Unmanned ship output limitation and quantification cooperative control method

Through historical data estimation of dynamic parameters and quantitative communication protocols, a limited output control algorithm is designed, which solves the problems of limited output of kinematic guidance layer and large communication data during the navigation of unmanned boat fleets, and realizes the safe navigation of unmanned boats and efficient communication.

CN118915725APending Publication Date: 2024-11-08NORTHEASTERN UNIV CHINA +1
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410947750.3
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-16
Publication Date
2024-11-08

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing unmanned boat fleet navigation technology has failed to fully consider the problem of limited output of the kinematic guidance layer. The dynamic parameter estimates are time-consuming and labor-intensive and the communication data volume is large, resulting in low navigation safety and communication efficiency.

Method used

Estimate dynamic parameters through historical data, design output limited control algorithms, use quantitative communication protocols to reduce data transfer, use inverse step control and least squares method to fit control inputs, design dynamics and kinematic control laws, and realize unmanned boats safe navigation and coordinated control.

Benefits of technology

Unmanned boats can strictly navigate in safe areas, reducing communication burden, improving navigation safety and communication efficiency, and reducing dependence on system models.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118915725A_ABST
    Figure CN118915725A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention relates to an unmanned ship output limitation and quantification cooperative control method, which comprises the following steps: establishing a single unmanned ship model, and determining a target expected path of an unmanned ship; output limited control parameters are determined according to the safe navigation area boundary and the expected path of the unmanned ship: according to a backstepping control design method, a kinematics expected control law is designed by utilizing a potential barrier Lyapunov function and serves as control input of the system, and the motion trail of the single unmanned ship is controlled; designing an observer to observe unknown total interference of the unmanned ship; fitting observation results stored in the unmanned ship by adopting a least square method to obtain observation results for controlling input gains; substituting the observation result of the unknown total interference and the observation result of the control input gain into a dynamic model of the unmanned ship for dynamic control of the unmanned ship; designing a dynamic control law; and a quantitative cooperative control law is designed, and cooperative control of the unmanned ship formation is completed.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of unmanned boat control, and in particular to an unmanned boat output limited and quantized coordinated control method. Background Art

[0002] With the increasing development of marine resources, marine surface vehicles (MSVs) play an important role in the process of developing marine resources. The navigation safety constraints of marine surface vehicles (MSVs) and the communication protocols with quantitative effects are of great significance for the navigation of unmanned boat formations. Most of the existing unmanned boat formation navigation technologies with constraint problems focus on the control input end of the system kinematics and dynamics, and indirectly ensure the navigation safety of unmanned boats by designing controllers with constraints. For the model parameters of the unmanned boat itself, most of the existing technical solutions are experimental measurements, and the final model parameters are obtained by conducting a large number of experiments. Due to the wide range of marine surveys, multi-unmanned boat collaborative surveys have become a popular method in recent years. With the increase in the number of unmanned boats, the amount of data communication between unmanned boats has also increased. In order to avoid the problem of channel congestion during communication, the existing technologies mainly focus on the encoding of communication data, which is first encoded at the sending end and then decoded at the receiving end to reduce the communication burden.

[0003] In recent years, the research on marine unmanned boat formations has achieved very rich research results, but the following problems still exist: First, in the maneuvering formation structure, scholars have not yet considered the problem of limited output of the kinematic guidance layer. However, in practical applications, its impact must be fully considered. For example, in a narrow channel space, the unmanned boat must strictly navigate in a safe area, otherwise it may collide with the stone wall and cause damage to the unmanned boat. This requires full consideration of kinematic limitations and environmental conditions in the control strategy to ensure the safe navigation of the unmanned boat. Second, the existing multi-MSV includes the control of the maneuvering formation, which requires assumptions about its dynamic parameters or a large number of experimental verifications to determine. However, in the actual operation process, this experimental verification process is a very time-consuming and labor-intensive process. At the same time, the accuracy of the dynamic parameters obtained by the experiment is also difficult to accurately estimate. Although some scholars have considered using data-driven methods to estimate the dynamic model of the system, they mainly focus on the estimation of monomer dynamics and do not fully consider the safety constraints in the process of unmanned boat dynamics estimation. Third, with the increase in the number of unmanned boats, the amount of communication data between them will grow exponentially. Although some scholars have tried to use coding techniques to reduce the amount of communication data, these methods often require certain assumptions to be met, which limits their widespread application in practice. Summary of the invention

[0004] In order to solve the above technical problems, the purpose of the present invention is to provide an output-limited and quantified cooperative control method for an unmanned boat. The dynamic parameters are estimated by collecting historical data without a large number of experiments, and a communication protocol with quantization is used to reduce the communication burden.

[0005] The present invention provides an unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method, comprising:

[0006] Step 1: Determine the safe navigation area of ​​the unmanned boat, with the center of the safe navigation area as the coordinate origin or coordinate axis;

[0007] Step 2: Establish a single unmanned boat model and determine the expected path of the unmanned boat target;

[0008] Step 3: Determine the output limited control parameters according to the safe navigation area boundary and the expected path of the unmanned boat:

[0009] Step 4: According to the restriction requirements of the safe navigation area of ​​the unmanned boat, determine the initial position of the unmanned boat and set the coordinates, that is, ensure that the initial position of the unmanned boat is within the safe navigation area;

[0010] Step 5: According to the backstepping control design method, the kinematic expectation control law is designed using the potential barrier Lyapunov function and used as the control input of the system to realize the control of the motion trajectory of a single unmanned boat;

[0011] Step 6: Design an observer to observe the unknown total interference of the unmanned boat;

[0012] Step 7: Establish a data storage unit for the unmanned boat to save the observation results;

[0013] Step 8: Use the least squares method to fit the observation results stored in the unmanned boat to obtain the observation results of the control input gain;

[0014] Step 9: Substitute the observation results of the unknown total disturbance and the observation results of the control input gain into the dynamic model of the unmanned boat for the dynamic control of the unmanned boat;

[0015] Step 10: Design the dynamic control law;

[0016] Step 11: Quantify the path variables and define the quantized cooperative error, and design the quantized cooperative control law;

[0017] Step 12: According to the specific value of the quantized coordination error, the unmanned boat autonomously determines whether the current value is the same as the value after the last quantization. If they are the same, the unmanned boat does not transmit the coordination parameter information to its neighbors; if they are different, the unmanned boat transmits the coordination parameter information to its neighbors;

[0018] Step 13: The unmanned boat waits for data to be sent by its neighbor. If data is sent, the unmanned boat uses the received data for collaborative control; if no data is sent, the unmanned boat uses the last received data for collaborative control.

[0019] The output-limited and quantitative collaborative control method of an unmanned boat of the present invention has the following beneficial effects: the output-limited algorithm of the present invention can ensure that the underwater robot strictly navigates within the artificially set safety area without violating the output constraint. The data-driven algorithm can ensure that the underwater robot can simultaneously estimate the total interference and control input gain without the need for an accurate system model, without the need for prior knowledge of the system. The quantitative control algorithm can effectively reduce the overall amount of information transmitted between underwater robots by reducing the number of data transmissions between underwater robots. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0020] Figure 1 The present invention is a flow chart of an unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0021] The present invention provides an unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method, comprising:

[0022] Step 1: Determine the safe navigation area of ​​the unmanned boat, with the center of the safe navigation area as the coordinate origin or coordinate axis.

[0023] Step 2: Establish a single unmanned boat model and determine the desired path of the unmanned boat target, specifically:

[0024] Step 2.1: Establish kinematic model and dynamic model of a single unmanned boat:

[0025]

[0026] Among them, η i =[x i y i ψ i ] T ∈R 3 is the position vector of the unmanned boat to be calculated, x i ,y i is the position of the unmanned boat, ψ i is the heading angle of the unmanned boat; v i =[u i , v i , r i ] T ∈R 3 represents the velocity vector described in the fixed reference frame, u i is the current oscillation speed of the i-th unmanned boat, vi is the current drift speed of the i-th unmanned boat, r i is the angular velocity of the i-th unmanned boat at the current moment; the transfer matrix between the unmanned boat coordinate system and the plane coordinate system is given by the following formula:

[0027]

[0028] is the control input vector whose parameters are the impact force, the sway force and the yaw moment, which need to be designed to satisfy the required leader-follower control scheme; is a constant positive definite mass matrix of 3-DOF form; is the skew-symmetric matrix of the Coriolis centripetal force; is the nonlinear damping matrix; represents the unknown moments acting on the USV and the unmodeled dynamics; represents the time-varying ocean environment disturbance, τ uwi represents the disturbance of the forward torque, τ vwi represents the disturbance of the lateral moment, τ rwi Represents the disturbance of the steering torque.

[0029] Remember fg(v i , t) = C(v i )v i +D(v i )v i +f i (η i , v i )-τ wi , then the single unmanned boat model is further expressed as:

[0030]

[0031] remember:

[0032]

[0033] U i =diag{τ iu , τ iv , τ ir}

[0034]

[0035] Among them, m 11 、m 22 、m 33 is the positive definite mass matrix M i Elements on the diagonal; called Θ i To control the input gain, we can further obtain:

[0036]

[0037] Step 2.2: Define the expected path: For a system consisting of N unmanned boats, indexed as i=i,...,N, define η id (θ i )=[x id (θ i ), y id (θ i ), ψ id (θ i )] T ∈R 3 is the expected parameterized path, i.e., the position requirement of the i-th unmanned boat in the current formation, x id (θ i ) is the horizontal coordinate of the expected position of the i-th unmanned boat, y id (θ i ) is the ordinate of the expected position of the i-th unmanned boat, ψ id (θ i ) is the heading angle of the parameterized path expected by the i-th unmanned boat; where θ i ∈R is the path parameter of the virtual moving point.

[0038] Step 3: Determine the output limited control parameters according to the safe navigation area boundary and the expected path of the unmanned boat, specifically:

[0039] Since the expected path of the unmanned boat is within the safe navigation area, the maximum safety error is the minimum distance from the expected path of the unmanned boat to the boundary of the safe navigation area. i and i Strictly restricted to safe areas icx , -k icx and k icy , -k icy Between, that is, |x i |<k icx and |y i |<k icy ,remember:

[0040]

[0041] satisfy:

[0042]

[0043] k ix <k iax <k icx

[0044]

[0045] k iy <k iay <k icy

[0046] in, and k ix They represent the expected path x i d(θ i ), and k iy Denote the expected path y id (θ i ), k ix , and k iy are all positive numbers, k ibx , k iax , k iby , k iay is the output limited control parameter.

[0047] Step 4: According to the restriction requirements of the safe navigation area of ​​the unmanned boat, determine the initial position of the unmanned boat and set the coordinates, that is, ensure that the initial position of the unmanned boat is within the safe navigation area.

[0048] Step 5: According to the backstepping control design method, the kinematic expectation control law is designed using the potential barrier Lyapunov function and used as the control input of the system to realize the control of the motion trajectory of a single unmanned boat. Specifically:

[0049] Step 5.1: Define the following errors:

[0050]

[0051] Among them, z i1 represents the path tracking error of a single unmanned boat, e ix represents the error along the trajectory, e iy represents the cross-track error, e iψ Represents the heading angle error; ω i It represents the update speed error of the path parameters of the unmanned boat and the expected update speed of the path variable v0.

[0052] Step 5.2: Select the following barrier Lyapunov function:

[0053]

[0054] Step 5.3: Using the backstepping design method, in order to make the kinematics stable, the potential barrier Lyapunov function is differentiated to obtain the kinematic desired control law:

[0055]

[0056] in:

[0057]

[0058] in, represents the parameterized path pair θ i Find the partial derivative, represents a diagonal matrix whose elements are all positive constants.

[0059] Step 6: Design an observer to observe the unknown total interference of the unmanned boat;

[0060] Specifically, the following observers are used to observe the unknown total interference of the unmanned boat:

[0061]

[0062] in, is the first estimate of the velocity vector, k iσ is a normal number, is an estimate of the unknown total interference, For the estimation of the control input gain, is the second estimate of the velocity vector, K if is a three-dimensional gain matrix.

[0063] Step 7: Establish a data storage unit for the unmanned boat to save the observation results;

[0064] Establish a data storage unit for the unmanned boat, i.e. and And save the observation results of the unmanned boat; and It means that at time t=t x (x=1,2,3,...,p), Represented as a memory stack that can store historical data,

[0065] Step 8: Use the least squares method to fit the observation results stored in the unmanned boat to obtain the observation results of the control input gain. Specifically, use the least squares method to fit the observation results stored in the unmanned boat, that is:

[0066]

[0067] in, is the estimate of the auxiliary variable, Γ i is a positive constant, t c for The time taken to reach full rank, The definition is as follows:

[0068]

[0069] in:

[0070]

[0071] ι represents a positive constant.

[0072] Step 9: Substitute the observation results of the unknown total disturbance and the observation results of the control input gain into the dynamic model of the unmanned boat for the dynamic control of the unmanned boat, specifically:

[0073]

[0074] Step 10: Design the dynamic control law, specifically:

[0075] Remember i2 =v i -α i , choose the second positive definite scalar function:

[0076]

[0077] remember V i2 Derivative, use the backstepping method to design the following dynamic control law:

[0078]

[0079] in, is a constant diagonal matrix.

[0080] Step 11: Quantify the path variables and define the quantized cooperative error, and design the quantized cooperative control law, specifically:

[0081] The goal of cooperative control is to ensure that multiple unmanned boats are evenly distributed on a path. There are two virtual leaders θ n+1 and θ n+2 satisfy Define the Laplace matrix L = [L1 L2], where:

[0082]

[0083] Define the coordination error:

[0084]

[0085] Define the quantized coordination error:

[0086]

[0087] remember right ζ The derivative is:

[0088]

[0089] in, Choose a third scalar function:

[0090]

[0091] Derivative V3 and introduce auxiliary state variable ρ i , the backstepping design method is used to design the coordinated control law ω i :

[0092]

[0093] Among them, κ i1 and Represents a positive constant.

[0094] Step 12: According to the specific value of the quantized coordination error, the unmanned boat autonomously determines whether the current value is the same as the value after the last quantization. If they are the same, the unmanned boat does not transmit the coordination parameter information to its neighbors; if they are different, the unmanned boat transmits the coordination parameter information to its neighbors;

[0095] Step 13: The unmanned boat waits for data to be sent by its neighbor. If data is sent, the unmanned boat uses the received data for collaborative control; if no data is sent, the unmanned boat uses the last received data for collaborative control.

[0096] The proposed method first derives a coordinated strategy for a group of unmanned boats, including maneuvering formations, to track a parameterized path guided by two virtual leaders, where the tracking error is constrained. For the guidance layer, in order to obtain the performance of the tracking error constraint, the guidance law is derived by developing a parameterized line-of-sight-based symmetric ln-type Lyapunov function, where the control function is injected into the guidance law to prevent constraint violations. If the constraint is removed, this method becomes a classical LOS method. This makes the proposed algorithm compatible with the classical line-of-sight method and is attractive for practical applications in improving the tracking accuracy of unmanned boats. The entire design can constrain the along-track and cross-track errors within the user-defined region, improve the convergence rate of the tracking error, and reduce the sensitivity of the initial position of the unmanned boat.

[0097] Then, an asymmetric control system structure for a group of unmanned vehicles in the inclusive manipulation framework is proposed. The structure is based on an asymmetric ln-type Lyapunov function (ABLF) instead of a symmetric ln-type Lyapunov function to limit the tracking error of the system to a specific range at the kinematic level. Compared with existing algorithms, the proposed ABLF strategy can not only limit the path tracking error to a certain range according to user-defined specifications, but also the asymmetric ln-type Lyapunov function allows a more flexible parameter design process, reduces the dependence on specific initial conditions, and provides a larger initial range in the inclusive manipulation framework. This approach improves the tracking accuracy of multiple small aircraft and is of great significance in practical applications. For the dynamic unknown dynamics, a data-driven adaptive disturbance observer (DADO) is introduced for estimation. Compared with existing disturbance estimation methods, the introduced DADO can estimate the input gain and total disturbance simultaneously without the need for the dynamic model parameters of the unmanned vehicle. Compared with the old DADO, the output constraint and reference velocity estimation are added to the control input, which makes the DADO controller have the characteristics of output constraint tracking control.

[0098] Finally, for the collaborative layer, a quantized communication protocol is proposed to reduce the amount of communication data, and a speed estimator is proposed to perform more complex and diverse tasks in collaboration. Compared with existing collaborative communication strategies, the communication protocol in this paper can significantly reduce the amount of communication data, which indirectly saves the bandwidth of the entire network and the energy of each unmanned boat. A speed estimator is proposed, through which the reference speed of the unmanned boat can be modified to enable the execution of more complex and diverse tasks, rather than keeping it at a fixed value.

[0099] The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and is not intended to limit the present invention. For those skilled in the art, the present invention may have various modifications and variations. Any modification, equivalent replacement, improvement, etc. made within the spirit and principle of the present invention shall be included in the protection scope of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for output-limited and quantized cooperative control of an unmanned boat, characterized in that: include: Step 1: Determine the safe navigation area of ​​the unmanned boat, with the center of the safe navigation area as the coordinate origin or coordinate axis; Step 2: Establish a single unmanned boat model and determine the expected path of the unmanned boat target; Step 3: Determine the output limited control parameters according to the safe navigation area boundary and the expected path of the unmanned boat: Step 4: According to the restriction requirements of the safe navigation area of ​​the unmanned boat, determine the initial position of the unmanned boat and set the coordinates, that is, ensure that the initial position of the unmanned boat is within the safe navigation area; Step 5: According to the backstepping control design method, the kinematic expectation control law is designed using the potential barrier Lyapunov function and used as the control input of the system to realize the control of the motion trajectory of a single unmanned boat; Step 6: Design an observer to observe the unknown total interference of the unmanned boat; Step 7: Establish a data storage unit for the unmanned boat to save the observation results; Step 8: Use the least squares method to fit the observation results stored in the unmanned boat to obtain the observation results of the control input gain; Step 9: Substitute the observation results of the unknown total disturbance and the observation results of the control input gain into the dynamic model of the unmanned boat for the dynamic control of the unmanned boat; Step 10: Design the dynamic control law; Step 11: Quantify the path variables and define the quantized cooperative error, and design the quantized cooperative control law; Step 12: According to the specific value of the quantized coordination error, the unmanned boat autonomously determines whether the current value is the same as the value after the last quantization. If they are the same, the unmanned boat does not transmit the coordination parameter information to its neighbors; if they are different, the unmanned boat transmits the coordination parameter information to its neighbors; Step 13: The unmanned boat waits for data to be sent by its neighbor. If data is sent, the unmanned boat uses the received data for collaborative control; if no data is sent, the unmanned boat uses the last received data for collaborative control.

2. The unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 2 is specifically as follows: Step 2.1: Establish kinematic model and dynamic model of a single unmanned boat: Among them, η i =[x i y i ψ i ] T ∈R 3 is the position vector of the unmanned boat to be calculated, x i ,y i is the position of the unmanned boat, ψ i is the heading angle of the unmanned boat; v i =[u i ,v i ,r i ] T ∈R 3 represents the velocity vector described in the fixed reference frame, u i is the current oscillation speed of the i-th unmanned boat, v i is the current drift speed of the i-th unmanned boat, r i is the angular velocity of the i-th unmanned boat at the current moment; the transfer matrix between the unmanned boat coordinate system and the plane coordinate system is given by the following formula: is the control input vector whose parameters are the impact force, the sway force and the yaw moment, which need to be designed to satisfy the required leader-follower control scheme; is a constant positive definite mass matrix of 3-DOF form; is the skew-symmetric matrix of the Coriolis centripetal force; is the nonlinear damping matrix; represents the unknown moments acting on the USV and the unmodeled dynamics; represents the time-varying ocean environment disturbance, τ uwi represents the disturbance of the forward torque, τ vwi represents the disturbance of the lateral moment, τ rwi represents the disturbance of the steering torque; Remember fg(v i ,t)=C(v i )v i +D(v i )v i +f i (η i ,v i )-τ wi , then the single unmanned boat model is further expressed as: remember: U i =diag{τ iu ,t iv ,t ir } Among them, m 11 、m 22 、m 33 is the positive definite mass matrix M i Elements on the diagonal; called Θ i To control the input gain, the single unmanned boat model is further obtained as: Step 2.2: Define the expected path: For a system consisting of N unmanned boats, with index i=i,…,N, define η id (θ i )=[x id (θ i ),y id (θ i ),ψ id (θ i )] T ∈R 3 is the expected parameterized path, i.e., the position requirement of the i-th unmanned boat in the current formation, x id (θ i ) is the horizontal coordinate of the expected position of the i-th unmanned boat, y id (θ i ) is the ordinate of the expected position of the i-th unmanned boat, ψ id (θ i ) is the heading angle of the parameterized path expected by the i-th unmanned boat; where θ i ∈R is the path parameter of the virtual moving point.

3. The unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 3 is specifically as follows: Since the expected path of the unmanned boat is within the safe navigation area, the maximum safety error is the minimum distance from the expected path of the unmanned boat to the boundary of the safe navigation area. i and i Strictly restricted to safe areas icx ,-k icx and k icy ,-k icy Between, that is, |x i | <k icx and |y i | <k icy ,remember: k iax =k icx - k ix k iay =k icy - k iy satisfy: k ix <k iax <k icx k iy <k iay <k icy in, and k ix They represent the expected path x id (θ i ), and k iy Denote the expected path y id (θ i ), k ix , and k iy are all positive numbers, k ibx , k iax , k iby , k iay is the output limited control parameter.

4. The unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 5 is specifically as follows: Step 5.1: Define the following errors: Among them, z i1 represents the path tracking error of a single unmanned boat, e ix represents the error along the trajectory, e iy represents the cross-track error, e iψ Represents the heading angle error; ω i represents the error in the update speed of the path parameters of the unmanned boat, and the expected update speed of the path variable v0; Step 5.2: Select the following barrier Lyapunov function: Step 5.3: Using the backstepping design method, in order to make the kinematics stable, the potential barrier Lyapunov function is differentiated to obtain the kinematic desired control law: in: in, represents the parameterized path pair θ i Find the partial derivative, represents a diagonal matrix whose elements are all positive constants.

5. The unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 6 specifically includes: using the following observer to observe the unknown total interference of the unmanned boat: in, is the first estimate of the velocity vector, k iσ is a normal number, is an estimate of the unknown total interference, For the estimation of the control input gain, is the second estimate of the velocity vector, K if is a three-dimensional gain matrix.

6. The unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 7 is specifically as follows: establish a data storage unit for the unmanned boat, that is, and And save the observation results of the unmanned boat; and It means that at time t=t x (x=1,2,3,…,p), Represented as a memory stack that can store historical data, 7. The unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 8 is specifically: using the least squares method to fit the observation results stored in the unmanned boat, that is: in, is the estimate of the auxiliary variable, Γ i is a positive constant, t c for The time taken to reach full rank, The definition is as follows: in: ι represents a positive constant.

8. The unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step 9, the observation results of the unknown total disturbance and the observation results of the control input gain are brought into the dynamic model of step 2.1, and further obtained:

9. The unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 10 is specifically as follows: Note i2 =v i -α i , choose the second positive definite scalar function: remember V i2 Derivative, use the backstepping method to design the following dynamic control law: in, is a constant diagonal matrix.

10. The unmanned boat output limited and quantized cooperative control method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step 11 is specifically as follows: The goal of cooperative control is to ensure that multiple unmanned boats are evenly distributed on a path. There are two virtual leaders θ n+1 and θ n+2 satisfy Define the Laplace matrix L = [L1 L2], where: Define the coordination error: Define the quantized coordination error: remember Taking the derivative of ζ, we get: in, Choose a third scalar function: Derivative V3 and introduce auxiliary state variable ρ i , the backstepping design method is used to design the coordinated control law ω i : Among them, κ i1 and Represents a positive constant.