Evaluation device, terminal, evaluation system, evaluation method, and program
The evaluation device and system address the lack of standardized cyber insurance premium calculation by assessing network equipment trustworthiness based on insurance company standards, ensuring reliable and standardized evaluation and premium determination.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2024548979
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-09-29
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-11
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-09-29
AI Technical Summary
The calculation of cyber insurance premiums is not systematically performed, and the criteria for judging the trustworthiness of network equipment vary based on the evaluator's perspective, lacking standardization in accordance with insurance company standards.
An evaluation device and system that acquires trust evaluation indices, inspects network equipment, and outputs a certificate with an electronic signature to assess trustworthiness based on insurance company standards, including devices for relaying or transferring data on a network, such as routers, hubs, and switches.
Provides a standardized evaluation tool that assesses trustworthiness in accordance with cyber insurance standards, enabling reliable determination of insurance premiums and issuing certificates to prove the evaluation results.
Smart Images

Figure 0007948325000001 
Figure 0007948325000002 
Figure 0007948325000003
Abstract
Description
TECHNICAL FIELD
[0001] The present disclosure relates to an evaluation device, a terminal, an evaluation system, an evaluation method, and a recording medium.
BACKGROUND ART
[0002] Methods for calculating insurance premiums for network devices are being studied.
[0003] For example, Patent Document 1 discloses that information assessed by selecting each assessment item related to a computer or the like is used to calculate the insurance premium for failure insurance of the computer and related devices. Patent Document 2 discloses that the insurance premium for industrial machines is calculated based on the reliability rate of the industrial machines calculated from a reliability index indicating how much various functions contribute to the reliability of various elements related to the industrial machines.
PRIOR ART DOCUMENTS
PATENT DOCUMENTS
[0004]
PATENT DOCUMENT 1
PATENT DOCUMENT 2
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
PROBLEMS TO BE SOLVED BY THE INVENTION
[0005] By the way, demand for cyber insurance that compensates for security risks is increasing. However, the calculation of cyber insurance premiums and the calculation of payment amounts at the time of incident occurrence may not be systematically performed in some cases.
[0006] Furthermore, the criteria for judging the trustworthiness of network equipment differ depending on the perspective and viewpoint of the evaluator. In the inventions described in Patent Documents 1 and 2, the information that forms the basis for calculating insurance premiums is assessed based on the evaluator's criteria. Trustworthiness for calculating cyber insurance needs to be evaluated based on the indicators adopted by the insurance company selling cyber insurance.
[0007] One example of the purpose of this disclosure is to provide an evaluation device that can assess the trustworthiness of a cyber insurance policy in accordance with the standards adopted by insurance companies. [Means for solving the problem]
[0008] An evaluation apparatus in one aspect of this disclosure comprises: an evaluation index acquisition means for acquiring a trust evaluation index for evaluating the trustworthiness adopted by an insurance company; an equipment information acquisition means for acquiring equipment information of network equipment on a network insured by a user business operator; an inspection means for inspecting network equipment using the equipment information based on the trust evaluation index; an evaluation means for evaluating trustworthiness based on the inspection results; and an output means for outputting the trustworthiness evaluation results.
[0009] An evaluation system in one aspect of the present disclosure is an evaluation system comprising a device information storage device for storing device information of network devices and the evaluation device described above, wherein the evaluation device includes: an evaluation index acquisition means for acquiring a trust evaluation index for evaluating the trustworthiness adopted by an insurance company; a device information acquisition means for acquiring device information of network devices on a network insured by a user business operator from the device information storage device; an inspection means for inspecting network devices using the device information based on the trust evaluation index; an evaluation means for evaluating trustworthiness based on the inspection results; and an output means for issuing a certificate to prove the trustworthiness evaluation result, and storing the certificate with an electronic signature in the device information storage device.
[0010] An evaluation method in one aspect of this disclosure involves a computer acquiring trust evaluation metrics for evaluating trustworthiness adopted by an insurance company, acquiring equipment information of network equipment on a network insured by a user business, inspecting the network equipment using the equipment information based on the trust evaluation metrics, evaluating trustworthiness based on the inspection results, and outputting the trustworthiness evaluation results.
[0011] A recording medium in one aspect of this disclosure stores a program that causes a computer to perform the following actions: acquire trust evaluation indicators for evaluating trustworthiness adopted by an insurance company; acquire device information of network devices on a network insured by a user business operator; inspect the network devices using the device information based on the trust evaluation indicators; evaluate trustworthiness based on the inspection results; and output the trustworthiness evaluation results. [Effects of the Invention]
[0012] One example of the effects of this disclosure is the ability to provide an evaluation tool that can assess the trustworthiness of a company in accordance with the cyber insurance standards adopted by insurance companies. [Brief explanation of the drawing]
[0013] [Figure 1] Figure 1 is a block diagram showing the configuration of the evaluation system in the first embodiment. [Figure 2] Figure 2 shows the hardware configuration of the evaluation device in the first embodiment, which is implemented using a computer and its peripheral devices. [Figure 3] Figure 3 is a flowchart of the evaluation system in the first embodiment. [Modes for carrying out the invention]
[0014] Next, embodiments will be described in detail with reference to the drawings.
[0015] [First Embodiment] The evaluation device 100 in the first embodiment is, for example, a device used by an insurance company that provides cyber insurance to a user business operator's network to evaluate the trustworthiness of the network equipment that constitutes the network. The cyber insurance in this embodiment includes liability for damages to third parties due to cyber incidents such as cyberattacks, as well as repair costs necessary for network restoration. Network equipment refers to devices used for relaying or transferring data on a network, such as routers, hubs, gateways, or switches. Furthermore, the network in this embodiment refers to a network composed of network equipment introduced by the user business operator.
[0016] The evaluation system 10 in this embodiment includes an evaluation device 100, an insurance company terminal 200 of an insurance company that requests the evaluation device 100 to evaluate the trustworthiness of network equipment, and an equipment information storage device 300 that stores equipment information for each network device. The equipment information storage device 300 is owned by a platform operator that manages the equipment information for each network device. The insurance company may, for example, request a third-party evaluation organization to evaluate the trustworthiness of network equipment through the platform operator.
[0017] The insurance company terminal 200 includes an evaluation index transmission unit 201, a certificate acquisition unit 202, a verification unit 203, and a determination unit 204, which transmit trust evaluation indicators adopted by the user company to the evaluation device 100. When the evaluation index transmission unit 201 transmits trust evaluation indicators to the evaluation device 100, it may also transmit information indicating that the user company has requested the user company to subscribe to cyber insurance. The insurance company terminal 200 is not limited to a terminal; it may also be implemented as a server (including the cloud).
[0018] The device information storage device 300 stores at least the configuration information and inspection information of the network equipment as device information. The device information stored in the device information storage device 300 is updated in accordance with the replacement of network equipment or the software version upgrade.
[0019] Figure 1 is a block diagram showing the configuration of the evaluation apparatus 100 according to the first embodiment. Referring to Figure 1, the evaluation apparatus 100 includes an evaluation index acquisition unit 101, a device information acquisition unit 102, an inspection unit 103, an evaluation unit 104, and an output unit 105. Hereinafter, the evaluation apparatus 100 of the present embodiment will be described in detail.
[0020] Figure 2 is a diagram showing an example of a hardware configuration in which the evaluation apparatus 100 according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure is implemented by a computer apparatus 500 including a processor. As shown in Figure 2, the evaluation apparatus 100 includes a CPU (Central Processing Unit) 501, a ROM (Read Only Memory) 502, a RAM (Random Access Memory) 503 and other memories, a storage device 505 such as a hard disk storing a program 504, a communication I / F (Interface) 508 for network connection, and an input / output interface 511 for inputting and outputting data. In the first embodiment, the trust evaluation index acquired by the evaluation index acquisition unit 101 is input to the evaluation apparatus 100 via the communication I / F 508, for example.
[0021] The CPU 501 operates an operating system to control the entire evaluation apparatus 100 according to the first embodiment of the present invention. In addition, the CPU 501 reads programs and data from a recording medium 506 mounted on, for example, a drive device 507 into the memory. Further, the CPU 501 functions as the evaluation index acquisition unit 101, the device information acquisition unit 102, the inspection unit 103, the evaluation unit 104, the output unit 105, and a part of these units in the first embodiment, and executes the processes or instructions in the flowchart shown in Figure 3 described later based on the program.
[0022] The recording medium 506 is, for example, an optical disk, a flexible disk, a magneto-optical disk, an external hard disk, a semiconductor memory, or the like. Some of the recording media of the storage device are non-volatile storage devices, on which the programs are recorded. In addition, the program may be downloaded from an unillustrated external computer connected to a communication network.
[0023] The input device 509 is implemented as, for example, a mouse, keyboard, or built-in key buttons, and is used for input operations. The input device 509 is not limited to a mouse, keyboard, or built-in key buttons; it may also be, for example, a touch panel. The output device 510 is implemented as, for example, a display, and is used to confirm the output.
[0024] As described above, the first embodiment shown in Figure 1 is realized by the computer hardware shown in Figure 2. However, the means for realizing each part of the evaluation device 100 in Figure 1 are not limited to the configuration described above. The evaluation device 100 may also be realized by a single physically coupled device, or by two or more physically separated devices connected by wired or wireless connections. For example, the input device 509 and the output device 510 may be connected to the computer device 500 via a network. Furthermore, the evaluation device 100 in the first embodiment shown in Figure 1 can also be configured using cloud computing or the like.
[0025] In Figure 1, the evaluation index acquisition unit 101 is a means for acquiring trust evaluation indices for evaluating the trustworthiness adopted by insurance companies. In this embodiment, the evaluation index acquisition unit 101 acquires trust evaluation indices from the evaluation index transmission unit 201 via a network.
[0026] Trustworthiness refers to the reliability of an entire network composed of multiple network devices, for example, the reliability of maintaining the stable operation of the entire network. Trust evaluation indicators are perspectives for evaluating trustworthiness, and include the existence of risks in network devices, countermeasures against those risks, the presence or absence of malicious functions such as backdoors, inspection status, and the visibility of device information.
[0027] The results of the trustworthiness assessment are referenced by insurance companies when underwriting insurance for user businesses, etc. Since trustworthiness is used for judgment by third parties, including user businesses and insurance companies, it is desirable that it be expressed in a way that facilitates objective determination. However, trustworthiness is not limited to numerical values; it may also be data in a format other than numerical values such as A-C. Specifically, trustworthiness can be expressed in the following ways, for example:
[0028] (1) Risk of shutdown Trustworthiness regarding downtime risk includes the likelihood of network equipment failure and the predicted downtime if failure occurs. Alternatively, downtime risk can be defined as the average interval between failures or the average recovery time. Downtime risk may also refer to the downtime risk of only a portion of the network equipment. For example, network equipment with low downtime risk is more trustworthy than network equipment with high downtime risk.
[0029] (2) Risk of information leakage Trustworthiness regarding information leakage risk is determined by factors such as whether or not information leakage has occurred or is likely to have occurred with network equipment, and the status of information leakage countermeasures. The status of information leakage countermeasures can include, for example, whether all information leakage countermeasures have been implemented, whether measures against major information leakage have been implemented, whether information leakage countermeasures are understood, or whether countermeasures are not understood. For example, network equipment with a low information leakage risk is more trustworthy than network equipment with a high information leakage risk.
[0030] (3) Back door Trustworthiness regarding backdoors depends on the presence or absence of backdoors in network devices, or the possibility of their existence. Alternatively, trustworthiness regarding backdoors can also depend on the inspection status of backdoors in network devices, such as the inspection method, scope, or timing of the inspection. Backdoor inspection methods include, for example, inspection using inspection applications, binary inspection of programs running on network devices, or source code inspection of programs. For example, network devices that have been inspected for backdoors are more trustworthy than network devices that have not been inspected for backdoors.
[0031] (4) Risk assessment The trustworthiness of a risk assessment depends on factors such as whether or not a risk assessment inspection of network equipment vulnerabilities was conducted, the inspection results, the status of implemented countermeasures, the timing of the inspection, or the time elapsed since the inspection. The status of implemented vulnerability countermeasures can include measures taken for all vulnerabilities, measures taken for critical vulnerabilities, measures taken for vulnerabilities are known, or measures are not known. For example, network equipment that has undergone a risk assessment inspection is more trustworthy than network equipment that has not undergone a risk assessment inspection.
[0032] (5) Incident response The trustworthiness of an incident response refers to the defined state of the response when an incident occurs in the network. The trustworthiness of an incident response may include the scope of incidents for which a response is defined, such as defined responses for critical incidents. For example, network devices with defined incident responses are more trustworthy than network devices for which incident responses are not defined.
[0033] (6) Performance evaluation test results The trustworthiness of performance evaluation test results depends on whether or not performance evaluation test results are available, and the performance content described in those results. The trustworthiness of performance evaluation test results can also depend on the performance evaluation status, such as the test methodology, scope, timing, or elapsed time since the test was conducted. For example, network equipment that has undergone performance evaluation is more trustworthy than network equipment that has not undergone performance evaluation.
[0034] (7) Business The trustworthiness of a business operation depends on the user's understanding of the business operations and their readiness for recovery. Understanding of business operations includes, for example, the understanding of the scope of impact of each operation or the understanding of the priority of each operation. For example, network equipment whose operations are understood has higher trustworthiness than network equipment whose operations are not understood. Readiness for recovery is, for example, the readiness to recover operations with a large scope of impact or high priority in the event of an incident. For example, network equipment for which recovery is prepared has higher trustworthiness than network equipment for which recovery is not prepared.
[0035] (8) Developers Developer trustworthiness depends on the level of understanding regarding the attributes of the network device's developers. This understanding can range from knowing all developers' attributes, to knowing some attributes, or knowing some developers' attributes. Attributes can include nationality, affiliation, development location, or past experience. Developer attributes are not limited to individuals; they can also include attributes of corporations or organizations such as development manufacturers. For example, network devices whose developers' attributes are known are more trustworthy than those whose developers' attributes are unknown.
[0036] (9) Supply chain The trustworthiness of a supply chain refers to the trustworthiness of the companies involved in the supply chain of network equipment. Companies involved in the supply chain include, for example, companies that design, provide, maintain, and manage network equipment. Furthermore, the trustworthiness of a company refers to, for example, the status of trust inspections conducted by each company and the content of the inspection results. The status of inspections includes whether or not inspections were conducted, the scope of inspections that have been conducted, or the scope of inspections that have not been conducted. For example, network equipment whose trustworthiness has been inspected by the companies in the supply chain is more trustworthy than network equipment whose trustworthiness has not been inspected by the companies in the supply chain.
[0037] Trust evaluation indicators are evaluation indicators for evaluating the trustworthiness of network equipment in accordance with the needs of user businesses. For example, trust evaluation indicators are evaluation indicators for the above-mentioned trustworthiness items, such as "presence or absence of backdoors." Trust evaluation indicators may be a single evaluation indicator, a set of multiple evaluation indicators, an integrated evaluation indicator, or an evaluation indicator calculated using multiple evaluation indicators such as an average. Insurance companies may create trust evaluation indicators in accordance with the trustworthiness required of network equipment by user businesses, or they may obtain trust evaluation indicators from a third-party organization or platform provider. The evaluation indicator acquisition unit 101 outputs the acquired trust evaluation indicators to the inspection unit 103.
[0038] The device information acquisition unit 102 is a means of acquiring device information of network devices on the network that are insured by the user business operator. The device information acquisition unit 102 acquires device information of the network device to be evaluated from the device information storage device 300, for example. Device information is information necessary to evaluate the trustworthiness of network devices and includes configuration information and inspection information. The device information storage device 300 stores configuration information and inspection information associated with each network device, for example.
[0039] Configuration information includes, for example, hardware and software information for network equipment. Hardware information includes developer information, model numbers of chips, boards, ports, etc. that make up the hardware, and identifiers assigned to the hardware. Software information includes developer information, the operating system (OS) that processes the hardware, the name of the software such as libraries or applications, the version information of that software, and the code information of the software. Configuration information is updated when the configuration information is updated, such as when the software is updated to a new version.
[0040] Inspection information refers to information regarding the results of inspections conducted by businesses in the supply chain, from the procurement of network equipment components to delivery, based on the configuration information of the network equipment. Inspection information includes the backdoor or risk assessment inspections mentioned above. When the equipment information acquisition unit 102 acquires the equipment information of the network equipment to be evaluated, it outputs it to the inspection unit 103.
[0041] The inspection unit 103 is a means of inspecting network equipment using equipment information based on trust evaluation indicators. The specific inspection method is as follows: The inspection unit 103 creates inspection items for network equipment to evaluate the trustworthiness of the network equipment based on configuration information and trust evaluation indicators. For example, the inspection unit 103 creates inspection items to evaluate the trust evaluation indicators for the network equipment to be evaluated.
[0042] In other words, for each of the trust evaluation indicators (1) to (9) described above, the items to be inspected are predetermined, and the inspection unit 103 selects inspection items according to the trust evaluation indicator selected for the insured network equipment or network. For example, if the trust evaluation indicator is a backdoor, the inspection unit 103 creates an inspection item to check for the possibility of a backdoor in the network equipment being inspected. The inspection unit 103 may create multiple inspection items for a single trust evaluation indicator, or it may create one inspection item for multiple trust evaluation indicators.
[0043] Next, the inspection unit 103 inspects the network equipment for each created inspection item using the evaluation criteria of the trust evaluation index. The inspection unit 103 may indicate the inspection results for each trust evaluation index as a binary value of 0 or 100, or as a specific rank such as A to C. Alternatively, the inspection unit 103 may indicate the inspection results for each trust evaluation index as a numerical value (score) such as 0 to 100%.
[0044] The evaluation unit 104 is a means of evaluating trustworthiness based on the inspection results. The evaluation unit 104 comprehensively evaluates the trustworthiness of network equipment based on the inspection results of each trust evaluation index.
[0045] The evaluation unit 104 evaluates trustworthiness, for example, by calculating the sum or average value of the inspection results for each trust evaluation indicator. The evaluation unit 104 may also determine that trustworthiness is not met if the inspection result for any of the trust evaluation indicators is 0, or if the inspection result for a predetermined trust evaluation indicator falls below a certain level. However, the evaluation method of trustworthiness by the evaluation unit 104 is not limited to these.
[0046] The output unit 105 is a means for outputting the trustworthiness evaluation results of network equipment. The output unit 105 displays the trustworthiness evaluation results on an output device 510 such as a display. The output unit 105 may also output the trustworthiness evaluation results of network equipment to a user business or an insurance company. The output unit 105 may also issue a certificate to prove the trustworthiness evaluation results. The certificate is issued to a third party, including the user business and the insurance company, to prove the trustworthiness evaluation results of network equipment. In this case, the output unit 105 electronically signs the certificate containing the trustworthiness evaluation results and stores it in the equipment information storage device 300 along with the public key.
[0047] Next, the configuration of the insurance company terminal 200 will be described. The insurance company terminal 200 performs the processing up to determining the insurance premium when a certificate of trust evaluation results is issued by the output unit 105. The certificate acquisition unit 202 is a means for acquiring the certificate issued by the evaluation device 100. The certificate acquisition unit 202 acquires the certificate stored in the equipment information storage device 300. Alternatively, the certificate acquisition unit 202 may acquire the certificate acquired by the user business from the equipment information storage device 300 from the user business. The certificate acquisition unit 202 outputs the acquired certificate to the verification unit 203.
[0048] The verification unit 203 is a means of verifying, based on the certificate, whether the network equipment installed by the user business is identical to the insured network equipment. Specifically, the verification unit 203 decrypts the hash value of the digital signature contained in the certificate input from the certificate acquisition unit 202 using a public key and compares it with the hash value of the network equipment installed by the user business to verify its identity with the network equipment installed by the user business. If the two network devices are not identical, the verification unit 203 requests a third-party organization to re-evaluate the trustworthiness of the network equipment identical to the network equipment installed by the user business.
[0049] The determination unit 204 is a means of determining the insurance premium based on the trust evaluation results. The determination unit 204 increases or decreases the insurance premium from a predetermined standard premium based on the level of trust for each trust evaluation indicator. For example, for (4) Risk Assessment, one of the examples of trust evaluation indicators mentioned above, the determination unit 204 increases the insurance premium from the standard premium if countermeasures for vulnerabilities are not known. On the other hand, the determination unit 204 decreases the insurance premium from the standard premium if countermeasures for vulnerabilities are known. The determination unit 204 may also determine the degree of increase or decrease from the standard premium based on the degree to which countermeasures for vulnerabilities are known.
[0050] Furthermore, the decision unit 204 determines that, regarding (5) incident response, one of the examples of trustworthiness evaluation indicators, if countermeasures against risks are defined and incident response is easy, the premium will be reduced from the standard premium. On the other hand, the decision unit 204 determines that if countermeasures against risks are not defined and incident response is difficult, the premium will be increased from the standard premium.
[0051] Furthermore, the decision unit 204 will reduce the insurance premium from the standard premium if it is prepared to restore operations starting with the highest priority operations when an incident occurs. On the other hand, the decision unit 204 will increase the insurance premium from the standard premium if it is not prepared to restore operations starting with the highest priority operations when an incident occurs.
[0052] The determination unit 204 may notify the user business operator of the insurance premium for the user business operator's network that has been determined in this manner.
[0053] The operation of the evaluation system 10, configured as described above, will be explained with reference to the flowchart in Figure 3.
[0054] Figure 3 is a flowchart outlining the operation of the evaluation device 100 in the first embodiment. Note that the processing shown in this flowchart may be executed based on the program control by the processor described above.
[0055] As shown in Figure 3, first, the evaluation index transmission unit 201 in the insurance company terminal 200 transmits the trust evaluation index adopted by the insurance company to the evaluation device 100 (step S101). Next, the evaluation index acquisition unit 101 in the evaluation device 100 acquires the trust evaluation index adopted by the insurance company from the insurance company terminal 200 (step S102). Next, the equipment information acquisition unit 102 acquires equipment information of network equipment on the network insured by the user business operator (step S103). Next, the inspection unit 103 inspects the network equipment based on the trust evaluation index (step S104). Next, the evaluation unit 104 evaluates the trust level based on the inspection results (step S105). Next, the output unit 105 issues a certificate to prove the trust level evaluation result (step S106).
[0056] Meanwhile, the certificate acquisition unit 202 in the insurance company terminal 200 acquires the certificate issued by the evaluation device 100 (step S107). The verification unit 203 uses the certificate to verify whether the network equipment installed by the user business is identical to the network equipment covered by the insurance (step S108). Finally, the determination unit 204, after verifying the identity of both network devices, determines the insurance premium for the network composed of the network equipment based on the trust evaluation result (step S109). With this, the evaluation system 10 terminates its operation.
[0057] In this embodiment, the evaluation device 100 includes an evaluation index acquisition unit 101 that acquires trust evaluation indexes adopted by the insurance company, an inspection unit 103 that inspects network equipment based on the trust evaluation indexes, and an evaluation unit 104 that evaluates the trustworthiness based on the inspection results. This makes it possible to evaluate trustworthiness in accordance with the cyber insurance standards adopted by the insurance company.
[0058] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the output unit 105 issues a certificate by attaching an electronic signature to the trustworthiness evaluation result. This ensures the legitimacy of the trustworthiness evaluation result. Insurance companies that have obtained a trustworthiness certificate can use legitimate trustworthiness evaluation results and determine cyber insurance premiums for user businesses' networks based on highly reliable trustworthiness evaluation results.
[0059] A modified version of this embodiment will be described, focusing on the differences from the first embodiment. In the first embodiment, the inspection unit 103 performed all inspections to evaluate the trust evaluation index. In contrast, the modified version assumes that the user business operator has already performed a trust evaluation of the network equipment. In this case, the network equipment is inspected only for items that have not yet been inspected, using the results of the trust evaluation that have already been performed. That is, the inspection unit 103 creates inspection items that have not yet been performed in order to evaluate the trust evaluation index. Next, the inspection unit 103 inspects the network equipment using the evaluation criteria of the trust evaluation index for each created inspection item. For example, if the presence or absence of a backdoor is included as an inspection item of the trust evaluation index, but a backdoor inspection has already been performed, the inspection unit 103 omits creating an inspection item for the presence or absence of a backdoor. Furthermore, the evaluation unit 104 evaluates the trust based on the inspection results performed by the inspection unit 103 and the inspection results already performed by the user business operator. However, even if the user company has conducted a trustworthiness assessment of the network equipment, if the inspection is conducted before the specified time, the inspection unit 103 may perform all inspections to evaluate the trustworthiness indicators without using the inspection results conducted by the user company. The configuration of the evaluation device 100 other than the inspection unit 103 and the evaluation unit 104 is the same.
[0060] In this modified example, the determination unit 204 in the insurance company terminal 200 determines the insurance premium based on the inspection items performed by the inspection unit 103, if the user business operator has performed a trustworthiness assessment of the network equipment. Specifically, the determination unit 204 deducts from the insurance premium calculated based on the trustworthiness assessment results the costs corresponding to the items that the inspection unit 103 did not inspect.
[0061] Although the present invention has been described above with reference to the embodiments described, the present invention is not limited to the above embodiments. Various modifications to the configuration and details of the present invention can be made that will be understood by those skilled in the art within the scope of the present invention.
[0062] For example, although multiple operations are described sequentially in flowchart format, the order in which they are described does not limit the order in which the operations are performed. Therefore, when implementing each embodiment, the order of the operations can be changed as long as it does not impair the content. In the flowchart of Figure 3, in step S106, the output unit 105 issued a certificate to prove the trustworthiness evaluation result. However, the output unit 105 could simply output the trustworthiness evaluation result to the output device 510. In this case, no further processing would be performed at the insurance company terminal 200. [Explanation of Symbols]
[0063] 10. Evaluation System 100 Evaluation device 101 Evaluation Metric Acquisition Section 102 Device information acquisition section 103 Inspection Department 104 Evaluation Department 105 Output section 200 Insurance Company Terminals 201 Evaluation Metric Transmission Unit 202 Certificate Acquisition Section 203 Verification Unit 204 Decision Section 300 Equipment information storage device
Claims
1. A means for obtaining trust evaluation indicators to assess the trustworthiness adopted by insurance companies, A means for obtaining device information of network equipment on a network that is insured by a user business operator, An inspection means generates inspection items for evaluating the trustworthiness of the network equipment using the trust evaluation index and the equipment information, and for each inspection item, inspects the network equipment using the equipment information based on the trust evaluation index; An evaluation means for evaluating trustworthiness based on the results of the aforementioned inspection, An evaluation device comprising an output means for outputting the trustworthiness evaluation results.
2. The evaluation apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the output means issues a certificate for certifying the trustworthiness evaluation result.
3. The evaluation apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the inspection means, when the user business operator is conducting an evaluation of the trustworthiness of the network equipment, inspects the network equipment with respect to items among the generated inspection items that were not inspected in the trustworthiness evaluation.
4. The evaluation apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the equipment information includes the configuration information and inspection information of the network equipment.
5. A certificate acquisition means for acquiring a certificate issued by the evaluation device described in claim 2, A verification means for verifying whether the network equipment installed by the user business is identical to the insured network equipment, based on the aforementioned certificate, After the aforementioned verification, a determination means determines the insurance premium for the network composed of the network equipment based on the trustworthiness evaluation results, A terminal equipped with the following features.
6. The terminal according to claim 5, wherein the determination means calculates the insurance premium based on the inspection items performed when the user business operator has performed an evaluation of the trustworthiness of the network equipment.
7. A device information storage device that stores device information of the aforementioned network device, An evaluation system comprising an evaluation device described in any one of claims 1 to 4, The evaluation device includes an evaluation index acquisition means for acquiring trust evaluation indices for evaluating the trustworthiness adopted by insurance companies, A means for acquiring device information of network devices on a network that a user business insures, obtained from the aforementioned device information storage device, An inspection means generates inspection items for evaluating the trustworthiness of the network equipment using the trust evaluation index and the equipment information, and for each inspection item, inspects the network equipment using the equipment information based on the trust evaluation index; An evaluation means for evaluating trustworthiness based on the results of the aforementioned inspection, An evaluation system comprising: an output means for issuing a certificate to prove the results of the trustworthiness evaluation, and storing the certificate with an electronic signature in the device information storage device.
8. Computers We obtain trust evaluation metrics used by insurance companies to assess their trustworthiness. The user company obtains device information for network equipment on the network that it insures, Using the trust evaluation index and the equipment information, inspection items for evaluating the trustworthiness of the network equipment are generated, and for each inspection item, the network equipment is inspected using the equipment information based on the trust evaluation index. Based on the results of the aforementioned inspection, we evaluated the trustworthiness. An evaluation method for outputting the results of the trustworthiness evaluation.
9. We obtain trust evaluation metrics used by insurance companies to assess their trustworthiness. The user company obtains device information for network equipment on the network that it insures, Using the trust evaluation index and the equipment information, inspection items for evaluating the trustworthiness of the network equipment are generated, and for each inspection item, the network equipment is inspected using the equipment information based on the trust evaluation index. Based on the results of the aforementioned inspection, we evaluated the trustworthiness. A program that causes a computer to output the results of the trustworthiness evaluation.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Fault insurance service system for computer and related apparatus
JP2006235961A
Method and apparatus for ephemeral trust devices
JP2013541087A
Risk evaluation system and risk evaluation method
JP2016143299A
Reliability calculation device and premium calculation device
JP2022011368A
Backdoor inspection device, user device, system, method, and non-transitory computer-readable medium
WO2021029160A1
