Air preheater mechanical operating state fault detection method

By dividing the rotation cycle in the air preheater, identifying and subtracting the overall load change of the cycle, and combining the corresponding load anomaly locations of adjacent cycles, the problem of detecting local mechanical interference in the air preheater under low-speed heavy-load environment is solved, improving the accuracy and reliability of the detection.

CN123065747APending Publication Date: 2026-11-10JIANGSU GELAN ENVIRONMENTAL TECH CO LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202611598023.6
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2026-10-15
Publication Date
2026-11-10

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies are unable to effectively identify intermittent local mechanical interference generated by air preheaters under low-speed, heavy-load, and variable-load operating environments, making the test results susceptible to dilution by overall load changes and normal operating factors.

Method used

By acquiring drive load detection values, rotor position detection signals, and operating condition parameters, the rotation cycle is divided and the normal load reference and fluctuation limit are determined. The overall load change component of the cycle is deducted, local load deviations are identified, and local mechanical interference faults are determined in the corresponding abnormal position segments within three adjacent cycles.

Benefits of technology

It reduces the impact of overall load changes on the test results, improves the accuracy of identifying local mechanical interference, provides the rotor position range corresponding to the fault, and provides a basis for subsequent mechanical inspection.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN123065747A_ABST
    Figure CN123065747A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present application relates to the technical field of fault detection, in particular to a kind of air preheater mechanical operating state fault detection method.The present application obtains driving load detection value, rotor position detection signal, operating condition parameter and normal operation reference data, to same rotor reference division rotation period and positioning;According to the condition and normal operation reference data, determine each position normal load reference and fluctuation limit, calculate relative load deviation, deduct cycle overall load change component, obtain local load deviation and abnormal position section;The position of adjacent three cycles of abnormal section is corresponding, when each cycle exists corresponding section, section center position deviation does not exceed limit, and the average of section local load deviation is greater than the average of the rest non-abnormal position in same cycle, determine local mechanical interference fault and output corresponding rotor position.The present application can reduce the influence of overall load change on abnormal detection.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention relates to the field of fault detection technology, specifically to a method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in air preheaters. Background Technology

[0002] Rotary air preheaters operate under low-speed, heavy-load, and variable-load conditions for extended periods. Mechanical interference, such as friction and abrasion, can occur between components like rotor seals, sector plates, and the casing due to thermal deformation, gap changes, or the intrusion of foreign objects. Current methods for detecting air preheater jamming typically involve collecting drive motor current and spindle speed data, comparing current current and speed variations with historical normal data under similar loads to determine whether the jamming is minor, moderate, or severe. Other technologies establish normal operating references based on the air preheater's operating mode and scenario, using deviations between real-time parameters and these references for fault warnings. Alternatively, they extract time-window features from measured parameters such as current, speed, vibration, and temperature, identifying rotor jamming and other faults based on the degree of deviation and correlation of different parameters.

[0003] However, when slight local mechanical interference occurs in the air preheater, the drive motor usually still has sufficient output torque to overcome the additional friction, and the spindle speed may remain essentially unchanged. Meanwhile, the additional resistance generated by local friction only increases briefly when the relevant components move near the interference position, accounting for a small proportion of the overall detection time window. If the current change rate, mean, RMS value, or overall deviation within the time window is used for judgment, this short-term load increment is easily diluted by other normal operating data within the window. On the other hand, normal operating factors such as unit load changes may cause the drive load to change synchronously throughout the detection period, causing it to overlap with the short-term load increment generated by local friction.

[0004] In summary, how to effectively identify the intermittent local mechanical interference generated during the continuous rotation of the air preheater under normal driving load changes is a technical problem that urgently needs to be solved in this field.

[0005] Therefore, a method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in air preheaters is proposed. Summary of the Invention

[0006] The purpose of this invention is to provide a method for detecting mechanical operational faults in air preheaters. By acquiring drive load detection values, rotor position detection signals, operating condition parameters, and normal operation reference data, rotation cycles are divided and located using the same rotor reference. Based on the operating conditions and normal operation reference data, the normal load reference and fluctuation limits for each position are determined. The relative load deviation is calculated, and the overall load change component of the cycle is subtracted to obtain local load deviations and abnormal position segments. The abnormal segments in three adjacent cycles are matched in position. When each cycle has a corresponding segment, the center position offset of the segment is within the limit, and the average local load deviation of the segment is greater than the average of other non-abnormal positions in the same cycle, a local mechanical interference fault is determined, and the corresponding rotor position is output. This invention can reduce the impact of overall load changes on fault detection.

[0007] To achieve the above objectives, the present invention provides the following technical solution: A method for detecting mechanical operating condition faults in an air preheater, comprising: Acquire the drive load detection value, rotor position detection signal, operating condition parameters and normal operation reference data of the air preheater, divide the rotation cycle according to the same rotor reference position based on the rotor position detection signal and determine the rotor position in each rotation cycle; For each complete rotation cycle, the normal load reference and normal load fluctuation limit for each position are determined based on the operating condition parameters and normal operation reference data. The relative load deviation of the drive load detection value relative to the normal load reference is calculated. The overall load change component of the cycle determined by the relative load deviation of each position in this cycle is deducted to obtain the local load deviation. The abnormal load location segment is determined based on the comparison result between the local load deviation and the corresponding normal load fluctuation limit. The load abnormality location segments of three adjacent cycles are matched. When there are corresponding load abnormality location segments in all three cycles, the maximum value of the shortest circumferential distance between the center rotor positions of each corresponding segment does not exceed the allowable position deviation, and the average local load deviation of each corresponding segment is greater than the average local load deviation of the other positions in the same cycle that have not been identified as load abnormalities, a local mechanical interference fault is determined and the corresponding rotor position is output.

[0008] Preferably, the rotor position detection signal is generated by a position encoder that rotates synchronously with the air preheater rotor; the reference position of the position encoder is used as the rotor reference position, and the running process between two adjacent passes of the rotor reference position is determined as a complete rotation cycle. Each complete rotation cycle is divided into corresponding position detection segments according to a preset angle width, so that each position detection segment has a rotor position determined relative to the rotor reference position.

[0009] Preferably, the three-phase current detection signal and rotor position detection signal of the drive motor are collected according to a unified sampling clock, and a sampling timestamp is assigned to the sampling data; the three-phase current detection signal is established with the corresponding position detection segment according to the sampling timestamp, the effective value of the three-phase current in each position detection segment is determined, and the arithmetic mean of the effective value of the three-phase current is determined as the drive load detection value of the corresponding position detection segment. The drive load detection value is a current characteristic quantity used to characterize the change of drive load.

[0010] Preferably, the operating condition parameters include unit load, air preheater speed, flue gas flow rate, primary air flow rate, and secondary air flow rate; the corresponding normal complete rotation cycle is determined from the normal operation reference data based on the operating condition parameters of the complete rotation cycle to be detected, and the normal load reference is determined based on the drive load detection value of the detection section at the same position in each normal complete rotation cycle; the relative load deviation of each detection section at each position in each normal complete rotation cycle relative to the normal load reference is determined respectively, and the normal local load deviation is obtained by determining and deducting the overall load change component of the cycle based on the relative load deviation of the same normal complete rotation cycle, and the normal load fluctuation limit is determined based on the normal local load deviation of the detection section at the same position.

[0011] Preferably, the ratio of the difference between the drive load detection value of each position detection segment in the complete rotation cycle to be detected and the corresponding normal load reference to the normal load reference is determined as the relative load deviation; the median of the relative load deviations of all position detection segments in the complete rotation cycle to be detected is used to determine the overall load change component of the cycle, and the overall load change component of the cycle is subtracted from the relative load deviations of each position detection segment to obtain the local load deviation of the corresponding position detection segment.

[0012] Preferably, the rotor position where the local load deviation exceeds the corresponding normal load fluctuation limit is determined as the load abnormal position, and adjacent load abnormal positions are merged along the rotor rotation direction to form a load abnormal position segment; for load abnormal positions distributed at the beginning and end of the complete rotation cycle, they are merged according to the circumferential relationship of the beginning and end of the complete rotation cycle; the rotor position at the beginning, the rotor position at the end, and the rotor position at the center of the segment are determined along the rotor rotation direction.

[0013] Preferably, the load anomaly location segment of the first rotation cycle in three adjacent complete rotation cycles is used as the reference segment. The positions of the rotor center positions of each reference segment are sequentially matched along the rotor rotation direction. For each reference segment, in subsequent rotation cycles, from the candidate segments that have not yet established a correspondence and whose shortest circumferential distance from the reference segment does not exceed the allowable position deviation, the candidate segment with the smallest shortest circumferential distance is selected to establish a correspondence. If the shortest circumferential distances are the same, the candidate segment that is reached first along the rotor rotation direction is selected. After the candidate segment establishes a correspondence, it no longer participates in the position matching of other reference segments. The maximum value of the shortest circumferential distance between the rotor center positions of a set of corresponding segments within three cycles is determined as the detection window position offset. The detection window position offset does not exceed the allowable position deviation, which is determined based on the angle width of the position detection segment.

[0014] Preferably, the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of each rotor position within the corresponding load abnormality position segment is calculated as the mean of the local load deviation of the corresponding segment; the rotor positions included in all load abnormality position segments within the same rotation cycle are excluded, and the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of the remaining rotor positions is calculated as the mean of the local load deviation of the remaining positions; if there are no remaining rotor positions, the comparison condition of the mean of the local load deviation is not met; the corresponding rotor position includes the first rotor position, the last rotor position, and the center rotor position of the corresponding segment.

[0015] Compared with the prior art, the beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: 1. This invention divides the complete rotation cycle by the same rotor reference position and maps the three-phase current characteristics of the drive motor to the corresponding position detection segment according to the sampling timestamp. This enables the drive load detection values ​​of different rotation cycles to have a unified rotor position attribute, which can reduce position mismatch caused by speed changes and fixed time window division, and provide a consistent data basis for position-by-position load comparison and cross-cycle anomaly correspondence.

[0016] 2. This invention selects normal operating reference data based on operating condition parameters, and establishes normal load benchmarks and normal load fluctuation limits for each rotor position. By calculating the relative load deviation and deducting the overall periodic load change component determined by each position within a rotation cycle, the influence of normal positional load differences and overall periodic load offset on the detection results can be reduced, while retaining the local load deviations concentrated in some rotor positions.

[0017] 3. This invention merges adjacent abnormal load locations into a single abnormal load location segment with a start, end, and center. It also performs circumferential position correspondence for abnormal segments in three consecutive complete rotation cycles. By combining the cross-cycle position offset condition of the abnormal segment with the average local load deviation between the abnormal segment and other non-abnormal positions in the same cycle, the possibility of single-cycle transient disturbances and overall load changes being judged as local mechanical interference can be reduced. Furthermore, the rotor position range corresponding to the fault is output, providing a basis for subsequent mechanical inspection. Attached Figure Description

[0018] Figure 1 A flowchart of a method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater, provided in an embodiment of the present invention; Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of the rotor position detection and drive load data mapping relationship provided in an embodiment of the present invention; Figure 3 This is a schematic diagram of the load anomaly location segment generation and cross-cycle corresponding logic structure provided in an embodiment of the present invention. Detailed Implementation

[0019] The technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention will be clearly and completely described below with reference to the accompanying drawings. Obviously, the described embodiments are only some embodiments of the present invention, and not all embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by those skilled in the art without creative effort are within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0020] Please see Figures 1 to 3 This invention provides a method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater, the technical solution of which is as follows: A method for detecting mechanical operating condition faults in an air preheater, comprising: Acquire the drive load detection value, rotor position detection signal, operating condition parameters and normal operation reference data of the air preheater, divide the rotation cycle according to the same rotor reference position based on the rotor position detection signal and determine the rotor position in each rotation cycle; For each complete rotation cycle, the normal load reference and normal load fluctuation limit for each position are determined based on the operating condition parameters and normal operation reference data. The relative load deviation of the drive load detection value relative to the normal load reference is calculated. The overall load change component of the cycle determined by the relative load deviation of each position in this cycle is deducted to obtain the local load deviation. The abnormal load location segment is determined based on the comparison result between the local load deviation and the corresponding normal load fluctuation limit. The load abnormality location segments of three adjacent cycles are matched. When there are corresponding load abnormality location segments in all three cycles, the maximum value of the shortest circumferential distance between the center rotor positions of each corresponding segment does not exceed the allowable position deviation, and the average local load deviation of each corresponding segment is greater than the average local load deviation of the other positions in the same cycle that have not been identified as load abnormalities, a local mechanical interference fault is determined and the corresponding rotor position is output.

[0021] Example 1: This embodiment is applied to the online monitoring of the mechanical operating status of an air preheater during boiler operation. The air preheater rotates continuously, and the drive motor drives the rotor through a transmission mechanism. During the monitoring process, drive motor operating data, rotor position data, and boiler operating condition data are acquired simultaneously. The changes in drive load corresponding to different rotor positions are monitored without altering the normal operating mode of the air preheater.

[0022] As one embodiment of the present invention, refer to Figure 1 A flowchart of a method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater, with reference to... Figure 2 A schematic diagram of the mapping relationship between rotor position detection and drive load data, refer to... Figure 3 A schematic diagram of the generation of load anomaly location segments and the corresponding logic structure across cycles.

[0023] During detection, firstly, consistent rotor position coordinates are established across each complete rotation cycle based on the rotor position detection signal, and the drive load detection value is correlated with the rotor position. Then, based on the current operating conditions, the corresponding normal load reference is obtained to determine the load deviation of different rotor positions in the current cycle. The load changes common to all positions within a complete rotation cycle are subtracted, and the local load deviations with positional differences are retained to determine the abnormal load location segment. Subsequently, it is determined whether the abnormal segment recurs at the corresponding position in consecutive rotation cycles, and the local load state of the abnormal segment is compared with that of other positions in the same cycle that have not been determined as abnormal load locations. If the judgment condition is met, the local mechanical interference fault judgment result and the corresponding rotor position are output. The local mechanical interference fault judgment result described in this embodiment is a diagnostic result generated based on the local distribution of the current characteristic quantity used to characterize the change in drive load at the rotor position and its repetitive relationship across rotation cycles. The corresponding rotor position represents the position range of the abnormal load location segment in the rotor position coordinates, and does not represent the direct measurement result of the specific component or physical contact point where contact occurs.

[0024] This invention enables mechanical interference detection to not directly rely on the overall rise and fall of the driving load, but to make judgments based on the distribution of local load changes on the rotor position and the cross-cycle repetition relationship. This can reduce the influence of the overall load offset that approximately acts on each rotor position within the relative load deviation domain of a complete rotation cycle on the local mechanical interference detection, while retaining the rotor position detection results corresponding to local load anomalies.

[0025] Furthermore, the rotor position detection signal is generated by a position encoder that rotates synchronously with the air preheater rotor; the reference position of the position encoder is used as the rotor reference position, and the running process between two adjacent passes of the rotor reference position is determined as a complete rotation cycle. Each complete rotation cycle is divided into corresponding position detection segments according to a preset angle width, so that each position detection segment has a rotor position determined relative to the rotor reference position.

[0026] Specifically, a position encoder is installed on the rotating component corresponding to the air preheater rotor, and the position encoder rotates synchronously with the rotor. A fixed correspondence is established between the reference position of the position encoder and the fixed mechanical position of the rotor. The running process between two adjacent passes through the reference position is defined as a complete rotation cycle. Based on the rotation angle relative to the rotor reference position, the complete rotation cycle is divided into position detection segments according to a preset angle width. Different rotation cycles use the same division starting point, division direction, and division angle width. The preset angle width is an integer multiple of the position encoder's angular resolution and remains consistent during normal operation reference data establishment and real-time detection.

[0027] The preset angle width is also subject to an upper limit, which ensures that the number of position detection segments divided in a complete rotation cycle is not less than a preset minimum number. The preset minimum number is determined based on the position encoder angle resolution and the positioning accuracy required to distinguish the rotor position corresponding to local mechanical interference, so as to ensure that the additional load generated by local mechanical interference is concentrated in some position detection segments and can be distinguished.

[0028] With the above settings, the position detection sections in different rotation cycles share a common mechanical position reference. When the actual rotation speed of the air preheater changes within its operating range, the detection data is still assigned according to the actual rotor position, avoiding position mismatches in different rotation cycles caused by using fixed time intervals. This provides a unified position coordinate for establishing a normal load reference and corresponding to abnormal positions across cycles.

[0029] Furthermore, the three-phase current detection signal and rotor position detection signal of the drive motor are collected according to a unified sampling clock, and a sampling timestamp is assigned to the sampling data. Based on the sampling timestamp, the three-phase current detection signal is associated with the corresponding position detection segment, the effective value of the three-phase current in each position detection segment is determined, and the arithmetic mean of the effective value of the three-phase current is determined as the drive load detection value of the corresponding position detection segment. The drive load detection value is a current characteristic quantity used to characterize the change of drive load.

[0030] Specifically, the three-phase current detection signals and rotor position detection signals of the drive motor are collected according to a unified sampling clock, and the sampling timestamps are recorded respectively. The position detection segment to which each current sampling data belongs is determined based on the sampling timestamp. The current RMS value calculation window covers an integer number of fundamental drive current cycles, and the number of current sampling points included in each calculation window is not less than the minimum number of RMS value calculation points determined by the current acquisition device. The preset angle width and current sampling frequency of the position detection segment satisfy the following: the duration for the air preheater rotor to pass through a position detection segment at the highest speed within the detection operating range is not less than one current RMS value calculation window. The current RMS value calculation window that completely falls within the same position detection segment is determined as the effective calculation window of that position detection segment. The RMS values ​​of the three-phase currents within the same position detection segment are determined according to the effective calculation windows. When there are multiple effective calculation windows for the same position detection segment, the RMS values ​​of the three-phase currents in each effective calculation window are calculated separately, and the RMS value of the three-phase currents in that position detection segment is determined based on the arithmetic mean of the RMS values ​​obtained from each effective calculation window. Calculate the arithmetic mean of the effective values ​​of the three-phase current in the detection section at this location, and use the resulting arithmetic mean as the drive load detection value for that location detection section. The drive load detection value is a current characteristic quantity used to characterize changes in the drive load and is not used as a direct measurement of the drive motor's output torque. Detection sections without a valid calculation window are marked as having missing current detection data; the complete rotation cycle to which this detection section belongs is not included in the determination of abnormal load location sections or cross-cycle fault judgment.

[0031] This invention converts the time-collected drive motor current into a current characteristic quantity with a clear rotor position attribute, so that the data to be detected can be compared with the normal operation reference data according to the same position coordinates, and uses the existing electrical detection data of the drive system to indirectly characterize the drive load change, providing detection input for subsequent identification of load anomalies concentrated in some rotor positions.

[0032] Furthermore, the operating condition parameters include unit load, air preheater speed, flue gas flow rate, primary air flow rate, and secondary air flow rate. Based on the operating condition parameters of the complete rotation cycle to be detected, the corresponding normal complete rotation cycle is determined from the normal operating reference data, and the normal load reference is determined based on the drive load detection values ​​of the detection sections at the same location in each normal complete rotation cycle. The relative load deviation of each detection section at each location in each normal complete rotation cycle relative to the normal load reference is determined. Based on the relative load deviation of the same normal complete rotation cycle, the overall load change component of the cycle is determined and subtracted to obtain the normal local load deviation. The normal load fluctuation limit is determined based on the normal local load deviation of the detection sections at the same location.

[0033] Specifically, the operating condition parameters include unit load, air preheater speed, flue gas flow rate, primary air flow rate, and secondary air flow rate. For each operating condition parameter, a valid value range and sequentially increasing boundary values ​​are preset. Parameter intervals are formed by adjacent boundary values ​​and assigned operating condition numbers. Except for the parameter interval with the highest value, each parameter interval includes a lower boundary but not an upper boundary; the parameter interval with the highest value also includes the highest value in the valid value range, ensuring that each cycle representative value corresponds to only one operating condition number. For each complete rotation cycle, a time-weighted average is calculated using the effective duration corresponding to the sampled value of each operating condition parameter as the weight, serving as the cycle representative value for the corresponding operating condition parameter. The combination of operating condition numbers corresponding to each cycle representative value serves as the operating condition index. The normal reference cycle and the complete rotation cycle to be tested use the same sampling range, valid value range, boundary values, and operating condition index determination method. The aforementioned valid value range and boundary values ​​are determined based on the equipment's allowable operating range and unit operating condition configuration, and remain unchanged during the establishment of normal reference data and the processing of corresponding data to be tested.

[0034] Normal operating reference data is established after the air preheater is installed and commissioned or after maintenance affecting the rotor's mechanical operation is completed. Before data collection, the rotor, sealing plates, sector plates, housing, and transmission mechanism are inspected according to equipment maintenance standards. Foreign objects affecting rotor rotation are removed, and the clearances of relatively moving parts are confirmed to meet equipment requirements. At least one complete rotation cycle is tested under the drive motor power supply mode and drive control mode used for reference data collection to confirm that no rotor stall or drive protection action occurs, and that all data acquisition devices are in normal acquisition status. The drive motor power supply mode, drive control mode, and current acquisition configuration are recorded. During the normal reference acquisition phase, a complete rotation cycle that meets the following conditions is determined as a valid normal reference cycle: the rotation cycle can be completely divided according to the rotor position detection signal; each position detection section has three-phase current detection data for determining the drive load detection value; the operating condition parameters can determine the cycle representative value; the current acquisition device does not generate range overflow, self-test abnormality, or communication interruption indicators; the sampling timestamps are continuous; the drive motor power supply mode, drive control mode, and current acquisition configuration are consistent with those confirmed during normal operation and have not been switched; and no maintenance or manual operation affecting the rotor drive load has occurred. If any condition is not met or any period representative value exceeds the corresponding valid value range, the complete rotation cycle is excluded.

[0035] After the operating condition index for a complete rotation cycle to be detected is determined, a valid normal reference cycle with the same operating condition index and consistent drive motor power supply method, drive control mode, and current acquisition configuration is obtained. For each position detection segment, the median of the drive load detection values ​​for that position detection segment over at least 20 valid normal reference cycles is used as the normal load benchmark. The effective lower limit of the normal load benchmark is taken as the lower limit of the accuracy guarantee range of the current acquisition device under the current range and sampling configuration; if there is a minimum valid measurement value specified, the larger of the two is taken. When the normal load benchmark is a finite positive number and not less than the effective lower limit, it is determined to be a valid normal load benchmark.

[0036] After obtaining valid normal load references for each detection segment, for each valid normal reference cycle, the drive load detection value of each detection segment is subtracted from the corresponding valid normal load reference, and the difference is divided by the valid normal load reference to obtain the normal relative load deviation. For the complete rotation cycle to be detected, the same calculation method is used: the drive load detection value of each detection segment is subtracted from the corresponding valid normal load reference, and the difference is divided by the valid normal load reference to obtain the current relative load deviation. The median of the normal relative load deviations of all detection segments in each valid normal reference cycle is used to determine the overall load change component of the corresponding cycle. After deducting the overall load change component of the cycle, the normal local load deviation is obtained. For the same detection segment, the maximum absolute value of the normal local load deviation corresponding to each valid normal reference cycle is used as the upper boundary of normal fluctuation; the ratio of the allowable error of current effective value measurement to the valid normal load reference of the corresponding detection segment is used as the lower limit of normal load fluctuation, and the larger value between the upper boundary of normal fluctuation and the lower limit of normal load fluctuation is determined as the normal load fluctuation limit. Data that meets the data integrity and acquisition status conditions is excluded not only because its drive load detection value is greater than other valid normal reference cycles. When the cycle representative value of any operating condition parameter of the complete rotation cycle to be detected exceeds the corresponding valid value range, the operating condition index of the complete rotation cycle to be detected is not determined, and an out-of-range indicator for the operating condition parameter is output. When there are fewer than 20 valid normal reference cycles with the same operating condition index and consistent drive configuration, the normal load benchmark and normal load fluctuation limit under the corresponding operating condition index are not established, and an insufficient normal reference data indicator is output. When the normal load benchmark of any position detection segment cannot be represented as a finite positive number or is less than the valid lower limit of the normal load benchmark, the normal load benchmark and normal load fluctuation limit under the corresponding operating condition index are not established, and an invalid normal load benchmark indicator is output. In any of the above situations, the current relative load deviation is not calculated for the corresponding complete rotation cycle to be detected, no abnormal load position segment is generated, and the three-cycle detection window containing the complete rotation cycle to be detected does not perform position correspondence and local mechanical interference fault determination for the abnormal load position segment.

[0037] Through the above processing, normal load benchmarks and normal load fluctuation limits for each rotor position can be established according to a unified operating condition index. Both the normal operating reference data and the data to be tested are first determined by subtracting the initial overall load change component of the cycle from the median relative load deviation of all position detection sections. When the data to be tested meets the secondary correction conditions, the overall load change component of the cycle is re-determined based on the remaining position detection sections after excluding the initial abnormal positions, and the current local load deviation is updated. Therefore, the normal local load deviation used to establish the normal load fluctuation limits and the initial local load deviation of the data to be tested are processed in the same way, while retaining the processing path for secondary correction of the data to be tested.

[0038] Furthermore, the ratio of the difference between the drive load detection value of each position detection segment in the complete rotation cycle to be detected and the corresponding normal load reference to the normal load reference is determined as the relative load deviation; the median of the relative load deviations of all position detection segments in the complete rotation cycle to be detected is used to determine the overall load change component of the cycle, and the overall load change component of the cycle is subtracted from the relative load deviations of each position detection segment to obtain the local load deviation of the corresponding position detection segment.

[0039] Specifically, let the drive load detection value of the j-th position detection segment in the k-th rotation cycle be... The normal load reference for the corresponding position is The relative load deviation, the overall periodic load variation component, and the local load deviation are determined according to the following formula: , , in, This is the relative load deviation. This represents the overall periodic load change component within the relative load deviation domain during the k-th rotation cycle. This refers to the local load deviation of the corresponding position detection segment. Normal local load deviation is determined using the same processing sequence for the normal operating reference data. In this embodiment, the additional load caused by local mechanical interference is concentrated in a portion of the position detection segments within a complete rotation cycle, and the number of position detection segments affected by this additional load is less than the number of unaffected position detection segments. Based on the above position quantity relationship, the position detection segments unaffected by local mechanical interference constitute the majority. When determining the overall periodic load change component using the median of the relative load deviation of all position detection segments, the median is mainly determined by the position detection segments unaffected by local mechanical interference. The overall periodic load change referred to in this embodiment refers to the change that forms approximately the same direction and similar magnitude of offset to each position detection segment within the relative load deviation domain of a complete rotation cycle. It does not include positional load trends formed by continuous increases or decreases over time within the rotation cycle, nor does it include absolute load increments that do not form approximately common offsets within the relative load deviation domain after normalization to the corresponding normal load benchmark.

[0040] This invention utilizes the normal load reference corresponding to each position to reduce the impact of differences in the original load levels at different mechanical positions. Then, it determines the overall load change component of the cycle using the median of the relative load deviations of the detection sections at each position within a complete rotation cycle. Under the condition that the number of detection sections at positions unaffected by local mechanical interference is greater than the number of detection sections at affected positions, and that the overall load change causes approximately the same direction and similar magnitude of offset to each detection section within the relative load deviation domain of a complete rotation cycle, the impact of additional loads concentrated at some rotor positions on the overall load change component of the cycle can be reduced. This ensures that the local load deviation obtained after deducting the overall load change component of the cycle retains the corresponding positional differences.

[0041] Furthermore, the rotor position where the local load deviation exceeds the corresponding normal load fluctuation limit is determined as the load abnormal position, and adjacent load abnormal positions are merged along the rotor rotation direction to form a load abnormal position segment; for load abnormal positions distributed at the beginning and end of the complete rotation cycle, they are merged according to the circumferential relationship of the beginning and end of the complete rotation cycle; the rotor position at the beginning, the rotor position at the end, and the rotor position at the center of the segment are determined along the rotor rotation direction.

[0042] Specifically, the local load deviation of each detection segment is compared with the normal load fluctuation limit corresponding to that position. Positions where the local load deviation exceeds the normal load fluctuation limit are identified as abnormal load positions. Adjacent abnormal load positions are continuously merged along the rotor rotation direction to form abnormal load position segments. For abnormal load positions that cross the rotor reference position, they are continuously merged according to the beginning and end of a complete rotation cycle. The first and last rotor positions of the abnormal load position segment are determined along the rotor rotation direction, and the midpoint of the circumferential interval formed from the first to the last position along this rotation direction is taken as the center rotor position of the segment.

[0043] This invention converts discrete position anomaly detection results into mechanical position segments with clearly defined start and end ranges, while maintaining the continuity of position representation for the same anomaly segment crossing the cycle boundary. The resulting load anomaly position segments simultaneously carry local load anomaly information and mechanical position information, and can be directly used as detection objects for position correspondence between subsequent different rotation cycles.

[0044] The first-cycle overall load change component is determined by subtracting the relative load deviation of all rotor positions in the current rotation cycle, and the first local load deviation is obtained. The preliminary abnormal position segment is determined based on the first local load deviation. The rotor positions corresponding to the preliminary abnormal position segment are excluded, and the second-cycle overall load change component is determined based on the relative load deviation of the remaining rotor positions. The second-cycle overall load change component replaces the first-cycle overall load change component, and the local load deviation and load abnormal position segment of each rotor position are re-determined.

[0045] Specifically, firstly, following the aforementioned method, the overall load change component of the first cycle is determined based on the relative load deviations of all rotor positions in the current rotation cycle. The first-cycle overall load change component is then subtracted from the relative load deviations of each rotor position to obtain the first local load deviation. Positions where the first local load deviation exceeds the corresponding normal load fluctuation limit are identified as preliminary abnormal positions, and preliminary abnormal position segments are formed according to the aforementioned adjacent position merging rules. Subsequently, rotor positions included in the preliminary abnormal position segments are excluded from the relative load deviations of the current rotation cycle, and the number of remaining rotor positions is determined. Only when the number of remaining rotor positions is not less than 3 and exceeds the number of rotor positions included in the preliminary abnormal position segments, the relative load deviations of the remaining rotor positions are used to determine the overall load change component of the second cycle using the same statistical method as the overall load change component of the first cycle. The overall load change component of the second cycle replaces the overall load change component of the first cycle, and the second-cycle overall load change component is again subtracted from the relative load deviations of each rotor position in the current rotation cycle to obtain the local load deviations used for subsequent fault detection. The abnormal load position segments are then re-determined based on the normal load fluctuation limit. The overall load change component in the second cycle is not an additional component subtracted from the first local load deviation. If the number of remaining rotor positions does not meet the above conditions, the second correction is not performed, and the overall load change component, the first local load deviation, and the initial abnormal position segment of the first cycle are retained as the processing result of this rotation cycle.

[0046] Through the above processing, the first determination of the overall periodic load change component is used to obtain the preliminary abnormal position. When the remaining rotor positions meet the quantity requirements, the second determination process excludes the preliminary abnormal positions from the statistical objects, which can reduce the impact of the drive load increment corresponding to local mechanical interference on the overall periodic load change component. When the number of remaining rotor positions is insufficient, the first correction result is retained to avoid increasing the instability of the correction result by determining the second periodic overall load change component based on the detection fluctuations of a small number of positions.

[0047] Furthermore, taking the load anomaly location segment of the first rotation cycle in three adjacent complete rotation cycles as the reference segment, the positions of the rotor center positions of each reference segment are sequentially matched along the rotor rotation direction. For each reference segment, in subsequent rotation cycles, from the candidate segments that have not yet established a matching relationship and whose shortest circumferential distance from the reference segment does not exceed the allowable position deviation, the candidate segment with the smallest shortest circumferential distance is selected to establish a matching relationship. When the shortest circumferential distances are the same, the candidate segment that is reached first along the rotor rotation direction is selected. After the candidate segment establishes a matching relationship, it no longer participates in the position matching of other reference segments. The maximum value of the shortest circumferential distance between the rotor center positions of a set of corresponding segments within three cycles is determined as the detection window position offset. The detection window position offset does not exceed the allowable position deviation, which is determined based on the angular width of the position detection segment.

[0048] Specifically, the load anomaly location segment of the first rotation cycle in the current detection window is used as the reference segment. Position correspondence is performed sequentially according to the order of the rotor center positions of each reference segment relative to the rotor reference position along the rotation direction. For each reference segment, in each subsequent rotation cycle, candidate segments that have not yet established a correspondence and whose shortest circumferential distance between their segment center rotor position and the reference segment's segment center rotor position does not exceed the allowable position deviation are identified. When multiple candidate segments exist, the candidate segment with the smallest shortest circumferential distance is selected to establish a correspondence. If the shortest circumferential distances are the same, the candidate segment first reached along the rotor rotation direction is selected, starting from the reference segment's segment center rotor position. After a candidate segment establishes a correspondence, it is marked as occupied and will not participate in the position correspondence of other reference segments within its rotation cycle. When there are no unoccupied candidate segments, no position correspondence is established between the reference segment and the corresponding subsequent rotation cycle. The allowable position deviation is the angular width of one position detection segment.

[0049] For a set of load anomaly location segments that form a corresponding relationship within the current detection window, the shortest circumferential distance between each pair of rotor center positions of each segment is determined, and the maximum value among them is determined as the detection window position offset. In this embodiment, the detection window is formed by three adjacent complete rotation cycles; when there are corresponding load anomaly location segments in all three complete rotation cycles, and the detection window position offset does not exceed the allowable position deviation, the subsequent locality judgment is initiated.

[0050] Each load anomaly location segment in the same subsequent rotation cycle enters at most one cross-cycle correspondence, which can avoid the same candidate segment being reused by multiple reference segments. In addition to meeting the single-cycle load over-limit condition, the load anomaly also needs to maintain a unique correspondence with the same rotor mechanical position during continuous rotation, so that the judgment of local mechanical interference has two detection criteria: load anomaly and mechanical position repetition.

[0051] For multiple load anomaly location segments corresponding to the completed position, they are transformed to the same continuous position coordinates according to the rotor circumferential position relationship, and the common coverage area of ​​each load anomaly location segment is determined under the continuous position coordinates; when a common coverage area exists, it is determined as the continuous anomaly core segment. Whether a continuous anomaly core segment has formed is not used as a criterion for determining a local mechanical interference fault. Only when a local mechanical interference fault is determined to exist based on the comparison of position correspondence, position deviation, and local load deviation, the formed continuous anomaly core segment is output as the rotor position range corresponding to the further fault.

[0052] Specifically, the rotor position at the center of the first load anomaly location segment corresponding to the completed position is taken as the zero point of the continuous position coordinates, and the rotor rotation direction is taken as the positive direction of the continuous position coordinates. For each subsequent corresponding load anomaly location segment, the shortest circumferential path is determined from the rotor position at the center of the segment corresponding to the zero point to the rotor position at the center of the load anomaly location segment. When the shortest circumferential path is in the same direction as the rotor rotation, the corresponding circumferential position distance is recorded as a positive value; when the shortest circumferential path is opposite to the rotor rotation direction, the corresponding circumferential position distance is recorded as a negative value. The continuous coordinates of the segment center of the load anomaly location segment are determined using the obtained directed circumferential position distance. For each load anomaly location segment, the circumferential interval length from the first rotor position to the center rotor position along the rotor rotation direction, and the circumferential interval length from the center rotor position to the last rotor position are determined. The first continuous coordinate is determined from the corresponding segment center continuous coordinate along the negative direction according to the previous circumferential interval length, and the last continuous coordinate is determined along the positive direction according to the next circumferential interval length, ensuring that the load anomaly location segment remains a complete segment in the continuous position coordinates. For each load anomaly location segment corresponding to a completed position, the maximum value among the first continuous coordinates of each segment is determined as the first continuous coordinate of the common coverage area, and the minimum value among the last continuous coordinates of each segment is determined as the last continuous coordinate of the common coverage area. When the first continuous coordinate is less than the last continuous coordinate, and there is at least one complete position detection segment between them, the range between the first and last continuous coordinates is determined as the continuous anomaly core segment. After confirmation, the persistent abnormal core segment is converted back to rotor position coordinates within a complete rotation cycle, and its initial rotor position, final rotor position, and center rotor position are saved as further rotor position range outputs after a local mechanical interference fault is determined. A persistent abnormal core segment is not formed when the initial continuous coordinates of the common coverage area are not less than the final continuous coordinates, or when there is no complete position detection segment between them. When a subsequent local mechanical interference fault is determined, the original position outputs of the corresponding load abnormal position segments are retained. The absence of a persistent abnormal core segment does not affect subsequent local mechanical interference fault determinations.

[0053] Through the above processing, when the load anomaly location segment in different rotation cycles experiences boundary expansion or finite position shift due to detection fluctuations, the rotor position range corresponding to the fault is not directly determined by the boundary of the anomaly segment in a single cycle. Instead, the rotor position continuously covered by the fault is determined from multiple anomaly segments whose positions have already been identified. Therefore, without changing the subsequent local mechanical interference fault determination conditions, a more concentrated position segment can be extracted from multiple load anomaly location segments with a common coverage area, which can be used to refine the rotor position range corresponding to the already determined local mechanical interference fault.

[0054] Further, the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of each rotor position within the corresponding load anomaly position segment is calculated as the mean of the local load deviation of the corresponding segment; the rotor positions included in all load anomaly position segments within the same rotation cycle are excluded, and the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of the remaining rotor positions is calculated as the mean of the local load deviation of the remaining positions; if there are no remaining rotor positions, the comparison condition of the mean of the local load deviation is not met; the corresponding rotor position includes the first rotor position, the last rotor position, and the center rotor position of the corresponding segment.

[0055] Specifically, for each rotation cycle within the detection window that corresponds to a load anomaly location segment, the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of each detection segment within that load anomaly location segment is calculated; simultaneously, the remaining detection segments within the same rotation cycle that are not identified as load anomaly locations are obtained, and their local load deviation arithmetic mean is calculated. If there are no other unmarked load anomaly locations, the rotation cycle does not satisfy the locality determination condition of this embodiment.

[0056] When three consecutive complete rotation cycles all have corresponding load anomaly locations, the detection window position offset does not exceed the allowable position deviation, and the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of each corresponding segment is greater than the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of the remaining positions not identified as load anomalies within the same cycle, a judgment result characterizing a local mechanical interference fault in the air preheater is generated. The detection result records the first rotor position, the last rotor position, and the center rotor position of the corresponding load anomaly location segment; when a persistent anomaly core segment is formed, the first rotor position, the last rotor position, and the center rotor position of the persistent anomaly core segment are further recorded. When no persistent anomaly core segment is formed, the position output of the corresponding load anomaly location segment is retained.

[0057] Through the aforementioned local comparisons, having eliminated the overall periodic load variation and confirmed the repetition of abnormal cross-cycle positions, it is further confirmed that the load increase is concentrated within a limited rotor position range, rather than manifesting as a change throughout the entire rotation cycle. Therefore, the correction of overall periodic load variation within the relative load deviation domain, the correspondence between cross-cycle positions, and the comparison of local differences within the cycle form a continuous fault determination chain, outputting the rotor position range corresponding to the load anomaly, providing a basis for conducting local mechanical interference checks within this rotor position range.

[0058] Example 2: This embodiment describes the core detection process of the fault detection method for mechanical operation status of air preheaters. It is used to detect local load anomalies that are concentrated in some rotor positions and recur across rotation cycles when the air preheater is continuously rotating and the driving load is affected by changes in operating conditions.

[0059] During the detection process, the three-phase current detection signal, rotor position detection signal, operating condition parameters, and normal operation reference data of the air preheater's drive motor are acquired. The rotor position detection signal is generated by a position encoder that rotates synchronously with the rotor. The reference position of the position encoder is used as the rotor reference position, and the process between two adjacent passes of the rotor reference position is defined as a complete rotation cycle. Each complete rotation cycle is divided into corresponding position detection segments according to the same starting point, rotation direction, and position angle width, ensuring that the detection data from different rotation cycles have unified rotor position coordinates. The three-phase current detection signal and rotor position detection signal are acquired according to a unified sampling clock, and the current detection data is assigned to the corresponding position detection segment based on the sampling timestamp. The effective value of the three-phase current within each position detection segment is determined, and the arithmetic mean of the three-phase current effective values ​​is used as the drive load detection value for the corresponding position detection segment. The drive load detection value is a current characteristic quantity used to characterize changes in the drive load and is not used as a direct measurement value of the drive motor's output torque.

[0060] For each complete rotational cycle to be tested, the corresponding normal complete rotational cycle is obtained from the normal operating reference data based on the unit load, air preheater speed, flue gas flow rate, primary air flow rate, and secondary air flow rate of that rotational cycle. For each position detection segment, the normal load benchmark is determined based on the drive load detection value of the same position detection segment in each normal complete rotational cycle. Following the same processing method as the data to be tested, the normal relative load deviation of each position detection segment relative to the normal load benchmark in each normal complete rotational cycle is determined. The median of the normal relative load deviation of all position detection segments in that normal complete rotational cycle is subtracted to obtain the normal local load deviation. The normal load fluctuation limit is then determined based on the normal local load deviation of the same position detection segment.

[0061] For a complete rotation cycle to be detected, the drive load detection value of each position detection segment is subtracted from the corresponding normal load reference, and the difference is divided by the normal load reference to obtain the relative load deviation. The median of the relative load deviations of all position detection segments in the rotation cycle is used to determine the overall load change component of the cycle, and it is subtracted from the relative load deviations of each position detection segment to obtain the local load deviation. This embodiment is applicable to operating scenarios where the number of position detection segments affected by local mechanical interference is less than the number of unaffected position detection segments, and the overall load change causes an approximately common offset to each position within the relative load deviation domain. Positions where the local load deviation exceeds the corresponding normal load fluctuation limit are identified as abnormal load positions. Adjacent abnormal load positions are merged along the rotor rotation direction to form abnormal load position segments; for abnormal positions that cross the rotor reference position, they are merged according to the relationship of the beginning and end of the complete rotation cycle. The first rotor position, the last rotor position, and the center rotor position of the abnormal load position segment are determined respectively.

[0062] A detection window is formed using three adjacent complete rotation cycles, and the load anomaly location segments in each rotation cycle are matched. When there are corresponding load anomaly location segments in all three rotation cycles, and the maximum value of the shortest circumferential distance between the center rotor positions of each corresponding segment does not exceed the allowable position deviation, the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of each detection segment within each corresponding segment is calculated, and the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of the remaining detection segments in the same rotation cycle that are not identified as load anomaly locations is also calculated. When the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of each corresponding segment is greater than the arithmetic mean of the local load deviation of the remaining detection segments in the same rotation cycle, a local mechanical interference fault judgment result is generated, and the first rotor position, the last rotor position, and the center rotor position of each corresponding load anomaly location segment are output.

[0063] Through the above process, the detection results simultaneously meet the conditions of local load exceeding limits, abnormal position repetition across cycles, and local load concentration within a cycle. This allows for the identification of repetitive local load anomalies related to rotor position, even when the overall load change of the cycle is superimposed on the drive load detection value. The output position is a rotor position range determined relative to the rotor reference position and does not represent a direct measurement of specific contact components or physical contact points.

[0064] Although embodiments of the invention have been shown and described, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes, modifications, substitutions and alterations can be made to these embodiments without departing from the principles and spirit of the invention, the scope of which is defined by the appended claims and their equivalents.

Claims

1. A method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater, characterized in that, include: Acquire the drive load detection value, rotor position detection signal, operating condition parameters and normal operation reference data of the air preheater, divide the rotation cycle according to the same rotor reference position based on the rotor position detection signal and determine the rotor position in each rotation cycle; For each complete rotation cycle, the normal load reference and normal load fluctuation limit for each position are determined based on the operating condition parameters and normal operation reference data. The relative load deviation of the drive load detection value relative to the normal load reference is calculated. The overall load change component of the cycle determined by the relative load deviation of each position in this cycle is deducted to obtain the local load deviation. The abnormal load location segment is determined based on the comparison result between the local load deviation and the corresponding normal load fluctuation limit. The load abnormality location segments of three adjacent cycles are matched. When there are corresponding load abnormality location segments in all three cycles, the maximum value of the shortest circumferential distance between the center rotor positions of each corresponding segment does not exceed the allowable position deviation, and the average local load deviation of each corresponding segment is greater than the average local load deviation of the other positions in the same cycle that have not been identified as load abnormalities, a local mechanical interference fault is determined and the corresponding rotor position is output.

2. The method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater according to claim 1, characterized in that, The rotor position detection signal is generated by a position encoder that rotates synchronously with the air preheater rotor. The reference position of the position encoder is used as the rotor reference position. The running process between two adjacent passes of the rotor reference position is determined as a complete rotation cycle. Each complete rotation cycle is divided into corresponding position detection segments according to a preset angle width, so that each position detection segment has a rotor position determined relative to the rotor reference position.

3. The method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater according to claim 2, characterized in that, The three-phase current detection signal and rotor position detection signal of the drive motor are collected according to a unified sampling clock, and a sampling timestamp is assigned to the sampling data. The three-phase current detection signal is associated with the corresponding position detection segment based on the sampling timestamp, the effective value of the three-phase current in each position detection segment is determined, and the arithmetic mean of the effective value of the three-phase current is determined as the drive load detection value of the corresponding position detection segment. The drive load detection value is a current characteristic quantity used to characterize the change of drive load.

4. The method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater according to claim 2, characterized in that, The operating condition parameters include unit load, air preheater speed, flue gas flow rate, primary air flow rate, and secondary air flow rate; the corresponding normal complete rotation cycle is determined from the normal operation reference data based on the operating condition parameters of the complete rotation cycle to be detected, and the normal load benchmark is determined based on the drive load detection value of the detection section at the same position in each normal complete rotation cycle. The relative load deviation of each detection segment relative to the normal load reference is determined in each normal complete rotation cycle. The normal local load deviation is obtained by determining and subtracting the overall load change component of the cycle based on the relative load deviation of the same normal complete rotation cycle. The normal load fluctuation limit is determined based on the normal local load deviation of the detection segment at the same position.

5. The method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater according to claim 2, characterized in that, The ratio of the difference between the drive load detection value of each position detection segment in the complete rotation cycle to be detected and the corresponding normal load reference to the normal load reference is determined as the relative load deviation; the median of the relative load deviations of all position detection segments in the complete rotation cycle to be detected is used to determine the overall load change component of the cycle, and the overall load change component of the cycle is subtracted from the relative load deviations of each position detection segment to obtain the local load deviation of the corresponding position detection segment.

6. The method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater according to claim 2, characterized in that, The rotor position where the local load deviation exceeds the corresponding normal load fluctuation limit is determined as the load abnormal position, and adjacent load abnormal positions are merged along the rotor rotation direction to form a load abnormal position segment. For load anomaly locations distributed at the beginning and end of a complete rotation cycle, they are merged according to the circumferential relationship of the beginning and end of the complete rotation cycle; the beginning rotor position, the end rotor position, and the center rotor position of the load anomaly location segment are determined along the rotor rotation direction.

7. The method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater according to claim 6, characterized in that, Using the load anomaly location segment of the first rotation cycle in three adjacent complete rotation cycles as the reference segment, the positions of the rotor center of each reference segment are sequentially matched along the rotor rotation direction. For each reference segment, in subsequent rotation cycles, from the candidate segments that have not yet established a correspondence and whose shortest circumferential distance from the reference segment does not exceed the allowable position deviation, the candidate segment with the smallest shortest circumferential distance is selected to establish a correspondence. If the shortest circumferential distances are the same, the candidate segment that is reached first along the rotor rotation direction is selected. Once the candidate segment establishes a correspondence, it will no longer participate in the position correspondence of other reference segments; the maximum value of the shortest circumferential distance between the rotor positions of the center of a set of corresponding segments within three cycles is determined as the detection window position offset, which does not exceed the allowable position deviation, and the allowable position deviation is determined according to the angle width of the position detection segment.

8. The method for detecting mechanical operating status faults in an air preheater according to claim 7, characterized in that, Calculate the arithmetic mean of the local load deviations of each rotor position within the corresponding load anomaly location segment, and use it as the mean of the local load deviations of the corresponding segment; exclude the rotor positions included in all load anomaly location segments within the same rotation cycle, and calculate the arithmetic mean of the local load deviations of the remaining rotor positions, and use it as the mean of the local load deviations of the remaining positions; if there are no remaining rotor positions, the comparison condition of the mean of local load deviations is not met; the corresponding rotor positions include the first rotor position, the last rotor position, and the center rotor position of the corresponding segment.