Information processing device, information processing method and program

The information processing device and method improve survey reliability by comparing store manager and undercover investigator reports, adjusting for biases, and training investigators to enhance accuracy.

JP2024168791AInactive Publication Date: 2024-12-05EXPERT PARTNERS CO LTD

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2023085738
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-05-24
Publication Date
2024-12-05
Estimated Expiration
Not applicable · inactive patent

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional techniques for surveying services suffer from biases and false inputs, leading to unreliable investigation reports and inaccurate evaluation of survey targets.

Method used

An information processing device and method that compares survey results from store managers and undercover investigators to determine reliability, adjusting for biases and false inputs, and provides training to investigators to minimize evaluation errors.

Benefits of technology

Enhances the reliability of survey results by identifying and correcting discrepancies, ensuring accurate evaluation of survey targets through cross-verification and investigator training.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2024168791000001_ABST
    Figure 2024168791000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To obtain an investigation result with high reliability in investigating execution contents of an object service or the like.SOLUTION: A party concerned investigation result acquisition part 51 of a server 1 acquires, as a store manager investigation report, information showing an investigation result of one or more prescribed items by a party concerned associated with an object service or the like (such as, a store manager) as a service of a prescribed investigation object or the object service or the like (a store service or the like). An investigator investigation result acquisition part 52 acquires information showing an investigation result of a prescribed item by, for example, an undercover investigator or the like about the object service or the like as an investigator investigation report. A reliability determination part 53 determines the reliability of a store manager investigation report in comparison with contents related to the same investigation item about the store manager investigation report and the investigator investigation report.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 4
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to an information processing device, an information processing method, and a program. [Background technology]

[0002] A system has been disclosed in which some users who are recruited to be mystery monitors are selected by lottery to qualify as mystery monitors, and the mystery monitors provide the business with monitor report data describing the matters they monitored in the store, and also receive monetary rebates (see, for example, Patent Document 1). A system has also been disclosed that allows store staff to view investigation reports, including mystery shopping reports, and accepts input of observations about the investigation reports and / or input of whether or not the staff supports the investigation reports (see, for example, Patent Document 2). [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0003] [Patent Document 1] JP 2008-210082 A [Patent Document 2] Patent No. 6689648 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0004] However, with only conventional technologies including Patent Documents 1 and 2, various biases, preconceptions, biased opinions and false inputs contained in the input of customers and staff can reduce the reliability of the survey report of the survey subjects, and the survey results cannot necessarily be said to be reliable, making it difficult to correctly evaluate the survey subjects.

[0005] The present invention has been made in view of the above circumstances, and has an object to obtain highly reliable research results. [Means for solving the problem]

[0006] In order to achieve the above object, an information processing device according to one aspect of the present invention comprises: a first investigation result information acquisition means for acquiring information indicating an investigation result conducted by a party involved in a specified investigation target service or product as the investigation target service as first investigation result information; A second investigation result information acquisition means for acquiring information indicating the investigation results of an investigation by a predetermined investigator regarding the target services, etc. as second investigation result information; a reliability determination means for determining the reliability of the first investigation result information by comparing the contents of the first investigation result information and the second investigation result information relating to the same investigation item; Equipped with.

[0007] An information processing method and a program according to one aspect of the present invention are an information processing method and a program corresponding to the information processing device according to the aspect of the present invention described above. Effect of the Invention

[0008] According to the present invention, highly reliable investigation results can be obtained. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0009] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a conceptual diagram showing an overview of a survey method for a service to which an embodiment of an information processing device of the present invention is applied. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of an information processing system applied to the present service of FIG. 1, that is, an information processing system including a server according to an embodiment of an information processing device of the present invention. [Diagram 3] 3 is a block diagram showing an example of a hardware configuration of a server in the information processing system shown in FIG. 2. [Figure 4] 4 is a functional block diagram showing an example of a functional configuration of a server having the hardware configuration shown in FIG. 3. [Diagram 5] 5 is a flowchart showing the operation of a server having the functional configuration of FIG. 4. [Figure 6]FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of investigating hotel services as a specific example of this service. [Figure 7] 7 is a diagram showing a table of an example of a store manager requirement diagnosis feedback report generated from the survey results of the service of FIG. 6. [Figure 8] FIG. 7 is a diagram showing a graph of an example of a store manager requirement diagnosis feedback report generated from the survey results of the service of FIG. 6. [Figure 9] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing the flow of mystery shopping conducted by the service provider of this service. [Figure 10] This is a diagram to explain the purpose and use of judgment and evaluation in mystery shopping when training investigators. [Figure 11] This is a diagram to explain the procedures for judging and evaluating mystery shopping and points to note when training investigators. [Figure 12] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing a first method for avoiding evaluation errors. [Figure 13] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing a second method for avoiding evaluation errors. [Figure 14] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing collection and recording of evaluation information (part 1). [Figure 15] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing collection and recording of evaluation information (part 2). [Figure 16] This is a diagram showing the implementation of evaluation (part 1) goal achievement evaluation. [Figure 17] This figure shows the implementation of evaluation (part 2) - functional level achievement evaluation. [Figure 18] FIG. 11 is a diagram showing a second example of investigating a car rental service as a concrete example of this service. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0010] First, before describing an embodiment of an information processing device of the present invention, an overview of a service to which the embodiment of the information processing device is applied (hereinafter, referred to as "this service") will be described with reference to FIG.

[0011] In this service, the service provider obtains information showing the results of a 44-item questionnaire (one or more specified items) conducted by the store manager T (the party involved) of a store involved in the service (target service, etc.) at store S, as a store manager survey report (e.g., a blue line in a line graph), as shown in Figure 1. In addition, the service provider obtains information showing the results of an investigation into the target services, etc., for example, 44 items by investigator C, etc., in the form of an investigator investigation report (for example, a gray line in a line graph, etc.). The service provider then compares the store manager survey report and the investigator survey report obtained as described above for the same survey items to determine the reliability of the store manager survey report. The survey (method) used for such a service is called a "cross-voice survey" or the like.

[0012] In this example, for question item “17,” Store Manager T’s self-evaluation is “1,” while Investigator C’s evaluation is “4.” This means that the evaluations of Store Manager T and Investigator C differ by three points, meaning that Store Manager T’s self-evaluation is low and Investigator C’s evaluation is high. In addition, for questions "21" and "34," Manager T's self-evaluation was "4," while Investigator C's evaluation was "1." This indicates that Manager T's self-evaluation is high and Investigator C's evaluation is low.

[0013] In this way, by assessing the effects of evaluation errors, lies, discrepancies in factual perception, etc. and judging the reliability of the store manager survey report, for example, by providing feedback to the store manager about discrepancies in items where factual perception is low and correcting the perception of items with low reliability, it becomes possible to obtain highly reliable survey results.

[0014] Next, the configuration of an information processing system that is applied to the present service of FIG. 1 will be described. FIG. 2 is a diagram showing an example of the configuration of an information processing system applied to the present service of FIG. 1, that is, an information processing system including a service provider server according to an embodiment of the information processing device of the present invention. The information processing system of this embodiment is configured by connecting a server 1 and a user terminal 4 to a network N such as the Internet, for example, as shown in FIG.

[0015] The server 1 is an information processing device managed by a service provider, and displays, for example, a website that is limited to members on the Internet, so that users who have registered as members can access the website. The user terminal 4 is an information processing device such as a personal computer, tablet, smartphone, etc., that accepts operations by a user such as a store owner. The user can access a website operated by a service provider from the user terminal 4 and receive the service (see FIG. 1) provided by the service provider.

[0016] In the present embodiment, for example, a first method is adopted in which the user terminal 4 accesses the website of the server 1 and displays the website as an example of cooperation between the user terminal 4 and the server 1. According to the first method, the user terminal 4 appropriately communicates with the server 1 and has the server 1 execute main processes. However, the method by which the user terminal 4 and the server 1 cooperate to realize this service is not particularly limited to the first method. For example, the user terminal 4 can adopt a second method of downloading and installing a dedicated application software program (hereinafter abbreviated as "app") in advance from the server 1 or a device (not shown) under its management, and executing the program using the app, as the "collaboration" method. Also, a method that appropriately combines the first and second methods can be adopted as the "collaboration" method. However, in the following example, for the sake of convenience, the first method will be described as being adopted as the "collaboration" method. That is, in the following example, the subject of processing is the "server 1" for illustrative purposes only, and it goes without saying that in implementation, the subject may be the "user terminal 4" as appropriate.

[0017] In this example, the server 1 executes the main processes, so the following description will focus on the server 1 in the information processing system of FIG.

[0018] FIG. 3 is a block diagram showing an example of a hardware configuration of a server in the information processing system shown in FIG.

[0019] The server 1 includes a CPU (Central Processing Unit) 11, a ROM (Read Only Memory) 12, a RAM (Random Access Memory) 13, a bus 14, an input / output interface 15, an output unit 16, an input unit 17, a memory unit 18, a communication unit 19, and a drive 20.

[0020] The CPU 11 executes various processes according to a program recorded in the ROM 12 or a program loaded from the storage unit 18 into the RAM 13 . The RAM 13 also stores data and the like necessary for the CPU 11 to execute various processes.

[0021] The CPU 11, ROM 12, and RAM 13 are connected to one another via a bus 14. An input / output interface 15 is also connected to this bus 14. An output unit 16, an input unit 17, a storage unit 18, a communication unit 19, and a drive 20 are connected to the input / output interface 15.

[0022] The output unit 16 is configured with a display such as a liquid crystal display, a speaker, and the like, and outputs various information as images and sounds. The input unit 17 is configured with, for example, a keyboard, and is used to input various information. The storage unit 18 is configured with a dynamic random access memory (DRAM) or the like, and stores various data. The communication unit 19 communicates with other devices (such as the store manager terminal 2, the investigator terminal 3, and the user terminal 4 in FIG. 2) via a network N including the Internet.

[0023] Removable media 30, such as a magnetic disk, an optical disk, a magneto-optical disk, or a semiconductor memory, is appropriately loaded into the drive 20. A program read from the removable media 30 by the drive 20 is installed in the storage unit 18 as necessary. Furthermore, the removable medium 30 can also store various data stored in the storage unit 18 in the same manner as the storage unit 18 .

[0024] Although not shown, the manager terminal 2, investigator terminal 3, user terminal 4, etc. in Figure 2 basically have the same hardware configuration as that shown in Figure 3. Therefore, explanations of the hardware configurations of the manager terminal 2, investigator terminal 3, and user terminal 4 will be omitted.

[0025] The cooperation of the various hardware and software components of the server 1 makes it possible to execute a series of processes for implementing the present service shown in FIG.

[0026] Hereinafter, an example of the functional configuration of the server 1 for executing the above-mentioned series of processes will be described with reference to FIG. FIG. 4 is a functional block diagram showing an example of the functional configuration of a server having the hardware configuration shown in FIG. As shown in FIG. 4, the storage unit 18 of the server 1 stores a DB 61.

[0027] DB61 stores member information, question information, store manager survey reports, investigator survey reports, owner survey reports, store manager requirement diagnosis results, reliability information, educational content, training content, performance information, and the like. Member information is information about individuals who have become members of the Service, such as name, age, occupation, contact details, user ID and password. The question information is information on a questionnaire given to members, which is composed of, for example, 44 questions and answer columns. The store manager survey report is information that lists the answers written by the store manager in the answer column of a questionnaire administered to the store manager, in the order of items. The investigator survey report is information that lists the answers that the investigator wrote in the questionnaire response columns when he or she visited the store, in order of item. The owner survey report is information that is compiled by listing answers written by the store owner in the response column of a questionnaire that the store owner fills out when the store owner visits the store. The results of the store manager requirement diagnosis are information summarizing the results of diagnosing the requirements of the store manager based on the responses to the above questionnaire. The reliability information is information indicating the reliability of the store manager's survey results, obtained by comparing the survey report (response) of the store manager, who is the party involved, with the survey reports (responses) of third parties such as the investigator and the store owner, among the responses to the above questionnaire. The educational content is, for example, book or video content such as industry business characteristics, evaluation criteria, etc. The training content is, for example, program content such as a role-playing application or a simulation application, and the person to be trained actually operates the application on a terminal to learn the content. The performance information includes, for example, sales, profits, and customer satisfaction.

[0028] As shown in Figure 4, when the CPU 11 of the server 1 executes the process of determining the reliability of the personal investigation report (store manager investigation result information), the following units function: a party investigation result acquisition unit 51, a third party investigation result acquisition unit 52, a reliability determination unit 53, an investigation result adjustment unit 54, an education unit 55, a training unit 56, a result acquisition unit 57, and a result-related item identification unit 58.

[0029] The party investigation result acquisition unit 51 acquires information indicating the results of an investigation of one or more predetermined items by a party, such as a store manager, involved in the target service, for example, a service or product that is a predetermined investigation target, such as a store service, as, for example, a store manager investigation report (personal investigation report). Specifically, the party investigation result acquisition unit 51 acquires a store manager investigation report (personal investigation report) input by the store manager operating the store manager terminal 2. Note that, although store services are exemplified as the target service, other items such as handmade products may also be used, and the target service may be any service or product that is a predetermined investigation target. Note that, although a store manager is exemplified as the party, other items such as store staff, product manufacturing staff, customers, etc. may also be used, as long as they are parties.

[0030] The third-party investigation result acquisition unit 52 acquires information showing the results of investigations of predetermined items by a predetermined investigator, such as a mystery investigator or a store owner, regarding the store service as a third-party investigation report such as an investigator investigation report or a store owner investigation report. Specifically, the third-party investigation result acquisition unit 52 acquires an investigator report in which information is input by an investigator operating the investigator terminal 3, and a store owner investigation report in which information is input by a store owner operating the user terminal 4. Note that although mystery investigators, store owners, etc. are exemplified here as predetermined investigators, other people who are not directly involved, such as managers, first-class architects, etc., may also be used as long as they are third parties.

[0031] The reliability assessment unit 53 assesses the reliability of the store manager survey report by comparing the contents of the store manager survey report and the investigator survey report relating to the same survey items (for example, questions "1" to "44" in Figure 1) (three questions out of 44, such as questions "17", "21", and "34", differ by three points or more). Specifically, the reliability judgment unit 53 compares the contents of the store manager survey report and the investigator survey report (e.g., questions "1" to "44") out of the 44 questions in Figure 1, and if three questions, e.g., questions "17," "21," and "34," deviate by three points or more, it judges the reliability of the store manager survey report as, for example, 41 / 44 x 100 ≒ 93%, etc. When the contents of the store manager survey report and the investigator survey report for the same survey item diverge by a predetermined amount or more, the reliability determination unit 53 notifies a user, such as a store owner, of this fact. For example, if the evaluation is on a scale of "1" to "5", the divergence is "3" or more. Here, "3" is used as an example, but other values ​​are also acceptable. This enables users to easily grasp the details of any discrepancies between the investigation report entered by the investigator and the investigation report entered by the customer or staff that exceed a specified level, allowing them to grasp the current situation in detail, analyze the causes, and consider improvement measures.

[0032] The survey result adjustment unit 54 adjusts the store manager survey report based on the reliability. Specifically, adjustments are made such as excluding responses to items with too low a score. This allows users such as store owners to more appropriately grasp the current situation while being prevented from being misled by survey results that are low in reliability and contain various biases, preconceptions, prejudices, and false inputs.

[0033] The education unit 55 outputs predetermined educational content such as industry and business characteristics and evaluation standards related to target services such as store services to predetermined investigators such as mystery shop investigators, for example, high school students to those in their 60s. This will make it easy to provide education to mystery shoppers ranging from high school students to those in their 60s to reduce the influence of various biases, preconceptions, and prejudices when conducting surveys.

[0034] The training unit 56 outputs program content (predetermined training content) such as a role-playing application or a simulation application related to target services such as store services to mystery shop investigators, for example, from high school students to those in their sixties. This makes it easy to train designated investigators (for example, high school students to undercover investigators in their 60s) to suppress the influence of various biases, preconceptions, and prejudices when conducting surveys.

[0035] The result acquisition unit 57 acquires result information such as sales, profits, customer satisfaction, etc., relating to target services such as store services.

[0036] The result-related item identification unit 58 identifies survey items highly related to results based on the results information such as sales, profits, customer satisfaction, etc. acquired by the result acquisition unit 57, as well as the store manager survey report or the investigator survey report. Specifically, the result-related item identification unit 58 identifies items that lead to results, for example, from the correlation between items that received good ratings in the responses to the store manager survey report or the investigator survey report and content that resulted in high customer satisfaction. This allows the store owner (user) who requested the survey to easily understand the items that lead to results such as sales, profits, and customer satisfaction, and to use the results to help the store manager and other store staff members reflect on the results.

[0037] Here, the operation of the server 1 having the functional configuration of FIG. 4 will be described with reference to the flowchart of FIG. FIG. 5 is a flowchart showing the operation of the server 1 having the functional configuration of FIG.

[0038] As shown in FIG. 5, in step S11, in the server 1, the party investigation result acquisition unit 51 acquires, as a store service, information indicating the results of an investigation of, for example, 44 items (one or more specified items) conducted by the store manager involved in the target service, etc., as a store manager investigation report. In step S12, the third-party survey result acquisition unit 52 acquires information indicating the survey results of 44 items by the mystery shopper regarding the store's services as an investigator survey report. The third-party survey result acquisition unit 52 also acquires survey results by store owners as third-party survey results. In step S13, the reliability judgment unit 53 judges the reliability of the store manager survey report by comparing the contents of the same survey items for the acquired store manager survey report and the investigator survey report. In addition, if there is a survey result by the store owner, this is also subject to comparison. Specifically, for example, when comparing the contents of questions "1" through "44" in Figure 1 between reports, three out of 44 questions, namely "17," "21," and "34," had a discrepancy of three points or more. Therefore, by excluding the responses to these three questions and calculating a response rate, for example, 41 / 44 x 100 ≒ 93%, the reliability of the store manager survey report can be determined.

[0039] A specific example of this service will be described below with reference to FIGS. Fig. 6 is a diagram showing an example of a hotel service survey as a specific example of this service. Fig. 7 is a diagram showing a table of an example of a manager requirement diagnosis feedback report generated from the survey results of the service in Fig. 6. Fig. 8 is a diagram showing a graph of an example of a manager requirement diagnosis feedback report generated from the survey results of the service in Fig. 6. As a specific example, a service provided by a store such as a hotel will be described.

[0040] As shown in FIG. 6, for example, a survey result 81 is obtained in which customers who have used accommodation services at a store such as a hotel participate in a questionnaire survey on the service and evaluate it. In addition, a questionnaire survey is conducted on the self-evaluation of hotel staff, such as managers, and the survey results are obtained. In addition, undercover investigators are sent to visit and infiltrate the hotels to receive services, and the evaluation results 83 of the undercover investigators are obtained. Then, based on the responses to the respective evaluation results 81 to 83, flagged data 84 is generated to visualize the evaluation errors of the three parties, and based on the flagged data 84, any inconsistencies in the evaluations of the three parties are visualized.

[0041] Specifically, the store manager requirements diagnosis feedback report is visualized in the table format shown in FIG. 7 and in the graph format shown in FIG. The table of the store manager requirement diagnosis feedback report shown in Figure 7 is divided into requirements, question number, question item, details of question item, self-evaluation a, owner evaluation b, SV evaluation c, ba, ca on the horizontal axis, and 44 questions in total are set for the eight requirements (major items) of the store manager on the vertical axis. SV is an abbreviation of SuperVisor, which here refers to a mystery shopper.

[0042] The eight requirements (major items) for store managers are, for example, strategy promotion activities, business execution activities, communication activities, leadership activities, motivation activities, self-management activities, LRS original (store operation and management), LRS original (other), etc. Each requirement (major item) includes multiple question items (minor items).

[0043] The horizontal axis shows the self-evaluation a, owner evaluation b, and SV evaluation c, which are the answers to each question item, given as a score (point) on a scale of 1 to 5. ba shows the numerical value of the evaluation gap (difference) between the owner evaluation b and the store manager's self-evaluation a. ca shows the numerical value of the evaluation gap (difference) between the mystery shopper's SV evaluation c and the store manager's self-evaluation a. Looking at this table, it is possible to determine in which of the three items evaluation errors are occurring based on the differences in each numerical value.

[0044] Of the graphs in the store manager requirements diagnosis feedback report shown in Figure 8, Figure 8(A) visualizes the numerical values ​​of each item by connecting them in order with a line graph, while Figure 8(B) visualizes the diagnosis results of the store manager requirements by calculating the average value of each item for each of the eight requirements (major items) for the store manager and plotting the numerical values ​​on a radar chart. Looking at the line graph in Figure 8(A), it is possible to determine in which of the three items evaluation errors are occurring based on the degree to which the lines overlap. By looking at the radar chart in Figure 8(B), it is possible to determine the degree of distribution bias, such as which of the eight requirements (major items) for store managers the evaluation errors are biased towards.

[0045] Here, we will explain the differences between this service and general mystery shopping services. A mystery shopping service is one in which a service provider (such as a research company) requests a mystery shopper to investigate a service that has been requested by a company, etc., and the mystery shopper experiences (investigates) the service. The mystery shopper then returns an evaluation of the customer service that he or she experienced to the service provider, who then provides feedback of the investigation results to the company. In the case of a typical mystery shopping service, companies request a survey from a service provider (such as a research company), and mystery shoppers receive compensation for using the service free of charge. On the other hand, in principle, this service does not receive survey requests from companies, but instead contracts surveys from companies that are convinced of the high reliability of the service provider's surveys and provides paid consulting guidance.The service provider then uses the guidance fees to develop and train mystery shoppers, and pays remuneration to the mystery shoppers who conduct the surveys. When hiring investigators, the service provider of this service interviews the candidates to determine their suitability (whether or not they have a tendency to complain, etc.), and then officially employs (registers) those who are deemed suitable as investigators. After officially employing them, the service provider of this service provides the investigators with prescribed investigative training to equip them with a certain level of investigative skills. By equipping each investigator with a certain level of investigative skills in this way, it is possible to eliminate evaluation errors in mystery shopping.

[0046] Here, we will explain our efforts to eliminate evaluation errors. To eliminate the evaluation error, The service provider of this service will: 1. Confirm with the mystery shopper the industry sector characteristics and evaluation criteria, 2. Conduct role-playing with the mystery shopper to imagine the customer profile, and 3. Conduct a simulation for reporting the survey results. In particular, for point 2 above, a trainer who specializes in customer service and is also an undercover investigator will conduct standardized training on judgment and evaluation, as well as role-playing. The unified training is aimed at helping mystery shoppers understand and avoid evaluation errors, which are patterns of failure in judgment and evaluation when checking, and is designed to eliminate the following: Specifically, these include the halo effect, tendency to be lenient, tendency to be strict, tendency to centralize, tendency to polarize, logic error, proximity error, contrast error, self-projection error, and end-stage error.

[0047] Next, the training of mystery shoppers conducted by the service provider of this service will be described with reference to FIGS. FIG. 9 is a diagram showing the flow of a mystery shopping carried out by the service provider of this service. Figure 10 is a diagram to explain the purpose and use of judgment and evaluation in mystery shopping when training investigators. Figure 11 is a diagram explaining the procedure for judging and evaluating mystery shopping and points to note when training investigators.

[0048] The mystery shopping conducted by the service provider of this service is carried out in the following order, as shown in Figure 9: survey planning and design, surveyor training, field survey, analysis and aftercare. Survey planning and design involves planning a survey including survey items, criteria, number of surveys, etc. The survey period is about 3 days to 1 week.

[0049] After a confidentiality agreement is signed with the investigator, the investigators undergo training through e-learning and remote role-playing, etc. The training period is at least two weeks. There are three key points in the investigator training. The first point is to understand the difference between absolute evaluation and relative evaluation, the second point is training to avoid evaluation errors, and the third point is to acquire knowledge of evaluation perspectives according to industry and business type. This investigator training is an important process for ensuring the reliability of the survey.

[0050] The second point, training of investigators, is particularly important because evaluation errors in surveys can make it difficult to maintain reliability. During the training, investigators are automatically sent cases in which they must look at images and videos and evaluate them on a four-point scale according to the survey items, and they must respond within the time limit. The participants review their answers, recognize the cause of their evaluation errors, and repeat 100 cases until they reach the pass standard. The cases include, for example, a customer service edition, a tool comparison edition, and a product comparison edition.

[0051] After two days of training, the field survey is conducted under the guidance of a senior surveyor. The survey period is more than two weeks. After the survey, the surveyor himself / herself writes a report. Analysis and aftercare involves analysis of survey results, reporting, compensation, and other aftercare for surveyors. The period is at least two weeks.

[0052] Here, the development training will be described. First, referring to Figure 10, we will explain the purpose and use of judging and evaluating mystery shopping during investigator training. As shown in Figure 10, store evaluation has a "selection aspect (classifying stores into good and bad)" and a "development aspect (developing stores to the desired image and level)." The assessment and evaluation items in the training cover the range and areas of skill development necessary for stores to produce results, making it easy to use not only for "selection" but also for "training." In training, it is important to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the store by assigning evaluation points and using this information in training. In the training, through judging and evaluating the store's services, the investigators can grasp the "strengths and weaknesses" of the store and use this information to "develop" the store in order to increase sales and repeat customer rates.

[0053] Next, with reference to Figure 11, we will explain the procedure and points to note for judging and evaluating mystery shopping during investigator training. During the investigator training, it is necessary for them to work on selecting evaluation items and evaluation points, taking into account the points to note at each stage and throughout the entire evaluation period.

[0054] As shown in Figure 11, points to note when starting the investigator training include checking the items, definitions, etc. from the evaluation sheet and materials containing criteria, etc. An important point to note during the on-site investigation is to limit it to "actual actions (facts)" in "work." Anything that happened before the relevant evaluation period will not be included. Behavior will be recorded so as not to be biased towards a particular period (see below). Store work behavior, contributions to work, and related activities will be included.

[0055] As the investigator training draws to a close, it is important to pay attention to the selection of items and stores to be judged and evaluated. The selection of items and judgment / evaluation stores is based on the principle of one action (fact) and one item. Specifically, as a rule, one behavior is evaluated for one item. If there is no evaluation item that perfectly applies, evaluate using the most relevant item. Select an evaluation point that is closest to the actual situation. Attributes (career history, age, etc.) are not taken into account.

[0056] In this way, the investigator training will cover all procedures from the beginning to the end of the period, following the above points.

[0057] Next, we will explain "evaluation error," which is a pattern of failure in judgment and evaluation. In personnel evaluation, mistakes that occur when making judgments or assigning evaluation points are called "evaluation errors." There are ten commonly occurring evaluation errors: The 10 patterns are: halo effect, tendency to be lenient, tendency to be strict, tendency to centralize, tendency to polarize, logical error, proximity error, contrast error, self-projection error, and end-of-period error. The halo effect, tendency to be lenient, tendency to be strict, tendency to be central, and tendency to be polarized are all errors in how we see and make impressions of people.

[0058] The halo effect is an error in which a certain characteristic permeates the entire impression of a person. The tendency to be lenient is the tendency to judge and evaluate things more leniently than they actually are. The trend towards stricter standards is the tendency to give judgments and evaluation scores that are harsher than they actually are. Central tendency is the tendency for judgment and evaluation scores to concentrate in the center. Polarization is the tendency for judgments and evaluation scores to be concentrated at the top or bottom. It is important for evaluators to be careful not to fall into these traps, and to reflect on their own tendencies in evaluation errors to improve their evaluation methods.

[0059] Logical errors, proximity errors, contrast errors, self-projection errors, end-of-period errors, etc. are errors in perspective and thinking that occur during the evaluation process. A logical error is an error in which one imagines that similar evaluation points are linked to evaluation items that one thinks might be related. Proximity error is an error in which similar evaluation points are given to evaluation items that are close to each other on the evaluation sheet. Contrastive error is the error of assigning evaluation points in comparison with the evaluator (oneself) or other employees, and is also the error of the evaluator (oneself) rating items too harshly in areas in which he or she has specialized knowledge and too leniently in areas in which he or she has little expertise. Self-projection error is an error in which an interviewer gives a higher score to an individual who they perceive as having a similar background and experience to themselves. End-of-period errors are errors in which evaluation marks are assigned based largely on impressions of events near the end of the period. Currently, as far as is generally understood, these are all the evaluation errors. If an examiner senses any of these, it is important to be aware of how to prevent or minimize them, and to keep a thorough record of the behavior and facts of the person being evaluated during the evaluation period.

[0060] As described above, investigators need to understand the 10 types of "evaluation errors" that lead to failure in judgment and evaluation mentioned above, and be careful not to fall into these "evaluation errors."

[0061] Next, with reference to Figs. 12 to 18, the exercises (training) for mystery shoppers conducted by the service provider of this service will be described. FIG. 12 is a diagram showing a first method for avoiding evaluation errors during exercises (training) for mystery shoppers. FIG. 13 is a diagram showing a second method for avoiding evaluation errors during exercises (training) for mystery shoppers. FIG. 14 is a diagram showing collection and recording (part 1) of evaluation information during exercises (training) for mystery shoppers. FIG. 15 is a diagram showing collection and recording (part 2) of evaluation information during exercises (training) for mystery shoppers. FIG. 16 is a diagram showing the evaluation of the achievement level of goals in the evaluation (part 1) during the exercise (training) for mystery shoppers. FIG. 17 is a diagram showing the evaluation of the achievement level of professional skills during the exercise (training) of mystery shoppers (part 2).

[0062] First, a method (part 1) for avoiding evaluation errors in exercises (training) will be described with reference to FIG. The first method of avoiding evaluation errors is an "approach" to avoiding evaluation errors. As shown in the table in Figure 12, the relationship between the avoidance methods and the main evaluation errors that can be avoided is shown. Specifically, for example, an approach such as "reading the materials and understanding the definitions of the evaluation items and the differences in evaluation points" will lead to the avoidance of evaluation errors such as a tendency to be lenient, a tendency to be strict, a tendency to centralize, a tendency to polarize, logical errors, proximity errors, contrast errors, and self-projection errors. Furthermore, for example, an approach such as "observing and recording overall behavior (facts) during the period and selecting evaluation items and evaluation points linked to that behavior" can help avoid evaluation errors such as the halo effect, tendency to be lenient, tendency to be strict, tendency to centralize, tendency to polarize, logical error, proximity error, contrast error, self-projection error, and confidentiality error. For example, an approach such as "assessment should be based on the principle of 'one behavior (fact), one evaluation item' (do not use one behavior in the evaluation of many items)" will help avoid evaluation errors such as the halo effect, tendency to be lenient, tendency to be strict, tendency to centralize, tendency to polarize, logical error, proximity error, and end-of-period error. For example, an approach such as "use absolute evaluation. Note that absolute evaluation means evaluation by comparing with established standards, while relative evaluation means evaluation by comparing the person being evaluated with the person being evaluated" would lead to avoid evaluation errors such as a tendency to be lenient, a tendency to be strict, a tendency to be centralized, a tendency to polarize, contrast error, self-projection error, and end-of-period error. For example, have an idea of ​​what level you can achieve (or if you can't), and what that would be the highest (or lowest) score, and if you cannot reach that level, give yourself a rating of "somewhat." " This approach will help avoid evaluation errors such as tendencies towards leniency, strictness, polarization, contrast errors, and self-projection errors. For example, an approach such as "evaluating items randomly rather than in the correct order" can help avoid evaluation errors such as the halo effect, tendency to be lenient, tendency to be strict, tendency to be central, tendency to polarize, logical error, and proximity error.

[0063] Next, a method (part 2) for avoiding evaluation errors in exercises (training) will be described with reference to FIG. The second way to avoid evaluation errors is to have a "mindset" to avoid evaluation errors. As shown in the table in Figure 13, there is a relationship between the ways to avoid evaluation errors and the main evaluation errors that can be avoided. Specifically, for example, if one has the mindset of "being aware that oneself is a 'developer' and grasping broadly both the strengths and weaknesses in order to develop," it will lead to avoiding evaluation errors such as the halo effect, tendency to be lenient, tendency to be strict, tendency to centralize, self-projection error, and terminal error. Furthermore, for example, if you have a mindset of "eliminating preconceived notions and stereotypes based on subjectivity, first impressions, and attributes (work history, experience, age, etc.)," ​​it will lead to the avoidance of evaluation errors such as the halo effect, tendency to be lenient, tendency to be strict, tendency to centralize, tendency to polarize, contrast error, and self-projection error. For example, if you have the mindset of "eliminating feelings of likes and dislikes among those being evaluated," it will lead to avoid evaluation errors such as the halo effect, tendencies to be lenient or strict, contrast errors, and self-projection errors. For example, having the mindset of "separating work from personal matters" can help avoid evaluation errors such as a tendency toward leniency and self-projection errors. For example, having a mindset of "not having overly unrealistic expectations" will help avoid evaluation errors such as a tendency to be strict, a tendency to polarize, and comparison errors. For example, having confidence in the amount of evaluation information, specificity, and evaluation skills will help avoid evaluation errors such as a tendency toward leniency, centralization, and polarization.

[0064] Next, the collection and recording (part 1) of evaluation information in an exercise (training) will be described with reference to FIG. Collecting and recording evaluation information (part 1) involves the investigator considering and recording "all evaluation items" during the investigation.

[0065] As shown in Figure 14, tasks are set at the beginning and during the period. At the beginning of the period, the evaluation items are confirmed. Specific evaluation items include, for example, "They understand the basic points of the work they are responsible for, and are working to be able to identify unnecessary or unnecessary work," and "They accurately grasp the necessary information, knowledge, and skills for the work they are responsible for, and are working to improve their own technical abilities." Examples of assessment items for the strategic planning and judgment theme include "anticipates challenges and effectively leads the team" and "organizes complex information and translates it into specific, prioritized strategies and actions."

[0066] During the period, behavior will be collected and recorded. Information is collected and recorded for each evaluation item at the beginning of the period regarding the facts of behavior related to the detailed definition (and check items). In addition, actions during the period are collected so that all evaluation items can be evaluated. In addition, facts are recorded while keeping in mind points to note so that "evaluation errors" do not occur.

[0067] Next, the collection and recording of evaluation information in an exercise (training) (part 2) will be described with reference to FIG. Collecting and recording evaluation information (part 2) will be recorded in a "survey diary" and will be used not only to determine evaluation points but also as "feedback" for training.

[0068] It is difficult for researchers to recall everything from memory, so they need a tool that allows them to look back and record materials that are useful for evaluation, i.e. evaluation information (facts that serve as the basis).The "investigation diary" shown in Figure 15 is used for this purpose, and it can also be used for feedback. If you record each of the details of the situation (S), action (fact (A)), and result (R) in three categories so that you can understand the situation and result at the time, it will be easier to remember them specifically. It will also make it easier to remember things other than the result.

[0069] A specific example of the present service in Fig. 1 realized by the server 1 having the configurations in Fig. 3 and Fig. 4 will be described below with reference to Fig. 6. Fig. 6 is a diagram showing a specific example of the present service in Fig. 1.

[0070] Next, with reference to FIG. 16, the implementation of evaluation in exercises (training) (part 1) goal achievement evaluation will be described. Conducting an evaluation (part 1) When evaluating the degree of achievement of goals, as shown in Figure 16, during the investigation, the degree of achievement of "deliverables," "situation," and "things and events" are kept track of as evaluation information. As a rule, targets are set through anonymous evaluation, so the degree of achievement of the targets during the survey period is understood. Specifically, if the level of achievement is below the standard (e.g., less than 75%), the grade will be a "D." If it is slightly below the standard (e.g., less than 90%), the grade will be a "C." If it meets the standard (e.g., 90% or more), the grade will be a "B." If it exceeds the standard (e.g., 105% or more), the grade will be an "A." If it significantly exceeds the standard (e.g., 120% or more), the grade will be an "S." Even in the case of the creation of deliverables or equipment that cannot be quantified, it is necessary to collect information on the status of creation or introduction (degree of achievement) during the investigation for evaluation purposes.

[0071] Next, the implementation of evaluation in the exercise (training) (part 2) of the evaluation of the achievement level of the professional ability (judgment of the professional ability level) will be described with reference to FIG. Conducting an evaluation (part 2): When evaluating the achievement of professional level (judging professional level), collect evaluation information at a level where the grounds can be explained, and judge "reproducibility of satisfaction" based on the collected evaluation information using "indicators of the number and quality of actions and facts" as shown in Figure 17. Specifically, convert the collected evaluation information into a numerical value using "indicators of the number and quality of actions and facts", and judge "reproducibility of satisfaction" based on that numerical value.

[0072] Independent completion is judged using measurement indicators such as number, frequency, number of times, quality of output, and customer satisfaction. Improvement actions and proposals are judged using measurement indicators such as number, frequency, scale, difficulty, effectiveness, and scope of impact. Advice and guidance are judged based on measurement indicators such as the number of times, frequency, number of people, scope, the other person's growth, and impact and effectiveness. The expertise demonstrated will be assessed using measurement indicators such as number, sufficiency of scope, sufficiency of expertise (depth, detail), etc. The judgment is made by choosing between "yes" or "no" at the line (threshold) at which one can be "sure" that satisfaction can be reproduced.

[0073] When assessing the achievement of professional level (professional level assessment), it is important to collect "assessment information" related to the definitions and items during the period while keeping in mind the prevention of evaluation errors, and to be able to explain the reasons for the evaluation with evidence. Then, evaluate it based on the image of the measurement index and choose "yes" or "no." The decision is based on whether or not you can "confident" about the versatility and reproducibility of satisfaction.

[0074] Next, as a specific example of this service, a second example of investigating the service content of a car rental store that provides a car rental service will be described with reference to FIG. FIG. 18 is a diagram showing a second case in which a car rental service is investigated as a specific example of this service. As a concrete example of this service, the second case, which investigates car rental services, is conducted using a questionnaire containing five categories and 25 survey items, as shown in Figure 18. The categories are, for example, 1. Impression of the store and staff when entering the store [Overall evaluation of the store], 2. Basic actions and reactions at reception, basic actions and reactions when guiding a car, 4. Vehicles, 5. Basic actions and reactions when returning the car, etc. Each category is associated with five survey items.

[0075] For example, the first category, "1. Impression of the store and staff upon entering [Overall evaluation of the store]," includes survey items such as "The store is well-cleaned inside and out, and has a feeling of cleanliness," "The store is tidy and tidy," "Appearance (clothing, hairstyle, mask) is appropriate and clean, and nameplates are worn on the left side of the chest," "Always smiles and gives a good impression to all customers," and "Uses customer service terminology and is able to use polite language." The second and subsequent categories also have survey items set in the same way as the first category. It should be noted that the examples of categories shown here (the number and contents of categories) are merely examples, and other categories may be used.

[0076] In the case of this survey example, the procedure for the store operation performance survey will be to have store staff answer the same 25 questions as those evaluated in the mystery shopping survey. The time to answer the 25 questions and write down their opinions will be approximately 30 minutes. When the server 1 receives responses to the questionnaire from the store staff, the server 1 performs quantitative and qualitative analysis on the contents of the responses (result data) of the store staff, and compares and analyzes them with the results of the mystery shopping. Specifically, similar to the example of Figure 6, the reliability determination unit 53 determines the reliability of the answers of the store staff by comparing the mystery shopping investigation results with the answers of the store staff, and presents the result to the user (such as the owner of the rental car store). In this example, as a result of the analysis, the error between A and C, and the error between B and C, are calculated for each survey item, and an error flag code according to the analysis result is assigned to each survey item.

[0077] Here, the error flag code is given to items that may be major evaluation errors that can be avoided. For example, in the category "The inside and outside of the store are well-cleaned and have a feeling of cleanliness," if the evaluation values ​​of A, B, and C indicate the possibility of a "logical error," "strict error," or "comparison error" as shown in Figure 12, the error flag code will be displayed as, for example, [XXX01]. This shows a sign that error adjustment is necessary based on the facts and photos on-site. Also, if there is a possibility of "a tendency towards leniency" or "self-projection error" from the evaluation values ​​of A, B, and C, for example, [XXX15] will be displayed. By looking at the error flag code in this way, you can see what you should do next for the item.

[0078] This allows users (rental car shop owners, etc.) to check the consistency of the two survey results, the mystery shop survey results and the responses of the store staff. In addition, by checking the quantified reliability and each survey item where there is a discrepancy between the two survey results, users can clarify store improvement themes.

[0079] Although one embodiment of the present invention has been described above, the present invention is not limited to the above-described embodiment, and modifications, improvements, etc. within the scope that can achieve the object of the present invention are included in the present invention.

[0080] For example, in the above embodiment (FIG. 1, etc.), an example was described in which the reliability of the investigation result of the store manager T (a party involved) was determined based on the investigation results of two parties, the investigator C (a third party) and the store manager T (a party involved), but the example of the survey subjects shown here is only one example, and other subjects may be surveyed. The investigator C and the store owner may be classified as third parties, and the store manager T and the store staff, etc. may be classified as parties involved. For example, the reliability of the store staff's investigation results may be determined based on the results of an investigation by three parties: Investigator C, a member of the higher organization that has jurisdiction over the store (such as the franchise headquarters), and the store staff, or investigations may be conducted in various combinations that include at least the parties involved and an investigator (third party). In other words, with a specified service or product that is the subject of an investigation as the target service, etc., information showing the results of an investigation into one or more specified items by a party involved in the target service, etc. is obtained as first investigation result information, and information showing the results of an investigation into the specified items by a specified investigator regarding the target service, etc. is obtained as second investigation result information, and the reliability of the first investigation result information can be determined by comparing the contents relating to the same investigation item in the first investigation result information and the second investigation result information.

[0081] For example, in the embodiment described above (see FIG. 5), the processes are executed in the order of steps S11, S12, and S13 in FIG. 5, but the processes of steps S11 to S13 do not necessarily have to be executed in that order. That is, the process of step S11 may be executed after step S12.

[0082] Furthermore, for example, the above-described series of processes can be executed by hardware or software. In other words, the functional configuration in FIG. 5 is merely an example and is not particularly limited. That is, it is sufficient that the information processing device is provided with a function capable of executing the above-mentioned series of processes as a whole, and the functional blocks and databases used to realize these functions are not limited to the example of FIG. 5. The locations of the functional blocks and databases are also not limited to those of FIG. 5 and may be arbitrary. For example, at least a portion of the functional blocks and databases required to execute various processes may be transferred to the user terminal 4. Conversely, although not shown, at least a portion of the functional blocks and databases of the user terminal 4 may be transferred to the server 1. Furthermore, one functional block and database may be configured as a single piece of hardware, a single piece of software, or a combination of these.

[0083] When the series of processes is executed by software, the program constituting the software is installed into a computer or the like from a network or a recording medium. The computer may be a computer implemented with dedicated hardware. Furthermore, the computer may be a computer capable of executing various functions by installing various programs, such as a server, a general-purpose smartphone, or a personal computer.

[0084] A recording medium containing such a program may be composed not only of a removable medium (not shown) that is distributed separately from the device main body in order to provide the program to a user, etc., but also of a recording medium that is provided to a user, etc. in a state where it is pre-installed in the device main body.

[0085] In this specification, the steps of describing a program to be recorded on a recording medium include processes that are performed chronologically in accordance with the order of the steps, but do not necessarily have to be performed chronologically, and also include processes that are performed in parallel or individually. In addition, in this specification, the term "system" refers to an overall device that is composed of a plurality of devices, a plurality of means, etc.

[0086] In other words, it is sufficient for an information processing device to which the present invention is applied to have the following configuration, and various embodiments can be adopted. That is, an information processing device to which the present invention is applied (for example, the server 1 in FIG. 4, etc.) A first investigation result information acquisition means (e.g., the party investigation result acquisition unit 51 in FIG. 4 ) for acquiring information showing the results of investigations of one or more predetermined items by parties involved in the target service (e.g., a store manager, store staff, product manufacturing staff, customers, etc.) regarding a predetermined investigation target service or product as a target service (store service, handmade product, etc.) as first investigation result information (e.g., personal investigation result information from a direct party such as a store manager investigation report, etc.); A second investigation result information acquisition means (e.g., the third-party investigation result acquisition unit 52 in FIG. 4 ) for acquiring information indicating the investigation results of the predetermined items by a predetermined investigator (e.g., a mystery investigator, a manager, a store owner, a franchise headquarters staff member, etc.) for the target service, etc. as second investigation result information (e.g., third-party investigation result information from a third party who is not a direct party to the investigator investigation report, etc.); a reliability determination means (e.g., reliability determination unit 53 in FIG. 4 ) for determining the reliability (e.g., 41 / 44×100≒93%) of the first investigation result information (e.g., store manager investigation result information such as the store manager investigation report) by comparing the contents of the same investigation item (e.g., questions "1" to "44" in FIG. 1 ) for the first investigation result information (e.g., the store manager investigation report) and the second investigation result information (e.g., the investigator investigation report) (three questions out of 44, such as questions "17", "21", and "34", differ by three points or more); Equipped with.

[0087] In this way, the reliability of the first investigation result information (store manager investigation report, etc.) is determined by combining the first investigation result information (store manager investigation result information, such as the store manager investigation report) entered by the parties involved, such as the store manager, customers, and store staff, with the second investigation result information (third party investigation result information, such as the investigator investigation report) entered by a designated investigator (for example, a third party such as an undercover investigator or the store owner), taking into account the effects of evaluation error, lies, and discrepancies in the perception of the facts. Therefore, for example, the parties surveyed can feed back the discrepancies to the surveyed person about items where they have a low perception of the facts and correct their perception of the items with low reliability, thereby obtaining highly reliable investigation results.

[0088] In an information processing device (for example, the server 1 in FIG. 4 ), The reliability determination means (e.g., reliability determination unit 53 in FIG. 4 ) further notifies a user (such as the store owner who requested the survey) of the first survey information (e.g., personal survey result information such as a store manager survey report) and the second survey information (e.g., third-party survey result information by an investigator, store owner, etc. (store manager survey report, etc.)) for the contents of the same survey item when the contents deviate by a predetermined amount or more (e.g., by 3 points or more).

[0089] This allows the user (person requesting the investigation) to easily grasp when third-party investigation result information (e.g., an investigator investigation report, etc.) entered by a designated investigator (e.g., an undercover investigator ranging from a high school student to someone in their sixties) and personal investigation result information entered by a customer or staff member (e.g., a store manager investigation report, etc.) deviate by a specified amount (e.g., three points or more), enabling them to grasp the current situation in detail, analyze the causes, and consider improvement measures.

[0090] In an information processing device (for example, the server 1 in FIG. 4 ), A survey result adjustment unit (e.g., survey result adjustment unit 54 in FIG. 4 ) for adjusting the first survey result information (e.g., a store manager survey report, etc.) based on the reliability; It further comprises:

[0091] This allows users (e.g., the store owner requesting the survey) to more appropriately grasp the current situation while avoiding being misled by survey results that contain various unreliable biases, preconceptions, prejudices, and false input.

[0092] In an information processing device (for example, the server 1 in FIG. 4 ), An educational means (e.g., the educational unit 55 in FIG. 4 ) for outputting predetermined educational content related to the target service to the predetermined investigator (e.g., a high school student to a mystery investigator in his / her 60s), It further comprises:

[0093] This makes it easy to provide training to designated investigators (for example, high school students to undercover investigators in their 60s) to reduce the influence of various biases, preconceptions, and prejudices when conducting surveys.

[0094] In an information processing device (for example, the server 1 in FIG. 4 ), A training means (e.g., the training unit 56 in FIG. 4 ) for outputting predetermined training content (e.g., program content such as a role-playing application or a simulation application) related to the target service to the predetermined investigator (e.g., a high school student to a mystery investigator in his / her 60s), It further comprises:

[0095] This makes it easy to train designated investigators (for example, high school students to undercover investigators in their 60s) to suppress the influence of various biases, preconceptions, and prejudices when conducting surveys.

[0096] In an information processing device (for example, the server 1 in FIG. 4 ), A result information acquisition means (e.g., the result acquisition unit 57 in FIG. 4 ) for acquiring result information (e.g., sales, profits, customer satisfaction, etc.) relating to the target service, etc.; A result-related item specifying means (e.g., the result-related item specifying unit 58 in FIG. 4 ) for specifying a survey item highly related to the results based on the result information (e.g., sales, profits, customer satisfaction, etc.) and the first survey information (e.g., the survey result information of the person involved, such as a store manager survey report) or the second survey information (e.g., the survey result information of a third party, such as a surveyor survey report); It further comprises:

[0097] This allows a user (e.g., the person requesting the survey, such as a store owner) to easily understand items that lead to results, such as sales, profits, customer satisfaction, etc., and use this information to help the relevant parties, such as the store manager and other store staff, review the results.

[0098] The information processing method to which the present invention is applied comprises: An information processing method executed by an information processing device (for example, the server 1 in FIG. 4), A first survey result information acquisition step (e.g., store manager survey result acquisition step S11 in FIG. 5) for acquiring information showing the results of a survey of one or more predetermined items by parties involved in a predetermined survey target service (e.g., store manager, store staff, product manufacturing staff, customers, etc.) regarding the target service or product as a predetermined survey target service, etc. as first survey result information (e.g., store manager survey result information from a direct party such as a store manager survey report); A second investigation result information acquisition step (e.g., third-party investigation result acquisition step S13 in FIG. 5 ) for acquiring information indicating the results of an investigation of the predetermined items by a predetermined investigator (e.g., a mystery investigator, a manager, a store owner, a franchise headquarters staff member, etc.) for the target services (store services, handmade products, etc.) as second investigation result information (e.g., a third-party investigation result such as an investigator investigation report); a reliability determination step (e.g., reliability determination step S13 in FIG. 5 ) for determining the reliability of the first investigation result information (store manager investigation report, etc.) by comparing the contents of the same investigation item for the first investigation result information (store manager investigation report, etc.) and the second investigation result information (investigator investigation report, etc.); Includes.

[0099] In this way, by combining and analyzing the first survey result information (store manager survey report) entered by the store manager, customers, store staff, etc., and the second survey result information (investigator survey report, etc.) entered by a designated investigator (for example, an undercover investigator or store owner, etc.), the influence of evaluation errors, lies, discrepancies in perception of facts, etc. can be evaluated to determine the reliability of the first survey result information (store manager survey report, etc.).For example, by feeding back discrepancies in items where perception of facts is low to the survey subject himself (store manager, etc.) and correcting his perception of items with low reliability, it is possible to obtain highly reliable survey results.

[0100] The program to which the present invention is applied is A first investigation result information acquisition step (e.g., the party investigation result acquisition step S11 in FIG. 5 ) for acquiring information showing the results of investigations of one or more predetermined items by parties involved in the target service (e.g., the store manager, store staff, product manufacturing staff, customers, etc.) regarding a predetermined investigation target service or product as a target service (store service, handmade product, etc.) as first investigation result information (e.g., the store manager investigation result report from the direct party such as the store manager investigation result information); A second investigation result information acquisition step (e.g., investigator investigation result acquisition step S13 in FIG. 5 ) for acquiring information indicating the investigation results by a specific investigator (e.g., a mystery investigator, a manager, a store owner, a franchise headquarters staff member, etc.) for the target service (store service, handmade product, etc.) as second investigation result information (e.g., third-party investigation result such as an investigator investigation report); a reliability determination step (e.g., reliability determination step S13 in FIG. 5 ) for determining the reliability of the first investigation result information (e.g., the store manager investigation report, etc.) by comparing the contents of the first investigation result information (e.g., the store manager investigation report, etc.) and the second investigation result information (e.g., the third party investigation report, etc.) relating to the same investigation item; The control process including the above steps is executed by a computer (eg, the CPU 11 of the server 1 in FIG. 4).

[0101] In this way, by combining and analyzing the first survey result information (store manager survey report) entered by the store manager, customers, store staff, etc., and the second survey result information (investigator survey report, etc.) entered by a designated investigator (for example, an undercover investigator or store owner, etc.), the influence of evaluation errors, lies, discrepancies in perception of facts, etc. can be evaluated to determine the reliability of the first survey result information (store manager survey report, etc.).For example, by feeding back discrepancies in items where perception of facts is low to the survey subject himself (store manager, etc.) and correcting his perception of items with low reliability, it is possible to obtain highly reliable survey results.

[0102] 1 Server, 2 Manager's terminal, 3 Investigator's terminal, 4 User's terminal, 11 CPU, 12 ROM, 18 Memory unit, 19 Communications unit, 51 Participant's investigation result acquisition unit, 52 Third-party investigation result acquisition unit, 53 Reliability determination unit, 54 Investigation result adjustment unit, 55 Education unit, 56 Training unit, 57 Results acquisition unit, 58 Results-related item identification unit, 61 DB

Claims

1. a first investigation result information acquisition means for acquiring information indicating the results of an investigation of one or more predetermined items by a party involved in a predetermined investigation target service or product as a target service, as first investigation result information; a second investigation result information acquisition means for acquiring information indicating the results of an investigation of the predetermined items by a predetermined investigator regarding the target services, etc., as second investigation result information; a reliability determination means for determining the reliability of the first investigation result information by comparing the contents of the first investigation result information and the second investigation result information relating to the same investigation item; An information processing device comprising:

2. The reliability determination means further notifies a user when the first survey result information and the second survey result information deviate from each other by a predetermined amount or more for the content of the same survey item. The information processing device according to claim 1 .

3. A search result adjustment means for adjusting the first search result information based on the reliability. The information processing device according to claim 1 .

4. an educational means for outputting predetermined educational content relating to the target service or the like to the predetermined investigator; The information processing device according to claim 1 , further comprising:

5. training means for outputting predetermined training content related to the target service or the like to the predetermined investigator; The information processing device according to claim 1 , further comprising:

6. An outcome information acquisition means for acquiring outcome information relating to the target service, etc.; A result-related item specifying means for specifying a survey item highly related to the result based on the result information and the first survey result information or the second survey result information; The information processing device according to claim 1 , further comprising:

7. An information processing method executed by an information processing device, a first investigation result information acquisition step of acquiring, as first investigation result information, information showing the results of an investigation of one or more predetermined items by a party involved in a predetermined investigation target service or product as the target service, etc.; a second investigation result information acquisition step of acquiring information indicating the results of an investigation of the predetermined items by a predetermined investigator regarding the target services, etc., as second investigation result information; a reliability determination step of determining the reliability of the first investigation result information by comparing the contents of the first investigation result information and the second investigation result information related to the same investigation item; An information processing method comprising:

8. On the computer, a first investigation result information acquisition step of acquiring, as first investigation result information, information showing the results of an investigation of one or more predetermined items by a party involved in a predetermined investigation target service or product as the target service, etc.; a second investigation result information acquisition step of acquiring information indicating the results of an investigation of the predetermined items by a predetermined investigator regarding the target services, etc., as second investigation result information; a reliability determination step of determining the reliability of the first investigation result information by comparing the contents of the first investigation result information and the second investigation result information related to the same investigation item; A program that executes control processing including:

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Method of processing store monitor management and server therefor

    JP2008210082A

  • Staff management device, staff management method, and staff management program

    JP6689648B2

Cited By

  • Information processing method, information processing system, and program

    JP7770736B1