Method for estimating the self-discharge of an electrochemical cell in a battery, associated methods and devices

The method estimates self-discharge in electrochemical elements to improve battery balancing by dynamically adjusting measurement intervals, reducing state of charge dispersion and enhancing battery performance.

FR3143763B1Active Publication Date: 2024-11-15SAFT GRP SA
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
FR2022013987
Authority / Receiving Office
FR · FR
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-12-20
Publication Date
2024-11-15
Estimated Expiration
2042-12-20

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for balancing the charging and discharging of electrochemical elements in batteries often require a complete discharge, which is problematic for certain applications, and there is a need for a more intelligent method to control current balancing without frequent complete discharges.

Method used

A method for estimating the self-discharge of electrochemical elements using a computer-based approach, involving capacity and measurement value calculations to determine self-discharge contributions, and a balancing current is applied to each element, with a hyperbolic gain coefficient for precision.

Benefits of technology

This method allows for improved current balancing by dynamically adjusting measurement intervals and reducing state of charge dispersion, enhancing battery performance and availability.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 00000028_0000
    Figure 00000028_0000
  • Figure 00000029_0000
    Figure 00000029_0000
  • Figure 00000030_0000
    Figure 00000030_0000
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

Method for Estimating the Self-Discharge of an Electrochemical Cell in a Battery, Associated Methods and Devices. The present invention relates to a method for estimating the self-discharge of an electrochemical cell to which a balancing current is applied. The method comprises the steps of: - obtaining: - the capacity of the electrochemical cell - initial measurement values ​​comprising measurements of the current and the balancing current applied at initial instants, and - second measurement values ​​comprising measurements of the state of charge at subsequent instants. Estimation of the self-discharge value at a second estimation instant by applying an estimation function to the values ​​obtained. The estimation function calculates a first contribution corresponding to the variation in the state of charge and a second contribution corresponding to the charge accumulation associated with the initial values. Figure for the abstract: Figure 3
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Title of the invention: Method for estimating the self-discharge of an electrochemical element of a battery, associated methods and devices

[0001] The present invention relates to a method for estimating the self-discharge of at least one electrochemical element of a battery. It also relates to methods implementing the aforementioned estimation method, namely a method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge and a method for controlling the current balancing of the electrochemical elements of a battery. The invention also relates to an associated calculator, management system and battery.

[0002] Typically a battery comprises one or more current accumulators also called electrochemical generators, cells or elements. An accumulator is an electricity production device in which chemical energy is converted into electrical energy. The chemical energy comes from the electrochemically active compounds deposited on at least one face of electrodes arranged in the accumulator. The electrical energy is produced by electrochemical reactions during a discharge of the accumulator. The electrodes, arranged in a container, are electrically connected to current output terminals which ensure electrical continuity between the electrodes and an electrical consumer with which the accumulator is associated.

[0003] In order to increase the electrical power delivered, several sealed accumulators can be combined together to form a battery. Thus, a battery can be divided into modules, each module being composed of one or more accumulators connected together in series and / or in parallel. Thus, a battery can, for example, comprise one or more parallel branches of accumulators connected in series and / or one or more parallel branches of modules connected in series.

[0004] A charging circuit is generally provided to which the battery can be connected to recharge the accumulators.

[0005] Furthermore, an electronic management system comprising measurement sensors and an electronic control circuit, more or less advanced depending on the applications, can be associated with the battery. Such a system makes it possible in particular to organize and control the charging and discharging of the battery, to balance the charging and discharging of the different accumulators of the battery in relation to each other.

[0006] To balance the charge and discharge of the different accumulators, it is necessary to be able to carefully obtain the current imbalance between these accumulators.

[0007] For this, it is known to carry out a complete discharge to determine the state of charge and then compensate for the observed state of charge differences by balancing the accumulators, but this involves frequently stopping the entire system, which can be problematic for certain applications.

[0008] There is therefore a need for a method for efficiently determining the quantities involved in the current balancing of electrochemical elements of a battery and for better controlling this balancing.

[0009] In particular, a good knowledge of self-discharge dispersions would allow more intelligent control of the balancing making it possible to compensate for these effects without having to carry out a complete discharge.

[0010] For this purpose, the description describes a method for estimating the self-discharge of at least one electrochemical element of a battery with respect to a reference value, a balancing current specific to the electrochemical element being applied to each electrochemical element, the method being implemented by a computer, the method comprising, for at least one electrochemical element, the steps of:

[0011] - obtaining:

[0012] - the capacity of the electrochemical element,

[0013] - first measurement values, the first values ​​comprising measurements or estimates of the current of the electrochemical element and of the balancing current applied to the electrochemical element at early times, and

[0014] - second measurement values, the second values ​​comprising measurements or estimates of the state of charge of the electrochemical element at second times, - estimation of the value of the self-discharge of the electrochemical element at a second time, called the second estimation time, by applying an estimation function to the capacity, the first measurement values ​​and the second measurement values,

[0015] the estimation function calculating two contributions to the self-discharge, a first contribution corresponding to the variation in the state of charge of the electrochemical element between the second estimation instant and a second earlier instant and a second contribution corresponding to the accumulation of charge in the electrochemical element linked to the first measurement values ​​in the time interval between the second earlier instant and the second estimation instant.

[0016] According to particular embodiments, the method for estimating self-discharge has one or more of the following characteristics, taken in isolation or in all technically possible combinations:

[0017] - the reference value is the self-discharge value of another electro-element chemical, the other electrochemical element preferably being the electrochemical element for which the self-discharge value at the second prior instant is the highest high, the estimation function also taking into account a third contribution corresponding to the variation in the state of charge of the other electrochemical element between the second estimation instant and the second previous instant and a fourth contribution corresponding to the accumulation of charge in the other electrochemical element linked to the first measurement values ​​in the time interval between the second previous instant and the second estimation instant.

[0018] - the estimation function is a weighted sum of the contributions and the value of self-discharge compared to the reference value at the second previous instant.

[0019] - the contributions are weighted by the same gain coefficient, the coefficient of dependent gain:

[0020] - of a first parameter, the first parameter being the product of the capacity of the electrochemical element with the time interval between the second previous instant and the second estimation instant,

[0021] - of a second parameter, the second parameter being an adjustable value, and even tually

[0022] - of a third parameter taking into account the uncertainty of the second measurements, the third parameter depends, preferably, on the ratio between the uncertainty of the second measurements and the value of the contributions,

[0023] the gain coefficient preferably being a hyperbolic function which can be written in the form:

[0024] / >3......b...... " PI2+P22

[0025] with PI the first parameter, P2 the second parameter and P3 the third parameter.

[0026] The description also relates to a method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge of a plurality of electrochemical elements of a battery, the plurality preferably comprising all of the electrochemical elements of the battery, the method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge being implemented by a computer and comprising the steps of:

[0027] - implementation, for the plurality of electrochemical elements of the battery (10), of steps of a method for estimating the self-discharge of an electrochemical element of a battery relative to a reference value, the method being as previously described, to obtain a self-discharge value relative to the reference value for each electrochemical element of the plurality of electrochemical elements, and

[0028] - determining the dispersion of the state of charge within the plurality at an instant evaluation as the difference between the state of charge of the electrochemical element of the plurality which is the highest and the state of charge of the electrochemical element of the plurality which is the least, the determining step comprising applying an evaluation function to values ​​used or obtained during the implementing step.

[0029] According to particular embodiments, the method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge has one or more of the following characteristics, taken in isolation or in all technically possible combinations:

[0030] - the battery is provided with a balancing circuit allowing a current to be applied respective balancing circuit in each electrochemical element of the plurality of electrochemical elements, the balancing circuit having two states, an active state and an inactive state,

[0031] the applied evaluation function being chosen from several sub-functions according to at least one predefined criterion, the at least one predefined criterion preferably being that the evaluation time corresponds to the second estimation time and the state of the balancing circuit at the evaluation time.

[0032] - the sub-functions are chosen from:

[0033] - a calculation subfunction calculating the maximum of the difference of the states of charge at the time of evaluation.

[0034] - an estimation function applied to the values ​​obtained at the end of the step of implementation, the estimation function calculating two contributions to the dispersion, a first contribution linked to the self-discharge specific to each electrochemical element and a second contribution linked to the maximum self-discharge of all the electrochemical elements of the plurality, and

[0035] - a subfunction is an estimation function applied to the values ​​obtained at at the end of the implementation step, the estimation function calculating three contributions to the dispersion, a first contribution linked to the self-discharge specific to each electrochemical element, a second contribution linked to the maximum self-discharge of all the electrochemical elements of the plurality and a third contribution linked to the balancing currents applied to the electrochemical elements of the plurality of electrochemical elements.

[0036] - when a criterion according to which the evaluation time corresponds to the second time estimation function is verified, the chosen evaluation function is the calculation sub-function, and when the balancing circuit is in the active state, the chosen evaluation function being the estimation sub-function calculating three contributions, the chosen evaluation function is the estimation sub-function calculating two contributions otherwise.

[0037] The description also relates to a method for controlling the current balancing of the electrochemical elements of a battery, the battery being provided with a balancing circuit making it possible to apply a respective balancing current in each electrochemical element of the plurality of electrochemical elements, the balancing circuit having two states, an active state and an inactive state, the control method being implemented by a computer, the control method comprising the steps of:

[0038] - implementation of the steps of the method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charging a plurality of electrochemical elements of a battery, the evaluation method being as previously described, to obtain an evaluated dispersion,

[0039] - comparison of the evaluated dispersion with a dispersion threshold, and

[0040] - control of the state of the balancing circuit according to the result of the comparison by placing the balancing circuit in the active state if the evaluated dispersion is greater than or equal to the dispersion threshold possibly reduced by a hysteresis threshold and placing the balancing circuit in the inactive state otherwise.

[0041] The description also relates to a method for controlling the current balancing of the electrochemical elements of a battery, the control method being implemented by a computer, the control method comprising the steps of:

[0042] - implementation of the steps of the method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charging a plurality of electrochemical elements of a battery, the evaluation method being as previously described, to obtain an evaluated dispersion,

[0043] - comparison of the evaluated dispersion with a dispersion threshold, and

[0044] - control of the time interval between two second consecutive instants to be used for further measurements depending on the comparison result.

[0045] According to particular embodiments, the method for controlling the current balancing of the electrochemical elements has one or more of the following characteristics, taken in isolation or in all technically possible combinations:

[0046] - the control step comprises an incrementation of the time interval by one first time increment when the evaluated dispersion is less than or equal to the threshold and a decrease in the time interval by a second time increment when the evaluated dispersion is less than or equal to the threshold, the time interval being set to a predefined value if the decrease in the second increment leads to a value less than the predefined value, the first time increment and the second time increment preferably being equal.

[0047] - the method further comprises a step of testing the validity of the measurement, the step test involving a test of the amplitude of variation of the dispersion in relation to a maximum possible variation value.

[0048] The description also relates to a computer capable of implementing a method as previously described.

[0049] The description also relates to a system for managing a plurality of electrochemical elements of a battery, the electrochemical elements having terminals, the management system comprising:

[0050] - a balancing circuit capable of applying a respective balancing current to each of the electrochemical elements of the plurality of electrochemical elements,

[0051] - for each electrochemical element of the plurality of electrochemical elements:

[0052] - a sensor of the current delivered by the electrochemical element,

[0053] - a sensor of the applied balancing current, and

[0054] - a voltage sensor suitable for measuring the voltage across the terminals of the electro-element chemical, and

[0055] - a calculator as previously described.

[0056] The description also relates to a battery comprising:

[0057] - electrochemical elements, and

[0058] - a management system as previously described.

[0059] In the present description, the expression “suitable for” means indifferently “adapted for”, “adapted to” or “configured for”.

[0060] Characteristics and advantages of the invention will appear on reading the description which follows, given solely by way of non-limiting example, and made with reference to the appended drawings, in which:

[0061] - [Fig.l] [Fig.l] is a schematic representation of an example of a battery comprising an electrochemical element,

[0062] - [Fig.2] [Fig.2] is a graph illustrating an example of a characteristic state of charge - open circuit voltage of the electrochemical element of [Fig.l],

[0063] - [Fig.3] [Fig.3] is a block diagram representation of an example of implementation work of a process for estimating the self-discharge of an electrochemical element,

[0064] - [Fig.4] [Fig.4] is a flowchart of an example of implementation of a method for evaluating the dispersion of charge state within a plurality of electrochemical elements,

[0065] - [Fig.5] [Fig.5] is a flowchart of an example of implementation of a balancing control method,

[0066] - [Fig.6] [Fig.6] is a flowchart of an example of implementation of another balancing control method,

[0067] - [Fig.7] [Fig.7] is a flowchart of an example of implementation of yet another other balancing control method,

[0068] - [Fig.8] [Fig.8] is a block representation of the arrangement of the processes of the figures 3 to 7,

[0069] - [Fig.9][Fig.lO][Fig.ll][Fig.l2] Figures 9 to 12 showing experimental results ingredients obtained by the Applicant by implementing the methods of figures 3 to 7.

[0070] A battery 10 is shown in [Fig. 1].

[0071] In a manner known per se, a battery is generally an arrangement of a plurality of electrochemical elements but for the sake of simplification of the subject, a case with a single electrochemical element is described in the following, knowing that the transposition to other arrangements is immediate.

[0072] The battery 10 comprises an electrochemical element 12 and a management system 14 of the electrochemical element 12.

[0073] As explained previously, an electrochemical element 12 is an electricity generating device in which chemical energy is converted into electrical energy.

[0074] The electrochemical element 12 therefore delivers a current and a voltage between two terminals.

[0075] The electrochemical element 12 may have a state of charge characteristic SOC - open circuit voltage OCV as seen in [Fig.2]. This characteristic is referred to as the SOC / OCV characteristic hereinafter.

[0076] The state of charge is information useful to the management system 14 to optimize the use and the lifespan of the battery 10. The state of charge is often designated by the abbreviation SOC which refers to the English term “State of Charge”.

[0077] Open circuit voltage is often referred to by the abbreviation OCV, which refers to the English term for “Open Circuit Voltage”.

[0078] In [Fig.2], the state of charge SOC is expressed as a percentage of a maximum state of charge.

[0079] The SOC / OCV characteristic may have, for example, four zones, a first zone Z1, a second zone Z2, a third zone Z3 and a fourth zone Z4.

[0080] The first zone Z1 corresponds to the start of charging and the fourth zone Z4 to the end of charging.

[0081] For the two intermediate zones, insofar as the second zone Z2 and third zone Z3 correspond to a flat portion, the term flat portion (Z23) will be used in the following.

[0082] The flat portion Z23 is a portion in which the open circuit voltage variation OCV is less than 30 mV for a variation of at least 10% of the state of charge SOC.

[0083] Such a type of SOC / OCV characteristic is found in particular when the electrochemical element 12 is an electrochemical element comprising a cathodic active material chosen from the following groups or their mixtures:

[0084] i) a compound of formula LixFei yMyPO4where M is selected from the group consisting of B, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, Y, Zr, Nb and Mo; and 0.8 <x<l,2 ; 0<y<0,6,

[0085] ii) a compound of formula LixMni y zM'yM”zPO4, where M' and M” are different from each other and are selected from the group consisting of B, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Ti, V, Cr, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, Y, Zr, Nb and Mo, with 0.8 <x<l,2 ; 0<y<0,6 ; 0<z<0,2,

[0086] iii) a compound of formula LixMn2_y_zNiyMzO4_d_cFc where M represents one or more elements selected from the group consisting of B, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Ti, V, Cr, Fe, Co, Cu, Zn, Y, Zr, Nb, Ru, W and Mo; and 1 <x<1,4 ; 0<y<0,6 ; 0<z<0,2 ; 0<d<l ; 0<c<l,

[0087] iv) a compound of formula LixMn2.y.zM'yM"zO4, where M' and M" are selected from the group consisting of B, Mg, Al, Si, Ca, Ti, V, Cr, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, Y, Zr, Nb and Mo; M' and M" being different from each other, and 1 <x<1,4 ; 0<y<0,6 ; 0<z<0,2, et

[0088] v) a compound of formula LiVPO4F.

[0089] The anode active material is not particularly limited. It is a material capable of inserting lithium into its structure. It may be selected from lithium compounds, carbon materials such as graphite, coke, carbon black, and glassy carbon. It may also be based on tin, silicon, carbon-silicon-based compounds, carbon-tin-based compounds, or carbon-tin-silicon-based compounds. It may also be a lithiated titanium oxide such as Li4Ti50i2 or a niobium titanium oxide such as TiNb2O7.

[0090] Of course, these examples are non-limiting and the methods described later can be used for any type of electrochemical element 12.

[0091] The management system 14 is a system suitable for managing the electrochemical element 12.

[0092] The management system 14 comprises a balancing circuit 15 and, for each electrochemical element 12, a voltage sensor 16, a first current sensor 18 and a second current sensor 20.

[0093] The balancing circuit 15 is capable of applying a respective balancing current to each of the electrochemical elements 12 of the battery.

[0094] The balancing circuit 15 has two states, namely an active state in which the balancing circuit 15 applies a balancing current and an inactive state in which the balancing circuit 15 does not apply the balancing current.

[0095] The voltage sensor 16 is suitable for measuring the voltage across the terminals of the electrochemical element 12.

[0096] The first current sensor 18 is suitable for measuring the current delivered by the electrochemical element 12.

[0097] The second current sensor 20 is capable of measuring the balancing current applied to the electrochemical element 12 by the balancing circuit 15.

[0098] The computer 22 is capable of implementing a plurality of methods which will be described later.

[0099] The calculator 22 is an electronic circuit designed to manipulate and / or transform data represented by electronic or physical quantities into computer registers and / or memories into other similar data corresponding to physical data in register memories or other types of display devices, transmission devices or storage devices.

[0100] As specific examples, the computer 22 includes a single-core or multi-core processor (such as a central processing unit (CPU), a graphics processing unit (GPU), a microcontroller, and a digital signal processor (DSP)), a programmable logic circuit, such as an application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a field-programmable gate array (FPGA), a programmable logic device (PLD), and programmable logic arrays (PLA), a state machine, a logic gate, and discrete hardware components.

[0101] An operation of the calculator 22 is now described with reference to [Fig. 3] which is a flowchart illustrating an example of implementation of a method for estimating the self-discharge of at least one electrochemical element 12 of the battery 10 relative to a reference value.

[0102] According to the example described, the estimation method comprises an obtaining step and an estimation step.

[0103] During an obtaining step, the computer 22 obtains the capacity of the electrochemical element 12, the first measurement values ​​and the second measurement values.

[0104] This obtaining step is shown diagrammatically in [Fig.3] by the squares 30, 32 and 34 corresponding respectively to the capacity, the first values ​​and the second values.

[0105] The capacity can be obtained by any means, in particular by implementing an estimation.

[0106] For the following, the capacity is noted Q1 with i an index used to identify the electrochemical elements 12. The capacity Q' is thus the capacity of the ith electrochemical element 12 of the battery 10.

[0107] Indeed, the electrochemical elements 12 are assumed here to be connected in series.

[0108] The first measurement values ​​are values ​​of the current of the electrochemical element 12 and of the balancing current applied to the electrochemical element 12.

[0109] In the following, and Z^; respectively denote the current of the electrochemical element 12 of index i and the balancing current applied to the electrochemical element 12 of index i.

[0110] Each of the first measurement values ​​are obtained at first instants.

[0111] According to the example described, the first measurement values ​​are obtained at intervals regular, this time interval being noted At.

[0112] According to the example described, the two current sensors 18 and 20 measure these values ​​of fluent.

[0113] Alternatively, the first measurement values ​​are obtained by an estimation.

[0114] The first measurement values ​​are therefore obtained either by measurements or by estimations or if this is relevant, for example because certain measurements are not feasible at certain first moments, by measurements and estimations.

[0115] The second measurement values ​​are values ​​of the state of charge of the electrochemical element.

[0116] Each of the second measurement values ​​are obtained at second times.

[0117] The second instants are noted tn in the following, the index n being an integer.

[0118] The second measurement values ​​can thus be noted SOC',^ i designating the i- th electrochemical element 12 and n the second instant tn.

[0119] As with the first measurement values, the second measurement values ​​are obtained either by measurements or estimations.

[0120] For a measurement, it is appropriate to carry out a complete discharge or charge.

[0121] Such an operation is often referred to as “taking a photo”.

[0122] At the end of the obtaining step, the calculator 22 thus has a plurality of values ​​for several physical quantities and will use these values ​​to estimate the self-discharge of the electrochemical element 12.

[0123] During the estimation step, the computer 22 thus estimates the value of the self-discharge of the electrochemical element 12 at a second instant, called the second estimation instant, by applying an estimation function to the capacity, the first measurement values ​​and a second measurement value.

[0124] This estimation step is symbolized by a rectangle 36.

[0125] According to a first example of embodiment of the obtaining step, the reference value is zero and the estimation function is an observer based on a formula which can be described as “coulometry”.

[0126] More precisely, the state of charge can be expressed by the following formula:

[0127] SOC(k+l)=SOC(k)+±l(k)

[0128] The estimation function therefore seeks to obtain the estimate of the self-discharge of the electrochemical element considered.

[0129] Generally, the self-discharge current is expressed as the loss of capacity per month of the electrochemical element 12 considered.

[0130] In other words, a loss of 3% of capacity per month of a 180 Ah electrochemical element corresponds to a current of L22UL2 = 75

[0131] It may also be specified here that the convention used for the current is the receiver convention, so that the discharge current is negative and thus the self-discharge currents to be estimated are negative currents.

[0132] In this case, the estimation function calculates two contributions to self-discharge, a first contribution and a second contribution.

[0133] The first contribution corresponds to the variation in the state of charge of the electrochemical element 12 between the second estimation instant and a second previous instant.

[0134] The second contribution corresponds to the accumulation of charge in the electrochemical element 12 linked to the first measurement values ​​in the time interval between the second previous instant and the second estimation instant.

[0135] More precisely, the estimation function is a weighted sum of the contributions and the value of the self-discharge relative to the reference value at the second prior instant.

[0136] The contributions are here weighted by the same gain coefficient.

[0137] The estimation function is written mathematically:

[0138] 4«,-

[0139] Where: • M = ^ > • ( / =-¼ Q • (rbai + Ibat) (tn + kàt) corresponds to the value of + Ihat at times + AAf, k being an integer varying between 0 and Ml, and • is the gain coefficient.

[0140] According to a first embodiment, the gain coefficient depends on two parameters, a first parameter being the product of the capacity of the electrochemical element with the time interval between the second previous instant and the second estimation instant and the second parameter being an adjustable value.

[0141] Furthermore, the gain coefficient is a hyperbolic function that can be written in the form:

[0142] ......£1...... piz+re2

[0143] with PI the first parameter and P2 the second parameter.

[0144] As a particular example, the gain coefficient is given by:

[0145] „ (Lam

[0146] Where: • P is a tuning parameter (second parameter P2) which allows to control the update speed of the observer.

[0147] According to a second embodiment, the gain coefficient used also takes into account a third parameter, the third parameter taking into account takes into account the uncertainty of the second measurements.

[0148] For example, the gain coefficient is a hyperbolic function that can be written in the form:

[0149] P3......n......

[0150] with PI the first parameter, P2 the second parameter and P3 the third parameter.

[0151] The gain coefficient then becomes:

[0152] Ki _ ajp'AtM 11 y2+(oiAtM)2

[0153] where O& denotes the third parameter and depends on the ratio between the uncertainty of the second measurements and the value of the contributions.

[0154] According to a particular example, the third parameter verifies the following relation:

[0155] , . / \ = p'niax^ 1--.....-, 0 j

[0156] Where: • p1 is an adjustment parameter, this parameter verifying 0 < < 1 • and ^2 represent, respectively, the uncertainty in the state measurement of charge at the second instants andt», • K corresponds to the uncertainties in the measurements of the currents of the 12 electrochemical and self-discharge elements, • 5 denotes a relatively small positive number, the role of which is to avoid the division by 0 if term 4 is zero, and • 4 denotes the error in the estimation of self-discharge, this value being given according to the following formula:

[0157] e'„ = SOC'll+l-SOC'n -rhul(+ kàt) j J

[0158] The third parameter 6¾ thus introduces a so-called dead zone mechanism into the estimation process. In other words, for there to be an update, the estimate e!n must be sufficiently large relative to the measurement uncertainties + ^2.

[0159] According to a second example, the estimation function is an observer based on a coulometry model and the reference value is the self-discharge value of a reference electrochemical element 12.

[0160] According to a particular example, the reference electrochemical element 12 is the electrochemical element 12 for which the self-discharge value at the second prior instant is the highest.

[0161] Such an estimation function thus allows the estimation of the difference in self-discharge between the electrochemical element 12 considered and that of the electro- reference 12 trochemical.

[0162] In addition to the first and second previous contributions, the estimation function according to the second example also takes into account two additional contributions.

[0163] The third contribution corresponds to the variation in the state of charge of the reference electrochemical element between the second estimation instant and the second previous instant.

[0164] The fourth contribution corresponds to the accumulation of charge in the reference electrochemical element linked to the first measurement values ​​in the time interval between the second previous instant and the second estimation instant.

[0165] Furthermore, as for the previous embodiment, the estimation function is a weighted sum of the contributions and the value of the self-discharge relative to the reference value at the second previous instant.

[0166] The contributions are here weighted by the same gain coefficient.

[0167] The estimation function is written mathematically:

[0168] = K'„ (ASOC^ - ASOCi - Al (('» + *Az) ' + (lf~ + k Al)) + (SOC^ - SOC^)).

[0169] Where: * at 1 represents the estimate of the self-discharge gap of the ith electronic element electrochemical 12 relative to the self-discharge of the reference electrochemical element 12, • Jn denotes the index of the reference electrochemical element, in the example described, due to the choice of the reference electrochemical element, the index Jn verifies the following relation:

[0170] jn = ar gminSOC^ i • ASOC', is the difference in state of charge between the ith electrochemical element and the reference electrochemical element, this value ASOCln thus verifying the following mathematical relationship: [oi7i] &soci, = soc't - soc'r

[0172] As for the previous case, two examples can be considered in particular for the gain coefficient .

[0173] According to the first example, the gain coefficient ^is always expressed as follows:

[0174] _ ff'AM

[0175] In the case of the second example, the gain coefficient ^ can be written:

[0176] Kln = gj as before (the quantity to be used always

[0177] where (¾ _ pimax( [ * fl \ 7,+¾ RM' to avoid division by 0) but with a new formulation for the estimate £4 which becomes :

[0178] eil = ASOC^rASOC)-At(Y^l)Jt„ + k&)-^) +

[0179] In each of the cases described above, a value for the self-discharge of an electrochemical element 12 is obtained at the end of the process. This is represented schematically in [Fig.3] by the circle 38.

[0180] Such a method thus makes it possible to obtain a more reliable estimate of self-discharge.

[0181] Self-discharge estimation can be used for many applications.

[0182] According to a first application, the estimation of the self-discharge is used to obtain the dispersion of the state of charge of the electrochemical elements.

[0183] Thus, by way of example, the computer 22 can also implement a method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge of the electrochemical elements according to the flowchart illustrated in [Fig.4].

[0184] The evaluation method comprises an implementation step and a determination step.

[0185] During the implementation step, the calculator 22 implements the method for estimating the self-discharge for a plurality of electrochemical elements 12 of the battery 10.

[0186] The plurality of electrochemical elements 12 preferably groups together all of the electrochemical elements 12 of the battery 10.

[0187] The calculator 22 thus makes it possible to obtain a self-discharge value relative to the reference value for each electrochemical element 12 of the plurality.

[0188] During the determination step, the calculator 22 determines the dispersion of the state of charge within the plurality at an evaluation time as the difference between the state of charge of the electrochemical element 12 of the plurality which is the highest and the state of charge of the electrochemical element 12 of the plurality which is the lowest.

[0189] Alternatively, it would be possible to envisage a determination step during which the estimation of the self-discharge difference relative to the electrochemical element 12 having the greatest self-discharge value is used.

[0190] According to the example of [Fig.4], the determination step comprises a test operation and an application operation.

[0191] During the test operation, one or more predefined criteria are used.

[0192] In the case described, two criteria are used.

[0193] A first criterion consists of determining whether the evaluation time corresponds to a second estimation time.

[0194] This test is represented in [Fig.4] by a diamond schematically representing a test of the value of the photo-taking variable PF.

[0195] If the photo-taking variable PF has a first value, this indicates that the photo has been taken, whereas if the photo-taking variable PF has a second value, this indicates that the photo has not been taken.

[0196] The photo-taking variable PF is thus, for example, a boolean whose first value is TRUE (noted O in [Fig.4]) and the second value is FALSE (noted N in [Fig.4]).

[0197] A second criterion used during the test operation is to test the state of the balancing circuit at the time of evaluation.

[0198] This test is represented in [Fig.4] by a diamond schematically representing a test of the value of the activation variable ABF.

[0199] The activation variable ABF is a boolean taking the value TRUE when the balancing circuit 15 is in the active state and FALSE otherwise.

[0200] During the application operation, the calculator 22 applies an evaluation function to values ​​used or obtained during the implementation step.

[0201] The applied evaluation calculation function is chosen according to the result of the test operation.

[0202] More precisely, the evaluation calculation function will be chosen from several sub-functions according to the predefined criterion(s) used during the test operation.

[0203] In the illustrated case, the calculator 22 has three different sub-functions noted respectively SFC, SFE1 and SFE2.

[0204] When the first criterion is verified, the calculator 22 applies a calculation sub-function SFC as a calculation function.

[0205] The calculation sub-function SFC calculates the maximum of the difference of the states of charge of the electrochemical elements 12 of the plurality at the evaluation time.

[0206] Such a SFC calculation subfunction is written:

[0207] SFC = min (SSmeasured (t„+1)) MOWSV measures \ n+1 / /

[0208] Where: • SS denotes the state-of-charge deviation SS, i.e. the percentage difference between the most charged electrochemical element 12 and the least charged electrochemical element 12 within the plurality, and • MOWS corresponds to the maximum window for observing deviations in charge states in the measurement area, such a window can for example be fixed as the maximum state of charge level of the zone ZI in [Fig.2],

[0209] When the second criterion is verified but not the first criterion, the calculator 22 applies as calculation function a first estimation sub-function SFE1.

[0210] The first estimation sub-function SFE1 is applied to the values ​​obtained at the end of the implementation step.

[0211] Unlike the calculation sub-function SFC which uses measurements also used in the implementation step, the first estimation sub-function SFE1 uses the output data from the implementation step.

[0212] The first estimation subfunction SFE1 estimates four contributions to the dispersion, namely:

[0213] - a first contribution linked to the deviation in the state of charge within the plurality,

[0214] - a second contribution linked to the self-discharge specific to each electro element chemical 12,

[0215] - a third contribution linked to the maximum self-discharge of all the electrochemical elements 12 of the plurality, and

[0216] - a fourth contribution linked to the balancing currents applied to the electrochemical elements 12 of the plurality of electrochemical elements 12.

[0217] More precisely, in the example described, the first estimation sub-function SFE1 is written:

[0218] SFE1 = SS (k + 1) + DT * (SBWB (k) + MSD% - CSD%;)

[0219] Where: • DT denotes the time interval between two iterations (in seconds), • SBWB designates the quantity of charge balanced by the balancing circuit 15 between the times F? and f?î+i as a percentage of the state of charge of the electrochemical element 12 considered, this corresponding to the following formula:

[0220] SBWB - ■ [% r1] onvyn 3600xQ

[0221] where i is the index of the electrochemical element 12 considered andlbali is the balancing current applied to the electrochemical element 12 i in amperes, • MSD%: maximum self-discharge estimated on all the electrochemical elements 12 constituting the plurality:

[0222] MSD r oouu U- LJ

[0223] Where Q denotes the capacity of cell i in Ah and CSD^j the self-discharge of the electrochemical element 12 estimated in A, and • CSD% 4: estimated self-discharge of the ith electrochemical element 12 considered:

[0224] _ lOOxCSD^ r 1 FoD%l- 3600x0. ]

[0225] When neither of the two criteria is verified, the calculator 22 applies a second SFE2 estimation subfunction.

[0226] The computer 22 therefore applies this second estimation sub-function SFE2 when the balancing circuit 15 is in the active state and the evaluation time does not correspond to the second estimation time.

[0227] As in the case of the first estimation sub-function SFE1, the second estimation sub-function SFE2 is an estimation function applied to the values ​​obtained at the end of the implementation step.

[0228] The second estimation subfunction SFE2 estimates three contributions to the dispersion, namely:

[0229] - a first contribution linked to the deviation in the state of charge within the plurality,

[0230] - a second contribution linked to the self-discharge specific to each electro element chemical 12, and

[0231] - a third contribution linked to the maximum self-discharge of all the electrochemical elements 12 of the plurality.

[0232] More precisely, in the example described, the second estimation sub-function SFE2 is written:

[0233] SFE2 = SS (k) + DT * (MSD - CSD)

[0234] In each case, a measured or estimated value is thus obtained at the end for the deviation in the SS load state, taking into account the best available values.

[0235] The evaluation method makes it possible to obtain the most accurate value of the state-of-charge deviation SS within the plurality of electrochemical elements 12.

[0236] According to a second application, the estimation of self-discharge is used to control the current balancing of electrochemical elements.

[0237] Two specific examples will now be described with reference to the flowcharts of Figures 5 and 6.

[0238] According to a first example corresponding to [Fig.5], the computer 22 implements a method for controlling the current balancing of the electrochemical elements.

[0239] The control method comprises an implementation step, a comparison step and a control step.

[0240] During the implementation step, the calculator 22 implements the previous evaluation method to obtain an evaluated dispersion.

[0241] The upper part of the figure (before the brace) therefore corresponds to the repetition of the flowchart of [Fig.4].

[0242] During the comparison step, the calculator 22 compares the evaluated dispersion with a dispersion threshold SST.

[0243] The dispersion threshold SST is a parameter setting the difference in percentage of maximum charge state tolerated in the plurality at the time of taking photos.

[0244] The SST dispersion threshold is chosen to ensure that at the time of taking photos the elements are observable and to prevent the available capacity from being too reduced. An SST dispersion threshold between 1% and 5% usually makes it possible to meet these conditions.

[0245] This operation is symbolized in [Fig.5] by a diamond giving the result of the comparison (O for dispersion greater than the SST dispersion threshold and N for dispersion less than the SST dispersion threshold).

[0246] During the control step, the computer 22 controls the state of the balancing circuit 15 according to the result of the comparison.

[0247] According to the example described, the computer puts the balancing circuit in the active state of the balancing circuit if the evaluated dispersion is greater than or equal to the dispersion threshold.

[0248] This is symbolized in [Fig.5] by a rectangle in which ABF =1 is written.

[0249] Otherwise, the computer 22 puts the balancing circuit 15 in the inactive state.

[0250] This is illustrated schematically by the rectangle where ABF = 0 is written.

[0251] According to a second example corresponding to [Fig.6], an additional test is added.

[0252] This test consists of verifying whether the evaluated dispersion is greater than or equal to the dispersion threshold reduced by a hysteresis threshold.

[0253] If yes, the computer 22 keeps the balancing circuit in the active state of the balancing circuit 15.

[0254] Otherwise, the computer 22 puts the balancing circuit in the inactive state, as schematically illustrated by the rectangle where ABF = 0 is written.

[0255] Such an additional test makes it possible to avoid blocking the balancing circuit 15 in active mode.

[0256] The balancing control method described above allows efficient management of the balancing circuit 15 so that it ensures good balancing of the state of charge of the electrochemical elements 12 within the plurality.

[0257] According to a second example corresponding to [Fig.7], the computer 22 implements a balancing control method comprising an implementation step, a comparison step and a control step.

[0258] The implementation and comparison steps are similar to the previous cases. The same remarks therefore apply here and are not repeated.

[0259] During the control step, the computer 22 controls the time interval between two second consecutive instants to be used for subsequent measurements as a function of the result of the comparison, i.e. the time interval between two photos taken.

[0260] Such a time interval will therefore be called in the following a measurement interval to clarify the rest of the description.

[0261] Ideally, this time interval should be as long as possible to interrupt the use of the battery 10 as little as possible.

[0262] The control carried out by the computer 22 may consist of implementing one or more of the operations set out below.

[0263] For example, according to a first operation, the measurement interval is incremented by a first time increment when the evaluated dispersion is less than or equal to a threshold.

[0264] According to a second operation, the measurement interval is reduced by a second time increment when the evaluated dispersion is less than or equal to the threshold.

[0265] According to a third operation, the measurement interval is set to a predefined value if the decrease of the second increment leads to a value lower than the predefined value.

[0266] In the three preceding operations, the first time increment and the second time increment can advantageously be equal.

[0267] In more complex operations, the first time increment and the second time increment depend on other parameters, for example the number of iterations already performed in the implementation of the method or the deviation of the dispersion evaluated from the threshold. The smaller the dispersion is compared to the threshold, the larger the first time increment can be.

[0268] For the specific example of [Fig.7], an example of sequences of actions is now described.

[0269] During an initialization action, the measurement interval BP is initialized to an initial value T0.

[0270] This action is represented in [Fig.7] by a rectangle in which BP=T0 is indicated.

[0271] As long as the time elapsed since the last photo was taken is less than the measurement interval BP, the computer 22 maintains the variable PR at a first value indicating that a discharge is not necessary.

[0272] When the elapsed time becomes greater than or equal to, the value of the variable PR is changed to a second value.

[0273] This second value corresponds to the fact that a discharge should be carried out.

[0274] For example, the first value is 0 and the second value is 1, so the first value is TRUE while the second value is FAKE.

[0275] This action is represented schematically by a diamond in which it is indicated Ar > BP and rectangles indicating PR = 0 or PR = 1 depending on the case.

[0276] According to a more elaborate embodiment, this action may include additional criteria, for example, if the dispersion of the state of charge exceeds a threshold, the change to 1 of the variable PR may also be imposed.

[0277] This information on the dispersion of the state of charge comes here from the evaluation method described previously.

[0278] The computer 22 then puts a test action to test if the electrochemical element 12 is in the measurement zone, that is to say a zone adapted from the SOC / OCV characteristic of [Fig.2],

[0279] Such a test action thus corresponds to a step of testing the validity of the measurement.

[0280] This action is represented schematically by a diamond in which it is indicated “Z1 / Z4?”.

[0281] When the electrochemical element 12 is actually in the measurement zone, it is then tested whether the difference in state of charge with balancing is less than or equal to the MOWS value already explained previously.

[0282] In Figure 7, it is a diamond with the indication SS < MOWS which corresponds to this action.

[0283] If not, the measurement interval BP is reset to the initial value T0 as indicated in the corresponding rectangle of [Fig.7].

[0284] In the other case, the calculator 22 implements a second test.

[0285] This test determines whether the difference in state of charge with balancing is less than or equal to the MUL value.

[0286] The MUL value corresponds to the maximum tolerance allowed for dispersion at the time of measurement.

[0287] The MUL value is less than or equal to the MOWS value.

[0288] The MUL value can in particular be set to the value of the SST dispersion threshold.

[0289] As previously, the action corresponding to the second test is represented by a diamond with the indication SS > MUL.

[0290] If the condition is met, the measurement interval BP is incremented by a predefined time interval TS relative to the current measurement interval value noted BPn in the corresponding rectangle.

[0291] The predefined time TS can be set to the desired value depending on the desired precision in obtaining the BP measurement interval. As a non-limiting example, a value equal to 1 day can be chosen.

[0292] If no, the current value of the BPn measurement interval is compared to the interval of predefined time TS.

[0293] If the difference result is positive (BPn > TS), the predefined time interval TS is subtracted from the current value of the measurement interval BPn to obtain a new value for the measurement interval BP and otherwise, the current value of the measurement interval BPn is retained.

[0294] Such a method is implemented iteratively until a value for the BP measurement interval is obtained which is satisfactory.

[0295] Such a control method therefore makes it possible to dynamically adjust the BP measurement interval. This results in increased availability of the battery 10.

[0296] With reference to [Fig.8] which is a block view of the methods which have just been described, the method comprises four blocks: a first block B1 providing a self-discharge value for each electrochemical element 12, a second block B2 giving the value of the dispersion within the plurality of electrochemical elements 12, a third block B3 controlling the measurement interval and a fourth block B4 controlling the activation of the balancing circuit 15.

[0297] These different blocks are independent in the sense that they only need the output of the previous block to be implemented.

[0298] This means that any other way of providing the same value can be considered.

[0299] Thus, as an example, the actions of the third block B3 can be implemented with any method make it possible to obtain the value of the dispersion within the plurality of electrochemical elements 12, for example, a combination of blocks B1 and B2 corresponding to the method described, but also a combination of B2 with a block other than block B1 or a combination of completely different blocks.

[0300] Similar remarks apply to the second block B2 and the fourth block B4.

[0301] In each case, blocks B1 to B4 are advantageously used to ensure better current balancing of the electrochemical elements 12.

[0302] This has been shown in the context of experiments carried out by the Applicant and the results of which are visible in Figures 9 to 12.

[0303] In these experiments, the battery comprises 5 electrochemical elements 12 in series.

[0304] The final time considered is 180 days.

[0305] The capacities and self-discharge of each electrochemical element 12 are given in the following table:

[0306] [Tables 1] Element El E2 E3 E4 E5 Capacity (Ah) 199.64 199.5 199.09 194.95 196.33 Self-discharge (mA) 2.5 1 2 6.5 5.5

[0307] The corresponding self-discharge curves for each of the electrochemical elements 12 are shown in [Fig.9] which shows the evolution of the current over time.

[0308] This information makes it possible to obtain the self-discharge dispersion by implementing the evaluation method.

[0309] The tolerance for the maximum dispersion of state of charge within the battery 10 is set to 1%.

[0310] With the implementation of the method, the results of figures 10 and 11 are obtained to be compared with the result of [Fig. 12] corresponding to a current balancing without implementation of the method.

[0311] Figures 10 and 12 represent the evolution of the charge state dispersion over time and in dotted lines the times at which a photo is taken.

[0312] [Fig. 11] shows how the BP measurement interval increases with time.

[0313] It emerges from this comparison that the method makes it possible to obtain a reduction of a factor of 4 in the dispersion of the state of charge as well as a gain of a factor of 3 on the BP measurement interval.

[0314] The methods described therefore make it possible to obtain better balancing with spaced photos taken.

Claims

Claims

1. Method for estimating the self-discharge of at least one electrochemical element (12) of a battery (10) relative to a reference value, a balancing current specific to the electrochemical element (12) being applied to each electrochemical element (12), the method being implemented by a computer (22), the method comprising, for at least one electrochemical element (12), the steps of: - obtaining: - the capacity of the electrochemical element (12), - first measurement values, the first values ​​comprising measurements or estimations of the current of the electrochemical element (12) and of the balancing current applied to the electrochemical element (12) at first instants, and - second measurement values, the second values ​​comprising measurements or estimations of the state of charge of the electrochemical element (12) at second times, - estimation of the value of the self-discharge of the electrochemical element (12) at a second instant, called the second estimation instant, by applying an estimation function on the capacity, of the first measurement values ​​and of the second measurement values, the estimation function calculating two contributions to the self-discharge, a first contribution corresponding to the variation in the state of charge of the electrochemical element (12) between the second estimation instant and a second earlier instant and a second contribution corresponding to the accumulation of charge in the electrochemical element (12) linked to the first measurement values ​​in the time interval between the second earlier instant and the second estimation instant.

2. A method for estimating self-discharge according to claim 1, wherein the reference value is the self-discharge value of another electrochemical element (12), the other electrochemical element (12) preferably being the electrochemical element (12) for which the self-discharge value at the second prior time is the highest, the estimation function also taking into account a third contribution corresponding to the variation in the state of charge of the other electrochemical element (12) between the second estimation instant and the second previous instant and a fourth contribution corresponding to the accumulation of charge in the other electrochemical element (12) linked to the first measurement values ​​in the time interval between the second previous instant and the second estimation instant.

3. A method for estimating self-discharge according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the estimation function is a weighted sum of the contributions and the value of self-discharge relative to the reference value at the second prior time.

4. A method for estimating self-discharge according to claim 3, wherein the contributions are weighted by the same gain coefficient, the gain coefficient depending on: - a first parameter, the first parameter being the product of the capacity of the electrochemical element (12) with the time interval between the second previous instant and the second estimation instant, - a second parameter, the second parameter being an adjustable value, and possibly - a third parameter taking into account the uncertainty of the second measurements, the third parameter preferably depending on the ratio between the uncertainty of the second measurements and the value of the contributions, the gain coefficient preferably being a hyperbolic function which can be written in the form: P3......£1....... ~ P l2+Pl~ with PI the first parameter, P2 the second parameter and P3 the third parameter.

5. Method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge of a plurality of electrochemical elements (12) of a battery (10), the plurality preferably comprising all of the electrochemical elements (12) of the battery (10), the method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge being implemented by a computer (22) and comprising the steps of: - implementing, for the plurality of electrochemical elements (12) of the battery (10), steps of a method for estimating the self-discharge of an electrochemical element (12) of a battery (10) with respect to a reference value according to any one of claims 1 to 4, to obtain a self-discharge value relative to the reference value for each electrochemical element of the plurality of electrochemical elements (12), and - determining the dispersion of the state of charge within the plurality at an evaluation time as the difference between the state of charge of the electrochemical element (12) of the plurality which is the highest and the state of charge of the electrochemical element (12) of the plurality which is the lowest, the determining step comprising the application of an evaluation function on values ​​used or obtained during the implementation step.

6. A method for evaluating state of charge dispersion according to claim 5, wherein: the battery (10) is provided with a balancing circuit (15) for applying a respective balancing current in each electrochemical element (12) of the plurality of electrochemical elements (12), the balancing circuit (15) having two states, an active state and an inactive state, the applied evaluation function being chosen from several sub-functions according to at least one predefined criterion, the at least one predefined criterion preferably being that the evaluation time corresponds to the second estimation time and the state of the balancing circuit (15) at the evaluation time.

7. A method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge according to claim 6, wherein the sub-functions are chosen from: - a calculation subfunction calculating the maximum of the difference of the charge states at the evaluation time. - an estimation function applied to the values ​​obtained at the end of the implementation step, the estimation function calculating two contributions to the dispersion, a first contribution linked to the self-discharge specific to each electrochemical element (12) and a second contribution linked to the maximum self-discharge of all the electrochemical elements (12) of the plurality, and - a sub-function is an estimation function applied to the values ​​obtained at the end of the implementation step, the estimation function calculating three contributions to the dispersion, a first contribution linked to the self-discharge specific to each electrochemical element (12), a second contribution linked to the maximum self-discharge of the assembly electrochemical elements (12) of the plurality and a third contribution linked to the balancing currents applied to the electrochemical elements (12) of the plurality of electrochemical elements.

8. Method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge according to any one of claims 6 and 7, in which: - when a criterion according to which the evaluation instant corresponds to the second estimation instant is verified, the evaluation function chosen is the calculation sub-function, and - when the balancing circuit (15) is in the active state, the evaluation function chosen being the estimation sub-function calculating three contributions, the evaluation function chosen is the estimation sub-function calculating two contributions otherwise.

9. A method for controlling the current balancing of the electrochemical elements (12) of a battery (10), the battery (10) being provided with a balancing circuit (15) for applying a respective balancing current in each electrochemical element (12) of the plurality of electrochemical elements (12), the balancing circuit (15) having two states, an active state and an inactive state, the control method being implemented by a computer (22), the control method comprising the steps of: - implementing the steps of the method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge of a plurality of electrochemical elements (12) of a battery (10) according to any one of claims 5 to 8, to obtain an evaluated dispersion, - comparing the evaluated dispersion with a dispersion threshold,and - controlling the state of the balancing circuit (15) as a function of the result of the comparison by placing the balancing circuit (15) in the active state if the evaluated dispersion is greater than or equal to the dispersion threshold possibly reduced by a hysteresis threshold and placing the balancing circuit (15) in the inactive state otherwise.,

10. Method for controlling the current balancing of the electrochemical elements (12) of a battery (10), the control method being implemented by a computer (22), the control method comprising the steps of: - implementing the steps of the method for evaluating the dispersion of the state of charge of a plurality of electrochemical elements (12) of a battery (10) according to any one of claims 5 to 8, to obtain an evaluated dispersion, - comparison of the evaluated dispersion with a dispersion threshold, and - control of the time interval between two second consecutive instants to be used for subsequent measurements depending on the result of the comparison.

11. A balancing control method according to claim 10, wherein the control step comprises an increment of the time interval by a first time increment when the evaluated dispersion is less than or equal to the threshold and a decrease of the time interval by a second time increment when the evaluated dispersion is less than or equal to the threshold, the time interval being set to a predefined value if the decrease of the second increment leads to a value less than the predefined value, the first time increment and the second time increment preferably being equal.

12. A method of controlling the balance according to claim 10 or 11, wherein the method further comprises a step of testing the validity of the measurement, the testing step comprising a test of the amplitude of variation of the dispersion with respect to a maximum possible variation value.

13. Calculator (22) capable of implementing a method according to any one of claims 1 to 12.

14. Management system (14) of a plurality of electrochemical elements (12) of a battery (10), the electrochemical elements (12) having terminals, the management system (14) comprising: - a balancing circuit (15) capable of applying a respective balancing current to each of the electrochemical elements (12) of the plurality of electrochemical elements (12), - for each electrochemical element (12) of the plurality of electrochemical elements (12): - a sensor of the current (18) delivered by the electrochemical element (12), - a sensor of the balancing current (20) applied, and - a voltage sensor (16) capable of measuring the voltage at the terminals of the electrochemical element (12), and - a computer (22) according to claim 13.

15. Battery (10) comprising: - electrochemical elements (12), and - a management system (14) according to claim 14.