Method of metal artifact reduction in x-ray dentistry volume tomography

By employing trained AI algorithms to generate 2D/3D masks for direct analysis of X-ray images or sinograms, the method addresses the inefficiencies of conventional methods, achieving faster and more accurate metal artifact reduction in X-ray dental volume tomography.

JP2024164073AInactive Publication Date: 2024-11-26DENTSPLY SIRONA INC +1

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2024135351
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2019-04-18
Filing Date
2024-08-14
Publication Date
2024-11-26
Estimated Expiration
Not applicable · inactive patent

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional methods for reducing metal artifacts in X-ray dental volume tomography are unreliable and time-consuming, especially when metal objects are outside the reconstructed volume, and classical image processing techniques struggle with accurate detection and correction.

Method used

A method utilizing trained artificial intelligence algorithms to generate 2D/3D masks directly from 2D X-ray images or sinograms for identifying metal objects, allowing for reliable detection and correction, thereby improving the speed and accuracy of metal artifact reduction.

Benefits of technology

The method enhances the speed and reliability of metal artifact reduction, ensuring accurate detection of metal objects within and outside the reconstructed volume, leading to improved tomographic image quality and facilitating easier medical diagnosis.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2024164073000001_ABST
    Figure 2024164073000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide a method of metal artifact reduction in an X-ray dentistry volume tomography.SOLUTION: A method of metal artifact reduction includes: a step S1 which obtains at least a part of a two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or a sinogram of a patient jaw that is acquired by relatively rotating an X-ray source and a detector around the patient jaw; a step S2 which detects the two-dimensional x-ray image (1) or a metal object (6) in the sinogram by using at least a trained artificial intelligence algorithm in order to generate a 2D face mask expressing the metal object (6) in the two-dimensional x-ray image (1) or a 3D face mask expressing the metal object (6) in the sinogram respectively; and a step S4 reconfiguring a three-dimensional tomographic image (8) on the basis of the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram and the 2D face mask or the 3D face mask that are generated respectively.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 9a
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to X-ray dental volume tomography (DVT), and more particularly to a method for metal artifact reduction (MAR) in X-ray dental volume tomography. [Background technology]

[0002] In X-ray dental volume tomography, a three-dimensional (3D) tomographic image of a patient's jaw is reconstructed based on a two-dimensional (2D) X-ray image. Metal objects such as metal fillings or implants in the patient's mouth may cause metal artifacts in the final three-dimensional tomographic image. Metal artifacts appear as dark or light stripes as shown in FIG. 1. These artifacts may complicate medical diagnosis. A conventional method for reducing metal artifacts is shown in FIG. 3. In the conventional method, a two-dimensional X-ray image is first acquired, which is then used to reconstruct a three-dimensional (3D) tomographic image. Then, the location of the metal object in the two-dimensional X-ray image is determined through a time-consuming analysis of the three-dimensional tomographic image. Once the location of the metal object is known, the metal artifact in the two-dimensional X-ray image is then corrected by classical image processing. Finally, a three-dimensional tomographic image with reduced metal artifacts is reconstructed based on the corrected and uncorrected two-dimensional X-ray images. FIG. 2 shows a tomogram in which the metal artifacts of FIG. 1 have been reduced by the method of FIG.

[0003] In many situations, only a portion (V) or a small volume of the patient's jaw (3a) is relevant for diagnosis, as shown in FIG. 6. In this case, only such a small volume (V) of the patient's jaw (3a) is irradiated from all angles and reconstructed. The remaining part of the patient's jaw (3a) is not irradiated from all angles and is seen in only a portion of the acquired two-dimensional X-ray images and is not reconstructed. These two-dimensional X-ray images may cause metal artifacts in the final three-dimensional tomographic image, as shown in FIG. 7, if a metal object (6a) is present outside the reconstructed small volume (V) as shown in FIG. 6, even if such a small volume (V) does not contain any metal object (6b). FIG. 8 shows a tomogram corresponding to the same cross section as FIG. 7, reconstructed with a conventional metal artifact reduction method as shown in FIG. 3. The metal artifact in FIG. 7 caused by the metal object (6a) outside the small volume (V) cannot be corrected by the conventional metal artifact reduction method shown in FIG. 3, so the conventional metal artifact reduction method is not robust.

[0004] In order to avoid the above-mentioned first reconstruction step in the conventional method of FIG. 3 and to prevent artifacts due to metal objects (6a) located outside the small volume (V) to be reconstructed, the detection of metal objects can be performed directly on the two-dimensional X-ray image. For this purpose, the two-dimensional X-ray image or alternatively a sinogram can be analyzed. The two-dimensional X-ray image represents the projection of the irradiated three-dimensional object, for example the patient jaw as shown in FIG. 4. A sinogram is created when these projections taken at all angles are combined into an array of projections as shown in FIG. 5a. The trace of the metal object imaged over time defines a curve in the sinogram as shown in FIGS. 5a and 5b. For the detection of metal objects in two-dimensional X-ray images, classical image processing methods such as thresholding, edge detection can be used. However, due to other dense structures such as bone or dentin, it is difficult to achieve a reliable detection of metal objects. High-density structures may be erroneously recognized as metal objects. The reverse may also happen, metal objects with lower density may not be detected. In such cases, metal artifact reduction based on classical image processing of two-dimensional X-ray images may not be achieved reliably.

[0005] In two-dimensional X-ray images, data for reconstructing artifact-free 3D tomographic images is generally missing where metal objects are located. In the method disclosed in WO 2018 / 126396, artificial intelligence is used to supplement two-dimensional X-ray images with missing data. The locations containing missing data are first determined by thresholding, and then supplemented with trained artificial intelligence to reconstruct 3D tomographic images with reduced metal artifacts. However, this method also tends to have the drawbacks of the classical image processing techniques mentioned above, including the use of thresholding. Summary of the Invention

[0006] SUMMARY OF THE PRESENT EMBODIMENT It is an object of the present invention to overcome the above-mentioned drawbacks of the prior art and to provide a method for metal artifact reduction in X-ray dental volume tomography.

[0007] This object is achieved by a method for reducing metal artifacts according to claim 1 and by an X-ray dental volume tomography system according to claim 10. The subject matter of the dependent claims relates to further developments.

[0008] The present invention provides a method for metal artifact reduction in X-ray dental volume tomography, comprising the steps of obtaining a two-dimensional X-ray image or sinogram of at least a portion of a patient's jaw, acquired by relatively rotating an X-ray source and a detector around the patient's jaw, detecting metal objects in the two-dimensional X-ray image or sinogram by using a trained artificial intelligence algorithm to generate a 2D mask representative of the metal objects in the two-dimensional X-ray image or a 3D mask representative of the metal objects in the sinogram, respectively, and reconstructing a three-dimensional tomographic image based on the two-dimensional X-ray image or sinogram and the generated 2D mask or 3D mask, respectively.

[0009] The main advantageous effect of the present invention is that the use of 2D / 3D masks generated by a trained artificial intelligence algorithm allows for more reliable detection of metal objects by direct and sole analysis of 2D X-ray images or sinograms. This allows for a relatively short processing time and a relatively light processing load, since it is not necessary to first reconstruct and analyze 3D tomographic images with metal objects. Thus, the speed of reconstructing 3D tomographic images with reduced metal artifacts is increased. Another main advantageous effect of the present invention is that metal objects that are not in the reconstructed volume can be reliably detected and metal artifacts caused by these metal objects can be reduced. Thus, the metal artifact reduction method of the present invention has an improved tomographic image quality, independent of the size of the reconstructed volume. Another main advantageous effect of the present invention is that the artificial intelligence algorithm can be continuously trained with the help of real / virtual data, including 2D X-ray images taken at various angles of the patient jaw or calibration body, so that the generation of 2D / 3D masks for detecting metal objects can be correspondingly improved through such training. This allows for easier medical diagnosis.

[0010] According to the invention, the three-dimensional tomographic image can be reconstructed in two alternative ways. In the first alternative, the method further comprises a step of correcting the two-dimensional X-ray image or sinogram using the generated 2D mask or 3D mask, respectively, and in the reconstruction step, the three-dimensional tomographic image is reconstructed on the basis of the corrected two-dimensional X-ray image or corrected sinogram. In the second alternative, in the reconstruction step, the three-dimensional tomographic image is reconstructed on the basis of the initially obtained two-dimensional X-ray image or sinogram and the generated 2D mask or 3D mask, respectively.

[0011] According to the invention, the 2D / 3D mask is preferably a 2D / 3D binary mask. Alternatively, a probability mask or a confidence mask can be used.

[0012] According to the invention, the 2D X-ray image or sinogram can be corrected by classical image processing. Alternatively, another artificial intelligence algorithm can be used to correct the 2D X-ray image. This artificial intelligence algorithm can be trained with 2D X-ray image data acquired from different patient jaws.

[0013] According to the invention, the reconstruction of the three-dimensional tomographic image may be based only on the corrected two-dimensional X-ray images or on the corrected sinograms, such that the metal objects are not present in the final three-dimensional tomographic image. Alternatively, the reconstruction of the three-dimensional tomographic image may be further based on the uncorrected two-dimensional X-ray images or on the uncorrected sinograms, such that the metal objects are present in the three-dimensional tomographic image.

[0014] According to the invention, the artificial intelligence algorithm is trained using data pairs, each pair consisting of a 2D X-ray image and an associated 2D mask representing the location of any metal objects in the associated 2D X-ray image. Alternatively, the artificial intelligence algorithm can be trained using sinograms and associated 3D masks. The 2D X-ray images are generated by rotating the X-ray source and detector around the patient jaw. The 2D or 3D masks used for training are obtained through the location of metal objects in the 2D X-ray images or sinograms. One way to obtain them is by analyzing the 3D tomographic images that are not corrected for metal artifacts (e.g., by thresholding or other image processing techniques) and then transferring the found masks to the 2D X-ray images or sinograms (e.g., using forward projection). Alternatively, the 2D and / or 3D masks used in the training step can be generated manually from the 2D X-ray images and / or sinograms that are not corrected for metal artifacts.

[0015] According to the present invention, the resulting two-dimensional x-ray image or sinogram is not limited to the entire patient jaw, but may also correspond to a portion of the patient jaw, such as a small volume. Such small volumes may vary in location, size, and shape. The metal artifact reduction method may be applied to any small volume, even if the small volume is free of metal objects and the patient jaw includes one or more metal objects outside the small volume.

[0016] The invention also provides an X-ray dental volume tomography system comprising an X-ray unit and a tomographic reconstruction unit. The X-ray unit comprises acquisition means for acquiring two-dimensional X-ray images or sinograms of at least a part, i.e. a small volume, of the patient's jaw by relatively rotating an X-ray source and a detector around the patient's jaw. The part of the patient's jaw to be examined is selected by a user and is irradiated accordingly, thus preventing overdosing of the patient. The tomographic reconstruction unit also comprises image processing means for carrying out the method according to the invention for metal artifact reduction in X-ray dental volume tomography.

[0017] In the following description, the invention is explained in more detail using exemplary embodiments and with reference to the drawings. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0018] [Figure 1] 1 is a tomogram with metal artifacts according to the prior art. [Diagram 2] FIG. 4 is a tomogram corresponding to the same cross section as FIG. 1, reconstructed using the prior art metal artifact reduction method as shown in FIG. 3. [Diagram 3] 1 is a flow chart showing steps of a prior art metal artifact reduction method. [Figure 4] 2 is a two-dimensional X-ray image acquired with an X-ray unit according to the present invention. [Figure 5a] 4 is a sinogram of a two-dimensional X-ray image acquired with an X-ray unit according to the present invention. [Figure 5b]FIG. 5b is a cross-sectional view of the sinogram of FIG. 5a, taken along a vertical direction. [Figure 6] 2 is a schematic cross-sectional top view of an X-ray unit of an X-ray dental volume tomography system according to the present invention; [Figure 7] 1 is a prior art tomogram having metal artifacts caused by metal objects outside the reconstructed volume. [Figure 8] 8 is a tomogram corresponding to the same cross section of FIG. 7 reconstructed using the prior art metal artifact reduction method as shown in FIG. 3 . [Figure 9a] FIG. 2 is a flow diagram illustrating steps of a metal artifact reduction method according to a first alternative embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 9b] FIG. 4 is a flow diagram illustrating steps of a metal artifact reduction method according to a second alternative embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 10] 1 illustrates a data pair used to train an artificial intelligence algorithm for generating a mask in accordance with the present invention, the data pair including a 2D X-ray image and an associated 2D mask. [Figure 11] 8 is a tomogram corresponding to the same cross section as in FIG. 7, reconstructed using the metal artifact reduction method according to the invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0019] The reference numbers shown in the drawings indicate the elements listed below and will be referenced in the subsequent description of the exemplary embodiments. 1: 2DX ray image 2: Sinogram 3: Patient 3a: patient jaw 4: X-ray source 5: Detector 6: Metal objects 6a: Metal object (outside small volume (v)) 6b: Metal object (inside a small volume (v)) 7: 2D Mask 8: 3D tomographic image 9: X-ray unit V: A part or small volume of the patient's jaw (3a)

[0020] Figure 6 shows an X-ray unit (9) according to an embodiment of the present invention. The X-ray unit (9) comprises acquisition means for acquiring a two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or sinogram (2) of at least a part (V) of the patient's jaw (3a), i.e. a small volume, by relatively rotating the X-ray source (4) and the detector (5) around the patient's jaw (3a). The X-ray unit (9) is connectable to a tomographic reconstruction unit comprising image processing means adapted to perform the method for metal artifact reduction in X-ray dental volume tomography according to the present invention. The X-ray unit (9) and the tomographic reconstruction unit together constitute an X-ray dental volume tomography system according to the present invention.

[0021] FIG. 9a illustrates steps (S1, S2, S3, S4) of a method for metal artifact reduction in X-ray dental volume tomography according to a first alternative embodiment of the invention.

[0022] In a first step (S1), a two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or a sinogram (2) of at least a part (V) of the patient's jaw (3a) is obtained from the acquisition means of the X-ray unit (9). In a second step (S2), metal objects (6) are detected in the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or in the sinogram (2) by using a trained artificial intelligence algorithm, which generates either a 2D mask (7) representing the metal object (6) in the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or a 3D mask representing the metal object (6) in the sinogram (2), respectively. In addition, to optimize the detection, optionally other 2D or 3D masks obtained from classical algorithms can be used in combination with the one generated by the trained artificial intelligence algorithm. In a third step (S3), the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) is corrected at least with the generated 2D or 3D mask, respectively. This correction can be performed by classical image processing. Alternatively, the correction can be performed by another trained artificial intelligence algorithm. In step (S4), a 3D tomographic image (8) is reconstructed based on the corrected 2D X-ray image (1) or the corrected sinogram (2). Alternatively, the reconstruction of the 3D tomographic image (8) may be based on the corrected and uncorrected 2D X-ray image (1) or the corrected and uncorrected sinogram (2), such that if a metal object (6) is present, the metal object (6) is also shown in the 3D tomographic image (8).

[0023] 9b shows steps (S1, S2, S5) of a method for metal artifact reduction in X-ray dental volume tomography according to a second alternative embodiment of the present invention. In the second alternative embodiment, the third step (S3) is omitted. A 3D tomographic image (8) is then reconstructed based on the initially acquired 2D X-ray image (1) or sinogram (2) and the generated 2D mask (7) or 3D mask, respectively.

[0024] For comparison, a prior art tomogram with metal artifacts caused by a metal object (6a) outside the reconstructed small volume (V) is shown in Fig. 7. Fig. 11 shows a tomogram corresponding to the same cross section as Fig. 7, reconstructed using the metal artifact reduction method according to the invention.

[0025] The artificial intelligence algorithm is trained using the data pairs. In the following description, a reference number with a prime sign indicates an element that is similar to an element without the prime sign, but is used in the training step of the method. Each data pair includes a two-dimensional X-ray image (1') and an associated 2D mask (7') representing the 2D position of any metal object (6') in the associated two-dimensional X-ray image (1'). Alternatively, each data pair includes a sinogram (2') and an associated 3D mask representing the 3D position of any metal object (6') in the sinogram (2'), where the two-dimensional X-ray image (1') and the sinogram (2') of the data pair preferably correspond to the entire patient jaw (3a') of any patient (3') and were generated by a relative rotation of the X-ray source (4') and the detector (5') preferably completely around the patient jaw (3a'). The 2D mask (7') and 3D mask used in the training step may be obtained by analyzing the 3D tomographic image (8') that has not been corrected for metal artifacts. For example, the 2D mask (7') and / or 3D mask used in the training step may be obtained from the prior art method of Fig. 3 as a by-product obtained in the analysis step. Alternatively, the 2D mask (7') and / or 3D mask used in the training step may be generated manually from the 2D X-ray image (1') and / or sinogram (2') that has not been corrected for metal artifacts.

[0026] In another embodiment, the tomographic reconstruction unit has input means for retrieving a trained artificial intelligence algorithm for generating the 2D mask (7) and the 3D mask. The input means can be a wireless connection or a wired connection that can be connected to a network or the like for data retrieval.

[0027] In another embodiment, the acquisition means is configured for user-selectable acquisition of two-dimensional X-ray images (1) or sinograms (2) corresponding to one of a number of different portions (V) of the patient's jaw (3a), each having a different volume, the user being able to select the portion (V) to be irradiated and adjust its size.

[0028] In another embodiment, the method is provided in the form of a computer readable program having code for causing a computer-based X-ray dental volume tomography system to perform the above-mentioned steps of the method for reducing metal artifacts in X-ray dental volume tomography.

[0029] In another embodiment, the computer readable program is stored in a computer readable storage device.

Claims

1. 1. A method for metal artifact reduction in x-ray dental volume tomography, comprising: obtaining (S1) a two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or sinogram (2) of at least a portion (V) of a patient's jaw (3a), the image being acquired by relatively rotating an X-ray source (4) and a detector (5) around said patient's jaw (3a); Equipped with The method comprises: detecting (S2) said metal object (6) in said two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or said sinogram (2) by using at least a trained artificial intelligence algorithm to generate a 2D mask (7) representing said metal object (6) in said two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or a 3D mask representing said metal object (6) in said sinogram (2), respectively; a reconstruction step (S4; S5) of reconstructing a three-dimensional tomographic image (8) based on the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) and the generated 2D mask (7) or the 3D mask, respectively; The method of claim 1, further comprising:

2. 2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that in the reconstruction step (S5), the three-dimensional tomographic image (8) is reconstructed based on the initially acquired two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) and on the generated 2D mask (7) or the generated 3D mask, respectively.

3. The method further includes a correction step (S3) of correcting the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) using at least the generated 2D mask (7) or the 3D mask, respectively, and in the reconstruction step (S4), the three-dimensional tomographic image (8) is reconstructed based on the corrected two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the corrected sinogram (2).

2. The method according to claim 1 .

4. 4. A method according to claim 3, characterized in that in the correction step (S3) the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) is corrected by classical image processing.

5. 4. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that in the correction step (S3) the 2D X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) is corrected by means of another trained artificial intelligence algorithm.

6. 6. The method according to claim 3, wherein in the reconstruction step (S4), the reconstruction of the three-dimensional tomographic image (8) is further based on the corrected two-dimensional X-ray image (1) and the uncorrected two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or on the corrected sinogram (2) and the uncorrected sinogram (2).

7. 7. The method according to claim 1, further comprising a training step of training the artificial intelligence algorithm by using data pairs, each data pair comprising a 2D X-ray image (1') and an associated 2D mask (7') representing the position of any metal object (6') in the associated 2D X-ray image (1') or each data pair comprising a sinogram (2') and an associated 3D mask representing the position of any metal object (6') in the sinogram (2'), the 2D X-ray image (1') and the sinogram (2') of the data pair corresponding to a part or the whole of a patient jaw (3a') of one or more patients (3'), having been generated by an X-ray source (4') and a detector (5') or by simulation techniques, covering a plurality of viewing angles, and at least one of the data pairs comprising at least one metal object (6).

8. 8. The method according to claim 7, characterized in that the 2D mask (7') or the 3D mask used in the training step is generated by analyzing a 3D tomographic image (8') that has not been corrected for metal artifacts.

9. 9. The method according to claim 1, wherein the obtained two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or sinogram (2) corresponds to a portion (V) of the patient's jaw (3a) which is free of metal objects (6) or which comprises at least one metal object (6b), and the remaining portion of the patient's jaw (3a) comprises at least one metal object (6a).

10. 1. An x-ray dental volume tomography system comprising: an X-ray unit (9) comprising acquisition means (10) adapted to acquire a two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or sinogram (2) of at least a portion (V) of a patient's jaw (3a) by relative rotation of an X-ray source (4) and a detector (5) completely around said jaw; a tomographic reconstruction unit comprising image processing means adapted to detect metal objects (6) in the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) acquired by the acquisition means; The X-ray dental volume tomography system includes: - detecting said metal object (6) by using a trained artificial intelligence algorithm to generate a 2D mask (7) representing said metal object (6) in said 2D X-ray image (1) or a 3D mask representing said metal object (6) in said sinogram (2), respectively; reconstructing a three-dimensional tomographic image (8) based on the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) and the generated 2D mask (7) or the generated 3D mask, respectively; The system further configured to:

11. The system according to claim 10, characterized in that the image processing means are further configured to reconstruct the three-dimensional tomographic image (8) on the basis of the initially obtained two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) and the generated 2D mask (7) or the 3D mask.

12. The image processing means comprises: - correcting the 2D X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) using the generated 2D mask (7) or the 3D mask, respectively; reconstructing the three-dimensional tomographic image (8) based on the corrected two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the corrected sinogram (2); 11. The system of claim 10, further configured to:

13. 13. The system according to claim 12, characterized in that the image processing means are further adapted to correct the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) by classical image processing.

14. 13. The system according to claim 12, characterized in that the image processing means is further configured to correct the 2D X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) by means of another trained artificial intelligence algorithm.

15. 15. The system according to claim 12, characterized in that the image processing means is further configured to reconstruct the three-dimensional tomographic image (8) on the basis of the corrected and uncorrected two-dimensional X-ray images (1) or the corrected and uncorrected sinograms (2).

16. 16. A system according to any one of claims 10 to 15, characterised in that the tomographic reconstruction unit comprises input means for retrieving said trained artificial intelligence algorithm.

17. 17. The system according to any one of claims 10 to 16, characterized in that the acquisition means is configured for user-selectable and adjustably acquiring the two-dimensional X-ray image (1) or the sinogram (2) corresponding to one of a plurality of different user-selectable and adjustable portions of the patient's jaw (3a) having different volumes.

18. A computer readable program comprising code for causing a computer based X-ray dental volume tomography system to carry out the method of any one of claims 1 to 9.

19. A computer readable storage device storing the computer readable program according to claim 18.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Image processing device, x-ray CT imaging apparatus, and image processing method

    JP2013233168A

  • Deep learning based estimation of data for use in tomographic reconstruction

    WO2018126396A1

Cited By

  • Method of metal artefact reduction in x-ray dental volume tomography

    US12374003B2