Program and evaluation support system
The use of pictograms to simplify the Barthel Index evaluation addresses the burden and time issues of conventional methods, enabling quicker and more frequent ADL assessments, which in turn supports timely interventions and reduces nursing care costs.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2024096256
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-12-08
- Filing Date
- 2024-06-13
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-14
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-06-13
AI Technical Summary
Existing ADL evaluation methods, such as the Barthel Index (BI), are burdensome and time-consuming, leading to a low frequency of regular evaluations, which hinders the timely detection of declines in physical and cognitive functions among elderly individuals, thereby increasing nursing care costs and reducing the quality of life.
A program utilizing pictograms to graphically represent the Barthel Index, allowing operators to select images corresponding to daily activities, with a computer calculating an evaluation score, and optionally adjusting for dementia, to simplify and expedite the evaluation process.
The program significantly reduces evaluation time and burden, promoting regular ADL assessments, thereby enhancing the notification of ADL maintenance premiums and maintaining or improving the quality of life for elderly individuals.
Smart Images

Figure 2024160702000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a program for evaluating the physical functions or cognitive functions necessary for a person to autonomously perform daily activities, or for evaluating a person's mental state or the abilities necessary for a person to engage in social activities, and an evaluation support system for executing the program. [Background technology]
[0002] Japan has the world's highest aging rate, and in 2025, when the baby boomers will be 75 years old or older, the number of elderly people (75 years old or older) is expected to reach 36.77 million (Cabinet Office, 2019 White Paper on the Elderly). It is believed that the majority of elderly people will gradually fall into a state of need for nursing care after passing through an intermediate stage called "frailty." In addition, elderly people who are in a frail state have nursing care costs that are about 24 times higher than healthy elderly people living in the community (Makizako H et al. 2021). It has also been revealed that the pathology of frailty is likely to manifest itself in low functional aspects such as mental and physical functions and life functions, and has characteristics that are difficult to reveal in general clinical medical tests (Nishi et al. 2012). Therefore, early detection of declines in ADL (Activities of Daily Living) in the elderly will lead to the maintenance and improvement of the quality of life of the elderly, which will ultimately result in an extension of healthy life expectancy and a reduction in medical and nursing care costs.
[0003] In the 2018 nursing care fee revision, a new "ADL maintenance etc. surcharge" was introduced for day care facilities to evaluate those who used the facility within a certain period of time and maintained or improved their ADL beyond a certain level, from the perspective of supporting independence and preventing deterioration. This is the first outcome evaluation in nursing care in Japan. The "Barthel Index (hereinafter BI, Mahoney, FI et al 1965)" was used as an evaluation index as a simple assessment method to measure the process of functional recovery for patients who are not independent in ADL. The BI has also been shown to correlate with nursing care certification evaluation (Tomoyuki, M et al 2019), and regular evaluation of ADL is important from the perspective of nursing care prevention and the optimization of home care services.
[0004] When physical functions such as physical strength, muscle strength, muscle mass, bone density, and visceral functions decline, problems with standing and walking, decreased balance, decreased dexterity and coordination, fatigue, and loss of appetite occur. Specifically, symptoms include unsteadiness when moving or walking, a tendency to fall, and difficulty using chopsticks or buttoning clothes. When cognitive functions decline, forgetfulness, memory disorders, disorientation, impaired executive function, and a decline in judgment and communication skills occur. Specifically, symptoms include being unable to remember the names of people or objects, not understanding the steps for cooking, being unable to choose clothes appropriate for the season or purpose, being unable to calculate money when shopping, and getting lost. When physical and cognitive functions decline, activity levels decline and mental conditions worsen. When opportunities to exercise, think using the brain, and communicate (social activities) are lost, the functions of the body and brain decline, making it easier to progress to a state of being bedridden.
[0005] Here, as a prior art document, Patent Document 1 discloses software for recording and displaying information related to nursing care services. This software includes an information processing device, an information input means for receiving input of diary report information, which is information on diary and reports created by caregivers, contact information, which is information handed over between caregivers, hospital record information, which is information on the care recipient's hospital visits, condition observation information, which is information on the care recipient and the observation content, nursing care service information, which is information on the content or results of the nursing care service provided to the care recipient, care recipient information, which is information including the care recipient's personal information and the degree of independence in nursing care, and vital information, which is information on the value of vital signs measured from the care recipient and the measurement date and time, and a recording device for recording the input diary report information, contact information, hospital record information, condition observation information, nursing care service information, care recipient information, and vital information. The software is configured to function as a means including: an information recording means for recording the care information of the care recipient; an alert notification means for notifying the care recipient of warning information, which is information on precautions regarding the content of the care service to be provided based on at least a portion of the recorded care service information; and a display information generation means for generating, as display information, the recorded diary report information, the contact information, the hospital record information, the condition observation information, the care service information, the care recipient information, and the vital sign information for each care recipient, the warning information, care daily schedule information which is information consisting of the care service information on the same date as the date on which the care service was provided, and vital sign daily schedule information which is information that graphs the values of the vital signs of the care recipient over a specified period of time. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0006] [Patent Document 1] Patent Publication No. 2021-189844 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0007] However, according to a survey conducted after the ADL maintenance etc. surcharge was established (Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare Research Project on the Evaluation of Service Quality under the Long-Term Care Insurance System), only 578 day care service providers (2.6%) and 57 community-based day care service providers (0.3%) were calculating the ADL maintenance etc. surcharge. The most common reason for not reporting the ADL maintenance etc. surcharge was "the burden of evaluation using BI is too great," at 43.3%. Based on the above survey, it is considered necessary to promote the reporting of the ADL maintenance etc. surcharge, reduce the evaluation burden in order to make regular ADL evaluation a habit, and develop evaluation indicators that allow ADL to be evaluated by people of any occupation.
[0008] The present invention has been made in consideration of the above circumstances, and aims to provide a program and an evaluation support system that can easily evaluate the ADL of users periodically at care facilities. [Means for solving the problem]
[0009] (1) In order to achieve the above object, the present invention provides the following means: That is, the program of the present invention is a program for evaluating the physical functions or cognitive functions necessary for a person to autonomously perform daily activities, or for evaluating a person's mental state or the abilities necessary for a person to perform social activities, and is characterized in that it causes a computer to execute the following processes: outputting, on a display, a plurality of types of images that graphically represent the scale of the evaluation for each type of daily activity performed by the person to be evaluated, outputting a numerical value corresponding to the image selected by an operator for each type of daily activity, calculating the sum of the numerical values when the operator has completed selection for all types of daily activity, and outputting the calculated sum as an evaluation value.
[0010] (2) The program of the present invention is characterized by further comprising a process for displaying an explanation of each of the images on the display based on an operation by an operator.
[0011] (3) The program of the present invention is further characterized by including a process of displaying, on the display, an explanatory text for selecting one of the two adjacent images based on an operator's operation.
[0012] (4) In addition, in the program of the present invention, the scale of evaluation is the Barthel Index (BI), and multiple types of images graphically expressing the contents of the BI are output on a display for each type of daily living activity performed by the person being evaluated, and a numerical value corresponding to the image selected by the operator for each type of daily living activity is output. When the operator has completed selection for all types of daily living activities, the numerical values are calculated, and the calculated total is output as an ADL (Activities of Daily Living) evaluation value.
[0013] (5) In the program of the present invention, the images are selected based on the Delphi method.
[0014] (6) Furthermore, the program of the present invention is characterized by further including a process for accepting input of information indicating whether the person being evaluated has dementia, and a process for correcting the evaluation value based on the information.
[0015] (7) The evaluation system of the present invention is characterized in that the program according to any one of (1) to (5) above is executed by a computer. Effect of the Invention
[0016] According to the present invention, when evaluating the physical or cognitive functions required for a person to autonomously perform daily activities, or evaluating a person's mental state or the abilities required for a person to perform social activities, the time required for evaluation can be significantly shortened. In addition, it is possible to reduce the burden of evaluation by making periodic ADL evaluation a habit. As a result, it is possible to promote the filing of ADL maintenance premiums. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0017] [Figure 1] 1 is a block diagram showing a schematic configuration of an ADL evaluation support system. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing a pictogram according to the embodiment; [Diagram 3] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing a pictogram according to the embodiment; [Figure 4] 4 is a flowchart showing a basic operation of the ADL evaluation support system according to the present embodiment. [Diagram 5] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of a screen display of the ADL evaluation support system. [Figure 6] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of a screen display of the ADL evaluation support system. [Figure 7] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of a screen display of the ADL evaluation support system. [Figure 8] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of a screen display of the ADL evaluation support system. [Figure 9] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of a screen display of the ADL evaluation support system. [Figure 10] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of a screen display of the ADL evaluation support system. [Figure 11] This is a pictogram showing the sixth test in Table 2. [Figure 12] 13 is a flowchart showing the procedure for creating an ADL evaluation index displayed as a pictogram. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0018] In Japan's nursing care medical fee system, a new ADL maintenance surcharge was introduced in fiscal year 2018, which allows patients to receive a surcharge if their ADL improves through periodic evaluation of ADL. The re-revision increased the remuneration tenfold, but the complexity of the evaluation was cited as an issue in the field. Under these circumstances, the inventor focused on "pictograms" and discovered a new ADL evaluation method that is easier than the conventional evaluation method using letters, leading to the invention.
[0019] In other words, the program of the present invention is a program for evaluating the physical functions or cognitive functions necessary for a person to autonomously perform daily living activities, or for evaluating a person's mental state or the abilities necessary for a person to perform social activities, and is characterized by having a computer execute the following processes: outputting multiple types of images that graphically represent the evaluation scales on a display for each type of daily living activity performed by the person being evaluated; outputting numerical values corresponding to the images selected by an operator for each type of daily living activity; calculating the sum of the numerical values when the operator has completed selection for all types of daily living activities; and outputting the calculated sum as an evaluation value.
[0020] As a result, the inventor has made it possible to significantly shorten the evaluation time when evaluating the physical functions or cognitive functions necessary for a person to autonomously perform daily activities, or when evaluating a person's mental state or the abilities necessary for a person to perform social activities. In addition, it has made it possible to reduce the evaluation burden by making periodic ADL evaluation a habit. And it has made it possible to promote the filing of ADL maintenance premiums. Hereinafter, the embodiments of the present invention will be specifically described.
[0021] [First embodiment] 1 is a block diagram showing a schematic configuration of an ADL evaluation support system. The ADL evaluation support system 1 receives input from an operator at an input unit 10. The display unit 12 has a display and is capable of displaying images. The display unit 12 may be provided with an audio output function such as a speaker or a headphone terminal.
[0022] The pictogram storage unit 14 stores image data that expresses the contents of the BI (Barthel Index) in pictograms. A pictogram is a typical graphic symbol, and is a symbol that uses the shape of a thing to understand the meaning concept. It is also called a pictograph. The pictogram storage unit 14 may also store an explanation of the BI corresponding to each pictogram. It may also store an explanation for the operator to select one of two adjacent pictograms in relation to the score to be given. Furthermore, the pictogram storage unit 14 may store additional notes for each country. For example, in the case of Myanmar, when assisting a person of the opposite sex, a caution for the subject may be added to the bathing icon. In the case of Indonesia, when there is a subject who may become violent during bathing assistance, there is a possibility that the hishab may be soiled, so a caution such as "It is better to prepare a replacement hishab" may be added.
[0023] 2 and 3 are diagrams showing pictograms according to this embodiment. The pictograms according to this embodiment are characterized by being a plurality of types of patterns that graphically express the contents of the BI (Barthel Index). The BI (Barthel Index) is "a method for evaluating ADLs by scoring a total of 10 items, including eating, moving from a wheelchair to a bed, grooming, toileting, bathing, walking, climbing stairs, changing clothes, bowel control, and urination control, in increments of 5 points, and evaluating the total score as a maximum of 100 points." Specifically, according to "Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare: Toward the Revision of Nursing Care Fees in FY2021 (Promotion of Support for Independence and Prevention of Severity). (Accessed February 10, 2022) https: / / www.mhlw.go.jp / content / 12300000 / 000672514.pdf.p.46," it is stipulated as follows.
[0024] [Table 1]
[0025] That is, each pictogram in Figures 2 and 3 corresponds to each BI in Table 1 above. For example, in the BI in Table 1 above, in the "eating" category, "independent, able to eat from a tray or table by themselves if food is placed within reach, able to attach care equipment if necessary, and finishes eating within an appropriate time" is given a score of 10, but in the "eating" category in Figure 2, this is expressed by only one pictogram showing the person eating alone. In addition, in the BI in Table 1 above, in the "transfer" category, "able to sit, but requires full assistance for movement" is given a score of 5, but in the "transfer" category in Figure 2, this is expressed by only one pictogram showing the care recipient receiving assistance from an assistant when standing up from a wheelchair.
[0026] In this way, the characteristics of each BI content are expressed by pictograms, enabling the operator to easily and quickly judge the condition of the care recipient and perform an ADL assessment.
[0027] 2, customer information database 16 stores information on the care recipient, the caregiver, the operator, etc. The communication interface has a function of connecting to a network and downloads and uploads data. It also transmits and receives information for applying for ADL maintenance premium under the control of control unit 20, which will be described later. Control unit 20 transmits and receives information to and from each component via the bus and controls the entire system.
[0028] FIG. 4 is a flowchart showing the basic operation of the ADL evaluation support system according to this embodiment. This operation is performed by installing and executing the ADL evaluation support program according to this embodiment on a computer (electronic communication device such as a smartphone, tablet, or notebook PC). Also, FIG. 5 to FIG. 10 are diagrams showing examples of screen displays of the ADL evaluation support system. In FIG. 4, when the ADL evaluation support program according to this embodiment is started on a computer, a login screen (not shown) is displayed (step S1), and when an operator inputs login information, it is determined whether or not ADL evaluation is selected (step S2). If ADL evaluation is not selected, the determination of step S2 is continued (or other processing is performed), and if ADL evaluation is selected, the initial screen shown in FIG. 5 is displayed. A start button 51 is displayed in the initial screen 50, and when the operator operates the start button 51, the screen transitions to the next screen.
[0029] Next, input of information on the care recipient is accepted (step S3). Here, an input screen 60 as shown in FIG. 6 is displayed, and information such as "staff number (e.g., operator identification number, etc.)", "user number (e.g., number identifying the care recipient)", "user name (name of care recipient)", "gender", and "use of walker / wheelchair" can be input. In addition, a list of users (care recipients) is provided, which can be used for searching. When performing ADL evaluation, the evaluation button 61 is operated. When the view button 62 is operated, the evaluation results from the previous time and earlier can be viewed. When the nationality of the care recipient is input, additional notes by country can also be displayed as described above.
[0030] In FIG. 6, when the evaluation button 61 is operated, as shown in the screen display example 70 of FIG. 7 and the screen display example 80 of FIG. 8, a pictogram corresponding to the BI is displayed for each action type corresponding to the BI (FIG. 4, step S4). Then, the operator's selection of a pictogram is accepted, and the score corresponding to each pictogram is added (FIG. 4, step S5). For example, in the screen display example 70 of FIG. 7, the action type of "eating 71" is selected as "assistance required, such as cutting food," which is 5 points, and the action type of "transfer between chair and bed 72" is selected as "partial assistance or supervision required at some stage," which is 10 points. In addition, the action type of "grooming 73" and the action type of "toilet action 74" are not selected, so arrows are displayed to alert the operator. In addition, in the action type of "bathing 75," "independence (soaking in a bathtub, using a shower)," which is 5 points, is selected. In the screen display example 70, when the "next button 76" is operated, a transition to the screen display example 80 is made.
[0031] In the example screen display 80 of FIG. 8, the action type of "walking on level ground 81" is selected as 10 points, "can walk on level ground 45 m if assistance or supervision is required," the action type of "going up and down stairs 82" is selected as 10 points, "independent, can use handrails or a cane," the action type of "dressing 83" is selected as 5 points, "requires partial assistance, but can do at least half of the procedure by himself and within an appropriate time frame," the action type of "bowel control 84" is selected as 10 points, "no incontinence, can administer enemas and suppositories," and the action type of "urination control 85" is selected as 5 points, "occasionally incontinent, including cases where assistance is required to administer a urine collector."
[0032] Each pictogram can be selected by touching, and it is also possible to configure the system so that when any pictogram is pressed and held, an explanation of the BI corresponding to that pictogram is displayed. In addition, in FIG. 7, when two pictograms corresponding to 10 points and 5 points of "eating 71" are pressed and held simultaneously, "For those who change their eating style, such as chopped food, click here → (meaning partial assistance on the right side)" is displayed. In addition, in FIG. 7, when two pictograms corresponding to 10 points and 5 points of "grooming 73" are pressed and held simultaneously, "Assistance such as supervision is required to walk to the washroom, but if you can brush your teeth using the set toothbrush, click here ← (meaning independence on the left side)" is displayed. This makes it possible to support the operator's judgment and shorten the time required for evaluation. In addition, a configuration can be adopted in which a pop-up is displayed at the time of bathing assistance (for example, 3 p.m.) to prompt the operator to evaluate "bathing" on the Barthel Index. In addition to bathing, for action types with fixed times, such as "eating" and "grooming," a pop-up can be displayed at that time.
[0033] In Fig. 4, it is determined whether all pictograms have been selected (step S6), and if all pictograms have not been selected, an unselected display, that is, an arrow is displayed at the unselected action type, as shown in the screen display example 70 of Fig. 7 (step S7). On the other hand, if all pictograms have been selected in step S6, the "Go to confirmation screen button 86" shown in Fig. 8 becomes operable, and when this button is operated, the sum of the numerical values is output (Fig. 4, step S8), and the process ends.
[0034] FIG. 9 shows a screen display example 90 showing the ADL evaluation result. Here, for example, 75 points is displayed as the total value 90a. Also, in the screen display example 90, the scores for all items are displayed in the score result section 90b. Also, in the screen display example 90, operating the "Register button 91" records the current ADL evaluation result. Also, operating the "Back button 92" transitions to a pictogram selection screen (screen display example 70 or screen display example 80).
[0035] 10 shows a comparison of the ADL evaluation results with the previous results in a bar graph 101, and also shows the numerical values of each item in the previous and current ADL evaluation results in a radar chart 102. These make it possible to grasp and evaluate the ADL evaluation results at a glance.
[0036] [Improved efficiency of evaluation by the present invention] The inventors measured the time required for evaluation using the conventional BI and the program of the present invention. Specifically, three operators performed evaluation using the conventional BI and the program of the present invention on 52 people requiring care, and calculated the average time required. The time required for evaluation using the conventional BI was 23.57143 seconds, while the time required for evaluation using the program of the present invention was 20.36735 seconds. In other words, the time required for evaluation was reduced by approximately 14%.
[0037] [Accuracy of evaluation according to the present invention] The inventor had one operator (care staff) measure the BI of 50 subjects with various levels of care using a conventional method and perform ADL evaluation. Next, two operators (care staff) measured the BI of 50 subjects with various levels of care using the program of the present invention and performed ADL evaluation. As a result, the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was 0.91, and the Pearson correlation coefficient was 0.86. Since an intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) of 0.6 or less is considered "moderate" and an ICC of 0.8 or less is considered "substantial," the fact that the intraclass correlation coefficient of 0.91 in the implementation result of the present invention means that the same accuracy as the conventional method was obtained. Regarding the Pearson correlation coefficient, the "Rule of Thumb for Interpreting the Size of a Correlation Coefficient" defines ".90 to 1.00" as "Very high positive correlation" and ".70 to .90" as "High positive correlation." Therefore, the fact that the Pearson correlation coefficient achieved in the implementation of the present invention was 0.86 means that the same level of accuracy was achieved as with conventional methods.
[0038] Here, the intraclass correlation coefficient is calculated as (intergroup variance-intragroup variance) / (intergroup variance+(intragroup variance / number of groups)). That is, the average value within the group is calculated, and then the overall average value is calculated. Next, the variance is calculated by calculating the intergroup variance (sum of squares of the difference between the average within the group and the overall average) and the intragroup variance (sum of squares of the difference between each score and the average of that group). By using these calculation results and applying them to the above formula, it is possible to obtain the intraclass correlation coefficient. The higher this coefficient, the closer the ADL evaluation based on the conventional BI measurement is to the ADL evaluation based on the BI measurement by implementing the program according to the present invention, and the more sufficient accuracy is expected.
[0039] The correlation coefficient is an index that measures the strength and direction of the linear relationship between two variables. The calculation method of Pearson's correlation coefficient (usually called the "correlation coefficient") is as follows. First, the average value of each variable is calculated, then the sum of the deviation products is calculated, and then the sum of the squared deviations is calculated. Finally, the sum of the deviation products is divided by the product of the sum of the squared deviations of each variable. The value of the correlation coefficient varies between "-1 and +1", where +1 means a perfect positive linear relationship, -1 means a perfect negative linear relationship, and 0 means that there is no linear relationship between the variables. Since the correlation coefficient of the present invention with the conventional method is 0.91, it can be said that there is a positive linear relationship, and it can be said that the ADL evaluation according to the present invention has the same accuracy as the conventional method.
[0040] In addition, ADL is often considered to be a component factor in evaluating "Quality of Life (QOL)," and it has been reported that it is a major area of QOL, especially for elderly people with illnesses. Therefore, according to the present invention, maintaining and improving ADL can be said to contribute to improving QOL.
[0041] [Second embodiment] In the second embodiment, correction of ADL evaluation results in the case of dementia will be described. In the case of dementia, the ADL tends to be high. In reality, the degree of care required should be evaluated higher, so in the present invention, the ADL evaluation results are corrected for care recipients with dementia.
[0042] Table 2 below shows the "Revised Hasegawa Shiki Simple Intelligence Assessment (https: / / www.jpn-geriat-soc.or.jp / tool / pdf / tool_05.pdf)." This Table 2 shows tests for evaluating the abilities required for people to engage in mental and social activities. In this application, these tests are displayed concisely using images (illustrations, photographs, etc.). For example, the sixth test in Table 2 is a test that asks, "Please say the number I am about to say backwards." If the person can say a three-digit or four-digit number correctly, one point is added for each, but if the person fails to say the three-digit number backwards, the test is terminated.
[0043] FIG. 11 is a pictogram showing the sixth test in Table 2. The pictogram on the left side of FIG. 11 shows a state where the three digits are successfully recited backwards, while the pictogram on the right side of FIG. 11 shows a state where the three digits are not successfully recited backwards. Rather than reading and understanding the characters shown in Table 2 and judging the state of the person being evaluated, the operator can easily, accurately, and more efficiently evaluate the test results by visually checking the pictograms shown in FIG. 11. [Table 2]
[0044] For example, if a subject scores 20 points or less in the above test, or if the subject has been diagnosed with Alzheimer's disease, vascular dementia, Lewy body dementia, frontotemporal dementia, Parkinson's disease dementia, traumatic dementia, or other dementia, the "Dementia Mode Changer" implemented in this invention will change the Barthel Index score to -10 points. This makes it possible to carry out ADL evaluation that takes dementia into consideration.
[0045] [Third embodiment] In the third embodiment, application to ADL maintenance etc. premium will be described. After executing the program according to the present invention, each of the 10 BI items is converted into CSV format and submitted to the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare's database. That is, information showing the ADL evaluation results obtained by executing the program according to the present invention is output in CSV file format and can be imported into the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare's database (LIFE). This reduces the burden of evaluation by making regular ADL evaluation a habit, and is expected to promote the filing of ADL maintenance premiums.
[0046] [Pictogram selection using the Delphi method] In this specification, the Delphi method is used to select pictograms. The Delphi method is a method mainly used in medical research (HASSON F., KEENEY S. & MCKENNA H. Research guidelines for the Delphi survey technique, Journal of Advanced Nursing 2000, 32(4), 1008-1015), in which each pictogram is evaluated by experts in the field, and the pictograms are scored and selected. Scores are out of 10, with 0 being "not at all representative" and 10 being "perfect representative." If more than half of the evaluators rate a pictogram at 7 points or higher, that pictogram is adopted. On the other hand, if the score is 7 points or lower, the pictogram is revised and reevaluated. This evaluation is repeated to select the pictogram.
[0047] FIG. 12 is a flow chart showing the procedure for creating an ADL evaluation index displayed by a pictogram. First, a proposal for an ADL evaluation index displayed by a pictogram is created (step S21). Next, a first Delphi round is conducted (step S22). Next, the result of the first Delphi round is fed back and a second Delphi round is conducted (step S23). Next, the result of the second Delphi round is fed back and a third Delphi round is conducted (step S24). Finally, an ADL evaluation index displayed by a pictogram is completed (step S25). In the above description, an example of conducting a third Delphi round is shown, but the present invention is not limited to this, and more Delphi rounds may be conducted. This makes it possible to select pictograms with high accuracy and rationality. [Explanation of symbols]
[0048] 1 ADL assessment support system 10 Input section 12 Display section 14 Pictogram storage section 16 Customer Information Database 20 Control section
Claims
1. A program for evaluating the physical or cognitive functions required for a person to autonomously perform daily activities, or for evaluating a person's mental state or the abilities required for a person to perform social activities, outputting a plurality of types of images that graphically represent the scales of evaluation on a display for each type of daily living activity performed by the person to be evaluated; outputting a numerical value corresponding to the image selected by an operator for each type of daily living activity; a process of calculating a sum of the numerical values when the operator has completed the selection of all the types of daily living activities; and outputting the calculated sum as an evaluation value.
2. 2. The program according to claim 1, further comprising a process for displaying an explanatory text for each of said images on said display in response to an operation by an operator.
3. 2. The program according to claim 1, further comprising a process for displaying, on the display, an explanation for selecting one of the two adjacent images based on an operation by an operator.
4. The scale of evaluation is the Barthel Index (BI), and multiple types of images that graphically represent the contents of the BI are output to a display for each type of daily living activity performed by the person being evaluated. outputting a numerical value corresponding to the image selected by an operator for each type of daily living activity; When the operator has completed the selection of all the types of daily living activities, the sum of the numerical values is calculated; 2. The program according to claim 1, further comprising: outputting the calculated total as an ADL (Activities of Daily Living) evaluation value.
5. 5. The program according to claim 4, wherein the images are selected based on the Delphi method.
6. A process of accepting input of information indicating whether the person being evaluated has dementia; 2. The program according to claim 1, further comprising a process of correcting the evaluation value based on the information.
7. 7. An evaluation support system comprising: a computer that executes the program according to claim 1.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Care card, care management method of care-requiring person using the same
JP1998264554A
Watching system, watching server device, watching method and computer program
JP2017151515A
Software and nursing care recording system
JP2021189844A
