SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR MEASURING THE BISTATIC RESPONSE OF AN ANECHOIC CHAMBER
The system with an active target and Vivaldi antennas addresses the challenges of measuring bistatic response in anechoic chambers by enhancing precision and efficiency in absorber evaluation and chamber configuration, ensuring accurate target characterization.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- FR2022013126
- Authority / Receiving Office
- FR · FR
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-12-09
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-29
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-12-09
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for measuring the bistatic response of an anechoic chamber face limitations due to multi-path reflections, spurious echoes, and challenges in accurately determining the coupling of the object with the chamber, especially at low frequencies, leading to imprecise absorber performance evaluation and chamber configuration validation.
A system and method using an active target with Vivaldi antennas arranged on a hollow metallic object, such as a sphere or polyhedron, coupled with a network analyzer and an SPMT switch, to measure the bistatic response by emitting and receiving electromagnetic waves, allowing for quick and precise evaluation of absorber performance and chamber configuration adjustments.
Enables rapid and accurate assessment of anechoic chamber performance by minimizing spurious echoes and optimizing absorber placement, thereby improving measurement precision and chamber suitability for target characterization.
Smart Images

Figure 00000013_0000 
Figure 00000013_0001
Abstract
Description
Title of the invention: SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR MEASURING THE BISTATIC RESPONSE OF AN ANECHOIC CHAMBER Technical field
[0001] The present invention relates generally to the field of measuring the radar equivalent surface (SER) of a target in an anechoic chamber. STATE OF THE PRIOR ART
[0002] The radar equivalent surface or SER is a fundamental quantity characteristic of a target. It is used both in the military field and in the civil field (for example for air traffic control) for the purpose of discriminating an object such as an aircraft or part of an aircraft.
[0003] The measurement of SER of an object is conventionally carried out in an electromagnetic anechoic chamber, by means of a single antenna (operating in transmission and reception) when it is a question of the measurement of a monostatic SER or of a pair of antennas (one operating in transmission and the other in reception) when it is a question of the measurement of a bistatic SER.
[0004] Similarly, an antenna is characterized by its radiation pattern (in intensity and / or in phase). Here again, the measurement of this pattern is conventionally carried out in an electromagnetic anechoic chamber.
[0005] An anechoic chamber for the electromagnetic characterization of targets or antennas consists of metal walls (walls, floor and ceiling) covered with materials absorbing electromagnetic waves in the measurement frequency band. The target or antenna to be characterized is generally placed on a weakly echogenic rotating positioner. The SER of the target is then obtained by illuminating it using an electromagnetic wave of a determined frequency and measuring the intensity of the wave backscattered by a measurement antenna. Similarly, the radiation pattern of an antenna can be obtained by illuminating the antenna to be characterized using an electromagnetic wave of a determined frequency and measuring the intensity of the wave captured by it (reception pattern).Alternatively, the antenna to be characterized can emit an electromagnetic wave, the characterization then being carried out by power measurements of the wave captured by a measuring antenna.
[0006] In certain cases, the measurement is carried out in a frequency band, which makes it possible, from Fourier transform-based processing, to determine the impulse response of the object and / or to improve the quality of the measurement.
[0007] More precisely, we determine from the transmitted signal and the signal received by the measuring antenna, the (complex) backscattering coefficient of the target placed within the anechoic chamber, for a plurality of frequencies equidistributed in the frequency band of interest, where appropriate for two distinct polarizations. The same measurements are also carried out in the empty anechoic chamber, i.e. in the absence of the target. The backscattering coefficient of the empty chamber is then subtracted from the backscattering coefficient of the target in the chamber to obtain a backscattering coefficient of the target alone for a plurality N of frequencies / = , / 0 ... fN V
[0008] In the same way, in a calibration phase, the complex backscattering coefficient of a standard object (generally a metallic sphere) is determined at these same frequencies, f - / 0 ■ - ■ fNA-
[0009] Knowing the theoretical response of the standard, 5^( obtained by simulation or by analytical calculation, and assuming that the response of the empty chamber is invariant between the two measurement campaigns, we estimate the specific backscattering coefficient of the target, ST ( f ), by means of:
[0010] [Math.l] s1 (f) = z (i)
[0011] Ultimately the estimation of the SER of the target at the frequency / is none other than -hhnr
[0012] Subtracting the response of the empty anechoic chamber makes it possible to overcome the intrinsic signature of the anechoic chamber. The ratio between the difference in measurements appearing in the numerator and the difference in measurements appearing in the denominator makes it possible to overcome the transfer function of the measurement system, which is assumed to be linear.
[0013] In practice, the walls of the anechoic chamber and the support of the object are not perfectly absorbent, in particular at low frequencies (absorbing dielectric coatings are less effective at low frequencies). This results in the chamber returning part of the emitted signal, either because this signal has been reflected directly (direct reflections on a wall or the support of the target), or because it has been backscattered a first time by the target and then reflected on a wall (indirect reflections).
[0014] Thus, a multi-path from a contributing point of the target has a distance of greater propagation than the direct line path from this same contributing point.
[0015] A known method for eliminating multipaths consists of performing a time windowing of the received signal by taking advantage of the fact that the useful signal, having propagated in a direct line, is received first. However, in practice, the target (or the antenna) has a certain spatial extension and certain parasitic echoes can be very close or even superimposed on the useful signal.
[0016] It is then essential to be able to determine the coupling of the object with the anechoic chamber, for each new object placed in the chamber, in the frequency range and, where appropriate, for the different polarizations used. This coupling depends both on the bistatic SER of the target and on the bistatic response (of the walls) of the chamber.
[0017] Measuring the bistatic response of the chamber makes it possible, for example, to add or orient absorbents in certain parts of the anechoic chamber, or even to choose their shapes (corners, pyramids, etc.) so as to minimize parasitic echoes when measuring the SER of the target.
[0018] It also makes it possible to validate that an anechoic chamber configuration is well suited to SER measurements to be carried out on a given type of target (dimensions, orientation range in bearing and elevation).
[0019] The bistatic response of the anechoic chamber is currently measured using a metal plate as a target. More precisely, the measuring antenna emits an electromagnetic wave (in the frequency band and with the polarizations of interest) which is reflected on the plate placed on the positioner (generally a weakly echogenic polystyrene column). For each deposit, the measuring antenna acquires a first signal reflected by the plate, corresponding to its monostatic SER, as well as that reflected a first time by the plate then, a second time, by the walls of the chamber (reflection of order 2), this second signal depending on the bistatic SER of the plate and the bistatic response of the chamber. When the plate has a small geometric extent, the second signal arrives after the first and can therefore be extracted by time windowing.
[0020] The analysis of the signal having undergone a reflection of order 2 makes it possible to estimate the performance of the absorbers of the chamber when they are illuminated by the signals reflected by the metal plate, this for a frequency range of interest and for given polarizations.
[0021] To obtain more precise measurements of the bistatic response of the chamber, it is necessary to use larger plates, the width of the main backscattering lobe of the plate being smaller the larger the size of the plate. However, the appearance of secondary lobes, the difficulty in quickly orienting and accurately a 3D metal plate and the risk of the positioner (polystyrene column) collapsing under the weight of the plate are all limiting factors of this method.
[0022] The object of the present invention is therefore to propose a device and a method for measuring the bistatic response of an anechoic chamber making it possible to quickly and precisely evaluate the actual performance of the absorbers, making it possible, where appropriate, to modify the types, positions and orientations of the latter in order to minimize parasitic echoes. Statement of the invention
[0023] The present invention is defined by a system for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber comprising a measuring antenna coupled to a network analyzer, said measuring antenna being intended to emit a wave towards a target and to receive a backscattered wave, the measurement being carried out at a plurality of frequencies / = / 0 • - • / v_r of a frequency band of interest, the network analyzer being adapted to measure the backscattering coefficients for each frequency of said plurality from the complex amplitude of the emitted wave and the complex amplitude of the received wave, the system being original in that it further comprises an active target intended to be placed in the anechoic chamber, the active target being in the form of a hollow metal object on the surface of which identical Vivaldi antennas are arranged so as to radiate radially,a first Vivaldi antenna of said plurality being pointed towards the measuring antenna and intended to operate in reception, the other Vivaldi antennas being intended to operate in transmission, the first Vivaldi antenna being connected to the input port of an SPMT switch and the other Vivaldi antennas being connected to the respective output ports of this switch, the SPMT switch being configured to switch the signal received on its input port to one of its output ports.
[0024] Advantageously, the hollow metal object is coated with a layer of absorbent material in the frequency band of interest.
[0025] In one embodiment, the hollow metal object has a recess and this recess is closed by a cover, said SPMT switch being housed inside said hollow metal object.
[0026] The signal received by the first antenna is then amplified by means of a low noise amplifier (LNA) before being supplied to the input port of the SPMT switch.
[0027] A battery may also be housed in the hollow metal object to power the SPMT switch and the low noise amplifier.
[0028] Each Vivaldi antenna is advantageously a bipolarization antenna, comprising a first elementary Vivaldi antenna and a second elementary Vivaldi antenna whose linear polarizations are crossed, each elementary Vivaldi antenna then being connected to a separate output port of the SPMT switch.
[0029] The SPMT switch can be remotely controlled by a control module so as to switch the output of the first Vivaldi antenna to the input of one of the other Vivaldi antennas.
[0030] According to a first variant, the shape of the hollow metal object is spherical.
[0031] According to a second variant, the shape of the hollow metal object is a regular or semi-regular polyhedron.
[0032] The invention also relates to a method for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber by means of a measuring system as set out above, according to which a wave is sent to the target by means of the measuring antenna, at a plurality of frequencies in the frequency band of interest and, for each of these frequencies, the input port of the SPMT switch is successively switched to each of its output ports, and the network analyzer measures the backscattering coefficient at each of these frequencies from the signal emitted and the signal received by the measuring antenna.
[0033] Advantageously, the received signal undergoes time windowing to eliminate the monostatic contribution of the target before being supplied to the network analyzer.
[0034] In an exemplary embodiment, the directions (a, (3) are determined in which the backscattering coefficient is greater in modulus than a predetermined threshold value. Brief description of the drawings
[0035] Other characteristics and advantages of the invention will appear on reading a preferred embodiment of the invention, made with reference to the attached figures among which:
[0036] [Fig-1] schematically represents an active target for measuring the bistatic response of an anechoic chamber, according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0037] [Fig.2] schematically represents a method of measuring the bi response static of an anechoic chamber using the active target of [Fig.l].
[0038] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF PARTICULAR EMBODIMENTS
[0039] We consider in the following a system for measuring the SER of a target as described in the introductory part. This system comprises an electromagnetic anechoic chamber, a weakly echogenic positioner placed within this chamber, a measuring antenna for illuminating the target and receiving the backscattered signal, and a network analyzer, connected to the measuring antenna and making it possible to measure the backscattering coefficients, from the emitted signal and the backscattered signal.
[0040] The idea behind the present invention is to provide an active target capable of receiving the wave emitted by the measuring antenna and re-emitting it in a direction controlled by the measuring system. The bearing and / or elevation scanning of the re-emission direction thus makes it possible to measure the bistatic response of the anechoic chamber quickly and relatively exhaustively.
[0041] A first embodiment of such an active target has been shown schematically in [Fig.l].
[0042] This target, 100, is in the form of a hollow metal sphere 110, where appropriate coated with a layer of electromagnetic absorber in the frequency range of interest, for example a layer of the same dielectric as that used in the absorbers of the anechoic chamber.
[0043] Alternatively, the target may be in the form of a regular or even semi-regular polyhedron, for example in the form of a Platonic solid or an Archimedean solid. This form is also metallic and hollow and coated, if necessary, with an electromagnetic absorber as indicated above.
[0044] Without loss of generality, and for the purpose of illustration, we will assume in the following that the target is in the form of a sphere.
[0045] The metal sphere is equipped with a plurality of Vivaldi antennas, 120, distributed on its surface, advantageously chosen to be identical. Preferably, these antennas are distributed regularly in bearing and elevation so as to present an isotropic angular coverage.
[0046] It is recalled that a Vivaldi antenna is a slot antenna whose opening is progressive, the narrow side of the slot being short-circuited by a circular tip whose diameter is equal to 2 / 4 where 2 is the wavelength corresponding to the central frequency of the antenna. A Vivaldi antenna emits a linearly polarized wave in the plane of the substrate on which it is formed.
[0047] Advantageously, the Vivaldi antennas will be chosen to be bipolarized. A bipolarized Vivaldi antenna comprises two elementary Vivaldi antennas 121, 122 crossed in direction (in other words having orthogonal substrate planes) so as to transmit according to two orthogonal polarizations, the polarization being able to be chosen by switching the transmission signal to one or the other elementary Vivaldi antenna.
[0048] A description of a bipolarized Vivaldi antenna can be found in particular in application US-A-2006 / 0273974.
[0049] The target is oriented so that a Vivaldi antenna of said plurality is oriented in the emission axis of the measuring antenna, for example a horn antenna having a truncated pyramid shape. More precisely, in the case of a bipolarized Vivaldi antenna, the axis defined by the intersection of the elementary Vivaldi antennas that constitute it is the same as the transmission axis of the measuring antenna. This bipolarized Vivaldi antenna then acts as a receiving antenna, the other antennas being exclusively transmission antennas.
[0050] The output of the receiving antenna is connected to the input port of a SPMT (Single Pole Multi Throw) microwave switch which can be implemented by means of a tree structure of SPDT (Single Pole Double Throw) switches. The bipolar Vivaldi transmitting antennas are connected to the respective output ports of the SPMT switch (not shown) by means of coaxial cables passing through the surface of the sphere, the switch being housed inside the sphere itself. The control of the SPMT switch can be ensured by a wired control, or even by a wireless remote control by providing a recess in the metal sphere, at the rear thereof (i.e. on the side of the sphere opposite the receiving antenna). This recess can be closed by a cover, 150, made of absorbent material of the same type as that covering the metal sphere.Alternatively, control of the SPMT switch can be achieved by modulating the signal emitted by the measuring antenna with a low-frequency control signal.
[0051] Optionally, a low noise amplifier (LNA) may be provided between the output of the Vivaldi receiving antenna and the input port of the SPMT switch. The gain of this amplifier may optionally be controlled via a wired control, a wireless remote control or modulation of the transmission signal as described above.
[0052] The active elements (SPMT switch, amplifier, etc.) housed within the metal sphere can be powered independently by a battery, or even by wire when wired control is provided.
[0053] The bipolarization Vivaldi antennas can form a removable set, one set of antennas being provided per measurement frequency range, to cover a wide range of frequencies of interest, for example from 1 to 18 GHz.
[0054] The measurement of the bistatic response of the anechoic chamber is carried out by selecting in turn the different Vivaldi transmitting antennas, if necessary, also choosing the polarization of the transmitting antenna thus selected. The measuring antenna receives the signal re-emitted by the active target in the selected direction and with the chosen polarization, after reflection on the walls of the anechoic chamber. The network analyzer can then measure the parameter Sb^f. a, 0, tt) where a, {J are the bearing and the elevation of the selected Vivaldi transmitting antenna and77 is the chosen polarization.
[0055] The signal received by the measuring antenna comprises, on the one hand, the passive contribution of the target, linked to its monostatic SER, and, on the other hand, the active contribution of the target, linked to the bistatic response of the anechoic chamber.
[0056] The passive contribution of the target results from the line-of-sight reflection on the metal sphere. Although this contribution can be reduced by covering the sphere with an absorber layer, a residual contribution may be present. Provided that the measurement signal has sufficient bandwidth, it is possible to eliminate the passive contribution by means of time windowing since it arrives (with a delay due to the line-of-sight round-trip propagation time between the measurement antenna and the sphere) earlier than the active contribution (with a delay due to the line-of-sight propagation time between the measurement antenna and the sphere, the delay in the LNA and the SPMT switch, the propagation time between the Vivaldi transmitting antenna and the wall in the selected re-transmission direction, and the propagation time of the reflected signal between the wall and the measurement antenna).
[0057] [Fig.2] schematically represents a method for measuring the bistatic response of an anechoic chamber using the active target of [Fig.l].
[0058] It is assumed that the active target is placed on a positioner in the anechoic chamber, preferably at the location where the targets to be characterized will subsequently be placed.
[0059] In a first step 210, the SPMT switch is controlled so as to select one of the Vivaldi transmission antennas of the active target.
[0060] Where appropriate, when the transmitting antenna is bipolarized, the elementary Vivaldi antenna corresponding to the chosen polarization is selected at 220 77.
[0061] An initial transmission frequency is selected at 230 from among the measurement frequencies f = fNA
[0062] A quasi-plane wave is then emitted at 240 by means of the measuring antenna. This wave is reflected on the one hand by the metal sphere (possibly coated with an absorber) and is re-emitted on the other hand by the selected transmission antenna before being reflected on the walls of the chamber.
[0063] The signal received by the measuring antenna is optionally subject to a 250 time window so as to eliminate the monostatic response of the target.
[0064] The network analysis measures in 260 from the transmitted signal and the received signal (where appropriate time-windowed), the parameter a, P, zr)-
[0065] The measurement operations are repeated for each transmitting antenna, characterized by its bearing and elevation angles, for each polarization and each frequency ~ A) ' ' ' ^NV
[0066] When we check at 270 that the measurement campaign is finished, we have at 280 the bistatic frequency response of the chamber for each triplet (a, [k rf).
[0067] If necessary, the bistatic response of the chamber can be obtained in the time domain by inverse discrete Fourier transform of the frequency response S^f, a, 0, tt} / = / 0 * • ■ f Nr
[0068] The bistatic response of the chamber can then be used to add or modify absorbers in critical directions where the modulus of the backscatter coefficient 5^'7 & yyj is greater than a predetermined threshold value.
Claims
Claims
1. System for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber comprising a measuring antenna coupled to a network analyzer, said measuring antenna being intended to emit a wave towards a target and to receive a backscattered wave, the measurement being carried out at a plurality of frequencies f — f{y fN_v of a frequency band of interest, the network analyzer being adapted to measure the backscattering coefficients for each frequency of said plurality from the complex amplitude of the emitted wave and the complex amplitude of the received wave, characterized in that it further comprises an active target (100) intended to be placed in the anechoic chamber, the active target being in the form of a hollow metal object (110) on the surface of which are arranged identical Vivaldi antennas (120) so as to radiate radially,a first Vivaldi antenna of said plurality being pointed towards the measurement antenna and intended to operate in reception, the other Vivaldi antennas being intended to operate in transmission, the first Vivaldi antenna being connected to the input port of an SPMT switch and the other Vivaldi antennas being connected to the respective output ports of this switch, the SPMT switch being configured to switch the signal received on its input port to one of its output ports.,
2. System for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber according to claim 1, characterized in that the hollow metallic object is coated with a layer of absorbent material in the frequency band of interest.
3. System for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that the hollow metal object has a recess and that this recess is closed by a cover (150), said SPMT switch being housed inside said hollow metal object.
4. System for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber according to claim 3, characterized in that the signal received by the first antenna is amplified by means of a low noise amplifier (LNA) before being supplied to the input port of the SPMT switch.
5. System for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber according to claim 4, characterized in that a A battery is also housed in the hollow metal object to power the SPMT switch and low noise amplifier.
6. System for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that each Vivaldi antenna is a bipolarization antenna, comprising a first elementary Vivaldi antenna (121) and a second elementary Vivaldi antenna (122) whose linear polarizations are crossed, each elementary Vivaldi antenna then being connected to a separate output port of the SPMT switch.
7. System for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the SPMT switch is remotely controlled by a control module so as to switch the output of the first Vivaldi antenna to the input of one of the other Vivaldi antennas.
8. System for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that the shape of the hollow metal object is spherical.
9. System for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber according to one of claims 1 to 7, characterized in that the shape of the hollow metallic object is a regular or semi-regular polyhedron.
10. Method for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber by means of a measuring system according to one of the preceding claims, characterized in that a wave is sent to the target by means of the measuring antenna, at a plurality of frequencies of the frequency band of interest and, that, for each of these frequencies, the input port of the SPMT switch is successively switched to each of its output ports, and that the network analyzer measures the backscattering coefficient at each of these frequencies from the signal emitted and the signal received by the measuring antenna.
11. A method of measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber according to claim 10, characterized in that the received signal undergoes time windowing to eliminate the monostatic contribution of the target before being supplied to the network analyzer.
12. Method for measuring the bistatic response of an electromagnetic anechoic chamber according to claim 10 or 11, characterized in that the directions (a, 0) in which the coefficient of backscattering is greater in modulus than a predetermined threshold value
