Method for detecting a lightning strike by measurement gradient inconsistency
The method analyzes gradients in electrical measurements to detect and exclude lightning-affected data, addressing engine regulation disruptions and improving aircraft engine thrust stability.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- FR2022011916
- Authority / Receiving Office
- FR · FR
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-11-16
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-11-16
AI Technical Summary
Aircraft engines experience disruptions in electrical measurements during lightning strikes, affecting engine regulation and thrust, necessitating a method to detect and mitigate these impacts.
A method for detecting lightning strikes by analyzing gradients between consecutive electrical measurements, identifying affected measurements, and excluding them from engine regulation to minimize disturbances.
Effectively detects lightning strikes and reduces engine thrust disturbances by excluding affected measurements, enhancing engine regulation robustness without requiring additional sensors.
Smart Images

Figure 00000010_0000 
Figure 00000010_0001 
Figure 00000011_0000
Abstract
Description
Title of the invention: Method for detecting a lightning strike by measurement gradient incoherence Technical field
[0001] The present invention relates to the general field of lightning strike detection, and more particularly to the detection by the engine control system of an aircraft of a lightning strike. Prior art
[0002] Aircraft engines are subjected to a severe lightning environment and in particular to lightning strikes. In the event of a lightning strike on an aircraft, the electrical measurements made on the engine or aircraft sensors may be disrupted for a short time. These disturbances can nevertheless affect the engine regulation and therefore influence the engine thrust.
[0003] It is therefore desirable to have a method for detecting a lightning strike that can accommodate these impacts and reduce disturbances to the engine thrust, in order to improve the robustness of the aircraft engine control system in the face of these impacts. Statement of the invention
[0004] The invention relates to a method for detecting a lightning strike on electrical measurements of an aircraft engine control system comprising: - determining at least one target evolution of (Nl) gradients between two consecutive electrical measurements of a set of N consecutive electrical measurements, N being an integer greater than or equal to 3 and a gradient being positive if the difference between measurement (i) and measurement (i-1) is greater than -e, negative if the difference between measurement (i) and measurement (i-1) is less than +e or zero if the difference between the two measurements (i) and (i-1) is between -e and +e, i being an integer between 2 and N, and e being a function of the noise and the precision of said measurements; - the comparison of the variation of the (Nl) gradients of N electrical measurements following the target developments and the detection of a lightning strike on one of the N measurements if the variation of the (Nl) gradients does not correspond to one of the target developments.
[0005] The method of the invention thus makes it possible to detect lightning strikes. In addition, thanks to the definition of the target developments, it makes it possible to detect lightning strikes which may disturb the system and not to take into account the measurement affected by the lightning strike in order to reduce the disturbances on the thrust.
[0006] Furthermore, as the detection is carried out by the regulation system, it does not require the presence of a specific sensor and therefore makes it possible to limit the size of the engine in the aircraft.
[0007] The N electrical measurements may include noise, so when we define a gradient as positive, this means that the difference between measurement (i) and measurement (i-1) is greater than -e, with e being a function of the noise and the accuracy of the measurement. Similarly, a negative gradient means that the difference between measurement (i) and measurement (i-1) is less than +e; and a zero gradient means that the difference between the two measurements (i) and (i-1) is between -e and +e. The measurement e can also be called the gradient detection threshold.
[0008] According to a particular characteristic of the invention, the method comprises the deletion of the measurement for which a lightning strike has been detected.
[0009] This allows the system to ignore measurements affected by lightning strike so that these measurements do not disrupt the thrust.
[0010] According to one embodiment of the invention, the method comprises deleting the N measurements if a lightning strike has been detected on one of the N measurements.
[0011] Thus, as soon as a lightning strike is detected on one of the N measurements, the N measurements are invalidated and deleted.
[0012] According to another embodiment of the invention, the method comprises providing the (il)-th measurement to the aircraft engine control system if a lightning strike has been detected on the i-th measurement among the N measurements, with i between 2 and N.
[0013] According to another embodiment of the invention, the aircraft engine regulation system comprises a filter with X inputs, X being an integer strictly less than N, and the method comprises providing the filter of the regulation system with X measurements, among the N measurements, of which no lightning strike has been detected.
[0014] Thus, only measurements not affected by a lightning strike are provided to the filter.
[0015] According to another particular characteristic of the invention, N is equal to 4.
[0016] Another object of the invention is a system for regulating an aircraft engine comprising: - a sensor configured to measure an electrical quantity; - an analog-to-digital converter configured to convert the sensor measurement into a digital signal, and - a programmable digital circuit configured to implement the method according to the invention on the measurements converted by the converter.
[0017] According to one embodiment of the invention, the regulation system also comprises a filter placed in parallel with the programmable digital circuit and configured to reduce noise and improve the precision and resolution of the digital signal from of the converter.
[0018] According to another embodiment of the invention, the regulation system also comprises a filter placed at the output of the programmable digital circuit and configured to reduce noise and improve the precision and resolution of the measurements provided by the programmable digital circuit. Brief description of the drawings
[0019] Other characteristics and advantages of the present invention will emerge from the description given below, with reference to the appended drawings which illustrate exemplary embodiments thereof which are not in any limiting nature.
[0020] [Fig.l] [Fig.l] schematically represents a flowchart of the detection method according to one embodiment of the invention.
[0021] [Fig.2A] [Fig.2A] represents an example of implementation of the method of the invention for N = 3, and more particularly, the possible variations of the two gradients of the three consecutive measurements.
[0022] [Fig.2B] [Fig.2B] represents an example of implementation of the method of the invention for N = 4, and more particularly, the possible variations of the three gradients of the four consecutive measurements.
[0023] [Fig.3] [Fig.3] represents, in a schematic and partial manner, a system of re regulation of an aircraft engine according to one embodiment of the invention.
[0024] [Fig.4] [Fig.4] represents, in a schematic and partial manner, a system of re regulation of an aircraft engine according to another embodiment of the invention. Description of the embodiments
[0025] [Fig.l] schematically represents a flowchart of the method 100 for detecting a lightning strike on electrical measurements of an aircraft engine regulation system according to one embodiment of the invention.
[0026] The detection method 100 comprises the determination 101 of at least one target evolution of (Nl) gradients between two consecutive electrical measurements of a set of N consecutive electrical measurements. N is an integer greater than or equal to 3 and the gradients can be positive, negative or null. Thus, a gradient is said to be positive if the difference between measurement (i) and measurement (i-1) is greater than -e, i being an integer between 2 and N and e being established according to the noise and the precision of the measurement. In the same way, a gradient is said to be negative when the difference between measurement (i) and measurement (i-1) is less than +e. As for the null gradient, this means that the difference between the two measurements (i) and (i-1) is between -e and +e. The measurement e can also be called the gradient detection threshold.
[0027] The detection threshold e, which is a function of the noise and the precision of the measurements, therefore represents the margin of error of the measurements. The detection threshold e depends in particular the type of measurement as well as the components implementing the method 100.
[0028] The determination 101 of these target developments makes it possible to characterize the effect of lightning on the electrical measurements at the input of the aircraft engine regulation system, to determine which measurement among the N measurements is affected by lightning and to subsequently determine whether or not the measurement affected by lightning is to be taken into account by the regulation system.
[0029] The effect of lightning on measurements depends in particular on the following elements: - the waveform and the repetition sequence of lightning: the DO-160 standard defines for example all the waveforms and repetition sequences which can be applicable to test the resistance of a system to a lightning strike; - the lightning injection direction: the lightning strike waveforms can be injected in positive or negative directions. Thus, depending on the lightning protection measures implemented in the control system, the effect of lightning on electrical measurements can be different depending on the lightning injection direction; - the injection time: the electrical measurement interfaces of the control system can have different measurement methods, and lightning strikes are generally very short. The relationship between the start of the lightning strike and the start of the measurement of the associated interface is therefore important in estimating the effect of lightning on this measurement; and
[0030] the measurement value at the time of the lightning strike: the value measured by the measurement interface at the time of the lightning strike can have an influence on the effect of lightning. It is therefore necessary to test different values of the measurement validity range to correctly characterize the effect of lightning on this interface.
[0031] By studying these effects, it is possible to predict the influence of lightning on the electrical measurements used by the engine control system. This allows us to determine the changes in gradients between several consecutive measurements to determine whether a measurement has been affected by lightning and whether it should be taken into account by the control system.
[0032] Examples of evolution of the gradients between three and four measurements are detailed with reference to FIGS. 2A and 2B. These examples do not show the target evolutions determined in step 101, but only all the possible evolutions of the gradients for a set of three or four consecutive electrical measurements.
[0033] The method 100 then comprises the comparison 102 between the target evolutions determined in step 101 and the variation of (Nl) gradients of N consecutive electrical measurements.
[0034] If the variation of the (Nl) gradients corresponds to one of the determined target evolutions, then it is considered that none of the N measurements has been affected by lightning, and therefore no lightning impact is detected (step 104).
[0035] If the variation of the (Nl) gradients does not correspond to any of the determined target evolutions, then it is considered that one of the N measurements has been affected by lightning and therefore a lightning impact is detected (step 103).
[0036] In this case, the measurement affected by lightning is invalidated and therefore deleted (step 105). This means that the aircraft engine control system will not take this measurement into account to determine the engine thrust.
[0037] Depending on the evolution signature of the gradients, it is possible to detect the measurement affected by lightning. Such identification generally follows empirical tests.
[0038] As an example, the gradient evolution example 26b indicates a positive gradient between the first measurement and the second measurement and then a negative gradient between the second measurement and the third measurement. There is therefore, according to said tests, a disturbance associated with the second measurement.
[0039] Following the deletion 105 of the measurement affected by lightning, the method may comprise one of the following steps: - step 106: the Nl other measurements among the N measurements are also invalidated and deleted, so the regulation system will not take into account any of the N measurements; or - step 107: if the measurement affected by lightning is not the first of the N measurements, then the method 100 provides the previous measurement to the regulation system, this previous measurement being a measurement not affected by lightning. Thus, the regulation system will take into account the last valid measurement, i.e. not affected by lightning, among the N measurements if a lightning strike is detected among the N measurements. If ever, the measurement affected by lightning is the first of the N measurements, in this case, the method does not provide any measurement to the regulation system, which amounts to applying step 106 of the method 100; or - step 108: the method, therefore the regulation system, only provides X measurements (X being an integer strictly less than N) not affected by lightning to the regulation system, and more particularly it provides these X measurements to a filter comprising X inputs present in the regulation system. For example, the system has carried out N measurements as explained for step 107, and it has detected several measurements affected by lightning but at least X measurements, among these N measurements, have not been affected by lightning, then the method will provide these X measurements to the filter. If ever, there are less than X measures affected by lightning, then the method will apply step 106 or 107.
[0040] Figures 2A and 2B represent examples of implementation of the method 100 for N = 3 ([Fig.2A]) and N = 4 ([Fig.2B]), and more particularly the possible variations for the two gradients of the three consecutive measurements, and the possible variations for the three gradients of the four consecutive measurements.
[0041] As indicated previously, a gradient can be positive, negative or zero. Thus, in Figures 2A and 2B, a positive gradient between two measurements is represented by an upward arrow, a negative gradient between two measurements is represented by a downward arrow and a zero gradient between two measurements is represented by a flat arrow. For example, in [Fig.2B], the first variation 1b represents three zero gradients, the second variation 2b three positive gradients or the sixteenth variation 16b the sequence of two positive gradients then a negative gradient.
[0042] For the case of three consecutive measurements, the target evolutions are therefore determined and chosen from the nine possible variations of [Fig.2A] (step 101 of the method 100). Then during step 102 of the method 100, the variations of the three consecutive electrical measurements of the engine regulation system are compared with the target evolutions.
[0043] For the case of four consecutive measurements, the target evolutions are chosen from the 27 possible variations of [Fig.2B]. Then during step 102 of method 100, the variations of the four consecutive electrical measurements of the engine regulation system are compared with the chosen target evolutions.
[0044] More generally, there are 3N 1 possible variations for N consecutive measurements, and the target evolutions are determined among these 3N 1 variations.
[0045] [Fig. 3] schematically and partially represents a regulation system 300 of an aircraft engine according to a first embodiment of the invention.
[0046] The regulation system 300 comprises a sensor 301 configured to measure an electrical quantity connected to an analog-to-digital converter 302 which makes it possible to convert the measurement from the sensor into a digital signal, the measurement of the electrical quantity being supplied to the converter 302 in the form of an analog electrical signal.
[0047] The system 300 also comprises a filter 303 and a programmable digital circuit 306 connected in parallel and placed at the output of the converter 302. The filter 303 is configured to reduce noise and improve the accuracy and resolution of the digital signal from the converter 302. The programmable digital circuit 306 is configured to implement the method according to the invention. The elements 304 and 305 of [Fig. 3] are part of the programmable digital converter 306 and make it possible to implement the method.
[0048] Thus, the converter 302 provides the N converted measurements to the filter 303 and to the programmable digital circuit 306. The filter 303 thus provides at its output the N filtered measurements, while the programmable digital circuit 306 first detects (element 304) the valid measurements among the N measurements (if a lightning strike has been detected by the programmable digital circuit, it is also possible that the circuit does not provide any measurement at its output in accordance with the method of the invention), then it combines them with the measurements provided by the filter 303 to provide at its output (at the output of the element 305) the valid and filtered measurements which will be taken into account by the regulation system 300 to determine the thrust of the engine.
[0049] The filter 303 may be an external or internal element of the programmable digital circuit 306. In this first embodiment, it is external to the programmable digital circuit 306.
[0050] The filter 303 provides in this embodiment N filtered measurements, but it can instead provide only one filtered measurement among the N measurements provided by the converter 302.
[0051] [Fig.4] schematically and partially represents a system for regulating an aircraft engine according to a second embodiment of the invention.
[0052] The regulation system 400 comprises a sensor 401 configured to measure an electrical quantity connected to an analog-to-digital converter 402 which makes it possible to convert the measurement from the sensor into a digital signal, the measurement of the electrical quantity being supplied to the converter 402 in the form of an analog electrical signal.
[0053] The system 400 also comprises a programmable digital circuit 304 connected to the converter 402 and a filter 403 connected to the output of the programmable digital circuit 404. The programmable digital circuit 404 is configured to implement the method according to the invention and therefore select valid measurements from among the N measurements converted and provided by the converter 402, N being an integer greater than or equal to 2. The filter 403 comprises X inputs with X an integer less than N, and it is configured to reduce noise and improve the accuracy and resolution of the valid measurements selected by the programmable digital circuit 404. The measurements provided at the output of the filter 403 are therefore the valid and filtered measurements taken into account by the regulation system 400 to determine the thrust of the engine.
[0054] Whatever the embodiment, the physical quantity measured by the sensor 301, 401 can be an electric current, an electric voltage, an electric resistance, a time or a frequency.
[0055] Whatever the embodiment, the programmable digital circuit can be a wired electronic logic circuit, or a microcontroller, or even a programmable logic circuit (FPGA, “Field-programmable Gate Array” in English).
Claims
Claims
1. Method (100) for detecting a lightning strike on electrical measurements of a control system (300, 400) of an aircraft engine comprising: - determining (101) at least one target evolution of (Nl) gradients between two consecutive electrical measurements of a set of N consecutive electrical measurements, N being an integer greater than or equal to 3 and a gradient being positive if the difference between measurement (i) and measurement (i-1) is greater than -e, negative if the difference between measurement (i) and measurement (i-1) is less than +e or zero if the difference between the two measurements (i) and (i-1) is between -e and +e, i being an integer between 2 and N, e being a function of the noise and the precision of said measurements;- the comparison (102) of the variation of the (Nl) gradients of N electrical measurements following the target developments and the detection (103) of a lightning strike on one of the N measurements if the variation of the (Nl) gradients does not correspond to one of the target developments.;
2. A detection method according to claim 1, comprising deleting (105) the measurement of which a lightning strike has been detected.
3. A detection method according to any one of claims 1 or 2, comprising deleting (106) the N measurements if a lightning strike has been detected on one of the N measurements.
4. A detection method according to any one of claims 1 or 2, comprising providing the (il)-th measurement to the aircraft engine control system if a lightning strike has been detected on the i-th measurement among the N measurements, with i between 2 and N.
5. Detection method according to any one of claims 1 or 2, in which the aircraft engine control system comprises a filter with X inputs, X being an integer strictly less than N, and the method comprises providing (108) to the filter of the control system X measurements, among the N measurements, of which no lightning strike has been detected.
6. A detection method according to any one of claims 1 to 5, in which N is equal to 4.
7. A system (300, 400) for regulating an aircraft engine comprising: - a sensor (301, 401) configured to measure an electrical quantity; - an analog-digital converter (302, 402) configured to convert the measurement from the sensor into a digital signal; and - a programmable digital circuit (304, 404) configured to implement the method according to any one of claims 1 to 6 on the measurements converted by the converter.
8. A control system (300) according to claim 7, also comprising a filter (303) placed in parallel with the programmable digital circuit (304) and configured to reduce noise and improve the accuracy and resolution of the digital signal from the converter.
9. A control system (400) according to claim 7, also comprising a filter (403) placed at the output of the programmable digital circuit (404) and configured to reduce noise and improve the accuracy and resolution of the measurements provided by the programmable digital circuit.
10. An aircraft engine comprising a control system (400) according to any one of claims 7 to 9.
