Method for measuring loss of magnetic body
By correcting loss measurements using relative magnetic permeability values from a network analyzer, the method addresses inaccuracies from leakage flux and lead wire inductance, enabling accurate loss determination in magnetic materials with low permeability.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023071455
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-04-25
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-07
AI Technical Summary
Conventional loss measurement methods for magnetic materials, particularly those with low relative magnetic permeability, suffer from errors due to leakage of magnetic flux and lead wire inductance, leading to inaccurate measurements at high frequencies.
A method that involves winding an excitation coil and a search coil around a magnetic material, measuring induced voltage and current, and correcting the loss value using the relative magnetic permeability measured with a network analyzer to account for leakage flux and lead wire inductance.
Enables accurate loss measurement of magnetic materials with low relative magnetic permeability by correcting for errors caused by leakage flux and lead wire inductance, ensuring precise determination of loss values.
Smart Images

Figure 2024157225000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for measuring loss in a magnetic material. [Background technology]
[0002] Electronic components using magnetic materials are widely used in IT devices and in-vehicle components. Magnetic materials are also used in electrical devices such as motors and generators. To improve the efficiency and miniaturization of such electronic components and electrical devices, it is important to accurately measure the loss of magnetic materials. In recent years, in particular, there have been efforts to increase the driving frequency in order to miniaturize electronic components and electrical devices, and loss measurement technology at high frequencies has become extremely important. Furthermore, simulation methods that incorporate precisely measured values of magnetic material loss and other measurements have become an indispensable technology for the design of electronic components and electrical devices.
[0003] Electrical losses in electronic components and electrical equipment that use magnetic materials include copper loss that occurs in the coil (Joule loss that occurs in the coil) and magnetic hysteresis loss and eddy current loss that occur in the magnetic material. Copper loss can be calculated analytically (mathematically) from the current flowing through the coil, but loss in magnetic materials must be found by actual measurement. In response to the miniaturization of electronic components and electrical equipment in recent years, magnetic materials with low relative magnetic permeability are increasingly being used at high frequencies, making it increasingly difficult to accurately measure losses in magnetic materials.
[0004] As a method for measuring the loss of a magnetic material, a method (such as a two-coil method) using a ring-shaped sample made of the magnetic material is widely used (for example, see Non-Patent Document 1). FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram of a loss measurement device 100 for a magnetic material, where FIG. 1(a) is a circuit configuration diagram of the loss measurement device 100 and FIG. 1(b) is a configuration diagram of the main part of the magnetic material. The loss measurement method for a magnetic material shown in the figure is a two-coil method in which an excitation coil (primary coil) 103 and a search coil (secondary coil) 105 are wound around a ring-shaped sample 101 made of the magnetic material to be measured, and a high-frequency AC current is applied to the excitation coil 103 via a signal generator 107 that generates a high-frequency signal and a high-frequency power amplifier 109, and a voltage V2 induced in the search coil 105 at that time and a current detection resistor R arranged on the excitation coil 103 side are measured. S The current value i measured at R This is a method for measuring the loss of a magnetic material by using an oscilloscope 111 as a measuring instrument.
[0005] The two-coil method described above is an excellent technique that is still widely used today. However, when measuring magnetic materials with low relative permeability, there is a problem in that magnetic flux leakage from the magnetic body increases, reducing the accuracy of loss measurement.
[0006] FIG. 2 is an enlarged view of the ring-shaped sample (magnetic material) in FIG. 1(b), showing the leakage of magnetic flux from the ring-shaped sample 101. FIG. 2 shows a schematic horizontal cross section of the ring-shaped sample 101, and also shows the cross sections of the excitation coil 103 and the search coil 105 in the horizontal cross section of the ring-shaped sample 101. When the relative permeability of the magnetic material is large, most of the magnetic flux a generated by passing an excitation current through the excitation coil 103 passes through the ring-shaped sample 101. In other words, the magnetic flux a in the figure is dominant. In such a case, the excitation magnetic field H generated by the excitation coil a can be calculated using equation (1).
[0007]
number
[0008] Here, N is the number of turns of the excitation coil, I is the excitation current, and L e is the magnetic path length of the ring-shaped sample, which is calculated from the outer diameter, inner diameter, and thickness of the ring-shaped sample. The magnetic flux density B inside the ring-shaped sample is given by equation (2).
[0009]
number
[0010] Here, μ0 is the magnetic permeability of a vacuum, μ is the relative magnetic permeability of the ring-shaped sample, Ha is the excitation magnetic field, N is the number of turns of the excitation coil, and I is the excitation current. When measuring the loss inside the ring-shaped sample, the excitation current I is adjusted so that the magnetic flux density B in equation (2) becomes the desired magnetic flux density Bm.
[0011] When the relative permeability of the ring-shaped sample becomes smaller, magnetic flux such as magnetic flux b occurs that, after passing through the search coil, does not pass through the ring-shaped sample but leaks out of the sample. When this happens, equation (1), which states that all magnetic flux passes through the ring-shaped sample, no longer holds. Because the leaked magnetic flux b passes through a path shorter than the magnetic path length Le, the effective magnetic path length Le' during loss measurement becomes shorter than Le (Le' < Le), and the magnetic flux density B' inside the ring-shaped sample at this time is measured as a value expressed by equation (3).
[0012]
number
[0013] Here, H a ' is the excitation magnetic field when there is leakage flux b. Equation (3) shows that the leakage flux b causes the ring-shaped sample to behave as if its relative permeability were μ(Le / Le'). As a result, the magnetic flux density B' is larger than the magnetic flux density B calculated from equation (2). Considering loss measurement, if the loss in the ring-shaped sample is to be measured at magnetic flux density Bm, the magnetic flux density B' in equation (3) is estimated to be larger than the magnetic flux density B calculated from equation (2) if the same excitation current I is applied as when there is no leakage from the ring-shaped sample, so the excitation current I is lowered to make B' equal to Bm. In other words, the actual relative permeability of the ring-shaped sample is μ, but since it is estimated to be (Le / Le') times larger, the excitation current I is adjusted to be smaller and the measured loss value is also smaller.
[0014] As electronic components and electrical equipment become increasingly high-frequency, magnetic materials with low relative permeability are being used, and the inductance of the ring-shaped sample tends to become smaller. As a result, the inductance L of the lead wire for connecting the search coil to the measuring instrument (oscilloscope) lead The effect of the lead wire inductance is considered and the magnetic flux density is given by equation (4).
[0015]
number
[0016]
number
[0017] Here, μ lead is the inductance of the lead wire, L lead is converted into relative permeability and given by equation (5). Ae is the effective cross-sectional area of the ring-shaped sample, and N is the number of turns of the search coil. The inductance L of the lead wire lead Like the leakage flux from the ring-shaped sample, this also acts to make the relative permeability μ of the ring-shaped sample appear larger, resulting in an error in the measurement of loss.
[0018] For loss measurement at high frequencies, a method called the resonance method, which is an improvement of the two-coil method, has been proposed as shown in Fig. 3. Fig. 3 is a schematic diagram of a loss measurement device 100' using the resonance method. A capacitor C R Insert the excitation coil 103, search coil 105 and capacitor C R An improved technique called the resonance method has been proposed, which measures in a resonant state by a search coil 105 (see, for example, Patent Document 1 and Non-Patent Document 2). R Since the search coil 105 and the capacitor C R are in a resonant state, the voltages due to the reactance components generated in the search coil 105 and the capacitor C R have the same magnitude but are out of phase with each other by 180°. R The voltage V3 in the series circuit and the current i flowing through the measurement circuit R are in phase, and the current detection resistor R S This reduces the effect of the parasitic inductance component of the loss, making it possible to measure losses at high frequencies exceeding 10 MHz.
[0019] In this method, a search coil 105 and a capacitor C R Since loss measurements are performed in a resonant state, it is necessary to reduce the inductance of the search coil 105 in order to perform measurements at high frequencies. To achieve this, the number of turns of the search coil 105 is reduced, but reducing the number of turns increases the leakage of magnetic flux from the ring-shaped sample, causing errors in the loss measurement. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0020] [Patent Document 1] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 3-221886 [Non-Patent Document 1] Keizo Ohta, "Fundamentals of Magnetic Engineering I", First Edition, Kyoritsu Shuppan Co., Ltd., June 1973, p.59 [Non-Patent Document 2] IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, (USA), Vol.29, NO.8, p.4374-4381 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0021] As described above, the conventional loss measurement method for each magnetic body has a problem that it is not possible to correct the error in loss measurement caused by the leakage of magnetic flux from the ring-shaped sample due to the reduction in the number of turns of the search coil. In addition, in the case of a ring-shaped sample with a small relative permeability, an error in loss measurement also occurs due to the inductance of the lead wire of the search coil, and this error also needs to be corrected.
[0022] In view of the above problems, the technology described in this specification aims to provide a loss measurement method that reduces the number of turns of a search coil and corrects errors in loss measurement due to magnetic flux leakage that occurs in a ring-shaped sample (magnetic material) with a small relative permeability. [Means for solving the problem]
[0023] The loss measurement method for a magnetic body of the present invention is characterized by comprising a measurement step of winding an excitation coil and a search coil around a magnetic body, applying an excitation current to the excitation coil to thereby measure an induced voltage in the search coil and a loss of the magnetic body using the excitation current of the excitation coil, and a correction step of correcting the loss value of the magnetic body measured by the measurement step based on the relationship between the relative permeability of the magnetic body measured during the measurement step and the relative permeability of the magnetic body measured in advance using a permeability measurement device. Effect of the Invention
[0024] According to the present invention, the loss of a magnetic body having a small relative permeability can be measured with high accuracy. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0025] [Figure 1]FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram of a conventional method for measuring loss of a magnetic body using a two-coil method. [Diagram 2] 2 is an explanatory diagram of leakage of magnetic flux from the magnetic body in FIG. 1. [Diagram 3] FIG. 1 is an explanatory diagram of a conventional improved method for measuring loss in a magnetic material by a resonance method using a capacitor Cr. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing a process flow of a loss measuring method for a magnetic body according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 5] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing the relative permeability of a magnetic material measured by a network analyzer. [Figure 6] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram of a loss correction method. [Figure 7] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the measurement results of relative permeability. [Figure 8] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the relationship between the number of turns of an excitation coil and a search coil and the loss before correction. [Figure 9] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing the relationship between excitation current and loss in a magnetic body. [Figure 10] 4 shows the relationship between the number of turns of the excitation coil and the search coil and the loss after compensation. [Figure 11] 1 is a diagram illustrating the relationship between the length of a lead wire for connecting a search coil of a magnetic material to a measuring instrument and the measured relative permeability. FIG. [Figure 12] This shows the results of measuring the loss of the magnetic material by changing the length of the lead wire. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0026] Hereinafter, an example of an embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. The components described in the present embodiment are merely examples, and are not intended to limit the scope of the present invention.
[0027] In the present invention, an excitation coil and a search coil are wound around a magnetic body, which is a ring-shaped sample to be measured, and an excitation current is applied to the excitation coil to measure the loss of the magnetic body using the induced voltage induced in the search coil and the excitation current of the excitation coil, and further, the effect of magnetic flux leaking from the magnetic body on the loss measurement is corrected using the value of relative permeability measured during loss measurement. Also, the effect of the inductance of the lead wire for connecting the search coil of the magnetic body to the measuring device (oscilloscope) affects the value of relative permeability in the same way as the leakage magnetic flux, so it is corrected in the same way.
[0028] That is, in order to address the issues involved in measuring the loss of a ring-shaped sample magnetic body (hereinafter simply referred to as magnetic body), such as the effects of magnetic flux leakage from the magnetic body and the inductance of the lead wires on the loss measurement, the relative permeability value measured in advance using a permeability measuring device such as a network analyzer or impedance analyzer, and the relative permeability value measured under the effects of magnetic flux leakage from the magnetic body and the inductance of the lead wires, are corrected to determine the correct loss of the magnetic body.
[0029] Fig. 4 is a diagram showing a process flow of a loss measurement method for a magnetic body in an embodiment of the present invention. The measurement process of the loss and relative permeability of the magnetic body is performed using the loss measurement device 100 using the two-coil method shown in Fig. 1 or the loss measurement device 100' using the resonance method shown in Fig. 3, and the correction process of the measured loss value may be performed by a calculation process using a calculation device such as a computer device.
[0030] First, the relative permeability of a magnetic material is measured using a permeability measuring device such as a network analyzer (S100).
[0031] Figure 5 shows how to measure the relative permeability of a magnetic material using a network analyzer. As shown in Figure 5, a measurement tool is used to measure the relative permeability without winding the magnetic material, so the measured value of the relative permeability is obtained without the influence of leakage flux or lead wire inductance.
[0032] Next, the magnetic material wound with the excitation coil and search coil is used to measure loss and magnetic permeability using the two-coil method or the resonance method (S102). At this time, the relative magnetic permeability is measured at a very small magnetic flux density or by changing the magnetic flux density in order to compare with the relative magnetic permeability measured by a permeability measuring device such as a network analyzer (VNA), and is calculated as an extrapolated value at zero magnetic flux density. The relative magnetic permeability measured by the network analyzer or the like is calculated as μ VNA , the relative permeability measured by the two-coil method or the resonance method is μ LOSS If this is the case, and there is no leakage flux from the magnetic body and the effect of the lead wire inductance is small, then ideally the relative permeability values of the two will be the same.
[0033] However, when there is leakage flux from the magnetic material or when there is influence from the lead wire inductance, the relative permeability μ LOSS is the relative permeability μ measured by a permeability measuring device such as a network analyzer. VNA Therefore, the actual magnetic flux density in the magnetic material (actual value of magnetic flux density) is μm smaller than the magnetic flux density set during measurement (set value of magnetic flux density). VNA / μ LOSS This undermeasured actual value of the magnetic flux density is multiplied by the measured relative permeability μ LOSS and μ VNA The magnetic flux density is corrected to a set value based on the relationship between the magnetic flux density and the magnetic flux density, and the error in the loss of the magnetic body is corrected from the corrected magnetic flux density to obtain a correct loss value (S104). The method of correcting the loss of the magnetic body will be described in more detail below.
[0034] Fig. 6 is a diagram for explaining loss correction of a magnetic body, showing the relationship between the magnetic flux density Bm of the magnetic body and its loss Pc. When measuring the loss of a magnetic body using a method such as the two-coil method or the resonance method, the relationship between the magnetic flux density Bm in the magnetic body and the loss Pc in the magnetic body is measured in advance, and correlation data between the magnetic flux density Bm of the magnetic body and its loss Pc as shown in Fig. 6 is obtained. The relative permeability μ LOSSis the relative permeability μ measured by a permeability measuring device (such as a network analyzer) VNA When the measurement is larger than the magnetic flux density Bm (magnetic flux density setting value) set during loss measurement, the magnetic material has a magnetic flux density (μ VNA / μ LOSS )Bm (actual value of magnetic flux density) is applied, the loss Pc of the magnetic material is measured as smaller than the actual loss value, as shown in Figure 6. In other words, the value at point A in the figure is measured as the loss for the magnetic flux density (set value of magnetic flux density) Bm set during measurement. Based on the correlation between the magnetic flux density Bm measured in advance and the loss Pc of the magnetic material (data shown in Figure 6), the loss value Pc at point A, which corresponds to the actual value of magnetic flux density, is corrected to the correct loss value Pc at point B, which corresponds to the set value of magnetic flux density. Specifically, the magnetic flux density at point A (actual value of magnetic flux density) is multiplied by the ratio μ of relative permeability LOSS / μ VNA The magnetic flux density at point B (the set value of the magnetic flux density) can be obtained by multiplying this by 1, and the loss Pc corresponding to the magnetic flux density at point B can be obtained from the correlation shown in Figure 6, making it possible to correct the loss Pc of the magnetic material.
[0035] [Example] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention will be described in detail with reference to the drawings. The measurements of relative permeability and loss were performed using a ring-shaped sample (magnetic body) of compacted powder made of Sendust magnetic particles with a particle size of about 10 μm. The relative permeability of the sample measured with a network analyzer (magnetic permeability measuring device) was about 30, and the dimensions were 13 mm in outer diameter, 8 mm in inner diameter, and 1 mm in thickness. The loss was measured using the resonance method shown in Figure 3. The magnetic body was wound with an excitation coil and a search coil using two parallel wires. The two parallel wires were used to reduce the gap between the excitation coil and the search coil. The number of turns of the excitation coil and the search coil was four types: 18 turns in 2 parallel, 8 turns in 4 parallel, 5 turns in 6 parallel, and 3 turns. Parallel here refers to a winding method in which multiple windings are wound at the same time and the start and end of the winding of the excitation coil and the search coil are connected respectively. By winding multiple windings in parallel in this way, the leakage of magnetic flux from the magnetic body is reduced, but magnetic flux leakage still occurs as the number of turns is reduced.
[0036] Figure 7 shows the results of measuring the relative permeability. In Figure 7, the results of measurements using a network analyzer (VNA) and the results of applying the four types of windings mentioned above are plotted together, and the measured value of the relative permeability using the network analyzer is μ VNA The relative permeability measured by the resonance method at a magnetic flux density of 0.25 mT was μ LOSS As the number of turns of the excitation coil and search coil decreases, the relative permeability μ LOSS increases and the measured value μ VNA In other words, the magnetic flux leakage from the magnetic body and the inductance of the lead wires are LOSS It is known that it has an impact on.
[0037] Figure 8 shows the results of measuring the loss of a magnetic material using the resonance method at a set magnetic flux density of 3 mT. The loss value is the loss Pc (J / m 3 As is clear from Figure 8, the loss in the magnetic material decreases as the number of turns decreases.
[0038] Figure 9 shows an example of measuring the loss of a magnetic material by changing the magnetic flux density. Figure 9 shows the result of a loss measurement when a 3-turn winding is applied, and the measurement frequency is about 30 MHz. When the set magnetic flux density Bm during loss measurement is 3 mT, the relative permeability μ measured by the network analyzer VNA The relative permeability measured by the two-coil method or the resonance method is μ LOSS From Figure 7, the values are approximately 29 and 65, respectively. Therefore, the magnetic flux density actually applied to the magnetic body (actual value of magnetic flux density) is 3mT×μ VNA / μ LOSS = 1.33mT. Although the set magnetic flux density Bm is 3mT, only 1.33mT is applied, and the loss is 0.0022 J / m 3 The relative permeability measured here is the relative permeability that includes both the effects of magnetic flux leakage from the magnetic material and the inductance of the lead wires.
[0039] This underestimation of loss is due to the fact that the magnetic flux density actually applied to the magnetic material is 1.33 mT μ LOSS / μ VNA Loss at point B of 3mT multiplied by 0.0115 J / m 3 The loss can be corrected by setting the following formula: Figure 10 shows the corrected loss values. Figure 10 shows the results of correcting all the measurement points in Figure 8. Figure 10 shows that the above loss correction makes the loss dependent on the number of turns of the excitation coil and search coil disappear, confirming the effectiveness of this loss correction process.
[0040] In this way, based on the relationship between the relative permeability of the magnetic body measured during loss measurement and the relative permeability of the magnetic body measured in advance using a permeability measuring device, the error in the loss of the magnetic body caused by the difference between the actual value of the magnetic flux density corresponding to the loss of the magnetic body measured by loss measurement and the set value of the magnetic flux density applied in loss measurement is corrected, and the loss value can be determined with high accuracy.
[0041] Fig. 11 is a diagram explaining the relationship between the length of the lead wire for connecting the search coil of the magnetic material to the measuring device and the measured relative permeability, Fig. 11(a) is a diagram showing the length of the lead wire extending from the magnetic material, and Fig. 11(b) is a graph showing the measured relative permeability corresponding to the length of the lead wire. As shown in Fig. 11(b), it was confirmed that the measured relative permeability changes depending on the length of the lead wire.
[0042] FIG. 12 shows the results of measuring the loss of the magnetic material by changing the length of the lead wire, where FIG. 12(a) shows the measurement results before correction processing for the lead wire length is performed, and FIG. 12(b) shows the measurement results after correction processing for the lead wire length is performed. For each loss value before correction shown in FIG. 12(a), the ratio μ LOSS / μ VNA By multiplying by , it is possible to obtain measurement results that eliminate the influence of the lead wire inductance, which does not depend on the length of the lead wire.
[0043] In this way, based on the relationship between the relative permeability of the magnetic material measured during loss measurement and the relative permeability of the magnetic material measured in advance using a permeability measuring device, errors in the loss of the magnetic material caused by differences in the length of the lead wires connecting the search coil to the measuring instrument are corrected, and the loss value can be determined with high accuracy. [Explanation of symbols]
[0044] 100, 100' loss measuring device 101 Ring-shaped sample (magnetic material) 103 Excitation coil (primary coil) 105 Search coil (secondary coil) 107 Signal Generator 109 Power Amplifier 111 Oscilloscope (measuring instrument)
Claims
1. a measurement step of winding an excitation coil and a search coil around a magnetic body, applying an excitation current to the excitation coil to generate an induced voltage in the search coil, and measuring a loss in the magnetic body using the excitation current of the excitation coil; and a correction step of correcting the loss value of the magnetic body measured in the measurement step based on the relationship between the relative permeability of the magnetic body measured in the measurement step and the relative permeability of the magnetic body measured in advance using a permeability measurement device.
2. In the correction step, 2. The method for measuring loss of a magnetic material according to claim 1, further comprising the step of determining a loss value of the magnetic material corresponding to a set value of magnetic flux density applied to the magnetic material based on a relationship between a value of the relative permeability of the magnetic material measured during loss measurement in the measurement step and a relative permeability measured in advance using the permeability measuring device.
3. The value of the relative permeability of the magnetic material measured during the loss measurement is μ LOSS year, The value of the relative permeability measured in advance using the permeability measuring device is μ VNA When The actual value of the magnetic flux density corresponding to the loss of the magnetic body measured in the measuring step is μ VNA/ μ LOSS 3. The method for measuring loss of a magnetic material according to claim 2, further comprising the steps of: multiplying the magnetic flux density applied to the magnetic material by a factor of 10; and determining a set value of the magnetic flux density applied to the magnetic material; and determining a loss value of the magnetic material corresponding to the set value of the magnetic flux density.
4. 4. A method for measuring loss of a magnetic material according to claim 1, further comprising the step of correcting an error in the loss of the magnetic material caused by a difference between an actual value of magnetic flux density corresponding to the loss of the magnetic material measured in the measurement step and a set value of magnetic flux density applied in the measurement step, based on a relationship between the relative permeability of the magnetic material measured in the measurement step and the relative permeability of the magnetic material measured in advance using a permeability measuring device.
5. 4. The method for measuring loss of a magnetic material according to claim 1, further comprising the step of correcting an error in loss of the magnetic material caused by a difference in length of a lead wire connecting the search coil to a measuring instrument, based on a relationship between the relative permeability of the magnetic material measured in the measurement step and the relative permeability of the magnetic material measured in advance using a permeability measuring device.
6. 4. The method for measuring loss of a magnetic material according to claim 1, wherein the magnetic permeability measuring device is a network analyzer or an impedance analyzer.
7. 4. The method for measuring loss of a magnetic material according to claim 1, wherein the measurement step measures the loss of the magnetic material by a two-coil method or a resonance method.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Method for measuring core loss
JP1991221886A
