Systematic intrinsic safety assessment method for electrolytic hydrogen production process
By establishing an intrinsic safety evaluation framework and using industrial software to simulate the electrolytic water process and calculating the intrinsic safety index, the safety assessment problem in the initial design stage of the electrolytic water hydrogen production process was solved, and systematic intrinsic safety assessment and safety improvement were achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410887180.3
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-03
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-19
AI Technical Summary
The existing safety evaluation methods are difficult to conduct systematic intrinsic safety analysis in the early design stage of new energy devices, especially the lack of effective safety evaluation methods for the electrolytic water hydrogen production process.
Using the intrinsic safety index method summarized by Sunhwa Park et al., combined with the intrinsic safety evaluation method of chemical engineering, an intrinsic safety evaluation framework was established in five aspects: physics and chemistry, process, reaction, activity and consequences. The electrolytic water process was simulated through industrial software, and multi-parameter super The cubic sampling method calculates the intrinsic safety index and provides a systematic intrinsic safety assessment.
A systematic intrinsic safety assessment of the electrolytic water process is realized, and reference data for design and parameter settings is provided, which helps improve the safety of the electrolytic system, makes up for the current situation of missing engineering data, and ensures the reliability and safety of new energy devices. sex.
Smart Images

Figure CN118982220A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the technical field of process safety assessment for hydrogen production by electrolysis. Specifically, the present invention relates to a systematic intrinsic safety assessment method for a hydrogen production by electrolysis process. Background Art
[0002] As the global demand for sustainable development and energy transformation increases, the development and application of new energy technologies continue to advance. However, there are also some safety challenges in the field of new energy, such as fire, explosion, radioactive radiation, etc. Therefore, it is crucial to study the intrinsic safety of new energy to ensure its sustainable, safe and reliable application. At present, the companies entering this link have a wide range of industry backgrounds, including electrolyzer-related companies, energy and power companies, chemical companies, companies in the renewable energy industry chain, and even steel, fuel cells, and construction companies. To improve the intrinsic safety of electrolysis devices built by companies in all walks of life, all fields must consciously realize the intrinsic safety design and apply it together with reliable safety assessment tools to help engineers discover potential dangers or risks and avoid unsafe designs.
[0003] At present, there are many safety evaluation methods, most of which are suitable for the later design stage when the equipment, chemistry and process conditions are known. The Dow Fire and Explosion Index, the Mond Index Method and the Hazard and Operability Analysis (HAZOP) are several common analysis methods in the process industry. However, since the above methods require very small details about the plant operating conditions and controls, they are not suitable for safety analysis of new device design and initial operation. The Prototype Intrinsic Safety Index (PIIS) is also a good safety analysis method, focusing on the sequence of raw materials and reaction steps, but this method focuses on the reaction and cannot analyze the safety of the entire process device. The intrinsic safety of the system is not only affected by the safety of the reaction, but also not suitable for the systematic safety analysis of new energy devices. The intrinsic safety index evaluation method (ISI) requires a small amount of data and can consider both the safety of chemicals and equipment. It is very suitable for safety analysis in the early design stage of the process. However, while it has a wide applicability, it cannot be specifically combined with the water electrolysis hydrogen production process for analysis. In this regard, how to apply the intrinsic safety index evaluation method to the water electrolysis hydrogen production process to make an accurate assessment of its systematic intrinsic safety in the early design stage has become a new technical problem raised in this technical field. Summary of the invention
[0004] The purpose of the present invention is to solve the above-mentioned problems and provide a systematic intrinsic safety assessment method for the electrolysis hydrogen production process. The safety indicators used in the present invention are a summary of various intrinsic safety methods and related intrinsic safety indexes made by Sunhwa Park et al. in 2020. Indicators suitable for electrolysis systems are selected, and an intrinsic safety assessment method corresponding to different operating conditions of water electrolysis hydrogen production systems is proposed.
[0005] The present invention is based on experimental research related to electrolytic materials and safety experimental research involving hydrogen combustion and explosion overpressure, analyzes the energy conversion, reaction and transfer processes of the electrolytic hydrogen production system, reviews the intrinsic safety evaluation index considered in the chemical intrinsic safety evaluation method, combines dozens of intrinsic safety evaluation indexes, selects indicators suitable for the electrolytic system, and gives the calculation method between each index and the operating parameters. Finally, an intrinsic safety assessment method corresponding to different operating conditions of the water electrolysis hydrogen production system is proposed. This method can evaluate the intrinsic safety factor of the electrolytic system under different operating parameters and equipment parameters.
[0006] The technical problem to be solved by the present invention is achieved by adopting the following technical solution: A systematic intrinsic safety assessment method for an electrolytic hydrogen production process comprises the following steps:
[0007] S1. Establish the corresponding analysis table between the intrinsic safety index structure and the electrolytic hydrogen production process
[0008] According to the intrinsic safety evaluation indexes involved in the six aspects of material physicochemical properties (physicochemical properties), process conditions (process characteristics), reaction parameters (reaction characteristics), equipment parameters (equipment characteristics), activity types (activity characteristics), and consequences (consequence characteristics) in the existing chemical intrinsic safety evaluation methods, the intrinsic safety evaluation index related to the electrolysis of water reaction is selected to establish an intrinsic safety evaluation framework for the six aspects of physicochemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index, and equipment intrinsic safety index;
[0009] S2. Performing process quantification or calculation quantification on the intrinsic safety evaluation index;
[0010] The process quantification of the intrinsic safety evaluation index establishes corresponding quantitative standards according to the nature of the intrinsic safety evaluation index, and the calculation quantification of the intrinsic safety evaluation index is achieved by establishing a corresponding model calculation formula or calculation method;
[0011] S3. Establishing the process model of water electrolysis:
[0012] According to the process data of hydrogen production by electrolysis, the chemical equation of the chemical reaction mechanism of hydrogen production by electrolysis of water is input into the industrial software to form the process model of the water electrolysis process, i.e. the reactor; the industrial software is Aspen custom modeler and Aspen plus;
[0013] S4. Under normal operating conditions, for the design variables of intrinsic safety parameters such as pressure, temperature, inlet and outlet water flow, input power, and number of series and parallel connections, the operating range values of the intrinsic safety parameters obtained by sampling the Sobol sequence of super Latin cube sampling (the threshold range calculated by the process model) are input into the process model of the water electrolysis process to calculate the intrinsic safety index of the water electrolysis process under a stable state, and process quantification or calculation quantification is performed respectively according to step S2, and finally the corresponding quantitative values of the various intrinsic safety indexes are determined respectively, that is, the safety quantification value threshold range of various intrinsic safety evaluation indexes of the water electrolysis process under a stable state is obtained; the intrinsic safety parameters include process parameters, operating parameters, equipment parameters and material property parameters (physical parameters);
[0014] S5. Setting different value assignment standards according to whether various intrinsic safety evaluation indexes are within the safety quantitative value threshold range determined in step S4;
[0015] This will enable quantification of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
[0016] Preferably, according to the present invention, step S6 is also included: inputting the same intrinsic safety parameters, and evaluating the intrinsic safety of process models of different water electrolysis processes according to the size of the quantitative values of one or more of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
[0017] Preferably, according to the present invention, in step S6, the specific method for evaluating the intrinsic safety of process models of different water electrolysis processes is:
[0018] The quantitative values of one or more of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index of process models of different water electrolysis processes are compared, and the process model with the smaller quantitative value is selected.
[0019] Preferably, according to the present invention, step S7 is also included: for different intrinsic safety parameters, the intrinsic safety level of the process model of the same water electrolysis process is evaluated using quantitative values of one or more of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
[0020] Preferably, according to the present invention, in step S7, the intrinsic safety level classification method is: different safety level judgment standards are set based on the degree of safety impact based on the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
[0021] Preferably, according to the present invention, the specific method for process quantification or calculation quantification of the intrinsic safety evaluation index intrinsic safety index within the intrinsic safety evaluation framework in step S2 is shown in Table 1:
[0022] Table 1 Correspondence analysis table between intrinsic safety index structure and electrolytic hydrogen production process
[0023]
[0024]
[0025]
[0026]
[0027]
[0028]
[0029] In the table, BLEVE means boiling liquid expanding steam explosion. The judgment criteria can be set by the user for complex or simple structures.
[0030] According to the preferred embodiment of the present invention, in Table 1,
[0031] 1) The calculation formula for reaction heat includes:
[0032]
[0033]
[0034]
[0035] In formula (1) to formula (3), V ocv is the open circuit voltage, Vcell is the actual output voltage of the battery, Vact is the activation overvoltage, Vohm is the ohmic overvoltage, Vcon is the concentration difference overvoltage, V TNVis the thermoneutral voltage, ΔG is the Gibbs free energy change, F is the Faraday constant, R is the gas constant, T is the temperature, and P H2 , P O2 , P H2O are the pressures of hydrogen, oxygen and water vapor respectively, and n represents the number of electrons transmitted during the reaction process, where n is 4 for the anode oxygen evolution reaction and 2 for the cathode hydrogen evolution reaction;
[0036] I Reaction Heat=Max(0,4*(V cell -V TNV ) / V cell )(4)
[0037] In formula (4), I Reaction Heat represents the intrinsic safety index of reaction heat;
[0038] 2) The calculation formula of laminar burning velocity is:
[0039]
[0040] In formula (5), a is -2.27×10 -10 , b is 2.05×10 -8 , c is 4.00×10 -6 , d is -6.64×10 -4 , e is 3.06×10 -2 , f is -4.33; V Laminarburning is the laminar combustion velocity, is the hydrogen concentration;
[0041]
[0042] In formula (6), I Flammability represents the intrinsic safety index of combustion, V Laminarburning,min is the minimum value of laminar combustion velocity, specifically 0m / s, V Laminarburning,max is the maximum value of laminar combustion velocity, specifically 3m / s;
[0043] 3) The calculation formula of overpressure value is:
[0044] The release rate of the liquid is:
[0045]
[0046] In formula (7), m L is the release rate of the liquid, kg / s; C D is the flow coefficient of the fluid; A h is the area of the leakage hole, m 2 ; ρ is the density of the material in the pipe, kg / m 3; Δp is the pressure difference between the inside and outside of the tube, Pa;
[0047] For the leakage of gas phase substances, if the pressure ratio between the inside and outside of the equipment is between 0.5 and 0.9, the leakage is in a blocked condition, and vice versa. The leakage rate of gas phase substances is calculated by the following formula:
[0048] Under blocking conditions, the gas release rate is:
[0049]
[0050] In formula (8), m V is the gas release rate, kg / s; γ is the specific heat ratio; p is the actual pressure of the substance in the tube, Pa;
[0051] Under non-blocking conditions, the gas release rate is:
[0052]
[0053] In formula (9), p amb is the ambient pressure, Pa;
[0054] The initial release amount when the equipment is damaged is calculated by formulas (7)-(9);
[0055] Then the combustible mass of the released combustible vapor cloud needs to be estimated using the following formula:
[0056]
[0057] In formula (10), m f represents the combustible mass of the steam cloud, kg; m represents the mass of the steam cloud released by the equipment, kg; c o Represents the actual concentration of the substance in the vapor cloud; c LFL Represents the lower explosion limit of the leaked substance, hydrogen;
[0058] The explosion overpressure also depends on the energy released by the explosion and the scaling distance. The two parameters are calculated by referring to the TNT equivalent method. The calculation formula is as follows:
[0059]
[0060]
[0061] In formulas (11)-(12), m TNT Represents the equivalent TNT mass of the substance, kg; η ex represents the explosion efficiency coefficient; m f Represents the combustible mass of the vapor cloud, kg; H V Represents the combustion energy of the leaked material, J / g; H V,TNTrepresents the combustion energy of TNT, J / g; z represents the actual distance, the maximum impact distance that can cause casualties and property losses, m; represents the scaling distance, m;
[0062] Finally, the explosion overpressure at different locations is estimated by the nonlinear regression equation fitted by the experiment. The specific calculation equation is as follows:
[0063]
[0064] In formula (13), p ovr represents explosion overpressure, kPa; a1, b1, c1 all represent overpressure constants;
[0065]
[0066] In formula (14), I Explosion represents the intrinsic safety index of explosion, p ovr,min is the minimum value of explosion overpressure, specifically 0Pa, p ovr,max is the maximum value of laminar combustion velocity, specifically 700Pa;
[0067] 4) Temperature: the temperature of the electrolytic cell;
[0068]
[0069] In formula (15), I Temperature represents the intrinsic safety index of temperature, Tcell represents the operating temperature of a single electrolytic cell, and T cell,min is the minimum value of the electrolytic cell temperature, the ambient temperature, specifically 35°C, T cell,min is the maximum value of the electrolytic cell temperature, specifically 100°C;
[0070] 5) Operating pressure: electrolysis operating pressure;
[0071]
[0072] In formula (16), IPressure represents the intrinsic safety index of pressure, p Cathode is cathode operating pressure, Pa; p atm is the ambient pressure, Pa; p Cathode,max is the maximum cathode operating pressure, Pa.
[0073] According to the preferred embodiment of the present invention, in Table 1, the flow rate threshold range is:
[0074] Normal pressure: 1-10m / s; high pressure: 10-30m / s; near the compressor: 30-60m / s. High pressure is relative to normal pressure, and the specific standard can be set by yourself.
[0075] Preferably, according to the present invention, the intrinsic safety evaluation index in the existing chemical intrinsic safety evaluation method in step S1 is specifically:
[0076] Chemical and physical properties of materials including flammability, explosiveness, toxicity, corrosiveness, volatility, material state, volume change, solubility, ability to precipitate, density difference, viscosity, relative density, molecular weight, hazardous substances and impurities;
[0077] Process conditions include temperature, pressure, output, inventory, process mode, flow rate, concentration, liquid level, pH, fluidity, and unit operation type;
[0078] Reaction parameters include chemical interactions, heat of primary reaction, heat of secondary reaction, reaction type, and runaway type;
[0079] Equipment parameters include outside the limit, inside the limit, structure, layout, complexity, equipment type, safety devices and emission rate of the equipment;
[0080] Activity types include transport, emission or combustion, maintenance, and other;
[0081] Consequences include fireballs, jet fires, pool fires, steam cloud explosions, boiling liquid expanding steam cloud explosions, confinement, and dispersion of toxic chemicals.
[0082] Compared with the prior art, the beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: according to the existing chemical intrinsic safety evaluation method, the present invention selects the intrinsic safety evaluation index related to the electrolysis reaction, establishes an intrinsic safety evaluation framework for six aspects of physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index, and performs process quantification or calculation quantification on the intrinsic safety evaluation index within the intrinsic safety evaluation framework; through process simulation software, the electrolysis hydrogen production process is reproduced, and through the multi-parameter hypercube sampling method, the reasonable range of the intrinsic safety evaluation index within the intrinsic safety evaluation framework of the electrolysis process under various common working conditions is calculated, and finally a set of intrinsic safety grading methods for the electrolysis process is obtained, which is used to evaluate the intrinsic safety factor of the electrolysis system under different operating parameters and equipment parameters. According to the quantitative values of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index, reference data is provided for the design and parameter setting of the electrolysis hydrogen production process, so as to facilitate the provision of reasonable improvement suggestions.
[0083] In the early stage of the establishment of new energy sources such as electrolysis of water, there is a lack of inherent safety research and application practice. By reviewing the progress of inherent safety research and using numerical modeling methods, we have made up for the current situation of missing engineering data while ensuring the validity of data as much as possible.
[0084] In terms of inherent safety index calculation, this paper comprehensively reviews the current status of research on inherent safety assessment methods, draws on the application experience of inherent safety evaluation methods in the chemical industry, and transfers and applies them to new energy devices. From six aspects, namely physical and chemical inherent safety index, process inherent safety index, reaction inherent safety index, activity inherent safety index, consequence inherent safety index and equipment inherent safety index, the intrinsic safety evaluation of the electrolysis hydrogen production process is carried out in a more comprehensive and reliable manner. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0085] Figure 1 It is a schematic flow chart of a systematic intrinsic safety assessment method for a hydrogen production process by electrolysis according to the present invention;
[0086] Figure 2 It is a schematic diagram of the intrinsic safety index involved in the existing chemical intrinsic safety assessment method;
[0087] Figure 3 It is a schematic diagram of the relationship between laminar combustion velocity and hydrogen concentration;
[0088] Figure 4 It is the polynomial fitting diagram of laminar combustion velocity and hydrogen concentration;
[0089] Figure 5 Schematic diagram of the protection layer of the safety device. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0090] The specific implementation of the present invention is further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and technical solutions.
[0091] like Figure 1 As shown in the figure, a systematic inherent safety assessment method for the electrolysis hydrogen production process is presented. The inherent safety assessment method focuses on how to reduce the possibility and severity of accidents through design and process selection to prevent accidents or minimize their impact. The selection of indicators has an important influence on the inherent safety assessment method and determines the focus and emphasis of the evaluation method. In 2020, Sunhwa Park et al. reviewed various inherent safety methods and the inherent safety indices involved, see Incorporating inherent safety during the conceptual process design stage: A literature review, sciencedirectassets.com, and summarized the safety indicators involved in the inherent safety assessment method in detail. Figure 2 .
[0092] Specifically, safety indicators involve six aspects: chemical and physical properties of materials, process conditions, reaction parameters, equipment parameters, activity types and consequences.
[0093] The chemical and physical properties of materials include flammability (I Flammability), explosiveness (I Explosivity), toxicity (I Toxicity), corrosivity (I Corrosivity), volatility (I Volatility), material condition (IMaterial Condition), volume change (I Volumechange), solubility (I Solubility), ability to precipitate (I Ability to precipitate), density difference (I Density difference), viscosity (I Viscosity), relative density (I Relative density), molecular weight (I Molecular weight), hazardous substances (I Hazardous substances) and impurities (I Impurities).
[0094] The process conditions include temperature (I Temperature), pressure (IPressure), output (I Yield), inventory (IInventory), process mode (IProcess mode), flow rate (I Flow rate), concentration (I Concentration), liquid level (I Level), pH value (IPH), fluidity (I Fluidity) and unit operation type (I Unit operation type).
[0095] The reaction parameters include chemical interactions (I Chemical Interactions), heat of main reaction (IMain reaction heat), heat of side reaction (I Side reaction heat), reaction type (I ReactionType) and runaway type (I Runaway type).
[0096] Equipment parameters include outside boundary area (IOutside boundary area), inside boundary area (I Insideboundary area, structure), structure (I Structure), layout (I Layout), complexity (I complexity, type of equipment), equipment type (I Type of equipment), safety devices (I Safetydevices) and emission rate of equipment (I Emission rate ofequipment).
[0097] Activity types include transport (I Transport), emission or combustion (IDischarge or combustion), maintenance (IMaintenance), and other (IOther).
[0098] The consequences include fireballs (I Fireballs), jet fires (I Jet fires), pool fires (IPoolfires), vapor cloud explosions (IVapour cloud explosions), boiling liquid extended vapor cloud explosions (I Boilingliquid extended vapour cloud explosions), containment (I Containment), and the dispersion of toxic chemicals (IDispersion of toxic chemicals). Among the above letters, I stands for Inherent index, which means the intrinsic safety index.
[0099] On this basis, each intrinsic safety evaluation index is analyzed in Table 1 in combination with the characteristics of the electrolysis system. Among them, due to the characteristics of no side reaction (I Side reaction heat), no other chemical interactions (IChemical interactions), non-toxic (I Toxicity), neutral electrolysis non-corrosive (I Corrosivity), and operation within the boundary area (I Inside boundary area, structure) in the process of hydrogen production by electrolysis of water, the corresponding safety index can be qualitatively quantified to 0 or other determined values. However, safety indicators such as flammability and explosiveness are closely related to the operation of the device and cannot be directly determined. It is necessary to further analyze the rules, determine the mathematical rules between the device parameters and the safety indicators, and normalize the parameters in combination with the safety index range. The present invention corresponds to the actual characteristics of the operation of the electrolysis water device with different safety indicators, that is, the safety index, and combines qualitative and quantitative analysis methods to finally determine the selection of the intrinsic safety evaluation index of the electrolysis water device and the calculation method of the full intrinsic safety index.
[0100] For the entire electrolysis process, the analysis is conducted based on the six existing aspects of intrinsic safety evaluation: physical and chemical properties of materials, process conditions, reaction characteristics, equipment, operation types, and consequences, combined with specific sub-category indicators.
[0101] In the calculation of chemical and physical properties, i.e. the physicochemical properties of materials, reference is made to the MSDS verification report indicators of perfluorosulfonic acid proton exchange membrane.
[0102] In the process characteristic calculation, the individual indicators such as reaction heat, flammability, and explosiveness are specifically analyzed in combination with the electrolysis process characteristics. For example, the reaction heat is quantified in combination with the heat absorption and release changes of the electrolysis reaction before and after the thermoneutral voltage; the flammability is quantified in combination with the empirical formula of the laminar combustion velocity and hydrogen concentration related tests; the explosiveness is quantified in combination with the TNO overpressure value and the physical parameters and operating parameters such as the isobaric heat capacity, isochoric heat capacity, relative concentration of hydrogen and oxygen, logistics density, and explosion limit of chemicals; and the minimum-maximum standardization method is used to process the data of all indicators to obtain the total intrinsic safety index. The details are as follows:
[0103] S1. Based on the existing chemical intrinsic safety assessment methods, the intrinsic safety assessment index related to the electrolysis of water reaction is selected to establish an intrinsic safety assessment framework including six aspects: physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
[0104] Appendix: Introduction to Safety Index Calculation
[0105] Table 1 Correspondence analysis table between intrinsic safety index structure and electrolytic hydrogen production process
[0106]
[0107]
[0108]
[0109]
[0110]
[0111]
[0112] In the table, BLEVE means boiling liquid expanding steam explosion. The judgment criteria can be set by the user for complex or simple structures.
[0113] In Table 1, the flow rate threshold range is:
[0114] Under normal pressure: 1-10m / s; under high pressure: 10-30m / s; near the compressor: 30-60m / s.
[0115] In Table 1, the protection layer of the safety device is checked according to the basic logic control system, safety instrument system, emergency stop system, personnel emergency system, etc. Figure 5 shown.
[0116] S2. Carry out process quantification or calculation quantification of the intrinsic safety evaluation index within the intrinsic safety evaluation framework;
[0117] (I) Reaction heat - thermal neutral voltage
[0118]
[0119]
[0120]
[0121] (1) is the calculation formula for the open circuit voltage. The open circuit voltage is the voltage across the battery when no current is flowing. This formula includes the Gibbs free energy change (ΔG), the Faraday constant (F), the gas constant (R), the temperature (T), and the pressures P of hydrogen, oxygen, and water vapor involved. H2 , P O2 , P H2O , n represents the number of electrons transmitted during the reaction process, where n is 4 for the anode oxygen evolution reaction and 2 for the cathode hydrogen evolution reaction.
[0122] (2) VCELL is the actual output voltage of the battery (Cell Voltage). In addition to the open circuit voltage part, it also includes activation overvoltage (V_act), ohmic overvoltage (V_ohm) and concentration overvoltage (V_con). These terms represent the additional voltage loss caused by chemical reaction kinetics, resistance loss and electrolyte concentration difference in actual operation of the battery. This voltage depends not only on the properties of the electrolyte material, but also on the battery design, operating conditions (such as temperature, pressure), charge transfer process and interface reaction.
[0123] (3) VTNV is the Theoretical Nernst Voltage, also known as the thermodynamic equilibrium voltage or the equilibrium potential of water electrolysis. The thermoneutral voltage refers to the potential difference between the Fermi levels of electrons and holes in a semiconductor device when thermal equilibrium is reached. It also refers to the voltage when the process of decomposing water into hydrogen and oxygen reaches thermodynamic equilibrium at a specific temperature. This is a theoretical value, which is calculated only based on the Gibbs free energy change and represents the spontaneity of the water decomposition reaction in the absence of an electrolysis process. This is the maximum voltage that a battery can reach under ideal conditions, and is often regarded as a theoretical upper limit of battery efficiency.
[0124] The electrolysis of water is impossible below VOCV (1.23V). If the applied voltage is less than VTNV (thermoneutral) but greater than EOCV, the electrolysis of water can occur. At this time, the overall thermal effect of the reaction is endothermic. When the voltage exceeds ETNV (thermoneutral), the voltage above 1.48V is used to generate heat.
[0125] I Reaction Heat=Max(0,4*(V cell -V TNV ) / V cell )(4)
[0126] In formula (4), I Reaction Heat represents the intrinsic safety index of reaction heat.
[0127] (II) Flammability - Laminar Burning Velocity
[0128] Laminar combustion velocity is one of the important parameters of the combustion characteristics of reaction fuels and is related to the fuel concentration. Figure 3 As shown. Figure 3 It can be seen that the laminar combustion velocity increases with the increase of hydrogen concentration, reaches a peak and then begins to decline. The simulation results of different models are compared with the experimental data. The simulation results of Cantera and GRI3.0 mechanisms (solid lines) have a higher degree of fit with the experimental data, while the simulation results of Chemkin and Peters and Rogg mechanisms (gray solid lines) and Cantera and Dryer mechanisms (dashed lines) also show similar trends, thus proving the rationality of the experimental data.
[0129] The laminar combustion velocity and hydrogen concentration were fitted using polynomials, among which the six-term equation can fit the experimental data well. The fitting diagram is shown in Figure 4 As shown, the final fitting formula is:
[0130]
[0131] In formula (5), a is -2.27×10 -10 , b is 2.05×10 -8 , c is 4.00×10 -6 , d is -6.64×10 -4 , e is 3.06×10 -2 , f is -4.33; V Laminarburning is the laminar combustion velocity, C H2 is the hydrogen concentration.
[0132]
[0133] In formula (6), I Flammability represents the intrinsic safety index of combustion, V Laminarburning,min is the minimum value of laminar combustion velocity, 0m / s, V Laminarburning,max is the maximum value of laminar combustion velocity. Figure 4 , is 3m / s.
[0134] (III) Explosiveness – Overpressure value
[0135] Explosion is the most common accident, and steam cloud explosion is considered the most common accident scenario. Explosion risk and consequence assessment requires determining the mass released in the accident. The amount of gas and liquid released is calculated by the following formula:
[0136] The release rate of the liquid is:
[0137]
[0138] In formula (7), m L is the release rate of the liquid, kg / s; C D is the flow coefficient of the fluid; A h is the area of the leakage hole, m 2 ; ρ is the density of the material in the pipe, kg / m 3 ; Δp is the pressure difference between the inside and outside of the tube, Pa.
[0139] For gas phase leakage, if the pressure ratio between the inside and outside of the equipment is between 0.5 and 0.9, the leakage is in a blocked condition, and vice versa. The leakage rate of gas phase substances is calculated by the following formula:
[0140] Under blocking conditions, the gas release rate is:
[0141]
[0142] In formula (8), m V is the gas release rate, kg / s; γ is the specific heat ratio; p is the actual pressure of the material in the tube, Pa.
[0143] Under non-blocking conditions, the gas release rate is:
[0144]
[0145] In formula (9), p amb is the ambient pressure, Pa.
[0146] The initial release amount when the equipment is damaged can be calculated using formulas (7)-(9).
[0147] Then the combustible mass of the released combustible vapor cloud needs to be estimated. The main calculation formula is as follows:
[0148]
[0149] In formula (10), m f represents the combustible mass of the steam cloud, kg; m represents the mass of the steam cloud released by the equipment, kg; c o Represents the actual concentration of the substance in the vapor cloud; cLFL Represents the lower explosion limit of the leaked substance, hydrogen.
[0150] The explosion overpressure also depends on the energy released by the explosion and the scaled distance. The two parameters are calculated by referring to the TNT equivalent method. The calculation formula is as follows:
[0151]
[0152]
[0153] In formulas (11)-(12), m TNT Represents the equivalent TNT mass of the substance, kg; η eX represents the explosion efficiency coefficient; m f Represents the combustible mass of the vapor cloud, kg; H V Represents the combustion energy of the leaked material, J / g; H V,TNT represents the combustion energy of TNT, J / g; z represents the actual distance, the maximum impact distance that can cause casualties and property losses, m; Represents the scaling distance, m.
[0154] Finally, the explosion overpressure at different locations is estimated by the nonlinear regression equation fitted by the experiment. The specific calculation equation is as follows:
[0155]
[0156] In formula (13), p ovr represents the explosion overpressure, kPa; a1, b1, c1 all represent overpressure constants. The fitting experiment is a prior art and will not be described in detail here.
[0157]
[0158] In formula (14), I Explosion represents the intrinsic safety index of explosion, p ovr,min is the minimum value of explosion overpressure, 0Pa, p ovr,max It is the maximum value of laminar combustion velocity, 700Pa.
[0159] (iv) Temperature: the temperature of the electrolytic cell.
[0160]
[0161] In formula (15), I Temperature represents the intrinsic safety index of temperature, T cell,min is the minimum value of the electrolytic cell temperature, ambient temperature, 35°C, T cell,min is the maximum value of the electrolytic cell temperature, 100°C.
[0162] (V) Operating pressure: the electrolysis operating pressure.
[0163]
[0164] In formula (16), IPressure represents the intrinsic safety index of pressure, p Cathode is cathode operating pressure, Pa; p atm is the ambient pressure, Pa; p Cathode,max is the maximum cathode operating pressure, Pa.
[0165] S3. Based on the process data of hydrogen production by electrolysis, the chemical equation of the chemical reaction mechanism of hydrogen production by water electrolysis is input into the industrial software to form a process model of the water electrolysis process, i.e., a reactor.
[0166] The process of establishing the process model of the water electrolysis process is specifically as follows: using process modeling and data analysis methods, numerical simulation based on the process, and using the calculation software Aspen custom modeler / Aspen Plus / Python, according to the quantitative method in step S2, the threshold of each indicator is strictly calculated. The specific method of model establishment is the existing technology and will not be described in detail here.
[0167] Based on the accurate modeling of reaction and transfer mechanism, it avoids the large amount of experimental investment in data collection without having to start and stop the device many times and change the operating parameters.
[0168] At the same time, the process data is connected with the Python mathematical calculation code, and the intrinsic safety index is used as the output to streamline the data processing process and reduce data processing errors.
[0169] S4. Combined with the intrinsic safety evaluation framework, as shown in Table 2, the operating range of the intrinsic safety parameters under normal conditions is taken as input, and the Sobol sequence sampling of super Latin cube sampling is used to calculate the safety quantitative value threshold range of various intrinsic safety evaluation indexes in the electrolysis water process under stable conditions.
[0170] Table 2 Operating range of some intrinsically safe parameters under normal conditions
[0171]
[0172]
[0173]
[0174]
[0175] Step S5: different value assignment standards are set according to whether various intrinsic safety evaluation indices are within the safety quantitative value threshold range determined in step S4.
[0176] Specifically, a real-time assessment is conducted on the systematic intrinsic safety assessment method of the hydrogen production process by electrolysis:
[0177] The intrinsic safety parameters collected in real time during the electrolytic hydrogen production process are compared with the calculated thresholds of the corresponding intrinsic safety indexes.
[0178] According to the comparison result, a value is assigned, for example: when it exceeds the threshold range, it is 1; when it is within the threshold range, it is 0.
[0179] Thus, the quantification of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index is realized. Specifically, the intrinsic safety evaluation indexes involving the physicochemical properties of materials, process conditions, reaction parameters, equipment parameters, activity types and consequences are accumulated to obtain the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
[0180] The systematic intrinsic safety assessment method for the electrolysis hydrogen production process also includes step S6: inputting the same intrinsic safety parameters, and evaluating the intrinsic safety of process models of different water electrolysis processes according to the size of the quantitative value of one or more of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
[0181] In step S6, the specific method for evaluating the intrinsic safety of the process models of different water electrolysis processes is:
[0182] The quantitative values of one or more of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index of process models of different water electrolysis processes are compared, and the process model with the smaller quantitative value is selected.
[0183] The systematic intrinsic safety assessment method for the electrolytic hydrogen production process also includes step S7: for different intrinsic safety parameters, the intrinsic safety level of the process model of the same water electrolysis process is evaluated using quantitative values of one or more of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
[0184] In step S7, the intrinsic safety level classification method is: different safety level judgment standards are set for the degree of safety impact of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
[0185] For example: the systemic intrinsic safety level of the hydrogen production process by electrolysis is divided into levels 1-6 and non-intrinsically safe states according to the size of the numerical value. Since the consequence intrinsic safety index has the greatest impact on the systemic intrinsic safety of the hydrogen production process by electrolysis, when the fireball evaluation index in the consequence intrinsic safety index is 1, there is no need to judge other intrinsic safety indices, and the systemic intrinsic safety level of the hydrogen production process by electrolysis is directly classified as a non-intrinsically safe state.
Claims
1. A systematic intrinsic safety assessment method for the electrolytic hydrogen production process, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: S1. Based on the existing chemical intrinsic safety evaluation methods, select the intrinsic safety evaluation index related to the electrolysis water reaction, and establish an intrinsic safety evaluation framework for six aspects: physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index; S2. Carry out process quantification or calculation quantification of the intrinsic safety evaluation index within the intrinsic safety evaluation framework; S3. According to the process data of the hydrogen production process by electrolysis, the chemical equation of the chemical reaction mechanism of hydrogen production by water electrolysis is input into the industrial software to form a process model of the water electrolysis process; S4. Combined with the intrinsic safety evaluation framework, the operating range of the intrinsic safety parameters under normal conditions is used as input, and the Sobol sequence of super Latin cube sampling is used to sample the design variables of the intrinsic safety parameters, and the safety quantitative value threshold range of various intrinsic safety evaluation indexes in the electrolysis water process under stable conditions is calculated; S5. Setting different value assignment standards according to whether various intrinsic safety evaluation indexes are within the safety quantitative value threshold range determined in step S4; This will enable quantification of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
2. The method for systematic intrinsic safety assessment of hydrogen production by electrolysis according to claim 1, characterized in that: It also includes step S6: input the same intrinsic safety parameters, and evaluate the intrinsic safety of process models of different water electrolysis processes according to the size of the quantitative value of one or more of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
3. The method for systematic intrinsic safety assessment of hydrogen production by electrolysis according to claim 2, characterized in that: In step S6, the specific method for evaluating the intrinsic safety of the process models of different water electrolysis processes is: The quantitative values of one or more of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index of process models of different water electrolysis processes are compared, and the process model with the smaller quantitative value is selected.
4. The method for systematic intrinsic safety assessment of hydrogen production by electrolysis according to claim 1, characterized in that: It also includes step S7: for different intrinsic safety parameters, the intrinsic safety level of the process model of the same water electrolysis process is evaluated using the quantitative values of one or more of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, the process intrinsic safety index, the reaction intrinsic safety index, the activity intrinsic safety index, the consequence intrinsic safety index and the equipment intrinsic safety index.
5. The method for systematic intrinsic safety assessment of hydrogen production by electrolysis according to claim 4, characterized in that: In step S7, the intrinsic safety level classification method is: different safety level judgment standards are set based on the degree of safety impact of the physical and chemical intrinsic safety index, process intrinsic safety index, reaction intrinsic safety index, activity intrinsic safety index, consequence intrinsic safety index and equipment intrinsic safety index.
6. The method for systematic intrinsic safety assessment of hydrogen production by electrolysis according to claim 1, characterized in that: The specific method for process quantification or calculation quantification of the intrinsic safety evaluation index within the intrinsic safety evaluation framework in step S2 is shown in Table 1: Table 1 Correspondence analysis table between intrinsic safety index structure and electrolytic hydrogen production process In the table, BLEVE means boiling liquid expanding steam explosion. The judgment criteria can be set by the user for complex or simple structures.
7. The method for systematic intrinsic safety assessment of hydrogen production by electrolysis according to claim 6, characterized in that: In Table 1: 1) The calculation formula for reaction heat includes: In formula (1) to formula (3), V ocv is the open circuit voltage, Vcell is the actual output voltage of the battery, Vact is the activation overvoltage, Vohm is the ohmic overvoltage, Vcon is the concentration difference overvoltage, V TNV is the thermoneutral voltage, ΔG is the Gibbs free energy change, F is the Faraday constant, R is the gas constant, T is the temperature, and P H2 , P O2 , P H2O are the pressures of hydrogen, oxygen and water vapor respectively, and n represents the number of electrons transmitted during the reaction process, where n is 4 for the anode oxygen evolution reaction and 2 for the cathode hydrogen evolution reaction; IReaction Heat=Max(0,4*(V cell -V TNV ) / V cell )(4) In formula (4), IReaction Heat represents the intrinsic safety index of reaction heat; 2) The calculation formula of laminar burning velocity is: In formula (5), a is -2.27×10 -10 , b is 2.05×10 -8 , c is 4.00×10 -6 , d is -6.64×10 -4 , e is 3.06×10 -2 , f is -4.33; V Laminarburning is the laminar combustion velocity, is the hydrogen concentration; In formula (6), I Flammability represents the intrinsic safety index of combustion, V Laminarburning,mib is the minimum value of laminar combustion velocity, specifically 0m / s, V Laminarburning,max is the maximum value of laminar combustion velocity, specifically 3m / s; 3) The calculation formula of overpressure value is: The release rate of the liquid is: In formula (7), m L is the release rate of the liquid, kg / s; C D is the flow coefficient of the fluid; A h is the area of the leakage hole, m 2 ; ρ is the density of the material in the pipe, kg / m 3 ; Δp is the pressure difference between the inside and outside of the tube, Pa; For the leakage of gas phase substances, if the pressure ratio between the inside and outside of the equipment is between 0.5 and 0.9, the leakage is in a blocked condition, and vice versa. The leakage rate of gas phase substances is calculated by the following formula: Under blocking conditions, the gas release rate is: In formula (8), m V is the gas release rate, kg / s; γ is the specific heat ratio; p is the actual pressure of the substance in the tube, Pa; Under non-blocking conditions, the gas release rate is: In formula (9), p amb is the ambient pressure, Pa; The initial release amount when the equipment is damaged is calculated by formulas (7)-(9); Then the combustible mass of the released combustible vapor cloud needs to be estimated using the following formula: In formula (10), m f represents the combustible mass of the steam cloud, kg; m represents the mass of the steam cloud released by the equipment, kg; c o represents the actual concentration of the substance in the vapor cloud; c LFL Represents the lower explosion limit of the leaked substance, hydrogen; The explosion overpressure also depends on the energy released by the explosion and the scaling distance. The two parameters are calculated by referring to the TNT equivalent method. The calculation formula is as follows: In formulas (11)-(12), m TNT Represents the equivalent TNT mass of the substance, kg; η eX represents the explosion efficiency coefficient; m f Represents the combustible mass of the vapor cloud, kg; H V Represents the combustion energy of the leaked material, J / g; H V,TNT represents the combustion energy of TNT, J / g; z represents the actual distance, the maximum impact distance that can cause casualties and property losses, m; represents the scaling distance, m; Finally, the explosion overpressure at different locations is estimated by the nonlinear regression equation fitted by the experiment. The specific calculation equation is as follows: In formula (13), p ovr represents explosion overpressure, kPa; a1, b1, c1 all represent overpressure constants; In formula (14), IExplosion represents the intrinsic safety index of explosiveness, p ovr,min is the minimum value of explosion overpressure, specifically 0Pa, p ovr,max is the maximum value of laminar combustion velocity, specifically 700Pa; 4) Temperature: the temperature of the electrolytic cell; In formula (15), I Temperature represents the intrinsic safety index of temperature, Tcell represents the operating temperature of a single electrolytic cell, and T cell,min is the minimum value of the electrolytic cell temperature, the ambient temperature, specifically 35°C, T cell,min is the maximum value of the electrolytic cell temperature, specifically 100°C; 5) Operating pressure: electrolysis operating pressure; In formula (16), IPressure represents the intrinsic safety index of pressure, p Cathode is cathode operating pressure, Pa; p atm is the ambient pressure, Pa; p Cathode,max is the maximum cathode operating pressure, Pa.
8. The method for systematic intrinsic safety assessment of hydrogen production by electrolysis according to claim 6, characterized in that: In Table 1, the flow rate threshold range is: Under normal pressure: 1-10m / s; under high pressure: 10-30m / s; near the compressor: 30-60m / s.
9. The method for systematic intrinsic safety assessment of the electrolytic hydrogen production process according to claim 1, characterized in that: The intrinsic safety evaluation index in the existing chemical intrinsic safety evaluation method in step S1 is specifically: Chemical and physical properties of materials including flammability, explosiveness, toxicity, corrosiveness, volatility, material state, volume change, solubility, ability to precipitate, density difference, viscosity, relative density, molecular weight, hazardous substances and impurities; Process conditions include temperature, pressure, output, inventory, process mode, flow rate, concentration, liquid level, pH, fluidity, and unit operation type; Reaction parameters include chemical interactions, heat of primary reaction, heat of secondary reaction, reaction type, and runaway type; Equipment parameters include outside the limit, inside the limit, structure, layout, complexity, equipment type, safety devices and emission rate of the equipment; Activity types include transport, emission or combustion, maintenance, and other; Consequences include fireballs, jet fires, pool fires, steam cloud explosions, boiling liquid expanding steam cloud explosions, confinement, and dispersion of toxic chemicals.
