Protection scheme decision-making method based on multi-dimensional composite weapon strike
By establishing a functional model of the city system and a weapon-strike damage effect database, combining Monte Carlo simulation and multi-objective optimization algorithm, the flexibility and accuracy of protection plan decision-making under multi-dimensional weapon strikes are solved, and a more comprehensive protection plan evaluation is achieved. and scientific decision-making have improved the scientificity and wide application of protection solutions.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411514575.5
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-10-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-10-29
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology cannot provide dynamic, flexible and highly adaptable protection plan decisions under multi-dimensional weapon strikes, and lacks comprehensive and precise protection plans for complex strikes and a large number of targets, especially in protective efficiency in building complexes and system functional cascade areas. Research.
By establishing a city system functional model, a weapon-strike damage effect database and a multi-layer system functional model, combining Monte Carlo simulation and multi-objective optimization algorithm, the protection measures of key nodes of the system are quantified, and the cost ratio of the protection plan is evaluated, and the final result is the most Excellent protection plan.
It has achieved more comprehensive and accurate protection plan decisions, improved the flexibility and adaptability of protection measures, provided more comprehensive damage assessment and data management, and improved the scientificity and wide application of protection plans.
Smart Images

Figure CN119026488A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of battlefield protection intelligent decision-making, and in particular to a protection scheme decision-making method based on multi-dimensional composite weapon strikes. Background Art
[0002] The decision-making of protection plans for multi-dimensional composite weapon strikes refers to the construction and optimal selection of an overall protection plan for urban areas under multi-stage, multi-scenario and other multi-random factor weapon strike scenarios.
[0003] With the acceleration of urbanization and the improvement of industrialization, modern cities and industrial areas are facing more and more complex explosion threats. The suddenness, high destructiveness and unpredictability of explosions pose a serious threat to personnel safety, buildings and infrastructure. Intelligent decision-making on protection plans under the attack of multi-dimensional composite weapons is the basis for the establishment of emergency response systems and the accumulation of safety protection technologies, and is the premise for the safety and protection of urban projects.
[0004] At present, the design of facility protection schemes, such as the Chinese invention patent "A research method for the protection of oil storage facilities" (application number: CN202310644969.1, publication date: 2023-09-29), takes vertical steel oil tanks as the application scenario, faces the problems of oil storage facility protection and tank bottom corrosion, and improves the anti-corrosion performance of oil tanks through the macroscopic and microscopic multi-scale structural design of materials. Similarly, the Chinese invention patent "Method, device, equipment and medium for determining the protection range of line fire protection facilities" (application number: CN202210999049.7, publication date: 2022-10-21) provides a method for determining the protection range of line fire protection facilities, by calculating the movement time of high-temperature objects and the influence of wind speed on their horizontal acceleration to determine the protection range. These public protection decision-making technologies provide valuable applications in their respective technical fields, but to form a decision-making method for protection schemes under multi-dimensional weapon strikes, a more comprehensive and result-oriented decision-making method is needed.
[0005] In addition, the existing work has not evaluated the impact of multi-dimensional strike events on the effectiveness of protection schemes; the protection effectiveness evaluation is only aimed at single-target areas such as protective clothing ("A fire-proof, nuclear radiation-proof, neutron ray-proof, and biological and chemical-proof split protective clothing", application number: CN202122451234.6, publication date: 2022-04-05), ships ("A method for evaluating the explosion protection effectiveness of anti-ship missiles", application number: CN202211568672.3, publication date: 2023-04-18), facility security ("A substation safety protection system based on multi-level intelligence", application number: CN202210203419.1, publication date: 2022-07-22), and cyber warfare (authorization number: CN113228713B, publication date: 2022-09-16), but lacks research on the protection effectiveness of regional targets such as building complexes and system function cascades that are hit by explosion impact firepower.
[0006] In summary, the problems existing in the existing technology are: due to the limitation of simulation calculation speed, it is impossible to dynamically provide protection basis according to the regional damage results in real time, and there is a lack of highly flexible and highly adaptable protection plan decision-making methods for explosive impact fire strikes; at the same time, for complex strikes and protection decisions for a large number of targets, it is impossible to provide comprehensive and accurate protection plans, and there is a lack of generalized methods for decision-making on protection plans under multi-stage and multi-scenario strikes. Summary of the invention
[0007] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a method for making a protection plan decision based on multi-dimensional composite weapon strikes, which comprehensively considers the system damage mode and the degree of loss of key nodes of the system, and can achieve more comprehensive and accurate protection plan decision-making.
[0008] The technical solution to achieve the purpose of the present invention is: A method for decision-making on a protection scheme based on multi-dimensional composite weapon strikes comprises the following steps: Establishment of urban system functional model: Extract regional geographic information from the geographic information system, combine it with key node location information, and establish an urban system functional model; Establishment of weapon strike damage effect database: Integrate multi-dimensional and multi-target weapon strike damage effect data collected from multiple channels, as well as protection technology data collected from multiple channels, to establish a weapon strike damage effect database; Establishment of multi-layer model of system function: According to the system function components, establish the subsystem function association model, integrate the multi-dimensional system status information, and establish the multi-layer model of system function; Quantification of protection measures for key nodes of the system: Based on the system functional operation requirements and the impact of weapon strikes on the entire system, the protection measures for key nodes of the system are quantified to obtain quantitative protection measures for key nodes; Protection scheme cost-effectiveness evaluation: Based on the multi-layer model of system functions and combined with the quantitative protection measures of key nodes, generate protection schemes for key urban node functions under multiple random attack events, and evaluate the protection effectiveness and cost of each protection scheme to obtain the cost-effectiveness ratio of each protection scheme; Decision on the optimal protection plan: Based on the cost-effectiveness ratio of each protection plan, the protection plan and its corresponding protection cost that all key nodes of the comprehensive system can achieve the set protection indicators under the protection measures are established, and a multi-objective constraint and multi-standard analysis model is established to form the optimal protection plan.
[0009] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following significant advantages: 1. Strong flexibility and good adaptability: The present invention adopts Monte Carlo simulation and multi-objective optimization algorithm, which can adjust and optimize the protection strategy in real time under complex and changeable attack scenarios. Compared with the traditional static protection design, the present invention improves the flexibility and adaptability of the protection measures and can respond to emergencies more effectively; 2. More comprehensive damage assessment: The present invention establishes a database of explosion impact damage effects, which can comprehensively analyze the impact of multi-dimensional weapon strike events on the system. Unlike traditional methods that only focus on a single damage effect, the present invention covers a comprehensive assessment of physical damage, functional loss and its cascading effects, providing more comprehensive protection decision support; 3. Comprehensive and accurate data: The present invention significantly improves the efficiency in data collection, storage and analysis by unifying the management system of multiple types of data. This efficient data management system supports the integration of multi-source data, ensures the comprehensiveness and accuracy of the data, and thus improves the scientific nature of the decision-making of the protection plan; 4. Wide application and effectiveness: The method of the present invention is applicable to the protection of infrastructure in complex environments such as cities and industrial areas. It not only provides protection for a single facility, but also provides comprehensive protection for the cascading effects of multiple systems. This global and detailed protection capability greatly improves the breadth and effectiveness of practical applications.
[0010] The present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0011] Figure 1 It is the main flow chart of the protection scheme decision-making method based on multi-dimensional composite weapon attack of the present invention.
[0012] Figure 2 yes Figure 1 Flowchart of the steps for establishing a weapon strike damage database.
[0013] Figure 3 yes Figure 1 Flowchart of the steps for establishing a multi-layer model of system functions.
[0014] Figure 4 yes Figure 1 Flowchart of the quantitative steps of protection measures for key nodes in the system.
[0015] Figure 5 yes Figure 1 Flowchart of the steps for cost-effectiveness evaluation of protection options.
[0016] Figure 6 yes Figure 1 Flowchart of the decision-making steps for the optimal protection plan. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0017] like Figure 1 As shown, the present invention is based on the protection scheme decision method of multi-dimensional composite weapon attack, comprising the following steps: Establishment of urban system functional model 10: Extract regional geographic information from the geographic information system (GIS), combine it with key node location information, and establish the urban system functional model.
[0018] The key nodes include roads, bridges, power stations, oil depots, and reservoirs.
[0019] Virtualized urban system functional model for subsequent simulation and evaluation.
[0020] Establishing a functional model of an urban system is an existing technology and will not be elaborated in this article.
[0021] Establishment of weapon strike damage effect database 20: Integrate the multi-dimensional and multi-target weapon strike damage effect data collected from multiple channels, as well as the protection technology data collected from multiple channels, to establish a weapon strike damage effect database.
[0022] The weapon strike damage database includes weapon strike damage data of multifunctional nodes at the city system level with or without protective measures.
[0023] The weapon strike damage database is used for subsequent query of the functional loss of each node.
[0024] like Figure 2 As shown, the steps of establishing the weapon strike damage database 20 include: Damage Effects Data Collection 21: Collect weapon strike damage effects data covering a variety of weapon types and damage modes, including experimental data, historical accident data, and computer simulation data.
[0025] By collecting data from multiple channels, including experimental data, historical accident data, and computer simulation data, and covering multiple weapon types and multiple damage modes, we can comprehensively obtain weapon strike damage effect data from multi-dimensional strikes and multi-target attacks; For example, the source of experimental data can be explosion tests, etc., the source of historical accident data can be industrial explosion records, etc., and the source of computer simulation data can be Abaqus simulation results, etc.
[0026] Weapon types, such as fuel-air explosives, penetrating bombs, explosive-killing bombs, thermobaric bombs, and other ammunition types; Target damage mode: different weapon types cause direct damage such as collapse, deformation, and penetration of components of urban core nodes such as buildings, bridges, and tunnel shelters; as well as secondary damage such as electromagnetic pulses and high-temperature combustion to functional nodes such as electronic equipment and communication facilities.
[0027] Protection technology data collection 22: Collect protection technology data from test data, historical data, and simulation data.
[0028] The protection technology data involves three-dimensional desensitization cascade structure, high temperature resistant and high resistance structure, camouflage protection technology; it also includes a variety of advanced protection materials and structural designs, such as high-performance composite fiber reinforced polymer, ultra-high performance concrete, etc., energy-absorbing protection structure, specially designed walls, foundations and support structures, the use of metal grilles and energy-absorbing layers, the establishment of protective walls and isolation barriers, etc.; Database establishment 23: pre-processing, classifying and integrating the damage effect data and protection technology data, entering the data into the database system, and establishing a weapon strike damage effect database.
[0029] Before entering the data into the database system, the ambiguity, differences and heterogeneity of the data in structure and semantics should be unified.
[0030] The database establishment 23 step comprises: Data preprocessing 231: remove or correct outliers, standardize feature values, normalize data; Extract the feature vector X=[x1, x2, …, xn] from the original data, standardize the feature values so that they are on the same scale, and use Min-Max or Z-score normalization, whichever is more appropriate depending on the type and distribution of the data; Data feature classification and fusion 232: Use convolutional neural networks to classify and fuse data features; Data Entry 233: Data entry system, to establish a database of weapon strike damage effects.
[0031] The present invention collects and integrates data from multiple sources and types, including historical data, experimental data and numerical simulation data, covering a variety of ammunition types and target damage effects, comprehensively evaluates physical damage, functional loss and its cascading impact on the system, and improves the accuracy of strike plans and the comprehensiveness of decision support.
[0032] Establishment of multi-layer model of system function 30: According to the system function components, establish subsystem function association model, integrate multi-dimensional system status information, and establish multi-layer model of system function.
[0033] Based on the node function loss data in the database and comprehensive consideration of the multi-dimensional strike damage effects, the logical relationship and linkage effect between different systems are established, such as the functional relationship between key infrastructure such as power systems, water supply systems, fuel / gas systems, transportation systems, and communication systems. The overall explosion resilience of the system is quantified using an aggregation method based on information, physics, and applications.
[0034] like Figure 3 As shown, the steps of establishing the system function multi-layer model 30 include: Confirmation of system functional components31: Confirm the mutual influence and linkage effects between system functional components, including the physical, geographical, network and logical connections between subsystems; The system functional component confirmation 31 step includes: Physical association identification 311: Identify the physical connections between systems and assess their association; Identify and evaluate the physical connections between systems, such as the energy supply relationship between the power system and the dispatch control center. Collect and organize the physical connection data of the facilities to ensure the integrity and accuracy of the data; Key location identification 312: identifying key node locations in the city system functional model based on the geographical location layout and interdependence of the nodes in the city system; Network association identification 313: Identify key communication nodes and control centers based on the role of information and control networks between systems in emergency situations; Evaluate the information and control networks between systems, especially in emergency situations. Identify key communication nodes and control centers and analyze their importance in maintaining system functionality; Logical association establishment 314: Establish a logical association model based on the logical relationship and linkage effect between different systems.
[0035] Analyze the logical relationship and linkage effect between different systems, such as the dependence of the water supply system on the power system. By converting various objects into relationships, such as one-to-one recursive relationship, one-to-one binary relationship, one-to-many binary relationship, etc., a logical association model is established to simulate the linkage reaction between systems under different conditions.
[0036] Establishment of subsystem functional association model 32: Based on the mutual influence and linkage effect between subsystems, the system dynamics modeling method is adopted to establish a subsystem functional association model for each key node.
[0037] Subsystems such as power systems, water supply systems, fuel / gas systems, transportation systems, and communication systems.
[0038] Multi-dimensional system status information integration33: Map the multi-dimensional system status information of the evaluation object to each system layer, and simulate the interaction and function transfer between each system layer.
[0039] The multi-dimensional system status information of the evaluation object includes geographic information and node information.
[0040] Multi-dimensional system status information integration can provide a comprehensive system status view and support functional evaluation under complex conditions; Functional multi-layer model establishment and evaluation 34: Establish a system functional multi-layer model with inter-layer connections to evaluate and determine the key impact chain and system resilience.
[0041] This step quantifies the impact of the explosion on key infrastructure and provides accurate quantitative indicators for loss assessment; The functional multi-layer model establishment and evaluation 34 steps include: Multi-layer model construction 341: Establish a multi-layer model of system functions that includes system node integrity and functional integrity; As described, the multi-layer model of system functionality can be comprehensively evaluated by combining physical damage data and functional loss data; Determination of critical impact chain system resilience 342: Determine critical impact chain and system resilience based on the functional interactions and impact paths between the system layers in the system function multi-layer model.
[0042] By analyzing the dependencies of each system and establishing physical, geographical and network correlation models, the purpose of assessing system resilience is achieved. This method accurately assesses the damage of a single subsystem, reveals the linkage effect between systems, and helps to more comprehensively understand the resilience and key nodes of the overall system, thereby optimizing the protection plan.
[0043] Quantification of protection measures for key nodes of the system 40: Based on the system functional operation requirements and the impact of weapon strikes on the entire system, the protection measures for key nodes of the system are quantified to obtain quantitative protection measures for key nodes; like Figure 4 As shown, the steps of quantifying the protection measures for key nodes of the system 40 include: Protection index confirmation 41: Refer to industry specifications or standards (such as ISO, ASTM, etc.) to determine the protection performance benchmark of each key node, and set specific protection indicators for each key node based on the functional attributes of the key nodes of the system; Protection indicators such as explosion resistance (PSI), impact resistance, fire resistance, etc.; Quantification of protective measures 42: Based on the protection indicators of each key node, the structural response of the node is matched according to the key node morphology, material and other attributes from the weapon strike damage effect database. At the same time, based on the protection feature data recorded in the database, that is, according to the damage results of the node under different weapon strikes after the introduction of protection technology, the quantitative protective measures required to evaluate the key nodes of the system to achieve the specified protection standards under the protection of existing protective measures when attacked by weapons; The quantitative protection measures include information such as protection area and protection location; Utilize the protection effects that can be achieved by the existing protection technologies in the database to quantify the protection measures required for the target key nodes to achieve the protection indicators.
[0044] Protection scheme cost-effectiveness evaluation 50: Based on the system function multi-layer model and in combination with the key node quantitative protection measures, generate protection schemes for key node functions in the city under multiple random attack events, and evaluate the protection effectiveness and protection cost of each protection scheme to obtain the cost-effectiveness ratio of each protection scheme; like Figure 5 As shown, the protection scheme cost-effectiveness evaluation 50 step includes: Protection plan generation 51: Using the Monte Carlo simulation analysis method, based on the multi-layer model of system functions and combined with the quantitative protection measures of key nodes in the target area after multi-dimensional weapon attacks, multiple protection plans are generated.
[0045] According to the key nodes in the target area, such as substations, water treatment plants, major transportation hubs, etc.
[0046] The protection scheme generation 51 step comprises: Monte Carlo simulation analysis 511: Monte Carlo simulation is used to analyze the loss distribution under different attack event combinations; Defining input parameters 512: According to the basic characteristics of weapons and ammunition, determining the range of strike event parameters as input variables of the decision model, the strike event parameters include the number of strikes, strike equivalent, and strike sequence of weapons and ammunition; Determine the parameter range of the strike event, including the number of strikes (such as 1, 2, 5, etc.), strike equivalent (ton level), strike sequence, and set the protection budget level (such as low, medium, high) as input variables of the decision model; Random strike event generation 513: Using the Monte Carlo method, the decision model generates multiple possible strike events by randomly sampling the number, equivalent and sequence of strikes. It uses an iterative calculation method to run multiple simulations for each strike event and calculate the potential losses and protection effectiveness in each case.
[0047] Protection target selection strategy 514: According to the importance of key nodes and their role in the system, set priorities and determine the nodes and high-priority protection targets of the urban system; Set priorities for each node to ensure the rationality and effectiveness of resource allocation and improve the overall effectiveness of protection measures; Formulate protection resource allocation strategy 515: Formulate protection resource allocation strategy based on the impact of key nodes in the system function multi-layer model and the set protection indicator level.
[0048] This includes the development of impact assessment models: , In the formula, Is a node The influence of is its priority, is its dependency in the system functional layer, is its connectivity in the system.
[0049] In addition, it also includes determining the protection requirements of each node based on its protection indicator level: , In the formula, Is a node protection needs, is the protection index level, It is the building standard grade of the node.
[0050] Protection resource allocation strategies such as giving priority to protecting key nodes and allocating more resources to areas with high protection requirements (high risks); Obtain different protection plans 516: formulate protection plans for each attack event, key system nodes, and protection resource allocation strategy, combined with quantitative protection measures; Protection plan, including protection area, protection location, different combinations of protection measures and implementation sequence, etc.
[0051] Evaluation of the effectiveness of protection schemes 52: Based on the multiple protection schemes, protection measures are simulated at the key nodes of the urban system function model. The protection characteristics recorded in the explosion damage database are used again to deduce the damage of the nodes under the protection of each protection scheme. The impact on the overall system function of the city is further evaluated through the system function multi-layer model. The final protection effect is unified with the system function retention, loss reduction ratio, and recovery speed data. All feasible schemes that achieve consistent protection effects are screened out, and the protection effectiveness of each scheme is evaluated according to the degree of impact.
[0052] The less the functions of urban systems are affected, the more effective the protection plan will be.
[0053] Protection cost assessment 53: Determine the main cost elements in the protection plan, including material cost, construction cost and maintenance and renewal cost, use decision tree neural network to establish the relationship model between cost elements and total cost, and evaluate the cost elements that have the greatest impact on the total cost.
[0054] The protection cost assessment 53 steps are specifically as follows: Material cost estimation 531: Estimate the market price of protective materials, such as high-strength concrete, steel bars, explosion-proof glass, etc.; Construction cost estimation 532: According to the project plan, refine the timetable and resource allocation of each work. Estimate the construction costs such as civil engineering, equipment installation, and labor costs; Maintenance and Renewal Cost Estimation 533: Based on the age and environmental conditions of the facility and the life cycle of the facility, estimate the cost of routine maintenance and periodic renewal, including regular inspections, repairs, and upgrades.
[0055] Establishment of the relationship model between cost factors and total cost 534: Use decision tree neural network to establish the relationship model between cost factors and total cost. By recursively splitting the data set, select the feature that can minimize the cost variance as the splitting point, retain the feature splitting point that contributes the most to cost prediction, evaluate the importance of each cost factor in the decision tree, and obtain the cost factor that has the greatest impact on the total cost.
[0056] Optimal protection scheme decision 60: Based on the cost-effectiveness ratio of each protection scheme, the protection schemes and their corresponding protection costs of the key nodes of the comprehensive system that all achieve the set protection indicators under the protection measures are established, and a multi-objective constraint and multi-standard analysis model is established to form the optimal protection scheme.
[0057] According to the type of target (such as power supply stations, oil storage depots, command centers, transportation hubs, etc.) and protection index requirements, select appropriate protection measures, optimize emergency response mechanisms, etc., so as to improve the explosion resistance and recovery capabilities of the overall system.
[0058] like Figure 6 As shown, the optimal protection solution decision 60 step includes: Multi-objective optimization 61: Define multi-objective functions, maximize protection effectiveness and minimize protection costs. According to the implementation costs of different protection schemes, use budget constraints, implementation events, and the availability of materials and human resources as model constraints. Obtain multiple protection strategy combinations through random generation or heuristic methods. Sort each solution in the solution set and identify solutions that cannot be dominated by other solutions to form a Pareto frontier. Further sort the solutions on the Pareto frontier and identify the non-dominated level of each solution to obtain the Pareto solution set. Taking into account that the optimal protection plan does not mean finding the extreme value, that is, there is a situation where there is no upper limit on the protection budget and extreme protection of key nodes is required, multiple standard criteria are set in the optimization model to achieve the purpose of optimal decision-making on demand.
[0059] Multi-criteria decision making 62: Based on the Pareto solution set, the weight of each criterion is set according to the decision maker's goals or resources; For example, protection effectiveness is prioritized, cost control is prioritized, etc. Ensure that the values of different standards are compared on the same scale; Selection of the optimal protection plan 63: Multi-criteria decision analysis is used to dynamically evaluate the weighted ratio scores of each plan under different criteria, and the optimal protection plan is determined based on actual protection needs.
[0060] Through the above steps, the blast resilience of urban integrated system functions under multiple strike events can be systematically evaluated, and scientific protection and recovery recommendations can be provided to ensure the safety and reliability of critical infrastructure.
[0061] The core advantage of the present invention lies in its flexibility and adaptability. Through Monte Carlo simulation and multi-objective optimization algorithms, it can adjust and optimize the protection strategy in real time and effectively respond to complex and changeable attack scenarios. In terms of technical implementation, the present invention first establishes an urban system function model and a database of weapon strike damage effects, then constructs a multi-layer model of system functions and quantifies the protection measures of key nodes of the system. On this basis, the present invention further evaluates the effectiveness and cost of the protection scheme, and determines the optimal protection scheme through multi-objective optimization and multi-criteria decision analysis.
[0062] The implementation of the present invention can not only improve the scientificity and accuracy of the protection plan, but also ensure the efficient use of resources through precise cost factor analysis, and can provide global and detailed protection plan decisions for key node facilities in the city, significantly improving the ability and efficiency of urban engineering safety and protection.
Claims
1. A decision-making method for a protection scheme based on multi-dimensional composite weapon strikes, characterized in that: The steps include: Establishment of urban system functional model: Extract regional geographic information from the geographic information system, combine it with key node location information, and establish an urban system functional model; Establishment of weapon strike damage effect database: Integrate multi-dimensional and multi-target weapon strike damage effect data collected from multiple channels, as well as protection technology data collected from multiple channels, to establish a weapon strike damage effect database; Establishment of multi-layer model of system function: According to the system function components, establish the subsystem function association model, integrate the multi-dimensional system status information, and establish the multi-layer model of system function; Quantification of protection measures for key nodes of the system: Based on the system functional operation requirements and the impact of weapon strikes on the entire system, the protection measures for key nodes of the system are quantified to obtain quantitative protection measures for key nodes; Protection scheme cost-effectiveness evaluation: Based on the multi-layer model of system functions and combined with the quantitative protection measures of key nodes, generate protection schemes for key urban node functions under multiple random attack events, and evaluate the protection effectiveness and cost of each protection scheme to obtain the cost-effectiveness ratio of each protection scheme; Decision on the optimal protection plan: Based on the cost-effectiveness ratio of each protection plan, the protection plan and its corresponding protection cost that all key nodes of the comprehensive system can achieve the set protection indicators under the protection measures are established, and a multi-objective constraint and multi-standard analysis model is established to form the optimal protection plan.
2. The protection scheme decision-making method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The steps of establishing the weapon strike damage database include: Damage effect data collection: Collect weapon damage effect data covering multiple weapon types and multiple damage modes, including experimental data, historical accident data and computer simulation data; Protection technology data collection: Collect protection technology data from test data, historical data, and simulation data; Database establishment: pre-process, classify and integrate the damage effect data and protection technology data, enter them into the library system, and establish a weapon strike damage effect database.
3. The protection scheme decision method according to claim 2, characterized in that: The database establishment step comprises: Data preprocessing: remove or correct outliers, standardize feature values, and normalize data; Data feature classification and fusion: Use convolutional neural networks to classify and fuse data features; Data entry: Data entry system, to establish database of weapon strike damage effects.
4. The protection scheme decision-making method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The system function multi-layer model establishment step includes: Confirmation of system functional components: Confirm the mutual influence and linkage effects between system functional components, including the physical, geographical, network and logical connections between subsystems; Establishment of subsystem functional association model: Based on the mutual influence and linkage effect between subsystems, the system dynamics modeling method is used to establish a subsystem functional association model for each key node; Integration of multi-dimensional system status information: Map the multi-dimensional system status information of the evaluation object to each system layer, and simulate the interaction and function transfer between each system layer; Functional multi-layer model establishment and evaluation: Establish a system functional multi-layer model with inter-layer connections to evaluate and determine the key impact chain and system resilience.
5. The protection scheme decision method according to claim 4, characterized in that: The system functional component confirmation step comprises: Physical association identification: Identify the physical connections between systems and assess their association; Key location identification: Based on the geographical layout and interdependence of the nodes in the urban system, key node locations are identified in the functional model of the urban system; Network association identification: Identify key communication nodes and control centers based on the role of information and control networks between systems in emergency situations; Establishing logical associations: Establishing logical association models based on the logical relationships and linkage effects between different systems.
6. The protection scheme decision method according to claim 5, characterized in that: The functional multi-layer model establishment and evaluation steps include: Multi-layer model construction: Establish a multi-layer model of system functions that includes system node integrity and functional integrity; Determination of key impact chain system resilience: Determine the key impact chain and system resilience based on the functional interactions and impact paths between the system layers in the system function multi-layer model.
7. The protection scheme decision method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The quantification steps of the key node protection measures of the system include: Confirmation of protection indicators: Refer to industry specifications or standards to determine the protection performance benchmark of each key node, and set specific protection indicators for each key node based on the functional attributes of the key nodes of the system; Quantification of protective measures: Based on the protection indicators of each key node, the structural response of the node is matched according to the key node morphology and material properties from the weapon strike damage effect database. Based on the protection feature data recorded in the database, the quantitative protective measures required to ensure that the key nodes of the system can meet the specified protection standards when hit by weapons under the protection of existing protective measures are evaluated.
8. The protection scheme decision method according to any one of claims 1 to 7, characterized in that: The protection scheme cost-effectiveness evaluation steps include: Protection plan generation: Using Monte Carlo simulation analysis, based on the multi-layer model of system functions and combined with quantitative protection measures for key nodes in the target area after multi-dimensional weapon strikes, multiple protection plans are generated; Evaluation of the effectiveness of protection schemes: Based on the multiple protection schemes, simulate the deployment of protection measures at the key nodes of the urban system function model, and again use the protection characteristics recorded in the explosion damage database to deduce the damage of the nodes under the protection of each protection scheme. Through the multi-layer model of system functions, further evaluate the impact on the functions of the entire urban system. Unify the final protection effect with the data of system function retention, loss reduction ratio, and recovery speed, screen out all feasible schemes that achieve consistent protection effects, and evaluate the protection effectiveness of each scheme according to the degree of impact; Protection cost assessment: Determine the main cost elements in the protection plan, including material cost, construction cost and maintenance and update cost, use decision tree neural network to establish the relationship model between cost elements and total cost, and evaluate the cost elements that have the greatest impact on the total cost.
9. The protection scheme decision method according to claim 8, characterized in that: The protection scheme generating step comprises: Monte Carlo simulation analysis: Monte Carlo simulation is used to analyze the loss distribution under different combinations of attack events; Defining input parameters: According to the basic characteristics of weapons and ammunition, determining the range of strike event parameters as input variables of the decision model, the strike event parameters include the strike quantity, strike equivalent, and strike sequence of weapons and ammunition; Random strike event generation: Using the Monte Carlo method, the decision model generates multiple possible strike events by randomly sampling the strike quantity, strike equivalent, and strike sequence. It uses an iterative calculation method to run multiple simulations for each strike event and calculate the potential loss and protection effectiveness in each case. Protection target strategy selection: according to the importance of key nodes and their role in the system, set priorities and determine the nodes and high-priority protection targets of the urban system; Formulate protection resource allocation strategy: formulate protection resource allocation strategy according to the impact of key nodes in the multi-layer model of system functions and the set protection indicator level; Protection plan acquisition: For each attack event, key system nodes and protection resource allocation strategy, a protection plan is formulated in combination with quantitative protection measures; the protection plan includes the protection area, protection location, different combinations of protection measures and implementation sequence.
10. The protection scheme decision method according to claim 9, characterized in that: The optimal protection solution decision-making steps include: Multi-objective optimization: define multi-objective functions, maximize protection effectiveness and minimize protection costs. According to the implementation costs of different protection schemes, use budget constraints, implementation events, and the availability of materials and human resources as model constraints. Obtain multiple protection strategy combinations through random generation or heuristic methods. Sort each solution in the solution set, identify solutions that cannot be dominated by other solutions, and form a Pareto frontier. Further sort the solutions on the Pareto frontier, identify the non-dominated level of each solution, and obtain the Pareto solution set. Multi-criteria decision-making: Based on the Pareto solution set, the weight of each criterion is set according to the decision maker's goals or resources; Selection of the optimal protection plan: Multi-criteria decision analysis is used to dynamically evaluate the weighted ratio scores of each plan under different standards, and the optimal protection plan is determined based on actual protection needs.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Target system analysis and weapon distribution method for joint operations
CN106203870A
Ground engineering target damage assessment system and method
CN110119580A
Typical target vulnerability damage assessment method and system
CN114492170A
