A Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method and system
By acquiring ADS-B message data and GPS differential positioning data, the accuracy, integrity, continuity and availability of Beidou navigation were evaluated, and the problem of lack of quantitative evaluation in the existing technology was solved, and the performance of Beidou aviation service was achieved. Comprehensive assessment and satisfaction of civil aviation operations.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202311557210.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-11-21
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-19
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-11-21
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology lacks quantitative evaluation methods for aircraft navigation service performance at different operating stages, and cannot comprehensively evaluate the accuracy, integrity, continuity and availability of Beidou aviation services.
By obtaining ADS-B message data, GPS differential positioning data and Beidou satellite navigation data, Beidou navigation accuracy, integrity, continuity and usability are evaluated separately, and whether the navigation performance meets the requirements based on the evaluation standards of different operation stages is determined, and a Quantitative evaluation methods and systems.
A multi-angle and quantitative evaluation of Beidou aviation service performance is achieved to ensure that it meets the requirements of civil aviation control operation and provides an executable and operational scaling scale.
Smart Images

Figure CN117784192B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the field of Beidou navigation technology, and in particular to a Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method and system. Background Art
[0002] At present, the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) has defined basic navigation service performance requirements, which mainly include four parameters: Accuracy, Integrity, Continuity, and Availability. Accuracy refers to the description of the difference between the position calculated by the GNSS navigation system and the actual position. Integrity refers to the measure of the degree of credibility of the correctness of the information provided by the entire GNSS navigation system, including the ability to provide timely and effective warnings to users when the system cannot be used for the scheduled operation (or flight phase). Continuity refers to the ability of the GNSS system to perform functions without unplanned interruptions during the expected operation. Availability refers to the proportion of time that the GNSS system can provide reliable navigation information to the flight crew, autopilot, or other systems that manage aircraft flights during the planned provision of navigation services.
[0003] ICAO also clearly puts forward the SIS performance requirements for GNSS (including GPS, GLONASS, ABAS, SBAS, GBAS, etc.) in Annex 10 Volume 1 "Radio Navigation Equipment", and the performance requirements are different in different flight phases. In December 2015, the Civil Aviation Administration of China issued the "Guidelines for the Approval of Satellite Landing System (GLS) Operations", and in its Appendix 1 "Introduction to the GBAS System", it is stipulated that the performance requirements for space signals that need to be met are consistent with the performance requirements in ICAO Annex 10. Therefore, considering domestic development and ICAO's future plans, combined with the current status of China's civil aviation approach operation capabilities, the Beidou aviation service performance indicators are recommended to adopt the ICAO service performance indicator requirements such as Figure 1 shown.
[0004] Regarding the application of the Beidou satellite navigation system in the field of aviation services, most of the existing patents are for ground test verification and flight tests on a small number of single technical elements, and there is a lack of analysis and evaluation methods for the navigation service performance of aircraft in different operating stages under civil aviation standards. Summary of the invention
[0005] In order to solve the problem in the above-mentioned prior art that although evaluation indicators are given, there is a lack of quantitative evaluation method for aircraft navigation service performance in different operation stages, the present invention proposes a Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method and system.
[0006] In order to achieve the above-mentioned object of the invention, the present invention provides the following technical solutions:
[0007] A Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method comprises the following steps:
[0008] Acquiring evaluation data, the evaluation data including ADS-B message data, GPS differential positioning data and Beidou satellite navigation data;
[0009] According to the evaluation data, respectively, Beidou navigation accuracy evaluation, integrity evaluation, continuity evaluation and availability evaluation are performed to obtain evaluation results, wherein the evaluation results are obtained in stages according to the route, terminal area, non-precision approach, vertical guidance approach and precision approach;
[0010] Among them, the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment, integrity assessment, continuity assessment and availability assessment adopt the following method: the first assessment value is obtained based on the GPS differential positioning data and the Beidou satellite navigation data; the second assessment value is calculated by the ADS-B message data, and the operation requirements are met only when the first assessment value meets the preset first assessment standard and the second assessment value meets the second assessment standard;
[0011] The aircraft operation status and track are obtained based on the evaluation results.
[0012] Further, the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment includes the following steps:
[0013] Determine whether the aircraft is in a vertical approach or precision approach phase. If so, calculate the horizontal and vertical positioning accuracy of Beidou navigation based on the GPS differential positioning data; if not, calculate the horizontal positioning accuracy of Beidou navigation based on the GPS differential positioning data;
[0014] For each operation stage, the calculated positioning accuracy values are arranged from small to large. After sorting, the Nth number in the sequence is taken as the Beidou positioning accuracy under the corresponding confidence level. The value of N is determined by the total number and confidence level of the sorted data.
[0015] For each operation stage, determine whether the Beidou positioning accuracy meets the first accuracy evaluation standard, and determine whether the NACp value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard. If both are met, the Beidou navigation accuracy meets the operation requirements.
[0016] Further, the determining whether the NACp value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard comprises the following steps:
[0017] Extracting the operation phase information and ADS-B message data of the aircraft during the flight process; parsing the ADS-B message data to obtain the NACp value; if the NACp value meets the preset NACp evaluation standard, the NACp value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard;
[0018] The preset NACp evaluation standard is obtained according to the mapping relationship between the NACp and positioning accuracy.
[0019] Furthermore, the integrity assessment includes the following steps:
[0020] The initial value of the integrity loss event is set to 0, and the operation phase information of the aircraft flight process, the horizontal protection limit value of each operation phase, the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites, the horizontal protection level, and the positioning accuracy calculated by the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment are extracted;
[0021] Determine whether the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites is less than 5 and lasts for more than TTA time. If so, enter the positioning accuracy determination process; if not, enter the HPL determination process;
[0022] In the HPL determination process, it is further determined whether the HPL is greater than the HAL and lasts for more than the TTA time. If so, the positioning accuracy determination process is entered; if not, the flight end determination process is entered;
[0023] In the positioning accuracy determination process, it is further determined whether the positioning accuracy is greater than HAL. If it is greater, it is recorded as an integrity loss event and then enters the flight end determination process; if it is not greater, it directly enters the flight end determination process;
[0024] In the flight end determination process, it is further determined whether the flight has ended. If not, the process returns to the visible satellite number determination process for the next cycle. If the flight has ended, the integrity index of the Beidou navigation is calculated according to the formula integrity = (1-integrity loss event / flight duration) × 100%.
[0025] For each operation stage, determine whether the integrity index of Beidou navigation meets the first integrity assessment standard, and determine whether the value of NIC and the value of SIL meet the second integrity assessment standard. If both are met, the integrity of Beidou navigation meets the operation requirements.
[0026] Further, the determining whether the NIC value and the SIL value meet the second integrity assessment standard comprises the following steps:
[0027] Extract the operational phase information and ADS-B message data of the aircraft flight process; parse the ADS-B message to obtain the NIC value and SIL value;
[0028] If the NIC value and the SIL value meet the preset NIC and SIL evaluation criteria, then the NIC value and the SIL value meet the second integrity evaluation criteria;
[0029] The preset NIC evaluation standard is obtained based on the mapping relationship between NIC and the horizontal capacity radius, and the preset SIL evaluation standard is obtained based on the mapping relationship between the SIL integrity probability under each horizontal capacity radius.
[0030] Further, the continuity assessment includes the following steps:
[0031] The initial value of the continuity loss event is set to 0, the operation phase information of the entire flight process of the aircraft, the HAL of each operation phase, the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites, the HPL and the positioning accuracy calculated by the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment module are extracted, and the event occurrence counter is introduced;
[0032] Determine whether the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites is less than 5 and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one, and then the HPL determination process is entered; if not, the HPL determination process is directly entered;
[0033] In the horizontal protection level determination process, it is further determined whether the horizontal protection level is greater than the horizontal protection limit and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one, and then the positioning accuracy determination process is entered; if not, the positioning accuracy determination process is directly entered;
[0034] In the positioning accuracy determination process, it is further determined whether the positioning accuracy is greater than the horizontal protection limit and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one, and then the event occurrence quantity determination process is entered; if not, the event occurrence quantity determination process is directly entered;
[0035] In the event quantity determination process, it is further determined whether two or more events occur at the same time. If so, it is recorded as a continuous loss event and then enters the flight end determination process; if not, it directly enters the flight end determination process;
[0036] In the flight end determination process, it is further determined whether the flight has ended. If not, the event occurrence counter is reset and the next cycle is performed. If the flight has ended, the continuity index of Beidou navigation is calculated according to the formula continuity = (1-continuity loss event / flight duration) × 100%.
[0037] For each operation stage, determine whether the continuity index of Beidou navigation meets the first continuity evaluation standard, and determine whether the SDA value meets the second continuity evaluation standard. If both are met, the Beidou navigation continuity meets the operation requirements.
[0038] Further, the determining whether the SDA value satisfies the second continuity evaluation criterion comprises the following steps:
[0039] Extracting the operational phase information and ADS-B message data of the aircraft flight process; parsing the ADS-B message to obtain the SDA value; if the SDA value meets the preset SDA evaluation standard, the SDA value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard;
[0040] The preset SDA evaluation standard is obtained according to the mapping relationship between the SDA value and the continuity probability.
[0041] Furthermore, the usability evaluation includes the following steps:
[0042] The initial value of the duration of the availability loss event is set to 0, and the operation phase information of the aircraft flight process, the horizontal protection limit of each operation phase, the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites, the horizontal protection level, the planned interruption event and the positioning accuracy calculated by the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment module are extracted. The event occurrence counter, the duration of event 1 t1, the duration of event 2 t2, the duration of event 3 t3 and the duration of event 4 are introduced. The event occurrence counter, t4, the initial values of t1, t2, t3 and t4 are all set to 0;
[0043] Determine whether the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites is less than 5 and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented and the t1 duration is updated, and then the HPL determination process is entered; if not, the HPL determination process is directly entered;
[0044] In the HPL determination process, it is further determined whether the HPL value is greater than the HAL value and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented and the t2 duration is updated, and then the positioning accuracy determination process is entered; if not, the positioning accuracy determination process is directly entered;
[0045] In the positioning accuracy determination process, it is further determined whether the positioning accuracy is greater than the HAL value and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented and the t3 duration is updated, and then the planned interruption event determination process is entered; if not, the planned interruption event determination process is directly entered;
[0046] In the planned interruption event determination process, it is further determined whether there is a planned interruption event. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one and the t4 duration is updated, and then the event occurrence quantity determination process is entered; if not, the event occurrence quantity determination process is directly entered;
[0047] In the event quantity determination process, it is further determined whether two or more events occur at the same time. If so, the duration of this event is accumulated on the basis of the duration of the availability loss event. The duration of this event is the duration that satisfies any combination of events, and then the flight end determination process is entered; if not, the flight end determination process is directly entered;
[0048] The availability index of Beidou navigation is calculated according to the availability calculation formula: availability = (1 – duration of availability loss event / (duration of availability loss event + flight time) × 100%; and whether the operation requirements are met is determined according to the preset availability standards.
[0049] Furthermore, it also includes an intelligent identification method for aircraft operation phase:
[0050] Extract the aircraft's current longitude, latitude, altitude, navigation frequency, longitude and latitude information of takeoff and landing airports, and initial approach positioning point information;
[0051] Determine whether the aircraft is currently located at the initial approach fix point. If so, the aircraft is in the approach phase. Further determine whether the aircraft navigation frequency is consistent with the frequency of the DME navigation station at the landing airport. If they are consistent, the aircraft's current operation phase is a non-precision approach; if they are inconsistent, further determine whether the aircraft navigation frequency is consistent with the frequency of the ILS navigation station at the landing airport. If they are consistent, the aircraft's current operation phase is a precision approach; if they are inconsistent, the aircraft's current operation phase is a vertical guidance approach; when the aircraft's current position is not at the initial approach fix point, further determine whether the aircraft's horizontal range from the take-off and landing airport is less than the preset maximum distance and the vertical range is less than the preset maximum height. If so, the aircraft's current operation phase is the terminal area; if not, the aircraft's current operation phase is the route.
[0052] Based on the same concept, a Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation system is also proposed, including an input module, a Beidou navigation accuracy evaluation module, a Beidou navigation integrity evaluation module, a Beidou navigation continuity evaluation module, a Beidou navigation availability evaluation module and an output module;
[0053] An input module is used to obtain evaluation data, wherein the evaluation data includes ADS-B message data, GPS differential positioning data and Beidou satellite navigation data;
[0054] A Beidou navigation accuracy assessment module, used for performing Beidou navigation accuracy assessment according to the assessment data; a Beidou navigation integrity assessment module, used for performing Beidou navigation integrity assessment according to the assessment data; a Beidou navigation continuity assessment module, used for performing Beidou navigation continuity assessment according to the assessment data; a Beidou navigation availability assessment module, used for performing Beidou navigation availability assessment according to the assessment data;
[0055] Among them, the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment, integrity assessment, continuity assessment and availability assessment adopt the following methods: obtain a first assessment value through GPS differential positioning data and Beidou satellite navigation data; calculate a second assessment value through ADS-B message data, and only when the first assessment value meets the preset first assessment standard and the second assessment value meets the second assessment standard, the operation requirements are met;
[0056] The output module is used to obtain the aircraft operation status and track according to the evaluation results; the evaluation results are obtained in stages according to the route, terminal area, non-precision approach, vertical guidance approach, and precision approach.
[0057] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0058] The present invention proposes a Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method and system. According to different operation stages of aircraft, a quantitative evaluation method for navigation performance is established from four performance index parameters of accuracy / precision, integrity, continuity and availability. At the same time, the navigation-related parameter performance indexes in the aircraft ADS-B OUT message are monitored to reflect the real performance of Beidou navigation equipment from multiple angles, and form an executable and operable quantitative scale of equipment performance, so as to ensure that it meets the requirements of civil aviation control operation. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0059] Figure 1 It is recommended to adopt the ICAO service performance index requirement table for the Beidou aviation service performance index in the background technology of the present invention;
[0060] Figure 2 The Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation system diagram in Embodiment 1 of the present invention;
[0061] Figure 3 This is a flow chart of the method for intelligently identifying the operation phase of an aircraft in Embodiment 1 of the present invention;
[0062] Figure 4 This is an overall block diagram of the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment method in Embodiment 1 of the present invention;
[0063] Figure 5 This is a flow chart of positioning accuracy calculation in Example 1 of the present invention;
[0064] Figure 6 This is a flow chart of NACp evaluation in Example 1 of the present invention;
[0065] Figure 7 This is an overall flow chart of the Beidou navigation integrity assessment method in Embodiment 1 of the present invention;
[0066] Figure 8 This is a flow chart of integrity assessment in Example 1 of the present invention;
[0067] Fig. 9 This is a flow chart of NIC and SIL evaluation standards in Example 1 of the present invention;
[0068] Fig.10 This is an overall flow chart of the Beidou navigation continuity assessment method in Embodiment 1 of the present invention;
[0069] Fig.11 This is a flow chart of continuity assessment in Example 1 of the present invention;
[0070] Fig.12 This is a flow chart of SDA evaluation in Example 1 of the present invention;
[0071] Fig.13 This is a flow chart of the Beidou navigation availability evaluation method in Embodiment 1 of the present invention;
[0072] Fig.14 This is a series of judgment flow charts before calculating availability in Embodiment 1 of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0073] The present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with test examples and specific implementation methods. However, this should not be understood as the scope of the above subject matter of the present invention being limited to the following embodiments, and all technologies realized based on the content of the present invention belong to the scope of the present invention.
[0074] Example 1
[0075] The BeiDou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation system consists of an aircraft operation phase intelligent identification module, a BeiDou navigation accuracy evaluation module, a BeiDou navigation integrity evaluation module, a BeiDou navigation continuity evaluation module, a BeiDou navigation availability evaluation module, an ADS-B message navigation performance indicator monitoring module, and an aircraft operation status and track 3D visualization module. Figure 2 shown.
[0076] The aircraft operation status and track 3D visualization module parses the received aircraft ADS-B messages and displays the aircraft's current position and status information in 3D visualization, including longitude, latitude, altitude, speed, heading, etc., and can also display track information.
[0077] The aircraft operation phase intelligent identification module uses the position information and status information obtained by the aircraft operation status and track 3D visualization module to intelligently identify the current operation phase of the aircraft. The operation phase is divided into route, terminal area, non-precision approach, vertical guidance approach and precision approach. Figure 3 shown.
[0078] Extract the aircraft's current longitude, latitude, altitude, navigation frequency, latitude and longitude information of the take-off and landing airports, and initial approach fix (IAF) information from the database server, and then determine whether the aircraft is currently located at the IAF point. If so, the aircraft is in the approach phase, and further determine whether the aircraft's navigation frequency is consistent with the frequency of the DME navigation station at the landing airport. If consistent, the aircraft's current operation phase is non-precision approach; if inconsistent, further determine whether the aircraft's navigation frequency is consistent with the frequency of the ILS navigation station at the landing airport. If consistent, the aircraft's current operation phase is precision approach; if inconsistent, the aircraft's current operation phase is vertical guidance approach. When the aircraft's current position is not at the IAF point, further determine whether the aircraft's horizontal range from the take-off and landing airport is less than 50 kilometers (preset maximum distance) and the vertical range is less than or equal to 6,000 meters (preset maximum altitude). If so, the aircraft's current operation phase is the terminal area; if not, the aircraft's current operation phase is the route.
[0079] The Beidou navigation accuracy evaluation module uses GPS differential positioning data as a benchmark to calculate and evaluate the Beidou positioning accuracy of aircraft in different operating stages. The overall block diagram of the Beidou navigation accuracy evaluation method is as follows: Figure 4 As shown in the figure, the positioning accuracy calculation process is as follows Figure 5 As shown in Figure 2, the NACp evaluation process is as follows: Figure 6 shown.
[0080] Extract the operation phase information, Beidou navigation positioning information and GPS differential positioning information of the entire flight process of the aircraft from the database server, and then determine whether the operation phase of the aircraft in each second is a vertical guidance approach or a precision approach. If so, the horizontal positioning accuracy and vertical positioning accuracy of Beidou navigation are calculated based on the GPS differential positioning information; if not, the horizontal positioning accuracy of Beidou navigation is calculated based on the GPS differential positioning information. After the calculation is completed, the positioning accuracy calculated in each operation phase is arranged from small to large, and the (total number × 0.95)th number in each operation phase sequence is taken as the Beidou positioning accuracy at 95% confidence.
[0081] For each operation stage, determine whether the Beidou positioning accuracy meets the first accuracy evaluation standard, and determine whether the NACp value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard. If both are met, the Beidou navigation accuracy meets the operation requirements.
[0082] Determining whether the NACp value meets the second accuracy evaluation criterion includes the following steps:
[0083] Extracting the operation phase information and ADS-B message data of the aircraft during the flight process; parsing the ADS-B message data to obtain the NACp value; if the NACp value meets the preset NACp evaluation standard, the NACp value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard;
[0084] The preset NACp evaluation standard is obtained according to the mapping relationship between the NACp and positioning accuracy.
[0085] Furthermore, the first accuracy evaluation standard is the accuracy evaluation standard at different operation stages:
[0086] Route: Positioning accuracy ≤3.7km;
[0087] Terminal area: positioning accuracy ≤ 0.74km;
[0088] Non-precision approach: positioning accuracy ≤ 220m;
[0089] Vertical guidance approach: positioning accuracy ≤16m;
[0090] Precision approach: positioning accuracy ≤16m.
[0091] Furthermore, the mapping relationship between NACp and positioning accuracy is established as follows. This mapping relationship is the corresponding relationship between positioning accuracy and NACp value obtained by further refining the positioning accuracy according to the accuracy evaluation criteria of different operation stages:
[0092] NACp=0: Positioning accuracy ≥18.52km
[0093] NACp=1: Positioning accuracy <18.52km
[0094] NACp=2: Positioning accuracy <7.408km
[0095] NACp=3: Positioning accuracy <3.704km
[0096] NACp=4: Positioning accuracy <1852m
[0097] NACp=5: Positioning accuracy <926m
[0098] NACp=6: Positioning accuracy <555.6m
[0099] NACp=7: Positioning accuracy <185.2m
[0100] NACp=8: Positioning accuracy <92.6m
[0101] NACp=9: Positioning accuracy <30m
[0102] NACp=10: Positioning accuracy <10m
[0103] NACp=11: Positioning accuracy <3m
[0104] Since the mapping relationship between NACp and positioning accuracy is established, the NACp evaluation criteria at different stages can be directly obtained:
[0105] Route: NACp≥3
[0106] Terminal region: NACp≥6
[0107] Non-precision approach: NACp ≥ 7
[0108] Vertical guidance approach: NACp ≥ 10
[0109] Precision approach: NACp ≥ 10
[0110] The mapping relationship between NACp and positioning accuracy proves the rationality of the NACp evaluation standard.
[0111] Next, the positioning accuracy calculation results are compared with the accuracy evaluation standards, and the NACp and NACp evaluation standards are compared. If both requirements are met, the Beidou navigation accuracy meets the operational requirements. Otherwise, the Beidou navigation accuracy does not meet the operational requirements.
[0112] The Beidou navigation integrity assessment module is used to calculate and assess the integrity of Beidou navigation data in different operating phases of aircraft. The overall process of the Beidou navigation integrity assessment method is as follows: Figure 7 As shown in Figure 8 As shown in the figure, the NIC and SIL assessment standard process is as follows Fig. 9 shown.
[0113] The initial value of the integrity loss event is set to 0, and the operation phase information of the entire flight process of the aircraft, the horizontal protection limit (HAL) of each operation phase, the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites, the horizontal protection level (HPL) and the positioning accuracy calculated by the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment module are extracted from the database server.
[0114] Determine whether the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites is less than 5 and lasts for more than TTA (10 seconds). If so, enter the positioning accuracy determination process; if not, enter the HPL determination process.
[0115] In the HPL determination process, it is further determined whether the HPL is greater than the HAL and lasts for more than TTA (10 seconds). If so, the positioning accuracy determination process is entered; if not, the flight end determination process is entered.
[0116] In the positioning accuracy determination process, it is further determined whether the positioning accuracy is greater than HAL. If it is, it is recorded as an integrity loss event and then enters the flight end determination process; if it is not, it directly enters the flight end determination process.
[0117] In the flight end determination process, it is further determined whether the flight has ended. If not, the process returns to the visible satellite number determination process for the next cycle. If the flight has ended, the integrity index of the Beidou navigation is calculated according to the formula: Integrity = (1-integrity loss event / flight duration) × 100%.
[0118] For each operation stage, determine whether the integrity index of Beidou navigation meets the first integrity assessment standard, and determine whether the value of NIC and the value of SIL meet the second integrity assessment standard. If both are met, the integrity of Beidou navigation meets the operation requirements.
[0119] Furthermore, the first integrity assessment standard is the pre-established integrity assessment standard for different stages:
[0120] Route: Integrity probability ≥ 1-1×10 -7 / h
[0121] Terminal area: integrity probability ≥ 1-1×10 -7 / h
[0122] Non-precision approach: integrity probability ≥ 1-1×10 -7 / h
[0123] Vertical guidance approach: integrity probability ≥ 1-2×10 -7 / approach
[0124] Precision approach: integrity probability ≥ 1-2×10 -7 / approach
[0125] Further, judging whether the NIC value and the SIL value meet the second integrity assessment standard is to consider the NIC and SIL assessment results at different stages. Judging whether the NIC value and the SIL value meet the second integrity assessment standard includes the following steps:
[0126] Extract the operational phase information and ADS-B message data of the entire flight process of the aircraft from the database server; parse the ADS-B message to obtain the values of the Navigation Integrity Category (NIC) and Surveillance Integrity Level (SIL);
[0127] If the NIC value and the SIL value meet the preset NIC and SIL evaluation criteria, then the NIC value and the SIL value meet the second integrity evaluation criteria;
[0128] The preset NIC evaluation standard is obtained based on the mapping relationship between NIC and the horizontal capacity radius, and the preset SIL evaluation standard is obtained based on the mapping relationship between the SIL integrity probability under each horizontal capacity radius.
[0129] Pre-established mapping relationship between NIC and horizontal capacity radius (Rc):
[0130] NIC=0: Rc unknown NIC=1: Rc<37.04km
[0131] NIC=2: Rc<14.816km NIC=3: Rc<7.408km
[0132] NIC=4: Rc<3.704m NIC=5: Rc<1852m
[0133] NIC=6: Rc<555.6m NIC=7: Rc<370.4m
[0134] NIC=8: Rc<185.2m NIC=9: Rc<75m
[0135] NIC=10: Rc<25m NIC=11: Rc<7.5m
[0136] The pre-established mapping relationship between SIL and integrity probability at each horizontal capacity radius (Rc) is:
[0137] SIL=0: The integrity probability under any Rc is ≤1-1×10 -3 / h
[0138] SIL=1: The integrity probability under any Rc is greater than 1-1×10 -3 / h
[0139] SIL=2: Integrity probability under any Rc>1-1×10 -5 / h
[0140] SIL=3: Integrity probability under any Rc>1-1×10 -7 / h
[0141] Since the mapping relationship between NIC and horizontal capacity radius (Rc) and the mapping relationship between SIL and integrity probability under each horizontal capacity radius (Rc) are established, the NIC and SIL evaluation standards at different stages can be obtained:
[0142] Route: NIC≥4 and SIL=3
[0143] Terminal area: NIC≥6 and SIL=3
[0144] Non-precision approach: NIC ≥ 8 and SIL = 3
[0145] Vertical guidance approach: NIC=11 and SIL=3
[0146] Precision approach: NIC=11 and SIL=3
[0147] The mapping relationship between NIC and horizontal capacity radius (Rc) and the mapping relationship between SIL and integrity probability at each horizontal capacity radius (Rc) prove the rationality of NIC and SIL evaluation standards at different stages. If the integrity calculation results meet the integrity evaluation standards, and NIC and SIL also meet the evaluation standards, the integrity of Beidou navigation meets the operational requirements, otherwise, the integrity of passive navigation does not meet the operational requirements.
[0148] The Beidou navigation continuity assessment module is used to calculate and assess the continuity of Beidou navigation data in different operating phases of aircraft. The overall flow chart of the Beidou navigation continuity assessment method is as follows: Fig.10 As shown in the figure, the continuous assessment process is as follows Fig.11 As shown in the figure, the SDA evaluation process is as follows Fig.12 shown.
[0149] The initial value of the continuity loss event is set to 0, and the operation phase information of the entire flight process of the aircraft, the horizontal protection limit (HAL) of each operation phase, the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites, the horizontal protection level (HPL) and the positioning accuracy calculated by the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment module are extracted from the database server, and an event occurrence counter is introduced.
[0150] Determine whether the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites is less than 5 and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one, and then the HPL determination process is entered; if not, the HPL determination process is directly entered.
[0151] In the HPL determination process, it is further determined whether the HPL is greater than the HAL and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one, and then the positioning accuracy determination process is entered; if not, the positioning accuracy determination process is directly entered.
[0152] In the positioning accuracy determination process, it is further determined whether the positioning accuracy is greater than HAL and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one, and then the event occurrence quantity determination process is entered; if not, the event occurrence quantity determination process is directly entered.
[0153] In the process of determining the number of events, it is further determined whether two or more events occur at the same time. If so, it is recorded as a continuous loss event and then enters the flight end determination process; if not, it directly enters the flight end determination process.
[0154] In the flight end judgment process, it is further determined whether the flight has ended. If not, the event occurrence counter is reset and the next cycle is performed. If the flight has ended, the continuity index of the Beidou navigation is calculated according to the formula: continuity = (1-continuity loss event / flight duration) × 100%.
[0155] For each operation stage, determine whether the continuity index of Beidou navigation meets the first continuity evaluation standard, and determine whether the SDA value meets the second continuity evaluation standard. If both are met, the Beidou navigation continuity meets the operation requirements.
[0156] Determining whether the value of SDA meets the second continuity evaluation criterion includes the following steps:
[0157] Extracting the operational phase information and ADS-B message data of the aircraft flight process; parsing the ADS-B message to obtain the SDA value; if the SDA value meets the preset SDA evaluation standard, the SDA value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard;
[0158] The preset SDA evaluation standard is obtained according to the mapping relationship between the SDA value and the continuity probability.
[0159] Furthermore, the first continuity assessment standard is the continuity assessment standard for different stages of establishment:
[0160] Route: Continuity probability ≥ 1-1×10 -4 / h
[0161] Terminal area: continuity probability ≥ 1-1×10 -4 / h
[0162] Non-precision approach: Continuity probability ≥ 1-1×10 -4 / h
[0163] Vertical guidance approach: continuity probability ≥ 1-8×10 -6 / 15s
[0164] Precision approach: continuity probability ≥ 1-8×10 -6 / 15s
[0165] Further, it is determined whether the value of SDA meets the second continuity evaluation standard, with the aim of also determining whether the system design reliability assurance (SDA) meets the requirements.
[0166] The mapping relationship between SDA and continuity probability is pre-established:
[0167] SDA=0: Continuity probability ≤ 1-1×10 -3 / h
[0168] SDA=1: Continuity probability>1-1×10 -3 / h
[0169] SDA=2: Continuity probability>1-1×10 -5 / h
[0170] SDA=3: Continuity probability>1-1×10 -7 / h
[0171] The mapping relationship between SDA and continuity probability is further refined according to the continuity evaluation criteria at different stages. Due to the existence of the mapping relationship between SDA and continuity probability, the SDA evaluation criteria at different operation stages are further derived, proving the rationality of the SDA evaluation criteria at different operation stages.
[0172] The SDA evaluation criteria for different operation stages are established as follows:
[0173] Route: SDA≥2
[0174] Terminal area: SDA ≥ 2
[0175] Non-precision approach: SDA ≥ 2
[0176] Vertical approach: SDA=3
[0177] Precision approach: SDA=3
[0178] If the calculated continuity index of Beidou navigation meets the continuity evaluation criteria of different stages, and the value of SDA meets the evaluation criteria, then the continuity of Beidou navigation meets the operational requirements, otherwise, it does not.
[0179] The Beidou navigation availability assessment module is used to calculate and assess the availability of Beidou navigation data in different aircraft operation phases. The Beidou navigation availability assessment method flow chart is as follows: Fig.13 As shown in the figure, a series of judgment processes before calculating availability are as follows Fig.14 shown.
[0180] The initial value of the duration of the availability loss event is set to 0. The operation phase information of the entire flight process of the aircraft, the horizontal protection limit (HAL) of each operation phase, the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites, the horizontal protection level (HPL), the planned interruption events and the positioning accuracy calculated by the Beidou navigation accuracy evaluation module are extracted from the database server. The event occurrence counter, the duration of event 1 (t1), the duration of event 2 (t2), the duration of event 3 (t3) and the duration of event 4 (t4) are introduced, and the initial values are all set to 0.
[0181] Determine whether the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites is less than 5 and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is increased by one and the t1 duration is updated, and then the HPL determination process is entered; if not, the HPL determination process is directly entered.
[0182] In the HPL determination process, it is further determined whether HPL is greater than HAL and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is increased by one and the t2 duration is updated, and then the positioning accuracy determination process is entered; if not, the positioning accuracy determination process is directly entered.
[0183] In the positioning accuracy determination process, it is further determined whether the positioning accuracy is greater than HAL and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is increased by one and the t3 duration is updated, and then the planned interruption event determination process is entered; if not, the planned interruption event determination process is directly entered.
[0184] In the planned interruption event determination process, it is further determined whether there is a planned interruption event. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one and the t4 duration is updated, and then the event occurrence quantity determination process is entered; if not, the event occurrence quantity determination process is directly entered.
[0185] In the process of determining the number of events, it is further determined whether two or more events occur at the same time. If so, the duration of this event is accumulated on the basis of the duration of the availability loss event. The duration of this event is the duration that satisfies any combination of events, and then the flight end determination process is entered; if not, the flight end determination process is directly entered.
[0186] In the flight end judgment process, the availability index of Beidou navigation is calculated according to the availability calculation formula: availability = (1-duration of availability loss event / (duration of availability loss event + flight time) × 100%; and whether the operation requirements are met is judged according to the preset availability standards.
[0187] In addition, the system also includes an ADS-B message navigation performance indicator monitoring module, which is used to monitor the integrity parameter indicators of the ADS-B message Beidou navigation availability assessment method, including navigation position accuracy category (NACp), navigation velocity accuracy category (NACv), navigation integrity category (NIC), system design assurance (SDA), and source integrity level (SIL) parameters.
[0188] The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and is not intended to limit the present invention. Any modifications, equivalent substitutions and improvements made within the spirit and principle of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Acquiring evaluation data, the evaluation data including ADS-B message data, GPS differential positioning data and Beidou satellite navigation data; According to the evaluation data, respectively, Beidou navigation accuracy evaluation, integrity evaluation, continuity evaluation and availability evaluation are performed to obtain evaluation results, wherein the evaluation results are obtained in stages according to the route, terminal area, non-precision approach, vertical guidance approach and precision approach; Among them, the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment, integrity assessment, continuity assessment and availability assessment adopt the following method: a first assessment value is obtained based on GPS differential positioning data and Beidou satellite navigation data; a second assessment value is calculated by the ADS-B message data, and the operation requirements are met only when the first assessment value meets the preset first assessment standard and the second assessment value meets the second assessment standard; Obtain the aircraft operation status and track based on the evaluation results; The Beidou navigation accuracy assessment includes the following steps: Determine whether the aircraft is in a vertical approach or precision approach phase. If so, calculate the horizontal and vertical positioning accuracy of Beidou navigation based on the GPS differential positioning data; if not, calculate the horizontal positioning accuracy of Beidou navigation based on the GPS differential positioning data; For each operation stage, the calculated positioning accuracy values are arranged from small to large. After sorting, the Nth number in the sequence is taken as the Beidou positioning accuracy under the corresponding confidence level. The value of N is determined by the total number and confidence level of the sorted data. For each operation stage, determine whether the Beidou positioning accuracy meets the first accuracy evaluation standard, and determine whether the NACp value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard. If both are met, the Beidou navigation accuracy meets the operation requirements; The first accuracy evaluation standard is the accuracy evaluation standard at different operation stages: Route: Positioning accuracy ≤3.7km; Terminal area: positioning accuracy ≤ 0.74km; Non-precision approach: positioning accuracy ≤ 220m; Vertical guidance approach: positioning accuracy ≤16m; Precision approach: positioning accuracy ≤16m; Determining whether the NACp value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard comprises the following steps: Extracting the operation phase information and ADS-B message data of the aircraft during the flight process; parsing the ADS-B message data to obtain the NACp value; if the NACp value meets the preset NACp evaluation standard, the NACp value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard; The preset NACp evaluation standard is obtained according to the mapping relationship between the NACp and the positioning accuracy; The corresponding relationship between positioning accuracy and NACp value includes: NACp=0: positioning accuracy ≥18.52km; NACp=1: positioning accuracy <18.52km; NACp=2: positioning accuracy <7.408km; NACp=3: positioning accuracy <3.704km; NACp=4: positioning accuracy <1852m; NACp=5: positioning accuracy <926m; NACp=6: positioning accuracy <555.6m; NACp=7: positioning accuracy <185.2m; NACp=8: positioning accuracy <92.6m; NACp=9: positioning accuracy <30m; NACp=10: positioning accuracy <10m; NACp=11: positioning accuracy <3m; Since the mapping relationship between NACp and positioning accuracy is established, the NACp evaluation criteria at different stages can be directly obtained: Route: NACp≥3 Terminal region: NACp≥6 Non-precision approach: NACp ≥ 7 Vertical guidance approach: NACp ≥ 10 Precision approach: NACp ≥ 10; The intelligent identification method of the aircraft operation phase includes: Extract the aircraft's current longitude, latitude, altitude, navigation frequency, longitude and latitude information of takeoff and landing airports, and initial approach positioning point information; Determine whether the aircraft is currently located at the initial approach fix point. If so, the aircraft is in the approach phase. Further determine whether the aircraft navigation frequency is consistent with the frequency of the DME navigation station at the landing airport. If they are consistent, the aircraft's current operation phase is a non-precision approach; if they are inconsistent, further determine whether the aircraft navigation frequency is consistent with the frequency of the ILS navigation station at the landing airport. If they are consistent, the aircraft's current operation phase is a precision approach; if they are inconsistent, the aircraft's current operation phase is a vertical guidance approach; when the aircraft's current position is not at the initial approach fix point, further determine whether the aircraft's horizontal range from the take-off and landing airport is less than the preset maximum distance and the vertical range is less than the preset maximum height. If so, the aircraft's current operation phase is the terminal area; if not, the aircraft's current operation phase is the route.
2. A Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The integrity assessment includes the following steps: The initial value of the integrity loss event is set to 0, and the operation phase information of the aircraft flight process, the horizontal protection limit value of each operation phase, the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites, the horizontal protection level, and the positioning accuracy calculated by the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment are extracted; Determine whether the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites is less than 5 and lasts for more than TTA time. If so, enter the positioning accuracy determination process; if not, enter the HPL determination process; In the HPL determination process, it is further determined whether the HPL is greater than the HAL and lasts for more than the TTA time. If so, the positioning accuracy determination process is entered; if not, the flight end determination process is entered; In the positioning accuracy determination process, it is further determined whether the positioning accuracy is greater than HAL. If it is greater, it is recorded as an integrity loss event and then enters the flight end determination process; if it is not greater, it directly enters the flight end determination process; In the flight end determination process, it is further determined whether the flight has ended. If not, the process returns to the visible satellite number determination process for the next cycle. If the flight has ended, the integrity index of the Beidou navigation is calculated according to the formula integrity = (1-integrity loss event / flight duration) × 100%. For each operation stage, determine whether the integrity index of Beidou navigation meets the first integrity assessment standard, and determine whether the value of NIC and the value of SIL meet the second integrity assessment standard. If both are met, the integrity of Beidou navigation meets the operation requirements.
3. A Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The determining whether the NIC value and the SIL value meet the second integrity assessment standard comprises the following steps: Extract the operational phase information and ADS-B message data of the aircraft flight process; parse the ADS-B message to obtain the NIC value and SIL value; If the NIC value and the SIL value meet the preset NIC and SIL evaluation criteria, then the NIC value and the SIL value meet the second integrity evaluation criteria; The preset NIC evaluation standard is obtained based on the mapping relationship between NIC and the horizontal capacity radius, and the preset SIL evaluation standard is obtained based on the mapping relationship between the SIL integrity probability under each horizontal capacity radius.
4. A Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The continuous assessment includes the following steps: The initial value of the continuity loss event is set to 0, the operation phase information of the entire flight process of the aircraft, the HAL of each operation phase, the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites, the HPL and the positioning accuracy calculated by the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment module are extracted, and the event occurrence counter is introduced; Determine whether the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites is less than 5 and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one, and then the HPL determination process is entered; if not, the HPL determination process is directly entered; In the horizontal protection level determination process, it is further determined whether the horizontal protection level is greater than the horizontal protection limit and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one, and then the positioning accuracy determination process is entered; if not, the positioning accuracy determination process is directly entered; In the positioning accuracy determination process, it is further determined whether the positioning accuracy is greater than the horizontal protection limit and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one, and then the event occurrence quantity determination process is entered; if not, the event occurrence quantity determination process is directly entered; In the event quantity determination process, it is further determined whether two or more events occur at the same time. If so, it is recorded as a continuous loss event and then enters the flight end determination process; if not, it directly enters the flight end determination process; In the flight end determination process, it is further determined whether the flight has ended. If not, the event occurrence counter is reset and the next cycle is performed. If the flight has ended, the continuity index of Beidou navigation is calculated according to the formula continuity = (1-continuity loss event / flight duration) × 100%. For each operation stage, determine whether the continuity index of Beidou navigation meets the first continuity evaluation standard, and determine whether the SDA value meets the second continuity evaluation standard. If both are met, the Beidou navigation continuity meets the operation requirements.
5. A Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: Determining whether the value of SDA meets the second continuity evaluation standard comprises the following steps: Extracting the operational phase information and ADS-B message data of the aircraft flight process; parsing the ADS-B message to obtain the SDA value; if the SDA value meets the preset SDA evaluation standard, the SDA value meets the second accuracy evaluation standard; The preset SDA evaluation standard is obtained according to the mapping relationship between the SDA value and the continuity probability.
6. A Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation method as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The usability evaluation includes the following steps: The initial value of the duration of the availability loss event is set to 0, and the operation phase information of the aircraft flight process, the horizontal protection limit of each operation phase, the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites, the horizontal protection level, the planned interruption event and the positioning accuracy calculated by the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment module are extracted. The event occurrence counter, the duration of event 1 t1, the duration of event 2 t2, the duration of event 3 t3 and the duration of event 4 are introduced. The event occurrence counter, t4, the initial values of t1, t2, t3 and t4 are all set to 0; Determine whether the number of visible Beidou navigation satellites is less than 5 and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented and the t1 duration is updated, and then the HPL determination process is entered; if not, the HPL determination process is directly entered; In the HPL determination process, it is further determined whether the HPL value is greater than the HAL value and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented and the t2 duration is updated, and then the positioning accuracy determination process is entered; if not, the positioning accuracy determination process is directly entered; In the positioning accuracy determination process, it is further determined whether the positioning accuracy is greater than the HAL value and lasts for more than 10 seconds. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented and the t3 duration is updated, and then the planned interruption event determination process is entered; if not, the planned interruption event determination process is directly entered; In the planned interruption event determination process, it is further determined whether there is a planned interruption event. If so, the event occurrence counter is incremented by one and the t4 duration is updated, and then the event occurrence quantity determination process is entered; if not, the event occurrence quantity determination process is directly entered; In the event quantity determination process, it is further determined whether two or more events occur at the same time. If so, the duration of this event is accumulated on the basis of the duration of the availability loss event. The duration of this event is the duration that satisfies any combination of events, and then the flight end determination process is entered; if not, the flight end determination process is directly entered; The availability index of Beidou navigation is calculated according to the availability calculation formula: availability = (1 – duration of availability loss event / (duration of availability loss event + flight time) × 100%; and whether the operation requirements are met is determined according to the preset availability standards.
7. A Beidou aviation service performance analysis and evaluation system, characterized in that: It includes input module, Beidou navigation accuracy assessment module, Beidou navigation integrity assessment module, Beidou navigation continuity assessment module, Beidou navigation availability assessment module and output module; An input module is used to obtain evaluation data, wherein the evaluation data includes ADS-B message data, GPS differential positioning data and Beidou satellite navigation data; A Beidou navigation accuracy evaluation module, used for evaluating the Beidou navigation accuracy according to the evaluation data; A Beidou navigation integrity assessment module, used for performing Beidou navigation integrity assessment based on the assessment data; A Beidou navigation continuity evaluation module, used for performing Beidou navigation continuity evaluation according to the evaluation data; A Beidou navigation availability evaluation module, used for performing Beidou navigation availability evaluation based on the evaluation data; Among them, the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment, integrity assessment, continuity assessment and availability assessment adopt the following methods: obtain a first assessment value through GPS differential positioning data and Beidou satellite navigation data; calculate a second assessment value through ADS-B message data, and only when the first assessment value meets the preset first assessment standard and the second assessment value meets the second assessment standard, the operation requirements are met; Wherein, the Beidou navigation accuracy assessment is implemented by using a Beidou aviation service performance analysis and assessment method as described in any one of claims 1 to 6; The output module is used to obtain the aircraft operation status and track according to the evaluation results; the evaluation results are obtained in stages according to the route, terminal area, non-precision approach, vertical guidance approach, and precision approach.
