Alignment methods and associated alignment and lithography equipment

By determining the correction weights in the lithography equipment and fitting the measurement data to correct for wavelength/polarization variations of the alignment marks, the measurement error problem caused by alignment mark defects in the lithography equipment is solved, and the alignment accuracy and overlap performance are improved.

CN116964530BActive Publication Date: 2026-11-17ASML NETHERLANDS BV
View PDF 9 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202280018266.1
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2021-03-02
Filing Date
2022-02-11
Publication Date
2026-11-17
Estimated Expiration
2042-02-11

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Defects in alignment marks in existing photolithography equipment cause changes in the wavelength/polarization correlation of measured values, which are difficult to be effectively corrected under various irradiation conditions, affecting the accurate alignment and overlapping performance of patterns.

Method used

By obtaining measurement data from multiple irradiation settings, a model is fitted and correction weights are determined to minimize the fitting residuals, thereby achieving alignment data correction.

Benefits of technology

It improves the calibration capability of the alignment sensor, enhances the measurement accuracy and precision of the lithography equipment under different wavelengths and polarization conditions, and ensures the correct alignment of the pattern on the substrate.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN116964530B_ABST
    Figure CN116964530B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A method for determining a set of correction weights to correct measurement data is disclosed. The method includes: obtaining first measurement data associated with a plurality of illumination settings for measuring radiation used to perform the measurement, wherein each illumination setting includes a different wavelength, polarization, or combination thereof; fitting the measurement data to a model for representing the measurement data and determining the fitting residuals; and determining the correction weights as correction weights that minimize the fitting residuals.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] Cross-references to related applications

[0002] This application claims priority to European application 21160224.8, filed on 2 March 2021, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference. Technical Field

[0003] This invention relates to methods and apparatus that can be used, for example, in device fabrication using photolithography, and to methods for fabricating devices using photolithography. The invention also relates to metrology apparatus, and more specifically to metrology apparatus for measuring the position of, for example, alignment sensors and photolithography apparatus having such alignment sensors. Background Technology

[0004] A photolithography apparatus is a machine that applies a desired pattern onto a substrate (typically a target portion of the substrate). For example, photolithography apparatus can be used in the fabrication of integrated circuits (ICs). In this case, a patterning apparatus, alternatively called a mask or photomask, can be used to generate a circuit pattern to be formed on a single layer of the IC. This pattern can be transferred onto a target portion (e.g., a portion of a die, a die, or several dies) on a substrate (e.g., a silicon wafer). Typically, the transfer is performed by imaging the pattern onto a layer of radiation-sensitive material (resist) disposed on the substrate. Typically, a single substrate will contain a grid of adjacent target portions that are continuously patterned. These target portions are often referred to as "fields".

[0005] In the fabrication of complex devices, numerous photolithographic patterning steps are typically performed, thereby forming functional features in successive layers on the substrate. Therefore, a key aspect of the performance of the photolithography apparatus is its ability to correctly and accurately position the applied pattern relative to features placed in previous layers (by the same or different photolithography apparatuses). For this purpose, the substrate is provided with one or more sets of alignment marks. Each mark is structured such that its position can be measured later using a position sensor or alignment sensor (both terms are used synonymously), typically an optical position sensor.

[0006] The lithography apparatus includes one or more alignment sensors that allow for the accurate measurement of the position of markings on a substrate. Different types of markings and different types of alignment sensors are known from various manufacturers and from different products of the same manufacturer. One type of sensor widely used in current lithography apparatuses is based on a self-reference interferometer as described in US6961116 (den Boef et al.). Various improvements, enhancements, and modifications to the position sensors have been developed, for example, as disclosed in US2015261097A1. All of these disclosures are incorporated herein by reference.

[0007] Imperfections in alignment marks can cause wavelength / polarization-dependent variations in measurements derived from those marks. Thus, corrections and / or mitigation of such variations are sometimes achieved by performing the same measurement using multiple different wavelengths and / or polarizations (or more generally, multiple different illumination conditions). Improvements will be needed in one or more aspects of measurement performed under multiple illumination conditions. Summary of the Invention

[0008] The present invention provides, in a first aspect, a method for determining a set of correction weights to correct measurement data; the method comprising: obtaining first measurement data associated with a plurality of illumination settings for performing measurement radiation, wherein each illumination setting includes a different wavelength, polarization, or combination thereof; fitting the measurement data to a model for representing the measurement data and determining a fitting residual; and determining the correction weights as correction weights that minimize the fitting residuals.

[0009] It also discloses a computer program, alignment sensor, and lithography apparatus capable of operating to perform the method of the first aspect.

[0010] The above and other aspects of the invention will be understood in light of the considerations given in the examples described below. Attached Figure Description

[0011] Embodiments of the invention will now be described by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:

[0012] Figure 1 The photolithography equipment is described;

[0013] Figure 2 Schematic map shows Figure 1 The measurement and exposure processes in the equipment;

[0014] Figure 3 This is a schematic diagram of an alignment sensor applicable according to an embodiment of the present invention; and

[0015] Figure 4 This is a flowchart of a color selection method according to an embodiment of the present invention. Detailed Implementation

[0016] Before describing the embodiments of the present invention in detail, it is helpful to provide example environments in which the embodiments of the present invention can be implemented.

[0017] Figure 1 A lithography apparatus LA is schematically depicted. The lithography apparatus includes: an irradiation system (irradiator) IL configured to modulate a radiation beam B (e.g., UV radiation or DUV radiation); a patterning apparatus support or support structure (e.g., a mask stage) MT configured to support a patterning apparatus (e.g., a mask) MA and connected to a first positioner PM configured to accurately position the patterning apparatus according to specific parameters; two substrate stages (e.g., wafer stages) WTa and WTb, each configured to hold a substrate (e.g., a resist-coated wafer) W, and each connected to a second positioner PW configured to accurately position the substrate according to specific parameters; and a projection system (e.g., a refractive projection lens system) PS configured to project a pattern imparted by the radiation beam B by the patterning apparatus MA onto a target portion C (e.g., comprising one or more dies) of the substrate W.

[0018] The irradiation system may include various types of optical components, such as refractive, reflective, magnetic, electromagnetic, electrostatic, or other types of optical components, or any combination thereof, for guiding, shaping, or controlling radiation.

[0019] The patterning apparatus MT holds the patterning apparatus in a manner dependent on the orientation of the patterning apparatus, the design of the lithography equipment, and other conditions such as whether the patterning apparatus is kept in a vacuum environment. The patterning apparatus support MT can employ mechanical, vacuum, electrostatic, or other clamping techniques to hold the patterning apparatus. The patterning apparatus support MT can be a frame or a table; for example, it can be fixed or movable as needed. The patterning apparatus support ensures that the patterning apparatus (e.g., relative to the projection system) is positioned as desired.

[0020] As used herein, the term "patterning apparatus" should be interpreted broadly as any apparatus that can be used to impart a pattern to the cross-section of a radiation beam in order to generate a pattern in a target portion of the substrate. It should be noted that the pattern imparted to the radiation beam may not correspond precisely to the desired pattern in the target portion of the substrate (e.g., if the pattern includes phase-shifting features or so-called auxiliary features). Typically, the pattern imparted to the radiation beam will correspond to a specific functional layer in a device (such as an integrated circuit) generated in the target portion.

[0021] As depicted herein, the device may be of the transmissive type (e.g., using a transmissive pattern forming apparatus). Alternatively, the device may be of the reflective type (e.g., employing a programmable mirror array of the type mentioned above, or employing a reflective mask). Examples of pattern forming apparatuses include masks, programmable mirror arrays, and programmable LCD panels. Any term “mask” or “pattern” used herein may be considered synonymous with the more general term “pattern forming apparatus.” The term “pattern forming apparatus” may also be interpreted as a means of storing pattern information in digital form for use in controlling such a programmable pattern forming apparatus.

[0022] As used herein, the term "projection system" should be interpreted broadly to include any type of projection system, including refractive, reflective, reflective-refractive, magnetic, electromagnetic, and electrostatic optical systems, or any combination thereof, as appropriate for the exposure radiation used or other factors such as the use of immersion liquids or vacuum. Any term "projection lens" used herein may be considered synonymous with the more general term "projection system."

[0023] The photolithography apparatus can also be of the type in which at least a portion of the substrate can be covered by a liquid (e.g., water) with a relatively high refractive index to fill the space between the projection system and the substrate. An immersion liquid can also be applied to other spaces within the photolithography apparatus, such as the space between the mask and the projection system. Immersion techniques are well known in the art for increasing the numerical aperture of a projection system.

[0024] In operation, the irradiator IL receives a radiation beam from a radiation source SO. The source and the lithography apparatus can be separate entities, for example, when the source is an excimer laser. In such cases, the source is not considered part of the lithography apparatus, and the radiation beam is delivered from the source SO to the irradiator IL by means of a beam delivery system BD comprising, for example, suitable directional mirrors and / or beam expanders. In other cases, the source can be an integral part of the lithography apparatus (e.g., when the source is a mercury lamp). The source SO, the irradiator IL, and the beam delivery system BD, provided as needed, can be collectively referred to as the radiation system.

[0025] The irradiator IL may, for example, include an adjuster AD, an integrator IN, and a concentrator CO for adjusting the angular intensity distribution of the radiation beam. The irradiator can be used to adjust the radiation beam to have a desired uniformity and intensity distribution in its cross-section.

[0026] The radiation beam B is incident on the patterning apparatus MA held on the patterning apparatus support MT and patterned by the patterning apparatus. Having traversed the patterning apparatus (e.g., a mask) MA, the radiation beam B passes through the projection system PS, which focuses the beam onto the target portion C of the substrate W. The substrate stage WTa or WTb can be accurately moved, for example, to position different target portions C within the path of the radiation beam B, by means of a second positioner PW and a position sensor IF (e.g., an interferometric device, linear encoder, 2D encoder, or capacitive sensor). Similarly, for example, after mechanical retrieval from a mask library or during scanning, the first positioner PM and another position sensor (… Figure 1 (Not explicitly shown) for accurately positioning the pattern forming apparatus (e.g., mask) MA relative to the path of the radiation beam B.

[0027] Patterning apparatus (e.g., mask) MA and substrate W can be aligned using mask alignment marks M1, M2 and substrate alignment marks P1, P2. Although the illustrated substrate alignment marks occupy dedicated target portions, they can be located in the space between multiple target portions (these are referred to as scribing alignment marks). Similarly, in cases where more than one die is disposed on the patterning apparatus (e.g., mask) MA, patterning apparatus alignment marks can be located between the dies. Small alignment marks can also be included within the dies, between device features, in which case it is desirable that the marks be as small as possible and do not require any imaging or process conditions different from adjacent features. An alignment system for detecting alignment marks is further described below.

[0028] The described apparatus can be used in various modes. In scanning mode, the pattern forming apparatus support (e.g., mask stage) MT and substrate stage WT are scanned synchronously while the pattern to be applied to the radiation beam is projected onto the target portion C (i.e., single dynamic exposure). The speed and direction of the substrate stage WT relative to the pattern forming apparatus support (e.g., mask stage) MT can be determined by the magnification (reduction) and image inversion characteristics of the projection system PS. In scanning mode, the maximum size of the exposure field limits the width of the target portion (along the non-scanning direction) in a single dynamic exposure, while the length of the scanning motion determines the height of the target portion C (along the scanning direction). Other types of lithography apparatus and operating modes are possible, as is known in the art. For example, stepping mode is known. In so-called “maskless” lithography, the programmable pattern forming apparatus is kept stationary but has a changing pattern, and the substrate stage WT is moved or scanned.

[0029] Alternatively, the above usage patterns or combinations and / or variations of completely different usage patterns may be adopted.

[0030] The lithography apparatus LA is a so-called dual-platform type, featuring two substrate stages WTa and WTb, and two stations—an exposure station EXP and a measurement station MEA—where the substrate stages can be exchanged. While a substrate on one stage is being exposed at the exposure station, another substrate can be loaded onto the other substrate stage at the measurement station, and various preparatory steps can be performed. This enables a significant increase in the apparatus's throughput. The preparatory steps may include mapping or plotting the surface height profile of the substrate using a level sensor LS and measuring the position of alignment marks on the substrate using an alignment sensor AS. If the position sensor IF cannot measure the position of the substrate stage simultaneously at both the measurement and exposure stations, a second position sensor can be provided to enable tracking of the substrate stage's position relative to the reference frame RF at both stations. Other arrangements are known and available instead of the illustrated dual-platform arrangement. For example, other lithography apparatuses in which substrate stages and measurement stages are arranged are known. These substrate stages and measurement stages are mated together during preparatory measurements and then dismounted during exposure.

[0031] Figure 2 The diagram illustrates the use of in Figure 1The steps for exposing a target portion (e.g., a die) on a substrate W in a dual-platform apparatus are described. The steps on the left-hand side within the dashed box are performed at the measurement station MEA, while the steps on the right-hand side are performed at the exposure station EXP. Typically, one of the substrate stages WTa and WTb will be located at the exposure station, while the other substrate stage will be located at the measurement station, as described above. For the purposes of this specification, it is assumed that the substrate W has already been loaded into the exposure station. At step 200, a new substrate W' is loaded into the apparatus via a mechanism not shown. Both substrates are processed in parallel to increase the throughput of the lithography apparatus.

[0032] First, consider the newly loaded substrate W'. This substrate can be a previously untreated substrate, prepared with a new photoresist for the first exposure in the apparatus. However, typically, the described lithography process will only be one step in a series of exposure and processing steps, such that the substrate W' has already passed through this apparatus and / or other lithography apparatuses several times, and may also undergo subsequent processes. In particular, to address the issue of improving overlap performance, the task will be to ensure that the new pattern is correctly applied to the correct position on the substrate that has already undergone one or more cycles of patterning and processing. These processing steps gradually introduce deformations into the substrate, which must be measured and corrected to achieve satisfactory overlap performance.

[0033] Pre- and / or subsequent patterning steps (as just mentioned) can be performed in other lithography equipment, and even in different types of lithography equipment. For example, in device fabrication, some layers with very high requirements for parameters such as resolution and overlap can be processed in more advanced lithography tools compared to other layers with less stringent requirements. Therefore, some layers can be exposed in immersion lithography tools, while others are exposed in "dry" tools. Some layers can be exposed in tools operating at DUV wavelengths, while others are exposed using EUV wavelength radiation.

[0034] At point 202, alignment measurements using the substrate marker P1 and an image sensor (not shown) are used to measure and record the alignment of the substrate relative to the substrate stage WTa / WTb. Additionally, an alignment sensor AS is used to measure several alignment marks throughout the substrate W'. In one embodiment, these measurements are used to establish a "wafer grid" that very accurately maps the distribution of the marks throughout the substrate, including any distortions relative to the nominal rectangular grid.

[0035] At step 204, the horizontal sensor LS is also used to measure the wafer height (Z) map relative to the XY position. Typically, height mapping is used only to achieve accurate focusing of the exposed pattern. However, height mapping can be used for other purposes.

[0036] When substrate W' is loaded, configuration data 206 is received, which defines the exposure to be performed and also defines the properties of the wafer, the previously fabricated pattern, and the pattern to be fabricated on the wafer. Measurements of wafer position, wafer grid, and height mapping taken at 202 and 204 are added to this configuration data, allowing a complete set of configurations and measurement data 208 to be passed to the exposure station EXP. Alignment data measurements include, for example, the X and Y positions of alignment targets formed in a fixed or nominally fixed relationship with the product pattern (which is the product of the lithography process). This alignment data, acquired just before exposure, is used to generate an alignment model with parameters that fit the model to the data. These parameters and the alignment model are used during the exposure operation to correct the position of the pattern applied in the current lithography step. The model used interpolates positional deviations between the measured positions. A typical alignment model may include four, five, or six parameters that together define the translation, rotation, and scaling of the "ideal" grid in different dimensions. Advanced models using even more parameters are known.

[0037] At 210, wafers W' and W are swapped so that the substrate W' being measured becomes the substrate W entering the exposure station EX. Figure 1 In the example apparatus, this interchange is performed by swapping the supports WTa and WTb within the apparatus, ensuring that the substrates W and W' remain accurately clamped and positioned on those supports to maintain relative alignment between the substrate stage and the substrate itself. Therefore, once the stage has been interchanged, determining the relative position between the projection system PS and the substrate stage WTb (formerly WTa) is necessary to control the exposure steps using measurement information 202, 204 of the substrate W (formerly W'). At step 212, mask alignment is performed using the mask alignment marks M1, M2. In steps 214, 216, 218, scanning motion and radiation pulses are applied to consecutive target locations across the substrate W to complete the exposure of multiple patterns.

[0038] By using alignment data and height mapping obtained at the measurement station during the exposure step, these patterns are precisely aligned relative to the desired locations, and specifically, relative to features previously placed on the same substrate. At step 220, the exposed substrate, now labeled "W", unloaded from the device, undergoes etching or other processes according to the exposed pattern.

[0039] Those skilled in the art will recognize that the above description is a simplified overview of many very detailed steps involved in an example of a real manufacturing scenario. For instance, instead of measuring alignment in a single stroke or pass-through, there are often separate stages of coarse and fine measurements using the same or different markings. The coarse alignment measurement steps and / or fine alignment measurement steps can be performed before or after the height measurement, or interleaved with the height measurement.

[0040] In the fabrication of complex devices, numerous photolithographic patterning steps are typically performed to form functional features in successive layers on the substrate. Therefore, a crucial aspect of the performance of the photolithography apparatus is its ability to correctly and accurately place the applied pattern relative to features set in previous layers (by the same apparatus or different photolithography apparatuses). For this purpose, the substrate is provided with one or more sets of markers. Each marker is structured such that its position can be measured later using a position sensor (typically an optical position sensor). The position sensor may be referred to as an "alignment sensor," and the marker may be referred to as an "alignment marker."

[0041] Photolithography apparatuses may include one or more alignment sensors that can accurately measure the position of alignment marks formed on a substrate. Alignment sensors (or position sensors) can use optical phenomena such as diffraction and interference to obtain positional information from alignment marks formed on the substrate. An example of an alignment sensor used in current photolithography apparatuses is based on a self-reference interferometer as described in US6961116. Various improvements and modifications to the position sensor have been developed, such as those disclosed in US2015261097A1. All of these disclosures are incorporated herein by reference.

[0042] The markers or alignment marks may comprise a series of gratings formed on or within a layer disposed on the substrate, or (directly) formed in the substrate. These gratings are regularly spaced and function as grating lines, such that the markers can be considered as diffraction gratings with a well-known spatial period (pitch). Depending on the orientation of these grating lines, the markers can be designed to allow measurements along the x-axis or along the y-axis (with the y-axis oriented approximately perpendicular to the x-axis). Markers arranged at +45 degrees and / or -45 degrees relative to both the x-axis and y-axis allow for combined x- and y-measurements using techniques described in US2009 / 195768A (which is incorporated herein by reference).

[0043] The alignment sensor optically scans each mark with a radiation spot to obtain a periodically varying signal, such as a sine wave. The phase of this signal is analyzed to determine the position of the mark, and thus the position of the substrate relative to the alignment sensor, which is in turn fixed relative to the reference frame of the photolithography apparatus. So-called coarse and fine marks involving different (coarse and fine) mark sizes can be provided, allowing the alignment sensor to distinguish different periods of the periodic signal and, more precisely, the exact position (phase) within a period. Marks with different pitches can also be used for this purpose.

[0044] Measuring the position of the markings can also provide information related to deformation of the substrate, which may be disposed on the substrate, for example, in the form of a wafer grid. Deformation of the substrate may occur, for example, by electrostatically clamping the substrate to the substrate stage and / or by heating the substrate when it is subjected to radiation.

[0045] Figure 3 This is a schematic block diagram of a known alignment sensor AS. A radiation source RSO provides a beam RB having one or more wavelengths, which is directed by a steering optics onto a marker (such as a marker AM located on a substrate W) as an illumination spot SP. In this example, the steering optics include a spot mirror SM and an objective lens OL. The diameter of the illumination spot SP (on which the marker AM is illuminated) can be slightly smaller than the width of the marker itself.

[0046] Radiation diffracted by the marker AM (in this example, through the objective lens OL) is collimated into the information-carrying beam IB. The term "diffraction" is intended to include complementary higher diffraction orders; for example, +1 and -1 diffraction orders (labeled +1, -1) and optionally, 0th-order diffraction from the marker (which may be referred to as reflection). A self-referenced interferometer SRI (e.g., of the type disclosed in US6961116 mentioned above) causes the beam IB to interfere with itself, after which the beam is received by a photodetector PD. In cases where the radiation source RSO generates more than one wavelength, additional optics (not shown) may be included to provide discrete beams. The photodetector may be a single element or may include multiple pixels (if desired). The photodetector may include a sensor array.

[0047] The steering optics (which in this example includes the speckle mirror SM) can also be used to block the zero-order radiation reflected from the marker, so that the information-carrying beam IB includes only the higher-order diffraction radiation from the marker AM (this is not necessary for measurement, but improves the signal-to-noise ratio).

[0048] The SRI intensity signal SI is supplied to the processing unit PU. Through a combination of optical processing in the self-reference interferometer SRI and computational processing in the unit PU, the values ​​of the X and Y positions on the substrate relative to the reference frame or reference system are output.

[0049] A single measurement of the type illustrated only fixes the position of the marker within a certain range corresponding to one pitch of the marker. Coarser measurement techniques can be used in conjunction with the single measurement to identify which period of the sine wave contains the marked position. To increase accuracy, i.e., precision and / or robust detection of the marker, regardless of the material on which the marker is made or on or below it, the same process is repeated at different wavelengths at coarser and / or finer levels. Improvements in performing and processing such multi-wavelength measurements are disclosed below.

[0050] In the context of wafer alignment, the following methods are being used or have been proposed to correct for mark asymmetry (asymmetry in the alignment marks that leads to positional errors or offsets): OCW (Optimal Color Weighted—described in more detail in U.S. Publication US2019 / 0094721 A1, which is incorporated herein by reference), OCIW (Optimal Color and Intensity Weighted—described in more detail in PCT Publication WO2017032534 A2), and WAMM (Wafer Alignment Model Mapping—described in more detail in PCT Publications WO2019001871 A1 and WO2017060054 A1).

[0051] Using the example of OCW, in OCW, based on a set of weights including the weight of each color. Least squares optimization is performed on the alignment model fitting coefficients X. These weights They minimize alignment and overlap measurements The difference between them is considered optimal; that is, the optimization finds the weights that best satisfy the following conditions.

[0052]

[0053] In each of these prior art methods, training with reference overlap data is required or desired. Other methods may rely on specific assumptions about the spatial distribution of mark deformation on the wafer. This means that these corrections can only be performed accurately if sufficient reference data is available and if process variations in the reference data represent variations that need to be corrected. This reference data can be measured by a reference sensor, such as post-exposure overlap data, like the data used in the OCW example just presented. This overlap measurement data is used as a reference in a feedback mode: after the wafer has been exposed, the resulting measurement error is observed post-exposure via overlap measurement and corrected in future exposures.

[0054] Using overlap measurement in this way has significant drawbacks. For example, overlap measurement is expensive, not all exposed wafers are typically measured, the measurement is performed relatively long after exposure, which means that the correction may be outdated when it is applied, and overlap measurements also suffer from very similar mark distortion errors and are therefore defective references.

[0055] Therefore, a method is proposed to correct for marking asymmetry using only alignment data, e.g., without relying on overlap measurement feedback. The proposed method is based on the observed correlation between wafer alignment model residuals (the difference between the measured alignment data and the alignment model fitted to the alignment data) and overlap performance. Due to marking asymmetry, each color measures a slightly different wafer shape, and the color that best fits the model can be selected as the preferred matching color. This concept can be extended to determine color weights for multiple colors in a manner similar to OCW, but without relying on reference overlap data. For the avoidance of doubt, all references or designations to “color” in this disclosure should be understood to encompass a specific wavelength and polarization combination (and are abbreviations for a specific wavelength and polarization combination).

[0056] The proposed method includes determining the color weight w for color n (the total number of colors is N). (n) When the color weights are applied to the measured alignment data (For the corresponding measurement position for each color), the correct alignment position x is generated:

[0057]

[0058] Furthermore, an additional constraint can be imposed on the color weights, namely, the sum of the color weights equals 1:

[0059]

[0060] The proposed method aims to determine a set of color weights that minimize the alignment model residuals, such that color-weighted locations have lower (or at least the same) model residuals compared to monochrome measurement locations. The specific illustrative method described below determines this set of color weights by performing a linear least-squares optimization of the model residuals for each measurement. However, it should be understood that this is only one optimization option and alternative optimization methods can be performed, for example, by including a regularization term in an L1-norm-based optimization.

[0061] The method includes obtaining alignment data comprising alignment values ​​for each color (i.e., for each alignment mark, there are multiple alignment values, one alignment value per color). The model residuals can be calculated for each alignment mark (a total of M marks) and for each color (a total of N colors) by fitting the measurements according to the colors using an alignment model and recording the fitting residuals. The alignment model can be any suitable alignment model used for alignment modeling. The fitting residuals can be represented as a residual matrix R, where each element includes the residuals for the alignment mark index m (where m = 1 to m) and the color channels n (where n = 1 to n).

[0062]

[0063] The residuals can be calculated for multiple wafers, and the residuals are stacked vertically in R.

[0064] The goal of the algorithm is to find a set of color weights that minimizes the residual R (e.g., in the least squares sense). That is, you will get:

[0065]

[0066]

[0067] As already stated, this system of equations can be solved, for example, via linear least squares regression under the additional constraint that the sum of the color weights equals 1:

[0068]

[0069] This constraint ensures that the determined alignment correction is invariant for translations across all colors and also avoids trivial solutions where all weights are equal to 0.

[0070] Once this system of equations is solved, applying the resulting optimal weights w to the alignment data will result in the minimum model residuals (e.g., the least square root / root mean square of the model residuals) on the (set of) wafers considered in the input. These weights can be applied to the alignment data to correct for mark asymmetry when determining the alignment grid for future exposures.

[0071] The proposed method can be implemented as an externally trained algorithm in a manner similar to OCW. Alignment data from one or more wafers can be used as training data to determine a set of color weights, which can then be applied to one or more (future) wafers. However, relying solely on alignment data without requiring reference overlap data also means that the same method can be used to perform in-line alignment correction based on the wafer; for example, within a scanner or a separate alignment station. After all alignment marks have been measured (e.g., within the measurement platform of a dual-platform system or a separate alignment station), but before the wafer has been transferred to the exposure platform or exposure station, the proposed method can be used to determine a set of color weights that minimize the model residual for each wafer on a wafer-by-wafer basis. In this way, the alignment grid for each wafer can be corrected using a set of optimal color weights specifically determined for that wafer.

[0072] Typically, the set of color weights obtained using the method described above will include non-zero values ​​for each color. For example, some alignment sensors can perform measurements using up to 24 illumination settings (e.g., 12 wavelengths and two polarizations), and thus, the method disclosed herein can determine 24 color weights.

[0073] In embodiments, it may be advantageous to limit the number of color weights used in the solution, for example, to limit the number of colors used for measurement (e.g., up to 4, 5, 6, or 7 colors). Advantages of this embodiment include stronger robustness against overfitting to outliers in the training data, and less stringent requirements on future chips to which matching schemes will be applied, since all colors with non-zero weights must also be valid (e.g., with sufficient signal strength).

[0074] A first method for reducing the number of color weights (which may be applied alone or in combination with other such methods described herein) may include applying an appropriate threshold to exclude colors with very small associated weights, and / or removing colors that do not contribute significantly to the result (e.g., colors with associated weights below the threshold may be excluded).

[0075] Figure 4This is a flowchart describing methods that can be used to reduce the number of colors (e.g., to determine a subset of enabled colors for measurement as available colors). This describes one method of removing colors via a predictor or predictor selected stepwise backward. Another approach would be to use stepwise forward selection, or a combination of both.

[0076] At step 402, the color influence index and current performance index are determined based on the residual (RES)R and weight (WT)w. This can be based on the regression error (e.g., the square root of the regression error). To determine the current performance, a color influence index can be constructed by multiplying each color (column) of the residual matrix by its corresponding color weight. Based on this, the RMS (or other suitable statistical measure) for each color can be determined, resulting in a color influence vector with values ​​for each color.

[0077] The method described in the flowchart can be repeated over multiple runs; for example, one color can be removed at a time. At step 404, it is determined whether this is the first run; if so, the current performance metric determined in the previous step is used to initialize the initial performance metric 408. At step 412, it is determined whether the difference between the current performance metric and the initial performance metric 408 is outside the performance threshold 410: if so, it is determined based on performance whether the previous run resulted in color removal. If so, the algorithm restores the weights from the previous run 418 to 416 and ends with these weights 420, presenting the enabled color.

[0078] If either step 412 or 414 is negative, then at step 422, it is determined whether the current number 426 of enabled colors is greater than the specified maximum number 424 of enabled colors. If not, then at step 430, it is determined whether any of these weights has a value lower than the minimum weight threshold 428. If not, then at step 440, it is determined whether the difference between the current performance metric and the initial performance metric 408 is within the performance threshold 410. If not, the process ends / terminates 444 with the current weights and enabled colors.

[0079] If the determination is yes for any of steps 422, 430, or 440, then the current weights of this run are stored at step 442, and it is determined at step 432 whether the number of colors is greater than 1. If no, the process ends / terminates at the current weights at step 444. If yes, then based on the currently enabled colors 434, the colors with the lowest associated color influence are removed to determine an updated set of enabled colors 438. Further runs can then be performed based on the updated enabled colors 438 and their associated weights at step 442.

[0080] Another approach to reducing the number of colors can be a brute-force method, or a strong method, where all color combinations are considered and the optimal combination is selected (e.g., the combination that satisfies all conditions). More specifically, the method can include calculating solutions with color weights for each possible group. This could include starting with solutions for all 1-colors, then all 2-colors, then all 3-colors, and so on until all color solutions are found. The optimal solution could be the one that uses the fewest number of colors to satisfy a certain performance threshold.

[0081] In embodiments, the disclosed method for optimizing residuals can also be combined (in a variety of different ways that will be apparent to those skilled in the art) with optimization for overlap; for example, to combine the method with an OCW method. For example, when only a small number of overlap wafers are available, as described above, optimization can be performed only for the alignment residuals. Later, once a sufficient number of overlap wafers are available, the method can alternatively and smoothly transition to optimizing the overlap data (e.g., optimizing the difference between the alignment and overlap data). Alternatively, or additionally, the overlap data can be used to perform co-optimization between minimizing residuals and the difference between the alignment and overlap data.

[0082] The method disclosed herein has the advantage of not requiring overlapping training data. Furthermore, in online embodiments, wafer alignment data can be corrected much faster than wafer correction based on overlapping training, because the alignment data is immediately available after exposure. Therefore, any changes requiring weight retraining can be detected and processed more quickly. Moreover, this multi-color minimum residual method exhibits significant performance gains (in terms of improved overlap performance) compared to single-color residual methods and overlapping-trained OCW methods.

[0083] While the above concepts are described in relation to wafer alignment, they are also applicable to other metrology aspects, such as overlap measurement. Overlap targets also encounter the same problem (unwanted asymmetry) and require correction of overlap measurement results based on multi-color measurements. Thus, the methods described above are directly applicable to such overlap measurement results, where the residuals are overlap residuals obtained by fitting an overlap model to the per-color overlap data.

[0084] Thus, the concept disclosed herein can be summarized as determining a set of color weights (or illumination setting weights, where the illumination setting is a combination of measurement wavelengths and polarizations) to correct multiple color / illumination setting measurements by minimizing the model residuals according to the weights, the model residuals being obtained by fitting the measurements to a model representing the measurements.

[0085] Further embodiments will now be described for application to a measurement tool (e.g., an alignment sensor) comprising the already described SRI (or phase channel) and an additional intensity channel. The embodiment will be described in relation to the measurement of intensity asymmetry using such an intensity channel. However, it will be understood that this embodiment may use any supplementary measurement data or parameters indicating obstructive components in the alignment data (e.g., due to marking asymmetry). The supplementary measurement data may complement and / or correspond to the alignment data, and may be measured simultaneously with the alignment data, for example.

[0086] SRI measures the phase difference between a pair of complementary diffraction orders from multiple wavelengths of the target, and thus measures the alignment position including any mark deformation error (which causes a change in alignment position according to the wavelength) for each of these wavelengths. The intensity channel simultaneously measures the intensity of each of the pair of complementary diffraction orders from the mark with respect to the SRI phase measurement, and therefore the difference between these diffraction orders (e.g., optionally a normalized difference) indicates only the mark deformation error component. Thus, the intensity channel output can be used to correct the alignment position for the mark deformation error.

[0087] More specifically, the complex electric field E of the -1 and +1 diffraction orders - (ω), E + (ω) is described as follows

[0088]

[0089]

[0090] Where ω is the angular frequency (=2πc / λ).

[0091] Measurement position x measured using SRI (phase channel) meas (ω) (including mark deformation error) can be described as follows:

[0092]

[0093] Where P is the target / marker pitch, and It is the phase difference between the +1 diffraction order and the -1 diffraction order. The measured (normalized) intensity asymmetry Q only indicates the marked deformation error. meas (ω) can be described as follows:

[0094]

[0095] Among them I + (ω) is the intensity of the +1 diffraction order, and I - (ω) is the intensity of the -1 diffraction order.

[0096] It is now proposed to extend the color weighting method disclosed herein to include additional color weighting for the intensity channel output. This method may include determining a first set of weights w for the position measurement results. (n) (As mentioned above), while simultaneously determining the results used for strength asymmetry measurements. The second set of weights v (n) (Intensity asymmetric weights). Thus, the weight w (n) v (n) The actual alignment position can be found using the following formula:

[0097]

[0098] As mentioned earlier, weights w can be applied. (n) An additional constraint that sums to 1. Note that this applies only to the alignment data weights, not to the intensity asymmetry weights. This is because the alignment position x resulting from the weighting should be insensitive to the position offset deltaΔ of all colors (since this corresponds to the actual position of the markings on the wafer, mechanical offsets, or displacements):

[0099]

[0100] According to this equation, the constraint that the sum of the phase channel weights should equal 1 follows. This is because of the intensity asymmetry measurement results. The constraint does not apply at that location unless it depends on the position of the mark itself.

[0101] Implementation of this method may include determining what makes the residual R I Minimize the set of color weights (For example, in the least squares sense):

[0102]

[0103]

[0104] in It is the residual of the intensity asymmetry model fitting. As mentioned before, m is the alignment mark index (where m = 1 to M), and n is the color channel index (where n = 1 to N). The basic method is the same as the previous embodiment, but without intensity asymmetry weighting.

[0105] Although specific embodiments of the invention have been described above, it will be understood that the invention may be practiced in ways different from those described.

[0106] While specific reference has been made above to embodiments of the invention within the context of optical lithography, it will be understood that the invention can be used in other applications, such as imprint lithography, and is not limited to optical lithography where circumstances permit. In imprint lithography, the morphology in a patterning apparatus defines a pattern formed on a substrate. The morphology of the patterning apparatus can be imprinted into a resist layer supplied to the substrate, whereby the resist is cured by applying electromagnetic radiation, heat, pressure, or a combination thereof. After the resist has been cured, the patterning apparatus is removed from the resist, thereby leaving a pattern therein.

[0107] As used herein, the terms “radiation” and “beam” include all types of electromagnetic radiation, including: ultraviolet (UV) radiation (e.g., having wavelengths of 365 nm, 355 nm, 248 nm, 193 nm, 157 nm, or 126 nm) and extreme ultraviolet (EUV) radiation (e.g., having wavelengths in the range of 1 nm to 100 nm), as well as particle beams, such as ion beams or electron beams.

[0108] Where context permits, the term "lens" can refer to any one or a combination of various types of optical components, including refractive, reflective, magnetic, electromagnetic, and electrostatic optical components. Reflective components can be used in equipment operating in the UV and / or EUV range.

[0109] The embodiments disclosed herein can be further described in the following aspects.

[0110] 1. A method for determining a set of correction weights to correct measurement data; the method comprising:

[0111] First measurement data are obtained in relation to multiple illumination settings of the measurement radiation used to perform the measurement, wherein each illumination setting includes a different wavelength, polarization, or combination thereof;

[0112] The measurement data is fitted to a model representing the measurement data, and the fitting residuals are determined.

[0113] The correction weights are determined to be the correction weights that minimize the fitting residuals.

[0114] 2. The method according to aspect 1, wherein the fitting step includes fitting the measurement data using the model according to the irradiation settings, and recording the fitting residuals for each irradiation setting.

[0115] 3. The method according to aspect 1 or 2, wherein the determining step includes optimizing the correction weights for minimizing the residual matrix, the residual matrix comprising the measurement data arranged in a first dimension according to the target or label and in a second dimension according to color.

[0116] 4. The method according to aspect 3, wherein the optimization includes least squares optimization.

[0117] 5. The method according to any of the foregoing aspects, wherein the correction weights include correction weights for each of the plurality of irradiation settings.

[0118] 6. The method according to any of the foregoing aspects further includes determining a preferred subset of the plurality of irradiation settings.

[0119] 7. The method according to aspect 6, wherein the step of determining the preferred subset includes:

[0120] Candidate combinations of irradiation settings were evaluated based on performance and impact metrics; and

[0121] Based on the performance and impact metrics, remove an irradiation setting from the candidate combination of irradiation settings or add an irradiation setting to the candidate combination.

[0122] 8. The method according to aspect 7, wherein the removal or addition step includes removing the irradiation condition with the lowest impact index, provided that a performance threshold is satisfied, to obtain an updated candidate combination of irradiation settings.

[0123] 9. The method according to aspect 7 or 8, comprising: performing the evaluation step and the removal or addition step, until the candidate combination of irradiation settings includes the desired number of irradiation settings.

[0124] 10. The method according to aspect 6, wherein the step of determining the preferred subset comprises: evaluating all possible combinations of irradiation settings; and

[0125] The preferred subset is selected as the combination of irradiation settings that meet the performance threshold using the fewest number of irradiation settings.

[0126] 11. The method according to any of the foregoing aspects, comprising: removing any irradiation setting for which a correction weight has been determined is below a significance threshold.

[0127] 12. The method according to any of the foregoing aspects, wherein the determining step is constrained such that the sum of the correction weights equals 1.

[0128] 13. The method according to any of the foregoing aspects, wherein the measurement data includes alignment data.

[0129] 14. The method according to aspect 13, comprising: applying the correction weight to an alignment measurement of a substrate performed using a plurality of irradiation settings to obtain a corrected alignment measurement result.

[0130] 15. The method according to aspect 13, wherein the measurement data further includes supplementary measurement data corresponding to the alignment data, the supplementary measurement data being related to supplementary measurement parameters; and the method further includes:

[0131] Simultaneously, the alignment data is fitted to a first model representing the alignment data and the alignment data fitting residual is determined; and the supplementary measurement data is fitted to a second model representing the supplementary measurement data and the supplementary measurement data fitting residual is determined; and

[0132] The correction weights are determined to be a first set of correction weights that minimizes the alignment fitting residuals and a second set of correction weights that minimizes the fitting residuals of the supplementary measurement data.

[0133] 16. The method according to aspect 15, wherein the supplementary measurement data indicates the obstructive components in the alignment data.

[0134] 17. The method according to aspect 15 or 16, wherein the supplementary measurement data indicates asymmetry in one or more targets or markers measured to obtain the alignment data and the supplementary measurement data.

[0135] 18. The method according to aspect 17, wherein the supplementary measurement parameter includes intensity asymmetry, the intensity asymmetry being related to a difference or imbalance between a pair of complementary diffraction orders from the one or more targets or markers.

[0136] 19. The method according to any one of aspects 15 to 18, comprising:

[0137] The first correction weight is applied to the alignment measurement of the substrate performed using multiple irradiation settings to obtain a weighted alignment measurement result;

[0138] The second correction weight is applied to the supplementary measurement parameter measurement result corresponding to the alignment measurement result to obtain a weighted supplementary measurement parameter measurement result; and

[0139] The corrected alignment measurement results are determined based on the weighted alignment measurement results and the weighted supplementary measurement parameter measurement results.

[0140] 20. The method according to aspect 14 or 19, comprising: performing the alignment measurement.

[0141] 21. The method according to any one of aspects 13 to 20, wherein the method is performed to determine the correction weights using a training substrate during an initial training phase, the determined correction weights being applied to a plurality of subsequent substrates.

[0142] 22. The method according to any one of aspects 13 to 20, wherein the method is performed between the alignment measurement step and the photolithography exposure step;

[0143] The method further includes performing the alignment measurement step to obtain the alignment measurement result, such that the first alignment data includes the alignment measurement result, and the method also includes:

[0144] The photolithography exposure step is performed using the alignment measurement results, which are corrected by applying a determined correction weight.

[0145] 23. The method according to aspect 22, wherein, prior to each exposure step, the alignment weight is determined individually for each substrate.

[0146] 24. The method according to any one of aspects 13 to 23, wherein the method comprises: when the amount of available overlapping data reaches a threshold, switching to optimization based on minimizing the difference between the overlapping data and the alignment data.

[0147] 25. The method according to any one of aspects 13 to 24, wherein determining the correction weights comprises performing a co-optimization between minimizing the fitting residuals and minimizing the difference between the overlapping data and the alignment data.

[0148] 26. The method according to any one of aspects 1 to 12, wherein the measurement data includes overlapping data.

[0149] 27. A computer program comprising program instructions operable to perform the method according to any one of aspects 1 to 26 when run on a suitable device.

[0150] 28. A non-transitory computer program carrier, the non-transitory computer program carrier comprising the computer program according to aspect 27.

[0151] 29. A processing system comprising a processor and a storage device, the storage device comprising a computer program according to aspect 28.

[0152] 30. An alignment sensor, said alignment sensor being operable to perform the method according to any one of aspects 13 to 23.

[0153] 31. A photolithography apparatus, comprising:

[0154] A pattern forming apparatus support member, the pattern forming apparatus support member being used to support the pattern forming apparatus;

[0155] Substrate support member, the substrate support member being used to support the substrate; and

[0156] Alignment sensor as described in aspect 30.

[0157] 32. A measuring device capable of operating to perform the method according to aspect 26.

[0158] The breadth and scope of this invention should not be limited by any of the exemplary embodiments described above, but should be defined only by the appended claims and their equivalents.

Claims

1. A method for determining a set of correction weights to correct measurement data; the method comprising: First measurement data is obtained in relation to multiple illumination settings of the measurement radiation used to perform the measurement, the first measurement data including alignment data or overlap data, wherein each illumination setting includes a different wavelength, polarization or combination thereof; The measurement data is fitted to a model representing the measurement data, and the fitting residuals are determined. The correction weights are determined to be the correction weights that minimize the fitting residuals.

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein, The fitting step includes using the model to fit the measurement data according to the irradiation settings, and recording the fitting residuals for each irradiation setting.

3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein, The determining step includes optimizing the correction weights to minimize the residual matrix, which includes the measurement data arranged in a first dimension according to labels and in a second dimension according to illumination settings.

4. The method according to claim 3, wherein, The optimization includes least squares optimization.

5. The method according to claim 1, wherein, The correction weights include correction weights for each of the plurality of illumination settings.

6. The method of claim 1, further comprising determining a preferred subset of the plurality of irradiation settings.

7. The method according to claim 6, wherein, The steps for determining the preferred subset include: Candidate combinations of irradiation settings were evaluated based on performance and impact metrics; and Based on the performance and impact metrics, remove an irradiation setting from the candidate combination of irradiation settings or add an irradiation setting to the candidate combination.

8. The method according to claim 7, wherein, The removal or addition step includes removing the irradiation setting with the lowest impact index, provided that the performance threshold is met, to obtain an updated candidate combination of irradiation settings.

9. The method according to claim 7 or 8, comprising: Perform the evaluation steps and the removal or addition steps until the candidate combination of irradiation settings includes the required number of irradiation settings.

10. The method according to claim 6, wherein, The steps for determining the preferred subset include: evaluating all possible combinations of irradiation settings; and The preferred subset is selected as the combination of irradiation settings that meet the performance threshold using the fewest number of irradiation settings.

11. The method of claim 7, comprising: Remove any irradiation settings for which the determined correction weight is below the significance threshold.

12. The method according to claim 1, wherein, The step of determining the correction weights is constrained such that the sum of the correction weights equals 1.

13. The method according to claim 1, comprising: The correction weights are applied to alignment measurements of the substrate performed using multiple irradiation settings to obtain corrected alignment measurement results.

14. The method according to claim 1, wherein, The measurement data also includes supplementary measurement data corresponding to the alignment data, the supplementary measurement data being related to supplementary measurement parameters; and the method further includes: Simultaneously, the alignment data is fitted to a first model representing the alignment data and the alignment data fitting residual is determined; and the supplementary measurement data is fitted to a second model representing the supplementary measurement data and the supplementary measurement data fitting residual is determined; and The correction weights are determined to be a first set of correction weights that minimizes the fitting residual of the alignment data and a second set of correction weights that minimizes the fitting residual of the supplementary measurement data.

15. The method according to claim 14, wherein, The supplemental measurement data indicates the obstructive components in the alignment data.

16. The method according to claim 14 or 15, wherein, The supplemental measurement data indicates the asymmetry in one or more marks measured to obtain the alignment data and the supplemental measurement data.

17. The method according to claim 16, wherein, The supplemental measurement parameters include intensity asymmetry, which relates to the difference or imbalance between a pair of complementary diffraction orders from the one or more markers.

18. The method of claim 14, comprising: The first set of correction weights is applied to the alignment measurement of the substrate performed using multiple irradiation settings to obtain a weighted alignment measurement result; The second set of correction weights is applied to the supplementary measurement parameter measurement results corresponding to the alignment measurement results to obtain weighted supplementary measurement parameter measurement results; as well as The corrected alignment measurement results are determined based on the weighted alignment measurement results and the weighted supplementary measurement parameter measurement results.

19. The method according to claim 13 or 18, comprising: Perform the alignment measurement.

20. The method according to claim 1, wherein, The method is performed to determine the correction weights using a training substrate during the initial training phase, and the determined correction weights are applied to multiple subsequent substrates.

21. The method according to claim 13 or 18, wherein, The method is performed between the alignment measurement step and the photolithography exposure step. The method further includes performing the alignment measurement step to obtain the alignment measurement result, such that the first alignment data includes the alignment measurement result, and the method also includes: The photolithography exposure step is performed using the alignment measurement results, which are corrected by applying a determined correction weight.

22. The method according to claim 21, wherein, Alignment weights are determined individually for each substrate before each exposure step.

23. The method according to claim 1, wherein, The method includes: when the amount of available overlapping data reaches a threshold, switching to optimization based on minimizing the difference between the overlapping data and the alignment data.

24. The method according to claim 23, wherein, Determining the correction weights involves performing a collaborative optimization between minimizing the fit residual and minimizing the difference between the overlapping data and the alignment data.

25. A computer program product comprising program instructions operable to perform the method according to any one of claims 1 to 24 when run on a suitable device.

26. A non-transitory computer program carrier, the non-transitory computer program carrier comprising the computer program product according to claim 25.

27. A processing system comprising a processor and a storage device, the storage device comprising a computer program carrier according to claim 26.

28. An alignment sensor, said alignment sensor being operable to perform the method according to any one of claims 13 to 22.

29. A photolithography apparatus, comprising: A pattern forming apparatus support member, the pattern forming apparatus support member being used to support the pattern forming apparatus; A substrate support member for supporting a substrate; as well as The alignment sensor according to claim 28.

30. A measuring device capable of operating to perform the method according to claim 1.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Alignment Mark and a Method of Aligning a Substrate Comprising Such an Alignment Mark

    US20090195768A1

  • Position Measuring Apparatus, Position Measuring Method, Lithographic Apparatus and Device Manufacturing Method

    US20150261097A1

  • Lithographic method

    US20190094721A1

  • Lithographic apparatus, device manufacturing method, and device manufactured thereby

    US6961116B2

  • Lithographic apparatus and device manufacturing method

    WO2017032534A2