Computer-implemented method for generation of specific scenarios for urban planning
The method uses action cards on a map to select objectives and constraints for urban planning, enabling the generation of optimized scenarios for infrastructure systems, addressing the limitations of existing tools by simplifying the input process and achieving efficient, intuitive optimization of urban planning problems.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/IB2024/054753
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-05-16
- Filing Date
- 2024-05-16
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
AI Technical Summary
Current urban planning simulation tools are limited in their ability to compute optimal solutions for urban infrastructure systems, as they rely on predefined scenarios and lack intuitive interfaces for selecting and inputting complex constraints and objectives, making it difficult to achieve multidimensional optimization goals efficiently.
A computer-implemented method that uses action cards to intuitively select objectives and constraints on a map, allowing users to generate optimized scenarios for infrastructure systems like heating, power, transport, and communication, by displaying a map with action cards that define objectives and constraints, enabling users to select elements and apply actions within given boundaries.
This method simplifies the selection of objectives and constraints, allowing for the generation of optimized urban planning scenarios in a time-efficient and intuitive manner, facilitating the computation of global optimum solutions for complex planning objectives, even for users without in-depth knowledge of urban planning or specific infrastructure systems.
Smart Images

Figure IB2024054753_21112024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Computer-implemented method for generation of specific scenarios for urban planningTechnical domain
[0001] The present invention concerns a computer-implemented method for generation of scenarios for urban infrastructure that require taking many georeferenced decisions, in particular generation of scenarios for heating, power, transport, sanitation, and / or communication infrastructure systems in urban planning projects.Related art
[0002] Designing and developing urban, rural and / or regional areas, also referred to as "urban planning", is a complex undertaking. To meet the needs of a community living in an area, the efficient use of building and transport infrastructure, its sanitation system, power, communication and heating systems, as well as the cost of implementing these structures and their impact on the environment, need to be carefully weighted and considered in the planning of the area.
[0003] A variety of different disciplines, such as architecture and engineering, contribute to meeting the multiple objectives defined for an area under development. Urban planning projects need to comply with regulatory and statutory requirements, and to correspond to the needs of the community.
[0004] A number of tools and methods have been developed for simulating urban infrastructures and energy consumption in an urban region. For example, https: / / www.youtube.com / watch?v=Q02ktyn4PnA is a tutorial for SimStadt software. User interface elements allow the selection of some elements from the map, such as buildings according to their age or roof surface. Other elements from the user interface can be used for entering hypotheses such as a proportion of heating of a certain type in a city or district. The software can then simulate anenvironmental analysis, for example to estimate the energy consumption of selected buildings. The tool can be used for simulating a predefined urban context, but not for computing an optimal solution to an urban planning problem.
[0005] Houet TT et AL., « Combining narrative and modelling approaches to simulate fine scale and long-term urban growth scenarios for climate adaptation », Environmental modelling & Software, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Vol. 86, N°48, 20 sept. 2016, pages 1-13, describes another simulation tool. The user interface is not described. The method cannot be used for computing optimal solutions to urban planning problems.
[0006] LI FENGQI et AL., « Infomorphism : Urban Planning For renewable energy Intergration Via Simulated Energy Exchange Networks », 2022 Annual modeling and simulation conference, 18 July 2022, pages 500-511, describes yet another simulation tool for simulating a predefined scenario.
[0007] ZHANG XINGXING et AL., « A review of urban energy systems at building cluster level incorporating renewable-energy-source (RES) envelope solutions », Applied Energy, Elsevier science publishers, vol. 230, 11 September 2018, pages 1034-1056 describes another simulation tool without any indications about the user interface and without any optimisation functions.
[0008] https: / / www.youtube.com / watch?v=fDlxiTeLGgk is a tutorial for the simulation software «City Energy Analystw
[0009] By simulating a predefined urban scenario, e.g. the current situation in an urban area and various other predefined scenarios that could be considered, it is possible to compare the impact of these different scenarios and choose the best. However, the number of possible scenarios for improving the planning of an area, such as the planning of energy networks in a district, is so large that it is hardly possible to consider and simulate them all. The efficiency of urban planning that can be achieved with the above simulation software therefore depends on thedesigner's intuition when predefining one or more scenarios before simulating them.
[0010] There is a need, however, for software tools that go beyond simulation alone, and which can be used to calculate an optimal solution to an urban spatial optimization problem, particularly one involving the optimization of energy infrastructure in an urban area.
[0011] Optimization relates to the selection of a best solution, with regards to some objectives, from a set of available alternatives. In the context of the invention, optimization relates to the computer-implemented selection of an optimized scenario for urban planning scenario among a plurality of possible scenarios.
[0012] Determining an optimal solution to an optimization problem depends first and foremost on the objective, i.e., on the parameter to be optimized. For example, one designer may seek to minimize greenhouse gas emissions, while another may seek to optimize the cost of transformations.
[0013] In most real life situations, some constraints apply to the optimization. In the case of a renovation, for example, certain buildings will have to be excluded from the renovation plan, or other regulatory or financial constraints will have to be taken into account.
[0014] Different algorithms exist to compute and optimize such planning scenarios based on constraints defined by a user. However, the selection and compilation of such constraints is a complex task and little guidance is available to facilitate inputting of the various pieces of information which are required to obtain a meaningful and effective solution adequately, accounting for a plurality of key aspects to achieve a particular urban planning objective. More advanced user interfaces are needed to enter spatial objectives and constraints in relation with elements or portions or a territory.
[0015] Inputs to a machine learning system, or in general to a module for determining an optimal solution to a problem, are called prompts. In the field of text generation using generative Al, the prompt is most often a question in the form of free text. In the field of urban planning scenario optimization, the prompt is often complex, involving numerous constraints and prior choices to be applied to a spatial area in order to achieve one or more optimization objectives. As the problem of urban planning is multidimensional, it frequently involves the selection and setting of several constraints among a large collection of possibilities. Prior art user interfaces, such as graphical user interfaces based on drop-down menus, are limited since they are unable to arrange all the selection options on the limited area of common computer display.
[0016] There is a need for a process to make the introduction of such prompts into the field of urban planning optimization simpler, faster and more efficient.
[0017] Another problem might include the difficulty to remember, retrieve and / or edit complex inputs which are numerous and spatially dependent.
[0018] This invention sets out to facilitate the provision and the application of constraints to automatically generate an optimized solution to achieve urban planning objectives.Short disclosure of the invention
[0019] It is an aim of the present invention to provide an input method which facilitates the selection of a plurality of objectives and constraints for generating an optimized scenario for the design of infrastructure systems in a spatial region.
[0020] . The input method should enable the user to enter the required information (the "prompt") in a time-efficient, intuitive and simple manner for computation of an adequate, for example an optimized, solution of an urban planning problem.
[0021] Within the invention, such an appropriate scenario can be automatically generated based on the selected constraints and objectives.
[0022] The scenario might be an urban planning scenario, for example a scenario for heating, power, transport, sanitation and / or communication systems for a spatial region.
[0023] It is yet another aim of this invention to provide an alternative method for generating urban planning scenarios, in particular to provide an alternative input method of inputing objectives constraints to a computation system in order to generate a scenario for urban planning.
[0024] According to the present invention, one or more of these aims are attained by the object of the attached claims, and especially by the independent claims. The dependent claims concern advantageous embodiments of the independent claims.
[0025] In particular, one or more of these aims are attained by a computer- implemented method to automatically generate an optimized scenario for the design of infrastructure systems, for example urban energy infrastructure systems such as heating, power, transport, sanitation, and / or communication systems, in a spatial region, comprising the steps of displaying on a display a map of a spatial region, simultaneously displaying a plurality of action cards onto said display, selecting at least one element of the spatial region displayed on the map, selecting an action card defining an objective for the scenario, selecting an action cards defining a constraint, for the scenario.
[0026] This method allows to select elements (e.g. buildings, streets, map sections, etc.) to be optimized, to define the objective of this optimization (e.g. to reduce CO2 emissions), and to define constraints for calculating the optimized solution (e.g. to intervene only on buildings heated by fossil fuels, etc.). All those elements of the optimization prompt are entered with similar user interface elements, i.e., action cards.
[0027] Some constraints and some objectives may be geo-referenced, i.e. apply to an optimization of a predefined spatial region.
[0028] At least one of the action cards may indicate an action. An action may be selected by selecting one or more action cards indicating an action. An example of action may include for example "adding photovoltaic panels to at east some selected buildings". The optimizing algorithm may execute some required action within the given constraints to achieve the prescribed objective.
[0029] Different action cards applied to one spatial region may be stacked and grouped into an action plan that defines the objectives, constraints and elements that the optimization algorithm should consider.
[0030] Action plans can be saved and re-applied to other spatial regions.
[0031] Selecting an action card to be applied on selected elements of the map defines objectives and constraints for the computation of an optimized scenario for the design of an infrastructure system in said spatial region or on said elements.
[0032] According to one aspect, the solution thus provides for a gamification of the user interface.
[0033] The method thus provides a new, time-efficient, intuitive and simple manner of selecting a plurality of objectives and constraints for the solutions of an urban planning problem.
[0034] The objective defines one value that one wants to optimize, such as the cost, the CO2generation, etc.
[0035] The constraints are boundaries that a solution needs to respect.
[0036] A possible constraint may be the energy from renewables that needs to be achieved by the generated scenario.
[0037] A special example of constraints are input parameters, such as the individual numbers specified prior to the optimization (e.g. emission factor of electricity from the national grid).
[0038] The computation of the scenario depends on those constraints. Some of the constraints may be defined by some action cards.
[0039] The computer-implemented method of this invention can be applied for the computation of infrastructure systems in the context of urban planning.
[0040] An infrastructure system may for example be a heating (or cooling) infrastructure system, power infrastructure system, or communication infrastructure system. The infrastructure system may however also be a transport infrastructure system, a sanitation infrastructure system, a recreational infrastructure, building design, etc. The method may be applied to compute optimized scenarios for a selected combination of different types of infrastructure systems.
[0041] An element in the context of urban planning is an infrastructure element. An infrastructure element may for example be one or more building structures, one or more streets or one or more neighborhoods / areas / urban assets (including mailboxes, vending machines, charging stations, parking spaces, etc...).
[0042] The term "element" may also refer to a more general type of element. The term "type of element" refers to a distinct group of elements comprising a defined common characteristic, for example a similar structure. An apartment block is for example an element of the building type element. A dual carriageway, or a single lane are elements of the street type of element.
[0043] One or a plurality of elements may be selected so that a selected action card will be applied only to the selected element(s).
[0044] Different element selection modes may be provided. For example, elements may be selected by clicking on them on the map, by touching them with the mousepointer while a button is pressed, with a lasso tool, a rectangular, geometric, straight-edged or free-form selection tool.
[0045] The selection of elements may depend on the location on the map where a card is dropped.
[0046] Elements may also be selected with one or a plurality of filters, for selecting only elements with some specific properties or of certain types. For example, a user may select an action card to select only commercial buildings, or buildings with a flat roof, on a map.
[0047] A user may also rely on an imported list of building addresses to select specific buildings.
[0048] Different selection tools may be combined. For example, a user may be interested in selecting only certain types of buildings within a geometric selection zone in a map.
[0049] Some selection mode may be available for some action cards but not for other action cards. For example, a selection of buildings based on the type or orientation of roofs may be relevant for an action card that optimizes planning of photovoltaic panels but less useful for another action card that optimizes a district heating or cooling network.
[0050] Some selection modes may be selected with a selection tool menu provided on at least some of the action cards. The menu may depend on the action card.
[0051] At least one action is selected by selecting one or more action cards indicating an action. An action may for example be specifying a particular technology, for example a type of heating system, a type of electricity system, or a type of communication system, to be used in the selected elements of a spatial region.
[0052] Some of the action cards may be used to define an urban planning objective to be attained.
[0053] An urban planning objective may for example be minimizing financial costs. A constraint is for example to maintain CO2 emissions under a given threshold for the selected building(s). An input parameter might be to assume an increased price at which to purchase electricity from the national grid or a certain heating capacity for the selected building(s).
[0054] Some of the action cards may define constraints, such as boundaries or input parameters, for calculating an urban planning scenario.
[0055] Such constraints may for example be numerical constraints, such as specified values, or geometrical constraints, such as an orientation of a surface or a roof. Further constraints may also pertain to financial aspects, for example a cost ceiling, to CO2 emissions, to energy consumption, to regulatory aspects such as maximal building size, etc.
[0056] The selected one or more actions are applied to the at least one selected element of the spatial region, resulting in the submission of instructions according to the selected action and the selected element for the computation of a scenario for the design of an infrastructure system in the spatial region.
[0057] The provision of action cards and maps to instruct the computation of adapted scenarios is intuitive and makes this method of urban planning accessible also to the layperson who does not have in- depth knowledge of urban planning or specific infrastructure systems, nor programming. Even entering complex instructions for the calculation of multiple-objective optimizations is rendered extremely straightforward due to the use of action cards, which may be organized in action plans.
[0058] Action cards may be juxtaposed.
[0059] Action cards may also be partially superimposed or superimposed as a card deck on the graphical user interface, thus allowing a large number of action cards to be provided simultaneously on the user interface.
[0060] Action cards may be collapsed, and thus presented with a smaller size and a reduced set of information so as to display more action cards on a given portion of the screen. Alternatively, action cards may be expanded so as to display a more complete set of information on a larger surface. Collapsing and / or expanding a card may be triggered with a button on the card. Collapsing and / or expanding a card may be triggered by moving a mouse pointer onto or outside of the card.
[0061] Some action cards may be two-sided. The front side may present more visual information than the back side, to make it easily recognizable even if the card is small or collapsed. The back side may include more text, small graphical user interface elements or widgets.
[0062] The back side (or "result side") of a two-sided action card may for example provide a summary about the results of an action card once it has been applied. Such a result may indicate for example the total costs of installing the selected system type in the selected buildings. An icon or a shortcut may be provided to flip the card.
[0063] Action cards may be editable, to enter new constraints. Action cards may be uneditable, for example after being applied.
[0064] The method is thus less screen-space intensive than most methods of the prior art, allowing a larger number of objectives and constraints to be selected from a single display.
[0065] The method is also very visual and thus provides a better memorability and communicability of user selections.
[0066] Action cards can be added to and / or removed from a map. Action cards can be moved on the display, so as to adapt to the size and shape of the spatial region to optimize and reduce overlapping with other action cards and / or with useful portions of the map.
[0067] In one aspect of this invention an action comprises computing a scenario for applying one or more heating units, such as a solar thermal panel or a district heating (and cooling) network, to a selected element or a spatial region.
[0068] An action may also involve computing a scenario for applying one or more power units, such as photovoltaic panels, energy storage units, power plants, and electric grid to a selected element or a spatial region.
[0069] An action may also involve computing a scenario for applying one or more communication units, such as local, metropolitan, or wide area networks (LAN, MAN or WAN), processing nodes, communication nodes, regional processing platforms, and management centres, to a selected element or a spatial region.
[0070] In one aspect of this invention at least one selected element might be a district heating or cooling network and one of the action cards defines a constraint for buildings which are intended to be connected to or excluded from said network.
[0071] In another aspect of this invention the selected action might comprise computing a scenario for applying photovoltaic panels to a selected element. Optionally, a further constraint, such as surface and / or roof orientation of the elements onto which said photovoltaic panels are intended to be installed, may be defined for said element.
[0072] It is possible to apply one or a combination of action cards pertaining to different infrastructure systems, for example cards pertaining to a heating infrastructure system and cards pertaining to a power infrastructure system, to elements, such as buildings and / or streets, of the spatial region.
[0073] It is also possible to combine specific actions pertaining to different units of the infrastructure system, for example the above-mentioned photovoltaic panels and the heating network, to elements, such as buildings and / or streets, of a spatial region. As a result, multiple systems may be optimized together to meet an urban planning objective.
[0074] It is also possible to combine several cards that specify the same action but apply to different elements selected with the selection tools.
[0075] By accounting for the constraints of a plurality of infrastructure systems according to this invention, the generated scenario can provide a global optimum for a complex planning objective in a spatial region.
[0076] To apply the action cards to a map, the card may be dragged and dropped onto the map.
[0077] Other possibilities to apply an action card might include:-by clicking on a button on the card or elsewhere in the user interface-by locating the cards at some place on the display, not necessarily on the map itself.
[0078] To apply the action cards to previously selected elements of a map, the card may be dragged and dropped onto the displayed map.
[0079] A selection of elements may be applied by dropping the action card onto a specific sub-portion of the map. For example, an action card may be dropped directly onto an element, or onto a set of elements, to be applied onto those elements.
[0080] A plurality of action cards may be applied iteratively to the selected elements. Successive action cards can therefore be applied to further refine a planning scenario.
[0081] Action cards may be weighted, i.e., prioritized, such as to indicate their relative importance for the computation of the scenario for the spatial region. This permits to define priorities for the computation of an optimized scenario. This enables a more accurate planning result in line with the planning requirements or user's wishes.
[0082] The priorities may be defined by the order of action cards within an action plan; an earlier action card may have a higher priority than a later introduced action card.
[0083] Some action cards may prevent the selection of some other action cards within the same action plan. For example, an action card defining an objective of minimizing the CO2 emission might prevent the selection of another action card defining an objective of minimizing the overall installation cost, as both objectives are not necessarily compatible.
[0084] Priorities of action cards might be defined for example but not only by dragging and dropping cards to change their order.
[0085] It is also possible to provide a functionality permitting to define a constraint provided by a selected action card either as optional or as obligatory for computation of the scenario. Such functionality may be provided directly on the action card. Preferably the functionality permits the user to choose between the optional and obligatory condition of the action card.
[0086] A card might also be marked as optional or obligatory by positioning it in predefined portions of the display.
[0087] An optional action is applied to the selected elements if the action optimizes a global objective.
[0088] An obligatory action is applied to all selected elements.
[0089] In case of conflicts between action cards, their prioritization is used to decide which action is applied to a specific element.
[0090] An action card, or each action card, may include a title, an image, a photo and / or an icon that indicates the action performed by the card.
[0091] The action card may further indicate the number of elements to which it is applied.
[0092] In one aspect of this invention action cards are substantially rectangular. Substantially rectangular refers to a quadrilateral shape with opposing sides being equal and parallel, and all four vertices being equal to 90°. The edges of the substantially rectangular shape may be rounded. The substantially rectangular action cards may be displayed in vertical mode.
[0093] The cards may be depicted as 3D objects, such as when they are flipped or dragged, the user views the rotation respectively displacement as if it were a 3D shape.
[0094] A plurality of action cards may be displayed as overlapping cards or as a deck of cards. When an action card is selected, it may be displayed on top of the overlapping cards or as the top card of the stack.
[0095] Other arrangements of the cards on the display are however also possible.
[0096] At least some of the action cards may be associated with an action plan. An action plan defines which one or more action cards associated with it may beselected (and possibly specified) and / or which action cards associated with it must be selected for the computation of a scenario.
[0097] Different cards belonging to the same action plan may form a deck.
[0098] Decks may be saved and retrieved, so that an action plan, corresponding to a set of action cards in a deck, can be easily applied to different maps or projects.
[0099] All the action cards in a deck can be manipulated, for example moved or applied to a map, simultaneously and / or with a single gesture.
[0100] Each action plan can be designed to address a specific urban planning objective. The action plan may provide a user with guidance to ensure that all required types of constraints for a meaningful computation of a planning solution are selected.
[0101] An action plan might result in several, one, or no scenario(s), depending on if the specified scenarios are conflicting or the specified constraints render the problem infeasible.
[0102] Multiple action plans, addressing different planning objectives, may be used for the same planning project.
[0103] Scenarios can be computed from each of these multiple action plans.
[0104] Depending on whether specified objectives are conflicting or not, the scenarios may be Pareto-optimal or globally optimal.
[0105] Action plans therefore further simplify the application of the method of this invention to multi-objective optimization. These action plans permit even a user who is unfamiliar with the specific technical field and / or urban planning to generate complex planning scenarios.
[0106] Multiple action plans (for example corresponding to multiple decks) can be combined to form a new action plan. For example, if an action plan concerns one city, and another action plan concerns a different city, both action plans can be merged and concern the region comprising both cities.
[0107] An action plan may indicate the optimization potential of the scenario to be generated. The scenario currently generated may be further optimized, for example by omitting certain constraints or by withdrawing a selected action card from the spatial region, or by selection of buildings per action. The action plan may comprise means for providing a suggestion as to which further action card or constraints should be omitted or adapted.
[0108] One or more action plans, each comprising one or more action cards, may be displayed on the display, for example as separate sections or as separate decks of action cards. Action cards of an action plan may for example be displayed on the map of the spatial region, if an action plan is selected.
[0109] With respect to what is known in the art, the method of this invention provides the advantage that an appropriate or optimized scenarios for simple or complex urban planning projects, which strive to achieve several objectives, can be generated in a simple, reliable and easily reproducible manner.
[0110] The invention is not particularly limited to heating, power and / or communication infrastructure systems.
[0111] The method of this invention may also be used to generate scenarios for other infrastructure systems, which are relevant for urban planning.
[0112] The method of this invention may for example be used or configured to be used to generate scenarios for transportation systems, or for sanitation systems. The method may also be used or adapted to be used for environmental planning, and / or land-use planning, or planning of urban revitalisation of spatial region.
[0113] The invention is not limited to urban planning.
[0114] The method may also be applied to other projects comprising arrangement or rearrangement or processing of elements in a spatial region, and / or applying one or more constraints to said elements. The method is therefore suitable for projects outside the urban planning context. The advantages of the method are the same when applied to these projects.
[0115] The invention is also related to a computer-implemented method for entering commands for processing elements displayed on a computer display, comprising any of the above mentioned steps.
[0116] The invention is also related to a computer program product including a program arranged for causing a computing device to perform a method comprising the above-mentioned steps.Short description of the drawings
[0117] Exemplar embodiments of the invention are disclosed in the description and illustrated by the drawings in which:Figure 1 illustrates schematically an embodiment of an action card of this invention;Figure 2 illustrates schematically an example of a graphical user interface for performing the method of this invention displaying a map, action plans and individual action cards of a selected action plan;Figure 3 illustrates schematically the map of Figure where elements impacted by selected action cards are marked;Figure 4A illustrates an alternative example of a graphical user interface in which action cards are embedded in an action plan field displayed next to the map of the spatial region;Figure 4B illustrates the same graphical user interface shown in 4A, in which a further numerical constraint has been set for an action plan to be chosen.Examples of embodiments of the present invention
[0118] A possible embodiment of an action card according to this invention is depicted in Figure 1. In this example, the action card indicates an action 12 to be performed on a spatial region. In this case the action is related to the addition of heating centre with energy systems of predefined types for a heating infrastructure system of a spatial region.
[0119] The card is, according to this invention, displayed on a display 100, shown here schematically and not to scale. The display 100 further displays a map of a spatial region to which the action card 1 may be applied if it is selected (not shown in Figure 1).
[0120] The action card may have a title 11, which provides the user with rapid information regarding the action performed by the card. In the example of Figure 1, the title 11 indicates that the action card can be used to define the heating centre of a district heating network.
[0121] The action card 1 may provide one or more means to select elements on the map to which the action defined on the action card could be applied. In the example shown in Figure 1, the user can select where to add a heating centre 13 on the map by activating a pin icon 131 displayed on the action card to mark a heating centre on the map (not shown in this Figure). An action may be mandatory on a given element; for example, the user might force the installation of a heating centre in a given building. Other actions might be optional on some elements - forexample, a user might select a set of buildings that could, but do not need to, be considered for a connection to a district heating network.
[0122] An action card may further provide a compilation of options 15 which may be selected. These options may be presented in different manner, for example as a series of icons 151 as shown in the example action card of Figure 1, or as a list of different options in a drop-down menu on the action card. The user may select one of these options. The user may also select several options. An action card may be configured to permit the simultaneous selection of only one option or of several options.
[0123] Other types of action indicated on such action cards may include for example adding photovoltaic panels, adding thermal solar panels, adding a district heating network, etc, to selected elements on the map.
[0124] In order to determine the optimum way to perform this action, the process defines the elements of the selected region for which the action is to be applied; the objectives that are to be optimized; and any constraints on the optimization. These various elements supplied to the optimization algorithm are introduced by means of other action cards. The set of action cards defining the data of the optimization problem to be applied to a spatial region forms a deck defining an action plan.
[0125] Some action cards may be used to define an objective, such as a global objective, for the optimization problem. An example of such an objective may be the minimization of CO2emissions. Another objective may be the reduction of the installation costs. Other objectives may be considered.
[0126] Some action cards may be used to select the elements on the map for which the action can be performed. For example, it might be possible to select only a subgroup of buildings, among all the buildings on the displayed map, which can be connected to the district heating network. This selection can be performed with selection tools provided on an action card. A menu of different element selectiontools may be provided on an action card. Alternatively, or in addition, specific action cards may be provided for selecting elements.
[0127] Some action cards may be directed to the selection of elements only, for example using selection tools such as lasso, selection zones, etc, and / or selection filters such as text filters for filtering elements according to the type of elements, or numerical filters.
[0128] An action card may for example be used to "specify a building type" onto which further action cards will be applied.
[0129] An element may for example be one or more building structures or one or more streets.
[0130] The user may for example select an element, group of elements, or a type of element to which an action is applied.
[0131] Other action cards may define constraints for the scenario. For example, one action card may be used to define a maximal cost for the scenario. The cost may correspond to a financial value, and / or to an environmental cost. Another action card may be used to restrict the elements, for example the buildings, that should be considered for the optimization. For example, one action card could be used to limit the addition of photovoltaic panels to roofs matching some criteria (age, surface, exposition, etc). Another action card may be used to connect only currently oil-heated buildings to a district heating network. Other action cards may include some reglementary constraints. Other action cards might indicate a maximal cost for the installation, a minimum return on investment, etc. Some action cards might indicate hard constraints that must be satisfied in any scenario - for example, one might indicate that a building must be excluded. Other action cards might indicate soft constraints that can be violated, but with a penalty in the objective function - for example, one might indicate that the cost should be preferably below a given threshold.
[0132] The action cards 1 shown in the Figures have a substantially rectangular shape with rounded edges. This shape provides an optimal use of card surface for a displaying information to be selected, and / or for permitting the user to input or select further parameters, conditions, and / or constraints.
[0133] Some cards or sections of the cards might be scrollable to display additional content.
[0134] Since information can be displayed in input in a space-saving manner on a substantially rectangular action card 1, the surface area of the card can be kept sufficiently small to allow it to be displayed next to or on a map 20 of the spatial region to which the action card is applied when selected, as shown in Figures 2, 3, 4A and 4B.
[0135] As illustrated on Figure 2, some cards are grouped into a plurality of card decks 3, corresponding here to an action plan. The cards in a deck are superimposed.
[0136] Other cards 1 on Figure 2 are partly superimposed, so that it is still possible to see a large portion of each card, only a portion being covered by another card.
[0137] Action cards may also be juxtaposed without any superimposition.
[0138] Some action cards 1 on Figure 2 are collapsed, i.e., displayed with a reduced size. Collapsed cards do not show the whole set of information associated with a card. Other action cards 12 are displayed in an extended view, with a larger size. Extended action cards display more information than collapsed action cards. The currently selected action card, and / or the action card onto which the mouse pointer 30 is pointing, may be displayed in an extended view.
[0139] Some cards may be double-sided. It is then possible to view more information on the back side of the card by flipping it.
[0140] This space-saving arrangement also allows the action card 1 to be dragged and dropped from a first display position to the map 20, or to a to subregion 201, to which the card is applied. Applying the action card 1 can be performed by dragging and dropping the action card to said spatial region 20, 201, submitting instructions for the computation of a scenario for said spatial region 20, 201. It is also possible to drag and drop several action cards onto a map, simultaneously or successively, so as to apply a plurality of corresponding actions to the selected elements of the map.
[0141] A action card may also be applied to selected elements of the map by clicking on an application button (not shown), for example an "OK" button.
[0142] Action cards 1 may be associated with action plans 3, as shown in Figures 2, 4A and 4B.
[0143] In Figure 2, four distinct action plans 3 are displayed. Each of the action plans 3 comprises a selection of action cards 1, which are displayed as a deck. The deck of action cards 1 is enlarged and expanded, when an action plan is selected, in the case shown in Figure 2, action plan 4 is selected and the map is updated to reflect the application of the selected action plan.
[0144] An action plan may be executed with the selected elements on the map so as to compute an optimized scenario to reach the objective given the constraints.
[0145] Action plans 3 may pertain to a particular infrastructure system. They may also pertain to a particular urban planning problem. They may pertain to a predefined urban planning objective. They may directed to a combination of an infrastructure system, a planning problem and / or a planning objective.
[0146] Action plans 3 may be predefined, which means they comprise a preselected set of action cards, which are considered important and / or essential for generating an adequate or optimized scenario.
[0147] An action plan typically comprises:• One action card defining a global objective, such as minimizing the CO2emissions, maximizing the renewable energy supply , etc• At least one action card defining actions to be performed, i.e., changes to an existing situation, such as adding photovoltaic panels, connecting buildings to a district heating network, improving insulation of buildings, etc;• At least one action card defining some constraints, such as maximal cost, maximal duration for the installation, minimum return on investment, buildings or elements that are excluded from the transformation, etc;• Possibly one or more action cards defining filters for the elements on which the action can be performed. Those action cards could be considered as specific constraints.
[0148] Not defining any constraints would also result into a valid scenario as there could still be an optimization taking place.
[0149] Some of those action cards could be combined. For example, as already mentioned, an action card indicating an action to be executed may include filters for filtering the elements on which it should be applied.
[0150] Application of an action plan on the selected elements of the map triggers the computation of an optimized scenario to reach the global objective, given the indicated constraints.
[0151] It is possible to permit further adaptation or modification of an action plan 3 by a user, for example by enabling a user to associate further action cards 1 to the action plan 3, by removing certain action cards 1 from the action plan 3, and / or by selecting some parameters / constraints on some of the cards of the action plan.
[0152] The example schematically depicted in Figure 2 shows an action plan for computation of the design of a district heating system. Elements of a spatial subregion, encircled by the dashed line 201, have been selected and the selected action plan 3 with its associated action cards 1 is displayed on the bottom part of map. The action card 12 may prompt the user to specify the buildings within that sub-region to be connected to the district heating system (DHN). A type of building to be connected may be selected by selecting one of the icons representing different types of buildings 161, by entering a text filter or numerical filter, etc. Buildings may also be selected by clicking on them.
[0153] The selected action plan 3 comprises more than one action card pertaining to the selection of buildings, therefore permitting a selection of buildings with different criteria.
[0154] Several action cards might be selected for allowing users to select elements according to different attributes.
[0155] One or a plurality of action cards might be available for defining some constraints to the optimization problem; for example, one might decide to connect only buildings that are public and constructed before 1970. Other constraints might limit the available budget for example. Still other constraints might prevent the district heating network to run along some streets.
[0156] The selected action plan 3 further comprises an action card 1A directed to the generation of an optimal scenario for the connection of the heating centre to the selected elements / buildings over a district heating or cooling network. Selecting this action card 1A initiates the computation of an optimized scenario for the design of the district heating and cooling network connecting a heating center to the selected buildings.
[0157] Alternatively, or in addition, the generation of a scenario might also be triggered by pressing a dedicated button on the user interface.
[0158] Information pertaining to the selected actions and elements in the selected spatial region is summarized in real time to the user in a separate component 4 on the screen. The summary of this example comprises the number of buildings which correspond to the selected building type in the selected sub-region 201, as well as computed values for average CO2 production and average energy consumption for the computed scenario over a defined period of time.
[0159] An optimization potential may be computed and displayed as a metric to provide the user with an indication of how much optimization is possible.
[0160] For example, if in the context of a scenario for a heating infrastructure system optimization a user defines that all buildings of a spatial region have to be connected, then the optimization potential is 0% since all decisions have already been taken by the user and there is no freedom for the optimization algorithm to improve upon.
[0161] Other metrics for representing and displaying an optimization potential may be computed and displayed as well. For example, the optimization potential could refer to the share in percentage of the achieved target value (e.g. costs or CO2emissions) over the target value that could be achieved if all user- defined constraints (spatial and global) would be dropped.
[0162] Optionally, measures to attain the full optimization potential may be taken. Such measures may for example be taken removing an action card or a specific constraint.
[0163] To facilitate and encourage further optimization of the computed scenario a value for the further optimization potential, for example the percentage of unfixed degrees of freedom of an optimized scenario based on all possible decisions as defined by action cards marked as optional, may be displayed on the screen, or the percentage of achievement of the global objective with regard to an unconstrained optimization. In Figure 4A, the further optimization potential of the computed scenario is presented in form of a bar 5. In the example shown, the fulloptimization potential is not attained due e.g. to some constraints that limit the optimization potential.
[0164] Some action cards might have an optionality option. For example, an action card may allow but not enforce that a specific system is installed (i.e., the action is optional) while another card will enforce that a system is installed (i.e., the action is not optional).
[0165] The optionality of actions might be specified at the level of specifications within a card, so that some specifications on a card are optional while other specifications on the same are mandatory.
[0166] Figure 3 corresponds to Figure 2; however, previously selected elements, such as buildings, that are impacted by action cards are marked and / or denoted by a mini icon indicating the number of impacting cards. This view can be used to see immediately which buildings, or other elements, are for example connected to a heating network or provided with solar panels in given scenarios.
[0167] Applying an action plan on selected elements of a map triggers the computation of a scenario. A scenario is computed by retrieving one optimal possibility of urban planning among a plurality of possibilities, given the action selected by the user, the elements selected by the user, and the further constraints indicated on the selected action cards. The computation of the scenario may result in additional or different information displayed onto the map.
[0168] Figure 4A shows another example of a graphical user interface.
[0169] In order to compute a scenario for a project 6, an action plan 3 has to be chosen for the project. The action plan may for example be based on a template developed based on action plans used previously for the computation of the same or a similar scenario for a different spatial region.
[0170] A project 6 may be optimized with a plurality of different action plans 3. For example, one action plan might be related to use of solar panels while another action plan might consider installing a district heating network. Selecting successively one or the other action plan allows for a comparison of the different optimization outcomes.
[0171] In the depicted embodiment, an action plan 3 can be selected from a drop-down menu. Upon selecting an action plan 3, a set of action cards 1 associated with the action plan becomes selectable. In the embodiment shown, the action cards 1 may also be selected from a drop-down menu. A selected action card is then displayed and the action card 1 may be parametrized.
[0172] The user may add and fill a plurality of action cards 1 for each action plan 3. Further specific constraints 8 may also be defined for an action plan 3. The optimization potential 5, in this case a bar, indicates how much of the optimization potential is remaining when a specific set of elements and / or constraints are applied to the spatial region.
[0173] Once the actions, constraints, selection filters, objectives and parameters are set, the project 6 as a whole may be applied to the spatial region 20 displayed on the same display screen 100.
[0174] The example depicted in Figure 4A is directed to the computation of a scenario for the spatial region depicted in the map. It may be one of the objectives for this project to design a heating system infrastructure. For this purpose, a district heating design action plan 3 may be parametrized.
[0175] Selecting a district heating design action plan will automatically add the action for selecting the heating centre, since this particular information is needed for generating the heating system scenario. This action can therefore not be removed from the action plan 3. It is however possible to add other options to the action plan 3. For this purpose, further action cards 1 may be added, for example by the user.
[0176] It may also be possible, or even required, to define or select a target quality 7 for an action plan 3. A target quality 7 may for example be the reduction of investment cost or the reduction of an emission rate of a specified compound or substance.
[0177] Figure 4B depicts the same project 7 as in Figure 4A, with the district heating design action plan 3 being selected. Compared to Figure 4A, a more restrictive set of action cards and / or additional constraints has been set in Figure 4B, resulting in a drop of the optimization potential value. Specifically, the action plan shown in Figure 4A contains a further constraint, i.e a defined value range for the linear heating network density (LHND). This constraint provides a limitation for the scenario to be computed.
[0178] Once all the parameters, i.e. an objective, some possible actions, some constraints and possibly some filters on elements, have been defined by selecting and parameterising all the action cards within an action plan, this action plan is executed, triggering the calculation of an optimized scenario to achieve the objective. In an example, the scenario could indicate which of the selected buildings should be equipped with photovoltaic panels in order to achieve an objective of maximising CO2 production, taking into account a cost constraint.
[0179] The calculation of the optimized scenario could be performed by a machine learning system that has been previously trained with training scenarios and evaluation of those scenarios.
[0180] Machine learning systems are effective at generating solutions in complex contexts. However, they are hardly deterministic, and difficult to train and update. Therefore, in a preferred embodiment, a deterministic method, such as a mixed integer linear programming (MILP) algorithm, is used to determine an optimized scenario. The MILP algorithm may use a search-based algorithm, such as a branch and bound (B&B) module, to evaluate many possible scenarios and find the optimal one, or at least an optimized one, taking into account both the possibleactions that can be taken to change the existing situation and hard and soft constraints indicated by the user.
[0181] In an even more preferred embodiment, the determination of the optimized scenario is performed using both a machine learning algorithm and a MILP algorithm. The machine learning system can then be used to prune the set of possible scenarios for the MILP algorithm to consider, thereby speeding up the execution of the MILP algorithm.Additional Features and Terminology
[0182] Although examples provided herein may be described in the context of urban planning, such as urban planning of energy infrastructure, one or more features may further apply to other types of planning and generation of scenarios in different contexts.
[0183] Many other variations than those described herein will be apparent from this disclosure. For example, depending on the embodiment, certain acts, events, or functions of any of the algorithms described herein can be performed in a different sequence, can be added, merged, or left out altogether (for example, not all described acts or events are necessary for the practice of the algorithms). Moreover, in certain embodiments, acts or events can be performed concurrently, for instance, through multi-threaded processing, interrupt processing, or multiple processors or processor cores or on other parallel architectures, rather than sequentially. In addition, different tasks or processes can be performed by different machines or computing systems that can function together.
[0184] Unless otherwise specified, the various illustrative logical blocks, modules, and algorithm steps described herein can be implemented as electronic hardware, computer software, or combinations of both. To clearly illustrate this interchangeability of hardware and software, various illustrative components, blocks, modules, and steps have been described above generally in terms of their functionality. Whether such functionality is implemented as hardware or softwaredepends upon the particular application and design constraints imposed on the overall system. The described functionality can be implemented in varying ways for each particular application, but such implementation decisions should not be interpreted as causing a departure from the scope of the disclosure.
[0185] Conditional language used herein, such as, among others, "can," "might," "may," "e.g.," and the like, unless specifically stated otherwise, or otherwise understood within the context as used, is generally intended to convey that certain embodiments include, while other embodiments do not include, certain features, elements or states. Thus, such conditional language is not generally intended to imply that features, elements or states are in any way required for one or more embodiments or that one or more embodiments necessarily include logic for deciding, with or without author input or prompting, whether these features, elements or states are included or are to be performed in any particular embodiment. The terms "comprising," "including," "having," and the like are synonymous and are used inclusively, in an open-ended fashion, and do not exclude additional elements, features, acts, operations, and so forth. Also, the term "or" is used in its inclusive sense (and not in its exclusive sense) so that when used, for example, to connect a list of elements, the term "or" means one, some, or all of the elements in the list. Further, the term "each," as used herein, in addition to having its ordinary meaning, can mean any subset of a set of elements to which the term "each" is applied.
Claims
Claims1 . A computer-implemented method scenario for the design of infrastructure systems, for example urban energy infrastructure systems such as heating, power, transport, sanitation, and / or communication systems, in a spatial region, comprising the steps of displaying on a display a map of a spatial region, simultaneously displaying a plurality of action cards onto said display, selecting at least one element of the spatial region displayed on the map, selecting an action card defining an objective for the scenario, selecting an action card defining a constraint, for the scenario, applying the selected one or more action cards to the at least one selected element of the spatial region, thereby submitting instructions for the computation of an optimized scenario for the design of an infrastructure system in said spatial region; computing an optimized scenario.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein at least one of the action cards indicates an action, and wherein one or more action is selected by selecting one or more action cards indicating an action.
3. The method of any of the claims 1 to 2, wherein the element is one or more building structures, one or more streets, one or more urban assets, or one or more neighbourhoods.
4. The method of one of the claims 1 to 3, wherein computing an optimized scenario involves executing a mixed integer linear programming (MILP) algorithm.
5. The method of claim 4, using a machine learning system for pruning a set of scenarios for the MILP algorithm to consider.
6. The methods of any of claims 2 to 5, wherein the action comprises at least one of applying: at least one of one or more heating units, such as a solar thermal panels or a district heating or cooling network, and / or at least one of one or more power units, such as photovoltaic systems, energy storage units, power plants, and electric grid, and / or at least one of one or more communication units, such as local, metropolitan, or wide area networks (LAN, MAN or WAN), processing nodes, communication nodes, regional processing platforms, and management centres, to a spatial region.
7. The method of any of claims 1 to 6, wherein at least one selected element is a building, and wherein at least one of said action cards can be used for determining a set of selected buildings to be connected to a district heating or cooling network.
8. The method of any of claims 1 to 7 wherein the selected action comprises applying photovoltaic panels to a selected element, and wherein one of said action cards define a further constraint, such as surface and / or roof orientation of the elements onto which said photovoltaic panels are intended to be installed, for said element.
9. The method of any of the claims 1 to 8, wherein at least one action card includes a selection tool for selecting at least one element of the spatial region displayed on the map.
10. The method of one of the claims 1 to 9, wherein an action card is applied to a spatial region by dragging and dropping the action card onto said spatial region.11 . The method of any of the claims 1 to 10, wherein a plurality of action cards is simultaneously applied to a spatial region.
12. The method of any of the claims 1 to 11, wherein at least one action card further comprises a functionality for defining the selected action either as an optional condition, or as an obligatory condition for the scenario.
13. The method of any of the claims 1 to 12, wherein at least one of the action cards is prioritized, such as to indicate its relative importance for the computation of the scenario for the spatial region.
14. The method of any of claims 1 to 13, wherein at least some of the action cards are groups within at least one action plan that can be saved and reapplied to other spatial regions.
15. The method of any of claims 1 to 14, wherein the action cards are substantially rectangular, and preferably displayed in vertical mode.
16. The method of any of claims 1 to 15, wherein the action cards are displayed as overlapping cards or as a stack of cards.
17. A computer program product including a program arranged for causing a computing device to perform a method comprising the steps of one of the above mentioned claims.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Urban central heating system integrated flexible scheduling method and system
CN110793094A
Communications network service deployment simulator
US8316112B2
