Graphical general killing chain construction and evaluation method
Through the graphical kill chain construction method, the subjectivity and mathematical modeling complexity of performance evaluation in kill chain research are solved, and fast and accurate kill chain combination scheme evaluation and optimization are achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202510652132.0
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2025-05-20
- Publication Date
- 2025-09-02
AI Technical Summary
The existing kill chain research has problems with insufficient subjectivity of performance evaluation and complexity of mathematical modeling, which affects rapidity and convergence.
A graphical general kill chain construction method is adopted, and a matrixed kill chain model is constructed, and the accessibility matrix is used to express it as a grid graph form. The kill chain combination scheme is obtained by traversing counterclockwise, and the reaction time, strike accuracy and firepower strike capability are calculated to establish an intuitive graphical closed-loop form.
It realizes the simplicity and speed of the kill chain construction process, provides an intuitive graphical closed-loop model, improves the accuracy and convergence of evaluation, and is suitable for engineering applications.
Smart Images

Figure CN120579309A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a collaborative combat system, and in particular to a graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method. Background Art
[0002] The kill chain is an agile, multi-platform collaborative combat system centered on firepower. It implements a closed-loop, interdependent, and sequentially executed mission model for striking battlefield targets, particularly time-sensitive ones. With the rise and implementation of combat styles such as multi-domain joint operations, mosaic warfare, and distributed collaborative operations, research on kill chain technology has garnered significant attention. Researchers both domestically and internationally have conducted a series of theoretical studies on the construction and evaluation of kill chains. However, existing research on kill chains primarily relies on qualitative analysis, and some literature's evaluation of kill chain effectiveness is subjective, potentially lacking objective and accurate results. Furthermore, some literature's mathematical modeling and calculation process for kill chains is complex, potentially lacking in speed and convergence.
[0003] Reference 1: Han Minglei, Ma Jing, Zhou Zeyu, et al. Research on naval battlefield kill chain evaluation system based on agent modeling [J]. Computer Simulation, 2022, 39(3): 11-16, 406. A hierarchical model of naval battlefield kill chain evaluation was designed, and an evaluation system based on HLA / RTI simulation framework and group decision-making hierarchical analysis method was constructed. This method is mainly qualitative analysis, and the group decision-making AHP method used relies on the subjective judgment of experts, which may lead to the evaluation indicators not being completely objective and accurate.
[0004] Reference 2: Wan Silai, Wang Guoxin, Ming Zhenjun, et al. Kill chain modeling and optimization method based on AGE-MOEA [J]. Acta Armamentarii, 2024, 45(8): 2617-2628. Aiming at the kill chain design problem of weapon equipment system, a kill chain modeling and optimization method based on adaptive geometric estimation multi-objective evolutionary algorithm is proposed. However, the mathematical modeling and calculation process of the kill chain of this method is relatively complicated, and there may be deficiencies in speed and convergence.
[0005] The above studies have the following problems:
[0006] First, the evaluation of kill chain effectiveness is subjective, and the results may not be objective and accurate.
[0007] Second, the mathematical modeling and calculation process of the kill chain is relatively complex, and there may be deficiencies in speed and convergence. Summary of the Invention
[0008] The purpose of the present invention is to propose a graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method.
[0009] The technical solution to achieve the purpose of the present invention is: a graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method, comprising the following steps:
[0010] Step 1: Kill chain matrix modeling: Based on the communication relationships among reconnaissance nodes, command nodes, firepower nodes, and targets in the closed kill chain system, a reachability matrix model for the nodes within the chain is constructed. The reachability matrix is expressed as a grid diagram. The kill chain combination solution is obtained by traversing the four regions of target → reconnaissance node → command node → firepower node → target in a counterclockwise manner.
[0011] Step 2: Kill chain combination plan evaluation: Calculate the kill chain's reaction time, strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability, evaluate the kill chain's performance, and determine the optimal kill chain combination plan.
[0012] Furthermore, step 1, kill chain matrix modeling: Based on the communication relationship between the reconnaissance node, command node, fire node and target in the closed system of the kill chain, a reachability matrix model of the nodes in the chain is constructed, and the reachability matrix is expressed as a grid diagram. Based on the four areas of target → reconnaissance node → command node → fire node → target, a counterclockwise traversal is taken to obtain the kill chain combination scheme, wherein: Based on the communication relationship between the reconnaissance node, command node, fire node and target in the closed system of the kill chain, a reachability matrix model of the nodes in the chain is constructed. The specific method is:
[0013] Set at a strike target t x Among the combat resources, there are l reconnaissance nodes, m command nodes, and n fire nodes. The set of reconnaissance nodes is O = (o1, o2, ..., o l ), the set of command nodes is C=(c1,c2,...,c m ), the set of firepower nodes is W=(w1,w2,...,w n ), a complete kill chain is represented by {o i 、c j 、w k , t x} is expressed by four elements, where the node numbers are i∈(1,…,l), j∈(1,…,m), and k∈(1,…,n);
[0014] Adopting the adjacency matrix construction form, a reachability matrix G0 containing the target is established. The rows and columns of the matrix are reconnaissance nodes, command nodes, fire nodes, and targets respectively. The reachability matrix is expressed as follows;
[0015]
[0016] Where f(a,b) is the reachability condition function between adjacent nodes a and b in the kill chain. The reachability between the reconnaissance node and the target refers to the reachable range of the reconnaissance node to the target; the reachability between the reconnaissance node and the command node, and between the command node and the fire node, refers to the reachable communication distance between them; the reachability of the fire node to the target refers to the reachable range of the fire node to the target. The definition formula is as follows:
[0017]
[0018] Among them, f(o i ,t x ) represents the reachability of the reconnaissance node to the target; f(w k ,t x ) represents the reachability of the firepower node to the target; f(o i ,c j )、f(c j ,w k ) represent the communication reachability from the reconnaissance node to the command node and from the command node to the fire node respectively.
[0019] Furthermore, let's assume a complete kill chain with a reachability closed loop connection of target → reconnaissance node → command node → fire node → target. While ensuring the reachability characteristics between all nodes in the kill chain, we retain the reachability elements while setting the other reachability elements to 0, forming the following kill chain closed loop reachability matrix G:
[0020]
[0021] The kill chain reachability matrix above only retains the reachability sub-regions between the four nodes, forming a counterclockwise closed loop of reachability “sub-blocks” from the upper right (target-reconnaissance node) → the upper left (reconnaissance node-command node) → the lower left (command node-firepower node) → the lower right (firepower node-target) → the upper right (target-reconnaissance node).
[0022] Furthermore, step 1, kill chain matrix modeling: Based on the communication relationship between the reconnaissance node, command node, fire node and target in the closed system of the kill chain, a reachability matrix model of the nodes in the chain is constructed, and the reachability matrix is expressed as a grid diagram. Based on the four areas of target → reconnaissance node → command node → fire node → target, a counterclockwise traversal is taken to obtain the kill chain combination scheme, wherein: the reachability matrix is expressed as a grid diagram, and the specific method is as follows:
[0023] In the grid diagram, 0 and 1 respectively express the reachability between nodes. The kill chain that meets the reachability selects the block with a value of 1, which is displayed in dark color. Otherwise, the block with a value of 0 is selected, which is displayed in white.
[0024] Furthermore, step 1, kill chain matrix modeling: Based on the communication relationship between the reconnaissance node, command node, fire node and target in the closed system of the kill chain, a reachability matrix model of the nodes in the chain is constructed, and the reachability matrix is expressed as a grid diagram. Based on the four areas of target → reconnaissance node → command node → fire node → target, a kill chain combination scheme is obtained by traversing in a counterclockwise manner. Among them, based on the four areas of target → reconnaissance node → command node → fire node → target, a kill chain combination scheme is obtained by traversing in a counterclockwise manner. The specific method is as follows:
[0025] Assume that the four dark rectangular areas in the matrix are labeled A, B, C, and D, where A is the reachability area between the target and the reconnaissance node, B is the reachability area between the reconnaissance node and the command node, C is the reachability area between the command node and the fire node, and D is the reachability area between the fire node and the target. The specific steps for searching for nodes in the kill chain based on the reachability matrix are as follows:
[0026] Step 1: For target t1, select the target and reconnaissance unit reachability blocks in area A in order. If the block diagram is 1, record the current row number o. i , go to step 2; if the block value is 0, find the block in the next row of column t1 in area A and repeat step 1;
[0027] Step 2: Select o in area B in order i The row's reachability block, if the block diagram is 1, records the current column number c j , go to step 3; if the block value is 0, find o in area B i Row the next column of blocks and repeat step 2;
[0028] Step 3: Select the C in the C area in order j The column's reachability block, if the block diagram is 1, records the current row number w k , go to step 4; if the block value is 0, search for c in area C j Arrange the next row of squares and repeat step 3;
[0029] Step 4: Select w in area D in order k The reachability block of the row, such as block 1, records the node selection of the kill chain t1-o respectively i -c j -w k ; If the block value is 0, it does not constitute a closed kill chain, and proceed to step 5;
[0030] Step 5, go to step 3 and select c in the C area j Next row of column w k+1 Blocks, until c j After the column traversal is completed, go to step 6;
[0031] Step 6, go to step 2 and select o in area B i The next column of blocks in the row, until o i After the row traversal is completed, go to step 7;
[0032] Step 7, go to step 1 and select the next row of column t1 in area A (o i+1 ) blocks until the t1 column is traversed.
[0033] Furthermore, step 2, kill chain combination scheme evaluation: calculate the kill chain reaction time, strike accuracy and firepower strike capability, evaluate the kill chain performance, and determine the optimal kill chain combination scheme. The specific method for calculating the kill chain reaction time is as follows:
[0034] The total time the kill chain takes to strike a target includes:
[0035] The reaction time of the reconnaissance unit is t observe ;
[0036] The command unit reaction time is t command ;
[0037] The reaction time of the firepower unit is recorded as t weapon ;
[0038] The above response times include the node’s local processing time and information transmission time;
[0039] t observe =t observe-deal +t observe-send
[0040] t command =t command-deal +t command-send
[0041] t weapon =t weapon-deal +t weapon-send
[0042] Among them, t observe-deal is the detection and signal processing time of the reconnaissance node, t observe-send The time it takes for the reconnaissance node to transmit target information to the command node, t command-deal is the time when command decision information is generated, t command-send is the time it takes for the command node to transmit information to the fire node, t weapon-deal Preparation time for shooting, t weapon-send The time for the ammunition to be released;
[0043] Therefore, the kill chain reaction time for a designated target is
[0044] t reaction =t observe-deal +t observe-send +t command-deal +t command-send +t weapon-deal
[0045] +t weapon-send
[0046] Among them, t observe-deal , t observe-send , t command-deal , t command-send and t weapon-deal Obtained through the performance parameters of the equipment itself or pre-arranged tests, t weapon-send Calculated based on the distance between the enemy and us and the exterior ballistic model.
[0047] Furthermore, step 2, kill chain combination scheme evaluation: calculate the kill chain's reaction time, strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability, evaluate the kill chain's performance, and determine the optimal kill chain combination scheme. Among them, the kill chain's strike accuracy is calculated. The specific method is:
[0048] The strike accuracy of the kill chain is closely related to the detection error of the reconnaissance node, the information processing error of the command node, and the shooting error of the fire node. The variance of the detection error is The variance of the command processing error is The variance of the weapon strike error is The above error terms are independent of each other, so the strike accuracy satisfies:
[0049]
[0050] Furthermore, step 2, kill chain combination scheme evaluation: calculate the reaction time, strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability of the kill chain, evaluate the performance of the kill chain, and determine the optimal kill chain combination scheme, including: calculating the firepower strike capability of the kill chain, the specific method is:
[0051] The firepower strike capability of the kill chain adopts a comprehensive damage capability evaluation system based on the benchmark ammunition, using the firepower index F k express;
[0052]
[0053] Among them, d represents the firepower platform w k Number of types of ammunition carried, N d is the number of d types of ammunition, ω dThe conversion coefficient of type D ammunition to a certain standard ammunition is based on different ammunition categories. Typical standard ammunition is selected from the categories and a conversion coefficient table for the standard ammunition is established.
[0054] Furthermore, step 2, kill chain combination scheme evaluation: calculate the kill chain's reaction time, strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability, evaluate the kill chain's performance, and determine the optimal kill chain combination scheme. The specific method for evaluating the kill chain's performance and determining the optimal kill chain combination scheme is as follows:
[0055] Based on actual battlefield requirements, the weights of various evaluation indicators are determined. The weight of the kill chain reaction time is c1, the weight of the kill chain system strike accuracy is c2, the weight of the kill chain firepower strike capability is c3, and the comprehensive capability of the kill chain is P. The expression of the kill chain comprehensive capability P is as follows:
[0056]
[0057] The kill chain with the largest comprehensive capability P is the optimal kill chain.
[0058] A graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation system implements the graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method to achieve graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation, and is divided into two modules, respectively performing steps 1 to 2.
[0059] A computer device includes a memory, a processor, and a computer program stored in the memory and executable on the processor. When the processor executes the computer program, the method for constructing and evaluating a graphical universal kill chain is implemented to achieve graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation.
[0060] A computer-readable storage medium stores a computer program. When executed by a processor, the computer program implements the wind turbine power curve extraction method based on the XAI method and the graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method, thereby realizing graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation.
[0061] Compared with the existing technology, the present invention has the following significant advantages: 1) the method model is simple and the algorithm is fast, which can accurately search all kill chain sets in a short time; 2) the kill chain construction model has an intuitive graphical closed-loop form, the mathematical logic framework of the chain construction process is clear, and it has good solution feasibility and result convergence, which is conducive to engineering applications. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0062] Figure 1 It is the reachability grid diagram of nodes in the kill chain.
[0063] Figure 2It is a graphical representation of the kill chain. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0064] In order to make the purpose, technical solutions and advantages of this application more clear, the following further describes this application in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are only used to explain this application and are not intended to limit this application.
[0065] This paper presents a graphical, universal kill chain construction and evaluation method that incorporates target nodes into a closed kill chain system, constructs a reachability matrix model for nodes within the chain, and provides a graphical representation of the kill chain and a quick kill chain search algorithm. Furthermore, to address the evaluation of multiple kill chains that may exist for a given target on the battlefield, evaluation metrics and calculation models for kill chain reaction time, system strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability are presented, providing quantitative support for the evaluation of multiple kill chains.
[0066] 1. Kill Chain Matrix Modeling
[0067] Considering the integrity of the elements of the kill chain, the present invention also incorporates the target to be attacked into the kill chain model system. Assume that in a strike target t x Among the combat resources, there are l reconnaissance nodes, m command nodes, and n fire nodes. The set of reconnaissance nodes is O = (o1, o2, ..., o l ), the set of command nodes is C=(c1,c2,...,c m ), the set of firepower nodes is W=(w1,w2,...,w n ), a complete kill chain is available {o i 、c j 、w k , t x} is expressed by four elements, where the node numbers are i∈(1,…,l), j∈(1,…,m), and k∈(1,…,n). To facilitate the description of the mathematical model of the kill chain, the present invention constructs a kill chain with one target as the attack object, that is, x=1.
[0068] Adopting the construction form of the adjacency matrix, the present invention establishes a reachability matrix G0 containing the target, where the rows and columns of the matrix are reconnaissance nodes, command nodes, firepower nodes, and targets, respectively. The reachability matrix is expressed as follows.
[0069]
[0070] The reachability matrix above represents the physical connectivity between all nodes in the kill chain. The reachability between the reconnaissance node and the target refers to the reachable range of the reconnaissance node to the target; the reachability between the reconnaissance node and the command node, and between the command node and the firepower node, refers to the reachable range between them; and the reachability of the firepower node to the target refers to the reachable range of the firepower node to the target. The reachability condition function f(a, b) between adjacent nodes a and b in the kill chain is defined as follows.
[0071]
[0072] Among them, f(o i ,t x ) represents the reachability of the reconnaissance node to the target; f(w k ,t x ) represents the reachability of the firepower node to the target. i ,c j )、f(c j ,w k ) represent the communication reachability from the reconnaissance node to the command node and from the command node to the firepower node, respectively. A typical connection relationship in a complete kill chain is a reachable closed loop connection from target → reconnaissance node → command node → firepower node → target.
[0073] Based on the above closed-loop reachability relationship of the kill chain, the present invention retains the reachability elements of some matrices while setting other reachability elements to 0, while ensuring the reachability characteristics of all nodes in the kill chain. This forms the following kill chain closed-loop reachability matrix G.
[0074]
[0075] As shown in the above formula, the above kill chain reachability matrix only retains the reachability sub-regions between the four nodes. In this way, the reachability matrix forms a counterclockwise closed loop of reachability "sub-blocks" from the upper right (target-reconnaissance node) → the upper left (reconnaissance node-command node) → the lower left (command node-firepower node) → the lower right (firepower node-target) → the upper right (target-reconnaissance node).
[0076] In this way, the reachability closed-loop matrix G realizes a one-to-one correspondence between the reachability matrix G and the OODA closed loop of the kill chain while retaining all the reachability characteristics of the nodes in the chain.
[0077] 1.1 Necessary conditions for building a kill chain
[0078] Based on the above reachability modeling of the four types of node elements in the kill chain, the target t is given. x The necessary conditions for building a kill chain are:
[0079] f(o i ,tx )=f(o i ,c j )=f(w k ,c j )=f(w k ,t x )=1
[0080] Represents the relationship between reconnaissance node i and command node j, command node j and fire node k, and fire node k and target t x A closed killing chain can be formed between them. It is easy to find that f(o i ,t x )、f(o i ,c j )、f(w k ,c j ) and f(w k ,t x )The positions of the four points are exactly the four corners of a rectangle, which can be graphically expressed as follows.
[0081] 1.2 Kill Chain Graphical Representation
[0082] Assume that the number of reconnaissance, command and firepower resources for target t1 is l=2, m=2, n=3 respectively, and express the above reachability matrix as the following grid diagram, where 0 and 1 represent the reachability between nodes respectively, as shown in the following example: Figure 1 The four dark-colored squares in the grid diagram represent the reachability between the target and the reconnaissance node, the reconnaissance node and the command node, the command node and the firepower node, and the firepower node and the target. To determine the closed-loop nature of the reachability relationship within the kill chain, the kill chain combination can be obtained by traversing the four regions of target → reconnaissance node → command node → firepower node → target in a counterclockwise manner.
[0083] Depend on Figure 1 As can be seen, the four dark rectangular areas in the matrix are labeled A, B, C, and D, respectively. A represents the reachability area between the target and the reconnaissance node, B represents the reachability area between the reconnaissance node and the command node, C represents the reachability area between the command node and the fire node, and D represents the reachability area between the fire node and the target. Therefore, a kill chain that meets reachability requirements must select blocks with a value of 1 within each of these four dark rectangular areas. Therefore, node selection for the kill chain can be determined by searching the reachability matrix. The search steps are as follows.
[0084] The node search step within the chain is designed as follows based on the counterclockwise kill chain combination solution search step of the reachability grid graph.
[0085] (1) For target t1, select the target and reconnaissance unit reachability blocks in area A in order. If the block diagram is 1, record the current row number oi (i=1,2,…,l), go to step (2); if the block value is 0, search for the block in the next row of column t1 in area A and repeat step (1). If the entire area A has been traversed, the search step ends.
[0086] (2) Select o in area B in order i The row's reachability block, if the block diagram is 1, records the current column number c j (j=1,2,…,m), go to step (3); if the block value is 0, search for o in area B i Move the block to the next column and repeat step (2). i After all rows are traversed, go to step (7).
[0087] (3) Select c in the C area in order j The column's reachability block, if the block diagram is 1, records the current row number w k (k=1,2,…,n), go to step (4); if the block value is 0, search for c in area C j Arrange the next row of blocks and repeat step (3). j After all columns are traversed, go to step (6).
[0088] (4) Select w in the D area in order k The reachability block of the row, such as block 1, records the node selection of the kill chain t1-o respectively i -c j -w k If the block value is 0, it does not constitute a closed kill chain. Go to step (5).
[0089] (5) Go to step (3) and select c in the C area. j The next row of the column (w j+1 ) blocks, until c j After the column traversal is completed, go to step (6).
[0090] (6) Go to step (2) and select o in area B i The next column of the row (c j+1 ) blocks, until o i The row traversal is complete. Go to step (7).
[0091] (7) Go to step (1) and select the next row of column t1 in area A (o i+1 ) blocks until all columns in t1 are traversed. The search step ends.
[0092] against Figure 1 Through the above steps, we can find the combination of all kill chains for target t1, denoted as Ltotle , L totle The number of kill chains is l. Figure 1 The corresponding kill chain set L totle The number of kill chains is l=3, which are L1:t1-o1-c1-w2, L2:t1-o2-c2-w1 and L3:t1-o2-c2-w2. Figure 2 shown.
[0093] As can be seen from the above example, all kill chain sets can be found by following the kill chain combination search steps. In order to find the most suitable kill chain combination solution in the kill chain set, an evaluation method for the kill chain combination solution is needed.
[0094] 2. Kill Chain Solution Evaluation
[0095] 2.1 Kill Chain Evaluation Index System
[0096] Compared with the effectiveness evaluation of single weapon equipment, the kill chain is a combat system that organically combines and coordinates multiple types of combat equipment. There are many indicators that affect the combat effectiveness of the kill chain. Based on the combat requirements of the kill chain to be fast, accurate and fierce, the present invention provides evaluation indicators and calculation models for the kill chain's reaction time, system strike accuracy and firepower strike capability to evaluate the performance of the kill chain.
[0097] 2.2 Kill Chain Time Calculation Model
[0098] The length of time it takes for a kill chain to detect a target and then destroy it plays a crucial role in mission success. Therefore, the total time it takes for a kill chain to strike a target is a key systemic indicator for responding to time-sensitive targets. The total time it takes for a kill chain to strike a target includes:
[0099] The reaction time of the reconnaissance unit is t observe ;
[0100] The command unit reaction time is t command ;
[0101] The reaction time of the firepower unit is recorded as t weapon ;
[0102] The above response times include the node's local processing time and information transmission time.
[0103] t observe =t observe-deal +t observe-send
[0104] t command =t command-deal +t command-send
[0105] tweapon =t weapon-deal +t weapon-send
[0106] Among them, t observe-deal is the detection and signal processing time of the reconnaissance node, t observe-send is the time it takes for the reconnaissance node to transmit target information to the command node, t command-deal is the time when command decision information is generated, t command-send is the time it takes for the command node to transmit information to the fire node, t weapon-deal Preparation time for shooting, t weapon-send The time it takes for the ammunition to be released.
[0107] Therefore, the kill chain reaction time for a designated target is
[0108] t reaction =t observe-deal +t observe-send +t command-deal +t command-send +t weapon-deal
[0109] +t weapon-send
[0110] Among them, t observe-deal , t observe-send , t command-deal , t command-send and t weapon-deal It can be obtained through the performance parameters of the equipment itself or pre-arranged tests, t weapon-send It can be calculated based on the distance between the enemy and us and the exterior ballistic model (shooting table or ballistic equation).
[0111] 2.3 Kill Chain Strike Accuracy Model
[0112] The strike accuracy of the kill chain is closely related to the detection error of the reconnaissance node, the information processing error of the command node, and the shooting error of the fire node. The variance of the detection error is The variance of the command processing error is The variance of the weapon strike error is Usually the above error terms are independent of each other, then the overall strike accuracy of the kill chain system satisfies
[0113]
[0114] in is the variance of the detection error of the reconnaissance node; The information processing accuracy of the command node is the variance of the calculation error of the generated task command. It can be ignored under the existing computing resources, so Therefore, the overall strike accuracy of the system can be simplified as
[0115]
[0116] 2.4 Kill Chain Firepower Strike Capability Model
[0117] The firepower strike capability of the kill chain adopts a comprehensive damage capability evaluation system based on the benchmark ammunition, using the firepower index F k express.
[0118]
[0119] Among them, d represents the firepower platform w k Number of types of ammunition carried, N d is the number of d types of ammunition, ω d The conversion coefficient of type D ammunition to a certain standard ammunition can be based on different ammunition categories (such as direct-fire ammunition, short- to medium-range suppression ammunition, short- to medium-range guided ammunition, and long-range guided ammunition). By selecting typical standard ammunition in each category and establishing a conversion coefficient table for standard ammunition, the comprehensive destructive capability evaluation of various types of firepower ammunition can be achieved.
[0120] In summary, the reaction time, system strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability of all kill chains in the kill chain set obtained based on the search step can be calculated. According to the actual battlefield requirements, the different weights of each evaluation indicator can be determined. The weight of the kill chain reaction time is c1, the weight of the kill chain system strike accuracy is c2, and the weight of the kill chain firepower strike capability is c3. The comprehensive capability of the kill chain is P. It is easy to know that P is inversely proportional to the kill chain reaction time and the kill chain system strike accuracy, and is directly proportional to the kill chain firepower strike capability. Therefore, the expression of the kill chain comprehensive capability P can be obtained as follows.
[0121]
[0122] The kill chain with the largest comprehensive capability P is the optimal kill chain.
[0123] The present invention also proposes a graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation system, which implements the graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method to achieve graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation, and is divided into two modules, respectively executing steps 1 to 2.
[0124] A computer device includes a memory, a processor, and a computer program stored in the memory and executable on the processor. When the processor executes the computer program, the method for constructing and evaluating a graphical universal kill chain is implemented to achieve graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation.
[0125] A computer-readable storage medium stores a computer program. When executed by a processor, the computer program implements the wind turbine power curve extraction method based on the XAI method and the graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method, thereby realizing graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation.
[0126] The technical features of the above embodiments can be combined arbitrarily. To make the description concise, not all possible combinations of the technical features in the above embodiments are described. However, as long as there is no contradiction in the combination of these technical features, they should be considered to be within the scope of this specification.
[0127] The above-described embodiments merely represent several implementation methods of the present application. While the descriptions are relatively specific and detailed, they should not be construed as limiting the scope of the present application. It should be noted that a person of ordinary skill in the art may make various modifications and improvements without departing from the spirit of the present application, and these modifications and improvements fall within the scope of protection of the present application. Therefore, the scope of protection of the present application shall be determined by the appended claims.
Claims
1. A graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method, characterized by: The steps include: Step 1: Kill chain matrix modeling: Based on the communication relationships among reconnaissance nodes, command nodes, firepower nodes, and targets in the closed kill chain system, a reachability matrix model for the nodes within the chain is constructed. The reachability matrix is expressed as a grid diagram. The kill chain combination solution is obtained by traversing the four regions of target → reconnaissance node → command node → firepower node → target in a counterclockwise manner. Step 2: Kill chain combination plan evaluation: Calculate the kill chain's reaction time, strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability, evaluate the kill chain's performance, and determine the optimal kill chain combination plan.
2. The graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: Step 1: Kill chain matrix modeling: Based on the communication relationship between the reconnaissance node, command node, firepower node and target in the closed system of the kill chain, a reachability matrix model of the nodes in the chain is constructed. The reachability matrix is expressed as a grid diagram. Based on the four areas of target → reconnaissance node → command node → firepower node → target, a counterclockwise traversal is taken to obtain the kill chain combination scheme. Among them: Based on the communication relationship between the reconnaissance node, command node, firepower node and target in the closed system of the kill chain, a reachability matrix model of the nodes in the chain is constructed. The specific method is as follows: Set at a strike target t x Among the combat resources, there are l reconnaissance nodes, m command nodes, and n fire nodes. The set of reconnaissance nodes is O = (o1, o2, ..., o l ), the set of command nodes is C = (c1, c2, ..., c m ), the set of firepower nodes is W = (w1, w2, ..., w n ), a complete kill chain is represented by {o i 、c j 、w k , t x } is expressed by four elements, where the node numbers are i∈(1,…,l), j∈(1,…,m), and k∈(1,…,n); Adopting the adjacency matrix construction form, a reachability matrix G0 containing the target is established. The rows and columns of the matrix are reconnaissance nodes, command nodes, fire nodes, and targets respectively. The reachability matrix is expressed as follows; Where f(a, b) is the reachability condition function between adjacent nodes a and b in the kill chain. The reachability between the reconnaissance node and the target refers to the reachable range of the reconnaissance node to the target; the reachability between the reconnaissance node and the command node, and between the command node and the fire node, refers to the reachable communication distance between them; the reachability of the fire node to the target refers to the reachable range of the fire node to the target. The definition formula is as follows: Among them, f(o i ,t x ) represents the reachability of the reconnaissance node to the target; f(w k ,t x ) represents the reachability of the firepower node to the target; f(o i ,c j )、f(c j ,w k ) represent the communication reachability from the reconnaissance node to the command node and from the command node to the fire node respectively.
3. The graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method according to claim 2 is characterized in that A complete kill chain has a reachability closed-loop connection: target → reconnaissance node → command node → fire node → target. While ensuring the reachability characteristics between all nodes in the kill chain, we retain the reachability elements while setting other reachability elements to 0, forming the following kill chain closed-loop reachability matrix G: The kill chain reachability matrix above only retains the reachability sub-regions between the four nodes, forming a counterclockwise closed loop of reachability "sub-blocks" from the upper right (target-reconnaissance node) → the upper left (reconnaissance node-command node) → the lower left (command node-firepower node) → the lower right (firepower node-target) → the upper right (target-reconnaissance node).
4. The graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method according to claim 3, characterized in that: Step 1: Kill chain matrix modeling: Based on the communication relationship between the reconnaissance node, command node, firepower node, and target in the closed system of the kill chain, a reachability matrix model of the nodes in the chain is constructed. The reachability matrix is expressed as a grid diagram. Based on the four areas of target → reconnaissance node → command node → firepower node → target, a counterclockwise traversal is taken to obtain the kill chain combination scheme. The specific method of expressing the reachability matrix as a grid diagram is as follows: In the grid diagram, 0 and 1 respectively express the reachability between nodes. The kill chain that meets the reachability selects the block with a value of 1, which is displayed in dark color. Otherwise, the block with a value of 0 is selected, which is displayed in white.
5. The graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method according to claim 4, characterized in that: Step 1: Kill chain matrix modeling: Based on the communication relationship between the reconnaissance node, command node, firepower node and target in the closed system of the kill chain, a reachability matrix model of the nodes in the chain is constructed. The reachability matrix is expressed as a grid diagram. Based on the four areas of target → reconnaissance node → command node → firepower node → target, a kill chain combination scheme is obtained by traversing the four areas of target → reconnaissance node → command node → firepower node → target in a counterclockwise manner. The specific method is as follows: Assume that the four dark rectangular areas in the matrix are labeled A, B, C, and D, where A is the reachability area between the target and the reconnaissance node, B is the reachability area between the reconnaissance node and the command node, C is the reachability area between the command node and the fire node, and D is the reachability area between the fire node and the target. The specific steps for searching for nodes in the kill chain based on the reachability matrix are as follows: Step 1: For target t1, select the target and reconnaissance unit reachability blocks in area A in order. If the block diagram is 1, record the current row number o. i , go to step 2; if the block value is 0, find the block in the next row of column t1 in area A and repeat step 1; Step 2: Select o in area B in order i The row's reachability block, if the block diagram is 1, records the current column number c j , go to step 3; if the block value is 0, find o in area B i Row the next column of blocks and repeat step 2; Step 3: Select the C in the C area in order j The column's reachability block, if the block diagram is 1, records the current row number w k , go to step 4; if the block value is 0, search for c in area C j Arrange the next row of squares and repeat step 3; Step 4: Select w in area D in order k The reachability block of the row, such as block 1, records the node selection of the kill chain t1-o respectively i -c j -w k ; If the block value is 0, it does not constitute a closed kill chain, and proceed to step 5; Step 5, go to step 3 and select c in the C area j Next row of column w k+1 Blocks, until c j After the column traversal is completed, go to step 6; Step 6, go to step 2 and select o in area B i The next column of blocks in the row, until o i After the row traversal is completed, go to step 7; Step 7, go to step 1 and select the next row of column t1 in area A (o i+1 ) blocks until the t1 column is traversed.
6. The graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: Step 2: Kill chain combination scheme evaluation: Calculate the kill chain's reaction time, strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability, evaluate the kill chain's performance, and determine the optimal kill chain combination scheme. The specific method for calculating the kill chain's reaction time is as follows: The total time it takes to strike a target in the kill chain includes: The reaction time of the reconnaissance unit is t observe ; The command unit reaction time is t command ; The reaction time of the fire unit is recorded as t weapon ; The above response times include the node’s local processing time and information transmission time; t observe =t observe-deal +t observe-send t command =t command-deal +t command-send t weapon =t weapon-deal +t weapon-send Among them, t observe-deal is the detection and signal processing time of the reconnaissance node, t observe-send is the time it takes for the reconnaissance node to transmit target information to the command node, t command-deal is the time when command decision information is generated, t command-send is the time it takes for the command node to transmit information to the fire node, t weapon-deal Preparation time for shooting, t weapon-send The time for the ammunition to be released; Therefore, the kill chain reaction time for a designated target is t reaction =t observe-deal +t observe-send +t command-deal +t command-send +t weapon-deal +t weapon-send Among them, t observe-deal , t observe-send , t command-deal , t command-send and t weapon-deal Obtained through the performance parameters of the equipment itself or pre-arranged tests, t weapon-send Calculated based on the distance between the enemy and us and the exterior ballistic model.
7. The graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: Step 2: Kill chain combination scheme evaluation: Calculate the kill chain's reaction time, strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability, evaluate the kill chain's performance, and determine the optimal kill chain combination scheme. Calculate the kill chain's strike accuracy using the following method: The strike accuracy of the kill chain is closely related to the detection error of the reconnaissance node, the information processing error of the command node, and the shooting error of the fire node. The variance of the detection error is The variance of the command processing error is The variance of the weapon strike error is The above error terms are independent of each other, so the strike accuracy satisfies:
8. The graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: Step 2: Kill chain combination scheme evaluation: Calculate the kill chain's reaction time, strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability, evaluate the kill chain's performance, and determine the optimal kill chain combination scheme. Calculate the kill chain's firepower strike capability using the following method: The firepower strike capability of the kill chain adopts a comprehensive damage capability evaluation system based on the benchmark ammunition, using the firepower index F k express; Among them, d represents the firepower platform w k Number of types of ammunition carried, N d is the number of d types of ammunition, ω d The conversion coefficient of type D ammunition to a certain standard ammunition is based on different ammunition categories. Typical standard ammunition is selected from the categories and a conversion coefficient table for the standard ammunition is established.
9. The graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: Step 2, Kill Chain Combination Solution Evaluation: Calculate the kill chain's reaction time, strike accuracy, and firepower strike capability, evaluate the kill chain's performance, and determine the optimal kill chain combination solution. Specifically, the kill chain's performance is evaluated and the optimal kill chain combination solution is determined as follows: Based on actual battlefield requirements, the weights of various evaluation indicators are determined. The weight of the kill chain reaction time is c1, the weight of the kill chain system strike accuracy is c2, the weight of the kill chain firepower strike capability is c3, and the comprehensive capability of the kill chain is P. The expression of the kill chain comprehensive capability P is as follows: The kill chain with the largest comprehensive capability P is the optimal kill chain.
10. A graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation system, characterized by: Implement the graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation method described in any one of claims 1 to 9 to realize graphical universal kill chain construction and evaluation, which is divided into two modules and performs steps 1 to 2 respectively.
