Stress-strain relationship estimation method
The torsion test method on round bar specimens with different radii enables accurate stress-strain relationship estimation in high strain regions, overcoming inaccuracies and equipment limitations of existing methods by converting shear stress-shear strain to simple tensile stress-strain, facilitating precise press forming analysis.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/JP2024/015860
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-05-16
- Filing Date
- 2024-04-23
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for estimating the stress-strain relationship in high strain regions of metallic materials, such as hydraulic bulge tests and compression tests, face inaccuracies due to assumptions about stress and strain distribution, require specialized equipment, and are not suitable for continuous data collection beyond uniform elongation, leading to errors in press forming analysis.
A method involving torsion tests on round bar specimens with different radii to estimate the shear stress-shear strain relationship, which is then converted to simple tensile stress-strain relationship, using a compact torsion testing machine to avoid constriction and achieve high precision.
This method allows for accurate estimation of stress-strain relationships in high strain regions exceeding uniform elongation without the need for large-scale equipment, providing continuous data and reducing errors associated with previous techniques.
Smart Images

Figure JP2024015860_21112024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Stress-strain relationship estimation method
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for estimating a stress-strain curve, and in particular to a method for estimating a stress-strain curve that can accurately estimate the relationship between stress and strain in a high strain region (strain portion larger than uniform elongation) that exceeds the uniform elongation of a metallic material.
[0002] In press forming of sheet metals, the material may undergo deformation exceeding the uniform elongation in uniaxial tension. Therefore, for performing press forming analysis using high-precision finite element analysis (FEM), it is important to understand the work-hardening properties (stress-strain relationship) after the uniform elongation in uniaxial tension. In particular, for super high tension materials, the uniform elongation is very small (e.g., the uniform elongation of 1180 MPa steel is 6-7%), so it is important to understand the stress-strain relationship after the uniform elongation (e.g., up to an elongation of about 20%).
[0003] Previously, methods have been proposed for obtaining stress-strain relationships using hydraulic bulging tests (Non-Patent Document 1), compression tests (Non-Patent Document 2), shear tests (Non-Patent Document 3, Patent Document 1), and other methods. These test methods involve deformation states that are less prone to necking than conventional uniaxial tensile tests and can impart large deformations, making it possible to obtain the stress-strain relationship after uniform elongation in uniaxial tensile testing. Additionally, a method has been proposed for estimating the stress-strain relationship in the high-strain region after necking using uniaxial tensile tests (Non-Patent Document 4, Patent Document 2). This method involves theoretically calculating the tensile load acting on a tensile test specimen from the strain distribution measured using digital image correlation (DIC) or other methods.
[0004] Patent No. 5910803 Patent No. 6669290
[0005] Nasser, A. et al.: J. Mater. Proc. Technol., 210 (2010), 429-436. Iwata et al.: Plasticity and Processing, 54-632 (2013), 836-840. Sumikawa et al.: Plasticity and Processing, 62-727 (2021), 103-108. Shirakami et al.: Iron and Steel, 103-10 (2017), 589-595.
[0006] However, the hydraulic bulge test of Non-Patent Document 1 obtains the stress-strain relationship in an equi-biaxial tensile stress state (a state in which stress is applied isotropically in a plane), while the compression test of Non-Patent Document 2 obtains the stress-strain relationship in a compressed state. In order to use the results obtained from these tests in press forming analysis using FEM analysis, it is necessary to convert them into a stress-strain relationship equivalent to uniaxial tension, and there is a possibility of errors occurring depending on the anisotropic yield function used in the conversion.
[0007] In addition, hydraulic bulge tests often assume that strain and stress at the apex of the specimen are equal regardless of direction. While recent strain measurements using DIC have enabled the influence of strain direction to be considered, stress is still estimated from hydraulic pressure, as in the past. Therefore, the estimated stress is likely to be subject to error, and the resulting stress-strain relationship is not sufficiently accurate. Furthermore, the hydraulic bulge test requires specialized testing equipment, making it impractical for general use. Furthermore, because hydraulic bulge tests ultimately result in necking and fracture, it is not possible to obtain the stress-strain relationship up to the high strain range where necking occurs.
[0008] On the other hand, in the compression test of Non-Patent Document 2, although necking does not occur even when the strain applied to the test piece increases, the friction with the jig pressing the test piece and the influence of the jig are significant, and correction using FEM analysis is necessary. Also, in order to apply the compression test to thin steel sheets, the thin steel sheets need to be stacked in order to measure the strain in the thickness direction, and it was thought that errors due to stacking would occur.
[0009] Furthermore, the methods of Non-Patent Document 3 and Patent Document 1 require the assumption of preconditions for the theoretical calculation of the load acting on the tensile test specimen (e.g., the associated flow rule, which is a relational expression expressing the relationship between the plastic strain increment and the stress state, and an anisotropic yield function). Furthermore, there is a problem of necking occurring in the tensile test specimen, and when necking begins to occur, the distribution of the strain ratio varies in the width direction. Therefore, the accuracy of the preconditions for the yield function is significantly affected, and errors may occur if the preconditions deviate from reality. In particular, after necking occurs in the thickness direction of the tensile test specimen, the specimen is affected by shear in the thickness direction. However, since the yield function does not take shear in the thickness direction into account, errors may become even larger. Furthermore, because this method uses a camera to measure strain, it is not suitable for continuously collecting data from the start of tensile load application to a strain range beyond uniform elongation, and is therefore premised on determining a regression curve for the relationship between stress and strain from time series data of discrete strain.
[0010] Furthermore, the shear tests in Non-Patent Document 4 and Patent Document 2 have the advantage that, because they apply shear deformation, no necking occurs in the test specimen, and the relationship between stress and strain up to fracture can be measured. However, these tests require a large-scale, specialized testing machine to clamp and fix the front and back sides of a rectangular test specimen in the width direction and move the chucks in relative directions to generate shear deformation within the surface of the test specimen. In addition, because the end of the test specimen is subjected to tensile deformation, it is not purely shear deformation, and there is a problem that thickness reduction at the end of the test specimen is large, resulting in errors.
[0011] The present invention has been made to solve the above-mentioned problems, and its purpose is to provide a method for estimating the stress-strain relationship that can directly estimate with high accuracy the relationship between stress and strain in a high strain range of a metallic material in a deformation form that does not cause necking.
[0012] The method for estimating stress-strain relationships according to the present invention is for estimating the stress-strain relationship of a metallic material, and includes a first torsion test step of applying a torsion torque T1 around the axis of a first round-bar specimen having a round bar-shaped parallel section with a first radius R1 to shear the parallel section, thereby obtaining a relationship between the torsion torque T1 and the torsion angle Φ1; and a second torsion test step of applying a torsion torque T2 around the axis of a second round-bar specimen having a round bar-shaped parallel section with a second radius R2 smaller than the first radius R1 to shear the parallel section. a second torsion test step in which a relationship between torsion torque T2 and torsion angle Φ2 is obtained; and a shear stress and a surface shear strain on the surface of the parallel portion of the first round bar test piece are calculated using the relationship between torsion torque T1 and torsion angle Φ1 obtained in the first torsion test step and the relationship between torsion torque T2 and torsion angle Φ2 obtained in the second torsion test step. and a stress-strain relationship estimation step of converting the shear stress τ and surface shear strain γ acquired in the shear stress-surface shear strain relationship acquisition step into a simple tensile stress σ and strain ε, and estimating the relationship between the simple tensile stress σ and strain ε. In the shear stress-surface shear strain relationship acquisition step, the shear stress τ is obtained using a torsion torque T1 at a torsion angle Φ1 acquired in the first torsion test step and a torsion torque T2' when the torsion angle Φ2 acquired in the second torsion test step is aligned with the torsion angle Φ1 acquired in the first torsion test step, and the surface shear strain γ is obtained using the torsion angle Φ1 acquired in the first torsion test step.
[0013] In the shear stress-surface shear strain relationship acquisition step, the shear stress τ may be calculated by equation (1), and the surface shear strain γ may be calculated by equation (2).
[0014] The first round bar test piece and the second round bar test piece have gripping portions extending outward in the longitudinal direction from both ends of the parallel portion via gradual change portions, and the torsion angle Φ1 obtained in the first torsion test step and the torsion angle Φ2 obtained in the second torsion test step are used to measure the torsional torque T in the elastic region. e The twist angle Φ is estimated as being proportional to e In the elastoplastic deformation portion, the measured value of the twist angle φ a (Φ1 or Φ2) is the measured value Φ0 of the twist angle at the elastic limit, which is the boundary between the elastic region and the elastoplastic region, and the estimated value Φ s The difference (=Φ0-Φ s ) and the torsion angle Θ(T) at the elastic limit point of the gradually changing portion of the first round bar test piece or the second round bar test piece s ) change from (Θ(T)-Θ(T s )) and the torsion angle φ corrected using t (=φ a -(Φ0-Φ s )-(Θ(T)-Θ(T s ))) would be a good idea.
[0015] In the first and second torsion test steps, when gripping the gripping portions at both longitudinal ends of each test piece with a test piece holder in order to apply a torsional torque to the first and second round bar test pieces, it is preferable to provide a gap between the gripping portions and the test piece holder.
[0016] The present invention makes it possible to directly and accurately obtain the relationship between stress and strain in a high strain range that exceeds uniform elongation in uniaxial tension of a metallic material. Furthermore, unlike conventional hydraulic bulge tests, compression tests, or shear tests, it does not require large-scale testing equipment, and the relationship between stress and strain in a high strain range can be continuously obtained using a relatively small and compact testing machine.
[0017] FIG. 1 is a flow chart illustrating the processing flow in a stress-strain relationship estimation method according to an embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 2 is a diagram illustrating an example of a round bar test specimen used in a torsion test in which a torsional torque is applied to cause shear deformation in the stress-strain relationship estimation method according to an embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 3 is a diagram illustrating a torsion test machine for a micro round bar used in the stress-strain relationship estimation method according to an embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 4 is a graph illustrating the relationship between torsion angle and torsion torque obtained in a torsion test using round bar test specimens with different parallel portion radii in the stress-strain relationship estimation method according to an embodiment of the present invention, and illustrates the relationship between torsion angle and torsion torque with and without torsion angle correction. Fig. 5 is a graph showing the results of a torsion test conducted on a round bar test specimen made from a 1.2 mm thick steel plate with a tensile strength of 980 MPa in the examples to estimate the relationship between uniaxial tension stress and strain (Invention Examples 1 and 2), and the stress-strain relationship obtained by a conventional hydraulic bulge test (Conventional Example 1) ((a) without torsion angle correction (Invention Example 1) and (b) with torsion angle correction (Invention Example 2)). Fig. 6 is a graph showing the results of a torsion test conducted on a round bar test specimen made from a 1.2 mm thick steel plate with a tensile strength of 590 MPa in the examples to estimate the relationship between uniaxial tension stress and strain (Invention Example 3), and the stress-strain relationship obtained by a conventional hydraulic bulge test (Conventional Example 2).
[0018] Before describing the stress-strain relationship estimation method according to the embodiment of the present invention, the background to the invention and the round bar test piece and the small round bar torsion testing machine used in the practice of the present invention will be described.
[0019] <Background to the Invention> The inventors focused on shear deformation in a torsion test using a round bar test specimen as a deformation mode that is less likely to cause necking than tensile deformation in a conventional uniaxial tensile test and can impart large deformation in a high strain range beyond uniform elongation. However, the shear strain in a round bar test specimen increases linearly from the center of the cross section (axial center) of the round bar test specimen toward the radially outward direction and is distributed concentrically from the axial center, so the shear strain within the cross section is not uniform.
[0020] Therefore, the inventors conducted extensive research into methods for determining shear stress and shear strain through torsion tests using round bar test specimens. As a result, they found that in torsion tests using minute round bar test specimens with slightly different diameters (e.g., 1 mm and 1.1 mm), it can be assumed that the shear stress τ generated on the surface of the round bar test specimens does not vary significantly due to the slight difference in diameter. Based on this assumption, they found that the shear stress τ acting on the surface of the round bar test specimens can be calculated from the difference in torsional torque in torsion tests of each round bar test specimen.
[0021] He then recalled that the shear strain of a shear-deformed round bar specimen could be approximated by the average value of the surface shear strain generated by torsion tests on round bar specimens with slightly different diameters. Therefore, he came up with the idea of determining the relationship between shear stress and surface shear strain by torsion tests on two types of round bar specimens with slightly different diameters.
[0022] Furthermore, by assuming isotropy of the material and correcting for the anisotropy of actual metal materials based on the results of uniaxial tensile tests, the researchers realized that they could convert the shear stress and surface shear strain obtained from torsion tests on two round bar specimens with different diameters into uniaxial tensile stress and strain. This led to the discovery that it is possible to estimate the relationship between uniaxial tensile stress and strain in the high strain range beyond uniform elongation.
[0023] <Round Bar Test Specimen> The round bar test specimen 10 is a small metal piece cut out from a metal plate (for example, a steel plate with a thickness of 1.2 mm) and machined while rotating it on a rotation axis along the longitudinal direction. As shown in Figure 2, the round bar test specimen 10 has a round bar-shaped parallel portion 11 and gripping portions 15 extending outward in the longitudinal direction from both longitudinal ends of the parallel portion 11 via gradually changing portions 13.
[0024] The parallel portion 11 is machined into a round bar shape with a predetermined diameter smaller than the thickness of the metal plate. The diameter of the parallel portion 11 is preferably as small as possible from the perspective of shear deformation, but is preferably approximately 1 mm from the perspective of dimensional accuracy. The longitudinal length of the parallel portion 11 is not particularly limited and may be set appropriately, for example, approximately 2 to 3 mm. The gradually changing portion 13 is formed between the parallel portion 11 and the gripping portion 15 and is a portion where the diameter gradually changes. The gripping portion 15 is a flat portion (fixing region) that is gripped and fixed by the test specimen holders 111 and 113 of the micro round bar torsion tester 100 described below. The thickness of the gripping portion 15 is preferably the same as the thickness of the metal plate used to make the round bar test specimen 10.
[0025] <Micro Round Bar Torsion Tester> Fig. 3 shows an example of a micro round bar torsion tester 100 for performing a torsion test using a round bar test piece 10. As shown in Fig. 3, the micro round bar torsion tester 100 includes a step motor 101, a reduction gear 103, a rotation side of a torsional axis 105, a coupling 107, a fixed side of a torsional axis 109, test piece holders 111 and 113, a torque meter 115, and an amplifier 117.
[0026] The rotating torsion shaft 105 is connected to a step motor 101 via a coupling 107 and a reducer 103. On the other hand, the fixed torsion shaft 109 is connected to a torque meter 115, which is connected to an amplifier 117. The command value of the step motor 101 and the output from the amplifier 117 are collected in a measurement recorder (not shown). The rotating torsion shaft 105 and the fixed torsion shaft 109 are each provided with test specimen holders 111 and 113 that grip the gripping portions 15 at both longitudinal ends of the round bar test specimen 10 in order to apply a torsional torque to the round bar test specimen 10.
[0027] When performing a torsion test on a round bar test piece 10 using the micro round bar torsion testing machine 100, first, the gripping portion 15 of the round bar test piece 10 is grasped by the test piece holder 111 on the rotating side torsion axis 105 side and the test piece holder 113 on the fixed side torsion axis 109 side.
[0028] Then, by inputting a predetermined command value to the step motor 101, a torsional torque T is applied to the grip portion 15 of the round bar test specimen 10 via the reducer 103, coupling 107, rotating torsion shaft 105, and test specimen holder 111, causing shear deformation of the parallel portion 11. The torsion angle Φ of the round bar test specimen 10 to which the torsional torque has been applied may be estimated from the command value of the step motor 101 and the reduction ratio of the reducer 103, or may be measured directly by installing a potentiometer or the like capable of measuring the rotation angle of the rotation shaft of the reducer 103.
[0029] In the micro rod torsion tester 100, it is important for the accuracy of torsional torque measurement that the axial centers of the rotating torsion shaft 105 and the fixed torsion shaft 109 are aligned. Therefore, the micro rod torsion tester 100 is preferably provided with an adjustment mechanism for centering the test specimen holders 111, 113 on both sides.
[0030] <Method for Estimating Stress-Strain Relationship> A method for estimating stress-strain relationship according to an embodiment of the present invention acquires the stress-strain relationship of a metallic material. As shown in Fig. 1, the method for estimating stress-strain relationship includes a first torsion test step S1, a second torsion test step S3, a shear stress-surface shear strain relationship acquisition step S5, and a stress-strain relationship estimation step S7. Hereinafter, the method for estimating stress-strain relationship according to this embodiment will be performed using a micro-round bar torsion testing machine 100 shown in Fig. 3, and each of the above steps will be described.
[0031] <First Torsion Test Step> In the first torsion test step S1, a first torsion test is performed in which a torsional torque T1 is applied around the axis of a first round bar test specimen 10 having a round bar-shaped parallel portion 11 with a first radius R1, thereby shearing the parallel portion 11. Then, the relationship between the torsional torque T1 applied to the first round bar test specimen in the first torsion test and the torsion angle Φ1 of the first round bar test specimen 10 is obtained. In the first torsion test step S1, it is preferable to obtain the relationship between the torsional torque T1 and the torsion angle Φ1 up to the maximum torsion angle at which a crack occurs in the parallel portion 11 of the first round bar test specimen 10.
[0032] <<Second Torsion Test Step>> In the second torsion test step S3, a second torsion test is performed in which a torsional torque T2 is applied around the axis of a second round bar test piece 10 having a round bar-shaped parallel portion 11 with a second radius R2 smaller than the first radius R1, thereby shearing the parallel portion 11. Then, the relationship between the torsional torque T2 applied to the second round bar test piece 10 in the second torsion test and the torsion angle Φ2 of the second round bar test piece 10 is obtained.
[0033] In the second torsion test step S3, the relationship between the torsion torque T2 and the torsion angle Φ2 up to the maximum torsion angle at which a crack occurs in the parallel portion 11 of the second round bar test piece 10 may be obtained.
[0034] <<Shear Stress-Surface Shear Strain Relationship Acquisition Process>> In the shear stress-surface shear strain relationship acquisition process S5, the relationship between the shear stress τ and the surface shear strain γ is obtained on the surface of the parallel portion 11 of the first round bar test specimen 10. To obtain the relationship between the shear stress τ and the surface shear strain γ, the relationship between the torsional torque T1 and the torsion angle Φ1 obtained in the first torsion test process S1 and the relationship between the torsional torque T2 and the torsion angle Φ2 obtained in the second torsion test process S3 are used.
[0035] The shear stress τ is determined using the torsional torque T1 at the torsion angle Φ1 obtained in the first torsion test step S1 and the torsional torque T2' obtained in the second torsion test step S3 when the torsion angle Φ2 is aligned with the torsion angle Φ1. On the other hand, the surface shear strain γ is determined using the torsion angle Φ1 obtained in the first torsion test step S1.
[0036] The shear stress τ and the surface shear strain γ can be calculated from the following formulas (1) and (2), respectively.
[0037] The shear stress τ shown in Equation (1) is derived as follows. When the torsion angle per unit length is equal for the first round bar test specimen 10 (radius R1) and the second round bar test specimen (radius R2, R1 > R2) with different radii of the round bar-shaped parallel portion 11 (Figure 2), the shear strain distributions from the axial center to R2 in the radial cross section of the parallel portion 11 are equal. As a result, the stress distributions that generate torque in the first and second round bar test specimens 10 are also equal. Therefore, the difference (T1 - T2') between the torque T1 of the first round bar test specimen 10 and the torque T2' of the second round bar test specimen 10 is the torque generated in the "ring portion (the portion of the first round bar test specimen 10) extending from the radius R2 to the radius R1." Furthermore, considering that the shear strain generated in the parallel portion 11 is proportional to the distance from the axial center, it can be assumed that the torque and shear strain in the annular portion of the first round bar test specimen 10 are constant when the difference in radius (R1 - R2) between the first round bar test specimen 10 and the second round bar test specimen 10 is very small. Based on this assumption, the shear stress τ on the surface of the parallel portion 11 can be expressed by Equation (1). Furthermore, the surface shear strain γ shown in Equation (2) is approximated by the average value of the shear strain generated on the surface of the parallel portion 11 by the torsion tests of the first and second round bar test specimens 10.
[0038] <Stress-Strain Relationship Estimation Step> In the stress-strain relationship estimation step S7, the shear stress τ and surface shear strain γ acquired in the shear stress-surface shear strain relationship acquisition step S5 are converted into simple tension stress σ and strain ε, respectively, and the relationship between uniaxial tension stress σ and strain ε is estimated.
[0039] The stress σ and strain ε under uniaxial tension can be converted using the following equations (3) and (4), respectively. Equation (3) assumes equivalent plastic work in an isotropic material (Mises material), and derives the strain ε under uniaxial tension using the shear strain γ and shear stress τ. This derivation uses the relationships between the strain and shear strain and the stress and shear stress under uniaxial tension in the plastic region, the relationship between the stress and strain under uniaxial tension using the longitudinal elastic modulus E in the elastic region, and the relationship between the shear stress and shear strain using the transverse elastic modulus G. Furthermore, the derivation of equation (3) uses the definition of the relationship between "elastic-plastic strain," "elastic strain," and "plastic strain" in uniaxial tension, and the definition of the relationship between "elastic-plastic shear strain," "elastic shear strain," and "plastic shear strain" in shear. Furthermore, equation (4) is a corrected version of the relationship between stress σ and shear stress τ in uniaxial tension, assuming an isoplastic strain state in an isotropic material (Mises material), taking into account the anisotropy of metallic materials.
[0040] In Equations (3) and (4), A is a correction coefficient that takes into account the anisotropy of the metallic material. If the metallic material is isotropic (i.e., non-anisotropic), A = 1. In contrast, if the metallic material is anisotropic, the value of A can be determined based on the stress-strain curve up to uniform elongation in a uniaxial tensile test. For anisotropic metallic materials, particularly those manufactured by rolling, it is known that the properties change in the rolling direction (L direction), perpendicular to the rolling direction (C direction), and 45° (D direction). Therefore, when taking tensile test specimens from a metallic material, for example, multiple specimens can be taken with their longitudinal directions corresponding to the anisotropy of the metallic material, and the value of A can be determined by performing a uniaxial tensile test. Furthermore, in Equation (3), E is the Young's modulus, and the value measured in a uniaxial tensile test of the metallic material can be used. Furthermore, G is the shear modulus, which can be calculated based on the longitudinal modulus E measured by a uniaxial tensile test and the Poisson's ratio of the metal material (a value of 0.28-0.30 when the metal material is steel plate).
[0041] As described above, the stress-strain relationship estimation method according to this embodiment can estimate the stress-strain relationship in a high strain range exceeding uniform elongation in uniaxial tension of a metallic material. Furthermore, the stress-strain relationship estimation method according to this embodiment involves performing a torsion test using a round bar test piece with a diameter of approximately 1 mm. Therefore, unlike conventional hydraulic bulge tests, compression tests, or shear tests, the torsion test using the relatively small and compact miniature round bar torsion testing machine 100 can estimate the stress-strain relationship in a high strain range without requiring large-scale equipment.
[0042] In the stress-strain relationship estimation method according to this embodiment, as described above, the shear stress τ acting on the surface of the parallel portion 11 of the first and second round bar test specimens 10 is calculated on the assumption that there is no significant difference due to the difference in the diameter of the parallel portion 11 (see Equation (1)). Therefore, the smaller the difference between the first radius R1 of the parallel portion 11 of the first round bar test specimen 10 and the second radius R2 of the parallel portion 11 of the second round bar test specimen 10, the more accurately the shear stress τ can be estimated. However, due to constraints on the processing accuracy of the round bar test specimens 10, the difference between the first radius R1 and the second radius R2 is preferably about 0.1 mm, more preferably about 0.05 mm.
[0043] In the above description, the torsion tests are performed using the micro round bar torsion tester 100 in the first torsion test step S1 and the second torsion test step S3 to obtain the relationship between the torsion torque and the torsion angle for two types of round bar test specimens 10 with different diameters. However, the micro round bar torsion tester 100 has mechanical backlash (backlash in the reducer 103 and backlash between the chucking portions of the test specimen holders 111 and 113 and the gripping portion 15 of the round bar test specimen 10). Therefore, the torsion angle obtained in the elastic region immediately after the application of torsional torque around the axis of the round bar test specimen 10 begins has a large error.
[0044] Therefore, it is preferable to correct the torsion angles (Φ1, Φ2) obtained in the first torsion test step S1 and the second torsion test step S3 as follows.
[0045] First, it is determined whether the shear deformation of the round bar test piece 10 in the torsion test is in the elastic region or the elasto-plastic region. The elastic region and the elasto-plastic region can be determined, for example, based on the following equation (5).
[0046] T e is the measured value of the torsional torque applied to the first and second round bar test pieces 10 (T1 or T2), T s is the torsional torque at the boundary between the elastic region and the elastoplastic region (elastic limit point). R is the radius (R1 or R2) of the parallel part 11 of the round bar test piece 10, and Y sis the uniaxial yield stress of the metal material used for the round bar test piece 10. Furthermore, A is a correction coefficient that takes into account the anisotropy of the metal material, and is the same as in equations (3) and (4).
[0047] The measured value of the torsional torque in the torsion test, T e T s If the measured value of the torsional torque T e T s In the above cases, the shear deformation in the parallel portion 11 of the round bar test specimen 10 is determined to be in the elasto-plastic region.
[0048] When it is determined that the torsion angle of the round bar test piece 10 is in the elastic region, the torsion angle is e The torsion angle Φ is estimated by the following equation (6): e Let's say.
[0049] G is the modulus of transverse elasticity (MPa) of the round bar test piece, and R is the radius (mm) of the parallel part 11 of the round bar test piece 10.
[0050] On the other hand, if it is determined to be in the elastoplastic region, the torsion angle obtained by the torsion test is the measured value of the torsion angle at the elastic limit point Φ0 and the estimated value of the torsion angle Φ s The difference (=Φ0-Φ s ) is corrected by offsetting Φ s is the measured value of the torsional torque T in equation (6). e is the torsional torque T at the elastic limit point s is the estimated twist angle when
[0051] Furthermore, in the round bar test piece 10, the radius of the gradually changing portion 13 from the grip portion 15 to the parallel portion 11 changes along the longitudinal direction. Therefore, based on the twist angle Θ of the gradually changing portion 13 given by equation (7), the change in the twist angle Θ of the gradually changing portion 13 from the elastic limit point (=Θ(T)-Θ(T s )) to further correct the torsion angle of the round bar test piece 10. Θ(T) is the torsion angle of the gradually changing portion 13 at the torsional torque T, Θ(T s ) is the elastic limit point (torsion torque T s) is the torsion angle of the gradually changing portion 13.
[0052] That is, when it is determined that the region is in the elastoplastic region, the measured value of the twist angle φ is calculated using the following equation (8). a The corrected value φ t is the twist angle of the round bar test piece 10.
[0053] Figure 4 shows a graph of the relationship between the unit torsion angle (torsional angle per unit length in the axial direction) and torsional torque with and without torsion angle correction in a torsion test using two types of round bar test specimens 10 with different diameters of the parallel portion 11. The graph shown in Figure 4 shows the results using round bar test specimens 10 made from steel plates with a tensile strength of 980 MPa and a plate thickness of 1.2 mm. The diameter of the parallel portion 11 of the first round bar test specimen 10 is 1.1 mm, and the diameter of the parallel portion 11 of the second round bar test specimen 10 is 1 mm. The horizontal axis of Figure 4 represents the unit torsion angles θ1 and θ2, which are the torsion angles Φ1 and Φ2 of the first round bar test specimen 10 and the second round bar test specimen 10, respectively, divided by the longitudinal length L of the parallel portion 11.
[0054] As shown in FIG. 4, in the region where the torsion angle is small, as mentioned above, the error in the torsion angle is large due to the mechanical backlash of the micro round bar torsion testing machine 100, and therefore it can be seen that a difference occurs in the torsional torque depending on whether or not the torsion angle is corrected.
[0055] In a typical round bar torsion tester, the gripping portion 15 of the round bar test specimen 10 is generally chucked completely by the test specimen holders 111, 113. However, in a micro round bar torsion tester 100 that uses a round bar test specimen 10 with a parallel portion 11 having a diameter of about 1 mm, even a slight misalignment of the axes of the rotating torsion shaft 105 and the fixed torsion shaft 109 of the micro round bar torsion tester 100 affects the accuracy of torsional torque measurement.
[0056] Therefore, in the first torsion test step S1 and the second torsion test step S3, when the gripping portions 15 at both longitudinal ends of each round bar test specimen 10 are gripped by the test specimen holders 111, 113, it is advisable to provide a gap between the gripping portions 15 and the test specimen holders 111, 113. This gap is preferably approximately 10 to 20 μm. This allows the gripping portions 15 to move freely without being fixed by the test specimen holders 111, 113 when the application of torsional torque to each round bar test specimen 10 begins. As a result, abnormalities such as torsional torque fluctuations occurring in the round bar test specimen 10 due to misalignment of the axes of the rotating torsion shaft 105 and the fixed torsion shaft 109 can be alleviated, thereby improving the accuracy of torsional torque measurement.
[0057] An experiment was conducted to verify the effects of the stress-strain relationship estimation method according to the present invention, and the results will be described below.
[0058] In this example, the relationship between stress and strain of steel plates having a tensile strength of 980 MPa and a tensile strength of 590 MPa was estimated as metal materials using the method according to the embodiment described above.
[0059] First, two types of round bar test specimens 10, namely, first and second round bar test specimens 10 shown in Fig. 3, which differ in the diameter of the parallel portion 11, were prepared from a steel plate having a plate thickness of 1.2 mm. The diameter of the parallel portion 11 of the first round bar test specimen 10 was 1.1 mm, and the diameter of the parallel portion 11 of the second round bar test specimen 10 was 1.0 mm.
[0060] Next, a torsion test was performed on each of the first and second round bar test pieces 10 prepared using a micro round bar torsion tester 100 shown in Figure 2, and the relationship between the torsional torque applied to each round bar test piece 10 and the torsion angle of each round bar test piece 10 was obtained.
[0061] Then, the shear stress and surface shear strain acting on the surface of the parallel portion 11 of the first round bar test specimen 10 were calculated from the relationship between the torsional torque and the torsion angle obtained for each of the first and second round bar test specimens 10. The shear stress and surface shear strain were calculated using the above-mentioned formulas (1) and (2).
[0062] Next, the shear stress and surface shear strain calculated using the above-mentioned equations (3) and (4) were converted into uniaxial tensile stress (equivalent stress) and strain (equivalent strain), and the relationship between stress and strain was estimated.
[0063] Furthermore, in this example, as explained in the embodiment, the stress and strain were also estimated when the shear stress and surface shear strain were calculated by correcting the torsion angle obtained in the torsion tests of the first and second round bar test pieces 10. In correcting the torsion angle, the uniaxial yield stress Ys and the modulus of transverse elasticity G were used, which were values measured in the uniaxial tensile tests of steel plates of each tensile strength.
[0064] In this example, the relationship between stress and strain was also obtained by a hydraulic bulge test for comparison. In the hydraulic bulge test, test specimens were prepared from steel plates with tensile strengths of 980 MPa and 590 MPa and a plate thickness of 1.2 mm.
[0065] Figure 5 shows a graph comparing the results of the uniaxial tensile stress-strain relationship (equivalent stress and equivalent strain) estimated using the method of the present invention for a 980 MPa-class steel plate with the results of the equivalent stress-strain relationship obtained by a hydraulic bulge test. The uniform elongation in the uniaxial tensile test of the 980 MPa-class steel plate was 7.0% (true strain 0.068).
[0066] 5 shows the stress-strain curves for Invention Examples 1 and 2, where round bar test pieces 10 were prepared and the relationship between stress and strain was estimated twice, with Invention Example 1 shown in Fig. 5(a) showing the results without correction for the torsion angle Φ, and Invention Example 2 shown in Fig. 5(b) showing the results with correction for the torsion angle Φ. Conventional Example 1 is a stress-strain curve obtained by a hydraulic bulge test.
[0067] As shown in Figure 5, there is good agreement between Inventive Example 1 and Conventional Example 1, and it is clear that Inventive Example 1 can estimate a high strain region that is 35% wider than Conventional Example 1. Furthermore, a comparison of Inventive Example 1 in Figure 5(a) with Inventive Example 2 in Figure 5(b) shows that by correcting the torsion angle Φ obtained from the torsion test, it is possible to reduce the variation in the elastic region in particular.
[0068] Figure 6 shows a graph comparing the results of uniaxial tensile stress-strain relationships (equivalent stress and equivalent strain) estimated using the method of the present invention for a 590 MPa-class steel plate (Example 3) with the results of equivalent stress-strain relationships obtained by a hydraulic bulge test (Conventional Example 2). The uniform elongation in the uniaxial tensile test of the 590 MPa-class steel plate was 15.1% (true strain 0.141). In Figure 6, Inventive Example 3 is a stress-strain curve for one round bar test piece 10 used to estimate the stress-strain relationship, while Conventional Example 2 is a stress-strain curve obtained by a hydraulic bulge test. In addition, Inventive Example 3 shows the results of a torsion test with the torsion angle corrected.
[0069] As shown in Figure 6, in Example 3, which was estimated for a steel plate with a tensile strength of 590 MPa, it was possible to estimate the relationship between stress and strain up to a high strain range that was more than four times higher than that of Conventional Example 2 in the hydraulic bulge test.
[0070] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide a method for estimating the stress-strain relationship that can directly estimate with high accuracy the relationship between stress and strain in a high strain range of a metallic material in a deformed form in which no necking occurs.
[0071] REFERENCE SIGNS LIST 10 Round bar test piece 11 Parallel part 13 Gradual change part 15 Grip part 100 Micro round bar torsion tester 101 Step motor 103 Reducer 105 Rotating side torsion shaft 107 Coupling 109 Fixed side torsion shaft 111 Test piece holder 113 Test piece holder 115 Torque meter 117 Amplifier
Claims
1. A method for estimating the stress-strain relationship of a metallic material, comprising: a first torsion test step of applying a torsion torque T1 about an axis of a first round bar test piece having a round bar-shaped parallel portion of a first radius R1, thereby shearing the parallel portion, and obtaining a relationship between the torsion torque T1 and a torsion angle Φ1; and a second torsion test step of applying a torsion torque T2 about an axis of a second round bar test piece having a round bar-shaped parallel portion of a second radius R2 smaller than the first radius R1, thereby shearing the parallel portion, and obtaining a relationship between the torsion torque T2 and a torsion angle Φ2. a shear stress-surface shear strain relationship acquisition step of determining the relationship between the shear stress τ and the surface shear strain γ on the surface of the parallel portion of the first round bar test piece using the relationship between the torsional torque T1 and the torsional angle Φ1 acquired in the first torsion test step and the relationship between the torsional torque T2 and the torsional angle Φ2 acquired in the second torsion test step; and a stress-strain relationship estimation step of converting the shear stress τ and the surface shear strain γ acquired in the shear stress-surface shear strain relationship acquisition step into a simple tensile stress σ and a strain ε, and estimating the relationship between the simple tensile stress σ and the strain ε, wherein in the shear stress-surface shear strain relationship acquisition step: the shear stress τ is calculated using a torsional torque T1 at the torsion angle Φ1 obtained in the first torsion test process and a torsional torque T2' when the torsion angle Φ2 obtained in the second torsion test process is aligned with the torsion angle Φ1 obtained in the first torsion test process, and the surface shear strain γ is calculated using the torsion angle Φ1 obtained in the first torsion test process.
2. A stress-strain relationship estimation method as described in claim 1, wherein in the shear stress-surface shear strain relationship acquisition process, the shear stress τ is calculated using equation (1) and the surface shear strain γ is calculated using equation (2).
3. The first round bar test piece and the second round bar test piece have gripping portions extending outward in the longitudinal direction from both ends of the parallel portion through a gradually changing portion, and the torsion angle Φ1 obtained in the first torsion test process and the torsion angle Φ2 obtained in the second torsion test process are, in the elastic region, a measured value T of the torsional torque. e The twist angle Φ is estimated as being proportional to e In the elastic-plastic region, the measured value of the twist angle φ a (Φ1 or Φ2) is the measured value Φ0 of the torsion angle at the elastic limit point, which is the boundary between the elastic region and the elastoplastic region, and the estimated value Φ s Difference (=Φ0-Φ s ) and the torsion angle Θ(T) at the elastic limit point of the torsion angle Θ(T) of the gradually changing portion of the first round bar test piece or the second round bar test piece s ) change from (Θ(T)-Θ(T s ) and the torsion angle φ corrected using t (=φ a -(Φ0-Φ s )-(Θ(T)-Θ(T s ))) The stress-strain relationship estimating method according to claim 1 or 2.
4. A method for estimating stress-strain relationships as described in claim 1 or 2, wherein in the first torsion test process and the second torsion test process, when gripping the gripping portions at both longitudinal ends of each test piece with a test piece holder in order to apply a torsional torque to the first round bar test piece and the second round bar test piece, a gap is provided between the gripping portions and the test piece holder.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Evaluation method of plastic material and evaluation method of plastic working of plastic material
JP5910803B2
Stress-strain relationship estimation method
JP6669290B1
Measurement combination for fastening process of automobile engine crankshaft belt pulley
CN105445122A
Method for measuring deformation resistance
JP2000234991A
Method and device for evaluating asphalt mixture and sample
JP2009192391A
