Analysis-based chiller ranking

By calculating the efficiency and health score of the cooler, its operating sequence is automatically adjusted, which solves the performance degradation problem caused by cooler aging and optimizes system efficiency.

CN110737214BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-26CARRIER CORP
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN201810808654.5
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2018-07-18
Publication Date
2024-11-26
Estimated Expiration
2038-07-18

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

When the performance of the cooler deteriorates due to aging and faulty components, existing technologies cannot effectively optimize its sequencing, resulting in a decrease in overall system efficiency.

Method used

By ranking the coolers based on measured efficiency and health values, and using sensor data to calculate efficiency and health scores, the operating sequence of the coolers is automatically adjusted to optimize system performance.

Benefits of technology

It enables automatic optimization of the overall performance of the cooler system without human intervention, maximizing efficiency and reducing further performance degradation.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN110737214B_ABST
    Figure CN110737214B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

Embodiments include systems and methods for performing analysis-based refrigerator ranking. Embodiments include: a plurality of refrigerators; a system controller configured to control the plurality of refrigerators; and one or more sensors in communication with the controller, the one or more sensors configured to generate operating data based on measured operating parameters of the plurality of refrigerators. Embodiments include a controller, the controller including a processor, the processor configured to obtain the operating data, calculate a score for each of the plurality of refrigerators based on the operating data, and rank the plurality of refrigerators based on the scores. The processor is also configured to rank the plurality of refrigerators based at least in part on the ranking, and to control the operation of the plurality of refrigerators based on the ranking.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Background Art

[0001] The present disclosure relates generally to chillers, and more particularly to performing analytics-based ranking of chillers.

[0002] In today's environment, refrigerators are used to provide cooling for buildings and structures of various sizes. Refrigerator and many other types of equipment together constitute the entire cooling system to regulate the interior space. For example, refrigerators include various sensors, motors, condensers, evaporators, etc. And other equipment in the cooling system includes pumps, cooling towers, air handlers, meters, etc. Large-scale cooling systems may include multiple refrigerators to achieve good energy efficiency under partial load conditions. As refrigerators operate over time, due to aging or fatigue wear of their mechanical parts, refrigerators may show some performance changes. Although refrigerators are still operable, because of performance degradation, performance may vary in a relatively wide range. Different refrigerators in the system may have different levels of performance degradation. Therefore, it is necessary to optimize the sequencing of refrigerators to maximize the overall performance of the system and minimize the further degradation of refrigerators. Summary of the invention

[0003] According to one embodiment, a system for performing analysis-based refrigerator ranking is provided. The system includes: a plurality of refrigerators; a controller configured to control the plurality of refrigerators; and one or more sensors communicating with the controller, the one or more sensors being configured to generate operating data based on the measured operating parameters of the plurality of refrigerators. The controller includes a processor configured to obtain the operating data, calculate a score for each refrigerator in the plurality of refrigerators based on the operating data, and rank the plurality of refrigerators based on the scores. The processor is also configured to rank the plurality of refrigerators at least in part based on the ranking, and to control the operation of the plurality of refrigerators based on the ranking.

[0004] In addition to or in lieu of one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include a score for each chiller including at least one of an efficiency score and a health score.

[0005] In addition to or in lieu of one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include a score that is a weighted score of at least one of an efficiency score and a health score.

[0006] In addition to or as an alternative to one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include a processor configured to calculate an efficiency score based on the chilled water capacity and the power consumed by each chiller.

[0007] In addition to or as an alternative to one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include a processor configured to estimate an efficiency score based on an estimated chilled water capacity and consumed power of each chiller.

[0008] In addition to or in lieu of one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include a health score based on the chilled water supply temperature of each chiller and the chiller water supply temperature set point.

[0009] In addition to or in lieu of one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include a health score based on at least one of a machine fatigue wear state, a noise level, or a vibration level.

[0010] In addition to or as an alternative to one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include ranking including performing a first ranking based on an efficiency score and performing a second ranking based on a health score.

[0011] In addition to or as an alternative to one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include a controller configured to re-sequence the plurality of refrigerators at configurable intervals.

[0012] According to one embodiment, a method for performing analysis-based refrigerator ranking is provided. The method includes obtaining operating data of each refrigerator in a plurality of refrigerators, calculating a score for each refrigerator in the plurality of refrigerators based on the operating data, and ranking the plurality of refrigerators based on the scores. The method also includes ranking the plurality of refrigerators based at least in part on the rankings, and controlling the operation of the plurality of refrigerators based on the rankings.

[0013] In addition to or in lieu of one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include a score for each chiller including at least one of an efficiency score and a health score.

[0014] In addition to or in lieu of one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include weighting at least one of the efficiency score and the health score.

[0015] In addition to, or in the alternative to, one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include calculating an efficiency score based at least in part on the chilled water capacity and the power consumed by each chiller.

[0016] In addition to, or in the alternative to, one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include estimating an efficiency score based at least in part on an estimated chilled water capacity and consumed power of each chiller.

[0017] In addition to or in lieu of one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include a health score based on the chilled water supply temperature and the chilled water supply temperature set point for each chiller.

[0018] In addition to or in lieu of one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include a health score based on at least one of a machine fatigue wear state, a noise level, or a vibration level.

[0019] In addition to or as an alternative to one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include performing a first ranking based on an efficiency score and performing a second ranking based on a health score.

[0020] In addition to or in lieu of one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include reordering a plurality of refrigerators at configurable intervals.

[0021] In addition to, or in the alternative to, one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include calculating an efficiency score when flow sensor data for each chiller is available.

[0022] In addition to, or in the alternative to, one or more of the features described above, further embodiments may include estimating efficiency scores when flow sensor data for each chiller is not available.

[0023] Unless otherwise explicitly stated, the aforementioned features and elements may be combined in various combinations without exclusivity. These features and elements and their operation will become more apparent from the following description and accompanying drawings. However, it should be understood that the following description and accompanying drawings are intended to be illustrative and explanatory rather than restrictive in nature. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0024] The following description should not be considered limiting in any way. Referring to the accompanying drawings, similar elements are numbered similarly:

[0025] Figure 1 is a perspective view of a refrigerator system according to one or more embodiments;

[0026] Figure 2 Depicted are systems for performing analysis-based chiller ranking according to one or more embodiments;

[0027] Figure 3 depicts hierarchical information according to one or more embodiments; and

[0028] Figure 4 Depicted is a flow diagram for performing analysis-based chiller ranking according to one or more embodiments. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0029] Due to the aging and faulty components of the refrigerator, refrigerator performance can deteriorate over time. For example, the refrigerator may experience mechanical degradation, such as reduced condenser performance, pump failure, motors that need to be repaired, etc. Usually, refrigerator equipment operators and refrigerator equipment managers / controllers cannot understand such problems, because the refrigerator is still operable. Therefore, they cannot adjust the refrigerator operation accordingly to actively manage operating efficiency. Only using refrigerator efficiency can not maximize overall system efficiency, because a specific refrigerator may operate effectively, but the desired cooling required cannot be obtained at the load, or some other health problems may exist, such as mechanical fatigue wear, abnormal noise, vibration, etc. The technology described herein maximizes overall refrigerator system performance by sorting the order of refrigerator operation based on measured refrigerator efficiency and health value.

[0030] Using the chiller system analysis, the chiller system controller determines the efficiency and health of each chiller. Next, the chillers are ranked according to their efficiency and health. Subsequently, the order of ranking is determined to optimize the chiller group efficiency of the chiller equipment system. In addition, the chiller equipment controller can automatically adjust the chiller ranking based on the updated system analysis. Therefore, the system does not need to rely on the operator to identify the performance degradation of the chiller and take corrective measures accordingly.

[0031] Figure 1 A refrigerator system 10 is depicted according to one or more embodiments. The refrigerator system 10 is a screw refrigerator, but embodiments are suitable for use with other compression refrigerator assemblies such as, for example, centrifugal refrigerators. Figure 1 As shown, the refrigerator system 10 includes a compressor 12 , a variable frequency drive 14 , a condenser 16 , and a chiller 18 .

[0032] In operation, gaseous refrigerant is introduced into compressor 12 and compressed. Compressor 12 is driven by a motor under the control of variable frequency drive 14. Variable frequency drive 14 controls the frequency of the alternating current (AC) supplied to the motor, thereby controlling the speed of the motor and the output of compressor 12. It should be understood that the technology described herein is independent of the type of refrigerator (such as variable speed refrigerator) and can also be applied to fixed speed refrigerators. After the refrigerant is compressed, the high temperature and high pressure refrigerant gas is supplied to condenser 16. In condenser 16, the gaseous refrigerant condenses into liquid due to the release of heat. The condensed liquid refrigerant then flows into chiller 18, which circulates the refrigerator water. The low pressure environment in chiller 18 causes the refrigerant to change state to gas, and when it changes, it absorbs the heat required for evaporation from the chilled water, thereby reducing the temperature of the water. Then the low pressure steam is sucked into the inlet of compressor 12 and the cycle is repeated continuously. The chilled water circulates through the distribution system to the cooling coil for comfort air conditioning.

[0033] Reference now Figure 2 , shows a refrigerator system 200 according to one or more embodiments. In one or more embodiments, the refrigerator system 200 includes a plurality of refrigerators, each of which may be a refrigerator such as Figure 1 The refrigerator 10 shown in FIG.

[0034] The refrigerator system 200 includes a controller 202 configured to control various operations of the refrigerator system 200. The refrigerator system 200 includes a group of refrigerators A, B, C, D, which are similar to Figure 1 200. Although only four refrigerators are shown, it should be understood that any number of refrigerators can be used and sequenced by the described technology. Each refrigerator in the group includes a corresponding input sensor 204 and an output sensor 206 to measure the different characteristics of refrigerators AD. For example, input sensor 204 and output sensor 206 include temperature sensors, flow meters, pressure sensors, etc. In addition, system 200 may include sensors for detecting voltage and current of other electrical components of motors or system 200.

[0035] Controller 202 is configured to receive readings from the sensors and control various operations of the refrigerator. For example, the data from the sensors can be used to calculate and / or estimate the coefficient of performance (COP), also known as the efficiency of the refrigerator. In addition, the data collected from the sensors can be used to calculate the health of the refrigerator.

[0036] In one or more embodiments, the controller 202 includes a processor 210 configured to calculate and estimate the COP and health score of the chiller system 200 .

[0037] Where chilled water flow sensors (such as sensors 204, 206) are available for the chiller, the COP may be calculated according to the following equation 1:

[0038]

[0039] Where capacity (cap) is calculated by Equation 2 (shown below). Power is measured using current and voltage from a motor coupled to the refrigerator, or power can be measured directly with a power meter. Equation 2 provides:

[0040] Cap=c w ×m chw ×ΔT chw (Equation 2)

[0041] where c w -Specific heat of water; m chw - Chilled water flow rate through the refrigerator; ΔT chw-The difference between the input chilled water temperature and the output chilled water temperature.

[0042] In various situations where a chilled water flow sensor is unavailable, the COP of each chiller may be estimated based on available reference loop variable measurements from the chiller's local controllers performing the chiller operation provided below.

[0043] First, the refrigerant flow rate through the compressor must be estimated, which is estimated using the following Equation 3:

[0044] IP×η 马达 =q m ×(h2-h1) (Equation 3)

[0045] Where, IP is the input power of the motor; η 马达 -Motor efficiency; q m - refrigerant flow rate; h2- compressor outlet enthalpy; h1- compressor inlet enthalpy.

[0046] Next, the chiller capacity is estimated by the following equations 4 and 5:

[0047] q0=q m ×(h1-h5) (Equation 4)

[0048] Q=q0-IP×(1-η 马达 ) (Equation 5)

[0049] where q m - refrigerant flow rate; h1-evaporator outlet enthalpy; h5-evaporator inlet enthalpy; IP-motor input power; Q-refrigerator capacity.

[0050] Finally, the refrigerator efficiency is estimated based on the following Equation 6:

[0051] COP = Q / IP (Equation 6)

[0052] In one or more embodiments, the calculated COP (Equation 1) or the estimated COP (Equation 6) is used to calculate the chiller efficiency score based on the following Equation 7;

[0053] Efficiency score = 100 × COP / COP ref (Equation 7)

[0054] Among them, COP ref- The user selects a reference COP value for a healthy refrigerator. It should be noted that Equation 7 is a non-limiting example, where the value 100 can be selected as a different value, and the equation form can be selected as any other monotonically increasing function. In this particular example, the value 100 is used to indicate a refrigerator having a COP greater than or equal to refA refrigerator with an efficiency of less than 100 is considered to be a high efficiency refrigerator. ref A refrigerator with a fraction of 100 is considered an inefficient refrigerator. It should be understood that in other configurations, different values ​​other than 100 may be used in Equation 7.

[0055] In one or more embodiments, the reference COP for the health of the refrigerator can be an average of the normal COPs of the refrigerators in the system from manufacturer data.As described above, the efficiency score is used to rank the refrigerators in the system.

[0056] In addition to using chiller efficiency as a factor in ranking the order of a group of chillers, the health of the chiller can also be considered. The health score representing the health of the chiller measures the average temperature error at the evaporator outlet to determine whether the desired chilled water temperature is delivered to the load. For example, if a chiller cannot deliver a chilled water temperature that references the chilled water supply temperature set point, the chiller is given a low operational priority.

[0057] In one or more embodiments, the health score of each chiller is related to the average chilled water temperature error T av_误差 Related and calculated by Equation 8:

[0058]

[0059] Where N represents the number of data samples; CHWST-chilled water supply temperature; CHWSTsp-chilled water supply temperature set point.

[0060] In one or more embodiments, the chiller health score is calculated based on the following Equation 9:

[0061] Health score = 100 + 50 × (1-T av_误差 / T av_误差_ref ) (Equation 9)

[0062] Where T av_误差_ref- Reference value of the average chilled water temperature error of a healthy refrigerator. It should be noted that equation 9 is a non-limiting example, in which the values ​​100 and 50 can be selected as different values, and the equation form can be selected as any other monotonically decreasing function. In this particular example, the values ​​100 and 50 are used to indicate that a refrigerator with an error equal to the reference error value is considered to be a healthy refrigerator and the score is 100. In addition, a refrigerator with an error up to 3 times the reference error value is considered to be a very unhealthy refrigerator and the score is 0. Although the values ​​100 and 50 are used in this example, other other values ​​can be selected based on the desired configuration.

[0063] In one or more embodiments, the margin of error for the refrigerator temperature may have a range of ±0.3°F, i.e., T av_误差ref = 0.3°F. In this case, a chiller with an error greater than 1°F is considered an unhealthy chiller because its health score is 0. In some cases, an unhealthy chiller can operate efficiently. The higher the chilled water supply temperature of the unhealthy chiller, the less power will be consumed to produce the required cooling. However, because the temperature control is not optimal, this particular chiller will not be selected as the first priority, even though it may have high efficiency.

[0064] In one or more embodiments, other sensor variables such as mechanical fatigue wear state, noise level, vibration level, etc. can also be used to calculate the refrigerator health score. For example, a refrigerator with a noise value greater than a certain reference value is considered to be an unhealthy refrigerator, and the health score of the noise can be calculated as a monotonically decreasing function of the noise value. Similarly, if the vibration sensor value is available, the health score of the vibration can also be obtained, and if the mechanical fatigue wear sensor value is available, the health score of the mechanical fatigue wear can also be obtained.

[0065] In one or more embodiments, a weighting factor may be introduced into the calculation to determine the efficiency score and the health score. For example, the efficiency score may be weighted as 1 and the health score may be weighted as 2 to adjust the priority in the score. In this example, the health score of each refrigerator has a first priority higher than the efficiency score, wherein the health score is weighted twice as much as the efficiency score. Due to the high chilled water supply temperature or some other health problems such as mechanical fatigue wear, abnormal noise, vibration, etc., the refrigerator that cannot deliver the desired cooling will have a lower priority in the sorting of each refrigerator. In another example, the efficiency score may be weighted as 1 and the health score may be weighted as 0.5, wherein the efficiency is provided with a first priority higher than the health score in the sorting of the refrigerator. In other embodiments, the weighting factor may also be used to calculate the final health score based on the health score of the refrigerator temperature (Equation 8 and Equation 9) and the individual health scores of mechanical fatigue or wear, noise level, vibration level, etc. For example, an independent health score may be calculated for each parameter such as chilled water supply temperature, mechanical fatigue, noise level, vibration level, etc. It should also be understood that when calculating the final health score, additional parameters or any combination of parameters may be used to determine the corresponding health score. In response to calculating each health score for each monitored parameter, the health scores may be combined, such as by averaging each score for multiple parameters, to calculate the final health score. In addition, a weight factor may be applied to each monitored parameter to provide a priority of importance for each monitored parameter. The weight factor is a configurable weight factor and may be modified according to the desired management of the refrigerator system. In a non-limiting example, a vibration level health score (e.g., the vibration experienced by the compressor of the refrigerator system) may be given a higher weight / priority than a noise level health score. In another example, a mechanical fatigue health score (which may be based on the age of the equipment or other factors) is given a higher weight / priority than the noise level and vibration level health scores. It should be understood that the refrigerator system and controller include appropriate interfaces and sensors to monitor the parameters used to calculate the corresponding health scores and the final health scores.

[0066] In response to determining the COP and health of each chiller, a ranking operation is performed to select which particular chiller to bring online. The results of the calculations, estimates, and rankings may be output to another system or device 208. For example, the data may be sent to an operator at a remote location for further analysis. Additionally, graphical information (in Figure 3 The data is sent to a system or display for presentation to an operator.

[0067] The system is optimized by the controller prioritizing the most efficient, healthiest chillers to operate first. Then, if the load is not maintained according to the desired set point, the second priority chiller can be operated, and then the third and fourth chillers, etc., if necessary.

[0068] Reference now Figure 3 , shows a refrigerator ranking 310 based on refrigerator efficiency according to one or more embodiments. The x-axis of 310 represents the different refrigerators (A, B, C, D) within the system, and the y-axis measures the refrigerator efficiency (COP). The ranking order is indicated above each refrigerator, which is based on the calculated efficiency. According to this non-limiting example, refrigerator D has the highest efficiency, so it has the highest efficiency score, followed by refrigerator C, then refrigerator A, and finally refrigerator B has the lowest efficiency, so it has the lowest efficiency score.

[0069] Still reference Figure 3 , shows a chiller ranking 320 based on chiller health according to one or more embodiments. The x-axis of 320 represents the different chillers (A, B, C, D) within the system, and the y-axis measures the chilled water temperature error (T av_误差 ). A ranking order is indicated above each chiller, which is based on the calculated health score. In this specific non-limiting example, chiller D has the lowest error margin, so it has the highest health score, followed by chiller A, then chiller B, and finally chiller C. Similarly, not shown in the figure, if sensor values ​​are available, a ranking order of chillers for mechanical fatigue wear, noise level, vibration level can also be obtained.

[0070] In one or more embodiments, the rankings provided in 310 and / or 320 may be used to determine a chiller ranking order, as shown in table 330. Table 330 provides a ranking order determined based on the efficiency ranking and the health ranking. As shown, chiller D receives the first priority for selection, followed by chiller A, then chiller C, and finally chiller B. In the event that chiller D is unable to generate cooling for the load, chiller A will be put online next to maximize the overall efficiency of the chiller system.

[0071] exist Figure 4 , a flow chart of a method 400 for performing analysis-based chiller ranking according to one or more embodiments is shown. It should be understood that the method 400 may be performed by Figure 1 and Figure 2The method 400 may be performed by any system of the invention and by systems with different configurations. The method 400 starts at frame 402 and proceeds to frame 404, which provides obtaining operating data of each refrigerator in a plurality of refrigerators. The operating data may include motor current / voltage, condenser, economizer, cooler, refrigerant pressure, compressor discharge temperature, water flow meter, water temperature, etc. It should be understood that the operating data may include any data monitored and / or controlled by a refrigerator controller.

[0072] At frame 406, method 400 provides the score of each refrigerator in multiple refrigerators.The score includes an efficiency score and a health score.The efficiency score indicates how effectively the refrigerator is operating based on the capacity and input power of the compressor of each refrigerator.The efficiency score can be calculated and / or estimated according to the equation provided above.The health score indicates the ability of the refrigerator to provide chilled water or the stability of the refrigerator at a desired temperature (accuracy).In one or more embodiments, the chilled water supply temperature can be measured and compared with the chilled water supply temperature set point to determine the error.The error value of each refrigerator can be averaged over time and used to grade the refrigerator according to the health score.

[0073] At box 408, method 400 provides for grading a plurality of refrigerators based on scores. The refrigerators may be graded according to at least one of an efficiency score and a health score. At box 410, method 400 provides for sorting a plurality of refrigerators based at least in part on the grading. In one or more embodiments, the grading is based on combining the efficiency grading / score and the health grading / score to determine the overall grading / score. In one or more embodiments, the efficiency grading / score and the health grading / score may be weighted according to the needs of the system. The weights provided to the efficiency score and the health score may be configured by an operator.

[0074] Frame 412 provides for controlling the operation of multiple refrigerators based on sequencing. In the case where the currently operating refrigerator cannot meet the requirements of the desired load, the subsequent refrigerators are put on line according to the priority order based on the efficiency and health of the refrigerators. In one or more embodiments, method 400 can be repeated at configurable intervals. Method 400 ends at frame 414.

[0075] The techniques provided herein allow the order of chillers to be adjusted in an automated manner without human intervention taking into account both chiller efficiency and health score.

[0076] A detailed description of one or more embodiments of the disclosed apparatus and methods is presented herein by way of example and not limitation with reference to the accompanying figures.

[0077] The term "about" is intended to include the degree of error associated with the measurement of the particular quantity based on the equipment available at the time the application was filed.

[0078] The terms used herein are only used for the purpose of describing specific embodiments and are not intended to be limitations of the present disclosure. As used herein, unless otherwise clearly indicated in the context, the singular forms "one", "a kind of" and "the / said" are also intended to include plural forms. It will be further understood that when used in this specification, the terms "include" and / or "comprising" specify the presence of stated features, integers, steps, operations, elements and / or parts, but do not exclude the presence or addition of one or more other features, integers, steps, operations, element parts and / or their groups.

[0079] Although the present disclosure has been described with reference to one or more exemplary embodiments, it will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that various changes may be made and equivalents may be substituted for elements of the present disclosure without departing from the scope of the present disclosure. In addition, many modifications may be made to adapt specific circumstances or materials to the teachings of the present disclosure without departing from the basic scope of the present disclosure. Therefore, the present disclosure is not intended to be limited to the specific embodiments disclosed as the best mode contemplated for carrying out the present disclosure, but the present disclosure will include all embodiments falling within the scope of the claims.

Claims

1. A system for performing analysis-based refrigerator ranking, the system comprising: multiple chillers; a controller configured to control the plurality of refrigerators; one or more sensors in communication with the controller, the one or more sensors configured to generate operating data based on measured operating parameters of the plurality of refrigerators; The controller comprises a processor configured to: obtaining the operation data, wherein the operation data comprises at least one of a mechanical fatigue wear state, a noise level, and a vibration level; calculating a score for each of the plurality of refrigerators based on the operational data, wherein a weighting factor is applied to each monitored parameter to provide a priority of importance of each monitored parameter; ranking the plurality of refrigerators based on the scores; ranking the plurality of refrigerators based at least in part on the ranking; and Operation of the plurality of refrigerators is controlled based on the ranking. 2 . The system of claim 1 , wherein the score for each chiller comprises at least one of an efficiency score and a health score.

3. The system of claim 2, wherein the score comprises a weighted score of at least one of an efficiency score and a health score. 4 . The system of claim 2 , wherein the processor is configured to calculate the efficiency score based on a chilled water capacity and a consumed power of each chiller. 5 . The system of claim 2 , wherein the processor is configured to estimate the efficiency score based on an estimated chilled water capacity and consumed power of each chiller.

6. The system of claim 2, wherein the health score is based on a chilled water supply temperature and a chilled water supply temperature set point for each chiller.

7. The system of claim 2, wherein the grading comprises performing a first grading based on the efficiency score and performing a second grading based on the health score.

8. The system of claim 1, wherein the controller is configured to reorder the plurality of refrigerators at configurable intervals.

9. A method for performing analysis-based chiller ranking, the method comprising: obtaining operation data of each of the plurality of refrigerators, wherein the operation data comprises at least one of a mechanical fatigue wear state, a noise level, and a vibration level; calculating a score for each of the plurality of refrigerators based on the operational data, wherein a weighting factor is applied to each monitored parameter to provide a priority of importance of each monitored parameter; ranking the plurality of refrigerators based on the scores; ranking the plurality of refrigerators based at least in part on the ranking; and Operation of the plurality of refrigerators is controlled based on the ranking.

10. The method of claim 9, wherein the score for each chiller comprises at least one of an efficiency score and a health score. The method of claim 10 , further comprising weighting at least one of the efficiency score and the health score.

12. The method of claim 10, further comprising calculating the efficiency score based at least in part on a measured chilled water capacity and consumed power of each chiller.

13. The method of claim 10, further comprising estimating the efficiency score based at least in part on an estimated chilled water capacity and power consumed by each chiller.

14. The method of claim 10, wherein the health score is based on a chilled water supply temperature and a chilled water supply temperature set point for each chiller.

15. The method of claim 10, wherein the grading comprises performing a first grading based on the efficiency score and performing a second grading based on the health score.

16. The method of claim 9, further comprising reordering the plurality of refrigerators at configurable intervals.

17. The method of claim 10, further comprising calculating the efficiency score when flow sensor data for each chiller is available.

18. The method of claim 10, further comprising estimating the efficiency score when flow sensor data for each chiller is not available.