Metrology target design for tilting device design

By calculating Zenik's sensitivity and cost function to optimize the metrology target design, the pattern placement error problem between the metrology target and the device characteristics is solved, and the measurement accuracy and robustness of semiconductor manufacturing are improved, especially under the conditions of the inclined device.

CN112485971BActive Publication Date: 2024-12-03KLA CORP
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202011278298.4
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2015-04-21
Filing Date
2016-04-19
Publication Date
2024-12-03
Estimated Expiration
2036-04-19

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

During semiconductor manufacturing, the pattern placement error between the metering target and the device feature leads to a deviation between the measurement result and the actual device edge placement, affecting the precision and accuracy of semiconductor manufacturing.

Method used

Through the Zenik sensitivity of the computing device design and multiple metrological target designs, the best metrological target design is selected using the cost function to reduce the difference in Zenik sensitivity and optimize the metrological target design, improve the pupil plane position and Zenik polynomial analysis. The Monte Carlo method is applied to improve the robustness and measurement accuracy of the target design.

Benefits of technology

Effectively reduce the difference in pattern placement error between the metering target and the device, improve the accuracy and robustness of measurement, especially under the characteristics of the tilting device, effectively tracking and optimizing the error caused by lens aberration. Improves the process control capabilities of semiconductor manufacturing.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN112485971B_ABST
    Figure CN112485971B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present application relates to metrology target design for tilted device design. The present invention provides metrology methods, modules and targets for measuring tilted device design. The method analyzes and optimizes the target design relative to the relationship of the Zernike sensitivity of the pattern placement error PPE between the target candidate and the device design. Monte Carlo methods can be applied to enhance the robustness of the selected target candidate to changes in lens aberrations and / or in the device design. In addition, it is considered to prudently modify the target parameters relative to the Zernike sensitivity to improve the metrology measurement quality and reduce inaccuracy.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] This application is a divisional application of the invention patent application with the invention name “Measuring target design for tilting device design”, application number 201680021294.3 and application date April 19, 2016.

[0002] CROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS

[0003] This application claims the benefit of U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 62 / 150,290, filed April 21, 2015, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. Technical Field

[0004] The present invention relates to the field of metrology, and more particularly, to metrology target design. Background Art

[0005] In the field of semiconductor metrology, a metrology tool may include: an illumination system that illuminates a target; a collection system that captures relevant information provided by the interaction (or lack of interaction) of the illumination system with a target, device, or feature; and a processing system that analyzes the collected information using one or more algorithms. Metrology tools may be used to measure structural and material properties associated with various semiconductor manufacturing processes (e.g., material composition, dimensional properties of structures and films (e.g., film thickness and / or critical dimensions of structures), overlay, etc.). These measurements are used to facilitate process control and / or yield in the manufacture of semiconductor dies. Metrology tools may include one or more hardware configurations that may be used in conjunction with certain embodiments of the present invention to, for example, measure various of the above-mentioned semiconductor structural and material properties. Examples of such hardware configurations include the following: spectroscopic ellipsometers (SE), SE with multiple illumination angles, SE that measures Mueller matrix elements (e.g., using a rotational compensator), single wavelength ellipsometers, beam profile ellipsometers (angle-resolved ellipsometers), beam profile reflectometers (angle-resolved reflectometers), broadband reflectance spectrometers (spectral reflectometers), single wavelength reflectometers, angle-resolved reflectometers, any imaging system, pupil imaging systems, spectral imaging systems, scatterometers (e.g., speckle analyzers), and the like.

[0006] Hardware configurations can be divided into discrete operating systems. On the other hand, one or more hardware configurations can be combined into a single tool. An example of this combination of multiple hardware configurations to a single tool is provided by U.S. Patent No. 7,933,026 (including, for example, broadband SE, SE with a rotating compensator, beam profile ellipsometer, beam profile reflectometer, broadband reflective spectrometer, and deep ultraviolet reflective spectrometer), which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. In addition, there are usually numerous optical elements in such systems, including certain lenses, collimators, mirrors, quarter-wave plates, polarizers, detectors, cameras, apertures and / or light sources. The wavelength used for the optical system can be changed from about 120nm to 3 microns. For non-ellipsometer systems, the collected signals can be polarization-resolved or unpolarized. Multiple metrology heads can be integrated on the same tool, however, in many cases, multiple metrology tools are used to measure single or multiple metrology targets, as described, for example, in U.S. Patent No. 7,478,019, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.

[0007] The illumination system of certain hardware configurations includes one or more light sources. The light source can generate light having only one wavelength (i.e., monochromatic light), light having several discrete wavelengths (i.e., polychromatic light), light having multiple wavelengths (i.e., broadband light), and / or light that sweeps wavelengths continuously or jumps between wavelengths (i.e., a tunable source or swept source). Examples of suitable light sources are: a white light source, an ultraviolet (UV) laser, an arc lamp or an electrodeless lamp, a laser sustained plasma (LSP) source, a supercontinuum source (e.g., a broadband laser source), or a shorter wavelength source such as an x-ray source, an extreme UV source, or some combination thereof. The light source can also be configured to provide light having sufficient brightness, which in some cases can be greater than about 1 W / (nm cm 2 The metering system may also include fast feedback to the light source for stabilizing its power and wavelength. The output of the light source may be delivered via free space propagation, or in some cases via any type of optical fiber or light guide.

[0008] The metrology target may possess various spatial properties and is typically constructed from one or more cells that may include features in one or more layers that may have been printed in one or more photolithographically distinct exposures. The target or cells may possess various symmetries (e.g., two- or four-fold rotational symmetry, reflection symmetry), as described, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 6,985,618, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. Different cells or combinations of cells may belong to distinct layers or exposure steps. Individual cells may include isolated non-periodic features, or alternatively individual cells may be constructed from one-, two-, or three-dimensional periodic structures, or a combination of non-periodic and periodic structures, as described, for example, in U.S. Pat. Publication No. 2013 / 042089, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. The periodic structure may be non-segmented, or the periodic structure may be constructed from finely segmented features that may be at or near the minimum design rules of the photolithographic process used to print the features. The metrology target may also be juxtaposed or in close proximity to a virtualized structure in the same layer of the metrology structure or in a layer above, below, or between the layers of the metrology structure. The target may include multiple layers (or films) whose thicknesses may be measured by the metrology tool. The target may include a target design placed (or already present) on a semiconductor wafer for use, for example, with alignment and / or overlay registration operations. Certain targets may be positioned at various locations on a semiconductor wafer. For example, the target may be positioned within a dicing street (e.g., between dies) and / or in the die itself. Multiple targets may be measured by the same or multiple metrology tools (simultaneously or at different times), as described, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 7,478,019, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. Data from such measurements may be combined. Data from metrology tools are used in semiconductor manufacturing processes, for example, to feed forward, feed back, and / or feed sideways corrections to processes (e.g., lithography, etching), see, for example, U.S. Pat. No. 8,930,156, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety, which discloses a feed forward method for reusing metrology target cells; and thus, a complete process control solution may be produced. Metrology tools are designed to make many different types of measurements related to semiconductor manufacturing, for example, measuring characteristics of one or more targets (e.g., critical dimension, overlay, sidewall angle, film thickness, process related parameters (e.g., focus and / or dose)). Targets may include certain regions of interest that are periodic in nature, such as, for example, gratings in a memory die.

[0009] As semiconductor device pattern sizes continue to shrink, smaller metrology targets are often required. In addition, measurement accuracy and matching with actual device characteristics increase the demand for device-like targets as well as in-die and even on-device measurements. Various metrology implementations have been proposed to achieve that goal. For example, focused beam ellipsometry based on primarily reflective optics is described in, for example, U.S. Pat. No. 5,608,526, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. Apodizers can be used to mitigate optical diffraction effects that cause illumination points to spread beyond the size defined by geometric optics, as described, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 5,859,424, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. The use of high numerical aperture tools with simultaneous multi-incident angle illumination is another way to achieve small target capabilities, as described, for example, in U.S. Pat. No. 6,429,943, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. Other measurement examples may include measuring the composition of one or more layers of a semiconductor stack, measuring certain defects on (or within) a wafer, and measuring the amount of lithographic radiation exposed to a wafer. In some cases, metrology tools and algorithms may be configured for measuring non-periodic targets, as described, for example, in U.S. Patent Application No. 14 / 294,540 and in U.S. Patent Publication No. 2014 / 0222380, which are incorporated herein by reference in their entirety.

[0010] The measurement of the parameters of interest typically involves several algorithms implemented by corresponding analysis units in the respective metrology tools. For example, the optical interaction of the incident beam with the sample is modeled using an EM (electromagnetic) solver and using such algorithms as RCWA (rigorous coupled wave analysis), FEM (finite element method), method of moments, surface integration method, volume integration method, FDTD (finite difference time domain) and others. The target of interest is typically modeled (parameterized) using a geometry engine or, in some cases, a process modeling engine, or a combination of both. The use of process modeling is described, for example, in U.S. Patent Publication No. 2014 / 0172394, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. The geometry engine is implemented, for example, in KLA-Tencor's AcuShape software product.

[0011] The collected data may be analyzed by a number of data fitting and optimization techniques and technologies, including libraries, fast degradation models; regression; machine learning algorithms, such as neural networks, support vector machines (SVM); dimensionality reduction algorithms, such as, for example, PCA (principal component analysis), ICA (independent component analysis), LLE (local linear embedding); sparse representations, such as Fourier or wavelet transforms; Kalman filters; algorithms that facilitate matching from the same or different tool types, and others. The collected data may also be analyzed by algorithms that do not include modeling, optimization, and / or fitting modeling, as described, for example, in U.S. Patent Publication No. 2014 / 0257734, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. Computational algorithms are typically optimized for metrology applications, using one or more methods, such as design and implementation of computing hardware, parallelization, distribution of computations, load balancing, multi-service support, dynamic load optimization, and the like. Different implementations of the algorithms may be accomplished in firmware, software, FPGAs (field programmable gate arrays), programmable optical device components, and the like. The data analysis and fitting steps typically pursue one or more of the following objectives: measurement of CD (critical dimension), SWA (sidewall angle), shape, stress, composition, film, bandgap, electrical properties, focus / dose, overlay, generation process parameters (e.g., resist state, partial pressure, temperature, focus model), and / or any combination thereof; modeling and / or design of metrology systems; and modeling, design, and / or optimization of metrology targets.

[0012] Metrology targets in general and overlay metrology targets in particular are needed to accurately represent the relative placement between device features in different layers. The presence of optical aberrations in known exposure tools can induce pattern placement errors that depend on variations in the spatial characteristics of the features. Furthermore, extreme off-axis illumination combined with masks containing OPCs are often used for the most critical layers in advanced semiconductor manufacturing nodes, increasing the placement error sensitivity to scanner aberrations. Therefore, any difference between the spatial characteristics of the device relative to the spatial characteristics of the metrology target is likely to induce a deviation between the metrology results and the actual device edge placement, which is sought in order to provide correctable control back to the lithography exposure tool. For example, U.S. Pat. Nos. 8,214,771 and 7,925,486, which are incorporated herein by reference in their entirety, teach the use of lithography or metrology simulations in order to predict the performance of metrology targets in terms of precision, accuracy, and device-related aspects. Lithography simulations are used in order to predict aberration-induced pattern placement errors of metrology targets and compare the aberration-induced pattern placement errors with the placement errors caused by device features under the same aberration conditions.

[0013] Figure 1is a high-level schematic illustration of an example of the effect of scanner aberrations on device patterns relative to two different types of superimposed metrology marks, illustrating a prior art pattern placement error (PPE) analysis according to the prior art. The difference in pattern placement error between the metrology target and the device features is shown for a given example lens aberration as achieved by lithography simulations through various methods including Kirchoff approximation for mask simulation and full physical model for resist. The difference in pattern placement error between the metrology target and the device features is shown for a given example lens aberration as achieved by lithography simulations through various methods including Kirchoff approximation for mask simulation and full physical model for resist. Figure 1 The gate cutout layer on top of the device shows the difference in PPE between the device and different types of metrology targets (SCOL—Scattermetry Overlay Target and AIM—Advanced Imaging Metrology Target). The illumination source is schematically depicted in Figure 1 Left side of the diagram—Dipole Y illumination source is used for the gate layer (bottom) and C-quad source is used for the gate cutout layer (top). Figure 1 The bottom of shows example lens aberrations used for these PPE calculations (RMS = 8.4 milliwaves, where milliwaves express aberrations, such as lens aberrations per unit wavelength—ie, one thousandth of the wavelength used). Figure 1 The demonstration shows that there are large and uncorrelated PPEs for both processes, leading to large measurement errors. Due to the use of different feature sizes for device and metrology targets, their diffracted wavefronts are almost always different. Therefore, PPE differences between metrology targets and device features are inevitable and the amount of PPE depends strongly on feature size and illumination shape. Summary of the invention

[0014] The following is a simplified summary to provide an initial understanding of the present invention. The summary does not necessarily identify key requirements, nor limit the scope of the present invention, but merely serves as an introduction to the following description.

[0015] One aspect of the present invention provides a method for metrology target design, the method comprising calculating Zernike sensitivities of pattern placement errors (PPEs) of at least one device design and a plurality of metrology target designs, and selecting an optimal metrology target design according to a value of a cost function derived from the calculated Zernike sensitivities, the cost function quantifying similarities of the Zernike sensitivities between the at least one device design and the plurality of metrology target designs.

[0016] One aspect of the present invention provides a method for measuring a target design, the method comprising: for each of at least one device design and a plurality of target design candidates: (i) repeatedly measuring, for a plurality of runs: for a plurality of Zernike polynomials Z i Each of the N i (N i>100) Zernike coefficient values, the values ​​being pseudo-randomly generated relative to a specified distribution within a specified range, calculating a PPE for each of the Zernike polynomials, and calculating a corresponding PPE measurement for the run; and deriving a distribution of the calculated corresponding PPE measurements; (ii) correlating each of the derived target design candidate distributions with at least one derived device design distribution to generate a device correspondence measurement for each target design candidate; and (iii) selecting an optimal metrology target design based on the derived device correspondence measurements.

[0017] One aspect of the present invention provides a method for optimizing a metrology target design, the method comprising starting with an initial target design determined according to metrology performance requirements and using a simulation tool: comparing Zernike sensitivities of pattern placement errors (PPEs) between the initial target design and at least one device design with respect to at least two directions, estimating a process window of the initial target design, and deriving an improved metrology target design from the initial target design by modifying the initial target design to increase the correspondence in Zernike sensitivity and increase the process window.

[0018] One aspect of the present invention provides a method of determining a target design relative to a device design, the method comprising: simulating pupil plane positions of zero-order and first-order diffraction signals of an initial target design and a device design, and modifying at least one parameter in the initial target design to produce an improved target design, the modification being implemented to provide a relationship between pupil plane positions of zero-order and first-order diffraction signals in the improved target corresponding to their relationship in the device design.

[0019] These, additional and / or other aspects and / or advantages of the invention are set forth in the detailed description which follows; may be inferred from the detailed description; and / or may be learned by practice of the invention. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0020] For a better understanding of embodiments of the invention and to show how they may be practiced, reference will now be made, purely by way of example, to the accompanying drawings in which like reference numerals designate corresponding elements or sections throughout.

[0021] In the attached picture:

[0022] Figure 1 A high level schematic illustration of an example of the effects of scanner aberrations on device patterns relative to two different types of superimposed metrology marks, illustrating prior art pattern placement error (PPE) analysis according to the prior art.

[0023] Figure 2 is a high level schematic illustration of various illuminations presented in a pupil plane of an optical system according to the prior art and according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0024] Figure 3A Exemplary simulation results of Zernike sensitivity for a device including line-and-space structures aligned in the x-direction with 100 nm pitch and 50 nm CD under dipole Y illumination according to some embodiments of the invention are illustrated.

[0025] Figure 3B A comparison of Zernike sensitivity between three metrology target candidates and a device with different parameters according to some embodiments of the present invention is demonstrated.

[0026] Figure 4 is a high-level schematic block diagram of a metrology module for target design and / or selection in a metrology system according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0027] Figure 5 and 6 1 is a high-level schematic flow chart of a method of target design and / or selection according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0028] Figure 7 is an illustrative example of a Monte Carlo analysis phase for a method according to some embodiments of the invention.

[0029] Figure 8 is an illustrative example of the Monte Carlo analysis phase of the method applied to conventional and two differently segmented AIM (Advanced Imaging Metrology) target designs according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0030] Fig. 9 is a high-level schematic illustration of device designs according to the prior art, the lighting conditions used to fabricate such devices, and typical imaging metrology objectives.

[0031] Fig.10 is a high-level schematic block diagram of a system 300 for target design and / or optimization according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0032] Fig.11A and 11B An exemplary comparison of different target designs, each compared to the same device with respect to its Zernike sensitivity, according to some embodiments of the invention is presented.

[0033] Fig. 12A is a schematic illustration explaining the sensitivity of a prior art target without Y odd aberration.

[0034] Fig. 12B is a high-level schematic model of oblique lighting according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0035] Fig. 12C is a high level schematic illustration of the effects of target spacing modification at the pupil plane according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0036] Fig.13A and 13B is a high level schematic illustration of the effects of target spacing modification at the pupil plane according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0037] Fig. 13C is a high level schematic illustration of the effect of target spacing on the PPE for different Y coma aberrations according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0038] Fig.14 is a high-level schematic illustration of a proposed method for determining target segmentation with respect to an apparatus according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0039] Fig.15A and 15B Schematically illustrate the method according to the prior art ( Fig.15A ) of some embodiments of the present invention ( Fig. 15B ) is used to improve and optimize the process window.

[0040] Fig.16 is a high-level schematic flow chart of a method for optimizing metrology target design according to some embodiments of the present invention.

[0041] Fig.17 is a high level schematic illustration of a tilt target according to some embodiments of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0042] In the following description, various aspects of the present invention are described. For the purpose of explanation, specific configurations and details are stated in order to provide a detailed understanding of the present invention. However, those skilled in the art will also understand that the present invention can be practiced without the specific details presented herein. In addition, well-known features may have been omitted or simplified so as not to confuse the present invention. With specific reference to the drawings, it is emphasized that the details shown are presented as examples and only for the purpose of illustrative discussion of the present invention, and in order to provide the most useful and easy to understand description of the principles and concepts of the present invention. At this point, no attempt is made to show the structural details of the present invention in more detail than is necessary for a basic understanding of the present invention, and the description in conjunction with the drawings makes it clear to those skilled in the art how several forms of the present invention can be embodied in practice.

[0043] Before explaining at least one embodiment of the present invention in detail, it should be understood that the present invention is not limited in its application to the details of construction and arrangement of components set forth in the following description or illustrated in the drawings. The present invention is applicable to other embodiments that can be practiced or implemented in various ways and to combinations of the disclosed embodiments. In addition, it should be understood that the words and terms used herein are for descriptive purposes and should not be considered limiting.

[0044] Unless expressly provided otherwise, as will be apparent from the following discussion, it should be understood that throughout the specification, discussions utilizing terms such as "processing," "computing," "calculating," "determining," "improving," or the like refer to the actions and / or processes of a computer or computing system, or similar electronic computing device, that manipulates and / or transforms data represented as physical (e.g., electronic) quantities within the computing system's registers and / or memories into other data similarly represented as physical quantities within the computing system's memories, registers, or other such information storage, transmission, or display devices.

[0045] Embodiments of the present invention provide efficient and economical methods and mechanisms for optimizing metrology target designs with respect to metrology parameters, optical aberrations, and process parameters in a manner that improves correspondence between the target and the device.

[0046] A metrology method, module, and target are provided for measuring tilted device designs. The method analyzes and optimizes the target design with respect to the relationship of the Zernike sensitivity of the pattern placement error (PPE) between the target candidate and the device design. Monte Carlo methods can be applied to improve the robustness of the selected target candidate to changes in lens aberrations and / or in the device design. In addition, judicious modification of target parameters with respect to the Zernike sensitivity is considered to improve metrology measurement quality and reduce inaccuracy.

[0047] Figure 2 8 is a high level schematic illustration of various illuminations presented in a pupil plane 90 of an optical system according to the prior art and in accordance with some embodiments of the present invention. Illuminations 80, 85 represent scanner illumination when fabricating devices with pitches of tens to hundreds of nanometers (nm) (e.g., 80 nm is common currently). Illumination 80 represents x-axis illumination (in numerical aperture coordinates NA x ) and illumination 85 represents oblique illumination (i.e., with Na y Component). Illumination 95 represents prior art metrology tool illumination for measuring targets that are at least an order of magnitude larger than the device (typically 1000 to 2000 nm). Due to the larger spacing, illumination 95 covers different pupil coordinates than scanner illumination 80 and is typically free of Na y Arrow 91 indicates the use of even and odd Zernike polynomials and (with corresponding Zernike radial polynomials Practical Ways to Analyze Pupil Plane Aberrations. Since scanner illumination 80, 85 typically uses a different region in pupil plane 90 than that used by prior art metrology illumination 95, it experiences different aberrations and metrology measurements suffer corresponding inaccuracies.

[0048] In the present invention, pupil plane aberrations are used to modify metrology target spacing and metrology illumination 101 via analysis of their representation in Zernike polynomials to provide better correspondence of metrology measurements to device parameters and reduce metrology inaccuracies. The disclosed method achieves optimized metrology targets and predicts pattern placement error (PPE) differences, particularly for patterns tilted from a vertical or horizontal axis in the presence of lens aberrations. The disclosed method relates to the design and / or optimization of the design of metrology targets to be used during semiconductor manufacturing to measure optical and / or structural and / or placement characteristics of device or test features. Examples of optical or structural characteristics include critical dimensions such as height, sidewall angle, spacing, line width, film thickness, refractive index, and overlay between exposures between different layers or within a single layer. The designed metrology targets can also be used to measure focus and dose of lithographic patterning of semiconductor devices. The method achieves the design and / or optimization of metrology targets that track pattern placement errors induced by aberrations caused by device features more effectively than the prior art. The method achieves the design of robust metrology targets that minimize placement error differences, particularly for tilted device features relative to the vertical / horizontal direction. Advantageously, the disclosed method optimizes imaging overlay objectives specifically for slanted line and space patterns in memory applications and can produce an estimated 26% reduction in pattern placement error.

[0049] Certain embodiments include a target design method that (i) implements Zernike sensitivity analysis using a cost function and / or (ii) uses a Monte Carlo method to analyze sensitivities and achieves design optimization for device aberration tracking. The disclosed method can be integrated in a metrology target design process in various ways, for example: (i) Split alternatives are generated, i.e., detailed configurations of metrology targets can be defined and all or a subset of such design permutations can be analyzed by PPE analysis as described below. A subset of winning competitors can then be sent to a second metrology simulation step that quantifies and ranks the remaining competitors. (ii) The PPE analysis can be performed in parallel with the metrology simulation step to minimize the time to produce results. (iii) A subset of competitors ranked high by the metrology simulation step can be used as input to the PPE analysis.

[0050] PROLITH simulations can be used to build lithography models for the device as well as the target candidates, and the PROLITH Programming Interface (PPI) using Matlab can be used for Zernike sensitivity and Monte Carlo analysis. To demonstrate the concepts, realistic lithography conditions for the use of immersion lithography tools are used in a non-limiting manner. The device is assumed to be a line and space structure aligned in the x-direction, so the correct choice of illumination is as follows Figure 1A dipole Y source is shown in Figure 1. A bright field mask (BFM) with a positive tone development process is used to print the pattern in the resist. A full physical resist model is used together with a Kirchhoff mask simulation mode. It is emphasized that similar methods can be applied to any realistic type of device, target and illumination.

[0051] Zernike sensitivity analysis

[0052] In practice, aberration-free imaging systems have never been achieved due to the difficulty in making perfect lenses, so aberrations are a fundamental problem for lithography lenses. Such lens aberrations can cause positional errors of printed features from the nominal center position, which is called pattern placement error (PPE). The lens aberration behavior can be characterized by the values ​​of 36 Zernike coefficients, and any example of lens aberrations (see, for example) Figure 1 The bottom of the Zernike polynomial term can be expressed as a mixture of Zernike polynomial terms. In particular, the PPE under the influence of lens aberrations can be modeled as expressed in Equation 1, where PPE(Z=0) represents a placement error without lens aberrations and PPE(Z i ) represents the placement error for the i-th Zernike coefficient value.

[0053]

[0054] The Zernike sensitivity to PPE can be defined as provides key information about the superposition performance. It should be noted that since the Z2 and Z3 terms corresponding to the tilt of the phase are generally maintained at zero after correction, Equation 1 only uses i=4, ..., 36. The Y-PPE for devices with i=4, ..., 36 can be initially calculated based on the Zernike coefficient values ​​and can vary from about -80 mW to +80 mW. The inventors have found that the Y-PPE is only effective for devices similar to Figure 1 The odd Zernike polynomials simulated under the conditions of Figure 3A (described in) has sensitivity. Figure 3A Exemplary simulation results of Zernike sensitivity for a device including line-and-space structures aligned in the x-direction with 100 nm pitch and 50 nm CD under dipole Y illumination according to some embodiments of the invention are illustrated. Figure 3A The linear relationship between PPE and Zernike coefficient change in the illustrated case Zernike coefficients Z8, Z11, Z15 and Z20 (111A, 111B) is illustrated. The sensitivity of PPE is different for different Zernike coefficients, resulting in different effects of the coefficients on PPE. A similar analysis can be performed for X-PPE.

[0055] Different targets can be compared with respect to their Zernike sensitivities, and the target with its Zernike sensitivity closest to the device's Zernike sensitivity can be selected to provide an appropriate metrology measurement.Ideally, an ideal overlay target has a device-like Zernike sensitivity given certain lens aberrations of the lithography tool. Figure 3B A comparison of Zernike sensitivities between three metrology target candidates and devices with different parameters according to some embodiments of the present invention is demonstrated. Figure 3B Results of calculating the Y-PPE of the device and target according to each Zernike term (Z8, Z11, Z15, Z20, Z24, Z27, Z31 and Z35) are presented. Here, a constant Zernike coefficient value of 20 milliwaves is assumed for Z4...Z36. In the example, the targets T1, T2, T3 have the same spacing of 450nm, and differ in CD to have values ​​of 100nm, 150nm, 200nm respectively.

[0056] Any target comparison data can be used to extract the ranking of available target candidates using a cost function metric, such as provided in Equation 2, where PPE D and PPE T Represents device PPE and target PPE respectively.

[0057]

[0058] The cost function expressed in Equation 2 provides the PPE difference between the device and the target, and thus enables the selection of the best performing target for a given nominal value of the Zernike coefficients. The cost function for Figure 3B The results of an exemplary, non-limiting comparison are presented in FIG. 1 . In this illustrative example, target 4 has the highest ranking and is selected to provide the metrology measurement that best represents the device under simulated lens aberrations and conditions. In certain embodiments, the ranking method may take into account additional factors, such as lithography metrics and other metrology metrics.

[0059] Table 1: Exemplary comparison of candidate targets versus devices using the cost function of Equation 2.

[0060] Pitch(nm) CD(nm) Cost(nm) Sorting Device 100 50 Goal 1 450 100 7.0803 2 Goal 2 450 150 8.4300 3 Goal 3 450 200 10.629 4 Goal 4 400 100 6.564 1

[0061] Figure 41 is a high-level schematic block diagram of a metrology module 100 for target design and / or selection in a metrology system according to some embodiments of the present invention. The metrology module 100 may be associated with a metrology tool and / or scanner 75 having an optical system 81 and a measurement module 82, the metrology tool and / or scanner 75 being configured to manufacture a device 84 and measure a metrology target provided by the metrology module 100 as explained below. The target design and / or selection module 100 includes at least one computer processor 89, the at least one computer processor 89 being configured to calculate the Zernike sensitivity of pattern placement errors (PPE) of at least one device design 84 and a plurality of metrology target designs 108, and to select the best metrology target design 86 according to the value of a cost function derived from the calculated Zernike sensitivity, the cost function quantifying the similarity of the Zernike sensitivity between the at least one device design 84 and the metrology target design 108. The metrology target design and / or selection module 100 may be configured to implement any of the target design and / or selection methods described herein. The metrology target designed by the metrology module 100 and its target design file are synonymous with the present invention.

[0062] Figure 5 is a high-level schematic flow chart of a method 150 of target design and / or selection according to some embodiments of the present invention. The steps of method 150 may be used in any other method described herein. Certain embodiments include a computer program product including a computer-readable storage medium having a computer-readable program embodied therewith and configured to implement the relevant stages of method 150. Certain embodiments include a target design file for a corresponding target designed by an embodiment of method 150.

[0063] Method 150 may include calculating pattern placement error (PPE) Zernike sensitivities for at least one device design and a plurality of metrology target designs (stage 160) (e.g., according to Equation 1), and selecting the best metrology target design (stage 170) (e.g., according to Equation 2) based on a value derived from a cost function of the calculated Zernike sensitivities. A cost function may be defined (stage 165) to quantify the similarity of Zernike sensitivities between the at least one device design and the plurality of metrology target designs. At least one of calculating 160 and selecting 170 (stage 190) may be implemented by at least one computer processor (e.g., processor 89). Zernike sensitivities may be calculated relative to Zernike coefficients Z4 ... Z36; only relative to odd Zernike coefficients; or only relative to Zernike coefficients Z8, Z11, Z15, Z20, Z24, Z27, Z31, and Z35. The cost function may include a distance metric between the PPE Zernike sensitivities of the at least one device design and the PPE Zernike sensitivities of the plurality of metrology target designs.

[0064] Monte Carlo Zernike Analysis

[0065] Certain embodiments provide for large aberrations (e.g., Figure 3A The disclosed method achieves targeted optimization for large Zernike drifts in lens aberrations or in the absence of precise lens aberration data but only with temporal and spatial features. Such Zernike drifts may be caused, for example, by lens heating due to extreme off-axis illumination which is a serious problem especially in advanced technology nodes. In addition, the disclosed method provides a robust analysis and achieves targeted optimization for the case where the lens aberrations vary between batches, wafers, and slits.

[0066] Monte Carlo (MC) methods can be used to optimize targets under strong Zernike variations. Analysis of Zernike drift via Monte Carlo sampling also enables extension of optimization to alternative devices and provides target statistics. As described below, device-like target optimization is achieved using MC without prior knowledge of the aberration fingerprint from the lithography scanner, resulting in more accurate targets.

[0067] Figure 6 is a high-level schematic flow chart of a method 200 of target design and / or selection according to some embodiments of the present invention. The steps of method 200 may be used in any other method described herein. Certain embodiments include a computer program product including a computer-readable storage medium having a computer-readable program embodied therewith and configured to implement the relevant stages of method 200. Certain embodiments include a target design file for a corresponding target designed by an embodiment of method 200.

[0068] Method 200 includes, for each of at least one device design and a plurality of target design candidates (stage 210): repeatedly for a plurality of runs (stage 220): for a plurality of Zernike polynomials Z i Each of the N i (N i>100) Zernike coefficient values ​​(stage 230), calculating PPE for each of the Zernike polynomials (stage 240), and calculating corresponding PPE measurements for the runs (stage 250). The values ​​may be pseudo-randomly generated relative to a specified distribution (e.g., a uniform distribution) within a specified range (e.g., corresponding to the lens aberration tolerance defined in the specification) (stage 235). For each of the plurality of runs, the method 200 includes deriving a distribution of the calculated corresponding PPE measurements (stage 260). Next, the method 200 includes correlating each of the derived target design candidate distributions with at least one derived device design distribution to generate a device corresponding measurement for each target design candidate (stage 265); and selecting the best metrology target design based on the derived device corresponding measurement (stage 270). At least one of generating 230, 235, calculating 240, 250, deriving 260, correlating 265, and selecting 270 (stage 290) may be implemented by at least one computer processor (e.g., by the processor 89).

[0069] The method 200 may further include selecting target design candidates to represent segmentation alternatives for the specified target design (stage 275) and ranking the segmentation alternatives using the device correspondence measure (stage 276). The method 200 may further include: performing the calculation stage (240 and / or 250) in parallel with the metrology simulation process (stage 280); and integrating the ranking using the device correspondence measure with the ranking derived from the metrology simulation process (stage 282). The method 200 may further include performing the method for multiple device designs (stage 285) and performing the selection (270) relative to the device correspondence measures derived for all device designs (stage 286). Optionally, the selection 270 may be performed relative to a robust measure derived from multiple device correspondence measures (stage 288).

[0070] The method 200 may be implemented by the metering module 100 (see Figure 4 ). The metrology module 100 includes at least one computer processor 89, which can be configured to: (i) repeatedly for a plurality of runs: for a plurality of Zernike polynomials Z i Each of the N i (N i>100) Zernike coefficient values, the values ​​being pseudo-randomly generated relative to a specified distribution within a specified range, calculating a PPE for each of the Zernike polynomials, and calculating a corresponding PPE measure for the run; and deriving a distribution of the calculated corresponding PPE measures; (ii) correlating each of the derived target design candidate distributions with at least one derived device design distribution to generate a device correspondence measure for each target design candidate; and (iii) selecting an optimal metrology target design based on the derived device correspondence measures.

[0071] The metrology module 100 may be further configured to select target design candidates to represent segmentation alternatives for a specified target design and optionally rank the segmentation alternatives using device correspondence measures. The metrology module 100 may be further configured to: implement the calculation phase in parallel with the metrology simulation process; and integrate the ranking using device correspondence measures with the ranking derived from the metrology simulation process. The metrology module 100 may be further configured to use multiple device designs and select the best target relative to the device correspondence measures derived for all device designs, and optionally select the best target relative to the robust measures derived from the multiple device correspondence measures. The metrology targets designed by the metrology module 100 and their target design files are synonymous with the present invention.

[0072] Figure 7 is an illustrative example for the Monte Carlo analysis phase of method 200 according to some embodiments of the present invention. In the example, non-limiting parameters are used: spacing = 100 nm, CD = 50 nm, N = 500, a range between 0 and 20 milliwaves, and the use of terms Z8, Z11, Z15, Z20, Z24, Z27, Z31, and Z35. By generating a larger number (N, e.g., N = ΣN) of terms Z8, Z11, Z15, Z20, Z24, Z27, Z31, and Z35 from the realistic range of interest for each Zernike term (e.g., between 0 and 0.02λ), the Zernike term is obtained. i =500) uniformly distributed pseudo-random coefficients are generated to show 230. By i )Calculate Y-PPE(Z i ) (as a non-limiting example, alternatively X-PPE or both) and calculates statistics such as mean, standard deviation and range for each Zernike term. By calculating Y-PPE (Z) (which may be Y-PPE (Z) for i=4...36 in Equation 1) from each MC run 250A i) and calculates statistics for a total of N samples 250B that can be used as a PPE measure to present a calculated PPE measure 250. After repeating stages 230 to 250 for multiple runs 220 for each metrology target candidate, deriving a PPE measurement distribution 260 and correlating the target with the device 265 can be performed by calculating a correlation coefficient R and a mean difference between the device and the target or by directly calculating a PPE difference between the device and the target. The PPE difference can be calculated based on known statistical correlation parameters such as R 2 , 3Σ, slope, or intercept) to calculate PPE measurements.

[0073] Figure 7 The correlation (265) of the derived distributions for the device and each target candidate T1, ..., T4 defined in Table 1 is further illustrated, and its statistics and ranking are summarized in Table 2. As illustrated in the correlation distributions, the method 200 can be used to provide a detailed comparison of various target candidates and device designs under varying conditions and without the assumption of linear Zernike sensitivity.

[0074] Table 2: Statistics for the device and four different scatterometry target candidates using the Monte Carlo method. All target candidates are ranked based on correlation coefficient values ​​and mean difference.

[0075]

[0076] Certain embodiments may implement method 200 for any number of candidate targets, device designs, for imaging targets, and for scatterometry targets, and also for simple or complex two-dimensional devices and targets. Any parameter values ​​of the simulation (conditions, runs, etc.) may be set depending on the given circumstances.

[0077] Figure 8 is an illustrative example of the Monte Carlo analysis phase of the method 200 applied to conventional and two differently segmented AIM (Advanced Imaging Metrology) target designs according to some embodiments of the present invention. The device CD and pitch are used as the segmented CD and pitch for the segmented target. The first segmented target has no assist features, while the second segmented target uses two sub-resolution assist features (SRAFs), one feature positioned adjacent to the top segmentation line and the other feature positioned adjacent to the bottom segmentation line. The Monte Carlo method 200 is used to calculate statistics and correlation coefficients from the propagated diffraction orders through the lithography lens with random aberrations. The PPE values ​​for the segmented AIM target with SRAFs are almost identical to those obtained in the device given 500 random aberrations, resulting in a strong correlation R=0.985, which may be attributed to the good match of the amplitude and phase distribution of the diffraction orders at the lens exit pupil between the segmented AIM target and the device. However, no correlation is observed between the device and the conventional AIM target as expected due to the large size difference between them. Figure 8The correlations (265) for the derived distributions for the device and three target candidates are presented. The non-limiting data and the resulting correlation coefficients and rankings are presented in Table 3.

[0078] Table 3: Statistics of target candidates for the device and three different AIMs using the Monte Carlo method. The target candidates are ranked based on the correlation coefficient values.

[0079]

[0080] Advantageously, method 150, and in particular method 200, (i) minimizes the need for input of precise aberration characteristics of the scanner lens, (ii) ensures a more lithographically robust target design because a variety of scanner lens aberration pattern alternatives can be considered in the selection process, and (iii) quantifies the correlation between device and target under conditions of variable lens aberrations. For example, the AIM segmentation scheme is shown to improve device and target correlation to over 98%.

[0081] Certain embodiments include lens aberration aware imaging based overlay target optimization methods for tilted patterns in memory active layers. These methods provide metrology solutions for measuring tilted devices (i.e., devices with pitch along directions tilted relative to the X and Y axes of the metrology target).

[0082] Fig. 9 FIG. 3 is a high level schematic illustration of a device design 30 according to the prior art, the illumination conditions 35A, 35B used to manufacture such a device, and typical imaging metrology targets 38A, 38B. The memory active layer device 30 generally consists of a spacing device P D (Typical spacing P D =80nm and CD=40nm) and is made with an optimized illumination source (e.g., a rotated dipole X illumination whose electrodes and tilt angle α are configured according to the device pitch and requirements). Pupil plane illumination 35A is shown at the source and pupil plane 35B is shown at the exit pupil, where diffraction orders 0 and 1 overlap as designed to optimize the printing process of the device. The tilt of the device design 30 and the rotation of the illumination are schematically indicated by the angle α. Prior art targets are aligned along the horizontal and vertical directions (X and Y), as described, for example, by U.S. Patents Nos. 7,408,642 and 7,667,842 for target 38A (standard AIM target, P T Typically 1600 to 2000 nm) and 38B (Segmented AIM Target, see above), which are incorporated herein by reference in their entirety as prior art. Differences in target orientation lead to printability issues and placement errors, for example, as described above for lens aberrations (see also Figure 285 relative to target illumination 95). It should be noted that prior art segmented metrology target designs are implemented to optimize metrology performance (e.g., contrast, diffraction efficiency, and precision), see, for example, Leray et al., 2015, "Overlay metrology solutions in a triple patterning scheme," SPIE Vol 9424 94240E, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety as prior art.

[0083] Certain embodiments include a target design method that incorporates lithography effects into target design considerations and allows for judicious determination of the segmentation spacing, critical dimensions, and other parameters of a metrology target. Advantageously, the disclosed method achieves: (i) improved overlay measurements, which can facilitate increased yield, (ii) overcoming lens heating issues due to optimized illumination sources, which lead to pattern placement errors (see also above), (iii) selecting a segmentation scheme that complies with optimized (rotated) illumination, (iv) reducing large PPE shifts due to differences between the positions of diffraction orders and differences in PPE sensitivity to Y odd aberration terms, which are strong in the device (due to the tilted design) and not present in the target, (v) overcoming the smaller process window of targets using device segmentation (see below), and (vi) deriving an optimized target spacing that takes into account both the device spacing and the tilt of a tilted LS pattern with a tilted extreme dipole source.

[0084] Fig.10 is a high-level schematic block diagram of a system 300 for target design and / or optimization according to some embodiments of the present invention. Fig.10 Any of the elements described in may be implemented as a module associated with a computer processor in a metrology tool and / or as a computer-readable storage medium having a computer-readable program embodied therewith and configured to implement the corresponding operations described below.

[0085] The system 300 includes a lithography model 68 for use in a metrology performance simulation 60 with respect to metrology parameters such as contrast, precision, and diffraction efficiency (in SCOL), an exemplary segmentation of a target element (in a process involving Fig. 9) is shown below the simulation module 60. The designed target is then enhanced 50, for example, by applying OPC (optical proximity correction) and SRAF (and / or other segmentation). An exemplary enhanced target element is shown, with SRAF segmentation indicated by an arrow. The enhanced target is then optimized with respect to its Zernike sensitivity 100 (as described above, and described in detail below) and may also be optimized with respect to its process window 40 (e.g., with respect to DOF (depth of focus) and EL (exposure latitude)). These two optimizations may be implemented 320 and correspondingly 310 in relation to additional metrology performance simulations 60 to produce an optimized target 330 with respect to all three sets of considerations, for example, a target with a segmentation spacing selected based on (i) minimum PPE offset (from 100), (ii) maximum process window (from 40), and (iii) maximum metrology performance (from 60). The system 300 is configured to calculate the optical segmentation spacing while improving both target printability on the wafer (i.e., larger process window) and device-target matching by reducing placement error offsets between the target and the device. The designed overlay target can be used for both ADI (after development inspection) and AEI (after etch inspection) stages. Segmentation generally increases the process window and the disclosed method provides optimization of the segmentation spacing and design. For example, the target is relative to Fig. 9 The typical rough pitch of the strip elements is usually 1500 nm, and the segment pitch can range, for example, from 80 to 100 nm. Any value on this range provides different metrology and process parameters for different targets.

[0086] Fig.11A and 11B An exemplary comparison of different target designs according to some embodiments of the present invention, each compared to the same device with respect to its Zernike sensitivity, is presented. In both cases, the device pitch is 80nm, CD=40nm and a constant Z factor of 20 milliwaves is used. Fig.11A In , the target segmentation has the same pitch as the device (80nm), while in Fig. 11B In the , the target segmentation spacing is different from the device spacing (90nm and 100nm; 80nm target is included for comparison). Both figures present the PPE of the device and target simulation according to the Zernike terms, where good correspondence between the target and device sensitivity is indicated at 340 and good correspondence between the target and device sensitivity is indicated at 345 (in Fig.11A The middle mark refers to the 80nm target, while Fig. 11B The symbols in the figure refer to the 90nm and 100nm targets. Fig.11AThe terms with the most PPEs in are the X odd aberration terms Z14 and Z26, and the Y odd aberration terms Z3, Z8, Z11, Z20, and Z27. As described in more detail below, the Y odd aberration terms Z3, Z8, Z11, Z20, and Z27 characterize the PPE sensitivity of the device to the Y odd aberrations due to its tilted orientation.

[0087] It should be noted that the use of is different from that used for object segmentation ( Fig. 11B Compared with the device pitch of the 90nm and 100nm targets in the Fig.11A ) results in a lower correspondence between the device and the target sensitivity. This result is unexpected since the convention is to segment the metrology target at the same spacing as the device.

[0088] Table 4 provides a comparison between target segmentation spacing with respect to device target matching (100) and process window parameters (40), which shows the best results for a target segmentation spacing of 100nm, which is 25% larger than the device spacing. The target of 100nm segmentation has better device matching and a larger process window (PW) resulting in a 35% reduction in PPE shift. For targets with segmentation spacing greater than 100nm, the overlap PW starts to decrease and the target also becomes non-SADP (self-aligned double patterning) process friendly, resulting in reduced target contrast in the AEI level. The DOF is calculated for the grooves in the design at 5% exposure level (EL), with the left and right grooves having the same value. Fig. 15B The process window parameter data is described in more detail in .

[0089] Table 4: Comparison between target segmentation spacings with respect to device target matching and process window parameters (bold—optimal target 330, target is the segmented AIM target with the indicated segmentation spacing).

[0090]

[0091] The inventors have discovered sources of improvement in target design, which are described below. Fig. 12A To C, it is indicated that there is no Fig.11A The prior art target sensitivity to Y odd aberrations described in, Fig.13A To C schematically illustrate Fig. 11B The sensitivity of the improved target to Y odd aberrations described in, Fig.14 Provides specifications for improving the match between targets and devices, and Fig. 15B Description relative to Fig.15A An improved process window of the prior art described in .

[0092] Fig. 12A is a schematic illustration of prior art target sensitivity without Y odd aberrations. Fig. 12AIllustrates an oblique illumination source 35A and a device diffraction signal 35B at the exit pupil, with congruent zeroth and first order diffractions (see also Fig. 9 ), and the response of a prior art metrology target 38B that is segmented but not tilted at the same pitch as device 30 (both are 80 nm). It should be noted that due to the different orientations and the same pitch, the zeroth and first order diffraction signals do not overlap but are spread throughout the pupil plane, thereby changing the aberration sensitivity of target 38B relative to device 30. In particular, while device 30 has a large PPE sensitivity to Y odd aberrations, prior art target 38B has relatively small or no PPE sensitivity to Y odd aberrations because the diffraction pattern for target 38B is aligned along the x-direction, while device 30 provides a diffraction pattern along a diagonal (tilted) direction.

[0093] Fig. 12B is a high level schematic model of an oblique illumination 38A according to some embodiments of the present invention. The illumination 38A is modeled as including two point sources 35C. Fig. 12B Schematically illustrating the paths and resulting phase differences of the zeroth and first order diffraction signals from point sources 36A, 36B, which result in a PPE when the metrology target is oriented vertically for a given rotating illumination 35C, since the first and zeroth order diffractions travel different distances. As expressed in Equation 3, the intensity of aerial imaging for a monopole source is the square of the electric field magnitude.

[0094]

[0095] When the illumination source is optimized for the device parameters (in the example, a pitch of 80 nm and a tilt (α) of 21°), the first-order diffraction signal passes through the exact opposite position to the zeroth-order diffraction signal.

[0096] Fig. 12C is a high level schematic illustration of the effect of target spacing modification 335 at the pupil plane according to some embodiments of the present invention. Fig. 12C Schematically illustrating illumination source 36A, its zeroth and first order diffraction signals for prior art target 36C, and its zeroth and first order diffraction signals for improved target 330, wherein the position of the first order diffraction signal is shifted relative to the zeroth order diffraction signal from its previous juxtaposition position. One of the examples shows the effect of target spacing modification 335 to illustrate the shift along the x-axis of the first order diffraction signal. Fig.13A As illustrated in C, while the use of X-direction illumination source 36A does not change the sensitivity of target 330 in the Y direction, once the illumination source is tilted, modification 335 results in a Y odd Zernike sensitivity for target 330.

[0097] Fig.13A and 13Bis a high level schematic illustration of the effect of target spacing modification 335 at the pupil plane according to some embodiments of the present invention. Fig.13A and 13B Illustrated with the exit pupil image of the prior art target 35C and the improved target 330 with the off-X-axis illumination source (monopole source, in Fig.13A Above the X-axis, Fig. 13B ), which illustrates the Y odd Zernike sensitivity of the improved target 330 by changing the position of the first order signal (indicated as Δφ1) related to the Zernike polynomial from a position equivalent to the position of the zero order signal (indicated as Δφ0) shown at 35C (Δφ0=Δφ1) to a position not equivalent to the position of the zero order signal Δφ0 shown at 330 (Δφ0≠Δφ1), which is therefore sensitive to aberrations along the Y axis. Fig.13A , 13B The graph in shows the dependence of PPE on target spacing for variations in Y coma (relative to Z8), starting from zero PPE for a prior art target segmented at the device spacing and the PPE (and Zernike sensitivity) increasing as the target segmentation spacing deviates from the device spacing (330). Fig. 13C 38B), 120 nm (modified target 330A), and 160 nm (modified target 330B). The graph shows the increase in sensitivity as the target spacing deviates from the device spacing. The two-beam imaging region represents the case when only the zeroth and first order diffraction are captured by the scanner lens array and the two beams interfere with each other. By increasing the spacing, more diffraction orders can be captured. Three-beam interference imaging is applicable when the zeroth, first, and second order diffraction are captured and interfere with each other.

[0098] Fig.14 2 is a high-level schematic illustration of a proposed method 250 for determining target segmentation relative to a device according to some embodiments of the present invention. A simulated illumination source 35C for manufacturing device 30 is calculated relative to at least one Zernike polynomial (e.g., Z8) on an exit pupil and a corresponding calculation is performed for a prior art target 38B, where P T =P D Next, the zeroth and first-order diffraction signals (Δφ 0 , Δφ 1 ) and the target parameters are modified (330) to provide a relative pupil plane position that better corresponds to the zeroth and first order diffraction signals (Δφ) in their relationship to the PPE sensitivity 0 , Δφ 1 )'s relative device position, which is reflected by the corresponding Zernike polynomial value.

[0099] Fig.15A and 15B Schematically illustrate the method according to the prior art ( Fig.15A ) of some embodiments of the present invention ( Fig. 15B ) for improving and optimizing the process window. In the example the process window is calculated for a ±10% CD variation from a nominal trench CD of 40 nm. For the prior art target 38B, the left trench and center trench process windows are presented in Fig.15A , and are respectively smaller than the left trench and center trench process windows for the improved targets 331, 330 having pitches of 90 nm and 100 nm, as listed above on Table 4. Target 330 is the optimal target in the illustrated example, providing the largest process window.

[0100] Similar to Equation 1, Equation 1A is based on the Zernike sensitivity and lens aberration information ΔZ i Express PPE.

[0101]

[0102] As expressed in Equation 2A, similar to Equation 2, a cost function ε may be defined relative to the difference between the Zernike sensitivities of the device and the target. 1 ) represents the device PPE for Z1 and PPE_T(Z 1 ) represents the target PPE for Z1 (i.e., PPE_D(Z 1 ) is equal to zero for zero lens aberration), and PPE_D(Z i ) represents the i-th device PPE and PPE_T(Z i ) represents the i-th target PPE. ΔZ i represents the actual drift measured from the scanner and Indicates the drift coefficient used to calculate sensitivity.

[0103]

[0104]

[0105] assumed (eg = 0.02), Equation 4 is derived from Equation 2A to represent the Euclidean distance in the LS case.

[0106]

[0107] Fig.16is a high-level schematic flow chart of a method 400 for optimizing metrology target design according to some embodiments of the present invention. The steps of method 400 may be used in any other method described herein. Certain embodiments include a computer program product including a computer-readable storage medium having a computer-readable program embodied therewith and configured to implement the relevant stages of method 400. Certain embodiments include a target design file for a corresponding target designed by an embodiment of method 400.

[0108] Method 400 includes: starting with an initial target design determined according to metrology performance requirements (stage 402); and using a simulation tool (stage 404); comparing Zernike sensitivity of pattern placement error (PPE) between the initial target design and at least one device design with respect to at least two directions (stage 410); estimating a process window for the initial target design (stage 420); and deriving an improved metrology target design from the initial target design by modifying the initial target design to increase the correspondence in Zernike sensitivity and increase the process window (stage 430). At least one of comparing 410, estimating 420, and deriving 430 may be implemented by at least one computer processor (e.g., processor 89).

[0109] Deriving an improved metrology target design 430 may further include iterative comparison and evaluation for successively derived improved target designs (stage 440). The at least two directions may include a target design direction and a direction perpendicular thereto (X, Y, respectively). At least one device design may be tilted relative to the target design direction. The pitch of the improved metrology target design may be 10 to 30% larger than the pitch of at least one device design in order to follow the device behavior for a given lens aberration.

[0110] Method 400 may further include determining a target design 450 relative to a device design, including simulating pupil plane positions of zero-order and first-order diffraction signals of an initial target design and the device design (stage 455), modifying at least one parameter of the initial target design to produce an improved target design (stage 460), e.g., to provide a relationship between pupil plane positions of zero-order and first-order diffraction signals in the improved target that corresponds to their relationship in the device design (stage 465). Method 400 may further include evaluating the correspondence of the relationship relative to at least one Zernike polynomial (e.g., at least one Zernike polynomial that is asymmetric relative to a segmentation direction of the initial target, as described above) (stage 470).

[0111] The system 300 may be at least partially implemented by a metering module 100 including at least one computer processor 89 (see Figure 4) is implemented, the at least one computer processor 89 is configured to start with an initial target design determined according to metrology performance requirements, and use a simulation tool to: compare the Zernike sensitivity of pattern placement error (PPE) between the initial target design and at least one device design with respect to at least two directions; estimate the process window for the initial target design; and derive an improved metrology target design from the initial target design by modifying the initial target design to increase the correspondence in Zernike sensitivity and increase the process window. The metrology module 100 may be configured to repeatedly compare and estimate for the continuously derived improved target designs. The at least two directions may include a target design direction and a direction perpendicular thereto. At least one device design may be tilted relative to the target design direction. The spacing of the improved metrology target design may be 10 to 30% larger than the spacing of at least one device design. The metrology target designed by the metrology module 100 and its target design file are the same meaning of the present invention.

[0112] The metrology module 100 may be configured to determine the target design relative to the device design by simulating pupil plane positions of zero-order and first-order diffraction signals of an initial target design and a device design, and modifying at least one parameter of the initial target design to produce an improved target design, the modification being performed to provide a relationship between pupil plane positions of zero-order and first-order diffraction signals in the improved target, the relationship corresponding to their relationship in the device design. The metrology module 100 may be further configured to evaluate the correspondence of the relationship relative to at least one Zernike polynomial, optionally wherein the at least one Zernike polynomial is asymmetric relative to the segmentation direction of the initial target. The metrology module 100 may be further configured to determine the target segmentation relative to the device design. The metrology target designed by the metrology module 100 and its target design file are synonymous with the present invention.

[0113] Fig.17 is a high level schematic illustration of a tilted target 360 according to some embodiments of the invention. Certain embodiments include a tilted metrology target 360 having elements and / or segmentation tilted, for example, at the same tilt angle as the device to be measured, possibly adding SRAF features that improve the manufacturing accuracy of the target 360, particularly relative to line edges.

[0114] Certain embodiments combine the disclosure provided above with information from the following publications: Lee et al., 2016, “Metrology target design (MTD) solution for diagonally orientated DRAM layer” (ISPE 9778, “Metrology, Inspection, and Process Control for Microlithography XXX”, 97782R (March 8, 2016); doi: 10.1117 / 12.2218659) and Lee et al., 2016, “Lithography aware overlay metrology target design method” (ISPE 9778, “Metrology, Inspection, and Process Control for Microlithography XXX”, 97782R (March 8, 2016); doi: 10.1117 / 12.2218659) XXX)”, 97781L (March 24, 2016); doi:10.1117 / 12.2218653), with the same first inventor and colleagues. These publications are incorporated herein by reference in their entirety.

[0115] Aspects of the present invention are described above with reference to flowchart illustrations and / or partial diagrams of methods, devices (systems) and computer program products according to embodiments of the present invention. It will be understood that each part of the flowchart illustrations and / or partial diagrams and the combination of parts in the flowchart illustrations and / or partial diagrams can be implemented by computer program instructions. These computer program instructions can be provided to a processor of a general-purpose computer, a special-purpose computer or other programmable data processing device to manufacture a machine, so that the instructions implemented by the processor of the computer or other programmable data processing device form a method for implementing the functions / actions specified in the flowchart and / or partial diagram part or parts.

[0116] These computer program instructions may also be stored in a computer-readable medium, which can instruct a computer, other programmable data processing equipment or other devices to operate in a specific manner, so that the instructions stored in the computer-readable medium produce an article of manufacture, which includes instructions for implementing the functions / actions specified in the flowchart and / or partial diagram portion or portions.

[0117] Computer program instructions may also be loaded onto a computer, other programmable data processing device or other apparatus to cause a series of operating steps to be executed on the computer, other programmable device or other apparatus to produce a computer-implemented process, so that the instructions executed on the computer or other programmable device provide a process for implementing the functions / actions specified in the flowchart and / or partial diagram portion or portions.

[0118] The foregoing flowcharts and diagrams illustrate the architecture, functionality and operation of possible implementation schemes of systems, methods and computer program products according to various embodiments of the present invention. At this point, each part in a flowchart or partial diagram may represent a portion of a module, fragment or code, which includes one or more executable instructions for implementing a specified logical function. It should also be noted that in some alternative implementations, the functions noted in the portion may occur out of the order noted in the diagram. For example, depending on the functionality involved, two portions shown in succession may in fact be executed substantially simultaneously, or the portions may sometimes be executed in reverse order. It will also be noted that each portion of the partial diagram and / or flowchart illustration and a combination of portions in the partial diagram and / or flowchart illustration may be implemented by a dedicated hardware-based system, and the dedicated hardware-based system implements a specified function or action or a combination of dedicated hardware and computer instructions.

[0119] In the above description, an embodiment is an example or implementation of the present invention. The various occurrences of "an embodiment", "an embodiment", "certain embodiments" or "some embodiments" do not necessarily all refer to the same embodiment. Although the various features of the present invention can be described in the context of a single embodiment, the features can also be provided separately or in any suitable combination. On the contrary, although the present invention can be described in the context of a separate embodiment for clarity herein, the present invention can also be implemented in a single embodiment. Certain embodiments of the present invention may include features from different embodiments disclosed above, and certain embodiments may incorporate elements from other embodiments disclosed above. The disclosure of the elements of the present invention in the context of a specific embodiment should not be understood to limit its use to a specific embodiment alone. In addition, it should be understood that the present invention can be implemented or put into practice in various ways and the present invention can be implemented in specific embodiments other than the embodiments summarized in the above description.

[0120] The present invention is not limited to those figures or corresponding descriptions. For example, the process does not need to move through each illustrated frame or state, or move in the same order as the illustrated and described. Unless otherwise defined, the meaning of the technical and scientific terms used in this article will be generally understood by those of ordinary skill in the art in the field to which the present invention belongs. Although the present invention has been described with reference to a limited number of embodiments, these embodiments should not be interpreted as limitations on the scope of the present invention, but as partial demonstrations of preferred embodiments. Other possible changes, modifications and applications are also within the scope of the present invention. Therefore, the scope of the present invention should not be limited by what has been described so far but by the attached claims and their legal equivalents.

Claims

1. A measurement target, comprising: a first set of cells having a first set of two or more periodic features in a first layer of the sample distributed along a measurement direction; as well as A second group of cells having the two or more periodic features in the second layer of the sample distributed along the measurement direction, wherein specific periodic characteristics of the two or more periodic features in any one of the first group of cells or the second group of cells include: A tilted segmented region surrounded by a boundary segment along the measurement direction, wherein the tilted segmented region includes two or more tilted segmented features distributed along a tilt angle at a tilt segmentation pitch, wherein the tilt angle corresponds to a tilt angle of a tilted device feature in a corresponding layer of the sample, wherein the tilt segmentation pitch is selected to match pattern placement errors of the two or more periodic features in the corresponding layer with pattern placement errors of the tilted device feature in the corresponding layer according to a Zernike polynomial analysis, wherein a measurement of the position of the first group of cells relative to the second group of cells along the measurement direction indicates a superposition along the measurement direction. 2 . The metrology target of claim 1 , wherein the first group of cells and the second group of cells are rotationally symmetric Advanced Imaging Metrology (AIM) cells.

3. The metrology target of claim 1, wherein the tilted division pitch of the two or more periodic features is equal to the tilted division pitch of the tilted device features in the corresponding layer.

4. The metrology target of claim 1, wherein the tilted segmentation pitch of the two or more periodic features is 10% to 30% greater than the tilted segmentation pitch of the tilted device features in the corresponding layer. 5 . The metrology target of claim 1 , wherein the oblique division spacing of the two or more periodic features in the first group of cells is equal to the oblique division spacing of the two or more periodic features in the second group of cells. 6 . The metrology target of claim 1 , wherein the oblique division spacing of the two or more periodic features in the first group of cells is different from the oblique division spacing of the two or more periodic features in the second group of cells. 7 . The metrology target according to claim 1 , wherein the tilt angles of the tilted segmented regions of two or more periodic features in the first group of cells are equal to the tilt angles of the tilted segmented regions of two or more periodic features in the second group of cells. 8 . The metrology target according to claim 1 , wherein the tilt angles of the tilted segmented regions of two or more periodic features in the first group of cells are different from the tilt angles of the tilted segmented regions of two or more periodic features in the second group of cells.

9. The metrology target of claim 1, wherein the boundary segments are further segmented to include optical proximity correction (OPC) features.

10. The metrology target of claim 9, wherein the optical proximity correction (OPC) feature comprises: Sub-resolution assist feature SRAF.

11. The metrology target of claim 10, wherein at least one of a size, a segmentation, or a tilt angle of the sub-resolution assist features (SRAF) is selected to match the pattern placement errors of the two or more periodic features in the respective layer with the pattern placement errors of the tilted device features in the respective layer according to a Zernike polynomial analysis.

12. The metrology target of claim 1, wherein the Zernike polynomial analysis comprises: pupil plane positions of zero-order and first-order diffraction signals simulating an initial target design of the metrology target and a design of the tilting device; as well as At least one parameter of the initial target design is modified to produce an improved target design, the modification being implemented to provide a relationship between the pupil plane positions of zeroth and first order diffraction signals in the improved target that corresponds to their relationship in the device design.

13. The metrology target of claim 12, wherein the at least one Zernike polynomial is asymmetric with respect to a segmentation direction of the initial target.

14. The metrology target of claim 1, wherein the Zernike polynomial analysis comprises: calculating Zernike sensitivities of pattern placement errors of at least one device design of the tilt device and a plurality of metrology target designs of the metrology targets; as well as An optimal metrology target design is selected according to a value of a cost function derived from the calculated Zernike sensitivities, the cost function quantifying similarities in Zernike sensitivities between the at least one device design and the plurality of metrology target designs.

15. The metrology target of claim 1, wherein the Zernike polynomial analysis comprises: For at least one device design and each of a plurality of target design candidates for the metrology target: Repeat for multiple runs: generating a plurality of Ni (Ni>50) Zernike coefficient values ​​for each of a plurality of Zernike polynomials Zi, the values ​​being pseudo-randomly generated relative to a specified distribution within a specified range, calculating a PPE for each of the Zernike polynomials; calculating a corresponding PPE measure for the run; deriving the calculated distribution of the corresponding PPE measurements; correlating each of the derived target design candidate distributions with at least one derived device design distribution to generate a device correspondence measure for each target design candidate; as well as The best metrology target design is selected based on the derived device corresponding measurements.

16. The metrology target of claim 1, wherein the Zernike polynomial analysis comprises: comparing a Zernike sensitivity of a pattern placement error PPE between an initial target design of the metrology target and at least one device design of the tilted device with respect to at least two directions; estimating a process window for the initial target design; as well as An improved metrology target design is derived from the initial target design by modifying the initial target design to increase the correspondence in the Zernike sensitivity and to increase the process window.

17. A metering module, comprising: At least one computer processor configured to: Design measurement objectives to include: a first set of cells having a first set of two or more periodic features in a first layer of the sample distributed along a measurement direction; and a second group of cells having the two or more periodic features in the second layer of the sample distributed along the measuring direction, a specific periodic feature of the two or more periodic features in either the first group of cells or the second group of cells comprising: a tilted segmented region surrounded by a boundary segment along the measuring direction, wherein the tilted segmented region comprises two or more tilted segmented features distributed at a tilted segmentation pitch along a tilt angle, wherein the tilt angle corresponds to a tilt angle of a tilted device feature in a corresponding layer of the sample; and The tilted segmentation spacing is selected to match the pattern placement errors of the two or more periodic features in the corresponding layer with the pattern placement errors of the tilted device features in the corresponding layer based on Zernike polynomial analysis, wherein the measurement of the position of the first group of units relative to the second group of units along the measurement direction indicates a superposition along the measurement direction.

18. The metrology module of claim 17, wherein the boundary segments are further segmented to include optical proximity correction (OPC) features.

19. The metrology module of claim 18, wherein the optical proximity correction (OPC) feature comprises: Sub-resolution assist feature SRAF.

20. The metrology module of claim 19, wherein the one or more processors are further configured to select at least one of a size, a segmentation, or a tilt angle of the sub-resolution assist features (SRAF) to match pattern placement errors of the two or more periodic features in the respective layer with the pattern placement errors of the tilted device features in the respective layer according to a Zernike polynomial analysis.

21. A measurement method, comprising: Design measurement objectives to include: a first set of cells having a first set of two or more periodic features in a first layer of the sample distributed along a measurement direction; as well as a second group of cells having the two or more periodic features in the second layer of the sample distributed along the measurement direction, a specific periodic feature of the two or more periodic features in either the first group of cells or the second group of cells comprising: a tilted segmented region surrounded by a boundary segment along the measurement direction, wherein the tilted segmented region comprises two or more tilted segmented features distributed along a tilt angle at a tilted segmentation pitch, wherein the tilt angle corresponds to a tilt angle of a tilted device feature in a corresponding layer of the sample; as well as The tilted segmentation spacing is selected to match the pattern placement errors of the two or more periodic features in the corresponding layer with the pattern placement errors of the tilted device features in the corresponding layer based on Zernike polynomial analysis, wherein the measurement of the position of the first group of units relative to the second group of units along the measurement direction indicates a superposition along the measurement direction.