Braking control system
The braking control system for railway vehicles addresses uneven wheel wear by dynamically adjusting brake workload, ensuring even wear and reducing maintenance needs, thereby enhancing safety and cost-effectiveness.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- GB2022011444
- Authority / Receiving Office
- GB · GB
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-08-05
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-13
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-08-05
AI Technical Summary
Railway vehicle wheels experience uneven wear due to different brake workload distributions, leading to varying diameters, which increases the risk of derailment and maintenance costs.
A braking control system that dynamically adjusts the mechanical brake workload to ensure even wear across wheels by applying a greater workload to selected wheels with larger diameters, converging their diameters to a uniform value, thereby reducing maintenance needs and improving ride quality.
The system effectively maintains even wheel diameters, reducing the risk of derailment and the frequency of maintenance, while optimizing maintenance costs and ensuring vehicle safety by integrating real-time wheel diameter measurement and adaptive braking control.
Smart Images

Figure 00000001_0000 
Figure 00000002_0000 
Figure 00000003_0000
Abstract
Description
Field of the Invention The present invention relates to braking control systems and particularly, although not exclusively, to braking control systems for railway vehicles. Background Train, trams and other railway vehicles typically run on wheels that do not have a rubber-based tyre. Instead, circumferential running surfaces of the typically metal wheels engage directly with the rails. Such vehicles may also utilise tread brakes, in which the running surface of the wheel that engages with the rail is also a brake track, a brake workload being applied to the wheel by means of a brake shoe that is pushed against the running surface. Overtime, the diameters of the wheels can be reduced due to frictional wear caused by application of the brake shoes, and also due to frictional wear with the rails, e.g. produced by slip and slide phenomena. The amount of wear experienced by each wheel of the vehicle, and thus the extent to which its diameter reduces overtime, is a function of its position in the vehicle and its relation to the other wheels of the vehicle. Accordingly, even when starting from a condition in which all of the wheels of the vehicle have equal diameters, the wheel diameters will likely differ after a period of use due to different wheels experiencing different wear rates. It is problematic for the wheels of a railway vehicles to have different wheel diameters because imbalances of wheel diameters can increase the risk of derailment and can reduce the ride quality of the vehicle. Accordingly, the wheels eventually reach a state where the discrepancy between the diameters of the wheels on the vehicle is too large, or the wheels reach a state in which one or more of them has a diameter less than a minimum permissible wheel diameter for the vehicle. When either of these states is reached, maintenance of the vehicle wheels is necessary: either the wheels with larger diameters can be machined down to a smaller diameter to better match the remaining wheels, or the wheels having small diameters can be replaced with new, larger diameter, wheels. However, such machining and / or replacement leads to an increase in the maintenance time and maintenance cost associated with the vehicle, especially when only a sub-set of the wheels needs machining or replacing at a given point in time. The present invention has been devised in light of the above considerations. Summary of the Invention It is desired to provide a braking control system for controlling the brake workload on different wheels of a railway vehicle with tread brakes such that the wheels of the vehicle wear at a more even rate and their wheel diameters remain similar. Accordingly, in a first aspect there is provided a braking control system for a railway vehicle according to claim 1. Advantageously, such a braking control system can distribute the mechanical brake workload such that the wheel diameters of the comparable wheels in a group all converge to the same value by applying a greater mechanical brake workload to the selected wheels, thus wearing down these wheels at a faster rate. A greater mechanical brake workload may be applied by a given brake by applying it for a longer period of time or applying it such as to exert a greater frictional force on its respective wheel. Accordingly, the ride quality of the vehicle can be maintained, the risk of vehicle derailment can be reduced, and the frequency of wheel maintenance, with its associated maintenance costs and maintenance time, can be reduced. Also the running condition is used to inform the operation of the braking control system to maintain the safety of the vehicle when running by avoiding application of an uneven brake workload in situations where doing so would put the vehicle at risk of an event such as buckling or derailment. Some optional features of the present disclosure will now be set out. These are applicable singly or in any combination with an aspect of the present disclosure except where such a combination is clearly impermissible or expressly avoided. The selection of suitable groups of comparable wheels depends on the configuration of the vehicle, and how it is operated. For example, the braking control system may be for a railway vehicle having plural bogies to which the wheels are mounted. In such a case, each group of comparable wheels may be formed by the wheels of a respective bogie. The wheel diameters of the plurality of wheels associated with a first bogie of the vehicle can thus all be made converge to the same value, but this value is not necessarily the same value that the wheel diameters of the wheels on a second bogie of the vehicle converge to. However, the lifetime of wheels on a given bogie can be prolonged. As another example, the braking control system may be for a railway vehicle having plural of carriages. In such a case, each group of comparable wheels may be formed by the wheels of a respective carriage. The wheel diameters of the plurality of wheels associated with a first carriage of the vehicle can thus all be made converge to the same value, but this value is not necessarily the same value that the wheel diameters of the wheels on a second carriage of the vehicle converge to. However, the lifetime of wheels on a given carriage can be prolonged. As yet another example, the braking control system may have a single group of comparable wheels, i.e. all of the plural wheels of the vehicle (whether formed from a single carriage or plural carriages) may form a group of comparable wheels. Optionally, the braking control system is configured to identify the selected wheels by identifying, in each group, the wheel having the smallest wheel diameter measurement of that group and selecting any wheel or wheels from that group having a wheel diameter measurement which is greater than the smallest wheel diameter measurement of the group by more than a threshold amount. This thresholding approach can reduce the likelihood of the braking control system overcompensating for a difference in wheel diameters which is not large enough to substantially increase the risk of derailment or to substantially reduce ride quality. The approach is especially advantageous in the case that updated wheel diameter measurements are relatively infrequently received by the vehicle control unit. The braking control system may further comprise a wheel measurement unit configured to measure the diameter of the wheels of the vehicle and provide the wheel diameter measurements as an input to the vehicle control unit. Alternatively, the wheel diameters can be measured by an automated or manually operated trackside system and then inputted into the braking control system. Conveniently, however, a wheel measurement unit which is part of the vehicle’s braking control system may reduce the maintenance time and costs associated with measuring the wheel diameters. Optionally the wheel measurement unit is configured to measure the diameter of the wheels of the vehicle whilst the vehicle is moving. This can help to improve the accuracy of the braking control system in maintaining the wheels of the or each group at the same diameter, as the selected wheels identified from the one or more groups can be changed in real time to reflect the updated wheel diameter measurements. Typically, each brake control unit is configured to provide braking feedback to the vehicle control unit and the vehicle control unit is configured to monitor the overall braking performance of the vehicle based on the braking feedback and disable the enhanced braking signal when the overall braking performance does not meet an overall braking performance standard. In this way, the overall braking performance can be compared with an overall braking performance standard, for example, a comparison to a reference braking pattern stored in signalling equipment of the railway vehicle can be made. This in turn allows the safety of the system to be improved, i.e. through feedback to the braking control system and disabling of the enhanced braking signal under certain running conditions of the vehicle where the overall braking performance standard cannot otherwise be met. Where the braking control system is for a railway vehicle having plural carriages, the braking control system may be configured such that each brake control unit is associated with a respective carriage (i.e. each brake control unit is associated with a single carriage, although each carriage may be associated with multiple brake control units) and receives, from the vehicle control unit, the mass of that carriage. The brake control unit may then be configured to calculate a mechanical brake workload to control the or each associated brake to apply to that brake’s respective wheel based on the brake command, the receipt or absence of an enhanced braking signal at the brake control unit for that brake, and the mass of the carriage the brake control unit is associated with (heavier carriages generally requiring a greater overall mechanical brake workload to achieve a given deceleration pattern). In this way, an appropriate overall mechanical brake workload for that carriage can be calculated more accurately and the ride quality can be improved. The braking control system may be for a railway vehicle having electrical traction motors for driving the vehicle, the motors being operable to perform regenerative braking in which kinetic energy of the vehicle is converted into electrical energy. In this case, the braking control system may be configured to obtain a total brake workload for the vehicle, calculate a total mechanical brake workload as a difference between the total brake workload and an electrical brake workload achievable by regenerative braking using the traction motors, and calculate a mechanical brake workload to apply with each brake to achieve the total mechanical brake workload. Advantageously, the braking control system can thus integrate regenerative and mechanical braking, and preferably prioritise regenerative braking over mechanical braking. The calculation of the total mechanical brake workload is typically performed centrally by the vehicle control unit but can also be conducted by one or more of the brake control units. Once the total mechanical brake workload has been calculated (by either a vehicle control unit or a brake control unit), the vehicle control unit may calculate the mechanical brake workload for each brake to apply, or each brake control unit may calculate the mechanical brake workload for each of its associated brakes. Having a brake control unit calculate the total mechanical brake workload and / or a mechanical brake workload for a brake to apply, is advantageous in that the brake control unit is generally more specialised with respect to brake control calculations. Moreover, having multiple brake control units calculate the total mechanical brake workload and / or a mechanical brake workload for a brake to apply provides the braking control system with higher redundancy, which is useful in the case of a fault with a brake control unit or vehicle control unit. The braking control system may further comprise a second vehicle control unit configured in the same manner as the first vehicle control unit. Advantageously, in the case of a vehicle that is to be operated from either end of the vehicle depending on the direction of travel, a vehicle control unit can be associated with a respective driver’s cab provided at each end of the vehicle. In a second aspect there is provided a railway vehicle comprising plural wheels, plural tread brakes for pushing against respective running surfaces of the wheels to apply mechanical brake workloads, and a braking control system according to the first aspect. In a third aspect there is provided a method of operating a vehicle braking system on a railway vehicle according to claim 12. The method of the third aspect can thus be implemented using the braking control system of the railway vehicle of the second aspect. Summary of the Figures Embodiments illustrating the principles of the invention will now be discussed with reference to the accompanying figures in which: Figure 1 illustrates schematically a railway vehicle having a braking control system. Figure 2 illustrates a process flowchart that the braking control system of Figure 1 can be configured to execute. Figure 3 illustrates schematically a railway vehicle having a variant braking control system. Figure 4A illustrates the progression of wheel wear in a conventional railway vehicle. Figure 4B illustrates the progression of wheel wear in a railway vehicle having the braking control system. Figure 5 illustrates schematically a railway vehicle having plural wheels and different groups of comparable wheels that the braking control system may identify selected wheels from. Figure 6 provides additional detail of a step of the process flowchart of Figure 2. Figure 7 provides additional detail of a further step of the process flowchart of Figure 2. Figure 8 illustrates a variant process flowchart that the braking control system can be configured to execute. Detailed Description of the Invention Aspects and embodiments of the present invention will now be discussed with reference to the accompanying figures. Further aspects and embodiments will be apparent to those skilled in the art. All documents mentioned in this text are incorporated herein by reference. Figure 1 illustrates schematically a railway vehicle comprising a braking control system. The railway vehicle comprises plural wheels 10a-j, each wheel 10 being associated with a carriage 50 of the vehicle and having a running surface. The vehicle further comprises plural tread brakes, each brake being configured to push against the running surface of a respective wheel 10. The braking control system comprises a vehicle control unit (VCU) 20 at a driver’s end of the vehicle and plural brake control units (BCUs) 30a-e in communication with the VCU 20 via a communication network. Each brake is associated with a respective BCU 30 that is configured to apply that brake to the brake’s respective wheel 10 on receipt of a brake command provided by the VCU 20. In the case of the vehicle in Figure 1, each carriage 50 of the vehicle comprises a BCU 30 and this BCU 30 is associated with all the brakes of the wheels 10 of that carriage, for example, BCU 30c is associated with the brakes of wheels 10e and 10f. However, other configurations can be envisaged. For example, there may be equal numbers of BCUs 30 and brakes to provide a one-to-one association of BCUs 30 and brakes, or there may be a respective BCU 30 for the brakes of each pair of wheels coupled together by an axle. A vehicle-mounted data storage unit 40, which is part of the braking control system, is configured to receive measured wheel diameters of the plural wheels 10 and provide the measured wheel diameters to the VCU 20. The operation of the braking control system illustrated in Figure 1 will now be described in relation to the process flowchart illustrated in Figure 2. Firstly, the wheel diameters of the plural wheels 10 of the vehicle are measured (step s100). The measured wheel diameters may be obtained in several different ways. For example, the wheel diameters may be measured automatically by the braking control system (described further in relation to Figure 3), or the wheel diameters may be manually measured by a trackside vehicle maintenance engineer or automatically measured by a trackside system, and then inputted into the braking control system. The trackside measurement and input may be part of regular maintenance procedures of the vehicle and may be carried out at a frequency in accordance with statutory requirements or regulations, or service requirements set by the vehicle operator. At step s200, the VCU 20 receives the wheel diameter measurements. At step s300, the VCU 20 obtains, e.g. from its own memory or from an external input, one or more groupings of comparable wheels. These groupings (described further in relation to Figure 4), which may be determined automatically by the VCU or by the vehicle operator, can be determined in reaction to the wheel diameter measurements. However, they may be determined in advance, in which case step s300 may be performed independently of (e.g. in parallel to) steps s100 and s200. Next, by comparing the wheel diameter measurements of the wheels 10 in each group of comparable wheels, the VCU 20 identifies selected wheels from the one or more groups of comparable wheels of the vehicle (step s400), each selected wheel 10 having a wheel diameter measurement that is greater than the wheel diameter measurements of other, unselected, wheels 10 of its group. The process of identifying selected wheels 10 from one or more groups of comparable wheels 10 of the vehicle is described further in relation to Figure 6. Once the selected wheels 10 are identified, the VCU 20 is configured to send an enhanced braking signal to the BCUs 30 fortheir associated brakes corresponding to the selected wheels 10 (step s500). Evidently, when a given BCU 30 is associated with more than one brake, the BCU 30 is also provided with the identities of the brakes of the selected wheels by the VCU 20. For example, the BCUs 30 can be associated with the wheels 10 by ID numbers or the like, which are also used as data tags for the wheel diameter measurements. The VCU 20 is configured to issue brake commands to the BCUs 30 when the brakes of the vehicle need to be applied to decelerate the vehicle (step s600). On receipt of a brake command, each BCU 30 controls an associated brake to apply a certain mechanical brake workload to that brake’s respective wheel 10 (step s700). In the case that the BCU 30 is associated with multiple brakes, it controls those associated brakes such that each brake applies a certain mechanical brake workload to that brake’s respective wheel 10. The braking control system is configured such that, on receipt of a brake command, each BCU 30 in receipt of an enhanced braking signal from the VCU 20 for an associated brake controls that brake to apply a greater brake workload to that brake’s wheel 10 than the brake workload applied to each unselected wheel 10 of the group. Accordingly, each time a brake command is received, the selected wheels 10 have a greater frictional workload applied to them than the other, unselected, wheels 10 of the group. This in turn increases the wear rate of the selected wheels 10 in comparison to the other, unselected, wheels 10 of the group. Accordingly, appropriate selection of the selected wheels 10 by the VCU 20 allows the wheel diameters of the wheels 10 in each group of comparable wheels to converge to the same value, thus helping to improve the ride quality of the vehicle and reduce derailment risk as a result equalising wheel diameters within the or each group of comparable wheels 10. Preferably, each BCU 30 receives the mass of the carriage 50 that it is associated with such that the mechanical brake workload exerted by each brake under the command of the BCU 30 can also factor in the mass of the carriage 50. In general, the heavier a given carriage, the higher the overall mechanical brake workload the brakes of the carriage should apply in order that all the carriages of the vehicle experience similar decelerations. Where the brake command is based on a discretised scale of braking levels, the mechanical brake workload to be exerted by a brake associated with a BCU 30 receiving an enhanced braking signal for that brake can be set, for example, as the midpoint between the braking level in the braking command and the braking level one level above the braking level in the braking command on the discretised scale. A greater brake workload may be obtained for a given brake by applying it on its respective wheel 10 for a longer period of time, but more typically it is obtained by applying the brake such as to exert a greater frictional force on the wheel 10. The present braking control system typically operates as a higher level system within the vehicle, and accordingly, it is possible to hand over operation of the brakes of the vehicle to a lower level braking system in the case of a malfunction, an incident, an emergency or the like. Figure 3 illustrates a railway vehicle comprising a braking control system modified from the braking control system of Figure 1. The first modification present in the braking control system in Figure 3 is the presence of multiple VCUs 20: a first VCU 20a is located in a carriage 50 at a first end of the vehicle and a second VCU 20b is located in a carriage 50 at a second end of the vehicle. Both the first VCU 20a and second VCU 20b are in communication with each of the BCUs 30a-e via the communication network. The first VCU 20a and second VCU 20b are configured in the same manner as the single VCU 20 described in relation to Figure 1. Providing the vehicle with a VCU 20a, 20b at either end of the vehicle facilitates operation of the vehicle from either end of the vehicle depending on the direction of travel. This is particularly useful where the vehicle is human-operated and the VCU 20 is configured to receive inputs from the operator in a driver’s cab. In any case, providing multiple VCUs 20 improves the resilience of the braking control system. The braking control system illustrated in Figure 3 further comprises an onboard wheel measurement unit 60 configured to measure the diameter of the plural wheels 10 of the vehicle. The wheel measurement unit 60 is configured to provide the wheel diameter measurements as an input to the VCU(s) 20. In Figure 3 the wheel diameter measurement input is via the data storage 40, but direct input into the VCU(s) 20 is also possible. The wheel measurement unit 60 may be configured to measure the wheel diameters whilst the vehicle is moving, for example, the wheel measurement unit 60 may use wheel diameter measurement technology as described in JPH02293667A or JPS55139002A. Advantageously, the wheel measurement unit 60 being able to automatically measure the wheel diameters whilst the vehicle is moving allows the VCU(s) 20 to be provided with real-time information on the wheel diameters, and accordingly the process of identifying selected wheels 10 from one or more groups of comparable wheels and sending enhanced braking signals to BCUs 30 for their associated brakes corresponding to those selected wheels 10 can be repeated at a higher frequency than if updated wheel diameter measurements can only be provided to the VCU(s) 20 when the vehicle is stationary. A benefit of real-time feedback to the VCU(s) 20 on wheel diameter measurements is that each wheel in a group of comparable wheels can be more precisely kept at the same diameter as the other wheels of that group. Finally, the vehicle in Figure 3 further comprises a traction unit (TU) 80 in a carriage 50 of the vehicle and the braking control system further comprises a traction control unit (TCU) 85 in communication with the TU 80, as well as in communication with the VCU(s) 20 and BCUs 30, via the communication network. The TU 80 comprises an electrical traction motor and a power conversion unit. Whilst only a single carriage 50 of the vehicle in Figure 3 has a TU 80, depending on the size and mass of the vehicle, multiple TUs 80 and TCUs 85 may be present in the vehicle. During deceleration of the vehicle, the motor of the TU 80 is operable to perform regenerative braking in which kinetic energy of the vehicle is converted into electrical energy by the power conversion unit. Accordingly, the TU 80 is able to provide an electrical brake workload to supplement a total mechanical brake workload applied by the tread brakes of the vehicle. The total brake workload is then the sum of the electrical brake workload and the total mechanical brake workload. The TCU 85 is configured to communicate with the TU 80 such as to control the electrical brake workload provided by the TU 80. Typically, regenerative braking is prioritised over mechanical braking, and thus the electrical brake workload is maximised where possible in the total brake workload. Figure 4A illustrates the progression of wheel wear in the case of a conventional railway vehicle without a braking control system of the type described above in relation to Figure 1 and 3. For the safety of railway vehicle operation and in order to maintain railway vehicle ride quality, it is typically required to replace a wheel 10 of a railway vehicle when either the diameter of the wheel reaches a minimum permissible wheel diameter, or the difference between the diameter of the wheel in question and the diameter of another wheel from a group of comparable wheels including the wheel in question becomes larger than a threshold amount. In Figure 4A, first wheel 10a and second wheel 10b form a group of comparable wheels. The wheels 10a, 10b of the vehicle in Figure 4A have worn unevenly to reach state 1: the first wheel 10a in state 1 of Figure 4A has a diameter of 910 mm and the second wheel 10b in state 1 of Figure 4A has a diameter of 880 mm. The diameter of the first wheel 10a in state 1 of Figure 4A is greater than the minimum permissible wheel diameter, and accordingly, the first wheel 10a does not require replacement in state 1. However, the diameter of the second wheel 10b in state 1 is the minimum permissible wheel diameter of the vehicle in Figure 4A (880 mm); accordingly, it is required to replace the second wheel 10b so that the vehicle operates safely and the ride quality does not deteriorate too greatly. In state 2 of Figure 4A, the second wheel 10b of the vehicle in state 1 has been replaced and the new second wheel 10b has a diameter of 940 mm, whilst the first wheel 10a of the vehicle is not replaced and still has a diameter of 910 mm. The difference in diameter between the first wheel 10a and the second wheel 10b is not greater than the threshold amount of, for example, 40 mm, and the vehicle can still be run safely. The vehicle is then run, and during running the first wheel 10a and second wheel 10b wear down through frictional interaction with the rails and brake shoes. After a period of running in which there is differential wear rates between the wheels 10a and 10b, state 3 of Figure 4A is reached, in which the wheel diameter of the first wheel 10a has reduced by 20 mm from state 2 to reach a diameter of 890 mm and the wheel diameter of the second wheel 10b has reduced by only 10 mm from state 2 to reach a diameter of 930 mm. In state 3, the difference in diameter between the first wheel 10a and the second wheel 10b is equal to the threshold amount by which wheel diameters of comparable wheels can differ for the vehicle in Figure 4A (40 mm). Accordingly, the running of the vehicle of Figure 4A is stopped for wheel maintenance when state 3 is reached. Since neither the first wheel 10a nor the second wheel 10b in state 3 of Figure 4A has a diameter equal to, or less than, the minimum permissible wheel diameter of the vehicle (880 mm), it is not desirable to replace either wheel 10a, 10b of the vehicle. Thus, rather than replacing the first wheel 10a, the second wheel 10b is machined down to have a diameter of 890 mm to match the first wheel’s diameter in state 3. Following this machining (state 4 of Figure 4A), both wheels 10a, 10b have a diameter (890 mm) greater than the minimum permissible wheel diameter (880 mm) and the difference in diameter between the first wheel 10a and the second wheel 10b (0 mm) is less than the threshold amount (40 mm), and accordingly the vehicle can continue to be run before it is necessary to replace one, or both, of the wheels 10a, 10b when one, or both, of the wheels reaches the minimum permissible wheel diameter (880 mm). In contrast to Figure 4A, Figure 4B illustrates the progression of wheel wear in the case of a railway vehicle running with the braking control system of Figure 1 or 3. States 1 and 2 of Figure 4B are the same as states 1 and 2 of Figure 4A described above. However, during the running between states 2 and 4 of Figure 4B, the braking control system is in use. The VCU 20 of the vehicle in Figure 4B receives wheel diameter measurements for the first wheel 10a and second wheel 10b of the vehicle, which form a group of comparable wheels of the vehicle. The VCU 20 identifies the second wheel 10b of the vehicle as a selected wheel from the group of comparable wheels because the diameter of the second wheel 10b in state 2 (940 mm) is greater than the diameter of the first wheel 10a in state 2 (910 mm). The VCU 20 then sends an enhanced braking signal to the BCU 30 for the brake corresponding to the selected second wheel 10b. Then, when a brake command is provided by the VCU 20 to the BCUs 30 during running of the vehicle, the BCU 30 corresponding to the second wheel 10b controls the brake of the second wheel 10b to apply a greater brake workload to that wheel 10b than the brake workload applied to the unselected first wheel 10a. As the vehicle uses tread brakes that push against the running surfaces of the wheels 10 of the vehicle, running the vehicle in this manner causes the second wheel 10b to be worn down at a greater rate than the first wheel 10a due to the greater frictional workload applied to the running surface of the second wheel 10b than the first wheel 10a. Thus, in state 3 of Figure 4B, the wheel diameter of the second wheel 10b has reduced by 40 mm from state 2, whilst the wheel diameter of the first wheel 10a has only reduced by 10 mm from state 2 and accordingly both wheels 10a, 10b have a diameter of 900 mm. In contrast to state 3 of Figure 4A, in state 3 of Figure 4B the difference in diameter between the first wheel 10a and the second wheel 10b (0 mm) is less than the threshold amount (40 mm), and also neither wheel 10a, 10b has a diameter less than the minimum permissible wheel diameter (880mm). Accordingly, the vehicle of Figure 4B can continue to run without undergoing the remedial machining process that was required in the case of Figure 4A. Eventually, state 4 of Figure 4B is reached, where both wheels 10a, 10b have reached the minimum permissible wheel diameter (880 mm) simultaneously, and conveniently both wheels 10a, 10b can be replaced at the same time. Figures 4A and 4B illustrate how the above-described braking control system can distribute a total mechanical brake workload that needs to be applied to the wheels 10 of a railway vehicle such that the wheel diameters of the wheels 10 in a group of selected wheels all converge to the same value by applying a greater brake workload to selected wheels 10 of the group that have a larger diameter than the other, unselected, wheels of the group, thus wearing down the selected wheels at a faster rate. Accordingly, the ride quality of the vehicle using the braking control system of Figures 1 and 3can be maintained, the risk of vehicle derailment can be kept lower than it would otherwise be, and the required frequency of wheel maintenance (e.g. wheel machining) and its associated maintenance costs and maintenance time, can be reduced. Figure 5 illustrates a railway vehicle having plural wheels 10a-p, plural bogies 90a-d, and plural carriages 50a, 50b, where each wheel 10a-p is mounted to a bogie 90 and each bogie 90a-d (and thus also each wheel 10a-r) is associated with a carriage 50 of the vehicle. For example, wheels 10a, 10b, 10i and 10k are mounted on bogie 90a, which is associated with carriage 50a. Moreover, each wheel 10 is coupled to another wheel 10 by an axle 11, for example, wheel 10a is coupled to wheel 10i by axle 11a. In the case of Figure 5, each bogie 90 is associated with two pairs of wheels and each carriage 50 is associated with two bogies 90 and thus four pairs of wheels, each pair of wheels coupled by an axle 11. However, it can be appreciated that the present invention is applicable to railway vehicles with different arrangements of wheels 10, bogies 90, carriages 50 and axles 11. In step s300 of Figure 2, the VCU 20 obtains groupings of comparable wheels of the vehicle, with the wheel diameter measurements of wheels within each group subsequently being compared to each other to identify one or more selected wheels from each such group (step s400). The BCUs 30 are then sent an enhanced braking signal (step s500) for the associated brakes corresponding to the selected wheels. The plural wheels of the vehicle can be grouped into groups of comparable wheels of the vehicle in a number of different ways. A first option is for each group of comparable wheels to be bogie-based, and thus formed by the wheels (10) of a respective bogie 90. In the case of the braking control system being applied to the vehicle in Figure 5, the groups of comparable wheels of the vehicle obtained by the VCU 20 can therefore be: Group 1: wheels 10a, 10b, 10i and 10j; Group 2: wheels 10c, 10d, 10k and 10I; Group 3: wheels 10e, 10f, 10m and 10n; and Group 4: wheels 10g, 10h, 10o and 10p. By identifying the comparable wheels of the vehicle as the wheels 10 mounted to the same bogie 90 of the vehicle as each other, the braking control system is able to converge all the wheel diameters of the wheels 10 mounted on a given bogie 90 to the same value, without this value necessarily being the same value to which the braking control system converges wheels 10 mounted on another bogie 90. Another option for grouping of wheels 10 is for each group of comparable wheels to be carriage-based and thus formed by the wheels 10 of a respective carriage 50a, 50b. In this case, the groups of comparable wheels of the vehicle obtained by the VCU 20 can therefore be: Group 1: wheels 10a-d, and 10i-l; and Group 2: wheels 10e-h, and wheel 10m-p. By identifying the comparable wheels of the vehicle as the wheels 10 associated with the same carriage 50a, 50b of the vehicle as each other, the braking control system is able to converge all the wheel diameters of the wheels 10 associated with a given carriage 50a, 50b to the same value, without this value necessarily being the same value to which the braking control system converges wheels 10 associated with another carriage 50a, 50b. Another option is for all of the wheels of the vehicle to form a single group of comparable wheels. In this case, the single group of comparable wheels of the vehicle obtained by the VCU 20 can therefore be: Group 1: wheels 10a-p. Another option for grouping of the wheels 10 is for each group of comparable wheels to be axle-based and thus formed by the wheels 10 of a respective axle 11. In this case, the groups of comparable wheels of the vehicle obtained by the VCU 20 can therefore be: Group 1: wheels 10a and 10i Group 2: wheels 10b and 10j Group 3: wheels 10c and 10k Group 4: wheels 10d and 101 Group 5: wheels 10e and 10m Group 6: wheels 10f and 10n Group 7: wheels 10g and 10o Group 8: wheels 10h and 10p By identifying the comparable wheels of the vehicle as the wheels 10 associated with the same axle 11 of the vehicle as each other, the braking control system is able to converge both wheels on an axle to the same value, without this value necessarily being the same value to which the braking control system converges wheels 10 associated with another axle of the same or a different carriage 50a, 50b. The choice of wheel group type will depend on factors such as: whether the carriages of a given vehicle formation are kept together or are swapped between other vehicle formations, whether a given vehicle experiences equal amounts of running in both directions, and whether the bogies are readily exchangeable. Having obtained the groups of comparable wheels of the vehicle, the VCU 20 considers each group in turn when identifying selected wheels. Each selected wheel identified by the VCU 20 from within a group of comparable wheels has a wheel diameter measurement that is greater than the wheel diameter measurements of other, unselected, wheels of its group of comparable wheels. Figure 6 provide further detail on how the VCU 20 may be configured to identify selected wheels from a group of comparable wheels, corresponding to step s400 in Figure 2. Firstly, a group of comparable wheels of the vehicle gj is selected (step s410). Then, the VCU 20 reads all the received wheel diameter measurements di j of wheels 10 within the group g^ (step s420). Having read the wheel diameters, the VCU 20 identifies the minimum wheel diameter dmiaj amongst the read wheel diameters dt j (step s430). Wheels 10 whose wheel diameters satisfy the inequality: di,j > dmin.j + th where th is a threshold amount set within the VCU 20 are identified as selected wheels of the group g^ (step s440). Having identified selected wheels of the group of comparable wheels, the VCU 20 checks if all groups of comparable wheels have been considered (step s450), if not all the groups have been considered, the process returns to step s410 for the next group, otherwise step s400 finishes. The threshold amount in step s 440 can be set based on the frequency with which updated wheel diameter measurements are received by the VCU 20. Generally, the lower the frequency with which the wheel diameter measurements are provided to the VCU 20, the larger th should be set, such that the braking control system does not overcompensate for a difference in wheel diameters by sending an enhanced brake signal for brakes that causes the wearing down of the selected wheels to overshoot by the time that updated wheel diameter measurements are received by the VCU 20. Advantageously, if the braking control system comprises a wheel measurement unit 60 that continuously measures the diameters of the wheels 10 and provides the wheel diameter measurements to the VCU 20, then th can be set low (even to zero) and the braking control system can provide real time control of the wheel diameters. Figure 7 provides further detail on how the present braking control system is typically configured to determine the mechanical brake workload for each brake in the case of a vehicle having traction units 80 whose traction motors are operable to perform regenerative braking, such as the vehicle illustrated in Figure 3. The process flowchart in Figure 7 corresponds to step s700 in Figure 2. At step s710, the total brake workload for a deceleration event is obtained based on the required deceleration of the vehicle, the starting velocity of the vehicle and desired finishing velocity of the vehicle for the deceleration event. At step s720, the electrical brake workload achievable by regenerative braking using the traction motors is obtained. In the case of the vehicle in Figure 3, for example, the achievable electrical brake workload is obtained by the TCU 85 from the TU 80. The total mechanical brake workload is then calculated by the VCU 20 as the difference between the total brake workload and the electrical brake workload (step s730). Once the total mechanical brake workload is calculated, the mechanical brake workload for each brake to apply is calculated by the VCU 20 based on the total mechanical brake workload, and whether or not that brake is for a selected or unselected wheel (i.e. whether or not the respective BCU 30 is in receipt of an enhanced braking signal for that brake from the VCU 20). In the case of a vehicle comprising a plurality of carriages 50, the respective masses of the carriage can also be a factor in determining the mechanical brake workloads of the brakes. Steps s730 and s740 may alternatively be conducted by one or more of the BCUs 30 or may be conducted by a combination of the VCU 20 and one or more BCUs 30. For example, it may be advantageous for the BCU(s) 30 to calculate the total mechanical brake workload and the mechanical brake workload for its associated brakes because there is higher redundancy for the BCUs 30 than with the VCU 20 (in the case of a fault or the like), or because the BCU 30 is better suited for brake control calculations. Alternatively, the VCU 20 may conduct step s730 and then provide the necessary information to each BCU 30 so that the BCUs 30 can conduct step s740. In any event, once the calculations are complete, each brake receives a signal from its associated BCU 30 to apply the mechanical brake workload calculated forthat brake to its respective wheel 10 (step s750). Figure 8 illustrates a modification of the process flowchart in Figure 2, wherein additional steps s800, s900 and s1200 are included for the purpose of monitoring the braking performance of the vehicle when operating under the braking control system. At steps800, the overall braking performance of the vehicle is monitored by each BCU 30 providing braking feedback for its associated brake(s) back to the VCU 20. Then, this overall braking performance is compared to an overall braking performance standard stored in the VCU 20 or signalling equipment for the vehicle (step s900). For example, a comparison between the overall braking performance and a reference braking pattern in signalling equipment for the railway vehicle can be made. Provided that the overall braking performance of the vehicle meets the standard, the VCU 20 can continue sending enhanced braking signal to the BCUs 30 for the brakes corresponding to selected wheels (step s500) and the braking control system waits for the next brake command to be issued by the VCU (s600). However, if the overall braking performance of the vehicle does not match the braking performance standard, the enhanced braking signal is disabled (step 1000). Figure 8 also contains another modification of the process flowchart in Figure 2 in the form of steps s1000, s1100 and s1200. In order to prevent the action of the braking control system from negatively impacting the safety of the vehicle during running, the brake control system is further configured such that the VCU 20 receives one or more running conditions of the vehicle (s1000) and, when the running condition indicates a heightened vehicle danger, the VCU 20 temporarily disables the enhanced braking signal (s1200). Examples of the running condition received by the VCU 20 include a speed of the vehicle, a required deceleration of the vehicle, a mass of the vehicle and a buckling risk of the vehicle. This modification enables the braking control system to avoid applying imbalanced mechanical brake workloads to the wheels 10 of the vehicle in scenarios where doing so would reduce the safety of the vehicle. One example of where the enhanced braking signal may be temporarily disabled is if the required deceleration of the vehicle is large in order to come to a stop before an obstacle: the VCU 20 disables the enhanced braking signal such that all of the brakes can be applied in such a way as to make the total mechanical brake workload of the vehicle as large as possible and thus achieve the large deceleration required. *** The features disclosed in the foregoing description, or in the following claims, or in the accompanying drawings, expressed in their specific forms or in terms of a means for performing the disclosed function, or a method or process for obtaining the disclosed results, as appropriate, may, separately, or in any combination of such features, be utilised for realising the invention in diverse forms thereof. While the invention has been described in conjunction with the exemplary embodiments described above, many equivalent modifications and variations will be apparent to those skilled in the art when given this disclosure. Accordingly, the exemplary embodiments of the invention set forth above are considered to be illustrative and not limiting. Various changes to the described embodiments may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention. For the avoidance of any doubt, any theoretical explanations provided herein are provided for the purposes of improving the understanding of a reader. The inventors do not wish to be bound by any of these theoretical explanations. Any section headings used herein are for organizational purposes only and are not to be construed as limiting the subject matter described. Throughout this specification, including the claims which follow, unless the context requires otherwise, the word “comprise” and “include”, and variations such as “comprises”, “comprising”, and “including” will be understood to imply the inclusion of a stated integer or step or group of integers or steps but not the exclusion of any other integer or step or group of integers or steps. It must be noted that, as used in the specification and the appended claims, the singular forms “a,” “an,” and “the” include plural referents unless the context clearly dictates otherwise. Ranges may be expressed herein as from “about” one particular value, and / or to “about” another particular value. When such a range is expressed, another embodiment includes from the one particular value and / or to the other particular value. Similarly, when values are expressed as approximations, by the use of the antecedent “about,” it will be understood that the particular value forms another embodiment. The term “about” in relation to a numerical value is optional and means for example + / - 10%.
Claims
1. A braking control system for a railway vehicle having plural wheels and plural tread brakes for pushing against respective running surfaces of the wheels to apply mechanical brake workloads, the braking control system comprising:a vehicle control unit; andplural brake control units in communication with the vehicle control unit, each brake being associated with a respective brake control unit that is configured to apply that brake on receipt of a brake command provided by the vehicle control unit;wherein the vehicle control unit is configured to:receive respective wheel diameter measurements for the wheels of the vehicle;identify selected wheels from one or more groups of comparable wheels of the vehicle, each selected wheel having a wheel diameter measurement that is greater than the wheel diameter measurements of other, unselected, wheels of its group; andsend an enhanced braking signal to the brake control units fortheir associated brakes corresponding to the selected wheels; andwherein the brake control units are further configured such that, when a brake command is provided by the vehicle control unit, each brake control unit in receipt of an enhanced braking signal for an associated brake controls that brake to apply a greater mechanical brake workload to that brake’s wheel than the mechanical brake workload applied to each unselected wheel of the group;wherein the vehicle control unit is further configured to receive one or more running conditions of the vehicle such as:a speed of the vehicle;a required deceleration of the vehicle;a mass of the vehicle; anda buckling risk of the vehicle; andwherein the vehicle control unit is further configured to temporarily disable the enhanced braking signal according to the running condition of the vehicle.
2. The braking control system according to claim 1, wherein the railway vehicle has plural bogies to which the wheels are mounted, and each group of comparable wheels is formed by the wheels of a respective bogie.
3. The braking control system according to claim 1, wherein the railway vehicle has plural carriages, and each group of comparable wheels is formed by the wheels of a respective carriage.
4. The braking control system according to claim 1, wherein the railway vehicle has a single group of comparable wheels.
5. The braking control system according to any preceding claim, wherein the vehicle control unit is configured to identify the selected wheels by:identifying, in each group, the wheel having the smallest wheel diameter measurement of that group; andselecting any wheel or wheels from that group having a wheel diameter measurement which is greater than the smallest wheel diameter measurement of the group by more than a threshold amount.
6. The braking control system according to any preceding claim, further comprising a wheel measurement unit configured to measure the diameter of the wheels of the vehicle and provide the wheel diameter measurements as an input to the vehicle control unit.
7. The braking control system according to claim 6, wherein the wheel measurement unit is configured to measure the diameter of the wheels of the vehicle whilst the vehicle is moving.
8. The braking control system according to any preceding claim, wherein:each brake control unit is configured to provide braking feedback to the vehicle control unit; andthe vehicle control unit is configured to monitor the overall braking performance of the vehicle based on the braking feedback and disable the enhanced braking signal when the overall braking performance does not meet an overall braking performance standard.
9. The braking control system according to any preceding claim, wherein the railway vehicle has plural carriages, and wherein:each brake control unit is associated with a respective carriage;each brake control unit receives, from the vehicle control unit, the mass of the carriage it is associated with; andeach brake control unit is configured to calculate a mechanical brake workload to control the or each associated brake to apply to that brake’s respective wheel based on the brake command, the receipt or absence of an enhanced braking signal for that brake at the brake control unit, and the mass of the carriage the brake control unit is associated with.
10. The braking control system according to any preceding claim, wherein the railway vehicle has electrical traction motors for driving the vehicle, the motors being operable to perform regenerative braking in which kinetic energy of the vehicle is converted into electrical energy, and wherein the braking control system is further configured to:obtain a total brake workload for the vehicle;calculate a total mechanical brake workload as a difference between the total brake workload and an electrical brake workload achievable by regenerative braking using the traction motors; andcalculate a mechanical brake workload to apply with each brake to achieve the total mechanical brake workload.
11. A railway vehicle comprising:plural wheels;plural tread brakes for pushing against respective running surfaces of the wheels to apply mechanical brake workloads; andthe braking control system according to any preceding claim.
12. A method of operating a railway vehicle braking system on a railway vehicle having plural wheels and plural tread brakes for pushing against respective running surfaces of the wheels to apply mechanical brake workloads,the method comprising performing an enhanced braking operation by executing the steps of: receiving respective wheel diameter measurements for the wheels of the vehicle; identifying selected wheels from one or more groups of comparable wheels of thevehicle, each selected wheel having a wheel diameter measurement that is greater than the wheel diameter measurements of other, unselected, wheels of its group; andcontrolling the mechanical brake workload applied to each wheel in a group of comparable wheels by its respective tread brake such that a greater brake workload is applied to each selected wheel of the group than is applied to each unselected wheel of the group; and the method further comprising:receiving one or more running conditions of the vehicle such as:a speed of the vehicle;a required deceleration of the vehicle;a mass of the vehicle; anda buckling risk of the vehicle; andtemporarily disabling performance of the enhanced braking operation according to the running condition of the vehicle.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Rail vehicle braking system and method for operating a rail vehicle braking system
US20180170329A1
Tachometer amplifier
US3640586A
Wheel slip system
US4347569A
Wheel diameter calibration system for vehicle slip / slide control
US6148269A
Traction control system and method
WO2009100498A1
