Static equipment multi-failure mode risk evaluation method
Through the risk assessment method of multi-failure mode of static equipment, different failure modes of oil and gas station equipment are identified and evaluated, and the risk matrix is established, which solves the problem of equipment integrity management and pipeline management not being combined and relying on a large amount of data in the existing technology, and realizes the problem of More accurate risk assessment and preventive maintenance support.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411014552.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-26
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
AI Technical Summary
The existing equipment integrity management has not been effectively combined with pipeline management in oil and gas stations, and relies on a large amount of failure data, which cannot effectively support preventive maintenance, resulting in insufficient risk assessment and difficulty in reducing the failure repair rate and safety hazards.
Using the risk assessment method of multi-failure mode in static equipment, the risk assessment method is adopted, and the failure causes and consequence levels in different failure modes are determined by collecting design, media, operation and environmental parameters, the risk matrix is established, the risk level is divided, and the thinning, environmental cracking and function are identified. Failure possibilities and consequences of failure modes such as mechanical failures.
It realizes risk assessment before failure occurs, reduces the fault repair rate, eliminates safety hazards, improves the pre-emptiveness and accuracy of equipment management, and supports preventive maintenance.
Smart Images

Figure CN118966761A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the technical field of risk assessment of station equipment, and specifically relates to a risk assessment method for multiple failure modes of static equipment, which is mainly used for risk identification and assessment of static equipment in oil and gas stations. Background Art
[0002] Since static equipment in oil and gas stations handles and stores flammable and explosive media, once equipment failure occurs, it may cause risks such as oil and gas leakage and explosion, threatening the safe and economical production of oil and gas stations.
[0003] Compared with pipelines, equipment integrity management started later. Currently, equipment integrity management follows PDCA, and continuously promotes the improvement of facility integrity through iteration. Based on the PDCA cycle, the traditional equipment integrity management system mainly consists of four links: planning, implementation and execution, inspection and review, and continuous improvement. They are interrelated and interpenetrating to ensure the system's systematicity, unity, and standardization.
[0004] Risk assessment is a key part of improving equipment integrity management. Currently, risk assessment methods are divided into three categories: qualitative risk assessment, semi-quantitative risk assessment and quantitative risk assessment. Qualitative risk assessment methods mainly include risk checklist qualitative risk analysis. Qualitative methods can provide relative levels of high, medium and low risks based on the opinions of experts. The operation is convenient and fast, but the frequency of dangerous accidents and the consequences of accident losses cannot be quantified.
[0005] Semi-quantitative risk assessment is a risk analysis method based on the quantitative indicators of risk. This method combines the chart-based model of qualitative methods with the knowledge of quantitative methods (such as the application of certain accident distribution probability models), excludes some unforeseen accident consequences, and focuses people's attention on the more likely accident consequences, greatly improving the practicality and accuracy of risk assessment.
[0006] Quantitative risk assessment method, also known as probabilistic risk analysis, is a rigorous mathematical and statistical method for quantifying the absolute frequency of accidents. Quantitative risk assessment can also be used in the analysis of risks, costs and benefits, which is something that the first two methods cannot do.
[0007] At present, the commonly used quantitative risk assessment method in stations is the risk-based inspection method (RBI). RBI establishes a risk matrix of failure probability and failure consequence for equipment risk assessment. Because the objects of RBI are mainly oil refineries, petrochemical and chemical plants, although the risk assessment of corrosion thinning failure mode is carried out, many failure factor conditions belong to high temperature conditions, which do not match the working conditions and basic failure probability of oil and gas processing stations. At the same time, the application of RBI requires the collection of a large amount of data, and the accuracy of the assessment results is difficult to guarantee.
[0008] The existing equipment integrity management process has not been integrated with pipeline and station integrity management in oil and gas station applications, making it difficult to implement equipment integrity management. Secondly, the risk management process relies on a large number of parameters such as failure data, and has not formed a pre-emptive risk assessment, which cannot effectively support preventive maintenance elements.
[0009] The present invention proposes a risk assessment method for multiple failure modes of static equipment. Based on the analysis of different failure modes of static equipment, according to risk occurrence process parameters such as operating parameters and medium parameters, a pre-classification index of failure causes under different failure modes of static equipment is established, and the failure possibility level and failure consequence level of different failure modes are determined respectively. The risk level under multiple failure modes is determined through a risk matrix, so that risk assessment can be performed before failure occurs. Summary of the invention
[0010] The present invention proposes a static equipment multi-failure mode risk assessment method to determine the risk level of static equipment, reduce the post-failure emergency repair rate, and eliminate potential safety hazards in a timely and effective manner.
[0011] In order to achieve the above object, the present invention adopts the following technical solutions:
[0012] S1: Collect the design parameters, medium parameters, operating parameters, environmental parameters and other risk-occurring process parameters of static equipment;
[0013] S2: Determine the possible failure modes of static equipment;
[0014] S3: Establish the pre-classification index of failure causes under different failure modes of static equipment, and determine the failure probability level of different failure modes respectively;
[0015] S4: Determine the failure consequence levels of different failure modes of static equipment;
[0016] S5: Establish a risk matrix and determine the risk level of static equipment under multiple failure modes based on the failure probability and failure consequences.
[0017] Possible failure modes of static devices are thinning, environmental cracking, and functional or mechanical failure.
[0018] The probability of failure (POF) classification index was established based on the risk factor analysis of three failure modes: thinning, environmental cracking, and functional or mechanical failure. The failure probability (failure possibility) was divided into five levels.
[0019] The consequences of failure (COF) are divided into area consequences and economic consequences; the economic consequences include repair and maintenance, environmental governance and other costs, and the economic consequence level is determined according to the company's own risk acceptance level; the area consequence area is divided into five levels: A, B, C, D, and E, among which the final consequence area (CA) ≤ 9m2 When the failure consequence level is A; when 9m 2 <CA≤93m 2 When 93m 2 <CA≤279m 2 When the failure consequence level is C; when 279m 2 <CA≤929m 2 When CA>929m 2 When , the failure consequence level is E.
[0020] The consequence area is calculated using the following steps:
[0021] 201: Calculate the area of the medium leakage hole:
[0022] 202: If the leaking medium is liquid, the theoretical liquid leakage rate is: If the leaking medium is gas, when the working pressure of the equipment is greater than the switching pressure, the gas leaks at the speed of sound. The theoretical leakage rate of the gaseous medium is: When the working pressure of the equipment is less than or equal to the switching pressure, the gas leaks at a subsonic speed. The theoretical leakage rate of the gaseous medium is:
[0023] 203: Actual leakage rate of the medium: rate n =W n (1-fact di ).
[0024] 204: The consequence area of liquid medium leakage failure considering factors such as medium properties, protection measures, leakage aperture, etc.: CA = min[a(rate n ) b ,929](1-fact mit ); The consequence area of gas medium leakage failure considering factors such as medium properties, protection measures and leakage aperture: CA = a (rate n ) b (1-fact mit ).
[0025] Where: CA——leakage impact area, m 2 ; a and b - constants related to the medium, as shown in GB / T26610.5 "Guidelines for the Implementation of Risk Detection of Pressure Equipment Systems Part V: Quantitative Analysis Methods for Failure Consequences" (as shown in Appendix B); C d ——Leakage coefficient, usually 0.61 for liquid and 0.90 for gas; rate n ——Actual leakage rate, kg / s; W n——Theoretical leakage rate, kg / s; A n ——leakage area at the leakage hole; d n ——leak hole diameter, mm; g c ——Mechanical constant, 1.0(kg·m) / (N·s 2 );T——operating temperature, ℃;P——internal pressure of pressure vessel, MPa, P atm ——Ambient pressure, MPa; ——Density of liquid medium under operating conditions, kg / m 3 ; MW - molar mass, g / mol; k - heat capacity ratio of ideal gas, dimensionless; R - gas constant, 8.314 J / (mol·K); fact di ——Reduction factor of leakage rate of detection and isolation system installed on pressure vessel; mit ——Area reduction factor of the protection system against combustion and explosion consequences.
[0026] According to API 581, a 5×5 risk matrix is established using POF and COF, and the failure risk is divided into four levels: low, medium, medium-high and high. The risk level of static equipment under multiple failure modes can be determined based on the failure possibility level and failure consequence level. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0027] Figure 1 A schematic diagram of a risk assessment method for multiple failure modes of static equipment according to the present invention
[0028] Figure 2 Failure probability classification index of thinning and environmental cracking of the present invention
[0029] Figure 3 It is the failure probability classification index of the functional or mechanical failure of the present invention
[0030] Figure 4 The risk matrix of the present invention is DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0031] In order to better explain the present invention and facilitate understanding, the present invention is described in detail below through specific implementation modes in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0032] The medium treated by the inlet separator of the raw gas compressor in the H joint station booster separation device contains corrosive gases such as carbon dioxide, oxygen and hydrogen sulfide, and there is a possibility of failure due to carbon dioxide corrosion, oxygen corrosion and hydrogen sulfide corrosion. According to the wall thickness detection data, the corrosion rate of the cylinder is 0.13mm / a, and the corrosion rate of the head is 0.11mm / a. Figure 2 , the internal corrosion failure probability of the natural gas separator belongs to level 3.
[0033] According to the macroscopic inspection results, the insulation layer is intact, there are no corrosion features on the equipment surface, and the possibility of external corrosion failure is level 1.
[0034] The stress corrosion cracking of the natural gas separator is mainly caused by chloride stress corrosion. The working temperature is about 50°C, the chloride ion concentration in the water is 102283.06 mg / L, the SVI of chloride stress corrosion cracking is about 3000, and the failure possibility level is 4.
[0035] The median particle size of the sand is 7.455 μm. The plugging failure possibility level is 1, and the operating temperature is 5°C higher than that of natural gas hydrate, and the hydrate plugging failure possibility level is also 1.
[0036] The working pressure of the separator is 0.3~0.45MPa and the design pressure is 1.0MPa. Therefore, the overpressure failure possibility level is level 1.
[0037] The maximum allowable filling volume of the natural gas separator is 50600kg. The current flow rate of the separator is 30.24×10 4 m 3 / d, the liquid level is between 15% and 30%, and the maximum allowable probability of blowby liquid failure is level 1.
[0038] The on-site staff has been trained, management measures are complete, no failures have occurred, and the possibility of failure due to misoperation is level 1.
[0039] The processing medium of the natural gas separator is mainly methane, which is a flammable medium, so the value of a is 55.13 and the value of b is 0.95. The working temperature of the separator is 60°C, the working pressure is 0.3-0.45MPa, and the local atmospheric pressure is 963kPa. According to the medium report, the average molar mass of the transport medium is 22.52g / mol. The failure consequence is calculated based on the failure leakage aperture of 100mm, where the detection and protection system installed in the separator gives the fact di The value is 0.15, the fact of prevention and control system mit The value is 0.25, and the calculated failure consequence affected area is about 259m 2 , the failure consequence level is C.
[0040] According to the 5×5 risk matrix ( Figure 4 ), combined with the failure possibility level and failure consequence level of each failure mode, the risk level of the natural gas separator under different failure modes is determined, as shown in Table 1. Among them, stress corrosion cracking reaches medium-high risk, internal corrosion and external corrosion reach low risk, and other failure risks are low.
[0041] Table 1 Risk levels under different failure modes
[0042] The above is only the technical solution of the present invention and is not intended to limit the present invention. Any modification, equivalent replacement and improvement made according to the technical essence of the present invention without departing from the content of the technical solution of the present invention are included in the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for risk assessment of multiple failure modes of static equipment, characterized in that: The process includes the following (Figure 1): S1: Collect the design parameters, medium parameters, operating parameters, environmental parameters and other risk-occurring process parameters of static equipment; S2: Determine the possible failure modes of static equipment; S3: Establish the pre-classification index of failure causes under different failure modes of static equipment, and determine the failure probability level of different failure modes respectively; S4: Determine the failure consequence levels of different failure modes of static equipment; S5: Establish a risk matrix and determine the risk level of static equipment under multiple failure modes based on the failure probability and failure consequences.
2. A static equipment multi-failure mode risk assessment method according to claim 1, characterized in that: Possible failure modes of the static equipment are thinning, environmental cracking, and functional or mechanical failure.
3. A static equipment multi-failure mode risk assessment method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The aforementioned pre-classification indexes of the failure causes and the failure probability under different failure modes of the static equipment are failure probability (POF) classification indexes established based on the analysis of the risk factors under different failure modes. The failure probability is divided into five levels, among which the classification indexes of thinning and environmental cracking are shown in FIG2 , and the classification indexes of functional or mechanical failures are shown in FIG3 .
4. A static equipment multi-failure mode risk assessment method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In the failure consequence level, the failure consequence (COF) is divided into area consequence and economic consequence; the economic consequence includes the cost of repair and maintenance, environmental governance, etc., and the economic consequence level is determined according to the enterprise's own risk acceptance level; the area consequence area is divided into five levels: A, B, C, D, and E, among which the final consequence area (CA) ≤ 9m 2 When the failure consequence level is A; when 9m 2 <CA≤93m 2 When 93m 2 <CA≤279m 2 When the failure consequence level is C; when 279m 2 <CA≤929m 2 When CA>929m 2 When the failure consequence level is E, the consequence area is calculated according to the following steps: 201: Calculate the area of the medium leakage hole: 202: If the leaking medium is liquid, the theoretical liquid leakage rate is: If the leaking medium is gas, when the working pressure of the equipment is greater than the switching pressure, the gas leaks at the speed of sound. The theoretical leakage rate of the gaseous medium is: When the working pressure of the equipment is less than or equal to the switching pressure, the gas leaks at a subsonic speed. The theoretical leakage rate of the gaseous medium is: 203: Actual leakage rate of the medium: rate n =W n (1-fact di ), 204: The consequence area of liquid medium leakage failure considering factors such as medium properties, protection measures, leakage aperture, etc.: CA = min[a(rate n ) b ,929](1-fact mit ); The consequence area of gas medium leakage failure considering factors such as medium properties, protection measures and leakage aperture: CA = a (rate n ) b (1-fact mit ), Where: CA——leakage impact area, m 2 ; a and b - constants related to the medium, as shown in GB / T26610.5 "Guidelines for the Implementation of Risk Detection of Pressure Equipment Systems Part V: Quantitative Analysis Methods for Failure Consequences" (as shown in Appendix B); C d ——Leakage coefficient, usually 0.61 for liquid and 0.90 for gas; rate n ——Actual leakage rate, kg / s; W n ——Theoretical leakage rate, kg / s; A n ——leakage area at the leakage hole; d n ——leak hole diameter, mm; g c ——Mechanical constant, 1.0(kg·m) / (N·s 2 );T——operating temperature, ℃;P——internal pressure of pressure vessel, MPa, P atm ——Ambient pressure, MPa; ——Density of liquid medium under operating conditions, kg / m 3 ; MW - molar mass, g / mol; k - heat capacity ratio of ideal gas, dimensionless; R - gas constant, 8.314 J / (mol·K); fact di ——Reduction factor of leakage rate of detection and isolation system installed on pressure vessel; mit ——Area reduction factor of the protection system against combustion and explosion consequences.
5. A static equipment multiple failure mode risk assessment method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The risk matrix is a 5×5 risk matrix established using POF and COF according to API 581, which divides the failure risk into four levels: low, medium, medium-high and high (Figure 4).
