A safe and efficient plasma electropolishing method for niobium and radio frequency superconducting cavities.

By using a non-aqueous solvent plasma electropolishing method, the safety hazards and low efficiency problems in the surface treatment of superconducting cavities have been solved, achieving efficient and safe polishing of niobium and radio frequency superconducting cavities, significantly improving the polishing rate, and resulting in a smooth surface without an oxide layer.

CN116219527BActive Publication Date: 2026-11-10INST OF MODERN PHYSICS CHINESE ACADEMY OF SCI +1
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202310261590.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-03-17
Publication Date
2026-11-10
Estimated Expiration
2043-03-17

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing surface treatment methods for superconducting cavities have safety hazards and low polishing efficiency, especially when using highly volatile and corrosive acids such as hydrofluoric acid and sulfuric acid, which have low polishing rates and cannot meet the requirements for high-efficiency processing.

Method used

Using safe and environmentally friendly non-aqueous solvents as electrolytes, niobium and radio frequency superconducting cavities are treated by plasma electropolishing. Ethylene glycol and glycerol are used as base electrolytes, and ammonium fluoride is used as functional electrolytes. Combined with a high-frequency DC power supply, the polishing rate is significantly improved.

Benefits of technology

It achieves safe and efficient polishing of niobium and radio frequency superconducting cavities, increasing the polishing rate by several orders of magnitude, greatly reducing polishing time, improving polishing efficiency, and producing no oxide layer on the surface with excellent mirror effect.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN116219527B_ABST
    Figure CN116219527B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention discloses a safe and efficient plasma electropolishing method for niobium and radio frequency superconducting cavities. The plasma electropolishing method includes the following steps: S1, pre-treating the niobium or radio frequency superconducting cavity; S2, preparing a plasma electropolishing solution; the plasma electropolishing solution consists of a basic electrolyte and a functional electrolyte; S3, immersing the niobium or radio frequency superconducting cavity in the plasma electropolishing solution, using the niobium or radio frequency superconducting cavity as the anode and stainless steel as the cathode, and performing plasma electropolishing treatment on the niobium or radio frequency superconducting cavity using a high-frequency DC power supply. This invention eliminates the use of highly volatile and corrosive acids such as hydrofluoric acid, sulfuric acid, and nitric acid, while increasing the polishing rate by several orders of magnitude, greatly reducing polishing time, improving polishing efficiency, and possessing high practical value.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention relates to a safe and efficient plasma electropolishing method for niobium and radio frequency superconducting cavities, belonging to the field of surface treatment technology. Background Technology

[0002] Radio frequency superconducting cavities (RF superconducting cavities) are core components of modern accelerator devices, widely used in nuclear physics, high-energy physics, synchrotron radiation sources, and free-electron lasers. The most widely used material for superconducting cavities is high-purity niobium (Nb), which possesses a high superconducting transition temperature (Tc ~ 9.25 K) and critical magnetic field (Bc ~ 200 mT). Because superconducting cavities need to operate in harsh environments of extremely low temperatures, high vacuum, and strong electromagnetic fields, their surface properties directly affect their acceleration gradient and quality factor, making surface treatment research one of the most crucial aspects of RF superconducting technology.

[0003] During the fabrication of superconducting cavities, a damage layer of approximately 150 μm forms on the surface, which must be removed by chemical or electrochemical polishing. This step significantly alters the surface of the superconducting cavity and is the most critical step in cavity processing. Buffered chemical polishing (BCP) and electrochemical polishing (EP) are commonly used surface treatment methods for superconducting cavities both domestically and internationally. The biggest problems with using BCP or EP for superconducting cavity surface treatment are the safety of the polishing solution and the low polishing efficiency. BCP uses a mixed acid solution of HF-HNO3-H3PO4 (volume ratio 1:1:2) as the polishing solution, while EP uses a mixed acid solution of HF and concentrated H2SO4 (volume ratio 1:9). Both of these polishing solutions are corrosive and volatile, posing significant safety hazards. Secondly, the polishing rate of BCP is approximately 0.5–1.5 μm / min, while the polishing rate of EP is only 0.1–0.5 μm / min, making the processing time for a single superconducting cavity excessively long. To address these issues, the field of radio frequency superconductivity urgently needs a safe and efficient polishing method. Furthermore, niobium, as a valve metal, typically produces a large amount of oxides on its surface when used as an anode under high temperature and high pressure conditions, which urgently needs improvement. Therefore, this invention is proposed. Summary of the Invention

[0004] The purpose of this invention is to provide a safe and efficient plasma electropolishing method for niobium and radio frequency superconducting cavities, which has high polishing efficiency and low energy consumption.

[0005] The plasma electropolishing method for niobium or radio frequency superconducting cavities provided by this invention includes the following steps:

[0006] S1. Pre-process the niobium or radio frequency superconducting cavity;

[0007] S2. Prepare plasma electrolytic polishing solution;

[0008] The plasma electrolytic polishing solution is composed of a basic electrolyte and a functional electrolyte;

[0009] S3. Immerse the niobium or the radio frequency superconducting cavity in the plasma electrolytic polishing solution, using the niobium or the radio frequency superconducting cavity as the anode and stainless steel as the cathode, and perform plasma electrolytic polishing treatment on the niobium or the radio frequency superconducting cavity using a high-frequency DC power supply.

[0010] In the plasma electropolishing method described above, step S1 includes the pretreatment steps of degreasing, cleaning, and drying performed sequentially.

[0011] In the above-mentioned plasma electropolishing method, in step S2, the basic electrolyte is composed of at least one of ethylene glycol, glycerol, propylene glycol, diethylene glycol, choline chloride, and urea, preferably a combination of ethylene glycol, glycerol, and propylene glycol, a combination of ethylene glycol, glycerol, and diethylene glycol, or a combination of ethylene glycol, choline chloride, and urea.

[0012] The functional electrolyte is composed of at least one of ammonium fluoride, ammonium hydrogen fluoride, ammonium fluoroborate, and sodium fluoride, preferably a combination of ammonium fluoride, ammonium hydrogen fluoride, ammonium fluoroborate, and sodium fluoride, a combination of ammonium hydrogen fluoride, ammonium fluoroborate, and sodium fluoride, or ammonium hydrogen fluoride.

[0013] In the above-described plasma electropolishing method, the mass fractions of each component in the base electrolyte are as follows:

[0014] 0–200 ethylene glycol, 0–100 glycerol, 0–150 1,2-propanediol, 0–300 diethylene glycol, 0–140 choline chloride and 0–120 urea, with each component not being zero at the same time;

[0015] The mass fractions of each component in the functional electrolyte are as follows:

[0016] It consists of 0–120 ammonium fluoride, 0–80 ammonium hydrogen fluoride, 0–40 ammonium fluoroborate, and 0–30 sodium fluoride, with each component not being zero at the same time.

[0017] In the above-mentioned plasma electropolishing method, the mass ratio of the base electrolyte to the functional electrolyte is 1:0.1 to 0.8, preferably 1:0.1 to 0.3, 1:0.1, 1:0.2 or 1:0.3.

[0018] In the above-described plasma electropolishing method, the conditions for plasma electropolishing are as follows:

[0019] The high-frequency DC power supply has a frequency of 0–500 Hz, a duty cycle of 8–100%, a polishing voltage of 100–500 V, and a polishing time of 5–60 min. Samples treated under these conditions have good mirror finish, low roughness, and the best polishing effect.

[0020] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following advantages:

[0021] This invention abandons the use of highly volatile and corrosive acids such as hydrofluoric acid, sulfuric acid, and nitric acid. Under high temperature and high pressure conditions, it uses a safe and environmentally friendly non-aqueous solvent as the electrolyte to achieve safe and efficient polishing of niobium and radio frequency superconducting cavities. At the same time, it increases the polishing rate by several orders of magnitude, greatly reduces the polishing time, and improves the polishing efficiency, which has high practical value. Attached Figure Description

[0022] Figure 1 and Figure 2 Comparison of optical photographs of niobium parts before and after treatment under different electropolishing conditions (Examples 1 and 2).

[0023] Figure 3 Comparison of optical photographs of the inner surface of the radio frequency superconducting cavity before and after electropolishing treatment (Example 3).

[0024] Figure 4 The diagram shows the structure of a 1.3GHz superconducting cavity (left) and the schematic diagram of a superconducting cavity polishing device (right).

[0025] Figure 5 and Figure 6 Comparison of optical photographs of niobium parts before and after processing under different electropolishing conditions (Comparative Examples 1 and 2). Detailed Implementation

[0026] Unless otherwise specified, the experimental methods used in the following examples are conventional methods.

[0027] Unless otherwise specified, all materials and reagents used in the following examples are commercially available.

[0028] Example 1: Plasma electropolishing of niobium sheets

[0029] The niobium sheet measures approximately 41mm × 15mm × 3mm.

[0030] (1) Place the niobium sheet in acetone or ethanol for ultrasonic cleaning to remove oil, rinse it with tap water, then rinse it with deionized water and blow it dry to obtain the pretreated niobium sample.

[0031] (2) Preparation of plasma electrolytic polishing solution:

[0032] A basic electrolyte was prepared by using 60g of ethylene glycol, 25g of glycerol, and 15g of 1,2-propanediol, and a functional electrolyte was prepared by using 10g of ammonium fluoride and 20g of ammonium bifluoride. The two electrolytes were mixed evenly to obtain a plasma electrolytic polishing solution with a mass ratio of 1:0.3.

[0033] (3) Using niobium sheet as the anode and stainless steel as the cathode, immerse the pretreated niobium sheet in the polishing solution, turn on the circulating cooling, select the constant voltage mode of the high-frequency DC power supply, and perform plasma electrolytic polishing treatment on the niobium sheet for 10 minutes under the conditions of 100Hz frequency, 50% duty cycle and 300V positive voltage. The electrolyte is kept fully stirred during the polishing process. After completion, remove the niobium sheet, rinse it with tap water and blow it dry.

[0034] Optical photographs of niobium sheets before and after polishing, as shown below. Figure 1 As shown, no oxide layer is formed on the polished surface, the polishing effect is good, and the mirror effect is obvious.

[0035] Based on the comparison of quality before and after polishing, the polishing rate in this embodiment is 38 μm / min, and the total polishing thickness is 380 μm.

[0036] Example 2: Plasma electropolishing of niobium sheets

[0037] The niobium sheet measures approximately 41mm × 15mm × 3mm.

[0038] (1) Place the niobium sheet in acetone or ethanol for ultrasonic cleaning to remove oil, rinse it with tap water, then rinse it with deionized water and blow it dry to obtain the pretreated niobium sample.

[0039] (2) Preparation of plasma electrolytic polishing solution:

[0040] 400g of ethylene glycol, 60g of glycerol and 40g of diethylene glycol were selected as the basic electrolyte, and 30g of ammonium hydrogen fluoride, 15g of ammonium fluoroborate and 55g of sodium fluoride were selected as the functional electrolyte. The two were mixed evenly to obtain the plasma electrolytic polishing solution, and the mass ratio of the two was 1:0.2.

[0041] (3) Using niobium sheet as the anode and stainless steel as the cathode, immerse the pretreated niobium sheet in the polishing solution, turn on the circulating cooling, select the constant voltage mode of the high-frequency DC power supply, and perform plasma electrolytic polishing treatment on the niobium sheet for 4 minutes under the conditions of 500Hz frequency, 8% duty cycle and 100V positive voltage. The electrolyte is kept fully stirred during the polishing process. After completion, remove the niobium sheet, rinse it with tap water and blow it dry.

[0042] Optical photographs before and after polishing, such as Figure 2 As shown, no oxide layer is formed on the polished surface, the polishing effect is good, and the mirror effect is obvious.

[0043] Based on the comparison of quality before and after polishing, the polishing rate was 22 μm / min, and the total polishing thickness was 88 μm.

[0044] Example 3: Plasma electropolishing of radio frequency superconducting cavity

[0045] A 3.9GHz superconducting cavity was selected, as shown in the schematic diagram. Figure 4 As shown in the middle left figure.

[0046] (1) Place the superconducting cavity in acetone or ethanol for ultrasonic cleaning to remove oil, rinse it with tap water, then rinse it with deionized water and blow it dry to obtain the pre-treated superconducting cavity.

[0047] (2) Preparation of plasma electrolytic polishing solution:

[0048] The basic electrolyte was composed of 8000g of ethylene glycol, 1400g of choline chloride and 1200g of urea. The functional electrolyte was composed of 900g of ammonium fluoride, 100g of ammonium hydrogen fluoride, 50g of ammonium fluoroborate and 50g of sodium fluoride. The two were mixed evenly to obtain the plasma electrolytic polishing solution. The mass ratio of the two was 1:0.1.

[0049] (3) Using a superconducting cavity as the anode and stainless steel as the cathode, the pretreated niobium sheet was immersed in the polishing solution. Circulating cooling was activated, and the niobium sheet was subjected to plasma electrolytic polishing for 15 minutes under the constant voltage mode of a high-frequency DC power supply, with a frequency of 200Hz, a duty cycle of 30%, and a positive voltage of 200V. The electrolyte was kept fully stirred throughout the polishing process. After polishing, the niobium sheet was removed, rinsed with tap water, and dried. A schematic diagram of the polishing process is shown below. Figure 4 As shown in the middle right figure.

[0050] Optical photographs before and after polishing, such as Figure 3 As shown, no oxide layer is formed on the polished surface, the polishing effect is good, and the mirror effect is obvious.

[0051] Based on the comparison of quality before and after polishing, the polishing rate was approximately 10 μm / min, and the total polishing thickness was approximately 150 μm.

[0052] Comparative Example 1: Plasma electropolishing of niobium sheets

[0053] The niobium sheet measures approximately 40mm × 20mm × 3mm.

[0054] (1) Place the niobium sheet in acetone or ethanol for ultrasonic cleaning to remove oil, rinse it with tap water, then rinse it with deionized water and blow it dry to obtain the pretreated niobium sample.

[0055] (2) Preparation of plasma electrolytic polishing solution:

[0056] 400g of ethylene glycol, 140g of choline chloride and 120g of urea were selected as the basic electrolyte, and 20g of ammonium fluoride and 20g of ammonium hydrogen fluoride were selected as the functional electrolyte. The two were mixed evenly to obtain the plasma electrolytic polishing solution, and the mass ratio of the two was 1:0.06.

[0057] (3) Using niobium sheet as the anode and stainless steel as the cathode, immerse the pretreated niobium sheet in the polishing solution, turn on the circulating cooling, select the constant voltage mode of the high-frequency DC power supply, and perform plasma electrolytic polishing treatment on the niobium sheet for 5 minutes under the conditions of 500Hz frequency, 8% duty cycle and 100V positive voltage. The electrolyte is kept fully stirred during the polishing process. After completion, remove the niobium sheet, rinse it with tap water and blow it dry.

[0058] Optical photographs before and after polishing, such as Figure 5 As shown in the figure, the polishing effect of the surface after polishing is poor.

[0059] Based on the comparison of quality before and after polishing, the polishing rate was 5 μm / min, and the total polishing thickness was 25 μm.

[0060] Comparative Example 2: Plasma electropolishing of niobium sheets

[0061] The niobium sheet measures approximately 41mm × 15mm × 3mm.

[0062] (1) Place the niobium sheet in acetone or ethanol for ultrasonic cleaning to remove oil, rinse it with tap water, then rinse it with deionized water and blow it dry to obtain the pretreated niobium sample.

[0063] (2) Preparation of plasma electrolytic polishing solution:

[0064] 100g of ethylene glycol and 100g of glycerol were selected as the basic electrolyte, and 150g of ammonium bifluoride, 20g of ammonium bifluoride, and 10g of sodium fluoride were selected as the functional electrolyte. The two were mixed evenly to obtain the plasma electrolytic polishing solution, with a mass ratio of 1:0.9.

[0065] (3) Using niobium sheet as the anode and stainless steel as the cathode, immerse the pretreated niobium sheet in the polishing solution, turn on the circulating cooling, select the constant voltage mode of the high-frequency DC power supply, and perform plasma electrolytic polishing treatment on the niobium sheet for 5 minutes under the conditions of 100Hz frequency, 20% duty cycle and 150V positive voltage. The electrolyte is kept fully stirred during the polishing process. After completion, remove the niobium sheet, rinse it with tap water and blow it dry.

[0066] Optical photographs before and after polishing, such as Figure 6 As shown, the surface roughness deteriorates significantly after polishing, with a large amount of grain boundary precipitation, and there is almost no polishing effect.

[0067] The results of Comparative Examples 1 and 2 show that both excessively high and low mass ratios of the functional electrolyte will affect the surface quality of the samples, failing to achieve the desired electropolishing effect. This invention, through extensive experiments, determined the types and mass ratios of the two electrolytes, thereby achieving safe and efficient electropolishing of niobium and radio frequency superconducting cavities.

Claims

1. A method for plasma electropolishing of a niobium-based radio frequency superconducting cavity, comprising the following steps: S1. Pre-process the niobium-based radio frequency superconducting cavity; S2. Prepare plasma electrolytic polishing solution; The plasma electrolytic polishing solution is composed of a basic electrolyte and a functional electrolyte. The basic electrolyte is composed of at least one of ethylene glycol, glycerol, 1,2-propanediol, diethylene glycol, choline chloride, and urea. The functional electrolyte is composed of at least one of ammonium fluoride, ammonium hydrogen fluoride, ammonium fluoroborate, and sodium fluoride. The mass fractions of each component in the basic electrolyte are as follows: 0~200 parts ethylene glycol, 0~100 parts glycerol, 0~150 parts 1,2-propanediol, 0~300 parts diethylene glycol, 0~140 parts choline chloride, 0~120 parts urea, with each component not being zero at the same time; The mass fractions of each component in the functional electrolyte are as follows: 0~120 parts ammonium fluoride, 0~80 parts ammonium hydrogen fluoride, 0~40 parts ammonium fluoroborate, 0~30 parts sodium fluoride, with each component not being zero at the same time; The mass ratio of the basic electrolyte to the functional electrolyte is 1:0.1~0.8; S3. Immerse the niobium radio frequency superconducting cavity in the plasma electrolytic polishing solution, using the niobium radio frequency superconducting cavity as the anode and stainless steel as the cathode, and perform plasma electrolytic polishing treatment on the niobium radio frequency superconducting cavity using a high-frequency DC power supply. The conditions for plasma electropolishing are as follows: The frequency of the high-frequency DC power supply is 100~500 Hz, the duty cycle is 8~100%, the polishing voltage is 100~500 V, and the polishing time is 5~60 min.

2. The plasma electropolishing method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S1, the pretreatment includes the sequential steps of degreasing, cleaning, and drying.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Plasma body polishing method of titanium and titanium alloy product

    CN1534113A

  • Electrolytic polishing liquid, and method for producing metal product

    JP2006348336A