Determining ranges between respective wireless communication devices

EP4457534A1Pending Publication Date: 2024-11-06TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON (PUBL)
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
EP2022835425
Authority / Receiving Office
EP · EP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2021-12-30
Filing Date
2022-12-14
Publication Date
2024-11-06

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current sidelink ranging technologies face challenges in accurately estimating the range between wireless communication devices, especially in Non-Line-of-Sight (NLOS) conditions, and struggle to meet the requirements for high accuracy and low power consumption, particularly in industrial IoT scenarios.

Method used

The method involves obtaining a first range estimate from sidelink signal measurements and a second range estimate from device positions, with the option to use a synthetic range estimate computed by a network node based on device positions, allowing for improved accuracy and reliability by combining or selecting between direct and synthetic estimates.

Benefits of technology

This approach enhances the accuracy and reliability of sidelink range estimation, particularly in NLOS conditions, while also improving power efficiency and meeting the requirements for industrial IoT applications.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 1.1
    Figure 1.1
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A wireless communication device (12-1) uses a synthetic sidelink range estimate as its estimate of sidelink range to another wireless communication device (12-2), where the synthetic estimate derives from the positions of the devices and offers a more reliable estimation under certain conditions, compared to a direct sidelink range estimate derived from sidelink signal measurements made by one or both the devices. For example, there may be no LoS propagation paths between the devices. In an embodiment, an apparatus such as a network node of a wireless communication network or a positioning reference unit sends the synthetic estimate to at least one of the devices. Sending of the synthetic estimate occurs, for example, responsive to receiving a request from at least one of the devices or based on determining that the synthetic estimate is preferable. In an embodiment, one or both devices decide that use of the synthetic estimate is preferable.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] DETERMINING RANGES BETWEEN RESPECTIVE WIRELESS COMMUNICATION DEVICES

[0002] TECHNICAL FIELD

[0003] Estimation of range between respective wireless devices depends on a first range estimate derived from measurement of sidelink signals between the devices, and a second range estimate derived from estimates of the respective positions of the devices.

[0004] BACKGROUND

[0005] One aspect of work ongoing by the Third Generation Partnership Project (3GPP) for Release 18 involves “sidelink” (SL) communications, with a focus on standardizing solutions for sidelink ranging. See, 3GPP document RP-213561, a portion of which is excerpted immediately below:

[0006] 3 Justification

[0007] In Release 17, 3GPP RAN conducted studies on "NR Positioning Enhancements" and "Scenarios and requirements of in-coverage, partial coverage, and out-of-co verage NR positioning use cases".

[0008] The study on "Scenarios and requirements of in-coverage, partial coverage, and out-of-coverage NR positioning use cases" focused on V2X and public safety use cases with the outcome being captured in TR38.845. Additionally, SAI has developed requirements in TS22.261 for "Ranging based services” and has developed positioning accuracy requirements in TS22.104 for IIoT uses cases in out-of-coverage scenarios. There is a need for 3 GPP to study and develop sidelink positioning solutions that can support the use cases, scenarios and requirements identified during these activities.

[0009] The study on "NR Positioning Enhancements" investigated higher accuracy, and lower latency location, high integrity and reliability requirements resulting from new applications and industry verticals for 5G. Some of the enhancements identified during that work have been specified during the Rel-17 Work Item on "NR Positioning Enhancements", but there remain a number of opportunities for enhancement that have not yet been incorporated into the specifications.

[0010] Positioning integrity is a measure of the trust in the accuracy of the position- related data and the ability to provide timely warnings based on assistance data provided by the network. The focus in Rel 17 work was on GNSS integrity, and for Rel-18 it is natural to extend this to address other positioning techniques as well as there are relevant integrity aspects of mission critical use cases that rely on positioning estimates and the corresponding uncertainty estimate. Integrity enables applications to make the correct decisions based on the reported position, e.g., when monitoring a robotic arm to decide whether its arm movement are within allowed limits to ensure safety distances to humans and other objects.

[0011] Regarding higher accuracy, two promising techniques identified in earlier studies will be considered in Rel-18: one is to take the advantage of the rich 5G spectrum to increase the bandwidth for the transmission and reception of the positioning reference signals based on PRS / SRS bandwidth aggregation for intraband carriers, and the other is to use the NR carrier phase measurements. GNSS carrier phase positioning has been used very successfully for centimeter-level positioning but is limited to outdoor applications. NR carrier phase positioning has the potential for significant performance improvements for indoor and outdoor deployments in comparison with the existing NR positioning methods, as well as shorter latency and lower UE power consumption in comparison with RTK-GNSS outdoors.

[0012] SAI has introduced requirements for LPHAP (Low Power High Accuracy Positioning) for industrial loT scenarios including use cases such as massive asset tracking, AGV tracking in industrial factory and person localization in danger zones. The SAI requirements are for high accuracy and extreme low power consumption with battery life sustainable up to one or more years. A typical scenario of interest is use case 6 as defined TS 22.104, which corresponds to tracking of workpiece (in- and outdoor) in assembly area and warehouse with a target accuracy of <lm, a positioning interval of 15-30 seconds, and a battery life of 6-12 months. While Rel- 17 NR positioning has introduced support for positioning in RRC_INACTIVE state, there is a need to evaluate whether the current system allows LPHAP requirements to be met.

[0013] Release- 17 has specified support for RedCap UEs with reduced bandwidth support and reduced complexity including reduced number of receive chains. Such UEs could support NR positioning functionality but there is a gap in that the core and performance requirements have not been specified for the positioning related measurements performed by RedCap UEs, and no evaluation was performed to see how the reduced capabilities of RedCap UEs might impact eventual position accuracy. This gap is to be investigated by the present SI.

[0014] 4 Objective

[0015] 4.1 Objective of SI or Core part WI or Testing part WI

[0016] • Study solutions for sidelink positioning considering the following:

[0017] [RANI, RAN2]

[0018] • Scenario / requirements o Coverage scenarios to cover: in-coverage, partial-coverage, and out- of-coverage o Requirements: Based on requirements identified in TR38.845 and TS22.261 and TS22.104 o Use cases: V2X (TR38.845), public safety (TR38.845), commercial (TS22.261), IIOT (TS22.104) o Spectrum: ITS, licensed

[0019] • Identify specific target performance requirements to be considered for the evaluation based on existing 3GPP work and inputs from industry forums [RANI]

[0020] • Define evaluation methodology with which to evaluate SL positioning for the use cases and coverage scenarios, reusing existing methodologies from sidelink communication and from positioning as much as possible [RANI].

[0021] • Study and evaluate performance and feasibility of potential solutions for SL positioning, considering relative positioning, ranging and absolute positioning: [RANI, RAN2] o Evaluate bandwidth requirement needed to meet the identified accuracy requirements [RANI] o Study of positioning methods (e.g., TDOA, RTT, AOA / D, etc.) including combination of SL positioning measurements with other RAT dependent positioning measurements (e.g., Uu based measurements) [RANI] o Study of sidelink reference signals for positioning purposes from physical layer perspective, including signal design, resource allocation, measurements, associated procedures, etc., reusing existing reference signals, procedures, etc. from sidelink communication and from positioning as much as possible [RANI] o Study of positioning architecture and signaling procedures (e.g., configuration, measurement reporting, etc.) to enable sidelink positioning covering both UE based and network based positioning [RAN2, including coordination and alignment with RAN3 and SA2 as required]

[0022] Note: When the bandwidth requirements have been determined and the study of sidelink communication in unlicensed spectrum has progressed, it can be reviewed whether unlicensed spectrum can be considered in further work. Checkpoint at RAN#97 to see if sufficient information is available for this review.

[0023] • Improved accuracy, integrity, and power efficiency: o Study solutions for Integrity for RAT dependent positioning techniques [RAN2, RANI]:

[0024] Identify the error sources, [RANI, RAN2].

[0025] Study methodologies, procedures, signaling, etc. for determination of positioning integrity for both UE -based and UE-assisted positioning [RAN2]

[0026] Focus on reuse of concepts and principles being developed for RAT-Independent GNSS positioning integrity, where possible. o Study solutions for accuracy improvement based on PRS / SRS bandwidth aggregation for intra-band carriers considering e.g., timing errors, phase coherency, frequency errors, power imbalance, etc. [RAN4]: o Study solutions for accuracy improvement based on NR carrier phase measurements [RANI, RAN4]

[0027] Reference signals, physical layer measurements, physical layer procedures to enable positioning based on NR carrier phase measurements for both UE -based and UE-assisted positioning [RANI]

[0028] Focus on reuse of existing PRS and SRS, with new reference signals only considered if found necessary o Study the requirements on LPHAP as developed by SAI and evaluate whether existing RAN functionality can support these power consumption and positioning requirements. Based on the evaluation, and, if found beneficial, study potential enhancements to help address any limitations [RAN2, RANI]

[0029] Study is limited to a single representative use case (use case

[0030] 6 as defined TS 22.104). The choice of selected use case can be reviewed at the start of the study. Study is limited to enhancements to RRC_IN ACTIVE and / or RRC_IDLE state

[0031] • Positioning support for RedCap UEs, considering the following: o Evaluate positioning performance of existing positioning procedures and measurements with RedCap UEs [RANI] o Based on the evaluation, assess the necessity of enhancements and, if needed, identify enhancements to help address limitations associated with for RedCap UEs [RANI, RAN2],

[0032] The term “SL” in this disclosure refers to the “sidelink” connection / communications directly between respective wireless communication devices. Such devices should be understood as essentially any type of communication apparatus that is configured for accessing and communicating through a wireless communication network, e.g., a Public Mobile Land Network (PLMN) operating according to 3 GPP specifications.

[0033] Previous standardization work for SL in 3GPP has focused on the communication aspects. Consideration of positioning has been with respect to the needs of the wireless communication network, e.g., the cellular system supporting wireless communication devices engaged in SL communications. New Radio (NR) in Fifth Generation (5G) wireless networks supports a number of positioning methods — here, the “position” of a device refers to the location of the device within some applicable frame of reference. See the 3GPP Technical Specification (TSs) 38.201, 38.300, 38.401, and 38.410 for example details regarding NR.

[0034] Downlink Time Difference of Arrival (DL-TDOA) is one such method and makes use of the DL Reference Signal Time Difference (RSTD) measured at the wireless communication device with respect to multiple Transmission Points (TPs) of a wireless communication network. For example, the wireless communication device measures a Positioning Reference Signal (PRS) transmitted by each among multiple TPs. Optionally, the wireless communication device also measures differences in the Reference Signal Received Power (RSRP) for PRSs received at the wireless communication device from multiple TPs. A positioning server in the network may provide assistance data to the wireless communication device for performing DL RSTD / RSRP measurements, and the resulting measurements are used along with other configuration information to determine the position of the wireless communication device in relation to the TPs.

[0035] Another approach relies on Round Trip Time (RTT) measurements and is referred to as “Multi-RTT.” The Multi-RTT positioning method makes use of Receive-Transmit (RX-TX) measurements at the wireless communication device and the involved radio network nodes of the wireless communication networks, where such nodes may be referred to as TPs or, more broadly, Transmission / Reception Points (TRPs). 5G base stations, referred to as gNBs, represent one example of TRPs that may be involved in Multi-RTT measurements. Example DL signals measured at the wireless communication device include DL PRS. Example uplink signals measured at the respective TRPs include Uplink (UL) Sounding Reference Signals (SRSs).

[0036] The UL-TDOA positioning method makes use of UL TDOA measurements at respective TRPs in the network. Optionally, the technique includes UL SRS-RSRP measurements at the multiple TRPs. The TRPs measure UL TDOA and, optionally, UL SRS-RSRP, based on assistance data received from the positioning server. The resulting measurements are used along with other configuration information to estimate the position of the wireless communication device.

[0037] Other positioning techniques rely on Angle-of- Arrival (AoA) measurements. With DL- AoA, the wireless communication device measures the AoA for DL PRS received from respective ones among multiple TRPs and may measure DL PRS RSRP. Assistance data from the positioning server enables such measurements by the wireless communication device, with the measurements used to estimate the position of the wireless communication device.

[0038] With the UL AoA positioning method, each TRP among multiple TRPs performs AoA measurements with respect to UL signals transmitted by a wireless communication device. The AoA measurements include azimuthal AoA measurements and zenith or elevational AoA measurements, with the resulting measurements used along with other configuration information to estimate the position of the wireless communication device.

[0039] Another positioning approach in NR is based on Enhanced Cell ID (NR-ECID). See the 3GPP Technical Specification (TS) 38.305 for example details.

[0040] Broadly, the various positioning modes belong to three categories, where the term “User Equipment” or “UE” is interchangeable with “wireless communication device.” A first category may be regarded as UE assisted, where the UE performs measurements with or without assistance from the network and sends the measurements to a positioning node in the network. An example positioning node is an Enhanced Serving Mobile Location Center (E-SMLC). See 3GPP TS 23.271 for example details.

[0041] A second category may be regarded as UE based, where the UE performs measurements and calculates its own position with assistance from the network. A third category is “standalone,” where the UE performs measurements and calculates its own position without network assistance.

[0042] 3GPP specified LTE D2D (device-to-device) technology, also known as ProSe (Proximity Services), in Releases 12 and 13 of LTE. Subsequent Releases 14 and 15 added LTE Vehicle-to-Every thing (V2X) related enhancements that targeted the specific characteristics of vehicular communications. 3GPP started a new work item in August 2018 within the scope of Release 16 to develop a NR version of V2X communications. The NR V2X specifications mainly target advanced V2X services, which can be categorized into four use case groups: vehicles platooning, extended sensors, advanced driving, and remote driving. The advanced V2X services require enhancements of the NR system and a new NR sidelink framework may be needed to meet the stringent requirements in terms of latency and reliability. NR V2X systems also expect to have higher system capacity and better coverage and to allow for an easy extension to support the future development of further advanced V2X services and other services.

[0043] Groupcast / multicast and unicast transmission types are desired in the context of the services targeted by NR V2X, in which the intended receiver of a message consists of only a subset of the vehicles in proximity to the transmitter (groupcast) or of a single vehicle (unicast). For example, in the platooning service context, there are certain messages that are only of interest to the members of the platoon, where those members constitute a “group” in the groupcasting context. In another example, the see-through use case most likely involves only a pair of vehicles, for which unicast transmissions naturally fit. Therefore, the NR sidelink can support broadcast (as in LTE), groupcast and unicast transmissions. Furthermore, NR sidelink is designed in such a way that its operation is possible with and without network coverage and with varying degrees of interaction between the UEs (user equipment) and the NW (network), including support for standalone, network-less operation.

[0044] In 3GPP Release 17, discussions addressed National Security and Public Safety (NSPS) as an important use case that would benefit from the already-developed NR sidelink features in Release 16. Therefore, it is most likely that 3GPP will specify enhancements related to NSPS use case taking NR Release 16 sidelink as a baseline. In some scenarios, NSPS services need to operate with partial or without NW coverage, such as indoor firefighting, forest firefighting, earthquake rescue, sea rescue, etc., where the infrastructure is (partially) destroyed or not available. Therefore, coverage extension is a crucial enabler for NSPS, for both NSPS services communicated between UE and cellular NW and that communicated between UEs over sidelink. In Release 17, a SID on NR sidelink relay (RP-193253) was launched which aims to further explore coverage extension for sidelink-based communication, including both UE to NW relay for cellular coverage extension and UE to UE relay for sidelink coverage extension. Now the work has proceeded to normative phase, and in the WID only UE to NW relay is considered.

[0045] In the discussions and planning for NR Release 18, sidelink based ranging or positioning has been agreed for standardization. Unless otherwise noted, “ranging” refers to the estimation of both distance and angle information about the wireless link between two wireless communication devices. Distance ranging is today available in other standards, e.g., IEEE 802.4z, where in general, a signal exchange takes place between two devices, allowing for calculation of the round-trip-time (RTT).

[0046] SUMMARY

[0047] Estimation of range between respective wireless communication devices depends on a first range estimate derived from measurement of sidelink signals between the devices, and a second range estimate derived from estimates of the respective positions of the devices. For example, determination of the first range depends on direct measurements of signal power, timing, or other characteristics of sidelink signals going between two wireless communication devices, and determination of the second range depends on received or calculated estimates of the positions of the two devices and occurs in a wireless communication network. An “improved” estimation of sidelink range then depends on both range estimates, such as by combining them or picking one of them as the preferred or better estimate of sidelink range.

[0048] A method of operation by a first wireless communication device in an example embodiment that includes the first device obtaining a first range estimate, containing one or both of distance and direction, with respect to a second wireless communication device. The first range estimate is based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the first and second wireless devices. The method further includes the first device obtaining a second range estimate, indicating one or both of distance and direction in a given frame of reference, with respect to the second device, based on estimated positions of the first and second wireless communication devices. Still further, the method includes the first device determining a final range estimate based on joint consideration of the first and second range estimates.

[0049] In another embodiment or under other operating circumstances, a method of operation by a wireless communication device includes deciding not to perform a range-estimation procedure with respect to another wireless communication device or deciding not to use results obtained from the range estimation procedure, and, in response to either decision, requesting a synthetic range estimate from a network node of a wireless communication network providing network coverage for the device. Here, the range-estimation procedure bases range estimation on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the two devices, and the network node or another network node in the wireless communication network computes the synthetic range estimate from the positions estimated or reported for the two devices.

[0050] In yet another embodiment or under other circumstances, a method of operation by a wireless communication device includes performing a sidelink ranging procedure with respect to another wireless communication device, the ranging procedure yielding a first range estimate for the distance between the wireless communication devices. The method further includes sending a request message towards a network node of a wireless communication network, requesting a second range estimate, the request message identifying the wireless communication devices. Still further, the method includes receiving the second range estimate from the network node or another network node of the wireless communication network, the second range estimate determined from estimated positions of the wireless communication devices and determining a final range estimate in dependence on the first range estimate and the second range estimate.

[0051] In another embodiment, a method of operation by a positioning reference unit or a network node of a wireless communication network includes determining a range estimate for the distance between first and second wireless communication devices, based on estimated positions of first and second wireless communication devices, sending the range estimate to one or both of the wireless communication devices.

[0052] In yet other embodiments, a wireless communication device uses a synthetic sidelink range estimate as its estimate of sidelink range to another wireless communication device, where the synthetic estimate derives from the positions of the devices and offers a more reliable estimation under certain conditions, compared to a direct sidelink range estimate derived from sidelink signal measurements made by one or both the devices. For example, there may be no Line-of-Sight (LoS) propagation paths between the devices. In at least one embodiment, a network node of a wireless communication network or a positioning reference unit sends the synthetic estimate to at least one of the devices. Sending of the synthetic estimate occurs, for example, responsive to receiving a request from at least one of the devices or based on determining that the synthetic estimate is preferable. In at least one embodiment, one or both devices decide that use of the synthetic estimate is preferable.

[0053] Thus, in one or more embodiments a node or device other than the two devices involved in the sidelink decide that use of the synthetic estimate is preferable as compared to use of the direct estimate, or preferable to the use of an estimate calculated from both the synthetic and direct estimates. In other embodiments, one or both of the two devices involved in the sidelink make that decision. In at least one embodiment, the decision that the synthetic estimate is preferable is made responsive to determining that the synthetic estimate is smaller than the direct estimate.

[0054] One example embodiment of such approaches comprises a method of operation by an apparatus such as a positioning reference unit or network node of a wireless communication network, for assisting a first wireless communication device with determining an estimate of sidelink range to a second wireless communication device. The method includes: (a) obtaining a synthetic sidelink range estimate that estimates the range between the first and second wireless communication devices, based on estimated positions of the first and second wireless communication devices; and (b) sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device.

[0055] Another example embodiment of such approaches comprises a method of operation by a wireless communication device for determining an estimate of sidelink range to another wireless communication device. The method includes: (a) receiving a synthetic sidelink range estimate from a positioning reference unit or a network node of a wireless communication network providing network coverage to the wireless communication device, the synthetic sidelink range estimate synthesized from estimated positions of the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device; and (b) using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device.

[0056] Additional embodiments include a wireless communication device comprising processing circuitry configured to carry out any of the device- side operations described herein, and one or more types of network nodes or positioning reference units comprising processing circuitry configured to carry out any of the network-side operations described herein.

[0057] Of course, the present invention is not limited to the above features and advantages. Those of ordinary skill in the art will recognize additional features and advantages upon reading the following detailed description, and upon viewing the accompanying drawings.

[0058] BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0059] Figure 1 is a block diagram of wireless communication devices and an associated wireless communication network, according to one embodiment.

[0060] Figure 2 is a block diagram illustrating an example network and sidelink connectivity.

[0061] Figures 3-7 are block diagrams of a network node and elements thereof, according to example embodiments.

[0062] Figure 8 is a logic flow diagram of a method of operation by a network node, according to one embodiment.

[0063] Figure 9 is a logic flow diagram of a method of operation by a network node and wireless devices, according to one embodiment.

[0064] Figure 10 is a signal flow diagram illustrating signaling going between wireless communication devices and respective network nodes, according to one embodiment.

[0065] Figures 11 and 12 are block diagrams illustrating example Non-Eine-of-Sight (NEOS) scenarios with respect to direct and synthetic determinations of sidelink range. Figures 13-16 are block diagrams of a wireless communication device and elements thereof, according to example embodiments.

[0066] Figures 17 and 18 are logic flow diagrams of method of operation by a wireless communication device, according to example embodiments.

[0067] Figure 19 is a logic flow diagram of operations performed by any one or any combination of a wireless communication device, a network node, or a positioning reference unit.

[0068] Figure 20 is a logic flow diagram of operations performed by a wireless communication device, according to an example embodiment.

[0069] Figure 21 is a block diagram of a wireless communication network according to another example embodiment.

[0070] DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0071] In the specific context of sidelink ranging, many challenges remain. For example, sidelink ranging between respective UEs may be difficult or perform poorly in instances where the UEs are Non-Line-of-Sight (NLOS). Certain antenna configurations or characteristics, such as directional antennas, antenna arrays, etc., may interfere with or complicate obtaining accurate sidelink ranging results.

[0072] One or more embodiments herein involve a Positioning Reference Unit (PRU), which is a node or device, such as a UE, that has a known position and transmits UL signals and can perform positioning measurements. A PRU can be used to identify positioning errors and that information can then be used to compensate the positioning errors of UEs, e.g., for improvement of determining positions or ranges of UEs involved in sidelink communications. PRU functionalities may include support for at least some of the UE positioning functionalities set out in Release 16, such as: providing the positioning measurements (e.g., RSTD, RSRP, Rx-Tx time differences); transmitting the UL SRS signals for positioning; providing known position coordinate information to a Location Management Function (LMF) of the involved communication network; if the antenna orientation information of the PRU is known, such information may be requested and provided to the LMF.

[0073] Figure 1 is a block diagram illustrating an example wireless communication network 10 and example wireless communication devices 12, also referred to as user equipments or UEs. Only two wireless communication devices 12 — hereafter “device” or “devices” 12 — are shown for convenience and are labeled as 12-1 and 12-2. There may be a multiplicity of devices 12 in operation, and some may be engaged only in “sidelink” communications with other devices 12, some may be engaged in network communications via the wireless communication network 10, and some may be engaged in both network communications and sidelink communications. Network communications include, for example, use of the wireless communication network 10 as an access network, for accessing one or more external networks 14, which in turn provide access to other devices or systems. For example, the external network(s) 14 include the Internet, and one or more devices 12 communicatively coupled with a host computer 16 via the wireless communication network 10, where the host computer 16 provides one or more types of communications services, such as streaming, web access, email, etc.

[0074] The devices 12 may be of a variety or mix of device types, such as smart phones or other mobile broadband devices, or Machine Type Communication (MTC) devices, or embedded UEs, such as the communication modules included in cars or other vehicles. In at least one embodiment, the network 10 is a Public Land Mobile Network (PLMN) operating according to 3GPP specifications, and the devices 12 are configured for operation according to the air interface provided by radio network nodes 22 included in a radio access network (RAN) 20 of the wireless communication network 10. Only two such nodes 22-1 and 22-2 are illustrated for convenience. The radio network nodes 22 may provide air interfaces based on more than one Radio Access Technology (RAT).

[0075] The RAN 20 couples to a core network (CN) 24 of the wireless communication network 10, which provides data routing and interfacing for user traffic, and provides connectivity to the one or more external networks 14. Although the CN 24 comprises a number of nodes that provide network functions for authentication and mobility management of devices 12, for convenience, Figure 1 illustrates only one example CN node; namely, a positioning node 26, which may be referred to as a Location Management Function that provides or supports positioning services for determining the positions of devices 12.

[0076] Figure 2 illustrates an example connectivity between a network node 32 and an example device 12-1 that is engaged in or will engage in sidelink communications with another device 12- 2. In the context of the illustrated example, at least the device 12-1 is within signal coverage of the network 10. Both devices 12-1 and 12-2 may be in network coverage and each may communicate with the network 10 in addition to carrying on sidelink communications. Here, “sidelink” communications refers to communications going directly between the two devices 12 via a direct radio link between the two devices 12.

[0077] In an example embodiment, the network node 30 is one of the radio network nodes 22 of the RAN 20, in which case the network node 30 communicates directly with the device 12-1, based on transmitting radio signals on the downlink (DL) and receiving radio signals on the uplink (UL). In another example embodiment, the network node 30 is not a radio network node 22 and instead communicates with the device 12-1 indirectly through another node, shown in dashed lines in Figure 2 as the network node 32. For example, the network node 30 is a type of positioning node 26 and it communicates with the wireless device 12-1 via the radio network node 22 that currently serves the device 12-1.

[0078] Figure 3 illustrates the network node 30 according to an example embodiment. The network node 30, as an example apparatus, includes communication circuitry 40, comprising transmit (TX) circuitry 42 and receive (RX) circuitry 44. Additionally, the network node 30 includes processing circuitry 46 and in one or more embodiments includes storage 48, e.g., for storing one or more computer programs (“CP”) 50 and various types of configuration or operational data (“CFG. DATA”) 52.

[0079] Depending upon the nature of the network node 30, the communication circuitry 40 may comprise a network interface transceiver 54, such as an ethemet or another data-network interface, with this example configuration shown in Figure 4. For example, if the network node 30 is a positioning node 26, the communication circuitry 40 is configured to exchange signaling with one or more other nodes, including one or more respective ones of the radio network nodes 22 in the RAN 20.

[0080] Figure 5 illustrates another example implementation of the communication circuitry 40 of the network node 30, corresponding to the example scenario where the network node 30 comprises one of the radio network nodes 22. In this context, the communication circuitry 40 includes one or more cellular transceivers 56 for communicating with devices 12 via radio signaling. The cellular transceivers 56 may be associated with one or more antennas 58, such as one or more antenna arrays that are configured for transmit beamforming or receive beamforming or both.

[0081] Of course, even in the radio -network-node example, the communication circuitry 40 may comprise more than one type of interface circuitry. For example, in addition to having radio communication circuitry, an example radio network node 22 includes communication-interface circuitry configured for communicating with other radio network nodes 22 and with one or more types of CN nodes, such as Authentication and Mobility Management Function (AMF) nodes, positioning nodes, etc.

[0082] Figure 6 illustrates example implementation details for the processing circuitry 46 according to an example embodiment. One or more microprocessors 60 are specially adapted to perform the operations described herein for the network node 30, based on the execution of computer program instructions 64 stored in one or more memories 62. The memories 62 comprise circuitry within the storage 48, for example, where the storage 48 shall be understood as comprising one or more types of computer-readable media that provide persistent storage for the computer program instructions 64. The storage 48 includes, for example, both volatile storage used for live program execution, and nonvolatile storage used for longer-term storage and retention of the program instructions and any longer-term data. Examples of the storage 48 include SRAM, DRAM, FLASH, EEPROMP, Solid State Disk (SSD), etc.

[0083] Broadly, the processing circuitry 46 comprises fixed circuitry or programmatically configured circuitry, or a mix of fixed circuitry and programmatically configured circuitry. In addition to, or as an alternative to the one or more microprocessors 60, the processing circuitry 46 may include any one or more of microcontrollers, digital signal processors, applicationspecific integrated circuits, field programmable gate arrays, complex programmable logic devices, or other digital processing circuitry.

[0084] Figure 7 illustrates an embodiment of the network node 30 implemented as processing units or processing modules. Here, a processing unit or module comprises a functional circuit or logic that is implemented via underlying physical processing circuitry and in the illustrated example the network node 30 includes a determining module 72 and a sending module 74.

[0085] In an example configuration, the determining module 72 is configured to determine a range estimate between first and second devices 12, based on estimated positions of the first and second devices 12. Correspondingly, the sending module 74 is configured to send the range estimate to one or both of the first and second devices 12.

[0086] Continuing the same example, the network node 30 includes a receiving module 76 that is configured to receive a request for the range estimate. The request may be sent by or on behalf of one or both the devices 12, and it is generally sent in the context of the two devices 12 performing or intending to perform sidelink ranging between them. The same or another receiving module within the network node 30 may be used to obtain information needed to estimate the respective positions of the two devices 12, or to obtain the estimates as determined by another node in the network 10.

[0087] The position estimates are, for example, estimates from satellite receiver modules within the respective devices 12, or are based on signal measurements made on uplink port downlink signals going between the network 10 and the respective devices 12. However the respective positions of the two devices 12 are estimated, the range estimate computed from the position estimates may be referred to as a “synthetic range estimate,” because it is not determined directly from measurements of sidelink signals going between the two devices 12. Conversely, a range estimate determined from sidelink signals going between the two devices 12 may be referred to as an “direct range estimate.”

[0088] Figure 8 illustrates a method 800 of operation by a network node 30, where the method 800 includes the network node 30 determining (Block 802) a range estimate between first and second devices 12, based on estimated positions of the first and second devices 12. Using the definitions provided immediately above, the processing of block 802 may be understood as the network node 30 determining a synthetic range estimate comprising an estimate of the distance or direction or both, as between the two devices 12. The synthetic range estimate may also be referred to as a synthetic sidelink range estimate, because it refers to the range between two devices 12.

[0089] The method 800 further comprises sending (Block 804) the range estimate to one or both of the devices 12. In an example scenario, two devices 12 perform sidelink ranging, resulting in a determination of a direct range estimate based on measurements of sidelink signals going between the two devices 12. One of the two devices 12 sends a request to a network node 30 for a synthetic range estimate. For example, the network node 30 is a positioning node 26 and the device 12 sends the request for the synthetic range estimate to the positioning node 26. In another example, the network node 30 is a serving radio network node 22 for the requesting device 12, and the requesting device 12 sends the request for the synthetic range estimate to the serving radio network node 22.

[0090] In either case, sending the synthetic range estimate to the wireless device 12 enables the wireless device 12 to determine a final or adjusted sidelink range estimate that is improved with respect to the direct range estimate determined between the two devices 12. For example, the wireless device 12 determines a final range estimate based on averaging or otherwise combining the synthetic range estimate and the direct range estimate, or by choosing the “better” one of the two range estimates. For example, the device 12 may be configured to choose the smaller one of the two range estimates, as the smaller range estimate is more likely to be associated with a Line- of-Sight (LOS) distance or direction. As another example, the device 12 may be configured to choose the range estimate that is associated with a greater confidence level.

[0091] Figure 9 illustrates a method 900 that includes operations carried out in the network 10 and operations carried out that one or both of the devices 12 involved in sidelink ranging. The method 900 begins with one or more network nodes determining (Block 902) positions of the two devices 12, e.g., using signal measurements made on the Uu interface between respective radio network nodes 22 of the network 10 and the two devices 12. Such measurements include, for example, any one or more of the positioning measurements discussed in the Background section of this document.

[0092] The one or more network nodes may be multiple radio network nodes 22 or may be a positioning node 26 working in coordination with multiple radio network nodes 22. In either case, the positioning measurements are used to determine the respective positions of the devices 12, with those positions then used for computing (Block 904) the range between the devices 12. The method 900 also includes the two devices 12 performing (Block 906) sidelink signal measurements for the determination of the sidelink range between the two devices 12.

[0093] The method 900 further includes determining (Block 908) a final range estimate, based on the two range estimates. Determination of the final range estimate may take place in the network 10 or in one or both of the devices 12, or in the network 10 and in the devices 12. In one embodiment or under one set of circumstances, determination of the final range estimate occurs in the network 10, e.g., at the network node 30. In another embodiment or under another set of circumstances, determination of the final range estimate occurs in one or both of the devices 12. As noted, the final range estimate may be a fusion of the direct range estimate and the synthetic range estimate, e.g., such as an averaging of the two range estimates.

[0094] However, in one or more embodiments or under certain circumstances, the final range estimate is a selected one of the two range estimates. For example, the two range estimates may have different confidence levels associated with them, or different quality or accuracy levels associated with them, such that the final range estimate is determined by selecting the superior or better one of the two range estimates, as indicated from the respective confidence or quality levels of the two range estimates.

[0095] Figure 10 illustrates an example signal flow according to one or more embodiments. A serving radio network node (RNN) 22 allocates resources for sidelink positioning. Here, the radio network node 22 is a serving radio network node with respect to at least one of the two illustrated devices 12, which are shown as UE1 and UE2. Allocating resources for sidelink positioning means allocating transmission resources in the spectrum used by the network 10, for use by the devices 12 in exchanging sidelink signaling for sidelink range determination.

[0096] The serving radio network node 22 provides one or both of the devices 12 with the signal allocation information, and the two devices 12 perform sidelink positioning. The sidelink positioning performed between the two devices 12 yields a first range estimate — i.e., a direct estimate of the sidelink range.

[0097] A positioning node — e.g., such as the node 26 introduced in Figure 1 — initiates networkbased positioning procedures with respect to each of the two devices 12. For example, the positioning node uses the LTE Positioning Protocol (LPP) to communicate with the respective devices 12 for positioning operations. Once the network 10 determines the respective positions of the two devices 12, either the serving radio network node 22 or the positioning node computes a synthetic range estimate and sends the synthetic range estimate to one or both of the devices 12, for use at the devices 12 in determining a final estimate of the sidelink range. The dashed lines going between the UE1 and the RNN indicate synthetic range request and return signaling that may be performed in one embodiment or under certain circumstances, while the solid lines going between the UE1 and the positioning node indicate the alternative approach of UE1 sending the synthetic range request to the positioning node. As a further alternative to the device(s) 12 requesting and receiving the synthetic range request, one or both of the devices 12 sends the first range estimate to the network 10 for determination of the final estimate of the sidelink range.

[0098] Figure 11 illustrates an example scenario where one or more radio network nodes 22 of the network 10 have LOS paths with respect to each of two wireless devices 12, where there is no LOS path between the two devices 12. Under the circumstances, the direct estimate of sidelink range computed at the devices 12 based on signal measurements made on exchange sidelink signaling reflects the NLOS path between the devices 12. Conversely, as the network 10 has LOS paths towards each of the devices 12, network-based positioning of the two devices 12 yields accurate estimates of the respective positions of the two devices 12, which in turn provides an accurate basis for computing the sidelink range based on the respective positions.

[0099] Under these example circumstances of Figure 11, the synthetic estimate of sidelink range may be more accurate than the direct estimate of sidelink range. In an example device configuration, one or both of the devices 12 receives the synthetic estimate of sidelink range, determines that it is smaller than the direct estimate of sidelink range, and in response chooses the synthetic estimate of sidelink range.

[0100] Figure 12 illustrates the converse case where there is an LOS path between the two devices 12 but where at least one of the two devices 12 does not have an LOS path to a radio network node 22 of the network 10. Under these conditions, the direct estimate of sidelink range computed by the devices 12 based on measurements of exchanged sidelink signaling may be more accurate than the computation by the network 10 of the synthetic range estimate. That is, network-based positioning may be less accurate because of the NLOS conditions between the network 10 in at least one of the devices 12.

[0101] According to this example, one or both of the devices 12 receives the synthetic range estimate from the network, recognizes that it is larger than the direct range estimate computed by the devices 12, with the result that the direct range estimate is chosen as the final range estimate. Of course, in this example or in any example context where the final range estimate is chosen as a selected one of the direct and synthetic range estimates, the choosing may be conditioned on a defined threshold. For example, the smaller one of the two range estimates is chosen as the final range estimate only if the difference between the direct and synthetic range estimates is larger than a first threshold amount but smaller than the second threshold amount.

[0102] Additionally, in at least one embodiment, the smaller one of the two range estimates is chosen only if the two range estimates have comparable confidence or quality levels, or if the smaller one of the two range estimates has a higher confidence or quality level than the larger one of the two range estimates. Further, rather than choosing the smaller one of the two range estimates, the choice may be based solely on comparison of the respective confidence or quality levels of the two range estimates. Still further, in embodiments where LOS / NLOS conditions are known with respect to the sidelink path between the devices 12 in the respective network paths between the network 10 and each of the devices 12, the final range estimate may be selected as the range estimate that is associated with LOS path(s). Still further, in one or more embodiments, if the respective positions of the two devices 12 are known at a confidence or quality level above a defined threshold, the synthetic range estimate computed from the respective positions of the two devices 12 is taken as the final estimate of the sidelink range.

[0103] Figure 13 illustrates a device 12 according to an example embodiment. The device 12 includes communication circuitry 80, comprising transmit (TX) circuitry 82 and receive (RX) circuitry 84. Additionally, the device 12 includes processing circuitry 86 and in one or more embodiments includes storage 88, e.g., for storing one or more computer programs (“CP”) 90 and various types of configuration or operational data (“CFG. DATA”) 92.

[0104] Depending upon the nature of the device 12, the communication circuitry 80 may include multiple communication interfaces, for example, one or more cellular radio transceivers, one or more wireless local access network transceivers, along with additional radio transceivers for Bluetooth, near field communications, etc. The device 12 may include one or more RX / TX antennas 94, e.g., implemented as one or more antenna arrays or antenna panels, for receive beamforming, transmit beamforming, or both.

[0105] Figure 14 illustrates example implementation details for the processing circuitry 86 according to an example embodiment. One or more microprocessors 100 are specially adapted to perform the operations described herein for the device 12, based on the execution of computer program instructions 104 stored in one or more memories 102. The memories 102 comprise circuitry within the storage ADA, for example, where the storage ADA shall be understood as comprising one or more types of computer-readable media that provide persistent storage for the computer program instructions 104.

[0106] The storage ADA includes, for example, both volatile storage used for live program execution, and nonvolatile storage used for longer-term storage and retention of the program instructions and any longer-term data. Examples of the storage ADA include SRAM, DRAM, FLASH, EEPROMP, Solid State Disk (SSD), etc.

[0107] Broadly, the processing circuitry 86 comprises fixed circuitry or programmatically configured circuitry, or a mix of fixed circuitry and programmatically configured circuitry. In addition to, or as an alternative to the one or more microprocessors 100, the processing circuitry 86 may include any one or more of microcontrollers, digital signal processors, applicationspecific integrated circuits, field programmable gate arrays, complex programmable logic devices, or other digital processing circuitry.

[0108] Figure 15 illustrates an embodiment of the device 12 implemented as processing units or processing modules. Here, a processing unit or module comprises a functional circuit or logic that is implemented via underlying physical processing circuitry, and in the illustrated example the device 12 includes an obtaining module 110 and a determining module 112.

[0109] In an example configuration, the obtaining module 110 is configured to obtain a synthetic range estimate computed based on the respective positions of the device 12 and another device 12 that is a sidelink-communications target for the device 12. For example, the obtaining module 110 is configured to request the synthetic range estimate from a node in the network 10. The determining module 112 is configured to determine a final range estimate based on the synthetic range estimate and a direct range estimate computed at the device 12 or at the other device 12, based on measurements of sidelink signaling exchanged between the two devices 12.

[0110] The device 12 in one or more embodiments further includes a sending module 114, where the sending module 114 is configured to send the direct range estimate to the network 10, for use by the network 10 in determining a final range estimate.

[0111] Figure 16 illustrates another example embodiment of a device 12, where the device 12 includes radio frequency (RF) front-end circuitry 120, baseband processing circuitry 122, host processing circuitry 124, a user interface 126, and a power supply / battery 128. The baseband processing circuitry 122 comprises all or part of the processing circuitry 86 illustrated in Figure 13, with the host processing circuitry 124 executing one or more software applications that make use of sidelink communications, where such usage may be conditioned or controlled in dependence on the sidelink range. Hence, the determination of an improved sidelink range estimate based on the use of direct and synthetic estimates of sidelink range provides an improved basis for conditioning or controlling sidelink communications.

[0112] The RF front-end circuitry 120 comprises all or part of the communication circuitry 80 illustrated in Figure 13, while details of the user interface 126 depend on the nature of the device 12. In one or more example embodiments, the user interface 126 includes a touchscreen and audio output.

[0113] Figure 17 illustrates a method 1700 of operation by a device 12, with the method 1700 including obtaining (Block 1702) a first range estimate with respect to a second device 12, based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged with the second device 12. The method 1700 further includes the device 12 obtaining (Block 1704) a second range estimate with respect to the second device 12, based on estimated positions of the two devices 12. For example, the device 12 carrying out the method 1700 obtains the second range estimate based on requesting it from a network node 30 in the network 10.

[0114] The method 1700 continues with the device 12 determining (Block 1706) a final range estimate based on joint consideration of the first and second range estimates. “Joint consideration” means deciding the final range estimate in view of the first and second range estimates, such as by fusing them or comparing them and selecting one of them based on a comparison.

[0115] Figure 18 illustrates another method 1800 performed at a device 12. The method 1800 includes the device 12 deciding (Block 1802) not to perform a range estimation procedure with respect to a second device 12. Here, the phrase “range estimation procedure” refers to a sidelink range procedure in the device 12 that may decide not to perform the procedure responsive to detecting or being informed of one or more conditions. For example, the device 12 may skip sidelink range estimation if it detects or otherwise knows that there is no LOS path to the other device 12.

[0116] Responsive to deciding not to perform the range estimation procedure, the device 12 requests (Block 1804) a synthetic range estimation from the network 10. In other words, in one or more embodiments of a device 12, or under certain conditions, the device 12 decides whether to perform sidelink range estimation with another device 12 and, in response to deciding not to perform sidelink range estimation, the device 12 obtains a synthetic estimate of the sidelink range from a network node 30 of the network 10.

[0117] Figure 19 illustrates a method 1900, which includes processing operations performed by any one or any combination of a first device 12, a network node 30, or a positioning reference unit, such as another device 12 operating as a positioning reference unit. The method 1900 includes deciding (Block 1902) that a synthetic sidelink range estimate should be used as the estimate of sidelink range between the first device 12 and a second device 12 and using or sending for use (Block 1904) the synthetic sidelink range estimate. For example, if the first device 12 makes the decision in Block 1902 and has or obtains the synthetic sidelink range estimate, then Block 1904 comprises the first device 12 using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the second device 12, e.g., for performing any computations or taking any actions that depend on the sidelink range between the first and second devices 12. On the other hand, if a network node or other entity makes the decision in Block 1902, then Block 1904 comprises, for example, that network node or other entity sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first device 12, for use.

[0118] Thus, one or more embodiments comprise a method 2000 of operation by a wireless communication device for determining an estimate of sidelink range to another wireless communication device. The method 2000, which is shown in Figure 20, includes: (a) receiving (Block 2002) a synthetic sidelink range estimate; and (b) using (Block 2004) the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device.

[0119] Receiving the synthetic sidelink range estimate comprises, for example, transmitting a request for the synthetic sidelink range estimate and receiving the synthetic sidelink range estimate in return. The synthetic sidelink range estimate is received, for example, from a LMF or a positioning reference unit. In at least one embodiment, the request identifies the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device, and the request indicates a location of the wireless communication device in at least one embodiment. The request may indicate the location of both wireless communication devices.

[0120] Receiving the synthetic sidelink range estimate comprises, for example, receiving the synthetic sidelink range estimate as assistance information sent from a LMF of the wireless communication network.

[0121] In at least one embodiment of the method, the method further includes the wireless communication device: (a) performing a sidelink ranging procedure with respect to another wireless communication device, the sidelink ranging procedure yielding a direct sidelink range estimate for the distance between the wireless communication devices that is based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device; and (b) sending a request message towards the positioning reference unit or the network node, requesting the synthetic sidelink range estimate. In this context, the wireless communication device using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device comprises deciding not to base the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device on the direct estimate of sidelink range in response to comparing the synthetic and direct sidelink range estimates.

[0122] In at least one embodiment, the wireless communication device using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device comprises the wireless communication device deciding to use the synthetic sidelink range estimate rather than a direct sidelink range estimate in response to determining that the synthetic sidelink range estimate is smaller than the direct sidelink range estimate. Here, the direct sidelink range estimate is based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device.

[0123] As another example, the wireless communication device using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device comprises the wireless communication device deciding to use the synthetic sidelink range estimate rather than a direct sidelink range estimate in response to receiving signaling from the network node, directing use of the synthetic sidelink range as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device.

[0124] Another example of carrying out the operations shown in Figure 19 comprises a method of operation by a network node of a wireless communication network, for assisting a first wireless communication device with determining an estimate of sidelink range to a second wireless communication device. The method includes the network node: (a) obtaining a synthetic sidelink range estimate that estimates the range between the first and second wireless communication devices, based on estimated positions of the first and second wireless communication devices; and (b) sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device.

[0125] Sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device comprises, for example, sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate in assistance information sent from the network node for the first wireless communication device. In one or more embodiments, the assistance information directs the first wireless communication device to use the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the second wireless communication device.

[0126] In at least one embodiment, sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device comprises the network node comparing a direct sidelink range estimate to the synthetic sidelink range estimate. Here, the direct sidelink range estimate is based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device, with the network node deciding to send the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device responsive to a result of the comparison. As a particular example, the network node decides to send the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device responsive to determining that the synthetic sidelink range estimate is smaller than the direct sidelink range estimate. The network node receives the direct sidelink range estimate from the first wireless communication device, for example.

[0127] In at least one embodiment, sending the sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device comprises the network node receiving a request for the synthetic sidelink range estimate from the first wireless communication device and sending the sidelink range estimate in response.

[0128] The network node for carrying out any of the above operations is a LMF, in one or more embodiments. Figure 21 illustrates another example of the network 10 where the RAN 20 is an NG- RAN that provides a NR air interface via gNBs as a first type of radio network node 22-1 and an LTE air interface via NG-eNBs as another type of radio network node 22-2. The example network 10 in Figure 19 further includes a Fifth Generation (5G) Core Network that includes an Authentication and Mobility management Function (AMF) 130, and a LMF 132, which may be coupled to an Emergency Services Call (EMC) function 134.

[0129] With the above in mind, the techniques disclosed herein in one or more embodiments exploit the combined knowledge of the devices 12 and the network 10, to produce a more reliable range estimate between two devices 12. This combined knowledge can be beneficial for both the network 10 and the devices 12, as to improve the accuracy of ranging, positioning, and other related services.

[0130] In at least one example embodiment or operating scenario, two devices 12 perform sidelink ranging, based on one or both of them making measurements on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between them. One or both devices 12 have coverage with respect to a network 10 and at least one of the devices 12 requests the network 10 to determine a synthetic estimate of the sidelink range — i.e., an estimate computed from the respective positions of the two devices 12 rather than estimated from sidelink signal measurements. The network 10 determines the position using any one or more network-based positioning procedures, e.g., a multilateration procedure, or the positions of the devices 12 are known from Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) measurements by GNSS receivers in the respective devices 12.

[0131] As noted, one or both the involved devices 12 may be interested in a service where the distance or range to another device must be determined. Once the network 10 provides a synthetic range estimate, potentially containing reliability information like estimation variance, the device 12 considers it jointly with the direct range estimate computed from sidelink signal measurements. For example, the device 12 combines the two estimates as a weighted combination, where the weights depend on the respective confidence or quality levels of the two estimates.

[0132] The range can be based upon distance calculation between a radio network node 22 and each of the devices 12, such as distance “d” = sqrt(x2-xl)pow2 + (y2-yl)pow2. The range can be also based upon pathloss calculation based upon any UL transmission from the respective devices 12, round-trip timing, angular / directional measurements, etc.

[0133] The synthetic range estimate can provide the direction between the devices 12 relative to a reference direction, e.g., the magnetic north pole. The device 12 that received the synthetic range estimate can then use internal sensors, e.g., a compass, to translate the relative direction into the coordinate system applicable at the device 12 and its antenna orientation. In one or more embodiments, a network node 30 in the network 10 obtains an improved estimate of sidelink range between two devices 12 by requesting a sidelink measurement report that includes a direct estimate of the sidelink range between the two devices 12 or provides measurements supporting computation of the direct estimate of sidelink range. The network 30 also obtains estimates of the respective positions of the two devices 12 and computes a synthetic range estimate from the positions and determines a final range estimate from the direct and synthetic range estimates.

[0134] In one embodiment, the two devices 12 know their positions, with or without network assistance, i.e., network independent. The two devices 12 then exchange their positions (potentially with reliability information) amongst each other, alternatively only one sharing its position with the other device 12. Based on the two position estimates, a synthetic range can be computed, to be fused with a range measurement between the two devices 12, as previously discussed.

[0135] In one embodiment, the smaller of the range estimates from the sidelink range measurements among UEs and synthetic range estimate at the network from the position estimates of the UEs would provide an indication of the correctness of the range estimates. It is more likely for the smaller range estimate to be more correct than the larger one.

[0136] As noted, a Positioning Reference Unit or PRU may perform the determination of the synthetic range estimate or provide positioning-error information for improving such determinations. In an Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT) context, a PRU can be installed at a known position with the antenna orientation known to a location server in the network 10 or provided to the devices 12, which can perform device-based positioning. In such cases, a given device 12 performs the ranging with the PRU and provides range estimation (or RTT between the device 12 and the PRU) to an LMF or other positioning node in the network 10. The LMF then computes a synthetic range estimate with respect to the device 12 and the PRU and provides the synthetic range estimate to the device 12.

[0137] Another example involves the case where there is NLOS between the involved radio network node(s) with respect to each of the two devices 12. The different computed RSTD and ranging errors need to be analyzed and the network 10 may need to apply quality tagging to such measurements. In one embodiment, the network 10 assigns appropriate weights to the position measurements depending on the quality of the synthetic and direct range estimates. For example, the network 10 recognizes that the channel conditions between the two devices 12 are not as good as between each device 12 and the network 10. Correspondingly, the network 10 assigns a lower weight to the direct range estimate as compared to the synthetic range estimate. More broadly, in at least one embodiment, one or more network nodes of the network 10 use knowledge of network and sidelink channel conditions to determine weights for use in combining or comparing the direct and synthetic range estimates.

[0138] In at least one embodiment, the network 10 uses the direct estimate of sidelink range determined by / between two devices 12 as a basis for improving or validating its position estimation(s) for one or both of the devices 12. That is, the network 10 determines the position of one or both of the two devices 12, e.g., based on network-based positioning measurements as described in the Background section, and it then checks or refines the resulting position estimate(s) based on the direct estimate of the sidelink range determined via the sidelink ranging procedure carried out between the devices 12.

[0139] In one embodiment, when NR DL-TDOA positioning method is used by the network 10, the location server (e.g., the LMF) may request a device 12 to report sidelink range measurements that it performed with one or more other devices 12 along with the RSTD measurements provided as part of the NR-DL-TDOA-ProvideLocationlnformation IE as defined in 3GPP TS 37.355 V16.7.0. In some embodiments, the request by the location server to a device 12 to report sidelink range measurements is included in the NR-DL-TDOA- RequestLocationlnformation information element (IE) as defined in 3GPP TS 37.355 V16.6.0.

[0140] In response to the request from the location server, the device will report sidelink range measurements as part of the NR-DL-TDOA-ProvideLocationlnformation IE as defined in 3GPP TS 37.355 V16.6.0. The device 12 may report sidelink range measurements associated with one other device 12 or multiple other devices 12 as part of the NR-DL-TDOA- ProvideLocationlnformation IE. As described above, the location server may combine the sidelink range measurements reported by the device with the RSTD measurements.

[0141] In another embodiment, when the NR downlink angle of departure (AoD) positioning method is used by the network 10, the location server (e.g., the LMF) may request a device 12 to report sidelink range measurements that it performed with other devices 12 along with the NR DL-AoD measurements provided as part of the NR-DL-AoD-ProvideLocationlnformation IE as defined in 3GPP TS 37.355 V16.6.0. In some embodiments, the request by the location server to a device 12 to report sidelink range measurements is included in the NR-DL-AoD- RequestLocationlnformation information element (IE) as defined in 3GPP TS 37.355 V16.6.0.

[0142] In response to the request from the location server, the device 12 will report sidelink range measurements as part of the NR-DL-TDOA-ProvideLocationlnformation IE as defined in 3GPP TS 37.355 V16.6.0. The device 12 may report sidelink range measurements associated with one other device 12 or multiple other devices 12 as part of the NR-DL-AoD- ProvideLocationlnformation IE. As described above the location server may combine the sidelink range measurements reported by the device 12 with the NR DL-AoD measurements. In yet another embodiment, when NR Multi-RTT positioning method is used by the network 10, the location server (e.g., the LMF) may request a device 12 to report sidelink range measurements that it performed with other devices 12 along with the UE Rx-Tx time difference measurements provided as part of the NR-Multi-RTT-ProvideLocationlnformation IE as defined in 3GPP TS 37.355 V16.6.0. In some embodiments, the request by the location server to a device 12 to report sidelink range measurements is included in the NR-DL-AoD- RequestLocationlnformation information element (IE) as defined in 3GPP TS 37.355 V16.6.0. In response to the request from the location server, the device 12 will report sidelink range measurements as part of the NR-Multi-RTT-ProvideLocationlnformation IE as defined in 3GPP TS 37.355 V16.6.0. The device 12 may report sidelink range measurements associated with one other device 12 or multiple other devices 12 as part of the NR-Multi-RTT- ProvideLocationlnformation IE. As described above, the location server may combine the sidelink range measurements reported by the device 12 with the UE Rx-Tx time difference measurements and the gNb Rx-Tx time difference measurements.

[0143] For examples of scenarios where one device 12 conditions or controls the use of one or more services based on sidelink range, see 3GPP TS 22.261, Section 7.9. There, listed use cases include smart TV remote operations, picture or video sharing, distance-based smart control of certain devices, etc. Thus, in an example scenario, an improved estimate of sidelink range — i.e., one based on joint consideration of synthetic and direct range estimates — may be used for improved enabling of a sidelink service between two devices 12. Example services include media content delivery, access control and enhanced security, and inter-vehicle distance measurements for safety applications.

[0144] Broadly, by jointly considering direct sidelink range estimates with synthetic range estimates derived from absolute positioning estimates of the involved devices 12, the reliability of the final range estimate can be improved. Conversely, the absolute positions estimated for a given device 12 may be improved by considering a direct estimate of the sidelink range(s) between that device 12 and one or more other devices 12.

[0145] Example Embodiments

[0146] Group A Embodiments

[0147] Al. A method of operation by a first wireless communication device, the method comprising: obtaining a first range estimate, containing one or both of distance and direction, with respect to a second wireless communication device, based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the first and second wireless devices; obtaining a second range estimate, containing one or both of distance and direction in a given frame of reference, with respect to the second wireless communication device, based on estimated positions of the first and second wireless communication devices; and determining a final range estimate based on joint consideration of the first and second range estimates.

[0148] A2. The method of embodiment Al, wherein obtaining the first range estimate comprises performing the signal measurements and calculating the first range estimate at the first wireless communication device, or receiving the signal measurements from the second wireless communication device and calculating the first range estimate at the first wireless communication device from them, or receiving the first range estimate from the second wireless communication device, based on the second wireless communication device performing the signal measurements.

[0149] A3. The method of embodiment Al or A2, wherein obtaining the second range estimate comprises receiving the second range estimate from a network node of a wireless communication network.

[0150] A4. The method of embodiment A3, further comprising receiving an indication of reliability or quality for the second range estimate, in conjunction with receiving the second range estimate.

[0151] A5. The method of embodiment A3 or A4, further comprising sending a request to the network node or another node in the wireless communication network, requesting the second range estimate, and wherein the second range estimate is received responsive to the request.

[0152] A6. The method of embodiment A5, wherein sending the request to the network node or the other network node in the wireless communication network is performed conditionally, in dependence on whether one or more defined conditions are fulfilled, such as a reliability or quality of the first range estimate being below a corresponding threshold.

[0153] A7. The method of any of embodiments A1-A6, wherein the first range estimate is a direct or measured range estimate determined by one or both the first and second wireless communication devices, based on the signal measurements, and wherein the second range estimate is an indirect range estimate, also referred to as a derived or synthesized range estimate, determined by a network node of a wireless communication network, based on the estimated positions of the first and second wireless communication devices.

[0154] A8. The method of any of embodiments A1-A7, wherein the estimated positions are determined using one or more of: measurements and procedures performed by nodes in the wireless communication network; or originating from the first and second wireless communication devices based on network-independent or network-assisted methods, such as Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) position determination.

[0155] A9. The method of any of embodiments A1-A8, wherein determining a final range estimate based on joint consideration of the first and second range estimates comprises any one of: choosing either the first or the second range estimate as the final range estimate, in dependence on which one has a higher reliability or quality; choosing the smaller one of the first and second range estimates as the final range estimate; determining the final range estimate as a combination of the first and second range estimates, such as forming the average of the first and second range estimates or forming a weighted average of the first and second range estimates, where the weighting is based on respective reliabilities or qualities of the first and second range estimates.

[0156] A10. A method of operation by a wireless communication device, the method comprising: deciding not to perform a range-estimation procedure with respect to another wireless communication device or deciding not to use results obtained from the range estimation procedure, and, in response to either decision, requesting a synthetic range estimate from a network node of a wireless communication network providing network coverage for the wireless communication device; wherein the range-estimation procedure bases range estimation on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device, and wherein the network node or another network node in the wireless communication network computes the synthetic range estimate from the positions estimated or reported for the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device. Al l. The method of embodiment A10, wherein requesting the synthetic range comprises sending a request message that identifies the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device.

[0157] A 12. The method of embodiment A10 or Al 1, wherein requesting the synthetic range comprising sending a request message that indicates the positions of the wireless communication device.

[0158] A13. A method of operation by a wireless communication device, the method comprising: performing a sidelink ranging procedure with respect to another wireless communication device, the ranging procedure yielding a first range estimate for the distance between the wireless communication devices; send a request message towards a network node of a wireless communication network, requesting a second range estimate, the request message identifying the wireless communication devices; receiving the second range estimate from the network node or another network node of the wireless communication network, the second range estimate determined from estimated positions of the wireless communication devices; and determining a final range estimate in dependence on the first range estimate and the second range estimate.

[0159] AA. A method of operation by a wireless communication device operative to carry out any of the steps of any of embodiments A1-A13, further comprising generating user data for a host computer, and transmitting the user data to a radio network node of a wireless communication network, for forwarding by the wireless communication network towards the host computer.

[0160] Group B Embodiments

[0161] B l. A method of operation by a network node of a wireless communication network, the method comprising: determining a range estimate for the distance between first and second wireless communication devices, based on estimated positions of first and second wireless communication devices; and sending the range estimate to one or both of the wireless communication devices. B2. The method of embodiment B l, further comprising receiving information from another node in the network or from one or both of the first and second wireless communication devices, indicating the estimated positions of the first and second wireless communication devices.

[0162] B3. The method of embodiment B 1 or B2, further comprising determining the range estimate responsive to receiving a request for the range estimate from one or both of the first and second wireless communication devices.

[0163] B4. The method of embodiment B 1 or B2, further comprising performing or initiating the performance of positioning procedures for the first and second wireless communication devices, the positioning procedures based network measurements, device measurements, or satellite positioning, or any combination thereof.

[0164] B5. The method of any of embodiments B 1-B4, wherein the network node comprises a radio access node, and wherein the method further comprises the radio access node allocating communication resources of the wireless communication network, for sidelink ranging operations between the first and second wireless communication devices.

[0165] B6. The method of embodiment B5, wherein the radio network node provides the range estimate as second range estimate in relation to a first range estimate determined by the first and second wireless communication devices using the allocated communication resources.

[0166] B7. The method of any of embodiments B 1-B4, wherein the network node comprises a positioning node in the wireless communication network, such as a Location Management Function (LMF) operating according to 3 GPP specifications.

[0167] B8. The method of any of embodiments B 1-B8, further comprising sending reliability or quality information for the range estimate, in conjunction with sending the range estimate.

[0168] BB. A method of operation by a network node of a wireless communication network, wherein the network node is operative to carry out any of the steps of any of embodiments B1-B8, and wherein the method comprises receiving user data sent from a host computer for a wireless communication device served by the wireless communication network, and transmitting the user data to the wireless communication device directly via a radio transmission, or indirectly by forwarding the user data to a radio access node for radio transmission. Group C Embodiments

[0169] Cl. A wireless communication device comprising: processing circuitry configured to perform any of the steps of any of the Group A embodiments; and power supply circuitry configured to supply power to the processing circuitry.

[0170] C2. A wireless communication device comprising: one or more microprocessors; and memory storing computer program instructions that, when executed by the one or more microprocessors, configure the one or more microprocessors to control the wireless communication device to perform any of the steps of any of the Group A embodiments.

[0171] C3. A wireless communication device comprising: communication circuitry configured to exchange wireless signaling with radio access nodes of a wireless communication network; and processing circuitry operatively associated with the communication circuitry and configured to carry out any of the steps of any of the Group A embodiments.

[0172] C4. A wireless communication device comprising: an antenna configured to send and receive wireless signals; radio front-end circuitry connected to the antenna and to processing circuitry, and configured to condition signals communicated between the antenna and the processing circuitry; the processing circuitry being configured to perform any of the steps of any of the Group A embodiments; an input interface connected to the processing circuitry and configured to allow input of information into the UE to be processed by the processing circuitry; an output interface connected to the processing circuitry and configured to output information from the UE that has been processed by the processing circuitry; and a battery connected to the processing circuitry and configured to supply power to the UE.

[0173] C5. A wireless communication network node comprising: processing circuitry configured to perform any of the steps of any of the Group B embodiments; and power supply circuitry configured to supply power to the processing circuitry.

[0174] C6. A wireless communication network node comprising: one or more microprocessors; and memory storing computer program instructions that, when executed by the one or more microprocessors, configure the one or more microprocessors to control the network node to perform any of the steps of any of the Group B embodiments.

[0175] C7. A wireless communication network node comprising: communication circuitry configured to communicate directly or indirectly with wireless communication devices having radio connections with the wireless communication network; and processing circuitry operatively associated with the communication circuitry and configured to control the network node to carry out any of the steps of any of the Group B embodiments.

[0176] C8. A host configured to exchange user data with a wireless communication device that is communicatively coupled to the host via a wireless communication network, the data exchanged in an over-the-top (OTT) service provided by the host, wherein the host comprises: processing circuitry configured to generate outgoing user data for the wireless communication device and process incoming user data from the wireless device; and a network interface configured to send the outgoing user data towards the wireless communication device, for wireless transmission to the wireless communication device by the wireless communication network, and receive the incoming wireless data sent by the wireless device via the wireless communication network; wherein the wireless communication device is configured to perform any of the steps of any of the Group A embodiments and a network node of the wireless communication network is configured to perform any of the steps of any of the Group B embodiments.

[0177] C9. The host of the previous embodiment, wherein the OTT service depends on a determination of range between the wireless communication device and another wireless communication device, and wherein the determination of the range is improved by the wireless communication device performing any of the steps of any of the Group A embodiments and the network node performing any of the steps of any of the Group B embodiments.

[0178] CIO. The host of the previous embodiment, wherein the network node comprises a positioning node of the wireless communication network, and wherein, as part of the OTT service, the host communicates with the network node, with respect to locating the wireless communication device, to support determination of the range according to the performance according to any of the steps of the Group A embodiments by the device and the performance according to any of the steps of the Group B embodiments by the network node. Notably, modifications and other embodiments of the disclosed invention(s) will come to mind to one skilled in the art having the benefit of the teachings presented in the foregoing descriptions and the associated drawings. Therefore, it is to be understood that the invention(s) is / are not to be limited to the specific embodiments disclosed and that modifications and other embodiments are intended to be included within the scope of this disclosure. Although specific terms may be employed herein, they are used in a generic and descriptive sense only and not for purposes of limitation.

Claims

CLAIMS1. A method of operation by a wireless communication device for determining an estimate of sidelink range to another wireless communication device, the method comprising: receiving a synthetic sidelink range estimate, the synthetic sidelink range estimate synthesized from estimated positions of the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device; and using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device.

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein the synthetic sidelink range estimate is received responsive to the wireless communication device transmitting a request for the synthetic sidelink range estimate.

3. The method according to claim 2, wherein the request identifies the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device.

4. The method according to claim 2 or 3, wherein the request indicates a location of the wireless communication device.

5. The method according to any one of claims 1-4, wherein receiving the synthetic sidelink range estimate comprises receiving the synthetic sidelink range estimate as assistance information sent from a Location Management Function (LMF) of the wireless communication network.

6. The method according to any one of claims 1-5, further comprising: performing a sidelink ranging procedure with respect to the other wireless communication device, the sidelink ranging procedure yielding a direct sidelink range estimate for the distance between the wireless communication devices that is based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device; and sending a request message towards a positioning reference unit or a network node, requesting the synthetic sidelink range estimate; and wherein using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device comprises deciding not to base the34estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device on the direct estimate of sidelink range in response to comparing the synthetic and direct sidelink range estimates.

7. The method according to any one of claims 1-5, wherein using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device comprises deciding to use the synthetic sidelink range estimate rather than a direct sidelink range estimate in response to determining that the synthetic sidelink range estimate is smaller than the direct sidelink range estimate, wherein the direct sidelink range estimate is based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device.

8. The method according to any one of claims 1-5, wherein using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device comprises deciding to use the synthetic sidelink range estimate rather than a direct sidelink range estimate in response to receiving signaling from the network node, directing use of the synthetic sidelink range as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device, wherein the direct sidelink range estimate is based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device.

9. A method of operation by a network node or positioning reference unit of a wireless communication network, for assisting a first wireless communication device with determining an estimate of sidelink range to a second wireless communication device, the method comprising: obtaining a synthetic sidelink range estimate that estimates the range between the first and second wireless communication devices, based on estimated positions of the first and second wireless communication devices; and sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate to at least one of the first wireless communication device and another positioning node in the network.

10. The method according to claim 9, wherein sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device comprises sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate in assistance information for the first wireless communication device.3511. The method according to claim 10, wherein the assistance information directs the first wireless communication device to use the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the second wireless communication device.

12. The method according to any one of claims 9-11, wherein sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device comprises comparing a direct sidelink range estimate to the synthetic sidelink range estimate, the direct sidelink range estimate based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device, and deciding to send the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device responsive to a result of the comparison.

13. The method according to claim 12, wherein deciding to send the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device comprises deciding to send the synthetic sidelink range estimate responsive to determining that the synthetic sidelink range estimate is smaller than the direct sidelink range estimate.

14. The method according to claim 12 or 13, further comprising receiving the direct sidelink range estimate from the first wireless communication device.

15. The method according to claim 9, wherein sending the sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device comprises receiving a request for the synthetic sidelink range estimate from the first wireless communication device and sending the sidelink range estimate in response.

16. The method according to any one of claims 9-15, wherein the network node is a Location Management Function (LMF).

17. A wireless communication device configured for determining an estimate of sidelink range to another wireless communication device, the wireless communication device comprising: communication circuitry; and processing circuitry configured to: receive, via the communication circuitry, a synthetic sidelink range estimate, the synthetic sidelink range estimate synthesized from estimated positions ofthe wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device; and use the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device.

18. The wireless communication device according to claim 17, wherein the processing circuitry is configured to transmit a request for the synthetic sidelink range estimate.

19. The wireless communication device according to claim 18, wherein the request identifies the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device.

20. The wireless communication device according to claim 18 or 19, wherein the request indicates a location of the wireless communication device.

21. The wireless communication device according to any one of claims 17-20, wherein the processing circuitry is configured to receive the synthetic sidelink range estimate as assistance information sent from a Location Management Function (LMF) of the wireless communication network.

22. The wireless communication device according to any one of claims 17-21, wherein the processing circuitry is configured to: perform a sidelink ranging procedure with respect to the other wireless communication device, the sidelink ranging procedure yielding a direct sidelink range estimate for the distance between the wireless communication devices that is based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device; and send a request message towards a positioning reference unit or a network node, requesting the synthetic sidelink range estimate; and wherein, with respect to using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device, the processing circuitry is configured to decide not to base the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device on the direct estimate of sidelink range in response to comparing the synthetic and direct sidelink range estimates.

23. The wireless communication device according to any one of claims 17-21, wherein, with respect to using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device, the processing circuitry is configured to decide to use the synthetic sidelink range estimate rather than a direct sidelink range estimate in response to determining that the synthetic sidelink range estimate is smaller than the direct sidelink range estimate, wherein the direct sidelink range estimate is based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device.

24. The wireless communication device according to any one of claims 17-21, wherein, with respect to using the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device, the processing circuitry is configured to decide to use the synthetic sidelink range estimate rather than a direct sidelink range estimate in response to receiving signaling from the network node, directing use of the synthetic sidelink range as the estimate of sidelink range to the other wireless communication device, wherein the direct sidelink range estimate is based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device.

25. An apparatus configured for operation in a wireless communication network, for assisting a first wireless communication device with determining an estimate of sidelink range to a second wireless communication device, the apparatus comprising: communication circuitry; and processing circuitry configured to: obtain a synthetic sidelink range estimate that estimates the range between the first and second wireless communication devices, based on estimated positions of the first and second wireless communication devices; and send, via the communication circuitry, the synthetic sidelink range estimate to at least one of the first wireless communication device and another positioning node in the network.

26. The apparatus according to claim 25, wherein the processing circuitry is configured to send the synthetic sidelink range estimate in assistance information for the first wireless communication device.3827. The apparatus according to claim 26, wherein the assistance information directs the first wireless communication device to use the synthetic sidelink range estimate as the estimate of sidelink range to the second wireless communication device.

28. The apparatus according to any one of claims 25-27, wherein, with respect to sending the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device, the processing circuitry is configured to compare a direct sidelink range estimate to the synthetic sidelink range estimate, the direct sidelink range estimate based on signal measurements made on one or more sidelink signals exchanged between the wireless communication device and the other wireless communication device, and decide to send the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device responsive to a result of the comparison.

29. The apparatus according to claim 28, wherein, with respect to deciding to send the synthetic sidelink range estimate to the first wireless communication device, the processing circuitry is configured to decide to send the synthetic sidelink range estimate responsive to determining that the synthetic sidelink range estimate is smaller than the direct sidelink range estimate.

30. The apparatus according to claim 28 or 29, wherein the processing circuitry is configured to receive the direct sidelink range estimate from the first wireless communication device.

31. The apparatus according to claim 25, wherein the processing circuitry is configured to receive a request for the synthetic sidelink range estimate from the first wireless communication device and send the sidelink range estimate in response.

32. The apparatus according to any one of claims 25-31, wherein the apparatus is a Location Management Function (LMF).39