METHOD FOR EVALUATING AT LEAST ONE LEVEL OF LIGHT PROTECTION OF AT LEAST ONE OPTICAL PRODUCT INTENDED TO BE FACED TOWARDS THE EYE OF A USER AND OPTICAL PRODUCT

The method addresses the inadequacy of existing light protection evaluations by integrating short-term and long-term factors, providing a comprehensive assessment for optical products to enhance user comfort and eye health.

BR112023023915B1Active Publication Date: 2026-11-10ESSILOR INTERNATIONAL(COMPAGNIE GENERALE D OPTIQUE)
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
BR112023023915
Authority / Receiving Office
BR · BR
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-05-31
Publication Date
2026-11-10
Estimated Expiration
2041-05-31

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for evaluating light protection of optical products, such as lenses, are inadequate for dynamic and varied lighting conditions, failing to provide a comprehensive assessment that considers both short-term comfort and long-term eye health impacts.

Method used

A method that evaluates light protection by determining short-term and long-term protection scores, incorporating environmental factors and product attributes, to provide a holistic assessment of optical products.

Benefits of technology

Enables a more relevant evaluation of optical products by considering both short-term comfort and long-term eye health, facilitating better product selection for individual needs.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention provides a method for evaluating at least one level of light protection of at least one optical product intended to be pointed at the eye of a user, the method comprising the following steps: - determination of at least one short-term light protection score representative of at least one short-term light protection attribute, - determination of at least one long-term light protection score representative of at least one long-term light protection attribute, evaluation of at least one level of light protection of at least one optical product based on said at least one short-term protection score and at least one long-term protection score.The invention also provides an optical product comprising a frame, at least one optical system product attached to said frame and intended to be faced toward a user's eye, a data collection device, and a controller configured to perform said evaluation method.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

1 / 40 “METHOD FOR EVALUATING AT LEAST ONE LEVEL OF LIGHT PROTECTION OF AT LEAST ONE OPTICAL PRODUCT INTENDED TO BE FACED TOWARDS THE EYE OF A USER AND OPTICAL PRODUCT”

[0001] The present invention generally relates to the field of light sensitivity.

[0002] More specifically, it relates to a method for evaluating at least one level of light protection of at least one optical product intended to be pointed at the eye of a user.

[0003] Likewise, it relates to a computer system and a computer program product comprising code instructions for performing the said method.

[0004] Inclusive, it relates to an optical product comprising a frame and at least one optical system.

[0005] It has been observed that most people, around 9 / 10 people, have light sensitivity. It can be a feeling of discomfort, headache, pain, glare or fatigue. It is a visual discomfort that can occur in many lighting conditions, namely in lighting conditions specific to a given user, as well as in indoor and outdoor situations (natural and artificial light).

[0006] The evaluation of the light protection of an optical product, such as a lens for a pair of glasses, is generally carried out considering short-term or long-term protection.

[0007] Short-term protection refers to the visual experience and user comfort in a given light situation. Short-term protection is most commonly assessed by eye health professionals (ECPs) in relation to the light transmittance of the lens.

[0008] Long-term protection refers to the impact of light on eye health. This long-term protection can be assessed in relation to exposure to blue-violet radiation or ultraviolet radiation.

[0009] The light protection level rating of a lens is known with Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 16 / 107 2 / 40 based on UV protection or light transmittance (e.g., categories 0, 1, 2, 3, and 4 for sunglasses). Allows you to quantify the level of light protection of a lens from a specific evaluation angle.

[0010] However, with this type of assessment it is difficult to evaluate the level of light protection of a lens in a comprehensive way. In fact, a user experiences various light environments under different light conditions. Every day, and throughout the day, a user is constantly bombarded with light, from the sun to our screens. The light environment is not static, it constantly changes over time and depends heavily on our activities. Therefore, with this type of assessment, it is difficult to provide a relevant evaluation to an eye care professional (ECP) or a user.

[0011] One problem that the invention aims to solve is thus to provide a method for evaluating the light protection level of an optical product in a more detailed and relevant way.

[0012] To solve this problem, the invention provides a method for evaluating at least one level of light protection of at least one optical product intended to be directed towards the eye of a user, the method comprising the following steps: - determination of at least one short-term light protection score representative of at least one short-term light protection attribute of the aforementioned optical product, - determination of at least one long-term light protection score representative of at least one long-term light protection attribute of the aforementioned optical product, - assessment of at least one level of light protection for at least one optical product based on the aforementioned, at least one, short-term protection score and at least one, long-term protection score.

[0013] The level of protection against light is thus evaluated by considering short-term and long-term protection to allow for a more complete assessment. The combination of Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 17 / 107 3 / 40 short- and long-term protection allows the light protection level to become more relevant for environments and conditions with significantly higher illumination. It better reflects the light protection level of the optical product in a holistic and ecological approach.

[0014] In this way, it is easier for an ECP or a user to determine which optical product is suited to the user's light protection needs.

[0015] According to one modality of the aforementioned evaluation method, it also includes: - determination of at least one light environment, - selection of said, at least one, short-term light protection attribute and said, at least one, long-term light protection attribute respectively from a group of short-term light protection attributes and a group of long-term light protection attributes, depending on said, at least one, determined light environment.

[0016] According to one embodiment of said evaluation method, said at least one light environment is selected from a group of light environments, said group of light environments comprising at least one of a bright light environment, a daytime driving environment, a nighttime driving environment, an indoor environment, a nighttime screen, an indoor-to-outdoor transition environment and an outdoor-to-indoor transition environment.

[0017] According to one embodiment of the aforementioned evaluation method, the aforementioned, at least one, short-term light protection score and / or the aforementioned, at least one, long-term score are determined using different weightings for the aforementioned, at least one, short-term light protection attribute and the aforementioned, at least one, long-term light protection attribute, respectively.

[0018] According to one modality of the aforementioned evaluation method, it also includes: Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 18 / 107 4 / 40 - determination of at least one vision experience score representative of at least one optical product quality attribute of said optical product, at least one, - determination of at least one short-term global light protection score based on the aforementioned short-term light protection score and the aforementioned vision experience score,

[0019] wherein the aforementioned, at least one, light protection level of the aforementioned, at least one, optical product is evaluated based on the aforementioned, at least one, overall short-term light protection score and the aforementioned, at least one, long-term light protection score.

[0020] According to one embodiment of the said evaluation method, the evaluation step for at least one level of protection comprises a step for determining at least one overall light protection score for said optical product based on said short-term and long-term light protection scores.

[0021] According to one modality of the aforementioned evaluation method, it also includes: - determination of at least two light environments,

[0022] where at least one short-term light protection score, at least one long-term score and at least one overall score are determined for each given light environment.

[0023] According to one embodiment of the said assessment method, it further comprises the step of determining a light protection assessment score based on each overall light protection score determined for a given light environment, wherein said light protection assessment score is determined using different weightings for said overall light protection scores, depending on at least two given light environments.

[0024] According to one modality of the aforementioned evaluation method, the aforementioned Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 19 / 107 The 5 / 40 global light protection score is determined using different weightings for the aforementioned, at least one, global short-term light protection score and the aforementioned, at least one, long-term light protection score.

[0025] According to one embodiment of the said evaluation method, said at least one short-term light protection attribute is one of a transmission attribute, a polarization attribute, a diffuse light discomfort attribute, and a spectral attribute.

[0026] For protection against short-term light, a transmission attribute can be luminous transmittance (Tv) or the variation in transmission speed (dimming or fading processes). A polarization attribute can be polarization efficiency (EP). A scatter light attribute can be multi-angle reflection efficiency (Rv, Rs). A spectral attribute can be blue light filtering.

[0027] According to one embodiment of the aforementioned evaluation method, said, at least one, long-term attribute is a spectral attribute.

[0028] For long-term light protection, a spectral attribute can be ultraviolet protection, blue-violet radiation protection, or infrared radiation protection.

[0029] According to one embodiment of the aforementioned evaluation method, said at least one optical product quality attribute is one of a transmission attribute, a diffuse light attribute, and a residual color perception attribute.

[0030] For protection against light in vision experiences, a transmission attribute can be luminous transmittance (Tv). A diffuse light attribute can be multi-angle reflection efficiency (Rv, Rs), ghost image transmission (Tgi), or haze. A residual color perception attribute can be color saturation (chroma) or yellowing (b*).

[0031] According to one embodiment of the aforementioned evaluation method, the aforementioned optical product may comprise a frame fixed to an optical system, the Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 20 / 107 6 / 40 frame attributes related to said frame being considered to evaluate said level of light protection. Said frame attributes may be used in determining said short-term light protection score, said long-term light protection score, said vision experience light protection score, or at least two of these.

[0032] The frame attribute may be the frame's engagement, frame size / thickness / shape, frame material and transparency, or face coverage rate of the optical product (frame and / or lenses).

[0033] According to one modality of the aforementioned evaluation method, it also includes: - determination of at least one need for light protection for a user, - determination of at least one optical product for the user based on the aforementioned, at least one, level of light protection and the aforementioned, at least one, need for light protection of the user.

[0034] According to one embodiment of the said evaluation method, it further comprises a stage of displaying said, at least one, short-term light protection score and said, at least one, long-term score on the same graph having a first and a second dimension, said, at least, short-term light protection being positioned relative to said first dimension and said, at least, long-term light protection being positioned relative to said second dimension.

[0035] According to one modality of the aforementioned evaluation method, the aforementioned method is a computer-implemented method.

[0036] The invention further relates to an optical product comprising a frame and at least one optical system fixed to said frame and intended to be directed towards the eye of a user, said optical product comprising a data collection device and a controller configured to perform a Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 21 / 107 7 / 40 method for evaluating at least one level of light protection of said optical product, the method comprising the following steps: - determination of at least one short-term light protection score representative of at least one short-term light protection attribute of the aforementioned optical product, - determination of at least one long-term light protection score representative of at least one long-term light protection attribute of the aforementioned optical product, - assessment of at least one level of light protection of the aforementioned optical product based on the aforementioned short-term protection score and at least one long-term protection score.

[0037] The invention is described in greater detail below by means of figures which show only a preferred embodiment of the invention.

[0038] Figure 1 shows a flowchart of a method according to the invention evaluating a light protection level of an optical product.

[0039] Figure 2 shows a table bringing together weighting factors for the optical product quality attributes used in the evaluation method of Figure 1.

[0040] Figure 3 shows a table bringing together an example of short-term light protection, long-term light protection and optical product quality attributes considered to determine a light protection level according to the method in Figure 1 for each selected light environment.

[0041] Figure 4 shows a table bringing together an example of weighting factors applied to short-term light protection, long-term light protection and optical product quality attributes for each selected light environment.

[0042] Figure 5 shows a table bringing together technical values ​​and associated scores for short-term light protection, long-term light protection, and optical product quality attributes for a given light environment for a plurality of optical products. Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 22 / 107 8 / 40

[0043] Figure 6 shows a table bringing together short-term light protection scores, long-term light protection scores, vision experience light protection scores, short-term overall light protection scores, and overall light protection scores for each of the optical products in Figure 5.

[0044] Figure 7 shows a graph illustrating the global light protection score of each of the optical products in Figures 5 and 6.

[0045] Figure 8 shows a graph in which each optical product from figures 5 and 6 is represented by a point having an X-axis coordinate referring to the short-term global light protection score and a y-axis coordinate referring to the long-term light protection score.

[0046] In the description that follows, the figures in the drawings are not necessarily to scale, and certain features may be shown in a generalized or schematic form for reasons of clarity and conciseness or for informational purposes. Furthermore, although the elaboration and use of various embodiments are discussed below in detail, it should be noted that, as described in this document, many inventive concepts are provided that can be incorporated into a wide variety of contexts. The embodiments discussed here are merely representative and do not limit the scope of the invention. Likewise, it will be obvious to a person skilled in the art that all technical features defined in relation to a process can be transposed, individually or in combination, to a device, and conversely, all technical features relating to a device can be transposed, individually or in combination, to a process.

[0047] The terms “compreender” (and any grammatical variation thereof, such as “compreende” and “compreendendo”), “ter” (and any grammatical variation thereof, such as “tem” and “tendo”), “conter” (and any grammatical variation thereof, such as “contém” and “contendo”) and “incluir” (and any grammatical variation thereof, such as “inclui” and “incluindo”) are indefinite linking verbs. They are used to specify the presence of particularities, whole numbers, steps or Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 23 / 107 9 / 40 components mentioned or groups thereof, but do not exclude the presence or addition of one or more other particularities, whole numbers, steps or components or groups thereof. As a result, a method, or a step in a method, that “comprises”, “has”, “contains” or “includes” one or more steps or elements has those one or more steps or elements, but is not limited to having only those one or more steps or elements.

[0048] The present invention provides a method for evaluating at least one level of light protection of at least one optical product intended to be directed towards the eye of a user.

[0049] An optical product according to the disclosure comprises at least one ophthalmic lens, an optical filter, an optical glass or an optical material suitable for human vision, for example, at least one ophthalmic lens, an optical filter or an optical film, each comprising a substrate, or adhesive intended to be fixed to a substrate, an optical glass or an optical material intended for use in an ophthalmic instrument, for example, to determine the visual acuity and / or refraction of a subject, or any type of safety device, including safety glasses or a safety wall intended to cover the eyes of an individual, as a protective device, for example, safety lenses or a mask or shield.

[0050] The optical product may be implemented as ocular equipment having a frame that at least partially surrounds one or more ophthalmic lenses. By way of non-limiting example, the optical product may be a pair of eyeglasses, sunglasses, protective eyewear, sports eyewear, a contact lens, an intraocular implant, an active lens with amplitude modulation, such as a polarized lens, or with phase modulation, such as an autofocus lens, etc.

[0051] In this document, the term “lens” means an organic or inorganic glass lens comprising a lens substrate, which may be coated with one or more coatings of various natures.

[0052] The term “ophthalmic lens” is used to mean a lens fitted to a spectacle frame, for example, to protect the eye and / or correct vision. The aforementioned Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 24 / 107 The 10 / 40 lens can be chosen from among afocal, single-vision, bifocal, trifocal, and progressive lenses. Although ophthalmic optics is a preferred field of the invention, it will be understood that this invention can be applied to optical products of other types, such as, for example, lenses for optical instruments, in photography or astronomy, optical aiming lenses, eyepieces, lighting system optics, safety lenses, etc.

[0053] At least one ophthalmic lens or optical glass or optical material suitable for human vision can provide an optical function to the user, that is, to the wearer of the lens.

[0054] It can be, for example, a corrective lens, namely, a power lens of the spherical, cylindrical and / or addition type for an ametropic user, for the treatment of myopia, hyperopia, astigmatism and / or presbyopia. The lens may have a constant power to provide power as a monofocal lens would, or it may be a progressive lens having variable power.

[0055] As used herein, a base material or substrate has at least one face, i.e., a surface on one side, coated with a multilayer interference coating providing asymmetric mirror properties.

[0056] The aforementioned base material may constitute the substrate of a lens, filter, glass, ophthalmic material, etc., as mentioned above, or it may constitute the main part of a patch intended to be fixed to that substrate to give it the properties of an asymmetric mirror.

[0057] The base material or substrate may also have a coated opposite face, i.e., a surface on the other side, also coated, so that, in this case, two faces of the optical product opposite each other may be coated.

[0058] When the base material constitutes a substrate for an ophthalmic lens, its front face is preferably coated with an anti-reflective or mirrored coating, and its back face is preferably coated with an anti-reflective coating.

[0059] When the base material constitutes the main part of a patch intended to be attached to an ophthalmic lens substrate, its front face is Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 25 / 107 11 / 40 preferably coated with an anti-reflective or mirrored coating, and its back face will be prepared in such a way as to be fixed to said substrate, which will have an anti-reflective coating on its back face.

[0060] As used herein, the back face of the base material or substrate is intended to mean the face which, when the product is being used, is closest to the user's eye, in the case of ophthalmic lenses. It is generally a concave face. Conversely, the front face of the substrate is the face which, when the product is being used, is furthest from the user's eye. It is generally a convex face. The optical product may also be a flat product.

[0061] The substrate may be made of mineral glass or organic glass, preferably organic glass. Organic glasses may be thermoplastic materials, such as polycarbonates and thermoplastic polyurethanes, or thermoset (crosslinked) materials, such as diethylene glycol bis(allyl carbonate) polymers and copolymers (in particular CR-39® from PPG Industries), thermoset polyurethanes, polythiourethanes, preferably polythiourethane resins having a refractive index of 1.60 or 1.67, polyepoxides, polyepisulfides, such as those having a refractive index of 1.74, substrates based on poly(meth)acrylates and copolymers, such as substrates comprising (meth)acrylic polymers and copolymers derived from bisphenol-A, polythio(meth)acrylates, as well as copolymers thereof and blends thereof.Preferred materials for lens substrates are polycarbonates (PC), diethylene glycol bis(allyl carbonate) polymers, and substrates obtained from thermosetting polythiourethane resins, which are marketed by Mitsui Toatsu Chemicals as the MR series, in particular MR6®, MR7®, and MR8® resins. These latter substrates, as well as the monomers used for their preparation, are specifically described in US patents 4,689,387, 4,775,733, 5,059,673, 5,087,758, and 5,191,055.

[0062] An interference coating may be associated, by coating or lamination, with a transparent base / substrate material, that is, a base / substrate material having an average visible light transmission factor Tv greater than 96%, or any other base / substrate material (including non-transparent ones), and define Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 26 / 107 12 / 40 with the latter being an optical article having an average visible light transmission factor (Tv) preferably ranging from 96% to 4%, more preferably from 90% to 4%. In most cases, the resulting optical article is a colored optical article.

[0063] The Tv factor, also called the relative light transmission factor in the visible spectrum, relative average visible light transmission factor or “luminous transmission” of the system, is as defined in the NF EN 1836 standard and refers to an average in the wavelength range of 380 to 780 nm that is weighted according to the sensitivity of the human eye at each wavelength in the range and measured under D65 illumination conditions (daylight).

[0064] As such, the interference coating according to the invention can be adapted so as to define, with the associated substrate, different shades of dark glasses with different average visible light transmission factors Tv: - above 80%, - 43 to 80% (known as category or class 1 sunglasses), - 18 to 43% (known as class 2 sunglasses), - 8 to 18% (known as class 3 sunglasses), - below 8% (known as class 4 sunglasses).

[0065] The aforementioned optical product may comprise a photochromic lens, an electrochromic lens, a clear lens, a blue light blocking lens or a sun lens.

[0066] “Electrochromic lens” means a lens comprising electroactive substances that are simultaneously oxidized and reduced in contact with power electrodes. At least some of these electroactive substances have different colors between their oxidized and reduced forms. The system thus changes color and / or exhibits variable light absorption when an electrical control, which is applied between the power electrodes, is itself varied.

[0067] “Photochromic lenses” means an ophthalmic article defined by, but not limited to, corrective lenses, non-corrective lenses, contact lenses, intraocular lenses, magnifying lenses, protective lenses and visors containing photochromic compounds in a coating, the lens material, a film or any layer. Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 27 / 107 13 / 40 adjacent. Photochromic compounds undergo a transformation from one state (or form) to another in response to certain wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation (i.e., “actinic radiation”). Each state has a characteristic absorption spectrum. For example, many photochromic compounds transform from a non-activated state (e.g., bleached or substantially colorless) to an activated state (e.g., colored) upon exposure to actinic radiation. When the actinic radiation is removed, the photochromic compounds reversibly transform from the activated state back to the non-activated state.

[0068] Non-limiting examples of suitable organic photochromic compounds may include benzopyrans, naphthopyrans (e.g., naphtho[1,2-b]pyrans and naphtho[2,1-b]pyrans), spiro-9-fluorene[1,2-b]pyrans, phenanthropyrans, quinopyrans, and indene-fused naphthopyrans, such as those disclosed in U.S. Patent No. 5,645,767 in column 1, line 10 to column 12, line 57 and in U.S. Patent No. 5,658,501 in column 1, line 64 to column 13, line 36, the disclosures of which are incorporated herein by reference. Additional non-limiting examples of organic photochromic compounds that may be used include oxazines, such as benzoxazines, naphthoxazines, and spirooxazines. Other non-limiting examples of photochromic compounds that may be used include: fulgides and fulgimides, for example 3-furyl and 3-thienyl fulgides and fulgimides, which are described in USN Patent° 4,931,220 in column 20, line 5 to column 21, line 38, the disclosure of which is incorporated herein by reference; diaryletenes, which are described in Publication of US Patent Application No. 2003 / 0174560 from paragraph

[0025] to

[0086] , the description of which is incorporated herein by reference; and combinations of any of the above-mentioned photochromic compounds. For example, the photochromic material (a) may comprise a compound selected from the group consisting of naphthopyrans, benzopyrans, phenanthropyrans, indenonaphthopyrans, spiro(indoline)naphthoxazines, spiro(indoline)pyridobenzoxazines, spiro(benzindoline)pyridobenzoxazines, spiro(benzindoline)naphthoxazines, spiro(indoline)benzoxazines, fulgides, fulgimides and mixtures thereof. Short-term light protection attributes Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 28 / 107 14 / 40

[0069] As shown in figure 1, the present evaluation method comprises first a step of determining a short-term light protection score 10 representative of at least one short-term light protection attribute 12 of said at least one optical product.

[0070] A short-term light protection score of 10 refers to the ability of an optical product to improve comfort and light resistance during light exposure. A short-term light protection attribute of 12 therefore refers to a structural, physical-chemical or optical characteristic or parameter of the optical product that impacts comfort and light resistance during that light exposure.

[0071] The short-term light protection attributes 12 can be chosen from luminous transmittance (Tv), transmission rate (light to dark, i.e., dimming process, and dark to light, i.e., fading process), polarizing efficiency (PE), multi-angle reflection efficiency (Rv, Rs), blue light filtering in the peak emission range of LED-based digital devices (“CUT_LED”, between 380 and 500 nm, preferably between 430 and 470 nm, more preferably between 440 and 460 nm).

[0072] Luminous transmittance (Tv) is the transmission of the optical product perceived by the observer under specified solar radiation (%). Luminous transmittance is preferably considered a short-term attribute for natural light environments, such as bright light and daytime driving environments. In this type of light environment, the amount of light experienced by the user is at an important level. Since luminous transmittance refers to the amount of light supplied to the user through the optical product, luminous transmittance is thus an attribute that is considered to improve short-term light protection in a bright light environment. It is defined by the average transmittance value of a lens in the visible range of 380 to 780 nm weighted by the irradiance of solar radiation (D65) and the photopic visibility function (V lambda). The principle is to measure the spectral transmission of the optical product at the reference point at normal incidence using a spectrometer.In photochromic lenses, Tv corresponds to luminous transmittance. Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 29 / 107 15 / 40 in three different states: - Darkened / Activated State (Tv out): The photochromic lens is activated for 15 minutes on an optical bench with two 150 W xenon arc lamps with a 50:50 beam splitter and irradiance through a KG2 filter providing UVA / VIS, and the second beam having a KG2 filter and a GG400 filter resulting in supplementary VIS only to provide 50 klux VIS and 6.7 W / m² UVA. A Zeiss M601 spectrophotometer then measures Tv after 15 minutes of activation at 23 °C and 35 °C. Tv out thus corresponds to the average Tv resulting from the lens in a bright light environment. -Behind-the-Windshield / In-car state (Tv bws): This is a measurement that mimics the performance of photochromic lenses behind a car's windshield. The photochromic lens is conditioned to a fully inactivated state by 5 minutes of activation with a 365 nm ultraviolet lamp, followed by heating to 70 °C and exposure to a yellow fluorescent lamp for 25 minutes, followed by storage in the dark for at least 1 hour. Then, the lens is activated using a 150 W lamp in the A-BMP with a KG2 filter and a windshield filter installed, and the irradiance adjusted to 1.0 W / m² integrated between 380 and 420 nm, 1.7 klux at 27 °C. The windshield glass consisted of 2 sheets of 2.3 mm solar green glass with Solutia-UV enhanced polyvinyl butyrate as the laminate. Tv bws is then measured after 15 minutes of activation. - Clear / Faded State (Tv in): The clear / faded state follows the ISO 8980-3 procedure regarding what constitutes a clear / faded photochromic lens. The Tv measurement on the photochromic lens is conditioned as explained in the section on Tvbws above, and then Tv in is read using a Hunter UltraScan Pro, which refers to the spectrally weighted transmittance associated with the eye's vision under good lighting conditions and defined by the luminosity function. Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 30 / 107 16 / 40 photopic CIE of 1931.

[0073] The variation in transmission speed corresponds to a criterion applicable only in dynamic situations (i.e., from the inside to the outside or vice versa). The speed corresponds to the activation speed for inside-to-outside situations and the fading speed for outside-to-inside situations.

[0074] For an inside-out situation, the test method consists of measuring the time the lenses take to reach 90% of the difference in transmission (Tv in (0.9*(Tv in - Tv out))). For an inside-out situation, this test method consists of measuring the time the lenses take to reach 70% of Tv in (0.7*Tv in). For an inside-out situation, the aforementioned test method is defined in a new ISO 12312-1 standard (standard in progress at the time of filing).

[0075] The aforementioned polarizing efficiency (PE) is the efficiency calculation (%) based on the luminous transmittance of the lens measured in two cross positions under polarizing light. The principle is to measure the luminous transmittance of the lens (Tv with D65 source) with linear polarizing light in two positions: Polarizing axis of the lens (if present) in parallel position (Tvpar) and then perpendicular (Tvper) to the polarized light source. This requires the implementation of a linear polarizer at the light source output in the spectrometer. The test method is detailed in ISO 8980-3. ISO 8980-3 and ISO 12312-1 specify the minimum value in polarizing efficiency to claim a lens as having a polarizing function: Peff must not be less than 60% for category 1 lenses and Peff must not be less than 78% for category 2, 3 or 4 lenses.

[0076] The aforementioned multi-angle reflection efficiency (Rv, Rs) is a criterion that quantifies the overall anti-reflective efficiency regardless of the direction of the light. The aforementioned multi-angle reflection efficiency (Rv, Rs) is preferably considered as a short-term attribute for environments illuminated with artificial light, such as night driving, indoor, and night screen environments. In this type of light environment, most of the light exposure is from point light sources and peripheral light sources. Multi-angle reflection efficiency is an attribute that is considered to improve the user's short-term light protection in these light environments.

[0077] The aforementioned multi-angle reflection efficiency can be expressed as a Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 31 / 107 17 / 40 integral of Rv in an angular range, for example [0° to 45°]. More generally, the overall efficiency α of an anti-reflective treatment on an optical surface for angles of incidence ranging from 0° to 0max can be quantified by the following parameter: fQ max α = KI Rv(9) sin Θ dO

[0078] The smaller the coefficient a, the smaller the global reflection phenomenon.

[0079] For comparison of anti-reflective coating performance in various incidence angle domains, the coefficient α is normalized with a numerical constant K so as to have a coefficient α equal to 1% for a model function Rv(0) being constant and equal to 1%. K depends only on Omax and is defined jr Θ max — = I sen Θ d6 by the following equation:Â

[0080] In this way, the performance of a lens in the [0°-40°] range can be compared with another lens in the [0°-50°] range.

[0081] An approximate value of the coefficient α can be computed through various simplifications. Since Rv(0) has several domains for 0 in which Rv is almost constant, it is possible to define the coefficient α by the following equation: — « / ?vl I sin Θ de + Rv2 í sin Θ άθ K 'θ 41

[0082] where Rv 1Λ is the average value of Rv in the range of 0oa 01 and Rv 2Λ is the average value of Rv in the range of 01 to Omax.

[0083] 01 is selected in order to separate a domain of low incident angles and a domain of high incident angles, including 0 min. In particular, 01 can be selected in the range of 15° to 40°.

[0084] With this definition, the two integrals of the approximate coefficient α are purely geometric and can be computed exactly, and are renormalized with the numerical constant K so as to have a coefficient α equal to 1% for a model function Rv(0) being constant and equal to 1%.

[0085] In particular, Omax is greater than 35°, preferably greater than 40°. In Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 32 / 107 18 / 40 In some modes, Omax is greater than 45°, even better if it's greater than 50°. The greater Omax, the more incident light is integrated into the coefficient a.

[0086] The overall efficiency of an anti-reflective treatment on a substrate having two opposing surfaces, such as an optical lens, for angles of incidence ranging from 0° to 0max can be quantified by the following parameter: (r Θ max j· Θ max í Rvfronial(0) sin θ άθ + I Rv (0) sin 0 άθ

[0087] Where Rvfrontal (0) represents the average light reflection factor for the main front face of the substrate and Rvtraseiro (0) represents the average light reflection factor for the main rear face of the substrate for an angle of incidence 0.

[0088] Approximate values ​​for the coefficient a2 can be computed in a similar way to the coefficient a. In particular, the numerical constant K2 is computed so as to have a coefficient a2 equal to 1% for the model functions Rvfrontal (Θ) and Rvtraseiro (Θ) being constant and equal to 1%.

[0089] In a specific embodiment, Omax is defined as 45°, Θ1 is defined as 25°, Rv1Λ is defined as Rv(15°) for front and back faces, Rv2Λ is defined as Rv(35°) for front and back faces, and the resulting formula for the coefficient a2 is as follows, the computation of which is detailed in the experimental section: al = 0.159.(1^ (15°) + a“(150)) + 0.341 .(R™ (35°) + tf(35°)),

[0090] This parameter is particularly significant because it takes into account both low and high angles of incidence.

[0091] Low α or a2 values ​​indicate high multi-angle efficiency of an anti-reflective treatment. The a2 parameter of the present optical lens is preferably equal to or less than 0.7, more preferably equal to or less than 0.6, even better equal to or less than 0.55. This high level of multi-angle efficiency of the anti-reflective property is obtained by optical lenses having an anti-reflective coating on both main faces according to the invention.

[0092] The α parameter of an anti-reflective coating according to the invention is preferably equal to or less than any of the following values: 0.85, 0.75, Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 33 / 107 19 / 40 0.70, 0.60, 0.50 and 0.40. An anti-reflective coating on the front surface of the lens preferably has an α parameter equal to or less than 0.85, more preferably equal to or less than 0.75, even better equal to or less than 0.70, 0.60 or 0.50. An anti-reflective coating on the front surface of the lens preferably has an α parameter equal to or less than 0.70, more preferably equal to or less than 0.60, even better equal to or less than 0.50 and much better equal to or less than 0.40.

[0093] The “average light reflection factor”, denoted Rv, also called “light reflection”, is defined in ISO 13666:1998 and measured according to ISO 8980-4 (for an angle of incidence less than 17°, normally 15°), that is, it is the weighted average of spectral reflection across the entire visible spectrum between 380 and 780 nm. The same can be measured for all angles of incidence q, thus defining a function Rv(q).

[0094] The average light reflection factor Rv can be defined by the following equation: R_ / ;7>(λ)·ν(λ)·Οκ(λ)·άλ 47'ν(λ)Ο«(Λ>άΛ

[0095] where R(À) is the reflectance at a wavelength λ, V(À) is the sensitivity function of the eye in the color space defined by the CIE (International Commission on Illumination, in French “Commission Internationale de l'Éclairage”) in 1931 and D65 (λ) is the illuminant of daylight defined in the CIE S005 / E-1998 standard.

[0096] The illuminant can be adapted according to the lighting situation. For example, a derived Rv function can be defined for indoor lighting situations using an LED illuminant instead of the usual D65.

[0097] The average light reflection factor Rv of a highly reflective coating or “mirror” coating is greater than 2.5%. The average light reflection factor Rv of an anti-reflective coating according to the invention is preferably equal to or less than 2.5%, more preferably equal to or less than 2% or 1%, even more preferably < 0.85%.

[0098] The characterization of the blue-violet radiation filtering performance of a lens, associated with long-term protection, is carried out by calculating a Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 34 / 107 20 / 40 weighted average blockage of blue-violet radiation from 400 to 455 nm, which corresponds to the harmful part of blue radiation as defined in ISO TR20772:2018 and in several peer-reviewed articles (Marie et al., Cell Death and Disease, 2020), (Marie et al., Cell Death and Disease, 2018), (Arnault, Barrau et al., 2013): BVC(B') = 100% Β'(λ) · Τ(λ) ·άλ _ MOOnntv 7 v 7f*5nSnmΒ'(λ) ·άλ7400ηηιv 7

[0099] or

[0100]

[0101] where BVC(B) = 100% Τ(λ): transmittance (%) ft? Β(λ) · Τ(λ) · άλ -*400 nmv 7 v 7ί?ηη,Β(λ)·άλ 400 nm '7

[0102] Β'(λ): blue radiation hazard function defined in the peer-reviewed article (Arnault et al., PlosOne, 2013) and consistent with the ISO definition of harmful blue radiation from 400 to 455 nm (ISO TR 20772:2018).

[0103] Β(λ): blue radiation hazard function (ISO 8980-3: Annex B), much broader than the refined B', proposed in the 1970s by ICNIRP.

[0104] The way BVC and Tv are calculated is similar: for both, the spectral transmittance of the lens is weighted by a biological function. For BVC, this is the blue hazard function for the retina B', and for TV, this is the photopic visual sensitivity function of the eye (V).

[0105] In addition to its impact on cumulative retinal damage, blue light radiation promotes glare discomfort (Bullough, 2009) and can promote symptoms of visual fatigue as it spreads further in the eye. In this sense, for short-term light protection, comfort is specifically calculated by weighting the spectral transmittance of the lens across the entire blue range from 380 to 500 nm with the spectral emission of a reference LED spectrum (CIE 015:2018) (Alexander Kokka et al. 2018 Metrologia 55 526) representative of the emission from digital screens based on LED. The spectral range may be limited to 430-470 nm in some modes, or even be from 440 to 460 nm, since the maximum emission is around 450 nm.

[0106] Filtering in this range can also provide improved visual performance. Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 35 / 107 21 / 40 due to increased contrast sensitivity.

[0107] To quantify the blocking of short wavelengths, i.e., blue light from, for example, LED car headlights, a parameter called the CutLED light blocking factor can be used. CutLED is defined as follows: 500 r500 Cut LED = 100 - — * T(A) * LED emission (λ) £50°οη LED emission (λ) ''A—doOv ζ

[0108] where Σ is a distinct or continuous sum operator, i.e., integral, λ is the wavelength in nm, T% of the lens is the spectral transmittance of the lens in % and LED emission is the spectral distribution of a white light-emitting diode. Since the light blocking factor is a weighted function of the light source, the exact type of light source is not relevant, so the main emission peak of the light source lies in a wavelength range between 430 nm and 480 nm, in particular between 440 nm and 465 nm.

[0109] The calculated CutLED is also indicative of the ability to filter sunlight, as the solar spectrum also comprises a high level of emission in the 430 nm to 480 nm range.

[0110] In one embodiment, LED emission is defined as a % in the Cut LED formula above.

[0111] The aforementioned short-term light protection score 10 can be determined with only one short-term attribute 12 or with a combination of a plurality of short-term attributes 12.

[0112] To determine the short-term light protection score 10 of the short-term light protection attributes 12, a distinct score is assigned, for example, from 0 to 4, depending on the technical values ​​and relative to normative recommendations or standards or field tests. For luminous transmittance, a continuous score may be used to have more precision in the level of protection provided by the optical product.

[0113] For a bright light environment, the luminous transmission ranges (Tv) are defined according to the standards presented above. The highest score Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 36 / 107 22 / 40 being assigned to the lower-end TV values. Regarding polarization efficiency, a first threshold value of 78% is provided (ISO standards). The second, at 95%, is defined from our internal knowledge, allowing us to discriminate the product's performance. Two threshold values ​​(1% and 0.5%) for haze are also based on internal R&D studies. The 1% value corresponds to discomfort felt by the user, and the 0.5% value to an aesthetic threshold. Similarly, for Rv, the first threshold value of 2.5% is provided by ISO standards, and the second, at 5%, is defined from our internal knowledge, allowing us to discriminate the product's performance.

[0114] For an indoor office lighting environment, the luminous transmission ranges (Tv) are also defined according to the standards presented in the previous section. However, the highest score is assigned to the higher range TV values. The same characteristics and explanations provided for a bright lighting environment apply here to indoor office lighting with respect to α and Rv values. Long-term light protection attributes

[0115] The method in question then includes a step of determining at least one long-term light protection score 14 representative of at least one long-term light protection attribute 16 of the said optical product, at least one.

[0116] A long-term light protection score refers to eye health. It refers to the ability of the optical product to limit the negative impact of light on eye health.

[0117] Long-term attributes can be chosen from blue light filtering (“CUT_LED”, especially between 400 and 455 nm), ultraviolet radiation protection (between 100 and 380 nm) and infrared radiation protection (between 780 and 1400 nm). All short-term attributes relating to the frame can also be considered as long-term attributes, as they can have an impact on eye health.

[0118] For long-term light protection, the blue light blocking function is Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 37 / 107 23 / 40 preferably between 400 and 455 nm (see equations BVC(B') and BVC(B) above).

[0119] The aforementioned protection against ultraviolet radiation corresponds to the ability of the optical product to reduce transmission from the front side of the lens and reflection from the back side of the lens in the UVA and UVB radiation ranges (respectively 315 to 380 nm and 280 to 315 nm), in order to allow the best protection of health against UV radiation.

[0120] It is advisable for a spectacle wearer to use an ophthalmic lens in front of each eye that strongly reduces reflection on the back surface in the UVA and UVB radiation ranges, which can be harmful to the anterior part of the eye (cornea and lens).

[0121] UV light reflection is not really problematic on the front surface of the lens, since most of the UV radiation that comes from in front of the user and could reach the user's eye (normal incidence, 0 to 15°) is generally absorbed by the ophthalmic lens substrate. On the other hand, UV radiation resulting from light sources located behind the user can reflect off the back surface of the lens and reach the user's eye if the lens does not have an anti-reflective coating that is effective in the ultraviolet region, thus potentially affecting the user's health. It is accepted that the light rays that can reflect off the back surface of the lens and reach the user's eye have a narrow range of incidence angles, varying from 30 to 45° (oblique incidence).

[0122] In this regard, the anti-reflective coating on the main rear face of the optical lens and, optionally, the anti-reflective coating on its main front face, which exhibits very good anti-reflective performance in the visible region, are preferably at the same time capable of significantly reducing the reflection of UV radiation, especially ultraviolet A and ultraviolet B rays, compared to an uncovered substrate or a substrate composed of a traditional anti-reflective coating that is only efficient in the visible region.

[0123] The average UV reflection factor on the main rear face between 280 nm and 380 nm, weighted by the W(A) function defined in ISO 13666:1998, is preferably less than 5%, preferably less than 4.5%, more Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 38 / 107 24 / 40 preferably equal to or less than 4%, even better equal to or less than 3% at an angle of incidence of 35°. In another embodiment, the average UV reflection factor on the main rear face between 280 nm and 380 nm, weighted by the W(A) function defined in ISO 13666:1998, is preferably less than 5% for both an angle of incidence of 30° and an angle of incidence of 45°. The aforementioned average UV reflection factor is defined by the following relationship: 380 r> _ 280__________________ 380 280

[0124] where R(À) represents the spectral reflection factor of the lens at a given wavelength, and W(À) represents a weighting function equal to the product of the solar spectrum irradiance Es(À) and the relative spectral efficiency function δ(λ). In certain embodiments, this factor can be measured at an angle of incidence ranging from 30° to 45° on the back face.

[0125] The spectral function W(λ), which allows the calculation of ultraviolet radiation transmission factors, is defined according to ISO 13666:1998. It makes it possible to express the distribution of mitigated ultraviolet solar radiation by the relative spectral efficiency of that radiation for the user, since it simultaneously takes into account both the solar spectral energy Es(λ), which globally emits fewer UVB rays compared to UVA rays, and the spectral efficiency S(λ), with UVB rays being more harmful than UVA rays. The values ​​for these three functions in the ultraviolet region are provided in the table revealed in ISO 13666:1998 (which is reproduced on page 6 of publication WO 2012 / 076714).

[0126] The above anti-UV performance is provided by the anti-reflective coating, maintaining low Rv factors for a wide range of incidence angles.

[0127] When the optical product is eyeglasses, UV protection can also be defined using an ESPF index. Document EP 2 607 884 proposes calculating said ESPF index which quantifies the overall reduction of ultraviolet radiation achieved by Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 39 / 107 25 / 40 glasses in question and combines for this purpose a transmission value through the glasses and a reflection value from the back of the glasses.

[0128] The ESPF index thus calculated makes possible an objective approach to evaluating the protection against ultraviolet radiation provided by various possible eyewear. In fact, when aiming to protect a user's eyes against ultraviolet radiation by means of eyewear, it is necessary to take into account not only the radiation transmitted through the lenses of these eyewear, but also the rays reflected from the back of these lenses.

[0129] The aforementioned long-term light protection score 14 can be determined with only one long-term attribute 16 or with a combination of a plurality of long-term attributes 16.

[0130] At least one light protection level 18 of at least one optical product is then evaluated based on the aforementioned protection scores of at least one short-term 10 and at least one long-term 12.

[0131] In addition to their ability to provide visual correction, optical lenses can thus be characterized by a large set of technical attributes that contribute differently to the modulation of light.

[0132] The aforementioned level of light protection allows an optical product to be evaluated by considering the combination of short-term and long-term attributes to better reflect the optical product's ability to provide comfort and light resistance, as well as reduce the negative impact of light on eye health.

[0133] The aforementioned light protection level may be used by displaying the aforementioned short-term light protection score of 10 and the aforementioned long-term score of 14 in the same graph or area. In other words, the aforementioned short-term light protection scores of 10 and long-term scores of 14 may be used as components of the light protection level to help distinguish how the light protection level is composed. For example, the aforementioned short-term light protection score of 10 and the aforementioned long-term score of 14 may be displayed so that the aforementioned short-term light protection score of 10 is Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 40 / 107 26 / 40 positioned relative to the aforementioned first dimension and the aforementioned, at least one, long-term light protection score of 14 positioned relative to the aforementioned second dimension, on the same graph. The aforementioned first and second dimensions can be axes of a rectangular coordinate system, as shown in Figure 8, where a light protection level of an optical product is positioned relative to the x-axis coordinate (short-term) and the y-axis coordinate (long-term). Optical product quality attributes

[0134] As shown in Figure 1, the said method may also comprise a step of determining at least one vision experience score 22 representative of at least one optical product quality attribute 24 of said at least one optical product. At least one short-term global light protection score 26 is then determined based on said at least one short-term light protection score 10 and said at least one vision experience score 22. The said at least one light protection level or global light protection score 20 of said at least one optical product is then evaluated based on said at least one short-term global light protection score 26 and said at least one long-term light protection score 14.

[0135] A vision experience light protection score of 22 refers to optical product features that could degrade user comfort and light resistance, such as low-quality lenses. This vision experience light protection score thus acts as a weighting factor for the short-term light protection score of 10. Preferably, the said vision experience light protection score of 22 is a weighting factor that is less than 1. The said vision experience light protection score of 22 can thus only reduce the short-term light protection score of 10.

[0136] For each optical product quality attribute, a score between 0.5 and 1 may be applied, more preferably between 0.8 and 1, according to the values Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 41 / 107 27 / 40 technicians.

[0137] The optical product quality attributes 24 can be chosen from at least ghost image transmission (Tgi), luminous transmittance (Tv), multi-angle efficiency criterion (Rv, Rs), ghost image transmission (Tgi), haze, color saturation (chroma) and yellowing (b*).

[0138] Luminous transmittance is preferably considered an attribute of optical product quality for environments illuminated with artificial light, such as night driving, indoor, and night screen environments. In this type of lighting environment, most of the light exposure comes from point light sources and peripheral light sources. As indicated above, luminous transmittance refers to a quantity of light experienced by the user at a significant level. Luminous transmittance is thus an attribute that is considered to reduce the user's viewing experience if this attribute is too high. This is why luminous transmittance is considered an attribute of optical product quality in this type of lighting environment.

[0139] The multi-angle efficiency criterion (Rv, Rs) is preferably considered as an attribute of optical product quality for environments with natural light, such as a bright light environment and daytime driving. In this type of light environment, the amount of light experienced by the user is at an important level.

[0140] The aforementioned ghost image transmission (Tgi) is a colorimetric suitable for evaluating the intensity and visibility of the ghost image as defined in European Patent Application No. 20306264.1. This ghost image is generated by an internal reflection within the lens. It can be calculated using the photopic visibility function. This parameter can be based on the calculation of the ghost image spectrum and also includes the spectrum of the light source and the CIE 1964 observer, which is considered more relevant than the conventional CIE 1931 observer.

[0141] To calculate the colorimetric parameters, in a first step, the transmittance spectrum of the ghost image is used. The transmittance spectrum allows us to obtain descriptive information about the color of the ghost image. From this, it is derived Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 42 / 107 28 / 40 is a numerical parameter that concisely and accurately describes and evaluates ghost images.

[0142] A numerical simulation tool was developed in Matlab to calculate the transmittance spectrum of the ghost image. The transmittance spectrum of the ghost image can also be calculated in the vStack function of the Macleod software (available with Macleod Enhanced Edition).

[0143] The numerical simulation is based on the following premises: - approximation of two parallel surfaces (lens correction not accounted for), - Absorption and substrate thickness are taken into account, - calculation performed with an angle of incidence of 15 degrees.

[0144] The angle of incidence is defined as 15 degrees to represent an average angle of observation. However, any non-zero angle of incidence, preferably between 5 and 30 degrees, may be used if necessary to match more particular sets of conditions.

[0145] The ghost image color is calculated using the ghost image transmittance in the spectral range of 380 to 780 nm.

[0146] The reference illuminant selected here is, for example, the reference illuminant that is an LED having a color temperature between 2700 Kelvin and 6000 Kelvin, in particular a 4000 K LED, or any point source, such as a filament lamp, a halogen lamp or even the sun (as revealed here, a point light source is a light source that appears small compared to the observer's field of view through the lens. For example, the angular size of the source is more than 5 to 10 times smaller than the observer's total field of view.

[0147] Color is calculated using the following tools: the necessary color calculation functions have been implemented in Matlab (also available as a commercial toolbox) and Macleod has a built-in color calculation function.

[0148] In the CIE XYZ color coordinate system, the RV of a coating Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 43 / 107 29 / 40 antireflective corresponds to the tristimulus value Y (the value representing luminance) calculated from the antireflective reflectance with a 2-degree observer (CIE 1931 observer). TGI is defined here as the tristimulus value Y of the ghost image transmittance, calculated instead with a 10-degree observer (or CIE 1964 observer). The 10-degree observer is an updated version of the 2-degree observer, providing corrections in the blue wavelength range and is the CIE recommendation for color calculation. Like RV, TGI is expressed as a percentage. In other words, TGI corresponds to a colorimetric parameter that represents the luminance of the ghost image color based on the sensitivity of the human eye of the CIE 1964 photopic observer and based on the spectrum of a point source illuminant (rather than the standard D65 reference).

[0149] The ghost image transmission, or ghost image transmission coefficient, denoted TGI, for a two-surface optical system is calculated by the following expression (I): TCI(15°) = 100 4»o S(À)Ta, lS°)y10(Á)d> Cs(À)y,„(À)dX

[0150] where S(λ) represents the spectrum of the light source depending on the wavelength λ in the visible spectral range between 380 nm and 780 nm, T(λ, 15°) represents the transmittance of the ghost image depending on the wavelength λ for an angle of incidence of 15 degrees, and is the spectral light efficiency for a CIE 1964 photopic observer (also known as a “10° observer”).

[0151] The ghost image transmittance for a two-surface optical system is calculated using the following expression (II): T(À, 15°) = TCx(À, 15°). RBCc(À, a). RBCx(À,a).TCc(À,a). (Tjnt(À,a))3

[0152] where TCx(À, 15°) represents the spectral transmission of the incident light beam through the first (convex) surface for an angle of incidence of 15 degrees depending on the wavelength λ, RBCc(À, a) represents the spectral reflection of the light beam on the second (concave) surface 12 for a reflection that Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 44 / 107 30 / 40 occurs from the interior of the substrate medium for a refraction angle α depending on the wavelength λ, RBCx(΀, α) represents the spectral reflection of the light beam on the first (convex) surface for a reflection occurring from the interior of the substrate medium for a refraction angle α depending on the wavelength λ, TCc(΀, α) represents the spectral transmission of the light beam through the second (concave) surface for a transmission occurring from the substrate medium to the air for a refraction angle α depending on the wavelength λ, and Tint(΀, α) represents the spectral transmission of the light beam through the substrate supporting the first and second surfaces for a refraction angle α depending on the wavelength λ.

[0153] For an angle of incidence of 15 degrees, the angle of refraction a is derived from the Snell-Descartes formula: narsene(15 ] risubstrateSine (cc)

[0154] where nar is the refractive index of air and nsubstrate is the refractive index of the lens substrate.

[0155] In the case of an optical system with two surfaces, a numerical limit for ghost image visibility of 0.007% was determined. In other words, in the case N=2, the numerical limit of ghost image visibility is identified as TGI = 0.007%.

[0156] Using the TGI(15°) formula above, the coatings on the first and second surfaces can be optimized to obtain a ghost image transmission that is below the ghost image visibility numerical limit value of 0.007%.

[0157] Figure 2 shows an example of vision experience light protection scores 22 or weighting factor matching for optical product quality attributes. For example, a weighting factor of 0.8 can be applied to the short-term light protection score 10 when fogging is above 1. In this example, the aforementioned overall light protection score 26 is determined as the product between the aforementioned vision experience light protection scores 22 and the aforementioned protection score Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 45 / 107 31 / 40 against short-term light 10. Global light protection score

[0158] The aforementioned assessment of at least one level of protection may also comprise a step in determining at least one overall light protection score 20 of said at least one optical product. The said at least one overall light protection score 20 is determined based on the said at least one short-term light protection score 10 and at least one long-term light protection score 14. It allows the ECP or the user to have a single score to assess the level of light protection of an optical product representative of short-term and long-term light protection.

[0159] According to a preferred embodiment, the aforementioned global light protection score 20 is calculated using the following equation.

[0160] OVERALL LIGHT PROTECTION SCORE = Average ((Light protection score ST * Light protection score VE); Light protection score LT)

[0161] With

[0162] Light protection score ST = (Attributes_1*Weighting_1 + Attributes_2*Weighting_2) / 4

[0163] VE light protection score = (Attributes_1*Weighting_1 + Attributes_2*Weighting_2 + Attributes_3*Weighting_3

[0164] Light protection score LT = (Attributes_1*Weighting_1 + Attributes_2*Weighting_2) / 4 Light environments

[0165] In a more preferred embodiment, the aforementioned method comprises a step of determining at least one light environment that is considered bothersome in terms of light conditions. The said light environments may be chosen from a list of predetermined light environments or determined depending on the user's habits and usage.

[0166] In a first modality in which the lighting environments are determined according to the user, the lighting components of said environment Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 46 / 107 32 / 40 light levels can be modulated according to the light conditions most commonly experienced by the user or considered by the user to be the most uncomfortable light conditions. Alternatively, said light environments can be determined using a measuring device positioned on the user. Said measuring device can be worn by the user over a period of time, allowing for the measurement of different light environments encountered by the user and better defining said light environment. Said measuring device can be integrated into said optical product to update said light environment over time.

[0167] In a second modality where light environments are chosen from a list of light environments, said light environment is preferably chosen from a bright light environment, a daytime driving environment, a nighttime driving environment, an indoor environment, a nighttime screen environment, an inside-to-outside transition environment, and an outside-to-inside transition environment. These seven light environments have been identified, frequently described as uncomfortable (Transitions, Light Experience Quiz, 22,660 respondents), representative of our daily lives with five static indoor or outdoor conditions and 2 transitions.

[0168] The aforementioned bright light environment may correspond to an outdoor situation representing a user walking in an open area on a bright sunny day. This illuminated environment is characterized by high levels of intensity and point reflection of light (sea, reflection from buildings, etc.), ultraviolet radiation, and exposure to blue light. In this illuminated environment, people need to close or half-close their eyes when exposed to harsh light that is too intense compared to the resistance of the retina. If the exposure is brief, adaptation to the light flux occurs. Whereas, if it is prolonged, saturation of the retinal processes will occur and a blinding glare will be experienced.

[0169] The aforementioned daytime driving environment corresponds to an outdoor situation representing a user driving on a bright sunny day.

[0170] The aforementioned night driving environment corresponds to a situation in Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 47 / 107 33 / 40 exterior depicting a user driving at night without road lighting. Vehicle headlights can result in discomfort and / or glare at night. Headlights are a focal or point source of artificial light – the smaller they are, the more visual discomfort they will produce, and the closer they are, the more disabling they will be. Individuals suffering from disabling discomfort / glare while driving will transition from low light levels (at night) to a sudden peak of light intensity (headlights). The variation in comfort and vision will depend on the light intensity before the stimulus.

[0171] The aforementioned indoor environment may correspond to an indoor situation representing a user working on their computer in an office with natural light. There is a high correlation between the luminance of a glare source (i.e., intensity) and the degree of discomfort. The uncomfortable perception of glare also depends on the observer's spatial situation relative to the glare source. Furthermore, the more peripheral the position of the glare source, the less discomfort is perceived. There is also a growing concern that LED-based light sources may cause more glare, as they have the characteristics of high surface luminance, small emission size, and special spectral power distribution due to their peculiar emission principle. Computer screens, LEDs, mobile phones, and a whole range of connected devices have had an impact on our daily lives.Both exposure time and proximity to the source affect visual discomfort (Coles-Brenann et al., 2019).

[0172] The aforementioned transitional environments from inside to outside and from outside to inside correspond to transitions from inside to outside and from outside to inside, respectively. If a user leaves an outdoor environment on a bright sunny day and enters a dimly lit room, initially they can hardly see what is around them. However, over time, the user gradually recovers their vision. This phenomenon is known as "dark adaptation" or the eye's ability to become more visually sensitive after remaining in darkness for a period of time. On the other hand, light adaptation occurs when Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 48 / 107 34 / 40 A user moves from darkness to bright light. The bright light momentarily dazzles the user, and all they see is white light because the sensitivity of the receptors is adjusted to soft light. In both scenarios, time is needed to regain comfort and good visual performance. This time depends on several factors, including the light level before the light change and the significance of the light jump (sudden change in intensity). The retina takes longer to adapt again to low light flux; in these cases, the term "vision recovery" is frequently used.

[0173] The aforementioned method may then comprise a selection step of at least one short-term light protection attribute 12 and at least one long-term light protection attribute 16 depending on the aforementioned, at least one, light environment. In other words, the short-term and long-term light protection attributes may be specifically chosen relative to the light environment that has been determined. The same applies to optical product quality attributes which may be selected depending on the light environment.

[0174] Figure 3 shows an example of determining the attributes based on the seven most bothersome light environments. “ST Att. X” refers to the short-term light protection attribute 12, “LT Att. X” refers to the long-term light protection attribute 16, and “OPQ Att. X” refers to the optical product quality attribute 24. These attributes are numbered differently for clarity, but different attributes can refer to the same attribute. For example, “ST Att. 1” and “ST Att. 3” can be the same attribute, e.g., luminous transmittance (Tv). Attributes from different categories (short-term, long-term, and viewing experience) can also refer to the same attribute. For example, “LT Att. 7” and “OPQ Att. 1” can be the same attribute, e.g., multi-angle reflection efficiency (Rs, Rv).

[0175] Luminous transmittance (Tv) and polarizing efficiency (PE) can be chosen as short-term attributes when considering a bright light environment. Blue light filtering (BVC(B')) can preferably be considered as the sole long-term light protection attribute for driving environments. Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 49 / 107 35 / 40 night vision, indoor and screen lighting in nighttime environments, since no UV light is emitted or it does not reach the eyes in these lighting conditions.

[0176] According to a preferred embodiment, at least two light environments are considered to evaluate the light protection level of the optical product. More preferably, each of the seven light environments mentioned above is considered for such evaluation.

[0177] In this preferred embodiment, each of the light protection scores is determined for each light environment. In other words, at least one short-term light protection score 10, at least one long-term light protection score 14, and at least one overall light protection score 20 are determined for each determined light environment. A vision experience light protection score 22 is also determined for each light environment when that score is determined. This preferred embodiment is, for example, illustrated in Figure 3, where each light environment refers to specific short-term light protection scores 10, long-term light protection scores 14, and vision experience scores 22.

[0178] This modality is particularly relevant because protection needs are significantly different from one light environment to another, which makes it more realistic to provide a score per light environment. Considerations

[0179] In one aspect, as shown in Figure 4, each attribute among short-term light protection attributes 12 and long-term light protection attributes 16 and optical product quality attributes 24 can be weighted when determining one or more among short-term light protection scores 10 and long-term light protection scores 14 and vision experience light protection score 22. For example, polarizing efficiency (here, ST Att. 2) and luminous transmittance (here, ST Att. 1) can respectively comprise 25% and 75% of the short-term light protection score 10 when considering a daytime driving environment. As another example, multi-angle reflection efficiency (Rv), haze, and color saturation (Chroma) can be equally considered when calculating the vision experience light protection score 22 for a bright light environment. Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 50 / 107 36 / 40

[0180] In a second aspect, a light protection rating score (not shown) can be determined based on each overall light protection score determined for a given light environment. This light protection rating score can be determined using different weightings for the aforementioned overall light protection scores depending on the light environments considered. It allows weighting one or more light environments relative to each other. It is particularly useful to provide this weighting when the user is more exposed to certain environments than others or for a specific use.

[0181] In a third aspect, the aforementioned global light protection score 20 can be determined using different weightings for the aforementioned, at least one, short-term global light protection score 26 and the aforementioned, at least one, long-term light protection score 14. This allows focusing the evaluation of the optical product on short-term or long-term protection, considering both protections.

[0182] The aforementioned assessment method may also include a step to determine at least one light protection need of a user. The aforementioned light protection need may include one or more of at least one physiological and / or optometric parameter, at least one light exposure profile, at least one user preference, at least one posture and eye / head behavior of the user and user activities, as well as the associated visual and cognitive requirement.

[0183] The aforementioned physiological and / or optometric parameter may include age, light sensitivity level, ametropia (type and value), visual or non-visual diseases (AMD, Glaucoma, etc.) and pupil behavior.

[0184] The aforementioned light exposure profile may include light exposure time, light environment mapping and prior light exposure.

[0185] The aforementioned posture and eye / head behavior of the user, which may include the position of the head / eye towards the light sources, may also be considered (head down, forward, etc.). Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 51 / 107 37 / 40

[0186] The aforementioned user activities and the associated visual and cognitive requirements may include user posture and visual performance / comfort, which may vary according to the activities (working on the computer, driving, walking, playing) for which the user's head / eye position will determine different light radiation.

[0187] At least one optical product can then be determined for the user based on the aforementioned, at least one, level of light protection and the aforementioned, at least one, light protection need of the user. In other words, at least one optical product can be identified as compatible with the user's light protection needs.

[0188] When said optical product comprises a frame attached to an optical system, the frame attributes relating to said frame may be considered in assessing said level of light protection. Said frame attributes may be used in determining said short-term light protection score, said long-term light protection score, said vision experience light protection score, or at least two of these. In other words, one or more short-term light protection attributes, long-term light protection attributes, and optical product quality attributes may comprise frame attributes.

[0189] The frame attribute may be the frame's engagement, frame size / thickness / shape, frame material and transparency, or face coverage rate of the optical product (frame and / or lenses).

[0190] The aforementioned frame attributes correspond to the frame's ability to influence the user's light protection. In fact, the frame forms a structural barrier to the user's eye's light exposure. The frame attributes can impact light protection for each short-term light protection, long-term light protection, and vision experience. In fact, when considering both short-term and long-term protection, the frame allows limiting the user's eye's light exposure and thus reduces discomfort and exposure to UV / IR radiation. Considering both short-term and long-term light protection, Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, p. 52 / 107 38 / 40 The more the frame covers the eyes, the more positive the frame is. Conversely, when the frame has significant coverage, the user's viewing experience is reduced. This is why frame attributes can be positively evaluated for short-term and long-term light protection, but negatively for light protection of the viewing experience. Example

[0191] As shown in figures 5 and 6, the level of protection against light can be evaluated for a plurality of optical products to allow comparison between these optical products.

[0192] In this example, the lighting environment considered is a bright lighting environment with: Two dominant attributes selected for PROTECTION SHORT TERM: TV and PE, with weightings: 0.75 (TV) and 0.25 (PE) Two dominant attributes selected for PROTECTION LONG TERM: BVCb' and Espf, with weightings: 0.50; 0.50 Three dominant attributes selected for EXPERIENCE VISION: Rv, Blurred, b*, with weightings: 1 / 3; 1 / 3; 1 / 3

[0193] Here, 15 filters were measured based on these selected attributes.

[0194] For each filter, each technical attribute is measured and reported in the table below (DATA). Then, the attributes are scored based on the ranges defined above between 0 and 4 for ST and LT light protection and between 0.5 and 1 for vision experience.

[0195] Figure 5 shows a table bringing together all the short-term 12 and long-term 16 light protection attributes, as well as the optical product quality attributes 24 in the first upper part of the table. The table also brings together in the second lower part of the table all the scores corresponding to the short-term 12 and long-term 16 light protection attributes, as well as the optical product quality attributes 24.

[0196] Figure 6 shows a table bringing together all the short-term light protection scores 10, the long-term light protection scores 14, the Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 53 / 107 39 / 40 light protection score for vision experience 22, overall short-term light protection score 26, and overall light protection score 20 for each optical product evaluated, for a given light environment.

[0197] The global light protection score 20 from figure 6 is then displayed in a graph in figure 7 for each optical product.

[0198] Figure 8 shows a specific presentation of long-term light protection score 14 and short-term global light protection score 26. Each optical product is represented by a point having coordinates on the x-axis and y-axis. The coordinates on the x and y axes refer respectively to the short-term global light protection score 26 and the long-term light protection score 14.

[0199] This presentation allows for a global view of the light protection level of optical products, as well as each of their components, i.e., the overall short-term light protection score 26 and the long-term light protection score 14. In fact, the diagonal line between the x-axis and the y-axis represents the overall light protection score 20. Therefore, it is possible to first consider the overall light protection level (short-term and long-term) of each optical product by considering the position of each optical product with respect to this diagonal line.

[0200] Meanwhile, each short-term global light protection score 26 and long-term light protection score 14 can still be evaluated independently considering only the x-axis or the y-axis. This type of presentation is therefore very useful for optimizing the information provided to an ECP or a user about the light protection level of optical products. The same type of presentation can be used for different graph forms, keeping each of the short-term global light protection scores 26 and long-term light protection scores 14 associated with different dimensions. For example, the graph can include bubbles, bar graphs, etc.

[0201] The present invention also provides an optical product comprising a frame and at least one optical system attached to said frame and intended Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 54 / 107 40 / 40 facing the user's eye. The optical product is preferably eyeglasses comprising lenses. Said optical product comprises a data collection device and a controller configured to perform the evaluation method described above.

[0202] The aforementioned evaluation method may be a computer-implemented method that may be performed using code instructions from a computer program product or a computer system. The computer system comprises a processor; and a memory with computer code instructions stored therein. The memory is operatively coupled to the processor so that, when executed by the processor, the computer code instructions cause the computer system to perform the light protection level evaluation method. Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 55 / 107

Claims

1 / 4 CLAIMS 1. A method for evaluating at least one level of light protection of at least one optical product intended to be pointed at the eye of a user and comprising a data collection device and a controller configured to perform the method, the method characterized by comprising the following steps: - determination of at least one short-term light protection score representative of at least one short-term light protection attribute of said at least one optical product, said at least one short-term light protection attribute being one of a transmission attribute, a polarization attribute, a scatter light attribute and a spectral attribute;- determination of at least one long-term light protection score representative of at least one long-term light protection attribute of said optical product, wherein said long-term attribute is a spectral attribute; - determination of at least two light environments, said light environments being selected from within a group of light environments, said group of light environments comprising at least one of a bright light environment, a daytime driving environment, a nighttime driving environment, an indoor environment, a nighttime screen environment, an inside-to-outside transition environment and an outside-to-inside transition environment;- selection of said, at least one, short-term light protection attribute and said, at least one, long-term light protection attribute respectively from a group of short-term light protection attributes and a group of long-term light protection attributes, depending on said, at least two, determined light environments; and - evaluation of at least one light protection level of at least one optical product based on said, at least one, short-term protection score and at least one, long-term protection score;wherein the assessment step for at least one level of protection Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 56 / 107 2 / 4, includes a step for determining at least one overall light protection score for said optical product based on said at least one short-term light protection score and at least one long-term light protection score, wherein at least one short-term light protection score, at least one long-term light protection score, and at least one overall light protection score are determined for each determined light environment.

2. A method according to claim 1, characterized in that said at least one short-term light protection score and / or said at least one long-term score are determined using different weightings for said at least one short-term light protection attribute and said at least one long-term light protection attribute, respectively.

3. A method according to any one of claims 1 or 2, further characterized by comprising: - determining at least one vision experience score representative of at least one optical product quality attribute of said at least one optical product, - determining at least one short-term overall light protection score based on said at least one short-term light protection score and said at least one vision experience score, wherein said at least one light protection level of said at least one optical product is evaluated based on said at least one short-term overall light protection score and said at least one long-term light protection score.

4. A method, according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized by comprising the step of determining a light protection rating score based on each overall light protection score determined for a given light environment, wherein said light protection rating score is determined using different weightings for said overall light protection scores depending on at least two given light environments.

5. A method, according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that said global light protection score is determined using different weightings for said, at least one, short-term global light protection score and said, at least one, long-term light protection score.

6. A method, according to any one of claims 1 to 4, in combination with claim 5, characterized in that said, at least one, optical product quality attribute is one of a transmission attribute, a diffuse light attribute, and a residual color perception attribute.

7. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, further characterized by comprising: - determining at least one light protection requirement of a user, - determining at least one optical product for the user based on said at least one light protection level and said at least one light protection requirement of the user.

8. A method according to any one of claims 1 to 7, characterized by further comprising a display step of said at least one short-term light protection score and said at least one long-term score on the same graph having a first and a second dimension, said at least one short-term light protection score being positioned relative to said first dimension and said at least one long-term light protection score being positioned relative to said second dimension.

9. Optical product comprising a frame and at least one optical system fixed to said frame and intended to be directed towards the eye of a user, said optical product comprising a data collection device and a controller configured to perform a method for evaluating at least one level of light protection of said optical product, Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, page 58 / 107 4 / 4 characterized in that the method comprises the following steps: - determination of at least one short-term light protection score representative of at least one short-term light protection attribute of said optical product, said short-term light protection attribute being one of a transmission attribute, a polarization attribute, a scatter light attribute and a spectral attribute;- determination of at least one long-term light protection score representative of at least one long-term light protection attribute of said optical product; - determination of at least two light environments, said light environments being selected from within a group of light environments, said group of light environments comprising at least one of a bright light environment, a daytime driving environment, a nighttime driving environment, an indoor environment, a nighttime display environment, an inside-to-outside transition environment and an outside-to-inside transition environment;- selection of said, at least one, short-term light protection attribute and said, at least one, long-term light protection attribute respectively from a group of short-term light protection attributes and a group of long-term light protection attributes, depending on said, at least two, determined light environments;(e) - assessment of at least one level of light protection of at least one optical product based on said at least one short-term protection score and at least one long-term protection score, wherein the assessment step of at least one level of protection comprises a step of determining at least one overall light protection score of said at least one optical product based on said at least one short-term light protection score and at least one long-term light protection score, wherein at least one short-term light protection score, at least one long-term light protection score and at least one overall light protection score are determined for each determined light environment. Petition 870260032280, dated 07 / 04 / 2026, pp. 59 / 107;