Gate area estimation program, gate area estimation method, and gate area estimation device

The gate area estimation program uses ensemble learning to enhance the accuracy and confidence of gate region estimation in flow cytometry by combining multiple learning models, addressing the limitations of conventional methods that fail to utilize inspectors' experience.

JP7580448B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-11HU GROUP RESEARCH INSTITUTE G K
View PDF 9 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2022510573
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2020-03-25
Filing Date
2021-03-24
Publication Date
2024-11-11
Estimated Expiration
2041-03-24

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional gate setting methods in flow cytometry rely on cell density information or rule-based approaches, failing to fully utilize inspectors' experience and knowledge, resulting in insufficient accuracy of gate area estimation using learning models.

Method used

A gate area estimation program that employs ensemble learning using multiple learning models to analyze scatter diagrams, combining outputs to enhance accuracy and confidence in gate region estimation.

Benefits of technology

Ensemble learning improves the accuracy and confidence of gate region estimation by leveraging inspectors' experience and knowledge, providing more precise gate area determination.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007580448000001
    Figure 0007580448000001
  • Figure 0007580448000002
    Figure 0007580448000002
  • Figure 0007580448000003
    Figure 0007580448000003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

Provided are a gate region estimation program, and the like, for outputting a more precise estimation result when a gate region is estimated through learning models. This gate region estimation program causes a computer to carry out processing for: acquiring a scatter diagram group including a plurality of scatter diagrams acquired through measurement of flow cytometry of different measurement items; inputting the acquired scatter diagram group to each of a plurality of learning models trained on the basis of training data including a scatter diagram group and a gate region; and outputting an estimation gate region acquired from each of the plurality of learning models.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a gate region estimation program for estimating a gate region in flow cytometry. [Background technology]

[0002] Flow cytometry (FCM) is a technology that can measure multiple characteristics of individual cells. In FCM, cells suspended in a flowing liquid are made to flow in a single file. Light is shone on each individual flowing cell, and the scattering and fluorescence of the light provides indicators of the cell's size, internal complexity, constituent materials, and other properties. In medicine, flow cytometry is used, for example, in cell-mediated immune testing.

[0003] In cellular immunity testing, multiple index values ​​obtained by flow cytometry are analyzed and returned as test results. One of the analysis techniques is gating. Gating is a technique for selecting and analyzing only specific groups from the obtained data. Traditionally, the group to be analyzed was specified by the technician drawing an ellipse or polygon (called a "gate") on a two-dimensional scatter plot. The setting of such gates is largely dependent on the technician's experience and knowledge. For this reason, it is difficult for technicians with little experience or knowledge to set appropriate gates.

[0004] In response to this, technologies to automate gate setting have been proposed (Patent Documents 1 and 2, etc.). However, the conventional technologies use setting methods that use cell density information or rule-based methods, and do not fully utilize the experience and knowledge accumulated by technicians. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0005] [Patent Document 1] Patent No. 6480918 [Patent Document 2] Patent No. 5047803 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0006] Therefore, it is conceivable to estimate the gate area using a learning model that performs deep learning using gate setting data based on the accumulated experience and knowledge of inspectors as training data. However, the accuracy of the estimation of the gate area using the learning model is insufficient.

[0007] The present invention has been made in view of the above circumstances. An object of the present invention is to provide a gate region estimation program or the like that outputs more accurate estimation results when estimating a gate region using a learning model. [Means for solving the problem]

[0008] The gate region estimation program of the present invention is characterized in that it causes a computer to perform a process of acquiring a group of scatter plots including a plurality of scatter plots obtained from flow cytometry measurements having different measurement items, inputting the acquired group of scatter plots into each of a plurality of learning models that have been trained based on training data including the group of scatter plots and the gate region, and outputting the estimated gate region obtained from each of the plurality of learning models. Effect of the Invention

[0009] In the present invention, it is possible to estimate the gate region with high accuracy by ensemble learning using a plurality of learning models. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0010] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram illustrating an example of the configuration of an inspection system. [Diagram 2] 3 is a block diagram showing an example of a hardware configuration of a processing unit; FIG. [Diagram 3] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a measurement value DB. [Figure 4] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a feature information DB. [Diagram 5]FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a gate DB. [Figure 6] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a threshold DB. [Figure 7] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a confidence level DB. [Figure 8] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram regarding a generation process of a regression model. [Figure 9] 13 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a procedure for generating a regression model. [Figure 10] 13 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a procedure for a threshold value determination process. [Figure 11A] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an estimation result of a gate region. [Figure 11B] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an estimation result of a gate region. [Figure 12] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of dispersion degree. [Figure 13A] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of dispersion degree. [Figure 13B] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of dispersion degree. [Figure 14] 13 is a flowchart showing an example of a procedure for gate region estimation processing. [Figure 15] 13 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a procedure for determining a degree of confidence. [Figure 16A] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an estimation result of a gate region. [Figure 16B] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an estimation result of a gate region. [Figure 17A] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of dispersion degree. [Figure 17B] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of dispersion degree. [Figure 18] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an estimation result of a gate region. [Figure 19A] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an estimation result display screen. [Figure 19B] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an estimation result display screen. [Figure 20] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an ID list screen. [Figure 21] 13 is a flowchart showing another example of the procedure of the gate region estimation process. [Figure 22A] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of excluding an outlier gate region. [Figure 22B] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of excluding an outlier gate region. [Figure 23] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of 10 small groups. [Figure 24] 13 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a procedure for gate selection processing. [Figure 25A] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of gate region selection. [Figure 25B] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of gate region selection. [Figure 26] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of gate region selection based on luminance information. [Figure 27] 13 is a flowchart showing another example of a procedure for the gate region selection process. [Figure 28] 13 is a flowchart showing another example of a procedure for the gate region selection process. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0011] Hereinafter, an embodiment will be described with reference to the drawings. In the following description, CD45 gating in Leukemia and Lymphoma Analysis (LLA) testing will be described as an example. First, the steps of the LLA testing will be described. The LLA testing roughly includes five steps: 1. Dispensing, 2. Pretreatment, 3. Measurement and depiction, 4. Analysis, and 5. Reporting.

[0012] The dispensing process is the process of dividing one sample (hereafter referred to as "ID"). In the LLA test, one ID is dispensed into up to 10 samples for testing. Each dispensed sample is referred to as a SEQ. The 10 dispensed samples are also referred to as SEQ1, SEQ2, ..., SEQ10. In the pre-processing process, common processing (such as adjusting the cell concentration) is performed on each SEQ, and a surface marker is individually attached. SEQ1 is the negative control. A negative control is a term used to refer to testing a subject that is already known to produce negative results under the same conditions as the subject whose effect is to be verified, or to that subject. It is also called a negative control. In the test, the results of the subject to be verified are compared with the results of the negative control, and the test results are analyzed from the relative differences.

[0013] In the measurement and depiction process, 10SEQ is measured with a flow cytometer to obtain fluorescence values. For each cell in each SEQ, information consisting of five items, including the measured value, is obtained. The items are FSC, SSC, FL1, FL2, and FL3. FSC indicates the measured value of forward scattered light (FSC). FSC indicates the value of scattered light detected in front of the optical axis of the laser beam. FSC is approximately proportional to the surface area or size of the cell, so it is an index value that indicates the size of the cell. SSC indicates the measured value of side scattered light (SSC). Side scattered light is light detected at an angle of 90° to the optical axis of the laser beam. Most of SSC is scattered when light hits substances inside the cell. SSC is approximately proportional to the granular properties and internal structure of the cell, so it is an index value that indicates the granular properties and internal structure of the cell. FL indicates fluorescence, but here it indicates the multiple fluorescence detectors equipped in the flow cytometer. The numbers indicate the sequential number of the fluorescence detector. FL1 indicates the first fluorescence detector, and here it is the name of the item in which the marker information of each SEQ is set as a marker. FL2 indicates the second fluorescence detector, and here it is the name of the item in which the marker information of each SEQ is set as a marker. FL3 indicates the third fluorescence detector, and here it is the name of the item in which the marker information of CD45 is set.

[0014] The flow cytometer creates two scatter plots for each SEQ and displays the scatter plots on a display etc. For example, one scatter plot has SSC on one axis and FL3 on the other axis, and another scatter plot has SSC on one axis and FSC on the other axis.

[0015] In the analysis process, the technician estimates the disease based on the appearance of the scatter plots and creates gates on each scatter plot that are useful for identifying the disease. Then, for each SEQ, a scatter plot of FL1-FL2 consisting of only cells present within the gate range is created and observed as a marker reaction. In the reporting process, two particularly useful gates are selected for reporting and a report is created.

[0016] (Embodiment 1) 1 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the configuration of an inspection system. The inspection system includes a flow cytometer (gate region estimation device) 10 and a learning server 3. The flow cytometer 10 and the learning server 3 are communicatively connected via a network N. The flow cytometer 10 includes a processing unit 1 that performs various processes related to the operation of the entire device, and a measurement unit 2 that receives a sample and performs measurement by flow cytometry.

[0017] The learning server 3 is composed of a server computer, a workstation, etc. The learning server 3 is not an essential component of the inspection system. The learning server 3 mainly serves to complement the flow cytometer 10, storing measurement data and learning models as backups. The learning server 3 may also generate learning models and re-learn the learning models in place of the flow cytometer 10. In this case, the learning server 3 transmits parameters that characterize the learning model, etc. to the flow cytometer 10. The functions of the learning server 3 may be provided as a cloud service.

[0018] 2 is a block diagram showing an example of the hardware configuration of the processing unit. The processing unit 1 includes a control unit 11, a main memory unit 12, an auxiliary memory unit 13, an input unit 14, a display unit 15, a communication unit 16, and a reading unit 17. The control unit 11, the main memory unit 12, the auxiliary memory unit 13, the input unit 14, the display unit 15, the communication unit 16, and the reading unit 17 are connected by a bus B. The processing unit 1 may be separate from the flow cytometer 10. The processing unit 1 is constructed by a PC (Personal Computer), a notebook computer, a tablet computer, or the like. The processing unit 1 may be constructed by a multicomputer consisting of multiple computers, a virtual machine constructed virtually by software, or a quantum computer.

[0019] The control unit 11 has one or more arithmetic processing devices such as a central processing unit (CPU), a micro-processing unit (MPU), a graphics processing unit (GPU), etc. The control unit 11 reads out and executes an operating system (OS) (not shown) and a control program 1P (gate region estimation program) stored in the auxiliary storage unit 13, thereby performing various information processing, control processing, etc. related to the flow cytometer 10. The control unit 11 also includes functional units such as an acquisition unit and an output unit.

[0020] The main memory unit 12 is a static random access memory (SRAM), a dynamic random access memory (DRAM), a flash memory, etc. The main memory unit 12 mainly temporarily stores data necessary for the control unit 11 to execute arithmetic processing.

[0021] The auxiliary storage unit 13 is a hard disk or a solid state drive (SSD) or the like, and stores a control program 1P and various DBs (databases) required for the control unit 11 to execute processing. The auxiliary storage unit 13 stores a measurement value DB 131, a feature information DB 132, a gate DB 133, a first regression model 1341 to a fifth regression model 1345, a threshold DB 135, and a confidence level DB 136. The auxiliary storage unit 13 may be an external storage device connected to the flow cytometer 10. The various DBs and the like stored in the auxiliary storage unit 13 may be stored in a database server or cloud storage connected via a network N.

[0022] In this embodiment, ensemble learning using a plurality of learning models is performed. Using the output results of the plurality of learning models, the confidence level is calculated for the estimation result of the gate region. In this embodiment, five learning models, the first regression model 1341 to the fifth regression model 1345, are used to perform the ensemble learning, but this is not limited thereto. The number of learning models may be two to four, or six or more.

[0023] The input unit 14 is a keyboard and a mouse. The display unit 15 includes a liquid crystal display panel or the like. The display unit 15 displays various information such as information for performing measurements, measurement results, and gate information. The display unit 15 may be a touch panel display integrated with the input unit 14. The information displayed on the display unit 15 may be displayed on an external display device of the flow cytometer 10.

[0024] The communication unit 16 communicates with the learning server 3 via the network N. In addition, the control unit 11 may use the communication unit 16 to download the control program 1P from another computer via the network N or the like, and store it in the auxiliary storage unit 13.

[0025] The reading unit 17 reads the portable storage medium 1a including a CD (Compact Disc)-ROM and a DVD (Digital Versatile Disc)-ROM. The control unit 11 may read the control program 1P from the portable storage medium 1a via the reading unit 17 and store it in the auxiliary storage unit 13. The control unit 11 may also download the control program 1P from another computer via a network N or the like and store it in the auxiliary storage unit 13. Furthermore, the control unit 11 may read the control program 1P from the semiconductor memory 1b.

[0026] The database stored in the auxiliary storage unit 13 will be described. FIG. 3 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a measurement value DB. The measurement value DB 131 stores the measurement values ​​of measurements made by the flow cytometer 10. FIG. 3 shows an example of one record stored in the measurement value DB 131. Each record in the measurement value DB 131 includes a basic section 1311 and a data section 1312. The basic section 1311 includes a reception number column, a reception date column, a test number column, a test date column, a medical record number column, a name column, a gender column, an age column, and a collection date column. The reception number column stores a reception number (identification information) issued when a test request is received. The reception date column stores the date when the test request is received. The test number column stores a test number issued when a test is performed. The test date column stores the date when the test was performed. The medical record number column stores the number of the medical record corresponding to the test request. The name column stores the name of the test subject who provided the sample. The gender column stores the gender of the test subject. For example, if the subject is male, the gender column stores M. If the subject is female, the gender column stores F. The age column stores the age of the subject. The collection date column stores the date the sample was collected from the subject. In data section 1312, each column stores the measurement value for each cell for the measurement item. Each row stores the measurement value for each measurement item for one cell.

[0027] FIG. 4 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the feature information DB. The feature information DB 132 stores information indicating features obtained from the measurement values ​​(hereinafter, also referred to as "feature information"). The feature information is, for example, a scatter plot or a histogram. The feature information DB 132 includes a reception number column, an examination number column, a sequence number column, a type column, a horizontal axis column, a vertical axis column, and an image column. The reception number column stores the reception number. The examination number column stores the examination number. The sequence number column stores the sequence number of feature information within the same examination. The type column stores the type of feature information. For example, the type is a scatter plot or a histogram as described above. The horizontal axis column stores the item adopted as the horizontal axis in the scatter plot or the histogram. The vertical axis column stores the item adopted as the vertical axis in the scatter plot. In the case of a histogram, the vertical axis is the number of cells, so the vertical axis column stores the number of cells. The image column stores the scatter plot or the histogram as an image.

[0028] FIG. 5 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the gate DB. The gate DB 133 stores information on the gates (gate information) set for the scatter diagram. The gate information is information for determining the gate area. The gate information is information on a figure showing the outline of the gate area, a value range of the measurement values ​​included in the gate area, a set of measurement values ​​included in the gate area, etc. It may be pixel coordinate values ​​of a point included in the gate area on the scatter diagram image. Here, the gate information is a figure showing the outline of the gate area, and the shape is an ellipse, but is not limited thereto. The figure may be a polygon consisting of multiple sides or a figure connecting multiple curves. The gate DB 133 includes a reception number column, an examination number column, a horizontal axis column, a vertical axis column, a gate number column, a CX column, a CY column, a DX column, a DY column, and a θ column. The reception number column stores the reception number. The examination number column stores the examination number. The horizontal axis column stores the item adopted as the horizontal axis in the scatter diagram. The vertical axis column stores the item adopted as the vertical axis in the scatter diagram. The gate number column stores the sequential number of the gate. The CX column stores the x-coordinate value of the center of the ellipse. The CY column stores the y-coordinate value of the center of the ellipse. The DX column stores the value of the major axis of the ellipse. The DY column stores the value of the minor axis of the ellipse. The θ column stores the inclination angle of the ellipse. For example, the inclination angle is the angle between the horizontal axis and the major axis of the ellipse. If a polygon can be set as the gate shape, gate DB133 stores the coordinate columns of multiple points that form the polygon.

[0029] FIG. 6 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the threshold DB. The threshold DB 135 stores thresholds related to indices (degree of dispersion) indicating the degree of variation in each item value indicating the gate region. The thresholds are used when determining the confidence level of the regression model. The example shown in FIG. 6 is a case where the gate region is an ellipse. The threshold DB 135 includes an ID column, a horizontal axis column, a vertical axis column, a CX column, a CY column, a DX column, and a DY column. The ID column stores an ID that specifies a threshold group. The horizontal axis column stores items that are the horizontal axis in a scatter plot. The vertical axis column stores items that are the vertical axis in a scatter plot. The CX column stores a threshold related to the center x coordinate value of the ellipse. The CY column stores a threshold related to the center y coordinate value of the ellipse. The DX column stores a threshold related to the major axis value of the ellipse. The DY column stores a threshold related to the minor axis value of the ellipse. The CX column, the CY column, the DX column, and the DY column each include an A column and a B column. The A column stores a threshold A. The B column stores a threshold B. A "-" in column B indicates that no value is set. If only threshold A is set, the confidence level of the regression model will be either high or low. If threshold B is set, the confidence level is indicated by a numerical value. For example, if it is smaller than threshold A, the confidence level is 50, and if it is further smaller than threshold B, the confidence level is 70. Note that there may be three or more thresholds.

[0030] FIG. 7 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the confidence level DB. The confidence level DB 136 stores the confidence level of the estimation result of the gate region by the regression model. The confidence level DB 136 includes a reception number column, an examination number column, a gate number column, a CX column, a CY column, a DX column, a DY column, a gate total column, and a total column. The reception number column stores the reception number. The examination number column stores the examination number. The gate number column stores the gate sequence number. The reception number column, the examination number column, and the gate number column enable association with the gate DB 133. The CX column stores the confidence level of the center x coordinate value of the ellipse. The CY column stores the confidence level of the center y coordinate value of the ellipse. The DX column stores the confidence level of the major axis length of the ellipse. The DY column stores the confidence level of the minor axis length of the ellipse. The gate total column stores the confidence level for each gate. The total column stores the confidence level for each examination. In the example shown in FIG. 7, the confidence level value is high or low.

[0031] Next, the preparation process will be described. The preparation process is a process carried out before actual operation begins. FIG. 8 is an explanatory diagram regarding the generation process of a regression model. Five learning models, a first regression model 1341 to a fifth regression model 1345, are generated. FIG. 8 shows the process of generating the first regression model 1341 to the fifth regression model 1345 by performing machine learning. The basic process is similar for all learning models. The basic process will be described using the first regression model 1341 as a representative example.

[0032] In the flow cytometer 10 of this embodiment, the processing unit 1 performs deep learning to learn the feature amount of an appropriate gate for the scatter plot image created based on the measurement result obtained by the measurement unit 2, thereby generating a first regression model 1341 that inputs multiple scatter plot images (scatter plot group) and outputs gate information. The multiple scatter plot images are multiple scatter plot images with at least one axis item different. For example, two scatter plot images are a scatter plot image with a horizontal axis of SSC and a vertical axis of FL3, and a scatter plot image with a horizontal axis of SSC and a vertical axis of FSC. Three or more scatter plot images may be input. The neural network is, for example, a CNN (Convolution Neural Network). The first regression model 1341 has multiple feature extractors that respectively learn the feature amount of each scatter plot image, a combiner that combines the feature amounts output by each feature extractor, and multiple estimators that estimate and output each item of the gate information (center X coordinate, center Y coordinate, major axis, minor axis, and inclination angle) based on the combined feature amount. It should be noted that instead of the scatter plot image, a set of measurement values ​​on which the scatter plot is based may be input to the first regression model 1341.

[0033] Each feature extractor includes an input layer and an intermediate layer. The input layer has a plurality of neurons that accept input of pixel values ​​of each pixel included in the scatter plot image, and passes the input pixel values ​​to the intermediate layer. The intermediate layer has a plurality of neurons, extracts features from the scatter plot image, and passes them to the output layer. For example, when the feature extractor is a CNN, the intermediate layer has a configuration in which a convolution layer that convolves the pixel values ​​of each pixel input from the input layer and a pooling layer that maps the pixel values ​​convolved in the convolution layer are alternately connected, and finally extracts image features while compressing pixel information. Instead of providing a feature extractor that inputs a scatter plot image for each image, a configuration in which multiple scatter plot images are input to one feature extractor may be used.

[0034] In this embodiment, the first regression model 1341 is described as being a CNN, but the first regression model 1341 is not limited to a CNN and may be a trained model constructed with other learning algorithms, such as a neural network other than a CNN, a Bayesian network, or a decision tree.

[0035] The processing unit 1 performs learning using training data in which a plurality of scatter plot images are associated with correct values ​​of gate information corresponding to the scatter plots. For example, as shown in FIG. 8, the training data is data in which gate information is labeled with a plurality of scatter plot images. For simplicity, two types of scatter plots are considered as one set of scatter plots. Also, although the description will be given assuming that one gate is provided for one set of scatter plots, multiple gates may be provided. In this case, the gate information includes a value indicating the usefulness.

[0036] The processing unit 1 inputs two scatter plot images, which are training data, into different feature extractors. The features output by each feature extractor are combined by a combiner. The combination by the combiner can be performed in a number of ways, including simply combining the features (Concatenate), adding values ​​indicating the features (Add), and selecting the feature with the maximum value (Maxpool).

[0037] Based on the combined feature quantities, each estimator outputs gate information as an estimation result. A combination of values ​​output by each estimator forms one set of gate information. The gate information to be output may be multiple sets. In this case, a number of estimators corresponding to the multiple sets are provided. For example, when gate information with the first priority and gate information with the second priority are output, the number of estimators in FIG. 8 will be 5 to 10.

[0038] The processing unit 1 compares the gate information obtained from the estimator with information labeled for the scatter plot image in the training data, i.e., the correct answer value, and optimizes parameters used in the calculation process of the feature extractor and the estimator so that the output value from the estimator approaches the correct answer value. The parameters are, for example, weights (coupling coefficients) between neurons and coefficients of activation functions used in each neuron. There are no particular limitations on the method of optimizing the parameters, but for example, the processing unit 1 optimizes various parameters using the backpropagation method. The processing unit 1 performs the above process on the data for each test included in the training data, and generates a first regression model 1341.

[0039] Next, the process performed by the control unit 11 of the processing unit 1 will be described. FIG. 9 is a flow chart showing an example of the procedure of the regression model generation process. The control unit 11 acquires an inspection history (step S1). The inspection history is an accumulation of past inspection results, and is past measurement values ​​stored in the measurement value DB 131. The control unit 11 selects one history to be processed (step S2). The control unit 11 acquires feature information corresponding to the selected history (step S3). The feature information is, for example, a scatter plot. The feature information is acquired from the feature information DB 132. If the feature information is not stored, it may be generated from the measurement value. The control unit 11 acquires gate information corresponding to the selected history (step S4). The gate information is acquired from the gate DB 133. The control unit 11 learns the first regression model 1341 using the acquired feature information and gate information as training data (step S5). The control unit 11 determines whether there is an unprocessed inspection history (step S6). When the control unit 11 determines that there is an unprocessed inspection history (YES in step S6), the process returns to step S2 and performs a process on the unprocessed inspection history. When the control unit 11 determines that there is no unprocessed inspection history (NO in step S6), the control unit 11 stores the first regression model 1341 (step S7) and ends the process.

[0040] A second regression model 1342, a third regression model 1343, a fourth regression model 1344, and a fifth regression model 1345 are generated by a process similar to that described with reference to FIG. 8 and FIG. 9. However, the first regression model 1341 to the fifth regression model 1345 are regression models with different generation conditions, for example, by changing the training data, the network structure, and the hyperparameters. Regarding the training data, the training data of the five learning models is made different by increasing the number of data by a sampling with replacement method used in data augmentation and the bootstrap method. Regarding the network structure, the number of input layers and output layers is changed. In addition, a different learning model is generated from a certain learning model by fine-tuning. Regarding the hyperparameters, the settings of the number of layers of the intermediate layer, the number of nodes in each layer, weights, loss function, optimization function, learning rate, batch size, etc. are made different.

[0041] After generating the first regression model 1341 to the fifth regression model 1345, a threshold for judging the confidence level is determined. FIG. 10 is a flowchart showing an example of a procedure of the threshold determination process. The control unit 11 acquires test data (step S11). The control unit 11 inputs the acquired test data to each regression model (step S12). The control unit 11 acquires an estimated output from each regression model (step S13). The estimated output is a parameter value indicating a gate region estimated by each regression model. If the gate region is an ellipse, the parameters are the center coordinates (Cx, Cy), the length between the major axis and the minor axis (Dx, Dy), and the angle (θ) between the major axis and the x-axis. If the gate region is a polygon, the parameters are the coordinate values ​​of each vertex. The control unit 11 calculates the degree of dispersion for each parameter from the values ​​output from each regression model (step S14). An example of the degree of dispersion is the standard deviation. The control unit 11 judges whether there is unprocessed test data (step S15). If the control unit 11 determines that there is unprocessed test data (YES in step S15), it returns the process to step S11 and processes the unprocessed test data. If the control unit 11 determines that there is no unprocessed test data (NO in step S15), it determines a threshold value for each parameter (step S16). The threshold value means the limit of the allowable variation in the output value. The threshold value is determined by a statistical method. Alternatively, the threshold value is determined, for example, by a veteran tester based on the dispersion value for each test data. The control unit 11 stores the determined threshold value (step S17) and ends the threshold value determination process. The threshold value may be adjusted for each environment in which the flow cytometer 10 is operated, for example, for each testing institution. The dispersion may be variance, unbiased variance, or average deviation other than the standard deviation.

[0042] A specific example of the threshold determination process will be described. FIG. 11A and FIG. 11B are explanatory diagrams showing an example of an estimated output of a gate area. FIG. 11 is an example of a scatter diagram in CD45 gating. FIG. 11A shows an example of an input scatter diagram. In FIG. 11A, the horizontal axis is SSC (Side Scattered Light) and the vertical axis is FL3 (FL=Fluorescence: fluorescence detector, 3 means third). FIG. 11B shows the results of five regression models estimating the gate area in the input scatter diagram. The vertical and horizontal axes in FIG. 11B are the same as in FIG. 11A. Here, an example is shown in which one elliptical gate area is estimated. In FIG. 11B, the gate area is overwritten on the input scatter diagram. AI-1 shows the estimated result of the first regression model 1341, AI-2 shows the estimated result of the second regression model 1342, and so on, and AI-5 shows the estimated result of the fifth regression model 1345. Below the scatter plot are the parameters of the ellipse that is the gate region. From top to bottom, they are the center X coordinate (Cx), center Y coordinate (Cy), major axis length (Dx), minor axis length (Dy), and inclination angle (θ).

[0043] FIG. 12 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the degree of dispersion. The degree of dispersion is the standard deviation (SD). The table on the left of FIG. 12 reproduces the values ​​shown in FIG. 11B. Note that the inclination angle is excluded from the calculation items of the SD, even if the SD becomes large, for example, when the shape of the gate region is a perfect circle, since it does not affect the confidence of the estimation result. The SD threshold is calculated for the results of multiple test data, and is determined based on the calculation results.

[0044] 13A and 13B are explanatory diagrams showing examples of the degree of scatter. FIG. 13A and FIG. 13B show the estimation results when different test data are input. In both FIG. 13A and FIG. 13B, the horizontal axis is SSC and the vertical axis is FL3. In FIG. 13A and FIG. 13B, the gate regions output by the five regression models are superimposed on the input scatter plot. The numbers on the right side of the scatter plot indicate the center coordinates that specify the ellipse and the SD of the major and minor axes. FIG. 13A shows an example in which the estimation results have a small variation, and FIG. 13B shows an example in which the estimation results have a large variation. From FIG. 13A and FIG. 13B, it is considered that the thresholds should be determined as follows: Cx: 5.6 or more, Cy: between 10.9 and 36.8, Dx: 12.3 or more, and Dy: 6.4 or more. It is desirable to determine the final thresholds for each parameter, taking into consideration the SD for not only the two test data but also other data. Once the thresholds for each parameter are determined, the preparation process is completed. In the above-mentioned threshold determination process, each regression model is assumed to output one gate as an estimation result of the gate region, but multiple gates may be output. In the case of multiple gates, a threshold is determined for each gate. In the case where a first gate, a second gate, and a third gate are output as the gate region, the degree of dispersion is calculated for the first gate of each regression model, and a threshold is determined.

[0045] Next, the operation process will be explained. In the following explanation, the dispersion is the standard deviation (SD). If the SD is equal to or less than the threshold, the confidence level is high. If the SD exceeds the threshold, the confidence level is low. Each regression model outputs the estimation results of multiple gate regions.

[0046] FIG. 14 is a flow chart showing an example of the procedure of the gate region estimation process. The control unit 11 acquires a scatter diagram (step S31). The scatter diagram here is a coordinate sequence of points showing the measurement results, the measurement items on the horizontal axis, and the measurement items on the vertical axis. The control unit 11 inputs the acquired scatter diagram to each regression model (step S32). The control unit 11 acquires the estimated output of the gate region from each regression model (step S33). The control unit 11 calculates the degree of dispersion, here the standard deviation, for each regression model, each gate, and each parameter (step S34). The control unit 11 judges the confidence level (step S35). The control unit 11 stores the result (step S36). The control unit 11 stores the estimation result of the gate region in the gate DB 133, and stores the confidence level in the confidence level DB 136. The control unit 11 ends the gate region judgment process.

[0047] FIG. 15 is a flowchart showing an example of the procedure of the confidence level determination process. The confidence level determination process corresponds to step S35 in FIG. 14. The control unit 11 selects a gate region to be processed (step S51). The control unit 11 selects parameters (variables such as Cx, Cy, Dx, and Dy) to be processed (step S52). The control unit 11 judges whether the standard deviation of the parameters is equal to or less than a threshold value (step S53). When the control unit 11 judges that the standard deviation of the parameters is equal to or less than a threshold value (YES in step S53), it judges whether all parameters have been processed (step S54). When the control unit 11 judges that all parameters have not been processed (NO in step S54), it returns the process to step S52 and performs processing on unprocessed parameters. When the control unit 11 judges that all parameters have been processed (YES in step S54), it stores in a temporary storage area that the confidence level of the gate to be processed is high (step S55). The temporary storage area is provided in the main storage unit 12 or the auxiliary storage unit 13. When the control unit 11 determines that the standard deviation of the parameters exceeds the threshold (NO in step S53), it stores in the temporary storage area that the confidence level of the gate being processed is low (step S56). The control unit 11 determines whether or not all gates have been processed (step S57). When the control unit 11 determines that all gates have not been processed (NO in step S57), it returns the process to step S51 and processes the unprocessed gates. When the control unit 11 determines that all gates have been processed (YES in step S57), it refers to the temporary storage area and determines whether or not the confidence levels of all gates are high (step S58). When the control unit 11 determines that the confidence levels of all gates are high (YES in step S58), it stores in the temporary storage area that the confidence level (overall confidence level) for the estimation result of the gate area in the scatter diagram being processed is high (step S59). When the control unit 11 determines that the confidence level of some gates is low, not high, rather than that of all gates (NO in step S58), it stores in a temporary storage area that the confidence level of the entire estimation result for the scatter diagram being processed is low (step S60).The control unit 11 returns the process to the caller.

[0048] A specific example of the gate region estimation process will be described. FIG. 16A and FIG. 16B are explanatory diagrams showing an example of the estimation result of the gate region. FIG. 16 is an example of a scatter diagram in CD45 gating, similar to FIG. 11. FIG. 16A is an example of an input scatter diagram, and FIG. 16B shows the results of the gate region in the input scatter diagram estimated by five regression models. In FIG. 16A and FIG. 16B, the horizontal axis is SSC and the vertical axis is FL3. Here, one of the gate regions obtained as an estimation result is displayed. In FIG. 16B, the gate region is overwritten on the input scatter diagram. AI-1 shows the estimation result of the first regression model 1341, AI-2 shows the estimation result of the second regression model 1342, and so on, and AI-5 shows the estimation result of the fifth regression model 1345. The parameters of the ellipse that is the gate region are written below the scatter diagram. From top to bottom, these are the center X coordinate (Cx), center Y coordinate (Cy), major axis length (Dx), minor axis length (Dy), and inclination angle (θ).

[0049] 17A and 17B are explanatory diagrams showing examples of the degree of scatter. The estimation results are obtained when different scatter plots are inputted from FIG. 17A and FIG. 17B. In both FIG. 17A and FIG. 17B, the horizontal axis is SSC and the vertical axis is FL3. FIG. 17A shows the five plots shown in FIG. 16B as one plot. That is, FIG. 17A shows the gate regions outputted by the five regression models superimposed on the input scatter plot. FIG. 17B is the same as FIG. 17A. The numbers on the right side of the scatter plot indicate the center coordinates and the SD of the major and minor axes that specify the ellipse. FIG. 17A shows an example in which the estimation results have a small variation, and FIG. 17B shows an example in which the estimation results have a large variation. Here, if the SD of each of Cx, Cy, Dx, and Dy is 20 or less, the confidence level is high, and if there is even one item that exceeds 20, the confidence level is low. In the case where the results shown in FIG. 17A have all SDs of 20 or less, the confidence level is determined to be high. On the other hand, in the result shown in FIG. 17B, since the SD of Cx and Dx exceeds 20, the confidence level is determined to be low.

[0050] Next, an example of the confidence level determination when multiple gate regions are estimated is shown. FIG. 18 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of the gate region estimation result. FIG. 18 shows the estimation results of three gate regions, G1 to G3. Each gate region is drawn on a scatter plot with the gate regions output by five regression models overlapping. The table below the scatter plot shows the SD of each parameter. Since all SDs of gates G1 and G2 are 20 or less, the confidence level is determined to be high. Since the SD of Cx of gate G3 exceeds 20, the confidence level is determined to be low. When multiple gate regions are estimated, if the confidence levels of the estimation results of all gate regions are high, the overall confidence level is high, and if there is even one low confidence level in the estimation results of the gate regions, the overall confidence level is low. If the determination is made by this definition, the estimation results shown in FIG. 18 are determined to have a low confidence level overall.

[0051] Next, the screen display of the estimation result of the gate area will be described. FIG. 19A and FIG. 19B are explanatory diagrams showing an example of the estimation result display screen. FIG. 19A is an example of the screen when the confidence level is high. FIG. 19B is an example of the screen when the confidence level is low. The estimation result display screen includes a scatter diagram 191, a confidence level 192, and a confidence level icon 193. The scatter diagram 191 displays the estimation result of the gate area in a scatter diagram. Here, the gate area to be displayed is one area selected by a predetermined algorithm from the five estimated areas output by the five regression models. The confidence level 192 displays the confidence level for the entire judgment result. In FIG. 19, the confidence level: high is displayed as High, and the confidence level: low is displayed as Low. The confidence level icon 193 expresses the confidence level with a face icon. If the confidence level is high, a smiley icon is displayed, and if the confidence level is low, a troubled face icon is displayed. In addition, in the scatter diagram 191, the gate regions to be displayed may be all five estimated regions output by the five regression models, similar to FIG.

[0052] Fig. 20 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of an ID list screen. The ID list screen displays a list of IDs assigned to each examination in association with the confidence level of the estimation result of the gate region. The ID list screen includes an ID display 201 and a confidence level display 202. The ID display 201 displays, for example, a reception number. The confidence level display 202 displays, for example, A when the confidence level is high and a when the confidence level is low. When one ID is selected from the ID display 201, the estimation result display screen shown in Fig. 19 is displayed.

[0053] In this embodiment, the estimation result of the gate region is output with a confidence level attached. This has the effect of enabling operation suited to the operational environment at the site, such as by referring to the confidence level display 202 and having a more skilled inspector give priority to carefully checking "A" and taking time to analyze "a" which is likely to be incorrect.

[0054] In this embodiment, the number of scatter diagrams input to each regression model is one, but it is not limited to this and may be two or more. Also, the scatter diagram is not limited to two dimensions and may be three or more dimensions.

[0055] The degree of dispersion is the standard deviation of the parameters of the figure representing the gate region, and in the case of an ellipse, the standard deviation of the central coordinates and the length of the semi-major axis, but is not limited to this. The area of ​​the gate region estimated by five regression models may also be the degree of dispersion. For example, when five estimated gate regions are superimposed on a scatter plot, the area of ​​the region containing the five regions and the area of ​​the region where the five overlap are calculated, and the ratio of the latter area to the former area is taken as the degree of dispersion. In this case, the smaller the value, the greater the variation. 1 is the maximum value, when all five regions match.

[0056] (Embodiment 2) This embodiment relates to a method for selecting one gate region to be presented to a user from five gate regions estimated by five regression models. In ensemble learning, the output results of multiple learning models are combined to obtain a final result. Since multiple learning models are used in ensemble learning, it has the effect of reducing output fluctuations. It is known to be particularly effective in neural networks, where accuracy fluctuations are likely to occur with each learning.

[0057] Ensemble learning is particularly effective in neural networks where accuracy is prone to fluctuate with each learning, and is a technique used in various competitions. However, the output of the regression model that estimates the gate area is multi-output and needs to be evaluated in a composite manner. Simply combining the outputs of multiple models by averaging them together is not likely to improve accuracy. When the gate area is estimated by multiple regression models that have been trained under different conditions, the estimation results differ due to differences in training. Therefore, when the average value of each parameter is calculated from the estimation results output by each regression model and the final gate area to be displayed is determined, it is highly likely that it will be unclear to the inspector which part of the scatter diagram is the gate to be surrounded. Therefore, in this embodiment, one optimal gate area to be presented to the user is selected from the five gate areas estimated by the five regression models. In this embodiment, the hardware configuration and the generation process of the first regression model 1341 to the fifth regression model 1345 are the same as those in the first embodiment. In the following description, differences from the first embodiment will be mainly described.

[0058] The preparation process is the same as in the first embodiment, so the description will be omitted. The operation process will be described below. FIG. 21 is a flowchart showing another example of the procedure of the gate region estimation process. A process for selecting a gate region is added to the process shown in FIG. 14. The control unit 11 acquires a scatter diagram (step S71). The control unit 11 inputs the acquired scatter diagram to each regression model (step S72). The control unit 11 acquires the estimated output of the gate region from each regression model (step S73). The control unit 11 removes the gate region including an outlier from the selection target (step S74). The median is calculated for each parameter of the gate region output by the five regression models. The gate region that deviates from the median in even one item is removed from the selection target. Note that step S74 is not an essential process and may be omitted. The control unit 11 calculates a feature amount for each gate region (step S75). The feature amount is the number of cells in the gate, the area of ​​the gate region, the cell density in the gate, the cell purity in the gate, etc. The feature amount will be supplemented later. The control unit 11 selects an optimal gate based on the feature amount (step S76). The control unit 11 calculates the degree of dispersion (step S77). The control unit 11 determines the confidence level (step S78). The contents of steps S77 and S78 are the same as those in the first embodiment, so the explanation is omitted. The control unit 11 stores the selected gate region and the confidence level (step S79), and ends the gate region estimation process.

[0059] Next, an example of excluding gate regions containing outliers from selection targets will be shown. Fig. 22A and Fig. 22B are explanatory diagrams showing an example of excluding outlier gate regions. Fig. 22A shows gate regions output by five regression models superimposed on a scatter plot. Among the gate regions, gate region Gj is different in size from the other gate regions, and is therefore excluded from selection as a gate region containing an outlier. Fig. 22B is a scatter plot showing only gate region Gj excluded from selection targets.

[0060] Next, we will explain cell purity, which is one of the features. In testing, it is desirable that each gate contains only one type of cell. The cell type can be roughly estimated from the information of FSC, SSC, and CD45. Therefore, the cell population is roughly classified into classes based on the information of FSC, SSC, and FL3, and the cell purity is defined as which class is most abundant in the target gate and what percentage of cells of that class are contained in the gate. As a specific example, in the distribution of FSC, SSC, and FL3, a three-dimensional automatic clustering method, k-means, is applied to create n small groups. n is a natural number. Here, n=10. Figure 23 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of 10 small groups. The pentagonal marks indicate the centers of each small group used in k-means. In Figure 23, the horizontal axis is a two-dimensional display with SSC and the vertical axis is FL3, but in reality it is a three-dimensional clustering with FSC as the axis normal to the paper. In Figure 23, there are many cells of class Cb in the gate area G. Therefore, the cell purity of the gate region G is the proportion of class Cb contained in the gate region G. In other words, the cell purity is calculated by finding the class of cells contained most frequently in the target gate region, and dividing the number of cells of that class contained in the target gate region by the total number of cells of that class.

[0061] FIG. 24 is a flow chart showing an example of the procedure of the gate selection process. The gate selection process corresponds to step S76 in FIG. 21. The control unit 11 performs cell clustering (step S91). For example, as described above, in the distribution of FSC, SSC, and FL3, three-dimensional automatic clustering is performed by k-means to classify the cells into 10 classes. The control unit 11 selects a gate region to be processed from five gate regions output by each of the five regression models (step S92). The control unit 11 obtains the number of cells for each class contained in the selected gate region, and identifies the class with the largest number of cells (step S93). The control unit 11 calculates the cell purity (step S94). The control unit 11 determines whether or not there is an unprocessed gate region (step S95). When the control unit 11 determines that there is an unprocessed gate region (YES in step S95), the process returns to step S92 and performs processing on the unprocessed gate region. When the control unit 11 determines that there is no unprocessed gate region (NO in step S95), it selects a gate region to be output (step S96). The control unit 11 selects the gate region with the highest cell purity from among the five gate regions. The control unit 11 ends the gate selection process.

[0062] 25A and 25B are explanatory diagrams showing an example of gate region selection. FIG. 25A shows gate regions output by five regression models superimposed on a scatter plot. The numerical values ​​on the right side of FIG. 25A indicate the cell purity of each gate region. In this case, the cell purity of the gate region output by AI-3, i.e., the third regression model 1343, is the largest value at 0.66, so this gate region is selected. FIG. 25B is an example of a scatter plot in which only the selected gate region is superimposed. A similar process is also possible when outputting multiple gate regions. Details will be described later.

[0063] Next, we will discuss features other than cell purity. The cell count is the number of cells contained in the gate region. The area is the area of ​​the shape that shows the gate region in the two-dimensional scatter plot. The cell density is the value obtained by dividing the cell count by the area.

[0064] Measurement values ​​other than the analysis axis may be used as feature quantities. The analysis axis is the horizontal and vertical axes of a two-dimensional scatter plot. In flow cytometry testing, cell types are identified from measurement values ​​in all dimensions. Therefore, even within a gate, measurement values ​​in other dimensions (other than the analysis axis) can be used as indicators for determining the optimal gate to narrow down cell types.

[0065] In the above example, the analysis axes are SSC and FL3 (CD45). In this case, examples of measurements other than the analysis axes are FSC and FL1 (CD34). At this time, CD34 is measured at FL1, and the optimal gate is selected based on the average value. For example, the average value of AI-1 is 0.21, the average value of AI-2 is 0.16, the average value of AI-3 is 0.18, and the average value of AI-4 is 0.20. The gate area output by AI-5 is excluded as an outlier gate area. At this time, the gate area output by AI-1 is selected.

[0066] Image information may be used as the feature quantity. When selecting the optimal gate based on the cell density within the gate, bias in cell distribution may affect the selection of an appropriate gate. To avoid this, the distribution situation is converted into an image to obtain the feature quantity. An example of processing is explained below. To treat the contents of the scatter plot as image information, here the brightness L, the areas where cells exist are expressed as black pixels (L<255) and the rest as white pixels (L=255).

[0067] FIG. 26 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of gate region selection based on luminance information. The top left of FIG. 26 is a scatter plot in which the gate region output by AI-1 is superimposed. The bottom left of FIG. 26 shows the feature amount of the gate region output by AI-1. The top right of FIG. 26 is a scatter plot in which the gate region output by AI-2 is superimposed. The bottom right of FIG. 26 shows the feature amount of the gate region output by AI-2. Note that the feature amounts of the gate regions output by AI-3 to AI-5 are smaller than those of the gate regions output by AI-1 and AI-2, and there is no possibility of selecting any of them. In the example of FIG. 26, the gate region to be selected is the region output by AI-1.

[0068] In the example of FIG. 26, if cell density is used as the feature for selecting the gate region, AI-1 is 1.0 and AI-2 is 1.1, so the gate region output by AI-2 will be selected. However, if black-white ratio (= number of white pixels / number of black pixels) is used as the feature for selecting the gate region, AI-1 is 0.7 and AI-2 is 0.5, so the gate region output by AI-1 will be selected. In the example of FIG. 26, there is a bias in the cell distribution, so if cell density is used as the feature, an inappropriate selection will be made. The black-white ratio can reflect the cell density to some extent while reducing the influence of the cell number, resulting in an appropriate selection result.

[0069] In the above description of this embodiment, the case where one gate region is obtained has been described. To obtain multiple gate regions, the process needs to be expanded, and there are two possible methods for this expansion. Method 1 is a method of selecting one optimal output from multiple AIs that output all gates. For example, this method is a method of selecting the estimation result output by AI-1 for all gate regions.

[0070] FIG. 27 is a flow chart showing another example of the procedure of the gate region selection process. FIG. 27 shows the selection process in the case where a plurality of gate regions are set in one scatter plot, and is the process according to the above-mentioned method 1. The control unit 11 selects a regression model to be processed (step S111). The control unit 11 selects a gate region to be processed from among the plurality of gate regions output by the selected regression model (step S112). The control unit 11 judges the confidence level of the selected gate region (step S113). The confidence level is judged as described above. The control unit 11 stores the confidence level in a temporary storage area (step S114). The control unit 11 judges whether or not there is an unprocessed gate region (step S115). If the control unit 11 judges that there is an unprocessed gate region (YES in step S115), the process returns to step S112 and processes the unprocessed gate region. If the control unit 11 judges that there is no unprocessed gate region (NO in step S115), the control unit 11 judges the confidence level of the entire gate region output by the selected regression model (step S116). For example, when there are three gate regions to be set and the confidence levels of each gate region are high, high, and low, the number of highs, 2, is set as the overall confidence level. The control unit 11 stores the confidence levels in a temporary storage area (step S117). The control unit 11 judges whether there is an unprocessed regression model (step S118). When the control unit 11 judges that there is an unprocessed regression model (YES in step S118), the process returns to step S111 and processes the unprocessed regression model. When the control unit 11 judges that there is no unprocessed regression model (NO in step S118), the control unit 11 selects a regression model based on the confidence level for each regression model (step S119). The control unit 11 outputs the gate region output by the selected regression model (step S120) and ends the process.

[0071] Method 2 is a method of selecting one optimal output for each gate from multiple AIs that output all gates. For example, the first gate selects the estimated result output by AI-1, the second gate selects the estimated result output by AI-4, and the third gate selects the estimated result output by AI-5. Method 1 has the advantage that there is little overlap between gates because one AI outputs each gate, but it has the disadvantage that if one gate is misaligned, the other gates are likely to be misaligned as well. Method 2 has the advantage that the influence of misalignment of other gates is small because selection is made for each gate, but it has the disadvantage that gates are likely to overlap if selection is made under conditions where there is no information on other gates. However, the impact of this disadvantage can be mitigated by ingeniously adding information on other gates.

[0072] A process for reducing the impact of the shortcomings of method 2 is explained below. The following conditions are used in gate selection to compare selected gates with and without adding other gate information. Condition 1: The feature "cell purity" is used as the criterion for determining the optimal gate. Condition 2: A gate is selected according to its usefulness (as analysis gates generally have a usefulness). At that time, cells contained in other gates are excluded from the feature calculation. Gate selection is performed when only condition 1 is applied, and when conditions 1 and 2 are applied. If there is no gate overlap in either case, that selection result is adopted. Note that the feature in condition 1 can be a feature other than cell purity as long as it is related to the gate area.

[0073] FIG. 28 is a flow chart showing another example of the procedure of the gate region selection process. FIG. 28 shows the selection process in the case where a plurality of gate regions are set in one scatter plot, and is the process according to the above-mentioned method 2. The control unit 11 selects a gate region to be processed from among a plurality of gate regions (step S131). For example, when three gate regions are set, they are designated as the first gate, the second gate, and the third gate, respectively. The order numbers are determined according to the usefulness, such as the order of importance in the report of the test results. At this time, the control unit 11 processes the first gate, the second gate, and the third gate in this order. The control unit 11 selects a regression model to be processed (step S132). The control unit 11 calculates the feature amount, for example, the cell purity, for the gate region output by the selected regression model (step S133). The control unit 11 judges whether or not there is an unprocessed regression model (step S134). When the control unit 11 judges that there is an unprocessed regression model (YES in step S134), the process returns to step S132, and the unprocessed regression model is processed. When the control unit 11 determines that there is no unprocessed regression model (NO in step S134), it selects a gate region to be finally output from among the gate regions output by any of the regression models based on the feature amount (step S135). The control unit 11 stores information on the selected gate region in a temporary storage area (step S136). The control unit 11 determines whether or not there is an unprocessed gate region (step S137). When the control unit 11 determines that there is an unprocessed gate region (YES in step S137), it returns the process to step S131 and performs processing on the unprocessed gate region. When the control unit 11 determines that there is no unprocessed gate region (NO in step S137), it outputs all gate regions based on the selection information stored in the temporary storage area (step S138) and ends the process.

[0074] In this embodiment, it is possible to select an optimal gate region from the estimation results of the gate region output by multiple regression models. In the above embodiment, CD45 gating in LLA is taken as an example, but CD45 gating in malignant lymphoma analysis (MLA) can also be performed in a similar procedure.

[0075] The technical features (constituent elements) described in each embodiment can be combined with each other, and by combining them, new technical features can be formed. The embodiments disclosed herein are illustrative in all respects and should not be considered as limiting. The scope of the present invention is defined by the claims, not by the above meaning, and is intended to include all modifications within the scope and meaning equivalent to the claims. [Explanation of symbols]

[0076] 10 Flow cytometer 1 Processing section 11 Control section 12 Main memory 13 Auxiliary storage 131 Measurement Data 132 Feature Information DB 133 Gate DB 1341 First Regression Model 1342 Second Regression Model 1343 Third Regression Model 1344 Fourth Regression Model 1345 Fifth Regression Model 135 Threshold DB 136 Confidence DB 14 Input section 15 Display 16 Communications Department 17 Reading section 1P control program 1a Removable storage media 1b Semiconductor memory 2 Measuring part 3 Learning Server

Claims

1. A group of scatter plots including multiple scatter plots obtained by flow cytometry measurements with different measurement items is obtained, The obtained scatter plot group is input to each of a plurality of learning models that have been trained based on training data including the scatter plot group and the gate region; Outputting the estimated gate regions obtained from each of the plurality of learning models A gate region estimation program for causing a computer to carry out processing.

2. A confidence level is determined based on the plurality of estimated gate regions.

2. The gate region estimation program according to claim 1, wherein the gate region estimation program is a program for estimating a gate region.

3. A confidence level is determined based on the distribution of each of the plurality of variables representing each of the plurality of estimated gate regions.

3. The gate region estimation program according to claim 2.

4. The degree of dispersion of each variable is compared with a plurality of predetermined thresholds, and the degree of confidence of each variable is determined in a plurality of stages, and the degree of confidence of the estimated gate region is determined based on the degree of confidence of each variable.

4. The gate region estimation program according to claim 3.

5. A degree of confidence of the estimated gate region for each measurement of a plurality of samples is determined, and the determined degree of confidence is output in association with identification information for identifying the sample.

5. The gate region estimation program according to claim 2, wherein the gate region estimation program is a program for estimating a gate region based on the gate region.

6. selecting one learning model based on the estimated gate regions obtained from each of the plurality of learning models; Output the estimated gate region output by the selected learning model.

2. The gate region estimation program according to claim 1, wherein the gate region estimation program is a program for estimating a gate region.

7. A learning model is selected based on the number of cells included in each of the estimated gate regions output by the plurality of learning models.

7. The gate region estimation program according to claim 6.

8. A learning model is selected based on the areas of the estimated gate regions output by the plurality of learning models.

7. The gate region estimation program according to claim 6.

9. Clustering the measured cells based on a scatter diagram obtained from the plurality of measurement items; A learning model is selected based on the cell purity obtained using the clustering result for each of the estimated gate regions output by the plurality of learning models.

7. The gate region estimation program according to claim 6.

10. obtaining a plurality of estimated gate regions from each of the plurality of learning models; Selecting one learning model for each group including a plurality of the estimated gate regions related to each other; Output the estimated gate region for each selected learning model 10. The gate region estimation program according to claim 1, wherein the gate region estimation program is a program for estimating a gate region based on the gate region.

11. determining a confidence level based on the plurality of estimated gate regions; selecting one learning model based on the estimated gate regions obtained from each of the plurality of learning models; Output the estimated gate region output by the selected learning model and the confidence level.

2. The gate region estimation program according to claim 1, wherein the gate region estimation program is a program for estimating a gate region.

12. The computer A group of scatter plots including multiple scatter plots obtained by flow cytometry measurements with different measurement items is obtained, The obtained scatter plot group is input to each of a plurality of learning models that have been trained based on training data including the scatter plot group and the gate region; Outputting the estimated gate regions obtained from each of the plurality of learning models A gate region estimation method comprising:

13. An acquisition unit that acquires a scatter plot group including a plurality of scatter plots obtained by flow cytometry measurements having different measurement items; an output unit that inputs the acquired scatter plot group to each of a plurality of learning models that have been trained based on training data including the scatter plot group and the gate region, and outputs the estimated gate region obtained from each of the plurality of learning models; A gate region estimation device comprising:

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Methods for classification and visualization of cellular populations on a single cell level based on microscopy images

    EP3054279A1

  • JP1975047803A

  • Optical fiber cable with memory and method for constructing optical fiber cable

    JP1989080918A

  • Blood cell analysis device, blood cell analysis method, and computer program

    JP2010122137A

  • Method and system for analyzing flow cytometry data using support vector machines

    JP2011515655A