Controlling maximum allowable thrust of a wind turbine based on YAW offset

By determining maximum allowable thrust based on target yaw offsets through scaling factors and advanced signal processing, the method addresses underactive thrust limitations, optimizing wind turbine performance and reducing fatigue, ensuring efficient power generation.

WO2026233520A1PCT designated stage Publication Date: 2026-11-12VESTAS WIND SYSTEMS AS
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/DK2026/060058
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2025-05-07
Filing Date
2026-05-05
Publication Date
2026-11-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for controlling maximum allowable thrust in wind turbines do not adequately account for yaw offsets, leading to underactive thrust limitation and potential exposure to higher loads when operating with non-zero yaw offsets, which can reduce the effectiveness of wind turbine power generation.

Method used

A method and controller that determine the maximum allowable thrust based on a target yaw offset by applying a scaling factor or adjustment to a baseline thrust limit, considering factors like turbulence intensity, wind speed, and flap load standard deviation, using m-blade coordinate transformations and high pass filtering to accurately assess blade loads.

Benefits of technology

This approach effectively protects wind turbines from excessive thrust loads during yawed operations, optimizing power generation by reducing blade deflections and fatigue, thereby enhancing the operational lifespan and efficiency.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure DK2026060058_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure DK2026060058_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention provides a method of controlling a wind turbine. The method comprises receiving a yaw offset signal indicative of a target yaw offset according to which the wind turbine is being controlled. The method comprises determining, based on the received yaw 5 offset signal, a thrust limit level indicative of a maximum allowable thrust to be experienced by the wind turbine. The method comprises controlling the wind turbine in accordance with the determined maximum allowable thrust. In this way, the invention beneficially protects the wind turbine from excessive thrust loading during operation at different yaw offsets.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] CONTROLLING MAXIMUM ALLOWABLE THRUST OF A WIND TURBINE BASED ON YAW OFFSET

[0002] TECHNICAL FIELD

[0003] The invention relates to a method of controlling a wind turbine and, in particular, to controlling the wind turbine in accordance with a maximum allowable thrust determined based on a yaw offset of the wind turbine.

[0004] BACKGROUND

[0005] Wind power plants consist of wind turbines which collectively generate power to be delivered to the grid. A wind turbine typically includes a tower that supports a nacelle and a rotor with three pitch-adjustable rotor blades that are mounted to the rotor. The blades and the rotor enable the wind turbine to deliver power to the grid by converting the kinetic energy from incoming wind into electrical energy to be delivered to the grid.

[0006] The power produced by a wind turbine depends on the availability of the wind in the vicinity of the wind turbine, and it is generally desirable to operate a wind turbine in such a manner that the electrical power generated from the wind turbine is maximised. This may be measured by referring to an AEP (annual energy production) of a wind turbine or wind power plant, which is the total amount of electrical energy that the wind power plant produces in the space of a year, e.g. in kilowatt or megawatt hours.

[0007] In practical terms, the power generated from a wind turbine can be optimised or maximised by controlling one or more components of the wind turbine, e.g. the pitch of pitch-adjustable rotor blades or the rotational speed of the rotor. However, in certain conditions, a wind turbine may experience high aerodynamic forces that result in high thrust loads and blade deflections due to the interaction between the incoming wind flow and the wind turbine. Continual operation of a wind turbine without mitigating such thrust loads may result in component fatigue and may reduce the ability of the wind turbine to generate electricity at its rated power. Therefore, to protect the wind turbines from such thrust loads, wind turbines are typically operated in a manner that balances maximising the power output while limiting the thrust loads on the wind turbine.European Patent Publication No. EP2582973B1 discloses a control method that enforces a minimum pitch angle to limit the thrust on the rotor blades to below a certain maximum allowable thrust. The maximum allowable thrust may vary and, in particular, may be determined based on a turbulence level / intensity of the incoming wind. As the maximum allowable thrust decreases, control of the wind turbine to limit the thrust level needs to increase or become more active, ensuring that the negative impact on AEP is minimum.

[0008] Previous approaches for setting a maximum allowable thrust may not take into account other aspects of wind turbine operation that may impact AEP. It is against this background to which the present invention is set.

[0009] SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

[0010] According to an aspect of the invention there is provided a method of controlling a wind turbine. The method comprises receiving a yaw offset signal indicative of a target yaw offset according to which the wind turbine is being controlled. The method comprises determining, based on the received yaw offset signal, a thrust limit level indicative of a maximum allowable thrust to be experienced by the wind turbine. The method comprises controlling the wind turbine in accordance with the determined maximum allowable thrust.

[0011] Determining the thrust limit level may comprise obtaining a baseline thrust limit level for the wind turbine. Determining the thrust limit level may comprise determining a thrust limit adjustment parameter based on the received yaw offset signal. Determining the thrust limit level may comprise applying the thrust limit adjustment parameter to the baseline thrust limit level to determine the thrust limit level. The thrust limit level may be less than or equal to the baseline thrust limit level.

[0012] The thrust limit adjustment parameter may be a scaling factor having a magnitude less than or equal to one.

[0013] The magnitude of the scaling factor may decrease as a magnitude of the target yaw offset increases. Optionally, the scaling factor magnitude varies nonlinearly with the target yaw offset magnitude.The thrust limit level may be less than the baseline thrust limit level when a magnitude of the target yaw offset is greater than a threshold magnitude. Optionally, the threshold magnitude is zero.

[0014] The method may comprise determining the baseline thrust limit level. This may comprise receiving a wind speed signal indicative of wind speed in the vicinity of the wind turbine. This may comprise receiving a flap load signal, from a blade load sensor of each of one or more rotor blades of the wind turbine, indicative of flap loading on the respective rotor blade. This may comprise determining, based on the received flap load signal, a standard deviation parameter indicative of volatility of loading on the rotor blades of the wind turbine. This may comprise determining the baseline thrust limit level based on the received wind speed and the determined standard deviation parameter. Optionally, the baseline thrust limit level is determined via a lookup table comprising pairs of wind speed and standard deviation parameter values.

[0015] Determining the thrust limit level may comprise receiving a wind speed signal indicative of wind speed in the vicinity of the wind turbine. Determining the thrust limit level may comprise receiving a flap load signal, from a blade load sensor of each of one or more rotor blades of the wind turbine, indicative of flap loading on the respective rotor blade. Determining the thrust limit level may comprise determining, based on the received flap load signal, a standard deviation parameter indicative of volatility of loading on the rotor blades of the wind turbine. Determining the thrust limit level may comprise determining the thrust limit level based on the received wind speed, the determined standard deviation parameter, and the received yaw offset signal.

[0016] The thrust limit level may be determined via a lookup table comprising, for each of a plurality of target yaw offset values, a respective plurality of pairs of wind speed and standard deviation parameter values.

[0017] Receiving the flap load signal may comprise receiving a flap load signal from each respective rotor blade of the wind turbine. Determining the standard deviation parameter may comprise applying an m-blade coordinate transformation to the flap load signals to obtain first, second and third mutually orthogonal components in a fixed coordinate frame of the wind turbine. Determining the standard deviation parameter may comprise applying a high pass filter to the first and second mutually orthogonal components to obtain filtered first, second and third mutually orthogonal components. Determining the standarddeviation parameter may comprise applying an inverse m-blade coordinate transformation to the filtered first, second and third mutually orthogonal components to obtain filtered flap load signals in a rotational coordinate frame of the wind turbine. This may then comprise determining the standard deviation parameter based on the filtered flap load signals.

[0018] The high pass filter may be arranged to remove OP content from the first, second and third mutually orthogonal components.

[0019] Determining the standard deviation parameter may comprise determining an individual standard deviation signal for each respective rotor blade based on the respective filtered flap load signal. Determining the standard deviation parameter may comprise selecting the individual standard deviation having the highest magnitude as the determined standard deviation parameter.

[0020] The method may comprise, prior to applying the m-blade coordinate transformation, applying a further high pass filter to the flap load signals to remove OP content.

[0021] Controlling the wind turbine in accordance with the determined maximum allowable thrust may comprise outputting the determined maximum allowable thrust to a thrust limit controller of the wind turbine to control a pitch angle of rotor blades of the wind turbine, or a rotation speed of a rotor of the wind turbine, based on the determined maximum allowable thrust.

[0022] According to another aspect of the invention there is provided a non-transitory, computer-readable storage medium storing instructions thereon that, when executed by one or more computer processors, cause the one or more computer processors to perform the method defined above.

[0023] According to another aspect of the invention there is provided a controller for a wind turbine. The controller is configured to receive a yaw offset signal indicative of a target yaw offset according to which the wind turbine is being controlled. The controller is configured to determine, based on the received yaw offset signal, a thrust limit level indicative of a maximum allowable thrust to be experienced by the wind turbine. The controller is configured to control the wind turbine in accordance with the determined maximum allowable thrust.According to another aspect of the invention there is provided a wind turbine comprising a controller as defined above.

[0024] According to another aspect of the invention there is provided a method of controlling a wind turbine. The method comprises receiving a flap load signal from a blade load sensor of each of one or more rotor blades of the wind turbine, indicative of flap loading on the respective rotor blade. The method comprises applying an m-blade coordinate transformation, e.g. a Coleman transformation, to the flap load signals to obtain first, second and third mutually orthogonal components in a fixed coordinate frame of the wind turbine. Optionally, prior to applying the m-blade coordinate transformation, the method comprises applying a further high pass filter to the flap load signals to remove OP content (in a rotational frame). The method comprises applying a high pass filter to the first, second and third mutually orthogonal components to obtain filtered first, second and third mutually orthogonal components. Optionally, the high pass filter is arranged to remove OP content from the first, second and third mutually orthogonal components (in the fixed coordinate frame). The method comprises applying an inverse m-blade coordinate transformation, e.g. inverse Coleman transformation, to the filtered first, second and third mutually orthogonal components to obtain filtered flap load signals in a rotational coordinate frame of the wind turbine. The method comprises determining a standard deviation parameter based on the filtered flap load signals. Optionally, determining the standard deviation parameter comprises: determining an individual standard deviation signal for each respective rotor blade based on the respective filtered flap load signal; and selecting the individual standard deviation having the highest magnitude as the determined standard deviation parameter. The method comprises controlling the wind turbine based on the determined standard deviation parameter. Optionally, controlling the wind turbine comprises determining, based on the determined standard deviation parameter, a maximum allowable thrust to be experienced by the wind turbine, and controlling the wind turbine in accordance with the determined maximum allowable thrust. Optionally, the maximum allowable thrust is determined based on the determined standard deviation parameter and a measurement of wind speed in the vicinity of the wind turbine, e.g. via a lookup table.

[0025] BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0026] Examples of the invention will now be described, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:Figure 1 schematically illustrates a wind turbine in accordance with an aspect of the invention;

[0027] Figure 2 schematically illustrates a control scheme to be performed by a controller of the wind turbine of Figure 1;

[0028] Figure 3 schematically illustrates another control scheme to be performed by a controller of the wind turbine of Figure 1 ;

[0029] Figure 4 shows the steps of a method, performed by a controller of the wind turbine of Figure 1, in accordance with an aspect of the invention; and

[0030] Figures 5(a) and 5(b) show plots of maximum allowable thrust and blade flap moment over time, respectively, comparing results when the method of Figure 4 is used relative to when a previous, known method is used.

[0031] DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0032] Figure 1 illustrates, in a schematic view, an example of a wind turbine 10. The wind turbine 10 includes a tower 102, a nacelle 103 disposed at the apex of, or atop, the tower 102, and a rotor 104 operatively coupled to a generator housed inside the nacelle 103. In addition to the generator, the nacelle 103 houses other components required for converting wind energy into electrical energy and various components needed to operate, control, and optimise the performance of the wind turbine 10. The rotor 104 of the wind turbine 10 includes a central hub 105 and three rotor blades 106 that project outwardly from the central hub 105. Moreover, the wind turbine 10 comprises a control system or controller (not shown in Figure 1). The controller may be placed inside the nacelle 103, in the tower 102 or distributed at a number of locations inside (or externally to) the turbine 10 and communicatively connected to one another.

[0033] The rotor blades 106 are pitch-adjustable. The rotor blades 106 can be adjusted in accordance with a collective pitch setting, where each of the blades are set to the same pitch value. The rotor blades 106 may additionally be adjustable in accordance with individual pitch settings, where each blade 106 may be provided with an individual pitch setpoint.The wind turbine 10 includes blade load sensors placed at, or in the vicinity of, each blade root in a manner such that the sensor detects loading in the blade 106. Blade load signals from such sensors may be used to determine how to adjust the pitch of each of the individual blades 106. Depending on the placement and the type of sensor, loading may be detected in the flap (flapwise) direction (in / out of plane) or in the edge (edgewise) direction (in-plane). Such sensors may be strain gauge sensors or optical Bragg-sensors, for instance. As the sensors are placed on the rotating blades 106, such load signals for each of the adjustable rotor blades 106 are measured in a rotational reference frame of the rotor 104.

[0034] Wind flowing past the wind turbine 10 drives rotational motion of the rotor blades 106, which causes rotation of the rotor 104. The interaction between the incoming wind flow and the wind turbine rotor 104 results in a thrust force that can generate blade loads and blade deflections, and fore-aft and side-side bending moments of the wind turbine tower 102.

[0035] The aerodynamic force generated by the interaction of the wind with the rotor blades 106 (and other wind turbine components) may be expressed as

[0036] Ft= ^ArotV2Ct(0

[0037]

[0038] where V is the free-stream wind speed, Arotis a swept area of the rotor blades 106, pairis the air density, and Ctis the thrust coefficient. The thrust coefficient Ctis a dimensionless parameter describing an axial force exerted by the wind turbine 10 to the incoming momentum of the wind flow. The thrust coefficient Ctis a function of tip speed-ratio (TSR) A and pitch angle 9 of the rotor blades 106. The TSR A is a ratio between the free-stream wind speed and the speed of the tips of the wind turbine blades 106 as they rotate about the rotor axis.

[0039] It is known to control a wind turbine to limit aerodynamic or thrust force loads experienced by the wind turbine. This is to protect one or more components of the wind turbine, e.g. the rotor blades, from high loading that may result in fatigue I damage of the components in a manner that reduces component lifespan or reduces the amount of power the wind turbine is capable of producing.

[0040] One known method for limiting the thrust loading is to set or determine a maximum threshold limit or reference value for the thrust coefficient, and then control the wind turbinesuch that the thrust coefficient value does not exceed the maximum thrust limit value during wind turbine operation. In particular, in known methods this is achieved by controlling the pitch angle 6 of the rotor blades 106 - by setting a pitch angle reference -to be no less than a defined minimum pitch angle emin. In this way, the wind turbine is controlled in accordance with a maximum allowable thrust.

[0041] The maximum allowable thrust may vary during operation of a wind turbine. In particular, the maximum allowable thrust may include two components: a ‘static’ part, which slowly changes the maximum allowable thrust as a function of a statistical indicator / proxy signal of turbulence intensity / level; and an ‘event detector’ part, which adjusts the maximum allowable thrust relatively quickly in response to detection of an anomaly.

[0042] The static part of the maximum allowable thrust may be determined based on an intensity of turbulence of wind in the vicinity of the wind turbine. In turn, the turbulence intensity may be determined based on the loading experienced by the rotor blades (e.g. as measured using blade load sensors), in particular how the loading varies overtime. Specifically, the turbulence intensity may be determined based on a determined statistical dispersion parameter - such as standard deviation - indicative of temporal variation in the blade loading.

[0043] The turbulence level is determined, and paired with a measurement of wind speed in the vicinity of the wind turbine, and then a minimum pitch angle eminmay be set / determined, e.g. via a lookup table, based on the pair of turbulence intensity and wind speed values. This minimum pitch angle may be enforced via blade pitch control to guarantee that the thrust loads do not exceed the maximum allowable thrust, i.e. by controlling pitch angle of the rotor blades in accordance with a pitch angle reference that is no less than the minimum pitch angle emin.

[0044] In known approaches, the above-described lookup tables are determined by considering non-yawed wind turbine operation only. However, when a wind turbine is operated with a non-zero target yaw offset, the perception of turbulence intensity as determined from blade load measurements is affected. This can lead to underactive thrust limitation, thereby exposing the wind turbine to higher loading that is desired.

[0045] The present invention is advantageous in that it provides a wind turbine method and controller that protects a wind turbine from excessive thrust loading for wind turbineoperation at different yaw offsets, and not just for zero (target) yaw offset. The invention achieves this by determining the maximum allowable thrust to be experienced by the wind turbine based on a target yaw offset according to which the wind turbine is to be controlled, and controlling the wind turbine in accordance with this maximum allowable thrust. In some examples, this is achieved via the application of a scaling factor, determined based on a target yaw offset, to a baseline maximum allowable thrust for non-yawed operation. In some examples, this is achieved via the provision of extended or further lookup tables that map turbulence intensity and wind speed to maximum allowable thrust, where the lookup tables are extended to introduce new lookup value sets or curves for different target yaw offsets. Further advantages of the invention will become apparent in the following description.

[0046] In examples of the invention, the wind turbine 10 is operated in accordance with a target yaw offset. The target yaw offset or yaw misalignment refers to a desired error / difference between a direction of incoming wind in the vicinity of the wind turbine and a direction in which the wind turbine 10 (or, more specifically, the wind turbine nacelle 103 and rotor 104) is facing. Note that an actual yaw offset of the wind turbine 10 may equal the target yaw offset, or may differ from the target yaw offset, e.g. as a result of changeable wind conditions.

[0047] Typically, power generation of a wind turbine is maximised when the wind turbine direction is aligned with the incoming wind direction, i.e. zero yaw offset. However, it may be desired in some cases to operate the wind turbine with a non-zero yaw offset. For instance, controlling a wind turbine to be misaligned with the incoming wind direction redirects the wake generated by the wind turbine, e.g. away from a further wind turbine downstream of the wind turbine under consideration. Such wake steering control can be used to maximise power generation at a plant level, rather than an individual turbine level, in a wind power plant comprising multiple wind turbines. Controlling a wind turbine according to a target yaw offset involves rotating the nacelle and rotor relative to the wind turbine tower about the tower / vertical axis via the use of a yaw bearing / ring between the nacelle and top of the tower.

[0048] The determination of maximum allowable thrust to take into account a target yaw offset may be performed in different ways in different examples of the invention. Figure 2 schematically illustrates a control scheme 20, of a controller of the wind turbine 10, that is for determining maximum allowable thrust in accordance with some examples of theinvention. In particular, the control scheme 20 illustrates an approach in which the maximum allowable thrust is determined as an adjustment to a baseline maximum allowable thrust - determined for a zero yaw offset - where the adjustment is determined based on a target yaw offset according to which the wind turbine 10 is to be controlled.

[0049] With reference to Figure 2, a baseline maximum allowable thrust Ftmaxis determined at a baseline thrust determination module 201. This baseline value may be determined as described above where yawed operation of the wind turbine is not considered, i.e. a zero yaw offset is assumed (implicitly). In particular, blade load sensors of the wind turbine 10 may be used to measure respective flap loads of the rotor blades 106. The standard deviation of these flap load measurements is then determined, where the standard deviation is indicative of volatility of loading on the rotor blades 106.

[0050] The flap load standard deviation may be determined in any suitable manner. In known approaches, measured blade flap load signals are obtained and then filtered to remove OP and 1 P frequency content, where 1 P is the rotational frequency of the rotor 104. OP content is influenced by non-turbulent processes, including control actions, and 1P content is strongly influenced by shear, which is another non-turbulent process. A notch filter may be used to attenuate the 1P content in the flap load signal; however, a relatively large notch may be needed to achieve this, and in some cases this can reduce the power left at 2P and even 3P frequencies in the measurement signal.

[0051] With additional reference to Figure 3, an approach / scheme 30 for determining (a proxy for) the turbulence level of the incoming wind based on blade load sensor measurements, in accordance with examples of the invention, is shown. This approach addresses the issue outlined above in relation to the 1P notch filter. At step 301 the flap load measurements are obtained from a blade load sensor of each respective rotor blade 106. As in the approach described above, OP frequency content (or very low frequency content) in the received flap load signals is removed at step 302, e.g. via the use of a high pass filter.

[0052] Unlike in the approach described above, at step 303 the filtered flap load signals are transformed from a rotational coordinate frame of the wind turbine 10 (e.g. centred at the rotor 104), into three mutually orthogonal components Md, Mq, Mnin a fixed coordinate frame of the wind turbine 10. This transformation is performed using an m-blade (multiblade) transformation. The m-blade transformation takes the three rotating signals into a fixed reference frame along first, second and third reference directions d, q and n. The m-blade coordinate transformation may be in the form of a Coleman transformation. The Coleman transformation may be defined as follows:

[0053] Mdcos(xp') cos(xp + 2TT / 3) cos(xp — 2TT / 3) Masin(i / 0 sin(V> + 2TT / 3) sin(V> — 2TT / 3) Mb

[0054]

[0055] Mn1 / 3 1 / 3 1 / 3 LMCJ where Mabcis a three-dimensional vector comprising (filtered) flap bending moments Ma, Mb, Mcassociated with respective ones of the three blades 106, (in the rotor coordinate frame), xp is the (1P) phase, and Mdqnis a vector in the fixed coordinate frame.

[0056] When Mabcis the vector containing the out-of-plane components of the flap bending moments Ma, Mb, Mcand the phase is set as the rotor azimuth, the first and second reference directions d, q are tilt and yaw directions, and the third reference direction n corresponds to thrust; however, in general, the Coleman transformation simply transforms the rotating signals into mutually orthogonal first, second and third components in the fixed reference frame.

[0057] 1P frequency content in the rotational frame signal is transformed at step 303 to OP frequency content in the fixed frame. Also, (the majority of) 2P frequency content in the rotational frame signal is transformed at this step to 3P frequency content in the fixed frame. That is, a larger separation is created between the 1P and 2P content in the rotational frame when the signals are transformed into the fixed frame, i.e. a separation of 3P-0P=3P in the fixed frame rather than 2P-1P=1P in the rotational frame. This is beneficial as it allows for frequency content that is to be removed, i.e. 1P content in the original signal, to be more readily attenuated without also attenuating some of the frequency content that it is desired to retain, i.e. 2P content in the original signal.

[0058] This process of transforming the measurement signal into the fixed frame in order to better attenuate 1P frequency content (in the rotational frame) may be particularly beneficial for use when the wind turbine 10 is in yawed operation (wake steering). This is because there is a correlation between wind turbine stall and 2P frequency content in the rotational frame, and there is a higher likelihood of stall in yawed operation. So, ensuring that 2P frequency content is not inadvertently attenuated when filtering 1P frequency content in the measurement signal is important in yawed operation for monitoring and mitigating stall risk. However, it is to be understood that the process of transforming the measurement signal into the fixed frame in order to better attenuate 1P frequency content (in therotational frame) is beneficial in and of itself during more general wind turbine operation, and not just during yawed operation.

[0059] Referring again to Figure 3, at step 304 a high pass filter is applied to remove OP content in the fixed frame (and retain 3P content). An inverse Coleman transform is applied at step 305 to transform the (filtered) signals back into the rotational frame of reference. In a corresponding manner to the above-described approach, the standard deviations of the three respective filtered signals are then determined at step 306. In the described example, the highest of the three standard deviation values is selected at step 307 to be used as the proxy signal 308 for turbulence intensity / level. It will be understood that in different examples the turbulence signal 308 may be determined differently at step 307, e.g. as an average of the three standard deviation signals.

[0060] Referring back to the baseline thrust determination module 201 in Figure 2, in addition to the turbulence level being determined (e.g. as in Figure 3), a measurement or estimation of wind speed in the vicinity of the wind turbine 10 is also obtained. For instance, a suitable sensor, e.g. anemometer, of the wind turbine 10 may be used to obtain measured wind speed. Alternatively, or in addition, an estimation of wind speed may be obtained, e.g. determined using a power curve of the wind turbine 10 and power output of the wind turbine 10.

[0061] As described above, the obtained standard deviation (of blade flap loads) and wind speed values are then used to determine the (baseline) maximum allowable thrust. This may be achieved via the use of a defined lookup table that maps pairs of standard deviation and wind speed values to respective values of baseline maximum allowable thrust Ftmax. Alternatively, a defined relationship may be evaluated for values of standard deviation and wind speed to obtain a baseline maximum allowable thrust value.

[0062] Referring again to Figure 2, the control scheme 20 includes modules for determining an adjustment to the baseline maximum allowable thrust Ftmax. The control scheme 20 receives a signal indicative of a target yaw offset to be applied to the wind turbine 10. The target yaw offset signal may for instance be received from a wake steering control function that sets an intended yaw offset for wind turbine operation to redirect generated wake flow in a desired manner.In the described example, a scaling / weighting factor is determined at processing / determination module 203 based on the target yaw offset. The scaling factor is to be applied to the baseline maximum allowable thrust Ftmaxto obtain the (adjusted) maximum allowable thrust. A zero yaw offset corresponds to a maximum thrust experienced by the wind turbine 10. When the wind turbine 10 is yawed out of the wind, the thrust force is reduced, but asymmetries (uneven measurements) are added that can appear as additional blade loads. The scaling factor is therefore used to ensure that the additional blade loads are interpreted correctly as increased asymmetries in yawed operation, rather than increased turbulence levels in the incoming wind. Lower wind speed may also be sensed in yawed operation for given wind conditions.

[0063] As a zero yaw offset corresponds to maximum thrust experienced by the wind turbine 10, the scaling factor is less than one for non-zero values of target yaw offset. This is to prevent underactive thrust limitation functionality in yawed operation of the wind turbine 10. In some examples, values of the scaling factor are determined to ensure that the wind turbine 10 does not experience additional loads when in yawed operation (wake steering) compared to non-yawed operation. It may generally be the case that the scaling factor decreases as the (magnitude of the) target yaw offset increases. This means that the wind turbine typically operates with a lower maximum allowable thrust for higher target yaw offsets.

[0064] In some examples, the scaling factor value is obtained via a lookup table mapping values of target yaw offset to respective scaling factor values. In other examples, a relationship describing scaling factor values as a function of target yaw offset values may be determined / defined. Such a function may be symmetrical about a zero target yaw offset. A linear or nonlinear (e.g. parabolic) relationship may be defined between the scaling factor and the (magnitude of the) target yaw offset. The relationship may be defined for a defined range of target yaw offset values (either side of a zero yaw offset). In some examples, the scaling factor is determined based on further parameters (in addition to the yaw offset), such as turbulence level, wind speed, etc.

[0065] Values of the scaling factor may be tuned via simulation, for instance. A change in measured flap loads of the rotor blades 106 may be monitored when the wind turbine 10 is operated with wake steering control, and this may be compensated via a thrust clip to obtain values for the scaling factor at different yaw offsets.Referring back to Figure 2, the determined scaling factor is applied to the baseline maximum allowable thrust Ftmax, e.g. via multiplication, at processing / combining module 204 to obtain the adjusted / new maximum allowable thrust. As the scaling factor is less than one for non-zero target yaw offsets, then the scaling factor acts to reduce the baseline maximum allowable thrust, i.e. the adjusted maximum allowable thrust is less than the baseline maximum allowable thrust for non-zero target yaw offset values.

[0066] In different examples of the invention, the baseline maximum allowable thrust may be adjusted to account for the target yaw offset by means of an offset / shift rather than a scaling factor as in the example described above. Such an offset may be subtracted from the baseline thrust to obtain a reduced / adjusted maximum allowable thrust.

[0067] In different examples of the invention, the maximum allowable thrust may not be determined as an adjustment to a baseline thrust limit (as in the above example), but rather it may be determined directly using a yaw offset signal indicative of target yaw offset of the wind turbine 10. In particular, in such examples, the standard deviation of the blade loading and the wind speed are obtained as described above. The maximum allowable thrust may then be determined directly based on the flap loading standard deviation, the wind speed and the target yaw offset. For instance, this may be performed via a lookup table. In one example, multiple lookup tables are defined for respective target yaw offset values. The relevant lookup table is selected based on target yaw offset and the pair of flap loading standard deviation and wind speed values is mapped to a maximum allowable thrust value.

[0068] Figure 4 summarises the steps of a method 40, performed by a controller of the wind turbine 10, in accordance with examples of the invention. At step 401, the method 40 involves receiving a yaw offset signal indicative of a target yaw offset according to which the wind turbine 10 is being, or to be, controlled. The yaw offset signal may be received from a wake steering controller or wake steering control module of the wind turbine 10.

[0069] At step 402, the method 40 involves determining, based on the received yaw offset signal, a thrust limit level indicative of a maximum allowable thrust to be experienced by the wind turbine 10. The thrust limit level may be determined as an adjustment to a baseline thrust limit level relevant to zero yaw offset operation of the wind turbine 10. The adjustment may be in the form of a scaling factor or offset, for instance, and may be determined via the use of a lookup table. The baseline level may be determined based on an indication of wind speed and wind turbulence level / intensity, and may be determined via the use of a(different) lookup table. Alternatively, the thrust limit level may be determined directly (rather than as an adjustment) based on the target yaw offset, the wind speed and the wind turbulence level, e.g. via the use of a lookup table.

[0070] At step 403, the method 40 involves controlling the wind turbine 10 in accordance with the determined maximum allowable thrust. In some examples, this is performed by setting a minimum allowable pitch angle for rotor blades 106 of the wind turbine 10, and controlling rotor blade pitch angle in accordance with this minimum allowable pitch angle. Specifically, in the equation for thrust force Ftoutlined above, the thrust force may be set to the determined maximum allowable thrust, i.e. set Ft= Ftmax, and then the equation is solved for the pitch angle 6 to obtain the minimum pitch angle.

[0071] A controller for implementing examples of the invention may be in the form of any suitable computing device, for instance one or more functional units or modules implemented on one or more computer processors. Such functional units may be provided by suitable software running on any suitable computing substrate using conventional or custom processors and memory. The one or more functional units may use a common computing substrate (for example, they may run on the same server) or separate substrates, or one or both may themselves be distributed between multiple computing devices. A computer memory may store instructions for performing the methods performed by the controller, and the processor(s) may execute the stored instructions to perform the method.

[0072] Figure 5 shows plots of simulation results illustrating the effect of implementing the method described above for adjusting maximum allowable thrust based on target yaw offset. In particular, Figure 5(a) shows plots of maximum allowable thrust to be experienced by the wind turbine 10 over time, and Figure 5(b) shows plots of blade flap moments over time. In both figures, comparative plots are provided for the cases in which the above-described method is and is not utilised when a defined non-zero target yaw offset is applied. In addition, both figures provide a plot corresponding to a case in which there is a zero target yaw offset, for further comparative purposes. The wind speed is the same across each of the simulations.

[0073] In more detail, Figure 5(a) shows a first plot 501 of maximum allowable thrust over time in the case of zero target yaw offset, which can be regarded as a baseline obtained using previous, known methods. A second plot 502 of maximum allowable thrust over time is obtained using the above-described method and corresponds to a case in which a definednon-zero target yaw offset is being applied. It is seen from Figure 5(a) that the maximum allowable thrust in the second plot 502 is lower than that in the first plot 501 in the zero target yaw offset case across the entire time trace. A third plot 503 of maximum allowable thrust over time corresponds to a case in which the defined non-zero target yaw offset is being applied, but where this non-zero target yaw offset is not taken into account in the determination of the maximum allowable thrust. As is seen from Figure 5(a), determining the maximum allowable thrust according to the described method when a non-zero target yaw offset is present leads to a lower maximum allowable thrust compared to when a previous, known method is used. The previous, known method may involve determining maximum allowable thrust only based on a turbulence level / intensity of the incoming wind, for instance.

[0074] Figure 5(b) shows how the maximum allowable thrusts shown in Figure 5(a) impact the flap moments on the rotor blades of the wind turbine 10. A first plot 511 shows flap moment over time in the zero target yaw offset case, for reference. A second plot 512 shows flap moment over time in the non-zero target yaw offset case where the described method is used to determine maximum allowable thrust. A third plot 513 then shows flap moment over time in the non-zero target yaw offset case where a previous, known method is used to determine maximum allowable thrust. It is seen that the flap moment is reduced when the described method is used compared to the flap moment observed when the maximum allowable thrust is determined using a previous, known method. In this way, it is seen that the described approach protects the wind turbine from excessive thrust loading for wind turbine operation at different yaw offsets.

[0075] Many modifications may be made to the described examples without departing from the scope of the appended claims.

Claims

CLAIMS1. A method of controlling a wind turbine, the method comprising:receiving a yaw offset signal indicative of a target yaw offset according to which the wind turbine is being controlled;determining, based on the received yaw offset signal, a thrust limit level indicative of a maximum allowable thrust to be experienced by the wind turbine; and controlling the wind turbine in accordance with the determined maximum allowable thrust.

2. A method according to Claim 1, wherein determining the thrust limit level comprises:obtaining a baseline thrust limit level for the wind turbine;determining a thrust limit adjustment parameter based on the received yaw offset signal; andapplying the thrust limit adjustment parameter to the baseline thrust limit level to determine the thrust limit level, wherein the thrust limit level is less than or equal to the baseline thrust limit level.

3. A method according to Claim 2, wherein the thrust limit adjustment parameter is a scaling factor having a magnitude less than or equal to one.

4. A method according to Claim 3, wherein the magnitude of the scaling factor decreases as a magnitude of the target yaw offset increases; optionally, wherein the scaling factor magnitude varies nonlinearly with the target yaw offset magnitude.

5. A method according to any of Claims 2 to 4, wherein the thrust limit level is less than the baseline thrust limit level when a magnitude of the target yaw offset is greater than a threshold magnitude; optionally, wherein the threshold magnitude is zero.

6. A method according to any of Claims 2 to 5, the method comprising determining the baseline thrust limit level, which comprises:receiving a wind speed signal indicative of wind speed in the vicinity of the wind turbine;receiving a flap load signal, from a blade load sensor of each of one or more rotor blades of the wind turbine, indicative of flap loading on the respective rotor blade;determining, based on the received flap load signal, a standard deviation parameter indicative of volatility of loading on the rotor blades of the wind turbine; and determining the baseline thrust limit level based on the received wind speed and the determined standard deviation parameter; optionally, wherein the baseline thrust limit level is determined via a lookup table comprising pairs of wind speed and standard deviation parameter values.

7. A method according to Claim 1, wherein determining the thrust limit level comprises:receiving a wind speed signal indicative of wind speed in the vicinity of the wind turbine;receiving a flap load signal, from a blade load sensor of each of one or more rotor blades of the wind turbine, indicative of flap loading on the respective rotor blade;determining, based on the received flap load signal, a standard deviation parameter indicative of volatility of loading on the rotor blades of the wind turbine; and determining the thrust limit level based on the received wind speed, the determined standard deviation parameter, and the received yaw offset signal.

8. A method according to Claim 7, wherein the thrust limit level is determined via a lookup table comprising, for each of a plurality of target yaw offset values, a respective plurality of pairs of wind speed and standard deviation parameter values.

9. A method according to any of Claims 6 to 8, wherein receiving the flap load signal comprises receiving a flap load signal from each respective rotor blade of the wind turbine, wherein determining the standard deviation parameter comprises:applying an m-blade coordinate transformation to the flap load signals to obtain first, second and third mutually orthogonal components in a fixed coordinate frame of the wind turbine;applying a high pass filter to the first, second and third mutually orthogonal components to obtain filtered first, second and third mutually orthogonal components; applying an inverse m-blade coordinate transformation to the filtered first, second and third mutually orthogonal components to obtain filtered flap load signals in a rotational coordinate frame of the wind turbine; anddetermining the standard deviation parameter based on the filtered flap load signals.

10. A method according to Claim 9, wherein the high pass filter is arranged to remove OP content from the first, second and third mutually orthogonal components.

11. A method according to Claim 9 or Claim 10, wherein determining the standard deviation parameter comprises:determining an individual standard deviation signal for each respective rotor blade based on the respective filtered flap load signal; andselecting the individual standard deviation having the highest magnitude as the determined standard deviation parameter.

12. A method according to any of Claims 9 to 11 , the method comprising, prior to applying the m-blade coordinate transformation, applying a further high pass filter to the flap load signals to remove OP content.

13. A method according to any previous claim, wherein controlling the wind turbine in accordance with the determined maximum allowable thrust comprises outputting the determined maximum allowable thrust to a thrust limit controller of the wind turbine to control a pitch angle of rotor blades of the wind turbine, or a rotation speed of a rotor of the wind turbine, based on the determined maximum allowable thrust.

14. A controller for a wind turbine, the controller being configured to:receive a yaw offset signal indicative of a target yaw offset according to which the wind turbine is being controlled;determine, based on the received yaw offset signal, a thrust limit level indicative of a maximum allowable thrust to be experienced by the wind turbine; andcontrol the wind turbine in accordance with the determined maximum allowable thrust.

15. A wind turbine comprising a controller according to Claim 14.