A comprehensive performance evaluation method for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials

By constructing a comprehensive performance evaluation index system for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, and using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and radar chart method, the gap in the performance evaluation of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials was filled, and a reasonable evaluation and display of the advantages and disadvantages of various properties were realized. Ge33As12Se55 material exhibits excellent comprehensive performance and is suitable for commercial acousto-optic devices.

CN117594160BActive Publication Date: 2026-11-17NINGBO UNIV +1
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202311394780.8
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-10-26
Publication Date
2026-11-17
Estimated Expiration
2043-10-26

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing technology lacks a comprehensive evaluation method for the properties of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, making it difficult to meet the practical application needs of acousto-optic devices.

Method used

A comprehensive performance evaluation index system for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials was constructed using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and radar chart method. The system includes acousto-optic figure of merit, mechanical properties, thermo-optic coefficient, laser damage resistance, and acoustic properties. A radar chart was generated for comprehensive evaluation through weight calculation and graded scoring.

Benefits of technology

This paper provides an intuitive and concise evaluation method that can reasonably assess the various properties of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials and ensure their application effect in acousto-optic devices. In particular, Ge33As12Se55 material exhibits excellent comprehensive performance and meets the requirements of commercial acousto-optic devices.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN117594160B_ABST
    Figure CN117594160B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention discloses a comprehensive performance evaluation method for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials. This method employs the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and radar charts for comprehensive quantitative evaluation. The evaluation index system includes important properties such as acousto-optic figure of merit, mechanical properties, thermo-optic coefficient, laser damage resistance, and acoustic properties. This method utilizes the AHP to calculate the weights of various performance characteristics of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, overcoming the shortcomings of subjective judgment by decision-makers and making the weights of the various performance evaluation indicators more rational. Simultaneously, this invention uses radar charts to evaluate the quality of various performance characteristics of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, intuitively and concisely demonstrating whether the material's various properties are balanced. This comprehensive performance evaluation method for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials provides important support for the application of these materials.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention relates to the field of acousto-optic technology, specifically to a method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials. Background Technology

[0002] Acousto-optic devices utilize ultrasonic waves to process the frequency, amplitude, and direction of optical signals, enabling rapid transmission and conversion of electrical, acoustic, and optical information. Acousto-optic devices, such as acousto-optic modulators, acousto-optic deflectors, and acousto-optic tunable filters, are widely used in optical information technology, laser technology, and radar receiving systems.

[0003] The core components of acousto-optic devices mainly consist of two parts: an ultrasonic transducer (using piezoelectric materials such as LiNbO3) and an acousto-optic medium. The performance improvement of acousto-optic devices depends on the acousto-optic medium material. Acousto-optic crystal materials, such as PbMoO4, GaAs, and TeO2, have become the main medium materials for acousto-optic devices due to their excellent optical homogeneity, high mechanical hardness, good thermal conductivity, low acoustic attenuation coefficient, and high laser damage threshold. With the development of industrial and defense technologies, the cutting-edge research and development of acousto-optic devices is currently trending towards low power consumption, high laser power processing capabilities, mid-infrared operating bands, and miniaturization. Traditional acousto-optic crystal materials, due to their low acousto-optic figure of merit (M2), complex fabrication processes, and difficulties in large-size fabrication, cannot meet the development needs of high-performance acousto-optic devices, necessitating the development of new acousto-optic medium materials.

[0004] Chalcogenide glasses possess advantages such as high optical refractive index, extremely high acousto-optic figure of merit (M²), and a very wide infrared transmission range. They are also easy to manufacture on a large scale, effectively improving the diffraction efficiency of acousto-optic devices and reducing power consumption. Therefore, they hold great promise for applications in the acousto-optic device field, and some international companies have already developed acousto-optic devices based on chalcogenide glasses. Compared to acousto-optic crystal materials, common chalcogenide glasses such as As²S³ and As²Se³ generally suffer from low mechanical strength, high acoustic attenuation coefficient, and low laser damage threshold. Furthermore, the thermal lensing effect of acousto-optic media is an important parameter to consider in practical applications. However, current technology lacks a comprehensive performance evaluation method for acousto-optic chalcogenide glasses. Therefore, how to evaluate the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glasses with different compositions to meet the practical application requirements of acousto-optic devices has become an urgent problem to be solved. Summary of the Invention

[0005] The technical problem to be solved by this invention is to provide a comprehensive performance evaluation method for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials to fill the gap in the prior art, and to provide important support for the application of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials.

[0006] The technical solution adopted by this invention to solve the above-mentioned technical problems is as follows: a method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, comprising the following steps:

[0007] S1. Determine the evaluation index system for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials. The evaluation index system includes acousto-optic figure of merit, mechanical properties, thermo-optic coefficient, laser damage resistance, and acoustic properties. The corresponding index parameters are shown in Table 1.

[0008] Table 1: Composition of the evaluation index system for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials

[0009]

[0010] S2. The index parameters in the evaluation index system for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials are graded and scored. The scoring rules and performance testing methods are shown in Table 2.

[0011] Table 2: Scoring Table for Comprehensive Performance Indicators of Acousto-optic Chalcogenide Glass Materials

[0012]

[0013] S3. Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), the weights of the index parameters of acousto-optic figure of merit, mechanical properties, thermo-optic coefficient, laser damage resistance, and acoustic properties are obtained.

[0014] S4. Calculate the graded evaluation results of the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials: The acousto-optic merit value score, mechanical property score, thermo-optic coefficient score, laser damage resistance performance score and acoustic property score are weighted and calculated to obtain the overall score of the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, thereby evaluating whether the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials is qualified.

[0015] S5. Draw a radar chart based on the graded scoring results of each indicator parameter in step S2;

[0016] S6. Evaluate the performance of various properties of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials based on radar charts.

[0017] The evaluation index system of the evaluation method of this invention includes the acousto-optic figure of merit, mechanical properties, thermo-optic coefficient, laser damage resistance, and acoustic properties. The specific corresponding index parameters are: acousto-optic figure of merit, Vickers hardness and Young's modulus, thermo-optic coefficient, laser damage threshold, and acoustic attenuation coefficient. Among them, the acousto-optic figure of merit mainly reflects the diffraction efficiency of the acousto-optic material, and the test method is BS 7604-1-1992; Vickers hardness and Young's modulus mainly reflect the processability of the acousto-optic material, i.e., its resistance to deformation, and their importance is not significantly different, therefore they are treated equally in the evaluation. The test method for Vickers hardness is GB / T5266-2006, and the test method for Young's modulus is GB / T 38897-2020; the thermo-optic coefficient reflects the stability of the acousto-optic material under long-term laser irradiation (thermal lensing effect), and the thermo-optic coefficient of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials is generally between 0-100×10⁻⁶. -6 The test method for materials with a laser damage resistance between / K is generally GB / T 42657-2023; the laser damage threshold of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials is the maximum laser energy density or laser intensity that the acousto-optic material can withstand before damage occurs. The quality of this performance determines whether acousto-optic devices can work for a long time under high-power lasers. The test method is GB / T 16601.2-2017; the acoustic attenuation coefficient refers to the absorption of sound waves by acousto-optic materials, which is inversely proportional to the square of the frequency. The test method is GB / T 5266-2006.

[0018] As a preferred option, the specific process of step S3 is as follows:

[0019] The evaluation indicators of the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials are ranked by importance, and a judgment matrix A is constructed:

[0020] a ii =1, a ij =1 / a ji a ji ≠0

[0021] Among them, a ij This indicates the importance of the i-th performance evaluation indicator compared to the j-th performance evaluation indicator, where i and j are both positive integers, i = 1, 2, ..., n, j = 1, 2, ..., n;

[0022] The weights of the evaluation indicators for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials are obtained using formula (1):

[0023] (A-λ max I)ω=0 (1)

[0024] Where λ max Let I be the largest eigenvalue of matrix A, I be the unit vector, and ω be the eigenvector of matrix A, which represents the weight of the evaluation index for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials.

[0025] Furthermore, in step S3, after obtaining the weights of the evaluation indicators for the comprehensive performance of the acousto-optic chalcogenide glass material, the weights are verified using formula (2):

[0026] CI=(λ max -n) / (n-1) (2)

[0027] CI stands for Consistency Index. When CI is less than 0.1, the weights obtained are considered reasonable.

[0028] As a preferred option, in step S4, the evaluation criteria for the comprehensive performance of the acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass material are as follows: a total score ≥ 80 indicates that the comprehensive performance of the acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass material is excellent; a total score ≤ 60 < 80 indicates that the comprehensive performance of the acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass material is qualified; and a total score < 60 indicates that the comprehensive performance of the acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass material does not meet the requirements.

[0029] Compared with existing technologies, this invention has the following advantages: This invention proposes for the first time a comprehensive performance evaluation method for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials. It is a comprehensive quantitative evaluation method implemented using the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and radar chart method. Its evaluation index system includes important properties such as acousto-optic figure of merit, mechanical properties, thermo-optic coefficient, laser damage resistance, and acoustic properties. This method utilizes the AHP to calculate the weights of various properties of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, overcoming the shortcomings of subjective judgment by decision-makers and making the weights of various performance evaluation indicators more rational. Simultaneously, this invention uses radar charts to evaluate the quality of various properties of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, intuitively and concisely demonstrating whether the material's various properties are balanced. This comprehensive performance evaluation method for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials provides important support for the application of these materials. Attached Figure Description

[0030] Figure 1 The image shown is a radar chart obtained from the comprehensive performance evaluation of three acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials in the example. Detailed Implementation

[0031] To better illustrate the present invention and facilitate understanding of its technical solutions, the present invention will be further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments.

[0032] With As2Se3, Ge 20 Sb 15 Se 65 、Ge 33 As 12 Se 55 Taking three acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials as examples, the comprehensive performance of these materials is evaluated using the method of this invention. The specific steps are as follows:

[0033] 1. Select As2Se3, Ge 20 Sb 15 Se 65 、Ge 33 As 12 Se 55 The acousto-optic figure of merit, Vickers hardness, Young's modulus, thermo-optic coefficient, laser damage performance threshold, and acoustic attenuation coefficient of these three acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials were used as evaluation indicators, and the measured values ​​of each indicator were obtained according to the test methods listed in Table 1.

[0034] 2. The measured values ​​of the index parameters of the three acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass materials were used to classify and score the comprehensive performance of the three acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass materials according to the scoring rules in Table 2.

[0035] The measured values ​​of various parameters and the grading results of the three acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials are shown in Table 3.

[0036] Table 3: Scoring Table for Comprehensive Performance Parameters of Three Acousto-optic Chalcogenide Glass Materials

[0037]

[0038] 3. Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), the weights of the index parameters for acousto-optic figure of merit, mechanical properties, thermo-optic coefficients, laser damage resistance, and acoustic properties were obtained, and an importance ranking table was constructed as shown in Table 4. When analyzing the weights of each index, we preferably assigned importance values ​​according to a comparison scale of 1 to 9. Scale 1 indicates that the two performance indicators are equally important; scale 3 indicates that the former is slightly more important than the latter; scale 5 indicates that the former is significantly more important than the latter; scale 7 indicates that the former is strongly more important than the latter; scale 9 indicates that the former is extremely more important than the latter; scales 2, 4, 6, and 8 represent the median values ​​of the above adjacent judgment results; if the ratio of the importance of performance index i to performance index j is a... ij Then the ratio of the importance of performance index j to performance index i is a. ji =1 / a ij .

[0039] Using formula (1), the weights of the performance evaluation indicators are obtained and normalized to get ω=[0.21,0.32,0.14,0.25,0.08], which represent the weight proportions of the acoustic-optical figure of merit, anti-laser damage performance, mechanical performance, thermo-optical coefficient, and acoustic performance indicators in the comprehensive performance evaluation index system as 21%, 32%, 14%, 25%, and 8%, respectively. In order to further determine the rationality of the evaluation index weights, formula (2) is used to verify the weights and we get CI=0.041<0.1, which indicates that the calculated weights are reasonable.

[0040] Table 4: Ranking of the importance of performance indicators for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials

[0041] One indicator Sound and light quality Laser damage resistance Mechanical properties Thermo-optic coefficient acoustic performance Sound and light quality 1 1 / 3 2 1 3 Laser damage resistance 3 1 2 1 3 Mechanical properties 1 / 2 1 / 2 1 1 / 2 2 Thermo-optic coefficient 1 1 2 1 3 acoustic performance 1 / 3 1 / 3 1 / 2 1 / 3 1

[0042] 4. Calculate the weighted scores for acoustic-optical excellence, mechanical properties, thermo-optical coefficient, laser damage resistance, and acoustic properties in Table 1 according to the weights of the indicators in the previous step. The mechanical properties score is calculated as follows: Mechanical properties score = (Vickers hardness score + Young's modulus score) / 2. The total score is calculated as: Acousto-optical excellence score × 21% + Mechanical properties score × 14% + Thermo-optical coefficient score × 25% + Laser damage resistance score × 32% + Acoustic properties score × 8%.

[0043] For As2Se3 acousto-optic chalcogenide glass, the comprehensive performance rating score is 44.7; for Ge... 20 Sb 15 Se 65 The comprehensive performance evaluation score for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials was 54.2; for Ge... 33 As 12 Se 55 The acousto-optic chalcogenide glass material scored 60.8 points in the comprehensive performance grading evaluation. This indicates that Ge... 33 As 12 Se 55 Acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials have the best overall performance, and their overall performance is qualified.

[0044] 5. Draw a radar chart: Plot the scores of each indicator in Table 1 on the indicator axis to obtain five points A, B, C, D, and E, representing the acousto-optic figure of merit, laser damage resistance, mechanical properties, thermo-optic coefficient, and acoustic performance indicators, respectively. Connect the five points to obtain a polygonal radar chart. Use lines of different shapes to represent different acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials. The resulting radar chart is shown below. Figure 1 As shown. Figure 1 The acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials corresponding to the dashed line, dotted line, and dotted-dash line are As2Se3 and Ge, respectively. 20 Sb 15 Se 65 、Ge 33 As 12 Se 55 .

[0045] Depend on Figure 1 It is clear that the performance indicators of As2Se3 acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials are developing unevenly, especially in terms of laser damage resistance and thermo-optic coefficient, which deteriorates the radar chart's tendency towards a positive pentagonal shape; Ge 33 As 12 Se 55The acousto-optic chalcogenide glass material has the most balanced performance indicators; overall, the thermo-optic coefficients of the three acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials are relatively poor.

[0046] Based on the comprehensive performance evaluation criteria for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, As2Se3 and Ge... 20 Sb 15 Se 65 、Ge 33 As 12 Se 55 The comprehensive performance of three acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials was evaluated: for As2Se3, Ge 20 Sb 15 Se 65 Regarding acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, Ge 20 Sb 15 Se 65 Acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials exhibit slightly inferior thermo-optic coefficients, acoustic properties, and laser damage resistance. While As₂Se₃ acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials possess an excellent acousto-optic figure of merit (M²), their other performance indicators are poor, resulting in overall scores below passing and failing to meet the requirements of acousto-optic devices for acousto-optic media materials. For Ge… 33 As 12 Se 55 The acousto-optic chalcogenide glass material exhibits balanced performance across all indicators, achieving a comprehensive score of 60.8. This material meets the overall performance standards and has been adopted as a dielectric material in commercial acousto-optic devices.

[0047] To verify the rationality of the comprehensive performance evaluation method for acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials of the present invention, As2Se3 and Ge were respectively tested. 20 Sb 15 Se 65 、Ge 33 As 12 Se 55 Three acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials were used to fabricate acousto-optic modulators to verify their performance. The three modulators were identical in design and process parameters except for the acousto-optic medium material. Measurement data are shown in Table 5. However, the As2Se3 acousto-optic modulator's low power tolerance prevented it from operating for extended periods and thus hindered practical application. Ge... 20 Sb 15 Se 65 、Ge 33 As 12 Se 55 Both acousto-optic modulators made from acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials exhibit high extinction ratios, while Ge... 33 As 12 Se 55Chalcogenide glass acousto-optic modulators, except for slightly lower diffraction efficiency, have higher optical power tolerance, lower insertion loss, and shorter optical pulse rise time, and are currently used as commercial acousto-optic modulators. The above verification results are consistent with the evaluation results obtained using the evaluation method of this invention.

[0048] Table 5: Performance Test Table of Chalcogenide Glass Acousto-Optical Modulators

[0049]

Claims

1. A method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: S1. Determine the evaluation index system for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials. The evaluation index system includes acousto-optic figure of merit, mechanical properties, thermo-optic coefficient, laser damage resistance, and acoustic properties. The corresponding index parameters are shown in Table 1. Table 1: Composition of the evaluation index system for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials S2. The index parameters in the evaluation index system for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials are graded and scored. The scoring rules and performance testing methods are shown in Table 2. Table 2: Scoring Table for Comprehensive Performance Indicators of Acousto-optic Chalcogenide Glass Materials S3. Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), the weights of the index parameters of acousto-optic figure of merit, mechanical properties, thermo-optic coefficient, laser damage resistance, and acoustic properties are obtained. S4. Calculate the graded evaluation results of the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials: The acousto-optic merit value score, mechanical property score, thermo-optic coefficient score, laser damage resistance performance score and acoustic property score are weighted and calculated to obtain the overall score of the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, thereby evaluating whether the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials is qualified. S5. Draw a radar chart based on the graded scoring results of each indicator parameter in step S2; S6. Evaluate the performance of various properties of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials based on radar charts.

2. The method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass materials according to claim 1, characterized in that, The specific process of step S3 is as follows: The evaluation indicators of the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials are ranked by importance, and a judgment matrix A is constructed: ,a ii =1,a ij =1 / a ji ,a ji ≠0 Among them, a ij This indicates the importance of the i-th performance evaluation indicator compared to the j-th performance evaluation indicator, where i and j are both positive integers, i = 1, 2, ..., n, j = 1, 2, ..., n; The weights of the evaluation indicators for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials are obtained using formula (1): (A-λ max I)ω=0 (1) Where λ max Let I be the largest eigenvalue of matrix A, I be the unit vector, and ω be the eigenvector of matrix A, which represents the weight of the evaluation index for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials.

3. The method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials according to claim 2, characterized in that, In step S3, after obtaining the weights of the evaluation indicators for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic chalcogenide glass materials, the weights are verified using formula (2): CI=(λ max -n) / (n-1) (2) CI stands for Consistency Index. When CI is less than 0.1, the weights obtained are considered reasonable.

4. A method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass materials according to any one of claims 1-3, characterized in that, In step S4, the evaluation criteria for the comprehensive performance of acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass materials are as follows: a total score ≥ 80 indicates that the comprehensive performance of the acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass material is excellent; 60 ≤ total score < 80 indicates that the comprehensive performance of the acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass material is qualified; and a total score < 60 indicates that the comprehensive performance of the acousto-optic-chalcogenide glass material does not meet the requirements.