Comprehensive evaluation method for severity of outburst inundation loss of silt dam system

Through the hierarchical analysis method and linear weighting method, a comprehensive evaluation model for the severity of submersion loss in the silt dam system was established, which solved the problem of neglecting downstream losses in the existing technology, and realized the systematic evaluation and classification of the risk of submersion dam system. Provides scientific risk management and risk removal and reinforcement support.

CN118941138AInactive Publication Date: 2024-11-12CHINA INST OF WATER RESOURCES & HYDROPOWER RES
View PDF 0 Cites 1 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410965782.6
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-18
Publication Date
2024-11-12
Estimated Expiration
Not applicable · inactive patent

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing technology lacks systematic considerations for downstream life, economic and social environmental losses in the risk assessment of silt dam collapse, and the risk model is mainly concentrated at the single dam level, and there is a lack of research on the overall risk of the dam system.

Method used

The comprehensive evaluation model of the severity of the severing flood loss of the silt dam system is established by using the hierarchical analysis method and linear weighting method, including life loss, social and environmental impact and economic loss models. Through normalization treatment and weight coefficient calculation, the silt dam system is constructed. Comprehensive evaluation criteria for the severity of flooding loss and risk classification criteria.

Benefits of technology

The systematic evaluation and risk classification of the risk of silt dam system collapse has been achieved, scientific risk ranking and risk removal and reinforcement technical support has been provided, and the ability to establish and manage the risk model of silt dam system collapse under extreme rainfall conditions has been improved.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118941138A_ABST
    Figure CN118941138A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses a comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of outburst submerging loss of a silt dam system, and belongs to the technical field of water and soil conservation silt dam engineering. Comprising the following steps: establishing a silt dam system outburst flood inundation loss calculation model, and calculating the model; a severity comprehensive evaluation function; determining a weight coefficient; and evaluating the outburst accident consequence of the silt dam system through a comprehensive severity evaluation standard of the outburst inundation loss of the silt dam system obtained by a linear weighted comprehensive evaluation method. The weight coefficient of each loss is calculated by using an analytic hierarchy process, and a comprehensive evaluation model for the severity of the outburst inundation loss of the silt dam system, which takes life loss as a first element, takes social environment influence as a second element and takes economic loss as the second element, is established based on a linear weighting method. And an evaluation standard of the comprehensive severity of the outburst submerging loss of the silt dam system is provided. And proposing a check dam system outburst risk grading standard and a risk prevention and control countermeasure, and systematically completing the establishment of a check dam system outburst risk model under the extreme rainfall condition.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of soil and water conservation silt dam engineering, and in particular to a comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of silt dam system breach and inundation losses. Background Art

[0002] In 1982, the risk concept of reservoir dams was first proposed by the United States Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), and a risk index was used to evaluate the risk level of reservoir dams. In 1991, the British Columbia Hydro (BC Hydro) of Canada first applied probabilistic risk analysis and dam checklists to the safety evaluation of reservoir dams. In 1994, the Australian Commission on Dams (ANCOLD) issued the "Australian Dam Risk Assessment Guidelines", which provided a conceptual basis for the risk evaluation of dams. Since then, Finland, Sweden and other countries have also carried out risk research on reservoir dams. With the country's attention to the safety of reservoir dams, the sustained and rapid development of my country's social economy, and the improvement of the public safety awareness of the people, my country's dam safety management has entered the third stage (starting in the 21st century), that is, the transformation from the concept of engineering safety management to the concept of engineering risk management, and the transition from the extensive management stage dominated by administrative management (i.e. the first stage, from the late 1940s to the late 1970s) and the engineering safety management stage dominated by institutional management (i.e. the second stage, from the late 1970s to the late 1990s). The core of the current stage is to consider the safety of the reservoir dam project and the public safety of the downstream people as an organic whole, form a system safety concept, and establish a comprehensive risk analysis system and model for the reservoir dam project risk and the risk of life loss, property loss, and social and environmental loss of the downstream people based on risk concepts and technologies. Many domestic scholars have done a lot of work on the research of reservoir dam risk analysis systems and models, and have systematically proposed a comprehensive evaluation method for engineering risks and downstream loss risks. In the risk analysis of reservoir dams, a variety of random factors are comprehensively considered, and a fuzzy risk analysis model for reservoir dam overtopping and collapse is established. The maximum entropy distribution is used as the distribution pattern of the highest water depth in front of the dam, and a dam overtopping risk calculation model for the combined action of floods and wind and waves is established, which improves the accuracy of dam overtopping risk calculation. Considering the uncertainty factors of extreme inflow floods and flood discharge, a risk model for outflow reservoir overtopping and collapse is established and corresponding risk analysis software is developed to guide the analysis of overtopping risks. Taking into account the impact of regional, time-varying and social characteristics on dam risk, an adaptive evaluation model for the comprehensive evaluation standard of dam risk was initially established, providing guidance for the formulation of risk standards. Combining various engineering defects and management defects that may occur in different dam types, a dam vulnerability calculation model was constructed to achieve the calculation and analysis of dam risk. A PMD assessment model was initially established to provide a theoretical basis and technical support for the risk analysis and prevention and control of cascade hydropower hubs. There are relatively few studies on the risk of silt dams. Most of the existing studies are to analyze the causes of silt dam failure and establish a silt dam flood control dam failure risk assessment and real-time early warning model covering hydrological risks and engineering risks. However, the determination of the risk level of this model does not take into account the disaster losses of dam failure, but only focuses on the risk of silt dam engineering failure.

[0003] At present, some technical personnel in this field have established a risk assessment model for dam breach in Gansu Province, which covers hydrological risk, operation risk, management risk and engineering risk. This model can be applied to the risk assessment of dam breach in flood season, but this model does not involve the risk of loss of life, economy and social environment in the downstream impact area. In the relevant literature, a safety assessment system for dam breach in small watersheds based on the TOPSIS method has been established, but it does not involve the consideration of downstream losses. Some scholars have established a comprehensive risk assessment model for dam breach using the TOPSIS method to achieve multi-objective risk ranking of dam breach. This model considers the risk of economic loss caused by breach to the downstream, but does not involve loss of life and social environment. In this technical field, a method has been proposed to use the product of flood loss and flood probability as the risk value to divide the risk level and evaluate the flood control risk of each dam in the basin, but this method does not take into account the loss of social impact, and the concept of risk is still at the level of a single dam, not the total risk at the level of the dam system. There are also related technologies that have established a risk level analysis model for silt dams based on the identification of risk factors for silt dams, including three levels of current risk, management risk, and accident consequences, with nine indicators. Although this model takes into account the loss of life and economic losses in the downstream, it does not involve the social and environmental losses. In summary, in recent years, my country has made rapid progress in the research of risk models for reservoir dams, not only the risk of a single dam, but also the risk of cascade reservoirs. However, most of the risk models for silt dams are based on the risk concept of a single dam, and the risk value of a single dam is calculated and analyzed. There is a lack of research on the overall risk of the dam system. At the same time, many silt dam risk models lack consideration of downstream losses, which is an indispensable part of systematic risk research. Summary of the invention

[0004] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system, and to establish a comprehensive evaluation model for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system by using the analytic hierarchy process and the linear weighted method, so as to achieve a comprehensive evaluation of the severity of all losses and propose a comprehensive evaluation standard for their severity. On the basis of the probability of collapse risk of a silt dam system and the comprehensive severity evaluation standard for collapse and flooding losses, a silt dam system collapse risk classification standard is proposed, and the establishment of a silt dam system collapse risk model under extreme rainfall conditions is systematically completed.

[0005] To achieve the above-mentioned purpose, the present invention provides a comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system, comprising the following steps.

[0006] S1. Establish a calculation model for flood losses caused by dam breach, including a life loss model, a social and environmental impact model, and an economic loss model, and calculate the life loss model, social and environmental impact model, and economic loss model respectively;

[0007] S2, comprehensive evaluation function of severity, which uses different normalized function models to non-dimensionalize the loss of life, economic loss, and social environmental impact, and obtains the severity coefficient of loss of life S1, the severity coefficient of economic loss S2, and the severity coefficient of social environmental impact S3, combined with the comprehensive evaluation function S of the severity of the flooding loss caused by the collapse of the silt dam system;

[0008] S3. Determination of weight coefficients: By establishing a hierarchical analysis structure, the comprehensive evaluation event of the severity of the dam burst and flooding losses is decomposed into an analysis model with a hierarchical structure, a judgment matrix is ​​constructed, the weight value is calculated, and its consistency is tested;

[0009] S4. The comprehensive severity evaluation standard of silt dam breach and inundation losses is obtained through the linear weighted comprehensive evaluation method, and the consequences of silt dam breach accidents are evaluated according to the comprehensive severity function S.

[0010] Preferably, in step S1, the influencing factors in the life loss model include the risk population P AR , Severity of flood outburst D , alarm time W T and the degree of understanding of the severity of outburst floods by the population at risk D .

[0011] The loss of life is calculated as follows:

[0012] L OL =P AR ×f×a

[0013] Among them, P AR is the risk population, f is the risk population mortality rate, and a is the correction coefficient for the mortality rate of the risk population due to dam burst flood.

[0014] Preferably, in step S1, the influencing factors in the economic loss model include the unit value W i , loss rate β i and flooded area A i ;

[0015] The calculation formula for the total economic losses in the flood-inundated area is as follows:

[0016]

[0017] Where, L E is the total economic loss caused by outburst flood, 10,000 yuan; Δβ is the growth rate of outburst flood loss, which is 3% for the silt dam system; n is the number of years between the year when the outburst flood occurred and the statistical base year, a.

[0018] Preferably, the calculation formula of social impact is as follows:

[0019]

[0020] I SE The social environmental impact index ranges from 1 to 50,000, where C1 is the risk population coefficient; C2 is the town scale coefficient; C3 is the technical facility importance coefficient; C4 is the cultural relics and historical sites level coefficient; C5 is the river morphology destruction degree coefficient; C6 is the animal and plant habitat protection level coefficient; C7 is the natural landscape level coefficient; C8 is the potential polluting enterprise scale coefficient; and C9 is the dam body damage degree coefficient.

[0021] Preferably, in step S2, the calculation formula of the comprehensive evaluation function S of the severity of the flooding loss caused by the collapse of the silt dam system is as follows:

[0022]

[0023] In the formula, q1 is the weight coefficient of life loss; q2 is the weight coefficient of economic loss; q3 is the weight coefficient of social and environmental impact.

[0024] Preferably, in step S3, the hierarchical analysis structure is established as follows:

[0025] The comprehensive evaluation event of the severity of the silt dam burst and inundation losses is decomposed into an analysis model with a hierarchical structure, in which the comprehensive evaluation function S of the severity of the silt dam burst and inundation losses is the target layer, and the severity coefficient S1 of the loss of life, the severity coefficient S2 of the economic loss, and the severity coefficient S3 of the social and environmental impact are the quasi-measurement layers.

[0026] Preferably, in step S3, the expression for constructing the judgment matrix is ​​as follows:

[0027]

[0028] a ij is the importance of element i relative to j; when i=j, it means that the importance of i relative to itself is 1; a ji =1 / a ij .

[0029] Therefore, the present invention adopts a comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of silt dam breach and flooding losses of the above structure, which has the following beneficial effects:

[0030] The present invention uses the analytic hierarchy process to calculate the weight coefficients of various losses, and based on the linear weighted method, establishes a comprehensive evaluation model for the severity of silt dam burst and inundation losses, with life loss as the first factor, social and environmental impact as the second factor, and economic loss as the second factor, and proposes an evaluation standard for the comprehensive severity of silt dam burst and inundation losses. The silt dam burst risk classification standard and risk prevention and control measures are proposed, and the establishment of a silt dam burst risk model under extreme rainfall conditions is systematically completed. The risk model can realize the risk analysis and evaluation of the silt dam system, and can also guide the risk ranking of different dam systems, providing technical support for the scientific assessment of the risk removal and reinforcement of the silt dam system.

[0031] The technical solution of the present invention is further described in detail below through the accompanying drawings and embodiments. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0032] Figure 1 A technical roadmap of a method for calculating flood losses caused by a silt dam burst flood of the present invention;

[0033] Figure 2 The present invention is a hierarchical structure diagram of a comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0034] The technical solution of the present invention is further described below through the accompanying drawings and embodiments.

[0035] Unless otherwise defined, the technical terms or scientific terms used in the present invention should be understood by people with ordinary skills in the field to which the present invention belongs. The words "first", "second" and similar words used in the present invention do not indicate any order, quantity or importance, but are only used to distinguish different components. "Include" or "comprise" and similar words mean that the elements or objects appearing before the word include the elements or objects listed after the word and their equivalents, without excluding other elements or objects. "Connect" or "connected" and similar words are not limited to physical or mechanical connections, but may include electrical connections, whether direct or indirect. "Up", "down", "left", "right" and the like are only used to indicate relative positional relationships. When the absolute position of the described object changes, the relative positional relationship may also change accordingly.

[0036] Example

[0037] like Figure 1-2 As shown, the present invention provides a comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system, comprising the following steps.

[0038] S1. Establish a calculation model for flood losses caused by dam breach, including a life loss model, a social and environmental impact model, and an economic loss model, and calculate the life loss model, social and environmental impact model, and economic loss model respectively;

[0039] S2, comprehensive evaluation function of severity, which uses different normalized function models to non-dimensionalize the loss of life, economic loss, and social environmental impact, and obtains the severity coefficient of loss of life S1, the severity coefficient of economic loss S2, and the severity coefficient of social environmental impact S3, combined with the comprehensive evaluation function S of the severity of the flooding loss caused by the collapse of the silt dam system;

[0040] S3. Determination of weight coefficients: By establishing a hierarchical analysis structure, the comprehensive evaluation event of the severity of the dam burst and flooding losses is decomposed into an analysis model with a hierarchical structure, a judgment matrix is ​​constructed, the weight value is calculated, and its consistency is tested;

[0041] S4. The comprehensive severity evaluation standard of silt dam breach and inundation losses is obtained through the linear weighted comprehensive evaluation method, and the consequences of silt dam breach accidents are evaluated according to the comprehensive severity function S.

[0042] In step S1, the influencing factors in the life loss model are the risk population P AR , Severity of flood outburst D , alarm time W T and the degree of understanding of the severity of outburst floods by the population at risk D .

[0043] The loss of life is calculated as follows:

[0044] L OL =P AR ×f×a

[0045] Among them, P AR is the risk population, f is the risk population mortality rate, and a is the correction coefficient for the mortality rate of the risk population due to dam burst flood.

[0046] In step S1, the influencing factors in the economic loss model include the unit value W i , loss rate β i and flooded area A i ;

[0047] The calculation formula for the total economic losses in the flood-inundated area is as follows:

[0048]

[0049] Where, L Eis the total economic loss caused by outburst flood, 10,000 yuan; Δβ is the growth rate of outburst flood loss, which is 3% for the silt dam system; n is the number of years between the year when the outburst flood occurred and the statistical base year, a.

[0050] The calculation formula for social impact is as follows:

[0051]

[0052] I SE The social environmental impact index ranges from 1 to 50,000, where C1 is the risk population coefficient; C2 is the town scale coefficient; C3 is the technical facility importance coefficient; C4 is the cultural relics and historical sites level coefficient; C5 is the river morphology destruction degree coefficient; C6 is the animal and plant habitat protection level coefficient; C7 is the natural landscape level coefficient; C8 is the potential polluting enterprise scale coefficient; and C9 is the dam body damage degree coefficient.

[0053] In step S2, since the units of life loss, economic loss and social environmental impact in the collapse and inundation losses of the silt dam system are different, it is impossible to directly comprehensively consider the three parts of the loss, so it is considered to process them dimensionlessly, that is, to use the normalization method to convert data with different scales and dimensions into a unified scale through a specific mathematical method, so as to facilitate the comprehensive impact of different indicators.

[0054] The calculation formula of the comprehensive evaluation function S of the severity of the flooding loss of the silt dam system is as follows:

[0055]

[0056] In the formula, q1 is the weight coefficient of life loss; q2 is the weight coefficient of economic loss; q3 is the weight coefficient of social and environmental impact.

[0057] In step S3, currently, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is widely used in the planning, design, construction, operation and management of reservoir dams, especially in safety evaluation and risk assessment. This method can help improve the scientificity and accuracy of decision-making and provide guarantees for the sustainable development and safe operation of reservoir dams. The core of the AHP is to structure and digitize the influencing factors of decision-making events based on the knowledge, experience and judgment of the expert and scholar group, so as to help people conduct systematic analysis and decision-making when facing complex decision-making problems. It is a quantitative analysis method commonly used in decision analysis, with high credibility and small error. Therefore, this study will use the AHP to determine the weight coefficients of life loss, economic loss and social environmental impact.

[0058] The hierarchical analysis structure is established as follows:

[0059] The comprehensive evaluation event of the severity of the silt dam burst and inundation losses is decomposed into an analysis model with a hierarchical structure, in which the comprehensive evaluation function S of the severity of the silt dam burst and inundation losses is the target layer, and the severity coefficient S1 of the loss of life, the severity coefficient S2 of the economic loss, and the severity coefficient S3 of the social and environmental impact are the quasi-measurement layers.

[0060] In step S3, the hierarchical analysis method usually uses the 1-9 scale method to form a judgment matrix, that is, two factors are compared with each other to avoid the difficulty caused by comparing all factors together, so as to improve accuracy. The scales 1, 3, 5, 7, and 9 respectively represent the importance of one factor to another factor, which is equal, slightly, obviously, strongly, and extremely important. 2, 4, 6, and 8 respectively represent the median of the above adjacent degrees. The two elements are reversely compared to the inverse of the original scale. The expression for constructing the judgment matrix is ​​as follows:

[0061]

[0062] a ij is the importance of element i relative to j; when i=j, it means that the importance of i relative to itself is 1; a ji =1 / a ij .

[0063] According to the known judgment matrix, the square root method is used to obtain the eigenvector and the maximum eigenroot, and the weight value of each indicator is calculated to reflect the importance of each indicator in decision-making.

[0064] Check the consistency of the judgment matrix to ensure that the comparison relationship between the indicators is reasonable and reliable, and avoid logical errors. The calculation results of the hierarchical analysis method show that the maximum characteristic root is 3.0. According to the RI table, the corresponding RI value is 0.525, so CR = CI / RI = 0.0 < 0.1, which passes the one-time test. In summary, the hierarchical analysis method is used to reasonably derive the weight coefficients of the severity coefficient of life loss S1, the severity coefficient of economic loss S2, and the severity coefficient of social and environmental impact S3. The weight coefficients are 0.797, 0.089, and 0.114 respectively. This group of weight coefficients is more in line with my country's current basic national conditions. Therefore, the comprehensive evaluation function S of the severity of the collapse and flooding losses of the silt dam system can be found in the following formula

[0065]

[0066] Therefore, the present invention adopts the above-mentioned comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of silt dam system breach and inundation losses, uses the analytic hierarchy process to calculate the weight coefficients of various losses, and establishes a comprehensive evaluation model for the severity of silt dam system breach and inundation losses based on the linear weighted method, with life loss as the first factor, social environmental impact as the second factor, and economic loss as the second factor, and proposes an evaluation standard for the comprehensive severity of silt dam system breach and inundation losses. A silt dam system breach risk classification standard and risk prevention and control measures are proposed, and the establishment of a silt dam system breach risk model under extreme rainfall conditions is systematically completed. This risk model can realize the risk analysis and evaluation of silt dam systems, and can also guide the risk ranking work of different dam systems, providing technical support for the scientific assessment of silt dam system risk removal and reinforcement work.

[0067] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solution of the present invention rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the preferred embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that they can still modify or replace the technical solution of the present invention with equivalents, and these modifications or equivalent replacements cannot cause the modified technical solution to deviate from the spirit and scope of the technical solution of the present invention.

Claims

1. A comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system, characterized in that: The following steps are included. S1. Establish a calculation model for flood losses caused by dam breach, including a life loss model, a social and environmental impact model, and an economic loss model, and calculate the life loss model, social and environmental impact model, and economic loss model respectively; S2, comprehensive evaluation function of severity, which uses different normalized function models to non-dimensionalize the loss of life, economic loss, and social environmental impact, and obtains the severity coefficient of loss of life S1, the severity coefficient of economic loss S2, and the severity coefficient of social environmental impact S3, combined with the comprehensive evaluation function S of the severity of the flooding loss caused by the collapse of the silt dam system; S3. Determination of weight coefficients: By establishing a hierarchical analysis structure, the comprehensive evaluation event of the severity of the dam burst and flooding losses is decomposed into an analysis model with a hierarchical structure, a judgment matrix is ​​constructed, the weight value is calculated, and its consistency is tested; S4. The comprehensive severity evaluation standard of silt dam breach and inundation losses is obtained through the linear weighted comprehensive evaluation method, and the consequences of silt dam breach accidents are evaluated according to the comprehensive severity function S.

2. The comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system according to claim 1 is characterized by: In step S1, the influencing factors in the life loss model are the risk population P AR , Severity of flood outburst D , alarm time W T and the degree of understanding of the severity of outburst floods by the population at risk D ; The loss of life is calculated as follows: L OL =P AR ×f×a Among them, P AR is the risk population, f is the risk population mortality rate, and a is the correction coefficient for the mortality rate of the risk population due to dam burst flood.

3. The comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system according to claim 1 is characterized by: In step S1, the influencing factors in the economic loss model include the unit value W i , loss rate β i and flooded area A i ; The calculation formula for the total economic losses in the flood-inundated area is as follows: Where, L E is the total economic loss caused by outburst flood, 10,000 yuan; Δβ is the growth rate of outburst flood loss, which is 3% for the silt dam system; n is the number of years between the year when the outburst flood occurred and the statistical base year, a.

4. The comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system according to claim 1 is characterized by: The calculation formula for social impact is as follows: I SE The social environmental impact index ranges from 1 to 50,000, where C1 is the risk population coefficient; C2 is the town scale coefficient; C3 is the technical facility importance coefficient; C4 is the cultural relics and historical sites level coefficient; C5 is the river morphology destruction degree coefficient; C6 is the animal and plant habitat protection level coefficient; C7 is the natural landscape level coefficient; C8 is the potential polluting enterprise scale coefficient; and C9 is the dam body damage degree coefficient.

5. The comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system according to claim 1 is characterized by: In step S2, the calculation formula of the comprehensive evaluation function S of the severity of the flooding loss caused by the collapse of the silt dam system is as follows: In the formula, q1 is the weight coefficient of life loss; q2 is the weight coefficient of economic loss; q3 is the weight coefficient of social and environmental impact.

6. The comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system according to claim 1 is characterized by: In step S3, the hierarchical analysis structure is established as follows: The comprehensive evaluation event of the severity of the silt dam burst and inundation losses is decomposed into an analysis model with a hierarchical structure, in which the comprehensive evaluation function S of the severity of the silt dam burst and inundation losses is the target layer, and the severity coefficient S1 of the loss of life, the severity coefficient S2 of the economic loss, and the severity coefficient S3 of the social and environmental impact are the quasi-measurement layers.

7. The comprehensive evaluation method for the severity of flooding losses caused by the collapse of a silt dam system according to claim 1 is characterized by: In step S3, the expression for constructing the judgment matrix is ​​as follows: a ij is the importance of element i relative to j; when i=j, it means that the importance of i relative to itself is 1; a ji =1 / a ij .

Citation Information

Cited By

  • Evaluation method for emergency decision-making effect of dam break emergencies based on multi-element coupling

    CN119692662A