Method and apparatus

The method addresses the inaccuracies in satellite navigation systems by comparing satellite data with reference values and using machine learning to correct for signal delays, resulting in improved positioning accuracy and reduced power consumption.

GB2607030BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-20NAURT LTD
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
GB2021007398
Authority / Receiving Office
GB · GB
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-05-24
Publication Date
2024-11-20
Estimated Expiration
2041-05-24

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional satellite navigation systems face significant errors in determining receiver position due to signal degradation from the ionosphere, unquantifiable signal delays, and rounding errors in orbital data, leading to inaccuracies in urban environments and increased power consumption in local computing devices.

Method used

A computer-implemented method that compares the apparent elevation and azimuth of satellites with reference values, using historic orbital data and machine learning models to compensate for ionospheric delays and other signal degradation, processed remotely to reduce computational load and improve accuracy.

Benefits of technology

This method provides more accurate receiver positioning by compensating for signal delays and data corruption, reducing errors and power consumption in satellite navigation systems, especially in urban environments, while leveraging remote computing resources for enhanced processing power.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 00000001_0000
    Figure 00000001_0000
  • Figure 00000002_0000
    Figure 00000002_0000
  • Figure 00000003_0000
    Figure 00000003_0000
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A computer-implemented method of determining a position based on Global Navigation Satellite System, GNSS, data, the method comprising receiving formatted GNSS data, determining apparent elevation and azimuth of a plurality of satellites based on the formatted GNSS data, comparing the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth. Determining a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Field of Invention The present invention relates to a method and apparatus for determining a receiver position. Background Satellite-based navigation systems utilise encoded radio signals emitted from a Global Navigation Satellite System that comprises a network of navigation satellites, example networks include GPS and GLONASS. The signals from these navigation satellites pass through the Earth's ionosphere and are received by a receiver. The signal emitted from the navigation satellites comprise the satellite date and time that the signal was transmitted and the satellite's status. The signal also includes orbital information for the transmitting satellite, and the status and low-resolution orbital information for every satellite in the constellation. Signals received by a receiver are decoded and analysed to provide a receiver position. The receiver position and decoded information is output by the receiver to a local computing component as a formatted data set for example NMEA 0183. The formatted data set contains the decoded time of transmission and corresponding orbital information obtained from the signals received from the navigation satellites as well as the receiver position. Commercially available satellite navigation systems are able to determine the position, longitude and latitude, of the receiver to within approximately 10-15m. An error of this magnitude is significant in a number of use cases for example navigational instructions often need a more accurate location to provide a moving user with timely information. This error can also increase significantly depending on the local environment of the receiver. A contributing factor to the error is the degradation of the transmitted signal from the navigation satellites to the receiver. A major source of signal degradation of the signals transmitted by navigation satellites is the Earth's ionosphere. Signal degradation can result in data loss or corruption in the transmitted signal. For example, , interference from the ionosphere can change the unique pseudo-random noise (PRN) number or ephemeris data given out by the satellite. Methods to take the ionospheric degradation into account are used but the error remains significant. Signal delay is also a contributing factor to the error in position. Signals can be delayed by the ionosphere and the environment local to the receiver, for example a signal may have been reflected off of a surface such as a building surface before reaching a receiver and / or the signal may have passed through materials transparent to electromagnetic radiation such as windows. For receivers in urban environments delays caused by reflection and / or refraction can contribute significantly to an error in receiver position. This can be particularly problematic when the receiver is located in an urban environment. A difficulty that conventional navigation systems is quantifying the delay so that it may be accounted for when calculating the receiver position. Furthermore, due to historical hardware limitations the formatted data provided by the receiver is rounded. In particular, the orbital information received from the satellite is rounded. This rounding of data creates a rounding error that propagates to the receiver position provided by the navigation system further contributing to the error. Other sources of error include de-synchronisation between the clock of the receiver and the "correct" atomic clock time of the navigation satellite. There is therefore a need to provide a more accurate method of determining a position of the receiver from received satellite signals . US2020 / 0049837 describes a device for implementing a system for estimating device location that includes at least one processor configured to receive an estimated position based on a positioning system comprising a Global Navigation Satellite System (GNSS) satellite, and receive a set of parameters associated with the estimated position. The processor is further configured to apply the set of parameters and the estimated position to a machine learning model, the machine learning model having been trained based at least on a position of a receiving device relative to the GNSS satellite. The processor is further configured to provide the estimated position and an output of the machine learning model to a Kalman filter, and provide an estimated device location based on an output of the Kalman filter. US2020 / 0049837 requires a computing system local to the receiver to perform complex calculations which may be detrimental to a battery or power source of the local computing device. Furthermore US2020 / 0049837 requires specialist hardware for example an inertial navigation system in the locality of the receiver so as to generate a reference receiver position. Summary Aspects and examples of the invention are set out in the claims and aim to address at least a part of the above described technical problem, and other problems. In an aspect there is provided a computer-implemented method of determining a position based on Global Navigation Satellite System, GNSS, data, the method comprising: receiving formatted GNSS data; determining apparent elevation and azimuth of a plurality of satellites based on the formatted GNSS data; comparing the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth; and determining a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth. Advantageously this method of comparing to a reference compensates for the ionospheric and other unquantifiable signal delays inherent to radio satellite communication systems to provide a receiver position that is more accurate than that provided by conventional radio-based navigation systems. Preferably the method includes obtaining historic orbital element\parameter data for the plurality of satellites; mapping the respective orbits of the plurality of reference satellites; and determining the elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of reference satellites to obtain the reference elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites. Advantageously, historic orbit elements\parameters are measured to a very high degree of accuracy and propagation\mapping of these historic orbital parameters\element scan be done using orbital mechanics equations to provide accurate theoretical\reference positions for the plurality satellites. The mapped\propagated orbital positions therefore provide accurate reference points. The method may determine a time based on the formatted data, and use the time in the determination of the reference elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites. Historic orbital parameters relate to the past orbital states and positions of the plurality of satellites, to provide more accurate reference positions the historic orbit parameters are propagated to an appropriate time for example the time of transmission of the signal, the time of receipt of the signal or the time that a location request was sent to the receiver. The determination of a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth may comprise determining a position on a great circle of an oblate spheroid earth. For example using a coordinate system such as the World Geodetic System 84. Preferably the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites is compared with a reference elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites that comprises, for each of the plurality of satellites, and the determined elevation and azimuth of a candidate satellite is matched to a reference satellite having a reference elevation and azimuth based on at least one of : (i) the reference satellite having a reference elevation and azimuth being the closest out of a plurality of possible reference satellites to the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite; and (ii) the reference elevation and / or azimuth being within a selected threshold of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite. Matching the reference satellite position with the apparent satellite position provides an advantageous method of identifying the apparent satellite. Optionally a threshold used to match the reference satellite and the apparent elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite could be a percentage of the reference value i.e. +- 1% or could be absolute for example 1 degree in the elevation or azimuth. The method may determine a receiver position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth by determining the true location of each of the plurality of satellites based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth, and determining a receiver location based on the true location of each of the plurality of satellites. Furthermore the method of determining a position may further comprise determining a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth, as well as a determined distance to each satellite. Optionally wherein the distance determined based on a time of flight of a signal from a satellite to the receiver. The method may further comprise: receiving GNSS signals at a satellite receiver of user equipment; processing the received GNSS signals at the user equipment to obtain formatted data; sending the formatted data from the user equipment to a remote device; at the remote device: determining apparent elevation and azimuth of a plurality of satellites based on the formatted GNSS data; comparing the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth; and determining a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth; and sending the determined position to the user equipment. The received GNSS signals may comprise: the navigation satellite date and time and the satellite's status, the ephemeris: orbital information for the transmitting satellite, and / or the almanac: status and low-resolution orbital information for every satellite in the GNSS. A first algorithm may be applied to filter the formatted data. The method may further comprise comparing the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth comprises determining the difference between the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth. Furthermore, the method may determine a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth comprises by applying a trained machine learning model to determine the distance and angle away from the apparent point the real point is. Preferably the method comprises determining a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth comprises processing multiple s and taking a consensus of a plurality of determined points. In another aspect there is provided a computer-implemented method of determining a position based on Global Navigation Satellite System, GNSS, data, the method comprising: receiving GNSS signals at a satellite receiver of user equipment; processing the received GNSS signals at the user equipment to obtain formatted data; sending the formatted data from the user equipment to a remote device; and receiving position information from the remote device. In another aspect there is provided a computer readable non-transitory storage medium comprising a program for a computer configured to cause a processor to perform the above described method. In another aspect there is provided a device for determining a position based on GNSS data, the device comprising: at least one processor, and a memory including instructions that, when executed by the at least one processor, cause the at least one processor to: receive formatted GNSS data; determining apparent elevation and azimuth of a plurality of satellites based on the formatted GNSS data; compare the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth; and determine a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth. In another aspect there is provided a system for determining a position based on Global Navigation Satellite System, GNSS, data, the system comprising: a network interface for receiving formatted GNSS data; at least one processor configured to determine an apparent elevation and azimuth of a plurality of satellites based on the formatted GNSS data; wherein the at least one processor is configured to compare the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth; and wherein the at least one processor is configured to determine a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth. Preferably the system is configured to send the determined position to user equipment via the network interface. Preferably, the at least one processor of the device is configured to: obtain historic orbital data for the plurality of satellites; map the respective orbits of the plurality of satellites; and determine the elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites to obtain the reference elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites. The system may be a scalable on demand computing environment such as that provided by cloud computing networks or edge computing networks. The resources and in particular the processing power of the remote computing system improves processing time of the formatted data to calculate both the apparent and theoretical receiver positions. Advantageously, the increased computing resources of the system enables the timely processing of the signal information. Remote computing systems can calculate apparent receiver position and the reference receiver position from more than 12 satellites allowing the accuracy of the calculated apparent and reference receiver position to be further improved. The use of a networked system may also significantly reduce the power cost of the satellite navigation system to a local computing device which is of particular importance for mobile devices such as smartphones. The at least one processor of the system may also be configured to: determine a time of transmission based on the -formatted data, and wherein the at least one processor is configured to determine the elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites is based on the determined time of transmission. Preferably the at least one processor is configured to determine a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth by determining a position on a great circle of an oblate spheroid earth. For example using World Geodetic System 84. The at least one processor may be configured to: compare the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites with a reference elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites comprises, for each of the plurality of satellites, matching the determined elevation and azimuth of a candidate satellite to a reference satellite having a reference elevation and azimuth based on at least one of: (i) the reference satellite having a reference elevation and azimuth being the closest out of a plurality of possible reference satellites to the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite; and (ii) the reference elevation and / or azimuth being within a selected threshold of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite. For example the threshold could be a percentage of the reference value of either elevation or azimuth i.e. +- 1% or could be absolute i.e. 1 degree. The at least one processor may also be configured to: determine the true location of each of the plurality of satellites based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth; and determine a location based on the true location of each of the plurality of satellites. Preferably wherein the at least one processor is configured to determine a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth, as well as a determined distance to each satellite. For example the determined distance could be determined based on a time of flight of a signal from a satellite to the receiver. Brief Description of Drawings Some practical implementations will now be described, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings in which: Figure 1 shows a method of determining the position of a receiver using signals received from one or more constellations of navigation satellites. Figure 2 shows a schematic diagram of an apparatus for determining a position of a receiver. Figure 3a is a "side-on" schematic view of the receiver showing an angle of elevation to an orbital position. Figure 3b is a "top down" schematic view of the receiver showing an azimuthal angle to an orbital position. Figure 4 shows a polar plot of the apparent and reference positions of navigation satellites visible to a receiver located at the origin. Figure 5 shows a method of predicting using AI neural networks the true position of a receiver using signals received from one or more constellations of visible navigation satellites. Figure 6 shows an example AI neural network. Figure 7 shows an example of another AI neural network. Specific Description Figure 1 shows a method 100 of predicting the position of a receiver 220 using signals 212 received from one or more constellations of navigation satellites 210. Figure 2 shows a schematic diagram of an apparatus 200 for determining a position of a receiver 220 and performing the method 100. A receiver 220 receives request to determine the receiver position and collects data from received radio signals 212 transmitted from navigation system satellites 210 in one or more global navigation satellite systems (GNSS). A signal may also be received from a regional navigation satellite system. Example GNSSs currently include the Global Positioning System (GPS), Global Navigation Satellite System (GLONASS), Galileo and Beidou. The method 100 may be configured to utilise signals from navigation satellites in any navigation satellite system. The radio signal 212 transmitted from a navigation system satellite 210 is an electromagnetic wave in the radio / microwave frequency spectrum. The transmitted radio signal 212 is modulated and encoded with a navigation message that comprises information pertaining to the satellite date and time that the radio signal 212 was transmitted; orbital information of the transmitting satellite 210 and status and orbital information for the other satellites belonging to the same GNSS. The receiver 220 can, as shown in Figure 1, simultaneously receive signals 212 from a plurality of "visible" navigation satellites 210 belonging to one or more navigation satellite systems. A navigation satellite 210 is considered to be visible to the receiver 220 if the receiver receives a signal 212 from the navigation satellite 210. The receiver 220 typically has a plurality of channels which in part determines the number of navigation satellite signals 212 that the receiver 220 is able to receive and process simultaneously. On receipt 110 of the modulated and encoded signals 212 from the navigation satellites 210 a decoding and demodulation module 224 of the receiver 220 demodulates and decodes 120 the encoded information contained in the signals 212. The receiver extracts from each of the decoded and demodulated signals 212 the satellite date and time of transmission from the transmitting satellite 210; the orbital information of the transmitting satellite 210 and the status and orbital information for the other satellites belonging to the same GNSS. The decoded and demodulated information is formatted 130 into a standard format for example NMEA 0183 by a formatting module 226 of the receiver 220. The formatted data 240 comprises the information decoded from the signals 212 received by the receiver 210. The formatted data 240 comprises for each received signal the satellite date and time of transmission from the transmitting satellite; the orbital information of the transmitting satellite and the status and orbital information for the other satellites belonging to the same GNSS. The formatted data 240 also comprises an apparent position of the receiver 210. The apparent position of the receiver is calculated by the receiver 220. For example, the receiver 220 may calculate an apparent receiver position using the orbital position and time of transmission information decoded from each visible navigation satellites 210. Conventionally to calculate the apparent position of a receiver signals from four navigation satellites are required. Each time a request to determine the position of the receiver is made from / to a local computing device 230 or receiver 220 in a satellite navigation system the receiver 220 collects signals 210 and a block of formatted data such as that shown below is returned by the receiver 220. Each block contains multiple strings, containing the apparent receiver location and information about the satellites 210 visible to the receiver. Each block is self contained and corresponds to one position request. Multiple position request can be made to obtain multiple formatted data blocks. An example of a "block" formatted data set (NMEA 0183) output from a receiver is shown below: $GPGSV,3,1,09,25,54,094,32,26,26,284,33,29,82,153,37,31,61,272,40,1*6F $GPGSV,3,2,09,04,09,331,,12,14,095,,16,00,000,,18,13,168„1*69 $GPGSV,3,3,09,32,06,217„l*5E $GLGSV,3,1,09,82,74,113,29,73,38,312,34,80,82,075,24,79,24,123,31,1*76 $GLGSV,3,2,09,83,35,188,26,81,34,036,27,72,14,331,29,65,05,012„l*79 $GLGSV,3,3,09,71,08,285„l*40 $GAGSV,3,1,10,09,11,254,26,26,49,074,29,31,73,299,31,33,45,154,33,7*78 $GAGSV,3,2,10,01,48,106,,03,02,350,,05,16,303,,12,04,189„7*7B $GAGSV,3,3,10,13,09,030„21,00,000„7*79 $GNGSA,A,3,02,04,12,25,26,29,31,,,,,,0.9,0.6,0.6,1*37 $GNGSA,A,3,65,72,73,79,80,81,82,83,,,,,0.9,0.6,0.6,2*37 $GNGSA,A,3,01,05,09,24,26,31,,,,,,,0.9,0.6,0.6,3*37 $GNVTG„T„M,0.0,N,0.0,K,A*3D $GNDTM,P90„0000.000026,S,00000.000000, E,0.973, W84*57 $GNRMC,142242.00,A,5102.732398,N,00015.238226,E,0.0,,160321,3.0,W,A,V*63 $GNGNS,142242.00,5102.732398,N,00015.238226,E,AAA,21,0.6,154.9,47.0,,,V*66 $GNGGA,142242.00,5102.732398,N,00015.238226,E,1,12,0.6,154.9,M,47.0,M„*77 In this example formatted data set, the strings of data containing 'GSV' comprise information about the visible navigation satellites 210. The string gives a navigation satellite ID, an elevation and azimuth, and a signal to noise ratio . The two letters preceding GSV indicate the constellation to which the navigation satellite belongs. GP indicates satellites from the GPS constellation, GL indicates the GLONASS constellation, GA indicates the Galileo constellation, GB (not in this block) indicates the BeiDou constellation. GN means multiple constellations . The last line of the example "block" of data starting 'GNGGA' contains information about the receiver location based on the information received in the transmitted signals of the visible navigation satellites. Specifically the 'GNGGA' string comprises a UTC timestamp from the start of the day and a northing and easting in the World Geodetic System coordinate system (WGS84) corresponding to the apparent receiver position.Other examples of formatted data include Receiver Independent Exchange Format (RINEX) data. The orbital information contained in the formatted data 240 includes the apparent azimuth and apparent elevation of the transmitting visible satellite 210 relative to an apparent position of the receiver 220. The apparent azimuth may be provided in the encoded signal data 212 received by the receiver 220 or may be determined by the receiver for example based on the direction of the received signal 212. The apparent orbital position of a visible satellite may be described in terms of the apparent azimuth and the apparent elevation. Figure 3a is a "side-on" schematic view of the receiver at the apparent receiver position 222 showing an angle of elevation 320 to an apparent orbital position. Figure 3b is a "top down" schematic view of the receiver at an apparent receiver position 322 showing an azimuthal angle 340 to an orbital position. As shown in Figures 3a and Figure 3b the orbital positions of visible navigation satellites comprises an elevation angle 320 and an azimuthal angle 340 relative to the apparent position of the receiver 322 on the Earth's surface. The elevation angle is the angular direction of the orbital position relative to a horizon 310 for example the astronomical horizon of the receiver 322. The azimuthal angle 340 is the angular direction of the orbital position relative to a reference direction 330, for example magnetic north of the Earth, from the receiver 322. In most conventional satellite navigation systems, a local computing device simply reads from the formatted data 240 a northing and easting and (optionally) converts these to a latitude and longitude to give the apparent receiver position and discards the other information. The apparent receiver position and orbital information provided by conventional satellite navigation systems is adversely affected by ionospheric corruption of signal data and unquantifiable signal delay of the local environment. In the current method 100, the formatted data 240 is communicated by the receiver 220 to a local computing system 230. The local computing system 230 is in the proximity of the receiver 210 for example the receiver 220 may be incorporated into the same device as the local computing system 230. For example the local computing system might be a smartphone or smartwatch comprising a receiver 220. The receiver 220 may have a wired or wireless communication connection to the local computing system 230. On receipt of the formatted data 240 from the receiver 220, the local computing system 230 extracts 130 information from the formatted data 240 for example the time of transmission and orbital information for each received signal and the apparent receiver position 322 provided in the formatted data 240. This information is then sent to remote computing system 250 using a communication module 232. In addition, the local computing system 230 may also provide the remote computing system 250 with the time that the signals 210 were received by the receiver 220. Alternatively, or in addition, the local computing system 230 may send the entirety of the formatted data 240 to the remote computing device for data extraction 130. For example, the remote computing system 250 may extract 130 information from the formatted data set 240 received from the local computing system 230 for example the remote computing system 250 may extract the time of transmission and orbital information for each received signal 210 and the apparent receiver position 322 provided in the formatted data set. Multiple sets of extracted 242 and / or formatted data 240, corresponding to multiple position requests made by the local computing system 230, may be sent from the local computing system 230 to the remote computing system 250. The remote computing system 250 may be a scalable on demand computing environment such as that provided by cloud computing networks or an edge device in a network. The extracted information 242 and / or formatted data 240 may be transmitted using a wireless network protocol such as Wi-Fi, broadband cellular network such as 3G,4G or 5G, or a wireless communication method such as Bluetooth. Wired communication between the local and remote computing system is also possible. The remote computing system 250 receives the extracted information 242 comprising for each received signal 212 the navigation satellite date and time of transmission from the transmitting navigation satellite; the orbital information of the transmitting satellite 210 and the status and orbital information for the other satellites belonging to the same GNSS. The formatted data 240 also includes the apparent receiver position 322 and the apparent azimuth and elevations of the visible navigation satellites for that position request relative to the apparent receiver position 322. The remote computing system 250 comprises or has access to a database of historic orbital elements / parameters for navigation satellites. For example the remote computing system 250 may access and extract information from a regularly updated web hosted database of historic orbital parameters 140. An example database is that provided in the publicly released NORAD catalogue which is available at for example https: / / celestrak.com / . The NORAD catalogue contains historic orbital parameters for navigation satellites in the form of Two Line Element Sets. An example of a Two Line Element Set for NAVSTAR 43 which belongs to the global position system constellation of navigation satellites is shown below: 0 NAVSTAR 43 (USA 132) 1 24876U 97035A 21074.16914125 .00000004 00000-0 00000-0 0 9998 2 24876 55.4659 173.5894 0047170 56.3811 304.0882 2.00562800173440 Line 0 of the Two Line Element Set is the name of the satellite, Line 1 comprises information regarding the catalogue ID, year of launch and epoch of the satellite. Line 2 of the Two Line Element Set comprises information pertaining to the orbital position and motion of the satellite at the given epoch. The database of historic orbital parameters 254 is updated regularly with current orbital parameters of navigation satellites. For example, the database 254 may contain historic orbital parameters of all navigation satellites in the GPS constellation, the GLONASS constellation, the Galileo constellation, and the BeiDou constellation. The remote computing system 150 selects a plurality of reference navigation satellites from the database and using the historic orbital parameters for these reference satellites propagates the orbital parameters of the reference satellites using orbital mechanics equations to provide reference orbital positions. Alternatively or in addition perturbation models for example SGP, SGP4, SDP may be used to propagate the orbital elements of the reference satellites to obtain reference orbital positions. The reference orbital positions of the reference satellites comprise reference elevations and azimuths relative to the apparent receiver position 322 at the indicated time of receipt of the received signals 212. Alternatively an averaged or a single time of transmission of a particular received signal may be used to provide the propagated reference positions. Furthermore the time the position request was made at the local computing system 230 may also be used to calculate the reference positions. The database of historic orbital parameters 254 is regularly updated so as to minimise the time difference between the historic orbital parameters and the time of receipt of the signals reducing the complexity and increasing the accuracy of the propagation calculation. The reference elevations and azimuths of the reference navigation satellites are calculated by the remote computing system 250 and these reference elevations and azimuths are compared to the apparent elevations and azimuths extracted or calculated from the formatted data 240. A difficulty with utilising the reference orbital positions is determining the received signal (and associated visible navigation satellite) for which the reference satellites (and associated reference orbital position) should act as a reference. The reference satellite should act as a reference only for itself i.e the ID of the reference satellite should match that of the visible satellite. Whilst the received signal 212 does contain an ID number for the visible navigation satellite 210 the ID numbers are pseudo-random and are changed frequently and cannot be relied on as a way of satellite identification. Furthermore, the identifier, a unique pseudo-random noise (PRN) number encoded into the transmitted signal 212 is susceptible to corruption by the Earth's ionosphere thereby making identification of the visible navigation satellite unreliable. Therefore, a method for matching the reference satellites (and propagated reference positions) for which a satellite ID is known to the visible transmitting satellite and associated apparent orbital position is needed. Figure 4 shows a graphical representation 400 of reference and apparent navigation satellite elevations and azimuths for a receiver 210 positioned at the origin 410 of a polar grid. The radial coordinates 420 of the grid are elevation and the angular coordinates 430 of the grid are azimuth. The reference positions are represented by crosses and the apparent positions are represented by circles. The extracted apparent elevations and azimuths of the visible navigation satellites 210 are matched by the remote computing system 250 to the reference elevations and azimuths of the reference navigation satellites to obtain the identity of the visible navigation satellite 210 and to pair the apparent orbital position with a reference orbital position. The apparent and reference orbital positions are matched by taking the apparent orbital position which is closest to each reference orbital position. The reference satellite having a reference elevation and azimuth being the closest out of a plurality of possible reference satellites to the apparent elevation and azimuth of the visible satellite is selected and matched to the associated visible satellite. Alternatively or in addition the reference satellite is matched to the visible satellite based on the reference elevation and / or azimuth being within a selected threshold of the apparent elevation and azimuth of the transmitting visible satellite. Furthermore, the signal data and the formatted data contain the constellation to which the transmitting visible satellite belongs. The remote computing system 250 may therefore improve the matching of the reference satellite to the visible satellites by matching only the closest satellite within the known constellation of the reference satellite i.e. GPS reference satellites are matched to GPS visible satellite. The matching may also be further improved by filtering out visible satellites which have an apparent elevation and azimuth of 0.0,0.0 as these are defaults commonly used by a receiver where a satellite is visible but for which the receiver cannot calculate the apparent elevation and azimuth. Further limits may be placed on the matching process such as a distance limit of an apparent satellite from a reference satellites, if the limit is exceeded the visible satellite is ignored for the calculation. In such cases where the distance limit is exceeded it is often the case that the ephemeris data of the received signal was badly damaged in the ionosphere. The difference between the apparent and reference elevation and azimuth are typically no more than 1°. This is significantly smaller than the distances between the orbit of navigation satellite in the same constellation which are typically spaced 5-6° in elevation and / or azimuth. As such the likelihood of an incorrect match based on proximity or an appropriate threshold value between the apparent and theoretical orbital positions is low. An appropriate threshold value could be a percentage of the reference value i.e. +- 1% of the reference elevation or reference azimuth and / or it could be absolute i.e. 1 degree]. The difference between the apparent azimuth and elevation matched visible satellite and the matched reference satellite reference azimuth and elevation is then calculated 170 by the remote computing system 250. This difference is calculated for all pairs of matched visible and reference satellites. The method 100 of Figure 1 and in particular step 180 may be implemented by the use of trained AI neural networks. In particular AI neural networks may be trained to provide a predicted distance and predicted angle to a true receiver position based on an input comprising an apparent elevation and azimuth of a visible navigation satellite 210 and a reference elevation and azimuth of a reference navigation satellite relative to an apparent receiver position. For example, the input may comprise: the difference between apparent elevation and elevation of a visible navigation satellite and the reference azimuth and reference azimuth of a matched reference navigation satellite; and an apparent receiver position from which the apparent and reference azimuth and elevation are provided. Figure 5 shows a method 500 of using trained AI neural networks to predict a true receiver position 180. Following on from the matching of the reference and apparent orbital positions and identification of the navigation satellites 160, the remote computing system 250 calculates the difference in the elevation and azimuth of matched reference and apparent orbital positions for each matched pair of reference and visible satellites 170. The calculated difference is optionally passed first to an optional first AI neural network to determine if, based on the difference between the apparent and reference navigation satellite elevations and azimuths, whether the signal received by the receiver 220 is suitable to be used in predicting the true position of the receiver. In the case in which the signal or signals are rejected by the first AI neural network a request is sent by the remote computing system 250 to the local computing device 230 and / or receiver 220 to obtain a further set of signals . An example of a neural network 600 is shown in Figure 6. The first AI neural network comprises an input layer 610 at least one hidden layer 620 and an output layer 630. The nodes and edges of the neural network are assigned weights such that the AI neural network may be trained using input parameters to determine if the received difference between the apparent and theoretical data is suitable for use. If the first AI neural network determines that the difference between the apparent and reference matched navigation satellite positions is suitable for use then the calculated difference data is passed to a second and a third AI neural network having a similar structure to that shown in Figure 6. Alternatively, if the optional first AI is not used then the differences in the apparent and reference azimuths and elevations for the matched satellites are passed directly to the second and third Ais. The second AI is for example a trained regressor AI neural network that has been trained to predict a distance that the true receiver position is from the apparent receiver position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation of each of the plurality of visible navigation satellites with a corresponding reference elevation from a matched reference navigation satellite. The third AI is, for example a trained regressor AI neural network that has been trained to predict the angle that the true receiver position is from the apparent receiver position 222 based on the comparison of the apparent elevation of each of the plurality of visible navigation satellites with a corresponding reference elevation from a matched reference navigation satellite . Both the second and third AI neural networks comprise an input layer 610 at least one hidden layer 620 and an output layer 630. The nodes and edges of the neural network are assigned weights such that the AI neural network may be trained using input parameters to predict a true receiver position relative to the apparent receiver position based on the received difference between the apparent and reference data. For example, the second and third AI neural networks may be trained by inputting signal data received by a receiver positioned at a known surveyed point with well-known longitudes and latitudes. A multitude of receiver data at a multitude of land surveyed points comprising a multitude of signal data can be used to train the second and third Ais to predict the angle and distance that the true receiver positions is from the apparent receiver position as described above. With each set of signal data at a well-defined point input into the second and third AI the Ais iteratively learn how to become good predictors of receiver position through adjustment of the weights of the nodes and edges in the hidden layers of the neural network. Supervised learning in which the weights of the nodes and edges were adjusted based on learning outputs can also be used to train the second and third Ais. For example, during the training process predicted angles and distances from the known receiver position 322 were acted upon either by the AI or through programmer intervention to adjust the weights of the nodes and edges of the neural network to provide an improved prediction of the known receiver positions 322. A large number of iterations were performed to train the second and the third Ais with an associated large number of changes to the hidden layer structure including the associated weighting of the edges and nodes. The initial weightings used in the second and third AI may be randomly seeded. The second and third AI can be trained for example by surveying a point to determine the position of the point to a high degree of accuracy (for example to within 1mm). A local computing device is placed at the point for example a smartphone having a receiver. The smartphone (and receiver) are configured to perform multiple position request so as to collect a large number (for example millions) of transmitted signals from visible satellites over a chosen timespan (for example hours, days, weeks or longer). The received signals are decoded and formatted. The receiver outputs the formatted data and the local computing device stores multiple formatted data sets containing the above detailed data for each of the received signals. The apparent position or positions returned in the formatted data sets are compared to the known location of the surveyed point. A direction and distance from the apparent position that is needed to move from the local computing system apparent position to the surveyed point is determined. The apparent elevations and azimuths of the visible satellites are compared with reference elevations and azimuths of reference satellites . This information is used as inputs to train the second and third Ais. The second and third Ais are constructed to regress the input data so as to be able to transform differences in elevations and azimuth between visible satellites and reference satellites into a prediction of direction and distance from an apparent receiver position to a true receiver position. Following on from the matching of visible and reference satellites and determination of the differences in orbital position of matched satellites 170 the second AI receives from the remote computing system or first AI the difference between the apparent and reference elevations of the matched satellites. The second AI uses this difference as an input to the neural network to predict 540 based on the difference in elevation the distance from the apparent receiver position to the position of the receiver. The third AI receives from the remote computing system 250 or first AI the difference between the apparent and reference azimuths of the matched satellites. The third AI uses this difference as an input to the neural network to predict 550 based on the difference in azimuth the angle from the apparent receiver position to the position of the receiver. Once the second and third AI have output the predicted angle and the predicted distance these are used to translate the apparent receiver position a distance and angle along a great circle of a oblate spheroid earth to obtain a true receiver position 560. The true receiver positions derived from the predictions of the second and third Ais are used to define a covariance ellipsoid. A point on the covariance ellipsoid corresponds to a predicted receiver position. A point is selected at random from the covariance ellipsoid as the predicted receiver position. Difference data for a number of matched satellites in the same "block" of formatted data (i.e from the same position request) may be input into the second and third Ais to improve the predicted distance and predicted angle and therefore improve the accuracy of the true receiver position. Data from multiple position requests or "blocks" of data made at the same receiver position may be processed using methods 100 and 500 to improve the predicted distance and predicted angle and therefore improve the accuracy of the true receiver position. By utilising multiple blocks of data methods 100 and 500 may produce multiple true receiver positions. The true receiver positions 260 derived from the predictions of the second and third Ais may be used to define a covariance ellipsoid. A point on the covariance ellipsoid corresponds to a predicted receiver position. A point is selected at random from the covariance ellipsoid as the true receiver position. Alternatively an average or weighted average of the true receiver positions may be used to provide a single true receiver position from the outputs of methods 100 and 500. The true receiver position based on the predicted angle and distance output from the second and third AI and calculated using these by the remote computing system 250 is communicated 570 to the local computing system 260 using communication module 256. The true receiver position 260 received by the local computing system 230 may then be presented to a user by the local computing system 230, for example on a screen of local computing system 230. The calculated receiver position may be transmitted using a wireless network protocol such as Wi-Fi, broadband cellular network such as 3G,4G or 5G, or a wireless communication such as Bluetooth. Wired communication between the local and remote computing system is also possible. Figure 7 shows a further example AI neural network that may be used for the first, second and / or third Ais. The example neural network comprises input layers 710, hidden layers 720, summation layer 730 and output layer 740. Each of these layers comprises a plurality of nodes. The nodes of layers are connected by edges both within the layer and to the nodes of other layers. In particular the neural network comprises four input layers 710 that each connect to a different first hidden layer. Inputs from the input layers 710 are processed in parallel by a series of hidden layers 720. The outputs from the hidden layers 720 are passed to a summation layer 730 where they are combined and processed. The processed information is then passed to an output layer 740 for providing an output for example a predicted distance and / or angle to a system for example the remote computing system 250. The method 100 and method 500 may not utilise a remote computing system 250. In such circumstances the formatted data or extracted information is not sent to a remote computing device and the information is instead processed locally at the local computing system 230. The steps of methods 100 and 500 that are performed on the remote computing system 250 are performed instead on the local computing system. The local computing system having access to a database of know satellite historic orbital elements and trained AI neural networks. The methods 100 and 500 described above compensates, for the signal delays and signal corruption that typically affects the accuracy of conventional radio satellite navigation systems by utilising a reference positions of reference navigation satellites . Furthermore, conventional satellite navigation systems are limited by the formatted data provided by the receiver 210. The formatted data typically comprises several truncated or rounded values relating to the orbital positions of the "visible" navigation satellites. For example, NMEA 0183 is an example of a formatted data structure typically used in navigation systems. The orbital positions in particular the elevation and azimuth of visible navigation satellites is rounded in NMEA 0183 data to the closest 1°. The rounding of the orbital position information in the formatted data can amount to significant error (l-2km) in the apparent orbital position of the navigation satellite. The error in the apparent orbital position of the navigation satellite contributes to the error in the receiver position of conventional radio navigation systems, this is compensated for in methods 100 and 500 through the use of reference satellites and predictor AI neural networks. The method 100 has significant advantages over conventional radio navigation systems. Conventional radio navigation systems process formatted data from a receiver locally using a local computing system such as smartphone to provide a receiver position. Typically, the processing power of such local computing systems is limited. As a result of the limited processing power the local computing systems are capable of processing positional data for a limited number of navigation satellites, typically signals from up to 12 satellites can be processed by the local computing system. In addition, the processing of the formatted data to produce a receiver position is often power intensive which can be particularly problematic for battery powered local computing systems such as smartphones. The limitations of local computing systems are detrimental to the accuracy of receiver position that is produced by conventional satellite navigation systems. In one embodiment of the current method 100 the processing limitations of the local computing system 230 are overcome by providing the formatted data or extracted information to a remote computing system 250. The remote computing system 250 may be a scalable on demand computing environment such as that provided by cloud computing networks or edge computing networks. The resources and in particular the processing power of the remote computing system 250 improves processing time of the formatted data. The use of a remote computing system 250 also significantly reduces the power cost of the satellite navigation system to the local computing device 230 which is of particular importance for mobile devices such as smartphones. Machine learning elements described herein (for example forming any of the first, second or third Ais mentioned above) may be provided in a number of forms. This may include computer program instructions configured to program a computer processor to operate according to the instructions. The instructions may comprise a finalised machine learning element such that a user may not be able to alter or identify properties associated with the element, or the instructions may be overwritten so that continued use of the machine learning element may enable the code to be updated (so as to further develop the element). As will be appreciated in the context of the present disclosure, the specific nature of the machine learning element is not to be considered limiting, and this may vary depending on the nature of data to be processed. Any suitable system for the provision of a machine learning element may be utilised. The machine learning element may comprise a neural network. A neural network may include a plurality of layers of neurons, where each neuron is configured to process input data to provide output data. It will be appreciated that any suitable process may be provided by any given neuron, and these may vary depending on the type of input data. Each layer of the network may include a plurality of neurons. The output of each neuron in one layer may be provided as an input to one or more (e.g. all) of the neurons in the subsequent layer. Each neuron may have an associated set of weightings which provide a respective weighting to each stream of input data provided to that neuron. Each path from a neuron to a neuron may be referred to as 'an edge' . Weightings may be stored at each neuron, and / or at each edge. Such a neural network may have at least two variables which can be modified to provide improved processing of data. Firstly, a neuron's functionality may be selected or updated. Systems and methods of neural architecture search may be used to identify suitable functionalities for neurons in a network. Secondly, the weightings in the network may be updated, such as to alter priorities of different streams of input and output data throughout the network. The machine learning element may be trained. For example, training the machine learning element may comprise updating the weightings. A plurality of methods may be used to determine how to update the weightings. For example, supervised learning methods may be used in which the element is operated on an input data for which there is a known correct output. That input / output is provided to the machine learning element after it has operated on the data to enable the machine learning element to update itself (e.g. modify its weightings). This may be performed using methods such as back propagation. By repeating this process a large number of times, the element may become trained so that it is adapted to process the relevant data and provide a relevant output. Other examples for training the machine learning element include use of reinforcement learning, where one or more rewards are defined to enable elements to be trained by identifying and utilising a balance between explorative and exploitative behaviour. For example, such methods may make use of bandit algorithms. As another example, unsupervised learning may be utilised to train the machine learning element. Unsupervised learning methods may make use of principal component and / or cluster analysis to attempt to infer probability distributions for an output based on characteristics of the input data (e.g. which may be associated with known / identified outputs). The specifics of the machine learning element, and how it is trained, may vary, such as to account for the type of input data to be processed. It will be appreciated that different types of machine learning element may be suited to different tasks or for processing different types of data. It will also be appreciated that data may be cast into different forms to make use of different machine learning elements. For example, a standard neural network could be used for processing numerical input data, such as empirical values from obtained measurements. For processing images, convolutional neural networks may be used, which include one or more convolution layers. Numerical data may be cast into image form, such as by using a form of rasterisation which represents numerical data in image form. A standard file format may be used to which the resulting image must adhere, and a convolutional neural network may then be trained (and used) to analyse images which represent the measurements (rather than values for the measurements themselves). Consequently, the specific type of machine learning element should not be considered limiting. The machine learning element may be any element which is adapted to process a specific type of input data to provide a desired form of output data (e.g. any element which has been trained / refined to provide improved performance at its designated task). The above examples are to be understood as illustrative examples. Further examples are envisaged. It is to be understood that any feature described in relation to any one example may be used alone, or in combination with other features described, and may also be used in combination with one or more features of any other of the examples, or any combination of any other of the examples. Furthermore, equivalents and modifications not described above may also be employed without departing from the scope of the invention, which is defined in the accompanying claims . Reference numerals appearing in the claims are by way of illustration only and shall have no limiting effect on the scope of the claims. The term 'comprising' as used herein preferably means 'including'.

Claims

CLAIMS :20 08 241. A computer-implemented method of determining a position based on Global Navigation Satellite System, GNSS, data, the 5 method comprising:receiving formatted GNSS data;determining apparent elevation and azimuth of a plurality of satellites based on the formatted GNSS data;comparing the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of 10 each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth; anddetermining a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation 15 and azimuth, wherein comparing the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites with a reference elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites comprises, for each of the plurality of satellites, matching the determined elevation and azimuth of a candidate satellite to a reference 20 satellite having a reference elevation and azimuth based on at least one of:(i) the  reference satellite  having a referenceelevation and azimuth being the closest out of a plurality of possible reference  satellites to the  determined apparent25 elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite; and(ii) the reference elevation and / or azimuth being within a selected threshold of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite,wherein the formatted GNSS data comprises: the satellite date 30 and time of transmission from the transmitting satellite; the orbital information of the transmitting satellite; the status and orbital information for the other satellites belonging to the same GNSS; and an apparent position of a receiver,wherein the reference elevation and azimuth are determined 35 relative to the apparent receiver position, andwherein the determined position is a predicted position of the receiver.20 08 242. The method of claim 1 further comprising: obtaining historic orbital element data for a plurality of reference satellites;5 propagating orbital parameters in the historic orbital element data of the plurality of reference satellites using orbital mechanics equations to provide reference orbital positions;mapping the respective orbits of the plurality of reference 10 satellites; anddetermining the elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites to obtain the reference elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites.15 3. The method of claim 2 further comprising determining a time based on the formatted data, and wherein determining the elevation and azimuth of the plurality of reference satellites is based on the determined time of transmission.20 4. The method of any preceding claim wherein determining a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth comprises determining a position on a great circle of an oblate spheroid 25 earth.

5. The method of any of the previous claims wherein determining a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites with a 30 corresponding reference elevation and azimuth comprises determining the true location of each of the plurality of satellites based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth, and determining 35 a location based on the true location of each of the plurality of satellites .20 08 246. The method of any of the previous claims, further comprising:receiving GNSS signals at a satellite receiver of user equipment;5 processing the received GNSS signals at the user equipment to obtain formatted data;sending the formatted data from the user equipment to a remote device;at the remote device:10           determining apparent elevation and azimuth of aplurality of satellites based on the formatted GNSS data;comparing the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth; and15           determining a position based on the comparison of thedetermined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth; andsending the determined position to the user equipment.

207. The method of any of the previous claims further comprising applying a first algorithm to filter the formatted data.

8. The method of any of the previous claims wherein comparing 25 the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth comprises determining the difference between the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation 30 and azimuth.

9. The method of any of the previous claims wherein determining a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with 35 a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth comprises applying a trained machine learning model to predict the distance and angle away from the apparent point the real point is.20 08 2410. The method of any of the previous claims wherein determining a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth comprises taking 5 a consensus of a plurality of determined point.

11. A computer readable non-transitory storage medium comprising a program for a computer configured to cause a processor to perform the method of any of the previous claims.1012. A device for determining a position based on GNSS data, the device comprising:at least one processor, anda memory including instructions that, when executed by the 15 at least one processor, cause the at least one processor to: receive formatted GNSS data;determining apparent elevation and azimuth of a plurality of satellites based on the formatted GNSS data;compare the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of 20 each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth; anddetermine a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation 25 and azimuth, wherein the at least one processor is configured to:compare the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites with a reference elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites comprises, for each of the plurality of satellites, matching the determined elevation and azimuth of a 30 candidate satellite to a reference satellite having a reference elevation and azimuth based on at least one of:(i) the  reference satellite  having a  referenceelevation and azimuth being the closest out of a plurality of possible reference  satellites to the determined  apparent35 elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite; and(ii) the reference elevation and / or azimuth being within a selected threshold of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite,20 08 24wherein the formatted GNSS data comprises: the satellite date and time of transmission from the transmitting satellite; the orbital information of the transmitting satellite; the status and orbital information for the other satellites belonging to the 5 same GNSS; and an apparent position of a receiver, wherein the reference elevation and azimuth are determined relative to the apparent receiver position, andwherein the determined position is a predicted position of the receiver.1013. A system for determining a position based on Global Navigation Satellite System, GNSS, data, the system comprising:a network interface for receiving formatted GNSS data;at least one processor configured to determine an apparent 15 elevation and azimuth of a plurality of satellites based on the formatted GNSS data;wherein the at least one processor is configured to compare the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation 20 and azimuth; andwherein the at least one processor is configured to determine a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth, 25 wherein the at least one processor is configured to:compare the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites with a reference elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites comprises, for each of the plurality of satellites, matching the determined elevation and azimuth of a 30 candidate satellite to a reference satellite having a reference elevation and azimuth based on at least one of:(i) the  reference satellite  having a referenceelevation and azimuth being the closest out of a plurality of possible reference  satellites to the  determined  apparent35 elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite; and(ii) the reference elevation and / or azimuth being within a selected threshold of the determined apparent elevation and azimuth of the candidate satellite,wherein the formatted GNSS data comprises: the satellite date and time of transmission from the transmitting satellite; the orbital information of the transmitting satellite; the status and orbital information for the other satellites belonging to the 5 same GNSS; and an apparent position of a receiver, wherein the reference elevation and azimuth are determined relative to the apparent receiver position, andwherein the determined position is a predicted position of the receiver.20 08 2414. The device of claim 12 or the system of claim 13 wherein the at least one processor is configured to:obtain historic orbital parameters for a plurality of 15 reference satellites;propagate orbital parameters in the historic orbital element data of the plurality of reference satellites using orbital mechanics equations to provide reference orbital positions;map the respective orbits of the plurality of respective 20 satellites; anddetermine the elevation and azimuth of each of the plurality of reference satellites to obtain the reference elevation and azimuth of the plurality of reference satellites.25 15. The device of claim 12 or the system of claim 13 wherein the at least one processor is configured to:determine a time based on the -formatted data, and wherein the at least one processor is configured to determine the elevation and azimuth of the plurality of satellites is based on 30 the time.

16. The device of claim 12 or the system of claim 13 wherein the at least one processor is configured to determine a position based on the comparison of the determined apparent elevation and 35 azimuth of each of the plurality of satellites with a corresponding reference elevation and azimuth by determining a position on a great circle of an oblate spheroid earth.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Detecting of a spoofing jammer for GNSS signals

    EP2796895A1

  • GPS accuracy improvement for luminaires

    US20170160396A1