Cable system bridge fire risk assessment method, system, equipment and medium
By comprehensively analyzing fire risk assessment methods for cable-stayed bridges and combining various data and analytical methods, this study addresses the lack of assessment methods in existing technologies, enabling effective assessment of bridge fire risks and the development of protective measures.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411400367.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-10-09
- Publication Date
- 2025-01-24
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies lack specific methods for fire risk assessment applicable to cable-stayed bridge systems, making it difficult to develop effective fire prevention measures and protective strategies for them.
By acquiring various data and utilizing the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and Bayes' conditional theorem, the fire risk of cable-stayed bridges is assessed, including weather, road alignment, vehicle collision, and spontaneous combustion data. Combined with structural damage and socioeconomic impacts, the fire risk level is calculated.
It provides a reliable basis for fire risk assessment, helps to develop effective fire prevention measures, identify high-risk fire scenarios and vulnerable components, and reduce bridge risks.
Smart Images

Figure CN119357821A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the field of bridge safety technology, and in particular to a method, system, equipment and medium for assessing fire risk of a cable system bridge. Background Art
[0002] During the daily operation and use of bridges, they are exposed to various risk factors (such as earthquakes, ship collisions, fires, etc.), and their service life often does not reach the designed service life. In recent years, accidents of bridge collapse caused by fire have occurred frequently, and the trend is gradually increasing. For cable system bridges, on the one hand, steel has strong thermal conductivity. When a fire occurs, the cable suspension system will suffer serious fire damage within 5-10 minutes, and the strength of some major load-bearing components will be reduced by more than 50%. In addition, the high-temperature creep effect will cause the pull / suspender rods and main cables to stretch and withdraw from the bridge load-bearing system. On the other hand, bridge fires will aggravate traffic congestion, prolong the arrival time of fire rescue, and make it difficult to extinguish the fire before the bridge structure is seriously damaged. Therefore, it is of great significance to assess the fire risk of bridges. However, there are currently very few specifications involving bridge fire safety and assessment, and there is no fire risk assessment method specifically set for cable system bridges, which makes it difficult to provide a basis for the design of fire prevention measures and the formulation of protective countermeasures for cable system bridges.
[0003] Therefore, a fire risk assessment method for cable system bridges is urgently needed to evaluate the fire risk level of cable system bridges and provide a reliable basis for the design of fire prevention measures and the formulation of protection countermeasures for cable system bridges. Summary of the invention
[0004] The present invention provides a cable system bridge fire risk assessment method, system, equipment and medium, which are used to solve the defect that the prior art lacks a fire risk assessment method specifically suitable for cable system bridges.
[0005] The present invention provides a cable system bridge fire risk assessment method, comprising:
[0006] Obtain the data on the growth probability of fire accidents caused by weather conditions, the growth probability of fire accidents caused by road lines, and the number of fire accidents caused by collisions with different types of vehicles. a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , annual traffic volume data, assessment length data L, and based on the weather-related fire accident growth probability data of the cable system bridge to be assessed, the road line type-related fire accident growth probability data, and the number of fire accidents caused by collisions of different types of vehicles N a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , evaluate the length data L, and obtain the annual total number of the i-th type of vehicle fires occurring on the cable system bridge to be evaluated Hi ;
[0007] Obtain the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated And according to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the annual total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained
[0008] Obtain the bridge age data, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance data of structural components, cable / sling number data, and cable tower layout data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, and obtain the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state through the hierarchical analysis method based on the bridge age data, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance data of structural components, cable / sling number data, and cable tower layout data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ;
[0009] Obtain the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles in the cable bridge to be evaluated when burning t t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure , according to the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles in the cable bridge to be evaluated when burning t t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure Get the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire And according to the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire and the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the assumed vehicle complete combustion state max,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type vehicle fire with / without fire prevention measures is obtained i,j ;
[0010] Obtain the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, and obtain the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated through the hierarchical analysis method based on the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ;
[0011] The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the fire of the i-th type vehicle with or without fire protection measures D i,j and the most adverse economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be assessedmax,j , and obtain the vulnerability D of the bridge structure of the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j ;
[0012] The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the fire of the i-th type vehicle with or without fire protection measures D i,j and the vulnerability of the bridge structure to be evaluated in terms of the cable system bridge component j i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained when the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has / does not have fire protection measures i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j ;
[0013] According to the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j , the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j ;
[0014] According to the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-type vehicle fire i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with / without fire protection measures is to be evaluated i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated at the same level k being affected by the i-th vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Accumulate and obtain the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated j ;
[0015] The component with the highest fire risk level in the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained, and the fire risk level of the component is used as the fire risk level of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. In one embodiment, the weather-related probability data for fire accidents includes the haze weather-related probability data P for fire accidents. fog The increase probability data of fire accidents on rainy days P rain , the increase probability data of road line type on fire accidents includes the increase probability data of slope on fire accidents P hThe growth probability data P of fire accidents due to slope length l ,
[0016] The method of obtaining the growth probability data of the weather on the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the growth probability data of the road line type on the fire accident, and the number of fire accidents caused by collision accidents of different types of vehicles N a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , annual traffic volume data, assessment length data L, and based on the weather-related fire accident growth probability data of the cable system bridge to be assessed, the road line type-related fire accident growth probability data, and the number of fire accidents caused by collisions of different types of vehicles N a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , evaluate the length data L, and obtain the total number of the i-th type of vehicle fires occurring on the cable system bridge to be evaluated H i ,include:
[0017] According to the number of collision accident fire data N of different types of vehicles a,i , using the Bayesian conditional theorem, the number of collision accident fires N after eliminating the influence of weather factors and road line factors on the fire of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained. b,i ;
[0018] The number of collision accident fires N after eliminating the influence of weather factors and road line factors on the fire of cable system bridges to be evaluated b,i and annual traffic volume data, the collision accident fire density P of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained b,i ;
[0019] According to the data of spontaneous combustion number of different types of vehicles N s,i and annual traffic volume data, the vehicle spontaneous combustion fire density P of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained s,i ;
[0020] According to the increase probability data of fire accidents caused by haze weather P fog , Rainy days increase the probability of fire accidents data P rain , the slope increases the probability of fire accidents P h , the slope length increases the probability of fire accidents P l , the collision accident fire density P of the cable system bridge to be evaluated b,i , Vehicle spontaneous combustion fire density P of the cable system bridge to be evaluated s,i , assessment length data L, annual traffic volume data, and obtain the total number of type i vehicle fires H on the cable system bridge to be assessed i .
[0021] In one embodiment, the total number of the i-th type of vehicle fires occurring in the cable system bridge to be evaluated is H i The expression is:
[0022] H i =(P b,i ×L×N i )×[(1+P fog )×(1+P r ain )×(1+P h )×(1+P l )]+P s,i ×L×N i .
[0023] In one embodiment, the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained. And according to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained include:
[0024] The preset fire impact range of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained, and the length data of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated within the preset fire impact range is obtained. As well as the evaluation length data L of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained
[0025] According to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , the annual number of times H that component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated is affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j ;
[0026] According to the annual number of times H that component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated is affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire i,j , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained
[0027] In one embodiment, the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is The expression is:
[0028]
[0029] In one embodiment, the annual number of times H that component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is i,jThe expression is:
[0030]
[0031] In one embodiment, the annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is The expression is:
[0032]
[0033] In one embodiment, the bridge age data, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance data of structural components, cable number data, and cable tower layout data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated are obtained, and the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under a preset vehicle complete combustion state is obtained by using a hierarchical analysis method based on the bridge age data, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance data of structural components, cable number data, and cable tower layout data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ,include:
[0034] The most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the assumed vehicle complete combustion state max,j As the first overall goal, according to the bridge age data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the data of the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the data of the number of cables / suspenders, and the tower arrangement data, the importance ranking of the bridge age, the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the number of cables / suspenders, and the tower arrangement to the first overall goal is obtained through the hierarchical analysis method, and the final weight λ of the bridge age, the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the number of cables / suspenders, and the tower arrangement to the first overall goal is obtained, so as to obtain the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state max,j .
[0035] In one embodiment, the most unfavorable loss state D of the component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state is max,j The expression is:
[0036] D max,j =∑λ.
[0037] In one embodiment, the damage reduction factor for the i-th type vehicle fire is The expression is:
[0038]
[0039] In one embodiment, the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire with and without fire protection measures is i,j The expression is:
[0040]
[0041] In one embodiment, the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated are obtained, and the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated is obtained by the hierarchical analysis method based on the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ,include:
[0042] The most unfavorable economic impact I of cable system bridge component j to be evaluated max,j As the second overall goal, according to the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the importance of life safety, traffic interruption time, two-way daily average traffic volume, traffic detour route volume, and repair cost to the second overall goal is ranked by the hierarchical analysis method, and the final weight β of life safety, traffic interruption time, two-way daily average traffic volume, traffic detour route volume, and repair cost to the second overall goal is obtained to obtain the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated max,j .
[0043] In one embodiment, the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated max,j The expression is:
[0044] I max,j =∑β.
[0045] In one embodiment, the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has a certain degree of bridge structure vulnerability D i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j The expression is:
[0046] I i,j =D i,j ×I max,j .
[0047] In one embodiment, the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with or without fire protection measures is i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The expression is:
[0048] C i,j =ω D D i,j ×+ω I I i,j ,
[0049] The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j In the expression of D The weight coefficient representing the vulnerability of the bridge structure, ω I Represents the weight coefficient of socioeconomic impact.
[0050] In one embodiment, the annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j , the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j ,include:
[0051] The annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Compare with the preset risk assessment matrix to obtain the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j under the i-th type of vehicle fire i,j , and further obtain risk assessment, which can be negligible risk, low risk, medium risk, high risk or extremely high risk.
[0052] In one embodiment, the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-type vehicle fire i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with / without fire protection measures is to be evaluated i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated at the same level being affected by the i-th vehicle fire is represented by k (k∈[1,5]). And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Accumulate and obtain the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated j ,include:
[0053] The annual probability of component j of the cable-type bridge to be evaluated of the same level k being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is Accumulate and get the cumulative annual probability
[0054] The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the cable system bridge component j of the same level k is D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Accumulate and get the cumulative fire risk consequence C j,k ;
[0055] Among them, the cumulative annual probability The expression is:
[0056]
[0057] Cumulative fire risk consequences C j,k The expression is:
[0058]
[0059] In one embodiment, the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated is j , the overall risk assessment R of the cable system bridge to be assessed is obtained through the evaluation expression, where the evaluation expression is:
[0060] R=max(R j ).
[0061] The present invention also provides a cable system bridge fire risk assessment system, comprising:
[0062] The vehicle fire number acquisition module is used to obtain the growth probability data of the weather on the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the growth probability data of the road line type on the fire accident, and the number of fire accidents caused by collision accidents of different types of vehicles. a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , annual traffic volume data, assessment length data L, and based on the weather-related fire accident growth probability data of the cable system bridge to be assessed, the road line type-related fire accident growth probability data, and the number of fire accidents caused by collisions of different types of vehicles N a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , evaluate the length data L, and obtain the total number of the i-th type of vehicle fires occurring on the cable system bridge to be evaluated H i ;
[0063] The module for obtaining the annual probability of component impact is used to obtain the fire component impact coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. And according to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained
[0064] The most unfavorable loss state obtaining module is used to: obtain the bridge age data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the data of the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the data of the number of pull / sling cables, and the cable tower layout data, and obtain the most unfavorable loss state D of the component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state through the hierarchical analysis method based on the bridge age data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the data of the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the data of the number of pull / sling cables, and the cable tower layout data. max,j ;
[0065] The bridge structure vulnerability acquisition module is used to obtain the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles when burning t for the cable system bridge to be evaluated. t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure , according to the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles in the cable bridge to be evaluated when burning t t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure Get the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire And according to the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire and the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the assumed vehicle complete combustion state max,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type vehicle fire with / without fire prevention measures is obtained i,j ;
[0066] The module for obtaining the most adverse economic impact is used to obtain the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, and obtain the most adverse economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated through the hierarchical analysis method based on the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ;
[0067] The socio-economic impact module is used to: Determine the vulnerability of the bridge structure to the fire of the i-th vehicle with or without fire protection measures D i,j and the most adverse economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be assessed max,j, the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained when the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has / does not have fire protection measures i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j ;
[0068] The fire risk consequence module is used to: determine the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures i,j And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained when the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has / does not have fire protection measures i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j ;
[0069] The fire risk degree obtaining module is used to: according to the annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j , the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j ;
[0070] The fire risk level module is used to: determine the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j under the i-th type of vehicle fire according to the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j under the i-th type of vehicle fire i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with / without fire protection measures is to be evaluated i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated at the same level k being affected by the i-th vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Accumulate and obtain the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated j ;
[0071] The overall fire risk level assessment module for bridges is used to obtain the component with the highest fire risk level of the cable system bridge to be assessed, and use the fire risk level of the component as the fire risk level of the cable system bridge to be assessed.
[0072] The present invention also provides an electronic device, comprising a processor and a memory storing a computer program, wherein the processor implements any of the above-mentioned methods for assessing the fire risk of a cable system bridge when executing the computer program.
[0073] The present invention also provides a non-transitory computer-readable storage medium on which a computer program is stored. When the computer program is executed by a processor, any of the above-mentioned methods for assessing the fire risk of a cable system bridge is implemented.
[0074] The present invention also provides a computer program product, which includes a computer program. The computer program can be stored on a non-transitory computer-readable storage medium. When the computer program is executed by a processor, the computer can execute any of the above-mentioned cable system bridge fire risk assessment methods.
[0075] The present invention provides a cable system bridge fire risk assessment method, system, equipment and medium, which considers the influence of weather factors and road line factors on the growth probability of fire accidents, takes collision accident fire and vehicle spontaneous combustion fire as the basis, integrates risk probability and risk consequence analysis, obtains the probability of each component of the cable system bridge to be assessed being affected by various vehicle fires, and combines structural damage and socio-economic impact to obtain the fire risk consequences of each component of the cable system bridge to be assessed under the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by different types of vehicle fires with / without fire prevention measures, thereby obtaining the fire risk level of each component of the cable system bridge to be assessed, and the highest risk of the most unfavorable component is the fire risk level of the cable system bridge to be assessed. The present invention is comprehensive and can be used not only for risk comparison between different cable system bridges, but also for the identification of high-risk fire scenarios and vulnerable components of the same cable system bridge. By comparing the fire risk levels of the entire bridge and key components under different fire extinguishing times and with or without fire retardant measures, it is helpful to formulate recommended measures to effectively reduce bridge risks, which has important guiding significance for fire risk assessment, fire prevention measures design and protection countermeasures formulation of cable system bridges. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0076] In order to more clearly illustrate the technical solutions in the present invention or the prior art, the following briefly introduces the drawings required for use in the embodiments or the prior art description. Obviously, the drawings described below are some embodiments of the present invention, and for ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without creative work.
[0077] Figure 1 A schematic flow chart of a cable system bridge fire risk assessment method provided by the present invention.
[0078] Figure 2Schematic diagram of the division of the fire impact area for cable system bridges.
[0079] Figure 3 The cumulative heat release curve of vehicle fire and the peak value of HRR heat release rate are shown. 3MW represents 5MW for cars, 20MW for buses, 30MW for ordinary trucks, 100MW for heavy-duty trucks, and 200MW for hazardous chemicals and tank trucks.
[0080] Figure 4 Schematic diagram of the main influencing factors of fire risk consequences of cable system bridges.
[0081] Figure 5 Schematic diagram of the process for assessing the risk consequences of fire on cable-type bridges.
[0082] Figure 6 This is a schematic structural diagram of an electronic device provided by the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0083] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the present invention clearer, the technical solution of the present invention will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with the drawings in the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments, and they should not be understood as limitations on the present invention. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention. In the description of the present invention, it should be understood that the terms used are only for descriptive purposes and cannot be understood as indicating or implying relative importance.
[0084] Combine the following Figure 1-Figure 6 The present invention describes a cable system bridge fire risk assessment method, system, equipment and medium.
[0085] This embodiment proposes a fire risk assessment method for cable system bridges. The fire risk level of the bridge is assessed by identifying key bridges, vulnerable components, and the most unfavorable fire scenario, which serves as the basis for the design of fire prevention measures and the formulation of protective countermeasures.
[0086] Figure 1 Schematic diagram of the cable system bridge fire risk assessment method provided by the present invention. Figure 1 The present invention provides a cable system bridge fire risk assessment method, which may include:
[0087] Step S110: Obtain the weather-related fire accident growth probability data for the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the road line type (such as the radius and length of the flat curve, different slopes and slope lengths) and the fire number data N for the collision accidents of different types of vehicles. a,i、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , annual traffic volume data (including total traffic volume throughout the year and traffic volume of different types of vehicles), evaluation length data L, and based on the weather-related probability data of fire accidents of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the road line type-related probability data of fire accidents, and the number of fire accidents caused by collisions of different types of vehicles N a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , evaluate the length data L, and obtain the total number of the i-th type of vehicle fires occurring on the cable system bridge to be evaluated H i , where the weather-related probability data on fire accidents include the haze weather-related probability data P fog The increase probability data of fire accidents on rainy days P rain , the increase probability data of road line type on fire accidents includes the increase probability data of slope on fire accidents P h The growth probability data P of fire accidents due to slope length l ;
[0088] Step S120: Obtain the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated And according to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained
[0089] Step S130, obtaining the bridge age data, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance data of structural components, cable / sling number data, and cable tower layout data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, and obtaining the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state through the hierarchical analysis method based on the bridge age data, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance data of structural components, cable / sling number data, and cable tower layout data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ;
[0090] Step S140: Obtain the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles of the cable bridge to be evaluated when burning t t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure , according to the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles in the cable bridge to be evaluated when burning t t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure Get the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire And according to the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire and the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the assumed vehicle complete combustion state max,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type vehicle fire with / without fire prevention measures is obtained i,j ;
[0091] Step S150: Obtain life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, and obtain the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated through the hierarchical analysis method based on the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ;
[0092] Step S160: Based on the vulnerability D of the bridge structure caused by the fire of the i-th type of vehicle with or without fire prevention measures i,j and the most adverse economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be assessed max,j , and obtain the vulnerability D of the bridge structure of the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j ;
[0093] Step S170: Based on the vulnerability D of the bridge structure caused by the fire of the i-th type of vehicle with or without fire prevention measures, i,j and the vulnerability of the bridge structure to be evaluated in terms of the cable system bridge component j i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained when the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has / does not have fire protection measures i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j ;
[0094] Step S180: according to the annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j , the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j ;
[0095] Step S190: according to the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire i,j, the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with / without fire protection measures is to be evaluated i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated at the same level k being affected by the i-th vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Accumulate and obtain the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated j ;
[0096] Step S110: obtaining a component with the highest fire risk level in the cable system bridge to be evaluated, and using the fire risk level of the component as the fire risk level of the cable system bridge to be evaluated.
[0097] It should be noted that the executor of the cable system bridge fire risk assessment method provided by the present invention can be any network side equipment / terminal side equipment that meets the technical requirements, such as a cable system bridge fire risk assessment device.
[0098] In this embodiment, various data can be obtained by querying historical accident data, bridge status data, original design data, monitoring data, etc. of the cable system bridge to be evaluated.
[0099] In one embodiment, step S110 may include:
[0100] According to the number of collision accident fire data N of different types of vehicles a,i , using the Bayesian conditional theorem, the number of collision accident fires N after eliminating the influence of weather factors and road line factors on the fire of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained. b,i ;
[0101] The number of collision accident fires N after eliminating the influence of weather factors and road line factors on the fire of cable system bridges to be evaluated b,i and annual traffic volume data, the collision accident fire density P of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained b,i ;
[0102] According to the data of spontaneous combustion number of different types of vehicles N s,i and annual traffic volume data, the spontaneous combustion fire density P of the cable bridge to be evaluated is obtained. s,i ;
[0103] According to the increase probability data of fire accidents caused by haze weather P fog , Rainy days increase the probability of fire accidents data P rain, the slope increases the probability of fire accidents P h , the slope length increases the probability of fire accidents P l , the collision accident fire density P of the cable system bridge to be evaluated b,i , the spontaneous combustion fire density P of the vehicle collision of the cable system bridge to be evaluated s,i , assessment length data L, annual traffic volume data, and obtain the total number of type i vehicle fires H on the cable system bridge to be assessed i .
[0104] Specifically, the number of collision accident fires of different types of vehicles on the cable system bridge to be evaluated is N a,i Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles N s,i The sum is the total number of type i vehicle fires occurring on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , that is, H i =N a,i +N s,i ;
[0105] Since the actual number of fire investigations already includes the impact of various factors on the probability of fire occurrence, the frequency of fires caused by collision accidents (the number of collision accident fires of different types of vehicles) can be set as the prior frequency, and the influencing factors such as weather and road characteristics can be used as conditions. The posterior frequency of fires caused by vehicle collisions of different types of vehicles (cars, buses, ordinary trucks...) can be calculated separately through the Bayesian conditional theorem (the number of collision accident fires N after eliminating the impact of weather factors and road line factors on the fire of the cable system bridge to be evaluated) b,i ) is: N h,i =N a,i / (1+P fog )×(1+P r ain )×(1+P h )×(1+P l );
[0106] The collision accident fire density P of the cable system bridge to be evaluated b,i The expression is: b,i =N b,i / (L total ×N i ), the spontaneous combustion fire density P of the vehicle collision of the cable system bridge to be evaluated s,i The expression is: s,i =N s,i / (L total ×N i ), L totle Indicates the length of the road section involved in the fire accident statistics, N i It represents the total annual traffic volume of type i vehicles passing through this road section;
[0107] In determining the collision accident fire density P of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, b,i and the spontaneous combustion fire density P of the vehicle in collision with the cable system bridge to be evaluated s,i Based on L totle Replaced with the assessment length L of the cable system bridge to be assessed (the assessment length refers to the distance between the main cable anchors and cable saddles of a suspension bridge or the distance between the outermost cable of a cable-stayed bridge and the intersection of the bridge deck), the total number of vehicle fires of the i-th type occurring in the cable system bridge to be assessed, H, can be obtained. i :
[0108] H i =(P b,i ×L×N i )×[(1+P fog )×(1+P r ain )×(1+P h )×(1+P l )]+P s,i ×L×N i .
[0109] The fire has a limited impact range and significant local effects. Under the condition that a fire on a bridge deck must occur, fires occurring at different locations are mutually exclusive, and different components have different probabilities of being affected by the fire. Figure 2 For example, B1 refers to the event of fire affecting the pier tower, B2 refers to the event of fire affecting the cable / suspender rod, and B3 refers to the event of fire affecting the suspension rod and main cable. Divide the vehicle accessible position on the bridge deck into a series of equal areas A1, A2..., An, then: P(A1) = P(A2) = ... = P(A n ), therefore, in this embodiment, the fire component influence coefficient is defined as the length of the component within the fire influence range Ratio to the evaluation length L.
[0110] In one embodiment, step S120 may include:
[0111] The preset fire impact range of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained, and the length data of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated within the preset fire impact range is obtained. As well as the evaluation length data L of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained Among them, the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is The expression is:
[0112]
[0113] According to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated Hi , the annual number of times H that component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated is affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j , where the fire accidents of bridges are independent of each other and follow the Poisson distribution. The annual number of times that component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire can be obtained as H i,j The expression is:
[0114]
[0115] According to the annual number of times H that component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated is affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire i,j , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained Among them, the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is The expression is:
[0116]
[0117] The annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire can be calculated as By comparing with Table 1, the risk probability level of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained.
[0118]
[0119] Table 1 Risk probability level assessment table for cable system bridge components affected by fire
[0120] In one embodiment, see Figure 4-Figure 5 , step S130 may include:
[0121] The most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the assumed vehicle complete combustion state max,j As the first overall goal, according to the bridge age data, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance between structural components (Di s), cable / suspender number data, and tower arrangement data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the importance ranking of bridge age, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance between structural components, cable / suspender number, and tower arrangement to the first overall goal is obtained through the hierarchical analysis method, and the final weight λ of bridge age, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance between structural components, cable / suspender number, and tower arrangement to the first overall goal is obtained (see Table 2), so as to obtain the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the complete combustion state max,j , where the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state max,j The expression is:
[0122] D max,j =∑λ.
[0123] Specifically, in this embodiment, the oil tanker is used as the preset vehicle, and the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained when the oil tanker is completely burned. max,j .
[0124]
[0125] Table 2 Final weights of the most unfavorable loss status
[0126] This example calculates the damage reduction factor The influence of fire intensity, fire duration and bridge structure materials on fire risk consequences is mainly considered to obtain the damage state D caused by the fire of the i-th type vehicle with or without fire prevention measures. i,j .
[0127] Specifically, in this embodiment, the damage reduction factor is defined as the ratio of the energy released by each type of burning vehicle in a fire to the energy required for component failure, that is, the damage reduction factor of the i-th type of vehicle fire is The expression is:
[0128]
[0129]
[0130]
[0131]
[0132] Where n represents the total number of vehicles involved in a fire, E i It represents the energy released by the fire of vehicle type i at time t. According to the Ingason H. heat release rate square growth model, the time is integrated and the cumulative heat release curve is as follows: Figure 4 When the horizontal distance between the component and the fire source is zero, the tanker fire lasts for more than a certain time and the structure fails. This time is called the critical failure time of the structure t failure , the burning time of a tanker truck reaches the critical failure time of the structure, and the accumulated heat released is the failure energy E failure .
[0133] In one embodiment, the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire with and without fire protection measures is i,j The expression is:
[0134]
[0135] In one embodiment, step S150 may include:
[0136] The most unfavorable economic impact I of cable system bridge component j to be evaluated max,m As the second overall goal, based on the life safety data (with bridge length as the evaluation index), traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the importance of life safety (bridge length), traffic interruption time, two-way daily average traffic volume, traffic detour route volume, and repair cost to the second overall goal is ranked by the hierarchical analysis method, and the final weight β of life safety, traffic interruption time, two-way daily average traffic volume, traffic detour route volume, and repair cost to the second overall goal is obtained (see Table 3), so as to obtain the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated. axj,m , where the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated is max,j The expression is:
[0137] I max,j =∑β.
[0138]
[0139] Table 3 Final weights of the most adverse economic impacts
[0140] By querying and calculating the local traffic volume and basic profile of the bridge, combined with query table 3, the most unfavorable economic impact of each component can be obtained. max,j .
[0141] In one embodiment, the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has a certain degree of bridge structure vulnerability D i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j The expression is:
[0142] I i,j =D i,j ×I max,j .
[0143] In one embodiment, the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with or without fire protection measures is i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The expression is:
[0144] C i,j =ω D D i,j ×+ω I I i,j ,
[0145] The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under Ci,j In the expression of D The weight coefficient representing the vulnerability of the bridge structure, ω I represents the weight coefficient of social and economic impact, ω in this embodiment D ,ω I Take 0.5 for both.
[0146] The bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type of vehicle fire for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated with or without fire protection measures is obtained. i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j After that, the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures can be obtained according to Table 4. i,j The fire risk consequence level under
[0147]
[0148] Table 4 Cable system bridge fire risk consequence level assessment table
[0149] In one embodiment, step S180 may include:
[0150] The annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Compare with the preset risk assessment matrix (see Table 5) to obtain the fire risk level of the cable system bridge component j under the i-th vehicle fire Get the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire i,j Including negligible risk, low risk, medium risk, high risk, and extremely high risk.
[0151] Table 5 Preset risk assessment matrix
[0152]
[0153]
[0154] In this embodiment, the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire is calculated. i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with / without fire protection measures is to be evaluated i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The data are classified into k levels (k∈[1,5]).
[0155] In one embodiment, step S190 may include:
[0156] The annual probability of component j of the cable-type bridge to be evaluated of the same level k being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is Accumulate and get the cumulative annual probability Among them, the cumulative annual probability The expression is:
[0157]
[0158] The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the cable system bridge component j of the same level k is D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Accumulate and get the cumulative fire risk consequence C j,k , where the cumulative fire risk consequence C j,k The expression is:
[0159]
[0160] Furthermore, the fire risk level of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated can be obtained: Fire risk level The maximum value of is taken as the final fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated. j =max(R j,k, ), and then the fire risk level of the component with the highest fire risk level in the cable system bridge to be evaluated is taken as the fire risk level of the cable system bridge to be evaluated R = max (R j ).
[0161] This embodiment provides a new method for fire risk assessment of cable system bridges that considers both risk probability and risk consequence analysis. This method mainly includes three parts. For risk probability research, firstly, the factors affecting the probability of fire on the bridge deck are analyzed, and a fire probability analysis model based on Bayes' theorem is proposed to obtain the probability of fire at different vehicle types at each component; for risk consequence analysis, it mainly includes structural damage and socio-economic impact analysis. Structural damage defines a damage reduction factor that can consider the fire intensity, duration and fire prevention measures of different types of vehicles based on the energy method principle, and defines the most unfavorable damage state based on the analytic hierarchy process calculation considering the minimum vertical distance between the fire source and the component in the transverse direction of the bridge, the number of cables, the cable, the tower layout, the bridge and other factors. A risk consequence assessment model combining the loss ratio and the most unfavorable damage state is proposed. The socio-economic impact takes into account direct impacts such as structural repair and reconstruction costs and indirect impacts such as economic damage caused by structural damage to life safety and traffic interruption. Finally, a fire risk assessment framework for cable-type bridges was proposed. Based on the risk matrix, the risk of each risk component of the bridge under different types of vehicle fires and the cumulative risk of all vehicle fires were analyzed to identify high-risk fire scenarios and high-risk components of the same bridge. The highest risk of the most unfavorable component was used as the bridge risk to achieve risk comparison between different bridges. Finally, the fire extinguishing time and the presence or absence of fire retardant measures were set as variables. By evaluating and comparing the risks of the two suspension bridges under different circumstances, the feasibility of the assessment system was verified and fire prevention measures were proposed.
[0162] The cable system bridge fire risk assessment method provided by the present invention considers the influence of weather factors and road line factors on the growth probability of fire accidents, takes collision accident fires and vehicle spontaneous combustion fires as the basis, integrates risk probability and risk consequence analysis, obtains the probability of each component of the cable system bridge to be assessed being affected by various vehicle fires, and combines structural damage and socioeconomic impact to obtain the fire risk consequences of each component of the cable system bridge to be assessed under the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by different types of vehicle fires with / without fire prevention measures, thereby obtaining the fire risk level of each component of the cable system bridge to be assessed, and the highest risk of the most unfavorable component is the fire risk level of the cable system bridge to be assessed. The present invention is comprehensive and can be used not only for risk comparison between different cable system bridges, but also for the identification of high-risk fire scenarios and vulnerable components of the same cable system bridge. By comparing the fire risk levels of the entire bridge and key components under different fire extinguishing times and with or without fire retardant measures, it is possible to formulate recommended measures to effectively reduce the risk of the bridge, which has important guiding significance for the fire risk assessment, fire prevention measure design and protection countermeasure formulation of cable system bridges.
[0163] The cable system bridge fire risk assessment system provided by the present invention is described below. The cable system bridge fire risk assessment system described below and the cable system bridge fire risk assessment method described above can be referenced to each other.
[0164] The present invention provides a cable system bridge fire risk assessment system, which may include:
[0165] The vehicle fire number acquisition module is used to obtain the growth probability data of the weather on the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the growth probability data of the road line type on the fire accident, and the number of fire accidents caused by collision accidents of different types of vehicles. a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , annual traffic volume data, assessment length data L, and based on the weather-related fire accident growth probability data of the cable system bridge to be assessed, the road line type-related fire accident growth probability data, and the number of fire accidents caused by collisions of different types of vehicles N a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , evaluate the length data L, and obtain the total number of the i-th type of vehicle fires occurring on the cable system bridge to be evaluated H i ;
[0166] The module for obtaining the annual probability of component impact is used to obtain the fire component impact coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. And according to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained
[0167] The most unfavorable loss state obtaining module is used to: obtain the bridge age data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the data of the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the data of the number of pull / sling cables, and the cable tower layout data, and obtain the most unfavorable loss state D of the component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state through the hierarchical analysis method based on the bridge age data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the data of the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the data of the number of pull / sling cables, and the cable tower layout data. max,j ;
[0168] The bridge structure vulnerability acquisition module is used to obtain the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles when burning t for the cable system bridge to be evaluated. t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure , according to the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles in the cable bridge to be evaluated when burning tt and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure Get the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire And according to the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire and the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the assumed vehicle complete combustion state max,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type vehicle fire with / without fire prevention measures is obtained i,j ;
[0169] The module for obtaining the most adverse economic impact is used to obtain the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, and obtain the most adverse economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated through the hierarchical analysis method based on the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ;
[0170] The socio-economic impact module is used to: Determine the vulnerability of the bridge structure to the fire of the i-th vehicle with or without fire protection measures D i,j and the most adverse economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be assessed max,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained when the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has / does not have fire protection measures i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j ;
[0171] The fire risk consequence module is used to: determine the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures i,j And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained when the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has / does not have fire protection measures i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j ;
[0172] The fire risk degree obtaining module is used to: according to the annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j, the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j ;
[0173] The fire risk level module is used to: determine the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j under the i-th type of vehicle fire according to the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j under the i-th type of vehicle fire i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with / without fire protection measures is to be evaluated i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated at the same level k being affected by the i-th vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under c i,j Accumulate and obtain the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated j ;
[0174] The fire risk level assessment module is used to obtain the component with the highest fire risk level in the cable system bridge to be assessed, and use the fire risk level of the component as the fire risk level of the cable system bridge to be assessed.
[0175] Figure 6 An example of a physical structure diagram of an electronic device is shown in FIG. Figure 6 As shown, the electronic device may include: a processor 810, a communication interface 820, a memory 830 and a communication bus 840, wherein the processor 810, the communication interface 820 and the memory 830 communicate with each other through the communication bus 840. The processor 810 may call the logic instructions in the memory 830 to execute any of the above-mentioned cable system bridge fire risk assessment methods.
[0176] In addition, the logic instructions in the above-mentioned memory 830 can be implemented in the form of a software functional unit and can be stored in a computer-readable storage medium when it is sold or used as an independent product. Based on such an understanding, the technical solution of the present invention, in essence, or the part that contributes to the prior art or the part of the technical solution, can be embodied in the form of a software product, and the computer software product is stored in a storage medium, including a number of instructions for a computer device (which can be a personal computer, a server, or a network device, etc.) to perform all or part of the steps of the method described in each embodiment of the present invention. The aforementioned storage medium includes: U disk, mobile hard disk, read-only memory (ROM, Read-Only Memory), random access memory (RAM, Random Access Memory), disk or optical disk and other media that can store program codes.
[0177] On the other hand, the present invention also provides a computer program product, which includes a computer program. The computer program can be stored on a non-transitory computer-readable storage medium. When the computer program is executed by a processor, the computer can execute any of the above-mentioned methods for assessing the fire risk of a cable system bridge.
[0178] On the other hand, the present invention also provides a non-transitory computer-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, which is implemented when the computer program is executed by a processor to perform any of the above-mentioned methods for assessing the fire risk of a cable system bridge.
[0179] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention, rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the aforementioned embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that they can still modify the technical solutions described in the aforementioned embodiments, or make equivalent replacements for some of the technical features therein. However, these modifications or replacements do not deviate the essence of the corresponding technical solutions from the spirit and scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for assessing fire risk of a cable system bridge, characterized in that: include: Obtain the data on the growth probability of fire accidents caused by weather conditions, the growth probability of fire accidents caused by road line types, and the number of fire accidents caused by collisions with different types of vehicles. a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , annual traffic volume data, assessment length data L, and based on the weather-related fire accident growth probability data of the cable system bridge to be assessed, the road line type-related fire accident growth probability data, and the number of fire accidents caused by collisions of different types of vehicles N a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , evaluate the length data L, and obtain the total number of the i-th type of vehicle fires occurring on the cable system bridge to be evaluated H i ; Obtain the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated And according to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained Obtain the bridge age data, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance data of structural components, cable / sling number data, and cable tower layout data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, and obtain the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state through the hierarchical analysis method based on the bridge age data, vehicle accessible area and minimum transverse distance data of structural components, cable / sling number data, and cable tower layout data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ; Obtain the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles in the cable bridge to be evaluated when burning t t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure , according to the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles in the cable bridge to be evaluated when burning t t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure Get the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire And according to the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire and the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the assumed vehicle complete combustion state max,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type vehicle fire with / without fire prevention measures is obtained i,j ; Obtain the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, and obtain the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated through the hierarchical analysis method based on the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ; The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the fire of the i-th type vehicle with or without fire protection measures D i,j and the most adverse economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be assessed max,j , and obtain the vulnerability D of the bridge structure of the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j ; The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the fire of the i-th type vehicle with or without fire protection measures D i,j and the vulnerability of the bridge structure to be evaluated in terms of the cable system bridge component j i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained when the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has / does not have fire protection measures i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j ; According to the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j , the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j ; According to the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-type vehicle fire i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with / without fire protection measures is to be evaluated i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated at the same level k being affected by the i-th vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Accumulate and obtain the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated j ; The component with the highest fire risk level in the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained, and the fire risk level of the component is used as the fire risk level of the cable system bridge to be evaluated.
2. The cable system bridge fire risk assessment method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The increase probability data of weather on fire accidents includes the increase probability data of haze weather on fire accidents P fog The increase probability data of fire accidents on rainy days P rain , the increase probability data of road line type on fire accidents includes the increase probability data of slope on fire accidents P h The growth probability data P of fire accidents due to slope length l , The method of obtaining the growth probability data of the weather on the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the growth probability data of the road line type on the fire accident, and the number of fire accidents caused by collision accidents of different types of vehicles N a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , annual traffic volume data, assessment length data L, and based on the weather-related fire accident growth probability data of the cable system bridge to be assessed, the road line type-related fire accident growth probability data, and the number of fire accidents caused by collisions of different types of vehicles N a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , evaluate the length data L, and obtain the total number of the i-th type of vehicle fires occurring on the cable system bridge to be evaluated H i ,include: According to the number of collision accident fire data N of different types of vehicles a,i , using the Bayesian conditional theorem, the number of collision accident fires N after eliminating the influence of weather factors and road line factors on the fire of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained. b,i ; The number of collision accident fires N after eliminating the influence of weather factors and road line factors on the fire of cable system bridges to be evaluated b,i and annual traffic volume data, the collision accident fire density P of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained b,i ; According to the data of spontaneous combustion number of different types of vehicles N s,i and annual traffic volume data, the spontaneous combustion fire density P of the cable bridge to be evaluated is obtained. s,i ; According to the increase probability data of fire accidents caused by haze weather P fog , Rainy days increase the probability of fire accidents data P rain , the slope increases the probability of fire accidents P h , the slope length increases the probability data of fire accidents P l , the collision accident fire density P of the cable system bridge to be evaluated b,i , the spontaneous combustion fire density P of the vehicle collision of the cable system bridge to be evaluated s,i , assessment length data L, annual traffic volume data, and obtain the total number of type i vehicle fires H on the cable system bridge to be assessed i ; Among them, the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable system bridge to be evaluated is H i The expression is: H i =(P b,i ×L×N i )×[(1+P fog )×(1+P rain )×(1+P h )×(1+P l )]+P s,i ×L×N i 。 3. The cable system bridge fire risk assessment method according to claim 2 is characterized in that: The fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained And according to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained include: The preset fire impact range of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained, and the length data of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated within the preset fire impact range is obtained. As well as the evaluation length data L of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is obtained According to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , the annual number of times H that component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated is affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j ; According to the annual number of times H that component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated is affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire i,j , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained Among them, the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated is The expression is: The annual number of times component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated is affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire H i,j The expression is: Annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be assessed being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire The expression is:
4. The cable system bridge fire risk assessment method according to claim 3 is characterized in that: The bridge age data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the data of the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural member, the data of the number of pull / sling cables, and the cable tower arrangement data are obtained, and the most unfavorable loss state D of the component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state is obtained through the hierarchical analysis method according to the bridge age data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the data of the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural member, the data of the number of pull / sling cables, and the cable tower arrangement data. max,j ,include: The most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the assumed vehicle complete combustion state max,j As the first overall goal, according to the bridge age data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the data of the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the data of the number of cables / suspenders, and the cable tower arrangement data, the importance ranking of the bridge age, the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the number of cables / suspenders, and the cable tower arrangement to the first overall goal is obtained through the hierarchical analysis method, and the final weight λ of the bridge age, the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the number of cables / suspenders, and the cable tower arrangement to the first overall goal is obtained, so as to obtain the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state max,j ; Among them, the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state is max,j The expression is: D max,j =∑λ; Damage reduction factor for the i-th type of vehicle fire The expression is: The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by fire of type i vehicle with / without fire prevention measures D i,j The expression is:
5. The cable system bridge fire risk assessment method according to claim 4, characterized in that: The life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated are obtained, and the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated is obtained through the hierarchical analysis method based on the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ,include: The most unfavorable economic impact I of cable system bridge component j to be evaluated max,j As the second overall goal, according to the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the importance of life safety, traffic interruption time, two-way daily average traffic volume, traffic detour route volume, and repair cost to the second overall goal is ranked by the hierarchical analysis method, and the final weight β of life safety, traffic interruption time, two-way daily average traffic volume, traffic detour route volume, and repair cost to the second overall goal is obtained to obtain the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated max,j ; Among them, the most unfavorable economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated max,j The expression is: i max,j =∑β; The vulnerability of the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated in the bridge structure D i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j The expression is: I i,j =D i,j ×I max,j ; The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The expression is: C i,j =ω D D i,j ×+ω I I i,j , The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j In the expression of D The weight coefficient representing the vulnerability of the bridge structure, ω I Represents the weight coefficient of socioeconomic impact.
6. The cable system bridge fire risk assessment method according to claim 5, characterized in that: The annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j , the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j ,include: The annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Compare with the preset risk assessment matrix to obtain the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j under the i-th type of vehicle fire i,j , the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j Including negligible risk, low risk, medium risk, high risk, and extremely high risk.
7. The cable system bridge fire risk assessment method according to claim 6, characterized in that: The fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-type vehicle fire i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with / without fire protection measures is to be evaluated i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated at the same level k being affected by the i-th vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Accumulate and obtain the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated j ,include: The annual probability of component j of the cable-type bridge to be evaluated of the same level k being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is Accumulate and get the cumulative annual probability The vulnerability of bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the cable system bridge component j of the same level k is D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Accumulate and get the cumulative fire risk consequence C j,k ; Among them, the cumulative annual probability The expression is: Cumulative fire risk consequences C j,k The expression is:
8. A cable system bridge fire risk assessment system, characterized in that: include: The vehicle fire number acquisition module is used to obtain the growth probability data of the weather on the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the growth probability data of the road line type on the fire accident, and the number of fire accidents caused by collision accidents of different types of vehicles. a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , annual traffic volume data, assessment length data L, and based on the weather-related fire accident growth probability data of the cable system bridge to be assessed, the road line type-related fire accident growth probability data, and the number of fire accidents caused by collisions of different types of vehicles N a,i 、N Data on the number of spontaneous combustion fires of different types of vehicles s,i , evaluate the length data L, and obtain the total number of the i-th type of vehicle fires occurring on the cable system bridge to be evaluated H i ; The module for obtaining the annual probability of component impact is used to obtain the fire component impact coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. And according to the fire component influence coefficient of the cable system bridge to be evaluated and the total number of type i vehicle fires on the cable bridge to be evaluated H i , the annual probability of component j of the cable bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained The most unfavorable loss state obtaining module is used to: obtain the bridge age data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the data of the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the data of the number of pull / sling cables, and the cable tower layout data, and obtain the most unfavorable loss state D of the component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the preset vehicle complete combustion state through the hierarchical analysis method based on the bridge age data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, the data of the minimum transverse distance between the vehicle accessible area and the structural components, the data of the number of pull / sling cables, and the cable tower layout data. max,j ; The bridge structure vulnerability acquisition module is used to obtain the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles of the cable system bridge to be evaluated when burning t t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure , according to the total energy data E released by all i-type vehicles in the cable bridge to be evaluated when burning t t and the failure energy data E when the vehicle combustion duration reaches the critical failure time of the structure failure Get the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire And according to the damage reduction factor of the i-th type vehicle fire and the most unfavorable loss state D of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated under the assumed vehicle complete combustion state max,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type vehicle fire with / without fire prevention measures is obtained i,j ; The module for obtaining the most adverse economic impact is used to obtain the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated, and obtain the most adverse economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated through the hierarchical analysis method based on the life safety data, traffic interruption time data, two-way daily average annual traffic volume data, traffic detour route volume data, and repair cost data of the cable system bridge to be evaluated. max,j ; The socio-economic impact module is used to: Determine the vulnerability of the bridge structure to the fire of the i-th vehicle with or without fire protection measures D i,j and the most adverse economic impact I of the cable system bridge component j to be assessed max,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained when the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has / does not have fire protection measures i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j ; The fire risk consequence module is used to: determine the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures i,j And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Socio-economic impacts of i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained when the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated has / does not have fire protection measures i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j ; The fire risk degree obtaining module is used to: according to the annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated being affected by the i-th type of vehicle fire And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j , the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated under the i-th type of vehicle fire is obtained i,j ; The fire risk level module is used to: determine the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j under the i-th type of vehicle fire according to the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j under the i-th type of vehicle fire i,j , the bridge structure vulnerability D caused by the i-th vehicle fire of the cable system bridge component j with / without fire protection measures is to be evaluated i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j The annual probability of component j of the cable system bridge to be evaluated at the same level k being affected by the i-th vehicle fire is And the vulnerability of the bridge structure caused by the i-th vehicle fire with or without fire protection measures for the bridge component j of the cable system to be evaluated D i,j Fire risk consequences under C i,j Accumulate and obtain the fire risk level R of the cable system bridge component j to be evaluated j ; The fire risk level assessment module is used to obtain the component with the highest fire risk level in the cable system bridge to be assessed, and use the fire risk level of the component as the fire risk level of the cable system bridge to be assessed.
9. An electronic device comprising a memory, a processor, and a computer program stored in the memory and executable on the processor, wherein: When the processor executes the program, the cable system bridge fire risk assessment method according to any one of claims 1 to 7 is implemented.
10. A non-transitory computer-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, characterized in that: When the computer program is executed by a processor, the method for assessing the fire risk of a cable system bridge according to any one of claims 1 to 7 is implemented.
Citation Information
Cited By
Fire resistance test method and test device for cable fireproof sealing system
CN121253592A
Rigid-flexible coordinated anti-impact-fireproof intelligent composite protection system for main cable of bridge
CN121519417A
A rigid-flexible cooperative bridge main cable impact-resistant-fireproof intelligent composite protection system
CN121519417B
Construction and use method of cable bridge member fire damage toughness evaluation system
CN122508939A
