METHOD AND COMPUTER PROGRAM PRODUCT FOR MONITORING AN AIRCRAFT PURIFICATION SYSTEM
Patent Information
- Application Number
- DE502021005774
- Authority / Receiving Office
- DE · DE
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-03-10
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-03-10
AI Technical Summary
Bleed air supply systems in aircraft have low reliability due to numerous mechanical components, leading to frequent failures and complex troubleshooting, with existing monitoring methods only checking against threshold values and not providing detailed fault information, resulting in unnecessary system deactivation and increased wear on redundant systems.
A method using at least two analog sensors to monitor the bleed air supply system by determining map point clouds from simultaneously recorded sensor data and comparing them to a characteristic curve, issuing warnings for deviations beyond a specified level, allowing for precise evaluation of dynamic states and identification of worn components.
This approach improves error diagnosis and prognosis by enabling detailed monitoring of bleed air supply systems, reducing unnecessary deactivations, and allowing for proactive replacement of worn components, thereby enhancing system reliability and reducing maintenance complexities.
Description
[0001] The invention relates to a method and a computer program product for monitoring a bleed air supply system of an aircraft.
[0002] In aircraft, especially commercial aircraft, compressed air is bleeded from an engine's turbocompressor to create or maintain a desired pressure in a pressurized cabin or in the aircraft's pneumatic systems. The engines can be jet engines, propeller turbines, or auxiliary power units (APUs). It is common practice for each engine of an aircraft to be equipped with a separate bleed air supply system, among other things to ensure redundancy.
[0003] Bleed air is extracted from an engine by a bleed air supply system and supplied to the various consumers. The bleed air supply system generally comprises various actuators, in particular controllable or self-regulating valves, pressure and temperature sensors or transducers, and, if required, a control unit that can actuate the actuators depending on the measured pressure and temperature values, as well as external control signals. It is also possible to dispense with a control unit, in which case purely pneumatic control of the individual actuators can be implemented. In both cases, in addition to maintaining a desired operating pressure, the temperature of the compressed air supplied to the various consumers can also be controlled.
[0004] Bleed air supply systems are characterized by low reliability due to their numerous mechanical components, especially when controlled purely pneumatically. If a malfunction occurs, the bleed air supply system must always be shut down for safety reasons, even though frequent failures can sometimes cause significant disruptions to the operation of an aircraft, especially a commercial aircraft.
[0005] To detect malfunctions in a bleed air supply system during a flight, the values determined by the pressure and temperature sensors of the bleed air supply system can be monitored. However, the current technology typically only checks these values against predefined thresholds, sometimes with lengthy confirmation times. If a measured value in such a system exceeds a threshold, the entire bleed air supply system is deactivated as a precautionary measure. This form of monitoring neither allows for consideration of the dynamic behavior of the components nor for an active assessment of the condition of the bleed air system.
[0006] Even if this monitoring of the bleed air supply system is capable of detecting possible faults in the bleed air supply system and deactivating the system if necessary, the monitoring devices known from the state of the art do not provide detailed information on the possible cause of a fault in the bleed air supply system in the fault messages, so that a fault regularly requires complex troubleshooting and rectification measures.
[0007] Deactivating bleed air supply systems in the event of malfunctions also has the disadvantage that when one system is deactivated, the aircraft's other bleed air supply systems must also provide the bleed air from the deactivated bleed air supply system, which increases wear and tear and also the risk of failure of the other bleed air supply systems.
[0008] Document US 9,555,903 B2 describes a method for diagnosing malfunctions in the bleed air supply system. This method involves reading various sensors located on the bleed air supply system and checking the respective sensor data for deviations from reference values. The reference values can be fixed values, parameters determined from operating parameters of the engine and the associated bleed air supply system, (average) values determined in the past for the bleed air supply system in question, or average values determined in the past for all bleed air supply systems in a series.
[0009] The interpretation of any detected deviations can be carried out for each flight phase, for example, separately for the takeoff, climb, descent, and cruise phases. In individual cases, certain deviations of the sensor values from the reference values in specified flight phases can then be attributed to specific malfunctions in the bleed air supply system. On the other hand, for example, insufficient pressure in the climb or cruise phase cannot actually be clearly attributed to any component or at least to a small group of components. At least in some of the fault reports, even with the method according to US 9,555,903 B2, no actual restriction of the potentially faulty components of the bleed air supply system is carried out, which makes troubleshooting in such a fault situation very complex.
[0010] US2014 / 309846 A1 discloses another system for monitoring a bleed air supply system of an aircraft with two analog sensors.
[0011] The object of the present invention is to provide a method and a computer program product for monitoring a bleed air supply system of an aircraft, which is improved over the prior art.
[0012] This object is achieved by a method according to the main claim and a computer program product or a set of computer program products according to claim 9. Advantageous further developments are the subject of the dependent claims.
[0013] Accordingly, the invention relates to a method for monitoring a bleed air supply system of an aircraft with at least two analog sensors for monitoring the condition of the bleed air supply system based on the sensor data; with the steps: Determining at least one characteristic map point cloud from the simultaneously recorded sensor data from two analog sensors each relating to the condition of the bleed air supply system over a predefined minimum period; comparing the characteristic map point cloud with a predefined characteristic curve for the relationship between the recorded sensor data depicted by the characteristic map point cloud; and if a deviation of the characteristic map point cloud from the predefined characteristic curve is detected beyond a predefined amount: issuing a warning.
[0014] Furthermore, the invention relates to a computer program product or a set of computer program products comprising program parts which, when loaded into a computer or into interconnected computers, are designed to monitor a bleed air supply system of an aircraft with at least two analog sensors for monitoring the condition of the bleed air supply system based on the sensor data according to the method according to the invention.
[0015] First, some terms used in connection with the invention will be explained.
[0016] An "analog sensor" is a sensor that can measure the physical properties of a component or its environment as a quantitative measurement. The measured value is provided as analog or, usually, digital sensor data. Typical examples of analog sensors are pressure sensors, temperature sensors, or absolute encoders. The opposite of an "analog sensor" is a "binary sensor," which, as a condition sensor, can only qualitatively confirm the presence of a specific, defined condition, e.g., whether a valve is closed or not. Corresponding condition information detectable by a binary sensor ("binary sensor data") can also be derived from the sensor data of an analog sensor by comparing the quantitative sensor data with a limit value, e.g., by comparing the valve position detected by an absolute encoder with a limit value to determine whether the valve is closed.
[0017] In a "characteristic map," correlations between sensor data from two different analog sensors can be mapped. Measurements taken by both analog sensors at the same time can be mapped as points, with the measured values as coordinates. If several corresponding points are mapped in a characteristic map over time, a "characteristic map point cloud" is created.
[0018] A target relationship can be specified for sensor data from two different analog sensors in the form of a "characteristic curve." A corresponding characteristic curve typically represents the relationship between the sensor data from two analog sensors that can generally be expected during fault-free operation. The characteristic curve can be derived from a theoretical model of the bleed air supply system or from historical data from one or more identical bleed air supply systems. The characteristic curve can be mapped using mathematical functions—possibly in sections—or by a polygon defined by pairs of coordinates.
[0019] The invention has recognized that fault diagnosis and fault prognosis in a bleed air supply system can be significantly improved if, instead of the temporal observation of individual state values of a bleed air supply system known from the prior art, one uses one or more characteristic maps each consisting of sensor data from two analog sensors that monitor the state of the bleed air supply system. Depending on the choice of analog sensors for a specific characteristic map, different components and / or different functions of the components of the bleed air supply system can be monitored. In particular, dynamic states of the bleed air supply system, which are practically impossible to evaluate when considering measured values in the time series, can be easily evaluated using the characteristic maps. This enables precise monitoring, in particular of the valves of the bleed air supply system that are particularly subject to wear.
[0020] The analog sensors used for this purpose can be directly assigned to the bleed air supply system. However, it is also possible for an analog sensor to be located in an aircraft component upstream or downstream of the bleed air supply system, e.g., the engine. The only important thing is that the analog sensor records a measured value that directly influences the bleed air supply system, e.g., the pressure prevailing in the engine near a bleed air supply system bleed point.
[0021] A characteristic map point cloud determined by the analog sensors can vary significantly depending on the operating state of the bleed air valve or the aircraft, particularly its engine. The characteristic map point cloud can change depending on the position of different valves of the bleed air valve and / or the engine speed. To still enable simple evaluation of the characteristic maps, e.g., by comparing them with a characteristic curve, it is preferred to determine operating-state-dependent characteristic maps, with the operating state of the bleed air supply system being specified by a control unit of the bleed air supply system or the aircraft and / or being determined by condition sensors on the bleed air supply system or the aircraft.
[0022] If the bleed air supply system comprises at least one pressure control valve, it may be preferable for its activation state to indicate different operating states, for which different characteristic maps are determined. The activation state can, in particular, be a binary indication, e.g., whether a specific valve is blocked. The binary blocking state is binary sensor data.
[0023] In bleed air supply systems, air is often bleed from at least two different pressure stages of an engine's compressor, with a separate pressure control valve being provided at at least one bleed point. The binary blocking state of this separate pressure control valve can indicate different operating states of the bleed air supply system.
[0024] It is also possible for one or more characteristic maps (including operating-state-dependent ones) to be parameter-dependent, i.e., in addition to the two sensor data to be correlated, at least one additional parameter is taken into account in the characteristic point cloud and the specified characteristic curve. The at least one additional parameter can preferably be a parameter measured by an analog sensor for monitoring the condition of the bleed air supply system or the environment, or a non-binary operating state value of the aircraft.
[0025] The parameter for parameter-dependent maps can, for example, be the flow rate through the bleed air supply system measured by a dedicated analog sensor and / or the air temperature measured by a dedicated analog sensor in the bleed air supply system or in the engine. The target engine speed specified by the control system or the pressure measured or derived from other variables in specified areas within the engine or in the environment can also be used as a parameter. Bleed air consumption and the associated requirements for the bleed air supply system can also be considered as a parameter.
[0026] Preferably, characteristic map point clouds are determined over discrete, non-overlapping time periods, so that a trend analysis can be performed using two or more characteristic map point clouds for different time periods. A corresponding trend analysis can map signs of wear on components of the bleed air supply system and proactively replace any worn component before a wear-related failure of the component and, if applicable, the entire bleed air supply system occurs. The time periods can be selected based on actual flights performed by the aircraft, i.e., from the start-up of the engines before takeoff to the shutdown of the engines after landing. It is also possible for a time period to extend over several corresponding flights.
[0027] Any detected deviations of the map point cloud from the specified characteristic curve can also be classified. It has been shown that different changes in a map point cloud that lead to deviations from the corresponding characteristic curve indicate different wear phenomena and / or faults, possibly in a specific component. By classifying the detected deviation, the actual cause of the fault can often be identified directly.
[0028] It is preferred if the bleed air supply system comprises at least one analog pressure sensor, the sensor data of which is recorded and taken into account when determining the characteristic map point cloud. In particular, at least two analog pressure sensors can be provided at different locations in the bleed air supply system, the sensor data of which together form a characteristic map point cloud.
[0029] The method can be implemented in the computer program product or set of computer program products according to the invention. An expert system can be provided for the possible classification of detected deviations.
[0030] The invention will now be described by way of example using an advantageous embodiment with reference to the accompanying drawings. They show: Figure 1: a detailed representation of a bleed air system designed to carry out the method according to the invention; Figure 2: a schematic representation of the bleed air system from Figure 1; Figures 3a, b: a first example of a characteristic map checked in the method according to the invention; Figures 4a, b: a second example of a characteristic map checked in the method according to the invention; Figure 5: exemplary representations of classifiable deviations from a first predetermined characteristic curve; and Figures 6a, b: exemplary representations of classifiable deviations from a second predetermined characteristic curve.
[0031] In Figure 1 and 2 a bleed air supply system 10 designed to carry out the method according to the invention is shown on the engine 1 of an aircraft (not shown), wherein Figure 1 shows the bleed air supply system 10 structurally on the engine 1, while Figure 2 a schematic functional sketch of the bleed air supply system 10 exclusively to the extent relevant for carrying out the method according to the invention.
[0032] The bleed air supply system 10 has two bleed points 11, 12 in the area of the compressor stages of the engine 1, wherein one bleed point 11 is arranged in the area of the outlet of the high-pressure compressor of the engine 1, while the other bleed point 12 is arranged in a region of the engine 1 with lower pressure.
[0033] A first control valve 13, the high-pressure valve, is assigned to the bleed point 11 in the area of the outlet of the high-pressure compressor of engine 1. The outlet of the valve is connected to the bleed point 12. The bleed point 12 and the outlet of the high-pressure valve 14 are connected to another control valve 15, the pressure control valve. From there, the bleed air passes through a heat exchanger 15, if necessary (see Fig. Figure 1 ) to cool the bleed air to the consumers or into a compressed air supply network (not shown).
[0034] The control valves 13, 14 can be self-regulating valves or valves actively controlled by a control unit (not shown) via control lines (not shown). In both cases, the bleed air supply is generally dependent on, among other things, the operating state of engine 1 and the air requirements of the consumers connected directly or via a compressed air supply network.
[0035] To monitor the bleed air supply system 10, a monitoring unit 20 is provided, which comprises a computer loaded with a computer program product according to the invention. The monitoring unit 20 can be located directly on the bleed air supply system 10, remotely on board the aircraft, or outside the aircraft on the ground. In the latter case, the necessary data is transmitted via a radio link.
[0036] The monitoring unit 20 comprises several inputs 21 for analog and binary sensor data, as well as operating status information from engine 1, and an output 22 for issuing any warnings. Any warnings generated by the monitoring unit 20 can, for example, be displayed in the cockpit of the aircraft or forwarded to a maintenance company, which can then prepare the maintenance of the bleed air system. Alternatively or additionally, graphical map displays, such as those used in Figures 3 to 6 shown, for further inspection by a maintenance technician.
[0037] Binary sensors 16, 17 are arranged at the valves 13, 14 at the inputs 21. Binary sensor 16 assigned to the high-pressure valve 13 indicates the blocking position of the high-pressure valve 13 and outputs a logical "yes" as sensor data when the high-pressure valve 13 is fully closed. The sensor data of binary sensor 17 on the pressure control valve 14 is a logical "yes" when the pressure control valve 14 is fully open.
[0038] In addition, two analog pressure sensors 18, 19 are connected to the inputs of the monitoring unit 20. The analog pressure sensor 18 measures the pressure in the supply line upstream of the pressure control valve 14, while the analog pressure sensor 19 measures the regulated pressure downstream of the pressure control valve 14.
[0039] The monitoring unit 20 is further connected via a data line 23 to a control and / or monitoring unit (not shown) of the engine 1 and / or the aircraft and receives further operating data and operating parameters of the engine 1 and / or the aircraft from there. In the example shown, the relative overpressure compared to the ambient air within the engine in the area of the bleed point 11, i.e., downstream of the high-pressure compressor of the engine 1, is fed to the monitoring unit 20 via the data line 23 as analog sensor data. Furthermore, the air temperatures at various points on the engine 1 can also be fed to the monitoring unit 20 via the data line 23; these temperatures can be considered as additional parameters in the characteristic map determination described below.
[0040] Depending on the operating states of the bleed air supply system 1 readable by the binary sensors 16, 17, different characteristic maps are used.
[0041] If engine 1 is idling, so that bleed air with sufficient pressure is not available at bleed point 12, the bleed point 11 downstream of the high-pressure compressor of engine 1 is used, where sufficient pressure for the bleed air supply exists even when engine 1 is idling. In this case, in the illustrated embodiment, the pressure control valve 14 is fully opened, and pressure control is achieved solely by appropriately controlling the high-pressure valve 13.
[0042] In this operating state, binary sensor 16 reports a logical "no" to monitoring unit 20 (the high-pressure valve 13 is at least not fully closed), while binary sensor 17 outputs a logical "yes" because the pressure control valve 14 is fully open in this operating state. Based on the sensor data from the two binary sensors 16, 17, monitoring unit 20 can determine the operating state of bleed air system 10 intended for idle operation of engine 1.
[0043] For this operating state, the characteristic map is intended to map the pressure in the supply line to the pressure control valve 14 as a function of the overpressure prevailing in the area of the bleed point 11 in the engine 1 compared to the ambient pressure. The pressure in the supply line to the pressure control valve 14 is detected by the analog pressure sensor 18, while the pressure in question inside the engine 1, which corresponds to the pressure downstream of the high-pressure compressor, is available as analog sensor data via the data line 23. The latter sensor data is detected by an analog sensor in the engine 1. The individual measured values are time-coded, so that value pairs 31 can be formed from measured values recorded at the same time from the sensor data, which then results in a characteristic value point cloud 30.
[0044] In Figure 3aA corresponding characteristic value point cloud 30 consisting of a plurality of value pairs 31 is shown as an example. The x-axis represents the overpressure relative to the ambient at the tapping point 11, and the y-axis represents the pressure detected by the analog pressure sensor 18.
[0045] For the same relationship, an operating condition-dependent characteristic curve 35 is provided, which depicts the ideal dependence of the two values considered.
[0046] As in Figure 3a As can be seen, taking into account typical measurement inaccuracies and tolerances, there is sufficient agreement between the characteristic point cloud 30 and the characteristic curve 35, so that no warning needs to be issued in the example shown. The monitoring unit 20 is designed to perform precisely this check, although in this case, no warning is issued via output 22.
[0047] In Figure 3b is one to Figure 3aIdentically determined and displayed characteristic value point cloud 30 is shown, whereby due to the considerable scatter of the value pairs 31 at higher pressures at the tapping point 11 (x-axis), a considerable deviation from the characteristic curve 35 can be detected - also by the monitoring unit 20 - so that a warning can be issued via the output 22. The Figure 3b The deviation shown indicates faulty behavior of valve 16, so troubleshooting can be limited to valve 16 (e.g., mechanical wear or leaks) or its control. More detailed statements about the cause of the error based solely on the detected deviations can be made, if necessary, by comparing them with previous similar deviations and their respective causes.
[0048] During the actual flight of the aircraft, engine 1 is no longer idling, and the bleed air supply system 10 is also in a different operating state. In this state, sufficient pressure is regularly present at the bleed point 12 for the bleed air supply, so that the high-pressure valve 13 is completely closed and pressure control is carried out exclusively via the pressure control valve 14. The operating state can again be determined by the monitoring unit 20 solely via the sensor data from the binary sensors 16, 17, since the binary sensor 16 outputs a logical yes for a fully closed high-pressure valve 13, and the binary sensor 17 outputs a logical no for a partially open pressure control valve 14.
[0049] For this operating state, the characteristic map is intended to map the pressure downstream of the pressure control valve 14 as a function of the pressure upstream of the pressure control valve 14. The former pressure is detected by the analog pressure sensor 19, while the pressure in the supply line to the pressure control valve 14 is detected by the analog pressure sensor 18. The individual measured values are each recorded simultaneously, so that value pairs 31 can be formed from the sensor data measured at the same time, which then results in a characteristic value point cloud 30.
[0050] In Figure 4a A corresponding characteristic value point cloud 30 consisting of a plurality of value pairs 31 is shown as an example. The x-axis represents the pressure upstream of the pressure control valve 14 detected by the analog pressure sensor 18, and the y-axis represents the pressure downstream of the pressure control valve 14 detected by the analog pressure sensor 18.
[0051] A corresponding, predefined characteristic curve 35 for the target dependency of the two values is also Figure 4a shown.
[0052] The deviations of the characteristic point cloud 30 from the characteristic curve 35 in Figure 4a is still within the permissible tolerance range that can be checked by the monitoring unit using known mathematical methods, so that in the example shown no warning needs to be or will be issued.
[0053] In Figure 4b is one to Figure 4a identically determined and displayed characteristic point cloud 30 is shown. In this example, the characteristic point cloud 30 is compared to Figure 4a However, it is shifted significantly "upwards", resulting in a significant deviation from the characteristic curve 35. This deviation is detected by the monitoring unit 20 as exceeding a specified tolerance and consequently a warning is issued via output 22. The Figure 4bThe deviation shown indicates faulty behavior of valve 14, so troubleshooting can be limited to valve 14 (e.g., mechanical wear or leaks) or its control. More detailed statements about the cause of the error based solely on the detected deviations can be made, if necessary, by comparing them with previous similar deviations and their respective causes.
[0054] From certain deviations of a characteristic point cloud 30 from the corresponding characteristic curve 35, conclusions about the type of defect can be drawn directly. The detected deviations are classified for this purpose—for example, directly by the monitoring unit 20. If the classification is sufficiently clear, the monitoring unit 20 can issue a corresponding indication via output 22.
[0055] In Figure 5 is a characteristic point cloud 30 according to Figure 3a , b, where the circled pattern of value pairs 31 allows the conclusion that the binary sensor 16 is defective or is delivering faulty sensor data. If the binary sensor 16 would correctly output a logical yes when the high-pressure valve 13 is actually closed, the value pairs 31 in question, which reflect the pressure control by the pressure control valve 15, would not be included in this characteristic map, as shown in Figure 5 shown (see explanations on the operating status for the Figure 3a ).
[0056] In Figure 6a, b are further examples of classifiable deviations from the characteristic curve 35 for characteristic point clouds 30 according to Figure 4a, b shown.
[0057] The Figure 6a The characteristic point cloud 30 shown indicates that the control of the pressure control valve 14 is not working properly. The characteristic point cloud 30 from Figure 6b indicates a worn pressure control valve 13.
Claims
1. A method for monitoring a bleed air supply system (10) of an aircraft, having - at least two analog sensors (18, 19) for monitoring the state of the bleed air supply system (10) based on the sensor data; having the steps of: - determining at least one characteristic map point cloud (30) from the simultaneously acquired sensor data from two respective analog sensors (18, 19) relating to the state of the bleed air supply system (10) over a predefined minimum period of time; - comparing the characteristic map point cloud (30) with a corresponding predefined characteristic curve (35) for the relationship between the acquired sensor data that is represented by the characteristic map point cloud (30); and - if a deviation of the characteristic map point cloud (30) from the predefined characteristic curve (35) beyond a predefined amount is detected: outputting a warning.
2. The method as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that operating-state-dependent characteristic maps are determined, wherein the operating state of the bleed air supply system (10) is predefined by a control unit of the bleed air supply system (10) or the aircraft and / or is determined by state sensors (16, 17) on the bleed air supply system (10) or on the aircraft.
3. The method as claimed in the preceding claim, characterized in that the bleed air supply system (10) comprises at least one pressure control valve (14), the activation state of which, preferably the binary blocking state of which, characterizes different operating states.
4. The method as claimed in one of the preceding claims, characterized in that parameter-dependent characteristic maps are determined, wherein the parameter preferably represents a by an analog sensor for monitoring the state of the bleed air supply system (10) or the environment or a non-binary operating state value of the aircraft.
5. The method as claimed in the preceding claim, characterized in that parameters for parameter-dependent characteristic maps are the flow rate through the bleed air supply system (10), as recorded by an analog sensor provided for this purpose, and / or the air temperature recorded by an analog sensor provided for this purpose in the bleed air supply system (10) or in the engine (1).
6. The method as claimed in one of the preceding claims, characterized in that at least two characteristic map point clouds (30) are determined over discrete, non-overlapping time periods and a trend analysis is carried out using appropriately recorded characteristic map point clouds (30) for different time periods.
7. The method as claimed in one of the preceding claims, characterized in that detected deviations of the characteristic map point cloud (30) from the predefined characteristic curve (35) are classified.
8. The method as claimed in one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the bleed air supply system (10) comprises at least one analog pressure sensor (18, 19) whose sensor data are acquired and taken into account when determining the characteristic map point cloud (30).
9. A computer program product or set of computer program products comprising program parts which, when loaded into a computer or into computers networked to each other, are designed to monitor a bleed air supply system (10) of an aircraft, having at least two analog sensors (18, 19) for monitoring the state of the bleed air supply system (10) based on the sensor data, according to the method as claimed in one of the preceding claims.
