Delayed neutron importance factors determination in flowing fuel reactors

A novel methodology using Monte Carlo methods and thermal hydraulics codes to determine βeffin flowing fuel reactors addresses the lack of granularity in existing methods, enhancing safety and control by accurately accounting for delayed neutron precursor movement in complex geometries.

WO2026235677A2PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2026-11-12TERRAPOWER LLC
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/US2024/051154
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-12-13
Filing Date
2024-10-11
Publication Date
2026-11-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for determining delayed neutron importance factors in flowing fuel reactors lack granularity and accuracy, particularly in complex geometries, leading to inadequate control and safety in these systems.

Method used

A methodology is developed to estimate the effective delayed neutron fraction (βeff) by extending base equations and using continuous energy Monte Carlo methods to account for the movement of delayed neutron precursors in flowing fuel reactors, discretizing the geometry into control volumes, and determining delayed neutron importance factors using thermal hydraulics and neutronics codes.

Benefits of technology

This approach provides a more accurate determination of βeff, enhancing the understanding of thermal hydraulics and reactivity in flowing fuel reactors, especially in complex geometries, and improving safety and control by accounting for unsteady flow conditions.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure US2024051154_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure US2024051154_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

Ksens tallies can be employed in Monte Carlo neutron transport simulations to model the importance factor of delayed neutrons in a nuclear reactor. The ksens tally can be used to determine how variations in specific parameters, such as nuclear cross-sections, material densities, or geometry, affect the criticality of the reactor. By evaluating the sensitivity of k-eff to these parameters, the most influential factors that may impact reactor performance, safety, and fuel optimization can be identified. The delayed neutron importance can be evaluated by performing local adjoint flux integrals. The result is a methodology to determine βeff as a function of mass flow rate of the flowing fuel.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

22-009-UT1-WO-INNDELAYED NEUTRON IMPORTANCE FACTORS DETERMINATION IN FLOWING FUEL REACTORSGOVERNMENT LICENSE RIGHTS

[0001] This invention was made with government support under DOE Cooperative Agreement No. DE-NE0009045 awarded by the U. S. Department of Energy. The government has certain rights in the invention.CROSS-REFERENCE

[0002] The present application claim benefit of priority to U. S. Provisional Patent Application No. 63 / 609,841, filed December 13, 2023, titled “DELAYED NEUTRON IMPORTANCE FACTORS DETERMINATION IN FLOWING FUEL REACTORS,” the entire contents of which is hereby incorporated by reference.BACKGROUND

[0003] In a nuclear reactor, delayed neutron importance factors play a crucial role in the control and safety of the reactor. Delayed neutrons are a type of neutron that are emitted by some fission products after a nuclear fission event. Unlike prompt neutrons, which are emitted immediately after fission, delayed neutrons have a longer delay time before being released.

[0004] The delayed neutron importance factors are used to quantify the contribution of delayed neutrons to the overall neutron population and the subsequent reactivity changes in the reactor. These factors are particularly important in reactors that rely on feedback mechanisms for power regulation and stability.

[0005] In a flowing fuel reactor, for instance, the delayed neutrons may be bom at a location that is removed from the core as they aren’t released until sometime after fission and are typically born as a result of radioactive decay of certain fission products. In a flowing fuel reactor, the fission products will drift throughout the reactor and are delayed neutron precursors that give up delayed neurons as they flow through the reactor. These delayed22-009-UT1-WO-INNneutrons will have an effect on reactivity, but the effect is somewhat determined by the location within the reactor at which the delayed neutrons are born.

[0006] It would be advantageous to be able to determine the delayed neutron importance factors in a flowing fuel reactor. Historically, the delayed neutron importance factors were determined by assuming a delayed neutron was worth one prompt neutron in the active core and worth 0 prompt neutrons when bom outside the core. This assumption has some benefits but lacks granularity and is inaccurate for fine feedback control of a flowing fuel reactor.

[0007] Additional systems and methodologies are needed to perform the complex calculations to determine the delayed neutron importance factors for a flowing fuel reactor in order to accurately weight the delayed neutrons in terms of location and energy level. These, and other advantages, will become apparent to those of skill in the art by reference to the following description.SUMMARY

[0008] A methodology to estimate the effective delayed neutron fraction (βeff) as a function of mass flow rate of the flowing fuel. The base equations to calculate βeffare extended to evaluate a system where the delayed neutron precursors are flowing and delayed neutron importance factors can be determined with continuous energy Monte Carlo methods. Characterizing the movement of the delayed neutron precursors and understand their effect on the neutron kinetics is an important step in understanding the thermal hydraulics in a flowing fuel reactor. In particular, the effective delayed neutron fraction βeffmust be calculated in a different manner than is currently available for static fueled systems. The βeffis important from a safety consideration for several reasons, such as, for example, it provides a reactivity margin to prompt critical events, in a molten salt system, βeffmay vary over time due to variations in flow rate and thereby insert, or remove, reactivity from the system.

[0009] According to embodiments, a novel methodology is provided to determine βeffin a flowing fuel nuclear reactor, and in a flowing fuel nuclear reactor having a complex geometry.

[0010] For example, in some embodiments, a method for determining an effective delayed neutron fraction in a flowing fuel nuclear reactor having a complex geometry comprises defining a complex geometry of the nuclear reactor, the complex geometry22-009-UT1-WO-INNincluding asymmetries in a fuel flow path; discretizing the complex geometry into a plurality of control volumes; determining a delayed neutron importance factor for each of the plurality of control volumes; determining a distribution of delayed neutron precursors in each of the plurality of control volumes; determining a delayed neutron emission distribution in each of the plurality of control volumes; determining reactivity sensitivity (ksens) tallies; and determining, based at least in part on the ksens tallies, the effective delayed neutron fraction.

[0011] Optionally, defining a complex geometry includes defining a geometry that does not align with regular hex, cartesian, or RZTheta meshes. This is referred to as a complex geometry. The described method is especially suitable for complex geometries.

[0012] In some cases, discretizing the complex geometry further comprises discretizing the complex geometry to describe the flowing fuel flow path through the flowing fuel nuclear reactor. In some instanced, determining the distribution of delayed neutron precursors in each of the plurality of control volumes is performed by executing a thermal hydraulics code. The thermal hydraulics code may be any suitable code base that may be configured to determine the distribution of delayed neutron precursors throughout the inventory of flowing fuel.

[0013] In some embodiments, determining the delayed neutron emission distribution in each of the plurality of control volumes comprises weighting delayed neutron emissions based upon a respective control volume in which the delayed neutrons are emitted.

[0014] The method may further include the step of determining ksens tallies by combining energy discretized ksens tallies. In some cases, the ksens tallies are determined, at least in part, based on adjust flux weighing.

[0015] The method may further include determining the effective delayed neutron fraction by determining the ksens tallies in a Monte Carlo neutronics analysis code.

[0016] In some cases, the method is performed by one or more processors configured with instructions to carry out the method.

[0017] Optionally, the method further includes performing a thermal hydraulics analysis, based at least in part on the effective delayed neutron fraction, for the flowing fuel nuclear reactor.22-009-UT1-WO-INN

[0018] Determining the distribution of delayed neutron precursors in each of the plurality of control volumes may be performed by tracking and determining an identification and location of delayed neutron precursors based on a mass flow through the complex geometry.

[0019] According to some embodiments, a method for determining an effective delayed neutron fraction in a flowing fuel nuclear reactor, comprising the steps of providing a complex geometry description of the flowing fuel nuclear reactor, the complex geometry including asymmetries in a fuel flow path o the flowing fuel nuclear reactor; discretizing the complex geometry into a plurality of control volumes; summing tallies for ksen tallies for delayed neutron and total fission neutron in each control volume; decomposing the delayed neutron ksen tally by delayed group for each fissionable isotope; determining a delayed neutron importance factor for each fissionable nuclide in each control volume; determining delayed neutron precursor generation in each control volume; determining a distribution of delayed neutron precursors; and determining an effective delayed neutron fraction.

[0020] In some examples, determining delayed neutron precursor generation in each control volume further comprises multiplying the delayed neutron per fission vector by energy dependent fission rate.

[0021] In some instances, determining distribution of delayed neutron precursor further comprises tracking the delayed neutron precursors through the complex geometry, modeling a radioactive decay of the delayed neutron precursors, modeling a generation of the delayed neutron precursors, and modeling an advection of the delayed neutron precursors into and out of the plurality of control volumes.

[0022] In some embodiments, decomposing the delayed neutron ksen tally further comprises determining an energy integrated average delayed neutron per fission from delayed neutrons. The method may further include weighting an integral delayed neutron sensitivity in an energy bin by a ratio of delayed neutrons in that delayed group emitted per each fission of the fissionable nuclide to the integral of delayed neutrons in the energy bin emitted per each fission of the fissionable neutrons.

[0023] In some embodiments, a method for determining an effective delayed neutron fraction in a flowing fuel nuclear reactor includes the steps of providing a complex geometry description of the flowing fuel nuclear reactor, the complex geometry including asymmetries in a fuel flow path of the flowing fuel nuclear reactor; discretizing the flowing fuel nuclear22-009-UT1-WO-INNreactor into a plurality of control volumes; determining a generation rate of total neutrons and delayed neutron precursors in each of the plurality of control volumes; determining a distribution of delayed neutron precursors in each of the plurality of control volumes; determining an emission distribution of delayed neutrons in each of the plurality of control volumes; determining a delayed neutron importance factor in each of the plurality of control volumes; and determining, based at least in part on the delayed neutron importance factor, an effective delayed neutron fraction.

[0024] The method may include determining the delayed neutron importance factor in each of the plurality of control volumes by Monte Carlo methods.BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0025] The accompanying drawings are part of the disclosure and are incorporated into the present specification. The drawings illustrate examples of embodiments of the disclosure and, in conjunction with the description and claims, serve to explain, at least in part, various principles, features, or aspects of the disclosure. Certain embodiments of the disclosure are described more fully below with reference to the accompanying drawings. However, various aspects of the disclosure may be implemented in many different forms and should not be construed as being limited to the implementations set forth herein. Like numbers refer to like, but not necessarily the same or identical, elements throughout.

[0026] The following drawing figures, which form a part of this application, are illustrative of described technology and are not meant to limit the scope of the technology as claimed in any manner, which scope shall be based on the claims appended hereto.

[0027] FIG. 1 illustrates a functional block diagram of a pool-type reactor designed for use with a fuel salt, in accordance with some embodiments.

[0028] FIG. 2 is a sectional perspective view of a pool-type reactor designed for use with a fuel salt, in accordance with some embodiments.

[0029] FIG. 3 illustrates the fuel salt volume and flow paths within a flowing fuel reactor, in accordance with some embodiments.

[0030] FIG. 4 illustrates kinetics parameters, delayed importance factors, and fission rates in various regions of a sample nuclear reactor with flowing fuel, in accordance with some embodiments.22-009-UT1-WO-INN

[0031] FIG. 5 is a graph 500 showing the effective delayed neutron fraction as a function of mass flow rate, in accordance with some embodiments.

[0032] FIG. 6A illustrates importance and delayed neutron emission distribution of bom neutrons at location of a flowing fuel flow path, in accordance with some embodiments.

[0033] FIG. 6B illustrates delayed neutron importance distribution for static fuel, in accordance with some embodiments.

[0034] FIG. 6C illustrates flowing fuel delayed neutron emission distribution, in accordance with some embodiments.

[0035] FIG. 7 is a process flow illustrating a method for determining transient thermal hydraulics of a flowing fuel nuclear reactor, in accordance with some embodiments.

[0036] FIG. 8 is a process flow diagram that illustrates a method for determining, based on ksens tallies, the effective delayed neutron fraction, in accordance with some embodiments.

[0037] FIG. 9 is a process flow diagram that illustrates a method for determining an effective delayed neutron fraction, in accordance with some embodiments.

[0038] FIG. 10 is a process flow diagram for determining the effective delayed neutron fraction in a flowing fuel reactor, in accordance with some embodiments.DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0039] During steady-state nuclear reactor operation, the rate of neutron production and the rate of neutron loss are in exact balance. If the neutron production and loss rates are not in balance, that is, if the reactor k-eff is not equal to one, the reactor power level will not remain constant, but rather will rise or decay exponentially on a period which is related to the neutron generation rate. For instance, assuming that the length of time between one neutron generation and the next is 0.00005 s and the neutron production rate was to exceed the neutron loss rate by only 0.1%, the reactor power level would increase by a factor of about 500,000,000 in one second. However, there are other factors that desensitize the k-eff swings.

[0040] In an operating fission reactor, the production of neutrons results not only directly from fission (called prompt neutrons) but also indirectly from certain fission product nuclides, which emit neutrons through radioactive decay (e.g., delayed neutrons). These22-009-UT1-WO-INNdelayed neutrons may be emitted anywhere from several seconds to a few minutes after the fission products are produced, and are important in understanding reactor transients and permitting the control of a nuclear reactor. If the reactor is subcritical on prompt neutrons alone, but supercritical when the delayed neutrons are included in the total neutron production rate, then the delayed neutrons will control the rate of change of the reactor transient. Thus, the delayed neutrons will enable the reactor period to be on the order of minutes rather than microseconds. The design and control of the reactor may be based on, among other things, the sensitivity of the reactor to transients. However, simulating and analyzing the sensitivity of a reactor is a difficult and computationally intensive process.

[0041] Monte Carlo simulations are a widely used tool in nuclear science and engineering to model complex systems and processes. These simulations are based on the statistical sampling of particles, which are tracked through the system to calculate the desired quantities. However, these simulations can suffer from source convergence issues, which can lead to large computational requirements and in some cases, inaccuracies in the results. In some cases, Monte Carlo codes, such as Monte Carlo N-Particle Code (MCNP) and the continuous energy sensitivity and uncertainty (SCALE TSUNAMI) code can be used to estimate the adjoint flux with Monte Carlo methods.

[0042] The adjoint flux represents the number of fission neutrons each descendant neutron causes. B This adjoint flux may be used to weigh the relative importance of delayed neutrons relative to all the fission-bom neutrons in the system. This methodology has been implemented with deterministic tools and with continuous energy Monte Carlo tools for fixed fuel systems. Calculation of the delayed neutron fraction with general purpose tools makes the assumption that the delayed neutron precursors emit delayed neutrons where the initial fission occurs, which is not a good assumption for flowing fuel systems.

[0043] The idea of calculating the effective delayed neutron fraction by adjoint weighting the delayed neutron flux distribution may be extended to flowing fuel systems by weighing the local delayed neutron emission distribution (discretized by local intensity, spatial distribution, and energy spectrum) and normalizing by the total neutron (prompt- and delayed neutron) emission distribution.

[0044] The delayed neutron emission distribution may be estimated with thermal hydraulic tools. A thermal hydraulics tool would track delayed neutron precursors generated22-009-UT1-WO-INNin one control volume and flows (via advection) throughout the flowing fuel system. This system would track delayed neutron precursors and also remove delayed neutron precursors as they decay. Either a steady state solution would be established, or the distribution of delayed neutron precursors could evolve in time. Once the distribution of delayed neutron precursors is known, the emission distribution of delayed neutrons may be calculated by multiplying the inventory of delayed neutron precursors by the decay constant of the delayed neutron precursor and multiplying by the delayed neutron energy emission distribution (chi). The capability to track delayed neutron precursors has been implemented in thermal hydraulics code.

[0045] One way to perform the adjoint weighting would be to couple a neutronics code to a thermal hydraulics code capable of direct adjoint multiplication. This has been implemented in research studies.

[0046] Another less intrusive way to perform the adjoint weighting integral would be to discretize the flowing fuel system into control volumes that are consistent between the thermal hydraulics model and the neutronics model, and then sum the product of the delayed neutron emission rate in each control volume by a factor, delayed neutron importance factor, that accounts for the spatial and energy importance of a delayed neutron emitted in the specific control volume. In some cases, these spatial delayed neutron importance factors may be precomputed using only neutronics information - thereby obviating the need for direct coupling of a neutronics code with a thermal hydraulics code to account for this phenomenon. These spatial delayed neutron importance factors may also be used to simplify the delay neutron term in the point kinetics equation such that transient calculations may be performed without direct coupling between neutronics and thermal hydraulics. These spatial delayed neutron importance factors may be calculated by performing summations with the adjoint flux from either deterministic methods or Monte Carlo methods.

[0047] Legacy structured coarse mesh deterministic models alone result in less than ideal results because the 3D geometry of many flowing fuel reactors may not strictly adhere to regular hex, cartesian, or RZTheta meshes which results in homogenization distortions.

[0048] As further discussed below, energy discretized ksens tallies may be combined in unique ways to result in a much more accurate representation. As used herein, ksens tallies are k-eff sensitivity tallies evaluated using the iterated fission probability method and22-009-UT1-WO-INNproduce values that are equivalent to adjoint flux weighted reaction rate integrals. More specifically, ksens (also written as k-sensitivity) tallies are used to measure the sensitivity of a reactor's criticality (k-eff) to changes in certain nuclear data or parameters. The k-eff is a measure of the reactor's multiplication factor, which indicates whether the reactor is critical (steady-state condition where neutron production equals neutron losses) or not.

[0049] The ksens tally can be employed in Monte Carlo neutron transport simulations, a computational method used to model the behavior of neutrons in a nuclear reactor. This method relies on statistical sampling to simulate the random interactions of neutrons with reactor materials.

[0050] In some cases, the ksens tally can be used to determine how variations in specific parameters, such as nuclear cross-sections, material densities, or geometry, affect the criticality of the reactor. By evaluating the sensitivity of k-eff to these parameters, the most influential factors that may impact reactor performance, safety, and fuel optimization can be identified.

[0051] Through sensitivity analysis using ksens tallies, reactor designs may be improved, fuel compositions can be adjusted, and the impact of uncertainties in nuclear data on reactor behavior can be assessed. Historically, it has been difficult to use structured mesh deterministic models for reactor designs that do not take on geometrically regular shapes, such as reactor designs that do not have equal sides or angles and / or may not be symmetrical.

[0052] FIG. 1 illustrates a functional block diagram of a pool-type reactor 100 designed for use with a molten nuclear flowing fuel. With additional reference to FIG.2, which illustrates another embodiment of a flowing fuel nuclear reactor, the reactor 100 includes a reactor system 110, a primary cooling system 112, and a heat rejection system 114. The reactor system 110 generates heat through fission of a molten salt fuel. The heat is removed from the reactor system 110 via the primary cooling system 112. That removed heat is then discharged into the atmosphere by the heat rejection system 114. Although the illustrated reactor 100 is designed for use with a chloride fuel salt such as a uranium, a plutonium, a thorium or a combination chloride fuel salt, alternative embodiments of the reactor may be designed for use with any fuel salt such as fluoride fuel salt and fluoride-chloride fuel salts. Examples of nuclear fuel salts include mixtures of one or more fissionable fuel salts such as PuCl3, UCl4, UCl3F, UCl3, UCl2F2, ThCl4, and UClF3, with one or more non-fissile salts such22-009-UT1-WO-INNas NaCl, MgCh, CaCh, BaCh, KC1, SrCl2, VCl3, CrCl3, TiCl4, ZrCl4, ThCl4, AlCl3, NpCl4, AmCl3, LaCl3, CeCl3, PrCl3, and NdCl3. For example, PuCh-NaCl, UCU-NaCl and UCI3-MgCh salts are contemplated.

[0053] The reactor system 100 includes a reactor core 102. The reactor core 102, during operation, is a central, open channel that contains a volume of molten fuel where the density of fast neutrons (where the average neutrons causing fission have an energy of 0.5 MeV or greater) is sufficient to achieve criticality. The size and shape of the channel is defined by a neutron reflector assembly 103 within the reactor vessel. The reflector assembly 103 surrounds the reactor core 102 and acts to reflect fast neutrons generated in the core 102 back into the core 102, thereby increasing the fast neutron density.

[0054] The size of the reactor core 102 may be selected based on the type of fuel being used, that is, the volume is sufficient to hold the necessary amount of molten fuel inventory to achieve critical mass in the reactor core 102. In some embodiments, during operation the reactor core 102 is unmoderated, that is, the reactor core contains no moderator rods or other moderator elements so as not to reduce the energy of fast neutrons in the core. In some embodiments, the reactor core 102 contains only molten fuel. That fact that the reactor core 102 can achieve criticality from the molten fuel within the core itself is one aspect that separates the fast reactor designs described herein from thermal reactors and from fast reactors that use a collection of individual fuel pins that, during operation, each contain a small amount of molten fuel insufficient to achieve criticality, but when collected into a fuel assembly in sufficient numbers can form a critical mass.

[0055] The core 102 and the reflector assembly 103 are surrounded by a reactor vessel 104 which, in the embodiment shown, is itself inside a shielding vessel 116. The reactor 100 is referred to as pool-type to indicate that molten fuel is contained within reactor vessel 104, which forms a pool that is filled with liquid molten fuel when in operation. Solid components, such as elements of the reflector assembly, may be within the pool formed by the reactor vessel 104 and may take up some of the volume within the reactor vessel 104. Such components are referred to herein as displacement elements because they displace fuel from the space they take up within the reactor vessel. Some displacement elements may perform no other function than to take up space within the reactor vessel. Other displacement elements, like the reflector assembly, may also perform functions such as directing the22-009-UT1-WO-INNcirculation of molten fuel and affecting the neutronics of the reactor core in addition to displacing molten fuel within the reactor vessel 104.

[0056] In some embodiments, the guard vessel 116 provides an added level of safety and may also serve as a secondary containment vessel in case of a rupture in the reactor vessel. In some cases, the reactor vessel 104 and the shielding vessel 116 are made of solid steel. Based on the operating conditions, which will at least in part be dictated by the fuel selection, any suitable high temperature and corrosion resistant steel, such as 316H stainless, HT-9, a molybdenum alloy, a zirconium alloy (e g., ZIRCALOY, a niobium alloy, nickel or alloy thereof (e.g., HASTELLOY™ trademarked by Haynes International, Inc, INCONEL™ 617 or INCONEL™ 625, both of which are nickel alloys trademarked by Huntington Alloys Corporation), or high temperature ferritic, martensitic, or stainless steel and the like may be used. For example, in an embodiment all molten fuel -contacting (salt-wetted) components may be made of or cladded with INCONEL™ 625 (UNS designation No6625) to reduce the corrosion of those components.

[0057] According to some embodiments, one or more pumps 118 are provided to circulate the molten fuel. In an alternative embodiment, the reactor system 110 is designed to operate under natural circulation and no pump is provided. During operation heated fuel is circulated between the reactor core 102 where fission heat is generated and the interior surface of the reactor vessel 104 where the fuel is cooled, and the fission heat is removed.

[0058] The reactor vessel 104 may be cooled by a primary cooling system 112. When operating at steady state the temperature within the reactor core 102 remains stable, with the excess heat generated by fission being removed by the primary cooling system 112. In some embodiments, the primary cooling system 112 consists of one or more cooling circuits (only one circuit is shown in FIG. 1) in which each circuit includes one or more heat exchangers 106 and a coolant blower 108. Alternatively, a liquid coolant could be used in conjunction with a liquid-to-air heat exchanger and a pump. In some cases, a liquid-to-liquid heat exchanger 106 may be used in the core, such as a heat exchanger configured to flow coolant salt in the reactor vessel that transfers heat to a secondary coolant salt flowing through the heat exchanger to take heat away from the reactor. In some cases, the coolant blower 108 forces cool primary coolant gas past the exterior surface of the reactor vessel 104 by flowing the coolant through a space provided between the reactor vessel 104 and the shielding vessel22-009-UT1-WO-INN116 for the primary coolant. Heat is removed from the reactor vessel 104 by passing the primary coolant along the exterior surface of the reactor vessel. Although some heat may be lost to parasitic losses, at steady state most if not all heat generated in the reactor core 102 is removed by the primary coolant system 112. To assist in the transfer of heat, fins, pins, dimples, or other heat transfer elements may be provided on the exterior surface of the vessel 104 to increase the surface area of the exterior surface exposed to the primary coolant as will be discussed in greater detail below.

[0059] The heated primary coolant then flows to the heat exchanger 106. Heated primary coolant gas passes through the heat exchanger 106 where the primary coolant gas is cooled and the air is heated. Cooled primary coolant is then recirculated to the reactor system 110 to form a primary coolant flow circuit. As shown in FIG. 2, one or more heat exchangers 106 may be located within the reactor vessel 104 in some embodiments to transfer heat from the hot fuel salt to another working fluid that flows outside the reactor vessel within the primary coolant loop.

[0060] In an embodiment, an inert gas, e.g., nitrogen or argon, is used as the primary coolant gas. However, any gas may be used. In an alternative embodiment, the reactor 100 may be designed to use any fluid, either gas or liquid, as the primary coolant.

[0061] The heat rejection system 114 may use air as the working fluid. In some embodiments, the heat rejection system 114 takes in ambient air at an ambient temperature and pressure. Using an air blower 128, the ambient air may be passed through the heat exchanger 106 where it received heat from the heat coolant. The now -heated air from the heat exchanger 106 is then vented to the environment. Similar to the primary cooling system 112, the heat rejection system 114 may include multiple, independent heat rejection circuits (again, only one is shown in FIG. 1). Each heat rejection circuit may include its own dedicated and independently controllable blower 128, air intake 120, heated air discharge vent 122 and associated piping / ducting.

[0062] In some embodiments, multiple independent cooling circuits and heat rejection circuits may be used. For example, in some embodiments four separate and independent cooling circuits may be used. In addition, an independent heat rejection circuit may be provided for each cooling circuit. In other embodiments, instead of four independent pairs of primary cooling / heat rejection circuits, there are two, three, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten,22-009-UT1-WO-INNor more independent pairs of primary cooling system 112 and heat rejection system 114. However, a one-to-one correspondence of primary cooling circuits to heat rejection circuits is not necessary. For example, in an embodiment the reactor 100 may have four primary cooling circuits but only two heat rejection circuit in which each heat rejection circuit serves two primary cooling circuits. Other configurations are possible.

[0063] In some instances, the power output of the reactor makes it feasible to reject the excess heat from the fission reaction to the environment. In the embodiment shown, the primary cooling system 112 is provided as a safety system to contain the primary coolant in case there may be any release of nuclear fuel or fission products from the reactor system 110 into the primary coolant circuit. In an alternative design, the heat may be rejected directly to the environment by discharging the primary coolant directly to the environment. This embodiment essentially eliminates the primary cooling system 112 so that heat is removed by the heat rejection system 114, although such a design may need additional safeguards such as an emergency shutoff system to meet safety requirements. In such an embodiment air may be used as the primary coolant. In an alternative embodiment, water may be used as the primary coolant and the blower 128 replaced with a pump that discharges heated water into the environment.

[0064] Alternatively, the heat removed from the reactor could be used beneficially to provide thermal energy to other systems. For example, in an embodiment the primary coolant could be passed to a thermal energy system for reuse as thermal energy in the reactor facility.

[0065] With additional reference to FIG 3, a flowing fuel volume and flow path is illustrated. It should be appreciated that the flowing volume and flow path of FIG. 3 is exemplary and does not illustrate a fuel volume and flow path of every flowing fuel reactor but is shown to describe how the fuel may flow in some embodiments. The fuel salt flow path may begin within the core 102 where fuel fissions and heats the fuel salt. Upon exiting the core 102 as hot molten fuel salt, the fuel salt is drawn into an exit our outlet flow channel 208 (FIG 2) in communication with the core 102. Fuel salt flow continues to the pump 118 that circulates the molten fuel salt through the reactor core 102. The pump 118 discharges molten salt to the primary heat exchanger 106 where heat is extracted from the hot molten fuel salt, and the molten fuel salt exits the primary heat exchanger 106 as cold molten fuel salt.22-009-UT1-WO-INN

[0066] Fuel salt flow may continue to an optional displacement volume 349 so the amount of fuel salt through the flow path can be reduced and / or increased as required or desired. In some examples, the optional displacement volume 349 may be in fluid communication with the separate displacement tank (not shown) that is configured to store at least a portion of the fuel salt. The cold molten fuel salt is then delivered to the core 102 through an entrance or inlet channel 218, where it is reheated, and the recirculation process continues.

[0067] FIG. 3 illustrates the fuel salt volume and flow circuits within a flowing fuel reactor. In particular, FIG. 3 illustrates the entire volume 300 of salt contained within an example reactor system 100. In addition to the flow paths, FIG. 3 additionally shows outline of the pump stator (in the form of directing vanes 312), a flow restriction device 360 (in the form of a gate valve) in one flow channel, and flow conditioner 320 (in the form of an orifice ring plate). In some examples, the optional flow restriction device 360 controls the flow of fuel salt in one of the fuel salt circuits. The flow restriction device 360 may be located at the top of one of the four illustrated upper flow exit channels 314 between the active core 102 and the reactor vessel interior surface. Although only one flow restriction device 360 in one of the four flow circuits is shown, in alternative embodiments some of the other or all of the fuel salt flow circuits may also be furnished with such flow restriction devices 360 (which may be any suitable device, such as, for example, a valve, a gate valve, sluice gate, pinch valve, or other suitable device) allows the flow rate of fuel salt through the circuit to be controlled.

[0068] The flow restriction device 360 may introduce asymmetries in the flows entering the active core 102, as well as to modify the effective delayed neutron fraction by varying the amount of delayed neutron precursors flowing (advecting) outside of the active core. This allows the operation of the reactor 100 to be varied in order to investigate different operating scenarios and reactor conditions.

[0069] During operation, heated fuel salt flows upwardly through the reactor core 102, into the impeller chamber 310. The rotating impeller (not shown) drives the fuel salt (illustrated by the arrows) through the directing vanes 312 of the pump stator where the fuel salt flow is separated into one of four upper, heated fuel salt exit channels 314. The exit channel 314 carries the fuel salt over a radial reflector (not shown) to a heat exchange duct22-009-UT1-WO-INN316. In some embodiments, the upper, heated fuel salt exit channels 314 may be narrower in width closest to the pump impeller and widen as they approach the reactor vessel.

[0070] The heat exchange duct 316 is a channel between the radial reflector (not shown) and the interior surface of the reactor vessel 104 extending from near the top of the radial reflector to a location near the bottom of the radial reflector. In some cases, one wall of the heat exchange duct 316 is in direct contact with the reactor vessel 104 so that fuel flowing downwardly through the eat exchange duct 316 is in direct contact with the reactor vessel 104. Fuel salt exits the heat exchange duct 316 via a lower, cooled fuel salt delivery channel 318. The lower, cooled fuel salt delivery channel 318 delivers the now cooled fuel salt from the heat exchange duct 316 into the bottom of the reactor core 102.

[0071] In some cases, an expansion chamber 349 may be provided to allow heated fuel salt to expand in the expansion chamber 349 volume during operation. The expansion chamber may also allow the free surface level of the fuel salt to rise and fall with thermal expansion of the fuel salt.

[0072] As will be appreciated by one of skill in the art, as the fuel salt flows along the fuel salt path, delayed neutrons may be born that have an impact on the overall reactivity of the reactor. A delayed neutron is a neutron emitted by an excited fission product nucleus during disintegration after the fission that created the product nucleus. Typically, neutrons generated later than 10-14seconds after the fission are considered delayed neutrons.

[0073] To date, no molten salt reactors have been operated for commercial electricity production and only recently has there been commercial interest in these systems. Therefore, methods to analyze molten salt specific phenomena are less developed than other more established types of nuclear reactors. Thus, delayed neutrons have not been a thoroughly understood phenomena in a molten salt reactor. For instance, in power generating designs, at any given time there is typically a significant amount of fuel salt outside of the reactor core traveling through the fuel salt cooling circuit through the heat exchangers. If the residence time of the delayed neutron precursors is long compared to the halfdife of the precursor then we can assume the delayed neutrons are emitted mostly in the core. In these designs, delayed neutrons have little effect on the reactivity of the reactor because most of the delayed neutrons are emitted before the fuel salt has completed a circuit through the heat exchangers and returned to the reactor core. However, economic incentives drive one to create a small22-009-UT1-WO-INNactive core with large heat exchangers and this phenomena becomes more important for high power density commercial reactors. Typically, molten salt reactors that circulate fuel salt through shell -and-tube heat exchangers require so much salt to be outside the reactor core for heat transport purposes that the effect of delayed neutrons cannot be ignored.

[0074] However, in some reactor designs, delayed neutrons could significantly affect the reactivity of the reactor and affect the kinetics of transient analysis and it is therefore essential to account for the delayed neutrons.

[0075] The delayed neutron importance factors may be used to quantify the contribution of delayed neutrons to the overall neutron population and the subsequent reactivity changes in the reactor. These factors are particularly important in reactors that rely on feedback mechanisms for power regulation and stability. For the following description, the following definitions will be helpful.

[0076] Delayed Neutron Fraction (β): The delayed neutron fraction, denoted as β, represents the ratio of delayed neutrons to total neutrons emitted per fission event. It quantifies the percentage of neutrons that are delayed. Generally, β is around 0.6-0.7% for typical nuclear fuel compositions, which is mostly U235 in most commercial reactors. The delayed neutron fraction is important because it introduces a time delay in the response of the reactor to changes in reactivity.

[0077] Effective Delayed Neutron Fraction (β_eff): The effective delayed neutron fraction takes into account the behavior of delayed neutrons in the reactor core, considering the delayed neutron precursor drift and the lower energy emission distribution of delayed neutrons relative to prompt neutrons. It represents the delayed precursor inventory multiplied by the precursor time constant. βeffcan be an important parameter in determining the stability and controllability of a nuclear reactor.

[0078] Delayed Neutron Precursors: Delayed neutrons are produced by the radioactive decay of specific fission products called delayed neutron precursors. These precursors have varying decay constants, which determine the time delay before the delayed neutrons are emitted. The concentrations of these precursors in the reactor core depend on the fuel composition and burnup.

[0079] Delayed Neutron Fraction Groups: The delayed neutron precursors may be grouped into several categories based on their decay constants. In some cases, delayed22-009-UT1-WO-INNneutron precursors may additionally or alternatively be grouped for each fissionable isotope. Each group may be associated with a specific fraction of delayed neutrons and contributes differently to the overall neutron population and reactivity.

[0080] Reactivity Effects: Delayed neutrons may provide an important impact on the reactivity of the reactor. Since they have a longer delay time compared to prompt neutrons, changes in the reactor conditions, such as changes to k-eff or fuel temperature, take longer to affect the delayed neutron population. This delayed response allows for effective feedback and control of the reactor power and stability.

[0081] Delayed Neutron Importance Factor: The delayed neutron importance factors are precomputed adjoint weighted values such that the sum of the importance factor weighted delayed neutron emission rates in each control volume and the total neutron emission rate over the whole system yield the effective delayed neutron fraction. The ratio of the importance of a delayed neutron of a specific fissionable nuclide, of a specific delayed group in a specific control volume to the importance of an average neutron in the application.

[0082] According to some embodiments, a new method is proposed for characterizing the movement of the delayed neutron precursors in order to understand their effect on the neutron kinetics. In particular, the effective delayed neutron fraction (β_eff) may be calculated in a different way than is currently available for static fueled systems. For instance, in a molten salt system, βeffmay vary over time due to variations in flow rate and thereby insert, or remove, reactivity from the system at different time instances. For clarity, the term βeffis used to indicate the delayed neutron fraction being calculated considering the drift of the delayed neutron precursors and the difference in energy emissions spectra. In most prior cases at addressing this phenomena, a steady state fuel flow was assumed. However, where the flow is unsteady, the βeffwill be unsteady and cause reactivity oscillations on the system. The described methods account of the unsteadiness and reactivity oscillations to allow an effective way of determining βefffor unstable flowing fuel systems with complex geometries.

[0083] In some cases, βeffis estimated to within an acceptable margin by calculating βeffas a function of mass flow rate of the fuel salt in combination with an evaluation of reactor kinetics parameters.22-009-UT1-WO-INN

[0084] Historically, deterministic models have been used to determine delayed neutron importance factors, such as by using the adjoint flux calculated from deterministic models of reactor systems. However, as discussed in further detail above, deterministic models of many reactor systems are not ideal because the complex geometry of many reactors does not lend itself to deterministic model calculations because many complex geometries do not align with regular hex, cartesian, or RZTheta meshes which results in homogenization distortions.

[0085] In some cases, a method involves combining energy discretized ksens tallies (k-eff sensitivity tallies from adjoint weighting) in unique ways and may be used to calculate the delayed neutron importance factors. Because the geometry description in some neutronics analysis packages (e.g., Monte Carlo Neutronics analysis) is flexible with regard to reactor geometry, the described methods allow evaluation of complex designs without regard to symmetry of the reactor system. In some cases, energy discretized ksens tallies are computed for asymmetric reactor geometries, including asymmetric irradiation guide tubes and / or asymmetric salt loop configurations.

[0086] FIG. 4 illustrates the distribution of delayed neutron importance factors that can be combined with the distribution of delayed neutron precursors to yield the effective delayed neutron fraction. The diagram shows several discretized locations throughout one fluid loop of the reactor, indicated such as by reference numerals 402, 404, 406, 408, 410, and 412. These discretized locations correspond with control volumes through which flowing fuel flows into and out of. As the fuel flows through these locations, delayed neutrons are born in some, or all, of the discretized control volumes. While the illustrated example shows control volumes defined in series, it should be appreciated that the control volumes and delayed neutron importance factor can be discretized in any suitable way. As can be seen from the diagram, the delayed neutrons born within the core, such as 402, 404, 406, are given the highest weight at 1.485. That is because delayed neutrons bom within the core have a stronger participation in the fission chain reaction happening within the core. As the fuel salt continues to flow upwards through the core, and then outwardly away from the core, such as at a perimeter control volume 408, the delayed importance reduces. The importance factor is the relative importance of a single neutron at a location relative to the average neutron in the system. Delayed neutrons are typically worth more than the average neutron because they’re emitted with a lower energy. A lower energy neutron contributes more to the fission chain22-009-UT1-WO-INNreaction than does a neutron having a higher energy. Therefore, a delayed neutron may have an average importance of 1.1 relative to the average neutron. As you would expect, the delayed neutrons are more important in the center of the core and less important at the periphery of the system. Moreover, the size of the bubbles shown in FIG 4 can be representative of the volume of fuel salt in each control volume. For example, a first bubble size 410 is smaller than a second bubble size 412 indicating that the volume of fuel salt is greater in the second control volume than in the first control volume. Accordingly, the graph presents the kinetics parameters, delayed neutron importance factors, and fission rates in various control volumes of the reactor that can be utilized in a flowing fuel reactor system’s thermal hydraulics code.

[0087] The effective delayed neutron fraction analysis implementation can be utilized for off-normal mass flow rates in reactor systems to functionalize βeffat equilibrium as a function of mass flow rate.

[0088] FIG. 5 is a graph 500 showing the effective delayed neutron fraction βeffas a function of mass flow rate, in accordance with some embodiments. In particular, the graph 500 illustrates that the equilibrium βeffis at least partially dependent on the mass flow rate of the flowing fuel.

[0089] By utilizing the distribution of delayed importance factors in combination with the distribution of delayed neutron precursors, a much more accurate determination of βeffcan be provided, which aids in understanding the thermal hydraulics and reactivity of the reactor system, even in reactor systems that are complex, such as asymmetrical geometries.

[0090] Drift of delayed neutron precursors with the fluid fuel is a phenomenon associated with flowing fuel reactors, such as, without limitation, a molten salt reactor or an aqueous homogeneous reactor.

[0091] Similar to static fueled reactors, fission occurs in a flowing fueled system, which results in the production of heat and fission products; however, the drift of delayed neutron precursors typically reduces the effectiveness of the delayed neutron source in the neutron multiplication. Some of these fission products are referred to as delayed neutron precursors as they decay by emitting neutrons but with a delay, typically between seconds and minutes compared to prompt neutron production. However, a difference in the flowing fuel system is that some of these delayed neutrons precursors experience drift, which results from the22-009-UT1-WO-INNadvection of fission daughter product nuclides with the flow rate of the fuel from the fission sites they were produced at and emit delayed neutrons elsewhere in the system. Various regions of the fluid fuel circuit have different importance with respect to the nuclear chain reaction. Importance (also known as the adjoint flux) is proportional to the change in reactivity per neutron absorbed at a position per second or conversely, proportional to the change in reactivity per neutron emission at a position per second. The drift of delayed neutron precursors moves delayed neutrons from high importance regions (e.g., the active core) to low importance regions (e.g., outside the active core) and then eventually back to the high importance region as the flowing salt returns to the active core. The combination of both the fuel movement and the fact that the decay will likely occur in a region of lower importance typically reduces the integral effective delayed neutron fraction on the neutron kinetics.

[0092] FIGS. 6A, 6B, and 6C illustrate importance and delayed neutron emission distributions in a sample reactor. More specifically, FIG. 6A illustrates the delayed neutron importance distribution, FIG. 6B illustrates the delayed neutron emission distribution in a static fuel, and FIG 6C illustrates flowing fuel delayed neutron emission distribution.

[0093] The effects of delayed neutron precursor drift are shown visually in FIGS 6A-6C. If we account for the drift of the delayed neutron precursors, the emission distribution shifts from a distribution that aligns well with the importance distribution (e.g., FIG. 6B), to one in which the delayed neutrons are emitted more uniformly around the fuel circuit (e g., FIG. 6C). This relative shift results in a misalignment with the importance distribution, thereby reducing the effectiveness of the delayed neutrons with respect to the nuclear chain reaction.

[0094] In many molten salt reactors (MSRs) it is assumed that if a precursor decays outside the active core, the delayed neutron does not affect the critical chain reaction.However, this assumption is only reasonable where the fuel loop is largely decoupled from the active core. In some cases, the delayed precursor drift can be approximated by accounting for precursor decay outside the core, τl, as opposed to resident time in the core τc. The standard point kinetics equations can be modified to include decay outside the core and can further be extended to include multiple fissionable nuclides and refactored as functions of reactivity rather than k.22-009-UT1-WO-INN

[0095]

[0096] In the above equations, the following variables are used:

[0097] n is the time dependent neutron population;

[0098] is the prompt-neutron lifetime, (seconds);

[0099] k is the reactor multiplication factor;

[0100] p0, is the reactivity to balance the delayed neutron precursor drift;

[0101] βT, is the total delayed neutron fraction;

[0102] Λ, is the mean neutron generation lifetime;

[0103] is the decay constant for the ithdelayed neutron precursor group;

[0104] Ci is the ithdelayed neutron precursor population;

[0105] (3i' is the total delayed neutron fraction for the ithdelayed neutron precursor group;

[0106] TCis the transit time in the active core; and

[0107] iLis the transit time outside of the core.

[0108] In some cases, a reactor system may include components adjacent to the active core with ambiguous degrees of importance to the system and may include fuel outside the active core with a non-negligible impact on the critical chain reaction. Moreover, parallel flow paths in regions of non-zero importance that necessitate a method of evaluating the impact of the flow of the ex-core and non-zero importance delayed neutron precursors and account for the hold up of any delayed neutron precursors in bypass flows.

[0109] In some cases, the reactivity effects of the motion of delayed neutron precursors can be calculated by adjoint weighting the delayed neutron emission distribution. The differences in the delayed neutron emission (which is proportional to Petr) term of the point kinetics equation is equivalent to changes in reactivity because they perturb the rate of change of the neutron population similarly. The traditional approach for calculating βeff in a22-009-UT1-WO-INNstatic fuel system relies on adjoint weighting the emission of delayed neutrons. This also assumes that the delayed neutrons are emitted with the same spatial distribution as the fission distribution, which is inaccurate in flowing fuel systems. In some cases, it is assumed that the adjoint and real fluxes do not change with time or due to the flow of delayed neutron precursors and neither do the fission cross sections. In principle, βeff can be dependent on time as changes in the fission cross section may be apparent due to fuel burn up, for instance. On the time scale of most transient events of interest, the change in fission cross section will be negligible and perturbations to the spatial flux shape are likely small. The below equation, Equation 3, shows a static fueled system in which the numerator is the adjoint weighted emission of delayed neutrons at equilibrium, that is, the decay of precursors is in equilibrium with the production of precursors at every location in the system.Equation 4

[0110] In equations 3 and 4 above, the following variables are used:

[0111] β(f,i) is the delayed neutron fraction for a given fissionable nuclide for the given delayed group;

[0112] the energy emission distribution of delayed neutron for a given fissionable nuclide for the given delayed group;

[0113] φ0†is the adjoint neutron flux;

[0114] νfis the number of neutrons emitted per fission for a given fissionable nuclide;

[0115] Σffisis the macroscopic fission cross section for a given fissionable nuclide;

[0116] φ is the forward neutron flux;

[0117] E is the neutron energy;

[0118] r⃗ is the position in the active core;22-009-UT1-WO-INN

[0119] x is the energy emission distribution of prompt fission neutrons for a given fissionable nuclide; and

[0120] peff is the total effective delayed neutron fraction.

[0121] In some embodiments, βeff can be calculated for a system with flowing delayed neutron precursors by extending this methodology by replacing the static delayed neutron emission term with a delayed neutron emission distribution accounting for the drift of the delayed neutrons. This approach involves determining the distribution of delayed neutron precursors, calculating the delayed neutron emission distribution based on the precursor distribution and then replacing the static delayed neutron emission distribution assumption in Equation 3 with a flowing delayed neutron emission distribution.

[0122] For instance, the distribution of precursors can be determined by discretizing the fueled region of a flowing fueled reactor and tracking the inventory of precursors in each control volume. Equation 5 below presents the conservation of precursors in a given control volume:Equation 5

[0123] In Equation 5 above, the following variables are used:

[0124] Cf,iis the total inventory of the precursors of the fissionable nuclide f for the given delayed group i in the control volume of interest;

[0125] νf,idis the number of delayed neutrons for the fissionable nuclide f for the given delayed group i emitted per fission;

[0126] Ff is the fission rate of the fissionable nuclide / ;

[0127] λf,iis the decay constant for the delay neutron precursor of the fissionable nuclide f for the given delayed group i;

[0128] u⃗ is the velocity of the delayed neutrons precursors; and

[0129] ∮ū(t,r⃗′)C_f,i(t,r⃗′) / V dA, is the net current of delayed neutron precursors into and outof the control volume of interest.22-009-UT1-WO-INN

[0130] In Equation 5, the first term on the right-hand side is the generation of precursors from fission. The second term on the right-hand side is the radioactive decay of the precursors. The third term is the current of precursors coming into the control volume from other control volumes and the precursors leaving the control volume of interest.

[0131] In relatively simple systems, each control volume has a single upstream control volume and a single downstream control volume. In this simple linear flow example in which each control volume has a single inlet and a single outlet, the equation may be reduced such that the first term characterizes the flow of delayed neutron precursors from an upstream control volume to the control volume of interest and the second term reduces to the flow of delayed neutron precursors from the control volume of interest away to the downstream control volume.

[0132] In those cases where there are flow bypasses, the more complicated flow analysis can account for multiple upstream control volumes that feed into the control volume of interest. The differential equations for each control volume in the system may be integrated into a single matrix and solved simultaneously. An initial distribution of precursors can be assumed (e.g., the delayed neutron precursor distribution if the fuel was static) and the precursors’ inventories can be tracked until they equilibrate. In some cases, the ratio of the rate of change of all the delayed neutron precursors in each control volume normalized to the inventory of delayed neutrons in the system may be used as the convergence criterion for the distribution of delayed neutron precursors.

[0133] Once the inventories of precursors are equilibrated in each control volume, the emission distribution can be determined by multiplying the precursor inventory in each control volume by the appropriate precursor time constant. The delayed neutron energy distribution for each precursor remains the same as for static fuel cases.

[0134] Given the above, in each control volume, the delayed neutron emission source can be calculated as follows:22-009-UT1-WO-INN

[0135] Where Sjdelayedis the delayed neutron source emitted in the control volume of interest;

[0136] Zf is the energy distribution of neutrons emitted from the precursor of fissionable nuclide f for delayed group i;

[0137] λf,iis the decay constant for the precursor of fissionable nuclide f for delayed group i; and

[0138] Cjf,iis the total inventory of the precursor of fissionable nuclide f for delayed group i in the control volume of interest, j.

[0139] The βeff equation (Equation 3) may be extended by substituting the flowing delayed neutron emission distribution for the static delayed neutron emission distribution as shown below:Equation 7

[0140] This approach of adjoint weighting of delayed neutron emissions for calculating βeffmay be implemented using a point kinetics module plugin in a reactor design and simulation software package, such as the ARMI® software product produced by TerraPower, LLC. This software package may additionally leverage further capabilities to calculate fission rates, process nuclear data, organize forward and adjoint flux.

[0141] In some cases, a software solution may utilize control volume objects which may include data regarding the control volume network, its volume, its mass, its temperature (such as for density / mass calculations), the mass flow rates to and from other control volumes, its fission rates, the expected yield of precursors for each fissionable nuclide, the energy per fission, the expected prompt neutrons per fission, the inventory of precursors, and the delayed and prompt neutron importance factors. The delayed neutron importance factor is a precomputed adjoint weighted value such that the sum of the importance factor weighted delayed neutrons equals the steady state ratio of the neutron population and the neutron lifetime multiplied by βeff (e.g. the sum of the adjoint weighted delayed neutrons normalized by and the sum of adjoint weighted prompt neutrons and delayed neutrons). The delayed22-009-UT1-WO-INNneutron importance factor may be defined this way so as to integrate easily into the delayed neutron source term of the point kinetics equation.

[0142] Rearranging the equation can yield the definition of the delayed neutron importance factor, which is defined as the relative importance of a delayed neutron from a specific delayed neutron precursor in a specific control volume compared to the average neutron in the system. In this way, the summation of the product of this delayed neutron importance factor and the delayed neutrons emitting in each control volume will yield the importance weighted delayed neutron emission.

[0143] In some cases, the adjoint flux can be calculated from a deterministic global flux solver. Alternatively, these adjoint flux weighted integrals can be calculated using sensitivity tallies (i.e., ksens tallies) in other solvers, such as for example, MCNP6.2. MCNP6.2 relates to the Monte Carlo N-Particle ® Transport Code System Version 6.2, owned and managed by Los Alamos National Security, LLC. Of course, it should be appreciated that other versions of MCNP, or other Monte Carlo codes, can be utilized with the methods described herein by implementing similar sensitivity tally functionality, or other continuous energy Mote Carlo codes or other solvers entirely. In some cases, sensitivity coefficients can be calculated with MCNP6.2 using ksens tallies as described herein.

[0144] A sensitivity tally in a control volume, in an energy bin, for the delayed energy emission of a fissionable nuclide produces a ratio of integrals that is useful for calculating the importance factor for a delayed neutron precursor of the fissionable nuclide in the cell. For this sensitivity tally, the delta function for scattering may be zero, the delta function for prompt fission may be zero, and the delta function for delayed fission may be set to 1. Thus, the perturbation operator reduces to just the inverse k-eff multiplied by the fission operator for the fissionable nuclide.

[0145] The delayed neutron importance factor is the ratio of the adjoint weighted delayed neutrons and the adjoint weighted total fission neutrons, as shown in Equation 8.22-009-UT1-WO-INNHere,i is the neutron fluxip* is the adjoint neutron fluxDjf,iis the delayed neutron operator -- Vj∬ dEdΩνd,f,i(E)Σffission(E)F is the fission neutron operator -- Vj∬ dEdΩνf(E)Σffission(E)Vj is the volume of the control volume, jνf(E) is the total number of neutrons produced per fission of fissionable nuclide, fνd,f,i(E) is the number of delayed neutrons per fission in delayed group, i, of fissionable nuclide, fΣffission(E) is the macroscopic fission cross section of fissionable nuclide, f

[0146] It can be shown that the ratio defined in Equation 8 can be calculated with sensitivity tallies, which are equivalent to adjoint weighted reaction rate tallies. The numerator calculates a delayed group specific sensitivity vector by multiplying the integral delayed emission sensitivity by the ratio of delayed neutrons in a specific delayed group and the total delayed neutrons produced for a fissionable nuclide. The denominator calculates the adjoint weighted fission neutron source divided by the fission neutron source rate also using sensitivity vectors. The delayed neutron importance factor can be calculated using sensitivity vectors according to Equation 9.Equation 9Here,is the delayed neutron operator for a specific neutron energy group, g —^k’x’dk-eff sensitivity vector to the delayed neutron emission spectrum ( / d) for a specific fissionable nuclide, f, in control volume, j.22-009-UT1-WO-INNis the k-eff sensitivity vector to the total neutron emission spectrum ( / y) for a specific fissionable nuclide, f, in control volume, j.

[0147] In some cases, a reactor model may rely on a core that is subdivided into several control volumes that account for the geometry of the core, including asymmetric and irregular geometries, thus any core geometry can be discretized into control volumes.

[0148] The result in an effective delayed neutron methodology that produces results consistent with expectations and reduces to the static effective delayed neutron methodology when the static fuel distribution of delayed neutron precursors is assumed.

[0149] The delayed neutron importance factors can be produced with either Monte Carlo methods or deterministic methods and produce similar results from completely different methodologies. Given the complex geometry of some reactor designs, the Monte Carlo generated delayed neutron importance factors, as described herein, will provide a higher level of certainty and accuracy than prior deterministic models. In addition, the methods described herein may be employed in a thermal hydraulics transient code to more rigorously determine the distributions of delayed neutron precursors and determine these effective delayed neutron fractions.

[0150] In some embodiments, a computing device having one or more processors may be programmed with instructions to carry out the methods described herein. In some cases, a list of operating parameters, such as reactor height, diameter of core, and other physical constraints may be input into a computing system and the output may be an input deck for an MCNP analysis and a soft copy of the MCNP input. In some cases, the soft copy of the MCNP input contains all the meta data that defines the components that create an MCNP model and all the meta data can facilitate reading, writing, and processing the inputs / outputs. In some applications, an input to MCNP in order to calculate sensitivity coefficients produces a local importance factor.

[0151] For example, the input may be physical characteristics of a nuclear reactor, which may be fed from one or more computer-aided design models and the MCNP may convert that physical geometry input to a neutronics model that looks similar to the computer aided design (CAD) model. Where an MCNP model has unstructured mesh capability, it may be configured to automatically perform neutron transport on unstructured mesh based on a CAD22-009-UT1-WO-INNfile. In some cases, a reactor model CAD file can be fed into a properly configured MCNP code, and the output may be a neutron transport analysis for the reactor model.

[0152] FIG. 7 is an example process flow that illustrates a method for determining transient thermal hydraulics of a flowing fuel nuclear reactor, in accordance with some embodiments. The process flow assumes that a reactor geometry has been provided, which may be a complex geometry that includes shapes, asymmetries, and the like that do not lend themselves well to traditional deterministic modeling because the shapes and asymmetries do not align with hex, cartesian, or RZTheta coordinate systems. At block 702, a reactor geometry is discretized into multiple control volumes. In some cases, this is performed by understanding the flowing fuel volume and its flow paths. The multiple control volumes can be discretized based upon volume, a dwell time of mass flow through a particular part of the reactor, a decay coefficient of the delayed neutron precursors, or some other factor or a combination of factors.

[0153] At block 704, the distribution of delayed neutrons is determined. This may be performed through any suitable method, which may include neutronics code solvers.

[0154] At block 706, the energy level of delayed neutrons at each control volume is determined. The delayed neutrons have a lower energy than prompt neutrons, which allows them to have a higher importance, on average, than prompt neutrons. Depending on the location of the delayed neutron emissions, their energies may have different importance to the overall reactivity of the nuclear reactor system.

[0155] At block 708, the discretized ksens tallies are determined. In some cases, the discretized ksens tallies are summed as a reflection of the sensitivity of the reaction to the delayed neutron emission at each of the control volumes. The ksens tallies may be determined by a suitable code base, such as a suitable Monte Carlo solver.

[0156] At block 710, the ratio of delayed neutron importance factors are determined, which are based on the ksens tallies. In other words, by using the ksens tallies, the ratio of delayed neutron importance factors can be directly determined. While this could be done by a deterministic model for reactors having simple geometry, the deterministic model is wholly inadequate for complex geometries.

[0157] At block 712, the ratio of delayed neutron importance factors can be used to conduct a transient thermal hydraulic analysis of the flowing fuel reactor.22-009-UT1-WO-INN

[0158] FIG. 8 is a process flow diagram that illustrates a method for determining, based on ksens tallies, the effective delayed neutron fraction, in accordance with some embodiments. At block 802, a reactor geometry is selected, and the reactor geometry is discretized into multiple control volumes. In other words, the reactor volume is split up into individual volumes for separate analysis.

[0159] At block 804, the distribution of delayed neutron precursors in each control volume is determined. This may be performed, for example, through any suitable solver that can track and determine an identification and location of delayed neutron precursors based on a mass flow through the reactor.

[0160] At block 806, the delayed neutron emission distribution is determined for each control volume. This likewise may be determined based on mass flow of flowing fuel through the reactor and a timewise dependency of the delayed neutron emissions.

[0161] At block 808, the ksens tallies are determined for each control volume. The ksens tallies are a measure of the reactors k-eff sensitivity from adjoint weighting.

[0162] At block 810, the effective delayed neutron fraction is determined, based at least in part on the ksens tallies. Thus, by discretizing the reactor geometry, the ksens tallies can be determined and used to generate the effective delayed neutron fraction. Thus, a thermal hydraulic analysis of a flowing fuel reactor can be performed by tracking delayed neutron precursors through different control volumes and effectively weighting the delayed neutrons emitted in different control volumes. In some cases, the calculation of delayed neutron importance factors may be performed with Monte Carlo methods which extends classical approaches for assessing the importance of delayed neutrons to a flowing fuel system in a mathematically rigorous and repeatable manner.

[0163] FIG. 9 illustrates a process 900 for determining the effective delayed neutron fraction in a flowing fuel nuclear reactor. At block 902, a reactor geometry is discretized in a plurality of control volumes as discussed with reference to embodiments herein. At block 904, tallies for each volume are determined and added.

[0164] At block 906, this method includes adding tallies for ksen tallies for delayed neutron and total fission neutron in each control volume. At block 908, a Monte Carlo neutron analysis may be performed using any suitable code base, after the Monte Carlo neutron transport analysis is completed, the sensitivity vectors and reactions rates presented22-009-UT1-WO-INNin the output files are processed into a data structure such that the precomputed sensitivity vectors and reaction rates in specific control volumes can be easily retrieved. At block 910, the system may be configured to decompose delayed neutron ksen tally by delayed group for each fissionable isotope by first calculating an energy integrated average delayed neutron per fission (chi) from delayed neutron data. Then, taking the energy discretized integral delayed neutron sensitivity and weighting the integral delayed neutron sensitivity in each energy bin by the ratio of delayed neutrons in that delayed group emitted per each fission of the fissionable nuclide to the integral delayed neutrons in that energy group emitted per each fission of the fissionable neutrons as shown in the numerator of Equation 9.

[0165] At block 912, the system determines delayed neutron importance factor for each fissionable nuclide in each control volume by performing the integral defined in Equation 9 using precomputed sensitivity vectors and reaction rate tallies.

[0166] At block 914, the system determines delayed neutron precursor generation in each control volume using the precomputed energy discretized fission rates in each control volume. The system multiplies the delayed neutron per fission vector (delayed nubar) by energy dependent fission rate. The delayed nubar vector is application-independent nuclear data that tabulates delayed neutrons produced in each delayed group per fission in each fissionable nuclide as a function of incident neutron energy causing fission. The precomputed energy dependent fission rate is also tabulated as a function of incident neutron energy. When the system crosses these two vectors, the delayed neutron emission rate (decomposed by delayed group and fissionable nuclide) is produced when the system crosses these two vectors.

[0167] At block 916, the method may include configuring thermal hydraulics model with fission rate, delayed neutron precursor generation rate, delayed neutron precursor decay constant, and delayed neutron importance factors. At block 918, the method includes determining, through thermal hydraulic simulation, a distribution of delayed neutron precursors. This may be performed, for example, by tracking the delayed neutron precursors through the nuclear reactor system, modeling their radioactive decay, modeling their generation, and modeling their advection into and out of specific control volumes.

[0168] At block 920, the method includes the step of determine, through thermal hydraulic simulation, effective delayed neutron fraction. In some examples, where the22-009-UT1-WO-INNdelayed neutrons have an unacceptable effect on keff, the reactor design may be modified to vary the volume ratio of the active core to the entire fuel circuit. In some cases, the volume ratio of the active core to the fuel circuit may be increased which leaves a greater number of delayed neutrons being born nearer the core. In some cases, the volume ratio of the active core to the fuel circuit may be reduced, which tends to cause an increased number of delayed neutrons to be born outside of the core. Either of these changes can dramatically affect the neutronics of the reactor and increase the stability of the reactor. In some cases, an unacceptable stability affect can lead to multiplying the volume fraction by a static βeffto discover what design changes may need to be made. For instance, if βeffis too low, the volume fraction of the active core to the fuel circuit may be increased. In some embodiments, this type of analysis considers the exact neutron distribution throughout the reactor system, which enables an accounting of time delay in the active core.

[0169] FIG. 10 illustrates a method 1000 for determining the effective delayed neutron fraction in a modified point kinetics equation. At block 1002, the method includes discretizing a reactor into multiple control volumes. At block 1004, the method may include determining the generation rate of delayed neutron precursors in each control volume.

[0170] At block 1006, the method includes determining the distribution of delayed neutron precursors in each control volume. At block 1008, the method includes determining the emissions distribution of delayed neutrons in each control volume. At block 1010, the method includes summing the delayed neutron importance factor weighted delayed neutron emissions. At block 1012, the method includes the step of determining the effective delayed neutron fraction or effective delayed neutron component in modified point kinetics equation.

[0171] The systems and methods described herein allow for neutron transport analysis to be performed very quickly, efficiently, and in some cases, automatically, on complex reactor geometries. As used herein, a complex reactor geometry is one that does not align with rectangular hex, cartesian, or RZTheta meshes. The disclosed methods allow an explicit use of all the reactor geometry, such that the method is not limited or inhibited by the shape of the nuclear reactor and can be utilized with any shape nuclear reactor. Furthermore, by discretizing the nuclear reactor into control volumes, the ratio of the delayed neutron importance is evaluated by performing local adjoint flux integrals by performing ksens tallies over the cells in the neutronics model that correspond to control volumes in the thermal22-009-UT1-WO-INNhydraulics model. The result is a methodology to determine βeffas a function of mass flow rate of the flowing fuel. As with any of the embodiments described herein, βeffis an important factor in reactor design and operation. Therefore, if the βeffis not within a desired range, the variables of reactor design and operation may be changed, such as, without limitation, reactor geometry, volume of fuel flowing through the periphery of the reactor system, flow rates of the flowing fuel, addition or subtraction of neutron reflectors, neutron absorbers, neutron poisons, or other neutron adjustment devices. Of course, other variables or conditions may be altered based on a determine of βeffof the reactor system.

[0172] The disclosure sets forth example embodiments and, as such, is not intended to limit the scope of embodiments of the disclosure and the appended claims in any way.Embodiments have been described above with the aid of functional building blocks illustrating the implementation of specified functions and relationships thereof. The boundaries of these functional building blocks have been arbitrarily defined herein for the convenience of the description. Alternate boundaries can be defined to the extent that the specified functions and relationships thereof are appropriately performed.

[0173] In some implementations, the processor(s) may include a central processing unit (CPU), a graphical processing unit (GPU), both CPU and GPU, a microprocessor, a digital signal processor or other processing units or components known in the art. Alternatively, or in addition, the functionally described herein can be performed, at least in part, by one or more hardware logic components. For example, and without limitation, illustrative types of hardware logic components that may be used include field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs), application-specific integrated circuits (ASICs), application-specific standard products (ASSPs), system-on-a-chip systems (SOCs), complex programmable logic devices (CPLDs), etc. Additionally, each of the processor(s) may possess its own local memory, which alsomay store program modules, program data, and / or one ormore operating systems. The one or more control systems, computer controller and remote control, may include one or more cores.

[0174] Embodiments may be provided as a computer program product including a non-transitory machine-readable storage medium having stored thereon instructions (in compressed or uncompressed form) that may be used to program a computer (or other electronic device) to perform processes or methods described herein. The computer-readable22-009-UT1-WO-INNmedia may include volatile and / or nonvolatile memory, removable and non-removable media implemented in any method or technology for storage of information, such as computer-readable instructions, data structures, program modules, or other data. The machine-readable storage medium may include, but is not limited to, hard drives, floppy diskettes, optical disks, CD-ROMs, DVDs, read-only memories (ROMs), random access memories (RAMs), EPROMs, EEPROMs, flash memory, magnetic or optical cards, solid-state memory devices, or other types of media / machine-readable medium suitable for storing electronic instructions. Further, embodiments may also be provided as a computer program product including a transitory machine-readable signal (in compressed or uncompressed form). Examples of machine-readable signals, whether modulated using a carrier or not, include, but are not limited to, signals that a computer system or machine hosting or running a computer program can be configured to access, including signals downloaded through the Internet or other networks.

[0175] The systems and methods described herein may be performed on suitable computing architecture hardware, which may include one or more high-performance computers (HCP), a cluster of computers, cloud-based computing resources, or a combination. In some cases, a first computing device submits a job to another computing resource (e.g., HPC or cluster). In some embodiments, the first computing device submits an MCNP job to an HPC. The first computing device receives the output of the MCNP job and process the outputs into the delayed neutron importance factors, and distribution of delayed neutron sources, to build a simplified thermal hydraulics model that models delayed neutrons being advected through the control volumes and decay of the delayed neutron precursors. Once the delayed neutron precursor distribution has equilibrated, the computing resources can determine βeff.

[0176] The foregoing description of specific embodiments will so fully reveal the general nature of embodiments of the disclosure that others can, by applying knowledge of those of ordinary skill in the art, readily modify and / or adapt for various applications such specific embodiments, without undue experimentation, without departing from the general concept of embodiments of the disclosure. Therefore, such adaptation and modifications are intended to be within the meaning and range of equivalents of the disclosed embodiments, based on the teaching and guidance presented herein. The phraseology or terminology herein is for the22-009-UT1-WO-INNpurpose of description and not of limitation, such that the terminology or phraseology of the specification is to be interpreted by persons of ordinary skill in the relevant art in light of the teachings and guidance presented herein.

[0177] The breadth and scope of embodiments of the disclosure should not be limited by any of the above-described example embodiments, but should be defined only in accordance with the following claims and their equivalents.

[0178] It should be appreciated that the logical operations described herein with respect to FIGs 7-108 may be implemented (1) as a sequence of computer implemented acts or program modules running on a computing system and / or (2) as interconnected machine logic circuits or circuit modules within the computing system. The implementation is a matter of choice dependent on the performance and other requirements of the computing system. Accordingly, the logical operations described herein are referred to variously as operations, structural devices, acts, steps, or modules. These operations, structural devices, acts, and modules may be implemented in software, in firmware, in special purpose digital logic, and any combination thereof. It should also be appreciated that more or fewer operations may be performed than shown in the figures and described herein. These operations may also be performed in parallel, or in a different order than those described herein.

[0179] Conditional language, such as, among others, “can,” “could,” “might,” or “may,” unless specifically stated otherwise, or otherwise understood within the context as used, is generally intended to convey that certain implementations could include, while other implementations do not include, certain features, elements, and / or operations. Thus, such conditional language generally is not intended to imply that features, elements, and / or operations are in any way required for one or more implementations or that one or more implementations necessarily include logic for deciding, with or without user input or prompting, whether these features, elements, and / or operations are included or are to be performed in any particular implementation.

[0180] Unless otherwise noted, the terms “connected to” and “coupled to” (and their derivatives), as used in the specification, are to be construed as permitting both direct and indirect (i.e., via other elements or components) connection. In addition, the terms “a” or “an,” as used in the specification, are to be construed as meaning “at least one of.” Finally, for ease of use, the terms “including” and “having” (and their derivatives), as used in the22-009-UT1-WO-INN

[0181] The specification and annexed drawings disclose examples of systems, apparatus, devices, and techniques that may provide methods for determining delayed neutron importance factors in a flowing fuel nuclear reactor. It is, of course, not possible to describe every conceivable combination of elements and / or methods for purposes of describing the various features of the disclosure, but those of ordinary skill in the art recognize that many further combinations and permutations of the disclosed features are possible. Accordingly, various modifications may be made to the disclosure without departing from the scope or spirit thereof. Further, other embodiments of the disclosure may be apparent from consideration of the specification and annexed drawings, and practice of disclosed embodiments as presented herein. Examples put forward in the specification and annexed drawings should be considered, in all respects, as illustrative and not restrictive. Although specific terms are employed herein, they are used in a generic and descriptive sense only, and not used for purposes of limitation.

[0182] From the foregoing, it will be appreciated that, although specific implementations have been described herein for purposes of illustration, various modifications may be made without deviating from the spirit and scope of the appended claims and the elements recited therein. In addition, while certain aspects are presented below in certain claim forms, the inventors contemplate the various aspects in any available claim form. For example, while only some aspects may currently be recited as being embodied in a particular configuration, other aspects may likewise be so embodied. Various modifications and changes may be made as would be obvious to a person skilled in the art having the benefit of this disclosure. It is intended to embrace all such modifications and changes and, accordingly, the above description is to be regarded in an illustrative rather than a restrictive sense.

Claims

22-009-UT1-WO-INNCLAIMSWHAT IS CLAIMED IS:

1. A method for determining an effective delayed neutron fraction in a flowing fuel nuclear reactor having a complex geometry, the method comprising:defining a complex geometry of the nuclear reactor, the complex geometry including asymmetries in a fuel flow path;discretizing the complex geometry into a plurality of control volumes; determining a delayed neutron importance factor for each of the plurality of control volumes;determining a distribution of delayed neutron precursors in each of the plurality of control volumes;determining a delayed neutron emission distribution in each of the plurality of control volumes;determining reactivity sensitivity (ksens) tallies; anddetermining, based at least in part on the ksens tallies, the effective delayed neutron fraction.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein defining a complex geometry includes defining a geometry that does not align with regular hex, cartesian, or RZTheta meshes.

3. The method of claim 1, wherein discretizing the complex geometry further comprises discretizing the complex geometry to describe the fuel flow path through the flowing fuel nuclear reactor.

4. The method of claim 1, wherein determining the distribution of delayed neutron precursors in each of the plurality of control volumes comprises executing a thermal hydraulics code.

5. The method of claim 1, wherein determining the delayed neutron emission distribution in each of the plurality of control volumes comprises weighting delayed neutron emissions based upon a respective control volume in which the delayed neutrons are emitted.22-009-UT1-WO-INN6. The method of claim 1, wherein determining ksens tallies comprises combining energy discretized ksens tallies.

7. The method of claim 1, wherein the ksens tallies are determined, at least in part, based on adjust flux weighing.

8. The method of claim 1, wherein determining the effective delayed neutron fraction comprises determining the ksens tallies in a Monte Carlo neutronics analysis code.

9. The method of claim 1, wherein the method is performed by one or more processors configured with instructions to carry out the method.

10. The method of claim 1, further comprising performing a thermal hydraulics analysis, based at least in part on the effective delayed neutron fraction, for the flowing fuel nuclear reactor.

11. The method of claim 1, wherein determining the distribution of delayed neutron precursors in each of the plurality of control volumes is performed by tracking and determining an identification and location of delayed neutron precursors based on a mass flow through the complex geometry.

12. A method for determining an effective delayed neutron fraction in a flowing fuel nuclear reactor, comprising the steps of:providing a complex geometry description of the flowing fuel nuclear reactor, the complex geometry including asymmetries in a fuel flow path o the flowing fuel nuclear reactor;discretizing the complex geometry into a plurality of control volumes; summing tallies for ksen tallies for delayed neutron and total fission neutron in each control volume;decomposing the delayed neutron ksen tally by delayed group for each fissionable isotope;determining a delayed neutron importance factor for each fissionable nuclide in each control volume;determining delayed neutron precursor generation in each control volume;22-009-UT1-WO-INNdetermining a distribution of delayed neutron precursors; and determining an effective delayed neutron fraction.

13. The method of claim 12, wherein determining delayed neutron precursor generation in each control volume further comprises multiplying the delayed neutron per fission vector by energy dependent fission rate.

14. The method of claim 12, wherein determining distribution of delayed neutron precursor further comprises tracking the delayed neutron precursors through the complex geometry, modeling a radioactive decay of the delayed neutron precursors, modeling a generation of the delayed neutron precursors, and modeling an advection of the delayed neutron precursors into and out of the plurality of control volumes.

15. The method of claim 12, wherein decomposing the delayed neutron ksen tally further comprises determining an energy integrated average delayed neutron per fission from delayed neutrons.

16. The method of claim 15, further comprising weighting an integral delayed neutron sensitivity in an energy bin by a ratio of delayed neutrons in that delayed group emitted per each fission of the fissionable nuclide to the integral of delayed neutrons in the energy bin emitted per each fission of the fissionable neutrons.

17. A method for determining an effective delayed neutron fraction in a flowing fuel nuclear reactor, comprising the steps of:providing a complex geometry description of the flowing fuel nuclear reactor, the complex geometry including asymmetries in a fuel flow path of the flowing fuel nuclear reactor;discretizing the flowing fuel nuclear reactor into a plurality of control volumes;determining a generation rate of total neutrons and delayed neutron precursors in each of the plurality of control volumes;determining a distribution of delayed neutron precursors in each of the plurality of control volumes;22-009-UT1-WO-INNdetermining an emission distribution of delayed neutrons in each of the plurality of control volumes;determining a delayed neutron importance factor in each of the plurality of control volumes; anddetermining, based at least in part on the delayed neutron importance factor, an effective delayed neutron fraction.

18. The method of claim 17, wherein determining the delayed neutron importance factor in each of the plurality of control volumes is performed with Monte Carlo methods.