METHOD FOR CONTROLLING A DRIVE DEVICE OF A FLEXIBLE PROTECTIVE ELEMENT AND DRIVE DEVICE FOR SUCH A FLEXIBLE PROTECTIVE ELEMENT
Patent Information
- Application Number
- DE602022008351
- Authority / Receiving Office
- DE · DE
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2021-09-10
- Filing Date
- 2022-09-09
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-04
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-09-09
AI Technical Summary
Existing drive mechanisms for flexible protective elements, such as canvas or roller shutter aprons, face challenges in maintaining tension when deployed horizontally or at a slight slope, leading to uncontrolled unwinding and potential motor overload due to speed differentials and accordion effects, which can reduce reliability and lifespan.
The method involves periodically modulating the rotation speed of drive motors based on the speed of the flexible protective element, adjusting the voltage to maintain optimal tension by calculating the speed ratio between winding and unwinding control shafts, and applying corrected supply voltages to ensure consistent torque and prevent excessive tension or braking.
This approach ensures constant tension on the flexible protective element, optimizing motor performance and preventing uncontrolled unwinding, thereby enhancing the reliability and lifespan of the drive device while maintaining efficient operation across deployment and folding phases.
Description
[0001] The invention relates to a method for controlling a drive device for a flexible protective element such as a canvas, a strip, a curtain or a roller shutter apron and such a drive device.
[0002] The invention relates to the field of devices for driving a flexible protective element intended to be deployed in a flat or slightly inclined manner above a surface to be protected from solar radiation and / or bad weather and / or cold and / or risk of intrusion.
[0003] Such drive devices generally comprise a flexible protective element designed to extend vertically and a manual or motor-driven mechanism for rotating a winding tube, also called a winding drive shaft, on which this flexible protective element is wound. Depending on the direction of rotation imparted to this tube, the flexible protective element deploys vertically through its weight or folds back by winding itself around the tube.
[0004] However, when this flexible protection element is intended to extend horizontally or with a slight slope above a surface to be protected, deployment can no longer occur under the influence of the weight of the flexible protection element alone. Depending on whether it is defined by a strip of canvas or an apron, this deployment is obtained by means of a shaft with unwinding control acting by traction or thrust on this flexible protection element.
[0005] In this case, in the case of a strip of canvas, this unwinding control shaft acts in a similar manner to the winding tube by being placed, relative to the latter, on the opposite side of the surface above which this strip of canvas is intended to extend. In short, during the deployment phase, this unwinding control shaft is controlled in rotation to ensure the winding of straps acting by traction on the strip of canvas so that it unwinds from the winding tube. Conversely, it is the latter which is controlled in rotation to ensure the folding of the strip of canvas.
[0006] In the case of an apron of the type fitted to a roller shutter, its deployment in a horizontal or low-slope position can be obtained by exerting a thrust on this apron by means of such an unwinding control shaft. This is placed immediately downstream of the winding tube and acts, for example by means of toothed wheels, on the ends of the apron slats equipped, as the case may be, with lugs or drive openings with which these toothed wheels cooperate to successively push these apron slats in the direction of deployment. Obviously, depending on whether the flexible protection element resulting from the drive, respectively, of the unwinding control shaft or the winding tube is being deployed or folded up, the drive mechanism, as the case may be, of the latter or of the unwinding control shaft must be disengaged or at least driven under conditions permitting the maneuver in progress.
[0007] Various solutions, mechanical or motor-driven, have already been developed to address this problem of deploying a flexible protective element horizontally or at a low slope above a surface to be protected.
[0008] In particular, document FR 0.452.120 discloses means for driving the unwinding control shaft in rotation, as well as transmission means connecting the latter to the winding tube and designed to drive the latter according to a variable transmission ratio. These transmission means comprise a reducer designed to transmit a variable speed to the winding tube through the rotational drive means acting on the unwinding control shaft.
[0009] The drive mechanism of a certain complexity described in this document FR 0.452.120 makes it possible to respond to the problem of driving both the winding tube and the unwinding control shaft, taking into account the speed differential of one in relation to the other, whether during the deployment or folding phase of the flexible protection element.
[0010] Indeed, for a given speed of the unwinding control shaft, that of the winding tube tends progressively to accelerate in the deployment phase or, on the contrary, to slow down in the folding phase due to the variation in its section occurring during each of these phases and linked to the number of turns described by the flexible protection element around this winding tube.
[0011] In the case of a winding tube and an unwinding control shaft placed, respectively, on either side of the surface above which the flexible protection element is to extend, it is necessary to keep the latter under tension during the deployment and folding phases to prevent this flexible protection element from unwinding in an uncontrolled manner to one side or the other, through its own weight, gradually falling back into its central part.
[0012] A solution has been provided to this problem through the drive and tensioning device described in document EP 0.645.518. This device comprises means for managing the power supply to the drive motors of the winding tube and the unwinding control shaft. In particular, in a first embodiment, these management means are defined to ensure the operation, at reduced power and in the opposite direction to the operation, of the motor of the winding control shaft or of the unwinding control shaft, depending on whether the motor is in the unwinding or winding phase, respectively. This solution has the consequence of creating a resistive torque with respect to the controlled operation.
[0013] In a second embodiment, these means for managing the power supply to the motors can also be defined to ensure the operation, at reduced speed or power and in the same direction as the operation, of the motor of the winding control shaft or of the unwinding control shaft, depending on whether one is in the unwinding or winding phase, respectively, again with a view to creating a resistive torque with respect to the controlled operation.
[0014] If we take the example of the winding phase of a flexible protection element such as a roller shutter apron, for a given rotation speed of the winding control shaft, there follows a progressively increasing speed of movement of the apron as the turns form around this winding control shaft.
[0015] By choosing in the initial winding phase a rotation speed of the unwinding control shaft for driving the apron at a speed lower than that communicated to it by the winding control shaft, the speed differential tends to gradually increase, as does the braking action provided by the unwinding control shaft.
[0016] This operation is not optimal and systematically leads to oversized power engines.
[0017] When the auxiliary motor experiences a rapid variation in its load or the transfer characteristic of the flexible protective element is changed cyclically, the motor acting as a drive motor may cause an accordion effect which may be detrimental to the reliability and service life of the drive device.
[0018] To overcome this problem, certain motor control methods have been proposed in the state of the art. These methods have the disadvantage of causing the speed of the motor acting as a drive motor to fluctuate around an average value and therefore follow an irregular curve. Some of these control methods primarily vary the speed of the motor acting as a drive motor, which has the disadvantage of addressing the consequences rather than the causes of the disturbances. The amplitude and frequency of the rapid fluctuations in the motor torque depend on the ratio of the winding radii, which changes irregularly during the travel of the flexible protection element.
[0019] If the electric motor acting as the drive motor is already associated with a separate speed control, nothing is provided to compensate for the accordion effect.
[0020] It was within the framework of a first inventive approach that it was imagined to periodically modulate the rotation speed of at least one of the drive motors of the winding and unwinding control shafts as a function of the speed of movement of the flexible protection element.
[0021] More specifically, the instantaneous rotation speed of each motor is periodically measured to compare it with the speed setpoint sent to each of them and the voltage applied to each motor is adjusted accordingly.
[0022] Knowing that the ratio of the winding radii of the flexible protection element on the winding control shaft and on the unwinding control shaft is inversely equal to the ratio of the measured speeds of the drive motors when said flexible element is tensioned, it is within the framework of a second inventive approach that it was thought to deduce the driving torque exerted by each of the motors on the flexible protection element and to adjust the tension exerted by these motors on the portion of flexible protection element extending between the winding control shaft and the unwinding control shaft.
[0023] The advantages that arise from the present invention consist in that the speed setpoints assigned to the motors can be constantly determined to permanently ensure a tension on the flexible protection element between the winding control shaft and the unwinding control shaft, tension which remains within a determined range so that the motors can work optimally and in concert during the winding or unwinding phase. [ Fig.1 ] illustrates a training device according to a first embodiment; [ Fig.2 ] illustrates a training device according to a second embodiment; [ Fig.3 ] is a schematic representation of the drive device according to the first embodiment; [ Fig.4a ] is a schematic representation of the drive device according to the first embodiment; [ Fig.4b ] is a schematic representation of the deployment training device according to the second embodiment; [ Fig.4c ] is a schematic representation of the folding drive device according to the second embodiment; [ Fig.5 ] is a graphic representation of the sequence of steps of a method for controlling the drive device according to the two embodiments; [ Fig. 6 ] is a detailed graphic representation of the sequence of steps of the method for controlling the drive device according to the two embodiments carried out when the flexible protective element of the drive device is not tensioned; [ Fig.7 ] is a detailed graphic representation of the sequence of steps of the method for controlling the drive device according to the two embodiments carried out when the flexible protection element of the drive device is stretched; [ Fig.8a ] is a graphical representation of the sequence of part of the steps of the method for controlling the drive device making it possible to determine a speed ratio according to the two embodiments; [ Fig.8b ] is a graphical representation of the sequence of part of the steps of the method for controlling the drive device making it possible to determine initial stabilized voltages according to the two embodiments; [ Fig.9 ] is a graphical representation of the sequence of part of the steps of the method for controlling the drive device making it possible to determine a torque setpoint of a second electric motor of the drive device according to the two embodiments; and [ Fig.10 ] is a graphical representation of the sequence of part of the steps of the method for controlling the drive device making it possible to determine a new voltage to be applied to the electric motors of the drive device according to the two embodiments as a function of the supply voltage of the motors at the previous iteration, possibly as a function of the starting supply, and of a reference torque; [ Fig.11 ] is a graphical representation of an alternative sequence to the sequence shown in the figure 7 steps of the method for controlling the drive device according to the two embodiments carried out when the flexible protection element of the drive device is stretched; [ Fig. 12 ] is a graphical representation of the sequence of part of the steps of the method for controlling the drive device making it possible to determine the torque ripple of an electric motor acting as an auxiliary motor as a function of the speed ratio and the torque of the electric motor acting as a drive motor according to the two embodiments; and [ Fig.13 ] is a set of curves visualizing the phase advance and the attenuation of a sinusoidal signal at the output of a digital filter according to the invention, adjustable according to an integer parameter k.
[0024] As appears in the attached figures, the present invention relates to the field of drive devices 1 of a flexible protection element 2 intended to extend in a substantially horizontal or gently sloping arrangement above a surface 8 to be protected, whether with respect to solar radiation and / or bad weather, such as rain or cold, or even an attempted intrusion.
[0025] Thus, this flexible protective element 2 can take the form of a shade cloth, a tarpaulin or even a roll-up protective apron, similar to those of roller shutters and composed of a plurality of slats connected together at least in an articulated manner.
[0026] There figure 1 and the figure 3 represent, schematically, a drive device 1 of a flexible protection element 2 in the form of a canvas 3 intended to be deployed above a surface 8 to be protected, this canvas 3 is initially wound around a winding control shaft 5 located on one side of this surface 8 to be protected, according to a first embodiment of the invention.
[0027] On the opposite side of this surface 8 is provided an unwinding control shaft 6 to which is connected the end of one, preferably several straps 7 which are also made integral at their opposite end 9, 10 with the free end 11 of the canvas 3. It is understood that by ensuring the rotation of the unwinding control shaft 6 in the direction S1 of deployment of the canvas 3, the straps 7 will gradually wind around the unwinding control shaft 6 by pulling on the end 11 of the canvas 3, leading to the unwinding of the latter from the winding control shaft 5 by rotation of the latter in the same direction S1 of deployment.
[0028] When the unwinding control shaft 6 rotates in the unfolding direction S1, the first electric motor M 1 acts as a drive motor and the second electric motor M 2 acts as an auxiliary motor. When the unwinding control shaft 6 rotates in the folding direction S2, the first electric motor M 1 acts as an auxiliary motor and the second electric motor M 2 acts as a drive motor.
[0029] Obviously, a reverse rotation command S2 generates the winding of the canvas 3 around the winding control shaft 5 and the unwinding of the straps 7 from the unwinding control shaft 6.
[0030] During these deployment or folding maneuvers of the canvas 3, the latter must be kept taut, otherwise it can unwind in an uncontrolled manner between the winding control shaft 5 and the unwinding control shaft 6 under the effect of its own weight.
[0031] There figure 2 illustrates, in a schematic manner, the case of deployment, horizontally or with a slight slope, of a flexible protection element 2 in the form of an apron 4 composed of a plurality of slats 17 at least articulated relative to each other in the manner of a roller shutter apron, according to a second embodiment.
[0032] If, in a substantially vertical position, such an apron 4 deploys naturally by its weight during rotation of the winding control shaft 5 in the direction of deployment S1, in a substantially horizontal position or with a slight slope it is appropriate, just as for a canvas, to assist this apron 4 in its deployment. This can be done by traction using straps or by pushing, a solution that the figure 2 .
[0033] Usually, whether in a vertical or substantially horizontal position, a flexible protective element in the form of an apron 4, of the roller shutter apron type, is guided laterally by profiles called slides 20, 21, in each of which slides an edge 18, 19 of the apron 4. In the latter, the slats 17 of the apron 4 can be progressively pushed back, in particular in a horizontal or substantially horizontal arrangement under the action of the unwinding control shaft 6. This is arranged, as illustrated in the figure 2 , downstream of the winding control shaft 5.
[0034] For example, such an unwinding control shaft 6 can act by means of the teeth 23 of one or more drive wheels on drive fingers or drive openings 24 provided at the ends of the blades 17 of the apron 4, somewhat like a rack.
[0035] Here again, the portion of apron 4 extending between the winding control shaft 5 and the unwinding control shaft 6 must be kept constantly under slight tension to avoid a possible blockage of the apron 4, or even a breakage of the latter. Indeed, the amplitude of pivoting of a blade 17 relative to another adjacent one is often limited, in particular in the direction opposite to the winding of these blades 17 around the winding control shaft 5. Consequently, if this portion of apron 4 were to relax too much between the winding control shaft 5 and the unwinding control shaft 6, the blades could bend excessively relative to each other until this limit is exceeded, causing the breakage of an articulation between these blades 17.
[0036] Furthermore, an absence of tension on this portion means that all of the forces for deploying or folding the apron 4 are provided by the motor of the unwinding control shaft 6.
[0037] There figure 4a is a schematic representation of the drive device 1 shown in the figure 1 , there figure 4a representing the drive device in both directions of movement, i.e. the deployment direction S1 and the folding direction S2, and illustrating only the tangential forces which apply to contact points P 1 and P 2 between the flexible protection element 2 and the winding 5 and unwinding 6 control shafts.
[0038] THE figures 4b et 4c are schematic representations of the drive device 1 shown in the figure 2 , in the direction of deployment S1 ( figure 4b ) and in the direction of the S2 folding ( figure 4c ), which illustrate only the tangential forces which apply to the contact points P 1 and P 2 between the flexible protection element 2 and the winding 5 and unwinding 6 control shafts.
[0039] In this regard and according to the invention, the rotational control of the winding control shaft 5 and the unwinding control shaft 6 occurs via two separate electric motors called, for ease of understanding of the present invention, first electric motor M 1 for the one acting on the unwinding control shaft 6 and second electric motor M 2 for the one driving the winding control shaft 5.
[0040] The drive device 1 comprises a control device 16 for controlling an electrical supply of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 . The control device 16 is shown in detail in the figure 3 The control device 16 may comprise a control module 31, 32 for each electric motor M 1 , M 2 forming part of the drive device 1.
[0041] For both embodiments of the invention, the control device 16 comprises a first control module 31 enabling the first electric motor M 1 to be controlled and a second control module 32 enabling the second electric motor M 2 to be controlled. For both embodiments of the drive device 1 described, the control modules 31, 32 may be identical.
[0042] Each control module 31, 32 may comprise a torque and / or current sensor 33, 34 and / or a rotation speed sensor 35, 36 of the respective electric motor M 1 , M 2 . Each control module 31, 32 may further comprise a communication interface 37, 38 capable of communicating with the communication interface 37, 38 of the other control module 31, 32, such as an RS232 serial link, a power interface 39, 40 such as a transistor bridge controlled by a driver, a processing and calculation unit 41, 42 such as a microcontroller and a power supply 43, 44.
[0043] The method according to the invention consists of: a) assigning to each of the electric motors M 1 and M 2 , depending on the direction of deployment control S1 or folding S2, a starting supply voltage U d1 ; U d2 ; b) determining the speed Ω 1 and Ω 2 of the electric motors M 1 and M 2 at a time t ; c) calculating the ratio ρ of the measured instantaneous speeds Ω 1 / Ω 2 at time t ; d) assigning a corrected supply voltage U' 1 and U' 2 to the electric motors M 1 and M 2 corresponding to a set speed Ω c1 and Ω c2 of these electric motors M 1 ; M 2 depending on the ratio ρ of the measured instantaneous speeds Ω 1 / Ω 2 , to exert on the flexible protection element 2, between the winding control shaft 5 and the unwinding control shaft 6, a voltage of a value within a defined range ; e) repeating the process in step b) at time intervals, preferably regular.Preferably, said starting supply voltage U d1; U d2 corresponds to a predefined starting set rotation speed Ω cd1 and Ω cd2. Step a) makes it possible to exert a voltage on the flexible protection element 2 between the winding control shaft 5 and the unwinding control shaft 6.
[0044] According to one possibility, the determination of the speed Ω 1 and Ω 2 of the electric motors M 1 and M 2 at a time t can be carried out using suitable speed sensors 35, 36.
[0045] The ratio ρ of the measured instantaneous speeds Ω 1 / Ω 2 corresponds to the inverse ratio of the winding radii R 2 / R 1 of the flexible protection element 2, respectively, on the winding control shaft 5 and the unwinding control shaft 6. During the initialization phase a) of the device no value is available for ρ. Advantageously, the method provides for assigning to the electric motors M 1 , M 2 supply voltages U 1 and U 2 which guarantee the voltage of the flexible protection element 2 in the most unfavorable situation.
[0046] [ Fig.5 ] is a graphic representation of the sequence of steps of the method for controlling the drive device 1 according to the two embodiments. [ Fig.6 ] is a graphical representation of the sequence of steps in the process of controlling the drive device 1 until the voltage of the flexible protection element 2 is obtained while [ Fig.7 ] is a graphic representation of the sequence of steps of the method for controlling the drive device 1 carried out when the flexible protection element 2 of the drive device is tensioned.
[0047] THE figures 8a à 10 are graphical representations of details of the process of controlling the drive device 1 of the figure 7 . [ Fig.8a ] is a graphical representation of the sequence of steps in the process for determining a speed ratio of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 . [ Fig.8b ] is a graphical representation of the sequence of steps in the process used to determine the stabilized voltages at the end of the voltage phase of the flexible protection element 2. [ Fig.9 ] is a graphical representation of the sequence of steps of the method for determining a torque setpoint for the second electric motor M 2 of the drive device 1. [ Fig.10 ] is a graphical representation of the sequence of steps of the method for determining the new corrected supply voltages U 1 '; U 2 ' to be applied to the electric motors M 1 ; M 2 of the drive device 1 as a function of the supply voltages U 1 ; U 2 previously applied and a reference torque.
[0048] In the figures 5 à 10 , the angular velocity of the first electric motor M 1 is represented by Ω 1 and the angular velocity of the second electric motor M 2 is represented by Ω 2 . K represents a coefficient of the low-pass filter. ρ represents the angular velocity ratio of the two electric motors M 1 , M 2 . ρ -1 represents the value of ρ at the previous iteration. Ψ represents the torque / speed characteristic function of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 used. C T1min is the minimum braking torque imposed by the second electric motor M 2 to the first electric motor M 1 . C T2min is the minimum braking torque imposed by the first electric motor M 1 to the second electric motor M 2 .
[0049] For example, for a flexible protection element 2 intended to be extended above a surface 8, the first electric motor M 1 acting on the unwinding control shaft 6 may be assigned a voltage U 1 corresponding to its nominal speed in the direction of deployment and the second electric motor M 2 acting on the winding control shaft 5 may be assigned a voltage U 2 corresponding to a speed much lower than this nominal speed in the same direction of deployment so as to be certain that it acts as a brake on the flexible protection element 2 relative to the winding speed of the latter on the unwinding control shaft 6.
[0050] The same reasoning can be applied if this first command were to intervene in the opposite direction or in the case of a flexible protection element 2 in the form of an apron 4 to guarantee the tensioning of the portion of apron between the unwinding control shaft 6 and the winding control shaft 5.
[0051] Note that even if the voltage on the flexible protection element 2 were to be excessive during an initialization phase, this only occurs very briefly. Indeed, as soon as the speed ratio is calculated validly during the execution of steps b), c) and d), the voltage of the deployable element 2 returns to a normal value. According to one possibility, the torques C 1 , C 2 respectively produced by the electric motors M 1 , M 2 are determined, in particular during step b).
[0052] For either of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 , the starting supply voltage U 1 , U 2 can be equal to a voltage corresponding to a theoretical speed Ω V1 , Ω V2 that the respective electric motor M 1 , M 2 would use at no load.
[0053] According to an exemplary embodiment, the starting setpoint speed Ω cd1 is chosen to be substantially equal to the theoretical speed Ω V1 that the electric motor M 1 would take when unloaded, and the starting setpoint speed Ω cd2 is chosen to be substantially equal to the theoretical speed Ω V2 that the electric motor M 2 would take when unloaded divided by the maximum value achievable by the inverse ratio of the winding radii ρ = R 2 / R 1 in the worst case. In short, the supply voltage U d1 of the electric motor M 1 at the first start corresponds to that of the theoretical speed Ω V1 that this electric motor M 1 would take when unloaded and the supply voltage U d2 of the electric motor M 2 at the first start corresponds to that of the theoretical speed Ω V2 that this electric motor M 2 would take when unloaded divided by the maximum value achievable by ρ = R 2 / R 1 in the worst case.These starting voltages U d1 , U d2 can correspond to data in the device's memory.
[0054] On the contrary, after initialization and first start-up and stop of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 , the method plans to keep in memory the last value of the ratio ρ of the measured speeds Ω 1 / Ω 2 .
[0055] Thus, upon restart, if ρ ≥ 1, the initial voltage of the first electric motor M 1 is equal to the maximum available voltage U max and the voltage of the second electric motor M 2 is equal to U max divided by ρ. Conversely, if ρ < 1, the initial voltage of the second electric motor M 2 is equal to U max and the voltage of the first electric motor M 1 is equal to U max multiplied by ρ. To ensure a better initial voltage, in the previous calculation, ρ can be multiplied by 0.75 in the folding direction and by 1.25 in the unfolding direction.
[0056] According to a possible additional feature, in step a), the starting supply voltage U d1 , U d2 is assigned to each of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 until a voltage state of the flexible protection element 2 is determined.
[0057] The flexible protection element 2 is considered to be tensioned if the difference Ev between the rotation speed measured at time t Ω 1 ; Ω 2 and the no-load rotation speed Ω V1 ; Ω V2 , on the motor chosen for tensioning, meets the following conditions, depending on its direction of rotation: Ev lower than a negative threshold if it acts as a drive (it goes slower than when empty), Ev higher than a positive threshold if it acts as a brake (it goes faster than when empty).
[0058] In other words, according to one possibility, when said flexible protection element 2 is unwound in a deployment direction S1, the tension state of the flexible protection element 2 can be determined when, in the driving mode of the unwinding control shaft 6, a difference between the speed Ω 1 of the first electric motor M 1 determined and the no-load rotation speed Ω V1 of the first electric motor M 1 is less than a first threshold and / or a difference between the speed Ω 2 of the second electric motor M 2 determined and the no-load rotation speed Ω V2 of the second electric motor M 2 is greater than a second threshold, and / or when said flexible protection element 2 is wound in the folding direction S2, the tension state of the flexible protection element 2 can be determined when, in the driving mode of the winding control shaft 5,a difference between the speed Ω 2 of the second electric motor M 2 determined and the no-load rotation speed Q V2 of the second electric motor M 2 is less than a third threshold and / or a difference between the speed Ω 1 of the first electric motor M 1 determined and the no-load rotation speed Ω V1 of the first electric motor M 1 is greater than a fourth threshold.,
[0059] According to another characteristic of the method according to the invention, during step (c) the torque C 1 and C 2 produced, respectively, by the electric motors M 1 and M 2 is also measured at time t.
[0060] Note that there are different ways to measure this torque C 1 , C 2 , possibly depending on the technology of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 . In the case of a brushed DC motor, the torque is proportional to the current consumed, therefore easily measurable by a low value series resistor or a current sensor. On a brushless motor, it is also possible to deduce the torque from the measurement of the three supply currents of the motor (by Clarke transform, then Park transform). For an asynchronous motor, the torque is calculated according to the slip. For a universal motor with series excitation, the torque is proportional to the square of the current consumed.
[0061] Consequently, the torque of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 is accessible indirectly by measuring the current consumed and / or the rotation speed, but also, in an alternative embodiment, by direct measurement with a torque meter inserted on the output shaft of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 .
[0062] The flexible protection element 2 is considered to be tensioned if, on the electric motor M 1 or M 2 chosen to tension, the difference Ec between the torque measured at time t C 1 ; C 2 and the no-load torque C V1 ; C V2 (corresponding to predefined data or data determined upstream) respects the following conditions according to the direction of rotation: Ec greater than a positive threshold if the electric motor chosen for tensioning acts as a drive (it forces more than when empty), Ec less than a negative threshold if the electric motor chosen for tensioning acts as a brake (it forces less than when empty).
[0063] In other words, according to one possibility, when said flexible protection element 2 is unwound in a deployment direction S1, the tension state of the flexible protection element 2 can be determined when, in the driving mode of the unwinding control shaft 6, a difference between the torque C 1 of the first electric motor M 1 determined and the no-load torque C V1 of the first electric motor M 1 is greater than a fifth threshold and / or a difference between the torque C 2 of the second electric motor M 2 determined and the no-load torque C V2 of the second electric motor M 2 is less than a sixth threshold, and / or when said flexible protection element 2 is wound in the folding direction S2, the tension state of the flexible protection element 2 can be determined when, in the driving mode of the winding control shaft 5,a difference between the torque C 2 of the second electric motor M 2 determined and the no-load torque C V2 of the second electric motor M 2 is greater than a seventh threshold and / or a difference between the torque C 1 of the first electric motor M 1 determined and the no-load torque C V1 of the first electric motor M 1 is less than an eighth threshold.,
[0064] According to another possibility, when the flexible protection element 2 is unwound in a deployment direction S1 and / or when the flexible protection element 2 is wound in the folding direction S2, the tension state of the flexible protection element 2 can be obtained when a difference between the torque C 2 of the second electric motor M 2 determined and the theoretical torque value C ref expected at time t as a function of the value of ρ is lower in absolute value than a ninth threshold. Preferably, this ninth threshold will be chosen equal to 1% of the theoretical torque value C ref expected. The theoretical torque value C ref expected can be calculated in the manner detailed by the figure 9 .
[0065] Preferably, the excess torque C 1 ; C 2 compared to the no-load torque C V1 ; C V2 of the driving electric motor M 1 ; M 2 can be equal to a deficit in torque C 1 ; C 2 of the braking electric motor M 1 ; M 2 multiplied by ρ. To have a regular tension force of the flexible protection element 2 over its entire movement, we start by predetermining the reference torque that it generates for the minimum winding radius R 1min ; R 2min . Then, to obtain the torque required at a given moment of the movement, it is sufficient to multiply the reference torque by the ratio of the external radius R 1 ; R 2 of the winding to the minimum radius R 1min ; R 2min and to subtract the result from the no-load torque C V1 ; C V2 .
[0066] It should be noted that the no-load torque C V1; C V2 of the electric motors M 1; M 2 is preferably determined under conditions in which the electric motor M 1; M 2 does not drive the flexible protection element 2, but taking into account the friction on the bearings or rollers of a possible reducer and, depending on the case, of the winding control shaft 5 or the unwinding control shaft 6.
[0067] Thus, it is possible to consider that if the actual torque measured at an instant t C 1 ; C 2 is greater than the no-load torque C V1 ; C V2 , the electric motor M 1 ; M 2 acts in traction, whereas if the measured torque C 1 ; C 2 is less than the no-load torque C V1 ; C V2 , the electric motor M 1 ; M 2 acts as a brake.
[0068] Advantageously, the case where the measured torque C 1 ; C 2 becomes negative (the electric motor operates as a generator) will be avoided. Thus, according to a preferred embodiment of the method according to the invention, the new corrected supply setpoint voltages U' 1 ; U' 2 of an electric motor M 1 ; M 2 will be adjusted for a setpoint speed Ω C1 ; Ω C2 defined to generate a positive torque C 1 ; C 2.In the case of a device where the flexible protection element 2 is intended to extend above the surface 8 to be protected by unwinding from the winding control shaft 5 to wind, through a strap in particular, onto the unwinding control shaft 6 and vice versa, it is sufficient to follow the torque C 1 ; C 2 on the braking electric motor M 1 ; M 2 and to adjust its set speed Ω C1 ; Ω C2 accordingly, taking into account the ratio ρ of the measured speeds Ω 1 / Ω 2 , remembering that it corresponds to the inverse ratio of the winding radii R 2 / R 1 , this so that this torque C 1 ; C 2 is substantially lower than its no-load torque C V1 ; C V2 .The mathematical study shows that at steady speed the surplus torque (compared to the no-load torque C V1 ; C V2 ) of the driving electric motor M 1 ; M 2 is equal to the deficit torque (compared to the no-load torque C V2 ; C V1 ) of the braking electric motor M 2 ; M 1 multiplied by the inverse ratio of the radii R 2 / R 1 .
[0069] According to the method of the invention, in order to have a substantially regular tension force of the flexible protection element 2 over the entire movement, a minimum tension torque C Tmin generated by this flexible protection element 2 is predetermined for a minimum winding radius, depending on the case, on the unwinding control shaft 6 in the unwinding phase or on the winding control shaft 5 in the folding phase.
[0070] Thus, at each iteration of steps b), c) the torque required for the motor M 1 ; M 2 is determined by multiplying the desired mechanical tension torque C Tmin by the ratio of the external radius of the winding R 1 ; R 2 to the minimum radius Rimin ; R 2min and subtracting the no-load torque C V1 ; C V2 from the result obtained. The minimum radius can correspond to a predefined data item in memory.
[0071] In the case of a flexible protective element 2 in the form of an apron 4 intended to unfold and fold, guided laterally by slides 20, 21, by only unwinding or winding around the winding control shaft 5, the unwinding control shaft 6 only serves as a constant radius drive shaft. In this case, it is appropriate to distinguish the two directions of movement. When the flexible protective element 2 unwinds from the winding control shaft 5 and unfolds in the slides 20, 21 while being pushed by the unwinding control shaft 6, it is defined that the second electric motor M 2 with which the winding control shaft 5 is equipped acts as a brake by maintaining its torque C 2 below its no-load torque C V2 through steps b), c) and d) of the method.The first electric motor M 1 will experience an excess torque compared to its no-load torque C V1 equal to the tension torque of the flexible protection element 2 to which is added, this time, the resistive torque linked to the effort to push this flexible protection element 2 in the form of apron 4 into these slides 20, 21.
[0072] In the other direction, the device exploits the braking effect linked to the tensile strength of the flexible protection element 2, in this case the apron 4 in the slides 20, 21 to tension this apron 4, which allows the two electric motors M 1 and M 2 to work in traction.
[0073] In this case, different solutions are possible: by adjusting the set speed Ω C2 of the second electric motor M 2 of the winding control shaft 5, it is possible to ensure that the measured torque C 2 on this second electric motor M 2 at a time t has a value substantially greater than its no-load torque C V2 , which is sufficient to maintain the tension of the flexible protection element 2, but does not distribute the tensile force for folding the flexible protection element 2, it is also possible to distribute the necessary tensile force equally between the two electric motors M 1 and M 2 , which generates an asymmetry between the two torques C 1 and C 2 which is all the greater as the ratio of the radii R 2 / R 1 moves further and further away from 1 during the winding of the flexible protection element 2, in this case the apron 4, on the winding control shaft 5.This results in an imbalance of the electrical currents consumed, equally distributing the torque (C 1 ≈ C 2 ) necessary on the two electric motors M 1 , M 2 to balance the electrical currents consumed, with the consequence of a variation in the tension force during movement on the portion of the apron 4 between the winding control shaft 5 and the unwinding control shaft 6.
[0074] According to a preferred embodiment applied to a flexible protection element 2 in the form of an apron 4 intended to be deployed and folded, guided laterally by guide rails or slides 20, 21, by unwinding or winding around the winding control shaft 5, the unwinding control shaft 6 only serving as a constant radius drive shaft, during folding: During at least a first phase, the speed Ω 1 and Ω 2 of the electric motors M 1 and M 2 are measured at a time t, the torque C 1 and C 2 produced by these electric motors M 1 and M 2 is measured and the set speeds Ω C1 and Ω C2 of the electric motors M 1 and M 2 are adjusted taking into account the ratio of the winding radius R 2 of the flexible protection element 2 on the winding control shaft 5 and the constant winding radius R 1 on the unwinding control shaft 6, a ratio which is equal to the ratio ρ of the measured speeds Ω 1 / Ω 2 , this in order to deliver through the first electric motor M 1 a torque C 1 substantially equal to the torque C 2 of the second electric motor M 2 .And, during at least a final folding phase, the set speed Ω C2 of the second electric motor M 2 of the winding control shaft 5 is adjusted so that the measured torque C 2 on this second electric motor M 2 at a time t has a value substantially greater than its no-load torque C V2 , to maintain the flexible protection element 2 in tension, in its portion between the winding control shaft 5 and the unwinding control shaft 6. .
[0075] Still, in the particular case of a flexible protection element 2 in the form of an apron on which the unwinding control shaft 6 acts by pushing or pulling at a constant diameter, it is possible to imagine choosing the set speed Ω C1 of the first electric motor M 1 acting on this unwinding control shaft 6 to be constant, whether in the deployment or folding phase. Indeed, in the deployment phase, the second electric motor M 2 acting on the winding control shaft 5 then gradually accelerates to compensate for the winding section of the apron around the latter, a section which decreases to a minimum value. Conversely, the second electric motor M 2 gradually slows down in the folding phase under these conditions.
[0076] However, by measuring the speeds Ω 1 and Ω 2 and the torques C 1 and C 2 , it will be determined whether the voltage on the flexible protection element 2 meets the voltage setpoint and the set speed Ω C2 of the second electric motor M 2 will be adjusted, or even that Ω C1 of the first electric motor M 1 if necessary, to comply with this voltage setpoint on the flexible protection element 2, in particular during the final and initial phases, respectively, of deployment and folding.
[0077] Indeed, depending on the winding section of this flexible protection element 2 on the winding control shaft 5, it is necessary to ensure that the speed of the second electric motor M 2 is capable of giving the flexible protection element 2 a movement speed in relation to that communicated to it by the unwinding control shaft 6 rotating under the impulse of the first electric motor M 1 operating at nominal speed.
[0078] According to a preferred embodiment of the method of the invention, the set speed Ω C1; Ω C2 of one of the electric motors M 1 ; M 2 is chosen to be constant. Preferably, it is chosen to be equal to the nominal speed of this electric motor M 1 ; M 2 . Preferably, the speed of the other electric motor M 1 , M 2 can be adjusted downwards so as to maintain the voltage of the flexible protection element 2 at a value within the predefined range.
[0079] The application of a new corrected supply voltage U' 1 , U' 2 to at least one of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 induces a change in the rotation speed differential between the two shafts 5, 6, which results in a controlled change in the tension force of the flexible protection element 2 and therefore in the torques C 1 , C 2 measured by the electric motors M 1 , M 2 .
[0080] According to a possible additional feature, the method further comprises the following steps: i) the rotational speed Ω 1 , Ω 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor is measured by the respective rotational speed sensor 35, 36, ii) a first value representing the rotational speed Ω 1 , Ω 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor is transferred by the communication interface device 15 from the control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor to the control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor, and iii) the setpoint speed ΩC1, ΩC2 of the electric motor M1, M2 acting as a drive motor and / or the setpoint speed Ω C1 , Ω C2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor is selected by the module control module 31, 32 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor depending on the ratio ρ and depending on the first value transmitted to the control module (31,32) associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor. ,
[0081] According to one possibility, the method may further comprise the following step: iv) the set speed ΩC1, ΩC2 to be applied to the electric motor M1, M2 acting as a drive motor is transferred back by the communication interface device 15 from the control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M1, M2 acting as an auxiliary motor to the control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M1, M2 acting as a drive motor.
[0082] Steps i), ii), iii) and iv) are preferably repeated at regular time intervals. According to one possibility, in step i), the torque C 1 , C 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor is further measured by the respective torque and / or current sensor 33, 34, in step ii), a second value representing the torque C 1 , C 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor is further transferred by the communication interface device 15 of the control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor to the control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor and in step iii), the set speed Ω C1 , Ω C2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor is further selected by the control module 31, 32 of the electric motor M 1 ,M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor depending on the second value transmitted to the control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor.,
[0083] According to a possible additional feature, in step i), an average of a plurality of torques C 1 , C 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor measured during previous implementations of step i) by the respective torque and / or current sensor 33, 34 is determined, in step ii), a third value representing the average of torques of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor is further transferred by the communication interface device 15 of the control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor to the control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor and, in step iii), the set speed Ω C1 , Ω C2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor is further chosen by the control module 31, 32 of the electric motor M 1 ,M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor depending on the third value transmitted to the control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor.,
[0084] According to a possible additional feature, the rotational speed Ω 1 , Ω 2 and / or the torque C 1 , C 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor is measured by the rotational speed sensor 35, 36 and / or the respective torque and / or current sensor 33, 34, the setpoint speed Ω C1 , Ω C2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor being further chosen in step iii) as a function of the measured rotational speed Ω 1 , Ω 2 and / or the measured torque C 1 , C 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor.
[0085] According to one possibility, the torque C 1 , C 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor measured by the respective torque and / or current sensor 33, 34 and / or the rotational speed Ω 1 , Ω 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor measured by the respective rotational speed sensor 35, 36 when carrying out step i) is filtered by a low-pass filter, a cut-off frequency and a gain of which are preferably adjusted as a function of the inverse of the ratio ρ in order to achieve that the attenuation and the phase shift of a signal from the respective rotational speed sensor 35, 36 is constant or quasi-constant. In this way, measurement noises that may disturb the following calculation can be avoided.
[0086] Thus, the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor sends to the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor two measured quantities, representative of the rotation speed Ω 1 , Ω 2 and the drive torque C 1 , C 2 . The control module 31, 32 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor calculates on the one hand, the ratio of the rotation speeds ρ, image of the inverse ratio of the radii R 2 / R 1 (if the flexible protection element 2 is taut), which is then suitably smoothed by low-pass filtering, on the other hand, the average value of the torque setpoint of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor to which a ripple will be added to compensate for the torque fluctuations of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor.
[0087] The cutoff frequency and gain of the filter can advantageously be self-adjusted according to the inverse ratio of the radii R 2 / R 1 on each shaft 5, 6 to maintain a quasi-constant gain and phase shift over the frequency range of the fluctuation.
[0088] Then, this filtered periodic signal generated by the rotation speed sensor 35, 36 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor (which approaches its fundamental sinusoidal component) can be sampled and stored in a table covering at least half a period when the latter is the longest.
[0089] If at a given position, N samples are required to cover a period, half of the difference between the current point of index n and the point of index nk stored in the table of previous values (with 0 ≤ k ≤ N / 2) represents a wave in phase advance with respect to the filtered signal generated by the rotation speed sensor 35, 36 associated with the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor. The result of the calculation is shown in figure 13 for different values of k.
[0090] Thus, a sinusoidal variation can undergo an advance which goes from 0° (at unit gain) for k = N / 2 up to 90° (but at zero gain) for k = 0, passing through an advance of 45° (gain = √2 / 2) for k = N / 4. For the control method according to the invention, a value of k between N / 4 and N / 2 is preferable.
[0091] For a desired phase advance, k is calculated as a function of N as well as the multiplier coefficient M to be applied to compensate for the gain ≤ 1. N depends on the inverse ratio of the winding radii (equal to ρ) divided by the average frequency of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as the drive motor. A constant phase advance is obtained without weakening of the signal over the entire movement. In the case where the fluctuation is not completely sinusoidal, the average value of the phase advance signal may be non-zero, which requires re-centering the curve by removing the average of the maximum and minimum values over a sliding range.The result, measured by a multiplier coefficient, is added to the voltage setpoint Ω C1 , Ω C2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor which therefore undulates around a central value to compensate in advance for variations in the torque C 1 , C 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor. As with any control system, the loop gain must be adjusted to limit the deviations as much as possible without generating instability.
[0092] If the two electric motors M 1 , M 2 are of the direct current type with or without brushes, the current being proportional to the torque C 1 , C 2 , the method will be applied to the current of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor, current which is easier to measure than the torque.
[0093] As illustrated in the figure 9 , the method may comprise a torque balancing step according to which the torque C 1 is multiplied by a factor (N+1) ρ / (Nρ + 1) with N preferably being 7, to which result is added the minimum braking torque C T1min imposed by the second electric motor M 2 on the first electric motor M 1 multiplied by (ρ - 1). The multiplicative factor is 1 when ρ = 1 and increases slightly with ρ, thus making it possible to create a slight asymmetry in favor of the torque C 2 of the second electric motor M 2 to reinforce the tension of the flexible protection element 2. C T1min × (ρ - 1) makes it possible to add a minimum tension when the flexible protection element 2 is almost wound on the winding control shaft 5 and no longer induces sufficient traction force.C 1 can be advantageously replaced by the average C avg = (C 1 + C 2 ) / 2 of the couples C 1 , C 2 of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 since C avg converges towards C 1 when the two couples C 1 , C 2 balance each other. This avoids instability of the drive device 1 as long as the condition C 1 = C 2 is not fulfilled.
[0094] According to one possibility, the method comprises a timing step after each modification of the controls of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 to allow time for the angular speed of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 to stabilize. Under these conditions, it is possible to consider that the algebraic sum of the torques applied to the contact points P 1 and P 2 of the figures 4a à 4c is zero and does not depend on the moment of inertia of shafts 5 and 6.
[0095] Referring to the first embodiment and in particular to the figure 4a , when the first electric motor M 1 rotates in order to wind the flexible protection element 2 around the unwinding control shaft 6, the driving force F M1 , FM2 of each electric motor M1, M2 opposes the tension force F T1 , F T2 of the deployable element at the contact point P 1 , P 2 . A positive amplitude balance of the tangential forces which apply to each shaft 5, 6 can be established. At the contact point P 1 , F M1 = F T1 and at the contact point P 2 , FT 2 = F M2 . Assuming that the flexible protection element 2 is non-deformable along its length, that is to say in the winding or unwinding direction, when the flexible protection element 2 is tensioned, we have F T1 = F T2 . It follows that F M1 = F M2 .As these forces are applied orthogonally to the radius of action, the useful torque developed by the first electric motor M 1 corresponds to: C M1 = F M1 × R 1 and the useful torque developed by the second electric motor M 2 corresponds to: C M2 = - F M2 × R 2 (braking torque, negative).
[0096] We have - C M2 / R 2 = C M1 / R 1, and therefore C M2 = - (R 2 / R 1) × C M1.
[0097] Furthermore, the total torque developed by the electric motor M 1 ; M 2 includes its respective no-load torque C V1 ; C V2 required to overcome internal friction. In other words, C 1 = C M1 + C V1 and C 2 = C M2 + C V2 . This results in C V2 - C 2 = (R 2 / R 1 ) × (C 1 - C V1 ).
[0098] According to one possibility, the flexible protective element 2 can be tensioned without the second electric motor M 2 operating as a generator. In this case, we have 0 < C 2 < C V2 , which gives C V1 < C 1 < C V1 x [1 + (R 1 / R 2 )]. According to a possible additional characteristic, a desired tension force F T1min of the flexible protective element 2 can be chosen from a predefined value range. A tension torque C T1min of the flexible protective element 2 can be defined for the minimum value of the radius R 1min of the radius R 1 and the torques C 1 and C 2 can be derived therefrom in the direction of deployment S1 using the following formulas: C 1 = C V1 + R 1 / R 1min × C T1min donc C 1 > C V1 And C 2 = C V2 − R 2 / R 1min × C T1min donc C 2 < C V2 .
[0099] On the other hand, in the direction of folding S2, when the second electric motor M 2 rotates in order to wind the flexible protection element 2 around the winding control shaft 5, we have: C 1 = C V1 − R 1 / R 1min × C T1min donc C 1 < C V1 And C 2 = C V2 + R 2 / R 1min × C T1min donc C 2 > C V2 .
[0100] According to one possibility, the electric motors M 1 , M 2 can be identical and have the same no-load torque Cv.
[0101] According to one possibility, the operating point of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 can be chosen so as to balance the forces by imposing on the second motor M 2 a surplus torque compared to the no-load torque C V2 equal to the surplus torque of the first motor M 1 compared to the no-load torque C V1 multiplied by the inverse ratio of the radii R 2 / R 1 as long as this is less than 1, then to balance the torques C 1 , C 2 as long as the resistive effect linked to the surface of the flexible protective element 2 remaining to be wound is sufficient, and finally to guarantee a minimum torque to maintain the tension at the end of the movement.
[0102] Referring to the second embodiment and in the direction of deployment S1 illustrated by the figure 4b , when the first electric motor M 1 rotates in order to drive the flexible protection element 2 around the unwinding control shaft 6 with a constant radius R 1 , a tangential force F R1 is applied corresponding to the sliding resistance of the flexible protection element 2 which can rub in its guide rails or slides 20, 21, to which is added or subtracted a part of the weight of the flexible protection element 2 depending on the angle that the guide rails or slides 20, 21 make with respect to the horizontal. This tangential force opposes the driving force of the first electric motor M 1 . As a result, at the first point of contact P1, F T1 = F M1 - F R1 and at the second point of contact P 2 , F T2 = F M2 .
[0103] Assuming that the flexible protection element 2 is non-deformable along its length, i.e. in the winding or unwinding direction, when the flexible protection element 2 is stretched, we have F T1 = FT2, therefore FM2 = FM1 - FR1.
[0104] At the level of useful torques, knowing that C M1 = F M1 × R 1 (motor torque, positive) and C R1 = - FR1 x R1, CM2 = - FM2 x R2 (braking torques, negative), the relation becomes: - CM2 = (R2 / R1) x (CM1 - CR1), which finally gives: Cv2 - C2 = (R2 / R1) x (C 1 - C V1 - C R1 ).
[0105] The condition for tensioning the flexible protection element 2 without the second electric motor M 2 operating as a generator in the direction of deployment S1 of the flexible protection element 2 is: 0 < C 2 < C V2 which gives: C R1 + C V1 < C 1 < C R1 + CV1 + CV2 x (R1 / R2).
[0106] In this same embodiment, in the direction of deployment S1 the flexible protection element 2 illustrated by the figure 4b , the tension force F T1min of the flexible protection element 2 in the direction of its length will have the effect of a torque C T1min on the motor M 1 . The radius R 1 remains constant at R 1 = R 1min . The total torque of each electric motor M 1 , M 2 can be calculated as follows:
[0107] According to one possibility, the torque of the braking force C T1min is limited to (R 1 / R 2max ) x C V2 to have C 2 > 0.
[0108] Still referring to the second embodiment but in the direction of the folding S2 of the flexible protection element 2 illustrated by the figure 4c , the driving force F M1 and the sliding resistance force of the flexible protection element F R1 , although always opposite, apply in the opposite direction with respect to deployment. At the contact point P 1 we have F T1 = F R1 - F M1 . At the contact point P 2 we have F T2 = F M2 .
[0109] Assuming that the flexible protection element 2 is non-deformable along its length, i.e. in the winding or unwinding direction, when the flexible protection element 2 is tensioned, we have F T1 = F T2 and therefore F M2 = F R1 - F M1 . Knowing that C M1 = F M1 × R 1 , C M2 = F M2 × R 2 and C R1 = F R1 × R 1 , the relationship becomes: C M2 = (R 2 / R 1 ) × (C R1 - C M1 ), which finally gives: C 2 - C V2 = (R 2 / R 1 ) × (C R1 - C 1 + C V1 ). The condition for tensioning the flexible protection element 2 without the motor M 2 operating as a brake is C 2 > C V2 , which gives C 1 < C V1 + C R1 .
[0110] In the direction of S2 folding, several operations are possible, because the two electric motors M 1 , M 2 can collaborate more or less to share the work.
[0111] According to a first operation, the drive device 1 can be controlled so that the tension force F T1min of the flexible protection element 2 is constant. To obtain a constant tension force F T1min of the flexible protection element 2, the second electric motor M 2 is controlled so that it develops a surplus torque compared to its no-load torque C V2 sufficient to guarantee the tension of the flexible protection element 2 while the first electric motor M 1 pulls the load. In this case, the following formulas are obtained: C 1 = C V1 + C R1 - C T1min (therefore C 1 < C V1 + C R1 ) and C 2 = C V2 + (R 2 / R 1 ) × C T1min (therefore C 2 > C V2 ).
[0112] According to a second operation, the drive device 1 can be controlled so that the driving forces F M1 , F M2 of the two electric motors M 1 , M 2 are substantially equal, that is to say that F M1 = F M2 = F R1 / 2. In this case we have: C M1 = C R1 / 2 and C M2 = (R 2 / 2R 1 ) × C R1 . This results for the total torque of the motors that C 1 = C V1 + C R1 / 2 (therefore C 1 < C V1 + C R1 ) and that C 2 = C V2 + [R 2 / (R 2 + R 1 )] × C R1 (C 2 > C V2 ). In this case, it is not necessary to know C R1 , but simply to control the speed of the second electric motor M 2 to ensure that the equation C 2 = (R 2 / R 1 ) × (C 1 - C V1 ) + C V2 is satisfied.
[0113] According to a third operation, the drive device 1 can be controlled so that the torques C M1 , C M2 of the two electric motors M 1 , M 2 are substantially equal. Thus, the total current consumed is distributed equally between the two electric motors M 1 , M 2 . We therefore obtain C M1 = C M2 = [R 2 / (R 2 + R 1 )] × C R1 . This results in C 1 = C V1 + [R 2 / (R 2 + R 1 )] × C R1 (therefore C 1 < C V1 + C R1 ) and C 2 = C V2 + [R 2 / (R 2 + R 1 )] × C R1 (C 2 > C V2 ). In this case, it is not necessary to know C R1 , but simply to control the speed of M 2 to keep the torques C 1 and C 2 substantially equal. The tension force is determined as follows: F T1 = [R 1 / (R 1 + R 2 )] × F R1 .
[0114] Since, in the second embodiment, the radius R 1 of the unwinding control shaft 6 is constant for the entire stroke of the flexible protection element 2, the tension force varies depending on the radius R 2 of the winding control shaft 5 and the winding resistance force F R1 . The winding resistance force F R1 becomes small (approaches 0) when the deployable element is almost completely wound onto the winding control shaft 5.
[0115] In order to guarantee a minimum tension force F T1min , the third operation described above can be implemented as long as C 2 > C V2 + (R 2 / R 1 ) × C T1min . Then, the drive device 1 can switch to either the first or the second operation. The method can therefore implement the third operation as long as the above condition on C 2 is fulfilled and switch to the first or the second operation as soon as the above condition on C 2 is no longer fulfilled. According to one possibility, a term can be added to C 2 corresponding to approximately C T1min (ρ - 1) to switch from the third operation to the first operation when ρ ≥ 1.
[0116] In summary, the voltage of the flexible protection element 2 will be guaranteed if the set speed Ω C1 ; Ω C2 of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 is adjusted so as to maintain the torque measured on one of them C 1 ; C 2 in a restricted range around the optimal value calculated according to the rules described in the previous paragraphs. These systematically involve the inverse ratio of the winding radii R 2 / R 1 which must be updated iteratively by calculating the ratio ρ of the measured angular rotation speeds Ω 1 / Ω 2 , preferably smoothed by a low-pass filter to keep only the average value.
[0117] We note that the inverse ratio of the winding radii R 2 / R 1 is used in all the torque calculation formulas. However, when the flexible protection element 2 is stretched, we have the equality R 1 × Ω 1 = R 2 x Ω 2 so ρ is equal to the ratio of the angular rotation speeds: ρ = R 2 / R 1 = Ω 1 / Ω 2 .
[0118] It is important to note that this ratio ρ is deterministic for a given position of the flexible protection element 2. Except for the first start, the initial speeds of the two electric motors M 1 , M 2 can be calculated based on the last value of ρ calculated during the previous movement.
[0119] In a drive device 1 provided with brushed electric motors M 1 , M 2 , the current of the second electric motor M 2 is controlled instead of controlling the torque C 2 , for the reason that there is a direct proportional relationship between the torque and the current.
[0120] According to one possibility, the measured rotation speed Ω 1 , Ω 2 is smoothed by a low-pass filter.
[0121] According to one possibility, when said flexible protection element 2 unwinds from the winding control shaft 5 in the deployment direction S 1 , the setpoint of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor starts at a low value and gradually increases to a value slightly lower than its no-load current. In the reverse folding direction S 2 , the currents supplying each of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 are balanced until reaching the torque peak C 1 , C 2 then the current of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor gradually becomes predominant over the current of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor to guarantee the tension of the flexible protection element 2.
[0122] In order to compensate for irregularities in the winding of the flexible protection element 2, a sinusoidal ripple that depends on the position of the flexible protection element 2 can be superimposed on the average (quasi-linear) current setpoint, to cancel out as much as possible the dips and antinodes on the torque curve C 1 , C 2 . This ripple is preferably perfectly timed according to the position of the flexible protection element 2. Poor timing can worsen the accordion effect instead of improving it. The position of the flexible protection element 2 can be determined by the ratio of the winding radii. This is deduced from the ratio of the rotation speeds Ω 1 , Ω 2 measured on condition that the flexible protection element 2 is tensioned. The initial values are established so as to guarantee this condition regardless of the starting point, then the method according to the invention optimizes the tension of the flexible protection element 2.
[0123] The value of the radius ratio at the time of an intermediate stop can be kept as the starting value for the next start, regardless of the direction. The advantages of the present invention consist in that it is suitable for implementation independently of the dimensions of the flexible protection element 2. Furthermore, the method is suitable for implementation independently of the starting position, does not require knowledge of the angular position of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 and allows the tension of the flexible protection element 2 to be maintained during the implementation of the method. Furthermore, by thus controlling the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor, compensation can be achieved at a level closer to the source of the disturbance, thus allowing the accordion effect on the flexible protection element 2 to be avoided.Thus, the speed of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor can continue to be controllable by a user, for example.
[0124] The method according to the invention is based on a transfer of the speed Ω 1 , Ω 2 and / or torque C 1 , C 2 measurements of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor to the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor via a communication interface 15. The speed Ω 1 , Ω 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor is adapted to smooth out the rapid fluctuations of the torque C 1 , C 2 of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor without impacting any slower variations in its average value. The method therefore makes it possible to anticipate the fluctuations of torque C 1 , C 2 dynamically as a function of the inverse ratio of the radii, linked to the ratio of the measured speeds Ω 1 , Ω 2, without needing to know the angular position of each electric motor M 1 , M2.
[0125] The method according to the invention is based on the principle of analysis by the control of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor of the fluctuations in the torque of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as a drive motor (or its current, in the case where the electric motors M 1 , M 2 are direct current electric motors). The method according to the invention thus makes it possible to adjust the speed of the electric motor M 1 , M 2 acting as an auxiliary motor to compensate for these fluctuations and ensure smooth movement. The method according to the invention uses signal processing tools dynamically parameterized on the basis of the inverse ratio of the winding radii, itself linked to the ratio of the speeds Ω 1 , Ω 2 of real rotations. The method according to the invention can be applied regardless of the length or thickness of the flexible protective element 2.The method according to the invention can be applied regardless of the starting position of the drive device 1. The method according to the invention can also be applied when the flexible protection element 2 is wound only on the winding control shaft 5, the unwinding shaft 6 only playing a driving role (via a toothed wheel for example). The drive device 1 with the aid of which the method according to the invention is implemented can comprise a communication interface device 15 allowing bidirectional communication between the control modules 31, 32 associated with one of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 . For the method according to the invention, it is not necessary to know the angular position of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 but only their rotation speed Ω 1 , Ω 2 and their output torque C 1 , C 2 , or physical quantities which depend thereon.One of two control modules 31, 32 calculates the value of ρ then the desired average optimal torque to which is added the ripple to compensate for the fluctuations and finally determines the updated values of the control voltages U 1 ', U 2 ' to be applied to each power interface 39, 40. These output data are also exchanged via the communication interface 15.
[0126] For both embodiments described, according to one possibility, the electric motors M 1 , M 2 can be brushed DC motors. Thus, since the measured currents are proportional to the torques C 1 , C 2 produced by the respective electric motors M 1 , M 2 , the algorithm used during the process sequence can be applied to the setpoint currents.
[0127] The advantages of the present invention consist in that it is suitable for implementation independently of the dimensions of the flexible protection element 2. Furthermore, the method is suitable for implementation independently of the starting position, does not require knowledge of the angular position of the electric motors M 1 , M 2 and makes it possible to maintain the tension of the flexible protection element 2 during the implementation of the method.
Claims
1. A method for controlling a drive device (1) of a flexible protective element (2), such as a fabric, tape, curtain or panel of a roller shutter, said drive device (1) comprising a winding control shaft (5) from which said flexible protective element (2) unwinds in a deployment direction (S1) and onto which said flexible protective element (2) winds in a retraction direction (S2), an unwinding control shaft (6) able to act on the flexible protective element (2) in order to unwind it from the winding control shaft (5), a first electric motor (M1), a second electric motor (M2), a control device (16) able to control a power supply of the first electric motor (M1) and to control a power supply of the second electric motor (M2), said winding shaft (5) being able to, in a drive mode of the winding control shaft (5), be driven by the second electric motor (M2) and / or able to, in a braking mode of the winding control shaft (5), be braked by the second electric motor (M2), said unwinding control shaft (6) being able to, in a drive mode of the unwinding control shaft (6), be driven by the first electric motor (M1) and / or able, in a braking mode of the unwinding control shaft (6), to be braked by the first electric motor (M1), the method comprising the following successive steps: a) in a starting phase, assigning to each of the electric motors (M1,M2) a starting supply voltage (U1, U2), respectively predefined as a function of the deployment direction (S1) or of the retraction direction (S2), b) determining, for each of the electric motors (M1, M2), a respective rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) at an instant (t), c) calculating the ratio (p) of the instantaneous speeds determined (Ω1, Ω2) respectively at time (t), d) assigning a corrected supply voltage (U'1, U'2) respectively to each electric motor (M1, M2) corresponding to a setpoint speed (ΩC1, ΩC2) for these electric motors (M1, M2) as a function of the ratio (p) of the measured instantaneous speeds (Ω1, Ω2), to exert on the flexible protective element (2), between the winding control shaft (5) and the unwinding control shaft (6), a voltage of a value within a defined range, e) repeating the method in step b) at time intervals, preferentially regular.
2. The control method according to claim 1, characterized in that the torques (C1, C2) respectively produced by the electric motors (M1, M2) are determined, in particular in step b).
3. The control method according to any one of claims 1 or 2, characterized in that, for one or other of the electric motors (M1, M2), the starting supply voltage (U1, U2) is equal to a voltage corresponding to a theoretical speed (ΩV1, ΩV2) at which the respective electric motor (M1, M2) would travel at no load.
4. The control method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized in that, in step a), the starting supply voltage (U1, U2) is assigned to each of the electric motors (M1, M2) until a voltage state of the flexible protective element (2) is determined.
5. The control method according to claim 4, characterized in that, - when said flexible protective element (2) is unwound in a deployment direction (S1), the voltage state of the flexible protective element (2) is determined when, in the drive mode of the unwinding control shaft (6), a difference between the speed (Ω1) of the first electric motor (M1) determined and a no-load speed (OV1) of the first electric motor (M1) is less than a first threshold and / or a difference between the speed (Ω2) of the second electric motor (M2) determined and a no-load rotation speed (ΩV2) of the second electric motor (M2) is greater than a second threshold, - and / or when said flexible protective element (2) is wound in the retraction direction (S2), the voltage state of the flexible protective element (2) is determined when, in the drive mode of the winding control shaft (5), a difference between the speed (Ω2) of the second electric motor (M2) determined and a no-load rotation speed (ΩV2) of the second electric motor (M2) is less than a third threshold and / or a difference between the speed (Ω1) of the first electric motor (M1) determined and a no-load speed (OV1) of the first electric motor (M1) is greater than a fourth threshold.
6. The control method according to claim 2 taken in combination with any one of claims 4 or 5, characterized in that, - when said flexible protective element (2) is unwound in an deployment direction (S1), the voltage state of the flexible protective element (2) is determined when, in the drive mode of the unwinding control shaft (6), a difference between the torque (C1) of the first electric motor (M1) determined and a no-load torque (CV1) of the first electric motor (M1) is greater than a fifth threshold and / or a difference between the torque (C2) of the second electric motor (M2) determined and a no-load torque (CV2) of the second electric motor (M2) is less than a sixth threshold, - and / or when said flexible protective element (2) is wound in the retraction direction (S2), the voltage state of the flexible protective element (2) is determined when, in the drive mode of the winding control shaft (5), a difference between the torque (C2) of the second electric motor (M2) determined and a no-load torque (CV2) of the second electric motor (M2) is greater than a seventh threshold and / or a difference between the torque (C1) of the first electric motor (M1) determined and a no-load torque (CV1) of the first electric motor (M1) is less than an eighth threshold.
7. The control method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, characterized in that the setpoint speed (ΩC1, ΩC2) of one of the electric motors (M1, M2) from the electric motors (M1, M2) is selected to be constant.
8. The control method according to claim 7, characterized in that the setpoint speed (ΩC1, ΩC2) of one of the electric motors (M1, M2) from the electric motors (M1, M2) is selected to be equal to the rated speed of this electric motor (M1, M2).
9. The control method according to one of claims 1 to 8, characterized in that the rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) is determined by measuring the rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) using a speed sensor.
10. The control method according to any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized in that the setpoint speed (ΩC1, ΩC2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as auxiliary motor from the electric motors (M1, M2) is selected as a function of the ratio (p) and as a function of the setpoint speed of the electric motor (M1,M2) acting as a drive motor from the electric motors (M1, M2).
11. The control method according to any one of claims 1 to 5 or according to claim 10, characterized in that, the rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) is determined by measuring the rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) using a speed sensor (35, 36).
12. The control method according to any one of claims 9 to 11, characterized in that the measured rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) is smoothed by a low-pass filter.
13. The control method according to claim 5 or according to any one of claims 10 to 12, said control device (16) comprising a first control module (31) for controlling the first electric motor (M1) and a second control module (32) for controlling the second electric motor (M2), each control module (31, 32) further comprising a rotation speed sensor (35, 36) of the respective electric motor (M1, M2), said control device (16) further comprising a communication interface device (15) allowing communication between the control modules (31, 32), characterized in that i) the rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor is measured by the respective rotation speed sensor (35, 36), ii) a first value representing the rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor is transferred by the communication interface device (15) from the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor to the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor and iii) the setpoint speed (ΩC1, ΩC2) of the electric motor (M1 ,M2) acting as an auxiliary motor is selected by the control module (31, 32) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor as a function of the ratio (p) and as a function of the first value transmitted to the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor, the steps i), ii) and iii) being preferably repeated at regular time intervals.
14. The control method according to claim 13, each control module (31, 32) further comprising a torque and / or current sensor (33, 34) of the respective electric motor (M1, M2), said method characterized in that, in step i), the torque (C1, C2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor is further measured by the respective torque and / or current sensor (33, 34), in step ii), a second value representing the torque (C1, C2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor is further transferred by the communication interface device (15) from the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1,M2) acting as a drive motor to the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor and in step iii), the setpoint speed (ΩC1, ΩC2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor is further selected by the control module (31, 32) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor as a function of the second value transmitted to the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor.
15. The control method according to claim 14, characterized in that steps i), ii) and iii) are repeated at regular time intervals, further characterized in that in step i), an average of a plurality of torques (C1, C2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor measured during previous implementations of step i) by the respective torque and / or current sensor (33, 34) is determined, in step ii), a third value representing the average torque of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor is further transferred by the communication interface device (15) from the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor to the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor, and in step iii), the setpoint speed (ΩC1, ΩC2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor is further selected by the control module (31, 32) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor as a function of the third value transmitted to the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor.
16. The control method according to any one of claims 13 to 15, characterized in that the rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) and / or the torque (C1, C2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor is measured by the respective rotation speed sensor (35, 36) and / or torque and / or current sensor (33, 34), the setpoint speed (ΩC1, ΩC2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor being, in step iii), further selected as a function of the measured rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) and / or torque (C1, C2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as an auxiliary motor.
17. The control method according to any one of claims 13 to 16, characterized in that the rotation speed (Ω1, Ω2) of the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor measured by the respective rotation speed sensor (35, 36) when implementing step i) is filtered by a low-pass filter, whose cut-off frequency and gain are preferably adjusted as a function of the inverse of the ratio (p), so that the attenuation and phase shift of a signal from the respective rotation speed sensor (35, 36) is constant or quasi-constant.
18. The control method according to any one of claims 13 to 17, characterized in that it comprises, following step iii), the following step in addition: iv) the setpoint speed (ΩC1, ΩC2) to be applied to the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor is transferred back via the communication interface device (15) from the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1,M2) acting as an auxiliary motor to the control module (31, 32) associated with the electric motor (M1, M2) acting as a drive motor.
19. A drive device for a flexible protective element (2), such as a roller shutter, fabric, tape, curtain or shutter, said drive device (1) comprising a winding control shaft (5) from which said flexible protective element (2) unwinds in a deployment direction (S1) and onto which said flexible protective element (2) winds in a retraction direction (S2), an unwinding control shaft (6) able to act on the flexible protective element (2) in order to unwind it from the winding control shaft (5), a first electric motor (M1), a second electric motor (M2), a control device (16) able to control a power supply of the first electric motor (M1) and to control a power supply of the second electric motor (M2), said winding shaft (5) being able to, in a drive mode of the winding control shaft (5), be driven by the second electric motor (M2) and / or able to, in a braking mode of the winding control shaft (5), be braked by the second electric motor (M2), said unwinding control shaft (6) being able to, in a drive mode of the unwinding control shaft (6), be driven by the first electric motor (M1) and / or able, in a braking mode of the unwinding control shaft (6), to be braked by the first electric motor (M1), said drive device configured for the implementation of the method according to any one of claims 1 to 17.
20. The drive device according to claim 19, characterized in that each of the electric motors (M1, M2) is provided with a speed sensor able to measure the rotation speed of the respective electric motor (M1, M2).
21. The drive device according to any one of claims 19 or 20, characterized in that each of the electric motors (M1, M2) is provided with a torque sensor able to measure the mechanical torque developed by the respective electric motor (M1, M2), or in that each of the electric motors (M1, M2) is provided with a current sensor, able to measure the intensity of the current flowing through the respective electric motor (M1, M2).
