Estimation device, estimation method, and estimation program

The estimation device addresses the challenge of unclear participant intentions in electronic conferencing by using vital measurements to assess engagement and present necessary meeting content, enhancing communication quality and participant involvement.

WO2024241592A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-11-28NT T INC
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/JP2023/019577
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-05-25
Publication Date
2024-11-28

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional communication technologies, such as electronic conferencing systems, fail to provide real-time status feedback on participants, leading to unclear intentions and potential repetition of information due to lack of awareness about viewer engagement.

Method used

An estimation device that acquires vital measurement values from participants using wearable devices, determines their viewing status, and estimates the quality of the conference based on these measurements, creating meeting minutes and presenting relevant sections to participants as needed to enhance communication quality.

Benefits of technology

Enables real-time monitoring of participant engagement, improving communication quality by ensuring that all participants are actively involved and aware of the meeting content, reducing the need for repeated information dissemination.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure JP2023019577_28112024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure JP2023019577_28112024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

Provided is an estimation device (10) in which an acquisition unit (15a) acquires measured vital-sign values of participants in an electronic meeting. An assessment unit (15b) uses the acquired measured vital-sign values to assess the viewing state of each participant. On the basis of the assessed viewing state of each participant, an estimation unit (15c) estimates the quality of the electronic meeting according to all the participants.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Estimation device, estimation method, and estimation program

[0001] The present invention relates to an estimation device, an estimation method, and an estimation program.

[0002] Recently, the COVID-19 pandemic has led to an increase in opportunities for telecommuting, and electronic conferencing has become more common (see Non-Patent Document 1). Electronic conferencing has enabled employees to communicate with each other even when working from home, making it possible to disseminate information about work and make decisions.

[0003] "webex by Cisco", [online], Cisco, [Retrieved April 26, 2023], Internet<URL:https: / / www.webex.com / ja / video-conferencing.html>

[0004] However, with conventional technology, it is not possible to know the status of conference participants in real time, and it is not possible to know whether their intentions are truly being conveyed, which can lead to poor communication. For example, in electronic conferences such as those on the Webex, it is not possible to get a complete picture of whether the viewers are able to hear what is being said, and it is not possible to know whether their intentions are truly being conveyed. Furthermore, if it is discovered after the conference that their intentions were not conveyed, they may have to repeat the same process.

[0005] The present invention has been made in view of the above, and has as its object to improve the quality of communication by grasping the status of conference participants in real time.

[0006] In order to solve the above-mentioned problems and achieve the objectives, the estimation device of the present invention is characterized by having an acquisition unit that acquires vital signs measurement values ​​of participants in an electronic conference, a determination unit that determines the viewing state of each participant using the acquired vital signs measurement values, and an estimation unit that estimates the quality of the electronic conference held by all participants based on the determined viewing state of each participant.

[0007] According to the present invention, it is possible to grasp the status of conference participants in real time and improve the quality of communication.

[0008] FIG. 1 is a diagram for explaining an overview of the estimation device of this embodiment. FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram illustrating a general configuration of the estimation device of this embodiment. FIG. 3 is a diagram for explaining processing by a determination unit. FIG. 4 is a diagram for explaining processing by the determination unit. FIG. 5 is a diagram for explaining processing by the determination unit. FIG. 6 is a diagram for explaining processing by the estimation unit. FIG. 7 is a diagram for explaining processing by the estimation unit. FIG. 8 is a diagram for explaining processing by the estimation unit. FIG. 9 is a diagram for explaining processing by a determination unit. FIG. 10 is a diagram for explaining processing by a presentation unit. FIG. 11 is a flowchart showing an estimation processing procedure. FIG. 12 is a diagram illustrating an example of a computer that executes an estimation program.

[0009] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described in detail with reference to the drawings. Note that the present invention is not limited to this embodiment. In addition, in the description of the drawings, the same parts are designated by the same reference numerals.

[0010] [Outline of Estimation Device] Fig. 1 is a diagram for explaining an outline of the estimation device of this embodiment. As shown in Fig. 1, the estimation device collects vital signs measured from meeting participants in real time (S1). As vital signs measured, for example, stress scores and the like are collected from commercially available wearable devices such as Fitbit and JINS-MEME.

[0011] The estimation device also monitors whether the meeting is proceeding smoothly and evaluates the quality of the meeting based on the collected vital signs (S2). For example, the estimation device estimates (determines) and displays the viewing status of each participant, the success of the entire meeting, and the degree of penetration of a common understanding based on the vital signs (S3). The estimation device also records the viewing status (level of understanding), number of comments, etc. for each participant (S3). This allows the speaker and participants to share their viewing status and realize communication.

[0012] The estimation device also creates minutes using commercially available AI minutes, etc. (S4). Then, the minutes are compared with the viewing state of each participant (S5), and if it is estimated that a review of the meeting is necessary due to a decline in attention, etc., the device extracts the relevant part of the minutes and presents it to the participants (S6).

[0013] [Configuration of the Estimation Apparatus] Fig. 2 is a schematic diagram illustrating the general configuration of the estimation apparatus of this embodiment. As illustrated in Fig. 2, the estimation apparatus 10 of this embodiment is realized by a general-purpose computer such as a personal computer, and includes an input unit 11, an output unit 12, a communication control unit 13, a storage unit 14, and a control unit 15.

[0014] The input unit 11 is realized using input devices such as a keyboard, a mouse, various measuring instruments, etc., and inputs various instruction information such as a command to start processing to the control unit 15 in response to input operations by an operator. The output unit 12 is realized by a display device such as a liquid crystal display, a printing device such as a printer, etc. For example, the output unit 12 outputs a viewing state log 14a and minutes 14b generated in the estimation process described below.

[0015] The communication control unit 13 is realized by a NIC (Network Interface Card) or the like, and controls communication between the control unit 15 and external devices via telecommunication lines such as a LAN (Local Area Network) or the Internet. For example, the communication control unit 13 controls communication between the control unit 15 and wearable devices worn by participants in an electronic conference, a management device that manages various information, and the like.

[0016] The storage unit 14 is realized by a semiconductor memory element such as a RAM (Random Access Memory) or a flash memory, or a storage device such as a hard disk or an optical disk. The storage unit 14 stores in advance a processing program for operating the estimation device 10, data used during execution of the processing program, and the like, or temporarily stores the data each time processing is performed. The storage unit 14 may be configured to communicate with the control unit 15 via the communication control unit 13. In this embodiment, the storage unit 14 stores a viewing state log 14a, minutes 14b, and the like generated in the estimation process described below.

[0017] The control unit 15 is realized using a CPU (Central Processing Unit) or the like, and executes a processing program stored in memory. As a result, the control unit 15 functions as an acquisition unit 15a, a determination unit 15b, an estimation unit 15c, a creation unit 15d, a determination unit 15e, and a presentation unit 15f, as illustrated in FIG. 2, to perform the estimation process. Note that each or some of these functional units may be implemented in different hardware. For example, the presentation unit 15c may be implemented in hardware different from the other functional units. The control unit 15 may also include other functional units.

[0018] The acquisition unit 15a acquires vital sign measurement values ​​of participants in an electronic conference. For example, the acquisition unit 15a acquires the vital sign measurement values ​​of the participant to be processed in real time via the input unit 11 or from a wearable device worn by the participant via the communication control unit 13. The acquisition unit 15a may store the acquired vital sign measurement values ​​in the storage unit 14.

[0019] The determination unit 15b determines the viewing state of each participant using the acquired vital sign measurement values. In this embodiment, the determination unit 15b uses, for example, the resting heart rate as the vital sign measurement value. For example, the determination unit 15b uses "reactivity" in the stress score obtained by Fitbit's stress management score determination method or the like. Specifically, if the "resting heart rate" is high in the stress score representing "reactivity," the determination unit 15b determines that the participant needs to rest and is in "poor physical condition."

[0020] Furthermore, the determination unit 15b uses, as the vital sign measurement value, a measurement value of the concentration level estimated from blinking, eye movement, and eye gaze stability detected by glasses. For example, a measurement value obtained by the JINS-MEME concentration level estimation method or the like is used. Specifically, the determination unit 15b determines a measurement value of 60 points or more out of 100 as "concentration," and a measurement value of 40 points or less as "distraction." Furthermore, the determination unit 15b determines a measurement value of less than 40 points as "looking away," and if the measurement is impossible, it considers the glasses to be not being worn and determines a "non-participation."

[0021] The judgment unit 15b acquires the vital signs measurement values ​​indicating the physical condition and the level of concentration collected, for example, every five minutes, and judges the viewing state of each participant at each time by combining these two types of vital signs measurement values.

[0022] 3 to 5 are diagrams for explaining the processing of the determination unit. First, FIG. 3 shows an example of a list of viewing states corresponding to each combination of vital signs. In the example shown in FIG. 3, the viewing state of the participant is one of five states: "concentrated and in good physical condition," "concentrated and in poor physical condition," "distracted and in good physical condition," "distracted and in poor physical condition," and "looking away and not participating."

[0023] The determination unit 15b also scores the determined viewing state of each participant. FIG. 4 illustrates a list of communication quality and scores corresponding to each viewing state. As illustrated in FIG. 4, when the viewing state is "concentration / good physical condition" or "concentration / poor physical condition," the determination unit 15b determines that the participant is able to concentrate on the conference and the communication quality is "high." The determination unit 15b then assigns a score of 10 points to "concentration / good physical condition," subtracts 2 points from the score for poor physical condition, and assigns a score of 8 points to "concentration / poor physical condition."

[0024] Furthermore, when the viewing state is "distracted and in good physical condition" or "distracted and in poor physical condition," the determination unit 15b determines that each participant is distracted and is not able to fully participate in the conference, and the quality of communication is "low."The determination unit 15b then assigns a score of 5 points to "distracted and in good physical condition," and subtracts 2 points from the score for poor physical condition, making the score for "distracted and in poor physical condition" 3 points.

[0025] Furthermore, when the viewing state is "looking away / not participating," the determining unit 15b determines that each participant is not participating in the conference and the quality of communication is "poor," and assigns a score of 0 regardless of whether the participant is in good or bad physical condition.

[0026] In other words, if the viewing condition scored in this way is 8 points or more, the quality of communication is judged to be "high," if it is 5 points or less, the quality of communication is judged to be "low," and if it is 0 points, the quality of communication is judged to be "poor."

[0027] 5 illustrates an example of the data structure of the viewing status log 14a. The determination unit 15b stores the viewing status at each time determined using the vital signs measured at predetermined intervals for each participant as the viewing status log 14a in the storage unit 14, as illustrated in FIG. 5. In the example shown in FIG. 5, the viewing status determined every five minutes for user 1, user 2, and user 3 is recorded. However, it can be seen that user 2 and user 3 were unable to be measured except for one measurement at the start of measurement.

[0028] The determination unit 15b may present the viewing status log 14a to, for example, a speaker who is in charge of proceeding with the conference. The speaker can grasp the overall situation from the status of each participant and proceed with the conference taking the overall situation into consideration.

[0029] Returning to the description of Fig. 2, the estimation unit 15c estimates the quality of the teleconference held by all participants based on the determined viewing state of each participant. Specifically, the estimation unit 15c estimates the quality of the teleconference by using the average value of the scores indicating the viewing state of each participant across all participants.

[0030] 6 to 8 are diagrams illustrating the processing of the estimation unit 15c. The estimation unit 15c tally up the cumulative average values ​​of the scores for each participant at each time, calculates the average of the cumulative average values ​​of all participants as an overall average value in real time, and estimates the quality of the conference using this overall average value.

[0031] Fig. 6 shows an example of a list of meeting quality corresponding to the overall average value. In the example shown in Fig. 6, if the overall average value is 8 points or more, the meeting quality is estimated to be "high," if it is 6 points or more but less than 8 points, the meeting quality is estimated to be "needs attention," and if it is 5 points or less, the meeting quality is estimated to be "low."

[0032] 7 and 8 show specific examples of the process of tallying the scores of the viewing situations of the participants by the estimation unit 15c. In FIGS. 7 and 8, low scores of 5 points or less for each participant are shown in bold. First, in the example shown in FIG. 7, scores indicating the viewing situations of 11 participants, Mr. A to Mr. K, at a meeting held from 10:00 AM to 11:00 AM are chronologically tallied. In this example, the overall average value is calculated to be 8.98, so it is estimated that the quality of the meeting was generally high and high-quality information was disseminated.

[0033] In the example shown in Figure 8, scores indicating the viewing status of the same 11 participants as in the example shown in Figure 7 for a meeting held from 8:00 PM to 9:00 PM on a different day are compiled in chronological order. In this example, there were periods when Mr. D and Mr. F did not participate (scored 0) due to attending another meeting. There were also several other participants with scores of 5 or less, who are presumed not to have fully participated in the meeting. In this example, the overall average score is calculated as 7.01, so the quality of the meeting is "needs attention" and it is presumed that the meeting content needs to be re-distributed. Therefore, the estimation device 10, through the processing of the functional units described below, presents each participant with the minutes of the meeting that are presumed not to have been shared and asks them to review them.

[0034] This makes it easy to identify, for example, participants who are on camera but not concentrating and are working on other tasks at the same time during the meeting, participants who pretend not to be there without being seen on camera, and participants who are doing homework while participating.

[0035] Returning to the explanation of Figure 2, the creation unit 15d creates minutes of the electronic conference. For example, the creation unit 15d performs voice recognition to convert the contents of the conference into text and create chronological minutes. Alternatively, the creation unit 15d uses AI minutes to create minutes that summarize the contents of the electronic conference. The creation unit 15d stores the created minutes of the electronic conference in the storage unit 14 as minutes 14b.

[0036] The creation unit 15d may also tally up the number of comments made by each participant and store it in the storage unit 14, for example, by adding it to the minutes 14b.

[0037] The determining unit 15e determines whether or not minutes are required to be presented based on the determined viewing state of each participant. Specifically, the determining unit 15e determines whether or not minutes are required based on the level of understanding of each participant estimated based on the viewing state. Here, the level of understanding refers to, for example, the quality of communication described above. In other words, the determining unit 15e determines that minutes are required to be presented for a participant whose communication quality is "poor," for example.

[0038] The determination unit 15e further uses the number of statements made by each participant to determine whether or not minutes should be presented. Specifically, the determination unit 15e may take the number of statements into consideration when estimating the level of understanding. For example, for a user whose number of statements is greater than a predetermined number, the determination unit 15e may estimate that the level of understanding is high and determine that presentation of minutes is "unnecessary" even if the quality of communication is not "high." Alternatively, for a user whose quality of communication is "low" and whose number of statements is less than a predetermined number, the determination unit 15e may estimate that the level of understanding is low and determine that presentation of minutes is "necessary" even if the quality of communication is not "poor."

[0039] 8, for example, C, E, G, I, and J have scores of 8 or more, and the quality of communication is determined to be “high.” In this case, the determining unit 15e may determine to notify each participant of a request to continue to actively participate in the event.

[0040] On the other hand, there are time periods when Mr. B and Mr. K have scores of 4 or less, indicating that they may be in poor health. In this case, the decision unit 15e may decide to send a notification thanking them for participating in the meeting despite their poor health.

[0041] Furthermore, although Person A generally has high scores, his / her score from 20:20 to 20:50 is 0 points, and it is highly likely that he / she did not participate in the meeting. In this case, the determining unit 15e determines to present the minutes from 20:20 to 20:55 to Person A in a highlighted display such as in bold to encourage him / her to review them.

[0042] Similarly, for Mr. B, his score from 20:20 to 20:25 was 0 points, and it is highly likely that he did not attend the meeting. Therefore, the decision unit 15e decides to present Mr. B with the minutes from 20:20 to 20:30 in highlighted text, such as in bold, to encourage him to review them.

[0043] Since it is known that Mr. D and Mr. F did not participate because they attended another meeting after 20:30 (score 0), the decision unit 15e decides to present the minutes from 20:30 onwards in bold or other highlighted font and request confirmation of the contents of the meeting.

[0044] Here, Fig. 9 is a diagram for explaining the processing of the determination unit. Fig. 9 illustrates an example of the estimated quality of the meeting and the participants for whom it has been determined that minutes of the meeting are required to be presented. In the example shown in Fig. 9, the estimation unit 15c estimates the quality of the meeting to be "high," and the determination unit 15e determines that presentation of the minutes of the meeting from the date and time "1 / 20 1:20 to 1 / 20 1:30" to user1 is "required."

[0045] The quality of the conference estimated in this way and the part of the minutes to be presented to participants who need to be presented with the minutes may be output to the speaker who is conducting the conference, for example, via the output unit 12 or the communication control unit 13 on the speaker's terminal, etc. This makes it easy for the speaker to grasp the overall situation of the conference and the status of each participant.

[0046] Returning to the explanation of Fig. 2, the presentation unit 15f presents the relevant portion of the minutes to the participants for whom it has been determined that the minutes should be presented. For example, the presentation unit 15f identifies the portion of the minutes for the time period determined by the determination unit 15e to be presented to the participants, and presents the relevant portion of the minutes to the output unit 12 or to the participants' terminals, etc. via the communication control unit 13, by highlighting the relevant portion by underlining or bolding, etc.

[0047] Fig. 10 is a diagram for explaining the processing of the presentation unit. Fig. 10 shows an example of the minutes to be presented to person F shown in Fig. 8. In the example shown in Fig. 10, the part of the minutes that is requested of person F for confirmation is shown in bold. In this way, it is possible to ensure a common understanding among the participants of the electronic conference.

[0048] [Estimation Process] Next, the estimation process performed by the estimation device 10 according to this embodiment will be described with reference to Fig. 11. Fig. 11 is a flowchart showing the procedure of the estimation process. The flowchart in Fig. 11 starts, for example, when the user performs an operation input to instruct the start of the process.

[0049] First, the acquisition unit 15a acquires vital signs of participants in the electronic conference (step S1). For example, the acquisition unit 15a acquires the vital signs of the participants to be processed in real time via the input unit 11 or from a wearable device or the like worn by the participant via the communication control unit 13.

[0050] Next, the determination unit 15b determines the viewing state of each participant using the acquired vital sign measurement values ​​(step S2). The determination unit 15b assigns a score to the determined viewing state of each participant. The determination unit 15b also stores the viewing state at each time determined using the vital sign measurement values ​​of each participant at predetermined intervals as a viewing state log 14a in the storage unit 14.

[0051] Next, the estimation unit 15c estimates the quality of the teleconference held by all participants based on the determined viewing state of each participant (step S3). For example, the estimation unit 15c estimates the quality of the teleconference by using the average score of all participants, which indicates the viewing state of each participant.

[0052] Next, the creation unit 15d creates minutes of the electronic conference (step S4). For example, the creation unit 15d performs voice recognition to convert the contents of the conference into text and create chronological minutes. Alternatively, the creation unit 15d uses AI minutes to create minutes that summarize the contents of the electronic conference. The creation unit 15d stores the created minutes of the electronic conference as minutes 14b in the storage unit 14.

[0053] Then, the decision unit 15e decides whether or not the minutes need to be presented based on the determined viewing state of each participant, and the presentation unit 15f presents the relevant part of the minutes to participants who are determined to need the minutes to be presented (step S5).

[0054] For example, the determination unit 15e determines whether or not minutes are necessary based on the level of understanding of each participant estimated based on the viewing state. The determination unit 15e also determines whether or not minutes are necessary to present based on the number of comments made by each participant. The presentation unit 15f then identifies the portion of the minutes for the time period determined by the determination unit 15e to be presented to the participants, and presents the portion of the minutes to the output unit 12 or to the participant's terminal, etc. via the communication control unit 13, highlighting the relevant portion by underlining or bolding, etc. This completes the series of estimation processes.

[0055] [Effects] As described above, in the estimation device 10 of this embodiment, the acquisition unit 15a acquires vital sign measurement values ​​of participants in an electronic conference. The determination unit 15b determines the viewing state of each participant using the acquired vital sign measurement values. The estimation unit 15c estimates the quality of the electronic conference held by all participants based on the determined viewing state of each participant.

[0056] Specifically, the estimation unit 15c estimates the quality of the teleconference by using the average value of the scores indicating the viewing state of each participant for all participants.

[0057] This allows the speaker in charge of the electronic conference to control the progress of the conference while understanding the viewing status of the participants. In this way, the status of conference participants can be grasped in real time, improving the quality of communication.

[0058] For example, even in electronic conferences using Webex or Zoom, the speaker can control the progress of the conference while understanding the viewing status of the participants. Also, in communication mediated by avatars in 3D virtual spaces such as Mozilla Hubs, people in the same virtual space can communicate not only through voice and image data but also while taking into account the status of the other person who cannot be seen directly.

[0059] The creating unit 15d creates minutes of the electronic conference. The determining unit 15e determines whether or not the minutes need to be presented based on the determined viewing state of each participant. The presenting unit 15f presents the relevant parts of the minutes to participants for whom it has been determined that the minutes need to be presented.

[0060] This will enable participants in the electronic conference to have a common understanding, further improving the quality of communication.

[0061] The determining unit 15e also uses the number of comments made by each participant to determine whether or not the minutes should be presented, thereby enabling the level of understanding of the participants to be estimated more accurately and improving the quality of communication.

[0062] [Example] Using the estimation device 10 of this embodiment, an internal group meeting was held via Webex. The first 10 minutes were spent reporting on public notices, followed by weekly reports every 10 minutes for subgroups A, B, and C. The final 20 minutes were spent on a question-and-answer session with the group leader. In this case, the viewing status of all participants was generally good, allowing the speaker to continue making announcements and presentations without interrupting. Meanwhile, Person A left the meeting for about 5 minutes due to poor health and returned shortly, but the time spanned the weekly reports for subgroups B and C. After the meeting ended, a non-viewing report was created based on the minutes 14b and the viewing status log 14a. Person A was notified by email that the minutes, with the content of the meeting time period he missed highlighted (e.g., underlined), were available for review. This allowed Person A to understand the content of the meeting that he did not watch.

[0063] In another example, in an internal group meeting using avatar-mediated communication in a 3D virtual space such as Mozilla Hubs, the first 10 minutes were spent reporting on general information, followed by weekly reports for subgroups A, B, and C every 10 minutes, and the final 20 minutes were spent on a Q&A session with the group leader. In this case, the viewing status of all participants was generally good, allowing speakers to continue their announcements and presentations without interruption. Meanwhile, Mr. A left the meeting for about five minutes due to poor health and returned shortly, but his absence overlapped with the weekly reports for subgroups B and C. After the meeting, a non-viewing report was created based on the minutes 14b and facial expression logs, and Mr. A was notified by email that he could view the minutes with the contents of the meeting he missed highlighted (underlined, etc.). This allowed Mr. A to understand the content of the meeting he missed.

[0064] [Program] A program written in a computer-executable language may be created to execute the processes performed by the estimation device 10 according to the above embodiment. In one embodiment, the estimation device 10 can be implemented by installing an estimation program that executes the above estimation process as package software or online software on a desired computer. For example, by executing the estimation program on an information processing device, the information processing device can function as the estimation device 10. The information processing device referred to here includes desktop and notebook personal computers. Other examples of information processing devices include mobile communication terminals such as smartphones, mobile phones, and PHS (Personal Handyphone Systems), as well as slate terminals such as PDAs (Personal Digital Assistants). The functions of the estimation device 10 may also be implemented on a cloud server.

[0065] 12 is a diagram showing an example of a computer that executes an estimation program. The computer 1000 includes, for example, a memory 1010, a CPU 1020, a hard disk drive interface 1030, a disk drive interface 1040, a serial port interface 1050, a video adapter 1060, and a network interface 1070. These components are connected by a bus 1080.

[0066] The memory 1010 includes a ROM (Read Only Memory) 1011 and a RAM 1012. The ROM 1011 stores a boot program such as a BIOS (Basic Input Output System). The hard disk drive interface 1030 is connected to a hard disk drive 1031. The disk drive interface 1040 is connected to a disk drive 1041. A removable storage medium such as a magnetic disk or optical disk is inserted into the disk drive 1041. The serial port interface 1050 is connected to a mouse 1051 and a keyboard 1052, for example. The video adapter 1060 is connected to a display 1061, for example.

[0067] Here, the hard disk drive 1031 stores, for example, an OS 1091, an application program 1092, a program module 1093, and program data 1094. The various pieces of information described in the above embodiments are stored in the hard disk drive 1031 or memory 1010, for example.

[0068] The estimation program is stored in the hard disk drive 1031 as, for example, a program module 1093 in which instructions to be executed by the computer 1000 are written. Specifically, the program module 1093 in which each process executed by the estimation device 10 described in the above embodiment is written is stored in the hard disk drive 1031.

[0069] Data used for information processing by the estimation program is stored as program data 1094, for example, in the hard disk drive 1031. Then, the CPU 1020 reads the program module 1093 and the program data 1094 stored in the hard disk drive 1031 into the RAM 1012 as necessary, and executes each of the above-described procedures.

[0070] The program module 1093 and program data 1094 related to the estimation program are not limited to being stored in the hard disk drive 1031, and may be stored in, for example, a removable storage medium and read by the CPU 1020 via the disk drive 1041. Alternatively, the program module 1093 and program data 1094 related to the estimation program may be stored in another computer connected via a network such as a LAN or a WAN (Wide Area Network), and read by the CPU 1020 via the network interface 1070.

[0071] Although the present invention has been described above as an embodiment, the present invention is not limited to the description and drawings that form part of the disclosure of the present invention. In other words, other embodiments, examples, and operational techniques that can be made by those skilled in the art based on the present invention are all included in the scope of the present invention.

[0072] REFERENCE SIGNS LIST 10 Estimation device 11 Input unit 12 Output unit 13 Communication control unit 14 Storage unit 14a Viewing state log 14b Minutes 15 Control unit 15a Acquisition unit 15b Determination unit 15c Estimation unit 15d Creation unit 15e Decision unit 15f Presentation unit

Claims

1. An estimation device comprising: an acquisition unit that acquires vital sign measurement values ​​of participants in an electronic conference; a determination unit that uses the acquired vital sign measurement values ​​to determine the viewing state of each participant; and an estimation unit that estimates the quality of the electronic conference held by all participants based on the determined viewing state of each participant.

2. The estimation device according to claim 1, characterized in that the estimation unit estimates the quality of the electronic conference by using an average value of the scores indicating the viewing state of each participant for all participants.

3. The estimation device according to claim 1, further comprising: a creation unit that creates minutes of the electronic conference; a decision unit that determines whether or not the minutes need to be presented based on the viewing state of each determined participant; and a presentation unit that presents the relevant parts of the minutes to participants for whom it has been determined that the minutes need to be presented.

4. The estimation device according to claim 3, characterized in that the determination unit further uses the number of comments made by each participant to determine whether or not the minutes should be presented.

5. An estimation method executed by an estimation device, comprising: an acquisition step of acquiring vital sign measurement values ​​of participants in an electronic conference; a determination step of determining the viewing state of each participant using the acquired vital sign measurement values; and an estimation step of estimating the quality of the electronic conference attended by all participants based on the determined viewing state of each participant.

6. An estimation program for causing a computer to execute the following steps: an acquisition step of acquiring vital sign measurement values ​​of participants in an electronic conference; a determination step of determining the viewing state of each participant using the acquired vital sign measurement values; and an estimation step of estimating the quality of the electronic conference held by all participants based on the determined viewing state of each participant.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Minutes file generating method, minutes file management method, conference server, and network conference system

    JP2005244524A

  • Conference support system and conference support program

    JP2019061594A