Judicial decision support apparatus, judicial decision support method, and judicial decision support program
The judicial decision support device enhances fair judicial decision-making by using AI robots to simulate legal debates and provide objective judgments based on acquired data, reducing the risk of miscarriages of justice.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023074696
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-04-28
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
AI Technical Summary
Conventional techniques fail to support fair judicial decisions, leading to miscarriages of justice, judgments based on incorrect information, and unreasonable judgments.
A judicial decision support device that acquires legal, judgment, and trial data to support fair judicial decisions by suggesting objective and rational judgments through a trained model, enabling mock trials with AI robots to simulate legal debates and discussions.
The device supports fair judicial decisions by reducing the risk of miscarriages of justice and improving the rationality of judgments through objective analysis and simulation.
Smart Images

Figure 2024158997000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a judicial decision support device, a judicial decision support method, and a judicial decision support program. [Background technology]
[0002] A technique for conducting mock trials is known (see, for example, Patent Document 1). A technique for generating emotions in a robot is known (see, for example, Patent Documents 2 to 4). Also, a technique for recognizing and detecting the emotions of a user is known (see, for example, Patent Documents 5 to 6). [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0003] [Patent Document 1] JP 2004-199547 A [Patent Document 2] Patent No. 6273314 [Patent Document 3] Patent No. 6273313 [Patent Document 4] Patent No. 6199927 [Patent Document 5] Patent No. 3676969 [Patent Document 6] Patent No. 4704952 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0004] However, the conventional technology may not be able to support fair judicial decisions. For example, the conventional technology is merely a technology for providing practical education on legal practice such as trials by analyzing human interactions based on conversations and the like contained in video information of a mock trial, and for training legal professionals, but is not a technology for directly supporting judicial decisions. For this reason, the conventional technology still has the risk of producing miscarriages of justice or decisions based on erroneous information, or decisions based on subjective judgments or irrational decisions, as in the current administration of trials. [Means for solving the problem]
[0005] A judicial decision support device according to one embodiment of the present invention comprises one or more judicial decision support devices, and includes an acquisition unit that acquires at least one of legal data related to laws, judgment data related to judgments, case data related to cases, and court data related to trials, and a judicial decision support unit that supports judicial decisions based on at least one of the legal data, the judgment data, the case data, and the court data acquired by the acquisition unit.
[0006] A judicial decision support method according to one embodiment of the present invention is a judicial decision support method executed by one or more judicial decision support devices, and includes an acquisition process for acquiring at least one of legal data related to laws, judgment data related to judgments, case data related to cases, and judicial data related to trials, and a judicial decision support process for supporting a judicial decision based on at least one of the legal data, the judgment data, the case data, and the judicial data acquired by the acquisition process.
[0007] A judicial decision support program according to one embodiment of the present invention causes a computer to execute an acquisition step of acquiring at least one of legal data relating to laws, judgment data relating to judgments, case data relating to cases, and judicial data relating to trials, and a judicial decision support step of supporting a judicial decision based on at least one of the legal data, judgment data, case data, and judicial data acquired by the acquisition step. Effect of the Invention
[0008] According to one aspect of the present invention, it is possible to support fair judicial decisions. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0009] [Figure 1] 1 is a block diagram showing an example of the configuration of a judicial decision support device 10. FIG. [Diagram 2] FIG. 1 is a diagram for explaining an example of a judicial decision support device 10. [Diagram 3] 4 is a flowchart showing an example of a process flow of the judicial decision support device 10. [Figure 4] 1 is a diagram illustrating an example of a hardware configuration of a judicial decision support device 10. FIG. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0010] Hereinafter, an embodiment for carrying out a judicial decision support device and a judicial decision support method according to one aspect of the present invention will be described in detail with reference to the drawings, but the judicial decision support device and the judicial decision support method according to one aspect of the present invention are not limited to this embodiment. In addition, the same parts in the following embodiments are given the same reference numerals, and duplicated explanations will be omitted.
[0011] (Embodiment) [1. Judicial decision support device] An example of a judicial decision support device 10 according to an embodiment will be described with reference to FIG. 1. FIG. 1 is a block diagram showing an example of the configuration of the judicial decision support device 10. The judicial decision support device 10 is one or more judicial decision support devices 10, and supports judicial decisions. The judicial decision support device 10 is realized by an AI (Artificial Intelligence) humanoid robot capable of recognizing emotions, such as Pepper (registered trademark), and is used in mock trials at educational institutions such as universities and legal training institutes, courts, and other legal debates and discussions. As shown in FIG. 1, the judicial decision support device 10 has an acquisition unit 11, a control unit 12, a presentation unit 13, and a storage unit 14. In the example shown in FIG. 1, there is one judicial decision support device 10, but there may be two or more.
[0012] (Acquisition part 11) The acquisition unit 11 acquires at least one of legal data related to laws, judgment data related to judgments, case data related to cases, and trial data related to trials. This allows the acquisition unit 11 to accumulate a huge amount of legal data, judgment data, case data, and trial data. As an example, the acquisition unit 11 acquires judgment data related to judgments from which past miscarriages of justice have been removed. As another example, the acquisition unit 11 acquires case data related to at least one of the outline of a case, facts, and evidence. As another example, the acquisition unit 11 acquires trial data related to at least one of conversations in a trial, facial expressions of participants, video, audio, and documents. Specifically, the acquisition unit 11 acquires trial data such as trial records that include at least one of these.
[0013] (Control unit 12) The control unit 12 controls the entire judicial decision support device 10. As an example, the control unit 12 is realized by a CPU (Central Processing Unit), an MPU (Micro Processing Unit), or the like executing various programs stored in a storage device inside the judicial decision support device 10 using a RAM as a working area. As another example, the control unit 12 is realized by an integrated circuit such as an ASIC (Application Specific Integrated Circuit) or an FPGA (Field Programmable Gate Array). In the example shown in FIG. 1, the control unit 12 has a trained model generation unit 121 and a judicial decision support unit 122.
[0014] (Trained model generation unit 121) The trained model generation unit 121 generates a trained model 141 using at least one of the legal data, judgment data, case data, and court case data acquired by the acquisition unit 11. The trained model 141 is a model that outputs data that is not input among the legal data, judgment data, case data, and court case data when at least one of the legal data, judgment data, case data, and court case data is input. As an example, the trained model generation unit 121 uses the legal data, judgment data, case data, and court case data acquired by the acquisition unit 11 as teacher data to generate a sentence generation model having an interactive function including the trained model 141 in which the judgment data, judgment data, and case data are output when the court case data is input. As another example, the trained model generation unit 121 uses the legal data, judgment data, case data, and court case data acquired by the acquisition unit 11 as teacher data to generate a sentence generation model having an interactive function including the trained model 141 in which the judgment data and court case data are output when the legal data and case data are input. A text generation model with dialogue capabilities is realized, for example, by ChatGPT (Chat Generative Pre-trained Transformer).
[0015] (Judicial Judgment Support Department 122) The judicial decision support unit 122 supports judicial decisions based on at least one of the legal data, judgment data, case data, and trial data acquired by the acquisition unit 11. As a result, the judicial decision support unit 122 suggests arguments and judgments based on objective and rational judgments, assists in appropriate judicial decisions, and can avoid or reduce miscarriages of justice and speed up trials, particularly in countries with immature judicial systems, thereby supporting fair judicial decisions. As an example, the judicial decision support unit 122 supports judicial decisions based on judgment data regarding judgments from which past miscarriages of justice have been removed, acquired by the acquisition unit 11. As a result, the judicial decision support unit 122 can easily avoid miscarriages of justice. As another example, the judicial decision support unit 122 supports judicial decisions based on case data regarding at least one of the outline, facts, and evidence of the case acquired by the acquisition unit 11. As a result, the judicial decision support unit 122 can easily avoid miscarriages of justice, judgments based on erroneous information, personal judgments, and unreasonable judgments. As another example, the judicial decision support unit 122 supports judicial decisions based on trial data related to at least one of conversations in a trial, facial expressions of participants, video, audio, and documents acquired by the acquisition unit 11. This makes it easier for the judicial decision support unit 122 to avoid miscarriages of justice, decisions based on erroneous information, personal decisions, and unreasonable decisions.
[0016] The judicial decision support unit 122 may use the trained model 141, which outputs data that has not been input among the legal data, judgment data, case data, and trial data when at least one of the legal data, judgment data, case data, and trial data acquired by the acquisition unit 11 is input, to cause the presentation unit 13 to present data output from the trained model 141. This allows the judicial decision support unit 122 to suggest arguments and decisions based on more objective and rational judgments, and to further support fair judicial decisions. The judicial decision support unit 122 may support judicial decisions using a sentence generation model with a dialogue function that includes the trained model 141. This allows the judicial decision support unit 122 to further support fair judicial decisions.
[0017] The judicial decision support unit 122 may perform a mock trial between the judicial decision support devices 10 or between the judicial decision support device 10 and a human, and may cause the presentation unit 13 to present data including trial data related to the mock trial. This allows the judicial decision support unit 122 to suggest arguments and decisions based on particularly objective and rational judgments. An example of a judicial decision by the judicial decision support unit 122 will be described below with reference to FIG. 2. FIG. 2 is a diagram for explaining an example of the judicial decision support device 10. As shown in FIG. 2, when the judicial decision support device 10 is a plurality of AI robots 10X, 10Y, and 10Z such as Pepper, the judicial decision support unit 122 assigns each of the plurality of robots 10X to 10Z to play the role of a plaintiff's lawyer, a defendant's lawyer, and a judge, and causes the robots 10X to 10Z to converse with each other and perform a mock trial. As an example, the judicial decision support unit 122 of the robot 10X and the robot 10Y acting as lawyers causes the presentation unit 13 to present at least one of the legal data, case precedent data, and fact data output from the trained model 141, and conducts a dialogue such as an argument advantageous to the robot. As another example, the judicial decision support unit 122 of the robot 10Z acting as a judge causes the presentation unit 13 to present data including trial data related to the process and result of the mock trial, such as a simulation result output from the trained model 141 in the form of a trial record, and conducts a dialogue such as the progress of the trial, the judgment of the verdict, and the reasoning thereof. The judicial decision support unit 122 of the robot 10Z acting as a judge causes the presentation unit 13 to present the above-mentioned simulation result as a trial record to the judge, and leaves it up to the judge to decide how to utilize it in the final judgment. In the example shown in FIG. 2, the judicial decision support unit 122 causes the judicial decision support devices 10, namely the robots 10X to 10Z, to conduct a mock trial, but the subject of the mock trial is not limited to this form. For example, the judicial decision support unit 122 may conduct a mock trial between the judicial decision support device 10 and a human, or may conduct training for a witness between the judicial decision support device 10 and a human (such as a witness). In addition, the judicial decision support device 10 may be used to support judicial decision making by conducting a mock trial for the same case in parallel with an actual trial.The trained model generation unit 121 may re-train the trained model 141 using information regarding judicial decisions in actual trials.
[0018] Returning to the explanation of FIG. 1, the judicial decision support unit 122 may cause the judicial decision support device 10 to perform an action based on emotion. For example, when the judicial decision support device 10 is a robot, in any of a mock trial between the judicial decision support devices 10 that are robots, a mock trial between the judicial decision support device 10 that is a robot and a human, and a training for witnesses between the judicial decision support device 10 that is a robot and a human (such as a witness), the robot recognizes the emotion of the other party, generates the emotion of the robot itself, and performs actions such as conversation and behavior that reflect the emotion. As a result, compared to a case where an existing text generation model is used, such as a plaintiff's lawyer robot having a text generation model with a dialogue function such as ChatGPT and a defendant's lawyer robot having a similar function are simply made to fight, and a judge's robot having a similar function judges which is appropriate, the judicial decision support unit 122 can give visual inspiration to judges and related parties based on the emotion of the judicial decision support device 10 such as a robot, thereby enhancing the sense of realism. The emotion recognition and generation methods are similar to those described in Patent Documents 2 to 6, and therefore detailed description thereof will be omitted. The emotion recognition method is not limited to these methods, and other known methods may be used.
[0019] The judicial decision support unit 122 may cause the presentation unit 13 to present data including trial data related to the mock trial to at least one of the judge, the prosecutor, the lawyer, the witness, and the jury. For example, the judicial decision support unit 122 causes the presentation unit 13 to present trial data (and judgment data) related to the mock trial to the judge, and causes the presentation unit 13 to present at least one of legal data, judgment data, and case data to the lawyer. This allows the judicial decision support unit 122 to suggest arguments and judgments based on more objective and rational judgments.
[0020] The judicial decision support unit 122 may cause the presentation unit 13 to present data including trial data in which at least one of the emotions and actions of participants in the mock trial is recorded. For example, the judicial decision support unit 122 of the robot playing the role of a judge causes the presentation unit 13 to present, as trial data, trial records in which emotions and actions of the robot or human speaker and listener are further recorded, together with data on audio and video such as conversations and statements that are not originally recorded, in addition to documents. As an example, the judicial decision support unit 122 of the robot playing the role of a judge causes the presentation unit 13 to present, when the robot is a witness, trial records in which emotions (impatience, anxiety, relief, etc.) generated by the robot during the testimony of the witness examination are further recorded. As another example, the judicial decision support unit 122 of the robot playing the role of a judge causes the presentation unit 13 to present, when a human is a witness, trial records in which emotions of the human recognized by a robot playing another role during the testimony of the witness examination are further recorded. In this way, the judicial decision support unit 122 can make the flow of the trial easier to understand.
[0021] (Presentation part 13) The presentation unit 13 presents data output from the trained model 141. The presentation method by the presentation unit 13 is not particularly limited, and for example, when the presentation unit 13 is an audio output unit, the presentation may be by audio output, when the presentation unit 13 is a display unit, the presentation may be by displaying characters, symbols, etc., or may be via communication.
[0022] (Storage unit 14) The storage unit 14 stores various data and various programs such as legal data, judgment data, case data, trial data, and trained model 141. The storage unit 14 is realized by, for example, a semiconductor memory element such as a random access memory (RAM) or a flash memory, or a storage device such as a hard disk or an optical disk.
[0023] [2. Judicial decision support method] An example of processing by the judicial decision support device 10 according to the embodiment will be described with reference to Fig. 3. Fig. 3 is a flowchart showing an example of the flow of processing by the judicial decision support device 10.
[0024] In step S1, the acquisition unit 11 acquires at least one of legal data related to laws, judgment data related to judgments, case data related to cases, and court case data related to court cases. For example, when the acquisition unit 11 receives a request related to a mock trial, it acquires at least one of legal data, judgment data, case data, and court case data.
[0025] In step S2, the judicial decision support unit 122 supports a judicial decision based on at least one of the legal data, the judgment data, the case data, and the trial data acquired by the acquisition unit 11. For example, the judicial decision support unit 122 causes a mock trial to be held between the judicial decision support devices 10, or between the judicial decision support device 10 and a human, and causes the presentation unit 13 to present data including trial data related to the mock trial output from a sentence generation model having a dialogue function.
[0026] [3. Hardware Configuration] 4 is a diagram showing an example of the hardware configuration of the judicial decision support device 10. A program installed in the computer 1200 functioning as the judicial decision support device 10 can cause the computer 1200 to function as one or more "parts" of the device according to the embodiment, or to execute an operation or one or more "parts" associated with the device, and can cause the computer 1200 to execute a process or a step of a process according to the embodiment. Such a program may be executed by the CPU 1212 to cause the computer 1200 to execute certain operations associated with some or all of the blocks of the flowcharts and block diagrams described herein.
[0027] The computer 1200 according to the embodiment includes a CPU 1212, a RAM 1214, and a graphic controller 1216, which are connected to each other by a host controller 1210. The computer 1200 also includes input / output units such as a communication interface 1222, a storage device 1224, a DVD drive 1226, and an IC card drive, which are connected to the host controller 1210 via an input / output controller 1220. The DVD drive 1226 may be a DVD-ROM drive, a DVD-RAM drive, or the like. The storage device 1224 may be a hard disk drive, a solid state drive, or the like. The computer 1200 also includes legacy input / output units such as a ROM 1230 and a keyboard, which are connected to the input / output controller 1220 via an input / output chip 1240.
[0028] The CPU 1212 operates according to a program stored in the ROM 1230 and the RAM 1214, thereby controlling each unit. The graphic controller 1216 acquires image data generated by the CPU 1212 into a frame buffer or the like provided in the RAM 1214 or into itself, and causes the image data to be displayed on the display device 1218.
[0029] The communication interface 1222 communicates with other electronic devices via a network. The storage device 1224 stores programs and data used by the CPU 1212 in the computer 1200. The DVD drive 1226 reads programs or data from a DVD-ROM 1227 or the like and provides the programs or data to the storage device 1224. The IC card drive reads programs and data from an IC card and writes the programs and data to the IC card.
[0030] The ROM 1230 stores therein programs that depend on the hardware of the computer 1200, such as a boot program that is executed by the computer 1200 upon activation. The input / output chip 1240 may also connect various input / output units to the input / output controller 1220 via a USB port, a parallel port, a serial port, a keyboard port, a mouse port, and the like.
[0031] The programs are provided by a computer-readable storage medium such as a DVD-ROM 1227 or an IC card. The programs are read from the computer-readable storage medium, installed in the storage device 1224, the RAM 1214, or the ROM 1230, which are also examples of computer-readable storage media, and executed by the CPU 1212. Information processing described in these programs is read by the computer 1200, and brings about cooperation between the programs and the various types of hardware resources described above. An apparatus or method may be constructed by implementing an operation or processing of information according to the use of the computer 1200.
[0032] For example, when communication is performed between the computer 1200 and an external device, the CPU 1212 may execute a communication program loaded in the RAM 1214 and instruct the communication interface 1222 to perform communication processing based on the processing described in the communication program. Under the control of the CPU 1212, the communication interface 1222 reads transmission data stored in a transmission buffer area provided in the RAM 1214, the storage device 1224, the DVD-ROM 1227, or a recording medium such as an IC card, and transmits the read transmission data to the network, or writes reception data received from the network to a reception buffer area or the like provided on the recording medium.
[0033] Furthermore, the CPU 1212 may cause all or a necessary portion of a file or database stored in an external recording medium such as the storage device 1224, the DVD drive 1226 (DVD-ROM 1227), or an IC card to be read into the RAM 1214, and may perform various types of processing on the data on the RAM 1214. The CPU 1212 may then write back the processed data to the external recording medium.
[0034] Various types of information, such as various types of programs, data, tables, and databases, may be stored in the recording medium and may undergo information processing. The CPU 1212 may perform various types of processing on the data read from the RAM 1214, including various types of operations, information processing, conditional judgment, conditional branching, unconditional branching, information search, replacement, etc., as described throughout this disclosure and specified by the instruction sequence of the program, and writes back the results to the RAM 1214. The CPU 1212 may also search for information in a file, database, etc. in the recording medium. For example, when a plurality of entries each having an attribute value of a first attribute associated with an attribute value of a second attribute are stored in the recording medium, the CPU 1212 may search for an entry whose attribute value of the first attribute matches a specified condition from among the plurality of entries, read the attribute value of the second attribute stored in the entry, and thereby obtain the attribute value of the second attribute associated with the first attribute that satisfies a predetermined condition.
[0035] The above-mentioned programs or software modules may be stored in a computer-readable storage medium on the computer 1200 or in the vicinity of the computer 1200. In addition, a recording medium such as a hard disk or a RAM provided in a server system connected to a dedicated communication network or the Internet can be used as a computer-readable storage medium, thereby providing the programs to the computer 1200 via the network.
[0036] The blocks in the flowcharts and block diagrams may represent stages of a process in which operations are performed or "parts" of apparatus responsible for performing the operations. Particular stages and "parts" may be implemented by dedicated circuitry, programmable circuitry provided with computer readable instructions stored on a computer readable storage medium, or a processor provided with computer readable instructions stored on a computer readable storage medium. Dedicated circuitry may include digital or analog hardware circuitry, and may include integrated circuits (ICs) or discrete circuits. Programmable circuitry may include reconfigurable hardware circuitry including AND, OR, XOR, NAND, NOR, and other logical operations, flip-flops, registers, and memory elements, such as field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs) and programmable logic arrays (PLAs).
[0037] A computer-readable storage medium may include any tangible device capable of storing instructions that are executed by a suitable device, such that a computer-readable storage medium having instructions stored thereon comprises an article of manufacture that includes instructions that can be executed to create means for performing the operations specified in the flowcharts or block diagrams. Examples of computer-readable storage media include electronic storage media, magnetic storage media, optical storage media, electromagnetic storage media, semiconductor storage media, and the like. More specific examples of computer-readable storage media may include floppy disks, diskettes, hard disks, random access memories (RAMs), read-only memories (ROMs), erasable programmable read-only memories (EPROMs or flash memories), electrically erasable programmable read-only memories (EEPROMs), static random access memories (SRAMs), compact disk read-only memories (CD-ROMs), digital versatile disks (DVDs), Blu-ray disks, memory sticks, integrated circuit cards, and the like.
[0038] The computer readable instructions may include either source code or object code written in any combination of one or more programming languages, including object-oriented programming languages such as Smalltalk, JAVA, C++, and conventional procedural programming languages, such as the "C" programming language or similar programming languages.
[0039] Computer readable instructions may be provided locally or over a local area network (LAN), a wide area network (WAN) such as the Internet, to a processor of a general purpose computer, special purpose computer, or other programmable data processing apparatus, or to a programmable circuit, such that the processor or programmable circuit executes the computer readable instructions to generate means for performing the operations specified in the flowcharts or block diagrams. Examples of processors include computer processors, processing units, microprocessors, digital signal processors, controllers, microcontrollers, etc.
[0040] Although one aspect of the present invention has been described above using an embodiment, the technical scope of the present invention is not limited to the scope described in the above embodiment. It is clear to those skilled in the art that various modifications and improvements can be made to the above embodiment. It is clear from the description of the claims that such modifications and improvements can also be included in the technical scope of the present invention.
[0041] It should be noted that the order of execution of each process, such as operations, procedures, steps, and stages, in the devices, systems, programs, and methods shown in the claims, specifications, and drawings is not specifically stated as "before" or "prior to," and that the process may be performed in any order unless the output of a previous process is used in a later process. Even if the operational flow in the claims, specifications, and drawings is described using "first," "next," etc. for convenience, it does not mean that the process must be performed in this order. [Explanation of symbols]
[0042] 10 Judicial decision support device 11 Acquisition Department 12 Control section 13 Presentation part 14 Storage section 121 Trained model generation unit 122 Judicial Decision Support Department 141 trained models
Claims
1. One or more legal decision support devices, An acquisition unit that acquires at least one of legal data related to laws, judgment data related to judgments, case data related to cases, and trial data related to trials; a judicial decision support unit that supports judicial decisions based on at least one of the legal data, the judgment data, the case data, and the trial data acquired by the acquisition unit; A judicial decision support device comprising:
2. The judicial decision support unit uses a trained model that outputs data that is not input among the legal data, the judgment data, the case data, and the trial data when at least one of the legal data, the judgment data, the case data, and the trial data acquired by the acquisition unit is input, and causes a presentation unit to present the data output from the trained model.
2. The judicial decision support device according to claim 1.
3. The judicial decision support unit supports the judicial decision using a sentence generation model having a dialogue function including the trained model.
3. The judicial decision support device according to claim 2.
4. The judicial decision support unit causes a mock trial to be held between the judicial decision support devices, or between the judicial decision support devices and a human, and causes the presentation unit to present the data including trial data relating to the mock trial.
4. The judicial decision support device according to claim 3.
5. The judicial decision support unit causes the judicial decision support device to perform an action based on emotion.
5. The judicial decision support device according to claim 4.
6. The judicial decision support unit causes the presentation unit to present the data including trial data related to the mock trial to at least one of a judge, a prosecutor, a lawyer, a witness, and a jury.
5. The judicial decision support device according to claim 4.
7. The judicial decision support unit causes the presentation unit to present the data including trial data in which at least one of emotions and actions of participants in the mock trial is recorded.
5. The judicial decision support device according to claim 4.
8. The acquisition unit acquires the judgment data regarding judgments from which past miscarriages of justice have been removed, The judicial decision support unit supports the judicial decision based on the judgment data regarding judgments from which past miscarriages of justice have been removed and which have been acquired by the acquisition unit. The judicial decision support device according to any one of claims 1 to 7.
9. 1. A method of legal decision support executed by one or more legal decision support devices, comprising: An acquisition step of acquiring at least one of legal data related to laws, judgment data related to judgments, case data related to cases, and court case data related to court cases; a judicial decision support step of supporting a judicial decision based on at least one of the legal data, the judgment data, the case data, and the trial data acquired by the acquisition step; A method for supporting judicial decision-making comprising:
10. An acquisition step of acquiring at least one of legal data related to laws, judgment data related to judgments, case data related to cases, and court case data related to court cases; a judicial decision support step of supporting a judicial decision based on at least one of the legal data, the judgment data, the case data, and the trial data acquired by the acquisition step; A judicial decision support program characterized by causing a computer to execute the above.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Magnetic recording medium
JP1986099927A
Current limiter for temperature regulator
JP1987073313A
Ac signal supply controller
JP1987073314A
Reciprocal action analysis system, and reciprocal action analysis program
JP2004199547A
Emotion detection method, emotion detection device, and recording medium
JP3676969B2
