A Power Grid Line Vulnerability Identification Method Considering Complex Environmental Characteristics

By improving the calculation of dielectric number and multiple vulnerability indicators, combined with the AHP-entropy weight method, a comprehensive assessment of the vulnerability of power grid lines has been solved, and the problem that the existing technology has failed to fully consider environmental vulnerability indicators has been improved, and the reliability of the assessment has been improved. Sex and accuracy.

CN114358512BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-01ZHUJI POWER SUPPLY CO OF STATE GRID ZHEJIANG ELECTRIC POWER CO LTD +2
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202111508677.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-12-10
Publication Date
2024-11-01
Estimated Expiration
2041-12-10

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The prior art fails to fully consider a variety of environmental vulnerability indicators when evaluating power grid line vulnerability, resulting in unreliable assessment results.

Method used

A method of identifying power grid line fragility that considers complex environmental characteristics is adopted. Through topological structure, the dielectric number is improved, and a variety of line states and environmental fragility indicators are calculated. The AHP-entropy weight method is used to comprehensively evaluate the line's Structural, state and environmental vulnerability.

Benefits of technology

It improves the reliability and objectivity of line vulnerability assessment, ensures that the evaluation results are more comprehensive and accurate, and reduces the uncertainty of the weight of a single empowerment law.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN114358512B_ABST
    Figure CN114358512B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention proposes a method for identifying the vulnerability of power grid lines considering complex environmental characteristics. First, 10 vulnerability sub-indicators in three aspects, namely, line structure vulnerability, state vulnerability and environmental vulnerability, are calculated and obtained. Then, the three indicators are weighted respectively to obtain the line structure vulnerability, state vulnerability and environmental vulnerability index values. Then, the three indicators are weighted again based on the AHP-entropy weight method, and finally the comprehensive vulnerability index value of the line is obtained by comprehensively considering the three aspects of structural characteristics, operating characteristics and environmental characteristics. The present invention is suitable for the evaluation and identification of power grid line vulnerability, and is of great significance for identifying vulnerable lines in power grids and preventing the occurrence of large-scale failures.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the field of power system security protection, and in particular to a power grid line vulnerability identification method taking into account complex environmental characteristics. Background Art

[0002] Electric power is a core component of the energy industry and public safety. The safe and stable operation of the power grid is closely related to economic development and social life. The scale of the power grid is getting larger and larger, and the progress of the power market is also constantly advancing. The power demand side has put forward higher requirements for power quality and power supply reliability. Its safe and stable operation needs to further reduce the risk of large-scale power outages. The root cause of large-scale power outages is the chain reaction caused by accidental and local failures. Its occurrence is often due to some weak or fragile links in the power grid. These links become the source of large-scale failures or play a role in "fueling" the development and expansion of accidents after the system is disturbed.

[0003] The power system is large in scale and its facilities are widely distributed. In addition to the structural characteristics and operating status of the system, various meteorological changes, geological activities and human activities may cause power system failures. Historical data show that natural disasters that have a greater impact on the power grid include: lightning activities, rain, snow and ice, strong storms, pollution flashover and wildfire disasters. The main reason for human activities to cause power system failures is external force damage. Based on this, representative lightning strikes, ice, strong winds, pollution, wildfires and external force damage are selected as line environmental vulnerability indicators, electrical intermediate number is the line structural vulnerability indicator, power level coefficient, impulse transfer ratio and voltage offset rate are used as line state vulnerability indicators, and the three aspects of structural characteristics, operating characteristics and environmental characteristics are comprehensively considered. A comprehensive assessment system for power grid line vulnerability is established, and a power grid line vulnerability identification method is proposed, which is of great significance for identifying vulnerable lines in the power grid and preventing the occurrence of large-scale failures. Summary of the invention

[0004] The purpose of the present invention is to solve the problem that a variety of environmental vulnerability indicators are not comprehensively considered when evaluating the vulnerability of power grid lines, and to propose a power grid line vulnerability identification method that takes into account complex environmental characteristics.

[0005] The technical solution of the present invention is a method for identifying the vulnerability of power grid lines taking into account complex environmental characteristics, comprising the following steps:

[0006] Step 1: Simplify the topological structure of the preset power grid system, and use the equivalent admittance between the power source and load node pairs as weights to improve the existing electrical betweenness, and obtain the improved electrical betweenness as a line structure vulnerability indicator;

[0007] Step 2: Calculate the power level coefficient, impulse transfer ratio and voltage deviation rate of the three lines as the state vulnerability indicators of each line;

[0008] Step 3. Calculate the direct lightning tripping rate of each line as the lightning vulnerability index in the line environmental characteristics; calculate the ice growth intensity value of each line based on the Makkonen icing prediction model and use it as the icing vulnerability index in the line environmental characteristics; calculate the wind load of each line and use it as the strong wind vulnerability index in the line environmental characteristics; obtain the equivalent salt density of each line as the line pollution vulnerability index in the line environmental characteristics; calculate the wildfire vulnerability index of each line based on the transmission line wildfire tripping calculation model; obtain the number of times each line is damaged by external force and perform normalization processing, and use it as the external force damage vulnerability index in the line environmental characteristics.

[0009] Step 4: For the line state vulnerability index and line environment vulnerability index with multiple sub-indicators, firstly use the AHP-entropy weight method to assign weights to each sub-indicator to obtain the line state vulnerability index value and the line environment vulnerability index value.

[0010] Step 5: Based on the AHP-entropy weight method, weights are assigned to the line structure vulnerability index, state vulnerability index, and environmental vulnerability index, and a comprehensive vulnerability index that considers the structural characteristics, state characteristics, and environmental characteristics of the network is established and calculated. Finally, the vulnerability of the lines in the network is ranked according to the index value.

[0011] As a preferred method, the equivalent admittance between the power supply and load node pairs is added as a weight to improve the electrical betweenness, and the improved electrical betweenness is as follows:

[0012]

[0013] Where: B e (m,n) is the electrical intermediate value of line (m,n), m and n are the two endpoints of the line, G and D are the power source and load node sets, respectively; P g and P d are the active powers of the power source node g and the load node d respectively; Y gd is the equivalent admittance between node g and node d, reflecting the transmission distance between node g and node d; N g and N d are the number of power supply and load nodes respectively; I gd (m,n) represents the current value caused on the line (m,n) after a unit current is applied between the power supply-load node pair (gd).

[0014] As a preference, for line state vulnerability, the joint influence of three sub-indicators, namely, power level coefficient, impulse transfer ratio and voltage deviation rate, is selected.

[0015] As a preferred option, six environmental indicators, including lightning strikes, icing, strong winds, pollution, wildfires and external force damage, which have a greater impact on line vulnerability, are considered to construct a comprehensive environmental vulnerability index.

[0016] As a preferred method, the AHP-entropy method is used to determine the weight of each indicator, so that the weight not only reflects the subjective opinions of experts, but also contains the effective information of objective data. The two complement each other, so that the obtained weight reflects both the subjective and objective degrees. Finally, the comprehensive vulnerability index is as follows:

[0017] S i =W1Q i,1 +W2Q i,2 +W3Q i,3

[0018] Where: S i Q is a comprehensive evaluation index of line vulnerability; i,1 ~Q i,3 They are the assessment indicators of line structure vulnerability, state vulnerability and environmental vulnerability respectively; W1~W3 are the weight coefficients of the corresponding indicators.

[0019] Compared with the existing power grid line vulnerability assessment method, the beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows:

[0020] (1) Taking into account the various environmental indicators that have a significant impact on line vulnerability, the constructed assessment system is more comprehensive, making the line vulnerability assessment results more reliable.

[0021] (2) The equivalent admittance between power source and load node pairs is used as the weight to improve the existing electrical betweenness. This can better reflect the characteristics of the actual power grid that the power generated by the power source supplies more of the nearby load nodes and has less impact on the more distant load nodes. This makes the characterization of the vulnerability of the network structure more accurate and objective.

[0022] (3) The weights of each vulnerability indicator are calculated by combining the AHP method and the entropy weight method, so that the weights not only reflect the subjective opinions of experts, but also contain the effective information of objective data. The two complement each other, so that the obtained weights reflect both the subjective and objective degrees, eliminating the uncertainty of the weight coefficient of each single weighting method.

[0023] The present invention is suitable for evaluating and identifying the vulnerability of power grid lines. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0024] Figure 1 The overall framework and concise calculation steps of the power line vulnerability identification method considering complex environmental characteristics are provided;

[0025] Figure 2 The weighting process of vulnerability indicators using the entropy weight method; DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0026] The specific implementation methods of the present invention are as follows:

[0027] The present invention provides a method for identifying the vulnerability of power grid lines taking into account complex environmental characteristics, such as Figure 1 As shown, the following steps are included:

[0028] Step 1: Simplify the topological structure of the preset power grid system, calculate the improved electrical betweenness of each line, and obtain the vulnerability index of the preset power grid line structure.

[0029] According to the principle of network simplification: 1) nodes are divided into three categories: power nodes, contact nodes, and load nodes; 2) the edges in the network are lines, and the weight of the edge is the impedance value of the line; 3) there is at most one edge connecting any two nodes, and multiple lines between two nodes are merged into one, that is, the line will not have self-loops; 4) the main wiring structure of the substation is not considered, and the power supply and load connected to the low-voltage side bus are merged into the power on the corresponding bus; 5) transmission lines on the same pole or multiple parallel transmission lines are not merged, and each transmission line is weighted according to its impedance; 6) all ground branches are ignored. The topological structure of the preset power grid system is simplified.

[0030] Improve the traditional electrical betweenness. Since the electric energy generated by the power source in the actual power grid is more supplied to the nearby load nodes, the impact on the more distant load nodes is small. The present invention increases the equivalent admittance between the power source-load node pair as a weight to improve the electrical betweenness. The improved electrical betweenness is as follows:

[0031]

[0032] Where: B e (m,n) is the electrical intermediate value of line (m,n), m and n are the two endpoints of the line, G and D are the power source and load node sets, respectively; P g and P d are the active powers of the power source node g and the load node d respectively; Y gd is the equivalent admittance between node g and node d, reflecting the transmission distance between node g and node d; N g and N d are the number of power supply and load nodes respectively; I gd (m,n) represents the current value caused on the line (m,n) after a unit current is applied between the power supply-load node pair (gd).

[0033] After calculating all power-load node pairs, the absolute values ​​of the results are summed up and recorded as the electrical betweenness of the line (m, n) and used as the structural vulnerability indicator of the line.

[0034] Step 2: Calculate the power level coefficient, impulse transfer ratio and voltage deviation rate of each line as three line state vulnerability sub-indicators.

[0035] Calculate the power level coefficient of each line. The larger the line power level coefficient, the closer the line is to the limit transmission power. The smaller the safety threshold for power fluctuations, the higher the vulnerability of the line. The calculation formula is as follows:

[0036]

[0037] Where: L i is the power level coefficient of line i; P i is the active power currently transmitted by line i; P imax is the maximum transmission power of line i.

[0038] Calculate the impulse transfer ratio of each line, and use this value to describe the impact of a line break on the network power change. The calculation formula is as follows:

[0039]

[0040] Where: G i is the impulse transfer ratio of line i; ΔP l is the power change of line l due to the disconnection of line i; P l is the original power of line l before line i is disconnected; P i is the original power of line i before disconnection; N L The total number of lines.

[0041] Calculate the voltage deviation rate of each line. The smaller the voltage deviation rate, the farther the line is from the voltage limit deviation level, and the greater the margin of the line voltage level from the occurrence of reactive power imbalance in the network. At this time, the line is safer. The calculation formula is as follows:

[0042]

[0043] Where: ΔU% is the voltage deviation rate of the line; U i , U j are the voltages at the nodes at both ends of a line; U cr is the reference rated voltage; ΔU lim is the maximum allowable voltage offset.

[0044] Step three: Calculate the vulnerability parameters of each line to lightning strikes, icing, strong winds, pollution, wildfires, and external force damage as sub-indicators of line environmental vulnerability.

[0045] Calculate the lightning trip rate of the line, the calculation formula is as follows:

[0046] n=n1+n2

[0047] =N·g·P1·η+N·P a ·P2·η

[0048] =N·η(g·P1+P a ·P2)

[0049] Where: n is the line tripping rate due to direct lightning; n1 is the tripping rate due to lightning striking the tower; n2 is the tripping rate due to lightning striking the conductor; N is the annual number of lightning strikes per 100 km line in an area with 40 thunderstorm days; g is the pole strike rate; P1 is the probability that the lightning current exceeds the line lightning withstand level I1 when the lightning strikes the tower, and I1 varies with the instantaneous value of the system working voltage at the moment of lightning strike; P a is the line shielding rate; P2 is the probability that the lightning current exceeds the line lightning withstand level when the lightning strikes the line; η is the probability that the impulse flashover is transformed into a stable power frequency arc.

[0050] The icing growth intensity of each line is calculated according to the Makkonen icing prediction model. The calculation formula is as follows:

[0051] I=π / 2Envw

[0052] Where: E is the capture rate of supercooled water by the conductor; n is the freezing factor of supercooled water; v is the falling speed of raindrops; w is the liquid water content in the ice.

[0053] Calculate the wind load of each line using the following formula:

[0054]

[0055] Where: α is the wind pressure unevenness coefficient related to wind speed; v(t) is the wind speed at a height of 10m; μ z is the wind pressure height variation coefficient, which is related to the surface roughness and the altitude of the line; μ sc is the conductor shape factor; β c is the wind load adjustment factor, which is 1.25 for 500kV and 750kV and 1 for lines of other voltage levels; d is the outer diameter of the conductor, and in the case of split conductors, this parameter is the sum of the outer diameters of all sub-conductors; l h is the horizontal spacing of the towers; B is the line icing increase coefficient, which is related to the thickness of the line icing; θ is the angle between the conductor and the wind direction.

[0056] The equivalent salt density (ESDD) of each line is obtained as the line pollution vulnerability indicator in the line environmental characteristics.

[0057] Based on vegetation and historical wildfire data, the line wildfire tripping situation is calculated and used as the line wildfire vulnerability indicator. The calculation formula is as follows:

[0058] PR=D R ·D B ·D F ·P V

[0059] Where: PR is the line fire vulnerability index; D R D is the precipitation coefficient for wildfire tripping; B Vegetation coefficient of the area where the line is located; D F is the wildfire spread coefficient; P V is the line gap breakdown coefficient in the case of wildfire. The precipitation coefficient of the area where the line is located is calculated by consulting the precipitation in the area near the line within 3 hours.

[0060] The historical data of the number of times each line was damaged by external forces within a year was obtained, and the number of times of external force damage on all lines was normalized according to the proportion of fault types, which was used as the external force damage vulnerability indicator in the environmental characteristics of the line.

[0061] Step 4: For the line state vulnerability index and the line environment vulnerability index, the AHP-entropy weight method is used to assign weights to each sub-indicator to obtain the line state vulnerability index value and the line environment vulnerability index value.

[0062] For line status vulnerability, the AHP method is first used to assign weights to each sub-indicator. The steps are as follows:

[0063] (1) Construct the criterion level judgment matrix A, whose elements are the importance ratios between the respective indicators;

[0064] (2) Solve the maximum eigenvalue of the judgment matrix and its corresponding eigenvector;

[0065] (3) Perform the following consistency check:

[0066]

[0067] Where: max is the maximum eigenvalue of the judgment matrix; n is the order of the judgment matrix, which is equal to the number of sub-indicators; CI is the intermediate variable; RI is the given average random consistency index, obtained by looking up the table; CR is the random consistency ratio.

[0068] (4) When CR < 0.1, it is considered that the hierarchical single sorting result has a satisfactory consistency. In this case, the eigenvector of the judgment matrix can be used to replace the weight vector α j , otherwise modify the elements in the judgment matrix A and go to step (2).

[0069] After calculating the values ​​of the three turntable vulnerability sub-indicators of each line, for m lines to be evaluated and 3 evaluation indicators, an m×3-order matrix R0 is formed, and the matrix is ​​standardized to obtain the matrix R. The formula for the standardized processing is as follows:

[0070]

[0071] For the correlation matrix R obtained through standardization, the entropy method is used to determine the target weight of each vulnerability indicator. The main steps are as follows: Figure 2 As shown, the entropy of any indicator j is calculated as follows:

[0072]

[0073] Where: E j is the entropy of index j, r ij ' is the element in the matrix R.

[0074] The entropy weight μ of the indicator is calculated based on the entropy value j :

[0075]

[0076] Using the calculated entropy weight μ j The weight α obtained by modifying AHP j , so the corrected weight coefficient θ is obtained j :

[0077]

[0078] The weight α obtained by AHP j And the corrected weight θ j Combine them to get the weight γ of the state vulnerability sub-indicator of AHP-entropy weight method j , that is:

[0079] γ j =ρα j +(1-ρ)θ j

[0080] Where: γ j is the final weight; ρ is the preference coefficient, usually 0.5.

[0081] At this point, the final state vulnerability results considering the power level coefficient, impulse transfer ratio and voltage deviation rate of the network are as follows:

[0082] Q i,2 =γ1L i +γ2G i +γ3ΔU%

[0083] Where: Qi,2 L is the line status vulnerability assessment index; i G is the power level coefficient vulnerability index of the line; i is the vulnerability index of the impulse transfer ratio of the line; ΔU% is the vulnerability index of the voltage deviation rate of the line; γ1~γ3 are the weight coefficients of the corresponding indicators.

[0084] For line environmental vulnerability, the same weighting method can be used to obtain the line environmental vulnerability assessment index Q i,3 as follows:

[0085] Q i,3 =β1N i +β2Φ i +β3F i +β4ESDD i +β5PR i +β6FD i

[0086] Where: β1~β6 are the weight coefficients of the corresponding indicators.

[0087] Since there is only one sub-indicator for the line structure vulnerability index, we can set Q1 = B e .

[0088] Step 5: Based on the AHP-entropy weight method, the line structure vulnerability index, state vulnerability index, and environmental vulnerability index Q i,1 ~Q3 is weighted, and a comprehensive vulnerability index S is established and calculated that takes into account the structural characteristics, state characteristics, and environmental characteristics of the network. i ,Finally the vulnerability of the lines in the network is ranked according to the index values.

[0089] Q i,1 ~Q i,3 The AHP-entropy weight method is also used for secondary weighting, and the comprehensive vulnerability index is as follows:

[0090] S i =W1Q i,1 +W2Q i,2 +W3Q i,3

[0091] Where: S i It is a comprehensive evaluation index of line vulnerability; W1~W3 are weight coefficients of corresponding indicators.

[0092] The above-described embodiment is only a preferred solution of the present invention and does not limit the present invention in any form. There are other variations and modifications without exceeding the technical solution described in the claims.

Claims

1. A power grid line vulnerability identification method considering complex environmental characteristics, It is characterized in that The following steps are involved: Step 1: Simplify the topological structure of the preset power grid system, and use the equivalent admittance between the power source and load node pairs as weights to improve the existing electrical betweenness, and obtain the improved electrical betweenness as a line structure vulnerability indicator; Step 2: Calculate the power level coefficient, impulse transfer ratio and voltage deviation rate of the three lines as the state vulnerability indicators of each line; Step 3: Calculate the direct lightning tripping rate of each line as the lightning vulnerability index in the line environmental characteristics; calculate the ice growth intensity value of each line based on the Makkonen icing prediction model and use it as the icing vulnerability index in the line environmental characteristics; calculate the wind load of each line and use it as the strong wind vulnerability index in the line environmental characteristics; obtain the equivalent salt density of each line as the line pollution vulnerability index in the line environmental characteristics; calculate the wildfire vulnerability index of each line based on the transmission line wildfire tripping calculation model; obtain the number of times each line is damaged by external forces and perform normalization processing, and use it as the external force damage vulnerability index in the line environmental characteristics; Step 4: For the line state vulnerability index and line environment vulnerability index with multiple sub-indicators, firstly use the AHP-entropy weight method to assign weights to each sub-indicator to obtain the line state vulnerability index value and the line environment vulnerability index value. Step 5: Based on the AHP-entropy weight method, weights are assigned to the line structure vulnerability index, state vulnerability index, and environmental vulnerability index, and a comprehensive vulnerability index that considers the structural characteristics, state characteristics, and environmental characteristics of the network is established and calculated. Finally, the vulnerability of the lines in the network is ranked according to the index value; The electrical betweenness is improved by adding the equivalent admittance between the power source and load node pairs as a weight, and the improved electrical betweenness is as follows: Where: B e (m,n) is the electrical intermediate value of line (m,n), m and n are the two endpoints of the line, G and D are the power source and load node sets, respectively; P g and P d are the active powers of the power source node g and the load node d respectively; Y gd is the equivalent admittance between node g and node d, reflecting the transmission distance between node g and node d; N g and N d are the number of power supply and load nodes respectively; I gd (m,n) represents the current value caused on the line (m,n) after a unit current is applied between the power supply-load node pair (gd).

2. A method for identifying power line vulnerability considering complex environmental characteristics according to claim 1, It is characterized in that For line state vulnerability, the joint influence of three sub-indicators, namely power level coefficient, impulse transfer ratio and voltage deviation rate, is selected.

3. According to the method for identifying power grid line vulnerability taking into account complex environmental characteristics as described in claim 1, It is characterized in that Taking into account six environmental indicators that have a greater impact on line vulnerability, including lightning strikes, icing, strong winds, pollution, wildfires and external force damage, a comprehensive environmental vulnerability index is constructed.

4. A method for identifying power line vulnerability considering complex environmental characteristics according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The AHP-entropy method is used to determine the weight of each indicator, so that the weight not only reflects the subjective opinions of experts, but also contains the effective information of objective data. The two complement each other, so that the obtained weight reflects both the subjective and objective degrees. Finally, the comprehensive vulnerability index is as follows: S i =W 1 Q i,1 +W 2 Q i,2 +W 3 Q i,3 Where: S i Q is a comprehensive evaluation index of line vulnerability; i,1 ~Q i,3 are the assessment indicators of line structure vulnerability, state vulnerability, and environmental vulnerability respectively; W 1 ~W 3 is the weight coefficient of the corresponding indicator.