Information processing system, information processing method, and program

The information processing system addresses the inefficiency in security evaluation by incorporating judgment rules and risk messages to guide service providers in correcting incomplete answers, thereby enhancing the accuracy and efficiency of security assessments.

JP7595217B1Active Publication Date: 2024-12-05BIZREACH INC

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2024169732
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-09-30
Publication Date
2024-12-05
Estimated Expiration
2044-09-30

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing systems lack an efficient method to evaluate security effectively, particularly in the context of security surveys for service providers, leading to incomplete or inaccurate assessments.

Method used

An information processing system that accepts multiple judgment rules and risk messages, displays risk messages for incomplete answers, and allows service providers to modify their responses, thereby enhancing the security evaluation process.

Benefits of technology

This system enables efficient and accurate security evaluation by allowing service providers to review and correct answers based on displayed risk messages, improving the overall quality of security assessments.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007595217000001_ABST
    Figure 0007595217000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

An information processing system capable of efficiently evaluating security is provided. [Solution] According to one aspect of the present invention, there is provided an information processing system having at least one processor, the processor being configured to execute each of the following steps by reading a program, wherein a judgment rule registration step accepts input from an evaluator of multiple judgment rules for answers to questions in a security survey and risk messages corresponding to each judgment rule, and combines and registers the judgment rules and the risk messages corresponding to the judgment rules in a database, the risk messages including sentences explaining matters that conflict with the judgment rules, a response acceptance step accepts input from a service provider of answers to the questions in the survey, a judgment step judges whether the inputted answers conflict with the judgment rules and, if there is a conflict, displays a risk message for the answers, and a rating acceptance step accepts from the evaluator an evaluation of the service provider's answers in the survey.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to an information processing system, an information processing method, and a program. [Background technology]

[0002] Patent Document 1 discloses a technique for accepting input of answers to questions regarding security and evaluating security. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0003] [Patent Document 1] JP 2005-234756 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0004] Here, it is desired to perform security evaluation efficiently.

[0005] In view of the above circumstances, the present invention provides an information processing system and the like that can efficiently evaluate security. [Means for solving the problem]

[0006] According to one aspect of the present invention, there is provided an information processing system comprising at least one processor, the processor being configured to execute each of the following steps by reading out a program, wherein a judgment rule registration step accepts input of a plurality of judgment rules for answers to questions in a security survey and risk messages corresponding to each of the judgment rules from an evaluator, and the judgment rules and the risk messages corresponding to the judgment rules are combined and registered in a database, the risk messages including sentences explaining matters that conflict with the judgment rules, a response acceptance step accepts input of answers to the questions in the survey from a service provider, a judgment step judges whether the input answers conflict with the judgment rules and, if there is a conflict, displays a risk message for the answers, and a rating acceptance step accepts an evaluation of the service provider's answers in the survey from the evaluator.

[0007] According to this embodiment, when inputting answers to questions in a security survey, the service provider (answerer) can review or correct the answer based on the risk message displayed for an incomplete answer, which results in efficient security evaluation. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0008] [Figure 1] 1 is a configuration diagram illustrating an information processing system 1. [Diagram 2] 2 is a block diagram showing the hardware configuration of the server device 10 and the provider terminal 20. FIG. [Diagram 3] FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing the hardware configuration of an evaluator terminal 30 and a user terminal 40. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing functions realized by a server device 10 (control unit 11), a provider terminal 20 (control unit 21), an evaluator terminal 30 (control unit 31), and a user terminal 40 (control unit 41). [Diagram 5] 13 is a diagram showing an example of a judgment rule registration screen RD displayed on the evaluator terminal 30. FIG. [Figure 6] 13 is a diagram showing an example of a judgment rule list screen LD displayed on the evaluator terminal 30. FIG. [Figure 7] 13 is a diagram showing an example of an answer input screen AD displayed on the provider terminal 20. FIG. [Figure 8] 13 is a diagram showing another example of the answer input screen AD displayed on the provider terminal 20. FIG. [Figure 9] 13 is a diagram showing yet another example of the answer input screen AD displayed on the provider terminal 20. FIG. [Figure 10] 13 is a diagram showing an example of a transmission confirmation screen CD displayed on the provider terminal 20. FIG. [Figure 11] 13 is a diagram showing another example of the transmission confirmation screen CD displayed on the provider terminal 20. FIG. [Figure 12] 2 is an activity diagram showing an example of the flow of information processing (security investigation processing) executed by the information processing system 1. FIG. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0009] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. Various characteristic features shown in the following embodiments can be combined with each other.

[0010] Incidentally, a program for realizing the software appearing in one embodiment may be provided as a non-transitory computer-readable recording medium, or may be provided so as to be downloadable from an external server, or may be provided so that the program is launched on an external computer and its functions are realized on a client terminal (so-called cloud computing).

[0011] In addition, in various information processing according to an embodiment, an input and an output according to the input can be realized. Here, as long as an output is obtained as a result of the input, the form of information referenced in such information processing (hereinafter referred to as reference information) is not limited. The reference information may be, for example, rule-based information such as a database, a lookup table, or a predetermined function (including a judgment formula such as a regression formula constructed by a statistical method), or may be a trained model that has previously trained the correlation between the input and the output, or may be a large-scale language model that can output a desired result by inputting a prompt.

[0012] In one embodiment, the term "unit" may include, for example, a combination of hardware resources implemented by a circuit in the broad sense and software information processing that can be specifically realized by these hardware resources. In one embodiment, various information is handled, and this information is represented by, for example, physical values ​​of signal values ​​representing voltage and current, high and low signal values ​​as a binary bit collection consisting of 0 or 1, or quantum superposition (so-called quantum bits), and communication and calculation can be performed on the circuit in the broad sense.

[0013] Furthermore, a circuit in the broad sense is a circuit realized by at least appropriately combining a circuit, circuitry, a processor, and a memory. The processor may be a general-purpose processor or a dedicated circuit. In other words, it includes an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a programmable logic device (e.g., a simple programmable logic device (SPLD), a complex programmable logic device (CPLD), and a field programmable gate array (FPGA)), etc.

[0014] 1. Hardware Configuration This section describes the hardware configuration.

[0015] <Information Processing System 1> 1 is a configuration diagram showing an information processing system 1. The information processing system 1 includes a communication line 2, a server device 10, a plurality of provider terminals 20, at least one evaluator terminal 30, and a plurality of user terminals 40. The server device 10, the provider terminal 20, the evaluator terminal 30, and the user terminal 40 are configured to be able to communicate with each other through the communication line 2. The connection between the server device 10, the provider terminal 20, the evaluator terminal 30, and the user terminal 40 may be wired or wireless.

[0016] The information processing system 1 constitutes at least a part of a security evaluation system for Internet services used by, for example, multiple service providers (a first service provider U1 and a second service provider U2), at least one evaluator U3, and multiple service users (a first service user U4 and a second service user U5). The information processing system 1 mainly evaluates the security of services provided by service providers and provides evaluation results of security investigations, and for example, the information processing system 1 mainly provides a security evaluation service by evaluators. In one embodiment, the information processing system 1 is composed of one or more devices or components. These components will be described below.

[0017] <Server device 10> Fig. 2 is a block diagram showing the hardware configuration of the server device 10 and the provider terminal 20. As shown in Fig. 2A, the server device 10 includes a control unit 11, a storage unit 12, a communication unit 13, and a communication bus 14. The control unit 11, the storage unit 12, and the communication unit 13 are electrically connected inside the server device 10 via the communication bus 14.

[0018] <Control unit 11> The control unit 11 performs processing and control of the overall operation related to the server device 10. The control unit 11 is, for example, a central processing unit (CPU). The control unit 11 realizes various functions related to the server device 10 by reading out a predetermined program stored in the storage unit 12. That is, information processing by software stored in the storage unit 12 can be specifically realized by the control unit 11, which is an example of hardware, and executed as each functional unit included in the control unit 11. These will be described in more detail in the next section. Note that the control unit 11 is not limited to being single, and multiple control units 11 may be provided for each function. Furthermore, the control unit 11 may have a configuration that combines these.

[0019] <Storage section 12> The storage unit 12 stores various information defined by the above description. This can be implemented, for example, as a storage device such as a solid state drive (SSD) that stores various programs and the like related to the server device 10 executed by the control unit 11, or as a memory such as a random access memory (RAM) that stores temporarily required information (arguments, arrays, etc.) related to the program calculations. The storage unit 12 stores various programs, variables, etc. related to the server device 10 executed by the control unit 11.

[0020] <Communications Division 13> The communication unit 13 is preferably a wired communication means such as USB, IEEE1394, Thunderbolt (registered trademark), wired LAN network communication, etc., but may also include wireless LAN network communication, mobile communication such as 3G / LTE / 5G, BLUETOOTH (registered trademark) communication, etc. as necessary. In other words, it is more preferable to implement it as a collection of multiple communication means. In other words, the server device 10 may communicate various information from the outside via the communication unit 13 and the network.

[0021] The server device 10 may be in an on-premise form or in a cloud form. The server device 10 in a cloud form may provide the above-mentioned functions and processes in the form of, for example, SaaS (Software as a Service) or cloud computing.

[0022] <Provider terminal 20> The provider terminal 20 is an information processing terminal used by a service provider that provides an IT service. As shown in Fig. 2B, the provider terminal 20 includes a control unit 21, a storage unit 22, a communication unit 23, an input unit 24, an output unit 25, and a communication bus 26. The control unit 21, the storage unit 22, the communication unit 23, the input unit 24, and the output unit 25 are electrically connected via the communication bus 26 inside the provider terminal 20. The explanation of the control unit 21, the storage unit 22, and the communication unit 23 will be omitted because they are the same as the explanation of each unit in the server device 10.

[0023] <Input section 24> The input unit 24 accepts an operation input made by a user. The operation input is transferred as a command signal to the control unit 21 via the communication bus 26. The control unit 21 can execute a predetermined control or calculation based on the transferred command signal as necessary. The input unit 24 may be included in the housing of the provider terminal 20, or may be externally attached. For example, the input unit 24 may be implemented as a touch panel integrated with the output unit 25. When the input unit 24 is implemented as a touch panel, the user can input a tap operation, a swipe operation, or the like to the input unit 24. As the input unit 24, a switch button, a mouse, a track pad, a QWERTY keyboard, or the like can be adopted instead of a touch panel.

[0024] <Output section 25> The output unit 25 displays a screen of a graphical user interface (GUI) that can be operated by the user. The output unit 25 may be included in the housing of the donor terminal 20, or may be attached externally. Specifically, the output unit 25 may be implemented as a display device such as a CRT display, a liquid crystal display, an organic EL display, a plasma display, or the like. It is preferable that these display devices are implemented by selectively using them according to the type of the donor terminal 20.

[0025] <Evaluator Terminal 30> The evaluator terminal 30 is an information processing terminal used by an evaluator who evaluates the user's answers. The evaluator is an organization such as a company that performs security evaluation (for example, a security evaluation company that performs security evaluation of services such as cloud services, software, etc.) or a person in charge thereof. The evaluator performs service evaluation from the evaluator terminal 30 via the information processing system 1, for example.

[0026] Fig. 3 is a block diagram showing the hardware configuration of the evaluator terminal 30 and the user terminal 40. As shown in Fig. 3A, the evaluator terminal 30 includes a control unit 31, a storage unit 32, a communication unit 33, an input unit 34, an output unit 35, and a communication bus 36. The control unit 31, the storage unit 32, the communication unit 33, the input unit 34, and the output unit 35 are electrically connected inside the evaluator terminal 30 via the communication bus 36. The explanation of the control unit 31, the storage unit 32, the communication unit 33, the input unit 34, and the output unit 35 of the evaluator terminal 30 will be omitted because they are the same as the explanation of each unit in the provider terminal 20.

[0027] <User terminal 40> The user terminal 40 is an information processing terminal used by a user of the security evaluation service provided by the server device 10. As shown in Fig. 3B, the user terminal 40 includes a control unit 41, a memory unit 42, a communication unit 43, an input unit 44, an output unit 45, and a communication bus 46. The control unit 41, the memory unit 42, the communication unit 43, the input unit 44, and the output unit 45 are electrically connected inside the user terminal 40 via the communication bus 46. The explanation of the control unit 41, the memory unit 42, the communication unit 43, the input unit 44, and the output unit 45 of the user terminal 40 will be omitted because they are similar to the explanation of each unit in the provider terminal 20.

[0028] 2. Functional configuration In this section, the functional configuration of the present embodiment will be described. Information processing by software stored in the storage unit 12 is specifically realized by the control unit 11, which is an example of hardware, and can be executed as each functional unit included in the control unit 11 (at least one processor included in the information processing system 1).

[0029] FIG. 4 is a block diagram showing functions realized by the server device 10 (controller 11), the provider terminal 20 (controller 21), the evaluator terminal 30 (controller 31), and the user terminal 40 (controller 41).

[0030] As shown in FIG 4A, the server device 10 (control unit 11) includes a basic display control unit 111, a judgment rule registration unit 112, an answer receiving unit 113, a judgment unit 114, an answer sending unit 115, an evaluation receiving unit 116, and a report output unit 117. As shown in FIG 4B, the provider terminal 20 (control unit 21) includes a display unit 211 and an operation acquisition unit 212. As shown in FIG 4C, the evaluator terminal 30 (control unit 31) includes a display unit 311 and an operation acquisition unit 312. As shown in FIG 4D, the user terminal 40 (control unit 41) includes a display unit 411 and an operation acquisition unit 412.

[0031] <Basic display control unit 111> The basic display control unit 111 is configured to display various information on the provider terminal 20, the evaluator terminal 30, and the user terminal 40. For example, the basic display control unit 111 displays an input form in which the service provider inputs an answer, the answers input by the service provider, the evaluation results by the evaluator, etc. on the display unit 211 of the provider terminal 20, the display unit 311 of the evaluator terminal 30, or the display unit 411 of the user terminal 40.

[0032] <Determination rule registration unit 112> The judgment rule registration unit 112 is configured to register judgment rules for answers to questions in a survey regarding the security of a service provider.

[0033] The "services" provided by a service provider include services provided via the Internet, such as SaaS, IaaS (Infrastructure as a Service), PaaS (Platform as a Service), and cloud services, and the "service provider" includes cloud service providers, etc. In addition, the "services" provided by a service provider may be services provided to business partners, customers, etc.

[0034] The "question items" are matters to which the service provider is requested to respond, and may include, for example, items related to the security of the service provider itself, the security of the services the service provider provides, etc. The question items may also include items related to the security of other organizations in the service provider's supply chain. "Other organizations" include, for example, business partners of the service provider, such as organizations to which the service provider outsources its operations (including outsourcees, sub-outsourcees, sub-sub-outsourcees, etc.).

[0035] A single question item may include multiple answer elements (answer columns). Also, a question item may include a so-called security check sheet.

[0036] The judgment rules are rules for judging the presence or absence of deficiencies, errors, inconsistencies, etc. in the answers to the questions. Deficiencies in answers, etc., are, for example, answers that make it impossible to evaluate security as they are, that reduce the accuracy of the security evaluation, or that significantly reduce the security evaluation, and are answers that require the evaluator to review the answer to the service provider or re-enter it.

[0037] The judgment rule may include at least one of a first conflict condition that specifies a conflict with other answers, a second conflict condition that specifies a conflict regarding a date, and a non-disclosure condition regarding non-disclosure of the answer. This allows for a highly accurate judgment of the presence or absence of a conflict by setting relatively simple conditions, thereby improving the quality of answers provided by the service provider. As a result, the occurrence of answers being sent back by evaluators is reduced, and the time required for evaluators to evaluate can be shortened.

[0038] The first contradiction condition specifies that a conflict occurs when there is a contradiction between the multiple specified answers (the multiple answers satisfy the definition condition of a contradiction). The other answers in the first contradiction condition should preferably include answers to other questions and answers within the same question. This makes it possible to determine contradictions in answers between independent questions and contradictions between multiple answer elements in one question, which helps to reduce the occurrence of answers being sent back by evaluators.

[0039] The second conflict condition specifies that a conflict occurs when, for example, the current date and the date on which the answer was entered or the date entered as the answer satisfy a predetermined relationship. This allows, for example, a risk message to be displayed in a question item regarding an item with an expiration date such as authentication when it is determined that the expiration date has passed.

[0040] The non-disclosure condition specifies that a violation occurs when "non-disclosure" is entered (selected) as the answer. This allows a risk message to be displayed for an input that makes the answer non-disclosure.

[0041] A judgment rule may include multiple conflicting conditions. A conflicting condition specifies each answer that constitutes a conflicting condition in one question item. This allows the evaluator to set judgment rules for each question item or answer, making it possible to efficiently build a network of judgment rules for security research.

[0042] The multiple conflict conditions may include those that specify the content of each of multiple answers in a question item for which multiple answers can be input or multiple answers must be input. For example, one judgment rule may include a conflict condition that "the answer to the Nth question item includes option A" and a conflict condition that "the answer to the Nth question item does not include option B." In addition, the judgment rule may include a combination of multiple questions that may cause a contradiction and a conflict condition for each of the multiple questions included in the combination.

[0043] A risk message is a notification that there is an answer that conflicts with a judgment rule. The risk message includes text that explains the matter that conflicts with the judgment rule. The "conflicting matter" includes, for example, the reason for the conflict with the judgment rule, the basis for determining that there is a conflict (date, etc.), related questions and the corresponding answers that have already been entered, etc. The risk message may also include suggestions for correcting the answer.

[0044] A "related question item" is a question item for which a contradictory relationship is defined in a judgment rule, in other words, a question item included in a "combination of multiple question items that may cause a contradiction" in a conflicting judgment rule.

[0045] A risk message may include links to other questions related to the risk message, which allows the service provider to immediately check related questions and modify answers to the related questions, thereby enabling the service provider to efficiently modify answers.

[0046] The link to another question item may be attached to a keyword (e.g., a question number) indicating the question item in the text included in the risk message, or may be included in the risk message as an object such as a button independent of the text. When an input operation is performed on the link in the provider terminal 20, an answer input screen (answer input field) for the linked question item is displayed on the provider terminal 20.

[0047] The judgment rule registration unit 112 receives input of a plurality of judgment rules and risk messages associated with each judgment rule from the evaluator, and registers the judgment rule and the risk messages associated with the judgment rule in combination in a rule database.

[0048] The judgment rule registration unit 112 displays a judgment rule registration screen on the evaluator terminal 30, the judgment rule registration screen including, for example, a judgment rule input field for receiving input of a judgment rule and a risk message input field for receiving input of a risk message associated with the judgment rule. The judgment rule registration unit 112 registers the judgment rule input in the judgment rule input field and the risk message input in the risk message input field in a rule database in association with each other. As a result, when the answer is judged to be in conflict with one judgment rule by the judgment unit 114 described later, one risk message registered in association with the judgment rule is displayed on the provider terminal 20. That is, the judgment rule and the risk message are in one-to-one association. In other words, each risk message is registered in the rule database in association with a judgment rule that includes, as a condition, a question item for which the risk message is to be displayed.

[0049] The judgment rule registration unit 112 may receive the setting of attributes for each judgment rule from the evaluator, and may register the judgment rule in the rule database in association with the attributes. The attributes of the judgment rule may include, for example, the warning level and warning timing of the judgment rule. The risk message of the judgment rule may be displayed in a form according to the attribute (for example, the higher the warning level, the more emphasized the message is). In addition, the risk message of the judgment rule may be displayed in a timing according to the attribute (for example, immediately after inputting an answer, after sending an answer, etc.).

[0050] In particular, the judgment rule registration unit 112 may accept from the evaluator, for each judgment rule, a setting of a correction requirement attribute indicating that an answer that conflicts with the judgment rule must be corrected, and may register the judgment rule and the correction requirement attribute in the rule database in association with each other. This makes it possible to prompt the service provider to correct an answer that includes content that the evaluator cannot evaluate before the evaluator submits the answer. As a result, security evaluation can be performed efficiently.

[0051] For example, when accepting input of a judgment rule and a risk message from the evaluator terminal 30, the judgment rule registration unit 112 further accepts input of whether or not the attribute is a correction required attribute. The correction required attribute may be input by selecting an option indicating that the attribute is a correction required attribute. The judgment rule registration unit 112 registers the correction required attribute in the rule database together with the judgment rule and risk message that have been input in association with each other. Therefore, the correction required attribute is also associated with the risk message.

[0052] The judgment rules registered in the rule database are commonly applied to all service providers. The judgment rule registration unit 112 may display a list of the registered judgment rules on the evaluator terminal 30. The judgment rule registration unit 112 may also accept editing (modification, deletion, etc.) of the registered judgment rules from the evaluator terminal 30.

[0053] In addition, the service provider and the user cannot register the judgment rules and risk messages. That is, the judgment rule registration unit 112 accepts the registration of the judgment rules and risk messages only from the evaluator terminal 30.

[0054] 5 is a diagram showing an example of a judgment rule registration screen RD displayed on the evaluator terminal 30. The judgment rule registration screen RD includes an ID input field IF, a rule name input field NF, a risk message input field MF, an attribute input field AF, a judgment rule input field RF, and a registration button B11.

[0055] The ID input field IF accepts input of an ID to be assigned to each judgment rule. Each judgment rule and risk message is identified and managed by this ID. The rule name input field NF accepts input of the name of the judgment rule. The risk message input field MF accepts input of a risk message. The risk message entered in the risk message input field MF is linked to the ID entered in the ID input field IF.

[0056] The attribute input field AF accepts input of attributes of the judgment rule. In the example of Fig. 5, the attribute input field AF displays options (check boxes) for attributes that must be corrected ("Must be corrected"). The attribute input (selected) in the attribute input field AF is linked to the ID input in the ID input field IF.

[0057] The judgment rule input field RF accepts input of specific conditions of the judgment rule. The judgment rule conditions input (selected) in the judgment rule input field RF are linked to the ID input in the ID input field IF. The judgment rule input field RF includes an overall condition input field ACF, at least one item condition input field ICF, and an add condition group button B12.

[0058] The item condition input field ICF accepts input of conflicting conditions for one question item. A condition group is made up of conflicting conditions input in at least one item condition input field ICF. Each item condition input field ICF includes a question item input field IF1, an answer option input field IF2, an auxiliary condition input field IF3, a delete button B13, and an add input field button B14.

[0059] The question item input field IF1 accepts input of a question item (question) that is the subject of a conflicting condition. In the example of FIG. 5, the question item input field IF1 displays multiple questions included in a security survey (an input form in which a service provider enters answers) in a pull-down menu and accepts selection of a question item. The answer option input field IF2 accepts input of answers (options) to the question item entered in the question item input field IF1. In the example of FIG. 5, the answer option input field IF2 displays multiple options set as answers to the question item entered in the question item input field IF1 in a pull-down menu and accepts selection of an answer (option).

[0060] The auxiliary condition input field IF3 accepts input of the judgment condition "whether or not the answer entered in the answer option input field IF2 is included." In the example of FIG. 5, the auxiliary condition input field IF3 displays multiple judgment conditions in a pull-down menu and accepts the selection of the judgment condition ("includes answer" or "does not include answer"). The Delete button B13 accepts input for deleting the item condition input field ICF. The Add Input Field button B14 accepts input for adding a new item condition input field ICF to the same condition group.

[0061] The overall condition input field ACF accepts input of theoretical conditions (AND conditions or OR conditions) for conflicting conditions (conditions entered in the item condition input field ICF) in multiple question items included in one condition group. In the example of Fig. 5, the overall condition input field ACF displays multiple theoretical conditions in a pull-down list and accepts selection of a theoretical condition ("and" or "or").

[0062] The add condition group button B12 accepts input of an operation to add a new condition group (a set of one overall condition input field ACF and at least one item condition input field ICF).

[0063] The register button B11 accepts input for an operation to register the items entered in the ID input field IF, the rule name input field NF, the risk message input field MF, the attribute input field AF, and the judgment rule input field RF in the rule database. With this operation, the judgment rule, the risk message, and the attribute are associated with the ID of one judgment rule and registered.

[0064] 6 is a diagram showing an example of a judgment rule list screen LD displayed on the evaluator terminal 30. The judgment rule list screen LD includes a query input field QF, a search execution button B21, and a list display field LF.

[0065] The list display field LF displays a list of registered judgment rules. The query input field QF accepts input of a search query for judgment rules (a condition for narrowing down the judgment rules displayed in the list display field LF). The search execution button B21 accepts input of an operation for searching (filtering) judgment rules using the search query entered in the query input field QF.

[0066] <Answer Reception Section 113> The answer receiving unit 113 is configured to receive input of answers to questions in the survey from the service provider.

[0067] The answer receiving unit 113 displays, for example, a predetermined input form for receiving input of answers to questions about security on the provider terminal 20. The questions include, for example, questions about authentication or evaluation of security, service level, scope of responsibility, security measures within the service provider, handling of data created by the service user, development of the service, maintenance or operation policy (account management, etc.), etc. (questions for which answers are requested from the service provider), etc.

[0068] After the service provider has completed inputting the answers, the answer receiving unit 113 receives an instruction to transmit the answers entered for the questions in the survey from the service provider. Specifically, the answer receiving unit 113 receives an instruction to transmit the answers entered in the input form (an instruction to submit to the evaluator) from the provider terminal 20.

[0069] <Determination unit 114> The judgment unit 114 is configured to judge whether the input answer conflicts with a registered judgment rule, and, if there is a conflict, to cause the provider terminal 20 to display a registered risk message for the answer.

[0070] The judgment unit 114 may judge that there is a conflict with the judgment rule when all of the conflict conditions included in the judgment rule are satisfied, or when any of the conflict conditions included in the judgment rule are satisfied. For example, when the theoretical condition (theoretical condition in the condition group) for the conflict conditions included in the judgment rule is an AND condition, the conflict judgment condition is that the answers mentioned in each conflict condition among the input answers match all the answer contents specified in each conflict condition. Also, for example, when the theoretical condition for the conflict conditions included in the judgment rule is an OR condition, the conflict judgment condition is that at least one of the answers mentioned in each conflict condition among the input answers matches the answer contents specified in each conflict condition.

[0071] The timing of the conflict determination by the determination unit 114 and the timing of the risk message display can be set arbitrarily by the evaluator as attributes of the determination rule. Also, the risk message does not necessarily have to be displayed immediately after the determination unit 114 determines that a conflict has occurred.

[0072] When an answer to a question item in a survey is input, the judgment unit 114 may display a risk message on the provider terminal 20 according to the judgment result of whether the answer conflicts with the judgment rule. This allows the service provider to instantly correct the question item without switching the question item, thereby improving the efficiency of answer input.

[0073] In the case of displaying a risk message when an answer is input, the judgment unit 114 performs a conflict judgment, for example, when at least one answer to one question is input, or when input of an answer to one question is confirmed (for example, when an answer to a question is saved), and after the conflict judgment, displays the risk message in association with the question. "Display associated with the question" includes display in an area allocated to the question in the input form (for example, an answer input field), display alongside the question, display as a pop-up with the question displayed, etc.

[0074] Fig. 7 is a diagram showing an example of an answer input screen AD displayed on the provider terminal 20. The answer input screen AD includes a question number QN, a question content QC, an answer input field AIF, an answer save button B41, and a proceed button B42. Note that, although one question item is displayed on the answer input screen AD in Fig. 7, multiple question items may be displayed on the answer input screen AD, and the question items displayed may be switched by, for example, an operation such as scrolling.

[0075] In the example of FIG. 7, a question content QC and an answer input field AIF of a question item with question number QN "AA-1" are displayed. A plurality of answer options AC and auxiliary options SC are displayed in the answer input field AIF. Each of the answer options AC is provided with an input reception object such as a check box that allows multiple selections. Furthermore, each of the auxiliary options SC is provided with an input reception object such as a radio button that allows exclusive selection. The auxiliary options SC may be provided with an input reception object different from the answer options AC so that they can be visually distinguished from the answer options AC.

[0076] The auxiliary options SC include, for example, an option indicating that there is no suitable (applicable) answer among the presented answer options AC, an option indicating that the service provider will not disclose the answer to the question (will not answer), etc. Furthermore, the auxiliary options SC and the answer options AC are in an exclusive selection relationship. In other words, if any of the auxiliary options SC is selected, any of the answer options AC cannot be selected at the same time. For example, if an auxiliary option SC is selected after an arbitrary authentication name has been selected, the selection of the answer option AC is deselected.

[0077] In the example of FIG. 7, "Question about the region or area of ​​the data center" is displayed as the question content QC, and options representing the region or area are displayed as a list of answer options AC, with the option "Japan" being selected as the answer. Also, in the example of FIG. 7, in this case, a risk message RM is displayed at the bottom of the answer input field AIF to explain that the answer "Japan" conflicts with the judgment rule. Specifically, a risk message RM is displayed that includes a sentence suggesting that the answer "Japan" is inconsistent with the answer to another question item ("DD-1"). Also, a link to this question item is set to a keyword ("DD-1") indicating another question item in the risk message RM. When an input operation is performed on the link of "DD-1" in the provider terminal 20, the question number QN, question content QC, and answer input field AIF of the question item "DD-1" are displayed on the provider terminal 20.

[0078] When the service provider corrects the answer to a question item for which a risk message RM is displayed (in the example of Figure 7, the answer to question item "AA-1" is corrected or the answer to question item "DD-1" is corrected), thereby resolving the conflict with the judgment rule, the display of the risk message RM is removed.

[0079] The answer save button B41 accepts input of an operation to save the answer entered in the answer input field AIF. The entered answer is stored, for example, in an answer database in the storage unit 12. At this time, if a risk message RM is displayed, unresolved information indicating that the risk message is displayed, that is, that the conflict with the judgment rule has not been resolved, is associated with the answer and stored in the answer database.

[0080] The proceed button B42 accepts input for switching the question items displayed on the answer input screen AD.

[0081] Fig. 8 is a diagram showing another example of the answer input screen AD displayed on the provider terminal 20. In the example of Fig. 8, the question content QC and the answer input field AIF of the question item with question number QN "CC-1" are displayed. Specifically, "Question about the presence or absence of security certification or evaluation" is displayed as the question content QC, options showing information (certification name) showing security certification are displayed as a list as the answer options AC, and the option "ISO / IEC XXX" is selected as the answer.

[0082] Also, in the example of FIG. 8, in this case, a risk message RM is displayed immediately below the corresponding answer (selected option) explaining that the answer "ISO / IEC XXX has been acquired" conflicts with the judgment rule. The risk message RM may be displayed below all options. Specifically, in the example of FIG. 8, a risk message RM is displayed that includes a sentence suggesting that the answer "ISO / IEC XXX has been acquired" conflicts with another answer in the same question item ("ISO / IEC XXX has not been acquired"). In the example of FIG. 8, when the conflict with the judgment rule is resolved by deselecting "ISO / IEC XXX" or selecting "ISO / IEC XXX", the display of the risk message RM is canceled.

[0083] The judgment unit 114 may display a list of the questions and answers for which a risk message is displayed on the provider terminal 20 together with the risk message. This allows the service provider to get an overview of the questions and answers for which a risk message is displayed (answers and questions that conflict with judgment rules) and correct the answers as necessary. As a result, the efficiency of correcting answers by the service provider increases.

[0084] For example, the determination unit 114 causes the question items, answers, and risk messages to be displayed in a list to be linked vertically on the provider terminal 20. Furthermore, the determination unit 114 may cause the provider terminal 20 to display, in a list, information indicating the question items to be displayed in a list (such as question numbers).

[0085] The determination unit 114 may, for example, display on the provider terminal 20 a notification, a menu item, or the like indicating that there is an answer that conflicts with the determination rule or that there is a question item that requires confirmation, and may accept an instruction to display the list from the provider terminal 20. For example, when there is no answer that conflicts with the determination rule, the determination unit 114 may inactivate or hide a menu item that accepts an instruction to display a list of answers that conflict with the determination rule and their question items, and when there is an answer that conflicts with the determination rule, may activate or visualize the menu item.

[0086] When displaying a list of question items and answers together with risk messages, the determination unit 114 may, for example, perform a conflict determination when an answer is input to each question item and store the result, and when receiving an instruction to display the list from the provider terminal 20, cause the question items, answers, and risk messages to be displayed in a list on the provider terminal 20 based on the stored determination result. Furthermore, after receiving an instruction to display the list from the provider terminal 20, the determination unit 114 may perform a conflict determination on the answers to question items for which answers have been input among multiple question items included in the survey, and after the conflict determination, cause the question items, answers, and risk messages that have been determined to be in conflict to be displayed in a list on the provider terminal 20.

[0087] The judgment unit 114 may display the question item and answer for which the risk message is displayed, and related question information including other question items and answers related to the risk message, side by side on the same screen on the provider terminal 20. This allows the service provider to check the reason for the conflict with the judgment rule from the answers to the other question items. Also, the answers to the other question items can be revised without having to display the other question items again on the provider terminal 20.

[0088] When an answer that conflicts with a judgment rule is input, the judgment unit 114 may display related question information together with a risk message on the provider terminal 20. Furthermore, the judgment unit 114 may also display related question information corresponding to each question item in a list display of a plurality of question items, answers, and risk messages that conflict with a judgment rule.

[0089] FIG. 9 is a diagram showing yet another example of the answer input screen AD displayed on the provider terminal 20. In the answer input screen AD of FIG. 9, information on related questions is displayed in the related question display field CAF together with an input form for the question for which the risk message RM is displayed. In the example of FIG. 9, the related question display field CAF is displayed next to the right of the display field for the question ("AA-1") for which the risk message RM is displayed. The related question display field CAF displays the question number, question content, inputted answer, etc. of the question ("DD-1") included in the risk message RM (for example, the question for which an answer contradicting the answer of "AA-1") has been input). Note that the related question display field CAF may accept corrections to answers.

[0090] The determination unit 114 may display an alert on the provider terminal 20 indicating that there is an answer that conflicts with the determination rules when the answer receiving unit 113 receives an instruction to send an answer to a question item. This allows the service provider to be given an opportunity to review or correct the answer before it is submitted to the evaluator. As a result, the occurrence of answer rejection is suppressed.

[0091] The alert may include conflicting question information (e.g., question number) indicating an answer or question item that conflicts with a judgment rule. If there are multiple conflicting answers, the alert may include multiple pieces of conflicting question information. Furthermore, the alert may include a risk message corresponding to the conflicting judgment rule.

[0092] The alert may include a link to a question item corresponding to the answer that violates the judgment rule, or an answer input form for the question item corresponding to the answer with the answer that violates the judgment rule displayed therein. This allows the service provider to immediately access the question item for which the answer is to be reviewed or revised, thereby reducing the time it takes for the service provider to submit the answer.

[0093] The link to the question item in the alert may be attached to the conflicting question information (e.g., question number), or may be included in the alert as an object such as a button, independent of the conflicting question information, risk message, etc. When an input operation is performed on the link in the provider terminal 20, an answer input screen (answer input field) for the linked question item is displayed on the provider terminal 20.

[0094] 10 is a diagram showing an example of a transmission confirmation screen CD displayed on the provider terminal 20. The transmission confirmation screen CD is displayed, for example, when the service provider inputs an instruction to transmit an answer to the evaluator (an instruction to request an evaluation). The transmission confirmation screen CD includes an alert message AM, a comment input field CIF, a cancel button B51, and a send button B52.

[0095] The alert message AM includes a sentence indicating that the answer contains an answer that conflicts with the judgment rule (an answer for which a risk message is displayed and the conflict has not been resolved), a keyword (question number) indicating the question item corresponding to the conflicting answer, etc. Furthermore, a link to this question item is set in the keyword indicating the question item. For example, when an input operation is performed on the link of "PU-1" in the alert message AM in the provider terminal 20, the question item and answer (input form) of "PU-1" are displayed on the provider terminal 20. Note that if the answer to be sent does not contain an answer that conflicts with the judgment rule, the alert message AM is not displayed.

[0096] The comment input field CIF accepts input of comments (handover matters) from the service provider to the evaluator. Examples of comments include the reason for inputting the answer that is the subject of the alert message AM.

[0097] The Cancel button B51 accepts input for canceling the sending of the answer. Input to the Cancel button B51 may also cause the answers that conflict with the judgment rules and their question items to be displayed in a list on the provider terminal 20. The Send button B52 accepts input for sending the answer. Input to the Send button B52 causes the answer entered by the service provider to be registered in the answer database and sent to the evaluator.

[0098] 11 is a diagram showing another example of the transmission confirmation screen CD displayed on the provider terminal 20. In the transmission confirmation screen CD of FIG. 10, a question item display field QIF is displayed in the alert message AM instead of a link ("DD-1") indicating a question item corresponding to a conflicting answer exemplified in the answer input screen AD of FIG. 9. In the question item display field QIF, question items corresponding to conflicting answers are displayed one by one, and switching objects CO on the left and right are used to switch between displayed question items. Note that the question item display field QIF may directly accept corrections to answers, or an input form for a question item displayed in the question item display field QIF may be displayed on the provider terminal 20 by selecting the question item displayed in the question item display field QIF (for example, by clicking anywhere in the display area).

[0099] The determination unit 114 displays the risk message and the alert on the provider terminal 20 using the written language of the question item (the input language of the answer). The written language of the question item is changed, for example, by a selection input from the provider terminal 20. The risk message, the alert, etc. may be registered for each of a plurality of written languages ​​(for example, Japanese and English).

[0100] <Response sending unit 115> The response sending unit 115 is configured to send the response to the security survey of the service provider, which is accepted by the response accepting unit 113, to the evaluator.

[0101] Specifically, the answer sending unit 115 receives input to a transmission input object (send button) that accepts transmission of an answer from the provider terminal 20, registers the answer of the service provider as evaluation information, and transmits the evaluation information or access information (address) to the evaluation information to the evaluator. When all answers to the mandatory questions in the security investigation have not been input, the answer sending unit 115 may set the transmission input object to an inactive state and not accept a transmission input from the service provider. Conversely, when all answers to the mandatory questions in the security investigation have been input, the answer sending unit 115 may set the transmission input object to an active state and accept a transmission input from the service provider.

[0102] "Evaluation information" is composed of the service provider's answers to a number of questions regarding the security of the service, etc., and is information that is the subject of an evaluator's check of the contents and evaluation, etc. The evaluation information may be evaluated only once or multiple times. In other words, the evaluation of the evaluation information may include an initial evaluation (so-called review), an interim evaluation, a final evaluation, etc. The initial evaluation and the interim evaluation are evaluations in which a further evaluation is performed after the evaluation. The multiple evaluations may be performed by the same evaluator, or may be performed by different evaluators (so-called reviewers, etc.). In the final evaluation, an evaluation is created that is used in a report or report to be provided to the service user. In addition, the evaluation information may be evaluated again by the evaluator when the service provider makes corrections, updates, etc.

[0103] The evaluation results of the evaluation information by the evaluator are used as part of a report or report, or as reference information. Note that the "service user" in the information processing system 1 includes not only individuals or organizations that use the service to be evaluated, but also individuals or organizations that request an evaluation of a specific service, such as a company that wants to evaluate the security of a cloud service or the like that it uses, or a company that wants to confirm the evaluation.

[0104] The evaluation information may include answers and questions corresponding to the answers, and may also include service attributes (information indicating the type of service, the destination of the service, the type of plan included in the service, or a combination of these).

[0105] The evaluation information is registered, for example, in an answer database in the storage unit 12. The answers to each question item included in the evaluation information are answers entered by the service provider for each question item presented in the input form, and are registered in the answer database. The answers to one question item may be organized in a hierarchical structure.

[0106] The answer sending unit 115 may determine whether the answer of the service provider in the security investigation includes a correction-required answer that conflicts with a determination rule in which a correction-required attribute is set, and may transmit the answer of the service provider to the evaluator if the answer does not include a correction-required answer. In other words, if the answer to be transmitted includes a correction-required answer, the answer sending unit 115 may not need to transmit the answer of the service provider to the evaluator. This can prevent answers including critical deficiencies from being transmitted to the evaluator, thereby improving the work efficiency of the evaluator.

[0107] The answer sending unit 115 may not accept a sending instruction from the service provider when a revision-required answer is included in the answer to be sent. For example, the answer sending unit 115 may inactivate a sending input object that accepts the sending of an answer when a revision-required answer exists. Conversely, the answer sending unit 115 may activate a sending input object that accepts the sending of an answer when a revision-required answer does not exist. In addition to this, the answer sending unit 115 may display on the provider terminal 20 information indicating the presence of a revision-required answer or information indicating a question item that includes a revision-required answer.

[0108] The response sending unit 115 may send information indicating the response that has not resolved the conflict with the judgment rule to the evaluator together with the response of the service provider in the security investigation. That is, the evaluation information may include information indicating the conflict with the judgment rule. This allows the evaluator to make comments, assign scores, etc. while checking the conflict with the judgment rule, thereby improving the efficiency of the evaluation work. Furthermore, the response sending unit 115 may send information indicating the attributes of the response that conflicts with the judgment rule to the evaluator.

[0109] The response sending unit 115 may receive a confirmation operation for the risk message from the service provider and send information indicating that the confirmation operation has been received to the evaluator. This allows the evaluator to confirm whether or not the service provider has confirmed the risk message and maintained the response that conflicts with the judgment rule. This improves the efficiency of tasks such as comment creation and scoring.

[0110] Examples of "confirmation operations for risk messages" include inputting information into a confirmation input object (e.g., a "confirmed" checkbox) attached to the risk message, scrolling to the end (bottom) of a screen displaying a list of answers and questions that conflict with the judgment rules, writing a comment on the conflict with the judgment rules, etc. The comment may include, for example, a supplementary explanation by the service provider when there is a contradiction between answers or when an answer is not public, the reason for inputting an answer, etc.

[0111] The response sending unit 115 may send the service provider's response to the evaluator only when the confirmation operation is accepted. In other words, the response sending unit 115 may not send the service provider's response to the evaluator when the confirmation operation is not accepted. Furthermore, the response sending unit 115 may make the confirmation operation of the risk message a prerequisite for transmission only when the response includes an answer that conflicts with a judgment rule for a predetermined attribute (for example, an answer that conflicts with a judgment rule for a high warning level).

[0112] <Evaluation Reception Department 116> The evaluation receiving unit 116 is configured to receive an evaluation of the answer of the service provider in the security investigation from the evaluator. The evaluation receiving unit 116 is configured to register the evaluated evaluation information together with the evaluation result in a response database or the like.

[0113] "Evaluation" refers to the act of checking whether there are any deficiencies in the answers included in the evaluation information, making comments on the contents of the answers, assessing the contents of the answers, scoring the answers based on predetermined criteria, etc. As described above, evaluation may be performed by multiple evaluators, or one evaluator may request other evaluators to evaluate the registered evaluation information. In this case, the evaluation receiving unit 116 may receive evaluations from other evaluators after one evaluator has performed their evaluation.

[0114] For example, when evaluation is performed in two stages, the initial evaluation (review) involves checking for deficiencies and creating issues. Subsequently, the evaluation information after the initial evaluation is subjected to a final evaluation, such as assessment and scoring of the content (answer) and creating comments on the entire evaluation information, based on a predetermined standard, and a report or report (e.g., a security report) including the results is created. The report or report is created by a final evaluator or an evaluation unit included in the control unit 11. The evaluation unit is configured to generate a part or the whole of the report or report based on the input evaluation information. The evaluation result of the evaluation information may be included in the report or report as a part of the report or report or as reference information. The report or report is transmitted to the user terminal 40 of the service user who requested the report or report.

[0115] The evaluation receiving unit 116 receives input of characters, sentences, etc. used for evaluation from the evaluator terminal 30. Note that evaluation is typically performed on evaluation information in which all questions have been answered. Evaluation information with unanswered questions (question items for which answers have not been registered) may not be subject to evaluation, and evaluation may not be received by the evaluation receiving unit 116. Even in the case of evaluation information including unanswered questions (question items for which answers have not been registered), only answered questions may be subject to partial evaluation. Furthermore, only answers that do not violate the judgment rules, or only answers that do not violate the judgment rules or for which a risk message confirmation operation has been received, may be subject to evaluation.

[0116] <Report Output Section 117> The report output unit 117 is configured to output a report or a report generated based on the evaluation received by the evaluation receiving unit 116 to the user terminal 40. The report or report includes at least the whole or part of the evaluation information input by the service provider and the evaluation result by the evaluator (e.g., evaluation value, comments, etc.).

[0117] <Display> The display unit 211 of the provider terminal 20, the display unit 311 of the evaluator terminal 30, and the display unit 411 of the user terminal 40 each display a screen indicated by the screen data transmitted from the server device 10.

[0118] <Operation acquisition part> The operation acquisition unit 212 of the provider terminal 20 accepts operations by a provider who uses the provider terminal 20. The operation acquisition unit 312 of the evaluator terminal 30 accepts operations by an evaluator who uses the evaluator terminal 30. The operation acquisition unit 412 of the user terminal 40 accepts operations by a user who uses the user terminal 40.

[0119] 3. Information processing method This section describes an information processing method of the server device 10. This information processing method is executed by a computer, with each unit of the server device 10 acting as each step.

[0120] This information processing includes a judgment rule registration step, an answer reception step, a judgment step, and an evaluation reception step. In the judgment rule registration step, input of a plurality of judgment rules for answers to questions in a security survey and risk messages corresponding to each judgment rule is received from an evaluator, and the judgment rules and the risk messages corresponding to the judgment rules are combined and registered in a database. In the answer reception step, input of answers to the questions in the survey is received from a service provider. In the judgment step, it is determined whether the input answers conflict with the judgment rules, and if there is a conflict, a risk message for the answers is displayed. In the evaluation reception step, an evaluation of the service provider's answers in the survey is received from the evaluator.

[0121] 12 is an activity diagram showing an example of the flow of information processing (security investigation processing) executed by the information processing system 1. The information processing will be described below along with each activity in this activity diagram.

[0122] The security investigation process starts with the registration of a judgment rule. The evaluator inputs the judgment rule and a risk message in association with each other at the evaluator terminal 30 (activity A101). The server device 10 accepts the judgment rule and the risk message transmitted from the evaluator terminal 30 (activity A102). Next, the server device 10 registers the accepted judgment rule and the risk message in association with each other (activity A103).

[0123] With the judgment rule and risk message registered, the service provider inputs an answer to the provider terminal 20 (activity A201). The server device 10 accepts the answer sent from the provider terminal 20 (activity A202). The server device 10 then judges whether the accepted answer conflicts with the judgment rule (activity A203). After judging the conflict, the server device 10 outputs a risk message to the provider terminal 20 according to the judgment result (activity A204). As a result, the risk message is displayed on the provider terminal 20 (activity A205).

[0124] The service provider receives the risk message and performs corresponding operations such as correcting the answer and confirming the risk message at the provider terminal 20, and also issues an instruction to transmit the answer (activity A206). The server device 10 registers the answer transmitted from the provider terminal 20 (activity A207). Next, the server device 10 transmits the registered answer to the evaluator terminal 30 (activity A208). As a result, the answer of the service provider is displayed on the evaluator terminal 30 (activity A209). The evaluator evaluates the answer at the evaluator terminal 30 and transmits the result (activity A210). The server device 10 accepts the evaluation transmitted from the evaluator terminal 30 and registers it (activity A211).

[0125] 4. Effect The operation of this embodiment can be summarized as follows. That is, when inputting an answer to a question in a security survey, the service provider (answerer) can review or correct the answer based on the risk message displayed for an incomplete answer. As a result, security can be evaluated efficiently.

[0126] Although the embodiment of the present invention has been described above, the present invention is not limited to this, and can be modified as appropriate without departing from the technical concept of the invention.

[0127] 5.Other In the above embodiment, the server device 10 performs various storage and control, but multiple external devices may be used instead of the server device 10. In other words, various information and programs may be distributed and stored in multiple external devices using block chain technology or the like.

[0128] The aspect of the present embodiment is not limited to the information processing system 1, and may be an information processing method or a program. The information processing method includes each step executed by the information processing system 1. The program causes a computer to execute each step of the information processing system 1.

[0129] It may be provided in any of the following ways:

[0130] (1) An information processing system comprising at least one processor, the processor being configured to execute each of the following steps by reading out a program: a judgment rule registration step accepts input of a plurality of judgment rules for answers to questions in a security survey from an evaluator, and a risk message corresponding to each of the judgment rules, and registers the judgment rules in combination with the risk messages corresponding to the judgment rules in a database, wherein the risk messages include text explaining matters that conflict with the judgment rules; a response acceptance step accepts input of answers to the questions in the survey from a service provider; a judgment step judges whether the input answers conflict with the judgment rules, and if there is a conflict, displays the risk message for the answers; and a rating acceptance step accepts an evaluation of the service provider's answers in the survey from the evaluator.

[0131] (2) In the information processing system described in (1) above, the judgment rules include at least one of a condition that specifies a contradiction with other answers, a condition that specifies a contradiction regarding a date, and a condition regarding the confidentiality of the answer.

[0132] (3) In the information processing system described in (2) above, the other answers include answers to other question items and answers to the same question item.

[0133] (4) In the information processing system described in any one of (1) to (3) above, the judgment rule includes a plurality of conflicting conditions, wherein the conflicting conditions specify, one by one, answer contents that constitute a condition for satisfying a conflict in one question item, and in the judgment step, when all of the plurality of conflicting conditions are satisfied, or when any of the plurality of conflicting conditions is satisfied, it is judged that there is a conflict with the judgment rule.

[0134] (5) In the information processing system according to any one of (1) to (4) above, the risk message includes a link to another question item related to the risk message.

[0135] (6) In the information processing system described in any one of (1) to (5) above, in the judgment step, when an answer is input to a question item in the survey, the risk message is displayed depending on the judgment result of whether the answer conflicts with the judgment rule.

[0136] (7) In an information processing system described in any one of (1) to (6) above, in the judgment step, the question items and answers for which the risk message is to be displayed are displayed in a list together with the risk message.

[0137] (8) In the information processing system described in any one of (1) to (7) above, in the answer receiving step, an instruction to send the answers entered in response to the questions in the survey is received from the service provider, and in the judgment step, an alert is displayed at the time of receiving the sending instruction, indicating that there is an answer that violates the judgment rule.

[0138] (9) In the information processing system described in (8) above, the alert includes a link to a question item corresponding to an answer that violates the judgment rule, or an answer input form for the question item corresponding to the answer, with the answer that violates the judgment rule displayed.

[0139] (10) In an information processing system described in any one of (1) to (9) above, in the judgment step, the question item and answer that are the subject of the risk message to be displayed and other question items and answers related to the risk message are displayed side by side on the same screen.

[0140] (11) In an information processing system according to any one of (1) to (10) above, in the judgment rule registration step, a setting of a correction requirement attribute is accepted from the evaluator for each judgment rule, indicating that an answer that conflicts with the judgment rule must be corrected, and the judgment rule and the correction requirement attribute are associated with each other and registered in the database.

[0141] (12) In the information processing system described in (11) above, in the response sending step, it is determined whether the response of the service provider in the survey includes a correction-required response that conflicts with the judgment rule in which the correction-required attribute is set, and if the correction-required response is not included, the response of the service provider is sent to the evaluator.

[0142] (13) In the information processing system described in any one of (1) to (12) above, in the response sending step, information indicating an answer that does not resolve a violation of the judgment rule is sent to the evaluator together with the service provider's response in the survey.

[0143] (14) In the information processing system described in (13) above, in the response sending step, a confirmation operation for the risk message from the service provider is accepted, and information indicating that the confirmation operation has been accepted is sent to the evaluator.

[0144] (15) An information processing method comprising steps executed by an information processing system according to any one of (1) to (14) above.

[0145] (16) A program for causing a computer to execute each step of the information processing system described in any one of (1) to (14) above. Of course, this is not the case.

[0146] Finally, although various embodiments according to the present disclosure have been described, these are presented as examples and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention. The novel embodiment can be implemented in various other forms, and various omissions, substitutions, and modifications can be made without departing from the spirit of the invention. The embodiments and their modifications are included within the scope and spirit of the invention, and are included in the scope of the invention and its equivalents described in the claims. [Explanation of symbols]

[0147] 1: Information processing system 2: Communication lines 10: Server device 11: Control section 12: Storage section 13: Communications Department 14: Communication bus 20: Provider terminal 21: Control section 22: Storage section 23: Communications Department 24: Input section 25: Output section 26: Communication bus 30: Evaluator terminal 31: Control section 32: Storage section 33: Communications Department 34: Input section 35: Output section 36: Communication bus 40: User terminal 41: Control section 42: Storage section 43: Communications Department 44: Input section 45: Output section 46: Communication bus 111: Basic display control unit 112: Judgment rule registration section 113: Answer Reception Department 114: Judgment section 115: Reply sending unit 116: Evaluation Reception Department 117: Report output section 211:Display section 212: Operation acquisition section 311: Display section 312: Operation acquisition section 411: Display section 412: Operation acquisition section AC: Answer options ACF: Overall condition input field AD: Answer input screen AF: Attribute input field AIF: Answer input field AM: Alert message B11: Registration button B12: Condition group add button B13: Delete button B14: Add input field button B21: Search execution button B41: Save answer button B42: Progress button B51: Cancel button B52: Send button CAF: Related Questions Display Area CD: Sending confirmation screen CIF: Comment input field CO : Switching object ICF: Item condition input field IF :ID input field IF1: Question entry field IF2: Answer selection input field IF3: Auxiliary condition input field LD: Judgment rule list screen LF: List display column MF: Risk message input field NF: Rule name input field QC: Question QF: Query input field QIF:Question item display field QN: Question number RD: Judgment rule registration screen RF: Judgment rule input field RM: Risk Message SC: Suboption

Claims

1. An information processing system, At least one processor; The processor is configured to execute the following steps by reading the program: In the judgment rule registration step, input of a plurality of judgment rules for answers to questions in a security survey and risk messages corresponding to each of the judgment rules is accepted from an evaluator, and the judgment rules and the risk messages corresponding to the judgment rules are combined and registered in a database, wherein the risk messages include text explaining matters that conflict with the judgment rules; In the answer receiving step, answers to the questions in the survey are received from the service provider; In the judgment step, it is judged whether the input answer conflicts with the judgment rule, and if there is a conflict, the risk message for the answer is displayed; In the evaluation receiving step, an evaluation of the answer given by the service provider in the survey is received from the evaluator; The judgment rule includes a plurality of conflicting conditions, and the conflicting conditions each specify an answer content constituting a conflicting condition in one question item, The information processing system, in the determining step, determines that there is a conflict with the determination rule when all of the plurality of conflicting conditions are satisfied or when any of the plurality of conflicting conditions is satisfied.

2. 2. The information processing system according to claim 1, The determination rule includes at least one of a condition that specifies a conflict with other answers, a condition that specifies a conflict regarding a date, and a condition regarding non-disclosure of the answer.

3. 3. The information processing system according to claim 2, The other answers include answers to other question items and answers to the same question item.

4. An information processing system, At least one processor; The processor is configured to execute the following steps by reading the program: In the judgment rule registration step, input of a plurality of judgment rules for answers to questions in a security survey and risk messages corresponding to each of the judgment rules is accepted from an evaluator, and the judgment rules and the risk messages corresponding to the judgment rules are combined and registered in a database, wherein the risk messages include text explaining matters that conflict with the judgment rules; In the answer receiving step, answers to the questions in the survey are received from the service provider; In the judgment step, it is judged whether the input answer conflicts with the judgment rule, and if there is a conflict, the risk message for the answer is displayed; In the evaluation receiving step, an evaluation of the answer given by the service provider in the survey is received from the evaluator; An information processing system, wherein the risk message includes links to other questions related to the risk message.

5. 2. The information processing system according to claim 1, In the determination step, when an answer to a question item in the survey is input, the information processing system displays the risk message according to a determination result of whether the answer conflicts with the determination rule.

6. 2. The information processing system according to claim 1, In the determining step, the information processing system displays a list of the questions and answers for which the risk message is to be displayed together with the risk message.

7. An information processing system, At least one processor; The processor is configured to execute the following steps by reading the program: In the judgment rule registration step, input of a plurality of judgment rules for answers to questions in a security survey and risk messages corresponding to each of the judgment rules is accepted from an evaluator, and the judgment rules and the risk messages corresponding to the judgment rules are combined and registered in a database, wherein the risk messages include text explaining matters that conflict with the judgment rules; In the answer receiving step, answers to the questions in the survey are received from the service provider; In the judgment step, it is judged whether the input answer conflicts with the judgment rule, and if there is a conflict, the risk message for the answer is displayed; In the evaluation receiving step, an evaluation of the answer given by the service provider in the survey is received from the evaluator; In the answer receiving step, an instruction to transmit answers inputted to questions in the survey is received from the service provider, In the determination step, an alert is displayed when the transmission instruction is received, the alert indicating that a response that conflicts with the determination rule is present; An information processing system, wherein the alert includes a link to a question item corresponding to the answer that violates the judgment rule, or an answer input form for the question item corresponding to the answer, with the answer that violates the judgment rule displayed.

8. 2. The information processing system according to claim 1, In the determining step, the information processing system displays the question item and answer for which the risk message is to be displayed and other question items and answers related to the risk message side by side on the same screen.

9. An information processing system, At least one processor; The processor is configured to execute the following steps by reading the program: In the judgment rule registration step, input of a plurality of judgment rules for answers to questions in a security survey and risk messages corresponding to each of the judgment rules is accepted from an evaluator, and the judgment rules and the risk messages corresponding to the judgment rules are combined and registered in a database, wherein the risk messages include text explaining matters that conflict with the judgment rules; In the answer receiving step, answers to the questions in the survey are received from the service provider; In the judgment step, it is judged whether the input answer conflicts with the judgment rule, and if there is a conflict, the risk message for the answer is displayed; In the evaluation receiving step, an evaluation of the answer given by the service provider in the survey is received from the evaluator; In the judgment rule registration step, an information processing system receives from the evaluator a setting of a correction requirement attribute indicating that an answer that conflicts with the judgment rule must be corrected for each judgment rule, and registers the judgment rule and the correction requirement attribute in the database in association with each other.

10. 10. The information processing system according to claim 9, In the answer sending step, the information processing system determines whether the answer provided by the service provider in the survey includes an answer that requires correction that conflicts with the judgment rule in which the required correction attribute is set, and if the answer that requires correction is not included, sends the answer provided by the service provider to the evaluator.

11. An information processing system, comprising: At least one processor; The processor is configured to execute the following steps by reading the program: In the judgment rule registration step, input of a plurality of judgment rules for answers to questions in a security survey and risk messages corresponding to each of the judgment rules is accepted from an evaluator, and the judgment rules and the risk messages corresponding to the judgment rules are combined and registered in a database, wherein the risk messages include text explaining matters that conflict with the judgment rules; In the answer receiving step, answers to the questions in the survey are received from the service provider; In the judgment step, it is judged whether the input answer conflicts with the judgment rule, and if there is a conflict, the risk message for the answer is displayed; In the evaluation receiving step, an evaluation of the answer given by the service provider in the survey is received from the evaluator; In the response sending step, the information processing system sends, to the evaluator, information indicating an answer in which a violation against the judgment rule has not been resolved, together with the answer of the service provider in the survey.

12. 12. The information processing system according to claim 11, The response sending step includes receiving a confirmation operation for the risk message from the service provider, and sending information indicating that the confirmation operation has been received to the evaluator.

13. 1. An information processing method, comprising: An information processing method comprising the steps executed by the information processing system according to any one of claims 1 to 12.

14. A program, A program for causing a computer to execute each step of the information processing system according to any one of claims 1 to 12.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Method and device for structuring security policy and method and device for supporting security policy structuring

    JP2002056176A

  • Security auditing device, security auditing method and security auditing program

    JP2004295591A

  • Security assessment support system and method, assessment item answer processor, and program

    JP2005234756A

  • Visit survey-support program, visit survey support device and control method for visit survey support device

    JP2006178852A

  • Knowledge information storage device and computer program

    JP2009003684A

Cited By

  • Information processing system, information processing method, and program

    JP7713610B1