Method for measuring cybersecurity state of ship, and method for evaluating cybersecurity risk and detecting abnormal sign of ship
The method addresses the limitations of conventional cyber risk assessment in ship environments by quantifying risks and using machine learning for real-time anomaly detection, ensuring ship availability and operational safety through a network-agnostic approach.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/KR2024/007462
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-06-07
- Filing Date
- 2024-05-31
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
AI Technical Summary
Conventional methods for assessing and quantifying cyber risks in ship environments face limitations due to their general network-centric approach, which can violate ship availability and struggle with real-time risk detection, especially in the unique maritime environment where traditional land-based cybersecurity measures are insufficient.
A method that collects and indexes cyber threat data from various sources, scores risks based on occurrence criteria, and divides ship areas by importance to provide quantified risk assessments without installing agents on the ship's network, using machine learning for anomaly detection and real-time threat analysis.
This approach maintains ship availability by providing quantified cybersecurity risk assessments and real-time anomaly detection, preventing false positives and excessive security measures, thus ensuring the safety of ship operations by predicting and mitigating cyber risks effectively.
Smart Images

Figure KR2024007462_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Methods for Measuring the Status of Ship Cybersecurity, and Methods for Assessing Ship Cybersecurity Risks and Detecting Anomalies
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for measuring the status of a ship's cybersecurity, and a method for evaluating ship cybersecurity risks and detecting abnormal signs, wherein risk data collected through various routes is indexed and scored according to various criteria such as the degree of risk occurrence, areas are divided according to importance such as a ship's cabin, bridge room, and engine room, and a quantitative risk scoring of the CBS of each area is provided.
[0002] Conventional techniques for assessing or quantifying cyber risks quantify them in network-connected situations. Because these quantification methods quantify the state of a typical network connection, their general applicability is limited depending on the industry.
[0003] Current conventional techniques for cyber threats involve calculating the overall cyber risk probability by calculating the probability between nodes by assigning weights to each node in the network, and installing agents on endpoints to collect and quantify data that can be retrieved from the system.
[0004] Scoring methods for various cyber risks use Bayesian probability / statistics, which requires probabilistic calculations, to derive the final risk probability by comparing it with past network behavior, or to estimate and sum the cyber threats that may occur from each client.
[0005] However, the conventional technology has a problem in that the method of analyzing the ship network may generate excessive network traffic, as agents for risk scoring are distributed to endpoints to collect possible risk data, or the method of monitoring the network and comparing it with past behavior patterns to perform analysis, and the method of installing agents on endpoints may violate ship availability, so there are limitations in use.
[0006] Furthermore, cybersecurity risk assessment methods typically used in land-based sectors such as finance, nuclear power plants, general businesses, and infrastructure are based on onshore cybersecurity risk assessments. Ships must also undergo maritime cybersecurity risk assessments, and to this end, the International Classification Society and each classification society are publishing cybersecurity risk assessment methods.
[0007] As illustrated in Figure 6, this diagram compares ISO 27001 and IACS Rec 171, with the ISO 27001 Information Security Management System (ISMS) setting the standard for information security control items. IACS Rec 171 presents a risk assessment for ships.
[0008] Therefore, based on the control items of ISO 27001 information security, the ship's risk can be assessed at each stage through IACS Rec 171.
[0009] In this regard, the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) ISO 31000:2018 “Risk management - Guidelines” describes the risk management process as follows: (1) communication and consultation, (2) scope, context, and criteria, (3) risk assessment, (4) risk treatment, (5) monitoring and review, and (6) recording and reporting. Here, risk assessment is described as the stages of risk identification, risk analysis, and risk evaluation.
[0010] The method for assessing the risk of a ship in the International Association of Classification Societies (IACS) Rec 171 “Recommendation on incorporating cyber risk management into Safety Management Systems” is as follows, as shown in Figure 7: (1) scope definition (S10), (2) UR E22 category classification (S20), (3) threat list identification (S30), (4) threat, attack, and technology impact (S40), (5) operational threat (S50), (6) likelihood assessment (S60), (7) risk level assessment (S70), (8) decision on risk action (S80), (9) risk mitigation (S90), and (10) residual risk (S92). The ship cybersecurity risk assessment methods announced by each classification society, such as Lloyd's Register of the UK, Bureau Veritas of France, Det Norske Veritas of Norway, and the Korean Register of Shipping, do not deviate from IACS Rec 171.
[0011] The three elements of security are confidentiality, integrity, and availability, and on land, confidentiality and integrity are given priority among the three elements of security.
[0012] Assets for risk assessment on land include servers, network equipment, security systems, DBMS, application programs, terminals, software, storage media, and control systems.
[0013] Therefore, in the process of deriving the possibility of risk occurrence in the risk assessment method presented by IACS or each classification society, when evaluating the grade of the end-user and attacker group during the shipbuilding process or during ship operation, the period of risk assessment due to the special nature of the ocean is physically and temporally insufficient, and the grade assessment is ambiguous due to human subjective standards, so a quantitative assessment method for risk assessment is required.
[0014] Furthermore, ships are comprised of complex systems equipped with multiple CBSs. With the increasing proportion of ICT-based ship equipment onboard, the risk of hacking and malware attacks is increasing.
[0015] Unlike land-based systems, it is not easy to apply cyber risk prevention measures to ships that hinder safe operation.
[0016] If normal operation data is blocked due to malfunction, false detection, or over-detection of security equipment such as intrusion prevention systems, serious physical damage such as collision or grounding may occur.
[0017] In a rapidly changing world of ICT-based ships, it is difficult to block cyber threats to the ship environment and equipment in real time, as cyberattack detection technologies specific to the ship's unique environment are not yet widespread.
[0018] Therefore, from a preventive perspective, it is efficient to predict cyber risks that may occur in the ship environment in advance, estimate the possible damage path and scope, and take preventive measures.
[0019] Related prior literature includes Korean Patent Publication No. 10-2020-0029266 (March 18, 2020), Korean Patent Registration No. 10-2406756 (June 10, 2022), Korean Patent Publication No. 10-2020-0141774 (December 21, 2020), and Korean Patent Registration No. 10-0604604 (July 24, 2006).
[0020] The purpose of the present invention is to maintain availability without installing or accessing the ship's network by calculating a risk scale by comparing the ship's CBS (Computer Based System) with risks collected from various sources. The risk data collected through various routes is indexed and scored based on various criteria such as the degree of risk occurrence. The purpose is to provide a method for measuring the ship's cybersecurity status by dividing the ship's cabin, bridge room, engine room, etc. into zones based on importance and providing a quantifiable risk scoring of the CBS for each zone.
[0021] Another object of the present invention is to provide a method for ship cybersecurity risk assessment that can quantify risk assessment by deriving a threat exposure level through the severity and degree of exposure of threats during cybersecurity risk assessment and utilizing them as factors for deriving the possibility of risk occurrence, and to build a quantified ship cybersecurity risk assessment method into a system and apply it to risk assessment, thereby contributing to resolving problems in risk assessment due to the special nature of the ocean.
[0022] Another object of the present invention is to provide a method for ship cybersecurity risk assessment that can meet cybersecurity requirements at the time of classification society certification by performing a risk assessment in accordance with the cybersecurity requirements of each classification society.
[0023] Another object of the present invention is to provide a machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method capable of preventing security accidents and preventing risk factors that may arise from real-time intrusion blocking, such as false detection and over-detection of security equipment, by predicting possible cyber risks based on ship network topology and CBS (Computer-based System) characteristic information and real-time detected threat information.
[0024] A method for measuring a ship's cybersecurity status according to one aspect of the present invention for achieving the above technical task may include a data collection step of collecting ship CBS data and collecting cyber threat and maritime intelligence data for the CBS; a CBS collection and management step according to ship zone; a data indexing step using cyber threat score criteria; a risk score calculation step according to ship zone; and a risk mitigation step of deriving a ship's cybersecurity status according to the risk score and mitigating the risk.
[0025] In addition, in a method for measuring the status of ship cybersecurity according to one aspect of the present invention, the cyber threat and maritime intelligence collection step may collect IT cyber risk intelligence and OT cyber risk intelligence in advance and verify the validity of the intelligence data.
[0026] In addition, in a method for measuring the status of ship cybersecurity according to one aspect of the present invention, the CBS collection and management step according to the ship zone may include a CBS management step by compartment; a CBS classification step by compartment; a CBS listing step by compartment; and a risk assessment step by compartment.
[0027] In addition, in a method for measuring a ship cybersecurity status according to one aspect of the present invention, the data indexing step using the cyber threat score criteria includes a cyber threat classification step;
[0028] It may include a cyber threat prioritization step; a cyber threat standardization step; and a priority-based scoring step.
[0029] In addition, in a method for measuring a ship cybersecurity status according to one aspect of the present invention, the step of calculating a risk score for each ship zone may further include a weighting step of dividing zones according to importance of each ship zone, such as a ship cabin, bridge room, and engine room, and assigning weights.
[0030] In addition, a method for assessing ship cybersecurity risks according to another aspect of the present invention for achieving the above technical task may include a scope selection step of checking the cybersecurity requirements of a classification society to which a ship subject to risk assessment is to be certified when performing a risk assessment and identifying assets of the ship to select a cybersecurity scope; a data collection step of classifying assets of the ship within the security scope selected through the scope selection step according to a CBS (Computer Based System) and collecting transmission and reception data for a plurality of networks connected to the classified assets by a data collection unit; and a risk assessment step of identifying and analyzing a threat list from the data collected in the data collection step to perform a cybersecurity risk assessment for cybersecurity threats for each of the plurality of networks.
[0031] In addition, in a method for assessing ship cybersecurity risk according to another aspect of the present invention, the scope selection step may select a cybersecurity risk assessment scope by searching a database (DB) in which cybersecurity rules required by each classification society that certifies a ship are stored, and identifying assets of the ship in accordance with the cybersecurity requirements of the classification society to which the ship is to be certified during the risk assessment.
[0032] In addition, in a method for assessing ship cyber security risks according to another aspect of the present invention, the data collection step may identify ship assets and set a data collection time by considering the importance of assets according to CBS classification.
[0033] Additionally, in a method for assessing ship cyber security risks according to another aspect of the present invention, the risk assessment step may include an impact assessment step, an attack surface assessment step, a threat exposure assessment step, and an occurrence likelihood assessment step.
[0034] In addition, in a method for assessing ship cyber security risks according to another aspect of the present invention, the threat exposure assessment step is characterized in that it evaluates threat exposure through an exposure grade calculated by evaluating severity and degree of exposure, replacing the end-user and attacker group that calculate human factors.
[0035] In addition, in a method for assessing ship cyber security risk according to another aspect of the present invention, the Threat Exposure is calculated according to each grade of two factors of Severity and Degree of Exposure. First, Severity is classified into Low, Medium, High, and Critical grades 1 to 4; and Degree of Exposure is classified into None, CVE, MCTI, Dark Web, and Naval grades 1 to 5; and once the grades of Severity and Degree of Exposure are determined, the Threat Exposure grade can be calculated by classifying it into grades 1 to 5 by adding the numerical values of the grades of each factor.
[0036] In addition, a machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method according to one aspect of the present invention for achieving the above technical task may include a CBS attack surface information scanning step for scanning real-time CBS attack surface information through a CBS definition unit; a CBS attack surface quantification step for quantifying a CBS attack surface by the CBS definition unit with respect to the CBS attack surface information scanned through the CBS attack surface information scanning step; a cyber risk index calculation step for calculating a cyber risk index in a risk analysis unit through machine learning for the CBS quantified through the CBS attack surface quantification step; and an anomaly graph generation step for analyzing the cyber risk index calculated through the cyber risk index calculation step and generating a path with a high risk of hacking occurring in the CBS by the risk analysis unit.
[0037] In addition, in the machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method according to one aspect of the present invention, the cyber risk index calculation step is characterized by generating a risk table through CBS security vulnerability information detected inside the ship, CVE, the ship's attack surface information, and information identified from an intrusion detection system installed in the ship's internal network.
[0038] In addition, a method for detecting anomalies in ship cybersecurity based on machine learning according to one aspect of the present invention, in the cyber risk index calculation step, the identified information includes source IP, destination IP, and detection rule importance information to create a risk table; and when CBS security control is set, a cyber risk index can be calculated by including the security control table.
[0039] In addition, a method for detecting anomalies in ship cybersecurity based on machine learning according to one aspect of the present invention can map a path with a high risk of hacking occurring in CBS by inserting a risk table and a security control table into the network topology in the anomaly graph generation step.
[0040] In addition, in the machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method according to one aspect of the present invention, in the anomaly graph generation step, the network topology can generate the anomaly graph through a tree topology.
[0041] According to the present invention, the availability of a ship's Computer Based System (CBS) is maintained without installation or access to the ship's network by calculating a risk scale by comparing the risk collected from various sources. The risk data collected through various routes is indexed and scored based on various criteria such as the degree of risk occurrence. The ship's cabin, bridge room, engine room, etc. are divided into zones based on importance, and this has the effect of providing a quantified risk scoring of the CBS for each zone.
[0042] In addition, according to the present invention, the severity and degree of exposure of threats are used to derive a threat exposure level during cybersecurity risk assessment, and the risk occurrence probability is derived by utilizing these as factors, thereby enabling quantification of risk assessment.
[0043] In addition, according to the present invention, a quantitative ship cyber security risk assessment method is constructed as a system and applied to risk assessment, thereby contributing to solving problems in risk assessment due to the special characteristics of the ocean.
[0044] In addition, according to the present invention, it is possible to perform a risk assessment in accordance with the cybersecurity requirements of each classification society, thereby achieving the effect of meeting the requirements for cybersecurity at the time of classification society certification.
[0045] In addition, according to the present invention, by predicting possible cyber risks based on ship network topology and CBS (Computer-based System) characteristic information and real-time detected threat information, it has the effect of preventing security accidents and preventing risk factors that may occur due to real-time intrusion blocking, such as false detection and over-detection of security equipment.
[0046] FIG. 1 is a diagram illustrating a method for calculating a risk score for each ship zone and assigning weights according to the importance of each zone in a method for measuring the status of ship cybersecurity according to the present invention.
[0047] FIG. 2 is a block diagram schematically illustrating a method for measuring a ship cybersecurity status according to the present invention.
[0048] FIG. 3 is a diagram showing CBS collection and management steps according to a ship area in a method for measuring ship cybersecurity status according to the present invention.
[0049] FIG. 4 is a diagram showing a data indexing step using a cyber threat score criterion in a method for measuring a ship cyber security status according to the present invention.
[0050] Figure 5 is a flowchart illustrating a method for measuring the cybersecurity status of a ship according to the present invention.
[0051] Figure 6 is a diagram comparing the information security items of the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) and the risk assessment items of the International Association of Classification Societies (IACS).
[0052] Figure 7 is a block diagram showing the procedure for performing risk assessment by the International Association of Classification Societies (IACS).
[0053] Figure 8 is a block diagram illustrating a procedure for performing a ship cyber security risk assessment according to an embodiment of the present invention.
[0054] Figure 9 is a block diagram showing the configuration of an evaluation system for performing a ship cyber security risk assessment of the present invention.
[0055] FIG. 10 is a drawing showing a detailed configuration of a ship cyber security risk assessment method according to an embodiment of the present invention.
[0056] Figure 11 is a flowchart showing the sequence of a machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method according to the present invention.
[0057] FIG. 12 is a diagram showing a risk table including a security control table in a machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method according to the present invention.
[0058] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing a route with a high risk of hacking occurring in CBS by mapping a route by substituting a risk and security control table into a ship network topology according to one embodiment of the present invention.
[0059] The purpose and technical configuration of the present invention and the resulting operation and effects will be more clearly understood through a detailed description based on the drawings attached to the specification of the present invention.
[0060] The terminology used herein is merely used to describe specific embodiments and is not intended to limit the present invention. For example, terms such as "consist of" or "include" used herein should not necessarily be construed to include all of the various components or various steps described in the invention, but should be construed to mean that some of the components or some steps may not be included, or that additional components or steps may be included. Furthermore, the singular expression "a" or "an" as used herein includes the plural expression unless the context clearly dictates otherwise.
[0061] Hereinafter, the present invention will be described in detail by describing preferred embodiments thereof with reference to the attached drawings. The embodiments described below are provided to facilitate the technical concept of the present invention for those skilled in the art to understand, and should not be construed as limiting the present invention. It should be understood that the embodiments of the present invention will have various applications to those skilled in the art.
[0062] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing a method for calculating a risk score for each ship zone and assigning weights according to the importance of each zone in a method for measuring a ship cybersecurity status according to the present invention, FIG. 2 is a block diagram schematically showing a method for measuring a ship cybersecurity status according to the present invention, FIG. 3 is a diagram showing a CBS collection and management step for each ship zone in a method for measuring a ship cybersecurity status according to the present invention, FIG. 4 is a diagram showing a data indexing step using a cyber threat score criterion in a method for measuring a ship cybersecurity status according to the present invention, and FIG. 5 is a flowchart showing a method for measuring a ship cybersecurity status according to the present invention.
[0063] Referring to FIGS. 1 to 5, a method for measuring a ship cybersecurity status according to the present invention collects cyber threat / maritime intelligence.
[0064] Cyber Threat Intelligence (CTI) refers to a method of collecting threat information, analyzing situations, and effectively responding to threats.
[0065] At this time, CBS (Computer Based System) data is collected and managed according to the ship zone, data is indexed using cyber threat score criteria, and a risk score is calculated for each ship zone.
[0066] At this time, the risk score for each ship section can be calculated by assigning weights according to the importance of each ship section.
[0067] In addition, a ship cybersecurity status measurement system for performing the method for measuring the ship cybersecurity status of the present invention may include a cyber threat / maritime intelligence data collection unit (10), a CBS data management unit (20), a cyber threat indexing unit (30), a ship zone-specific risk score calculation unit (40), and a cybersecurity status derivation and risk mitigation unit (50).
[0068] As shown in Figure 1, cyber threat / maritime intelligence can be collected and weighted according to the priority (level A to D) of each ship zone to calculate a risk score from 0 to 100.
[0069] In addition, the method for measuring the ship cybersecurity status according to the present invention, referring to FIG. 2, may include a step (10) of collecting CBS data for the entire ship and collecting cyber threat and maritime intelligence data for CBS, a step (20) of collecting and managing CBS according to ship zone, a step (30) of indexing data using cyber threat score criteria, a step (40) of calculating a risk score for each ship zone; and a step (50) of deriving the ship cybersecurity status according to the risk score and mitigating the risk.
[0070] In addition, the cyber threat and maritime intelligence data collection step (10) can collect IT (Information Technology) cyber risk intelligence and OT (Operational Technology) cyber risk intelligence data and verify the validity of the intelligence data.
[0071] In addition, the CBS data collection and management step (20) according to the ship section may include a compartment-specific CBS management step (21), a compartment-specific CBS classification step (22), a compartment-specific CBS listing step (23), and a compartment-specific risk assessment step (24), as illustrated in FIG. 3.
[0072] In addition, the data indexing step (30) using the cyber threat score criteria may include a cyber threat classification step (31), a cyber threat priority designation step (32), a cyber threat standardization step (33), and a priority-based scoring step (34), as illustrated in FIG. 4.
[0073] In addition, the step of calculating the risk score by ship zone (40) may further include a weighting step (45) of dividing the zones according to the importance of each ship zone, such as the ship's cabin, bridge room, and engine room, and assigning weights to them.
[0074] Looking more specifically with reference to FIG. 5, the method for measuring the status of ship cybersecurity according to the present invention includes a data collection step (S1) for collecting cyber threat and marine intelligence data, which collects IT (Ionformation Technology) cyber risk intelligence and OT (Operational Technology) cyber risk intelligence through a data source, and can check the validity of the intelligence data (S11).
[0075] At this time, in the data collection step (S1), marine intelligence data can be collected in advance and stored in a data source, and the stored data can be received and collected.
[0076] The CBS collection and management step (S2) according to the ship area can collect ship CBS data through a data source (S21), analyze CBS classification / function (S22), check the validity of the classified CBS (S23), correct CBS data if invalid (S24), and manage the CBS system (S25).
[0077] The data indexing step (S3) using the cyber threat score criteria is a process of listing the risk matrices that can occur in the registered CBS and assigning scores for ratings. Risk scores are assigned to each CBS category classification, access rights, breach cases, vulnerabilities, external connection status, accessible ports, and power.
[0078] Therefore, the data indexing step (S3) using the cyber threat score criteria creates a multidimensional risk matrix (S31), checks the matrix factor validity (S32), and finally, in the single risk matrix creation step (S33), derives a matrix that integrates the scores of all registered CBSs.
[0079] In this case, if it is impossible to create a single matrix, the matrix elements are re-explored (S34) or if a CBS that does not match the multidimensional risk matrix is registered, it is calculated as an exception and given an N / A rating.
[0080] The step of calculating the risk score by ship zone (S4) measures the risk / severity by zone (S41).
[0081] At this time, weights can be set (S45) according to the importance of each zone, and when dividing zones, if the zone (room) is isolated (closed) from the outside, a lower weight can be set.
[0082] The risk mitigation stage (S5) assigns a grade according to the risk level to the risk score.
[0083] It is possible to derive the status of ship cybersecurity based on risk scores and mitigate risks.
[0084] Accordingly, according to the present invention, the availability of a ship's CBS (Computer Based System) is maintained without being installed or accessed on the ship's network by calculating a risk scale by comparing the risk collected from various sources. The risk data collected through various routes is indexed and scored based on various criteria such as the degree of risk occurrence. The ship's cabin, bridge room, engine room, etc. are divided into zones based on importance, and this has the effect of providing a quantified risk scoring of the CBS for each zone.
[0085] Referring to FIGS. 8 to 10, a method for assessing ship cybersecurity risks according to the present invention may include a scope selection step of checking the cybersecurity requirements of a classification society to which a ship subject to risk assessment is to be certified when performing a risk assessment and selecting a cybersecurity scope among the identified ship's assets; a CBS classification step of classifying CBS categories within the cybersecurity scope selected through the scope selection step; a data collection step of collecting, by a data collection unit, transmission and reception data for a plurality of networks connected to the classified assets through the CBS classification step; and a risk assessment step of identifying and analyzing a threat list from the data collected in the data collection step and performing a cybersecurity risk assessment for cybersecurity threats to each of the plurality of networks.
[0086] More specifically, as illustrated in Fig. 8, it can be composed of the following procedures: (1) scope selection step (S110), (2) CBS (Computer Based System) category classification (S120), (3) threat list identification (S130), (4) threat impact (S140), (5) operational threat (S150), (6) occurrence probability assessment (S160), (7) risk level assessment (S170), (8) decision on risk measures (S180), (9) risk mitigation (S190), and (10) residual risk (S192).
[0087] The scope selection step (S110) can select the cybersecurity scope by checking the cybersecurity requirements of the classification society to which the ship subject to the risk assessment will be certified during the risk assessment and identifying the ship's assets.
[0088] The CBS (Computer Based System) category classification step (S120) classifies assets within the ship into categories of the CBS (Computer Based System).
[0089] Ships prioritize availability among the three key security elements. Furthermore, ship assets are classified as systems falling under the Computer Based System (CBS) category. Therefore, when assessing ship cybersecurity risks, assets must be identified and classified according to their CBS classification, and risk analysis and risk management measures must be implemented with availability in mind.
[0090] The threat list identification step (S130) can identify a list of assets that may pose cybersecurity threats in the classified CBS categories and collect transmission and reception data for multiple networks to which the assets are connected.
[0091] Identification of critical equipment and systems can identify and assess key onboard assets vulnerable to cyberattacks.
[0092] Impact assessment can consider the consequences of a threat in terms of availability to a system.
[0093] At this time, the network may include VSAT (Very Small Aperture Terminal) that connects to satellites, IT (Information Technology) networks, and OT (Operational Technology) networks.
[0094] In addition, the method may include a risk assessment step of analyzing the list of threats identified through the threat list identification step (S130) and performing a cybersecurity risk assessment on cybersecurity threats to each of multiple networks.
[0095] At this time, the risk assessment step may include a threat impact assessment step (S140), an operational threat assessment step (S150), and an occurrence likelihood assessment step (S160).
[0096] Additionally, the operational threat assessment step (S150) may include a first assessment step, an attack surface assessment step (S155), and a second assessment step, a threat exposure assessment step (S159).
[0097] Additionally, the attack surface evaluation step (S155) can evaluate the attack surface by considering connectivity (S152) and complexity (S154).
[0098] In addition, the threat exposure assessment step (S159) can evaluate threat exposure by deriving an exposure grade through the severity of the threat (S157) and the degree of exposure (S158).
[0099] That is, in IACS Rec 171, which takes into account the differences between land and sea, Severity, Degree of Exposure, and Threat Exposure are presented as factors that can replace the End-User, Attacker Group, and Human Factor factors that are difficult to measure in risk assessment, and the presented factors have the effect of enabling a clear and quantifiable risk level assessment on ships.
[0100] Therefore, according to the present invention, since it is difficult to clearly determine the end-user and attacker group for calculating the human factor in the risk assessment of IACS Rec 171, it is possible to evaluate a clear and quantifiable risk level by replacing it with a threat exposure assessment.
[0101] Referring to FIG. 9, the ship cyber security risk assessment system (100) may include a risk assessment range selection unit (110) that sets a cyber security range according to cyber security for each classification society and selects a risk assessment range, a data collection unit (120) that collects transmission and reception data for multiple networks, an analysis unit (130) that identifies and analyzes a threat list in the CBS category and performs a cyber security risk assessment for cyber security threats for each of the multiple networks, a database unit (140) that stores cyber security rules required by each classification society, and a control unit (150) that controls the risk assessment time according to the importance of the asset.
[0102] Accordingly, the ship cybersecurity risk assessment method according to the present invention includes a range selection step in which a cybersecurity range according to the cybersecurity of each classification is set in a risk assessment range selection unit (110) of a ship cybersecurity risk assessment system (100) and stored in a database, a data collection step in which assets of a ship are classified according to a CBS (Computer Based System) within the security range selected through the range selection step and stored in a database unit (140), and transmission / reception data for a plurality of networks connected to the classified assets are collected in a data collection unit (120), and a risk assessment step in which a threat list is identified from the data collected in the data collection step, and risks considering availability are analyzed in an analysis unit (130) to perform a cybersecurity risk assessment for cybersecurity threats to each of the plurality of networks.
[0103] Additionally, the scope selection stage can create a database of cybersecurity rules required by each classification society that certifies ships, and select the scope of the cybersecurity risk assessment in accordance with the cybersecurity requirements of the classification society to which the ship will be certified during the risk assessment.
[0104] In addition, the data collection step can identify the assets of the ship and set the data collection time in the control unit (150) by considering the importance of the assets according to the CBS classification.
[0105] Additionally, the risk assessment phase may include an impact grade assessment phase, an attack surface assessment phase, a threat exposure assessment phase, and a likelihood assessment phase, and the threat exposure assessment phase may include:
[0106] Threat exposure can be evaluated by deriving an exposure level through the severity of the threat and the degree of exposure.
[0107] As illustrated in FIG. 10, the detailed configuration of the ship cyber security risk assessment method according to the embodiment of the present invention may include a preliminary consultation and scope selection step (S100), a risk analysis step (S150), and a termination step (S200). The preliminary consultation and scope selection step (S100) may include preliminary preparation (S101), project execution request (S102), certification classification society consultation (S103), legal compliance country consultation (S104), target and scope, period consultation (S105), risk analysis procedure consultation (S106), and CBS identification request (S107).
[0108] Additionally, the risk analysis step (S150) may include a pre-analysis, a real-time analysis, and an evaluation step.
[0109] The pre-analysis phase may include CBS classification (S120), impact assessment (S140), attack surface level assessment (S155), threat exposure level assessment (S159), likelihood of occurrence level assessment (S160), and risk level assessment (S170).
[0110] In addition, the Threat Exposure grade evaluation (S159) is calculated according to each grade of two factors: Severity and Degree of Exposure. First, Severity is classified into Low, Medium, High, Critical grades 1-4, and Degree of Exposure is classified into None, CVE, MCTI, Dark Web, Naval grades 1-5. Once the Severity and Degree of Exposure grades are determined, the Threat Exposure grade is calculated by adding the grade values of each factor and classifying it into grades 1-5. Naval Degree of Exposure can be calculated as grade 5 regardless of Severity.
[0111] Additionally, the line analysis phase may include risk identification (S171), penetration testing (S172), risk analysis checklist (S173), and risk identification and analysis (S174) phases.
[0112] Additionally, the assessment phase may include the steps of assessing the risk mitigation level (S191a), assessing the risk mitigation period (S191b), calculating the Response Rate Limiting (RRL) (S191c), and establishing protective measures (S191d).
[0113] Additionally, the termination phase may include the steps of establishing a response plan (S201), writing a report (S202), reviewing the report (S203), submitting the report (S204), and closing the project (S205).
[0114] According to the present invention, the severity and degree of exposure of threats are used to derive a threat exposure level during a cybersecurity risk assessment, and the risk occurrence probability is derived by utilizing these as factors, thereby enabling the quantification of risk assessment.
[0115] In addition, according to the present invention, a quantitative ship cyber security risk assessment method is constructed as a system and applied to risk assessment, thereby contributing to solving problems in risk assessment due to the special characteristics of the ocean.
[0116] In addition, according to the present invention, it is possible to perform a risk assessment in accordance with the cybersecurity requirements of each classification society, thereby achieving the effect of meeting the requirements for cybersecurity at the time of classification society certification.
[0117] FIG. 11 is a flowchart showing the sequence of a machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method according to the present invention, FIG. 12 is a diagram showing a risk table including a security control table in a machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method according to the present invention, and FIG. 13 is a diagram showing a route with a high risk of hacking occurring in CBS by substituting a risk and security control table into a ship network topology according to one embodiment of the present invention.
[0118] Referring to FIGS. 11 to 13, a machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method according to one aspect of the present invention may include a CBS attack surface information scanning step (S300), a CBS attack surface quantification step (S310), a cyber risk index calculation step (S320), and an anomaly graph generation step (S330).
[0119] More specifically, as illustrated in FIG. 11, the CBS (Computer Based System) attack surface information scanning step (S300) scans information on the CBS attack surface through the CBS definition unit (310).
[0120] In the CBS attack surface quantification step (S310), the CBS definition unit (310) can quantify the CBS attack surface for the CBS attack surface information scanned through the CBS attack surface information scanning step (S300).
[0121] In other words, as the proportion of ship equipment equipped with ICT environments increases, it is possible to quantify the attack surface of CBS specialized for the ship's unique environment, predict cyber risks in advance, and prevent them by calculating the possible damage path and scope.
[0122] In addition, the cyber risk index calculation step (S320) can calculate a cyber risk index in the risk analysis unit (320) through machine learning for the CBS quantified through the CBS attack surface quantification step (S310).
[0123] The probability of cyber risk occurrence can be calculated using the following formula.
[0124]
[0125] Additionally, the following formula represents the probability that damage from a cyberattack may occur due to CBS installed inside a ship.
[0126]
[0127] In addition, the abnormal symptom graph generation step (S330) can analyze the cyber risk index generated through the cyber risk index calculation step (S320) to generate and map a path with a high risk of hacking occurring in CBS and display it.
[0128] At this time, the CBS value can create a risk table using the security vulnerability information of the CBS installed inside the ship, the CVE, the ship's attack surface information, and information identified from the intrusion detection system installed in the ship's internal network.
[0129] Information on a ship's attack surface can be obtained through open port information, operating service information, and operating daemon information.
[0130] Additionally, in the cyber risk index calculation step (S320), the identified information can create a risk table, including source IP, destination IP, and detection rule importance information.
[0131] Additionally, if CBS security controls are set, a cyber risk index can be calculated by including the security control table.
[0132] That is, since the risk can be reduced when CBS security control is set, a risk table including a security control table can be created as shown in Fig. 12.
[0133] In addition, as illustrated in FIG. 13, the machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method according to one aspect of the present invention for ship network can map a path with a high risk of hacking occurring in CBS by inserting a risk table and a security control table into the network topology in the anomaly graph generation step (S130).
[0134] Network topology refers to the pattern or arrangement in which network devices and computer systems are connected to each other, and a network refers to nodes that represent computers or devices that are connected to share information and data.
[0135] Additionally, topology represents the connection pattern and design between multiple interconnected nodes that direct the flow of information.
[0136] Additionally, in the anomaly symptom graph generation step (S330), the network topology can generate an anomaly symptom graph through a tree topology.
[0137] A tree topology can be formed by a combination of star and bus topologies.
[0138] The tree topology has the advantage of being easy to install new extended networks due to the star nature of the topology, and the ease of troubleshooting problems with nodes that have coupling increases the efficiency of the network without affecting the main network.
[0139] Additionally, the tree topology has the advantage of being able to transmit signals over long distances without signal loss.
[0140] Therefore, according to the present invention, by predicting possible cyber risks based on ship network topology and CBS (Computer-based System) characteristic information and real-time detected threat information, it has the effect of preventing security accidents and preventing risk factors that may arise due to real-time intrusion blocking, such as false detection and over-detection of security equipment.
[0141] The embodiments of the present invention described above may be implemented in the form of program commands that can be executed through various computer components and recorded on a computer-readable recording medium. The computer-readable recording medium may include program commands, data files, data structures, etc., either singly or in combination. The program commands recorded on the computer-readable recording medium may be specially designed and configured for the present invention or may be known and available to those skilled in the art of computer software. Examples of computer-readable recording media include magnetic media such as hard disks, floppy disks, and magnetic tapes, optical recording media such as CD-ROMs and DVDs, magneto-optical media such as floptical disks, and hardware devices specifically configured to store and execute program commands, such as ROMs, RAMs, and flash memories. Examples of program commands include not only machine language codes generated by a compiler, but also high-level language codes that can be executed by a computer using an interpreter, etc. Hardware devices may be changed into one or more software modules to perform processing according to the present invention, and vice versa.
[0142] The embodiments described above are provided to enable those skilled in the art to easily understand the technical concept of the present invention, and should not be construed as limiting the present invention thereby. It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that the embodiments of the present invention can be variously modified and altered without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention. Accordingly, such modifications or variations should be considered to fall within the scope of the claims of the present invention.
Claims
1. Collect ship CBS data and collect cyber threat and maritime intelligence data for CBS; CBS data collection and management steps according to ship area; Data indexing step using cyber threat score criteria; Steps for calculating risk scores by ship section; and A method for measuring the cybersecurity status of a ship, comprising: deriving a ship cybersecurity status based on a risk score and including a risk mitigation step for mitigating the risk.
2. In claim 1, The cyber threat and maritime intelligence data collection phase is: A method for measuring the cybersecurity status of a ship by collecting IT and OT cyber risk intelligence and validating the intelligence data.
3. In claim 1, The steps for collecting and managing CBS data according to the above ship area are: CBS management steps by section; CBS classification step by section; CBS listing steps by section; and A method for measuring the cybersecurity status of a ship, comprising a compartment-by-compartment risk assessment step.
4. In claim 1, The data indexing step using the above cyber threat score criteria is: Cyber threat classification steps; Cyber threat prioritization phase; Cyber threat uniformity stage; and A method for measuring the cybersecurity status of a ship, comprising a priority-based scoring step.
5. In claim 1, The above ship zone risk score calculation steps are: A method for measuring the cybersecurity status of a ship, further comprising a weighting step of assigning weights to areas according to their importance, such as a ship's cabin, bridge room, and engine room.
6. Scope selection step, which selects the scope of cybersecurity by checking the cybersecurity requirements of the classification society to which the ship subject to risk assessment is to be certified during the risk assessment and identifying the ship's assets; A data collection step in which the assets of the ship are classified according to CBS (Computer Based System) within the security range selected through the above range selection step, and the data collection unit collects transmission and reception data for multiple networks connected to the classified assets; and A ship cybersecurity risk assessment method, comprising a risk assessment step of identifying and analyzing a list of threats from data collected in the above data collection step and performing a cybersecurity risk assessment for cybersecurity threats to each of a plurality of networks.
7. In claim 6, The above range selection step is: A ship cybersecurity risk assessment method that searches a database (DB) containing cybersecurity rules required by each classification society that certifies ships, identifies the ship's assets in accordance with the cybersecurity requirements of the classification society to which the ship will be certified during the risk assessment, and selects the scope of the cybersecurity risk assessment.
8. In claim 6, The above data collection steps are: A ship cybersecurity risk assessment method that identifies ship assets and sets data collection periods considering asset importance according to CBS classification.
9. In claim 6, The above risk assessment steps are: A ship cybersecurity risk assessment method comprising an impact assessment step, an attack surface assessment step, a threat exposure assessment step, and an occurrence likelihood assessment step.
10. In claim 9, A ship cybersecurity risk assessment method characterized in that the above threat exposure assessment step evaluates the severity and degree of exposure by replacing the end-user and attacker group that calculate the human factor, and evaluates the threat exposure through the calculated exposure level.
11. In claim 10, The above threat exposure is calculated based on two factors: severity and degree of exposure. First, severity is classified into 4 levels: Low, Medium, High, and Critical (1 to 4); The degree of exposure is classified into None, CVE, MCTI, Dark Web, and Naval 1-5; A ship cybersecurity risk assessment method that calculates the Threat Exposure grade by classifying it into grades 1 to 5 by adding the numerical values of each factor once the grades of the above Severity and Degree of Exposure are determined.
12. CBS attack surface information scanning step that scans real-time CBS attack surface information through the CBS definition department; The CBS attack surface quantification step quantifies the CBS attack surface for the CBS attack surface information scanned through the above CBS attack surface information scanning step; A cyber risk index calculation step in which the risk analysis department calculates a cyber risk index through machine learning for the CBS quantified through the above CBS attack surface quantification step; and A machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method, comprising a step of generating an anomaly graph in which a risk analysis department analyzes the cyber risk index calculated through the above cyber risk index calculation step and generates a path with a high risk of hacking occurring in the CBS.
13. In claim 12, The above cyber risk index calculation steps are: A machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method characterized by generating a risk table using CBS security vulnerability information stored inside a ship, CVE, ship attack surface information, and information identified from an intrusion detection system installed in the ship's internal network.
14. In claim 13, In the above cyber risk index calculation step, The above identified information creates a risk table, including source IP, destination IP, and detection rule importance information; A machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method that calculates a cyber risk index including a security control table when CBS security control is set.
15. In claim 12, In the above abnormal symptom graph generation step, A machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method that maps paths with a high risk of hacking from CBS by inserting a risk table and a security control table into the network topology.
16. In claim 12, In the above abnormal symptom graph generation step, Network topology is a machine learning-based ship cybersecurity anomaly detection method that generates anomaly graphs through tree topology.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Method for securing system using server security solution and network security solution, and security system implementing the same
KR100604604B1
Methods for communicating using non-terrestrial network and apparatuses thereof
KR1020200110619A
System and Method for correcting facial asymmetry based expression training using correction mirror
KR1020220057008A
Apparatus and Method for estimating automated network penetration path based on network reachability
KR101893253B1
Single-Crystal Diamond Substrate Based on Buffer Layer Comprising Organic Material and Manufacturing Method Thereof
KR1020240129919A
Cited By
Large-arrangement laying design method for geotextile laying ship
CN120012613A
Ship network asset identification and risk analysis method, device and equipment
CN120450449A
Ship control cabinet network security protection method and system
CN120498771A
