Seismic Strengthening Design Method for Existing Frame Structures Based on Toughness Indicators
By using a design method based on toughness indices, grouping components and quantifying engineering requirements parameters, and combining finite element analysis and reinforcement design, the problem of missing toughness indices in the seismic reinforcement of existing frame structures was solved, thereby improving the safety and functional recovery capabilities of the structure.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202611603337.0
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-10-16
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-17
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies have failed to effectively incorporate toughness indicators in the seismic reinforcement design of existing frame structures, making it difficult to achieve seismic damage control and rapid post-earthquake functional recovery. Furthermore, existing methods are mostly used for new structures and are difficult to apply directly to existing buildings.
By using a design method based on toughness indices, components are grouped and engineering requirements parameters are quantified. Combined with finite element analysis and reinforcement design, differentiated reinforcement of structural and non-structural components is achieved to ensure the target values of inter-story drift angle and floor acceleration. A scientific reinforcement process is established, and adjustments are made step by step to meet the toughness index requirements.
To improve the seismic toughness of existing frame structures, reduce post-earthquake repair costs and time, lower the risk of casualties, and ensure the rapid restoration of structural safety and functionality.
Smart Images

Figure CN123116731A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention relates to the field of seismic reinforcement technology for building structures, specifically to a seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on toughness indices. Background Technology
[0002] Earthquakes are a significant natural disaster threatening the structural safety of buildings. Traditional seismic design relies on strength and ductility principles, allowing structural plastic deformation to dissipate seismic energy. However, this often results in substantial component damage and residual deformation after an earthquake, disrupting building functionality and incurring high post-earthquake repair costs. With the increasing societal demand for rapid post-earthquake restoration of building functionality, "recoverable seismic-resistant structures" have become a crucial research direction in seismic engineering. By rationally utilizing mechanisms such as swaying, self-resetting, replaceability, and energy dissipation, damage is concentrated in replaceable energy-dissipating components or parts, thereby protecting the main structure and enabling it to be repaired without damage or quickly.
[0003] Current seismic design methods primarily focus on controlling deformation indices such as inter-story drift angles to ensure structural safety under seismic loads. However, they lack a systematic quantitative assessment of the structure's post-earthquake functional recovery capabilities. In recent years, seismic toughness-based design methods have begun to incorporate repair costs, functional losses, repair time, injury rates, and mortality rates as indicators for evaluating building seismic performance. Existing toughness design methods are mostly used for the design of new structures or for toughness assessments after structural design is completed. These methods have not yet fully integrated the existing load-bearing capacity of frame structures, nor have they established a complete implementation process for progressively converting toughness targets into reinforcement parameters for structural and non-structural components.
[0004] Therefore, there is an urgent need for a seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on resilience indices. This method would integrate the concept of seismic resilience into the entire reinforcement design process, simultaneously improve the seismic performance of structural and non-structural components through reasonable reinforcement measures, effectively control seismic damage to the structure and rapidly restore its post-earthquake function, and provide a scientific and systematic design basis for the seismic resilience reinforcement of existing frame structures. Summary of the Invention
[0005] The present invention aims to overcome the shortcomings of the prior art and provide a seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on toughness index, which organically combines the quantification of seismic toughness with the reinforcement design scheme to improve the seismic toughness level of existing frame structures.
[0006] To achieve the above objectives, the technical solution adopted by the present invention is as follows: A seismic strengthening design method for existing frame structures based on resilience indices includes the following steps: S1. Determine the target resilience level based on the building's functional category, subsequent service life, and building importance level, and then determine the limits for repair cost indicators, repair time indicators, and personnel casualty indicators. S2. Group the components and establish a quantitative relationship between toughness indices and engineering requirement parameters; S3. Determine the target value of the inter-story drift angle; S4. Based on the target value of the inter-story drift angle, design reinforcement for structural members and displacement-sensitive non-structural members; S5. Establish a finite element model of the reinforced structure, analyze the distribution of peak acceleration along the height of the structure on each floor, and determine the target value of floor acceleration. S6. Based on the actual acceleration requirements of each floor or the target acceleration value of the floor, carry out reinforcement design for acceleration-sensitive non-structural components; S7. Conduct a seismic toughness assessment of the overall reinforced structure; S8. Determine whether the various indicators calculated in step S7 meet the target limits determined in step S1. If they do, complete the reinforcement design. If they do not, adjust the target value of the inter-story drift angle and the target value of the floor acceleration, and repeat steps S3 to S7 until the target limits are met.
[0007] Preferably, step S2 is completed through the following steps: S21. The components of a building structure are divided into structural components (S-PSD), displacement-sensitive non-structural components (NS-PSD), and acceleration-sensitive non-structural components (NS-PFA). S22. Select inter-story drift angle and floor acceleration as engineering requirement parameters; S23. Establish the relationship between component loss and engineering requirement parameters based on the component vulnerability database; S24. Combining floor location, workload, repair sequence, and number of personnel, summarize the relationship between building resilience indicators and engineering requirement parameters.
[0008] Preferably, step S3 is completed through the following steps: S31. Based on the proportion of repair costs for each component under extreme conditions, allocate the total building repair cost index to the S-PSD, NS-PSD, and NS-PFA component groups. S32. Based on the relationship between the component losses of the S-PSD component group and the NS-PSD component group and the engineering requirement parameters, calculate the corresponding inter-story drift angle limits respectively. S33. Take the smaller value among the inter-story drift angle limits as the inter-story drift angle target value, and verify whether the repair time index and personnel casualty index under the inter-story drift angle target value meet the target limits.
[0009] Preferably, step S4 is completed through the following steps: S41. Identify the weak points of the existing frame structure through finite element analysis or building inspection and appraisal reports. The weak points include inter-story deformation concentration layers, components with insufficient load-bearing capacity, locations with abrupt stiffness changes, weak connections, and unfavorable structures. S42. For structures that do not meet performance requirements, reinforcement shall be carried out by means of energy dissipation and vibration damping devices and / or self-resetting swing walls. S43. For components that do not meet performance requirements, local reinforcement shall be carried out by increasing the cross-section, encasing them in steel plates and / or adding walls. S44. After reinforcement design, check the reserve of reset force, the replaceability of energy-consuming components, and the load-bearing capacity of structural components.
[0010] Furthermore, step S4 also includes: S45. Based on the inter-story deformation response of the reinforced structure, design reinforcement measures for displacement-sensitive non-structural components such as partition walls, infill walls, curtain walls, stairs, doors and windows, including connection, gap, sliding, and flexible construction.
[0011] Preferably, the method for determining step S5 is as follows: A finite element model of the reinforced structure is established to analyze the distribution of peak acceleration along the height of the structure on each floor, and the target value of floor acceleration for the corresponding floor is determined based on the peak acceleration of each floor.
[0012] Preferably, step S6 is completed through the following steps: Based on the actual acceleration requirements of each floor, identify ceiling, equipment, and pipeline supports, etc. Identify the weak points of acceleration-sensitive non-structural components and design anchoring, limiting, supporting, vibration isolation, damping, or replacement of these components according to the target floor's acceleration spectrum.
[0013] Preferably, step S7 is completed through the following steps: S71. Establish a finite element model of the overall reinforced structure and conduct seismic response analysis to obtain the structural engineering requirements parameters; S72. Determine the damage status of components based on their vulnerability; calculate repair cost indicators, repair time indicators, and personnel casualty indicators based on the damage status of components.
[0014] Preferably, in step S8, when the repair cost index, repair time index, and personnel casualty index all meet the corresponding target limits, it is determined that the reinforced structure meets the toughness target; when any of the indicators does not meet the corresponding target limits, the inter-story drift angle target value and the floor acceleration target value are adjusted, and steps S3 to S7 are executed again.
[0015] Compared with the prior art, the beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: 1. This invention balances the safety of the frame structure with functional restoration. The reinforcement performance targets cover three resilience indicators: repair cost, repair time, and casualty rate. It integrates the concept of resilience throughout the entire process of existing frame reinforcement design, shifting the focus from "ensuring no collapse" to "rapid functional restoration after an earthquake." This helps reduce the risk of injury caused by post-earthquake unavailability, prolonged shutdown, and secondary disasters.
[0016] 2. This invention is adapted to the existing conditions of existing buildings, fully considering the existing load-bearing capacity of the frame structure. It first utilizes the inter-story drift angle target to reinforce the main structural components, and then uses the actual inter-story deformation and acceleration response after reinforcement to complete the reinforcement design of displacement-sensitive and acceleration-sensitive non-structural components, avoiding the failure of the original non-structural design after changes in the stiffness of the main structure. This overcomes the shortcoming of existing toughness methods, which are mostly used for new buildings and difficult to directly apply to the reinforcement of existing buildings.
[0017] 3. Differentiate reinforcement of two types of non-structural components: Components are divided into displacement-sensitive and acceleration-sensitive types. The main structure and infill walls are controlled by inter-story drift angle, while the ceiling and mechanical and electrical equipment are controlled by floor acceleration. The earthquake damage of both main and non-structural components is managed simultaneously, which greatly reduces the cost of post-earthquake repair and shortens the repair cycle.
[0018] 4. This invention can be used for seismic toughness retrofitting of existing reinforced concrete frame buildings such as schools, hospitals, and office buildings, providing a systematic and quantitative design basis for seismic reinforcement of such projects. Attached Figure Description
[0019] To more clearly illustrate the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention or the prior art, the drawings used in the description of the embodiments or the prior art will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the drawings described below are only some embodiments of the present invention. For those skilled in the art, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without creative effort.
[0020] Figure 1 This is a flowchart illustrating the seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on toughness indices, as described in this invention. Detailed Implementation
[0021] The preferred embodiments of the present invention will now be described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings, so that the advantages and features of the present invention can be more easily understood by those skilled in the art, thereby providing a clearer and more explicit definition of the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0022] like Figure 1As shown, this paper discloses a seismic strengthening design method for existing frame structures based on toughness indices, including the following steps: S1. Determine the target resilience level based on the building's functional category, subsequent service life, and building importance level, and then determine the limits for repair cost indicators, repair time indicators, and personnel casualty indicators. S2. Group the components and establish a quantitative relationship between toughness indices and engineering requirement parameters. This is accomplished through the following steps: S21. The components of a building structure are divided into structural components (S-PSD), displacement-sensitive non-structural components (NS-PSD), and acceleration-sensitive non-structural components (NS-PFA). S22. Select inter-story drift angle and floor acceleration as engineering requirement parameters; S23. Establish the relationship between component loss and engineering requirement parameters based on the component vulnerability database; S24. Combining floor location, workload, repair sequence, and number of personnel, summarize the relationship between building resilience indicators and engineering requirement parameters.
[0023] S3. Determine the target value of the inter-story drift angle, which is accomplished through the following steps: S31. Based on the proportion of repair costs for each component under extreme conditions, allocate the total building repair cost index to the S-PSD, NS-PSD, and NS-PFA component groups. S32. Based on the relationship between the component losses of the S-PSD component group and the NS-PSD component group and the engineering requirement parameters, calculate the corresponding inter-story drift angle limits respectively. S33. Take the smaller value among the inter-story drift angle limits as the inter-story drift angle target value, and verify whether the repair time index and personnel casualty index under the inter-story drift angle target value meet the target limits.
[0024] S4. Based on the target value of the inter-story drift angle, perform reinforcement design for structural members and displacement-sensitive non-structural members. The reinforcement design process mainly includes the following steps. S41. Identify the weak points of the existing frame structure through finite element analysis or building inspection and appraisal reports. The weak points include inter-story deformation concentration layers, components with insufficient load-bearing capacity, locations with abrupt stiffness changes, weak connections, and unfavorable structures. S42. For structures that do not meet performance requirements, reinforcement shall be carried out by means of energy dissipation and vibration damping devices and / or self-resetting swing walls. S43. For components that do not meet performance requirements, local reinforcement shall be carried out by increasing the cross-section, encasing them in steel plates and / or adding walls. S44. After reinforcement design, check the reserve of reset force, the replaceability of energy-consuming components, and the load-bearing capacity of structural components.
[0025] Furthermore, the reinforcement design process in step S4 also includes: S45, based on the inter-story deformation response of the reinforced structure, performing connection, gap, slip, and flexible structure reinforcement design on displacement-sensitive non-structural components such as partition walls, infill walls, curtain walls, stairs, doors and windows.
[0026] S5. Establish a finite element model of the reinforced structure, analyze the distribution of peak acceleration along the height of the structure at each floor, and determine the target value of the floor acceleration. The method for determining the target value is as follows: A finite element model of the reinforced structure is established to analyze the distribution of peak acceleration along the height of the structure on each floor, and the target value of floor acceleration for the corresponding floor is determined based on the peak acceleration of each floor.
[0027] S6. Based on the actual acceleration requirements of each floor or the target acceleration value of the floor, conduct reinforcement design for acceleration-sensitive non-structural components. The implementation process includes: Based on the actual acceleration requirements of each floor, identify ceiling, equipment, and pipeline supports, etc. For weak points in acceleration-sensitive non-structural components, design anchoring, limiting, supporting, vibration isolation, damping, or replacement of the acceleration-sensitive non-structural components according to the acceleration spectrum of the target floor.
[0028] S7. Conduct a seismic toughness assessment of the overall reinforced structure, which is completed through the following steps; S71. Establish a finite element model of the overall reinforced structure and conduct seismic response analysis to obtain the structural engineering requirements parameters; S72. Determine the damage status of components based on their vulnerability; calculate repair cost indicators, repair time indicators, and personnel casualty indicators based on the damage status of components.
[0029] S8. Determine whether the various indicators calculated in step S7 meet the target limits determined in step S1. If they do, complete the reinforcement design. If they do not, adjust the target value of the inter-story drift angle and the target value of the floor acceleration, and repeat steps S3 to S7 until the target limits are met.
[0030] The above description is merely a specific embodiment of the present invention, but the scope of protection of the present invention is not limited thereto. Any changes or substitutions conceived without inventive effort should be included within the scope of protection of the present invention. Therefore, the scope of protection of the present invention should be determined by the scope defined in the claims.
Claims
1. A seismic strengthening design method for existing frame structures based on resilience indices, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: S1. Determine the target resilience level based on the building's functional category, subsequent service life, and building importance level, and then determine the limits for repair cost indicators, repair time indicators, and personnel casualty indicators. S2. Group the components and establish a quantitative relationship between toughness indices and engineering requirement parameters; S3. Determine the target value of the inter-story drift angle; S4. Based on the target value of the inter-story drift angle, design reinforcement for structural members and displacement-sensitive non-structural members; S5. Establish a finite element model of the reinforced structure, analyze the distribution of peak acceleration along the height of the structure on each floor, and determine the target value of floor acceleration. S6. Based on the actual acceleration requirements of each floor or the target acceleration value of the floor, carry out reinforcement design for acceleration-sensitive non-structural components; S7. Conduct a seismic toughness assessment of the overall reinforced structure; S8. Determine whether the various indicators calculated in step S7 meet the target limits determined in step S1. If they do, complete the reinforcement design. If they do not, adjust the target value of the inter-story drift angle and the target value of the floor acceleration, and repeat steps S3 to S7 until the target limits are met.
2. The seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on toughness indices according to claim 1, characterized in that, Step S2 is completed through the following steps: S21. The components of a building structure are divided into structural components, displacement-sensitive non-structural components, and acceleration-sensitive non-structural components, denoted as S-PSD, NS-PSD, and NS-PFA, respectively. S22. Select inter-story drift angle and floor acceleration as engineering requirement parameters; S23. Establish the relationship between component loss and engineering requirement parameters based on the component vulnerability database; S24. Combining floor location, workload, repair sequence, and number of personnel, summarize the relationship between building resilience indicators and engineering requirement parameters.
3. The seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on toughness indices according to claim 1, characterized in that, Step S3 is completed through the following steps: S31. Based on the proportion of repair costs for each component under extreme conditions, allocate the total building repair cost index to the S-PSD, NS-PSD, and NS-PFA component groups. S32. Based on the relationship between the component losses of the S-PSD component group and the NS-PSD component group and the engineering requirement parameters, calculate the corresponding inter-story drift angle limits respectively. S33. Take the smaller value among the inter-story drift angle limits as the inter-story drift angle target value, and verify whether the repair time index and personnel casualty index under the inter-story drift angle target value meet the target limits.
4. The seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on toughness indices according to claim 1, characterized in that, Step S4 is completed through the following steps: S41. Identify the weak points of the existing frame structure through finite element analysis or building inspection and appraisal reports. The weak points include inter-story deformation concentration layers, components with insufficient load-bearing capacity, locations with abrupt stiffness changes, weak connections, and unfavorable structures. S42. For structures that do not meet performance requirements, reinforcement shall be carried out by means of energy dissipation and vibration damping devices and / or self-resetting swing walls. S43. For components that do not meet performance requirements, local reinforcement shall be carried out by increasing the cross-section, encasing them in steel plates and / or adding walls. S44. After reinforcement design, check the reserve of reset force, the replaceability of energy-consuming components, and the load-bearing capacity of structural components.
5. The seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on toughness indices according to claim 1, characterized in that, Step S4 further includes: S45. Based on the inter-story deformation response of the reinforced structure, design reinforcement measures for displacement-sensitive non-structural components such as partition walls, infill walls, curtain walls, stairs, doors and windows, including connection, gap, sliding, and flexible construction.
6. The seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on toughness indices according to claim 1, characterized in that, The method for determining step S5 is as follows: A finite element model of the reinforced structure is established to analyze the distribution of peak acceleration along the height of the structure on each floor, and the target value of floor acceleration for the corresponding floor is determined based on the peak acceleration of each floor.
7. Seismic reinforcement of existing frame structures based on toughness index as described in claim 1 The design method, characterized in that, Step S6 includes: Based on the actual acceleration requirements of each floor, identify ceiling, equipment, and pipeline supports, etc. For weak points in acceleration-sensitive non-structural components, design anchoring, limiting, supporting, vibration isolation, damping, or replacement of the acceleration-sensitive non-structural components according to the acceleration spectrum of the target floor.
8. The seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on toughness indices according to claim 1, characterized in that, Step S7 is completed through the following steps: S71. Establish a finite element model of the overall reinforced structure and conduct seismic response analysis to obtain the structural engineering requirements parameters; S72. Determine the damage status of components based on their vulnerability; calculate repair cost indicators, repair time indicators, and personnel casualty indicators based on the damage status of components.
9. The seismic reinforcement design method for existing frame structures based on toughness indices according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S8, if the repair cost index, repair time index, and casualty index all meet the corresponding target limits, the reinforced structure is determined to meet the toughness target; if any of the indicators does not meet the corresponding target limits, the inter-story drift angle target value and the floor acceleration target value are adjusted, and steps S3 to S7 are executed again.
