Information processing method, computer program, information processing system, and information terminal device
The use of NFTs within a blockchain system addresses the challenges of medical data distribution by ensuring secure, reliable, and transparent access and compensation, enhancing the integrity and usability of medical data across institutions.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/JP2024/019616
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-05-30
- Filing Date
- 2024-05-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
AI Technical Summary
The challenge lies in securely and effectively distributing medical data across different institutions while ensuring its reliability and authenticity, as existing systems face issues with data standardization, tampering, and lack of standardized access controls, hindering cross-institutional use and return on investment.
The method employs Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) within a blockchain system to manage medical data access, allowing for secure distribution and remuneration based on transparent transaction conditions, ensuring that medical data is only accessed with consent from all stakeholders, including patients and medical institutions, thereby maintaining data integrity and reliability.
This approach ensures that medical data is securely and reliably distributed, preventing unauthorized access and ensuring that all stakeholders receive fair compensation, thus supporting trustworthy medical research and data utilization.
Smart Images

Figure JP2024019616_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Information processing method, computer program, information processing system, and information terminal device
[0001] The present invention relates to an information processing method, a computer program, an information processing system, and an information terminal device that realize safe and effective distribution of medical data.
[0002] In light of social conditions such as a declining birthrate and aging population, proposals are continuing to be made for telemedicine systems that enable access to medical care over the network. Even now, healthcare services that apply cutting-edge technologies such as AI, such as preventive medicine, advanced medical techniques, and health maintenance and promotion, are being planned and proposed.
[0003] A characteristic of medical data is that its value decreases when it is abstracted, except for personal names. For example, data that is fully linked with information such as gender, age, and medical history is more important for research and diagnosis. However, medical data is not standardized and is generated individually by medical institutions, doctors, measurement devices, manufacturers, etc. Furthermore, in consideration of concerns about tampering and guaranteeing data authenticity, medical institutions and research institutions each individually enter into contracts with patients regarding the provision of medical data and clinical trials, and the data is only freely used within that institution. This makes it difficult to use medical data across other medical institutions or to improve usability, which inevitably hinders the return of benefits from medical data.
[0004] In order to prevent tampering, a data distribution system has been proposed that applies blockchain technology to medical data so that it can only be used by users who have access rights, rather than allowing complete freedom in the use of medical data (Patent Document 1).
[0005] A data trading system that uses blockchain technology to trade health checkup results has also been proposed (Patent Document 2).
[0006] Patent No. 6721903 Patent No. 6830719
[0007] The players involved in making medical data available in a blockchain system are not limited to patients and medical institutions. If the reliability of any of the various businesses, such as manufacturers of diagnostic testing equipment, maintenance and management companies, developers of applications for registering data in the blockchain system, or network maintenance and management personnel, is lost, the reliability of the medical data will also be lost. It is necessary to automatically obtain consent from multiple businesses, including patients and medical institutions, to ensure reliability.
[0008] An object of the present invention is to provide an information processing method, a computer program, an information processing system, and an information terminal device that realize safe and effective distribution of medical data.
[0009] In one embodiment of the information processing method of the present disclosure, a computer accepts purchase conditions for a set of NFTs (Non-Fungible Tokens) issued for access to patient medical data, outputs search results for sets of NFTs that match the accepted purchase conditions and sales conditions for the searched set of NFTs, accepts a purchase request specifying the set of NFTs to be purchased from the search results, transfers the set of NFTs to a purchaser in response to the purchase request, and provides a reward corresponding to the transfer of the set of NFTs to the registrants registered for each of the NFTs included in the set.
[0010] According to this disclosure, agreements to provide medical data and the provision of compensation based on the sales amount for the provision of medical data are executed not only for patients who are the source of the medical data and medical professionals at the medical institution that performed the diagnosis, but also for businesses. Guarantees and agreements are made, and furthermore, medical data obtained without a share of contributions is prevented from being provided to researchers, which makes it possible to guarantee the reliability of the medical data.
[0011] FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram of a medical data trading system of a first embodiment. FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram of medical data and NFTs to be traded in the medical data trading system. FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing the configuration of a node. FIG. 3 is a block diagram showing the configuration of a first information terminal device. FIG. 4 is a block diagram showing the configuration of a second information terminal device. FIG. 5 is a flowchart showing an example of a processing procedure executed in the medical data trading system. FIG. 6 is a flowchart showing an example of a processing procedure for creating a set of NFTs. FIG. 7 is a flowchart showing an example of a procedure for deriving sales conditions for a set of NFTs. FIG. 8 is a flowchart showing an example of an extraction processing procedure. FIG. 9 is a schematic diagram of a medical data trading system of a second embodiment.
[0012] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS The present disclosure will be specifically described with reference to the drawings illustrating embodiments thereof. In the following embodiments, a medical data trading system to which the information processing method of the present disclosure is applied will be described.
[0013] In this disclosure, a "blockchain system" refers to a system that includes multiple computers that can communicate with each other and a network that connects these multiple computers, and creates a blockchain through distributed processing of the multiple computers. The blockchain incorporates the details of requested transactions.
[0014] (First embodiment) Figure 1 is a schematic diagram of a medical data trading system 100 of the first embodiment. The medical data trading system 100 is a system that provides medical data using a blockchain system to researchers and doctors and distributes the costs incurred for providing the data as compensation. The medical data trading system 100 includes an information processing device 1, a storage 2, a plurality of first information terminal devices 3, and a plurality of second information terminal devices 4. The medical data trading system 100 includes a network N that is a communication medium between the information processing device 1, the storage 2, the first information terminal device 3, and the second information terminal device 4.
[0015] The information processing device 1 is a smart contract implemented by a computer (node) 10 constituting the blockchain system S1. Hereinafter, the information processing device 1 will be described as a virtual entity realized by the cooperation of the hardware of the node 10 and an information processing program.
[0016] Alternatively, the information processing device 1 may be a device installed outside the blockchain system S1, having an account in the blockchain system S1, and capable of sending transactions to the blockchain system S1 where an NFT of medical data is issued. The information processing device 1 may be a device capable of sending requests to a smart contract related to the NFT of medical data deployed on the blockchain system S1. If the NFT is implemented in a smart contract, the request destination may be the NFT itself. Alternatively, the information processing device 1 may be a device capable of delegating to another device in the blockchain system S1 that can send requests to the above-mentioned smart contract.
[0017] The blockchain system S1 uses, for example, a blockchain based on a protocol called Secret Network. The blockchain system S1 may be an Ethereum (registered trademark)-based blockchain system. The blockchain system S1 is a public chain and a blockchain with a protocol that allows smart contracts to be used.
[0018] Storage 2 uses a blockchain system to record medical data in a way that makes it difficult to tamper with. Storage 2 uses, for example, a Dfinity-based blockchain system S2. The blockchain system S2 applied to storage 2 is a public chain and is accessible from either the first information terminal device 3 or the second information terminal device 4. Specifically, storage 2 is configured to include multiple distributed storage media. When a request (transaction) to write medical data to storage 2 is executed, an address (e.g., a URI or identification data) for accessing the medical data is returned. The second information terminal device 4 can access the medical data in storage 2 using this address.
[0019] Storage 2 does not necessarily use the blockchain system S2, but may also be a storage medium that can securely store medical data as a so-called cloud server and has a communication connection that allows it to be accessed from a terminal device with an account that has an NFT.
[0020] The first information terminal device 3 is an information terminal device used by people who contribute to the provision of medical data (patients, medical providers such as doctors), medical institutions, and support providers. The first information terminal device 3 is a device having a communication means and a user interface, such as a smartphone, tablet terminal, or personal computer. The first information terminal device 3 is used by a person who owns an account assigned a blockchain address (wallet address, wallet ID) that can be used in the blockchain system S1, and may store account data (key).
[0021] The second information terminal device 4 is an information terminal device used by a researcher or doctor who wishes to use (reference) medical data. The second information terminal device 4 is a device having a communication means and a user interface, such as a personal computer, smartphone, or tablet terminal. The second information terminal device 4 is used by a person who owns an account assigned a blockchain address (wallet ID, wallet address) that can be used in the blockchain system S1, and may store account data (key).
[0022] The first information terminal device 3 and the second information terminal device 4 can send requests to smart contracts (issuance, purchase, search, etc.) related to NFTs issued for medical data in the blockchain system S1 based on pre-stored account data or input account data.
[0023] The network N is a communication network including a carrier network and a public communication network (Internet). The network N may include a dedicated line. The carrier network includes a base station. The public communication network includes an access point.
[0024] 2 is a schematic diagram of medical data and NFTs to be traded in the medical data trading system 100. In the medical data trading system 100, storage 2 stores encrypted medical data such as test results (numerical data, image data, medication records, etc.) generated by medical treatment for patients and patient-performed measurements, medical interview data from medical institutions in response to the test results, diagnostic data, and genetic information.
[0025] Specifically, medical data is imported into the blockchain system S2 of storage 2 by verifying and approving a transaction requesting storage of the medical data in storage 2. In addition, along with the transmission of the transaction requesting storage of the medical data, a smart contract for issuing an NFT is invoked in the blockchain system S1, and an NFT is issued for the medical data stored in storage 2. The NFT includes a token ID that identifies the NFT, individual identification data of the patient who is the subject of the medical data and is the original NFT owner, a summary of the medical data (search keywords, etc.), the address of the medical data in storage 2, and individual transaction conditions for the NFT, and is imported into the blockchain system S1. Individual transaction conditions may be registered in metadata corresponding to the token, which can be identified by the address of the medical data, or other information may be added. In the example of FIG. 2 , multiple NFTs are issued for one medical data (one test result for one patient), and each NFT contains a serial number (1 / 20: the first of 20).
[0026] The transaction terms for each NFT can take various forms, but preferably include at least a condition regarding the distribution amount for each NFT. The distribution amount preferably includes a minimum desired distribution amount. The distribution amount may be based on the wishes of each patient, medical institution, medical device manufacturer, app provider, platform operator, or network provider, or may be automatically calculated and registered based on their track record (or reliability assessed based on track record).
[0027] The transaction terms here include conditions set not only by the patient, but also by medical institutions (medical professionals such as doctors and laboratory technicians) that contributed to the creation of the medical data, and other businesses. The transaction terms can impose restrictions on reliability, such as restricting the use date of medical equipment, so that businesses will not agree to provide medical data measured with older equipment. The transaction terms may be written in the NFT itself, or may be registered as data that can be referenced from the information processing device 1 in metadata corresponding to the URI of the same medical data. The transaction terms themselves may be converted into hash data.
[0028] As shown in Figure 2, when medical data is stored in storage 2 and NFTs corresponding to that medical data are issued to the blockchain system S1, the medical data trading system 100 performs the following processing.
[0029] In the medical data trading system 100, the information processing device 1 accepts a search request from the second information terminal device 4 for a collection of multiple medical data items, rather than a single medical data item, along with purchase conditions for purchasing the multiple medical data items. The purchase conditions include the number of medical data items, the attributes (types) of the medical data items, and the total price. The information processing device 1 searches for multiple NFTs corresponding to the medical data items stored in the storage 2 based on the purchase conditions and presents sales conditions for changing (transferring) the ownership of the searched collection of medical data items to the requester. The purchase conditions may be based on those proposed by the information processing device 1, such as by outputting a type selection screen or outputting conditions to be set based on past performance. The sales conditions include at least an estimated sales price (cost). At this time, the information processing device 1 calculates and presents a set value for the searched collection of multiple medical data items. The set value is calculated using the set creation algorithm of each information processing device 1 based on the amount of data, the complexity of the data, the freshness of the data, and the like. When the information processing device 1 confirms the purchase request for the presented sales price estimate, it receives payment of the sales price and changes the owner of each NFT corresponding to the target multiple medical data to the account corresponding to the requesting second information terminal device 4. Following the transfer, the information processing device 1 executes the provision of rewards from the sales price to contributors, including at least patients, in the account data of the first information terminal device 3, based on the transaction conditions of each NFT.
[0030] 3 is a block diagram showing the configuration of the node 10. The node 10 is a device that realizes the blockchain system S1 that implements the information processing device 1. The node 10 may be a server computer, a desktop or laptop personal computer, or a communication terminal device such as a smartphone.
[0031] The node 10 includes a processing unit 11, a storage unit 12, and a communication unit 13. As long as the node 10 is a device that includes at least the processing unit 11 and the communication unit 13, part of the processing unit 11 can constitute part or all of the node.
[0032] The processing unit 11 includes a processor such as a central processing unit (CPU) or a graphics processing unit (GPU), and a memory such as a read-only memory (ROM) or a random access memory (RAM). The processing unit 11 may be configured as a single piece of hardware (SoC: System on a Chip) that integrates the processor, memory, storage unit 12, and communication unit 13. The memory of the processing unit 11 may store a private key unique to each node 10. The processing unit 11 executes processes based on a node program stored in the storage unit 12, causing the general-purpose computer to function as a node in the blockchain system S1. Furthermore, the processing unit 11 functions as the information processing device 1, which is a smart contract, by processing based on a smart contract program (information processing program P1) stored in the storage unit 12, and executes the processes described below.
[0033] The storage unit 12 uses a hard disk, a solid state drive (SSD), or a flash memory, and stores programs and data referenced by the processing unit 11, including the node program and the smart contract program. The storage unit 12 stores the blockchain in the blockchain system S1. The private key described above may be stored in the storage unit 12.
[0034] The information processing program P1 stored in the storage unit 12 may be an information processing program P9 stored in a computer-readable storage medium 9 that has been read by the processing unit 11 and stored in the storage unit 12. The information processing program P1 may also be downloaded from a distribution server device outside the system and stored in the storage unit 12.
[0035] The communication unit 13 realizes mutual communication with other nodes 10 in the blockchain system S1, and realizes sending and receiving of data with the first information terminal device 3 and the second information terminal device 4 via the network N. Specifically, the communication unit 13 uses a network card, an optical communication device, a wireless communication device, or the like.
[0036] FIG. 4 is a block diagram showing the configuration of the first information terminal device 3. As described above, the first information terminal device 3 is a personal computer, smartphone, or tablet device primarily used by patients. The first information terminal device 3 functions based on accounts in the blockchain system S1 that are assigned to patients and medical professionals, such as doctors, who contributed to the storage of medical data in the storage 2. Each of the first information terminal devices 3 also functions based on accounts assigned to manufacturers (developers) of medical devices such as testing equipment, app providers for the remote medical care system, platform providers for the blockchain system S1, network providers, and even the operator (support provider) of the medical data trading system 100 itself. Here, for patients, accounts are issued based on the patient's individual identification data (a combination of a facial photograph, My Number (registered trademark), identification data from an insurance card, etc.). Accounts are also issued based on individual identification data, such as a business number and tax-related identification data, for medical providers, manufacturers, app providers, and network providers.
[0037] The first information terminal device 3 includes at least a processing unit 30, a storage unit 31, a communication unit 32, a display unit 33, and an operation unit .
[0038] The processing unit 30 uses a processor such as a CPU or a GPU, and a memory such as a ROM or a RAM. The processing unit 30 may be configured as a single piece of hardware that integrates the processor, the memory, and further the storage unit 31 and the communication unit 32.
[0039] The storage unit 31 uses a hard disk, SSD, or flash memory and stores programs and data referenced by the processing unit 30, including the first information terminal program P3. The first information terminal program P3 is a program for causing a computer to function as the first information terminal device 3 in the information processing method of the present disclosure. The storage unit 31 stores the user's account data (also referred to as wallet address or wallet ID) and private key in the blockchain system S1. The private key may be stored in a non-rewritable manner, or may be stored in other hardware (a hardware wallet).
[0040] The communication unit 32 is a communication device that establishes a communication connection with the blockchain system S1 including the information processing device 1 via the network N. The communication unit 32 may be a network card, a wireless communication device, or a carrier communication device.
[0041] The display unit 33 uses a display device such as a liquid crystal panel or an organic EL display. The operation unit 34 is an interface that accepts operations by the user on the medical data provider side. The operation unit 34 uses physical buttons, a touch panel device with a built-in display, a speaker, a microphone, etc. The operation unit 34 may accept operations on a screen displayed on the display unit 33 using physical buttons or a touch panel, or may recognize the operation content from input voice using a microphone and accept the operation in an interactive format using the voice output from a speaker.
[0042] When the first information terminal device 3 configured as described above is connected to a measuring device for measuring vital data of a patient, the first information terminal device 3 creates medical data by associating individual identification data, such as the MAC address of the measuring device, with the vital data based on the first information terminal program P3. The created medical data is sent directly to the storage 2 or to the storage 2 via a medical institution and stored there. The information processing device 1 can trace data identifying the device's manufacturer from the individual identification data of the measuring device included in the medical data. In this case, if a blockchain-related application is used to support the storage of medical data in the storage 2, it is preferable that the medical data or corresponding metadata include information indicating that the medical data was sent via the application. The information processing device 1 can also trace data identifying the application's management company or the network operator. When medical data is sent to the storage 2 via a medical institution, the medical institution's identification data and the medical provider's identification data are additionally associated with text data corresponding to the vital data and the diagnosis results, and stored as medical data.
[0043] The transaction conditions for each NFT are stored in association with the account data so as to be referable to the information processing device 1. The storage location may be the storage 2, a storage medium in the blockchain system S1, or the storage unit 31 of each first information terminal device 3.
[0044] FIG. 5 is a block diagram showing the configuration of the second information terminal device 4. As described above, the second information terminal device 4 is a device used by researchers and medical institutions who wish to use the medical data stored in the storage 2. The second information terminal device 4 functions as the second information terminal device 4 based on an account in the blockchain system S1 assigned to researchers, research institutions, medical institutions, etc., and a second information terminal program P4. The hardware configuration of the second information terminal device 4 is similar to that of the first information terminal device 3, so corresponding reference numerals are used and detailed description is omitted. The second information terminal device 4 is capable of communicating with the information processing device 1.
[0045] A second information terminal program P4 for causing a general-purpose computer to function as the second information terminal device 4 is stored in the storage unit 41 of the second information terminal device 4. The second information terminal program P4 may be a second information terminal program P8 stored in a computer-readable storage medium 8 that has been read by the processing unit 40 and stored in the storage unit 41. The second information terminal program P8 may also be downloaded from a distribution server device outside the system and stored in the storage unit 41.
[0046] The processing unit 40 of the second information terminal device 4 is capable of searching for and receiving medical data from the storage 2 or NFTs in the blockchain system S1 based on the second information terminal program P4. The second information terminal device 4 also has a wallet, i.e., a blockchain account, set up that can access at least the blockchain system S1. For example, a blockchain account is issued based on individual identification data such as a researcher's researcher identification data or a My Number card that identifies an individual researcher or representative. It may also be issued based on individual identification data assigned to medical institutions or research institutions. The account data is stored in the storage unit 41.
[0047] In the medical data trading system 100 configured as described above, researchers and medical institutions who wish to use the medical data stored in the storage 2 purchase a collection of NFTs of medical data using the second information terminal device 4. Medical data that is more valuable to research institutions is data on various patients related to the same case, data on various symptoms detected through tests for the same patient, or data summarizing changes over time, rather than individual pieces of data. Therefore, in the medical data trading system 100 to which the information processing system disclosed herein is applied, the function of the information processing device 1 is to appropriately extract sets of medical data stored in the storage 2, calculate a set value for the extracted set, and present it to the second information terminal device 4.
[0048] FIG. 6 is a flowchart showing an example of a processing procedure executed by the medical data trading system 100.
[0049] A researcher who wishes to use medical data edits purchase conditions specifying the type of medical data desired using the second information terminal device 4. Here, the processing unit 40 of the second information terminal device 4 identifies the purchase conditions for purchasing NFTs to access the medical data based on the researcher's operation on the operation unit 44 (step S401).
[0050] The purchase conditions specify at least one of the following: the number of medical data, the type of medical data (blood glucose data, X-ray data, blood pressure data, etc.), the time the medical data was created, the time the diagnosis or test was performed, and the attributes of the patient from whom the medical data is derived (age, gender, symptoms, illness, etc.). The purchase conditions may further specify the medical institution where the diagnosis was made, or the manufacturer of the medical equipment used in the test. For example, the purchase conditions may be specified as "50 units," "after 2020," "foot X-ray," or "age 60 or older."
[0051] The processing unit 40 specifies the purchase conditions and transmits a request for searching for NFTs of medical data to the information processing device 1 (step S402). In step S402, the processing unit 40 invokes and activates a smart contract (information processing device 1) that executes an NFT search in the blockchain system S1, and transmits the request by passing the purchase conditions. In step S402, the processing unit 40 invokes the smart contract by specifying its own wallet ID.
[0052] The called information processing device 1 receives the search request together with the purchase conditions (step S101), and creates one or more patterns of sets of NFTs that match the specified purchase conditions based on the received search request (step S102). The multiple patterns of sets of NFTs created in step S102 are the search results.
[0053] For each of the multiple patterns of NFT sets created, the information processing device 1 derives sales conditions for the set of NFTs based on the transaction conditions set for each NFT included in the set (step S103). In step S103, the information processing device 1 may calculate the total cost (sales amount) required to purchase the NFTs for each set of NFTs, or may identify the attributes of researchers (institutions) permitted to download them. The cost required to purchase the set of NFTs may be the total of the minimum desired distribution amounts included in the transaction conditions associated with each NFT, or, as described below, the total value (set value) derived based on the amount of medical data corresponding to the set of NFTs. The cost may include transaction fees for each NFT included in the set, as well as fees such as gas fees for processing by the information processing device 1 (smart contract). The cost may be calculated so that its value fluctuates using one or more of the following: the degree of distribution of the medical data corresponding to the set of NFTs (the storage location of the actual data), the complexity of the medical data corresponding to the set of NFTs, and the number of conditions specified in the purchase conditions received in step S101.
[0054] The information processing device 1 extracts a set of NFTs from the set of NFTs created in S102, each of which has calculated sales conditions that match the received purchase conditions (step S104). In step S104, the information processing device 1 extracts a set of NFTs that satisfy all of the transaction conditions set for each of the received purchase conditions, as described below (see FIG. 9 ). That is, at the time of step S104, NFTs that include registered users who cannot agree to the purchase conditions are excluded. Depending on the strength of the conditions, NFTs may be excluded if there is even one registered user who cannot agree (if all transaction conditions are not met), or may not be excluded if at least the patient's transaction conditions are met.
[0055] The information processing device 1 transmits (outputs) a list (search result) of one or more extracted sets of NFTs and the sales conditions for each set derived in step S103 to the second information terminal device 4 that originated the search request (step S105).
[0056] The second information terminal device 4 receives the list of extracted NFT sets (search results) and the sales conditions for each set (step S403), and outputs the received search results and sales conditions to the display unit 43 (step S404). The processing unit 40 accepts a selection of a set of NFTs to be purchased from the search results (step S405), and transmits a purchase request specifying the selected set of NFTs to the information processing device 1 (step S406).
[0057] The information processing device 1 receives a purchase request specifying a set of NFTs to be purchased (step S106), and executes a transfer of the NFTs specified in the purchase request to the blockchain account corresponding to the requesting second information terminal device 4 (step S107). In step S107, the information processing device 1 executes a transaction to change (transfer) the owner of the NFTs to the blockchain account of the second information terminal device 4.
[0058] Following the transfer, the information processing device 1 executes a process of distributing and providing rewards for each NFT included in the specified set of NFTs to patients, medical institutions, and other businesses registered in the NFTs (step S108).
[0059] In step S108, the information processing device 1 transfers and distributes an amount equivalent to a sales amount derived for the specified set of NFTs from the assets associated with the second information terminal device 4 in the blockchain system S1 to the account data of each registrant. The information processing device 1 may deduct a fee from the assets transferred from the second information terminal device 4 and then provide a reward based on the transaction conditions registered for each NFT to the account data of each registrant. The reward amount is not limited to the amount stated in the transaction conditions, and may be an amount calculated separately to satisfy the transaction conditions. Note that the purchase price included in the purchase request received in step S106 may be allowed to exceed the sales price by settings. In this case, in step S108, an amount equivalent to the purchase price specified by the purchaser may be transferred and distributed.
[0060] Through the above-mentioned processing, the processing unit 40 can obtain the URI of the target medical data in storage 2 using the NFT belonging to the blockchain account in the blockchain system S1 of the second information terminal device 4, and can decrypt the encrypted medical data.
[0061] 7 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a process for creating a set of NFTs. The process shown in the flowchart of FIG. 7 corresponds to the details of step S102 in the process shown in FIG.
[0062] The information processing device 1 extracts medical data and its NFT based on the type of data requested and included in the purchase conditions (step S201). For example, the information processing device 1 may search for medical data that is explicitly identified as blood glucose level data from the storage 2, or may search for an NFT that includes a summary description of blood glucose level from the blockchain system S1.
[0063] The information processing device 1 determines whether a patient attribute is specified in the purchase conditions (step S202). If it is determined that an attribute is specified (S202: YES), the information processing device 1 narrows down the medical data NFTs extracted in step S201 to NFTs of medical data from patients with the specified attribute (step S203). The attributes in step S202 include gender, age, address, medical history, blood type, genetic information, etc.
[0064] If it is determined in step S202 that no attribute is specified (S202: NO), the information processing device 1 omits the process of step S203.
[0065] The information processing device 1 determines whether a time period is specified in the purchase conditions (step S204). If it is determined that a time period is specified in the purchase conditions (S204: YES), the information processing device 1 narrows down the NFTs extracted in step S201 to NFTs of medical data that were generated and stored during the specified time period (step S205). If it is determined that a time period is not specified in step S204 (S204: NO), the information processing device 1 omits the processing of step S205.
[0066] The information processing device 1 determines whether the number of data or the number of patients is specified in the purchase conditions (step S206). If it is determined that the number of data or the number of patients is specified (S206: YES), the information processing device 1 determines whether the number of NFTs corresponding to the medical data extracted and narrowed down up to step S206 matches the number specified in the purchase conditions (step S207). In step S207, if a minimum number of data is specified in the purchase conditions, the information processing device 1 determines that the number of NFTs of the extracted and narrowed down medical data matches if the number of NFTs is equal to or greater than the minimum number of data. If a range of the number of data is specified in the purchase conditions, the information processing device 1 determines that the number of NFTs of the extracted and narrowed down medical data matches if it is within the range of the number of data specified in the purchase conditions. If a maximum number of data is specified in the purchase conditions, the information processing device 1 determines that the number of NFTs of the extracted and narrowed down medical data matches if it is equal to or less than the maximum number of data.
[0067] If the information processing device 1 determines that the number of NFTs corresponding to the medical data extracted and narrowed down up to step S206 matches the number specified in the purchase conditions (S207: YES), it stores the NFTs of the medical data extracted and narrowed down up to step S206 as a set of NFTs and stores the token IDs of the NFTs (step S208).The information processing device 1 returns the process to step S103 in the flowchart of FIG.
[0068] If the information processing device 1 determines that the number of NFTs corresponding to the medical data extracted and narrowed down by step S206 does not match the number specified in the purchase conditions (S207: NO), the information processing device 1 sorts the NFTs corresponding to the medical data extracted and narrowed down by step S206 (step S209). In step S209, the information processing device 1 may sort the medical data in descending order of creation date and time, or in descending order of the number of remaining NFTs (rareness). In step S209, the information processing device 1 may sort the medical data by patient identification data (patient ID, account data) so that more medical data from the same patient is included. The information processing device 1 extracts the NFTs of the sorted medical data from the top according to the specified number (step S210). The information processing device 1 stores the token IDs of the extracted medical data as a set of NFTs (S208) and returns the process to step S103 of the flowchart of FIG. 6.
[0069] If it is determined in step S207 that there is no match (S207: NO), or if the number of NFTs extracted and narrowed down up to step S206 is insufficient to satisfy the purchase conditions, such as if the number of data items is less than the minimum number, the processes of steps S209 and S210 cannot be executed. In this case, the information processing device 1 determines that no NFTs matching the purchase conditions have been found, and terminates the process.
[0070] If it is determined in step S206 that the number of data or the number of patients has not been designated (S206: NO), the information processing device 1 skips the processes of steps S207-S210 and proceeds to step S208.
[0071] Of course, the process for creating a set of NFTs is not limited to the process shown in Fig. 7. The purchase conditions may include the designation of the medical institution and medical personnel where the diagnosis was made, the designation of the medical equipment used for the measurement, and the designation of the manufacturer of the medical equipment. The purchase conditions may also include the designation of the app provider that supports remote diagnosis.
[0072] The information processing device 1 may execute the processing procedure shown in the flowchart of FIG. 7 multiple times to extract and output multiple patterns of NFT sets as search results. Furthermore, for example, if the number of NFTs corresponding to medical data extracted and narrowed down before step S206 is greater than the number specified in the purchase conditions, the information processing device 1 may sort the data based on criteria such as those shown in step S209 to extract multiple patterns of NFT sets. The information processing device 1 may perform sorting such as step S209 based on different criteria to extract the top results and extract multiple patterns of NFT sets. If the purchase conditions specify multiple conditions (type, attribute, period, medical institution, etc.) using a logical OR, multiple patterns of NFT sets may be extracted for each condition. The information processing device 1 may extract multiple patterns of sets depending on which condition is prioritized for extraction. The information processing device 1 may extract multiple patterns of NFT sets for each condition, such as the type of data, patient attributes, and period, specified in the purchase conditions. 7 may be executed based on feedback so that the value calculated after this extraction process is maximized. The processes of S102 to S104 may be executed repeatedly so that the sales price matches the specified purchase conditions and satisfies the transaction conditions of each NFT.
[0073] Fig. 8 is a flowchart showing an example of a procedure for deriving sales conditions for a set of NFTs. The procedure shown in the flowchart of Fig. 8 corresponds to the details of the process of step S103 in the procedure shown in Fig. 6. The information processing device 1 executes the following procedure for each of the extracted NFT sets of one or more patterns.
[0074] The information processing device 1 identifies the data amount (number of data) for the target NFT set (step S301).
[0075] The information processing device 1 identifies the parameter of the data type (e.g., blood glucose level) specified when extracting the NFT (step S302), and calculates the rarity value based on the parameter and a predetermined comparison value (step S303).
[0076] The information processing device 1 calculates an index of the degree of dispersion of the extracted NFTs (step S304). In step S304, the information processing device 1 may derive an index (market value) corresponding to the difficulty of collecting data from the degree of physical dispersion of the medical data within storage 2. If the data is obtained from the same storage medium, the index is low, and if the data is obtained from different storage media across network N, for example, the index is high. In step S304, the information processing device 1 may derive an index corresponding to the difficulty of collection from the degree of dispersion of the location of the patient from whom the medical data originated (derived from a MAC address, etc.) and the location of the medical institution where the diagnosis was made. In this case, the information processing device 1 may use the maximum radius and average distance from the center of gravity of the location of each medical data as the index. The information processing device 1 calculates the market value based on the index of the degree of dispersion derived in step S304 (step S305).
[0077] The information processing device 1 calculates a complex value based on the complexity of the medical data corresponding to the NFT included in the set (step S306). In step S306, the information processing device 1 may calculate a higher complex value the greater the number of patients that are the source of the medical data. The information processing device 1 may calculate a higher complex value the greater the amount of medical data associated with the patient that is the source of the medical data. The information processing device 1 may calculate a higher complex value if the medical data is data from a device that is pre-set as a specific medical device. The information processing device 1 may calculate a very high complex value if data of the same type (blood glucose level) for the same patient is arranged in chronological order. The information processing device 1 may calculate a higher complex value the greater the number of conditions included in the purchase conditions. The information processing device 1 calculates a higher complex value the greater the number of arithmetic expressions connecting the number of conditions (the more complex the expressions).
[0078] In step S306, the information processing device 1 may calculate a higher complex value the more recent (fresher) the medical data of the extracted NFT is. In step S306, the information processing device 1 may calculate a higher complex value the longer the period from the generation of the medical data to the recording of the corresponding NFT is. The information processing device 1 may calculate a higher complex value depending on whether the medical data is from an epidemic period of a specific infectious disease or the like.
[0079] The information processing device 1 identifies a trust value for a set of NFTs (step S307). In step S307, the information processing device 1 calculates a higher trust value the more businesses (stakeholders) that have registered transaction terms in the NFT. The information processing device 1 may identify a set of trust values according to the level of trust in each business (such as the size of the medical institution).
[0080] The information processing device 1 determines the aggregate value of the set of NFTs and the unit price of each NFT of medical data based on the calculated rarity value, distribution value, complexity value, and trust value (step S308). In step S308, the information processing device 1 may calculate the aggregate value by adding up the unit prices of each value using a table showing the correspondence between the calculated rarity value, distribution value, complexity value, and trust value and the unit prices determined from each value. The information processing device 1 may calculate the unit price by multiplying the unit price corresponding to the number of data identified in step S301 (based on a table in which the price is cheaper the larger the quantity) by a rate set for each range of rarity value, distribution value, complexity value, and trust value. The information processing device 1 may first calculate the unit price of each extracted NFT based on rarity value, complexity value, and trust value, add them up, and then multiply them by a rate corresponding to the distribution value corresponding to the degree of dispersion.
[0081] The information processing device 1 determines the selling price based on the collective value and unit price of the collection of NFTs, adding a transaction fee, etc. (step S309), and returns the process to step S104 of the flowchart in Figure 6.
[0082] Fig. 9 is a flowchart showing an example of an extraction process. The extraction process shown in the flowchart of Fig. 9 is a process executed after the unit price of each NFT is determined by the process of Fig. 8, and corresponds to the details of step S104 in the process of Fig. 6.
[0083] The information processing device 1 selects one of the sets of extracted NFTs (step S501). Then, it selects one of the NFTs included in the selected set (step S502). It references the unit price (temporarily stored or stored in the memory unit 12) determined in step S308 for the selected NFT (step S503). The information processing device 1 determines whether the remuneration distribution amount based on the unit price referenced in step S503 satisfies the transaction conditions for distribution to each of the patients and other businesses registered with the selected NFT (step S504).
[0084] In step S504, the information processing device 1 compares the unit price referenced in step S503 with the patient and other businesses to determine the distribution amount, which is divided at a predetermined ratio, against the transaction terms. For example, a predetermined distribution rate can be set such that the patient's share is 50%, the medical institution's share is 25%, and the remainder is divided by the number of businesses for which transaction terms are registered. In this case, if the unit price referenced in step S503 is 160 and a medical institution, a medical device manufacturer, and an app provider are registered in addition to the patient, the distribution amounts are: patient: 80, medical institution: 40, manufacturer: 20, and app provider: 20. Here, if the patient has registered a minimum desired distribution amount of 90 for the NFT as a transaction term, the information processing device 1 determines in step S504 that there is no match. Alternatively, if the patient has registered a minimum desired distribution amount of 60, the medical institution a minimum desired distribution amount of 40, the manufacturer a minimum desired distribution amount of 5, and the app provider a minimum desired distribution amount of 5, the information processing device 1 determines in step S504 that the transaction conditions are met.
[0085] Transaction terms are not limited to distribution at the predetermined distribution rate set as described above. For example, distributions to patients who benefit from the activities of researchers and doctors who purchase medical data may be set at zero, and distributions to other businesses may be allocated equally. When applied to advertising businesses using medical data, distribution rates to patients or businesses (stakeholders) who are the target of advertising may be increased. When applied to advertising businesses, advertisers may acquire a collection of NFTs to access medical data. A collection of NFTs may also be provided for public benefit by patient groups.
[0086] In step S504, if the information processing device 1 determines that the distribution amount of the reward satisfies each transaction condition (S504: YES), it determines whether all NFTs included in the set have been processed (step S505). If the information processing device 1 determines that all NFTs included in the selected set have been processed (S505: YES), it stores the result as a search result (step S506) and proceeds to step S507.
[0087] When the information processing device 1 determines that some of the NFTs included in the selected set have not been processed (S505: NO), the process returns to step S502 and the next NFT is selected.
[0088] In step S504, if the information processing device 1 determines that the distribution amount of the reward does not satisfy some or all of the transaction conditions (S504: NO), it excludes the set from the search results, assuming that the distribution amount of the reward does not satisfy the transaction conditions as a set (step S508). In step S504, for example, if the transaction conditions set for one NFT included in the set do not satisfy the transaction conditions of one patient or business, the information processing device 1 determines that the distribution amount of the reward does not satisfy the transaction conditions (S504: NO). In this case, the information processing device 1 stops processing the selected set and proceeds to step S507.
[0089] The information processing device 1 determines whether all sets have been selected (step S507). If it is determined that there is an unselected set (S507: NO), the information processing device 1 returns the process to step S501 and executes the process for the remaining sets.
[0090] If it is determined that all sets have been selected (S507: YES), the information processing device 1 ends the extraction processing procedure and returns the process to step S105 in FIG.
[0091] By using the extraction process procedure in Figure 9, even some businesses will be excluded from the aggregate search results if the amount of reward distribution does not meet the transaction conditions. This prevents medical data obtained without a guarantee or consent from being provided to researchers, thereby ensuring the reliability of the medical data.
[0092] 6 to 9 have been described as being executed by the information processing device 1, which is a single smart contract, but they may also be executed by a combination of different smart contracts. The transfer process of the collection of NFTs and the distribution of rewards may be executed by calling a smart contract, but other processes may be executed by other information processing devices inside or outside the blockchain system S1.
[0093] The medical data trading system 100 shown in the first embodiment makes it possible to automatically obtain agreement on the terms of the transaction among the stakeholders who contribute to the creation of medical data and its storage in the storage 2, and then transfer the NFT. The medical data obtained through the NFT is guaranteed to be highly reliable data obtained with the consent of all stakeholders. This makes it possible to support medical research based on unaltered medical data, with clear origins of the medical institutions, measuring equipment, etc. involved in the creation of the medical data.
[0094] Second Embodiment In the first embodiment, the information processing device 1 that performs searches and outputs estimates is realized as a single smart contract. In contrast, in the second embodiment, multiple smart contracts, each with a different extraction algorithm, are deployed, allowing researchers to select one of them.
[0095] 10 is a schematic diagram of a medical data trading system 100 according to the second embodiment. The medical data trading system 100 according to the second embodiment has the same configuration as that of the first embodiment, except that there are multiple information processing devices 1 and the processing performed accordingly is different. Therefore, the components of the medical data trading system 100 according to the second embodiment that are common to the medical data trading system 100 according to the first embodiment are denoted by the same reference numerals and detailed descriptions thereof will be omitted.
[0096] As shown in FIG. 10, in the second embodiment, the information processing device 1 searches for information using a plurality of different algorithms, and is configured to be deployed as a plurality of smart contracts managed by different operators.
[0097] In the second embodiment, when a researcher who wants to use medical data uses the second information terminal device 4 to edit and determine the purchase conditions for the type of medical data they want, the second information terminal device 4 calls the multiple information processing devices 1 in the blockchain system S1. The processing unit 40 of the second information terminal device 4 executes the processing procedure shown in FIG. 6 of the first embodiment for the multiple information processing devices 1, and selects and operates a set of NFTs from the search results output from each of the multiple information processing devices 1. Of the multiple information processing devices 1, any information processing device 1 that was not selected from the search results for the set of output (transmitted) NFTs does not execute the processing from step S106 onwards.
[0098] According to the second embodiment, researchers can select and purchase NFTs of medical data stored in the same storage 2 from information processing devices 1 that have different methods for creating the collection. This makes it possible to appropriately select different curator businesses (information processing devices 1) for the medical data storage 2, thereby supporting technological development through the use of highly reliable medical data.
[0099] In the first and second embodiments described above, the information processing device 1 is realized by a smart contract that operates in a blockchain system. However, the information processing device is not limited to this, and may be an information processing device that is capable of searching for NFTs outside the chain but within the blockchain system.
[0100] The embodiments disclosed above are illustrative in all respects and are not restrictive. The scope of the present invention is defined by the claims, and includes all modifications within the meaning and scope of the claims.
[0101] REFERENCE SIGNS LIST 1 Information processing device 10 Node 11 Processing unit 12 Storage unit 13 Communication unit P1, P9 Information processing program 2 Storage 4 Second information terminal device 40 Processing unit 43 Display unit P4, P8 Second information terminal program 8, 9 Storage medium
Claims
1. An information processing method in which a computer executes the following processes: accepts purchase conditions for a set of Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) issued for access to patient medical data; outputs search results for sets of NFTs that match the accepted purchase conditions and sales conditions for the searched set of NFTs; accepts a purchase request specifying the set of NFTs to be purchased from the search results; transfers the set of NFTs to a purchaser in response to the purchase request; and provides a reward corresponding to the transfer of the set of NFTs to the registrants registered for each of the NFTs included in the set.
2. The information processing method described in claim 1, wherein at least the transfer of the collection of NFTs and the provision of the reward among the processes are performed by a smart contract on a blockchain.
3. The information processing method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the registrants include at least one of the patients, medical professionals involved in the creation of the medical data, platform operators issuing NFTs of the medical data, medical device developers involved in the creation of the medical data, and operators supporting the collection of the medical data.
4. The information processing method of claim 1, wherein the computer creates a collection of NFTs of medical data based on the purchase conditions, calculates a collection value for the created collection of NFTs, and outputs sales conditions for the collection of NFTs based on the calculated collection value.
5. The information processing method according to claim 4, wherein the computer creates a set of NFTs corresponding to the medical data according to attributes of the medical data based on the purchase conditions.
6. The information processing method according to claim 4 or 5, wherein the sales conditions include an estimated sales amount for each set based on the calculated set value.
7. The information processing method according to claim 4 or 5, wherein the computer creates a set of NFTs corresponding to the medical data based on different algorithms and calculates a set value of the set of NFTs, and outputs search results and sales conditions for the set of NFTs for each algorithm.
8. The information processing method of claim 4 or 5, wherein the computer calculates a set value for the set based on at least one of the following: the population of medical data contained in the set of NFTs, the degree of distribution of the medical data contained in the set, the complexity of the medical data contained in the set, and the number of purchase conditions related to the extraction of the set.
9. The information processing method of claim 1 or 2, wherein each of the NFTs is stored in association with transaction conditions, and the computer determines whether the amount of the reward provided satisfies the transaction conditions of each of the NFTs, and if it determines that the conditions are satisfied, outputs the result as a search result.
10. A computer program that causes a computer to execute the following processes: accept purchase conditions for a collection of NFTs issued for access to patient medical data; output search results for collections of NFTs that match the accepted purchase conditions and sales conditions for the searched collection of NFTs; accept a purchase request specifying the collection of NFTs to be purchased from the search results; transfer the collection of NFTs to a purchaser in response to the purchase request; and provide a reward corresponding to the transfer of the collection of NFTs to the registrants registered for each of the NFTs included in the set.
11. An information processing system comprising: a blockchain system in which NFTs are issued for access to patient medical data; a plurality of information processing devices each performing processing related to the NFTs in the blockchain system; and an information terminal device which transmits and receives data via communication with the plurality of information processing devices, wherein the information terminal device transmits a search request based on purchase conditions for the collection of NFTs to each of the plurality of information processing devices, and each of the plurality of information processing devices transmits search results for the collection of NFTs that match the received purchase conditions and sales conditions for the searched collection of NFTs to the information terminal device, wherein the information terminal device displays the search results and sales conditions transmitted from the plurality of information processing devices on a display unit, accepts selection of a collection of NFTs from the search results of any one of the information processing devices, and transmits a purchase request specifying the selected collection of NFTs to the one of the information processing devices, and the one of the information processing devices performs a transfer process of the collection of NFTs to a purchaser in response to the received purchase request, and provides a reward corresponding to the transfer of the collection of NFTs to a registrant registered for each of the NFTs included in the set.
12. A computer program that causes a computer to execute the following processes: accept editing of purchase conditions for a collection of NFTs issued for access to a patient's medical data; display on a display unit search results for collections of NFTs that match the edited purchase conditions and sales conditions for the searched collection of NFTs; accept selection of a collection of NFTs to be purchased from the displayed search results; and receive the transfer result of the NFTs based on a purchase request that specifies the selected collection of NFTs.
13. An information terminal device comprising: a memory unit storing account data in a blockchain system to which NFTs are issued for access to a patient's medical data; and a display unit displaying the medical data; accepting edits to purchase conditions for a collection of NFTs; displaying on the display unit search results for collections of NFTs that match the edited purchase conditions and sales conditions for the searched collection of NFTs; accepting selection of a collection of NFTs to be purchased from the displayed search results; and receiving the transfer result of the NFTs based on a purchase request specifying the selected collection of NFTs.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Health and Medical Information Sharing System
JP7149022B1
Medical data sharing using blockchain
WO2022263589A1
