Simulation method for a coating installation, and corresponding coating installation
Patent Information
- Application Number
- EP2023716537
- Authority / Receiving Office
- EP · EP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-04-04
- Filing Date
- 2023-04-03
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-04
AI Technical Summary
Current simulation methods for coating systems, while capable of simulating painting processes, do not adequately account for the degree of wetness and its impact on coating quality, which is crucial beyond uniform layer thickness.
The simulation method incorporates the degree of wetness as a quality parameter, allowing for the superimposition of multiple instantaneous spray patterns and their geometric projection onto the component surface, with adjustments using artificial intelligence to optimize coating parameters such as spray patterns and paths, ensuring a satisfactory coating result.
This approach enhances the simulation's ability to achieve optimal coating quality by considering the degree of wetness, leading to improved uniformity and layer thickness distribution, even in complex coating scenarios, and can be applied to various coating materials and systems beyond painting.
Smart Images

Figure 1.1
Abstract
Description
[0001] DESCRIPTION
[0002] Simulation method for a coating system and corresponding coating system
[0003] Field of the invention
[0004] The invention relates to a simulation method for a coating system for coating a component using an applicator, in particular for a painting system for painting motor vehicle body components using an atomizer or a print head. Furthermore, the invention relates to a corresponding coating system for implementing the simulation method.
[0005] Background of the invention
[0006] From DE 10 2019 113 341 Al and DE 10 2020 114 201 Al a simulation method is known that makes it possible to simulate painting processes.
[0007] This involves first specifying geometric data that represents the geometry of the component to be painted. For example, this geometric data can be provided in the form of a CAD file (CAD: Computer Aided Design), where the CAD file represents the shape of a vehicle body to be painted.
[0008] Furthermore, general painting parameters are specified, such as the air temperature in the paint booth or paint parameters (e.g. viscosity of the paint).
[0009] In addition, a painting path is specified, which is to be followed by the paint impact point of the application device used (e.g. rotary atomizer) during operation.
[0010] Furthermore, initial values for the painting parameters to be optimized are initially determined. These can be instantaneous spray patterns, i.e., layer thickness distributions around the respective paint impact point. These instantaneous spray patterns are then superimposed during the simulation.
[0011] This computational superimposition of the instantaneous spray patterns can also be performed within the scope of the invention using a projection method, i.e., the spray patterns (possibly adapted with regard to certain aspects of the coating situation) are geometrically projected onto the workpiece geometry. The instantaneous spray patterns projected onto the workpiece geometry are then superimposed. The term "superimposition of the instantaneous spray patterns" used within the scope of the invention therefore also encompasses the projection method mentioned above.
[0012] In a simulation loop, the current spray patterns can then be optimized to achieve the best possible painting result within the simulation. For example, one optimization goal might be to achieve the most uniform layer thickness possible.
[0013] The instantaneous spray patterns used in the simulation of the coating process can be derived from reference spray patterns stored in a database for various reference painting situations. Within the simulation loop, the instantaneous painting situation is first determined for each point along the painting path. A reference spray pattern is then read from the database. This reference spray pattern was measured in a reference painting situation that corresponds as closely as possible to the current instantaneous painting situation. However, the database does not usually contain corresponding reference spray patterns for all possible instantaneous painting situations. Therefore, in practice, the instantaneous spray pattern is determined by interpolation or by mathematically adapting reference spray patterns stored in the database.
[0014] The known simulation method described above already delivers satisfactory simulation results. However, there is a need for further optimization of this known simulation method.
[0015] Description of the invention
[0016] The invention is therefore based on the object of creating a correspondingly improved simulation method. Furthermore, the invention is based on the object of creating a correspondingly adapted coating system suitable for implementing the simulation method according to the invention.
[0017] This object is achieved by a simulation method according to claim 1 or by a coating system according to the independent claim. The invention is based on the newly acquired technical-physical insight that the quality of the coating depends not only on the uniformity of the layer thickness. Rather, the quality of the coating is also determined by the so-called degree of wetness. Thus, in the simulation, several instantaneous spray patterns are superimposed, so that the coating in the simulation consists of several superpositions of instantaneous spray patterns. Accordingly, the actual coating on the actual component also has several superpositions resulting from several spray patterns that were applied to the component surface, for example, along parallel coating paths.
[0018] Here, it is possible for the various superimposed instantaneous spray patterns to each contribute equally to the total layer thickness. If, for example, three instantaneous spray patterns are superimposed at one point on the component surface, each instantaneous spray pattern can contribute one-third to the total layer thickness. However, it is also possible for the various superimposed instantaneous spray patterns to contribute very differently to the total layer thickness. With three superimpositions, for example, it is possible for the individual superimpositions to contribute to the total layer thickness in a ratio of 70%:20%:10%. Within the scope of the invention, the degree of wetness can then reflect the percentage share of the total layer thickness of the coating that the individual superimposed layers have. For example, the degree of wetness can indicate the largest percentage share of one of the superimpositions in the total layer thickness.
[0019] Furthermore, the number of overlapping layers of different layers can also vary within the coated component surface. For example, the coating at one location on the component surface may consist of three overlapping layers of instantaneous spray patterns, while the coating at another location on the component surface may consist of five overlapping layers of instantaneous spray patterns. The term "wetness level" used in the context of the invention can then also indicate how many overlapping layers of instantaneous spray patterns the coating consists of at each point on the component surface.
[0020] Furthermore, the degree of wetness can also reflect the geometric properties of the instantaneous spray patterns that influence the overall layer thickness at the respective point on the component surface.
[0021] Furthermore, within the scope of the invention, it is also possible for the degree of wetness to indicate the total layer thickness at a particular point on the component surface. The term "degree of wetness" used within the scope of the invention may reflect one or more of the aforementioned definitions.
[0022] When determining the degree of wetness, within the scope of the invention, several or all locally involved spray patterns can be taken into account (e.g. mean value of the proportions, ratios of the proportions, ...) or only one specific locally involved spray pattern (e.g. that which leads to the highest degree of wetness at the point under consideration, which is the last to be coated, ...).
[0023] It should be noted that when calculating the simulated coating result, different instantaneous spray patterns can be used than when calculating the wetness level.
[0024] The simulation method according to the invention is preferably suitable for a paint shop for painting motor vehicle body components using an atomizer (e.g., a rotary atomizer) or a print head. However, the invention is not limited to use in a paint shop, but can also be implemented in conjunction with a coating system that applies other coating materials, such as adhesives, insulating materials, or sealants, to name just a few examples.
[0025] Furthermore, the invention is not limited to use in a painting system that paints motor vehicle body components. With regard to the components to be coated, the invention is therefore not limited to motor vehicle body components.
[0026] Furthermore, the invention is suitable not only for simulations in coating systems that use an atomizer (e.g., a rotary atomizer) or a print head as an applicator. The principle of the invention is therefore also generally applicable in this regard.
[0027] The simulation method according to the invention, in accordance with the known simulation method described above, initially provides for the specification of geometric data that represent the geometry of the component to be coated. For example, this geometric data can be read from a component file in the form of CAD (Computer Aided Design) data of the component to be coated. Alternatively, however, it is also possible for the geometric data of the component to be coated to be initially generated by measuring a real component.
[0028] Furthermore, the simulation method according to the invention, in accordance with the known simulation method described above, also provides for the initial specification of general coating parameters, such as coating agent parameters (e.g., viscosity), applicator type, bell cup type, or path spacing of adjacent coating paths. These general coating parameters are preferably specified by the user or read from a data storage device. It should be noted that these general coating parameters do not need to be optimized within the scope of the simulation method according to the invention. However, it is also possible within the scope of the invention for the general coating parameters to be optimized as well.
[0029] In addition, initial values for the coating parameters to be optimized are then determined. The coating parameters to be optimized initially comprise a coating path consisting of numerous path points, which is to be traversed from the paint impact point of the applicator (e.g., rotary atomizer) during coating operation, as is known per se from the prior art. It should be noted that the term "path point" is to be understood generally within the scope of the invention and preferably refers to the temporal or spatial discretization of the path trajectory (e.g., one path point every x milliseconds or one path point every y millimeters).
[0030] In addition, the coating parameters to be optimized also include so-called instantaneous spray patterns for the individual points of the coating path, whereby the instantaneous spray patterns reflect the layer thickness distribution on the component around the paint impact point on the component.
[0031] It should be noted that the starting values of the coating parameters to be optimized do not have to be specified by the user, but can be determined programmatically. For example, the starting values of the current spray patterns can be derived from reference spray patterns previously determined for various coating situations, for example, by coating test sheets, as is known from the prior art.
[0032] The simulation method according to the invention then provides for the program-controlled execution of several steps in a simulation loop, wherein the individual steps are carried out for the individual path points of the coating path.
[0033] First, a simulated coating result is calculated within the simulation loop by superimposing the current spray patterns for the individual points along the coating path. This superimposition of the current spray patterns can also be achieved, for example, using a projection method, as will be described in detail below.
[0034] The next step in the simulation loop is to test the simulation results, where, for example, the uniformity of the resulting layer thickness is evaluated as a quality parameter. However, the invention differs from the known simulation method described above in that the degree of wetness at individual points on the component surface is determined and considered as a quality parameter.
[0035] In the simulation loop, the next step is to adjust the coating parameters to be optimized (e.g. current spray patterns, coating path) in order to optimize the simulated coating result.
[0036] The simulation loop is then repeated until the simulated coating result is satisfactory and the degree of wetness determined during the simulation at the individual points on the component surface is acceptable.
[0037] The procedure explained above is described again below in other words to avoid misunderstandings. This allows the user to assign different (or identical) reference spray patterns to different path sections. For the first simulation run, these would be the starting values specified by the user (e.g., in a brush table with spray pattern width and scaling factor for the spray pattern height). Depending on the painting situation on the workpiece, these reference spray patterns can be automatically adjusted by the program to create current spray patterns, which are then used for the simulation. For the first simulation run, these would be the starting values automatically determined by the program based on the reference spray patterns specified by the user and the painting situation on the workpiece. If the first simulation result is not satisfactory, the user changes the assignment of reference spray patterns (e.g.,(wider spray pattern, higher spray pattern, etc.), i.e., it changes the starting values from the first simulation run. Consequently, the automatically determined instantaneous spray patterns used for the simulation also change. This continues until a satisfactory coating thickness result is achieved.
[0038] As already mentioned above, the coating parameters to be optimized (e.g., current spray patterns, coating path) are optimized within the simulation loop. This optimization can be performed, for example, by an operator based on experience. In a preferred embodiment, however, the adjustment of the coating parameters to be optimized in the simulation loop is carried out using artificial intelligence (K1).
[0039] At the beginning of the simulation loop, initial values for the current spray patterns are specified at the individual points along the coating path. When determining the current spray patterns, the respective current coating situation is preferably taken into account. For example, the current coating situation is characterized by the coating distance (i.e., the distance between the applicator and the component surface), the component geometry at the paint impact point, and similar coating parameters. Depending on this current coating situation at the individual points along the coating path, the corresponding current spray patterns can then be determined using a spray pattern database in which reference spray patterns for various coating situations are stored.
[0040] For example, the stored reference spray patterns can be determined in spray pattern tests in which test sheets are coated in different reference coating situations. The coating thickness distribution on the test sheets is then measured and stored in the spray pattern database along with the associated coating parameters that define the respective reference coating situation. The current spray patterns can then be derived from the stored reference spray patterns, which can also be achieved, for example, by interpolating various stored reference spray patterns. If, for example, the current coating situation does not exactly match the reference coating situation of the reference spray patterns stored in the spray pattern database, two or more reference spray patterns determined in similar coating situations can be interpolated.
[0041] However, the determination of the current spray patterns from the stored reference spray patterns does not necessarily have to be done by interpolating from several stored reference spray patterns. Alternatively, a current spray pattern can also be determined by mathematically adjusting a stored reference spray pattern. This adjustment of the reference spray patterns stored in the database according to the current coating situation can also be performed using an algorithm, for example, using artificial intelligence (Kl).
[0042] In practice, the adjustment can be performed automatically using correction or scaling factors if the current coating situation involves a geometric edge (e.g., coating path at the workpiece edge), since in this case a certain percentage of the coating agent jets (projection jets) bypass the workpiece. The adjusted spray pattern can then be projected onto the workpiece surface.
[0043] The current coating situation and the reference coating situation can be defined, for example, by at least one of the following variables:
[0044] • Type of applicator,
[0045] • Type of bell cup of a rotary atomizer that forms the applicator,
[0046] • Type of shaping air ring used on the applicator,
[0047] • Application parameters, especially
[0048] • Coating agent flow rate,
[0049] • shaping air volume flow,
[0050] • Speed of the bell cup,
[0051] • High voltage of an electrostatic coating agent charge,
[0052] • spatial orientation of an applicator axis of the applicator relative to the surface of the component to be coated,
[0053] • absolute spatial direction of an applicator axis in space,
[0054] • Cabin parameters of a coating cabin, especially
[0055] • cabin temperature in the coating cabin,
[0056] • Descending air speed in the coating booth,
[0057] • Track spacing between adjacent coating tracks,
[0058] • Path speed at which the applicator is moved along the coating path,
[0059] • Coating track used for measuring the reference spray pattern,
[0060] • Coating path in the current coating situation,
[0061] • Geometry of the test component used to measure the reference spray pattern,
[0062] • Geometry of the component to be coated.
[0063] As already mentioned above, the reference spray patterns stored in the spray pattern database can be determined prior to the simulation loop through coating tests on test panels. The coating thickness distribution measured on the test panels is then stored in the spray pattern database as a reference spray pattern, associated with the respective reference coating situation.
[0064] It should also be noted that the reference spray patterns stored in the spray pattern database can be either dynamic or static spray patterns. Dynamic spray patterns are measured as the result of coating processes in which the applicator moves relative to the component (e.g., test sheet). Static spray patterns, on the other hand, are measured as the result of coating processes in which the applicator is stationary relative to the component (e.g., test sheet).
[0065] The simulation loop can then continuously check at which points along the coating path the adjustment of the coating parameters to be optimized has led to a change in the coating parameters. This means that the coating parameters are typically not changed at all points along the coating path during the various runs of the simulation loop. The simulation then only needs to be updated at those points along the coating path where the optimization of the coating parameters has actually led to a change. Therefore, within the scope of the invention, it is not necessary for the simulation loop to extend over all points along the coating path in each run.
[0066] Furthermore, it should be noted that the general coating parameters mentioned above may include at least one of the following:
[0067] • Coating agent properties of the coating agent, in particular viscosity of the coating agent,
[0068] • Type of applicator,
[0069] • Type of bell cup of a rotary atomizer,
[0070] • Cabin parameters of a coating cabin, especially
[0071] • cabin temperature in the coating cabin,
[0072] • Descending air speed in the coating booth,
[0073] • desired layer thickness of the coating agent on the component,
[0074] • Track spacing between adjacent coating tracks,
[0075] • Path speed at which the applicator is moved along the coating path.
[0076] The coating parameters to be optimized can, for example, include at least one of the following:
[0077] • spatial course of the coating path, in particular with coordinates of the individual path points,
[0078] • spatial orientation of the applicator axis of the applicator in the individual points of the coating path,
[0079] • Brush parameters, especially coating agent flow,
[0080] shaping air flow,
[0081] Voltage of an electrostatic coating agent charge,
[0082] • Switch-on points of the applicator on the coating path,
[0083] • Switch-off points of the applicator on the coating path,
[0084] • Coating agent flow in the individual points of the coating path,
[0085] • Atomizer speed at the individual points of the coating path,
[0086] • High voltage of an electrostatic coating agent charge,
[0087] • Type of applicator, especially for sealing applications,
[0088] • Track spacing between adjacent coating tracks,
[0089] • Path speed at which the applicator is moved along the coating path,
[0090] • the general coating parameters mentioned above.
[0091] Within the scope of the invention, the simulated coating result can then be displayed graphically on a screen to allow an operator to easily assess it. However, it is also possible for the simulated coating result to be evaluated automatically, for example, using artificial intelligence (Kl).
[0092] After the simulation process according to the invention has been completed, optimized coating parameters are available for the individual points along the coating path. These optimized coating parameters can then be transferred to a control system of the coating system, so that the control system can then control the coating system accordingly during real coating operation. In practice, the optimized coating parameters are thus converted into real control variables for controlling the coating system.
[0093] This conversion ("forward translation") of the optimized coating parameters into real control variables for controlling the coating system preferably concerns the commissioning or optimization of existing systems or existing coatings. However, within the scope of the invention, it is also possible for existing control variables of the coating system to be read in by the simulation computer and converted into start parameterizations for the simulation. Control variables for controlling the coating system that have already been tested in practice are used as starting values for the coating parameters to be optimized ("backward translation"). The term "conversion of the optimized coating parameters into real control variables for controlling the coating system" used within the scope of the invention is therefore to be understood in a correspondingly general manner.Furthermore, it should be noted that the invention not only claims protection for the above-described simulation method according to the invention. Rather, the invention also claims protection for a corresponding coating system suitable for implementing the simulation method according to the invention. For this purpose, the coating system according to the invention comprises, in addition to at least one coating robot with an applicator (e.g., rotary atomizer) and a control system, a simulation computer on which a simulation program is stored, which, when executed, executes the simulation method according to the invention.
[0094] In general, the simulation can also be carried out on an "offline" computer (e.g. office laptop) (e.g. planning department, offline department, training department, ...), and the coating parameters found can then be transferred to the control system later / if required.
[0095] Other advantageous developments of the invention are characterized in the subclaims or are explained in more detail below together with the description of the preferred embodiments of the invention with reference to the figures.
[0096] Brief description of the drawings
[0097] Figures 1A and 1B show a flow chart to illustrate the simulation method according to the invention.
[0098] Figure 2A shows a schematic representation of the superposition of three instantaneous spray patterns applied on three parallel painting paths.
[0099] Figure 2B shows the resulting layer thickness of the superposition of the three instantaneous spray patterns.
[0100] Figure 2C shows the number of overlays of the instantaneous spray patterns at different points on the component surface.
[0101] Figure 2D shows the wetness level for different points on the component surface.
[0102] Figure 3A shows a coating with three overlays of instantaneous spray patterns, each contributing very differently to the total coating thickness. Figure 3B shows a variation of Figure 3A, with the individual overlays contributing equally to the total coating thickness.
[0103] Figure 4A shows a reference spray pattern measured in a reference painting situation.
[0104] Figure 4B shows a corresponding instantaneous spray pattern in a changed instantaneous painting situation, whereby the instantaneous spray pattern was derived from the reference spray pattern according to Figure 4A.
[0105] Figure 5 shows a simplified schematic representation of a painting system according to the invention with a simulation computer for carrying out the simulation method according to the invention.
[0106] Detailed information The flow chart shown in Figures 1A and 1B will now be described, which shows the simulation method according to the invention in simplified form.
[0107] In a first step (S1), a file containing a definition of the geometry of the vehicle body to be painted is imported. For example, this file can be provided by the manufacturer of the respective vehicle as a CAD file.
[0108] In a further step S2, general painting parameters are then set, such as the following painting parameters:
[0109] • Distance between the painting tracks,
[0110] • Track speed,
[0111] • Paint properties of the paint used,
[0112] • Atomizer type,
[0113] • cabin temperature in the paint booth,
[0114] • Descending air velocity in the paint booth.
[0115] In a further step S3, initial values for the painting parameters to be optimized are then programmatically specified for a subsequent simulation run. For example, the painting parameters to be optimized could be the following:
[0116] • Course of the painting path, • Switch-on and switch-off points of the atomizer along the painting path,
[0117] • Orientation of the atomizer axis at the various points of the painting path,
[0118] • Brush parameterization, e.g. paint flow, shaping air flow, voltage of the electrostatic high-voltage charge.
[0119] After the initial run of the simulation loop, the painting parameters to be optimized are adjusted for the next simulation run in step S4. This adjustment can be performed, for example, based on experience by an operator or by artificial intelligence (Kl).
[0120] In the next step (S5), those points along the robot path are determined where the adjustment of the painting parameters to be optimized has led to a significant change in the painting situation. This is useful so that the simulation loop described in detail below does not have to include all points along the robot path, including those points where the adjustment of the painting parameters to be optimized does not lead to a significant change.
[0121] In the following steps S6, S7 and S8, a simulation loop is then run through, which extends over all points of the painting path in which the painting parameters have been significantly changed.
[0122] The first step S6 provides for the determination of current spray patterns at the individual path points according to the respective current painting situation. For example, reference spray patterns can be read from a spray pattern database. These reference spray patterns can be previously determined, for example, by coating test panels. When determining the current spray patterns according to the respective current painting situation, a check is first carried out to determine whether a reference spray pattern is stored in the spray pattern database that was measured in a reference painting situation that exactly corresponds to the current painting situation. If this is the case, the stored reference spray pattern can be read out and adopted as the current spray pattern.
[0123] However, this is usually not possible. Instead, in practice, the current spray pattern is mathematically derived from one or more stored reference spray patterns measured under similar reference coating situations. This adaptation of the stored reference spray patterns to determine the current spray patterns to be used according to step S7 can be performed, for example, using artificial intelligence (K1). For example, a projection method can also be used, as already mentioned.
[0124] In the next step S8, the painting result is simulated, including the degree of wetness, based on the following parameters:
[0125] • Current spray patterns for the individual points of the painting path,
[0126] • general painting parameters,
[0127] • Geometry of the vehicle body,
[0128] • Painting parameters that need to be optimized.
[0129] In the next step, S9, it is checked whether the simulated painting result is satisfactory. If this is not the case, the painting parameters to be optimized are adjusted again for the next simulation run in step S4.
[0130] Otherwise, the optimized painting parameters are saved in the next step S10 and can then be used in real painting operations to control the painting system.
[0131] Figure 2A shows, by way of example, three instantaneous spray patterns 1, 2, and 3, which are applied by a rotary atomizer while traveling along three parallel sections of a painting track, with the instantaneous spray patterns 1-3 partially overlapping on a component surface 4. The instantaneous spray patterns 1-3 are shown in a highly simplified trapezoidal form. In practice, however, the instantaneous spray patterns 1-3 have a slightly different shape depending on the type of application device used. The schematic representation of the instantaneous spray patterns 1-3 therefore serves only to illustrate the invention.
[0132] Figure 2B shows the resulting layer thickness SD for various points on the component surface perpendicular to the path sections of the paint path. This illustration shows that the layer thickness SD is completely constant with optimal superposition of the adjacent instantaneous spray patterns 1-3, which is an unattainable optimal condition in practice.
[0133] Fig. 2C further shows that, due to their superposition, the instantaneous spray patterns 1-3 result in a coating composed of a different number of overlays. For example, the coating between x=x2 and x=x3 consists of n=2 overlays, while the coating between x=x3 and x=x4 consists of a single overlay (n=1). It should be noted that this example is purely theoretical and is intended to illustrate the invention.
[0134] Finally, Figure 2D shows the progression of a possible wetness level NG along the component surface transversely to the track sections of the painting tracks. It is assumed that the desired number of overlays is nsou=2, i.e., the coating should, if possible, consist of n=2 overlays of the instantaneous spray patterns 1-3 at every point on the component surface. The wetness level NG is then defined at every point on the component surface as the deviation from this target value. Thus, the coating between x=x3 and x=x4 consists only of the instantaneous spray pattern 2, so that the deviation from the desired number nsou=2 of overlays is NG=1. Between x=x2 and x=x3, however, the coating consists of the overlay of the two instantaneous spray patterns 1, 2, so that the wetness level NG, as a deviation from the target value, is NG=0.
[0135] In the illustration according to Figures 2A-2D, the degree of wetness NG only indicates how many superimposed layers of the instantaneous spray patterns 1-3 the coating consists of at the respective point on the component surface.
[0136] However, the wetness level can also indicate the percentage of the total coating thickness that the individual layers of the instantaneous spray patterns represent. Figures 3A and 3B show a coating 5 with a total layer thickness SD, where coating 5 is composed of three overlays 6-8 of instantaneous spray patterns. In Figure 3A, overlay 6 accounts for a large portion of the total layer thickness SD, resulting in a correspondingly greater wetness level. In Figure 3B, however, overlays 6-8 each contribute equally, one-third, to the total layer thickness SD, resulting in a correspondingly lower wetness level.
[0137] Figure 4A schematically shows a reference spray pattern 9 on a component surface 10, wherein the reference spray pattern 9 was applied and measured in a reference painting situation. The reference painting situation was characterized, among other things, by the applicator axis being oriented perpendicular to the component surface 10.
[0138] Figure 4B, on the other hand, shows a current painting situation in which the applicator axis is aligned obliquely to the component surface 10. The deviation between the reference painting situation according to Figure 4A and the current painting situation according to Figure 4B leads to a correspondingly adjusted current spray pattern 11. This adjustment of the stored reference spray pattern 9 to determine the current spray pattern 11 suitable for the simulation can be carried out, for example, using artificial intelligence (K1). For example, a correction method or a projection method can also be used, as already mentioned.
[0139] The schematic diagram shown in Figure 5 will now be described. The diagram initially shows, in a highly simplified form, a conventional painting system 12, which is controlled by a control computer 13.
[0140] Also shown is a simulation computer 14, which serves to carry out the simulation method according to the invention. For this purpose, the simulation computer 14 is connected to a database computer 15, which contains a spray pattern database with stored reference spray patterns.
[0141] On the input side, the simulation computer 14 first receives the geometric data of the vehicle bodies to be painted.
[0142] In addition, the simulation computer 14 also receives general painting parameters on the input side.
[0143] Furthermore, the simulation computer 14 receives starting values for the painting parameters to be optimized. These starting values can include, for example, the painting path and current spray patterns for the individual points along the painting path.
[0144] The simulation computer 14 then transmits the respective current painting situation to the database computer 15, which determines a suitable current spray pattern corresponding to the respective current painting situation, usually by adapting or interpolating stored reference spray patterns. The database computer 15 then supplies the simulation computer 14 with a suitable current spray pattern for each individual path point of the painting path. The simulation computer 14 can then, together with the database computer 15, execute the simulation process shown in Figures 1A and 1B.
[0145] The invention is not limited to the preferred embodiments described above. Rather, a multitude of variants and modifications are possible, which also utilize the inventive concept and therefore fall within the scope of protection. In particular, the invention also claims protection for the subject matter and features of the subclaims, independently of the respective claims referred to, and in particular even without the features of the main claim. The invention thus encompasses various aspects of the invention that are protected independently of one another. In particular, the following aspects of the invention are worth mentioning, which can be protected independently of one another:
[0146] • Topic “degree of wetness”, i.e. the consideration of the degree of wetness as a quality parameter for the assessment of the simulated painting result.
[0147] • Topic “Adapting the reference spray patterns to the current painting situation”.
[0148] List of reference symbols:
[0149] 1-3 current spray patterns
[0150] 4 Component surface 5 Coating
[0151] 6-8 Overlays of the individual instantaneous spray patterns
[0152] 9 Reference spray pattern
[0153] 10 Component surface
[0154] 11 Current spray pattern 12 Painting system
[0155] 13 tax calculators
[0156] 14 simulation computers
[0157] 15 database computers with database of reference spray patterns
[0158] SD total layer thickness
Claims
REQUIREMENTS 1. Simulation method for a coating system for coating a component by an applicator, in particular for a painting system (12) for painting a motor vehicle body component by an atomizer or a printhead, comprising the following steps: a) specification of geometry data representing the geometry of the component to be coated, in particular by a) reading the geometry data of the component to be coated from a component file or a2) measuring the component to be coated and generating the geometry data during the measurement of the component to be coated, b) specification of general coating parameters, c) specification of initial values of coating parameters to be optimized, including: c) a coating path consisting of numerous path points to be traversed by the applicator during coating operation, and c2) instantaneous spray patterns (1-3;11) for the individual path points of the coating path, wherein the instantaneous spray patterns (1-3; 11) represent the layer thickness distribution on the component around the coating material impact point on the component, wherein the initial values of the instantaneous spray patterns (1-3; 11) are preferably derived programmatically from reference spray patterns (9) that have been determined for various reference coating situations, d) Program-controlled execution of the following steps in a simulation loop for the individual path points of the coating path: dl) Calculation of a simulated coating result, in particular the layer thickness of the coating on the component, by computational superposition of the instantaneous spray patterns (1-3; 11) provided for the individual path points of the coating path, d2) Verification of the simulated coating result, d3) Adjustment of the coating parameters to be optimized, in particular the instantaneous spray patterns (1-3;11) and / or the coating track, and repeat the simulation loop if the simulated coating result is not satisfactory; d4) Terminating the simulation loop if the simulated coating result is satisfactory and adopting the optimized coating parameters, characterized in that, e) during the calculation of the simulated coating result in the simulation loop, the degree of wetness of the simulated coating on the component is calculated for various points on the component surface (4; 10), where the degree of wetness represents, el) how many superimposed layers (6-8) of instantaneous spray patterns (1-3; 11) the coating consists of at the respective point on the component surface (4; 10), and / or e2) what percentage of the total layer thickness (SD) of the coating the individual superimposed layers (6-8) of instantaneous spray patterns (1-3; 11) have at the respective point on the component surface (4; 10), and / or e3) what geometric properties the instantaneous spray patterns have that are present at the respective point on the component surface (4;10) have an influence on the total layer thickness (SD), and / or e4) what the total layer thickness (SD) is at the respective point on the component surface (4; 10).; 2. Simulation method according to claim 1, characterized in that a) the adjustment of the coating parameters to be optimized in the simulation loop is carried out by an operator based on experience in the event of an unsatisfactory coating result, or b) the adjustment of the coating parameters to be optimized in the simulation loop is carried out by means of artificial intelligence in the event of an unsatisfactory coating result.
3. Simulation method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized by the following steps for determining the instantaneous spray patterns (1-3; 11) which are used in the simulation loop at the individual path points of the coating path to simulate the coating result: a) Determining an instantaneous coating situation at the individual path points of the coating path, wherein the instantaneous coating situation is defined by the geometry data, the coating parameters to be optimized and the general coating parameters, and b) Determining the instantaneous spray patterns (1-3; 11) according to the instantaneous coating situation, in particular by b) Reading the instantaneous spray patterns (1-3; 11) for the individual path points depending on the respective instantaneous coating situation from a spray pattern database (15) in which reference spray patterns (9) for different reference coating situations are stored, or b2) Calculating the instantaneous spray patterns (1-3; 11) according to the instantaneous coating situation from given reference spray patterns (9) that represent a reference coating situation.
4. Simulation method according to claim 3, characterized by the following steps in determining the instantaneous spray patterns (1-3; 11) to be used in the individual path points of the coating path: a) Determination of the instantaneous coating situation in the individual path points of the coating path, b) Determination of the specified reference coating situation, which forms the basis of the reference spray pattern read from the spray pattern database (15), c) Comparison of the instantaneous coating situation with the reference coating situation and determination of a deviation between the instantaneous coating situation and the reference coating situation, d) Adjustment of the reference spray pattern (9) read from the spray pattern database (15) depending on the deviation between the instantaneous coating situation and the reference coating situation.
5. Simulation method according to claim 4, characterized in that a) the adaptation of the reference spray pattern (9) read from the spray pattern database (15) according to the current coating situation is carried out by an algorithm, in particular by an artificial intelligence algorithm, and / or b) the adaptation of the reference spray pattern (9) read from the spray pattern database (15) is carried out by correction or scaling factors, in particular if the current coating situation is a geometric boundary, since then a certain percentage of the coating material jets miss the workpiece.
6. Simulation method according to one of claims 3 to 5, characterized in that the instantaneous coating situation and the reference coating situation are defined by at least one of the following parameters: a) Coating material properties of the coating material, in particular viscosity, b) Type of applicator, c) Type of bell-shaped disc of a rotary atomizer forming the applicator, d) Type of a guiding air ring used on the applicator, e) Application parameters, in particular el) Coating agent outflow rate, e2) Guiding air volume flow rate, e3) Rotational speed of the bell-shaped disc, e4) High voltage of an electrostatic coating agent charge, f) Spatial orientation of an applicator axis of the applicator relative to the surface of the component to be coated, g) Absolute spatial direction of an applicator axis in space, h) Cabin parameters of a coating booth, in particular hl) Cabin temperature in the coating booth, h2) Descending air velocity in the coating booth, i) Web spacing between adjacent coating webs, j) Web speed at which the applicator is moved along the coating web, k) Coating web used for measuring the reference spray pattern (9),l) Coating path in the instantaneous coating situation, m) Geometry of the test component used for measuring the reference spray pattern (9), n) Geometry of the component to be coated.
7. Simulation method according to claims 3 to 6, characterized in that a) the reference spray patterns (9) stored in the spray pattern database (15) are determined by coating tests before the simulation loop, b) test panels are coated in different coating situations during the coating tests, c) the layer thickness distribution on the test panels is measured during the coating tests, and d) the layer thickness distribution measured on the test panels is stored in the spray pattern database (15) as a reference spray pattern in an assignment to the respective reference coating situation.
8. Simulation method according to one of claims 3 to 7, characterized in that a) the reference spray patterns (9) stored in the spray pattern database (15) are dynamic spray patterns which are measured as a result of coating processes in which that the applicator moves relative to the component, and / or b) that the reference spray patterns (9) stored in the spray pattern database (15) are static spray patterns measured as a result of coating processes in which the applicator is stationary in relation to the component.
9. Simulation method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that a) in the simulation loop it is checked in which path points of the coating path the adjustment of the coating parameters to be optimized has led to a change in the coating parameters, and b) in the simulation loop the simulated coating result is recalculated completely or as a difference to the previous simulated coating result only in the area of those path points of the coating path in which the adjustment of the coating parameters to be optimized has led to a change in the coating parameters.
10. Simulation method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the general coating parameters comprise at least one of the following quantities: a) properties of the coating material, in particular viscosity of the coating material, b) type of applicator, c) type of bell plate of a rotary atomizer forming the applicator, d) cabin parameters of a coating cabin, in particular dl) cabin temperature in the coating cabin, d2) sinking air velocity in the coating cabin, e) desired layer thickness of the coating material on the component, f) web spacing between adjacent coating webs, g) web speed at which the applicator is moved along the coating web.
11. Simulation method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the coating parameters to be optimized comprise at least one of the following quantities: a) spatial and / or temporal progression of the coating path, in particular with coordinates and / or times of the individual path points, b) spatial orientation of the applicator axis of the applicator in the individual path points of the coating path, c) Brush parameters, in particular coating medium flow rate, d) switch-on points of the applicator on the coating web, e) switch-off points of the applicator on the coating web, f) coating medium flow rate at the individual web points of the coating web, g) atomizer speed at the individual web points of the coating web, h) high voltage of an electrostatic coating medium charge, i) type of applicator, in particular in sealing applications, j) web spacing between adjacent coating webs, k) web speed at which the applicator is moved along the coating web, l) the general coating parameters according to claim 10.
12. Simulation method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized by the following steps within the scope of testing the simulated coating result in the simulation loop: a) Graphical representation of the simulated coating result on a screen and evaluation by an operator, or b) Automatic evaluation of the simulated coating result using artificial intelligence.
13. Simulation method according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that a) the simulated coating parameters are transferred to a control system of the coating system after the simulation loop has ended, and b) the control system (13) controls the coating system according to the transferred coating parameters, in particular by converting the coating parameters into control variables for the coating system.
14. Coating system for coating components, in particular for painting motor vehicle body components, comprising a) at least one coating robot, b) at least one applicator guided by the coating robot, and c) a control system (13) that controls the applicator and the coating robot, characterized by d) a simulation computer (14) with a stored simulation program which, in one embodiment, performs the simulation method according to one of the preceding claims.
