Regional security risk evaluation method and system based on combined empowerment

Through the combined empowered regional security risk assessment method, combined with the entropy weight method, Critic method and AHP method, a multi-level evaluation system was built, which solved the problems of incomplete evaluation and poor objectivity in the existing technology, and achieved danger to the petrochemical industry Comprehensive and scientific risk assessment of chemical companies.

CN118941067APending Publication Date: 2024-11-12CHINA PETROLEUM & CHEMICAL CORP +1
View PDF 0 Cites 5 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202310531831.0
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-05-11
Publication Date
2024-11-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing regional safety risk assessment methods are incomplete and have poor objectivity, especially in the petrochemical industry, which lacks effective risk assessment methods for hazardous chemicals.

Method used

The regional security risk assessment method with combination empowerment is adopted, and the operation data of hazardous chemical companies is collected, and the entropy weight method and Critic method is combined for objective empowerment, and the hierarchical analysis method and AHP method are used for subjective empowerment to construct multi-level evaluation. System, calculates the combined weights of each indicator, calculates risk scores and rank ranking based on the Topsis method.

Benefits of technology

A comprehensive and objective assessment of regional safety risks has been achieved, the scientificity and accuracy of risk assessment has been improved, and the major safety risks of hazardous chemical companies can be better reflected.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118941067A_ABST
    Figure CN118941067A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The embodiment of the invention provides a regional security risk evaluation method and system based on combined empowerment, and belongs to the technical field of risk evaluation. The method comprises the following steps: acquiring operation data of each hazardous chemical enterprise in a region; based on different preset objective weighting methods, objective weights of the evaluation indexes under the objective weighting methods are obtained respectively, and based on the objective weights of the evaluation indexes under the objective weighting methods, objective comprehensive weights of the evaluation indexes are obtained; based on the objective comprehensive weights of the evaluation indexes, objective weights of the first-level indexes are obtained, and subjective weights of the first-level indexes are obtained based on a subjective weighting method; and based on the objective weight and the subjective weight, obtaining a combined weight of the first-level indexes, and based on the combined weight of each first-level index, performing regional security risk evaluation of the corresponding region. According to the scheme, the problems of incomplete evaluation and poor objectivity of an existing regional safety risk evaluation method are solved.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of risk assessment, and in particular to a combined weighted regional safety risk assessment method and a combined weighted regional safety risk assessment system. Background Art

[0002] The petrochemical industry is one of the pillar industries for the development of the national economy. The hazardous chemicals involved in the production process of petrochemical enterprises have different degrees of harm in terms of physics, health, and environment. Once an accident occurs, it may cause casualties, property losses, and even secondary disasters, causing a greater social impact. In view of this problem, it is particularly important to accurately analyze and judge the major safety risks of hazardous chemicals and scientifically guide the prevention and control of major safety risks of hazardous chemicals to effectively prevent and resolve major safety risks of hazardous chemicals. Among the existing safety risk assessment methods, there are two main types of methods that are widely used. One is the subjective weighting method, including the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method, the expert consultation method (Delphi method), and the hierarchical analysis method; the other is the objective weighting method, including the coefficient of variation method, the standard deviation method, the entropy weight method, the critic weight method, the principal component analysis method, and the Topsis method. The objective weighting method mainly reflects the characteristics and mathematical properties of the original data, and there are errors with the actual situation. For example, the entropy weight method only considers the information entropy of the indicator to measure the weight, and the critic rule measures the weight based on the comparison strength of the indicator and the conflict between the indicators. The essence of the subjective weighting method is to use the knowledge and experience of experts to determine the importance of indicators to measure weights. It has a large subjective influence and cannot reflect the characteristics of real data.

[0003] At present, there are two main problems with the combined weighted risk assessment method. First, the risk assessment method is mainly used in the fields of transportation, production quality control, etc., and there are few related applications of regional hazardous chemicals major safety risk assessment methods; second, most combined weighted methods only consider a combination of an objective weighting method and a subjective weighting method, which does not fully reflect the characteristics of the original data and the actual situation. In view of the problems of incomplete evaluation and poor objectivity of the existing regional safety risk assessment methods, it is necessary to create a new regional safety risk assessment method. Summary of the invention

[0004] The purpose of the embodiments of the present invention is to provide a combined weighted regional security risk assessment method to at least solve the problems of incomplete assessment and poor objectivity in existing regional security risk assessment methods.

[0005] In order to achieve the above-mentioned purpose, the first aspect of the present invention provides a regional safety risk assessment method with combined weighting, which is used to evaluate the safety risk status in each designated area. The method includes: collecting operating data of each hazardous chemical enterprise in the area, and preprocessing the operating data to obtain evaluation data of preset evaluation indicators; based on different preset objective weighting methods, respectively obtaining the objective weights of each evaluation indicator under each objective weighting method, and based on the objective weights of each evaluation indicator under each objective weighting method, obtaining the objective comprehensive weight of each evaluation indicator; based on the objective comprehensive weight of the evaluation indicator, calculating the score of the evaluation indicator step by step through a preset multi-level evaluation system to obtain the objective weight of the first-level indicator, and obtaining the subjective weight of the first-level indicator based on the subjective weighting method; the first-level indicator is the top-level indicator of the multi-level evaluation system; based on the objective weight and the subjective weight, obtaining the combined weight of the first-level indicator, and performing regional safety risk assessment on the corresponding area based on the combined weight of each first-level indicator.

[0006] Optionally, the preprocessing of the operating data includes: classifying the operating data related to the preset evaluation indicators into corresponding evaluation indicators; based on the impact relationship between the corresponding evaluation indicators and the risks, distinguishing the evaluation indicators into positive indicators and negative indicators; and normalizing the operating data of the evaluation indicators to eliminate the dimensions.

[0007] Optionally, the preset evaluation indicators are: evaluation indicators of the indicator layer constructed based on the hierarchical analysis method for the preset target layer; the preset target layer includes: inherent risks, dynamic risks, personnel capabilities and qualities, digital and intelligent construction, and accident conditions.

[0008] Optionally, the objective weighting method includes: entropy weight method and critic method.

[0009] Optionally, the objective weights of each evaluation index under the entropy weight method are obtained based on the entropy weight method, including: calculating the information entropy and information redundancy of the preprocessed evaluation index based on the entropy weight method; and obtaining the first objective weight of the corresponding evaluation index based on the information entropy and information redundancy of the evaluation index.

[0010] Optionally, the objective weights of each evaluation indicator under the Critic method are obtained based on the Critic method, including: calculating the mean and standard deviation of the preprocessed evaluation indicators to obtain indicator variability; calculating the correlation coefficient between the preprocessed evaluation indicators to obtain indicator conflict; calculating the information amount of the evaluation indicators based on the indicator variability and the indicator conflict, and obtaining a second objective weight of the corresponding evaluation indicator based on the information amount.

[0011] Optionally, the objective comprehensive weight based on the evaluation index calculates the score of the evaluation index step by step through a preset multi-level evaluation system to obtain the objective weight of the first-level index, including: based on a simple weighted algorithm, performing a simple weighted calculation on the first objective weight and the second objective weight of the evaluation index to obtain the comprehensive weight of the superior evaluation index of the evaluation index; continuing to perform a simple weighted calculation based on the comprehensive weight of the superior evaluation index to obtain the comprehensive weight of the first-level index as the objective weight of the first-level index.

[0012] Optionally, the method also includes: constructing a preset multi-level evaluation system, including: taking the preset target layer as the first-level indicator, and obtaining the quasi-side layer indicators and indicator layer indicators of each first-level indicator through correlation splitting; wherein the quasi-side layer indicators are second-level indicators; and the indicator layer indicators are evaluation indicators.

[0013] Optionally, the subjective weight of the first-level indicator is obtained based on the subjective weighting method, including: obtaining the score of the first-level indicator based on the 1-9 digit scaling method; constructing a comparison judgment matrix based on the Delphi method and the scores of each first-level indicator; obtaining the corresponding AHP weight index based on the AHP method and the comparison judgment matrix; performing a consistency check on the comparison judgment matrix, determining that the corresponding AHP weight index is valid after the check passes, and obtaining the corresponding subjective weight of the first-level indicator.

[0014] Optionally, obtaining the combined weight of the first-level indicators based on the objective weight and the subjective weight includes: processing the objective weight and the subjective weight based on a multiplication and normalization method to obtain the combined weight of the first-level indicators.

[0015] Optionally, the safety risk assessment of each region is performed based on the combined weight of each first-level indicator, including: determining the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution of the safety risk assessment of each region based on the Topsis superior-inferior solution distance method; determining the weighted distance of each first-level indicator to the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution based on the combined weight of each first-level indicator; calculating the safety risk score of each region based on the weighted distance of each first-level indicator to the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution; and performing safety risk assessment and evaluation grade ranking of each region based on the safety risk score of each region.

[0016] The second aspect of the present invention provides a regional safety risk assessment system with combined weighting, which is used to evaluate the safety risk status in each designated area. The system includes: a collection unit, which collects the operating data of each hazardous chemical enterprise in the area, and pre-processes the operating data to obtain evaluation data of preset evaluation indicators; a processing unit, which is used to: based on different preset objective weighting methods, respectively obtain the objective weights of each evaluation indicator under each objective weighting method, and based on the objective weights of each evaluation indicator under each objective weighting method, obtain the objective comprehensive weight of each evaluation indicator; based on the objective comprehensive weight of the evaluation indicator, calculate the score of the evaluation indicator step by step through a preset multi-level evaluation system to obtain the objective weight of the first-level indicator, and obtain the subjective weight of the first-level indicator based on the subjective weighting method; the first-level indicator is the top-level indicator of the multi-level evaluation system; based on the objective weight and the subjective weight, obtain the combined weight of the first-level indicator, and perform regional safety risk assessment for the corresponding area based on the combined weight of each first-level indicator.

[0017] On the other hand, the present invention provides a computer-readable storage medium having instructions stored thereon, which, when executed on a computer, enables the computer to execute the above-mentioned combined weighted regional safety risk assessment method.

[0018] Through the above technical scheme, the scheme of the present invention constructs a multi-level key characteristic indicator system for major safety risks of hazardous chemicals. By collecting and obtaining data of hazardous chemical enterprises in each region, the improved entropy weight method and the Critic method-like objective weighting method are used to weight the three-level indicators respectively. The comprehensive weight of the indicator layer relative to the criterion layer, as well as the weight of the criterion layer to the target layer are obtained by the weighted method. The subjective weighting method weight of the target layer is calculated using the hierarchical analysis method, and an overall consistency test is performed. Combined with the comprehensive weight of the objective weighting method, the final combined weighting weight is obtained using the multiplication and normalization method. The risk score index of each region is calculated based on the Topsis superior and inferior solution distance method, and the risk index of each region is sorted and graded. The problems of incomplete evaluation and poor objectivity in the existing regional safety risk assessment methods are solved.

[0019] Other features and advantages of the embodiments of the present invention will be described in detail in the following detailed description. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0020] The accompanying drawings are used to provide a further understanding of the embodiments of the present invention and constitute a part of the specification. Together with the following specific embodiments, they are used to explain the embodiments of the present invention, but do not constitute a limitation on the embodiments of the present invention. In the accompanying drawings:

[0021] Figure 1 It is a flowchart of the steps of a combined weighted regional safety risk assessment method provided by an embodiment of the present invention;

[0022] Figure 2 It is a system structure diagram of a combined weighted regional safety risk assessment system provided by an embodiment of the present invention;

[0023] Figure 3 It is a structural diagram of a regional safety risk assessment system with combined weighting provided by one embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0024] The specific implementation of the present invention is described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. It should be understood that the specific implementation described here is only used to illustrate and explain the present invention, and is not used to limit the present invention.

[0025] The petrochemical industry is one of the pillar industries for the development of the national economy. The hazardous chemicals involved in the production process of petrochemical enterprises pose varying degrees of hazards in terms of physical, health, and environment. Once an accident occurs, it may cause casualties, property losses, and even secondary disasters, causing a greater social impact.

[0026] In view of this problem, it is particularly important to accurately analyze and judge the major safety risks of hazardous chemicals and scientifically guide the prevention and control of major safety risks of hazardous chemicals to effectively prevent and resolve major safety risks of hazardous chemicals. Among the existing safety risk assessment methods, there are two main types of methods that are widely used. One is the subjective weighting method, including fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method, expert consultation method (Delphi method), hierarchical analysis method, etc.; the other is the objective weighting method, including coefficient of variation method, standard deviation method, entropy weight method, critic weight method, principal component analysis method, Topsis method, etc. The objective weighting method mainly reflects the characteristics and mathematical properties of the original data, and there are errors with the actual situation. For example, the entropy weight method only considers the information entropy of the indicator to measure the weight, and the critic rule measures the weight based on the comparison strength of the indicator and the conflict between the indicators. The essence of the subjective weighting method is to use the knowledge and experience of experts to determine the importance of the indicator to measure the weight, which has a large subjective influence and cannot reflect the characteristics of the actual data.

[0027] At present, there are two main problems with the combined weighting risk assessment method. First, the risk assessment method is mainly used in the fields of transportation, production quality control, etc., and there are few related applications of regional hazardous chemicals major safety risk assessment methods; second, most combined weighting methods only consider a combination of an objective weighting method and a subjective weighting method, which does not fully reflect the characteristics of the original data and the actual situation.

[0028] In view of the problems of incomplete evaluation and poor objectivity in the existing regional safety risk assessment methods, the scheme of the present invention proposes a new combined weighted regional safety risk assessment method. The scheme of the present invention constructs a multi-level key characteristic indicator system for major safety risks of hazardous chemicals. The major safety risk assessment indicator system is divided into three levels according to the hierarchy: target layer (first-level indicator), criterion layer (second-level indicator) and indicator layer (third-level indicator). By collecting and obtaining data of hazardous chemical enterprises in each region, the three-level indicators are weighted respectively by using the improved entropy weight method and the Critic method-like objective weighting method, and the comprehensive weight of the indicator layer relative to the criterion layer and the weight of the criterion layer to the target layer are obtained by the weighted method. The subjective weighting method weight of the target layer is calculated by the hierarchical analysis method, and an overall consistency test is performed. Combined with the comprehensive weight of the objective weighting method, the final combined weighting weight is obtained by the multiplication and normalization method. The risk score index of each region is calculated based on the Topsis superior and inferior solution distance method, and the risk index of each region is sorted and graded.

[0029] Figure 1 1 is a method flow chart of a combined weighted regional security risk assessment method provided by an embodiment of the present invention. Figure 1 As shown, an embodiment of the present invention provides a combined weighted regional security risk assessment method, the method comprising:

[0030] Step S10: collecting the operating data of each hazardous chemical enterprise in each region, and preprocessing the operating data to obtain evaluation data of each preset evaluation index.

[0031] Specifically, the solution of the present invention is to evaluate the safety risk of the corresponding area based on the operating data of hazardous chemical enterprises in each region, collect real operating data, and then evaluate the safety risk of the corresponding area based on a pre-built multi-level evaluation system. Based on this, it is first necessary to collect the real operating data of each enterprise in the corresponding area.

[0032] In the existing enterprise management, in order to meet the needs of intelligent management, the corresponding hazardous chemical enterprises are equipped with corresponding integrated management systems. Preferably, the combined weighted regional safety risk assessment method proposed in the scheme of the present invention is directly connected to the integrated management system of these enterprises, and the operation data of the corresponding enterprises are obtained through the integrated management system. In order to protect the security of the core data of the enterprise, the security level of various data is preset, and the corresponding low-level operation data is opened based on the actual situation. As long as the evaluation requirements can be met, the remaining data can be protected by the preset security level. While completing the safety risk assessment of each region, the core data of each hazardous chemical enterprise will not be leaked.

[0033] Preferably, the collected operating data comes from all workshops and all equipment, but only a part of the data will cause safety risks. In order to ensure the accuracy of the subsequent safety risk assessment, it is preferably necessary to preprocess the collected data to ensure that the data finally obtained can accurately conduct safety risk assessment. Furthermore, the safety risk of a region is a combination system composed of multiple factors. It is not affected by only one indicator, but the coupling of various factors. Therefore, in order to accurately and comprehensively conduct a regional safety risk assessment, it is necessary to split all possible influencing factors and then evaluate these factors separately. And the degree of influence of various influencing factors on the final safety risk is different. Therefore, the constructed evaluation system also needs to consider the influence weights of various evaluation factors, and weight them by the degree of influence to ensure that the final evaluation results are in line with the actual situation.

[0034] Based on this, the scheme of the present invention includes: constructing a preset multi-level evaluation system, including: taking the preset target layer as the first-level indicator, and obtaining the quasi-side layer indicators and indicator layer indicators of each first-level indicator through correlation splitting; wherein the quasi-side layer indicators are second-level indicators; and the indicator layer indicators are evaluation indicators.

[0035] Preferably, the preset target layers include: inherent risks, dynamic risks, personnel capabilities and qualities, digital and intelligent construction, and accident situations.

[0036] Preferably, the preprocessing of the operating data includes: classifying these related operating data into corresponding evaluation indicators based on the preset operating data related to each evaluation indicator; distinguishing each evaluation indicator into positive indicators and negative indicators based on the impact relationship between each corresponding evaluation indicator and the risk; and normalizing the operating data of each evaluation indicator to eliminate the dimension.

[0037] In one possible implementation, a framework for a major safety risk index evaluation system for hazardous chemicals is constructed, and the specific steps are as follows: based on the actual situation of major risk hazards and accidents in hazardous chemical companies, the main influencing factors of the major safety risk index are analyzed, and a target layer (first-level indicator) is constructed from five aspects, namely, the company's inherent risks, dynamic risks, personnel capabilities and qualities, digital and intelligent construction, and accident situations; based on the five constructed target layers, further refine and analyze, and construct a criterion layer (second-level indicator) under the target layer, and an indicator layer (third-level indicator) under the criterion layer, and provide calculation formulas and value descriptions for the indicator data.

[0038] Furthermore, by collecting and acquiring data from hazardous chemical companies in each region, a risk index evaluation system was constructed, and indicators were calculated according to the formula. According to the numerical meaning of the original data, the indicators that are positively correlated with major risks are marked as positive indicators, and the indicators that are negatively correlated with major risks are marked as negative indicators. The indicator data are normalized to eliminate the original data dimension and convert the data to the range of [0,1].

[0039] Step S20: Based on a plurality of preset objective weighting methods, objective weights of the evaluation indicators under each objective weighting method are obtained respectively, and based on the weights of the evaluation indicators under each objective weighting method, objective comprehensive weights of the evaluation indicators are obtained.

[0040] Specifically, the preset multiple different objective weighting methods include: entropy weight method and critic method. Obtaining the objective weight of each evaluation indicator based on the entropy weight method includes: calculating the information entropy and information redundancy of each evaluation indicator after preprocessing based on the entropy weight method; obtaining the first objective weight corresponding to each indicator based on the information entropy and information redundancy of each evaluation indicator. Obtaining the objective weight of each evaluation indicator based on the critic method includes: calculating the mean and standard deviation of each evaluation indicator after preprocessing to obtain indicator variability; calculating the correlation coefficient between each evaluation indicator after preprocessing to obtain indicator conflict; calculating the amount of information of each evaluation indicator based on the indicator variability and the indicator conflict, and obtaining the second objective weight of each evaluation indicator based on the information amount.

[0041] In a possible implementation, different objective weighting methods are used to weight the three-level indicators in five aspects: inherent risk, dynamic risk, personnel capability and quality, digital intelligent construction, and accident situation. Combining the weight of each objective weighting method, the comprehensive weight of the objective weighting method at the indicator layer relative to the criterion layer is obtained. The improved entropy weight method is used to weight the three-level indicators respectively. The proportion of each area under each indicator is calculated, and the formula is given and the information entropy and information redundancy of each indicator are calculated to obtain the entropy weight method weight. The three-level indicators are weighted respectively using the Critic method. First, the mean and standard deviation of each indicator are calculated to obtain the indicator variability and the Critic method weight. Secondly, the correlation coefficient between the indicators is calculated to obtain the indicator conflict. According to the variability and conflict, the amount of information of each indicator is calculated, and the Critic method weight is obtained.

[0042] Step S30: Based on the objective comprehensive weight of each evaluation indicator, the score of each indicator is calculated step by step through a preset multi-level evaluation system to obtain the objective weight of each first-level indicator, and the subjective weight of each first-level indicator is obtained based on the subjective weighting method.

[0043] Specifically, based on a simple weighted algorithm, the first objective weight and the second objective weight of each evaluation indicator are weighted to obtain the comprehensive weight of the superior evaluation indicator of the corresponding evaluation indicator; simple weighting is continued based on the comprehensive weight of all superior indicators to obtain the comprehensive weight of each first-level indicator as the objective weight of each first-level indicator.

[0044] In a possible implementation, the entropy weight method weight and the critic weight are combined by a simple weighting method to obtain the comprehensive weight of the three-level indicators under the objective weighting method, and the corresponding weight of the secondary indicator can be obtained by adding them.

[0045] Step S40: Based on the objective weight and the subjective weight, a combined weight of each primary indicator is obtained, and a safety risk assessment of each area is performed based on the combined weight.

[0046] Specifically, based on the 1-9 digit scaling method, the scores of each primary indicator are obtained; based on the Delphi method and the scores of each primary indicator, a comparison judgment matrix is ​​constructed; based on the AHP method and the comparison judgment matrix, the corresponding AHP weight index is obtained; the comparison judgment matrix is ​​subjected to a consistency check, and after the check is passed, the corresponding AHP weight index is determined to be valid, and the corresponding subjective weight of each primary indicator is obtained.

[0047] In one possible implementation, the indicators of the target layer are scored using a 1-9 digit scaling method. The Delphi method is combined to construct a comparative judgment matrix. The weight index and the maximum characteristic root under the AHP method are calculated by using the judgment matrix using the AHP method. The inconsistency index is calculated, the random consistency index is consulted, and the judgment matrix is ​​tested for overall consistency to determine the validity of the weights of the subjective assignment method. If the consistency test fails, the subjective weighting step is repeated until the consistency check passes.

[0048] Furthermore, the objective weight and the subjective weight are processed based on the multiplication and normalization method to obtain the combined weight of each primary indicator, and the combined weight of each indicator is calculated using the multiplication and normalization method.

[0049] Preferably, the safety risk assessment of each region based on the combined weight includes: determining the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution of the safety risk assessment of each region based on the Topsis superior-inferior solution distance method; determining the weighted distance of each first-level indicator to the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution based on the combined weight of each first-level indicator; calculating the safety risk score of each region based on the weighted distance of each first-level indicator to the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution; and performing safety risk assessment and evaluation level ranking for each region based on the safety risk score.

[0050] In one possible implementation, the risk score of each area is calculated and ranked, and the risk index of each area is graded accordingly. Based on the Topsis superior-inferior solution distance method, the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution are determined. According to the combined weight obtained by combining the subjective and objective weighting methods, the weighted distance of each indicator to the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution is defined. Finally, the major risk score of hazardous chemicals in each preset area is calculated based on the distance, and the risk level of each preset area is ranked and divided.

[0051] In the embodiments of the present invention, common risk assessment methods in the prior art are mainly used in the fields of transportation, quality control, etc. The major safety risk index evaluation method constructed by the present invention is mainly used in the field of safe production of hazardous chemicals. It selects risk data of different types of hazardous chemicals to display the major risk situations of each region from multiple dimensions. The combined weighting method in the prior art is more of a comprehensive weighting of subjective and objective methods, and does not consider the situation of multi-level indicators. The present invention adopts a subjective weighting method for the target layer indicators, and an objective weighting method for the three-level indicators under each target layer indicator. The established evaluation index method is more scientific and reasonable.

[0052] Example 1: Performing a security risk assessment based on an actual area, the specific steps are as follows:

[0053] Step 1: Based on the actual situation of major risks and accidents in hazardous chemical companies, analyze the main influencing factors of the major safety risk index, and construct the target layer (first-level indicator) from five aspects: inherent risks, dynamic risks, personnel capabilities and qualities, digital and intelligent construction, and accident situations of the company.

[0054] Step 2: Further refine and analyze the five target layers, respectively construct the criterion layer (secondary indicators) under the target layer, and the indicator layer (third-level indicators) under the criterion layer, and give the calculation formula and value description of the indicator data. The specific division rules are shown in Table 1:

[0055]

[0056]

[0057]

[0058] Table 1 Rules for constructing a multi-level evaluation system

[0059] Step 3: Collect data from hazardous chemical companies in each preset area, build a risk index evaluation system, and calculate indicators.

[0060] Step 4: Normalize the indicator data to eliminate the dimension of the original data and make it within the range of [0,1]. According to the numerical meaning of the original data, the indicators that are positively correlated with major risks are marked as positive indicators, and the indicators that are negatively correlated with major risks are marked as negative indicators. After normalization, they are recorded as X' ij . It is expressed as:

[0061] Positive indicators:

[0062]

[0063] Negative indicators:

[0064]

[0065] For the convenience of expression, X' ij Note: X ij .

[0066] Step 5: Use different objective weighting methods to assign weights to the three-level indicators in the five aspects of inherent risk, dynamic risk, personnel ability and quality, digital intelligent construction, and accident situation. Combine the weights of each objective weighting method to obtain the objective weighting method comprehensive weight of the indicator layer relative to the criterion layer, and then obtain the objective weighting method comprehensive weight of the target layer to the criterion layer by summing them up. The specific steps are:

[0067] 1) The improved entropy weight method is used to assign weights to the three-level indicators respectively, and the entropy weight method weight w1 is obtained.

[0068] 2) Use the Critic method to assign weights to the three-level indicators respectively and obtain the Critic method weight w2.

[0069] 3) By weighting, the entropy weight method weight w1 in S1 and the critic weight w2 in S2 are combined to obtain the objective weighting method comprehensive weight w:

[0070] w j =αw1 j +βw2 j

[0071] Among them, α+β=1. Then the weight of the criterion layer indicator can be obtained by adding the weight of the corresponding indicator layer indicators.

[0072] Step 6: Use the subjective weighting method to calculate the subjective weighting weight λ of the target layer indicators. Specifically:

[0073] 1) Use the Delphi method to score the indicators of the target layer and construct a comparative judgment matrix.

[0074] 2) The weight index λ is calculated by using the AHP method through the judgment matrix, and an overall consistency test is performed.

[0075] Step 7: Combine the comprehensive weight w of the objective weighting method in step 3 and the weight λ of the subjective weighting method in step 4, and use the multiplication and normalization method to calculate the combined weight W of each indicator:

[0076]

[0077] Step eight: Calculate the risk score S of each area, and classify the risk index S of each area accordingly. Based on the Topsis superior-inferior solution distance method, calculate the major risk score S of hazardous chemicals in each preset area according to the weight W obtained by subjective and objective combined weighting, and classify the risk level of each preset area according to S. Through the above steps one to six, a combined weighted regional major safety risk evaluation index system of an embodiment of the present invention, compared with other evaluation systems, adopts a method combining the improved entropy weight method and the Critic method to obtain the objective weighting method weight, which can more comprehensively extract the original data features, and adopt the subjective weighting method and the objective weighting method of AHP to combine and obtain the weights, which is more in line with the actual situation of major risks of hazardous chemical enterprises.

[0078] Embodiment 2:

[0079] For the above step 6: using the improved entropy weight method to weight the three-level indicators to obtain the weight w1. Specifically, the following steps are included:

[0080] 1) Calculate the proportion p of the jth region under the jth indicator ij

[0081]

[0082] 2) Calculate the entropy value e of the jth indicator j , considering the use of normalized original data, the calculation of p ij The present invention makes a simple improvement to the information entropy formula, assuming that when the proportion is 0, the information entropy is also 0, so:

[0083]

[0084] where k = 1 / ln(n)>0, satisfying e j ≥0.

[0085] 3) Calculate the information entropy redundancy d j

[0086] d j =1-e j

[0087] 4) Calculate the weight w1 of each indicator j

[0088]

[0089] Embodiment three:

[0090] The above step 5 uses the Critic method to weight the three-level indicators and obtain the weight w2. Specifically, it includes the following steps:

[0091] 1) Calculate the index variability s j , expressed in the form of standard deviation, namely:

[0092]

[0093] 2) Calculate the index conflict R j , expressed in the form of correlation coefficient, namely:

[0094]

[0095] Among them, r kl is the Pearson correlation coefficient between indicators k and l, and the calculation formula is:

[0096]

[0097] 3) Calculate the information content c of the indicator j

[0098] c j =s j *R j

[0099] 4) Calculate the weight w2 of each indicator j

[0100]

[0101] Embodiment 4:

[0102] In step 6 above, the Delphi method is used to score the indicators of the target layer and construct a comparative judgment matrix. Specific steps:

[0103] 1) Invite some experts in the field of chemical safety management to judge and score the secondary indicators based on their actual experience using a 1-9 digit scale. The scoring rules are shown in Table 2:

[0104] Importance meaning illustrate 1 Equally important Both factors are equally important 3 Slightly important Factor 1 is slightly more important than factor 2 5 Clearly important Factor 1 is significantly more important than factor 2 7 Very important Factor 1 is much more important than factor 2 9 Extremely important Factor 1 is much more important than Factor 2 Even numbers: 2, 4, 6, 8 The middle value of the above adjacent judgments Countdown (1 / 3, 1 / 6) The degree to which factor 1 is less important than factor 2

[0105] Table 2 Subjective assignment rules

[0106] 2) After weighing the two using the Delphi method, the judgment value is given, and the judgment matrix A of the criterion layer to the target layer is constructed.

[0107] Embodiment five:

[0108] In step 6 above, the weight index λ is calculated by using the AHP method through the judgment matrix, and an overall consistency test is performed. Specific steps:

[0109] 1) Using the square root method, multiply and normalize the rows of the judgment matrix A to obtain the eigenvector λ j . And calculate the largest eigenvalue of the matrix:

[0110]

[0111] 2) Perform consistency check on the judgment matrix A and calculate the inconsistency index CI of the judgment matrix:

[0112]

[0113] Where n represents the order of the judgment matrix. CI = 0, with complete consistency. The larger the CI, the more serious the inconsistency. Judgment is made based on the random consistency index RI:

[0114]

[0115] It is believed that the judgment matrix has complete consistency and can better reflect the relative importance of each indicator, and the weight λ of the subjective weighting method under the AHP method is obtained. j Otherwise, rebuild the judgment matrix A and repeat the consistency check steps.

[0116] The Topsis superior-inferior solution distance method is used to calculate the major risk score S of hazardous chemicals in each preset area, and the risk level of each preset area is divided according to the ranking result of S. Specific steps:

[0117] 1) Determine the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution: define the maximum value of each normalized indicator as the positive ideal solution:

[0118]

[0119] Define each normalized minimum index as a negative ideal solution:

[0120]

[0121] 2) Calculate the weighted distance between the data of each preset area and the positive (negative) ideal solution:

[0122]

[0123]

[0124] 3) Calculate the comprehensive score S of major risks in each preset area:

[0125]

[0126] The higher the comprehensive score of major risks, the greater the major security risks in the preset area.

[0127] Figure 2 : is a system structure diagram of a combined weighted regional security risk assessment system provided by an embodiment of the present invention. Figure 2 As shown, an embodiment of the present invention provides a regional safety risk assessment system with combined weights, and the system includes: a collection unit, which is used to collect operation data of each hazardous chemical enterprise in each region, and pre-process the operation data to obtain evaluation data of preset evaluation indicators; a processing unit, which is used to: based on a plurality of preset objective weighting methods, respectively obtain the objective weights of each evaluation indicator under each objective weighting method, and based on the weights of each evaluation indicator under each objective weighting method, obtain the objective comprehensive weight of each evaluation indicator; based on the objective comprehensive weight of each evaluation indicator, calculate the score of each indicator step by step upward through a preset multi-level evaluation system to obtain the objective weight of each first-level indicator, and obtain the subjective weight of each first-level indicator based on the subjective weighting method; an evaluation unit, which is used to obtain the combined weight of each first-level indicator based on the objective weight and the subjective weight, and perform safety risk assessment of each region based on the combined weight.

[0128] Preferably, the acquisition unit includes a data collection module and a data preprocessing module; the processing unit includes a subjective weighting method module and an objective weighting method module; and the evaluation unit includes a risk index score calculation module and a risk index score output module.

[0129] Embodiment six:

[0130] like Figure 3 ,construct a combined weighted regional safety risk assessment system, including: data collection module, data preprocessing module, subjective weighting method module, objective weighting method module, risk index score calculation module, and risk index score output module. The data collection module is an independent terminal set up in the enterprise to collect data related to major risks of hazardous chemical enterprises in various regions.

[0131] The data processing module is used to clean, deduplicate, delete and supplement the data collected by the data collection module. The indicator data is classified into positive and negative indicators, normalized and stored.

[0132] The subjective weighting method module uses the AHP subjective weighting method to assign weights to the target layer indicators.

[0133] The objective weighting method module uses the objective weighting method to assign weights to the three-level indicators in the target layer.

[0134] The risk index score calculation module calculates the risk index score of each area using the Topsis method.

[0135] The risk index score output module is used to grade the risk index of each area and present it in a visual form.

[0136] In an embodiment of the present invention, the combined weighted regional safety risk assessment system proposed in the scheme of the present invention can comprehensively collect and mine major safety risk data of hazardous chemicals, and through combined weight calculation and judgment, can comprehensively and effectively reflect the major safety risk status of each region.

[0137] The embodiment of the present invention further provides a computer-readable storage medium, on which instructions are stored, which, when executed on a computer, enable the computer to execute the above-mentioned combined weighted regional safety risk assessment method.

[0138] Those skilled in the art will understand that all or part of the steps in the method for implementing the above-mentioned embodiments can be completed by instructing the relevant hardware through a program, and the program is stored in a storage medium, including several instructions for making a single-chip microcomputer, a chip or a processor (processor) perform all or part of the steps of the method described in each embodiment of the present invention. The aforementioned storage medium includes: U disk, mobile hard disk, read-only memory (ROM, Read-Only Memory), random access memory (RAM, Random Access Memory), disk or optical disk and other media that can store program codes.

[0139] The optional embodiments of the present invention are described in detail above in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. However, the embodiments of the present invention are not limited to the specific details in the above embodiments. Within the technical concept of the embodiments of the present invention, the technical scheme of the embodiments of the present invention can be subjected to a variety of simple modifications, and these simple modifications all belong to the protection scope of the embodiments of the present invention. It should also be noted that the various specific technical features described in the above specific embodiments can be combined in any suitable manner without contradiction. In order to avoid unnecessary repetition, the embodiments of the present invention will not further describe various possible combinations.

[0140] In addition, various embodiments of the present invention may be arbitrarily combined, and as long as they do not violate the concept of the embodiments of the present invention, they should also be regarded as the contents disclosed in the embodiments of the present invention.

Claims

1. A combined weighted regional security risk assessment method for evaluating the security risk status in each defined area, characterized in that: The method comprises: Collecting the operating data of each hazardous chemical enterprise in the region, and preprocessing the operating data to obtain evaluation data of preset evaluation indicators; Based on different preset objective weighting methods, the objective weights of each evaluation indicator under each objective weighting method are obtained respectively, and based on the objective weights of each evaluation indicator under each objective weighting method, the objective comprehensive weights of each evaluation indicator are obtained; Based on the objective comprehensive weight of the evaluation index, the score of the evaluation index is calculated step by step through a preset multi-level evaluation system to obtain the objective weight of the first-level index, and the subjective weight of the first-level index is obtained based on the subjective weighting method; the first-level index is the top-level index of the multi-level evaluation system; Based on the objective weight and the subjective weight, the combined weight of the first-level indicators is obtained, and based on the combined weight of each first-level indicator, a regional safety risk assessment of the corresponding area is performed.

2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The preprocessing of the operation data includes: Classify the operation data related to the preset evaluation indicators into corresponding evaluation indicators; Based on the impact relationship between the corresponding evaluation indicators and risks, the evaluation indicators are divided into positive indicators and negative indicators; The operating data of the evaluation indicators are normalized to eliminate the dimension.

3. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The preset evaluation index is: an evaluation index of an index layer constructed based on a preset target layer based on the analytic hierarchy process; The preset target layer includes: Inherent risks, dynamic risks, personnel capabilities and qualities, digital and intelligent construction, and accident situations.

4. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The objective weighting method includes: Entropy weight method and Critic method.

5. The method according to claim 4, characterized in that Based on the entropy weight method, the objective weights of each evaluation index under the entropy weight method are obtained, including: Based on the entropy weight method, the information entropy and information redundancy of the preprocessed evaluation indicators are calculated respectively; The first objective weight of the corresponding evaluation index is obtained based on the information entropy and information redundancy of the evaluation index.

6. The method according to claim 5, characterized in that Based on the Critic method, the objective weights of each evaluation index under the Critic method are obtained, including: Calculate the mean and standard deviation of the preprocessed evaluation index to obtain the index variability; Calculate the correlation coefficients between the preprocessed evaluation indicators to obtain the indicator conflict; The information amount of the evaluation indicator is calculated based on the indicator variability and the indicator conflict, and a second objective weight corresponding to the evaluation indicator is obtained based on the information amount.

7. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that The objective comprehensive weight based on the evaluation index is calculated by presetting a multi-level evaluation system to obtain the objective weight of the first-level index, including: Based on a simple weighted algorithm, a first objective weight and a second objective weight of the evaluation indicator are simply weighted to obtain a comprehensive weight of the parent evaluation indicator of the evaluation indicator; Based on the comprehensive weight of the superior evaluation index, simple weighted calculation is continued to obtain the comprehensive weight of the first-level index, which is used as the objective weight of the first-level index.

8. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The method further comprises: Construct a preset multi-level evaluation system, including: The preset target layer is taken as the first-level indicator, and the quasi-side layer indicators and indicator layer indicators of each first-level indicator are obtained through correlation splitting; among them, The quasi-lateral layer index is a secondary index; The indicator layer indicators are evaluation indicators.

9. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The subjective weight of the primary indicator obtained based on the subjective weighting method includes: Based on the 1-9 digit scale, the score of the first-level indicator is obtained; A comparative judgment matrix was constructed based on the Delphi method and the scores of each primary indicator; Based on the AHP method and the comparison judgment matrix, a corresponding AHP weight index is obtained; The comparison judgment matrix is ​​subjected to consistency check, and after the check is passed, the corresponding AHP weight index is determined to be valid, and the subjective weight of the corresponding primary index is obtained.

10. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The step of obtaining the combined weight of the primary indicator based on the objective weight and the subjective weight includes: The objective weight and the subjective weight are processed based on the multiplication and normalization method to obtain the combined weight of the primary indicator.

11. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The safety risk assessment of each region based on the combined weight of each primary indicator includes: Based on the Topsis good-bad solution distance method, the positive ideal solution and negative ideal solution of the safety risk assessment of each area are determined; Based on the combined weights of each first-level indicator, determine the weighted distances of each first-level indicator to the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution respectively; The safety risk score of each area is calculated based on the weighted distance of each primary indicator to the positive ideal solution and the negative ideal solution; Based on the security risk scores of each area, the security risk of each area is evaluated and the evaluation level is ranked.

12. A combined weighted regional safety risk assessment system for assessing the safety risk status within each designated area, characterized in that: The system comprises: A collection unit collects the operation data of each hazardous chemical enterprise in the region, and pre-processes the operation data to obtain evaluation data of preset evaluation indicators; A processing unit for: Based on different preset objective weighting methods, the objective weights of each evaluation indicator under each objective weighting method are obtained respectively, and based on the objective weights of each evaluation indicator under each objective weighting method, the objective comprehensive weights of each evaluation indicator are obtained; Based on the objective comprehensive weight of the evaluation index, the score of the evaluation index is calculated step by step through a preset multi-level evaluation system to obtain the objective weight of the first-level index, and the subjective weight of the first-level index is obtained based on the subjective weighting method; the first-level index is the top-level index of the multi-level evaluation system; The evaluation unit is used to obtain the combined weight of the first-level indicators based on the objective weight and the subjective weight, and to perform regional safety risk evaluation of the corresponding area based on the combined weight of each first-level indicator.

13. A computer-readable storage medium having instructions stored thereon, which, when executed on a computer, enables the computer to execute the combined weighted regional safety risk assessment method described in any one of claims 1 to 12.

Citation Information

Cited By

  • Multi-element multi-scale highway traffic operation risk assessment method and device

    CN119229657A

  • Holographic diagnosis method for fast moving consumer goods brands based on deep mining

    CN120471660A

  • Evaluation method and system for overall design of extra-long highway mountain tunnel

    CN121212568A

  • Driver behavior comprehensive evaluation method based on Ahp-entropy weight

    CN121412766A

  • Filling chamber operation environment multi-factor evaluation method

    CN122390476A