of the processing executed in this way are stored on the blockchain, it is virtually impossible to tamper with the results of the processing.
[0254] Figure 21 is an explanatory diagram showing the structure of an NFT and metadata. An NFT is a token stored on a distributed ledger and is a unique token (in other words, a non-fungible token). NFTs are standardized, for example, as ERC (Ethereum Request for Comments) 721, but are not limited to this, and may conform to different standards or be non-standard (for example, unique to an organization).
[0255] Figure 21 shows transaction data B21 stored in the distributed ledger. Transaction data B21 contains NFTs.
[0256] An NFT has metadata. The metadata may be located in a location accessible via the network (e.g., storage device B22). A token URI indicating the location of the metadata is calculated using the NFT's token ID and a predetermined base URI.
[0257] Information managed as an NFT may be included in transaction data B21 or in metadata. Including information managed as an NFT in metadata has the advantage of reducing the amount of information that can be included in transaction data B21 (in other words, the information that can be included in the blockchain). In this case, metadata can be said to contain the actual information managed as an NFT. When an image is managed as an NFT, the URL that points to the image data of that image may be managed as an NFT.
[0258] In the above embodiment, each component may be implemented by dedicated hardware or by executing a software program suitable for each component. Each component may also be implemented by a program execution unit such as a CPU or processor reading and executing a software program recorded on a recording medium such as a hard disk or semiconductor memory. Here, the software that implements the information processing system, etc., of the above embodiment is the following program.
[0259] In other words, this program is a program that causes a computer to execute an information processing method in which, when the evaluation value of a first organization is affected by the evaluation value of a k-th organization (where k is an integer of 2 or more) related to the first organization, and the evaluation value of a first offering that includes at least one of the goods and services provided by the k-th organization is affected by the evaluation value of a first offering that includes at least one of the goods and services provided by the k-th organization, and there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th offering, the program derives the evaluation value of the first offering using the evaluation value of the k-th organization, or when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th organization, the program derives the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the k-th offering.
[0260] Although information processing methods and the like relating to one or more embodiments have been described above based on embodiments, this disclosure is not limited to these embodiments. Without departing from the spirit of this disclosure, various modifications that a person skilled in the art could conceive of may be applied to these embodiments, and forms constructed by combining components from different embodiments may also be included within the scope of one or more embodiments.
[0261] The information processing methods disclosed herein can be used as a method for evaluating organizations or offerings.
[0262] 1 Information Processing System 5, B22 Storage Device 10, 10B, 20, 20B Ledger System 10A Common Ledger System 11, 11A, 11B, 12, 12A, 12B, 13, 13A, 13B, 21, 21B, 22, 22B, 23, 23B Ledger Server 30B Organization-Responding System 40B Provided Item-Responding System 101, 101A, 201 Information Acquisition Unit 103, 103A, 203 Information Processing Unit 104, 104A, 204 Storage Unit 104a, 204a, B10 Distributed Ledger B1, B2, B3 Block B11, B15, B21 Transaction Data B12 Contract Code B16 Instruction BP1 Transaction Body BP2 Digital Signature N Network T1, T2, T3 terminals
Claims
1. An information processing method performed by one or more computers, wherein the evaluation value of a first organization is influenced by the evaluation value of a k-th organization (where k is an integer of 2 or more) related to the first organization, and the evaluation value of a first offering, which includes at least one of the goods and services provided by the k-th organization, is influenced by the evaluation value of a first offering, which includes at least one of the goods and services provided by the k-th organization, and when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th offering, the method derives the evaluation value of the first offering using the evaluation value of the k-th organization, or when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k-th organization, the method derives the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the k-th offering.
2. The information processing method according to claim 1, wherein, when it is determined that there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the provided item k because an evaluation value for the provided item k does not exist, the evaluation value of the first provided item is derived using the evaluation value of the organization k instead of the evaluation value of the provided item k, or, when it is determined that there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the organization k because an evaluation value for the organization k does not exist, the evaluation value of the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the provided item k instead of the evaluation value of the organization k.
3. The information processing method according to claim 1, further comprising deriving an evaluation value for the first provided item or an evaluation value for the first organization by referring to the relationship between the first organization and the organization k, the relationship between the first provided item and the provided item k, the relationship between the first organization and the first provided item, and the relationship between the organization k and the provided item k.
4. The information processing method according to claim 1, wherein the first organization is an organization that generates the first offerings based on the offerings of k.
5. The information processing method according to claim 1, wherein if the evaluation value of the organization k is equal to or greater than a predetermined evaluation standard, it is determined that the evaluation value of the first provided item meets the evaluation standard.
6. The information processing method according to claim 1, wherein if the evaluation value of the provided items k is less than a predetermined evaluation standard, it is determined that the evaluation value of the first organization does not meet the evaluation standard.
7. The information processing method according to claim 1, wherein, when deriving the evaluation value of the organization k, the evaluation value of the organization k is adjusted based on the data collected by the automated data collection system used by the organization k.
8. The information processing method according to any one of claims 1 to 7, wherein the evaluation value is recorded on a blockchain.
9. The information processing method according to claim 8, wherein, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k provided item recorded on the blockchain, the evaluation value of the first provided item is derived using the evaluation value of the k organization recorded on the blockchain, and the evaluation value of the first provided item is recorded on the blockchain, or, when there is insufficient information regarding the evaluation value of the k organization recorded on the blockchain, the evaluation value of the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the k provided item recorded on the blockchain, and the evaluation value of the first organization is recorded on the blockchain.
10. The information processing method according to claim 8, which issues a proof token based on the evaluation value recorded on the blockchain and displays the proof token.
11. The information processing method according to claim 8, wherein when the evaluation value of the first provided item is derived using the evaluation value of the organization k, information is recorded on the blockchain indicating that the evaluation value of the first provided item was derived using an evaluation value other than the evaluation value of the provided item k that should have been used, or when the evaluation value of the first organization is derived using the evaluation value of the provided item k, information is recorded on the blockchain indicating that the evaluation value of the first organization was derived using an evaluation value other than the evaluation value of the organization k that should have been used.
12. The information processing method according to claim 8, wherein if the evaluation value of the organization k is lower than a predetermined evaluation value, information indicating that the organization k needs to be monitored is recorded on the blockchain, or if the evaluation value of the goods provided by k is lower than a predetermined evaluation value, information indicating that the goods provided by k need to be monitored is recorded on the blockchain.
13. The aforementioned evaluation values include the evaluation of employee labor, legal compliance, environmental impact, and CO2 levels of the first organization and the k organization, respectively. 2 An information processing method according to any one of claims 1 to 7, derived based on an evaluation of emissions, an evaluation of the maintenance of the first item and the item k, an evaluation of the traceability tracking length, and an evaluation of the risk to changes in economic conditions.
14. An information processing system comprising: an information acquisition unit that acquires information regarding the evaluation value of the first organization, the evaluation value of the k organization, the evaluation value of the first item, and the evaluation value of the k item, which includes at least one of the goods and services provided by the k organization, when the evaluation value of the k organization is insufficient, and when the evaluation value of the k item is insufficient, an information processing unit that derives the evaluation value of the first item using the evaluation value of the k organization, or derives the evaluation value of the first organization using the evaluation value of the k item, when the information regarding the evaluation value of the k item is insufficient.
15. A program that causes one or more computers to execute the information processing method described in any one of claims 1 to 7.
