A wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system and method
By building a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system, using hierarchical analysis method and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method, the problem of lack of evaluation index system and model in the existing technology is solved, and the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation of wearable exoskeleton robots is realized systematization and scientificization.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202111615355.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-12-27
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-22
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-12-27
AI Technical Summary
The existing human-machine collaboration safety evaluation of wearable exoskeleton robots lacks a specific evaluation index system and system model, resulting in a lack of reasonable basis when choosing.
A human-machine collaborative safety evaluation system was built, including the evaluation index system construction module and the evaluation model construction module. Wearables were established using hierarchical analysis method, Saaty 1-9 scale method, regularization and accumulation method, and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method. Human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system and model of exoskeleton robots.
It provides a systematic evaluation method and decision-making basis, and determines the index weight and comprehensive evaluation model through fuzzy hierarchy analysis method, which improves the scientificity and reliability of human-computer collaborative safety evaluation.
Smart Images

Figure CN114202240B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of human-machine collaboration safety evaluation, and in particular to a wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system and method. Background Art
[0002] With the fading of the demographic dividend, the need for enterprise automation upgrades, and the support of national policies, the development of wearable exoskeleton robots, as an important part of current automation, intelligence, and industrialization, has been greatly promoted. Through literature review, it is found that scholars' research on this topic is mostly focused on the dynamic analysis, structural design, gait planning, and control strategies of human-wearable exoskeleton robots when they move or work. Their common point is that they all take the guarantee of human-machine collaboration safety as the basis, focus on a certain point to study the factors related to safety, emphasize the mutual coordination and stable cooperation between humans and wearable exoskeleton robots, and continuously improve and innovate on the basis of previous research. Therefore, the human-machine collaboration safety of wearable exoskeleton robots has been valued by many scholars, but there is still a lack of a systematic evaluation system for the actual evaluation of their safety. At the same time, when selecting wearable exoskeleton robots available on the market, considering the uncertainty of human-machine collaboration safety, there is still a lack of reasonable selection basis.
[0003] The existing safety evaluation of human-machine collaboration for wearable exoskeleton robots has the following shortcomings: first, there is a lack of a specific and targeted evaluation index system; second, there is a lack of a systematic evaluation model; third, considering the factors of human-machine collaboration safety, there is a lack of reasonable selection basis when faced with a variety of wearable exoskeleton robot products. Summary of the invention
[0004] The purpose of the present invention is to address the defects of the prior art and provide a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system and method for a wearable exoskeleton robot, construct a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model, and compare the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation schemes of multiple wearable exoskeleton robots, a newly created human-machine collaboration safety evaluation method for wearable exoskeleton robots, and a decision-making basis for selecting multiple exoskeleton robots.
[0005] In order to achieve the above purpose, the present invention adopts the following technical solutions:
[0006] A wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system includes an evaluation index system building module and an evaluation model building module; the evaluation model building module includes a first building module, an evaluation module, a second building module, a calculation module, a verification module, and a third building module;
[0007] The evaluation index system construction module is used to preliminarily formulate the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system for wearable exoskeleton robots based on the three perspectives of human, machine, and human-machine interaction;
[0008] The first building module is used to construct a hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system using the hierarchical analysis method;
[0009] An evaluation module is used to evaluate the importance of indicators in the tomography model according to the Saaty 1-9 scale;
[0010] The second construction module is used to compare two indicators according to the importance rating level and construct a judgment matrix;
[0011] A calculation module is used to calculate the weight of the indicator using normalization and sum-product method;
[0012] A test module, used for testing the consistency of the judgment matrix using a consistency ratio;
[0013] The third construction module is used to construct a membership matrix according to the membership of the indicators in the comment level, obtain a fuzzy evaluation matrix, and generate a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model according to the fuzzy evaluation matrix.
[0014] Furthermore, the index system includes ease of operation, intrinsic reliability of the wearable exoskeleton robot, shape adaptability, and motion matching.
[0015] Furthermore, the hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system constructed by the hierarchical analysis method in the first building module is specifically:
[0016] According to the analytic hierarchy process, the index set U={u1,u2,...,u n}, and then divided into several first-level indicators according to the indicator division principle, each first-level indicator is further divided into several second-level indicators, and finally a hierarchical structure model of indicator factors is constructed.
[0017] Furthermore, the evaluation module evaluates the importance of the indicators in the chromatography model according to the Saaty 1-9 scale, specifically:
[0018] According to the subset B of the lower-level indicators in the indicator set U = {B1, B2, B3, ..., B n}, compare the indicator elements in B two by two, and rank their importance according to the Saaty 1-9 scale.
[0019] Furthermore, the judgment matrix in the second building module is expressed as:
[0020]
[0021] Where V = (b ij ) represents the judgment matrix; n represents the number of indicators in the fuzzy subset B.
[0022] Furthermore, the calculation module uses normalization and sum-product method to calculate the weight of the index, specifically:
[0023] Each column of the judgment matrix is normalized and expressed as:
[0024]
[0025] Among them, a ij represents the values of the judgment matrix after normalization; b ij It represents the importance scale value of indicator i to indicator j; n represents the number of indicators; k represents the kth scale value in each column of the judgment matrix.
[0026] The judgment matrix after normalization of each column is summed up row by row, expressed as:
[0027]
[0028] Among them, U i It represents the sum of i indicators by row.
[0029] For vector U = [U1,U2,...,U n ] T Normalized, expressed as:
[0030]
[0031] Among them, ω i represents the weight vector, ω=[ω1,ω2,...,ω n ] T ; U j Represents the sum of j indicators.
[0032] After the weight vector is normalized, it is expressed as:
[0033]
[0034] Among them, 1 means obtaining the maximum eigenvector, that is, the indicator weight.
[0035] Furthermore, the consistency of the judgment matrix is checked in the checking module, which is expressed as:
[0036]
[0037] Among them, CR represents the consistency ratio; RI represents the average random consistency index; CI represents the consistency index, which is expressed as:
[0038]
[0039] The largest characteristic root λ max The approximate value of is calculated as:
[0040]
[0041] Among them, λ max represents the largest characteristic root, (Vω) i Represents the sum of each row of the judgment matrix V after normalization.
[0042] Furthermore, the fuzzy evaluation matrix in the third building block is expressed as:
[0043]
[0044] Among them, R represents the fuzzy evaluation matrix; r ij Indicates factor B i The evaluation level is the membership degree of j; m represents the number of indicators.
[0045] Furthermore, the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model in the third building block is expressed as:
[0046]
[0047] Among them, G i Represents the comprehensive evaluation value of the i-th solution.
[0048] Accordingly, a wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation method is also included, including:
[0049] S1. Based on the three perspectives of human, machine, and human-machine interaction, a preliminary evaluation index system for the human-machine collaboration safety of wearable exoskeleton robots is formulated;
[0050] S2. Use the analytic hierarchy process to construct a hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system;
[0051] S3. Rating the importance of the indicators in the tomography model according to the Saaty 1-9 scale;
[0052] S4. Compare two indicators according to the importance rating and construct a judgment matrix;
[0053] S5. Use normalization and sum-product method to calculate the weight of the indicators;
[0054] S6. Use consistency ratio to test the consistency of the judgment matrix;
[0055] S7. Construct a membership matrix according to the membership of the indicators in the comment level, obtain a fuzzy evaluation matrix, and generate a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model based on the fuzzy evaluation matrix.
[0056] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0057] 1. A safety evaluation index system for human-machine collaboration of wearable exoskeleton robots was constructed. From the three perspectives of humans, wearable exoskeleton robots, and human-machine interaction, with the risk identification of possible safety incidents as the core, the safety evaluation index system for human-machine collaboration of wearable exoskeleton robots was studied.
[0058] 2. A human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model for wearable exoskeleton robots was established. Using the fuzzy analytic hierarchy process, the analytic hierarchy process was first used to determine the weights of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation indicators for wearable exoskeleton robots through the processes of establishing a structural hierarchy model, constructing a judgment matrix, performing consistency testing, and calculating indicator weights.
[0059] 3. Use the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method to determine the index factor set and the scheme set to form the membership matrix, and obtain the relative membership matrix through calculation.
[0060] 4. Finally, a comprehensive evaluation scheme is obtained, and a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model for wearable exoskeleton robots is constructed. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0061] Figure 1 It is a structural diagram of a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation method for a wearable exoskeleton robot provided in Example 1;
[0062] Figure 2 It is a structural diagram of a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system for a wearable exoskeleton robot provided in Example 1;
[0063] Figure 3 Schematic diagram of the three exoskeletons provided in Example 2, all of which are wearable exoskeleton robots;
[0064] Figure 4 It is a schematic diagram of the hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system provided in Example 2. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0065] The following describes the embodiments of the present invention by specific examples, and those skilled in the art can easily understand other advantages and effects of the present invention from the contents disclosed in this specification. The present invention can also be implemented or applied through other different specific embodiments, and the details in this specification can also be modified or changed in various ways based on different viewpoints and applications without departing from the spirit of the present invention. It should be noted that the following embodiments and features in the embodiments can be combined with each other without conflict.
[0066] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system and method in view of the defects of the prior art.
[0067] Embodiment 1
[0068] This embodiment provides a wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system. Figure 1 As shown, it includes an evaluation index system construction module and an evaluation model establishment module.
[0069] The evaluation index system construction module is used to preliminarily formulate the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system for wearable exoskeleton robots based on the three perspectives of human, machine, and human-machine interaction;
[0070] The construction of the evaluation index system includes literature review, brainstorming and expert interviews.
[0071] Literature review: Based on the theories and research related to wearable exoskeleton robots and human-machine system safety, a certain theoretical foundation is laid for the preliminary analysis of the factors affecting the safety of human-machine collaboration.
[0072] Brainstorming method: The various indicators obtained through brainstorming are preliminarily classified according to the safety issues caused by four angles: people, exoskeleton robots, environment, and people-machine-environment; then, the general keywords in these four categories are taken out and summarized for the second time to obtain the first-level indicators, as shown in Table 1.
[0073] Table 1 Summary of brainstorming meeting results
[0074]
[0075]
[0076]
[0077] Note: The machine in the table represents a wearable exoskeleton robot
[0078] Expert interview: In order to more comprehensively supplement and standardize the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation indicators of wearable exoskeleton robots, open interviews were conducted with experts and engineers from the exoskeleton R&D team. The interview results were sorted, summarized, and summarized to improve the indicators.
[0079] The evaluation indicators were initially formulated through the above three methods. Specifically, the evaluation indicators of human-machine collaboration safety of wearable exoskeleton robots were classified into four first-level evaluation indicators from the three perspectives of human, machine, and human-machine interaction after multiple group analysis, discussion, expert suggestions, and feedback: namely, ease of operation, intrinsic reliability of wearable exoskeleton robots, shape adaptability, motion matching, and second-level indicators under each first-level indicator. Therefore, the evaluation indicators of human-machine collaboration safety of wearable exoskeleton robots were initially formulated, as shown in Table 2.
[0080] Table 2 Preliminary human-machine collaboration safety evaluation indicators
[0081]
[0082]
[0083] In this embodiment, the Delphi method is also used for evaluation, specifically:
[0084] Establishment of an expert group: The expert group includes 15 experts from the exoskeleton team of a Hangzhou enterprise R&D department and related research fields of universities. With their approval, the expert group was established. A questionnaire survey was conducted based on the preliminary human-machine collaboration safety evaluation indicators.
[0085] Expert consultation: The Delphi method was used to conduct two rounds of expert consultation in the form of questionnaires. The statistical results of the two rounds were then subjected to expert authority coefficient test, exoskeleton robot familiarity analysis, evaluation result discreteness analysis, consistency test, evaluation index selection, and experience research on related wearable exoskeleton products. Finally, four primary indicators, namely, ease of operation, intrinsic reliability, appearance adaptability, and motion matching, and 21 secondary indicators, were determined to constitute the complete evaluation index system of this study, such as Figure 2 shown.
[0086] Determine the evaluation indicators.
[0087] The evaluation model building module includes a first building module, an assessment module, a second building module, a calculation module, a verification module, and a third building module.
[0088] The first building module is used to construct a hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system using the hierarchical analysis method;
[0089] The hierarchical analysis method is used to construct a hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system.
[0090] According to the analytic hierarchy process, the index set U={u1,u2,...,u n}, according to certain index division principles, it is divided into several first-level indicators in turn, and each first-level indicator is further divided into several second-level indicators, and finally a hierarchical structure model of indicator factors is constructed.
[0091] An evaluation module is used to evaluate the importance of indicators in the tomography model according to the Saaty 1-9 scale;
[0092] Starting from the criterion layer, we introduce a subset of lower-level indicators in the indicator set U, B = {B1, B2, B3, ..., B n}, compare the indicator elements in B two by two, and rate their importance according to the Saaty 1-9 scale.
[0093] The second building block compares the indicators pairwise according to the importance rating level and constructs a judgment matrix;
[0094] According to the Saaty 1-9 scaling method, the comparison is performed pairwise, and the resulting matrix V = (b ij ) is the judgment matrix, expressed as:
[0095]
[0096] Where V = (b ij ) represents the judgment matrix; n represents the number of indicators in the fuzzy subset B.
[0097] A calculation module is used to calculate the weight of the indicator using normalization and sum-product method;
[0098] Using the sum-product method, first normalize each column of the judgment matrix V. After normalization, the sum of the elements in each column is 1, that is:
[0099]
[0100] Among them, a ij represents the values of the judgment matrix after normalization; b ij It represents the importance scale value of indicator i to indicator j; n represents the number of indicators; k represents the kth scale value in each column of the judgment matrix.
[0101] The judgment matrix after normalization of each column is summed up row by row, expressed as:
[0102]
[0103] Among them, U iIt represents the sum of i indicators by row.
[0104] For vector U = [U1,U2,...,U n ] T Normalized, expressed as:
[0105]
[0106] Among them, ω i represents the weight vector, ω=[ω1,ω2,...,ω n ] T ; U j Represents the sum of j indicators.
[0107] After normalizing the weight vector, it satisfies the following formula:
[0108]
[0109] Among them, 1 means obtaining the maximum eigenvector, that is, the indicator weight.
[0110] A test module, used for testing the consistency of the judgment matrix using a consistency ratio;
[0111] When comparing evaluation indicators one by one, differences will occur due to differences in their respective value orientations, grading methods, etc. Therefore, when n>2, it is usually difficult to construct a judgment matrix that meets the consistency test. Therefore, it is usually necessary to use the consistency ratio (CR) to test the consistency of the judgment matrix, which can be expressed as:
[0112]
[0113] Among them, CR represents the consistency ratio; RI represents the average random consistency index; CI represents the consistency index; when CR<0.1, it means that the consistency test has been passed; otherwise, it is unreasonable and needs to be readjusted and modified until the consistency test has been passed. The average random consistency index is shown in Table 2. The calculation formula of the consistency index CI is expressed as:
[0114]
[0115] The largest characteristic root λ max The approximate value of is calculated as:
[0116]
[0117] Among them, λ max represents the largest characteristic root, (Vω) i Represents the sum of each row of the judgment matrix V after normalization.
[0118] Table 2 Average random consistency index
[0119]
[0120] Combining the above process and according to the results of the second expert consultation, the weight vectors and indicator weights of various indicators for the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation of wearable exoskeleton robots were finally obtained, as shown in Table 3.
[0121] Table 3 Weight vector and indicator weight of human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index
[0122]
[0123]
[0124] The third construction module is used to construct a membership matrix according to the membership of the indicators in the comment level, obtain a fuzzy evaluation matrix, and generate a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model according to the fuzzy evaluation matrix.
[0125] In order to determine the factor set and solution set, we first conduct a single factor evaluation B i (i=1,2,...,m), and so on, we can get the membership degree r of each indicator of the wearable exoskeleton robot to the level ij , then get the i-th factor b i The judgment set r i =(r i1 ,r i2 ,...,r in ), and finally, according to the membership degree r of each factor index in the evaluation level i The membership matrix composed of is the fuzzy evaluation matrix R, which is expressed as:
[0126]
[0127] Among them, R represents the fuzzy evaluation matrix; r ij Indicates factor B i The evaluation level is the membership degree of j; m represents the number of indicators.
[0128] If the value of this evaluation index is as large as possible, the formula r is used. ij =a ij / maxa ij ; If the value of this evaluation index is as small as possible, then the formula r is used. ij =mina ij / a ij , and get the relative membership matrix.
[0129] The weight vector ω is multiplied by the relative membership matrix R, and fuzzy comprehensive calculation is performed to obtain the scheme evaluation results G at the target layer and the criterion layer, that is, the final evaluation model, which is expressed as:
[0130]
[0131] Among them, G i Represents the comprehensive evaluation value of the i-th scheme. The scheme with a high evaluation value should be adopted first.
[0132] The beneficial effects of this embodiment are:
[0133] 1. A human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system for wearable exoskeleton robots was constructed. From the three perspectives of human, machine, and human-machine interaction, with the risk identification of possible safety incidents as the core, the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system for wearable exoskeleton robots was studied.
[0134] 2. The weights of various indicators for the safety evaluation of human-machine collaboration of wearable exoskeleton robots were determined. The fuzzy analytic hierarchy process was used to first establish a structural hierarchy model, construct a judgment matrix, perform consistency testing, and calculate indicator weights to determine the weights of various indicators for the safety evaluation of human-machine collaboration of wearable exoskeleton robots.
[0135] 3. Use the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method to determine the index factor set and the scheme set to form the membership matrix, and obtain the relative membership matrix through calculation.
[0136] 4. Finally, a comprehensive evaluation scheme is obtained, and a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model for wearable exoskeleton robots is constructed.
[0137] Accordingly, a wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation method is also included, including:
[0138] S1. Based on the three perspectives of human, machine, and human-machine interaction, a preliminary evaluation index system for the human-machine collaboration safety of wearable exoskeleton robots is formulated;
[0139] S2. Use the analytic hierarchy process to construct a hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system;
[0140] S3. Rating the importance of the indicators in the tomography model according to the Saaty 1-9 scale;
[0141] S4. Compare two indicators according to the importance rating and construct a judgment matrix;
[0142] S5. Use normalization and sum-product method to calculate the weight of the indicators;
[0143] S6. Use consistency ratio to test the consistency of the judgment matrix;
[0144] S7. Construct a membership matrix according to the membership of the indicators in the comment level, obtain a fuzzy evaluation matrix, and generate a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model based on the fuzzy evaluation matrix.
[0145] Embodiment 2
[0146] This embodiment provides an application of a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model for a wearable exoskeleton robot. The difference between the first embodiment and the first embodiment is that:
[0147] This embodiment is described by taking top drilling construction as an example.
[0148] Top drilling construction is widely used in the fields of building facility installation, rail transit construction, automobile parts assembly, etc. Through field research, it was found that drilling tasks have problems such as low work efficiency, heavy human load, and high safety hazards. This paper takes the drilling construction project as a case starting point and uses the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method to evaluate and compare the safety of human-machine collaboration of three wearable exoskeleton robots.
[0149] 1. Research preparation
[0150] (1) Human-machine collaboration safety evaluation scale. This survey involved 8 experimental researchers, all of whom had experience wearing these three exoskeleton robots. Based on the research results of fuzzy mathematics, the previous method of fuzzy comprehensive evaluation using factor sets, comment sets and fuzzy judgment matrices was optimized. The index scoring method of 0 to 100 was adopted to retain the subjective evaluation of the object to the maximum extent. Then, a standardized scheme was introduced to establish a relative membership matrix for fuzzy comprehensive evaluation and scheme comparison, so as to select the better scheme. The questionnaire combines the Likert five-point scale and the percentage scoring method, and is divided into five levels: unqualified, poor, medium, good, and excellent. The interval is divided from 0 to 100 to strengthen the wearer's sense of scoring boundaries, as shown in Table 4.
[0151] Table 4 Safety evaluation criteria for human-machine collaboration of wearable exoskeleton
[0152]
[0153] (2) Wearable exoskeleton robot prototypes. Before selecting the research prototype, considering the matching degree of the drilling construction workers and the fact that the main stress-bearing parts of the operation are the arms and waist, three upper limb exoskeleton robots were selected, namely, FA flexible power-assisted exoskeleton ( Figure 2 Left), CS shoulder-assisted industrial exoskeleton ( Figure 2 middle) and TA upper limb assist exoskeleton ( Figure 2Right). All three exoskeletons are wearable exoskeleton robots, suitable for drilling operations, such as Figure 2 shown.
[0154] 2. Determination of indicator weights
[0155] (1) Establish a hierarchical model. The human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model constructed in this paper has a certain degree of universality. Therefore, in the actual evaluation application, corresponding adjustments were made according to the actual conditions of the three wearable exoskeleton robots, that is, the indicators that do not involve the display, controller, and protective device design were not evaluated. Finally, the hierarchical analysis method was used to construct a hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system for wearable exoskeleton robots, such as Figure 3 shown.
[0156] (2) Calculate the indicator weight. Take the average of the results of the second round of expert consultation and divide and round it up using the 1-9 scale. The lowest average of the indicator importance score is 3.80 points, and the full score is 5 points. Therefore, taking 3.74 points as the benchmark, 3.74-5 points are divided into 9 intervals from 0 to 9. The importance score of each interval is the value of the interval, as shown in Table 5.
[0157] Table 5 Importance score mean division interval
[0158]
[0159]
[0160] Note: 2 / 4 / 6 / 8 are the middle values of two adjacent judgments.
[0161] According to the above method, the indicator weights of each level of indicators are obtained, as shown in Table 6-10. And according to the formula, all indicators pass the consistency test.
[0162] Table 6 Weights of first-level indicators B1 to B4
[0163]
[0164] Table 7 Operational convenience C 11 ~C 13 The indicator weight
[0165]
[0166] Table 8 Exoskeleton robot intrinsic reliability C 21 ~C 25 The indicator weight
[0167]
[0168]
[0169] Table 9 Appearance adaptability C 31 ~C 35 The indicator weight
[0170]
[0171] Table 10 Motion matching C 41 ~C 44 The indicator weight
[0172]
[0173] Construct the membership matrix:
[0174] Based on their own wearing experience, eight researchers scored the human-machine collaboration safety of the three exoskeleton robots from 0 to 100, obtained the average value, and calculated the mean of the three exoskeleton robots as the standardized reference scheme. The summarized results are shown in Table 11.
[0175] Table 11 Summary of mean values and standardization schemes for safety evaluation of human-machine collaboration
[0176]
[0177]
[0178] According to the human-machine collaboration safety scores of the three wearable exoskeletons and the standardized evaluation results, the membership matrix is obtained, which is expressed as follows:
[0179]
[0180] The matrix is normalized, and the larger the evaluation score of each indicator of the wearable exoskeleton, the better. Therefore, the formula r is used ij =a ij / maxa ij , the relative membership matrix is obtained as follows:
[0181]
[0182] Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation:
[0183] The product of the weight matrix and the relative membership matrix, that is, the formula, is used to perform fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, and finally the safety evaluation result of human-machine collaboration of wearable exoskeleton is obtained.
[0184] Operational convenience G1:
[0185]
[0186] Intrinsic reliability G2:
[0187]
[0188] Form Factor Adaptability G3:
[0189]
[0190] Sports compatibility G4:
[0191]
[0192] Program evaluation:
[0193] The comprehensive evaluation results of the three wearable exoskeleton robots are summarized as shown in Table 12. From the comprehensive evaluation results, it can be found that the CS shoulder-assisted industrial exoskeleton has the highest human-machine collaboration safety evaluation, which is higher than the standard level. From the evaluation results of various indicators, the evaluation results of the operation convenience of the FA flexible power-assisted exoskeleton and the CS shoulder-assisted industrial exoskeleton are similar, both above the average level, and better than the TA upper limb power-assisted exoskeleton. The intrinsic reliability and motion matching of the CS shoulder-assisted industrial exoskeleton are significantly higher than those of the other two wearable exoskeletons. The evaluation results of the TA upper limb power-assisted exoskeleton are relatively low in terms of operation convenience and intrinsic reliability, but it has obvious advantages in appearance adaptability.
[0194] Table 12 Comprehensive evaluation results of human-machine collaboration safety
[0195]
[0196]
[0197] Based on the safety evaluation results of the above three wearable exoskeleton robots for human-machine collaboration, the following suggestions are made for drilling personnel to choose wearable exoskeleton robots:
[0198] (1) FA flexible power-assisted exoskeleton. The FA flexible power-assisted exoskeleton has the highest score in terms of ease of operation, which is higher than the other two exoskeleton robots. Although its intrinsic reliability is slightly lower than the standardized reference solution, it is also significantly better than the TA upper limb power-assisted exoskeleton robot. Therefore, for those who are concerned about the safety and reliability of the exoskeleton robot itself, the operation process, ease of wearing, size adjustment, etc., the FA flexible power-assisted exoskeleton robot can be considered.
[0199] (2) CS shoulder-assisted industrial exoskeleton. From the comprehensive scoring results, only the CS shoulder-assisted industrial exoskeleton has a score greater than the standard solution, and the scores of various indicators are all above 0.8 points; and its inherent reliability and motion matching have significant advantages over the other two exoskeleton robots. People who value comprehensive human-machine collaborative safety and coordination can choose the CS shoulder-assisted industrial exoskeleton robot.
[0200] The specific embodiments described herein are merely examples of the spirit of the present invention. Those skilled in the art may make various modifications or additions to the specific embodiments described or replace them in similar ways, but they will not deviate from the spirit of the present invention or exceed the scope defined by the appended claims.
Claims
1. A wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system, characterized in that: It includes an evaluation index system building module and an evaluation model building module; the evaluation model building module includes a first building module, an evaluation module, a second building module, a calculation module, a verification module, and a third building module; The evaluation index system construction module is used to preliminarily formulate the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system for wearable exoskeleton robots based on the three perspectives of human, machine, and human-machine interaction; The first building module is used to construct a hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system using the hierarchical analysis method; An evaluation module is used to evaluate the importance of indicators in the tomography model according to the Saaty 1-9 scale; The second construction module is used to compare two indicators according to the importance rating level and construct a judgment matrix; A calculation module is used to calculate the weight of the indicator using normalization and sum-product method; A verification module, used for verifying the consistency of the judgment matrix using a consistency ratio; The third construction module is used to construct a membership matrix according to the membership of the indicators in the comment level, obtain a fuzzy evaluation matrix, and generate a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model according to the fuzzy evaluation matrix; The calculation module uses normalization and sum-product method to calculate the weight of the index, specifically: Each column of the judgment matrix is normalized and expressed as: Among them, a ij represents the values of the judgment matrix after normalization; b ij represents the importance scale value of indicator i to indicator j; n represents the number of indicators; k represents the kth scale value in each column of the judgment matrix; The judgment matrix after normalization of each column is summed up row by row, expressed as: Among them, U i It represents the sum of i indicators by row; For vector U = [U1,U2,...,U n ] T Normalized, expressed as: Among them, ω i represents the weight vector, ω=[ω1,ω2,...,ω n ] T ; U j represents the sum of j indicators; After normalizing the weight vector, it satisfies: Among them, 1 means obtaining the maximum eigenvector, i.e., the indicator weight; The consistency of the judgment matrix is checked in the checking module, which is expressed as: Among them, CR represents the consistency ratio; RI represents the average random consistency index; CI represents the consistency index, which is expressed as: The largest characteristic root λ max The approximate value calculation is expressed as: Among them, λ max represents the largest characteristic root, (Vω) i Represents the sum of each row of the judgment matrix V after normalization.
2. A wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system according to claim 1, characterized in that: The index system includes ease of operation, intrinsic reliability of the wearable exoskeleton robot, shape adaptability, and motion matching.
3. A wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system according to claim 1, characterized in that: The first building module uses the analytic hierarchy process to build a hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system, specifically: According to the analytic hierarchy process, the index set U={u1,u2,...,u n }, and then divided into several first-level indicators according to the indicator division principle, each first-level indicator is further divided into several second-level indicators, and finally a hierarchical structure model of indicator factors is constructed.
4. A wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system according to claim 3, characterized in that: The evaluation module evaluates the importance of the indicators in the chromatography model according to the Saaty 1-9 scale, specifically: According to the lower-level indicator subset B in the indicator set U = {B1, B2, B3, ..., B n }, compare the indicator elements in B two by two, and rank their importance according to the Saaty 1-9 scale.
5. A wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system according to claim 4, characterized in that: The judgment matrix in the second building block is expressed as: Where V = (b ij ) represents the judgment matrix; n represents the number of indicators in the fuzzy subset B.
6. The human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system for a wearable exoskeleton robot according to claim 5, characterized in that: The fuzzy evaluation matrix in the third building block is expressed as: Among them, R represents the fuzzy evaluation matrix; r ij Indicates factor B i The evaluation level is the membership degree of j; m represents the number of indicators.
7. The human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system of a wearable exoskeleton robot according to claim 6 is characterized in that: The human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model in the third building block is expressed as: Among them, G i Represents the comprehensive evaluation value of the i-th solution.
8. An evaluation method for a wearable exoskeleton robot human-machine collaboration safety evaluation system based on any one of claims 1 to 7, characterized in that: Evaluation methods include: S1. Based on the three perspectives of human, machine, and human-machine interaction, a preliminary evaluation index system for the human-machine collaboration safety of wearable exoskeleton robots is formulated; S2. Use the analytic hierarchy process to construct a hierarchical model of the human-machine collaboration safety evaluation index system; S3. Rating the importance of the indicators in the tomography model according to the Saaty 1-9 scale; S4. Make pairwise comparisons based on the importance ratings and construct a judgment matrix; S5. Use normalization and sum-product method to calculate the weight of the indicators; S6. Use consistency ratio to test the consistency of the judgment matrix; S7. Construct a membership matrix according to the membership of the indicators in the comment level, obtain a fuzzy evaluation matrix, and generate a human-machine collaboration safety evaluation model based on the fuzzy evaluation matrix.
