How to prevent vibrations inside a pump

The method adjusts pump rotational speed using frequency converters to mitigate resonant vibrations in centrifugal pumps, reducing wear and noise, and provides early damage detection through frequency monitoring.

JP7583742B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-14KSB SE & CO KGAA
View PDF 6 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2021562026
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2019-04-18
Filing Date
2020-04-14
Publication Date
2024-11-14
Estimated Expiration
2040-04-14

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Mechanical vibrations in centrifugal pumps, particularly those handling abrasive materials, cause increased wear and noise due to resonant vibrations when the impeller rotational frequency matches the pump's natural frequency or pipeline resonance.

Method used

A method using a frequency converter to dynamically adjust the pump's rotational speed based on real-time signal analysis, such as motor current or discharge pressure, to avoid resonant vibrations by identifying and minimizing amplitude through iterative or optimized speed adjustments.

Benefits of technology

Effectively reduces mechanical vibrations, minimizes wear, and detects potential damage by monitoring frequency shifts, thereby enhancing pump operation efficiency and reliability.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007583742000001
    Figure 0007583742000001
  • Figure 0007583742000002
    Figure 0007583742000002
  • Figure 0007583742000003
    Figure 0007583742000003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention relates to a method for preventing or reducing mechanical vibrations during pump operation of a pump, in particular a centrifugal pump, in which a frequency converter and a pump control device are provided, the pump control device detecting at least one signal of a pump operating parameter and examining the signal fluctuations to detect mechanical vibrations occurring in the pump, and varying the speed of the pump by the frequency converter to reduce the detected vibrations.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a method for preventing or reducing mechanical vibrations during operation of a pump, in particular a centrifugal pump. [Background technology]

[0002] Mechanical vibrations in centrifugal pumps are responsible for increased wear and unwanted noise during operation. The causes of vibrations can be manifold. They can be externally excited vibrations, for example due to the rotation of the pump impeller, or free vibrations due to the natural frequencies of the self-contained pump.

[0003] Free vibrations occur in particular in solids pumps, which are centrifugal pumps for transporting pumped media with a highly abrasive solid fraction, such as, for example, slag, coal or ore suspensions in mining. The pumped media may also occasionally contain stones or other rigid elements which, if striking the pump structure during operation, may generate shocks which are responsible for exciting free vibrations of the pump. This phenomenon occurs particularly in pumps for the drainage sector.

[0004] Particularly unfavourable cases arise when the rotational frequency of the impeller, i.e. the set pump rotational speed, is equal to the natural frequency of the integrated pump or corresponds to an integer multiple of the natural frequency. In this case, resonant vibrations arise, i.e. two sources of vibration amplify each other. Problems arise as well if the set rotational frequency of the impeller corresponds to pipeline resonances of the conveying system.

[0005] Such a resonance case is illustrated in Figure 1. The figure shows the frequency response of a ready-to-use self-contained centrifugal pump. The natural frequencies at which the system vibrates freely have vibration values ​​f1, f2, f3. The frequency response, i.e. the location of the natural frequencies f1, f2, f3, depends on the specific pump structure, the selected installation location, the materials used and the mounted bearings. If the rotation frequency of the pump wheel, set with the frequency converter, is equal to one of the shown natural frequencies f1, f2, f3 or is instead an integer multiple of them, the system is excited by the externally excited impeller rotation and an amplified resonant vibration of the pump occurs. If instead the impeller rotation frequency is within the range of one of the here depicted anti-resonances af1, af2, this effect is minimal and there are no vibrations or only very slight vibrations. Summary of the Invention

[0006] The idea of ​​the present application is formed on the basis of the above findings and proposes a method for reducing to a minimum the risk of possible vibrations, in particular the occurrence of resonances, by measures directed during the operation of the pump.

[0007] This object is achieved by a method according to the features of claim 1. Advantageous embodiments are the subject matter of the dependent claims.

[0008] For the embodiment of the method, the key point is the use of a frequency converter to change the rotational speed of the pump. However, it is not important whether such a frequency converter is integrated inside the pump, attached to the pump housing, or installed separately from the pump. The same applies to the pump control device for the embodiment of the method, which may be an integral part of the pump, but may also be attached to the pump as a separate unit, optionally together with a separate frequency converter.

[0009] The solution according to the invention consists in varying the rotational speed by a pump control device for a pump with a frequency converter during operation of the pump, so that the mechanical vibrations of the pump are reduced as optimally as possible. Based on this finding, another core aspect of the invention further consists in the pump independently identifying (determining) its natural vibration frequencies present during operation by means of suitable signal evaluation, in order to make it possible to optimally adapt the set pump rotational speed.

[0010] The pump therefore does not require information about the frequency response generated in advance and stored in the pump, but instead can determine it independently during operation. For this purpose, the pump records a signal during pump operation. This signal characterizes the pump operating parameters that are affected by the mechanical vibrations that occur. The recorded signal is then investigated by the pump for the presence of vibrations, in particular resonant vibrations. Such vibrations are then reduced by appropriate rotational speed modifications.

[0011] In the recorded signal, in particular signal fluctuations caused by mechanical vibrations of the pump can be identified. The amplitudes of the identified vibration frequencies of the signal are reduced by a suitable change in the rotation speed. Thus, according to an advantageous embodiment of the method, the frequency spectrum of the recorded signal is taken into account. This is advantageous if the signal is first transformed into its frequency spectrum by a transformation, in particular by a Fast Fourier Transform, to identify the corresponding frequency values ​​and the associated amplitudes of the occurring signal vibrations.

[0012] The motor current or the current of the pump drive has proven to be a suitable operating signal for identifying vibrations. The current values ​​can be obtained with the frequency converter used in any way, so that no further sensors are required. Also, since the mechanical vibrations of the pump system are reflected in the magnetic induction in the motor windings of the pump drive and also in the motor current, the motor serves as an effective sensor that is always available. By means of a suitable current analysis, the mechanical vibrations of the pump system can be identified with sufficient accuracy. This possibility exists independently of the type of motor of the electric pump drive used.

[0013] As an alternative or additional operating parameter for determining the frequency response of the pump, the pump pressure, e.g. Discharge Pressure Here, the mechanical vibration is reflected in the signal shape. Discharge Pressure can be determined, for example, by an existing pressure sensor and converted into its frequency spectrum by a signal transformation, in particular a fast Fourier transformation.

[0014] However, it is not necessary to have a suitable sensor always available to acquire the signal. Instead, for example, the current pump pressure can be determined mathematically by operating point estimation. A possible method for this is disclosed in DE102018200651, the content of which is hereby fully incorporated.

[0015] According to a possible embodiment, the method can be carried out iteratively, for example varying the pump rotation speed in order to identify the pump rotation speed at which the amplitude of the identified vibrations is the smallest possible, by reanalysing the frequency spectrum of the signal recorded iteratively after each change in rotation speed to see whether the change in rotation speed has resulted in a corresponding decrease in amplitude.

[0016] The repeated implementation of the steps of the method may involve arbitrary or random or other controlled changes in the rotational speed. For example, if the amplitude increases, the change in rotational speed carried out between two iterations is reversed, otherwise it is maintained. It is also conceivable to continuously drive through a certain range of rotational speeds and then set the rotational speed that results in the minimum amplitude of the pump action.

[0017] An alternative is to use suitable methods and algorithms for identifying local or global amplitude minima at the associated rotation speed. Interval bisection and / or optimization methods, such as active set and / or Newton's methods, are conceivable in order to determine as quickly as possible the appropriate rotation speed that results in the amplitude minimum. Genetic algorithms, which are relatively time consuming but allow for identifying the global minimum frequency response, are also conceivable.

[0018] Furthermore, the setting of the rotational speed or its change during the iterations of the method depends on which operating conditions are predefined, for example by the pump operator. For example, it is conceivable that the pump operator specifies a constant pump rotational speed or specifies only a narrow tolerance range for the change of the rotational speed. During the iterations of the method, the rotational speed is only changed within the predefined tolerance range. In such a case, it is usually sufficient to perform the iterations of the method, during which all or at least part of the permitted rotational speeds are operated and the amplitude minimum corresponding to this range is determined.

[0019] On the other hand, if the operator has not specified the permissible rotational speed range, i.e. it can be the entire technically possible rotational speed range of the pump, then the method expediently uses one of the above-mentioned methods for identifying a suitable rotational speed.

[0020] However, according to a further advantageous embodiment of the invention, not only can the method help to reduce the generation of vibrations, but the determination of the frequency response according to the invention is also suitable for pump monitoring, for example for early detection of wear or damage of the pump mechanism. As has already been explained in detail above, a core aspect of the invention is to determine the frequency response of the pump. This depends essentially on the pump design, its installation position, the materials used and the mounted bearing components. If one of these factors changes, for example due to wear or material damage, the frequency response of the pump changes. The pump therefore preferably stores the determined frequency response and monitors the frequency response by performing repeated measurements on frequency shifts of identified suitable frequencies. If such a frequency deviation is detected, this is an indication of wear or of pump damage. The pump can then generate a corresponding warning message or perform appropriate measurements.

[0021] Further investigation of the frequency change can also distinguish between wear and damage. Wear usually results in a gradual change in the frequency response, whereas pump damage, e.g. bearing damage or impeller breakage, results in an abrupt change in the frequency response. Thus, in its assessment, the pump takes into account a time-related factor of the detected change in order to distinguish between wear and damage. The extent of the change can also be included.

[0022] In addition to the method according to the invention, the invention furthermore relates to a pump, preferably a centrifugal pump, particularly preferably a drainage pump or a solids pump or a feed pump, which is equipped with an internal or external frequency converter and an internal or external pump control device for carrying out the method according to the invention. Such a pump is therefore characterized by the same advantages and properties as have already been described in detail above on the basis of the method according to the invention. A repeated description will be omitted for this reason.

[0023] In addition, the use of a centrifugal pump as a pump, in particular as a drainage pump, solids pump or feed pump, according to the invention is proposed by the present application. The minimization of mechanical vibration generation according to the invention is particularly important for drainage or solids pumps, and in such pump types the application of the method according to the invention brings about far-reaching advantages.

[0024] Further advantages and properties of the invention are explained in more detail below on the basis of the illustrated exemplary embodiments. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0025] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 illustrates the expected frequency response of a stationary centrifugal pump during operation. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a time diagram of a periodic signal. [Diagram 3] FIG. 3 is a frequency spectrum of the time signal calculated from FIG. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0026] The present invention describes a method for preventing unwanted vibration amplification by a frequency converter in the case of resonances during operation of a pump, in particular a solids pump, a drainage pump or another supply pump. The basis for preventing these resonance vibrations is that such resonances must first be detected by the pump control device, preferably without the need to incorporate special sensor systems such as accelerometers in the pump. However, the pump may be equipped with additional sensors, for example accelerometers, which may improve the accuracy of the method if necessary.

[0027] Since mechanical vibrations are the result of the interaction of the motor structure with the forces, these mechanical vibrations can further be recognized as superpositions of the pump currents of the pump drive on the drive currents. Since the intensity of the individual superimposed vibrations is of interest here, the evaluation of the motor currents is carried out by analyzing the frequency spectrum of the recorded motor signal. The frequency spectrum is obtained by the pump control device performing a Fast Fourier Transform (FFT).

[0028] This process can be illustrated briefly on the basis of the representations in figures 2 and 3. Figure 2 shows the time diagram of the recorded signal, which for simplicity is generated by superposing three sinusoidal signals with different frequencies. By applying an FFT, the time signal can be decomposed into its harmonic components, resulting in the frequency amplitude spectrum shown in figure 3. From this spectrum, as expected, the individual frequencies of the sinusoidal signals can be read off.

[0029] Thus, the FFT of the motor current allows the pump to detect mechanical vibrations reflected in the recorded motor current. Then, in a following step, the pump or the pump control tries to set the pump rotation speed so that the rotation frequency resulting from the impeller does not overlap with the natural frequency of the pump or a multiple of such a natural frequency. For this purpose, first the rotation speed is changed and in a next step a spectral analysis of the currently recorded motor current is carried out again at the changed rotation speed. If the amplitude of the occurring current oscillations becomes smaller, this indicates that the mechanical vibrations have been successfully reduced by the change in the rotation speed. The method is carried out iteratively in order to reduce as small as possible the amplitude values ​​of the fluctuations occurring in the current signal. The identification of the ideal rotation speed can in principle be carried out according to two scenarios:

[0030] [Scenario 1: The required rotation frequency is subject to certain requirements.] According to scenario 1, the rotational frequency may only have certain values. There may be energy-related reasons or the intended purpose requires a certain (fixed) rotational speed. In this case, the pump operator specifies in the pump control the maximum tolerance within which the circulating frequency may deviate from the set value, for example ±3 Hz. The pump control then varies the rotational speed within the tolerance range and iteratively finds the rotational speed at which the amplitude of the vibrations is minimal. In many cases, even very small variations are sufficient to deviate from the natural frequency of the system and therefore minimize the occurrence of mechanical vibrations.

[0031] [Scenario 2: There are no special requirements for the rotation frequency.] In the absence of process requirements regarding the rotational frequency, the pump controller can change the pump rotational speed at will. This allows searching for an anti-resonance and setting the final operating rotational speed of the pump at this anti-resonance. The simplest way to determine the suitable rotational speed (anti-resonance) from the available rotational speed range (and therefore the one with the lowest memory and process requirements) is based on a dichotomy method. Mathematical optimization methods such as the "active set method" or the "Newton method" are faster and more effective. The global optimization can furthermore be determined reliably by a genetic algorithm.

[0032] Separately or in addition to the motor current, the pump Discharge Pressure The signals of can also be examined. Here, as with the motor currents, the frequency spectrum for the corresponding resonant frequencies is analyzed and evaluated by means of a fast Fourier transform. Discharge Pressure can be calculated, for example, using a pump pressure sensor or by estimating the operating point.

[0033] To improve signal quality, both signals ( Discharge Pressureand motor current) can also be merged by sensor data fusion. If this is not possible, the current and pressure signals can also be evaluated individually. With regard to sensor fusion, for example, the individual signal values ​​can be evaluated as described above and then merged by weighting. It is also conceivable to define a range in which the individual results of the individually evaluated signals can be weighted differently. For example, the evaluation results of the motor current in the frequency range of 10-200 Hz can be used, while the evaluation results of the higher frequency signals can be weighted differently. Discharge Pressure The evaluation results will be taken into account.

[0034] A particular advantage of the method presented here is that the pump itself can find its natural frequency, so no mathematical processing model is required, which would be complicated to develop. The main application of the method presented here is to prevent or reduce vibrations in order to reduce wear and noise during pump operation. In addition, the process can also contribute to wear and damage monitoring, and can warn the user in case of damage.

[0035] [Wear monitoring] With the presented method, the frequency response of the self-contained pump is permanently monitored. However, as mentioned above, the frequency response depends on the pump's construction, installation position, material and bearings. A change in the frequency response is therefore in any case an indication that one or more of these variables have changed, for example due to wear. This information can then be used for wear monitoring, for example in combination with the solution of DE 10 2018 200 651, which is expressly referred to herein. The combination of these two approaches allows a more accurate assessment of the wear state.

[0036] [Damage warning] In contrast to wear, which causes a very slow change in frequency response, pump damage will cause a sudden and significant change in frequency response. Damage can include, among other things, bearing or impeller failure. The rapid change in frequency response allows the pump controller to reliably distinguish between wear and damage and to provide a warning to the operator in the event of damage.

Claims

1. A method for preventing or reducing mechanical vibrations during pump operation of a pump, including a centrifugal pump, comprising: a first step in which a frequency converter and a pump controller are provided; a second step of detecting mechanical vibrations of the pump by the pump controller detecting at least one signal of a pump operating parameter and examining the at least one signal for signal vibrations; a third step of reducing the detected mechanical vibrations by varying the rotational speed of the pump by the frequency converter; Including, The method, characterized in that the second and third steps are repeatedly performed while varying the rotational speed of the pump within a predefined tolerance range with a maximum possible deviation for a particular rotational speed of the pump in order to identify a pump rotational speed at which the amplitude of mechanical vibrations detected in the frequency spectrum of the at least one signal is minimized.

2. 2. The method of claim 1, wherein the frequency spectrum of said at least one signal is calculated by means of a Fast Fourier Transform.

3. 3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that the at least one signal investigated corresponds to a motor current of a pump drive.

4. 4. The method according to claim 1, wherein the at least one signal to be investigated corresponds to a discharge pressure of the pump, the discharge pressure being determined by at least one of the following: measurement using a pressure sensor and estimation of an operating point of the pump defined by a discharge flow rate and a total head during operation of the pump.

5. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that the at least one signal comprises a signal corresponding to a motor current of a pump drive and a signal corresponding to a discharge pressure of the pump, and in the third step, depending on the rotational speed of the pump, a first mechanical vibration of the pump detected for the signal corresponding to the motor current of the pump drive or a second mechanical vibration of the pump detected for the signal corresponding to the discharge pressure of the pump is used.

6. The method described in claim 5, wherein the first mechanical vibration is used when the rotational speed of the pump is relatively low and the second mechanical vibration is used when the rotational speed of the pump is relatively high.

7. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, characterized in that the method is repeatedly performed while arbitrarily varying the rotational speed of the pump in order to identify at least one anti-resonance of the pump and to operate the pump at said anti-resonance.

8. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 7, characterized in that the frequency of the identified resonant vibration is stored and the method is repeatedly performed to detect changes in the frequency of the identified resonant vibration.

9. The method of claim 8, wherein the pump is capable of detecting at least one of material wear of the pump and any damage to the structure of the pump based on the detected change in frequency.

10. A pump configuration comprising a frequency converter and a pump control device configured to carry out the method according to any one of claims 1 to 9, the pump configuration being a centrifugal pump including a drainage pump, a solid pump for transporting a liquid having a solid portion or a feed pump.

11. Use of the pump configuration described in claim 10 as a drainage pump, a solids pump for transporting a liquid having a solid portion, or a feed pump.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Engine control device for hydraulic type construction machine

    JP2000303872A

  • Operation supervisory and controlling system

    JP2003271241A

  • Monitoring method and device for pump vibration

    JP2003315146A

  • Damage detecting method and device for impeller

    JP2006009581A

  • high speed rotary vacuum pump

    JP2008516139A