Guard
The guard with a tubular body and cup-shaped shield effectively prevents pine weevil damage by creating a dead-end space and using a variable diameter seal, offering superior protection to conifer saplings without pesticides or frequent reapplication, addressing the limitations of existing barriers in high pine weevil populations.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- GB2023008138
- Authority / Receiving Office
- GB · GB
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-31
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-04
AI Technical Summary
Current physical barriers for protecting conifer saplings from pine weevils, such as wax barriers and mechanical collars, have limited efficacy in areas with high pine weevil populations, and there is a need for a more effective solution that does not rely on pesticides or frequent reapplication.
A guard comprising a tubular body with a collar featuring a base platform and a cup-shaped shield creates a dead-end space that prevents insects from climbing, combined with a variable diameter seal and spring mechanism for easy application and long-lasting protection.
The guard provides enhanced protection against pine weevils, outperforming existing barriers without the need for pesticides or reapplication, effectively safeguarding saplings for up to three years by preventing insect access to the vulnerable lower sap content area.
Smart Images

Figure 00000000_0000_ABST
Abstract
Description
The present invention relates to a guard for plant saplings and particularly, although not necessarily exclusively, for protecting conifer saplings from pine weevils. Background to the Invention The large pine weevil (Hylobius abietis) is a beetle native to the UK and most of Europe. Adult pine weevils eat the bark of tree branches and saplings. The larval and pupal stages of the pine weevil lifespan are conducted in felled tree stumps where they consume the dead wood. Overpopulation of pine weevils has occurred, as the practise of clear-felling provides the perfect breeding ground for the pine weevils, because large numbers of tree stumps are provided for the weevils to lay eggs in. After 1-2 years when the adult pine weevils emerge, planting has typically commenced leaving the adults with an abundant food source. Pine weevils eat both deciduous (broadleaf) trees and conifers. For conifers in particular, damage is concentrated to the bottom 7-10 cm of the sapling (old growth) where the sap content is lowest. Should bark be eaten all of the way round the sapling at its base, the sapling can easily be killed. It is estimated that if left unprotected, 50-100% of saplings in a pine stand can be expected to perish. Currently, pesticides are used to protect saplings against pine weevils. In particular, pesticides containing acetamiprid are applied to the bark of the sapling. Pesticide is reapplied once or twice a year for 3-5 years after the tree was first planted. However, there is generally a desire in the field of agriculture and forestry to avoid the use of pesticides where possible. Alternative strategies to the use of pesticides include use of fallow periods (i.e. not planting trees immediately after clear-felling has occurred), real-time pine weevil monitoring, and the use of physical barriers. A few physical barriers are known in the art. Broadly, these can be split into two categories: chemical barriers and mechanical barriers. In the former category, Kvaae™ wax barriers are applied to the saplings at the nursery by spraying hot wax on to the sapling and using a conveyor belt system to cool the plant down again so that it remains dormant. However, a wax barrier has a limited efficacy and has a tendency to flake, reducing the time it is able to protect the sapling. Instead of a wax barrier, coatings comprising glue and sand (e.g. Conniflex™) can be sprayed onto the sapling. In the mechanical category, MultiPro™ is a cardboard sleeve which covers the bottom 7-10 cm of the sapling, and WeeNet™ is a plastic netting covering the length of the sapling with an open top. However, both of these barriers also have a limited efficacy. HyloPro™ uses a truncated cone-shaped collar to keep the pine weevils off the sapling. Physical barriers known in the art have typically been used in areas with a low-to-medium pine weevil population. In areas and countries (such as the UK) with widespread clearfelling practices, pine weevil populations are much higher and present a more significant problem. Thus, there is a need in the art for an improved barrier which offers greater protection to saplings from pine weevils. Summary of the Invention There is generally a need for an apparatus and method which addresses one or more of the problems identified above. Further aims and objects of the invention will become apparent from reading the following description. According to a first aspect of the invention, there is provided a guard for protecting a plant sapling from insects, comprising a tubular body and a collar, the tubular body defining an axial direction, wherein the collar comprises a base platform extending radially from the tubular body; and a cup-shaped shield. The guard is arranged to surround the plant sapling (i.e. the plant sapling is within the tubular body and collar). The collar provides a dead-end space for insects. This means the insects are unable to orient themselves in an effective climbing position, thereby preventing the insects from contacting the plant sapling. The inventors have surprisingly found the guard of the present invention to be more effective at protecting plant saplings than the prior art physical barriers (including those with a truncated cone-shaped collar). Additionally, the guard of the present invention advantageously does not require the use of pesticides, nor does it require reapplication over a period of time (unlike pesticides and other chemical barriers). Without wishing to be bound by any theory, it is the combination of a base platform and a cup-shaped shield that creates a particularly effective dead-end space, and thus an improved guard. Preferably, the cup-shaped shield is spaced axially from the base platform. The internal distance between the base platform and the cup-shaped shield (i.e. the “spacing”) may be from about 5 mm to about 11 mm, or from about 6 mm to about 10 mm, or from about 7 mm to about 9 mm, or about 7 mm, or about 8 mm, or about 9 mm. The internal distance may be at least about 5 mm. The internal distance may be less than about 11 mm. This internal distance is defined as from the point where the base platform intersects the tubular body to the point where the cup-shaped shield intersects the tubular body. The cup-shaped shield may have an inverted truncated (curved) cone shape. The cupshaped shield may be bell-shaped. The sides of the cup-shaped shield may be straight or, alternatively, the sides of the cup-shaped shield may be curved. The cup-shaped shield may comprise a lip perpendicular to the axis of the tubular body. The base platform may comprise an annulus. The annulus may preferably be flat or horizontal. In other words, the base platform may be substantially perpendicular to the tubular body. Alternatively, the base platform may be sloped. That is, instead of being flat, the base platform may be inclined at an angle. The base platform may preferably be inclined at an angle towards the cup-shaped shield. That is, the base platform is vertically highest at the external edge. In these embodiments, the base platform may be considered to comprise a shallow inverted truncated cone. The cup-shaped shield may preferably comprise an opening into the tubular body. This advantageously allows for the plant sapling to grow out through the opening. The opening may be at least partially covered. This advantageously reduces the effects of bridging - when insects use surrounding vegetation to bypass the guard. The most desirable section of the sapling is typically the bottom 7-10 cm of the sapling (measured from the root collar upwards), because of the lower sap content found there. Thus, by at least partially covering the opening, insects are prevented from having access to this section of the sapling. The opening may be covered by a variable diameter seal. The variable diameter seal may comprise a plurality of fins. The fins create a deflectable grating which prevent insects (and particularly pine weevils) from passing through, while also deflecting as the plant grows through the opening. Preferably, the fins are made of the same material as the cup-shaped shield. While the fins may be arranged horizontally across the opening, it is preferred that the fins are raised, such that they create a dome-shape across the opening. This advantageously allows for greater deflection around the growing plant. The guard may preferably be injection moulded. The guard may be made of plastic. The guard may be partially or entirely made from a biodegradable material. As all materials can be considered “biodegradable” to a greater or lesser extent, by “biodegradable” it is preferably meant a material which is conventionally known in the art as being biodegradable. The guard may be partially or entirely made from a biobased polymer. The guard may be formed as multiple parts (preferably two parts) that, in use, together surround (or enclose) the plant sapling. The inventors have found this arrangement to be quick and easy to apply to plant saplings by planters, and advantageously fits in with the existing (tree) planting cycle. Furthermore, the guard being formed as two parts means that the plant sapling does not need to be pulled through the guard to be applied (thus preventing possible damage to the sapling during application of the guard), and means the guard will remain closed even as the plant grows. One of, both of, some of, or all of, the parts may comprise an overlap portion such that, when assembled, the portion at least partially overlaps with an adjacent part. This advantageously ensures that there are no gaps between parts once assembled, which could otherwise reduce protection of the sapling. An overlap portion may be present on the base platform and / or the cup-shaped portion. Preferably, an overlap portion is present on both the base platform and the cup-shaped portion. The guard may further comprise fixing means for, in use, holding the multiple parts of the guard together. The fixing means may comprise a spring mechanism. Spring mechanisms are advantageous as they consist of few parts, are very easy to operate, do not rely on the material (of the guard) being flexible, and do not carry the risk of early deployment. In use, the spring mechanism closes the two parts of the guard. The spring mechanism of the present invention advantageously contributes to the speed of application of the guard; a planter can apply a guard and plant into the ground in less than 5 seconds. The spring mechanism may be a circular spring, which advantageously serves the dual function of holding the guard parts together and providing the spring (opening) mechanism. The circular spring is preferably suitable for affixing to the guard by hand. The spring mechanism may comprise one or more tool clips, preferably a plurality of tool clips, more preferably two tool clips. The one or more tools clips may be made of plastic or, preferably, a metal such as steel. The one or more tool clips may preferably be applied to the tubular body. The one or more tool clips may be spaced axially apart (and preferably evenly distributed) along the length of the tubular body. The diameter of the tool clips may be equal to, or (slightly) less than the diameter of the tubular body. This advantageously means the tool clips apply an inward force to the two parts of the guard, keeping the two parts closed together and the plant sapling enclosed. The guard may comprise one or more levers (or handles), preferably a plurality of levers, more preferably two levers. The levers may be present on the tubular body. Preferably, each part of the guard comprises a lever. Therefore, in embodiments where the guard is formed as two parts, the guard may comprise two levers - one lever on each part. The lever allows for the guard to be opened and placed round the plant sapling. The tubular body may comprise means for providing air circulation to the sapling. The means may comprise one or more slots. The one or more slots preferably extend axially along part of, or the entire, length of the tubular body. The one or more slots are narrow enough to prevent an insect from entering, and are preferably narrower than about 2 mm. The one or more slots may have a length of from about 30 mm to about 40 mm, or about 35 mm. Alternatively, or additionally, the means may comprise one or more holes. The length of the guard may be from about 7 cm to about 14 cm, or from about 8 cm to about 13 cm, or from about 9 cm to about 12 cm, or from about 10 cm to about 11 cm. The length of the guard may be less than about 14 cm, or less than about 13 cm, or less than about 12 cm. The width of the tubular body may be from about 1 cm to about 10 cm, or from about 1 cm to about 7 cm, or from about 1 cm to about 4 cm, or from about 1.5 cm to about 3.5 cm, or from about 2 cm to about 3 cm, or from about 2.5 cm. The width of the tubular body may be less than about 10 cm, or less than about 7 cm. The base platform may extend radially from the tubular body by from about 2.6 cm to about 3.5 cm, or from about 2.8 cm to about 3.3 cm, or from about 3.0 cm to about 3.1 cm. The plant may be a tree. The plant may be a conifer. The insects are preferably pine weevils. The inventors have found the guard of the present invention to be particularly effective at protecting conifer sapling from pine weevils. According to a second aspect of the invention, there is provided a use of a guard according to the first aspect of the invention for protecting a plant sapling from insects. Embodiments of the second aspect of the invention may include one or more features of the first aspect of the invention or its embodiments, or vice versa. According to a third aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of protecting a plant sapling from insects, comprising the step of applying a guard according to the first aspect of the invention to the plant sapling. The method may comprise one or more of the following steps: a) fitting the guard round the plant sapling; b) attaching a fixing means to the guard; c) placing the sapling and guard together in a hole in the ground; and d) compressing soil in the hole around the sapling and guard. The guard of the present invention may protect the plant sapling for up to about 1 year, or up to about 2 years, or up to about 3 years, or for about 3 years. Embodiments of the third aspect of the invention may include one or more features of the first or second aspects of the invention or their embodiments, or vice versa. According to a fourth aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of manufacturing a guard according to the first aspect of the invention. The method may comprise the steps of: a) providing a tubular body, the tubular body defining an axial direction; and b) providing a collar, the collar comprising a base platform extending radially from the tubular body; and a cup-shaped shield. The guard may preferably be injection moulded. Embodiments of the fourth aspect of the invention may include one or more features of the first to third aspects of the invention or their embodiments, or vice versa. Brief Description of the Drawings There will now be described, by way of example only, various embodiments of the invention with reference to the drawings, of which: Figure 1 is a perspective view of a guard in accordance with an embodiment of the invention; Figure 2 is a side view of the guard in Figure 1; Figure 3 is an exploded perspective view of the guard in Figure 1; Figure 4 is a perspective view of the cup-shaped shield of the guard in Figure 1; and Figure 5 is a cut-away perspective view of the cup-shaped shield of the guard in Figure 1. Detailed Description of the Preferred Embodiments An explanation of the present invention will now be described with reference to Figures 1 to 5. The invention in its various aspects has particular application to protecting conifer saplings from pine weevils. There is shown generally at 10 a guard for protecting a plant sapling from insects. The guard 10 comprises a tubular body 11. The tubular body 11 defines an axial direction A, in which the tubular body 11 extends. That is, the tubular body 11 is longer in the axial direction A than it is wide. In this embodiment, the tubular body 11 has a length of approximately 8.3 cm and a width of approximately 2.5 cm. The purpose of the tubular body is to enclose and surround the plant sapling and prevent direct access to the sapling from insects. The guard also comprises a collar, shown generally at 13. The collar comprises a base platform 15, which extends radially from the tubular body 11 by a distance of about 3 cm. The base platform 15 has a flat annulus shape, such that the base platform 15 is substantially perpendicular to the tubular body 11. The collar 13 also comprises a cup-shaped shield 17 spaced axially from the base platform 13 by a distance d of 0.7 cm. The cup-shaped shield 17 is generally bell-shaped (or may be considered goblet-shaped or curved cone-shaped), with a lip perpendicular to the axis A of the tubular body 11. In alternative embodiments, the base platform 15 may comprise a shallow inverted truncated cone. In other words, the base platform 15 may be angled upwards towards the cup-shaped shield 17, such that the base platform 15 is vertically highest at the external edge of the base platform 15, and lowest at the point that the base platform 15 intersects with the tubular body 11. The cup-shaped shield 17 has an opening 19 into the tubular body 11, which allows for a plant sapling to grow up the tubular body 11 and out through the opening 19. However, the opening 19 provides an opportunity for insects to reach the plant sapling through bridging -when insects use surrounding vegetation to bypass the guard 10. Thus, the opening 19 is partially covered by a plurality of parallel fins 21, arranged in two rows (shown in Figure 4). Preferably, the fins 21 are made of the same material as the cup-shaped shield 17. The fins 21 are flexible enough such that the fins deflect upwards as a growing plant sapling pushes on the underside of the fins, but also resilient enough to bear the weight of an insect and act as a closed seal. The fins 21 are positioned such that the space between each fin is substantially smaller than the size of the insect. As can be seen in Figure 5, the fins 21 are raised, such that they create a dome-shape (indicated by the dotted line) across the opening 19. In alternative embodiments, the fins 21 may be arranged horizontally across the opening 19 (i.e. flat across the opening 19). The cup-shaped shield 17 is positioned such that the centre of the cup-shaped shield 17 is aligned with the axis A of the tubular body 11. This permits straight growth of the plant up the tubular body 11 and through the opening 19. The tubular body 11 comprises a slot 23 extending axially along part of the length of the tubular body 11. In this embodiment, the slot 23 has a length of about 35 mm and a width of about 2 mm. The slot 23 allows for air circulation to the sapling, but is sufficiently narrow to prevent an insect accessing the plant sapling through the slot 23. As an alternative (or in addition to), the tubular body 11 can comprise one or more air holes. A method of manufacturing the guard 10 is disclosed. The guard shown in Figures 1 to 5 is made by injection moulding of two parts 10a, 10b. While the two parts 10a, 10b are generally mirror parts, there may be some differences between the two parts. The guard 10 is made from plastic, but it will be appreciated that any suitable material can be used to make the guard. Plastic is particularly preferred because it is cheap, suitable for injection moulding, and sufficiently resilient for the desired application. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 A method of protecting a plant sapling from insects is disclosed. The method comprises applying a guard 10 to the plant sapling. The guard 10 shown in Figures 1 to 5 is applied according to the following steps: a) each of the two half parts 10a, 10b of the guard are placed around the plant sapling; b) a fixing means 25 is attached to the guard 10, to hold the two parts 10a, 10b together; c) the sapling and guard 10 are placed together in a hole in the ground; and d) soil is compressed in the hole around the sapling and guard 10. The guard covers the bottom 7-10 cm of the sapling (measured from the root collar upwards) - which is most desirable to insects - and prevents the insects from climbing over the top of the guard and feeding from the exposed section of the sapling. The base platform 15 on one of the half parts 10a comprises an overlap portion 16 which, when assembled (see Figure 1), overlaps (by sliding) underneath the base platform 15 on the other half part 10b. Thus, the overlap portion 16 has a lower vertical height than the remainder of the base platform 15. Alternatively, the overlap portion 16 could have a higher vertical height than the remainder of the base platform 15. Similarly, the cupshaped shield 17 on one of the half parts 10a also comprises an overlap portion 18 which, when assembled, overlaps (by sliding) underneath the cup-shaped shield 17 on the other half part 10b. These overlaps ensure that there are no gaps between the parts once assembled, which could otherwise reduce protection of the sapling. To aid in opening and placing the two half parts 10a, 10b around the plant sapling, the guard 10 comprises two levers 27 - one lever on each half part 10a, 10b. The levers 27 are positioned on the tubular body 11. The levers 27 behave as a handle and permit for easier assembly onto the plant sapling. While the lever 27 in this embodiment is broadly rectangular (having a length of about 3cm), it will be appreciated that any suitable lever or handle known in the art can be used, the size and shape of which will be dependent on the size and shape of the guard. To keep the two parts together and closed around the plant sapling, the guard comprises a fixing means 25. In this embodiment, the fixing means 25 comprises two steel tool clips, the shape and function of which is known in the art. The tool clips act as circular flat springs and are positioned around the circumference of the tubular body 11. The tool clips are applied by pushing the tool clips onto the tubular body 11. They are axially spaced along the tubular body 11 to ensure the guard 10 is kept closed along the length of the guard. Therefore, preferably, one clip is positioned just below the base platform 15, and one clip is positioned towards the bottom of the guard 10 (i.e. just below the levers 27). In this embodiment, the tubular body 11 has a diameter of 2.5 cm, and the tool clips 25 have an internal diameter of 2.5 cm. Thus, the tool clips 25 apply a sufficient force on the tubular body 11 to keep the two parts 10a, 10b closed together. The guard is not limited to the use of tool clips and may comprise any suitable mechanism or means for keeping the two parts 10a, 10b together. This may be reversible (e.g. with tool clips) or irreversible (e.g. with glue). The use of tool clips is particularly preferred because they are quick and straightforward to apply. The guard 10 is particularly directed towards protecting conifer saplings from pine weevils. However, the present invention is not necessarily limited as such, and may be used in any appropriate situation where a plant needs to be protected. A guard 10 for protecting a plant sapling from insects is disclosed. The guard 10 comprises a tubular body 11 and a collar 13, the tubular body 11 defining an axial direction A. The collar 13 comprises a base platform 15 extending radially from the tubular body 11, and a cup-shaped shield 17. The collar 13 provides a dead-end space for insects, meaning that insects are unable to orient themselves in an effective climbing position, thereby preventing the insects from contacting the plant sapling. The guard 10 is more effective at protecting plant saplings than the prior art physical barriers, and does not require the use of pesticides, nor does it require reapplication over a period of time. Throughout the specification, unless the context demands otherwise, the terms “comprise” or “include”, or variations such as “comprises” or “comprising”, “includes” or “including” will be understood to imply the inclusion of a stated integer or group of integers, but not the exclusion of any other integer or group of integers. Furthermore, unless the context clearly demands otherwise, the term “or” will be interpreted as being inclusive not exclusive. 1 The foregoing description of the invention has been presented for purposes of illustration 2 and description and is not intended to be exhaustive or to limit the invention to the precise 3 form disclosed. The described embodiments were chosen and described in order to best 4 explain the principles of the invention and its practical application to thereby enable others 5 skilled in the art to best utilise the invention in various embodiments and with various 6 modifications as are suited to the particular use contemplated. Therefore, further 7 modifications or improvements may be incorporated without departing from the scope of 8 the invention as defined by the appended claims. 9
Claims
1. A guard for protecting a plant sapling from insects, comprising a tubular body and a collar, the tubular body defining an axial direction, wherein the collar comprises a base platform extending radially from the tubular body; and a cup-shaped shield.
2. The guard according to claim 1, wherein the cup-shaped shield is spaced axially from the base platform.
3. The guard according to claim 1 or claim 2, wherein the cup-shaped shield is bellshaped.
4. The guard according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the base platform comprises an annulus.
5. The guard according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein the cup-shaped shield comprises an opening into the tubular body.
6. The guard according to claim 5, wherein the opening is at least partially covered.
7. The guard according to claim 6, wherein the opening is covered by a plurality of fins.
8. The guard according to any one of claims 1 to 7, wherein the guard is injectionmoulded.
9. The guard according to any one of claims 1 to 8, wherein the guard is formed as two parts.
10. The guard according to claim 9, wherein the guard comprises fixing means for holding the two parts together in use.
11. The guard according to claim 10, wherein the fixing means comprises a spring mechanism, optionally one or more circular springs.
12. The guard according to claim 11, wherein the spring mechanism comprises one or more tools clips, optionally two tool clips.
13. The guard according to any one of claims 1 to 12, wherein the guard comprises one or more levers, optionally two levers.
14. The guard according to any one of claims 1 to 13, wherein the tubular body comprises means for providing air circulation to the sapling.
15. The guard according to claim 14, wherein the means for providing air circulation comprises one or more slots.
16. The guard according to any one of claims 1 to 15, wherein the plant to be protected is a conifer sapling.
17. The guard according to any one of claims 1 to 16, wherein the insects are pine weevils.
18. Use of a guard according to any one of claims 1 to 17 for protecting a plant sapling from insects.
19. A method of protecting a plant sapling from insects, comprising the step of applying a guard according to any one of claims 1 to 17 to the plant sapling.
20. A method of manufacturing a guard according to any one of claims 1 to 17, comprising the steps of:a) providing a tubular body, the tubular body defining an axial direction; andb) providing a collar, the collar comprising a base platform extending radially from the tubular body; and a cup-shaped shield.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Plant protection
EP1089611A1
Device and method for protection of tree seedlings
EP3560333A1
Plant cistern
US3755965A
Plant protector
WO2014170630A1
Anordning för att skydda en planta
SE1150618A1
