Automated health check risk assessment of computing assets
By introducing components of baseline, weakness, environment, criticality and maturity factors into the calculation of the health check risk assessment of assets, automating the calculation of the health check risk assessment of assets, solving the inaccuracy of manual assessment and neglecting important aspects in the prior art. The problem has achieved a more accurate and standardized risk assessment.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202180063734.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2020-10-23
- Filing Date
- 2021-08-31
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-08-31
AI Technical Summary
In the prior art, the risk assessment of health checks for computed assets mainly relies on manual processes, is error-prone and non-standardized, ignores important aspects of computing assets and incompatible controls, and cannot accurately evaluate the risks and levels of importance of different controls.
Provides a system that includes baseline components, weakness components, environmental components, critical components and maturity components, generates automated health check risk scores through computer-executable components, considering the state, environmental factors, critical factors and maturity of the asset Factors, adjust baseline health check risk scores to achieve more accurate risk assessment.
The automated health check risk assessment of computing assets is realized, which improves the accuracy and standardization of assessments, enables more precise identification and priority of incompatible controls, reduces human errors, and enhances data security.
Smart Images

Figure CN116235478B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Background Art
[0001] The present disclosure relates to computing assets, and more particularly to automated health check risk assessment of computing assets.
[0002] A computing asset may be any suitable combination of computer hardware and / or computer software. A computing asset may be subject to one or more controls. In various aspects, a control may be a standard, rule, regulation, and / or benchmark designed to enhance and / or protect computing security and / or network security. For example, a control may include a Center for Internet Security (CIS) benchmark, a security technical implementation guide (STIG), an industry standard, and / or any other suitable technical regulation. In different examples, a control may regulate and / or belong to any suitable technical attribute / characteristic of a computing asset. If a computing asset complies with specified controls, then the computing asset may be considered to minimize its vulnerability to security vulnerabilities and / or exploits. However, if a computing asset does not comply with specified controls, then the computing asset may be considered vulnerable and / or compromised in terms of data security.
[0003] Health checks may be performed periodically on computing assets to determine whether the computing assets meet specified controls. In various cases, health checks may be security processes that check information technology system and / or application configurations in order to harden the systems and / or configurations to prevent and / or mitigate attacks. Often, a computing system may be composed of many different computing assets, and the number of incompatible controls may be so large as to overwhelm an operator of the computing system. In such cases, different incompatible controls for different computing assets may pose different risks, and an operator of the computing system may be unsure how to shunt the incompatible controls.
[0004] Conventionally, health check risk assessments are performed to assign severity levels to non-compliant controls. For example, health check risk scores can be assigned to different controls via the Common Configuration Scoring System (CCSS), and the risks for various computing assets can be derived from these scores based on non-compliant controls. However, such conventional health check risk assessment techniques are typically manual processes performed by operators once or twice a year. Even for conventional health check risk assessment techniques that are automated, they are based on subjective assessments of operators and are therefore prone to errors and are non-standardized. In addition, such conventional health check risk assessment techniques ignore different important aspects of computing assets and non-compliant controls, as explained herein.
[0005] Systems and / or techniques that could improve upon and / or solve one or more of these technical problems may be desirable. Summary of the invention
[0006] The following presents an overview to provide a basic understanding of one or more embodiments of the invention. This overview is not intended to identify key or important elements, or to delineate any scope of a particular embodiment or any scope of the claims. Its sole purpose is to present concepts in a simplified form as a prelude to a more detailed description presented later. In one or more embodiments described herein, devices, systems, computer-implemented methods, apparatus, and / or computer program products are described that can facilitate automated health check risk assessment of computing assets.
[0007] According to one or more embodiments, a system is provided. The system may include a memory that may store a computer executable component. The system may further include a processor that may be operably coupled to the memory and may execute the computer executable component stored in the memory. In various embodiments, the computer executable component may include a baseline component that may generate a baseline health check risk score corresponding to the non-compliance of the computing asset with the prescribed control. In various aspects, the computer executable component may also include an adjustment component that may adjust the baseline health check risk score based on a weakness factor of the prescribed control. In some cases, the weakness factor may be based on the magnitude of the deviation of the state of the computing asset from the prescribed control. In various embodiments, the adjustment component may also adjust the baseline health check risk score based on an environmental factor of the computing asset. In various cases, the environmental factor may be based on a security mechanism or security protocol associated with the computing asset. In various embodiments, the adjustment component may also adjust the baseline health check risk score based on a criticality factor. In some instances, the critical factor may be based on the importance level of the computing asset. In various embodiments, the adjustment component may further adjust the baseline health check risk score based on a maturity factor. In some aspects, the maturity factor may be based on the difference between the prescribed controls and the recommended controls.
[0008] According to one or more embodiments, the above system may be implemented as a computer-implemented method and / or a computer program product. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0009] Figure 1 A block diagram illustrating an example non-limiting system that facilitates automated health check risk assessment of computing assets in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein.
[0010] Figure 2 A block diagram is shown of an example non-limiting system including a baseline health check risk score that facilitates automated health check risk assessment of computing assets in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein.
[0011] Figure 3A block diagram is shown of an example, non-limiting system including a vulnerability factor that facilitates automated health check risk assessment of computing assets in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein.
[0012] Figure 4 An exemplary, non-limiting table associated with vulnerability factors according to one or more embodiments described herein is shown.
[0013] Figure 5 A block diagram is shown of an example non-limiting system including environmental factors that facilitate automated health check risk assessment of computing assets in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein.
[0014] Figure 6 An example non-limiting table associated with environmental factors according to one or more embodiments described herein is shown.
[0015] Figure 7 A block diagram illustrating an example non-limiting system including criticality factors that facilitate automated health check risk assessment of computing assets in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein.
[0016] Figure 8 A block diagram is shown of an example non-limiting system including a maturity factor that facilitates automated health check risk assessment of computing assets in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein.
[0017] Fig. 9 A block diagram illustrating an example non-limiting system including a tuning component that facilitates automated health check risk assessment of computing assets in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein.
[0018] Fig.10 A block diagram of an example, non-limiting system including an aggregation component that facilitates automated health check risk assessment of computing assets is shown in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein.
[0019] Fig.11 A block diagram illustrating an example, non-limiting computing asset hierarchy according to one or more embodiments described herein.
[0020] Fig.12 A flow chart is shown of an example, non-limiting computer-implemented method for facilitating automated health check risk assessment of computing assets in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein.
[0021] Fig.13 Block diagram illustrating an example non-limiting operating environment in which one or more embodiments described herein may be facilitated.
[0022] Fig.14An example non-limiting cloud computing environment is shown in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein.
[0023] Fig.15 Example non-limiting abstract model layers are shown in accordance with one or more implementations described herein. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0024] The following detailed description is illustrative only and is not intended to limit the embodiments and / or the application or uses of the embodiments. Furthermore, there is no intention to be bound by any explicit or implicit information presented in the previous background or overview section or the detailed description section.
[0025] One or more embodiments are now described with reference to the accompanying drawings, wherein the same reference numerals are used throughout to refer to the same elements. In the following description, for the purpose of explanation, many specific details are set forth in order to provide a more thorough understanding of one or more embodiments. However, it is apparent that in various cases, one or more embodiments may be practiced without these specific details.
[0026] A computing asset may be any suitable combination of computer hardware and / or computer software (e.g., a server, a data center, a software application, a browser, a network, a laptop, a mobile computing device, and / or any other suitable information technology system). As described above, a computing asset may be subject to and / or managed by one or more controls, which may take the form of standards, regulations, rules, and / or benchmarks designed, configured, and / or intended to enhance and / or protect computing security and / or network security. For example, a control may include a Center for Internet Security (CIS) benchmark, a security technical implementation guide (STIG), an industry standard, and / or any other suitable technical regulation intended to improve computing security. As an example, a computing asset may electronically store / maintain password protection data. In this case, a first control may specify that a password should have a minimum character length (e.g., at least 10 characters long), a second control may specify that a password should include a specific character type (e.g., numbers, letters, punctuation, other symbols), and / or a third control may specify that a password should be younger than a maximum age (e.g., less than 90 days old). In various examples, controls can regulate and / or relate to any suitable technical attributes / characteristics of a computing asset (e.g., passwords, privileges / permissions, data management policies, data storage policies, authentication policies, audit policies, infrastructure). If a computing asset complies with specified controls, then the computing asset can be considered to have minimized its vulnerability to security breaches and / or exploits. However, if a computing asset does not comply with specified controls, then the computing asset can be considered vulnerable and / or compromised with respect to data security.
[0027] Health checks may be performed periodically (e.g., once every 24 hours) on computing assets to determine whether the computing assets meet specified controls. Often, a computing system may be composed of many different computing assets, and the number of non-compliant controls may be so large as to overwhelm an operator of the computing system (e.g., many different computing assets may comply with and / or violate many different controls). In such cases, different non-compliant controls for different computing assets may pose different risks, and an operator of the computing system may be uncertain how to triage the non-compliant controls (e.g., may be uncertain which non-compliant controls are the most pressing and / or the least pressing in order to determine which non-compliant controls should be corrected first).
[0028] Conventionally, health check risk assessments are performed to assign severity levels to non-compliant controls so that classification can be performed. For example, health check risk scores can be assigned to non-compliant controls via the Common Configuration Scoring System (CCSS). However, such conventional health check risk assessment techniques are typically manual processes performed by operators once or twice a year. Even when conventional health check risk assessment techniques are automated, they are based on subjective assessments of operators and are therefore prone to error and non-standardized (e.g., different operators may have different expertise, different levels of experience, and / or different opinions about which non-compliant controls of which computing assets pose more or less serious security threats).
[0029] Furthermore, such conventional health check risk assessment techniques do not consider different important aspects of computing assets and non-compliant controls. Specifically, such conventional health check risk assessment techniques only consider controls in a binary manner. That is, they only determine whether a control is met or violated; they do not consider the magnitude of the non-compliance. This may be suboptimal because larger magnitudes of non-compliance may pose a greater security risk (e.g., a password that is 6 months too large is a much greater security risk than a password that is one day too large; a password that is many characters too short is a much greater security risk than a password that is one character too short; privileges shared with dozens of additional entities are much greater security risks than privileges shared with only one additional entity; performing an audit that is 50% too infrequent has a greater security risk than performing an audit that is 5% too infrequent). Furthermore, such conventional health check risk assessment techniques ignore the importance level of computing assets. This may be suboptimal because a more important computing asset that violates a regulatory control by a given magnitude may pose a greater security risk than a less important computing asset that violates the same control by the same magnitude (e.g., consider an online shopping account and a database storing sensitive / private data; although both the online shopping account and the database may each be protected by a corresponding password that is one month too large, the database may be considered a more important and / or critical computing asset than the online shopping account, and thus a non-compliant database may pose a much greater security risk than a non-compliant online shopping account). Further, such conventional health check risk assessment techniques take regulatory controls at face value and never compare such regulatory controls to recommended controls and / or to best practices in the industry. This may be suboptimal because less mature (e.g., less cybersecurity-savvy) organizations may establish controls that differ significantly from industry standards (e.g., a company may stipulate that data center passwords must be no more than 180 days old, while best practices in the industry may recommend that data center passwords must be no more than 90 days old; therefore, a 120-day-old data center password may be considered compliant with regulatory controls, but may still pose a significant security risk because the regulatory controls are significantly less stringent than the recommended controls). Furthermore, such conventional health check risk assessment techniques are typically implemented manually (e.g., they rely on subjective scoring assessments by operators and do not implement any form of artificial intelligence to enhance standardization). Therefore, conventional health check risk assessment techniques suffer from various technical problems.
[0030] Various embodiments of the present invention can solve one or more of these technical problems. Specifically, various embodiments of the present invention can provide systems and / or technologies that can facilitate automatic health check risk assessment of computing assets. In other words, various embodiments of the present invention can be considered as computerized diagnostic tools (e.g., computer-implemented software) that can monitor the compliance and / or non-compliance of computing assets with one or more prescribed controls. In various aspects, such a computerized diagnostic tool can assign a baseline health check risk score (e.g., a CCSS score) to each non-compatible control of the computing asset, and can adjust such a baseline health check risk score based on a corresponding weakness factor (e.g., a CCSS score). It can consider the magnitude of non-compliance), environmental factors (e.g., it can consider the built-in security mechanisms of the computing asset), criticality factors (e.g., it can consider the importance level of the computing asset), and / or maturity factors (e.g., it can explain the deviation between the prescribed control and the best practices and / or industry standards).
[0031] In various embodiments, such a computerized diagnostic tool may include a baseline component, a vulnerability component, an environment component, a criticality component, and / or a maturity component.
[0032] In various aspects, the computerized diagnostic tool may scan and / or query the computing asset to obtain status information about the computing asset. That is, any suitable electronic scanning, querying, and / or information retrieval technology may be implemented to determine the status of the computing asset. In various cases, the status of the computing asset may be any suitable technical characteristic and / or attribute of the computing asset that is governed by and / or subject to a prescribed control. For example, the status of the computing asset may be the age of a password implemented by the computing asset, and the prescribed control may specify a maximum password age; the status of the computing asset may be the length of a password implemented by the computing asset, and the prescribed control may specify a minimum password length; the status of the computing asset may be the number of allowable login attempts implemented by the computing asset, and the prescribed control may specify a maximum number of allowable login attempts; the status of the computing asset may be the audit frequency implemented by the computing asset, and the prescribed control may specify a minimum audit frequency; and / or the status of the computing asset may be the capacity and / or file count of a database maintained by the computing asset, and the prescribed control may specify a maximum capacity and / or file count. In various aspects, the computerized diagnostic tool may learn the prescribed control by any suitable technique (e.g., may query any suitable electronically accessible data source to learn the prescribed control, may be preprogrammed to already have and / or know the prescribed control, may receive the prescribed control as input from an operator and / or from any suitable electronic device).
[0033] In various cases, the baseline component of the computerized diagnostic tool can generate a baseline health check risk score based on the state of the computing asset and the specified controls. In various cases, any suitable risk scoring and / or risk quantification technique can be implemented to generate the baseline health check risk score, such as the CCSS technique. In various aspects, the remaining components of the computerized diagnostic tool can adjust the baseline health check risk score as described herein to make the baseline health check risk score more accurate (e.g., to address the above-mentioned shortcomings of the CCSS technique).
[0034] In various aspects, the weakness component can generate a scalar quantity referred to as a weakness factor for a computing asset and / or for a prescribed control. In various cases, the value of the weakness factor can be a function of the difference between the state of the computing asset and the prescribed control (e.g., calculated via subtraction). As described above, conventional health check risk assessment techniques operate in a binary manner such that if the prescribed control is complied with, a risk score is assigned, and if the prescribed control is not complied with, a different risk score is assigned. In contrast, in various aspects, the weakness factor can be based on the magnitude and / or severity of the non-compliance (e.g., can be based on the extent and / or severity to which the state of the computing asset fails to meet the prescribed control). If the state of the computing asset is only slightly non-compliant with the prescribed control (e.g., if the password is only one character too short, if the password is only one day too old, if the data center is only one file over capacity, and / or if privileges have been granted to only one entity too many), then the value of the weakness factor can be correspondingly small (e.g., indicating a low risk). On the other hand, if the state of the computing asset is more severely incompatible with the prescribed controls (e.g., if the password is several characters too short, if the password is several weeks too long, if the data center is several files over capacity, and / or if privileges have been granted to many entities), the value of the vulnerability factor may be correspondingly larger (e.g., indicating a high risk). In various cases, the baseline health check risk score can be mathematically adjusted (e.g., increased and / or decreased) based on the vulnerability factor. In this way, the computerized diagnostic tool can take into account the degree of non-compliance of the computing asset with the prescribed controls. As used herein, the term "vulnerability factor" can mean a metric (e.g., a number) whose value is based on how incompatible the computing asset is with the prescribed controls. In other words, the difference between the state of the computing asset and the prescribed controls can be calculated via subtraction, and the value of the vulnerability factor can be based on such a difference. In various cases, the value of the vulnerability factor can be any suitable mathematical function of such a difference (e.g., the vulnerability factor can be calculated by applying any suitable mathematical operation to the difference between the state of the computing asset and the prescribed controls). The vulnerability factor can then be used to mathematically adjust (e.g., increase and / or decrease) the baseline health check risk score as described herein (e.g., as described with respect to Fig. 9 explained).
[0035] In different instances, the weakness component may generate and / or calculate a weakness factor based on the value of the state of the calculated asset and based on the value of the specified control. In some cases, the weakness component may include a trained machine learning model that can be utilized to generate / calculate the weakness factor. In various aspects, the trained machine learning model can be any suitable computer-implemented artificial intelligence algorithm (e.g., neural network, linear regression, logistic regression, Native Bayes, support vector machine, random forest), which can be trained to classify and / or label input data (e.g., can be trained via supervised learning, unsupervised learning and / or reinforcement learning). In different cases, the weakness component can be configured to electronically receive and / or retrieve one or more control documents (e.g., natural language documents) describing different technical details of the specified control from any appropriate electronically accessible data structure. Such control documents may, for example, include GitHub documents, development / design documents and / or any other similar documents that describe and / or characterize the technical characteristics / characteristics of the specified control. In various cases, any other suitable input data characterizing the specified control can be implemented. In various cases, the vulnerability component can generate a digital representation (e.g., vector, tensor) of one or more control documents (e.g., by applying any suitable word embedding techniques and / or language modeling techniques). In various cases, the trained machine learning model can then receive the digital representation of one or more control documents as input and can generate a classification and / or label associated with a specified control as output.
[0036] As explained in the above paragraphs, the control document can be a natural language document (e.g., written in human-readable text). However, the machine learning model of the weakness component may not typically receive human-readable text / prose as input. Instead, any suitable word embedding technology can be implemented that produces a digital representation of the control document. The "digital representation" of the control document can be a vector, a tensor, and / or any other suitable digital set representing the content of the control document and / or related to the content of the control document (e.g., the word embedding algorithm is configured to assign numerical values to human-readable words and / or sentences based on the context of human-readable words and / or sentences). The machine learning model of the weakness component can then receive the digital representation and can generate a classification / label as described herein. The word embedding technology can be a natural language processing algorithm that is configured to map human-readable words or phrases in a given vocabulary to vectors and / or tensors of real numbers of any suitable dimension. More specifically, word embedding utilizes the principle that words that usually appear near each other in a document have similar meanings. Thus, word embedding can assign an n-dimensional vector to a particular word (and / or phrase) in a control document for any suitable integer n, where the value of the n-dimensional vector is based on other words that appear near the particular word. Similar words can therefore have similar vectors, and dissimilar words can therefore have different vectors. As will be appreciated by one of ordinary skill in the art, word embedding techniques can be facilitated via trained neural networks and / or via dimensionality reduction of a word co-occurrence matrix corresponding to an input control document. Note that these are merely examples of word embedding techniques, and in different embodiments, any suitable word embedding technique may be implemented. Word embedding techniques and the digital representations they generate are known in the art, and additional details regarding word embedding techniques and the digital representations they generate need not be elaborated herein.
[0037] In various aspects, the classifications and / or labels generated by the machine learning model of the vulnerability component can identify the vulnerability category to which the specified control belongs based on one or more control documents describing the specified control. For example, the specified control can be classified and / or labeled as being related to passive weaknesses, direct active weaknesses, and / or indirect active weaknesses. In different situations, for example, if non-compliance with the specified control can enable an attacker to prevent the computing asset from performing authorized actions (e.g., preventing the computing asset from performing security audits, preventing the computing asset from managing the fully automatic Turing test to distinguish between computers and humans (CAPTCHA test), preventing the computing asset from initiating automatic security protocols, and preventing the computing asset from executing a system service or daemon), then the specified control may involve passive weaknesses (e.g., may be passive controls). Passive weaknesses may not be actively exploited by an attacker, but they can prevent the attacker's unauthorized actions from being detected. In various examples, a prescribed control may involve an active vulnerability (e.g., may be an active control) if, for example, noncompliance with the prescribed control may enable an attacker to perform unauthorized actions (e.g., gain access to and / or read sensitive / private data, make copies of sensitive / private data, edit sensitive / private data, upload and / or store malware and / or spyware). In various cases, a prescribed control may involve a direct active vulnerability (e.g., may be a direct active control) if, for example, the prescribed control involves an active vulnerability and an exploit of the prescribed control is known to already exist (e.g., installing an outdated vulnerability in a computing asset for which an exploit is known to exist may enable an attacker to immediately attack the computing asset). Conversely, a prescribed control may involve an indirect active vulnerability (e.g., may be an indirect active control) if, for example, it involves an active vulnerability and an exploit of the prescribed control is not known to already exist (e.g., implementing a vulnerability password in a computing asset does not necessarily allow an attacker to immediately attack the computing asset, but it may present an opportunity to the attacker to exploit). In various aspects, a trained machine learning model can determine which weakness category a prescribed control belongs to (e.g., it can be determined whether a prescribed control is a passive control, a direct active control, or an indirect active control), and can then assign a weakness factor based on the weakness category. For example, if a prescribed control belongs to a passive weakness category, the weakness factor can have a low value (e.g., a passive weakness can be considered not to be a very weak weakness). If a prescribed control belongs to a direct active weakness category, the weakness factor can have a high value (e.g., a direct active weakness can be considered to be an unacceptably weak weakness). If a prescribed control belongs to an indirect active weakness category, the weakness factor can have a value that depends on the magnitude of the noncompliance (e.g., the value of the weakness factor can be proportional to the extent to which the state of the computing asset violates the prescribed control, and can be bounded below by a value associated with a passive weakness and above by a value associated with a direct active weakness). In different embodiments, any other suitable weakness category can be implemented.In other words, the weakness component can receive a technical document that describes the properties of the specified controls, the trained machine learning model can classify the specified controls into weakness categories based on the technical document, the value of the weakness factor can vary for different weakness categories, and the value of the weakness factor for some weakness categories can be based on how incompatible the computing asset is with the specified controls.
[0038] As explained in the above paragraphs, the machine learning model of the weakness component can determine the weakness category of the specified control and can then assign a value to the weakness factor based on the type of the determined weakness category. Although the above embodiments only mention passive weaknesses, direct active weaknesses, and indirect active weaknesses, these are only examples and are non-limiting. In different embodiments, any other suitable weakness category can be implemented. The above paragraphs define "passive weaknesses", "direct active weaknesses", and "indirect active weaknesses". In one or more embodiments, the definition of a passive weakness (or passive control) can be a weakness or control where non-compliance allows an attacker to prevent authorized actions of the system (e.g., automatic security audits). In one or more embodiments, the definition of an active weakness (or active control) can be a weakness or control where non-compliance allows an attacker to perform unauthorized actions (e.g., read / edit data). In one or more embodiments, the definition of a "direct active weakness" can be an active weakness for which an exploit (e.g., malicious computer software that exploits a computer vulnerability or weakness) is already known to exist in the industry / field (e.g., immediately exploitable). In some aspects, the weak point component may be pre-programmed with (and / or may otherwise have any suitable form of access to) a list of exploits known to exist in the industry / domain at any suitable time. In one or more embodiments, the definition of an "indirect active vulnerability" may be an active vulnerability in the industry / domain for which exploits are not yet known to exist (e.g., not necessarily immediately exploitable).
[0039] In different instances, the environment component can generate a scalar referred to as an environmental factor for computing assets and / or for specifying controls. In different cases, the value of the environmental factor can be a function of different security mechanisms and / or security protocols implemented by the computing assets to prevent security threats. For example, if the computing asset implements advanced and / or strict protection mechanisms (e.g., data masking / encryption instead of automatic data discovery / classification, anomaly prevention / interception instead of anomaly detection, internal access only instead of public access), the value of the environmental factor can be correspondingly smaller (e.g., indicating low risk). On the other hand, if the computing asset implements less advanced and / or less strict protection mechanisms (e.g., automatic data discovery / classification instead of data masking / encryption, anomaly detection only instead of anomaly prevention / interception, public access instead of internal access only), the value of the environmental factor can be correspondingly larger (e.g., indicating high risk). In different cases, the baseline health check risk score can be mathematically adjusted (e.g., increased and / or decreased) based on the environmental factor. In this way, the computerized diagnostic tool can take into account the built-in security mechanisms of the computing asset, which can make the computing asset inherently less vulnerable to security attacks. As used herein, the term "environmental factor" can mean a metric (e.g., a number) whose value is based on a property of a computing asset (e.g., based on how many and / or what types of security mechanisms are implemented by the computing asset). In various cases, the value of the environmental factor can be any suitable mathematical function of such properties of the computing asset. The environmental factor can then be used to mathematically adjust (e.g., increase and / or decrease) a baseline health check risk score, as described herein (e.g., as described with respect to Fig. 9 explained).
[0040] In different examples, the environment component can generate and / or calculate environment factors based on different security / privacy policies implemented by the computing assets. In some cases, the environment component can include a trained machine learning model that can be utilized to generate / calculate environment factors. As described above, the trained machine learning model can be any suitable computer-implemented artificial intelligence algorithm that can be trained to classify and / or label input data. In different cases, the environment component can be configured to electronically receive and / or retrieve one or more asset documents (e.g., natural language documents) describing different technical details of the computing assets from any suitable electronically accessible data structure. Such asset documents can, for example, include GitHub documents, development / design documents, and / or any other similar documents that describe and / or characterize the technical attributes / characteristics of the computing assets. In different cases, any other suitable input data that characterizes the technical characteristics of the computing assets can be implemented. Similar to the vulnerability component, the environment component can generate digital representations (e.g., vectors, tensors) of one or more asset documents (e.g., via word embedding and / or language modeling). In different cases, the trained machine learning model of the environment component can then receive digital representations of one or more asset documents as input, and can generate different determinations associated with the computing assets as output.
[0041] As explained in the above paragraphs, the asset document can be a natural language document (e.g., written in human-readable text). However, the machine learning model of the environment component may not typically receive human-readable text / prose as input. Instead, any suitable word embedding technology can be implemented that produces a digital representation of the asset document. The "digital representation" of the asset document can be a vector, a tensor, and / or any other suitable set of numbers representing the content of the asset document and / or related to the content of the asset document (e.g., the word embedding algorithm is configured to assign numerical values to human-readable words and / or sentences based on the context of the human-readable words and / or sentences). The machine learning model of the environment component can then receive the digital representation and can generate different determinations as described herein. The word embedding technology can be a natural language processing algorithm that is configured to map human-readable words or phrases in a given vocabulary to vectors and / or tensors of real numbers of any suitable dimension. More specifically, word embeddings utilize the principle that words that typically appear near each other in a document have similar meanings. Thus, for any suitable integer n, word embedding can assign an n-dimensional vector to a particular word (and / or phrase) in an asset document, where the value of the n-dimensional vector is based on other words that appear near the particular word. Similar words can therefore have similar vectors, and dissimilar words can therefore have different vectors. As will be appreciated by one of ordinary skill in the art, word embedding techniques can be facilitated via trained neural networks and / or via dimensionality reduction of a word co-occurrence matrix corresponding to an input asset document. Note that these are merely examples of word embedding techniques, and in different embodiments, any suitable word embedding technique may be implemented. Word embedding techniques and the digital representations they generate are known in the art, and additional details regarding word embedding techniques and the digital representations they generate need not be elaborated herein.
[0042] In various aspects, the determination of the machine learning model of the environment component can identify various technical aspects and / or technical attributes of the computing asset based on one or more asset documents describing the computing asset. In some cases, the determination can identify the type of access protocol implemented by the computing asset (e.g., it can be determined whether the computing asset is only accessible internally (less risk) or whether the computing asset is publicly accessible (greater risk)). In some cases, the determination can identify the type of modification paradigm implemented by the computing asset (e.g., it can be determined whether the computing asset is immutable (less risk) or whether the computing asset is mutable / ephemeral (greater risk)). In some cases, the determination can identify the type of instantiation paradigm implemented by the computing asset (e.g., it can be determined whether the computing asset is isolated (less risk) or whether the computing asset is configured for multi-tenancy (greater risk)). In some cases, the determination can identify the type of service availability associated with the computing asset (e.g., whether service and / or maintenance is still available for the computing asset (less risk) or whether service / maintenance is no longer available for the computing asset (greater risk)). In some cases, the determination can identify the data protection protocols implemented by the computing asset (e.g., it can be determined whether the computing asset automatically implements data masking / encryption, even for signed-in entities (less risk), or whether the computing asset automatically implements data discovery / classification (greater risk)). In some cases, the determination can identify the type of compliance enforcement implemented by the computing asset (e.g., it can be determined whether controls are regularly checked and remediated (less risk) or whether controls are only checked periodically (greater risk)). In some cases, the determination can identify the type of anomaly detection implemented by the computing asset (e.g., it can be determined whether the computing asset automatically blocks and / or hinders unusual behavior (less risk) or whether the computing asset only notifies when unusual behavior is detected (greater risk)). In some cases, the determination can identify any other suitable characteristics of the computing asset. In various cases, the trained machine learning model of the environment component can assign values to the environment factor based on these determinations. Specifically, when the trained machine learning classifier determines that the computing asset incorporates more stringent and / or advanced security mechanisms (e.g., in this case, the computing asset can be considered a hardened target that is more resistant to exploitation despite not complying with specified controls; therefore, the computing asset can pose a lower security risk). On the other hand, when the trained machine learning model determines that the computing asset incorporates less stringent and / or advanced security mechanisms, the environmental factor may be higher (e.g., in this case, the computing asset may be considered a softened target that is less resistant to exploitation; therefore, the computing asset may be considered to be particularly at risk in the presence of non-compliant controls). In other words, the environment component may receive technical documentation describing properties of the computing asset, the trained machine learning model of the environment component may determine what security mechanisms are implemented by the computing asset based on the technical documentation, and the value of the environmental factor may be based on such security mechanisms / protocols.
[0043] In different instances, the criticality component can generate a scalar called a criticality factor for computing assets and / or for specifying controls. In different cases, the value of the criticality factor can be a function of the importance level of the computing asset to the entity that owns and / or operates the computing asset. For example, if the computing asset is very important to the entity that owns / operates the computing asset (e.g., a banking institution may have a computing application that transfers funds into and / or out of a client account, and such a computing application may be very important to the banking institution), then the criticality factor may be correspondingly larger in value (e.g., indicating a high risk). On the other hand, if the computing asset is less important to the entity that owns / operates the computing asset (e.g., a banking institution may have a website dedicated to advertising and / or outreach, and the website may not be critical to the banking institution), then the criticality factor may be correspondingly smaller in value (e.g., indicating a low risk). In different cases, the baseline health check risk score can be mathematically adjusted (e.g., increased and / or decreased) based on the criticality factor. In this way, the computerized diagnostic tool can take into account how important the computing asset is to the entity that owns / operates the computing asset. As used herein, the term "criticality factor" may refer to a metric (e.g., a number) whose value is based on a criticality level of a computing asset. In various cases, the value of the criticality factor may be any suitable mathematical function of such criticality level of the computing asset (e.g., the criticality factor may be calculated by applying any suitable mathematical operation to the criticality level of the computing asset). The criticality factor may then be used to mathematically adjust (e.g., increase and / or decrease) a baseline health check risk score, as described herein (e.g., as described with respect to Fig. 9 explained).
[0044] In various instances, a criticality component may generate and / or calculate a criticality factor based on electronic input received by an entity that owns / operates a computing asset. In other cases, a criticality component may include a trained machine learning model that can be utilized to generate / calculate a criticality factor. As described above, a trained machine learning model may be any suitable computer-implemented artificial intelligence algorithm that can be trained to classify and / or label input data. In various cases, a criticality component may be configured to electronically receive and / or retrieve one or more documents (e.g., natural language documents) from any suitable electronically accessible data structure that describe different details of a computing asset and / or different goals / purposes of an entity that owns / operates a computing asset. Such documents may include, for example, advertisements, business plans / demonstrations, mission statements, non-technical descriptions, and / or any other similar documents that describe / characterize the goals of an entity that owns / operates a computing asset and / or describe / characterize how a computing asset is utilized by an entity that owns / operates a computing asset. In various cases, any other suitable input data that characterizes the goals / activities of a computing asset and / or an entity that owns / operates a computing asset may be implemented. Similar to the weakness component and / or the environment component, the criticality component can generate digital representations (e.g., vectors, tensors) of one or more documents (e.g., via word embeddings and / or language modeling). In different cases, the trained machine learning model of the criticality component can then receive the digital representations of the one or more documents as input and can generate a classification and / or label associated with the computing asset as output. In various aspects, the classification and / or label can identify how important the computing asset is to the entity that owns / operates the computing asset (e.g., can identify how important the computing asset is to the entity's business activities and / or purposes / goals). For example, the classification and / or label can be non-critical (e.g., indicating that the computing asset is not an incredibly important aspect of the activities / goals of the entity that owns / operates the computing asset), the classification and / or label can be critical (e.g., indicating that the computing asset is an important aspect of the activities / goals of the entity that owns / operates the computing asset), and / or the classification and / or label can be very critical (e.g., indicating that the computing asset is an incredibly important aspect of the activities / goals of the entity that owns / operates the computing asset).
[0045] As explained in the above paragraphs, a document can be a natural language document (e.g., written in human-readable text). However, the machine learning model of the criticality component may not typically receive human-readable text / prose as input. Instead, any suitable word embedding technology can be implemented that produces a digital representation of a document. The "digital representation" of a document can be a vector, a tensor, and / or any other suitable digital set representing the document content and / or related to the document content (e.g., a word embedding algorithm is configured to assign numerical values to human-readable words and / or sentences based on the context of human-readable words and / or sentences). The machine learning model of the criticality component can then receive the digital representation and can generate classifications / labels as described herein. The word embedding technology can be a natural language processing algorithm that is configured to map human-readable words or phrases in a given vocabulary to vectors and / or tensors of real numbers of any suitable dimension. More specifically, word embedding utilizes the principle that words that typically appear near each other in a document have similar meanings. Thus, for any suitable integer n, word embedding can assign an n-dimensional vector to a particular word (and / or phrase) in a document, where the value of the n-dimensional vector is based on other words that appear near the particular word. Similar words can therefore have similar vectors, and dissimilar words can therefore have different vectors. As will be appreciated by one of ordinary skill in the art, word embedding techniques can be facilitated via trained neural networks and / or via dimensionality reduction of a word co-occurrence matrix corresponding to an input document. Note that these are merely examples of word embedding techniques, and in different embodiments, any suitable word embedding technique may be implemented. Word embedding techniques and the digital representations they generate are known in the art, and additional details regarding word embedding techniques and the digital representations they generate need not be elaborated herein.
[0046] In different situations, the trained machine learning model of the criticality component can assign values to the criticality factor based on the classification and / or labeling. Specifically, the criticality factor can be lower when the trained machine learning classifier determines that the computing asset is not critical (e.g., non-compliance with regulatory controls can cause low security risks because the computing asset is not very important), the criticality factor can be higher when the trained machine learning classifier determines that the computing asset is critical (e.g., non-compliance with regulatory controls can cause moderate security risks because the computing asset is important), and the criticality factor can be highest when the trained machine learning classifier determines that the computing asset is ultra-critical (e.g., non-compliance with regulatory controls can cause high security risks because the computing asset is very important). In other words, the criticality component can receive a document describing the characteristics of the computing asset and / or describing the goals / purposes of the entity that owns / operates the computing asset, the trained machine learning model of the criticality component can determine a level of importance and / or criticality to assign to the computing asset based on the document, and the value of the criticality factor can be based on such level of importance and / or criticality.
[0047] In various instances, the maturity component may generate a scalar referred to as a maturity factor for computing assets and / or for prescribed controls. In various cases, the value of the maturity factor may be a function of the difference (e.g., calculated by subtraction) and / or deviation between prescribed controls and industry standards / best practices. For example, an entity that owns / operates computing assets may establish more relaxed and / or less stringent prescribed controls than the industry standards and / or best practices recommended for computing assets. In this case, the entity that owns / operates computing assets may be considered less mature from a network security perspective. In various aspects, computing assets may therefore comply with prescribed controls and nonetheless cause security risks because prescribed controls are looser and / or less secure than industry standards and / or recommendations. In addition, since prescribed controls are looser and / or less secure than industry standards and / or recommendations, computing assets may also only slightly fail to comply with prescribed controls and still cause significant security risks. As an example, assume that prescribed controls specify that passwords in computing assets are at least 4 characters long, and assume that industry standards and / or industry best practices instead recommend that passwords in such computing assets be at least 10 characters long. In this case, a password of 6 characters long may be considered to comply with the prescribed control, but it may still pose a security threat because the prescribed control is less stringent than the industry standard (e.g., a 4-character password is inherently less secure than a 10-character password). In addition, if the password of the computing asset is only three characters long, it may be considered to be only slightly inconsistent with the prescribed control. However, such a three-character password may pose a significant security threat because the prescribed control is much lower than the industry standard. Therefore, in various embodiments, the maturity component may generate a value for the maturity factor based on the different degrees of prescribed control compared to the recommended control, best practices, and / or industry standards. In various cases, the baseline health check risk score may be mathematically adjusted (e.g., increased and / or decreased) based on the maturity factor. In this way, the computerized diagnostic tool may consider how mature the entity that owns / operates the computing asset is in network security. As used herein, the term "maturity factor" may mean a metric (e.g., a number) whose value is based on the difference (e.g., calculated via subtraction) between the prescribed control and the recommended control (e.g., best practice). In various cases, the value of the maturity factor can be any suitable mathematical function of such a difference (e.g., the maturity factor can be calculated by applying any suitable mathematical operation to the difference between the prescribed control and the recommended control). The maturity factor can then be used to mathematically adjust (e.g., increase and / or decrease) the baseline health check risk score as described herein (e.g., as described with respect to Fig. 9 explained).
[0048] In various instances, the maturity component may generate and / or calculate a maturity factor based on electronic input received by an entity that owns / operates the computing asset. In other cases, the maturity component may query any suitable data structure that the maturity component can access electronically to learn best practices, industry standards, and / or industry recommendations associated with the specified control. In such cases, the maturity component may then compare the retrieved value specified by the best practices, industry standards, and / or industry recommendations to the value specified by the specified control to determine how much more relaxed and / or less stringent / ensured the specified control is compared to the best practices, industry standards, and / or industry recommendations. In various cases, the value of the maturity factor may be set accordingly. Specifically, if the maturity component determines that the prescribed control is consistent with the recommended control (e.g., within predetermined limits), the maturity factor can be low, if the maturity component determines that the prescribed control is more stringent than the recommended control, the maturity factor can be even lower, if the maturity component determines that the prescribed control is more lax and / or less stringent than the recommended control by a certain percentage, the maturity factor can be high, and when the maturity component determines that the prescribed control is more lax and / or less stringent than the recommended control by an even greater percentage, the maturity factor can be even higher. In other words, the maturity component can be informed of the recommended controls related to the computing assets, the maturity component can determine differences and / or deviations between the prescribed controls and the recommended controls, and the value of the maturity factor can be based on such level differences and / or deviations.
[0049] As described above, the computerized diagnostic tool may generate a baseline health check risk score, a vulnerability factor, an environmental factor, a criticality factor, and / or a maturity factor based on the state of the computing asset and the prescribed control. In different cases, the computerized diagnostic tool may adjust the baseline health check risk score based on the vulnerability factor, the environmental factor, the criticality factor, and / or the maturity factor. In some cases, the computerized diagnostic tool may multiply the baseline health check risk score by the environmental factor to produce a first product, may add the vulnerability factor to the first product to produce a first sum, may multiply the criticality factor by the first sum to produce a second product, and may multiply the maturity factor by the second product to produce an adjusted health check risk score for the computing asset based on the prescribed control. This is just one example of how an adjusted health check risk score for the computing asset may be calculated based on the baseline health check risk score, the vulnerability factor, the environmental factor, the criticality factor, and / or the maturity factor. In other cases, any other suitable equation, formula, and / or mathematical operation may be performed on the baseline health check risk score, vulnerability factor, environmental factor, criticality factor, and / or maturity factor to calculate an adjusted health check risk score for the computing asset (e.g., the environmental factor may be added rather than multiplied; the vulnerability factor may be multiplied rather than added; the criticality factor may be added rather than multiplied; the maturity factor may be added rather than multiplied). In various cases, the adjusted health check risk score may quantify the level of security risk associated with the computing asset due to the computing asset's noncompliance with prescribed controls. As explained above, the adjusted health check risk score may be more accurate than the baseline health check risk score (e.g., generated via CCSS technology) due to the vulnerability factor (e.g., which may explain the magnitude of the noncompliance of the computing asset), the environmental factor (e.g., which may explain the built-in security mechanisms of the computing asset), the criticality factor (e.g., which may explain the level of importance of the computing asset), and the maturity factor (e.g., which may explain the differences between prescribed controls and best practices).
[0050] In various instances, a single computing asset may be subject to and / or managed by many different prescribed controls. Thus, in various embodiments, the computerized diagnostic tool may generate many different adjusted health check risk scores for a single computing asset based on the many different prescribed controls that govern the single computing asset (e.g., one adjusted health check risk score for each prescribed control that governs the computing asset). In various cases, the computerized diagnostic tool may include an aggregation component that may aggregate these many different adjusted health check risk scores together (e.g., via a weighted average and / or via a maximum function) to produce an aggregated adjusted health check risk score for the computing asset (e.g., one score for the computing asset aggregated for all of the many different prescribed controls that govern the computing asset). Similarly, a computing system may include many different computing assets. Thus, the aggregation component may generate an aggregated adjusted health check risk score for each computing asset, and may aggregate them together (e.g., via a weighted average and / or a maximum function) to produce a final adjusted health check risk score for the entire computing system. In this manner, the computerized diagnostic tool can quantify the risk level associated with the computing system, can quantify the individual risk level of each computing asset of the computing system, and / or can quantify an even more fine-grained risk level of each prescribed control of each computing asset of the computing system. Thus, triage between computing assets and / or between prescribed controls of a single computing asset can be precisely performed.
[0051] In various aspects, the computerized diagnostic tool may generate any suitable electronic notifications and / or alerts based on the generated adjusted health check risk score (e.g., the entity that owns / operates the computing asset may be notified and / or alerted of the adjusted health check risk score, the adjusted health check risk score may be displayed on an electronic screen / monitor). In various circumstances, the computerized diagnostic tool may take any appropriate form of remedial action based on the adjusted health check risk score (e.g., the computing asset may be automatically locked and / or shut down until a non-compliant control having an adjusted health check risk score above a predetermined threshold is fixed, maintenance / maintenance of the computing asset may be automatically scheduled and / or obtained in order to fix a non-compliant control having an adjusted health check risk score above a predetermined threshold).
[0052] Various embodiments of the present invention may be used to solve problems that are highly technical in nature (e.g., facilitating automated health check risk assessment of computing assets), are not abstract, and cannot be performed by a person as a set of mental actions using hardware and / or software. Further, some of the processing performed may be performed by a dedicated computer (e.g., generating a baseline health check risk score corresponding to a noncompliance of a computing asset with a specified control by a device operatively coupled to a processor; adjusting the baseline health check risk score by the device based on a vulnerability factor of the specified control, wherein the vulnerability factor is based on the magnitude of a deviation of the state of the computing asset from the specified control; adjusting the baseline health check risk score by the device based on an environmental factor of the computing asset, wherein the environmental factor is based on a security mechanism or security protocol associated with the computing asset; adjusting the baseline health check risk score by the device based on a criticality factor of the computing asset, wherein the criticality factor is based on an importance level associated with the computing asset; and adjusting the baseline health check risk score by the device based on a maturity factor of the computing asset, wherein the maturity factor is based on a difference between a specified control and a recommended control). Such defined tasks are typically not performed manually by a person. Furthermore, neither the human mind nor a person with pen and paper can scan and / or query computing assets to obtain status information, generate a baseline health check risk score for computing assets based on the status information and prescribed controls, generate a vulnerability factor, an environmental factor, a criticality factor, and / or a maturity factor for computing assets, and adjust the baseline health check risk score based on the vulnerability factor, the environmental factor, the criticality factor, and / or the maturity factor. Furthermore, as explained herein, various embodiments of the present invention can utilize machine learning models to assist in such generation and / or adjustment, and neither the human mind nor a person with pen and paper can electronically execute the machine learning model. Rather, various embodiments of the present invention are inherently and inseparably dependent on computer technology and cannot be implemented outside of a computing environment (e.g., computing assets are inherently computerized devices that cannot exist outside of a computing system; similarly, computerized diagnostic tools that automatically monitor computing assets for compliance with prescribed controls are inherently computerized devices that also do not exist outside of a computing system).
[0053] In various instances, embodiments of the present invention may integrate the disclosed teachings regarding automatic health check risk assessment of computing assets into practical applications. In fact, as described herein, various embodiments of the present invention, which may take the form of a system and / or computer-implemented method, may be considered a computerized diagnostic tool that evaluates control information of a computing asset and assigns an adjusted health check risk score to the computing asset based on such control information. More specifically, embodiments of the present invention may assign a health check risk score to a computing asset that quantifies the extent of the security threat posed by the computing asset. Such quantification is certainly a useful and practical application of computers, at least because it allows an operator to classify and / or prioritize different non-compliant controls of different computing assets and / or a single computing asset (e.g., without such a health check risk score, the operator would not know which non-compliant controls to address / remediate first). In addition, as described above, conventional techniques for assigning such health check risk scores completely ignore the magnitude of non-compliance, the criticality of a given computing asset, and the deviations between the prescribed controls and industry standards / best practices. As explained herein, various embodiments of the present invention can address these shortcomings via vulnerability factors, environmental factors, criticality factors, and / or maturity factors, with the result that an adjusted baseline health check risk score generated by an embodiment of the present invention can be more accurate than a conventionally generated baseline health check risk score. Systems and / or techniques that can generate health check risk scores that are more accurate than conventionally generated baseline health check risk scores clearly constitute concrete and tangible technical improvements in the field of automated health check risk assessment of computing assets.
[0054] In addition, various embodiments of the present invention may control tangible, hardware-based and / or software-based devices based on the disclosed teachings. For example, various embodiments of the present invention may generate an adjusted health check risk score that quantifies the security risk associated with a tangible computing asset (e.g., a server, a data center) that does not comply with the specified control. In some cases, embodiments of the present invention may generate electronic notifications and / or warnings based on such adjusted health check risk scores (e.g., such electronic notifications / warnings may be transmitted to other tangible devices, such electronic notifications / warnings may be displayed on a tangible electronic screen / monitor). In some cases, various embodiments of the present invention may take actions based on such adjusted health check risk scores. For example, embodiments of the present invention may lock and / or power down a tangible computing asset when the adjusted health check risk score exceeds a predefined threshold (e.g., by transmitting a lock instruction / command and / or a power down instruction / command to the tangible computing asset). As another example, when the adjusted health check risk score exceeds a predetermined threshold (e.g., by electronically contacting a tangible computing device associated with a service / maintenance entity), embodiments of the present invention may schedule and / or obtain service / maintenance for the tangible computing asset. As yet another example, embodiments of the present invention may issue any suitable visible and / or audible alarm when the adjusted health check risk score exceeds a predefined threshold (e.g., by transmitting appropriate instructions / commands to a tangible alarm device that can generate a visible and / or audible alarm). In various aspects, embodiments of the present invention may initiate and / or perform any other suitable type of protective and / or preventative actions to protect computing assets when the adjusted health check risk score exceeds a predetermined threshold. Thus, embodiments of the present invention constitute concrete and tangible technical improvements in the field of automated health check risk assessment of computing assets.
[0055] It should be understood that the drawings and the disclosure herein describe non-limiting examples of various embodiments of the present invention.
[0056] Figure 1 A block diagram of an example non-limiting system 100 that can facilitate automated health check risk assessment of computing assets according to one or more embodiments described herein is shown. As shown, health check risk assessment system 102 can have any suitable form of electronic communication (e.g., wired and / or wireless) with computing assets 104.
[0057] In various cases, computing assets 104 can be any suitable combination of computer hardware and / or computing software. For example, computing assets 104 can be computers, software applications, websites, databases, files, mobile devices, and / or any other suitable information technology systems. In various cases, computing assets 104 can include state 106 and can be governed by and / or subject to prescribed controls 108. In various aspects, state 106 can be any suitable technical attribute / characteristic of computing assets 104, and prescribed controls 108 can be any suitable rules, regulations, benchmarks, and / or standards that state 106 should satisfy. As some non-limiting examples, state 106 may be password length (e.g., the actual character length of a password actually implemented by computing asset 104), and specified control 108 may be the minimum acceptable password length; state 106 may be password age (e.g., the actual age of a password actually implemented by computing asset 104), and specified control 108 may be the maximum acceptable password age; state 106 may be database file count (e.g., the actual number of files stored in a database actually maintained by computing asset 104), and specified control 108 may be the maximum acceptable database file count; and / or state 106 may be audit frequency (e.g., the actual audit frequency actually implemented by computing asset 104), and specified control 108 may be the minimum acceptable audit frequency.
[0058] although Figure 1 Provisioned controls 108 are depicted as being within computing asset 104, but this is a non-limiting example presented for illustrative convenience. In various situations, computing asset 104 may not be aware of and / or may not have access to provisioned controls 108. Figure 1 Computing asset 104 is described as having only one state 106 and being managed by only one provisioning control 108, but this is a non-limiting example. In various aspects, computing asset 104 may have any suitable number of states and may be managed by any suitable number of provisioning controls.
[0059] In various cases, the status 106 may violate and / or be noncompliant with the regulatory control 108. In various cases, the health check risk assessment system 102 may quantify the level of security risk associated with such noncompliance, as explained below.
[0060] In various embodiments, the health check risk assessment system 102 may include a processor 110 (e.g., a computer processing unit, a microprocessor) and a computer-readable memory 112 operably connected to the processor 110. The memory 112 may store computer-executable instructions that, when executed by the processor 110, may cause the processor 110 and / or other components of the health check risk assessment system 102 (e.g., the baseline component 114, the vulnerability component 116, the environment component 118, the criticality component 120, the maturity component 122) to perform one or more actions. In various embodiments, the memory 112 may store the computer-executable components (e.g., the baseline component 114, the vulnerability component 116, the environment component 118, the criticality component 120, the maturity component 122), and the processor 110 may execute the computer-executable components.
[0061] In various embodiments, the health check risk assessment system 102 can scan and / or query the computing assets 104 to obtain the state 106 via any suitable technique. That is, the health check risk assessment system 102 can electronically retrieve the state 106 (e.g., the value of the state 106) from the computing assets 104. In various embodiments, the health check risk assessment system 102 can learn the prescribed control 108 via any suitable technique. For example, the health check risk assessment system 102 can electronically retrieve the prescribed control 108 from any suitable data structure and / or data source accessible to the health check risk assessment system 102 (e.g., again, although Figure 1 The prescribed controls 108 are depicted as being within the computing asset 104, but this is non-limiting; in some cases, the prescribed controls 108 may be stored in a data structure (not shown) remote from the computing asset 104. In some cases, the health check risk assessment system 102 may be preprogrammed to already know the prescribed controls 108 and / or may electronically receive the prescribed controls 108 as input from an operator. In any case, the health check risk assessment system 102 may be aware of both the state 106 and the prescribed controls 108.
[0062] In various embodiments, the health check risk assessment system 102 may include a baseline component 114. In various aspects, the baseline component 114 may generate a baseline health check risk score based on the state 106 and / or the prescribed control 108. In various aspects, the baseline component 114 may implement any suitable risk quantification technique to generate a baseline health check risk score, such as a CCSS technique (e.g., including attack vectors, access complexity, authentication metrics, confidentiality impact, integrity impact, and / or availability impact). However, as described above, such risk quantification techniques may be suboptimal because they may not be able to take into account different details, such as the size of the non-compliance, the criticality of the computing asset 104, and / or the deviation between the prescribed control 108 and the corresponding recommended control (e.g., industry standards and / or best practices). The health check risk assessment system 102 may address these issues by mathematically adjusting the baseline health check risk score based on the vulnerability factor, the environmental factor, the criticality factor, and / or the maturity factor.
[0063] In various embodiments, the health check risk assessment system 102 may include a vulnerability determination component 116. In various aspects, the vulnerability determination component 116 may generate and / or calculate a vulnerability factor, which may be based on the magnitude by which the state 106 violates the prescribed control 108. For example, assume that the state 106 is password age and the prescribed control 108 is the maximum acceptable password age. If the state 106 is only slightly inconsistent with the prescribed control 108 (e.g., if the state 106 is 91 days and the prescribed control 108 is 90 days), the vulnerability factor may be numerically small (e.g., proportional to and / or otherwise a function of the percentage difference between the state 106 and the prescribed control 108), which may indicate a low security risk. On the other hand, if the status 106 is severely out of compliance with the prescribed control 108 (e.g., if the status 106 is 150 days and the prescribed control 108 is 90 days), the vulnerability factor may be numerically large (e.g., proportional to the percentage difference between the status 106 and the prescribed control 108), which may indicate a high security risk. As further explained herein, the vulnerability component 116 may generate the vulnerability factor via machine learning techniques in some cases.
[0064] In various embodiments, the health check risk assessment system 102 may include an environment component 118. In various aspects, the environment component 118 may generate and / or calculate an environment factor, which may be based on the built-in security mechanisms implemented by the computing asset 104. For example, if the computing asset 104 implements effective and / or strict security / privacy mechanisms (e.g., data masking / encryption, automatic blocking of abnormal behavior even for signed-in entities, such as locking the computing asset 104 after a maximum number of sign-in attempts, internal accessibility only), the environment factor may be numerically small (e.g., indicating that the computing asset 104 is a hardened target that is resistant to exploitation despite failure to comply with the regulatory controls 108). On the other hand, if the computing asset 104 implements ineffective and / or non-strict security / privacy mechanisms (e.g., automatic data discovery / classification of signed entities, only notification of abnormal behavior, public accessibility), the environment factor may be numerically large (e.g., indicating that the computing asset 104 is a soft target that is not very resistant to exploitation, which increases the security risk associated with failure to comply with the regulatory controls 108). As further explained herein, in some cases, the environmental component 118 may generate the environmental factors via machine learning techniques.
[0065] In various embodiments, the health check risk assessment system 102 may include a criticality component 120. In various aspects, the criticality component 120 may generate and / or calculate a criticality factor, which may be based on the importance level of the computing asset 104. Assume that the computing asset 104 is a software application employed by a financial institution and electronically facilitates the actual purchase and / or sale of commercial stock. Because such a software application is critical to the purpose / goals / activities of the financial institution, the criticality factor may be large in value (e.g., because the software application is so important to the financial institution, non-compliance with the prescribed control 108 may pose a particularly high security risk). On the other hand, assume that the computing asset 104 is a website employed by the financial institution and displays advertising materials. Since such a website is not critical to the purpose / goals / activities of the financial institution, the criticality factor may be small in value (e.g., because the website is not so important to the financial institution, non-compliance with the prescribed control 108 may not be of particular concern). As explained more herein, in some cases, the criticality component 120 may generate the criticality factor via machine learning techniques.
[0066] In various embodiments, the health check risk assessment system 102 may include a maturity component 122. In various aspects, the maturity component 122 may generate and / or calculate a maturity factor, which may be based on differences and / or deviations between the prescribed control 108 and the recommended control (e.g., best practices and / or industry standards). For example, assume that the prescribed control 108 specifies a maximum acceptable password age of 90 days, and the recommended control specifies a maximum acceptable password age of 60 days. In this case, the prescribed control 108 is more relaxed and / or less stringent than the recommended control. Therefore, even if the state 106 complies with the prescribed control 108, the state 106 may still pose a significant security risk. For example, if the state 106 is an actual password age of 80 days, the state 106 satisfies the prescribed control 108 that specifies a maximum acceptable password age of 90 days, however, because the prescribed control 108 is inconsistent with the recommended control that specifies a maximum acceptable password age of 60 days, the state 106 is objectively insecure.
[0067] In various cases, the health check risk assessment system 102 can include an adjustment component 124. In various aspects, the adjustment component 124 can mathematically adjust the baseline health check risk score using the vulnerability factor, the environmental factor, the criticality factor, and / or the maturity factor to produce an adjusted health check risk score that is more accurate than the baseline health check risk score.
[0068] Figure 2 A block diagram of an example non-limiting system 200 is shown that includes a baseline health check risk score that can facilitate automatic health check risk assessment of computing assets according to one or more embodiments described herein. As shown, in some cases, system 200 can include the same components as system 100, and can also include a baseline health check risk score 202.
[0069] As explained above, the baseline component 114 can generate and / or calculate the baseline health check risk score 202 based on the state 106 and / or the prescribed control 108 via any suitable health check risk assessment technique (e.g., CCSS technique). In various aspects, as described above, the baseline health check risk score 202 can quantify the risk level associated with the non-compliance of the state 106 with the prescribed control 108 (e.g., a higher value of the baseline health check risk score 202 can indicate a higher risk level). However, the baseline health check risk score 202 can be suboptimal and / or not completely accurate, at least because the CCSS technique fails to consider the magnitude of the non-compliance (e.g., non-compliance). They consider the state 106 binary as to whether it violates the prescribed control 108, without considering the severity and / or number of violations), the CCSS technique cannot account for the importance level of the computing assets 104 (e.g., if they violate the same prescribed control, they consider two different computing assets to pose an equal risk level, regardless of how important each asset is), and the CCSS technique cannot account for differences between the prescribed control 108 and the recommended control (e.g., how important each asset is). Even though the regulatory controls 108 are significantly less stringent than industry standards, they take the regulatory controls 108 at face value.) As explained herein, the health check risk assessment system 102 can adjust the baseline health check risk score 202 to address these shortcomings.
[0070] Figure 3 A block diagram of an example non-limiting system 300 including a vulnerability factor that can facilitate automated health check risk assessment of computing assets according to one or more embodiments described herein is shown. As shown, in some cases, system 300 can include the same components as system 200, and can further include a machine learning classifier 302 and a vulnerability factor 304.
[0071] In various embodiments, the machine learning classifier 302 can be any suitable computer-implemented artificial intelligence algorithm that can be trained to receive input information about the specified control 108 and generate as an output the vulnerability category to which the specified control 108 belongs. That is, the machine learning classifier 302 can determine whether the specified control 108 is a passive weakness (e.g., the specified control 108 can be labeled as a passive control), a direct active weakness (e.g., the specified control 108 can be labeled as a direct active control), or an indirect active weakness (e.g., the specified control 108 can be labeled as an indirect active control). Although not shown in the figure, in some aspects, the weakness component 116 can electronically receive and / or retrieve one or more control documents as input from any suitable electronically accessible data source. In various cases, the one or more control documents can be technical documents (e.g., GitHub documents, design / development documents) that describe and / or characterize the properties, purpose, and / or details of the specified control 108. In various aspects, the one or more control documents can be written in any suitable natural language (e.g., any suitable human-readable text). In various examples, the weakness component 116 can generate a digital representation of one or more control documents as described herein by any suitable technique, such as word embedding and / or language modeling. In various cases, the machine learning classifier 302 can be trained to receive as input a digital representation of one or more control documents describing a prescribed control 108 (e.g., the digital representation can be considered a feature vector of the input), and determine as output a weakness category to which the prescribed control 108 belongs. In various aspects, the weakness component 116 can then generate a weakness factor 304 based on the weakness category determined by the machine learning classifier 302.
[0072] Figure 4An exemplary, non-limiting table 400 associated with a weakness factor according to one or more embodiments described herein is shown. In other words, table 400 shows a brief description of various, non-limiting weakness categories that a machine learning classifier 302 can be trained to label a prescribed control 108. As shown, a prescribed control 108 can be classified as belonging to a passive weakness or an active weakness. In different cases, if failure to comply with a prescribed control 108 presents a risk of enabling an attacker to prevent a computing asset 104 from performing an authorized action (such as preventing the execution of a particular component and / or software application or preventing the generation of an audit log record), the prescribed control 108 may involve a passive weakness. In various aspects, if a prescribed control 108 is not complied with, the prescribed control 108 may involve an active weakness, thereby presenting a risk of enabling an attacker to perform an unauthorized action (such as accessing, copying and / or editing sensitive data). In addition, in some cases, active weaknesses can be further divided into direct active weaknesses and indirect active weaknesses. In various cases, if the specified control 108 is an active weakness and if it is known that an exploit of the specified control 108 has already existed, then the specified control 108 may relate to a direct active weakness. On the other hand, if the specified control 108 is an active weakness and if it is not known that an exploit of the specified control 108 has already existed, then the specified control 108 may be an indirect active weakness. One of ordinary skill in the art will appreciate that passive weaknesses, direct active weaknesses, and indirect active weaknesses are based on a common configuration scoring system established by the National Institute of Standards and Technology. In various aspects, any other suitable vulnerability categories and / or subcategories may be implemented.
[0073] The machine learning classifier 302 can receive as input a numerical representation of a technical document describing / characterizing a specified control 108 as described herein, and can determine as output a vulnerability category belonging to the specified control 108 (e.g., it can be determined whether the specified control 108 is a passive weakness, a direct active weakness, or an indirect active weakness). In various aspects, the weakness component 116 can generate and / or calculate the weakness factor 302 based on the determined weakness category. For example, if the machine learning classifier 302 determines that the specified control 108 is a passive weakness, the weakness component 116 can determine that the failure of the state 106 to comply with the specified control 108 is not particularly serious (e.g., passive weaknesses can be considered not particularly serious because they are not associated with the execution of unauthorized actions; in contrast, passive weaknesses are associated with the prevention of authorized actions, and it is recognized in the art that the execution of unauthorized actions is a worse threat than the prevention of authorized actions). Therefore, the weakness factor 304 can be set to a relatively low value (e.g., such as Figure 40 shown in ). Conversely, if machine learning classifier 302 determines that prescribed control 108 is a direct-action weakness, then vulnerability component 116 can determine that failure of state 106 to comply with prescribed control 108 is particularly severe (e.g., a direct-action weakness can be considered particularly severe because a known exploit already exists). As a result, vulnerability factor 304 can be set to a relatively high value (e.g., as shown in ). Figure 4 3 shown in ). In various cases, if the machine learning classifier 302 determines that the prescribed control 108 is an indirect active weakness, the weakness component 116 can determine that the state 106 fails to comply with the prescribed control 108 depending on the magnitude of the non-compliance (e.g., indirect active weaknesses can be considered to be less severe depending on the severity of the non-compliance because they are associated with the performance of unauthorized actions, but no known exploits exist yet). Therefore, the weakness factor 304 can be a function of the difference (e.g., percentage difference and / or absolute difference) between the state 106 and the prescribed control 108. In various cases, when the prescribed control 108 is an indirect active weakness, the value of the weakness factor 304 can be bounded below by the value set for a passive weakness and can be bounded above by the value set for a direct active weakness. For example, if the state 106 complies with the prescribed control 108, the weakness factor 304 may be 0; if the state 106 violates the prescribed control 108 by a first predetermined margin / percentage (e.g., if the state 106 is 50% too high / too low), the weakness factor 304 may be a correspondingly higher value (e.g., 1); if the state 106 violates the prescribed control 108 by a second predetermined margin / percentage that is greater than the first predetermined margin / percentage (e.g., 1). If the state 106 is 75% too high / too low), the weakness factor 304 may be an even higher value (e.g., 2). In any case, when the prescribed control 108 is a weakness of an indirect activity, the weakness factor 304 may be any suitable function of the difference between the state 106 and the prescribed control 108. As described above, conventional health check risk assessment techniques ignore such differences.
[0074] In various aspects, the machine learning classifier 302 may be trained using any suitable training technique (e.g., supervised learning, unsupervised learning, reinforcement learning). Furthermore, in some cases, the machine learning classifier 302 may undergo active learning. That is, in various embodiments, the weakness component 116 may receive real-time feedback on the weakness category classification of the output generated by the machine learning classifier 302 from any suitable operator (not shown). In various aspects, the parameters of the machine learning classifier 302 may be updated and / or retrained based on such feedback (e.g., via back-propagation).
[0075] To facilitate some of the above-mentioned machine learning aspects of various embodiments of the present invention, consider the following discussion of artificial intelligence. Different embodiments of the present invention may use artificial intelligence (AI) to facilitate automating one or more features of the present invention. Components may use different AI-based schemes to perform different embodiments / examples disclosed herein. In order to provide or assist in the various determinations of the present invention (e.g., determine, determine, infer, calculate, predict, predict, estimate, derive, predict, detect, calculate), components of the present invention may check all or a subset of the data to which they are authorized to access, and may infer or determine the state of the system and / or environment based on a set of observations captured via events and / or data. For example, determination may be used to identify a specific context or action, or a probability distribution over a state may be generated. Determination may be probabilistic; that is, a probability distribution over a state of interest is calculated based on consideration of data and events. Determination may also refer to a technique for composing a higher-level event from a set of events and / or data.
[0076] Such determination can result in constructing new events or actions from a set of observed events and / or stored event data, whether or not these events are closely related in time, and whether these events and data are from one or several events and data sources. The components disclosed herein can be combined with the claimed subject matter to perform automatic and / or determined actions and adopt different classification (explicit training (e.g., via training data) and implicit training (e.g., via observed behavior, preferences, historical information, receiving external information)) schemes and / or systems (e.g., support vector machines, neural networks, expert systems, Bayesian belief networks, fuzzy logic, data fusion engines). Thus, classification schemes and / or systems can be used to automatically learn and perform multiple functions, actions and / or determinations.
[0077] The classifier can map an input attribute vector z=(z1, z2, z3, z4, zn) to a confidence that the input belongs to a class, such as by f(z)=confidence(class). Such classification can use probabilistic and / or statistical analysis (e.g., decomposed into analytical utility and cost) to determine the action to be automatically performed. A support vector machine (SVM) may be an example of a classifier that can be used. SVM operates by finding a hypersurface in the space of possible inputs, where the hypersurface attempts to separate triggering criteria from non-triggering events. Intuitively, this makes the classification correct for test data that is close to the training data but not the same as the training data. Other directed and undirected model classification methods include, for example, naive Bayes, Bayesian networks, decision trees, neural networks, fuzzy logic models, and / or probabilistic classification models that provide different independent modes, any of which can be used. Classification as used herein also includes statistical regression for developing priority models.
[0078] Figure 5 A block diagram of an example non-limiting system 500 including environmental factors that can facilitate automated health check risk assessment of computing assets according to one or more embodiments described herein is shown. As shown, in some cases, system 500 can include the same components as system 300, and can further include a machine learning classifier 502 and environmental factors 504.
[0079] In various embodiments, the machine learning classifier 502 can be any suitable computer-implemented artificial intelligence algorithm that can be trained to receive input information about the computing asset 104 and generate a determination about the computing asset 104 as an output. Although not shown in the figure, in some aspects, the environment component 118 can electronically receive and / or retrieve one or more asset documents as input from any suitable electronically accessible data source. In various cases, the one or more asset documents can be technical documents (e.g., GitHub documents, design / development documents) that describe and / or characterize the properties, purpose, and / or details of the computing asset 104. In various aspects, the one or more asset documents can be written in any suitable natural language (e.g., any suitable human-readable text), and the environment component 118 can generate a digital representation of the one or more asset documents as described herein by any suitable technology (such as word embedding and / or language modeling). In various cases, the machine learning classifier 502 can be trained to receive a digital representation of one or more asset documents describing the computing asset 104 as input (e.g., the digital representation can be considered as a feature vector of the input), and determine what built-in security mechanism the computing asset 104 adopts as an output. In different cases, different above-described artificial intelligence details can be applied to the machine learning classifier 502. In various aspects, the environment component 118 can then generate the environment factor 504 based on the security mechanism detected by the machine learning classifier 502.
[0080] Figure 6An example non-limiting table 600 associated with environmental factors according to one or more embodiments described herein is shown. In other words, table 600 shows different non-limiting security mechanisms that can be implemented by computing assets 104 and can be detected by machine learning classifier 502. In addition, table 600 shows different non-limiting weights that can be assigned to each security mechanism. For example, machine learning classifier 502 may determine what type of access is implemented by computing asset 104 (e.g., internal only (more protection) vs. publicly accessible (less protection)), what type of modification paradigm is implemented by computing asset 104 (e.g., immutable (more protection) vs. mutable / ephemeral (less protection)), what type of instantiation paradigm is implemented by computing asset 104 (e.g., isolation (more protection) vs. multi-tenant (less protection)), whether a service is still available to computing asset 104 (e.g., available (more protection) vs. unavailable (less protection)), what type of data protection protocol is implemented by computing asset 104 (e.g., auto-discovery (less protection) vs. masking / encryption (more protection)), what type of compliance enforcement is implemented by computing asset 104 (e.g., inspection only (less protection) vs. remediation (more protection)), and / or what type of anomaly detection is implemented by computing asset 104 (e.g., notification only (less protection) vs. prevention / blocking (more protection)). It should be understood that Figure 6 are non-limiting examples, and machine learning classifier 502 may detect any other suitable security mechanism.
[0081] As shown, environment component 118 can assign different values / weights to different security mechanisms, and environment factor 504 can be any suitable function (e.g., maximum, average) of the values / weights of the different security mechanisms implemented by computing asset 104. For example, if computing asset 104 is only accessible internally (0.2), mutable / ephemeral (0.6), and only provides notifications (0.8), then environment factor 504 can be a maximum of 0.2, 0.6, and 0.8, i.e., 0.8. In another embodiment, environment factor 504 can be an average of 0.2, 0.6, and 0.8.
[0082] Figure 7 A block diagram of an example non-limiting system 700 including criticality factors that can facilitate automated health check risk assessment of computing assets according to one or more embodiments described herein is shown. As shown, in some cases, system 700 can include the same components as system 500, and can also include a machine learning classifier 702 and a criticality factor 704.
[0083] In various embodiments, the machine learning classifier 702 may be any suitable computer-implemented artificial intelligence algorithm that may be trained to receive input information about the computing asset 104 and generate as output determinations about the computing asset 104. Although not shown in the figure, in some aspects, the criticality component 120 may electronically receive and / or retrieve one or more documents as input from any suitable electronically accessible data source. In various cases, the one or more documents may describe and / or characterize the attributes, objectives, goals, and / or details of the computing asset 104 and / or the entity that owns / operates the computing asset 104 (e.g., an advertisement, a mission statement, a business plan / demonstration). In various aspects, the one or more documents may be written in any suitable natural language (e.g., any suitable human-readable text), and the criticality component 120 may generate a digital representation of the one or more documents as described herein by any suitable technique (such as word embeddings and / or language modeling). In various cases, the machine learning classifier 702 can be trained to receive as input a digital representation of one or more documents describing the computing asset 104 and the entity that owns / operates the computing asset 104 (e.g., the digital representation can be considered a feature vector of the input), and determine as output a degree of importance of the computing asset 104 to the goals / purposes / activities of the entity that owns / operates the computing asset 104. In various instances, the importance level of the computing asset 104 can be based on the entire application cluster associated with the computing asset 104 (e.g., the importance of a server can be based not only on the server itself, but also on any application running on the server and / or on any data stored, maintained, retrieved, edited, and / or otherwise interacted with by the server). In various cases, different of the above-described artificial intelligence details can be applied to the machine learning classifier 702. In various aspects, the criticality component 120 can then generate a criticality factor 704 based on the importance level determined by the machine learning classifier 702.
[0084] For example, if the machine learning classifier 702 determines that the computing asset 104 is not very important to the goals / purposes / activities of the entity that owns / operates the computing asset 104, then the value of the criticality component 704 may be low (e.g., a banking institution may utilize a website for advertising purposes; because the website is not important to the goals / purposes / activities of the banking institution, the criticality factor 704 of the website may be 0). If the machine learning classifier 702 determines that the computing asset 104 is important to the goals / purposes / activities of the entity that owns / operates the computing asset 104, then the value of the criticality component 704 may be moderate (e.g., a banking institution may utilize a database for storing sensitive client information; because the database is important to the goals / purposes / activities of the banking institution, the criticality factor 704 of the database may be 1.3). If the machine learning classifier 702 determines that the computing asset 104 is very important to the goals / purposes / activities of the entity that owns / operates the computing asset 104, then the value of the criticality component 704 may be higher (e.g., a banking institution may utilize a software application for electronically transferring funds into and / or out of client accounts; because the software application is very important to the goals / purposes / activities of the banking institution, the criticality factor 704 of the software application may be 4.3). In various aspects, any suitable number of criticality levels / grades may be implemented (e.g., non-critical, critical, ultra-critical, and / or any other intermediate levels). In some embodiments, the entity that owns / operates the computing asset 104 may manually configure the criticality factor 704 as needed. As described above, conventional health check risk assessment techniques ignore the importance level of the computing asset.
[0085] Figure 8 A block diagram of an example non-limiting system 800 including a maturity factor that can facilitate automated health check risk assessment of computing assets according to one or more embodiments described herein is shown. As shown, in some cases, system 800 can include the same components as system 700, and can also include maturity factor 802.
[0086] Although not shown in the figures, in various embodiments, the maturity component 122 may electronically receive and / or retrieve recommended controls corresponding to the prescribed controls 108 from any suitable electronically accessible data source. In various aspects, as described above, the prescribed controls 108 may be viewed as rules, regulations, standards, and / or benchmarks established by an entity that owns / operates the computing assets 104 that should be followed by the state 106. However, in various cases, the recommended controls may be best practices implemented in the relevant industry, and the prescribed controls 108 may not match and / or be inconsistent with the recommended controls. Therefore, in some cases, the state 106 may comply with the prescribed controls 108 and still present a serious security threat because the prescribed controls 108 may be more relaxed and / or less stringent than the recommended controls. For example, assume that the prescribed controls 108 specify a maximum acceptable password age of 60 days, and the recommended controls specify a maximum acceptable password age of 30 days. If state 106 is an actual password age of 50 days, then state 106 may be considered compliant with prescribed controls 108, however state 106 may be a significant security threat because it does not comply with recommended controls (e.g., because prescribed state 108 is less stringent and / or less secure than recommended controls). In various aspects, the value of maturity factor 802 may therefore be any suitable function of the difference and / or deviation between prescribed controls 108 and recommended controls (e.g., may be proportional to a percentage difference and / or an absolute difference). As described above, conventional health check risk assessment techniques ignore such differences / deviations.
[0087] In some cases, as further explained below, computing assets 104 may be subject to and / or controlled by many different regulatory controls. In such cases, maturity factor 802 may be based on the average difference and / or average deviation between these different regulatory controls and their corresponding best practice values. If the average difference / deviation is greater than a first predetermined threshold, maturity factor 802 may take a first value. If the average difference / deviation is greater than a second predetermined threshold, maturity factor 802 may take a second value. Any suitable number of predetermined thresholds and / or values may be implemented.
[0088] Fig. 9 A block diagram of an example non-limiting system 900 including an adjustment component that can facilitate automatic health check risk assessment of computing assets according to one or more embodiments described herein is shown. As shown, in some cases, system 900 can include the same components as system 800, and can also include adjustment component 124.
[0089] In various embodiments, the adjustment component 124 may adjust the baseline health check risk score 202 based on the vulnerability factor 304, the environmental factor 504, the criticality factor 704, and / or the maturity factor 802. Specifically, the adjustment component 124 may multiply the baseline health check risk score 202 by the environmental factor 504, thereby producing a first product. In various aspects, the adjustment component 124 may add the vulnerability factor 304 to the first product, thereby producing a first sum. In various cases, the adjustment component 124 may multiply the first sum by the criticality component 704, thereby producing a second product. In various cases, the adjustment component 124 may multiply the second product by the maturity component 802, thereby producing an adjusted health check risk score 902. In other words, the adjusted health check risk score 902 may be given by:
[0090] ARS=(BRS*EF+WF)*CF*MF
[0091] Wherein ARS represents the adjusted health check risk score 902, where BRS represents the baseline health check risk score 202, where EF represents the environmental factor 504, where WF represents the vulnerability factor 304, where CF represents the criticality factor 704, and where MF represents the maturity factor 802. In various aspects, the above equations showing how ARS can be a function of BRS, EF, WF, CF, and MF are non-limiting examples of equations that can be used to generate the adjusted health check risk score 902, but other equations are possible. For example, the adjusted health check risk score 902 can be any other suitable mathematical function of the vulnerability factor 304, the environmental factor 504, the criticality factor 704, and / or the maturity factor 802 (e.g., EF can be added instead of multiplied, WF can be multiplied instead of added, CF can be added instead of multiplied, and MF can be added instead of multiplied). That is, in various embodiments, any other suitable equations and / or mathematical operations may be applied to the BRS, EF, WF, CF, and MF in any suitable permutation and / or combination to generate the ARS. In various cases, the adjusted health check risk score 902 may more accurately quantify the risk level associated with the state 106 not being compliant with the prescribed control 108 because the adjusted health check risk score 902 considers the severity / magnitude of the noncompliance (e.g., the vulnerability factor 304), the built-in security mechanisms of the computing asset 104 (e.g., the environmental factor 504), the importance of the computing asset 104 (e.g., the criticality factor 704), and / or the difference between the prescribed control 108 and the best practice (e.g., the maturity factor 802).
[0092] In various embodiments, the health check risk assessment system 102 may perform any suitable action based on the adjusted health check risk score 902. For example, the health check risk assessment system 102 may generate, transmit, and / or display an electronic warning / alert on a computer monitor / screen based on the adjusted health check risk score 902 (e.g., if the adjusted health check risk score 902 is above a predetermined threshold, a suitable warning / alert may be generated and / or displayed). In some cases, the health check risk assessment system 102 may automatically schedule, request, and / or obtain service / maintenance for the computing asset 104 based on the adjusted health check risk score 902 (e.g., if the adjusted health check risk score 902 exceeds a predetermined threshold, the health check risk assessment system 102 may automatically electronically contact a service / maintenance entity).
[0093] Fig.10 A block diagram of an example, non-limiting system 1000 is shown that includes an aggregation component that can facilitate automated health check risk assessment of computing assets in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein. As shown, system 1000 may include the same components as system 900 in some cases, and may also include aggregation component 1002.
[0094] The above description so far mainly explains how the health check risk assessment system 102 can generate an adjusted health check risk score 902 for a computing asset 104 based on the specified control 108. However, in different embodiments, a computing asset 104 can be controlled by multiple specified controls (in Fig.11 In such cases, health check risk assessment system 102 can generate / calculate a separate adjusted health check risk score for each of the plurality of prescribed controls that govern computing asset 104, and aggregation component 1002 can aggregate such adjusted health check risk scores together via any suitable technique (e.g., via a weighted average function, via a maximum function) to generate an aggregated health check risk score for computing asset 104. Furthermore, in some cases, health check risk assessment system 102 can be electronically coupled to a plurality of computing assets (in Fig.11 ). In various aspects, the health check risk assessment system 102 can calculate a separate aggregated health check risk score for each of the plurality of computing assets, and the aggregation component 1002 can aggregate such aggregated health check risk scores together via any suitable technique (e.g., via a weighted average function and / or a maximum function).
[0095] Fig.11A block diagram of an example, non-limiting computing asset hierarchy 1100 is shown according to one or more embodiments described herein. As shown, computing accounts 1102 may include multiple computing groups 1104. In addition, in some cases, multiple computing groups 1104 may include multiple computing assets 1106, which may be subject to and / or subject to multiple prescribed controls 1108. Specifically, multiple computing groups 1104 may include computing groups 1 to computing groups N of any suitable number N. In addition, as shown, computing group 1 itself may correspond to multiple computing assets (e.g., computing asset 1_1 to computing asset 1_M for any suitable number M). Similarly, computing group N may correspond to multiple computing assets (e.g., computing asset N_1 to computing asset N_M for any suitable number M). Although computing group 1 and computing group N are depicted as having the same number of computing assets, this is a non-limiting example. In various cases, they may have different numbers of computing assets. In various aspects, computing asset 1_1 can be subject to and / or dominated by multiple specified controls (e.g., control 1_1_1 to control 1_1_P, for any appropriate number P). Similarly, computing asset N_M can be subject to and / or dominated by multiple specified controls (e.g., control N_M_1 to control N_M_P, for any appropriate number P). Although computing asset 1_1 and computing asset N_M are depicted as being subject to the same number of specified controls, this is a non-limiting example. In various cases, they can be subject to different numbers of specified controls.
[0096] As described above, the health check risk assessment system 102 can generate an adjusted health check risk score for each of the plurality of prescribed controls 1108 (e.g., a baseline health check risk score can be calculated for each prescribed control, a vulnerability factor for each prescribed control, an environmental factor for each prescribed control, a criticality factor for each prescribed control, and / or a maturity factor for each prescribed control, and these can be combined together by the adjustment component 124 to calculate an adjusted health check risk score for each prescribed control, thereby producing a total of N*M*P adjusted health check risk scores). In different instances, for each of the plurality of computing assets 1106, the aggregation component 1002 can aggregate together the computing asset (e.g., all adjusted health check risk scores associated with the computing asset). via a weighted average and / or maximum function) to form an aggregated asset health check risk score for the computing assets (e.g., the adjusted health check risk scores associated with computing asset 1_1 can be aggregated to generate an aggregated asset health check risk score for computing asset 1_1, the adjusted health check risk scores belonging to computing asset 1_M can be aggregated to generate an aggregated asset health check risk score for computing asset 1_M, the adjusted health check risk scores regarding computing asset N_1 can be aggregated to generate an aggregated asset health check risk score for computing asset N_1, and the adjusted health check risk scores regarding computing asset N_M can be aggregated to generate an aggregated asset health check risk score for computing asset N_M, thereby producing a total of N*M aggregated asset health check risk scores). In different embodiments, for each of the multiple computing groups 1104, the aggregation component 1002 can aggregate all aggregated asset health check risk scores associated with the computing group (e.g., one or more computing groups). The aggregated group health check risk scores may be aggregated together (e.g., via a weighted average and / or maximum function) to form an aggregated group health check risk score for the compute group (e.g., the aggregated asset health check risk scores belonging to compute group 1 may be aggregated to generate an aggregated group health check risk score for compute group 1, and the aggregated asset health check risk scores belonging to compute group N may be aggregated to generate an aggregated group health check risk score for compute group N, resulting in a total of N aggregated group health check risk scores). Finally, in various aspects, the aggregation component 1002 may aggregate all of the aggregated group health check risk scores together (e.g., via a weighted average and / or maximum function) to generate an aggregated account health check risk score. In this manner, accurate health check risk scores may be generated at any suitable level of granularity (e.g., for each prescribed control, for each compute asset, for each compute group, and / or for each compute account).Thus, the health check risk assessment system 102 can make it easier for an operator to accurately categorize different non-compliant controls, different computing assets, different computing groups, and / or different computing accounts that constitute useful and practical applications of computing. In other words, the management, service, and / or maintenance of computing assets can be prioritized based on the adjusted and / or aggregated health check risk scores (e.g., computing assets / groups / accounts with higher health check risk scores can be considered more urgent and thus can be serviced first, while computing assets / groups / accounts with lower health check risk scores can be considered less urgent and thus can be serviced later).
[0097] Although the above discussion mentions that weighted averages and / or maximum functions can be used to aggregate health check risk scores to a higher level (e.g., aggregating computing assets to computing groups, and aggregating computing groups to computing accounts), this is a non-limiting example. In various aspects, any other suitable aggregation algorithm can be implemented. For example, the total risk of a computing group can be determined by counting the number of high-risk computing assets (e.g., if the aggregated asset health check risk score of the computing assets exceeds a high threshold, then the computing asset can be high risk), counting the number of medium-risk computing assets (e.g., if the aggregated asset health check risk score of the computing assets exceeds a medium threshold, then the computing asset can be medium risk), and / or counting the number of low-risk computing assets (e.g., in a computing group, if the aggregated asset health check risk score of the computing assets exceeds a low threshold), then the computing asset can be low risk. For example, if a computing group has more than 1% high-risk computing assets or more than 20% medium-risk computing assets, the computing group may be considered high risk; if a computing group has less than 1% high-risk computing assets, less than 20% medium-risk computing assets, or more than 50% low-risk computing assets, the computing group may be considered medium risk; otherwise, the computing group may be considered low risk.
[0098] Fig.12 12 is a flow chart showing an example, non-limiting computer-implemented method 1200 that can facilitate automatic health check risk assessment of computing assets in accordance with one or more embodiments described herein. Fig.12 The actions performed in are non-limiting examples and may be performed in any suitable order (e.g., not limited to Fig.12 ) are executed in the order shown in .
[0099] In various embodiments, action 1202 may include generating a baseline health check risk score (e.g., 202) for a computing asset (e.g., 104) corresponding to a noncompliance with a specified control (e.g., 108) by operating a device coupled to a processor (e.g., 114).
[0100] In various cases, action 1204 may include adjusting, by the device (e.g., 116), a baseline health check risk score based on a vulnerability factor (e.g., 304) of a specified control, where the vulnerability factor may be based on a magnitude by which a state of the computing asset (e.g., 106) deviates from the specified control.
[0101] In various aspects, action 1206 may include adjusting, by a device (eg, 118 ), the baseline health check risk score based on an environmental factor (eg, 504 ) of the computing asset, where the environmental factor may be based on a security mechanism or security protocol associated with the computing asset.
[0102] In various cases, action 1208 may include adjusting, by a device (eg, 120 ), the baseline health check risk score based on a criticality factor (eg, 704 ) of the computing asset, where the criticality factor may be based on a level of importance of the computing asset.
[0103] In various cases, action 1210 may include adjusting, by a device (eg, 122 ), a baseline health check risk score based on calculating a maturity factor (eg, 802 ) for the asset, where the maturity factor may be based on a difference between a prescribed control and a recommended control.
[0104] It should be understood that the numerical values, percentages and / or thresholds disclosed herein are non-limiting examples. In various aspects, any other suitable values, percentages and / or thresholds may be implemented.
[0105] Although the description herein explains that artificial intelligence paradigms can be used to generate / calculate weakness factors 304, environmental factors 504, criticality factors 704, and / or maturity factors 802, this is a non-limiting example. In various aspects, such factors can be generated / calculated via any suitable technology, whether or not machine learning is implemented.
[0106] Many of the above discussions use password age and / or password length as examples to illustrate the above teachings. These examples should be understood to be non-limiting. In different situations, the teachings herein can be applied to any suitable state, characteristic, and / or technical attribute of a computing asset.
[0107] Various embodiments of the present invention constitute a computerized diagnostic tool that can monitor one or more computing assets for compliance and / or non-compliance with one or more prescribed controls, and can accordingly generate / calculate an adjusted health check risk score that quantifies the security risk associated with such compliance and / or non-compliance. This can allow an operational entity to prioritize which non-compliant issues / assets to service first (e.g., divert). Furthermore, as explained above, an adjusted health check risk score as described herein can be more accurate than conventionally known baseline health check risk scores because various embodiments of the present invention can take into account the magnitude of non-compliance, asset criticality, and / or control maturity.
[0108] To provide additional context for the various embodiments described herein, Fig.13 The following discussion is intended to provide a brief general description of a suitable computing environment 1300 in which different embodiments of the embodiments described herein may be implemented. Although the embodiments have been described above in the general context of computer-executable instructions that may be executed on one or more computers, those skilled in the art will recognize that the embodiments may also be implemented in conjunction with other program modules and / or as a combination of hardware and software.
[0109] Generally, program modules include routines, programs, components, data structures, etc. that perform specific tasks or implement specific abstract data types. In addition, those skilled in the art will recognize that the methods of the present invention can be practiced with other computer system configurations, including single-processor or multi-processor computer systems, minicomputers, mainframe computers, Internet of Things (IoT) devices, distributed computing systems, as well as personal computers, handheld computing devices, microprocessor-based or programmable consumer electronics, etc., each of which can be operably coupled to one or more associated devices.
[0110] The illustrated embodiments of the embodiments herein may also be practiced in distributed computing environments where certain tasks are performed by remote processing devices that are linked through a communications network. In a distributed computing environment, program modules may be located in both local and remote memory storage devices.
[0111] Computing devices typically include various media, which may include computer-readable storage media, machine-readable storage media, and / or communication media, the two terms being used differently from each other herein as follows. Computer-readable storage media or machine-readable storage media may be any available storage media that can be accessed by a computer, and include volatile and non-volatile media, removable and non-removable media. By way of example and not limitation, computer-readable storage media or machine-readable storage media may be implemented in conjunction with any method or technology for storing information such as computer-readable or machine-readable instructions, program modules, structured data, or unstructured data.
[0112] Computer readable storage media may include, but are not limited to, random access memory (RAM), read-only memory (ROM), electrically erasable programmable read-only memory (EEPROM), flash memory or other memory technology, compact disk read-only memory (CDROM), digital versatile disk (DVD), Blu-ray disk (BD) or other optical disk storage, magnetic cassettes, magnetic tape, magnetic disk storage or other magnetic storage devices, solid-state drives or other solid-state storage devices, or other tangible and / or non-transitory media that may be used to store the desired information. In this regard, the terms "tangible" or "non-transitory" as applied herein to storage, memory, or computer readable media should be understood as excluding only propagating transient signals per se as a modifier, and not as a disclaimer to all standard storage, memory, or computer readable media that propagate not only transient signals per se.
[0113] Computer-readable storage media may be accessed by one or more local or remote computing devices, such as via access requests, queries, or other data retrieval protocols, for various operations relative to the information stored on the media.
[0114] Communication media typically embodies computer readable instructions, data structures, program modules, or other structured or unstructured data as a data signal such as a modulated data signal (e.g., a carrier wave or other transport mechanism), and includes any information delivery or transmission media. The term "modulated data signal" refers to a signal that has one or more of its characteristics set or changed in a manner that encodes information in one or more signals. By way of example, and not limitation, communication media includes wired media such as a wired network or direct-wired connection, and wireless media such as acoustic, RF, infrared and other wireless media.
[0115] Reference again Fig.13 , an exemplary environment 1300 for implementing various embodiments of aspects described herein includes a computer 1302, which includes a processing unit 1304, a system memory 1306, and a system bus 1308. The system bus 1308 couples system components including, but not limited to, the system memory 1306 to the processing unit 1304. The processing unit 1304 can be any of a variety of commercially available processors. Dual microprocessors and other multi-processor architectures can also be used as the processing unit 1304.
[0116] The system bus 1308 may be any of several types of bus structures capable of further interconnecting to a memory bus (with or without a memory controller), a peripheral bus, and a local bus using any of a variety of commercially available bus architectures. The system memory 1306 includes a ROM 1310 and a RAM 1312. The basic input / output system (B1OS) may be stored in a nonvolatile memory such as a ROM, an erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM), an EEPROM, and the BIOS contains basic routines such as those that help transfer information between elements within the computer 1302 during startup. The RAM 1312 may also include a high-speed RAM such as a static RAM for caching data.
[0117] The computer 1302 further includes an internal hard disk drive (HDD) 1314 (e.g., EIDE, SATA), one or more external storage devices 1316 (e.g., a magnetic floppy disk drive (FDD) 1316, a memory stick or flash drive reader, a memory card reader, etc.), and a drive 1320 (e.g., such as a solid-state drive, an optical drive, which can read or write from a disk 1322 such as a CD-ROM disk, a DVD, a BD, etc.). Alternatively, in the case of a solid-state drive, the disk 1322 will not be included unless it is separate. Although the internal HDD 1314 is illustrated as being located within the computer 1302, the internal HDD 1314 can also be configured for external use in a suitable chassis (not shown). In addition, although not shown in the environment 1300, a solid-state drive (SSD) can be used as a supplement or replacement for the HDD 1314. The HDD 1314, external storage device 1316, and drive 1320 can be connected to the system bus 1308 via a HDD interface 1324, an external storage interface 1326, and a drive interface 1328, respectively. The interface 1324 for external drive implementations may include at least one or both of Universal Serial Bus (USB) and Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) 1394 interface technologies. Other external drive connection technologies are within the contemplation of the embodiments described herein.
[0118] The drives and their associated computer-readable storage media provide non-volatile storage of data, data structures, computer-executable instructions, etc. For the computer 1302, the drives and storage media accommodate the storage of any data in a suitable digital format. Although the above description of computer-readable storage media refers to corresponding types of storage devices, it should be understood by those skilled in the art that other types of storage media (whether currently existing or developed in the future) that can be read by a computer can also be used in the example operating environment, and further, any such storage media can contain computer-executable instructions for performing the methods described herein.
[0119] A number of program modules may be stored in the drives and RAM 1312, including an operating system 1330, one or more application programs 1332, other program modules 1334, and program data 1336. All or portions of the operating system, application programs, modules, and / or data may also be cached in RAM 1312. The systems and methods described herein may be implemented using different commercially available operating systems or combinations of operating systems.
[0120] Computer 1302 may optionally include emulation technology. For example, a hypervisor (not shown) or other intermediary may emulate a hardware environment for operating system 1330, and the emulated hardware may optionally communicate with the operating system 1330. Fig.13 1302. In this embodiment, the operating system 1330 may include a virtual machine (VM) in a plurality of VMs hosted at the computer 1302. In addition, the operating system 1330 may provide a runtime environment for the application 1332, such as a Java runtime environment or a .NET framework. The runtime environment is a consistent execution environment that allows the application 1332 to run on any operating system that includes a runtime environment. Similarly, the operating system 1330 may support containers, and the application 1332 may be in the form of containers, which are lightweight, independent, executable software packages that include, for example, code, runtime, system tools, system libraries, and settings for the application.
[0121] Further, the computer 1302 may enable a security module, such as a trusted processing module (TPM). For example, for a TPM, before loading the boot component, the boot component hashes the boot component in time and waits for the result to match the security value. This process may be performed at any layer in the code execution stack of the computer 1302, such as at the application execution level or at the operating system (OS) kernel level, thereby achieving security at any code execution level.
[0122] A user may enter commands and information into the computer 1302 through one or more wired / wireless input devices (e.g., a keyboard 1338, a touch screen 1340, and a pointing device such as a mouse 1342). Other input devices (not shown) may include a microphone, an infrared (IR) remote control, a radio frequency (RF) remote control, or other remote control, a joystick, a virtual reality controller and / or a virtual reality headset, a game controller, a stylus, an image input device (e.g., a camera), a gesture sensor input device, a visual movement sensor input device, an emotion or facial detection device, a biometric input device (e.g., a fingerprint or iris scanner), or the like. These and other input devices are often connected to the processing unit 1304 through an input device interface 1344 that may be coupled to the system bus 1308, but may be connected through other interfaces such as a parallel port, an IEEE 1394 serial port, a game port, a USB port, an IR interface, a Interfaces, etc.
[0123] A monitor 1346 or other type of display device may also be connected to the system bus 1308 via an interface, such as a video adapter 1348. In addition to the monitor 1346, computers typically include other peripheral output devices (not shown) such as speakers, printers, and the like.
[0124] The computer 1302 can operate in a networked environment using logical connections via wired and / or wireless communications to one or more remote computers, such as one or more remote computers 1350. The remote computers 1350 can be workstations, server computers, routers, personal computers, portable computers, microprocessor-based entertainment devices, peer devices, or other public network nodes, and typically include many or all of the elements described relative to the computer 1302, but for simplicity, only the memory / storage device 1352 is shown. The depicted logical connections include wired / wireless connections to a local area network (LAN) 1354 and / or a larger network, such as a wide area network (WAN) 1356. Such LAN and WAN networking environments are common in offices and companies, and facilitate enterprise-wide computer networks, such as intranets, all of which can be connected to a global communication network, such as the Internet.
[0125] When used in a LAN networking environment, the computer 1302 can be connected to the local network 1354 through a wired and / or wireless communication network interface or adapter 1358. The adapter 1358 can facilitate wired or wireless communication to the LAN 1354, which can also include a wireless access point (AP) deployed thereon for communicating with the adapter 1358 in a wireless mode.
[0126] When used in a WAN networking environment, the computer 1302 may include a modem 1360 or may be connected to a communication server on the WAN 1356 via other means for establishing communications over the WAN 1356, such as through the Internet. The modem 1360, which may be internal or external and a wired or wireless device, may be connected to the system bus 1308 via the input device interface 1344. In a networked environment, program modules depicted relative to the computer 1302, or portions thereof, may be stored in the remote memory / storage device 1352. It should be appreciated that the network connections shown are examples and other means of establishing a communications link between the computers may be used.
[0127] When used in a LAN or WAN networking environment, the computer 1302 may access a cloud storage system or other network-based storage system, in addition to or in lieu of the external storage device 1316 described above, such as, but not limited to, a network virtual machine that provides one or more aspects of storage or processing of information. Typically, the connection between the computer 1302 and the cloud storage system may be established, for example, through an adapter 1358 or a modem 1360 over a LAN 1354 or WAN 1356, respectively. When the computer 1302 is connected to the associated cloud storage system, the external storage interface 1326 may manage the storage provided by the cloud storage system with the aid of the adapter 1358 and / or the modem 1360, as with other types of external storage. For example, the external storage interface 1326 may be configured to provide access to cloud storage sources as if those sources were physically connected to the computer 1302.
[0128] The computer 1302 may be operable to communicate with any wireless device or entity operable to be placed in wireless communication, such as, for example, a printer, a scanner, a desktop and / or portable computer, a portable data assistant, a communication satellite, any piece of equipment or location associated with a wirelessly detectable tag (e.g., a self-service terminal, a news station, a store shelf, etc.), and a telephone. This may include Wireless Fidelity (Wi-Fi) and Wireless technologies. Thereby, the communication can be a predefined structure like a conventional network or an ad hoc communication between at least two devices.
[0129] See now Fig.14 , depicts an illustrative cloud computing environment 1400. As shown, cloud computing environment 1400 includes one or more cloud computing nodes 1402, with which local computing devices used by cloud consumers (such as, for example, personal digital assistants (PDAs) or cellular phones 1404, desktop computers 1406, laptop computers 1408, and / or automotive computer systems 1410) can communicate. Nodes 1402 can communicate with each other. They can be physically or virtually grouped (not shown) in one or more networks, such as private clouds, community clouds, public clouds, or hybrid clouds, or combinations thereof, as described above. This allows cloud computing environment 1400 to provide infrastructure, platforms, and / or software as services for which cloud consumers do not need to maintain resources on local computing devices. It should be understood that Fig.14 The types of computing devices 1404 - 1410 shown in are intended to be illustrative only, and computing node 1402 and cloud computing environment 1400 may communicate with any type of computerized device over any type of network and / or network-addressable connection (eg, using a web browser).
[0130] See now Fig.15 , showing a cloud computing environment 1400 ( Fig.14 ) provides a set of functional abstraction layers. For the sake of brevity, repeated descriptions of similar elements used in other embodiments described herein are omitted. It should be understood in advance that Fig.15 The components, layers, and functions shown in are intended to be illustrative only, and embodiments of the present invention are not limited thereto. As described, the following layers and corresponding functions are provided.
[0131] The hardware and software layer 1502 includes hardware and software components. Examples of hardware components include: host 1504; server 1506 based on RISC (Reduced Instruction Set Computer) architecture; server 1508; blade server 1510; storage device 1512; and network and networking components 1514. In some embodiments, software components include network application server software 1516 and database software 1518.
[0132] Virtualization layer 1515 provides an abstraction layer from which the following examples of virtual entities can be provided: virtual servers 1522 ; virtual storage 1524 ; virtual networks 1526 , including virtual private networks; virtual applications and operating systems 1528 ; and virtual clients 1530 .
[0133] In one example, the management layer 1532 may provide the functionality described below. Resource provisioning 1534 provides dynamic procurement of computing resources and other resources for performing tasks within a cloud computing environment. Metering and pricing 1536 provides cost tracking when resources are utilized within a cloud computing environment, and bills or invoices for the consumption of these resources. In one example, these resources may include application software licenses. Security provides authentication for cloud consumers and tasks, as well as protection for data and other resources. User portal 1538 provides access to the cloud computing environment for consumers and system administrators. Service level management 1540 provides cloud computing resource allocation and management so that the required service levels are met. Service level agreement (SLA) planning and fulfillment 1542 provides pre-scheduling and procurement for cloud computing resources, anticipating future requirements for the cloud computing resources based on the SLA.
[0134] Workload layer 1544 provides examples of functionality that can take advantage of a cloud computing environment. Examples of workloads and functionality that can be provided from this layer include: mapping and navigation 1546; software development and lifecycle management 1548; virtual classroom education delivery 1550; data analytics processing 1552; transaction processing 1554; and differentiated private federated learning processing 1556. Various embodiments of the present invention can utilize reference Fig.14 and Fig.15 The cloud computing environment described is used to perform one or more differentiated private federated learning processes according to different embodiments described herein.
[0135] The present invention can be a system, method, device and / or computer program product on any possible technical details integration. The computer program product may include a computer-readable storage medium (or multiple media) having a computer-readable program instruction for causing a processor to execute various aspects of the present invention. The computer-readable storage medium may be a tangible device that can retain and store instructions for use by an instruction execution device. The computer-readable storage medium may be, for example but not limited to, an electronic storage device, a magnetic storage device, an optical storage device, an electromagnetic storage device, a semiconductor storage device, or any suitable combination of the above. A non-exhaustive list of more specific examples of computer-readable storage media may also include the following: a portable computer disk, a hard disk, a random access memory (RAM), a read-only memory (ROM), an erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM or flash memory), a static random access memory (SRAM), a portable compact disk read-only memory (CD-ROM), a digital versatile disk (DVD), a memory stick, a floppy disk, a mechanical encoding device such as a punch card or a protruding structure in a groove with instructions recorded thereon, and any suitable combination of the above. Computer-readable storage media as used herein should not be construed as transitory signals per se, such as radio waves or other freely propagating electromagnetic waves, electromagnetic waves propagating through waveguides or other transmission media (e.g., light pulses passing through fiber optic cables), or electrical signals transmitted through wires.
[0136] The computer-readable program instructions described herein can be downloaded from a computer-readable storage medium to a corresponding computing / processing device via a network (e.g., the Internet, a local area network, a wide area network, and / or a wireless network), or downloaded to an external computer or external storage device. The network can include copper transmission cables, optical transmission fibers, wireless transmissions, routers, firewalls, switches, gateway computers, and / or edge servers. The network adapter card or network interface in each computing / processing device receives the computer-readable program instructions from the network, and forwards the computer-readable program instructions to be stored in the computer-readable storage medium in the corresponding computing / processing device. The computer-readable program instructions for performing the operation of the present invention can be assembly instructions, instruction set architecture (ISA) instructions, machine instructions, machine-related instructions, microcodes, firmware instructions, state setting data, configuration data of an integrated circuit, or source code or object code written in any combination of one or more programming languages, and these programming languages include object-oriented programming languages (such as Smalltalk, C++, etc.) and process programming languages (such as "C" programming languages or similar programming languages). Computer readable program instructions can be executed completely on a user's computer, partially on a user's computer, as an independent software package, partially on a user's computer, partially on a remote computer, or completely on a remote computer or server. In the latter case, the remote computer can be connected to the user's computer through any type of network (including a local area network (LAN) or a wide area network (WAN)), or can be connected to an external computer (for example, using an Internet service provider through the Internet). In certain embodiments, electronic circuits including, for example, programmable logic circuits, field programmable gate arrays (FPGAs), or programmable logic arrays (PLAs) can perform computer readable program instructions by utilizing the state information of computer readable program instructions to personalize the electronic circuits so as to perform aspects of the present invention.
[0137] The present invention will be described below with reference to the flowchart and / or block diagram of the method, device (system) and computer program product according to an embodiment of the present invention.It should be understood that each square frame of the flowchart and / or block diagram and the combination of each square frame in the flowchart and / or block diagram can be realized by computer-readable program instructions.These computer-readable program instructions can be provided to the processor of a general-purpose computer, a special-purpose computer or other programmable data processing device to produce a machine, so that the instructions executed by the processor of the computer or other programmable data processing device create a device for realizing the function / action specified in one or more boxes of the flowchart and / or block diagram.These computer-readable program instructions can also be stored in a computer-readable storage medium, and these instructions make the computer, programmable data processing device, and / or other equipment work in a specific manner, so that the computer-readable storage medium wherein the instruction is stored includes the manufacture of the instruction of the aspect of the function / action specified in one or more boxes in the flowchart and / or block diagram. Computer-readable program instructions may also be loaded onto a computer, other programmable data processing apparatus, or other device, so that a series of operational actions are performed on the computer, other programmable apparatus, or other device to produce computer-implemented processing, so that the instructions executed on the computer, other programmable apparatus, or other device implement the functions / actions specified in one or more boxes of the flowchart and / or block diagram.
[0138] The flow charts and block diagrams in the accompanying drawings show the architecture, functions and operations of the possible implementations of the system, method and computer program product according to different embodiments of the present invention. To this end, each box in the flow chart or block diagram may represent a module, segment or part of an instruction, which includes one or more executable instructions for implementing a specified logical function. In some alternative implementations, the functions marked in the box may not occur in the order marked in the figure. For example, depending on the functions involved, the two blocks shown in succession can actually be executed substantially simultaneously, or these blocks can sometimes be executed in reverse order. It should also be noted that each box in the block diagram and / or flow chart, and the combination of the boxes in the block diagram and / or flow chart can be implemented with a dedicated hardware-based system that performs a specified function or action or performs a combination of dedicated hardware and computer instructions.
[0139] Although the subject matter has been described above in the general context of computer executable instructions of computer program products running on computers and / or computers, it will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that the present disclosure may also be implemented or combined with other program modules. Typically, program modules include routines, programs, components, data structures, etc. that perform specific tasks and / or implement specific abstract data types. In addition, it will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that the computer-implemented method of the present invention may be practiced with other computer system configurations, including single-processor or multi-processor computer systems, small computing devices, large computers, and computers, handheld computing devices (e.g., PDAs, phones), microprocessor-based or programmable consumer or industrial electronics, etc. The aspects shown may also be implemented in a distributed computing environment, in which tasks are performed by remote processing devices linked by a communication network. However, some (if not all) aspects of the present invention may be practiced on stand-alone computers. In a distributed computing environment, program modules may be located in both local and remote memory storage devices.
[0140] As used in this application, the terms "component", "system", "platform", "interface", etc. may refer to and / or may include computer-related entities or entities related to an operating machine having one or more specific functions. The entities disclosed herein may be hardware, a combination of hardware and software, software, or software in execution. For example, a component may be, but is not limited to, a process, a processor, an object, an executable file, an execution thread, a program, and / or a computer running on a processor. As an illustration, both an application running on a server and a server may be a component. One or more components may reside within a process and / or a thread of execution, and a component may be located on one computer and / or distributed between two or more computers. In another example, a corresponding component may be executed from different computer-readable media having different data structures stored thereon. Components may communicate via local and / or remote processes, such as according to a signal having one or more data packets (e.g., data from a component interacting with another component in a local system, a distributed system, and / or data from a component interacting with other systems across a network such as the Internet via the signal). As another example, a component may be a device having a specific functionality provided by a mechanical component operated by an electrical or electronic circuit that is operated by a software or firmware application executed by a processor. In such a case, the processor may be internal or external to the device and may execute at least a portion of the software or firmware application. As yet another example, a component may be a device that provides a specific functionality by an electronic component without a mechanical component, wherein the electronic component may include a processor or other device for executing software or firmware that at least partially imparts the functionality to the electronic component. In one aspect, the component may simulate the electronic component via, for example, a virtual machine within a cloud computing system.
[0141] In addition, the term "or" is intended to mean an inclusive "or" rather than an exclusive "or". That is, unless otherwise specified or clear from the context, "X employs A or B" is intended to mean any natural inclusive arrangement. That is, if X employs A; X employs B; or X employs both A and B, then "X employs A or B" is satisfied in any of the foregoing cases. In addition, the articles "a" and "an" as used in the subject specification and drawings should generally be interpreted as meaning "one or more", unless otherwise specified or clear from the context to point to the singular form. As used herein, the terms "example" and / or "exemplary" are used to indicate use as an example, instance, or illustration. For the avoidance of doubt, the subject matter disclosed herein is not limited to such examples. In addition, any aspect or design described herein as an "example" and / or "exemplary" is not necessarily to be construed as superior or preferred to other aspects or designs, nor is it meant to exclude equivalent exemplary structures and techniques known to those of ordinary skill in the art.
[0142] As used in this specification, the term "processor" may refer to substantially any computational processing unit or device, including but not limited to a single-core processor; a single processor with software multithreaded execution capability; a multi-core processor; a multi-core processor with software multithreaded execution capability; a multi-core processor with hardware multithreading technology; a parallel platform; and a parallel platform with distributed shared memory. In addition, a processor may refer to an integrated circuit, an application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a digital signal processor (DSP), a field programmable gate array (FPGA), a programmable logic controller (PLC), a complex programmable logic device (CPLD), discrete gate or transistor logic, discrete hardware components, or any combination thereof, designed to perform the functions described herein. Further, the processor may utilize nanoscale architectures, such as but not limited to molecular and quantum dot-based transistors, switches, and gates, in order to optimize space usage or enhance the performance of user devices. The processor may also be implemented as a combination of computational processing units. In this disclosure, terms such as "storage," "storage," "data storage," "data store," "database," and substantially any other information storage component related to the operation and functionality of a component are used to refer to a "memory component," an "entity embodied in a "memory," or a component that includes a memory. It should be understood that the memory and / or memory components described herein may be volatile memory or non-volatile memory, or may include both volatile memory and non-volatile memory. By way of example and not limitation, non-volatile memory may include read-only memory (ROM), programmable ROM (PROM), electrically programmable ROM (EPROM), electrically erasable ROM (EEPROM), flash memory, or non-volatile random access memory (RAM) (e.g., ferroelectric RAM ( Volatile memory may include, for example, RAM that may act as an external cache memory. By way of illustration and not limitation, RAM may be available in many forms, such as synchronous RAM (SRAM), dynamic RAM (DRAM), synchronous DRAM (SDRAM), double data rate SDRAM (DDRSDRAM), enhanced SDRAM (ESDRAM), Synchlink DRAM (SLDRAM), direct Rambus RAM (DRRAM), direct Rambus dynamic RAM (DRDRAM), and Rambus dynamic RAM (RDRAM). In addition, the memory components of the systems or computer-implemented methods disclosed herein are intended to include, but are not limited to, these and any other suitable types of memory.
[0143] What has been described above includes only examples of systems and computer-implemented methods. Of course, for purposes of describing the present disclosure, it is not possible to describe every conceivable combination of components or computer-implemented methods, but one of ordinary skill in the art will recognize that many further combinations and permutations of the present disclosure are possible. In addition, to the extent that the terms "includes," "has," "possesses," and the like are used in the detailed description, claims, appendices, and drawings, these terms are intended to be inclusive in a manner similar to the term "comprising," as "comprising" is interpreted when "comprising" is used as a transitional word in a claim.
[0144] The description of different embodiments has been presented for the purpose of illustration, but is not intended to be exhaustive or limited to the disclosed embodiments. Many modifications and variations will be apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art without departing from the scope of the described embodiments. The terminology used herein is selected to best explain the principles of the embodiments, practical applications, or technical improvements over technologies found in the marketplace, or to enable those of ordinary skill in the art to understand the embodiments disclosed herein.
Claims
1. A system comprising: A processor that executes computer executable components stored in the memory, the computer executable components comprising: A baseline component that generates a baseline health check risk score corresponding to a computing asset not complying with a specified control; A weakness component, wherein the weakness component determines, via a machine learning model, a weakness category to which the prescribed control belongs based on one or more control documents describing the prescribed control, the weakness category comprising a passive weakness, a direct active weakness, and an indirect active weakness, wherein: The passive weakness indicates that non-compliance with regulatory controls may enable an attacker to prevent the computing asset from performing authorized actions, The indirect active weakness indicates that noncompliance with a prescribed control may enable an attacker to perform unauthorized actions on the computing asset, and an exploit of the prescribed control is known to exist, and The direct active weakness indicates that noncompliance with a prescribed control may enable an attacker to perform unauthorized actions on a computing asset, and exploitation of the prescribed control is not known to exist, wherein a vulnerability factor of the prescribed control is assigned based on the vulnerability category; an adjustment component that adjusts the baseline health check risk score based on a vulnerability factor of the prescribed control to produce an adjusted health check risk score, wherein the vulnerability factor is based on a magnitude by which a state of the computing asset deviates from the prescribed control; and In response to the adjusted health check risk score satisfying a condition associated with a predetermined threshold, shutting down the computing asset.
2. The system of claim 1, wherein the adjustment component further adjusts the baseline health check risk score based on an environmental factor of the computing asset, wherein the environmental factor is based on a security mechanism or security protocol associated with the computing asset.
3. The system of claim 2, wherein the adjustment component further adjusts the baseline health check risk score based on a criticality factor of the computing asset, wherein the criticality factor is based on an importance level associated with the computing asset.
4. The system of claim 3, wherein the adjustment component further adjusts the baseline health check risk score based on a maturity factor of the computing asset, wherein the maturity factor is based on a difference between the prescribed control and the recommended control.
5. The system according to claim 4, wherein: At least one of the vulnerability factor, the environmental factor, the criticality factor, or the maturity factor is generated using a machine learning model.
6. A system according to claim 4, wherein the adjustment component multiplies the baseline health check risk score by the environmental factor to produce a first quantity, adds the vulnerability factor to the first quantity to produce a second quantity, multiplies the criticality factor by the second quantity to produce a third quantity, and multiplies the maturity factor by the third quantity to produce an adjusted health check risk score corresponding to the non-compliance of the computing asset with the specified control.
7. The system of claim 1, further comprising: An aggregation component aggregates the adjusted health check risk score with a plurality of other adjusted health check risk scores corresponding to a plurality of other prescribed controls by applying a weighted average or a maximum function to the adjusted health check risk score and the plurality of other adjusted health check risk scores.
8. A computer-implemented method comprising: generating, by a device operatively coupled to the processor, a baseline health check risk score corresponding to a computing asset not being in compliance with a prescribed control; The device determines, via a machine learning model, a vulnerability category to which the prescribed control belongs based on one or more control documents describing the prescribed control, the vulnerability category comprising passive weaknesses, direct active weaknesses, and indirect active weaknesses, wherein: The passive weakness indicates that non-compliance with regulatory controls may enable an attacker to prevent the computing asset from performing authorized actions, The indirect active weakness indicates that noncompliance with a prescribed control may enable an attacker to perform unauthorized actions on the computing asset, and an exploit of the prescribed control is known to exist, and The direct active weakness indicates that noncompliance with a prescribed control may enable an attacker to perform unauthorized actions on a computing asset, and exploitation of the prescribed control is not known to exist, wherein a vulnerability factor of the prescribed control is assigned based on the vulnerability category; adjusting, by the device, the baseline health check risk score based on a vulnerability factor for the prescribed control to produce an adjusted health check risk score, wherein the vulnerability factor is based on a magnitude by which a state of the computing asset deviates from the prescribed control; and In response to the adjusted health check risk score satisfying a condition associated with a predetermined threshold, shutting down the computing asset.
9. The computer-implemented method of claim 8, further comprising: The baseline health check risk score is adjusted, by the device, based on an environmental factor of the computing asset, wherein the environmental factor is based on a security mechanism or a security protocol associated with the computing asset.
10. The computer-implemented method of claim 9, further comprising: The baseline health check risk score is adjusted, by the device, based on a criticality factor of the computing asset, wherein the criticality factor is based on an importance level associated with the computing asset.
11. The computer-implemented method of claim 10, further comprising: The baseline health check risk score is adjusted, by the device, based on a maturity factor of the computing asset, wherein the maturity factor is based on a difference between the prescribed control and the recommended control.
12. The computer-implemented method of claim 11 , further comprising: At least one of the vulnerability factor, the environmental factor, the criticality factor, or the maturity factor is generated by the device using a machine learning model.
13. The computer-implemented method of claim 11 , further comprising: multiplying, by the device, the baseline health check risk score and the environmental factor to produce a first quantity; adding, by the device, the weakness factor to the first quantity, thereby producing a second quantity; multiplying the criticality factor by the second quantity using the device to produce a third quantity; as well as The device multiplies the maturity factor by the third quantity to produce an adjusted health check risk score corresponding to the non-compliance of the computing asset with the prescribed control.
14. The computer-implemented method of claim 8, further comprising: The device aggregates the adjusted health check risk score with a plurality of other adjusted health check risk scores corresponding to a plurality of other prescribed controls by applying a weighted average or a maximum function to the adjusted health check risk score and the plurality of other adjusted health check risk scores.
15. A computer program product for facilitating automated health check risk assessment of computing assets, the computer program product comprising a computer readable memory having program instructions embodied therein, the program instructions executable by a processor to cause the processor to: generating, by the processor, a baseline health check risk score corresponding to the computing asset not being in compliance with a specified control; The processor determines, via a machine learning model, a vulnerability category to which the prescribed control belongs based on one or more control documents describing the prescribed control, the vulnerability category comprising a passive vulnerability, a direct active vulnerability, and an indirect active vulnerability, wherein: The passive weakness indicates that non-compliance with regulatory controls may enable an attacker to prevent the computing asset from performing authorized actions, The indirect active weakness indicates that noncompliance with a prescribed control may enable an attacker to perform unauthorized actions on the computing asset, and an exploit of the prescribed control is known to exist, and The direct active weakness indicates that noncompliance with a prescribed control may enable an attacker to perform unauthorized actions on a computing asset, and exploitation of the prescribed control is not known to exist, wherein a vulnerability factor of the prescribed control is assigned based on the vulnerability category; adjusting, by the processor, the baseline health check risk score based on a vulnerability factor of the prescribed control to produce an adjusted health check risk score, wherein the vulnerability factor is based on a magnitude by which a state of the computing asset deviates from the prescribed control; as well as In response to the adjusted health check risk score satisfying a condition associated with a predetermined threshold, shutting down the computing asset.
16. The computer program product of claim 15, wherein: The program instructions are further executable to cause the processor to: The baseline health check risk score is adjusted, by the processor, based on an environmental factor of the computing asset, wherein the environmental factor is based on a security mechanism or a security protocol associated with the computing asset.
17. The computer program product of claim 16, wherein: The program instructions are further executable to cause the processor to: The baseline health check risk score is adjusted, by the processor, based on a criticality factor of the computing asset, wherein the criticality factor is based on an importance level associated with the computing asset.
18. The computer program product of claim 17, wherein: The program instructions are further executable to cause the processor to: The baseline health check risk score is adjusted, by the processor, based on a maturity factor of the computing asset, wherein the maturity factor is based on a difference between the prescribed control and the recommended control.
19. The computer program product of claim 18, wherein: The program instructions are further executable to cause the processor to: At least one of the vulnerability factor, the environmental factor, the criticality factor, or the maturity factor is generated by the processor using a machine learning model.
20. The computer program product of claim 19, wherein: The program instructions are further executable to cause the processor to: multiplying, by the processor, the baseline health check risk score and the environmental factor to produce a first quantity; adding, by the processor, the weakness factor to the first quantity to produce a second quantity; multiplying, by the processor, the criticality factor by the second quantity to produce a third quantity; as well as The maturity factor is multiplied by the third amount by the processor to produce an adjusted health check risk score corresponding to the non-compliance of the computing asset with the prescribed control.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Industrial device and system attestation in a cloud platform
CN104142663A
Agentless baseline profile compilation for application monitoring solution
CN104572232A
Gas turbine engine health determination
CN105986907A
Component based risk system
US8478628B1
Method and apparatus for determining health state of information system
WO2015018266A1
