Method and device for detection and measurement
By optimizing the design and selection of measurement targets in lithography equipment and combining simulation and measurement data, precise monitoring and control of the lithography process can be achieved, solving the problem of error monitoring and control in semiconductor manufacturing and improving the manufacturing accuracy and production efficiency of devices.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202110313757.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2015-04-10
- Filing Date
- 2016-03-24
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-05
- Estimated Expiration
- 2036-03-24
AI Technical Summary
Existing photolithography equipment has difficulty effectively monitoring and controlling errors in the photolithography process during the manufacturing of semiconductor devices, resulting in substandard device performance, especially in terms of overlap, alignment, and dimensional measurement.
By combining simulation and measurement data, the design and selection of measurement targets are optimized, key performance indicators are displayed using a graphical user interface, and the parameters of lithography equipment and inspection equipment are adjusted to achieve precise monitoring and control of the lithography process.
This improved the precision and consistency of the photolithography process, reduced the production of defective products, and increased production efficiency and product quality.
Smart Images

Figure CN113050388B_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] This application is a divisional application of the Chinese invention patent application with application date of March 24, 2016, application number 201680020990.2, and invention name “Method and device for detection and measurement”.
[0002] CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
[0003] This application claims priority to U.S. Application No. 62 / 146,079, filed April 10, 2015, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. Technical Field
[0004] The present description relates to methods and apparatus for correcting errors in a measured radiation distribution captured from a metrology target. Background Art
[0005] A lithographic apparatus is a machine that applies a desired pattern to a substrate (usually to a target portion of the substrate). A lithographic apparatus can be used, for example, in the manufacture of an integrated circuit (IC) or other device. In this case, a pattern forming device, alternatively referred to as a mask or a reticle, can be used to generate a circuit pattern to be formed on a separate layer of the IC. The pattern can be transferred to a target portion (e.g., including a portion of a die, one or several die) on a substrate (e.g., a silicon wafer). The transfer of the pattern is typically by imaging onto a layer of radiation-sensitive material (resist) disposed on the substrate. In general, a single substrate will contain a network of adjacent target portions that are patterned one after another. Known lithographic apparatus include: a so-called stepper, in which each target portion is irradiated by exposing the entire pattern to the target portion at one time, and a so-called scanner, in which each target portion is irradiated by scanning the pattern by a radiation beam in a given direction (the "scanning" direction), while simultaneously scanning the substrate in parallel or antiparallel to the direction. The pattern can also be transferred from the pattern forming device to the substrate by imprinting the pattern onto the substrate. Summary of the invention
[0006] The manufacture of devices such as semiconductor devices typically involves processing a substrate (e.g., a semiconductor wafer) using multiple fabrication processes to form various features and multiple layers of the device. Such layers and features are typically fabricated and processed using, for example, deposition, photolithography (which typically involves transferring a pattern to a radiation-sensitive resist disposed on a substrate), etching, chemical mechanical polishing, and ion implantation. Multiple devices may be fabricated on multiple dies on a substrate and subsequently separated into individual devices.
[0007] Metrology processes are used at various steps during a device fabrication process to monitor and control the process. For example, metrology processes are used to measure one or more characteristics of a substrate, such as the relative positioning (e.g., overlay, alignment, etc.) or dimensions (e.g., line width, critical dimension, thickness, etc.) of features formed on the substrate during the process, so that the performance of the process can be determined from the one or more characteristics. If one or more characteristics are unacceptable (e.g., outside a predetermined range of characteristics), the measurement of the one or more characteristics can be used to change one or more parameters of the process so that further substrates fabricated by the process have acceptable characteristics.
[0008] Therefore, important aspects of enabling a device manufacturing process include developing the process itself, setting it up for monitoring and control, and then actually monitoring and controlling the process itself. Assuming the configuration of the basics of the device manufacturing process (such as patterning device pattern, resist type, post-lithography process steps such as development, etching, etc.), etc., it is desirable to set up the lithography equipment for transferring the pattern to the substrate, develop the metrology targets to monitor the process, set up the metrology process to measure the metrology targets, and then implement the process of monitoring and controlling the process based on the measurements.
[0009] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: performing a simulation to evaluate a plurality of measurement targets and / or a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets; identifying one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the plurality of evaluated measurement targets and / or measurement options; receiving measurement data of the one or more identified measurement targets and / or measurement options; and using the measurement data to adjust simulated measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters.
[0010] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: receiving measurement data of a plurality of different measurement targets, each measurement target being measured with a plurality of measurement options; and using the measurement data to verify one or more parameters of a simulation, wherein the simulation is used to evaluate the plurality of measurement targets and / or a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets.
[0011] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: simulating a plurality of measurement targets and / or a plurality of measurement options taking into account expected process conditions; identifying one or more measurement targets and / or options from the plurality of simulated measurement targets and / or options; receiving measurement data of the one or more identified measurement targets and / or options; and using the measurement data to verify the expected process conditions.
[0012] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: performing simulation to evaluate a plurality of measurement targets and / or a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets, and determining parameters representing performance of one or more of the measurement targets and / or measurement options; identifying one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and / or measurement options; receiving measurement data of the one or more identified measurement targets and / or measurement options; and selecting one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the identified one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options based on the measurement data and the parameters.
[0013] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: performing simulation to evaluate a plurality of measurement targets and a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets; identifying one or more combinations of measurement targets and measurement options from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and measurement options; customizing a plurality of measurement options for one or more measurement targets from the identified one or more combinations based on one or more measurement options from the identified one or more combinations; and receiving measurement data of the one or more measurement targets measured using the customized plurality of measurement options from the identified one or more combinations.
[0014] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: determining, based on data of a measurement target measured under a plurality of measurement options, a parameter representing the sensitivity of one or more measurement options or one or more measurement option parameters to one or more measurement targets; and evaluating, based on the parameter representing the sensitivity, a plurality of measurement options used to measure the measurement targets by simulation or according to the measured data to identify one or more measurement options among the plurality of measurement options for use in measuring the measurement targets.
[0015] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: evaluating a plurality of measurement targets and / or a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets by simulation or based on measured data; and identifying one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and / or measurement options whose diffraction efficiency or a parameter derived from the diffraction efficiency crosses a threshold.
[0016] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: evaluating a plurality of measurement targets and / or a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets by simulation or based on measured data; and identifying one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and / or measurement options whose measurement device properties or parameters derived from the measurement device properties exceed a threshold.
[0017] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: evaluating, based on measurement data across a substrate, one or more mathematical models used to fit the measured data and one or more measurement sampling schemes used to measure the data relative to parameters representing residual uncertainty of the mathematical models that fit the measured data; and identifying one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes whose parameters cross a threshold.
[0018] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: evaluating, based on measurement data across a substrate, one or more mathematical models used to fit the measured data and one or more measurement sampling schemes used to measure the data relative to a first evaluation parameter and a different second evaluation parameter; and identifying one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes at which the first and second evaluation parameters cross a threshold.
[0019] In one aspect, a method is provided for determining a sampling scheme for measuring data and / or a mathematical model for fitting the measured data to monitor process steps in a lithography process, the method comprising: determining the sampling scheme and the mathematical model based at least in part on a throughput model of an inspection device.
[0020] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: receiving measurement data of a measurement target measured according to a measurement option; determining a sampling scheme for measuring data using the measurement target using the measurement option based at least in part on a throughput model of an inspection device; determining an evaluation parameter based on the measurement data and the sampling scheme; determining whether the evaluation parameter crosses a threshold; and if it is determined that the evaluation parameter crosses the threshold, changing the sampling scheme based at least in part on the throughput model.
[0021] In one aspect, a method is provided, comprising: displaying a plurality of graphical user interface elements, each graphical user interface element representing a step in a measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process, and each graphical user interface element enabling a user to access further steps in the measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process for the step associated with the graphical user interface element; and displaying an indicator associated with one or more of the plurality of graphical user elements, the indicator indicating that a step in the measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process is not completed and / or a key performance indicator associated with a step in the measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process has passed a threshold.
[0022] In one aspect, a non-transitory computer program product is provided, comprising computer readable instructions for causing a processor to cause the execution of a method as described herein.
[0023] In one aspect, a system is provided, comprising: an inspection apparatus configured to provide a beam onto a measurement target on a substrate and detect radiation redirected by the target to determine a parameter of a lithography process; and a non-transitory computer program product as described herein. In an embodiment, the system further comprises a lithography apparatus comprising a support structure configured to hold a patterning device to modulate a radiation beam and a projection optical system arranged to project the modulated radiation beam onto a radiation sensitive substrate.
[0024] In one aspect, there is provided a system comprising: an alignment sensor comprising: an output for providing radiation from a radiation source onto a target, a detector configured to receive radiation from the target, and a control system configured to determine alignment of two or more objects in response to the received radiation; and a non-transitory computer program product as described herein. In an embodiment, the system further comprises a lithographic apparatus comprising a support structure configured to hold a patterning device to modulate a radiation beam and a projection optical system arranged to project the modulated radiation beam onto a radiation sensitive substrate.
[0025] In one aspect, there is provided a system comprising: a level sensor comprising: an output for providing radiation from a radiation source onto a surface, a detector configured to receive radiation from the surface, and a control system configured to determine a position of the surface in response to the received radiation; and a non-transitory computer program product as described herein. In an embodiment, the system further comprises a lithographic apparatus comprising a support structure configured to hold a patterning device to modulate a radiation beam and a projection optical system arranged to project the modulated radiation beam onto a radiation sensitive substrate.
[0026] In one aspect, a method for manufacturing a device is provided, wherein a device pattern is applied to a series of substrates using a photolithography process, the method comprising: inspecting a target identified using the methods described herein and / or inspecting a target using a measurement option identified using the methods described herein, the target being formed on at least one of the substrates as part of the device pattern or outside the device pattern; and controlling the photolithography process for subsequent substrates based on the inspection results.
[0027] In one aspect, a method of manufacturing a device is provided, wherein a device pattern is applied to a series of substrates using a photolithography process, the method comprising inspecting at least a target formed on at least one of the substrates as part of the device pattern or outside the device pattern using a sampling scheme determined using the method described herein, and controlling the photolithography process for at least one substrate or another substrate based on the inspection results.
[0028] In one aspect, a method of manufacturing a device is provided, wherein a device pattern is applied to a series of substrates using a lithography process, the method comprising: inspecting at least a target formed on at least one of the substrates as part of the device pattern or outside the device pattern, wherein the inspection is performed using a sampling scheme identified using the method described herein and / or measured data from the inspection is modeled using a mathematical model identified using the method described herein; and controlling the lithography process for at least one substrate or another substrate based on the results of the inspection. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0029] Embodiments will now be described, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0030] Figure 1 An embodiment of a lithographic apparatus is schematically depicted;
[0031] Figure 2 An embodiment of a lithographic cell or cluster is schematically depicted;
[0032] Figure 3 schematically depicts a flow chart of an embodiment of a portion of device manufacturing process development, monitoring and control;
[0033] Figure 4 A flow chart schematically depicts an embodiment of a metrology setup;
[0034] Figure 5 A flow chart schematically depicts an embodiment of a metrology target design;
[0035] Figure 6 schematically depicts a flow chart of an embodiment of measurement target design selection and qualification;
[0036] Figure 7 schematically depicts a flow chart of an embodiment of a further metrology target design qualification;
[0037] Figure 8 Schematically depicts a flow chart of an embodiment of measurement target design, selection, and qualification;
[0038] Fig. 9 A flow chart schematically depicts an embodiment of a measurement data mathematical model and sampling scheme evaluation;
[0039] Fig.10 A flow chart schematically depicts an embodiment of a method of verifying expected performance; and
[0040] Fig.11 A user interface of software of an embodiment to provide a portion of device manufacturing process development, monitoring and control is schematically depicted. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0041] Before describing the embodiments in detail, it is instructive to present an example environment in which the embodiments may be implemented.
[0042] Figure 1 A lithographic apparatus LA is schematically depicted. The apparatus comprises:
[0043] - an illumination system (illuminator) IL configured to condition a radiation beam B (e.g. UV radiation or DUV radiation);
[0044] a support structure (e.g., mask table) MT configured to support a patterning device (e.g., mask) MA and connected to a first positioner PM configured to accurately position the patterning device according to certain parameters;
[0045] a substrate table (e.g. wafer stage) WT configured to hold a substrate (e.g. resist-coated wafer) W and connected to a second positioner PW configured to accurately position the substrate according to certain parameters; and
[0046] - a projection system (e.g., a refractive projection lens system) PL, which is configured to project the pattern imparted to the radiation beam B by the patterning device MA onto a target portion C (e.g., comprising one or more dies) of the substrate W, the projection system being supported on a reference frame (RF).
[0047] The illumination system may include various types of optical components, such as refractive, reflective, magnetic, electromagnetic, electrostatic or other types of optical components, or any combination thereof, for directing, shaping or controlling the radiation.
[0048] The support structure supports the patterning device in a manner that depends on the orientation of the patterning device, the design of the lithographic apparatus, and other conditions such as, for example, whether the patterning device is held in a vacuum environment. The support structure can hold the patterning device using mechanical, vacuum, electrostatic or other clamping techniques. The support structure can be, for example, a frame or a stage, which can be fixed or movable as required. The support structure can ensure that the patterning device is in a desired position, for example relative to a projection system. Any use of the term "reticle" or "mask" herein can be considered synonymous with the more general term "patterning device".
[0049] The term "patterning device" as used herein should be broadly interpreted as referring to any device that can be used to impart a radiation beam with a pattern in its cross-section so as to create a pattern in a target portion of the substrate. It should be noted that the pattern imparted to the radiation beam may not exactly correspond to the desired pattern in the target portion of the substrate, for example if the pattern includes phase-shifting features or so-called assist features. Generally, the pattern imparted to the radiation beam will correspond to a specific functional layer in a device such as an integrated circuit being created in the target portion.
[0050] The patterning device may be transmissive or reflective. Examples of patterning devices include masks, programmable mirror arrays, and programmable LCD panels. Masks are well known in photolithography and include mask types such as binary, alternating phase shift, and attenuated phase shift, as well as various hybrid mask types. An example of a programmable mirror array employs a matrix arrangement of small mirrors, each of which can be individually tilted to reflect an incoming radiation beam in different directions. The tilted mirrors impart a pattern in the radiation beam reflected by the mirror array.
[0051] The term "projection system" as used herein should be interpreted broadly to cover any type of projection system, including refractive, reflective, catadioptric, magnetic, electromagnetic and electrostatic optical systems, or any combination thereof, depending on the exposure radiation being used or other factors such as the use of immersion liquid or the use of vacuum, etc. Any use of the term "projection lens" herein may be considered synonymous with the more general term "projection system."
[0052] As depicted here, the device is transmissive (eg, employing a transmissive mask). Alternatively, the device may be reflective (eg, employing a programmable mirror array of the type mentioned above, or employing a reflective mask).
[0053] The lithographic apparatus may be of a type having two (dual stage) or more stages (e.g. two or more substrate tables WTa, WTb, two or more patterning device tables, substrate table WTa and table WTb being below the projection system without a dedicated substrate for example to facilitate measurement and / or cleaning etc.). In such a "multi-stage" machine, the additional stages may be used in parallel, or preparatory steps may be performed on one or more stages while one or more other stages are being used for exposure. For example, alignment measurements using an alignment sensor AS and / or level (height, tilt etc.) measurements using a level sensor LS may be performed.
[0054] The lithographic apparatus may also be of a type in which at least a portion of the substrate may be covered by a liquid having a relatively high refractive index, such as water, so as to fill the space between the projection system and the substrate. Immersion liquid may also be applied to other spaces in the lithographic apparatus, for example, between the pattern forming device and the projection system. Immersion techniques are well known in the art for increasing the numerical aperture of projection systems. The term "immersion" as used herein does not mean that structures such as substrates must be immersed in the liquid, but only means that the liquid is located between the projection system and the substrate during exposure.
[0055] See also Figure 1 , the illuminator IL receives a radiation beam from a radiation source SO. The source and the lithographic apparatus may be separate entities, for example, when the source is an excimer laser. In such a case, the source is not regarded as forming part of the lithographic apparatus, and the radiation beam is delivered from the source SO to the illuminator IL with the help of a beam delivery system BD comprising, for example, suitable guide mirrors and / or a beam expander. In other cases, the source may be an integral part of the lithographic apparatus, for example when the source is a mercury lamp. The source SO and the illuminator IL together with the beam delivery system BD (if necessary) may be referred to as a radiation system.
[0056] The illuminator IL may include an adjuster AD configured to adjust the angular intensity distribution of the radiation beam. In general, at least the outer radial extent and / or the inner radial extent (often referred to as "σ-outer" and "σ-inner", respectively) of the intensity distribution in a pupil plane of the illuminator may be adjusted. In addition, the illuminator IL may include various other components, such as an integrator IN and a condenser CO. The illuminator may be used to condition the radiation beam to have a desired uniformity and intensity distribution in its cross-section.
[0057] The radiation beam B is incident on a patterning device (e.g. a mask) MA held on a support structure (e.g. a mask table) MT and is patterned by the patterning device. After traversing the patterning device MA, the radiation beam B passes through a projection system PL which focuses the beam onto a target portion C of the substrate W. With the aid of a second positioner PW and a position sensor IF (e.g. an interferometer arrangement, a linear encoder, a 2-D encoder or a capacitive sensor), the substrate table WT can be accurately moved, for example in order to position a different target portion C in the path of the radiation beam B. Similarly, the first positioner PM and a further position sensor (which is located in the substrate) are arranged in a manner similar to that of the first positioner PM and the second position sensor IF. Figure 1The support structure MT (not explicitly depicted in the figure) can be used to accurately position the pattern forming device MA relative to the path of the radiation beam B, for example after mechanical retrieval from a mask library, or during scanning. In general, the movement of the mask table MT can be achieved with the help of a long-stroke module (coarse positioning) and a short-stroke module (fine positioning) forming part of the first positioner PM. Similarly, the movement of the substrate table WT can be achieved using a long-stroke module and a short-stroke module forming part of the second positioner PW. In the case of a stepper (as opposed to a scanner), the support structure MT may be connected only to the short-stroke actuator, or may be fixed. The pattern forming device MA and the substrate W can be aligned using pattern forming device alignment marks M1, M2 and substrate alignment marks P1, P2. Although the substrate alignment marks as shown occupy dedicated target portions, they can be located in the space between the target portions (these are called scribe alignment marks). Similarly, in the case where more than one die is arranged on the pattern forming device MA, the pattern forming device alignment marks can be located between the die.
[0058] The depicted lithographic apparatus may be used in at least one of the following modes:
[0059] 1. In step mode, the support structure MT and substrate table WT are held substantially stationary while the entire pattern imparted to the radiation beam is projected onto a target portion C at one time (i.e. a single static exposure). The substrate table WT is subsequently shifted in the X and / or Y direction so that a different target portion C can be exposed. In step mode, the maximum size of the exposure field limits the size of the target portion C imaged in a single static exposure.
[0060] 2. In scan mode, the support structure MT and substrate table WT are scanned synchronously while a pattern imparted to the radiation beam is projected onto a target portion C (i.e. a single dynamic exposure). The speed and direction of the substrate table WT relative to the support structure MT may be determined by the (de-)magnification and image reversal characteristics of the projection system PL. In scan mode, the maximum size of the exposure field limits the width of the target portion in a single dynamic exposure (in the non-scanning direction), while the length of the scanning movement determines the height of the target portion (in the scanning direction).
[0061] 3. In another mode, the support structure MT is held substantially stationary holding the programmable patterning device, and the substrate table WT is moved or scanned while a pattern imparted to the radiation beam is projected onto a target portion C. In this mode, a pulsed radiation source is typically employed, and the programmable patterning device is updated as required after each movement of the substrate table WT or between successive radiation pulses during a scan. This mode of operation can be readily applied to maskless lithography using a programmable patterning device such as a programmable mirror array of the type mentioned above.
[0062] Combinations and / or variations of the described modes of use or entirely different modes of use may also be employed.
[0063] like Figure 2 As shown, the lithography apparatus LA forms part of a lithography cell LC, sometimes also referred to as a lithography cell or cluster, which also includes equipment for performing pre-exposure and post-exposure processes on a substrate. Traditionally, these equipment include one or more spin coaters SC for depositing a resist layer, one or more developers DE for developing the exposed resist, one or more chill plates CH and / or one or more baking plates BK. A substrate handler or robot RO picks up one or more substrates from input / output ports I / O1, I / O2, moves them between different process equipment and transfers them to a loading platform LB of the lithography apparatus. These equipment, often collectively referred to as tracks, are under the control of a track control unit TCU, which itself is controlled by a monitoring system SCS, which also controls the lithography apparatus via a lithography control unit LACU. Therefore, different equipment can be operated to maximize throughput and processing efficiency.
[0064] In order for substrates exposed by the lithographic apparatus to be correctly and consistently exposed, it is desirable to inspect the exposed substrates to measure one or more properties such as overlay error between subsequent layers, line thickness, critical dimension (CD), focus offset, material properties, etc. Accordingly, the manufacturing facility in which the lithocell LC is located also typically comprises a metrology system MET which receives some or all of the substrates W that have been processed in the lithocell. The metrology system MET may be part of the lithocell LC, for example it may be part of the lithographic apparatus LA.
[0065] The metrology results may be provided directly or indirectly to the monitoring system SCS. If an error is detected, adjustments may be made to the exposure of subsequent substrates (especially if the inspection can be completed quickly enough that one or more other substrates of the same batch are still to be exposed) and / or to the subsequent exposure of already exposed substrates. Also, already exposed substrates may be stripped and reprocessed to increase productivity, or discarded, thereby avoiding further processing on substrates known to be defective. In the case where only some target portions of the substrate are defective, further exposures may be performed only on those target portions that are good.
[0066] In the measurement system MET, an inspection device is used to determine one or more properties of the substrate, and in particular, to inspect how one or more properties of different substrates vary or how different layers of the same substrate vary from layer to layer. The inspection device can be integrated into the lithography device LA or the lithography unit LC, or can be an independent device. In order to enable rapid measurement, it is desirable that the inspection device measures one or more properties in the exposed resist layer immediately after exposure. However, the latent image in the resist has a low contrast—there is only a very small difference in refractive index between the part of the resist that has been exposed to radiation and those that have not been exposed—and not all inspection devices have sufficient sensitivity to perform useful measurements of the latent image. Thus the measurement can be performed after a post-exposure baking step (PEB), which is customarily the first step performed on the exposed substrate and increases the contrast between the exposed and unexposed parts of the resist. At this stage, the image in the resist can be referred to as semi-latent. Measurements can also be made on a developed resist image - when exposed or unexposed parts of the resist have been removed - or after a pattern transfer step such as etching etc. The latter possibility limits the possibilities for reworking of defective substrates but can still provide useful information.
[0067] In order to monitor a device manufacturing process including at least one lithography step, a patterned substrate is inspected and one or more parameters of the patterned substrate are measured. One or more parameters may include, for example, an overlay error between successive layers formed in or on the patterned substrate, a critical line width (e.g., critical dimension (CD)) of a developed photoresist, a focus or focus error of lithography, a dose or dose error of lithography, aberration of lithography, etc. The measurement may be performed on a target of the product substrate itself and / or on a dedicated measurement target disposed on the substrate. There are various techniques for performing measurements of structures formed in the device manufacturing process, including the use of scanning electron microscopes, image-based measurement or inspection tools, and / or various specialized tools. A fast and non-invasive form of specialized measurement and / or inspection tools is one in which a beam of radiation is directed to a target on the surface of the substrate and the properties of the scattered (diffraction / reflection) beam are measured. By comparing one or more properties of the beam before and after scattering by the substrate, one or more properties of the substrate may be determined. This may be referred to as diffraction-based measurement or inspection. A particular application of this diffraction-based metrology or inspection is in the measurement of feature asymmetry within a periodic target. This can be used, for example, as a measure of overlay error, but other applications are also known. For example, asymmetry can be measured by comparing relative portions of the diffraction spectrum (e.g., comparing the -1 and +1 orders in the diffraction spectrum of a periodic grating). This can be done simply as described, for example, in U.S. Patent Application Publication US2006-066855, which is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety.
[0068] Important aspects of enabling a device manufacturing process include developing the process itself, setting it up for monitoring and control, and then actually monitoring and controlling the process itself. Assuming a basic configuration of the device manufacturing process (such as, patterning device pattern, resist type, post-lithography process steps (such as development, etching, etc.), etc.), it is desirable to set up the lithography equipment for transferring the pattern to the substrate, develop the measurement target to monitor the process, set up the measurement process to measure the measurement target, and then implement the process of monitoring and controlling the process based on the measurement. Although the discussion in this application will consider embodiments of measurement targets designed to measure the overlap between one or more layers of a device being formed on a substrate, the embodiments herein are equally applicable to other measurement targets, such as targets for measuring alignment (e.g., between the patterning device and the substrate), targets for measuring critical dimensions, etc. Accordingly, references herein to overlay measurement targets, overlay data, etc. should be considered as appropriately modified to enable other kinds of targets and measurement processes.
[0069] See also Figure 3 , showing a high-level overview of the development, monitoring, and control process. Figure 3 Each of these various steps shown in the embodiment is implemented at least in part using software. In an embodiment, the software associated with each of the steps is integrated together so that available results, designs, data, etc. from one of the multiple parts of the integrated software application can be shared as input to another of the multiple parts of the integrated software application.
[0070] As noted above, at 300, a lithographic apparatus may be set up for performing lithographic aspects of a device fabrication process, and may optionally be configured to correct for deviations occurring within the lithographic apparatus or in other processes in the device fabrication process. Such setting includes setting one or more parameters of the lithographic apparatus.
[0071] In an embodiment, the setting may include establishing a baseline setting for the lithographic apparatus and enabling subsequent monitoring of the lithographic apparatus and adjustment of one or more parameters of the lithographic apparatus. For example, the lithographic apparatus may be set to its baseline setting for optimal operation. Such a setting may match other lithographic apparatus in the factory. However, over time, system performance parameters will drift. In addition to stopping production and recalibrating or rematching, one or more monitoring substrates may be exposed and measured, for example, using a measurement system MET, to capture one or more performance parameters of the lithographic apparatus, such as the overlapping grid of the lithographic apparatus and the focus calibration state of each substrate stage. Based on these measurements, one or more parameters are identified, and correction or change of the parameters will enable the lithographic apparatus to return to its baseline setting. In addition, an updated value of one or more parameters identified is calculated to return the lithographic apparatus to optimal operation. Subsequently, when production continues, one or more lithographic apparatus parameters are automatically updated based on the measured parameters to return the lithographic apparatus to its baseline. Such a "reset" may occur, for example, once a day or in other regular time periods. Optionally, the software can decide when updates should be applied, and whether they need to be rewritten on the lithography equipment or whether it needs to be shut down for a certain time. An example of such software is ASML's Baseliner software.
[0072] In an embodiment, one or more inspection devices may be configured to perform lithographic aspects of a device manufacturing process and may optionally be configured to correct for deviations occurring within the inspection device or in other processes in the device manufacturing process. Such configuration includes setting one or more parameters of the inspection device. Such inspection devices may be diffraction-based overlay metrology tools that can measure, for example, overlay, critical dimensions, and / or other parameters. Such inspection devices may be alignment devices used to measure the relative position between two objects, such as between a pattern forming device and a substrate. Such inspection devices may be level sensors used to measure the position of a surface, such as the height and / or rotational position of a substrate surface.
[0073] In an embodiment, the setting may include establishing a baseline setting for the inspection device and enabling subsequent monitoring of the inspection device and adjustment of one or more parameters of the inspection device. For example, the inspection device may be set to its baseline setting for optimal operation. Such a setting may match other inspection devices in the factory. However, over time, system performance parameters will drift. In addition to stopping production and recalibrating or rematching, one or more monitoring substrates may be exposed and measured, for example, using an inspection device or a measurement system MET, to capture one or more performance parameters of the inspection device. Based on these measurements, one or more parameters are identified, and correction or change of the parameters will enable the inspection device to return to its baseline setting. In addition, an updated value of one or more parameters identified is calculated to return the inspection device to optimal operation. Subsequently, when production continues, one or more inspection device parameters are automatically updated based on the measured parameters to return the inspection device to its baseline. Such a "reset" may occur, for example, once a day or at other regular time periods. Optionally, the software may decide when updates should be applied, and whether they need to be rewritten on the inspection device or whether they need to be shut down for a certain time.
[0074] At 310, the measurement can be set up for the device manufacturing process. In an embodiment, the setting includes the design of one or more measurement targets for the device manufacturing process. For example, one or more overlapping measurement targets can be developed for exposure on a substrate during production. In addition, measurement options for one or more measurement targets can be developed. The measurement option is one or more parameters (and one or more associated values) associated with the measurement equipment itself and / or the measurement process used to measure one or more measurement targets, such as one or more wavelengths of the measurement beam, one or more types of polarization of the measurement beam, one or more dose values of the measurement beam, one or more bandwidths of the measurement beam, one or more aperture settings of the inspection equipment used with the measurement beam, alignment marks for positioning the measurement beam on the target, the alignment scheme used, the sampling scheme, the layout of the measurement target, and the movement scheme for measuring the target and / or the point of interest of the target, etc. In an embodiment, one or more measurement targets can be qualified for the device manufacturing process. For example, multiple measurement target designs can be evaluated to identify one or more measurement targets that minimize residual variation (systematic and / or random). In an embodiment, multiple metrology target designs may be evaluated to identify one or more metrology targets whose performance matches that of the device, e.g., to identify metrology targets whose measure of overlay error matches that of the device. The metrology targets may be, for example, designs for measurements of overlay, focus, critical dimension (CD), alignment, asymmetry in the target, etc., and any combination thereof.
[0075] In addition, the device manufacturing process may have specific systematic changes (fingerprints) generated by the nature of the process. For example, the device manufacturing process may require the use of a specific substrate stage in the lithography unit LC, the use of a specific etching or development type, the use of specific baking parameters, the use of specific focus and dose settings, etc., which may cause specific periodic changes in the exposure of multiple substrates. Therefore, at 320, the process can be set by determining the correction of one or more parameters (e.g., one or more parameters of the lithography equipment, one or more parameters of the track, etc.) to be applied to the device manufacturing process to take into account the systematic changes generated by the specific device manufacturing process. This may result in a high-order set of corrections to the baseline settings as described above. In order to achieve this correction, a process fingerprint can be estimated by simulation and / or by measuring the substrate exposed in the development stage. From the process fingerprint, one or more lithography and / or process correction models can be developed, which can be applied to modify the lithography equipment, track, etc., to at least partially correct the process fingerprint.
[0076] The lithographic apparatus setup 300, the metrology setup 310 and the process setup 320 may together be considered as part of a process development phase 330. In addition to process development, steps of monitoring and controlling the device manufacturing process should also be performed during high volume manufacturing (HVM).
[0077] At 340, the metrology process is configured to enable measurement of one or more metrology targets to enable monitoring and control of the device manufacturing process at 350. It may be too time consuming to measure each metrology target for each substrate of each batch (a batch is a group of substrates of typically the same characteristics that are processed together during the operation of the device manufacturing process; a batch of substrates is typically held together in a movable container such as a FOUP). Therefore, a measurement sampling scheme can be established for measuring one or more metrology targets. The sampling scheme for the metrology process may include one or more parameters selected from the following parameters: the number of substrates per batch sampled; the numerical designation of a batch or each batch of substrates sampled; the number of fields sampled; the positioning of the sampled fields on the substrate; the number of sites in each field; the positioning of the sites in the field; the frequency of sampling; the type of metrology target; or the measurement algorithm. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme is designed to minimize variation. For example, the sampling scheme can be selected to minimize substrate-to-substrate variation, batch-to-batch variation, and / or machine-to-machine variation (e.g., variation between lithographic equipment in a factory). In addition, one or more key performance indicators (KPIs) can be identified, and one or more thresholds associated with the KPIs can be determined to enable process control. For example, an average, a variation, etc. can be identified as a KPI and a threshold value (e.g., a value not exceeded, a value not lower than, etc.) can be determined to be used as a control limit for the process. In addition, the measurement results of the measurement target can be modeled using one or more appropriately parameterized measurement data mathematical models (i.e., a mathematical model with appropriately determined and defined parameters and their available values to fit the data (wherein fitting does not necessarily mean a perfect fit using all data) to the mathematical model). Therefore, a measurement data mathematical model can be established for measuring one or more measurement targets. In an embodiment, a measurement data mathematical model and a sampling scheme are established together. In an embodiment, a mathematical model may include one or more basic functions specified by one or more parameters; typically, a mathematical model may include a combination of multiple basic functions. In an embodiment, the mathematical model is parameterized with the values of the parameters that fit the data.
[0078] See also Figure 4, depicting a more detailed flow chart of an embodiment of a metrology setup. At 400, data for a design of one or more metrology targets is obtained or provided. For example, the data may include, for example, information about the properties of one or more layers produced using a device manufacturing process (and to which one or more metrology targets are to be applied). This may be referred to as stacking information. Such data may include information about parameters such as layer thickness, layer material, layer refractive index, layer absorption index, etc., and may include variation data associated with such parameters (e.g., a certain range of expected variations associated with the parameters). The data may include, for example, information about the properties of one or more processes associated with one or more layers. Such data may include types and / or parameters of etching, types and / or parameters of post-exposure baking, types and / or parameters of resist development, etc., and may include variation data associated with such parameters (e.g., a certain range of expected variations associated with the parameters). The data may include, for example, an overlap tree that specifies which layers of a plurality of layers overlap measurements are expected between.
[0079] At 405, one or more metrology target designs are determined. In an embodiment, the one or more metrology target designs are determined by a simulation program that simulates the device manufacturing process and measurement process of the candidate target design based on, for example, an applicable full layer stack to allow the design parameters of the target for a given layer to be optimized. Therefore, in the simulation, one or more design parameters of the target can be fixed or allowed to vary. Such parameters can include the pitch of the periodic structure of the target, the critical dimension of the features of the periodic structure of the target, the thickness, etc. In addition, one or more parameters of the measurement option (e.g., measurement beam wavelength, measurement beam polarization, measurement beam dose, aperture settings associated with the measurement beam, etc.) can be fixed or allowed to vary. In an embodiment, the software accepts or provides a user interface to allow the stack and process (e.g., layer material, etching type, deposition type, polishing (e.g., CMP) process, etc.) to be defined, specified, indicate which one or more parameters can be fixed and which can be varied, specify the range of variability of the varied parameters, design rules or constraints, etc.
[0080] Once the starting conditions are specified, the software can run simulations to identify one or more metrology target designs, one or more metrology options (e.g., for a particular metrology target design), and / or one or more combinations of metrology designs and metrology options that meet printability, detectability, throughput, process stability (e.g., sensitivity to process variations), and / or tool dependency (e.g., sensitivity to inspection equipment specific parameters). Overlay accuracy and lens aberration performance can be further determined through simulation.
[0081] So, for example, based on the conditions of the stack and device manufacturing process, simulation models (such as image / resist models and resist processing models that can optionally be specially configured for the capabilities of a particular lithography or other equipment) can be used to determine how various metrology target designs with different design parameters and / or various metrology target options with different option parameters will be generated for applicable device manufacturing processes. For example, by including information about the exposure process, the sensitivity of the metrology target design to projection system aberrations can be matched to the sensitivity of the key device features being printed in a specified layer, so that overlap gain can be achieved. In addition, simulation models of the measurement process (such as diffraction simulation models that can optionally be specially configured for the measurement capabilities of a particular inspection equipment) can be used to evaluate various metrology target designs according to specified or varying metrology options (e.g., different wavelengths, different polarizations, different doses, etc.) and / or to evaluate metrology target designs for varying metrology options. The results may be a ranking by performance (e.g., printability, detectability, throughput, process stability, tool dependency, etc.) or measure of performance of various metrology target designs and / or metrology options to allow selection of one or more metrology target designs and / or one or more metrology options by a user or by automated processing. Where one or more parameters of the metrology options are allowed to vary, the results for the metrology target designs may include associated specifications for one or more parameters of the metrology options for various metrology target designs. So, for example, the ranking may be a presentation of metrology target designs, may be a presentation of metrology target designs, may be a presentation of combinations of metrology target designs and metrology options (so that, for example, a particular metrology target design may have multiple metrology options that produce multiple combinations of the same metrology target design with different metrology options, etc.), where the base ranking may be on metrology target designs or on metrology options, etc.
[0082] In addition, in an embodiment, the robustness of various metrology target designs and / or metrology options to process variations can be evaluated by allowing perturbations of one of a plurality of parameters (e.g., based on variation data) to determine the sensitivity of the various metrology target designs and / or metrology options to perturbations of the various parameters. The perturbations can be for etching parameters, for polishing process parameters, for critical dimensions of structures of the target, and the like. The result can be a ranking by robustness or a measure of robustness of the various metrology target designs and / or metrology options to allow selection of one or more metrology target designs and / or metrology options by a user or by automatic processing. One or more of the identified metrology target designs and / or metrology options can be selected for use or further evaluation, and in the case of metrology target designs, the software can output pattern forming device patterns for one or more identified metrology target designs, for example in a GDS format. Thus, the software can evaluate thousands, if not millions, of metrology target designs and / or metrology options, and thus allow for good exploration of the design space by identifying metrology target designs and / or metrology options that balance precision and accuracy.
[0083] At 410, one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement options (typically multiple measurement target designs and / or measurement options) from 405 are further evaluated in an experimental manner. In particular, multiple measurement options for inspection equipment can be determined for each measurement target design (which may include one or more measurement options from 405, where one or more measurement options are output), and then the inspection equipment is used to create and measure one or more measurement target designs under each measurement option. Each measurement target design is evaluated according to multiple measurement options to enable the determination of a suitable or optimal option. In an embodiment, the total measurement uncertainty of one or more of the measurement target designs is determined. In an embodiment, the accuracy of one or more of the measurement target designs is determined (for example, through the use of residuals). From the various results, a ranking by performance or measure of performance of the evaluated one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement options can be created to allow selection of one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement options from the evaluated one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement options by a user or by automatic processing.
[0084] At 415, one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement options (typically a plurality of measurement target designs and / or measurement options) from 410 are further evaluated experimentally. In an embodiment, the accuracy of one or more of the measurement target designs and / or measurement options is determined (e.g., through the use of residuals). From the various results, a ranking by performance or measure of performance of the evaluated one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement options can be created to allow selection of one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement options from the evaluated one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement options by a user or by automated processing.
[0085] At 420, one or more metrology target designs and / or metrology options (typically multiple metrology target designs) from 410 are further evaluated experimentally using multiple inspection devices, for example, in cases where more than one inspection device is used to measure one or more metrology targets, for example, in process development and / or HVM, and / or different inspection devices are used for evaluation than, for example, in process development and / or HVM. In an embodiment, a correction for one or more of the inspection devices may be determined based on measurements of the one or more metrology target designs and / or using one or more metrology options. In an embodiment, the correction may cause the inspection devices to have matching performance.
[0086] At 425, one or more identified and evaluated metrology target designs and / or metrology options are ready for use in HVM. In the event that multiple metrology target designs and / or metrology options exist, the user may select which one or more metrology target designs and / or metrology options are appropriate for the device manufacturing process.
[0087] At 430, feedback information may be provided for subsequent preparation and provision of data 400. Using the feedback information, data 400 may be improved or better selected.
[0088] Referring to 435, processes 405, 410, 415, and 420 are repeated for each layer / measurement step. That is, these processes are repeated for each layer designed to have a metrology target measured by a processing step and for each measurement step involving that layer (e.g., a target in a layer can be used to measure different layers, whether at the same measurement time or at different times in the device manufacturing process). Therefore, multiple metrology target designs are evaluated for each layer designed to have a metrology target, and further evaluated according to each measurement step associated therewith.
[0089] Referring to 440, process 410 is repeated for each measurement target design and / or measurement matching scheme, which may be each measurement target design and / or measurement matching scheme from process 405. For example, it may involve evaluating approximately 10 to 40 measurement target designs. The output result of process 401 may be one or more of the measurement target designs and / or measurement matching schemes started, for example, a subset of 2 to 15 measurement target designs. Referring to 445, process 415 is repeated for each measurement target design and / or measurement matching scheme, which may be each measurement target design and / or measurement matching scheme from process 410. For example, it may involve evaluating approximately 2 to 15 measurement target designs. The output result of process 415 may be one or more of the measurement target designs and / or measurement matching schemes started, for example, a subset of 1 to 10 measurement target designs. Referring to 450, process 420 is repeated for each measurement target design and / or measurement option, which may be each measurement target design and / or measurement option from process 415. For example, it may involve evaluating approximately 1 to 10 measurement target designs. The output of process 420 may be one or more of the starting measurement target designs and / or measurement options, for example, 1 to 5 measurement target designs.
[0090] See also Figure 5 , presenting details of an embodiment of process 405. As described above, using data 400, one or more metrology target designs are determined at 500 by a simulation program, which simulates the device manufacturing process and measurement process of the candidate target design based on, for example, an applicable full layer stack to allow the design parameters of the target for a given layer to be optimized. As noted above, in the simulation, one or more design parameters of the target can be fixed or allowed to vary. Such parameters can include the pitch of the periodic structure of the target, the critical dimension of the structural feature, the thickness, etc. In addition, one or more parameters of the measurement option (e.g., measurement beam wavelength, measurement beam polarization, measurement beam dose, aperture setting associated with the measurement beam, etc.) can be fixed or allowed to vary. In an embodiment, at 505, the software accepts or provides a user interface to allow the stack and process (e.g., layer material, etching type, deposition type, polishing (e.g., CMP) process, etc.) to be defined, specified, indicate which one or more parameters can be fixed and which can be varied, specify the range of variability of the varied parameters, design rules or constraints, etc.
[0091] At 510, a ranking by performance (e.g., printability, detectability, robustness, etc. or combinations thereof, including weighted combinations) or measures of performance of various metrology target designs is provided to allow selection of one or more metrology target designs by a user or by automatic processing. The output may be hundreds if not thousands of metrology target designs. As discussed above, the metrology target designs may also be associated with one or more parameters of a metrology match, particularly where one or more of the metrology match parameters are variable during simulation. The parameters of the metrology target designs may be characterized by various parameters such as, for example, target coefficient (TC), stack sensitivity (SS), overlap impact (OV), asymmetry (as described herein), diffraction efficiency (as described herein), or the like. Stack sensitivity may be understood as a measure of how much signal strength changes as overlap changes due to diffraction between target (e.g., grating) layers. The target coefficient may be understood as a measure of the signal-to-noise ratio for a particular measurement time as a result of changes in photon collection by the measurement system. In embodiments, the target coefficient may also be considered as a ratio of stack sensitivity to photon noise; that is, the signal (i.e., stack sensitivity) may be divided by a measure of the photon noise to determine the target coefficient. Overlay shock measures the change in overlay error as a function of the target design. Additionally, the performance of the metrology target design may be characterized by its robustness with respect to variations, such as its sensitivity with respect to variations in one or more process parameters.
[0092] At 515, one or more measurement target designs (and, if applicable, associated measurement matching scheme parameters) are selected from the multiple measurement target designs at 510, either manually or through automated processing. At 515, one or more guidelines, constraints, or thresholds may be provided to facilitate the selection of one or more measurement target designs. For example, a manual or automated criterion may be the selection of a certain number of the highest ranked measurement target designs from 510. The ranking may be based on a single performance parameter, on a combination of performance parameters, or on a weighted combination of performance parameters, and so on. Another manual or automated criterion may be the selection of measurement target designs that pass a certain threshold of performance parameters, optionally whether those measurement target designs pass another threshold. For example, a manual or automated criterion may be an evaluation of the measurement target designs based on stack sensitivity related to a target coefficient.
[0093] At 520, the selected one or more metrology target designs (and associated metrology matching solution parameters, if applicable) from 515 are output along with the specification of the metrology target designs (and associated metrology matching solution parameters, if applicable). The selection can be 10 to 40 metrology target designs per layer.
[0094] At 530, an optical proximity correction process is performed to convert the metrology target design into a design for a patterning device (e.g., a mask). The base metrology target design may not be directly convertible into a pattern for a patterning device or a pattern for a patterning device and produce a designed metrology target on a substrate. Accordingly, various optical proximity correction processes such as wiring, bias, scattering bars, etc. may need to be added to the metrology target design to create a metrology target design suitable for a patterning device. The output at 535 may be a metrology target design pattern for a patterning device, for example, in a GDS format, for each metrology target design.
[0095] At 540, one or more patterning device patterns of the metrology target design may be inserted into the device pattern of one or more patterning devices used in the device manufacturing process. The result will include information 545 about the selected one or more metrology target designs and the location of the patterns of the selected one or more metrology target designs in the device pattern of one or more patterning devices used in the device manufacturing process.
[0096] See also Figure 6 , presenting details of an embodiment of processes 410 and 415. Using information 545, one or more metrology profiles (typically a plurality of metrology profiles) are generated for each of the selected one or more metrology target designs. As noted above, a metrology profile includes one or more parameters (and one or more associated values) associated with the metrology equipment itself used to measure the one or more metrology targets and / or the measurement process, such as one or more wavelengths of the measurement beam, one or more types of polarization of the measurement beam, one or more doses of the measurement beam, one or more bandwidths of the measurement beam, one or more aperture settings on the inspection equipment associated with the measurement beam, alignment marks used to position the measurement beam on the target, the alignment scheme used, the sampling scheme, the layout of the metrology targets, and the movement scheme used to measure the targets and / or points of interest of the targets, etc.
[0097] To enable generation of one or more metrology matching schemes, metrology matching scheme template information 605 may be provided. The metrology matching scheme template information 605 may define common details about one or more parameters of the metrology matching scheme, such as alignment marks used to position the measurement beam on the target, the alignment scheme used, the size of the measurement beam spot, the sampling scheme, etc.
[0098] At 610, a metrology profile optimization process is performed to determine one or more suitable metrology profiles for each metrology target design. To do so, measurement results 615 from one or more substrates patterned with one or more metrology target designs and measured under one or more generated metrology profiles may be analyzed. In an embodiment, such results are from a selected number of targets (i.e., a sample of targets) exposed on a substrate. One or more performance parameters may be calculated for a combination of metrology profiles and metrology target designs and evaluated to determine which one or more metrology profiles are most suitable. Result information, such as optimized performance results, may be generated at 620.
[0099] At 625, a total measurement uncertainty (TMU) of one or more metrology target designs is determined using one or more selected metrology recipes from 610. To do so, measurement results 630 from one or more substrates patterned using one or more metrology target designs and measured under one or more selected metrology recipes may be analyzed. In an embodiment, such results are from a selected number of targets (i.e., a sample of targets) exposed on a substrate. In an embodiment, any combination of metrology target designs and selected metrology recipes that equal or exceed a threshold value for TMU may be excluded for further evaluation. Result information, such as a TMU verification result, may be generated at 635.
[0100] At 640, the accuracy of one or more of the metrology target designs is determined (e.g., by the use of residuals). In an embodiment, one or more metrology target designs with sufficient TMU from 625 and one or more associated metrology options are analyzed. In order to determine the accuracy, measurement results 645 from one or more substrates that are patterned using those one or more metrology target designs and measured under their associated one or more metrology options can be analyzed. In an embodiment, such results come from all, almost all, or at least most of the targets exposed on the substrate. In an embodiment, such results come from less than most of the targets exposed on the substrate, for example, using an appropriate sampling scheme. From the measurement results, the accuracy of the metrology target design can be evaluated by calculating the residual between the measurement results and the parameterized measurement data mathematical model used to describe the measurement results. Those metrology target designs with low residuals are those that are more accurate. Information such as accuracy performance results and optional inspection equipment calibration to reduce or minimize residuals can be generated at 620. In addition, correction settings for inspection equipment used during process control can be determined at 650.
[0101] In an embodiment, process 625 may be performed after process 640 .
[0102] At 655, one or more measurement target designs are evaluated along with one or more measurement options thereof to identify a subset of measurement target designs suitable for further evaluation. The evaluation may be performed on the results from processes 610, 625, 640, or any combination selected therefrom. For example, a ranking by performance or measure of performance of a combination of the evaluated measurement target designs and measurement options may be created to allow selection of one or more measurement target designs (and their associated measurement options) from a combination of the evaluated measurement target designs and measurement options by a user or by automated processing.
[0103] At 660, a list of the selected one or more metrology target designs is generated, which may include details of the one or more metrology target designs and details of the associated one or more metrology options. In the case where the metrology target is measured using only a single inspection device, the list may be ready for use in the HVM, particularly in the case where the inspection device used is an inspection device used in the HVM.
[0104] See also Figure 7 , presenting details of an embodiment of process 420, where, for example, more than one inspection device is used to measure one or more measurement targets in the HVM and / or the inspection device used for evaluation is different from the inspection device used by the HVM. From the data from 660, one or more combinations of measurement target designs and measurement options are selected. For each combination, the measurement target is patterned onto the substrate and then measured using the inspection device using the measurement option. In this case, each combination is measured using a first inspection device at 700, a second inspection device at 705, and a third inspection device at 710. In this example, there are three inspection devices, but there may be more or fewer inspection devices. From the measurement results, applicable corrections 715, 720, 725 for the corresponding inspection devices can be determined, for example, to reduce or minimize residuals. In addition, at 730, the results from 700, 705, 710, the results from 715, 720, 725, and / or the performance parameters derived from any of the foregoing can be evaluated to determine the matching performance between the inspection devices. For example, if one or more combinations of metrology target designs and metrology configurations perform better on the inspection equipment collective than on one or more other combinations, then those combinations may be selected for HVM.
[0105] At 735 , a list of one or more selected metrology targets is generated, for example, for HVM or for development of a manufacturing process, the list may include details of one or more metrology target designs and details of associated one or more metrology options.
[0106] See also Figure 8 , depicts a schematic flow chart of an embodiment of measurement target design, selection, and qualification. In this figure, certain aspects of the process are divided into general categories. The first category 800 of operations involves the design and selection of one or more measurement target designs through calculation or simulation. This generally corresponds to the measurement target design 405 and Figure 5 The operations of the second category 805 involve analysis of data associated with one of the multiple measurement target designs selected in category 800 to select one or more measurement target designs for HVM. Also, the operations of the third category 810 involve collection of data for use in one or more of the operations in category 800 and / or 805.
[0107] Thus, at 815, various parameters including stack or other process conditions (e.g., information about the material, dimensions, and / or optical properties of a layer in which the metrology target or a portion thereof is disposed (e.g., optical properties, material thickness, refractive index, absorption index, etc.), information about one or more layers above the metrology target (e.g., thickness of a process layer, refractive index of a process layer, absorption index of a process layer, etc.), information about how the layer is processed (e.g., polishing parameters, etching parameters, etc.), information about characteristics of an inspection apparatus (as further described below), information about settings of an inspection apparatus, information about characteristics of a lithography apparatus, information about an alignment strategy used to measure the target, etc., and / or information about a measure of a change in any of the foregoing) are used to perform the above-described processes as described for example with respect to metrology target design 405 and Figure 5 The simulation steps described in all or a portion of the processes such as processes 500, 510, 520, and 525 of the present invention are performed to simulate the performance of one or more different metrology target designs, which can be created by the simulation by varying one or more metrology target design parameters (such as periodic structure pitch, structural feature critical dimensions, etc. and including one or more stacking or other process conditions). As discussed above, the performance can be and the performance parameters can represent printability, detectability, precision, robustness, throughput, accuracy, asymmetry, diffraction efficiency (as described below), inspection tool specific parameters (e.g., sensitivity to sensor artifacts as described below), etc., or a combination thereof.
[0108] The measurement target design can be ranked or otherwise evaluated based on its simulation performance (which is at nominal stacking information). In an embodiment, the simulation is performed under a range of stacking or other processing conditions around the expected or measured processing conditions as described below. The range can be defined by the user.
[0109] As described above, simulations can be performed using various different measurement scheme parameters (e.g., different measurement beam wavelengths, different measurement beam polarizations, different measurement beam doses, etc. or any combination thereof) and different values thereof. Thus, the result can be a combination of a measurement target design and one or more measurement scheme parameters (and associated values) that is, for example, ranked highly through a threshold, etc.
[0110] From the simulation, one or more of the metrology target designs may be selected to provide an initial set of metrology target designs. These metrology target designs are output at 817. The data at 817 may further include stacking information, simulation performance of the metrology target designs, their ranking, and / or specification of one or more associated metrology matching scheme parameters.
[0111] At 820, based on the data of 817, the software generates one or more measurement options (typically a plurality of measurement options) for one or more, if not all, of the measurement target designs at 817 for use in the measurement target design performance evaluation. This step generally corresponds to step 600 described above. In an embodiment, the measurement options include all specific wavelength and polarization combinations available at the inspection device. In an embodiment, the one or more measurement options for a specific measurement target design include one or more of the associated measurement option parameters (and their associated values) from the data 817. In an embodiment, the one or more measurement options for a specific measurement target design may include a range of values around or relative to the values of one or more of the associated measurement option parameters from the data 817. For example, if data 817 specifies a measurement beam wavelength, then one or more measurement matches may include those having the measurement beam wavelength and / or within a range around or relative to the measurement beam wavelength (e.g., a range of 50 nm, 100 nm, 150 nm, 200 nm, 250 nm, 300 nm, or 350 nm). At 822, the matches are output.
[0112] At 825, the measurement target design for which the matching scheme is generated at 820 is formed onto a plurality of substrates processed using a device manufacturing process, and then measured using the matching scheme of 822 using an inspection device. This step generally corresponds to step 615. As described above with respect to step 615, the data set may be a sample of the target on the substrate to assist in the speed of evaluation. In an embodiment, a programmed change relative to a measured or derived parameter may be introduced. For example, in the case where the measurement involves overlap, a known programmed overlap error may be introduced to assist in performance evaluation. Output 827 will be, for example, overlap data for each of a plurality of measurement target designs. And for each measurement target design, there will be data for a plurality of matching schemes. In an embodiment, the data may represent measured values or parameters derived from measured values for one or more various measurement target design parameters and / or one or more various measurement matching scheme parameters. In an embodiment, the data collected at 825 may be data for determining parameters representing the sensitivity of one or more measurement matching schemes or one or more measurement matching scheme parameters to one or more measurement targets.
[0113] In an embodiment, measurements of a structure (e.g., a periodic structure) of a measurement target design may be performed to determine parameters representing changes in the structure due to process variability. For example, the structure may have asymmetry due to variability in the processing of the structure and / or one or more layers above the structure. In an embodiment, in order to obtain such measurements, specific marks or features may be used to measure such changes. Such specific marks or features may also be used to monitor device manufacturing processes. In an embodiment, in the case where the measurement target design includes a lower periodic structure and an upper periodic structure, measurements of the lower periodic structure of the measurement target design may be performed when the associated upper periodic structure of the measurement target design is not located above the lower periodic structure during measurement.
[0114] Thus, these measurements can represent process variations that arise in the creation of the structure of the measurement target and / or one or more layers overlying the structure (and can subsequently be used to achieve robustness of the measurement target design to process variability). For example, these measurements can represent the amount of asymmetry present in a structure (e.g., a lower periodic structure of a measurement target design having an upper periodic structure). For example, low asymmetry can represent a robustness target or target parameter. For example, a set of data can represent the value of asymmetry for different combinations of wavelength and polarization for each of a plurality of measurement target designs. Such data can, for example, represent or be used to derive parameters representing the sensitivity of one or more measurement options or one or more measurement option parameters to one or more measurement targets, because such data shows how different options measure the same target. As another example, a set of data can represent the value of asymmetry for different values of measurement target design parameters, such as the pitch of a periodic structure of a measurement target design, the critical size of a structural feature of a measurement target design, the segmentation of features of a periodic structure of a measurement target design, and the like. As another example, a set of data may represent measured strengths for various metrology target design parameters or metrology recipe parameters.
[0115] Additionally, measurements may be made at different stages of the device manufacturing process to determine which process steps are likely to cause variability in the results, such as causing deformation of the structure of the measurement target. That is, in an embodiment, the asymmetry may be measured after each layer or a certain number of layers of the stack have been applied (as an example) to investigate which of the layers in the device manufacturing process caused the asymmetry to occur. This allows for layer-by-layer analysis of the stack, which may be used for adjustments as described herein.
[0116] In an embodiment, one or more properties may be varied at one or more of these different stages to help determine whether the metrology target design is robust to variations in the one or more properties. The one or more properties may include one or more selected from the following: optical properties of a layer (e.g., material refractive index or material absorption index), material thickness, polishing parameters, and / or etching parameters.
[0117] At 830, the data 827 is evaluated to filter combinations of measurement target designs and options based on performance. This step generally corresponds to step 610 and optional 625. For example, the data 827 is processed to determine one or more parameters about the performance of the measurement target design and / or measurement options. In an embodiment, the software generates one or more performance parameters about detectability, precision, throughput, and / or accuracy. Based on the measurement target performance information from the data 827 (e.g., the data itself and / or the generated performance parameters), one or more measurement target designs and associated one or more measurement options are selected manually or through automated processing. In an embodiment, additionally or alternatively, in order to select based on the measurement target performance parameters from the data 827, one or more measurement target designs and associated one or more measurement options are selected manually or through automated processing based on data from the simulation 815 (e.g., obtained from 817 and / or 819) (such as parameters representing the performance of one or more of the measurement targets and / or measurement options). In an embodiment, the selection is based on measurement target performance information from data 827 and data from the simulation at 815. In an embodiment, the simulation is performed based on adjustment of measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters as described below, and the selection is based on data from the simulation based on adjustment of measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters at 815. In an embodiment, the simulation is performed based on adjustment of measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters as described below, and the simulation evaluates one or more new or changed measurement targets and / or measurement options. In an embodiment, measurement data of one or more new or changed measurement targets and / or measurement options is obtained, and the selection is based on measurement data of one or more new or changed measurement targets and / or measurement options (in addition to or alternatively to data based on the simulation at 815).
[0118] In an embodiment, combinations of measurement target designs and measurement options are ranked according to one or more performance parameters alone (which may themselves be derived from multiple performance parameters, such as weighted combinations of performance parameters) and / or according to combinations of performance parameters (e.g., two or more performance parameters are ranked individually or based on a combination of two or more performance parameters). In an embodiment, the ranking of combinations of measurement target designs and measurement options may be presented in a user interface (e.g., a graphical user interface). In an embodiment, one or more combinations of measurement target designs and measurement options may be automatically selected if they pass a threshold. These promising measurement target designs and measurement options may then be analyzed, as discussed herein, for accuracy verification. The selected measurement target designs and measurement options and optionally their performance are output at 832.
[0119] In an embodiment, parameters representing the sensitivity of one or more metrology options or one or more metrology option parameters to one or more metrology targets, such as parameters representing changes in the structure of the metrology target due to process variability (e.g., derived from measurements of a lower periodic structure of a metrology target design performed when the associated upper periodic structure of the metrology target design was not located above the lower periodic structure at the time of measurement) are fed forward at 827 for use in the evaluation of the complete metrology target design. In an embodiment, the measurements are used to determine which one or more measurement settings have high or low sensitivity to process variations in the structure of the metrology target and / or in the creation of one or more layers overlying the structure. Thus, in an embodiment, the measurements are used to determine which one or more measurement settings have low or high sensitivity to deformations of the structure, such as periodic structure symmetry. These results can then be used in the evaluation of the complete metrology target design at 830 to identify and / or select one or more metrology target designs having one or more low or minimal sensitivity settings. In an embodiment, the results may be fed forward to the creation of metrology profiles at 829 such that metrology profiles having one or more low or minimal sensitivity settings are selected, which may improve throughput by eliminating metrology profiles that are highly sensitive to process variations.
[0120] In an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: determining a parameter representing the sensitivity of one or more metrology options or one or more metrology options parameters to one or more metrology targets based on measurement data of a metrology target measured under multiple metrology options; and evaluating multiple metrology options used to measure the metrology target by simulation or according to the measured data based on the parameter representing the sensitivity to identify one or more options in the multiple metrology options for use in measuring the metrology target. In an embodiment, the measurement data includes a parameter representing a change in the structure of the metrology target due to process variability. In an embodiment, the parameter represents a measure of asymmetry present in the structure of the metrology target. In an embodiment, the measurement data includes measurements at different stages of processing of the structure and / or application of a layer above the structure. In an embodiment, the method further includes varying properties of the processing of the structure. In an embodiment, the properties of the processing include one or more selected from the following: optical properties of the layer, material thickness, polishing parameters and / or etching parameters. In an embodiment, the structure of the metrology target is a lower periodic structure of the metrology target, and the measurement data relates to the lower periodic structure if the upper periodic structure of the metrology target is not located above the lower periodic structure at the time of acquisition of the measurement data.
[0121] At 834, feedback data from the measurement data collected at 825 or generated from the measurement data is provided back to the simulation or computational process at 800. The data can be used to validate the simulation, simulation parameters, and / or give confidence to the simulation. Thus, in an embodiment, the data is used to adjust the metrology target parameters and / or metrology recipe parameters derived or used in the simulation.
[0122] In embodiments, data 834 may be or include values of one or more parameters of the stack, such as thickness of one or more layers, refractive index of one or more layers, absorption index of one or more layers, etc., and / or a measure of variability of one or more parameters of the stack, such as variability of thickness of one or more layers. The adjustments may be of one or more layers at or above the target and / or of one or more layers below the target. Such data 834 may be measured directly by a metrology tool. Such data 834 may be collected by a metrology tool that is not designed to use a target (e.g., by a CD-SEM tool), but the target is designed for use by a diffraction-based measurement tool.
[0123] In an embodiment, data 834 may be or include indirect information about metrology target parameters and / or metrology recipe parameters. For example, data 834 may include values of measured intensity of radiation redirected by a measured metrology target design, measured values of overlap, measured values of critical dimensions, values of one or more parameters (KPIs) derived from the measured data such as mean, standard deviation, stack sensitivity, target coefficient, asymmetry, diffraction efficiency, etc., etc. In an embodiment, data 834 may include measured data or one or more parameters derived from the measured data representing reproducibility (i.e., an indicator of the ability of the metrology design to actually be produced in the designed stack) and / or detectability (i.e., an indicator of the ability of an inspection device to detect the metrology design) of the metrology target design.
[0124] At 840, the feedback data can be used to evaluate the correctness and / or consistency of one or more measurement target parameters and / or measurement matching scheme parameters of the simulation, and appropriate corrections can be applied in the absence of correctness and / or consistency. For example, one or more of the initial or expected stacking or other process conditions used to run the simulation can be verified based on data 834 to verify the validity of the one or more initial or expected stacking or other process conditions. If one or more initial or expected stacking or other process conditions are invalid (for example, the value of the number does not match, the variability of the parameter is greater than that used in the simulation, etc.), the simulation can be rerun using the updated one or more stacking or other process conditions supplied at 842. For example, one or more measured stacking or other process conditions from the feedback data can be used in the simulation instead of one or more of the initial or expected stacking or other process conditions. The re-execution of the simulation can simply involve the re-ranking of the previously determined measurement target design and / or measurement matching scheme based on the updated one or more stacking or other process conditions, or can involve determining one or more new measurement target designs and / or measurement matching schemes based on the updated one or more stacking or other process conditions. Verification can vary from a simple comparison of numbers to complex statistical analysis. For example, the measurement detectability of the measurement target design can be evaluated based on the measurement of the measurement target design for multiple values of the measurement matching scheme parameters or for multiple measurement matching scheme parameter combinations. This can produce a set of data or functions for the measurement detectability of the values of the measurement matching scheme parameters or multiple measurement matching scheme parameter combinations. A comparable set of data or functions can be derived from the simulation and then statistically compared. If there is no accuracy or consistency, corrections can be applied to the simulation. In an embodiment, the simulation can change one or more measurement target parameters and / or measurement matching scheme parameters (such as one or more parameters of the stack) until there is a match with the data 834, and then apply corrections based on the result. As an example, the simulation can change one or more parameters of the stack until there is a match with the data 834, and the values of the one or more parameters of the stack in the simulation when matching can represent the actual stack characteristics. The one or more parameters of the stack in the simulation when matching can then be used in subsequent simulations for the device manufacturing process. In an embodiment, the measurement of critical dimensions can be used to constrain stack adjustments and to obtain a better (physical) solution for the adjusted stack.
[0125] Relatedly, if the measurement agrees with or confirms the accuracy of one or more measurement target parameters and / or measurement option parameters of the simulation, the simulation can use this information 842 to improve or optimize the measurement target design and / or measurement option. For example, strong correlations can be identified between parameters and used to guide the design of the measurement target design and / or measurement option to favor those parameters that have strong correlations with parameters that represent good performance. For example, if the measurement results for multiple measurement target designs (with varying measurement target design parameters) for, for example, multiple or one or more applicable measurement option parameters agree with or confirm the accuracy of one or more measurement target parameters and / or measurement option parameters of the simulation, then the simulation can use this information to improve or optimize the measurement target design and / or measurement option (e.g., by giving greater weight to parameters that have stronger correlations with better performance, etc.).
[0126] In an embodiment, in the event that the correlation result between the measured data and the initial data in 840 indicates that one or more parameters of the stack and / or the variability of one or more parameters of the stack are incorrect, a measurement can be performed to obtain the value of the one or more parameters of the stack and / or the variability of one or more parameters of the stack. For example, such data can be collected at 825 and triggered to be collected in response to 840 determining that one or more parameters of the stack and / or the variability of one or more parameters of the stack are incorrect. The initial data can be updated based on such data or replaced with such data. From the correlation at 840, step 840 can determine one or more specific parameters of the stack and / or the variability of one or more parameters of the stack to be measured at 825. In an embodiment, step 840 can automatically prepare or provide a measurement option template for use with 825 to measure the variability of one or more parameters of the stack and / or the one or more parameters of the stack that are determined to be incorrect.
[0127] In an embodiment, data 834 can be used or derived as weight values used in simulation to adjust measurement target parameters and / or measurement option parameters. For example, the weight values can be effectively used to eliminate one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement target options. As an example, data 834 representing reproducibility or detectability can be used as a "heavy" weight to exclude or lower in ranking certain measurement target designs and / or measurement target options. The result can be faster simulation and more effective results.
[0128] In an embodiment, if the difference between one or more initial or expected stacking or other process conditions or expected data and one or more of the measured stacking or other process conditions or measured data remains within a threshold, then one or more metrology targets and / or options may be selected based on performance. In an embodiment, performance may be determined using performance parameters or indicators including one or more selected from the group consisting of detectability, precision, throughput, accuracy, diffraction efficiency, asymmetry, target coefficient, stack sensitivity, and / or sensitivity to sensor artifacts. In an embodiment, selection is based on a balance between several performance parameters and / or a balance between performance parameters and inspection equipment specific parameters.
[0129] In an embodiment, the feedback data used for consistency and / or accuracy evaluation can be feedback data corresponding to one or more specific simulated measurement target designs and / or measurement options (e.g., using measured data of a specific measurement design to adjust one or more parameters of the simulation of the specific measurement design). Therefore, in an embodiment, only specific measurement target designs and / or specific measurement options can be evaluated during a rerun of a simulation based on data 834. This can be achieved using, for example, a weighting factor (such as, a weighting factor based on data 834 representing reproducibility or detectability). In an embodiment, the feedback data used for consistency and / or accuracy evaluation can be general for multiple measurement target designs and / or measurement options.
[0130] In an embodiment, adjustment of metrology target parameters and / or metrology profile parameters renders a particular metrology target and / or metrology profile more robust to variations in a process for forming or measuring a particular metrology target, variations in a process for forming a metrology target for use with a particular metrology profile, or variations in a process for measuring using a particular metrology profile. For example, in an embodiment, measurements representing variations in a structure of a metrology target due to process variability (such as measurements of a lower periodic structure of a metrology target design performed when an associated upper periodic structure of the metrology target design is not located above the lower periodic structure at the time of measurement) are used as or to derive feedback data 834. Feedback data 834 may then represent process variations resulting from creation of the structure of the metrology target and / or one or more layers overlying the structure, which may then be used to achieve robustness of the metrology target design and / or metrology profile to process variability. For example, feedback data 834 indicating low asymmetry indicates that the metrology target design and / or metrology profile is robust to process variations. The feedback data 834 may, for example, represent a set of data or a function of asymmetry for values of a measurement target design pitch, a measurement beam wavelength, and the like. And thus, the feedback data 834 may be used in a simulation to design and / or select a measurement target design and / or measurement matching scheme having one or more parameters that exhibit robustness. The feedback data 834 may further represent different stages of a device manufacturing process and thus may be applied to appropriate portions of a simulation. Thus, the feedback data 834 may be used in a simulation to identify one or more parameters that may be adjusted to produce a more robust measurement target design and / or measurement matching scheme.
[0131] In an embodiment, the simulation process 815 can be rerun in response to feedback or feedforward data. In an embodiment, if the difference between one or more initial or expected stackup or other process conditions or expected data and one or more of the measured stackup or other process conditions or measured data crosses a threshold, the simulation can be re-executed using a change in the initial or expected stackup or other process conditions (e.g., using one or more of the measured stackup or other process conditions), and the identification of one or more metrology target designs and / or metrology options from these simulations can be re-executed.
[0132] In an embodiment, when rerunning the simulation process 815, the process may proceed from the simulation process 815 to the measurement matching solution customization at 820, and so on. For example, this may be particularly the case where the feedback or feedforward data will produce a changed or new measurement target design that should be measured at 825. In an embodiment, in response to the feedback or feedforward data, the process may proceed to the evaluation process at 830 via 819. For example, this may be particularly the case where there is no changed or new measurement target design that should be measured. Data may be supplied via 819 to assist in the selection of one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement matching solutions. For example, the data may include a revised ranking of one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement matching solutions and / or new values of performance parameters associated with the one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement matching solutions initially supplied via 817. The ranking and / or revised or new values may be used in the selection of one or more measurement target designs and / or measurement matching solutions at process 830.
[0133] At 835, one or more selected measurement target designs at 830 are formed onto a plurality of substrates processed using a device manufacturing process, and then measured using an inspection device using one or more measurement options associated therewith for accuracy verification. This step generally corresponds to step 645. As discussed above with respect to step 645, the data set may be a more comprehensive analysis of all, substantially all, or most of the targets on the substrate. In an embodiment, programmed changes to measured or derived parameters may be introduced. For example, in the case where the measurement involves overlap, a known programmed overlap error may be introduced to assist in performance evaluation. Output 837 will be, for example, overlap data for each of a plurality of measurement target designs. And for each measurement target design, there will be data for a plurality of options. In an embodiment, the data may represent measured values or parameters derived from measured values for one or more various measurement target design parameters and / or one or more various measurement option parameters. In an embodiment, measurements may be performed to determine changes in the structure (e.g., periodic structure) of the measurement target attributed to process variability. As a non-limiting example, such a measurement may be of a lower periodic structure of a measurement target design when the associated upper periodic structure of the measurement target design is not located above the lower periodic structure. These measurements may represent, for example, the amount of asymmetry present in the structure, and may subsequently be used to achieve robustness of the measurement target design to process variability. For example, low asymmetry may represent a target or target parameter for robustness. For example, a set of data may represent the value of asymmetry for different combinations of wavelength and polarization for each of a plurality of measurement target designs. As another example, a set of data may represent the value of asymmetry for different values of measurement target design parameters, such as the pitch of the periodic structure of the measurement target design, the critical dimensions of the structural features of the measurement target design, the segmentation of the features of the periodic structure of the measurement target design, and the like. As another example, a set of data may represent the measured intensities for various measurement target design parameters or measurement matching scheme parameters. In addition, measurements may be performed at different stages of the device manufacturing process to determine which process steps are likely to cause deformation of the structure.
[0134] Based on the data 837, one or more performance indicators are calculated at 845 for one or more selected measurement target designs and associated one or more measurement options measured at 830. This step generally corresponds to step 640 and optional step 625. For example, the data 837 is processed to determine one or more parameters of performance such as detectability, precision, throughput, and / or accuracy of the measurement target design and / or measurement option. In an embodiment, parameters regarding accuracy performance are calculated for the measurement target design-measurement option combination. In an embodiment, the accuracy performance parameters include residuals between the measured data and a mathematical model used to fit the measured data. Based on the measurement target performance determined from the data 837, one or more measurement target designs and associated one or more measurement options are selected manually or through automated processing. In an embodiment, combinations of measurement target designs and measurement options are ranked according to one or more performance parameters alone (which may themselves be derived from multiple performance parameters, such as weighted combinations of performance parameters) and / or according to combinations of performance parameters (e.g., two or more performance parameters are ranked alone or based on a combination of two or more performance parameters). In an embodiment, the ranking of the combination of measurement target designs and measurement options may be presented in a user interface (e.g., a graphical user interface). In an embodiment, one or more combinations of measurement target designs and measurement options may be automatically selected if they pass a threshold. These measurement target designs and measurement options may then represent one or more measurement target design-measurement option combinations ready for consideration for HVM, and thus may be output at 860, optionally with associated performance. In an embodiment, a user or software may select one or more candidate "reference point" (POR) measurement target designs having, for example, good target performance. One or more POR measurement target designs and associated measurement options and optionally associated performance are output at 847.
[0135] In an embodiment, the feedback and feedforward described above (eg, steps 819 , 827 , 829 , and / or 834 ) may be applied in association with step 845 .
[0136] At 850, one or more POR measurement target designs at 845 are formed onto multiple substrates processed using a device manufacturing process, and then measured using multiple inspection devices using one or more measurement options associated with the POR measurement target designs for matching inspection devices to inspection devices. This step generally corresponds to steps 700, 705, and 710. As noted above, this data set will be applicable if, for example, multiple inspection devices are used to measure measurement targets in a device manufacturing process or where different inspection devices are used for development than in HVM. The data set can be a more comprehensive analysis of all, substantially all, or most of the targets on a substrate. Output 852 will be, for example, overlapping data for each of the multiple measurement target designs. And for each measurement target design, there will be data for multiple inspection devices.
[0137] Based on data 852, applicable corrections for corresponding inspection devices can be determined, for example to reduce or minimize residuals at 855. Additionally or alternatively, at 855, the matching performance between the inspection devices is evaluated. For example, one or more parameters can be derived from data 852 to evaluate the matching of the performance of the measurement target design-measurement option combination for each of the inspection devices, optionally all or multiple layers, for the substrate. This step generally corresponds to steps 715, 720, 725, and 730. For example, if one or more combinations of measurement target designs and measurement options perform better on the inspection devices collectively than on one or more other combinations, then those combinations can be selected for HVM. Based on the matching performance determined from data 837, one or more measurement target designs and associated one or more measurement options can be selected manually or through automated processing. In an embodiment, combinations of measurement target designs and measurement options are ranked according to one or more performance parameters alone (which may themselves be derived from multiple performance parameters, such as weighted combinations of performance parameters) and / or according to combinations of performance parameters (e.g., two or more performance parameters are ranked alone or based on a combination of two or more performance parameters). In an embodiment, the ranking of combinations of measurement target designs and measurement options may be presented in a user interface (e.g., a graphical user interface). In an embodiment, one or more combinations of measurement target designs and measurement options may be automatically selected if they pass a threshold. The selected one or more POR measurement target design-measurement option combinations may then represent one or more measurement target design-measurement option combinations ready for HVM, and may therefore be output at 860, optionally together with associated performance.
[0138] Therefore, in an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: performing a simulation to evaluate a plurality of metrology targets and / or a plurality of metrology options for measuring the metrology targets; identifying one or more metrology targets and / or options from a plurality of evaluated metrology targets and / or options; receiving measurement data of one or more identified metrology targets and / or options; and using the measurement data to adjust simulated metrology target parameters and / or metrology option parameters. In an embodiment, the adjustment of the metrology target parameters or metrology option parameters makes the identified metrology target and / or metrology option more robust to variations in a process for forming or measuring the identified metrology target, to variations in a process for forming the metrology target for use with the identified option, or to variations in a process for measuring using the identified metrology option. In an embodiment, the measurement data comprises a parameter representing variations in the structure of the metrology target due to process variability. In an embodiment, the parameter represents a measure of asymmetry present in the structure of the metrology target. In an embodiment, the measurement data comprises measurements at different stages of processing of the structure and / or application of a layer above the structure. In an embodiment, the method further comprises changing the properties of the processing of the structure. In an embodiment, the properties of the processing include one or more selected from the following: optical properties of the layer, material thickness, polishing parameters and / or etching parameters. In an embodiment, the periodic structure of the measurement target is a lower periodic structure of the measurement target, and the measurement data relates to the lower periodic structure when the upper periodic structure of the measurement target is not located above the lower periodic structure when the measurement data is acquired. In an embodiment, the measurement data includes the measured sensitivity of the parameters of the measurement target to the wavelength of the measurement beam. In an embodiment, the method further comprises using the measurement data to derive parameters and using the derived parameters to adjust the measurement target parameters or measurement matching scheme parameters. In an embodiment, the derived parameters include one or more selected from the following: overlap, stacking sensitivity, target coefficient, asymmetry and / or diffraction efficiency. In an embodiment, the method further comprises selecting one or more measurement targets and / or measurement matching schemes from the identified one or more measurement targets and / or measurement matching schemes based on the measurement data. In an embodiment, the method further comprises: performing a simulation based on the adjustment of the measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters, and reselecting one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the identified one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options based on the measurement data of the one or more identified new or changed measurement targets and / or measurement options from the simulation and / or based on the performance parameters determined based on the adjustment of the measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters. In an embodiment, the reselection is based on the performance parameters, and the performance parameters include one or more selected from the following: overlap, stacking sensitivity, target coefficient, asymmetry and / or diffraction efficiency.
[0139] In an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: receiving measurement data of a plurality of different metrology targets, each metrology target being measured with a plurality of metrology options; and using the measurement data to verify one or more parameters of a simulation, wherein the simulation is used to evaluate the plurality of metrology targets and / or a plurality of metrology options for measuring the metrology targets. In an embodiment, the method further comprises changing one or more parameters based on the measurement data. In an embodiment, the one or more parameters represent one or more parameters of a process for forming the metrology target. In an embodiment, the one or more parameters of the process for forming the metrology target include one or more selected from the following: optical properties of a layer, material thickness, polishing parameters, and / or etching parameters. In an embodiment, the simulation uses the measurement data to optimize the metrology target and / or the metrology options. In an embodiment, the measurement data includes a measured sensitivity of a parameter of the metrology target to a wavelength of a measurement beam. In an embodiment, the method further comprises selecting one or more metrology targets and / or metrology options from the evaluated one or more metrology targets and / or metrology options based on the measurement data. In an embodiment, the method further comprises: performing a simulation based on the changed one or more parameters, and reselecting one or more metrology targets and / or metrology options from the evaluated one or more metrology targets and / or metrology options based on measurement data of the one or more evaluated new or changed metrology targets and / or metrology options from the simulation and / or based on performance parameters determined based on the changed one or more parameters. In an embodiment, the reselection is based on performance parameters, and the performance parameters include one or more selected from the following: overlap, stacking sensitivity, target coefficient, asymmetry and / or diffraction efficiency.
[0140] In an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: simulating a plurality of metrology targets and / or a plurality of metrology options taking into account expected process conditions; identifying one or more metrology targets and / or options from the plurality of simulated metrology targets and / or options; receiving measurement data of one or more identified metrology targets and / or options; and using the measurement data to verify the expected process conditions. In an embodiment, the method further comprises: if the difference between the expected process conditions or the expected data and the measured process conditions or the measured data, respectively, exceeds a threshold, re-performing the simulation and identification using a change in the expected process conditions. In an embodiment, the simulation is performed under a range of processing conditions around the expected or measured processing conditions. In an embodiment, the range is defined by a user. In an embodiment, the metrology target comprises a lower target portion, and comprises an upper target portion arranged in a layer between the lower target portion and an inspection device, the inspection device being configured to determine an overlap value between the upper and lower target portions. In an embodiment, receiving the measurement data comprises receiving measurement data only from the lower target portion. In an embodiment, the method further comprises: if the difference between the expected process conditions or expected data and the measured process conditions or measured data, respectively, remains within a threshold, then one or more measurement targets and / or matching schemes are selected based on performance. In an embodiment, the performance is determined using performance indicators including one or more selected from the following: detectability, precision, throughput, accuracy, diffraction efficiency, asymmetry and / or sensitivity to sensor artifacts. In an embodiment, the performance is a balance between several performance indicators and / or a balance between performance indicators and inspection equipment tool characteristics. In an embodiment, the inspection equipment tool characteristics include parameters representing the sensitivity of the inspection equipment measurement to sensor artifacts and / or stray light. In an embodiment, the process conditions include one or more selected from the following: optical properties of the layer, material thickness, polishing parameters, etching parameters, refractive index of the processed layer, absorption index of the processed layer, thickness of the processed layer, changes in the layer, characteristics of the inspection equipment, settings of the inspection equipment, measurement beam wavelength used by the inspection equipment, characteristics of the lithography equipment and / or alignment strategy.
[0141] In an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: performing simulation to evaluate a plurality of measurement targets and / or a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets, and determining parameters representing performance of one or more of the measurement targets and / or measurement options; identifying one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and / or measurement options; receiving measurement data of the one or more identified measurement targets and / or measurement options; and selecting one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the identified one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options based on the measurement data and the parameters. In an embodiment, the method further comprises: using the measurement data to adjust the simulated measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters, and performing simulation based on the adjustment of the measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters to determine the parameters representing performance. In an embodiment, performing simulation based on adjustment of metrology target parameters or metrology option parameters includes evaluating one or more new or changed metrology targets and / or metrology options, the method further includes receiving measurement data of one or more new or changed metrology targets and / or metrology options, and selecting includes selecting one or more new or changed metrology targets and / or metrology options based on performance parameters and the measurement data. In an embodiment, the parameters representing performance include one or more selected from the group consisting of: overlap impact, stack sensitivity, process variation robustness, target coefficient, asymmetry, and / or diffraction efficiency.
[0142] In an embodiment, a method is provided, including: performing simulation to evaluate a plurality of measurement targets and a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets; identifying one or more combinations of measurement targets and measurement options from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and measurement options; customizing a plurality of measurement options for one or more measurement targets from the identified one or more combinations based on one or more measurement options from the identified one or more combinations; and receiving measurement data of the one or more measurement targets measured using the customized plurality of measurement options from the identified one or more combinations. In an embodiment, the method further includes selecting one or more measurement targets from the one or more measurement targets from the identified one or more combinations based on the measurement data. In an embodiment, the customized plurality of measurement options includes one or more measurement options from the identified one or more combinations. In an embodiment, the one or more measurement options from the identified one or more combinations include parameters, and the customized plurality of measurement options include measurement options having values for the parameters within a range of values for the parameters of the one or more measurement options from the identified one or more combinations.
[0143] In an embodiment, a measurement target design / measurement target selection simulation, evaluation and / or selection may consider diffraction efficiency (DE) or a parameter derived from diffraction efficiency as an additional or alternative parameter (e.g., as a ranking parameter or as a calculated parameter (e.g., a multiplication factor)). The diffraction efficiency parameter represents the proportion of radiation that is redirected (e.g., diffracted) by the target toward the detector. Thus, the diffraction efficiency can, for example, be used to help distinguish radiation that should be measured from stray radiation during a measurement. A higher DE can mean a shorter integration time to achieve the measurement. As another example, a higher DE can mean less sensitivity to inspection device sensor artifacts. So, for example, a measurement target design having comparable target coefficients but a measurement target design having a target coefficient at a higher DE is preferred over a measurement target design having a target coefficient at a lower DE. In an embodiment, a threshold value can be associated with the diffraction efficiency parameter, such as a threshold value that the diffraction efficiency must exceed.
[0144] Therefore, in an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: evaluating a plurality of measurement targets and / or a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets by simulation or based on measured data; and identifying one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and / or measurement options whose diffraction efficiency or a parameter derived from the diffraction efficiency exceeds a threshold. In an embodiment, the measurement options include measuring beam wavelength and / or measuring beam polarization.
[0145] In an embodiment, the measurement target design / measurement target matching scheme simulation, evaluation and / or selection may take into account inspection device specific parameters or parameters derived from inspection device specific parameters as additional or alternative parameters (e.g., as ranking parameters or as calculation parameters (e.g., multiplication factors)). Inspection device specific parameters may be specific to a single inspection device, to a specific group of single inspection devices, or to a certain type of inspection device. Inspection device specific parameters are distinguished from universal parameters such as wavelength selection, polarization selection, etc., which are applicable to inspection (and therefore are generally all inspection devices). However, inspection device specific parameters may be variability associated with one or more such universal parameters that are specific to the inspection device. In an embodiment, the inspection device specific parameters include the measurement beam wavelength dependence of the inspection device. In an embodiment, the inspection device specific attributes include parameters representing the sensitivity of the inspection device measurement to sensor artifacts and / or stray light. In an embodiment, the inspection device specific attributes include characteristics or sensitivity of the sensor of the inspection device. In an embodiment, the inspection device specific parameters include parameters representing the dependence of inspection device artifacts or stray light on the measurement beam wavelength. Such a parameter may involve a mathematical function or set of data representing the dependence of the inspection device artifacts on the measurement beam wavelength. In an embodiment, the function or set of data may be a representation of the inspection device sensor background noise or intensity as a function of the measurement beam wavelength value. In general, the inspection device may have a higher amount of sensor artifacts at higher measurement beam wavelengths. So, for example, a measurement target design with comparable stack sensitivity but a measurement target design with stack sensitivity at a lower measurement beam wavelength is preferred over a measurement target design with stack sensitivity at a higher measurement beam wavelength. In an embodiment, a threshold value may be associated with an inspection device specific parameter, for example, a threshold value that the inspection device specific parameter should or must exceed or should or must remain below (for example, in the case where the parameter represents the dependence of the inspection device artifacts on the measurement beam wavelength, the threshold value may be a measurement beam wavelength limit).
[0146] Therefore, in an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: evaluating a plurality of measurement targets and / or a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets by simulation or based on measured data; and identifying one or more measurement targets and / or options for which a measurement device property or a parameter derived from the measurement device property crosses a threshold from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and / or options. In an embodiment, the measurement device property comprises a measurement beam wavelength dependency of the measurement device. In an embodiment, the measurement device property comprises a multiplication factor associated with the measurement beam wavelength dependency of the measurement device. In an embodiment, the measurement device property comprises a function or data representing a background intensity of the measurement device for the measurement beam wavelength. In an embodiment, the measurement options comprise a measurement beam wavelength and / or a measurement beam polarization. In an embodiment, the measurement device property comprises a characteristic or sensitivity of a sensor of the measurement device. In an embodiment, the measurement device property comprises a dependency of stray light or sensor artifacts of the inspection device on the measurement beam wavelength.
[0147] Once one or more measurement target designs and associated one or more measurement options are selected for HVM, the measurement process is configured to enable measurement of one or more measurement targets on the substrate for monitoring and control of the device manufacturing process. This is generally described with respect to step 340. As noted above, it may be too time consuming to measure each measurement target for each substrate in each batch. In addition, the measurement results of the measurement targets can be modeled using one or more appropriately parameterized measurement data mathematical models (i.e., a mathematical model with appropriately determined and defined parameters and their available values to fit the data, such as to mathematically specify the data and model the data). Therefore, a measurement data mathematical model and / or a measurement sampling scheme can be established for measuring one or more measurement targets.
[0148] Therefore, in an embodiment, an application is provided that determines one or more settings for a subsequently exposed substrate based on measurements of an exposed substrate. However, the measurements are inevitably uncertain (e.g., contaminated by noise) and / or are inevitably not fully fitted by a mathematical model. In addition, there may be other sources of uncertainty in the flow from measurements on a previous substrate to settings for future substrates. In addition, there may be systematic changes in the measured data. Therefore, a method is provided that takes into account systematic changes and uncertainties to achieve settings that can reduce uncertainty.
[0149] Fig. 9 A flow chart of an embodiment of a measurement data mathematical model and sampling scheme evaluation is schematically depicted. Fig. 9The analysis in the method will typically be per layer and per device manufacturing process (including different device patterns used in the device manufacturing process). In an embodiment, the method can perform parallel processing if there are various different layers, device manufacturing processes, etc. under consideration.
[0150] At 900, various preparation data are obtained and some optional preparation data processing is performed. At 905, measurement results from one or more substrates (desirably multiple substrates) are obtained or received, and the one or more substrates are patterned using one or more measurement target designs and measured using inspection equipment under one or more measurement options associated with them. In an embodiment, such results come from all, almost all, or at least most of the targets exposed on the substrate. In an embodiment, the measurement data comes from a batch of substrates that are densely measured. Using a batch helps avoid batch-to-batch variations, but substrate-to-substrate variations within a batch still exist. For example, in an embodiment, there may be data from more than 2000 points on each substrate in a batch of 20 or more substrates. The data can be converted into a map corresponding to the layout of the substrate. In an embodiment, the measurement data includes one or more of the following: overlap data, overlap error data, alignment data, critical dimension data (e.g., critical dimension uniformity data) and / or focus data.
[0151] At 910 , the measurement data from 905 may optionally be processed to remove corrections that may have been applied in an inspection device used to measure the data from 905 and / or in a device fabrication process used to process a substrate corresponding to the data from 905 .
[0152] At 920, one or more measurement data mathematical models are provided for consideration, which can be determined or specified, for example, for the measurement data. For example, there may be a set of measurement data mathematical models and each measurement data mathematical model can be evaluated as discussed below. The mathematical model can define a set of basis functions that fit the data once parameterized. In an embodiment, one or more measurement data mathematical models of the set (which can be all measurement mathematical data models in the set) can be determined as a possible fit (e.g., a relatively close fit) for the data by mathematical evaluation (e.g., the "fingerprint" of the data roughly or nearly matches the one or more measurement data mathematical models of the set). In an embodiment, a user can specify one or more measurement data mathematical models of the set for further consideration as discussed below, regardless of whether the measurement data mathematical model is determined to be a fit. For example, an interface (such as a graphical user interface) can allow a user to specify a measurement mathematical data model for consideration. In an embodiment, multiple measurement mathematical data models are determined or specified for further evaluation as discussed below, and it is desired to fit the measurement data as many models as possible. In an embodiment, the data model can be adjusted to match the fingerprint for optimal noise suppression (e.g., eliminating redundant orders or reducing the use of higher orders).
[0153] At 925, one or more inspection equipment throughput models are specified. In an embodiment, the inspection equipment throughput model specifies, for example, the number of substrates measured per unit time, the number of targets or points measured per unit time, or other metrics representing the throughput of the measurement of targets on the substrate. In an embodiment, the inspection throughput model may specify the position of the target on the substrate and / or the distance between the targets, the measurement field size, the number of points on the target to be measured, the substrate and / or the beam scanning speed, the loading time of the substrate in the inspection device, the alignment time of the substrate in the inspection device, the repositioning time of the substrate in the inspection device, the time for positioning the measurement target in the measurement position in the inspection device, the time for retrieving measurement data from the measurement target in the inspection device, etc., which data can be used to achieve the measurement throughput. The inspection equipment throughput model can be a complex mathematical formula that allows the variables to be changed as further described. In an embodiment, a user can specify a throughput threshold, such as a certain minimum throughput expected. In an embodiment, multiple inspection equipment throughput models, each representing different inspection equipment, are specified for further evaluation as discussed below. In an embodiment, the mathematical model can be configurable by the user in terms of parameters to be used in the fit. For example, a user may be presented with one or more underlying mathematical models and may select or constrain which one or more parameters of these one or more underlying mathematical models are used in the fit. In an embodiment, the mathematical model may be parameterized for a specific feature of a device manufacturing process or a device. For example, the mathematical model may be parameterized for a specific substrate stage of a plurality of substrate stages (e.g., in a lithographic apparatus). As a further example, the mathematical model may be parameterized for a specific substrate movement direction (e.g., a scan direction) during exposure.
[0154] At 930, one or more sampling schemes for the metrology process are determined for further evaluation as discussed below. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme may include one or more parameters selected from the following: the number of sampling points per substrate, the number of substrates per batch sampled; the numerical designation of the substrates in a batch or each batch sampled; the number of fields sampled; the layout / position of the sampled fields on the substrate; the number of sites in each field; the location of the sites in the field; the frequency of sampling; the type of metrology target; or the measurement algorithm.
[0155] In an embodiment, one or more sampling schemes are determined based on one or more throughput models, such as sampling schemes that can meet a throughput threshold. In an embodiment, one or more sampling schemes are determined based on a throughput model and a measurement mathematical data model. In an embodiment, multiple sampling schemes are determined based on a throughput model and / or a measurement data mathematical model. For example, the number of sampled points is limited by the available measurement time. For example, if the inspection device is in a lithography device or otherwise in line with the processing of substrates in a lithography unit, the total available measurement time can be determined by the exposure time of the entire batch. In any provision of available time, different combinations of the number of substrates and the number of points per substrate are possible. More points per substrate result in a more detailed but potentially noisier description of the measured data "fingerprint". More substrates with fewer points per substrate result in stronger uncertainty (e.g., noise) averaging. Therefore, the number of sampled substrates and / or the possible combinations of the number of points per sampled substrate are determined by means of an inspection device throughput model. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme can be determined based on multiple throughput models for different inspection devices.
[0156] In an embodiment, a sampling scheme optimizer model may be used to further determine one or more aspects (e.g., the placement of locations / targets of sampling) for each combination of a mathematical model and a number of sampling points (e.g., the number of substrates sampled and / or the number of points per substrate sampled). For example, the sampling scheme optimizer may take into account various constraints or restrictions, such as selecting sampling locations at a minimized distance from the edge of the substrate to avoid unyielding dies.
[0157] In an embodiment, a sampling scheme optimizer may determine a sampling scheme for measuring data using a measurement target using a measurement matching scheme based at least in part on a throughput model of an inspection device. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme may be further based on a mathematical model. The sampling scheme optimizer may further determine (e.g., calculate itself or obtain from, for example, steps 935 and / or 940 described below) an evaluation parameter based on the measurement data and the sampling scheme. For example, the evaluation parameter may include a substrate-to-substrate variation within a batch of substrates, such as a residual uncertainty discussed in more detail below, a residual systematic variation discussed in more detail below, and the like. The sampling scheme optimizer may then determine whether the evaluation parameter crosses a threshold. And, if it is determined that the evaluation parameter crosses a threshold, the sampling scheme optimizer may change the sampling scheme based at least on the throughput model (e.g., modify the sampling scheme so that the sampling scheme still satisfies one or more criteria of the throughput model). If the sampling scheme has changed, the sampling scheme optimizer may further at least re-execute: determining the evaluation parameter based on the measurement data and the changed sampling scheme, and determining whether the evaluation parameter determined based on the measurement data and the changed sampling scheme crosses a threshold.
[0158] The use of higher order basis functions to fit the data typically results in increased sensitivity to noise. On the other hand, with basis functions of increasing order, the residual will be reduced. Therefore, the sampling scheme optimizer can take this into account when implementing the sampling scheme, so as to match the model by balancing the cost function of the higher order that considers reducing residuals but controlling sampling to keep low sensitivity to noise. For example, the sampling scheme affects the reduction of input noise, the number of measurable substrates per batch affects the reduction of noise and / or batch sampling affects the output noise. Therefore, as part of the optimization, various different sampling scheme variants can be used. For example, the number of measured substrates per batch and / or the number of sampling positions of each substrate can be reduced. As a further example, more measurement points can be selected near the boundary of the field and / or substrate, because the basis function can "behave" "wildest" there and therefore expect more information there.
[0159] In an embodiment, a sampling scheme optimizer selects an optimal subset of measurement locations from a set of potential measurement locations. Therefore, the input to the sampling scheme optimizer may be one or more mathematical models that may represent a fingerprint of the measured data and a measurement layout from which a sampling scheme may be determined (e.g., all locations that may be measured on a substrate, e.g., where a measurement target may be or is located). From this input, the sampling scheme optimizer may evaluate the one or more models and the measurement layout based on a cost function to implement one or more sampling schemes involving a subset of measurement locations (e.g., the number of measurements and / or specific locations). The cost function may involve reducing residual uncertainty, obtaining a uniform distribution of measurement locations, reducing clustering of measurement locations, reducing batch-to-batch variation, reducing substrate-to-substrate variation, and / or obtaining fast execution time. In an embodiment, a user may further impose constraints, such as the number of points to be measured, exclusion of certain fields or points within a field, parameters representing the distribution of points (e.g., more points toward the center or more points toward the edge), and the like. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme optimizer may impose constraints, such as the exclusion of measurement points from unyielding die. In addition, the sampling scheme optimizer may use a throughput model to constrain the evaluation so that one or more sampling schemes meet the criteria of the throughput model. The output of the sampling scheme optimizer is one or more sampling schemes. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme optimizer may provide a graphical user interface to enable inputs and constraints. In addition, the graphical user interface may present a graphical representation of the sampling scheme (e.g., a diagram or picture of a substrate in which the number of measurement locations is graphically depicted along with their locations). The graphical user interface may also present performance information about the sampling scheme, such as residual uncertainty (e.g., for different directions).
[0160] Therefore, the sampling scheme optimizer can optimize between a sparse sampling scheme and a dense sampling scheme based on the mathematical model, the available layout, and the throughput model. Sparse sampling can have the lowest possible residual uncertainty (and therefore has the robust capture of the mathematical model), but may have poor substrate coverage and poor robustness to mismatches between the model and the fingerprint. On the other hand, dense sampling may have large or widely varying residual uncertainty, but may have good substrate coverage, avoid clustering, and have good robustness to mismatches between the model and the fingerprint.
[0161] In an embodiment, as noted above, a user may specify constraints on the sampling schemes, e.g., a maximum number of samples per substrate, a maximum number of substrates per batch sampled, etc. For example, an interface (such as a graphical user interface) may allow a user to specify the constraints. In an embodiment, a user may specify one or more sampling schemes to be evaluated. For example, an interface (such as a graphical user interface) may present a plurality of sampling schemes to a user for selection of one or more or all of the sampling schemes, and / or allow a user to add a sampling scheme for consideration.
[0162] In an embodiment, where a new device pattern (and therefore new measurement data) is used for an otherwise identical device manufacturing process and the same layer, one or more previously determined models (but parameterized for the new measurement data) and sampling schemes may be used; thus, it may not be necessary to newly determine one or more mathematical models or to newly determine one or more sampling schemes.
[0163] In an embodiment, given a certain model, the sampling scheme optimizer selects the measurement point positions that provide the most information for the model fitting process. At the same time, the sampling scheme optimization algorithm attempts to position the selected measurement point positions in a uniform manner so that the two objectives are balanced. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme optimization is an input with a list of potential measurement point positions. Subsequently, the sampling scheme is initialized by selecting a small number of initially selected measurement point positions. The initially selected measurement point positions should be selected according to one or more criteria based on the model. In an embodiment, each of these selected measurement point positions can be a selected measurement point position located at the edge of the effective area of the substrate and separated at equal angles. The initialization step can also include defining an exclusion zone around each selected measurement point position. All measurement point positions outside the exclusion zone are candidate measurement point positions; that is, "selectable" in future iterations. The exclusion zone can be circular and centered on each selected measurement point position, that is, all measurement point positions within a certain distance of the selected measurement point position can be within the exclusion zone. Subsequently, all candidate measurement point positions that are all non-selected measurement point positions that are not within the exclusion zone are evaluated. For each candidate measurement point position, calculate how much the informativeness of the sampling scheme will be improved if the measurement point position is selected. The criterion used in the evaluation can be D-optimality. The size of the initial exclusion zone should be selected to ensure that the initial set of candidate measurement point positions is not too large. The number of candidate measurement point positions should be a compromise between the uniformity, informativeness (e.g., D-optimality) of the final sampling scheme and the speed of the algorithm. After evaluating all candidate measurement point positions, the measurement point positions that contribute the most information to the sampling scheme according to the evaluation are then added to the sampling scheme. Determine whether the sampling scheme includes sufficient selected measurement point positions. If so, the sampling scheme is ready. If the sampling scheme does not have sufficient selected measurement point positions, then an exclusion zone is added around the newly selected measurement point position (other selected measurement point positions will also have exclusion zones). Subsequently, while maintaining an appropriate balance between informativeness and uniformity, determine whether there are a sufficient number of candidate measurement point positions remaining to be selected from. In an embodiment, if it is determined that there are too few candidate measurement point positions, this can be solved by reducing the exclusion zone. The exclusion zone may be narrowed for all of the selected metrology point locations that are now included in the sampling scheme, or only for a subset of these selected metrology point locations. Subsequently, the determination of whether there are a sufficient number of candidate metrology point locations remaining to select from and narrowing down, if necessary, is iteratively repeated until there are a sufficient number of candidate metrology point locations from which to complete the sampling scheme. When there are a sufficient number of candidate metrology point locations, the candidate metrology point location evaluation and subsequent steps are repeated. In an embodiment, the optimization may determine different sampling schemes for different substrates.Furthermore, different sampling schemes for different substrates may be connected such that the selected measurement point locations are distributed with a high degree of uniformity across multiple substrates: e.g. substrates per batch. In particular, the sampling scheme optimization method may cause measurement point locations that have been selected for a previous sampling scheme (for a previous substrate) to not be selected for a subsequent sampling scheme (for a subsequent substrate) within a batch. In this way, each selected measurement point location for the batch of substrates is unique. In an embodiment, the optimization helps ensure that for each individual substrate, the normalized model uncertainty is minimized: all parameter values can be determined with improved accuracy. It does this by minimizing the impact that changes in the measurements have on changes predicted by the model.
[0164] At 935, the residual systematic variation between the measured data under the selected sampling scheme and the selected mathematical model used to fit the measured data is calculated. For example, the residual systematic variation can be calculated for each sampling scheme in conjunction with each mathematical model.
[0165] Various systematic influences during the processing of the substrate can determine the systematic changes in the output of the process, and are therefore reflected in the measurement results as systematic changes (e.g., systematic overlapping changes), sometimes also referred to as the fingerprint of the process. A portion of the fingerprint (e.g., the statistically relevant portion) is described by a selected mathematical model. However, the remaining portion is not captured by the mathematical model, but is still systematic. This is the residual systematic change. In an embodiment, the residual systematic change includes the distance between the average of the measurement data across multiple substrates and the selected mathematical model. In an embodiment, the residual systematic change can take into account the statistical (sampling) accuracy of the average (e.g., a confidence interval of 95% to 90%). Accuracy is useful for considering, for example, overfitting, substrate-to-substrate variation and / or the number of substrates used. In an embodiment, the accuracy can be, for example, in the range of 0.1nm to 0.8nm, for example, about 0.5nm.
[0166] The remaining systematic variation for certain substrates processed in a device manufacturing process may be specific to a particular sub-process or apparatus used in the processing of the substrates. For example, the remaining systematic variation for a substrate in a device manufacturing process may be further specified with respect to one or more substrate stages, one or more etch chambers, etc., used to process the substrate, since the substrate may not be processed by the same substrate stage, etch chamber, etc. in each iteration of the device manufacturing process, and there may be variations in the systematic effects (and therefore fingerprints) caused by different substrate stages, etch chambers, etc. Further, the remaining systematic variation may be specified for batches, since there may be differences in systematic effects from batch to batch.
[0167] In an embodiment, the residual systematic variation includes residual systematic variation within a single substrate measured for monitoring a device manufacturing process, or substrate-to-substrate residual systematic variation among a plurality of substrates measured for monitoring a device manufacturing process.
[0168] At 940, the residual uncertainty (e.g., residual noise) of the mathematical model that fits the measured data under the selected sampling scheme and the selected mathematical model used to fit the measured data is calculated. For example, like the residual systematic variation, the residual uncertainty can be calculated for each sampling scheme in conjunction with each mathematical model.
[0169] Various influences during the processing of the substrate (e.g., measurement noise, random variation, etc.) can determine the uncertainty in the output of the process, and are therefore reflected in the measurement results as uncertainty (e.g., noise). In addition, the way of performing the measurement and mathematical modeling of the measurement may be inaccurate and at least partially due to the noise in the measurement. Therefore, a part of the process uncertainty can be described by the selected mathematical model. However, the uncertainty remainder is not captured by the mathematical model. The remainder is the residual uncertainty. In an embodiment, the residual uncertainty includes an estimate of the uncertainty of the selected fitting mathematical model for the measurement data. In an embodiment, the residual uncertainty can be determined by calculating the mathematical model of the selection of the fitting on the sub-sampled data for each substrate (substrate pair) and determining the change of the evaluation of the fitting results of all substrates (substrate pairs) across the dense grid (e.g., full measurement grid). In an embodiment, the part of the residual uncertainty derived from the uncertainty (e.g., noise) input in the substrate can be calculated using the noise propagation of the mathematical model and the measure of the uncertainty (e.g., noise) input in the substrate.
[0170] In an embodiment, the residual uncertainty may include a residual uncertainty specified within the substrate. In an embodiment, an estimate of the residual uncertainty within the substrate may be determined by calculating an average substrate (e.g., for each substrate stage), calculating a residual relative to the corresponding average substrate for each substrate, and then (e.g., for each substrate stage) taking all determined residuals as a group and calculating a 3σ value. To check the estimate, the 3σ value may be optionally compared to a limit in different directions. For example, a good estimate may be when the 3σ value is less than or equal to a certain amount, such as when the 3σ value is less than or equal to 2.5nm in the x and / or y direction. Another check may be whether the distribution of the 3σ values is a Gaussian distribution. Another check may be whether a stacked, overlapping plot shows little or no systematic variation / fingerprint. Another check may be whether the plot of the 3σ values for each position across the substrate is substantially uniform. In order to improve the residual uncertainty values (by removing systematic effects from the values), the data may be mathematically modeled for each substrate. Subsequently, the value of the average residual substrate is subtracted from the value of the individual residual substrate rather than from the original value of the substrate. By doing so, systematic variations may be reduced or eliminated. Similarly, within one substrate, the fields can be modeled and then the value of the average residual field subtracted from the values of the individual residual fields.
[0171] In an embodiment, the residual uncertainty may include model uncertainty or normalized model uncertainty. When there is noise in the data, the data may be modeled in different ways depending on the nature of the noise, the measurement (e.g., sampling) scheme used, etc. Therefore, model uncertainty provides a measure of the noise sensitivity of the mathematical model when its parameters are estimated on a given measurement scheme using noise measurements. Therefore, model uncertainty can be interpreted as a noise amplification / suppression factor of the change from the noise present in the measurement to the model predicted value. Model uncertainty is a function of the mathematical model used, the location of the measurement point, the location where the model is evaluated (interpolated and extrapolated), and the number of substrates measured. Normalized model uncertainty (NMU) is a unitless version of model uncertainty and does not change as a function of the noise level. NMU<1 implies noise suppression, and NMU>1 implies noise amplification. Therefore, normalized model uncertainty indicates the amount of change in the modeled value scaled by the amount of noise in the measurement. Low NMU (<1) helps ensure that the sampling scheme-mathematical model combination will result in a consistent fit, i.e., a robust fit to noise (although it may not be guaranteed that the model will accurately describe the actual measurement). In an embodiment, for good noise suppression, the maximum NMU should be less than 0.6, less than 0.5, less than 0.4 or less than 0.3. The product of the intra-substrate noise (e.g., 3σ value) and the NMU is the output noise (e.g., residual noise) based on the intra-substrate noise. It is the theoretical output noise and is an indicator showing the impact of the selected model and the sampling scheme used. Therefore, in an embodiment, the sampling scheme optimizer can optimize to reduce or minimize the NMU, and then the residual uncertainty can be determined by multiplying the applicable NMU value by the intra-substrate noise (e.g., 3σ value) of the measured data, and the residual uncertainty is used for further use in evaluating one or more mathematical models and sampling schemes in view of the measured data.
[0172] In an embodiment, the residual uncertainty can include substrate to substrate variation. This can be determined by, for example, calculating the average 3σ substrate to substrate variation of a mathematical model across measured data for multiple substrates. The calculation of the output noise generated from the noise within the substrate and the substrate to substrate variation combination can be performed by sampling each substrate with a selected number of points. Then, for each substrate (or each combination of a substrate and a specific substrate stage), the selected model is fitted to the data. The model parameter values obtained are evaluated on the complete measurement layout. Then, for each position on the substrate, the standard deviation is calculated. Then, the standard deviation of each position obtained can be averaged across all positions.
[0173] In an embodiment, the remaining uncertainty may include batch-to-batch variations where data from multiple batches are used.
[0174] The residual uncertainty for certain substrates processed in a device manufacturing process may be specific to a particular sub-process or apparatus used in the processing of the substrate. For example, the residual uncertainty for a substrate in a device manufacturing process may be further specified with respect to one or more substrate stages, one or more etching chambers, etc., used to process the substrate, since the substrate may not be processed by the same substrate stage, etching chamber, etc. in each iteration of the device manufacturing process, and there may be variations in, for example, noise caused by different substrate stages, etching chambers, etc. Furthermore, the residual uncertainty may be specified for a batch, since there may be uncertainty differences from batch to batch.
[0175] At 945, various plots of the results of 930, 930, and 935 may be provided. Such plots may include preparation graphs, charts of the data, maps of the data across the substrate, and the like.
[0176] At 950, an analysis of the data is provided and a presentation of the results and balance recommendations is performed. At 955, one or more mathematical models for fitting the measured data and one or more measurement sampling schemes for measuring the data are evaluated for the measured data across the substrate with respect to one or more evaluation parameters. In an embodiment, the one or more evaluation parameters include a parameter representing the residual uncertainty of the mathematical model that fits the measured data. In an embodiment, the one or more evaluation parameters include a parameter representing the residual systematic variation between the measured data and the mathematical model that fits the measured data. In an embodiment, the one or more evaluation parameters include a first evaluation parameter and a different second evaluation parameter. In an embodiment, the first evaluation parameter includes a parameter representing the residual uncertainty of the mathematical model that fits the measured data, and / or the second evaluation parameter includes a parameter representing the residual systematic variation between the measured data and the mathematical model that fits the measured data. In an embodiment, the first evaluation parameter and the second evaluation parameter can be combined together as a total.
[0177] Subsequently, one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes (of the evaluated one or more mathematical models and measurement sampling schemes) are identified for which the evaluation parameter crosses a threshold (e.g., exceeds a specific value, exceeds the value of another mathematical model and / or sampling scheme, etc.). For example, one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes are selected manually or by automated processing. One or more guidelines, restrictions, thresholds, charts and / or tables may be provided to facilitate the selection of one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes. For example, a ranking of the evaluated one or more mathematical models and / or measurement sampling schemes may be provided. The manual or automated criteria may then be the selection of a certain number of the highest ranked mathematical models and / or measurement sampling schemes. The ranking may be based on a single performance parameter, on a combination of performance parameters, or on a weighted combination of performance parameters, etc. A further manual or automated criteria may be the selection of one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes that pass a certain threshold for the evaluation parameter, optionally if those one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes pass or fail another threshold. For example, the manual or automated criteria may be an evaluation of the mathematical model and / or measurement sampling scheme for matching the fingerprint of the data (residual systematic variation) with respect to noise suppression (residual uncertainty); for example, a suitable mathematical model and / or sampling scheme may be one that has a fingerprint capture capability of the model that is balanced against noise suppression capability. As another example, if the residual uncertainty is not below a certain value, then one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes may be excluded (e.g., if NMU>0.6, then exclude). As another example, if the residual systematic variation is above a certain value, then one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes may be excluded (e.g., if the residual systematic variation is>1nm to 5nm, such as 1nm, 1.5nm, 2nm, 2.5nm, 3nm, 3.5nm, 4nm, 4.5nm, or 5nm, then exclude).
[0178] In an embodiment, the results may include an evaluation of the evaluation parameter for each evaluated mathematical model (e.g., multiple mathematical models) according to the evaluated one or more sampling schemes (e.g., multiple sampling schemes, such as the number of points per substrate sampled). As an example, the results may be an evaluation of the residual uncertainty parameter for each of the multiple mathematical models according to the number of points per substrate sampled (or other sampling schemes). In an embodiment, those results may be graphically represented. In an embodiment, those results may be statistically analyzed or otherwise evaluated according to a threshold value, for example, to provide a user with a suggestion about the results. As an example, the results may be evaluated to identify one or more combinations of mathematical models and sampling schemes having the maximum or minimum value of the evaluation parameter (or values within 30%, within 20%, within 15%, within 10%, or within 5%), and optionally rank these combinations from highest to lowest relative to the maximum or minimum value, as appropriate. As a further example, the results may be evaluated to identify one or more combinations of mathematical models and sampling schemes having a combination of a good value (e.g., high or low) of the evaluation parameter and a good (e.g., high) throughput value combination of the sampling scheme. Therefore, the combination of mathematical model and sampling scheme that does not have the best value of the evaluation parameter may be selected because it has a better throughput. An appropriate cost function may be used (using, for example, weighting).
[0179] In an embodiment, one or more sampling schemes evaluated are designed or confirmed based on a throughput model of an inspection device used to measure a target. Thus, the software enables the sampling scheme and / or mathematical model used to monitor process steps in a lithography process to be determined by determining the sampling scheme and the mathematical model based at least in part on the throughput model of the inspection device. Therefore, in the case of the example presented above of the results of the evaluation of the residual uncertainty parameter according to the multiple points (or other sampling schemes) of each substrate sampled for each of the multiple mathematical models, the software can identify or evaluate those specific specific numbers of points (or other specific sampling schemes) of each substrate that will satisfy the throughput model of the inspection device. Thus, specific combinations of mathematical models and sampling that satisfy the throughput model can be presented to the user, and in addition those specific combinations or information about selecting specific combinations that obtain the best performance for certain characteristics (such as a good match between the fingerprint of the data and good noise suppression) are presented.
[0180] In an embodiment of the balance recommendation, a measure of statistical accuracy of the average substrate (ie, used as an input for determining the remaining systematic variation) is used along with warning limits to help the user identify potential problems with the metrology target / metrology recipe / sampling scheme / mathematical model.
[0181] In further embodiments of balancing recommendations, one or more KPIs for substrate-to-substrate variations across a substrate are used with warning limits to help the user identify potential problems with the metrology target / metrology recipe / sampling scheme / mathematical model. For example, the software may recommend that the user implement edge exclusion for the sampling scheme (i.e., prevent sampling of regions near the edge of the substrate, where the KPI used to identify this problem may be the maximum value of the substrate-to-substrate standard deviation across the substrate), to indicate the potential benefit of substrate level correction (where the KPI used to identify this problem may be the spread of the standard deviation across the substrate), or to identify potential problems with the overall noise level of the measured data (where the KPI used to identify this problem may be the average value of the standard deviation across the substrate).
[0182] At 960, guidance on key performance indicators (KPIs) may be provided to the user. In an embodiment, key performance indicators for evaluation and / or limits for key performance indicators may be determined. For example, one or more KPIs may be identified and one or more thresholds associated with the KPIs may be determined to enable process control. For example, an average value, standard deviation, variation, etc. may be identified as a KPI, and a threshold value (e.g., a value not exceeded, a value not lower than, etc.) may be determined to enable process control. The software may analyze various KPIs in view of, for example, measured data or simulations to identify one or more selected KPIs that are statistically significant for an applicable mathematical model / sampling scheme combination. Similarly, the software may analyze one or more selected KPIs based on, for example, measured data or simulations to identify one or more statistically significant thresholds for one or more selected KPIs. For example, the software may identify average overlap as a meaningful KPI for a specific overlap measurement target / matching scheme / model / sampling scheme combination, and further identify the maximum value associated with the KPI for use during process control. So, for example, if the overlay in a device manufacturing process using a particular overlay measurement target / scheme / model / sampling scheme combination drifts above a maximum value of the average overlay KPI, control of the device manufacturing process can take appropriate actions, such as reprocessing, determining and / or applying changes to the device manufacturing process (e.g., changing lithography equipment parameters, changing etching parameters, etc.), stopping the device manufacturing process, and the like.
[0183] In addition, in an embodiment, at 960, the user may be able to gain insight into measured data and data (measured or derived data) associated with one or more mathematical models, one or more sampling schemes, one or more measurement target designs, one or more measurement matching schemes, and / or one or more KPIs. For example, the graphical user interface of the software may present results as described above to the user, and those results may have one or more links to view, for example, details of measured data (e.g., a schematic diagram or picture of a substrate showing, for example, the distribution of overlapping results), details of the sampling scheme (e.g., a schematic diagram or picture of a substrate showing the location of sampling points at the field and / or one or more fields showing the location within the field), details of the mathematical model (e.g., the type of model, basis functions, parameter values, etc.), details of one or more KPIs (e.g., values for different directions, etc.). The insightful data may be presented on different screens (e.g., overlapping windows, etc.). In an embodiment, the user may select a KPI for review and / or set a user-defined threshold on the KPI and gain insight into the data (e.g., measured data, sampling scheme, mathematical model, etc.) using the KPI and / or the user-defined threshold.
[0184] At 965, one or more measurement target design-measurement matching scheme combinations ready for consideration for HVM, optionally with associated performance, may be output. In addition, one or more associated mathematical models and one or more associated sampling schemes may be output, optionally with associated performance.
[0185] Once one or more mathematical models and / or one or more sampling schemes have been determined for the selected one or more measurement targets and the associated one or more measurement options, it may be desirable to verify their expected dynamic performance prior to implementation into the HVM. Fig.10 A flow chart of an embodiment of a method of verifying expected performance is schematically depicted.
[0186] At 1000, various preparation data are obtained and some optional preparation data processing is performed. At 1005, measurement results from one or more substrates (desirably multiple substrates) are obtained or received, and the one or more substrates are patterned using one or more measurement target designs and measured using inspection equipment under one or more measurement options associated therewith and sampled under one or more sampling schemes associated therewith. In an embodiment, the measurement data comes from multiple batches of substrates. For example, in an embodiment, the sampling scheme may be 200 points for each substrate of a batch of 6 substrates, and there may be data from 20 or more batches. Therefore, for multiple substrates of each batch in multiple batches, measured measurement data across the substrate is obtained. The data can be converted into a map corresponding to the layout of the substrate. In an embodiment, the measurement data includes one or more of the following: overlap data, overlap error data, alignment data, critical dimension data, focus data and / or critical dimension uniformity data.
[0187] At 1010 , the measurement data from 1005 may optionally be processed to remove corrections that may have been applied in an inspection device used to measure the data from 1005 and / or in a device fabrication process used to process a substrate corresponding to the data from 1005 .
[0188] At 1015, data processing is performed, including, for example, simulation. At 1020, the software may determine a correction based on data derived from measured data for a particular batch subset of multiple batches. The correction may be an estimated correction. In an embodiment, the correction includes a change in a parameter of a lithographic device used to expose a substrate. The correction may be determined using one or more mathematical models associated with one or more sampling schemes, one or more measurement targets, and one or more measurement matching schemes selected. In an embodiment, the software evaluates the measurement data for multiple substrates of a particular batch to obtain values of parameters of one or more mathematical models for the measurement data, wherein the data derived from the measured data includes the values of the parameters. In an embodiment, the correction may be derived using a simulation that simulates device manufacturing and measurement processes, for example, an image / resist simulation model for lithography together with a substrate processing simulation model for development, etching, etc. and a simulation model for measuring measurement targets on a simulated substrate.
[0189] At 1025, the software performs a simulation applying the correction to obtain simulated measurement data for a set of subsequent batches. In an embodiment, the simulation simulates the device manufacturing and measurement processes, for example, an image / resist simulation model for lithography along with a substrate processing simulation model for development, etching, etc. and a simulation model for measuring a metrology target on the simulated substrate. The simulated measurement data for the set of subsequent batches can be compared with the measured data for the set of subsequent batches.
[0190] At 1050, various plots of the results of 1020 and 1025 may be provided. Such plots may include preparation graphs, charts of the data, maps of the data across the substrate, and the like.
[0191] At 1030, analysis of the data is provided and presentation of results and recommendations is performed. At 1035, the results are presented, for example, through a user interface. The results can be, for example, a graph depicting the results of parameters (such as overlap) for each of the batches for the measured measurement target / matching scheme / model / sampling scheme combination and the simulated measurement target / matching scheme / model / sampling scheme combination. Graphs for two different directions, such as the X and Y directions, can be provided. The graph will give the user a presentation of how well the predicted performance of the measurement target / matching scheme / model / sampling scheme combination from, for example, 965 matches the measured data for the measurement target / matching scheme / model / sampling scheme combination.
[0192] At 1040, guidance on key performance indicators (KPIs) may be provided to the user. In an embodiment, a key performance indicator for evaluating simulated measurement data based on measured data and / or a limit for the key performance indicator may be determined, and / or a key performance indicator for evaluating a process and / or a limit for the key performance indicator may be determined. For example, one or more KPIs may be identified, and one or more thresholds associated with the KPIs may be determined to enable verification between measured and simulated results. For example, an average value, a standard deviation, a change, etc. may be identified as a KPI, and a threshold value (e.g., a value not exceeded, a value not lower than, etc.) may be determined to enable verification of a measurement target / matching scheme / model / sampling scheme combination. For example, if the average value and / or standard deviation value for the measured and simulated results are not within a certain amount of each other, the determination of the measurement target / matching scheme / model / sampling scheme combination may need to be re-performed using different parameters, different parameter values, etc.
[0193] Additionally or alternatively, for example, one or more KPIs may be identified and one or more thresholds associated with the KPIs may be determined to enable process control. For example, an average value, standard deviation, variation, etc. may be identified as a KPI, and a threshold value (e.g., a value not exceeded, a value not lower than, etc.) may be determined to enable process control. The software may analyze various KPIs in view of, for example, measured data or simulations to identify one or more selected KPIs that are statistically significant for a measurement target / matching scheme / model / sampling scheme combination. Similarly, the software may analyze one or more selected KPIs based on, for example, measured data or simulations to identify one or more statistically significant thresholds for one or more selected KPIs. For example, the software may identify average overlap as a meaningful KPI for a specific overlap measurement target / matching scheme / model / sampling scheme combination, and further identify the maximum value associated with the KPI for use during process control. So, for example, if the overlay in a device manufacturing process using a particular overlay measurement target / scheme / model / sampling scheme combination drifts above a maximum value of the average overlay KPI, control of the device manufacturing process can take appropriate actions, such as reprocessing, determining and / or applying changes to the device manufacturing process (e.g., changing lithography equipment parameters, changing etching parameters, etc.), stopping the device manufacturing process, and the like.
[0194] At 1045, the user or software may select one or more measurement target / alternatives / models / sampling scheme combinations based on the KPIs and their thresholds, such as those with good target performance. One or more measurement target design-measurement alternative combinations ready for consideration for HVM may be output, optionally with associated performance. In addition, one or more associated mathematical models and one or more associated sampling schemes may be output, optionally with associated performance.
[0195] In an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: evaluating, based on measurement data across a substrate, one or more mathematical models used to fit the measured data and one or more measurement sampling schemes used to measure the data relative to parameters representing residual uncertainty of the mathematical models that fit the measured data; and identifying one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes whose parameters cross a threshold.
[0196] In an embodiment, the method further comprises: evaluating one or more mathematical models and one or more measurement sampling schemes relative to the residual systematic variation between the measured data and the mathematical model that fits the measured data. In an embodiment, the residual systematic variation comprises the distance between the average of the measured data across multiple substrates and the mathematical model. In an embodiment, the residual systematic variation further takes into account the statistical accuracy of the average. In an embodiment, the residual uncertainty comprises an estimate of the uncertainty of the fitted mathematical model for the measured data. In an embodiment, the identification comprises providing a ranking of the evaluated one or more mathematical models and / or the evaluated one or more measurement sampling schemes for fitting the measured data. In an embodiment, the measurement data comprises one or more of the following: overlap data, overlap error data, alignment data, critical dimension data, focus data and / or critical dimension uniformity data. In an embodiment, the method further comprises enabling a user to select multiple mathematical models and / or multiple sampling schemes for evaluation. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme comprises one or more selected from the following: the number of sampling points per substrate, the layout of the sampling points and / or the number of substrates per batch. In an embodiment, the method further comprises: receiving measured cross-substrate measurement data for a plurality of substrates for each of a plurality of batches, wherein the measurement data is modeled using one or more identified mathematical models and / or measured using one or more identified measurement sampling schemes; performing simulations involving applying corrections based on data derived from the measured data for a particular subset of batches in the plurality of batches to obtain simulated measurement data for a set of subsequent batches; and evaluating the simulated measurement data for a set of subsequent batches based on the measured data for the set of subsequent batches. In an embodiment, the measurement data is obtained using a particular measurement recipe and a particular measurement sampling scheme, and the correction is determined and / or the simulation is performed using a particular mathematical model for the measurement data. In an embodiment, the method further comprises evaluating the measurement data for a plurality of substrates for a particular batch to obtain values of parameters for a mathematical model of the measurement data, wherein the data derived from the measured data comprises the values of the parameters. In an embodiment, the correction comprises a change in a parameter of a lithographic apparatus used to expose the substrate. In an embodiment, the method further comprises determining a key performance indicator and / or a limit for the key performance indicator for evaluating the simulated measurement data based on the measured data.
[0197] In an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: evaluating, based on measurement data across a substrate, one or more mathematical models for fitting the measured data and one or more measurement sampling schemes for measuring the data relative to a first evaluation parameter and a different second evaluation parameter; and identifying one or more mathematical models and / or one or more measurement sampling schemes at which the first and second evaluation parameters cross a threshold.
[0198] In an embodiment, the first or second evaluation parameter comprises a residual systematic variation between the measured data and a mathematical model used to fit the measured data. In an embodiment, the first or second evaluation parameter comprises a parameter representing the residual uncertainty of the mathematical model that fits the measured data. In an embodiment, the identification comprises providing a ranking of one or more evaluated mathematical models and / or one or more evaluated measurement sampling schemes for fitting the measured data. In an embodiment, the measurement data comprises one or more of the following: overlap data, overlap error data, alignment data, critical dimension data, focus data, and / or critical dimension uniformity data. In an embodiment, the method further comprises enabling a user to select multiple mathematical models and / or constraints on the sampling scheme for evaluation. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme comprises one or more selected from the following: the number of sampling points per substrate, the layout of the sampling points, and / or the number of substrates per batch. In an embodiment, the method further comprises: receiving measured cross-substrate measurement data for a plurality of substrates for each of a plurality of batches, wherein the measurement data is modeled using one or more identified mathematical models and / or measured using one or more identified measurement sampling schemes; performing simulations involving applying corrections based on data derived from the measured data for a particular subset of batches in the plurality of batches to obtain simulated measurement data for a set of subsequent batches; and evaluating the simulated measurement data for a set of subsequent batches based on the measured data for the set of subsequent batches. In an embodiment, the measurement data is obtained using a particular measurement recipe and a particular measurement sampling scheme, and the correction is determined and / or the simulation is performed using a particular mathematical model for the measurement data. In an embodiment, the method further comprises evaluating the measurement data for a plurality of substrates for a particular batch to obtain values of parameters for a mathematical model of the measurement data, wherein the data derived from the measured data comprises the values of the parameters. In an embodiment, the correction comprises a change in a parameter of a lithographic apparatus used to expose the substrate. In an embodiment, the method further comprises determining a key performance indicator and / or a limit for the key performance indicator for evaluating the simulated measurement data based on the measured data.
[0199] In an embodiment, a method is provided for determining a sampling scheme for measuring data and / or a mathematical model for fitting the measured data to monitor process steps in a lithography process, the method comprising: determining the sampling scheme and the mathematical model based at least in part on a throughput model of an inspection device.
[0200] In an embodiment, the throughput model specifies a loading time of a substrate in an inspection device, an alignment time of a substrate in an inspection device, a repositioning time of a substrate in an inspection device, a time for positioning a measurement target in a measurement position in the inspection device, and / or a time for retrieving measurement data from a measurement target in the inspection device. In an embodiment, determining comprises determining based on a plurality of throughput models for different inspection devices. In an embodiment, determining further comprises determining based on a residual systematic variation between measured data and a mathematical model for fitting the measured data. In an embodiment, determining further comprises determining based on a parameter representing a residual uncertainty of a mathematical model for fitting the measured data. In an embodiment, the residual systematic variation or residual uncertainty comprises a residual systematic variation or residual uncertainty within a single substrate measured for monitoring a process step, or a substrate-to-substrate residual systematic variation or residual uncertainty among a plurality of substrates measured for monitoring a process step, respectively. In an embodiment, the inspection device is an inspection device in a lithography device. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme comprises one or more selected from the following: the number of sampling points per substrate, the layout of the sampling points, and / or the number of substrates per batch.
[0201] In an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: receiving measurement data of a measurement target measured according to a measurement matching scheme; determining a sampling scheme for measuring data using the measurement target using the measurement matching scheme based at least in part on a throughput model of an inspection device; determining an evaluation parameter based on the measurement data and the sampling scheme; determining whether the evaluation parameter crosses a threshold; and if it is determined that the evaluation parameter crosses the threshold, changing the sampling scheme based at least in part on the throughput model.
[0202] In an embodiment, the evaluation parameter includes a substrate-to-substrate variation within a batch of substrates. In an embodiment, the method further includes determining a mathematical model for fitting the measurement data, and wherein determining the sampling scheme is further based on the mathematical model. In an embodiment, the method further includes: if the sampling scheme has changed, at least re-performing the determination of the evaluation parameter based on the measurement data and the changed sampling scheme and determining whether the evaluation parameter determined based on the measurement data and the changed sampling scheme crosses a threshold. In an embodiment, determining the sampling scheme includes determining based on a plurality of throughput models for different inspection devices. In an embodiment, the method further includes determining the sampling scheme and / or the mathematical model for fitting the measured data based on the residual systematic variation between the measured data and the mathematical model for fitting the measured data. In an embodiment, the method further includes determining the sampling scheme and / or the mathematical model for fitting the measured data based on a parameter representing the residual uncertainty of the mathematical model for fitting the measured data. In an embodiment, the sampling scheme includes one or more selected from the following: the number of sampling points per substrate, the layout of the sampling points, and / or the number of substrates per batch. In an embodiment, the throughput model specifies a loading time of a substrate in an inspection apparatus, an alignment time of a substrate in an inspection apparatus, a repositioning time of a substrate in an inspection apparatus, a time for positioning a measurement target within a measurement position in the inspection apparatus, and / or a time to retrieve measurement data from a measurement target in the inspection apparatus. In an embodiment, the metrology target comprises an alignment target.
[0203] Fig.11 A user interface of software of an embodiment to provide a portion of device manufacturing process development, monitoring and control is schematically depicted. Fig.11 An embodiment of is a graphical user interface of software designed for measurement design, setup and / or monitoring processes such as described above. In an embodiment, Fig.11 The concepts can be extended to software that enables other parts of device manufacturing process development, monitoring and control.
[0204] See also Fig.11 , depicting a plurality of graphical user interface elements 1100. Each graphical user interface element 1100 represents a step in a measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process, and each graphical user interface element enables access by a user to further steps in the measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process for the associated step of the graphical user interface element. For example, clicking on a graphical user interface element enables a user to access further steps associated with the description of the graphical user element. Additional steps may appear on further screens (not depicted here for clarity).
[0205] A collection of one or more graphical user interface elements 1100 (e.g., Fig.11100) may be associated with a particular functionality represented by the associated graphical user interface element 1110. The graphical user element 1110 itself may enable access by a user to further steps in the measurement design, setup, and / or monitoring process for the associated functionality of the graphical user interface element. In embodiments, one or more of the graphical user interface elements 1110 may not enable access to further steps, and may merely provide information about the particular functionality and functionality represented by the associated one or more graphical user interface elements 1100 (e.g., Fig.11 Information of one or more steps represented by the columns of associated one or more graphical user interface elements 1100 shown in .
[0206] In addition, an indicator associated with one or more of the plurality of graphical user elements 1100, 1110 may be displayed. In an embodiment, the indicator indicates that a step in the measurement design, setting and / or monitoring process is not completed and / or a key performance indicator associated with the step in the measurement design, setting and / or monitoring process has passed a threshold. In an embodiment, the indicator includes a color of the graphical user interface element and / or a symbol associated with the graphical user interface element. For example, an indicator 1130 (e.g., a stop sign or similar symbol) may indicate that a step in the measurement design, setting and / or monitoring process is not completed and / or a key performance indicator associated with the step in the measurement design, setting and / or monitoring process has not successfully met a criterion. For example, an indicator 1120 (e.g., an alarm sign, an exclamation mark sign or other similar symbol) may indicate that a key performance indicator associated with a step in the measurement design, setting and / or monitoring process has passed a threshold. Additionally or alternatively, one or more of the plurality of graphical user elements 1100, 1110 may be provided with different colors, shades or textures depending on a particular state. For example, the graphical user elements 1100, 1110 with dot filling indicate that, for example, a step or function has been completed or is OK in another way. The dot filling indicates, for example, green, a specific dark shade, and / or a specific texture. Therefore, the dot filling indicates that, for example, a step in a measurement design, setting, and / or monitoring process is completed and / or a key performance indicator associated with a step in a measurement design, setting, and / or monitoring process successfully meets the criteria. As another example, the graphical user elements 1100, 1110 with hatched filling indicate that, for example, a step or function is not completed or is not OK in another way. The hatched filling indicates, for example, red or orange, a specific dark shade, and / or a specific texture. Therefore, the hatched filling indicates that, for example, a step in a measurement design, setting, and / or monitoring process is not completed and / or a key performance indicator associated with a step in a measurement design, setting, and / or monitoring process does not successfully meet the criteria. As another example, the graphical user elements 1100, 1110 without filling indicate that, for example, a step or function has not been started or cannot be accessed. The no filling indicates, for example, white, a specific dark shade, and / or a specific texture. Thus, an unfilled representation, for example, indicates that a step in a measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process in a step or function represented by a graphical user interface element was not attempted or could not be attempted because, for example, one or more earlier or dependent steps were not completed or attempted, and / or a key performance indicator associated with an earlier or dependent step in the measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process did not successfully meet criteria.
[0207] In an embodiment, the software prevents access by the user to further steps in the measurement design, setup, and / or monitoring process for steps associated with a particular graphical user interface element, despite user engagement with the particular graphical user interface element. For example, access to one or more of the graphical user elements that are not filled may be prevented until one or more steps associated with, for example, a graphical user interface element or indicator 1120 or 1130 having a hatched fill are completed.
[0208] In an embodiment, one or more of the graphical user interface elements or indicators may represent key performance indicators and / or guidelines, or may display information about key performance indicators and / or guidelines or enable the display of such information. For example, one or more graphical user interface elements 1100 or indicators 1120 or 1130 may represent key performance indicators and / or guidelines, such that the graphical user interface elements enable access to key performance indicators and / or guidelines by, for example, a user clicking on the graphical user interface elements. In an embodiment, one or more graphical user interface elements 1100 or indicators 1120 or 1130 may display information about key performance indicators and / or guidelines or enable the display of such information. For example, one or more graphical user interface elements 1100 or indicators 1120 or 1130 may display the value of a key performance indicator or a signal that the key performance indicator is OK or not OK. In an embodiment, a user may “fly” one or more graphical user interface elements 1100 or indicators 1120 or 1130 using, for example, a pointer icon to display information about a key performance indicator (e.g., a value of a key performance indicator or a signal that a key performance indicator is OK or not OK) and / or guidance.
[0209] In an embodiment, one or more of the graphical user interface elements may have an indicator 1140 to allow for an update or refresh of data. A user may click or otherwise engage indicator 1140 to cause an update or refresh of data associated with one or more steps associated with the graphical user interface, which may cause a change in accessing steps associated with one or more other graphical user interface elements and / or a change in indicators 1120 or 1130.
[0210] In an embodiment, a method is provided, comprising: displaying a plurality of graphical user interface elements, each graphical user interface element representing a step in a measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process, and each graphical user interface element enabling a user to access further steps in the measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process for the step associated with the graphical user interface element; and displaying an indicator associated with one or more of the plurality of graphical user elements, the indicator indicating that a step in the measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process is not completed and / or a key performance indicator associated with a step in the measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process has passed a threshold.
[0211] In an embodiment, the method further comprises: preventing access by the user to further steps in the measurement design, setup and / or monitoring process for steps associated with a particular graphical user interface element despite user engagement with the particular graphical user interface element. In an embodiment, the indicator comprises a color of the graphical user interface element and / or a symbol associated with the graphical user interface element. In an embodiment, the method further comprises displaying a graphical user interface element representing a key performance indicator and / or guideline or displaying information about the key performance indicator and / or guideline or enabling display of the information.
[0212] Embodiments of the present invention may take the form of a computer program containing one or more sequences of machine-readable instructions describing the methods disclosed herein, or a data storage medium (e.g., a semiconductor memory, a magnetic disk, or an optical disk) having such a computer program stored therein. In addition, the machine-readable instructions may be embodied in two or more computer programs. The two or more computer programs may be stored on one or more different memories and / or data storage media.
[0213] Any controller described herein may be operable individually or in combination when one or more computer programs are read by one or more computer processors located in at least one component of the lithographic apparatus. The controllers may have any suitable configuration for receiving, processing and sending signals, individually or in combination. One or more processors are configured to communicate with at least one of the controllers. For example, each controller may include one or more processors for executing a computer program including machine-readable instructions for the method described above. The controller may include a data storage medium for storing such a computer program, and / or hardware for receiving such a medium. So the controller can operate according to the machine-readable instructions of one or more computer programs. Although the use of the inspection device in the manufacture of ICs may be specifically referenced in this text, it should be understood that the inspection device described herein may have other applications, such as the manufacture of integrated optical systems, for magnetic domain memory, flat panel displays, liquid crystal displays (LCDs), guidance and detection patterns of thin film heads, and the like. It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that in the context of such alternative applications, any use of the term "wafer" or "die" herein may be considered to be synonymous with the more general term "substrate" or "target portion", respectively. The substrates referred to herein may be processed before or after exposure in, for example, a track (a tool that typically applies a layer of resist to a substrate and develops the exposed resist), a metrology tool, and / or an inspection tool. Where applicable, the disclosure herein may be applied to such and other substrate processing tools. In addition, a substrate may be processed more than once, for example to create a multi-layer IC, so that the term substrate as used herein may also refer to a substrate that already contains multiple processed layers.
[0214] Although specific reference may be made above to the use of embodiments of the invention in the context of optical lithography, it will be appreciated that the invention may be used in other applications, such as imprint lithography, and is not limited to optical lithography where the context permits. The terms "radiation" and "beam" as used herein encompass all types of electromagnetic radiation, including ultraviolet (UV) radiation (e.g., having a wavelength of or about 365 nm, 355 nm, 248 nm, 193 nm, 157 nm, or about 126 nm) and extreme ultraviolet (EUV) radiation (e.g., having a wavelength in the range of 5 nm to 20 nm), as well as particle beams such as ion beams or electron beams.
[0215] The term "lens" may refer, where the context permits, to any one or combination of various types of optical components, including refractive, reflective, magnetic, electromagnetic, and electrostatic optical components.
[0216] References herein to crossing or passing a threshold may include something having a value below a particular value or below or equal to a particular value, something having a value above a particular value or above or equal to a particular value, something being ranked higher or lower than something else (by, for example, classification) based on, for example, a parameter, etc.
[0217] As used herein, the terms "optimize" and "optimize" refer to or mean adjusting lithographic equipment, device manufacturing processes, etc. so that the results and / or processes of lithography or device manufacturing have more desired characteristics, such as higher accuracy of projection of the design layout on the substrate, a larger process window, etc. Therefore, as used herein, the terms "optimize" and "optimize" refer to or mean identifying one or more values for one or more parameters that provide an improvement, such as a local optimum, in at least one relevant metric compared to an initial set of one or more values for those one or more parameters. "Optimal" and other related terms should be interpreted accordingly. In an embodiment, the optimization step can be applied iteratively to provide further improvements in one or more metrics.
[0218] In the optimization process of the system, the quality factor of the system or process can be expressed as a cost function. The optimization process is reduced to the process of finding a set of parameters (design variables) that optimize (e.g., minimize or maximize) the cost function of the system or process. The cost function can have any suitable form depending on the goal of the optimization. For example, the cost function can be the weighted root mean square (RMS) of the deviation of certain characteristics (evaluation points) of the system or process relative to the expected values (e.g., ideal values) of these characteristics; the cost function can also be the maximum value (i.e., the worst deviation) of these deviations. The term "evaluation point" in this article should be broadly interpreted to include any characteristics of the system or process. The design variables of the system may be limited to a limited range and / or interdependent due to the practicality of the implementation of the system or process. In the case of lithographic equipment or device manufacturing processes, constraints are often associated with physical properties and characteristics of hardware such as adjustable ranges and / or pattern forming device manufacturability design rules, and evaluation points can include physical points on the resist image on the substrate, as well as non-physical characteristics such as dose and focus.
[0219] The present invention can be further described using the following clauses:
[0220] 1. A method comprising:
[0221] Performing simulations to evaluate multiple measurement targets and / or multiple measurement options for measuring the measurement targets;
[0222] Identifying one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and / or measurement options;
[0223] Receiving measurement data for one or more identified measurement targets and / or measurement options; and
[0224] Use measurement data to adjust simulation measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters.
[0225] 2. A method as in clause 1, wherein adjustment of a metrology target parameter or a metrology option parameter makes the identified metrology target and / or the metrology option more robust to variations in a process for forming or measuring the identified metrology target, to variations in a process for forming the metrology target for use with the identified option, or to variations in a process for measuring using the identified metrology option.
[0226] 3. The method of clause 1 or 2, wherein the measurement data comprises parameters representing variations in the structure of the metrology target attributable to process variability.
[0227] 4. A method as in clause 3, wherein the parameter represents a measure of asymmetry present in the structure of the measurement target.
[0228] 5. A method as claimed in clause 3 or 4, wherein the measurement data comprises measurements at different stages of processing of the structure and / or application of a layer above the structure.
[0229] 6. The method of clause 5, further comprising varying a processed property of the structure.
[0230] 7. The method of clause 6, wherein the properties of the processing include one or more selected from the group consisting of: optical properties of the layer, material thickness, polishing parameters, and / or etching parameters.
[0231] 8. A method as in any of clauses 3 to 7, wherein the structure is a lower periodic structure of the measurement target, and the measurement data relates to the lower periodic structure in the absence of an upper periodic structure of the measurement target being located above the lower periodic structure at the time of acquisition of the measurement data.
[0232] 9. A method as in clause 1 or 2, wherein the measurement data comprises a measured sensitivity of a parameter of the measurement target to the wavelength of the measurement beam.
[0233] 10. The method of any of clauses 1 to 9, further comprising selecting one or more metrology targets and / or metrology options from the identified one or more metrology targets and / or metrology options based on the measurement data.
[0234] 11. The method of clause 10, further comprising: performing simulation based on adjustment of measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters, and reselecting one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the identified one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options based on measurement data of one or more identified new or changed measurement targets and / or measurement options from the simulation and / or based on performance parameters determined based on the adjustment of the measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters.
[0235] 12. The method of clause 11, wherein the reselection is based on performance parameters, and the performance parameters include one or more selected from the group consisting of: overlap, stacking sensitivity, target coefficient, asymmetry and / or diffraction efficiency.
[0236] 13. The method of any of clauses 1 to 12, wherein the plurality of metrology targets comprises an alignment target.
[0237] 14. A method comprising:
[0238] Receiving measurement data of a plurality of different measurement targets, each measurement target being measured using a plurality of measurement options; and
[0239] The measurement data is used to verify one or more parameters of a simulation for evaluating a plurality of metrology targets and / or a plurality of metrology options for measuring the metrology targets.
[0240] 15. The method of clause 14, further comprising changing one or more parameters based on the measurement data.
[0241] 16. The method of clause 14 or 15, wherein the one or more parameters represent one or more parameters of a process used to form the metrology target.
[0242] 17. The method of clause 16, wherein the one or more parameters of the process used to form the metrology target include one or more selected from the group consisting of: optical properties of a layer, material thickness, polishing parameters, and / or etching parameters.
[0243] 18. The method of any of clauses 14 to 17, wherein the simulation uses the measurement data to optimize the metrology goals and / or metrology options.
[0244] 19. The method of any of clauses 14 to 18, wherein the measurement data comprises a measured sensitivity of a parameter of the measurement target to the wavelength of the measurement beam.
[0245] 20. The method of any of clauses 15 to 19, further comprising selecting one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the evaluated one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options based on the measurement data.
[0246] 21. The method of clause 20, further comprising: performing simulation based on the changed one or more parameters, and reselecting one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the evaluated one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options based on measurement data of the one or more evaluated new or changed measurement targets and / or measurement options from the simulation and / or based on performance parameters determined based on the changed one or more parameters.
[0247] 22. The method of clause 21, wherein the reselection is based on performance parameters, and the performance parameters include one or more selected from the group consisting of: overlap, stacking sensitivity, target coefficient, asymmetry, and / or diffraction efficiency.
[0248] 23. The method of any of clauses 14 to 19, comprising using a parameter derived from the measurement data to adjust a metrology target parameter or a metrology recipe parameter.
[0249] 24. The method of clause 23, wherein the derived parameters include one or more selected from the group consisting of: overlay, stacking sensitivity, process variation robustness, target coefficient, asymmetry, and / or diffraction efficiency.
[0250] 25. The method of any of clauses 14 to 24, wherein the plurality of metrology targets comprises an alignment target.
[0251] 26. A method comprising:
[0252] Simulate multiple metrology targets and / or multiple metrology options taking into account expected process conditions;
[0253] Identify one or more measurement targets and / or options from the plurality of measurement targets and / or options simulated;
[0254] Receiving measurement data of one or more identified measurement targets and / or options; and
[0255] Use measurement data to verify intended process conditions.
[0256] 27. The method of clause 26, further comprising: if the difference between the expected process condition or the expected data and the measured process condition or the measured data, respectively, crosses a threshold, re-performing the simulation and identification using a change in the expected process condition.
[0257] 28. The method of clause 26 or 27, wherein the simulation is performed under a range of process conditions surrounding expected or measured process conditions.
[0258] 29. The method of clause 28, wherein the range is defined by a user.
[0259] 30. The method of any of Clauses 26 to 29, wherein the metrology target comprises a lower target portion and comprises an upper target portion arranged in a layer between the lower target portion and the inspection device, the inspection device being configured to determine an overlap value between the upper and lower target portions.
[0260] 31. The method of clause 30, wherein receiving measurement data comprises receiving measurement data from only the lower target portion.
[0261] 32. The method of any of clauses 26 to 31, further comprising: selecting one or more measurement targets and / or options based on performance if the difference between the expected process conditions or expected data and the measured process conditions or measured data, respectively, remains within a threshold.
[0262] 33. The method of clause 32, wherein performance is determined using performance indicators comprising one or more selected from the group consisting of detectability, precision, throughput, accuracy, diffraction efficiency, asymmetry, and / or sensitivity to sensor artifacts.
[0263] 34. The method of clause 33, wherein the performance is a balance between several performance indicators and / or a balance between a performance indicator and an inspection equipment tool characteristic.
[0264] 35. The method of clause 34, wherein the inspection equipment tool characteristics include parameters representing sensitivity of inspection equipment measurements to sensor artifacts and / or stray light.
[0265] 36. A method as described in any of clauses 26 to 34, wherein the process conditions include one or more selected from the following: optical properties of the layer, material thickness, polishing parameters, etching parameters, refractive index of the treated layer, absorption index of the treated layer, thickness of the treated layer, variations in the layer, characteristics of the inspection equipment, settings of the inspection equipment, wavelength of the measurement beam used by the inspection equipment, characteristics of the lithography equipment and / or alignment strategy.
[0266] 37. The method of any of clauses 26 to 36, wherein the plurality of metrology targets comprises an alignment target.
[0267] 38. A method comprising:
[0268] Performing simulations to evaluate a plurality of measurement targets and / or a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement targets and determining parameters representative of performance of one or more of the measurement targets and / or measurement options;
[0269] Identifying one or more measurement targets and / or measurement options from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and / or measurement options;
[0270] Receiving measurement data for one or more identified measurement targets and / or measurement options; and
[0271] One or more metrology targets and / or metrology options are selected from the identified one or more metrology targets and / or metrology options based on the measurement data and the parameters.
[0272] 39. The method of clause 38, further comprising: using the measurement data to adjust a measurement target parameter or a measurement option parameter of the simulation, and performing the simulation based on the adjustment of the measurement target parameter or the measurement option parameter to determine a parameter representative of the performance.
[0273] 40. A method as described in clause 39, wherein performing simulation based on adjustment of measurement target parameters or measurement option parameters includes evaluating one or more new or changed measurement targets and / or measurement options, the method further includes receiving measurement data of one or more new or changed measurement targets and / or measurement options, and selecting includes selecting one or more new or changed measurement targets and / or measurement options based on performance parameters and measurement data.
[0274] 41. The method of any of clauses 38 to 40, wherein the parameters indicative of performance include one or more selected from: overlay shock, stacking sensitivity, process variation robustness, target coefficient, asymmetry, and / or diffraction efficiency.
[0275] 42. The method of any of clauses 38 to 41, wherein the plurality of metrology targets comprises an alignment target.
[0276] 43. A method comprising:
[0277] Performing simulations to evaluate multiple measurement targets and multiple measurement options for measuring the measurement targets;
[0278] Identifying one or more combinations of measurement targets and measurement options from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and measurement options;
[0279] Customizing a plurality of measurement options for one or more measurement targets from the one or more identified combinations based on the one or more measurement options from the identified one or more combinations; and
[0280] Measurement data of one or more metrology targets measured using the customized plurality of metrology profiles is received from the identified one or more combinations.
[0281] 44. The method of clause 43, further comprising selecting one or more metrology targets from the one or more metrology targets from the identified one or more combinations based on the measurement data.
[0282] 45. The method of clause 43 or 44, wherein the customized plurality of measurement matches comprises one or more measurement matches from the identified one or more combinations.
[0283] 46. The method of any of clauses 43 to 45, wherein the one or more measurement options from the identified one or more combinations include parameters, and the customized plurality of measurement options include measurement options having values for the parameters within a range of values for the parameters of the one or more measurement options from the identified one or more combinations.
[0284] 47. The method of any of clauses 43 to 46, wherein the plurality of metrology targets comprises an alignment target.
[0285] 48. A method comprising:
[0286] Determining parameters representing the sensitivity of one or more measurement options or one or more measurement option parameters to one or more measurement targets based on measurement data of the measurement targets measured under a plurality of measurement options; and
[0287] Based on the parameter representing the sensitivity, a plurality of measurement options for measuring the measurement target are evaluated by simulation or according to measured data to identify one or more measurement options of the plurality of measurement options for use when measuring the measurement target.
[0288] 49. The method of clause 48, wherein the measurement data includes parameters representing variations in the structure of the metrology target attributable to process variability.
[0289] 50. The method of clause 49, wherein the parameter represents a measure of asymmetry present in the structure of the measurement target.
[0290] 51. A method according to clause 49 or 50, wherein the measurement data comprises measurements at different stages of processing of the structure and / or application of a layer over the structure.
[0291] 52. The method of clause 51, further comprising varying a processed property of the structure.
[0292] 53. The method of clause 52, wherein the properties of the processing include one or more selected from the group consisting of: optical properties of the layer, material thickness, polishing parameters, and / or etching parameters.
[0293] 54. A method as in any of clauses 49 to 52, wherein the structure is a lower periodic structure of the metrology target and the measurement data relates to the lower periodic structure without an upper periodic structure of the metrology target being located above the lower periodic structure at the time of acquisition of the measurement data.
[0294] 55. The method of any of clauses 48 to 54, wherein the plurality of metrology targets comprises an alignment target.
[0295] 56. A method comprising:
[0296] Evaluating multiple measurement targets and / or multiple measurement options for measuring the measurement targets through simulation or based on measured data; and
[0297] One or more metrology targets and / or metrology matches whose diffraction efficiency or a parameter derived from the diffraction efficiency crosses a threshold are identified from the evaluated plurality of metrology targets and / or metrology matches.
[0298] 57. The method of clause 56, wherein the measurement profile comprises measurement beam wavelength, measurement beam polarization, measurement beam dose, and / or an aperture setting associated with the measurement beam.
[0299] 58. A method comprising:
[0300] Evaluating multiple measurement targets and / or multiple measurement options for measuring the measurement targets through simulation or based on measured data; and
[0301] One or more measurement targets and / or measurement options for which a measurement device property or a parameter derived from the measurement device property crosses a threshold value are identified from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and / or measurement options.
[0302] 59. The method of clause 58, wherein measuring the device property comprises measuring a measurement beam wavelength dependency of the device.
[0303] 60. The method of clause 58 or 59, wherein the measurement device property comprises a multiplication factor associated with a measurement beam wavelength dependence of the measurement device.
[0304] 61. The method of any of clauses 58 to 60, wherein the measurement device attribute comprises a function or data representing a background intensity of the measurement device for a wavelength of the measurement beam.
[0305] 62. The method of any of clauses 58 to 61, wherein the measurement profile comprises measurement beam wavelength, measurement beam polarization, measurement beam dose, and / or an aperture setting associated with the measurement beam.
[0306] 63. The method of any of clauses 58 to 62, wherein measuring a device property comprises measuring a characteristic or sensitivity of a sensor of the device.
[0307] 64. The method of any of clauses 58 to 63, wherein measuring a device property comprises examining the device for a dependence of stray light or sensor artifacts on the wavelength of the measurement beam.
[0308] 65. The method of any of clauses 58 to 64, wherein the plurality of metrology targets comprises an alignment target.
[0309] 66. A non-transitory computer program product comprising computer readable instructions for causing a processor to cause execution of the method according to any of clauses 1 to 65.
[0310] 67. A system comprising:
[0311] an inspection device configured to provide a beam onto a measurement target on the substrate and detect radiation redirected by the target to determine parameters of the lithography process; and
[0312] A non-transitory computer program product according to clause 66.
[0313] 68. The system of clause 67, further comprising a lithographic apparatus comprising a support structure configured to hold a patterning device to modulate a radiation beam and a projection optical system arranged to project the modulated radiation beam onto a radiation sensitive substrate.
[0314] 69. A system comprising:
[0315] Alignment sensor, including:
[0316] output for providing radiation from the radiation source to a target,
[0317] a detector configured to receive radiation from the target, and
[0318] a control system configured to determine alignment of two or more objects in response to the received radiation; and
[0319] A non-transitory computer program product according to clause 66.
[0320] 70. The system of clause 69, further comprising a lithographic apparatus comprising a support structure configured to hold a patterning device to modulate a radiation beam and a projection optical system arranged to project the modulated radiation beam onto a radiation sensitive substrate.
[0321] 71. A method of manufacturing a device in which a device pattern is applied to a series of substrates using a photolithography process, the method comprising at least inspecting a target formed on at least one of the substrates as part of the device pattern or outside the device pattern using a method according to any one of clauses 1 to 65, and controlling the photolithography process for at least one substrate or another substrate based on the results of the inspection.
[0322] 72. A method of manufacturing a device, wherein a device pattern is applied to a series of substrates using a photolithographic process, the method comprising:
[0323] inspecting a target identified using a method according to any one of clauses 58 to 65 and / or inspecting a target identified using a matching scheme using a method according to any one of clauses 1 to 65, the target being formed on at least one of the substrates as part of a device pattern or in addition to the device pattern, and
[0324] A photolithography process for at least one substrate or another substrate is controlled based on the results of the inspection.
[0325] Although specific embodiments of the present invention have been described above, it will be appreciated that the invention may be practiced in other ways than those described. For example, the invention may take the form of a computer program containing one or more sequences of machine-readable instructions describing the methods disclosed above, or a data storage medium (e.g., a semiconductor memory, a magnetic disk, or an optical disk) having the computer program stored therein.
[0326] The above description is intended to be illustrative rather than limiting. It will therefore be apparent to those skilled in the art that modifications may be made to the invention as described without departing from the scope of the claims set forth hereinafter.
Claims
1. A method for detecting and measuring in a semiconductor manufacturing process, comprising: Evaluate multiple measurement targets and / or multiple measurement options for measuring the measurement targets by simulation or based on measured data; as well as One or more metrology targets and / or metrology matches whose diffraction efficiency or a parameter derived from the diffraction efficiency crosses a threshold are identified from the evaluated plurality of metrology targets and / or metrology matches.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein the measurement profile comprises a measurement beam wavelength, a measurement beam polarization, a measurement beam dose, and / or an aperture setting associated with the measurement beam.
3. A method for detecting and measuring in a semiconductor manufacturing process, comprising: Evaluate multiple measurement targets and / or multiple measurement options for measuring the measurement targets by simulation or based on measured data; as well as One or more measurement targets and / or measurement options are identified from the evaluated plurality of measurement targets and / or measurement options for which a measurement device property or a parameter derived from the measurement device property crosses a threshold value.
4. The method of claim 3, wherein the measurement device properties include a measurement beam wavelength dependency of the measurement device.
5. The method of claim 3, wherein the measurement device properties include a multiplication factor associated with a measurement beam wavelength dependency of the measurement device.
6. The method of claim 3, wherein the measurement device properties include a function or data representing a background intensity of the measurement device for a measurement beam wavelength.
7. The method of claim 3, wherein the measurement profile comprises a measurement beam wavelength, a measurement beam polarization, a measurement beam dose, and / or an aperture setting associated with the measurement beam.
8. The method of claim 3, wherein the measuring device attribute comprises a characteristic or sensitivity of a sensor of the measuring device.
9. The method of claim 3, wherein measuring device properties comprises examining the device for dependence of stray light or sensor artifacts on the wavelength of the measurement beam.
10. The method of claim 3, wherein the plurality of metrology targets include alignment targets.
11. A non-transitory computer program product comprising computer readable instructions for causing a processor to cause execution of the method according to claim 1.
12. A non-transitory computer program product comprising computer readable instructions for causing a processor to cause execution of the method according to claim 3.
13. A system for a semiconductor manufacturing process, comprising: an inspection device configured to provide a beam onto a measurement target on the substrate and detect radiation redirected by the target to determine a parameter of the lithography process; as well as A non-transitory computer program product according to claim 11 or 12.
14. A system for a semiconductor manufacturing process, comprising: Alignment sensor, including: output for providing radiation from the radiation source to a target, a detector configured to receive radiation from the target, and a control system configured to determine alignment of two or more objects in response to the received radiation; and A non-transitory computer program product according to claim 11 or 12.
