Methods and devices for mutual evaluation services using decentralized transaction databases

By using verifiable reputation credentials and hash values ​​of third-party maintained evaluation data in a decentralized transaction database, the problems of information asymmetry and strong subjectivity in reputation systems are solved, achieving autonomous and objective evaluation and data privacy protection, making it suitable for machine-to-machine transactions in IoT environments.

CN114119217BActive Publication Date: 2026-11-17ROBERT BOSCH GMBH
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202110988075.5
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2020-08-27
Filing Date
2021-08-26
Publication Date
2026-11-17
Estimated Expiration
2041-08-26

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing reputation systems in decentralized transactions suffer from problems such as information asymmetry, susceptibility to abuse, and strong subjectivity, making it difficult to achieve self-sovereign data management and objective evaluation.

Method used

By using Verifiable Reputation Certificates (VRCs) in a decentralized transaction database, and having the hash value of the evaluation data maintained by a third party in the reputation system, the integrity and uniqueness of the evaluation are ensured. The provider cannot tamper with the evaluation data, and the evaluation is jointly verified by the recipient and potential interaction parties.

Benefits of technology

It enables autonomous and objective evaluation, ensuring the accuracy of the evaluation and the protection of data privacy. It is suitable for machine-to-machine transactions in the Internet of Things environment, reducing the arbitrariness and subjectivity of the evaluation.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN114119217B_ABST
    Figure CN114119217B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention relates to a method and apparatus for mutually evaluating services by means of a decentralized transaction database. A method (10) for evaluating a provider (20) of a service (21) by means of a decentralized transaction database is characterized by the following features: - The provider (20) accepts evaluation by the recipient (22) of the service (21), or vice versa; - The last data record (23) added to the transaction database is mapped to a first hash value under a hash function; - The evaluation and the first hash value are combined (13) into a new data record (23); - The new data record (23) is added to the transaction database and mapped (14) to a second hash value under a hash function; and - The new data record (23) or the second hash value is managed by a selected (28) third party (24) and provided (15) to an interested party (25) of the service (21) upon inquiry (27), said third party not acting in the interest of the evaluated party.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention relates to a method for evaluating service providers (Leistungserbringers) using a decentralized transaction database. In addition, this invention relates to a corresponding device, a corresponding computer program, and a corresponding storage medium. Background Technology

[0002] Every protocol in a computer network that reaches consensus on the order of transactions is called a decentralized transaction system, transaction database, or distributed ledger. A common manifestation of such systems is based on blockchain, which forms the basis of many so-called cryptocurrencies.

[0003] US 2019 / 0325432 A1 discloses a blockchain-based reputation system.

[0004] Furthermore, blockchain is used, for example, in the context of so-called decentralized identity (DID) and, in particular, self-sovereign identity (SSI), whereby individual identity holders can manage their identities and inspect the use of their personal data without the assistance of intermediaries or central administrative bodies. Specifically, DID can be used, for example, as a verifiable credential for claimed characteristics, which can be provided through a verifiable representation.

[0005] DE212019000019U1 discloses a system for authorizing carriers of identity documents and includes the following: an identity provider for providing a decentralized identity to the carrier; means for providing the carrier with digitally signed biometric data related to the identity document, wherein the biometric data is signed by a trust anchor and verified as output to the decentralized identity, wherein the biometric data includes an image of the carrier; means for providing an administrative authority with the carrier's decentralized identity and biometric data for verification before the carrier's travel, the biometric data including an image, the administrative authority being responsible for the carrier's entry permission, wherein the carrier receives authorization from the administrative authority after verification; an image detection system for detecting the carrier's image upon arrival; an image registration system for registering the carrier's image with images of multiple carriers already authorized by the administrative authority; and a kontrollgate for granting entry permission to the carrier after successful registration. Summary of the Invention

[0006] The present invention provides a method, a corresponding device, a corresponding computer program, and a corresponding storage medium for evaluating service providers and service recipients (Leistungsempfaenger) using a decentralized transaction database, as described in the independent claims.

[0007] The solution according to the invention is based on the understanding that in known reputation systems, most are central providers who, on the one hand, offer the possibility of evaluating another party, and on the other hand, are ultimately the owners of the reputation data issued. This leads to, on the one hand, the relevance of different parties evaluating each other's interactions, and on the other hand, to information asymmetry that benefits the operator. Furthermore, these systems are vulnerable because the evaluation function can be easily abused, especially since creating evaluations often does not require interactive credentials, but only an account on the corresponding evaluation platform.

[0008] In traditional reputation systems, for the reasons mentioned, it may be possible to improve one's own reputation while simultaneously making competitors' reputations appear inferior at low cost. Furthermore, these evaluations are largely subject to arbitrariness and subjectivity, making them unreasonable and difficult to understand in many situations.

[0009] The proposed solution is also based on the understanding that reputation systems are crucial for autonomous interactions (machine-to-machine, M2M) between internet-enabled devices in decentralized systems, because there is no intermediary responsible for rule-compliant behavior and held accountable in case of doubt. Therefore, a reputation system that eliminates intermediaries is used to establish trust between parties who are unaware of each other.

[0010] In this context, the advantage of the method according to the present invention lies in its ability to ensure both the data sovereignty of the evaluated party and the accuracy of the evaluation.

[0011] The measures outlined in the dependent claims may advantageously extend and improve the basic concept described in the independent claims. This allows for the establishment of credentials regarding the authority to evaluate the corresponding service provider. In this way, it prevents arbitrary issuance of evaluations by parties who have never interacted with the evaluated party. Attached Figure Description

[0012] Embodiments of the present invention are shown in the accompanying drawings and will be described in more detail in the following description. Wherein: Figure 1 A flowchart of a method for evaluating service providers according to a first embodiment is shown.

[0013] Figure 2 This demonstrates a guarantee of the completeness of the evaluation.

[0014] Figure 3 The correctness of the evaluation is demonstrated.

[0015] Figure 4 The role allocation among the parties involved in the method is shown.

[0016] Figure 5 The control device according to the second embodiment is shown schematically. Detailed Implementation

[0017] Figure 1The diagram illustrates the basic steps of the method (10) according to the invention, the process of which will now be described with reference to the following diagram. Following a successful interaction, which, for example, involves the exchange of monetary payments, goods, or services between two parties, the parties can receive evaluations of each other (process 11). The evaluation is generated as a single, atomic data record and can be issued in the form of Verifiable Reputation Credentials (VRCs), similar to certificates. These data records may also correspond to other forms. Here, the evaluation is transmitted only to the party being evaluated, who is also the sole owner of the evaluation data.

[0018] These VRCs are collected by the evaluated recipients and can be provided in express form to potential next interactors, who can then verify their correctness.

[0019] To achieve this, when the evaluation is issued by the service recipient (hereinafter referred to as "the recipient"), a hash value of the final VRC is always generated (process 12), which is transmitted as part of the expression by the service provider to be evaluated (hereinafter referred to as "the provider"). Figure 2 As explained, the hash value is now entered by the receiver (22) into its newly created evaluation data record (VRC) (23) (procedure 13- Figure 1 ), and use its DID to sign. Therefore, after a data record (23) is added to the transaction database, it is impossible for the provider (20) to remove any previously negative reviews from the database, since each data record (23) is cipher-linked to its predecessor.

[0020] However, if the included evaluation is not to the Provider's (20) liking and the Provider's (20) does not want to present the evaluation, the Provider's (20) may discard the data record (23) before adding it to the transaction database without any further measures. To prevent this, a trusted third party (24) is set up to maintain the hash value of the latest data record (23), provide the hash value to potential new interacting parties, and thus ensure the verifiability of the data record (23). Alternatively, the data record (23) itself may also be managed by the third party (24); however, only the disclosure of the hash value guarantees better data protection (privacy) because the third party (24) does not gain knowledge of the evaluation contained in the data record (23) in this way.

[0021] In detail, this method (10- Figure 1 The process is as follows: The receiver (22) maps the VRC of the transaction database in the Verifiable Presentation of the last evaluation data record added to the service provider to the hash value (procedure 12-). Figure 1 ), and combine the hash value with its evaluation to form a new data record (23) (procedure 13- Figure 1 ). Then, the receiver (22) generates the hash value of the data record (process 14-). Figure 1 ), and transmit the latter to a third party (24) in the form of a signed message.

[0022] If now (as in) Figure 3 If a new interested party (25) in the provided service (21) wants to view the evaluation of the provider (20), he can use a third party (24) to verify the correctness and completeness of the evaluation by comparing the hash value of the latest data record (23) with the hash value held by the third party (24) (process 15-) Figure 1 Under consistent conditions, the evaluation is correct, and the interested party (25) knows that he can trust the provider (20).

[0023] The evaluation scenario involves interrelationships and roles within it. Figure 4 The following is clarified. In this embodiment, a third party (24) selected by the provider (20) serves the recipient (22) not only by verifying the integrity of the evaluation (30) included in the new data record (23), but also by managing the credentials (26) provided by the recipient (22) that the recipient has fully used the provider's service (21) and is therefore entitled to evaluate it. The provider (20) may confirm this authorization through the third party (24) before adding the new data record (23). The credentials (26) in this regard may have been provided to the recipient (22) by the provider (20) of the service (21), or otherwise prove that the recipient (22) has used the service (21). Therefore, if one of the parties (20, 22) wants to prevent the evaluation, it is ensured that the other party can provide the credentials (26) instead.

[0024] Another aspect of this method (10) is that it enables autonomous and objective evaluation because products and services can be evaluated in a largely standardized and neutral manner within the context of the Internet of Things (IoT). Therefore, the preferred implementation is designed to assess the measurable characteristics of goods or business services. This ensures that there is no arbitrariness in the evaluation.

[0025] To illustrate this point, the autonomous evaluation of digital services, such as the provision of databases, should be considered. In this context, criteria such as availability, processing time, consistency, and partition tolerance may come into play. All of these are measurable standards that allow for objective evaluation. The corresponding concepts apply to most IoT applications, where machines act autonomously and complete transactions independently. Another optional security measure is that the evaluation is not subject to a uniform computational methodology, but rather interpreted by each market participant in its own way. Therefore, attacks or manipulation of the computational process are not permissible.

[0026] For example, the method (10) can be implemented in a control device (50) in a software, hardware, or hybrid form of software and hardware, such as... Figure 5 The diagram explains it clearly.

Claims

1. A method (10) for evaluating service (21) providers (20) using a decentralized transaction database. characterized in that The following characteristics: - The provider (20) accepts (11) evaluation by the recipient (22) of the service (21). - Finally, the data record (23) of the transaction database added to the expression / assembly of the evaluation data record is mapped (12) to the first hash value under the hash value function. - The evaluation and the first hash value are combined (13) into a new data record (23). - The new data record (23) is added to the transaction database and mapped (14) to a second hash value under the hash function. - The second hash value is managed by the selected (28) third party (24) and is provided (15) to the interested party (25) of the service (21) upon inquiry (27), and - The interested party (25) verifies the correctness and completeness of the evaluation with the help of a third party (24) by comparing the hash value of the latest data record (23) with the hash value held by the third party (24).

2. The method (10) according to claim 1. characterized in that The following characteristics: - In addition, the third party (24) manages the recipient's (22) credentials (26) regarding their authority to evaluate the provider (20), and - Before adding the new data record (23), the third party (24) confirms (29) the permissions of the provider (20).

3. The method (10) according to claim 2. characterized in that At least one of the following characteristics: - The provider (20) of the service (21) provides the credential (26) to the recipient (22), or - The credential (26) proves that the service (21) was used by the recipient (22).

4. The method (10) according to claim 2. Its features At least one of the following characteristics: - The new data record (23) is signed by the recipient (22) of the service (21). - The second hash value is signed by the recipient (22) of the service (21), or - The recipient (22) of the service (21) signs the credential (26) regarding the permission.

5. The method (10) according to any one of claims 1 to 4. Its features The following characteristics: - The evaluation defines the decentralized identity of the provider (20) in the transaction database, and - The interested party (25) requests, when necessary, the evaluation of the identity, a verifiable expression (28) using the transaction database.

6. The method (10) according to claim 5. Its features The following characteristics: - The decentralized identity is the self-sovereign identity of the provider (20), and - The expression (28) is performed by the provider (20).

7. The method (10) according to any one of claims 1 to 4. Its features The following characteristics: - The transaction database includes a blockchain, and The addition of the data record includes incorporating the corresponding data block into the blockchain.

8. A computer program product comprising a computer program configured to perform the method (10) according to any one of claims 1 to 7.

9. A machine-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, the computer program being configured to perform the method (10) according to any one of claims 1 to 7.

10. An apparatus (50) configured to perform the method (10) according to any one of claims 1 to 7.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Autonomous exchange via entrusted ledger key management

    US20190325432A1

  • Block chain-based commenting data processing method and device and commenting system

    CN111160998A